Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 303 / Brett Marchand / Plus Company / Chief Executive Officer
Transcript
- 0:00Brett Marchand: The fundamental thing is, are we measuring what
- 0:03all this stuff is doing to actually help us either build a
- 0:06brand or sell product? If you forget about that, I think you
- 0:09get lost.
- 0:16Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:19is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:22combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:24as 26 grammes of protein per bag. So you can be both a little
- 0:28bit bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:31brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:35owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:38defy with an eye snacks.com and follow us on social at defy
- 0:42snacks.
- 0:49Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:52My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of automated creative,
- 0:56the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and this is a
- 0:58podcast about the future of data driven marketing. Every week or
- 1:02so I have the pleasure and the privilege of interviewing one of
- 1:04our industry's leaders about where this industry is going,
- 1:08and this week is no different. I'm on a call with Brett
- 1:10Marchand, who is CEO of Plus Company. Brett, for anyone who
- 1:15doesn't know who you are and what you do, can you give him a
- 1:18bit of background?
- 1:19Brett Marchand: see you. Tom, or talk to you at least. Yeah, I'm
- 1:23the CEO, plus company owns a bunch of agencies, mostly North
- 1:26American wide, but also we are social, which a lot of people
- 1:29know, I think you know a little bit about. And I'm I started as
- 1:35a brand. I'm Canadian, born and raised in Canada. I started at
- 1:40P&G, so I was a brand marketer. I went from P&G to Campbell Soup
- 1:43to Molson. I did a fairly famous campaign when I was at Molson,
- 1:47and then I became an ad ex, and most of that has been at what
- 1:53was called Cossette, and now has become Plus Company. So I've
- 1:56sort of, you know, started running an office, and then
- 1:58eventually the country, and then eventually the company.
- 2:01Tom Ollerton: Fantastic. And what a journey. So, okay, you've
- 2:05been brand side, agency side. You've come up through the
- 2:08ranks, the top job. What's been your biggest screw up to date?
- 2:14What has been that mistake you made, where you were red faced
- 2:17and you're head in hand, but actually looking back, you're
- 2:19glad it happened.
- 2:20Brett Marchand: I mean, a lot, by the way, I think. But
- 2:24interestingly enough, I had a, had a section of my career,
- 2:29which was actually between being a client and in the agency
- 2:33world, where I started a tech company with three partners, and
- 2:38we made, we basically made the software that allowed you to do
- 2:43customization in the footwear and apparel business. So if
- 2:48you've ever been on Nike ID, you know, you get on you, you design
- 2:53a shoe for yourself, and then it magically gets manufactured and
- 2:57sent to you. So in 1999 actually, we started developing
- 3:02the software for companies to be able to do that, whether it was
- 3:06for a person on the other end or it was for companies, because
- 3:11retailers like to have sort of unique items. And yeah, we built
- 3:16that, launched it, spent a lot of my own money, my partners'
- 3:22money, and investors' money to build it. The dotcom crash
- 3:27happened, which then impacted everything, and it was a
- 3:30miserable failure, and I lost everything, literally
- 3:34everything. So, but I also, you know, we had 40 or 50 employees
- 3:39who all lost their jobs pretty quickly. So yeah, that was a
- 3:45pretty miserable failure.
- 3:46Tom Ollerton: So what did it teach you?
- 3:49Brett Marchand: Well, I learned a bunch of things about that. I
- 3:51mean, first of all, timing's everything, and particularly
- 3:54with technology, I think it's really important because, I
- 4:00mean, now, you know, everyone uses this kind of technology and
- 4:05software. You just, you know, you go on a site and customise
- 4:07something, and it's and it just happens, but at the time, you
- 4:12know, you know, internet speeds just weren't ready for a product
- 4:19like that. But also the VC community, and obviously this,
- 4:25you know, the dotcom hysteria. So a bunch of things were
- 4:28happening. And I think it's not just that timing is everything.
- 4:31It's also be extremely careful not to jump on the horse,
- 4:36because everyone else is riding fast, and that you have to be
- 4:40very careful that when the wind for everyone is blowing in the
- 4:44same direction, that maybe it's going to shift.
- 4:47Tom Ollerton: And so what was your mental process for picking
- 4:50yourself up from that, right? Because that's hard man, like
- 4:5340-50 people, all your money, all your best mates' money, and
- 4:57sounds pretty much it was out of your hands. Maybe you were a bit
- 4:59early. Perhaps, to your own admission, but that's going to
- 5:03be really intellectually and financially crushing. How, how
- 5:07did you pick yourself up? Did you just shrug it off and say,
- 5:09whatever? Or was it a bit more complicated?
- 5:10Brett Marchand: No, it was definitely more complicated. I
- 5:14mean, I, you know, I was lucky. My wife was working. I mean, she
- 5:17was carrying the load, not just working, but also, we had two
- 5:20young kids at the time, and, you know, we had to get a rented
- 5:25house, and she was paying for that, etc. I think I was off
- 5:28work for three months, and then I, interestingly enough, I then
- 5:32went into the ad business. So I, yeah, I was bit depressed for a
- 5:39couple of months, you know, because you felt like I felt
- 5:43like a failure, and I was the CEO, I was the company, it was
- 5:46my idea in the first place, and I was sort of driving, like,
- 5:49unfortunately, driving a lot of this sort of, you know, spending
- 5:54and not, you know, not putting on the brakes probably soon
- 5:56enough, etc. So, yeah, and, and, I think I thought it was three
- 6:02months and I was okay. But, you know, in in hindsight, it was
- 6:05probably three years I went through that. Luckily I, you
- 6:11know, I ended up at my first agency. Role was at one of the
- 6:15Lowe agencies. It was actually a very good agency that was bought
- 6:19by Frank Lowe called Roche McCauley and partners. Geoffrey
- 6:21Roche, who was the founder, was just, you know, a visionary,
- 6:25creative guy, and we did really well. And so that probably
- 6:29helped more than anything, you know, that I found a new career,
- 6:33and I learned a lot from him, and we did really well together.
- 6:36So, yeah, I think that's, that's what helped. But it took a long
- 6:40Tom Ollerton: It must have been interesting. You going into an
- 6:40time.
- 6:42agency environment with all of that experience and that, that
- 6:45pain and anguish, because you must have been bulletproof. You
- 6:48know, when people were complaining about a bad
- 6:50situation, you must have been like, that's not a bad
- 6:53situation. Let me tell you about bad situations. But anyway, I
- 6:56would love to know another time. I'd love to know more about that
- 6:59story.
- 7:03So let's bring it all back to data driven marketing
- 7:08specifically. So what is your best bit of data driven
- 7:11marketing advice you've been brand side, you've been startup
- 7:14side, now agency side. What bit of advice do you find yourself
- 7:18as being true and find yourself sharing most often.
- 7:21Brett Marchand: I guess I have believed this for a long time.
- 7:24When I started at Procter, I was working on marketing mix
- 7:27modelling, and this is in the 80s, I have always thought that
- 7:31the most important thing you have to measure is whether it's
- 7:34working or not, like at the end of the day, you know,
- 7:37advertising and marketing is about selling stuff to make
- 7:40money. And there's so much data out there, and by the way, a lot
- 7:47of it is really good for generating insights, you know,
- 7:51finding a competitive advantage, figuring out, you know, what an
- 7:54individual consumer wants. I mean, listen, I started
- 7:57basically a company that was the book mass customization, but,
- 8:01but I always think that the fundamental thing is, are we
- 8:05measuring what all this stuff is doing to actually help us either
- 8:09build the brand or or sell product? And people forget that.
- 8:12I think often I have discussions with clients that are that have
- 8:17huge data teams that are doing an immense amount of measurement
- 8:20and data science and using AI and but at the end of the day,
- 8:24they don't actually know whether it's having an impact or not
- 8:27thinking. If you forget about that, I think you get lost.
- 8:31Tom Ollerton: And what's the one question to ask to work out, if
- 8:34you are measuring the right things?
- 8:35Brett Marchand: Is there a KPI that's meaningful for your
- 8:39business, and are you measuring it in a in a comprehensive way,
- 8:42so that you understand all the things you're doing in
- 8:44marketing, or actually making it, you know, an impact on that
- 8:47KPI? Most people can't answer that question, by the way.
- 8:49Tom Ollerton: No, of course. My version of that is, are you
- 8:51going to do something differently based on this bit of
- 8:54data that you're capturing about your marketing? If you go that's
- 8:58interesting. Then it's just noise, right? But if it, if it
- 9:01tells you something where you're like, right? Okay, I now know
- 9:04neat. I now know what I need to go and do, then it's right. I
- 9:08mean, that's what we talk about at automated creative a lot, is
- 9:11people don't need more, like, more data, more decks and more
- 9:15dashboards.They need inspiration, right? You need
- 9:17data that tells you what the next thing you should do. You
- 9:21should be hands in the air going, Yes, brilliant, this
- 9:24thing I need to do. And if your data is not driving inspiration,
- 9:27it's just noise, then, yeah, to your point, you're just
- 9:30collecting a bunch of things that don't tell you that the
- 9:33business is moving in the right direction or not.
- 9:36Brett Marchand: I worked at P&G. It was really interesting. I
- 9:38mean, you know, it's, like, it's really a great company in many,
- 9:42many ways, P&G, at least. And the five years I spent there, I
- 9:45just, I still use what I learned in that company every single
- 9:48day. I really do. And when I got there, like it was about brand
- 9:52share, it was about market share in your category, that was
- 9:56fundamentally what we measured. You know, the first thing they
- 9:59made you do as brand assistant was write, it was write a
- 10:03monthly review and and it was all about market share, like,
- 10:07how did your market share? How did things impact that market
- 10:10share? The Good, the Bad, the what did you learn? Etc. And I
- 10:14always just found that super valuable. And I think it's a
- 10:17reason that that company's done so you know so well for hundreds
- 10:20of years is that, you know, it's super focused on one thing. So I
- 10:24learned a huge lesson at P&G about that.
- 10:32Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 10:35brought to you in partnership with Madfest. Whether it's live
- 10:38in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 10:42you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 10:45fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 10:48unconventional entertainment from Madfest events. You'll find
- 10:51me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 10:54podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 10:57people in marketing. Check it out at www.madfestlondon.com.
- 11:09So your shiny new object is the democratisation of brands. So
- 11:14when you said this, I didn't, wasn't quite sure what you
- 11:16meant. You've explained it to me now, so I would love it if you
- 11:19could explain what that is to the audience, so we can get into
- 11:22Brett Marchand: So if you think about, I mean, P&G is probably a
- 11:22it.
- 11:25good example, right? I mean, we all know that brands started
- 11:28because people were manufacturing things, and they
- 11:29want to, you know, they were, they were better, and they're
- 11:32therefore they branded them because they wanted to tell you
- 11:35that it's worth, you know, buying this thing and paying
- 11:38more for it because, you know, it's a product of quality and
- 11:42consistency and all those things. And so, you know, the
- 11:48the ability to manufacture something and do it in the right
- 11:52way was the first thing that made a huge difference to, you
- 11:55know, brands, and then you needed a lot of money to be able
- 11:59to talk about it, right? Because distributing that message was
- 12:05expensive. You know, in the early days, it was through
- 12:07newspapers, and of course, it's, you know, expanded greatly
- 12:11through the decades. I think everything has changed when it
- 12:15comes to that. So, you know, manufacturing tariffs right now,
- 12:20aside for a second. I mean, almost anyone can manufacture
- 12:24like you. You need very little money to manufacture something
- 12:27in, usually countries like Vietnam and China and other
- 12:31places, and be able to ship it almost anywhere, at least on the
- 12:34product side of things. Or, you know, you can start a consulting
- 12:37company overnight. Or you guys have started a company with two
- 12:43of you. So, you know, the barriers there are much lower.
- 12:46Second of all, you know, the internet changed everything,
- 12:49because you could talk to a giant swath of the of the world,
- 12:53you know, again, without having to spend millions of dollars on
- 12:58production and TV or or some other areas. And then E commerce
- 13:02actually changed that even more, because you didn't have to pay
- 13:05for listing fees. You didn't need a whole lot of money. You
- 13:07didn't have to be able to, you know, get Walmart to be
- 13:10convinced to bring your, you know, put your product on their
- 13:13shelves, etc. And then, of course, the pandemic accelerated
- 13:16all of that, because people were at home, so they couldn't go to
- 13:17retailers, and they were in front of their computers, and
- 13:20they computers and their phones to buy things and, you know, and
- 13:26now AI has accelerated it even more because you can actually
- 13:31develop a brand, you can come up with a logo, you can design the
- 13:35product, you know. I mean, you can build a website. You don't
- 13:38even have to pay somebody to code anymore. So I just think it
- 13:41has fundamentally turned this idea of brand on its on its ear.
- 13:47I mean, some of, I mean, I still am a huge fan of brands like,
- 13:51you know, Nike and McDonald's and, you know, Adidas, and I
- 13:58don't know, you know, I still love Mercedes and Audi's. I
- 14:02think they're great. But you can build products. You know, some
- 14:06of the best products in those categories and other categories
- 14:10are actually brands that have come out of nowhere in in only
- 14:13the last year or two. And think the the environment, the
- 14:18infrastructure, all these changes that I just talked about
- 14:22have created this new era of almost anyone can build and
- 14:27distribute and market a brand today.
- 14:29Tom Ollerton: Thanks for the little history of why that all
- 14:31came about, that was really nicely put together. However, I
- 14:34gotta push you on this right? I think it's really easy for
- 14:37people to make things that look like brands, as opposed to
- 14:41actually being brands, right? So, you know, you and I throw up
- 14:45the the Tom and Brett burger company, right? And we and,
- 14:49yeah, you can throw up a website without any coding. You can
- 14:53order some cheap patties online and get delivered to our burger
- 14:56restaurant. We can do a logo and put on T shirts, you know,
- 14:59business cards and. Whole thing. Probably even get chat GPT to
- 15:01design the menu and all the variants and the pricing and
- 15:04stuff. But... and you will look like a brand, like you will have
- 15:09all of the hallmarks of a brand, but until you have that thing
- 15:12where it's the mental association, availability and
- 15:15the motion associated with those things that make up a brand, ie,
- 15:20you know, the logo the shop, the whatever the power of it's
- 15:23distributed, and I think that that's the kind of curse of AI
- 15:27is it's given people the impression that they're doing
- 15:30the thing that works, because it looks like the thing that works,
- 15:33but actually, it's not actually doing the job. So, yeah, you've
- 15:36got, you've got a logo that looks like a logo, but unless
- 15:39anyone recognises that logo. The logo is not doing the job.
- 15:42Brett Marchand: I think you're right. I mean, I mean, it's my
- 15:46latest shiny new object. It's one of the things I've been
- 15:49thinking a lot about. I mean, not just for the last year, but
- 15:52for the last few years. But I agree with you, I don't, I'm not
- 15:57sure that that means success. I think actually, if you're a big
- 16:03brand, if you're a Procter & Gamble or Adidas or an Audi, I
- 16:10think they're think you have the right to be successful. I think
- 16:14you It changes the way you have to think about things, though. I
- 16:18think if you ignore all these other brands and this
- 16:21democratisation of brands, I think you do it at your own
- 16:24peril. Um, I think this is Starbucks. Is a good example. I
- 16:29am a, you know, I have been a huge Starbucks fan from the
- 16:31first time I went into a Starbucks in 1993. I always
- 16:37thought what Howard Schultz was doing there was absolutely
- 16:40brilliant on a branding standpoint. But meanwhile, you
- 16:44know, as you know you're, you're in London, there's a coffee
- 16:46shop, you know, on every corner, and a lot of them are marketing
- 16:54in a way that they never could before. They've got apps that
- 16:59you can order from, you can see how they're rated versus the
- 17:04other coffee shops. Never mind the Starbucks around the corner
- 17:07on whatever you're looking at, Google Maps or Yelp or etc. And
- 17:13I think it's hurt the Starbucks brand. I think they have been
- 17:16challenged in a way that they haven't been in a long time. And
- 17:19this is the reason why, I don't think anyone's talking about it,
- 17:23but I think that's actually the fundamental issue for Starbucks
- 17:26right now.
- 17:26Tom Ollerton: I think about coffee too much. Not that I'm a
- 17:29massive coffee aficionado, but there's a certain amount of
- 17:32brands that I think what they do is they they raise the floor,
- 17:35right? So before things like Starbucks, right? You had,
- 17:38certainly, when I was growing up, we had, like, I don't know,
- 17:40Nescafe granules, right? If you wanted a coffee, that's, that's
- 17:43kind of what you did there was, there wasn't really any, if you
- 17:45had a French press or something, if you were a bit fancy, but
- 17:49generally speaking, it was that. And then all coffee shop coffee
- 17:52was pretty much the same thing. And then Starbucks came along
- 17:55and kind of made that, you know, the base level coffee, the
- 17:57everyman coffee, like, so much better. And whereas now, like,
- 18:01what you look at something like Blank Street, right? And
- 18:03they've, they've kind of taken it, taken it up a notch, you
- 18:05know, they kind of lift that thing up and then, Nespresso,
- 18:09they sort of made home coffee, just that, that little bit
- 18:11better. Some might argue, I wouldn't argue, but, but there
- 18:14you go. So, so you get these brands that kind of lift the
- 18:18floor to make the make the base thing better. Some brands are
- 18:21like, kind of Ferraris or whatever, just kind of make the
- 18:24best car better, Tesla, you could argue, and all that kind
- 18:26of stuff. So, so what? So in that world, what is the, what is
- 18:32the role of the democratised brand? Is if everyone can make a
- 18:35nice looking logo and website and do an order through an app
- 18:38and all the rest of it, like, what's really going to matter?
- 18:41Is it creativity, or is it timing, or is it strategy? If
- 18:44everyone can make a brand overnight for no money and
- 18:46dropship it from China, you know if that all starts again. If it
- 18:50does, what's really going to matter? Because if it's been the
- 18:56level the play field has been levelled, something's going to
- 18:58win. So who's going to win?
- 18:58Brett Marchand: I think creativity is a huge part of
- 19:01that. And, you know, it's right now, it seems to be less
- 19:03important. Think a lot of brands have sort of rushed to the
- 19:08bottom of the funnel because of all the things we just talked
- 19:11about, right? You know, because of what's happening with E
- 19:13commerce, what's happening with other brands, what happened with
- 19:16the pandemic. You know, as the world moved online, because of
- 19:21the pressure on delivering against sales objectives, etc.
- 19:25But I think, I think brand and creativity, and, you know, what
- 19:29is your purpose and and what's it, you know, how do you fit
- 19:32into people's lives, and how you talk about that in a meaningful
- 19:35way? I think, is one of the, one of the most important things.
- 19:44Tom Ollerton: One of the scariest things I saw, and I'd
- 19:46love to get your view on this. I'm doing a podcast challenge
- 19:49with my nephew at the minute, where we listen to a new podcast
- 19:52show every day for a year, not like a series, but the whole new
- 19:56production every day, which seemed quite eye opening. And I
- 19:58found this podcast called, like, cool things to do with chat GPT.
- 20:01And it said, like, here's five businesses you can start with a
- 20:06with chat GPT tomorrow. And any ideas, Brett, can you pick two
- 20:11of those five?
- 20:12Brett Marchand: Another chat GPT.
- 20:14Tom Ollerton: I mean, I don't know it was. It's a tough it's a
- 20:23tough question. The first one was a branding agency. They're
- 20:26like, look, you've got Chat GPT. You can just set up a branding
- 20:32agency tomorrow. You can design websites, you can design logos
- 20:36and come up with names. I was like, I was like, oh, no, no,
- 20:36you can't. You can do something that looks like a branding
- 20:38agency, but it designs the artefacts of a brand, but
- 20:43doesn't design a brand. And then the other one, the only other
- 20:46one, and this is like, so telling how popular this show
- 20:49is. It might not be popular at all, but the other thing was an
- 20:52email marketing agency. And like, I'm sure you've seen your
- 20:55inbox like, everyone else's just explode with people constantly,
- 20:59constantly trying to hook you in, going, Hey, Brett, quick
- 21:02question, or like, do you like making money, Brett, and all the
- 21:04stuff that you you know, then you'll probably got 50 of them
- 21:07in your inbox, as we've been speaking as do I.
- 21:09Brett Marchand: I delete at least two every morning.
- 21:12Tom Ollerton: It's crazy, but it must... someone must be making
- 21:15money out of this. It's madness. But do you know they don't
- 21:18like... and email marketing in a B2B context is very hard, and
- 21:22that is very difficult to get right. You know, as I'm sure
- 21:25you'll have attested to.
- 21:27Brett Marchand: But let's be honest, right? Like being able
- 21:29to start a branding agency has never had very high barriers,
- 21:32ever like, you know, there's, I don't know what the number is,
- 21:35but there must be hundreds of 1000s of brand agencies in the
- 21:38world, and have been for decades, like, you know,
- 21:43successful ones, whole different story, as we know. But I, you
- 21:47know, there's not that many barriers to be able to start a
- 21:49brand agency, branding agency. And I, you know, listen, AI
- 21:53makes it even easier. I agree. But that does not mean you're
- 21:56going to be successful, because there are, you know, many, many
- 21:59other things that you have to do to be able to a run a business
- 22:02like that successfully, but also b be able to help clients, and
- 22:06especially big clients and enterprise clients, do the
- 22:09things that they need to do to differentiate themselves,
- 22:11particularly in a world of democratisation of brands. So I,
- 22:15you know, I think chat GPT is, I'm not sure that they're right
- 22:21Tom Ollerton: Well, look, Brett, unfortunately, I've got a tonne
- 22:23more questions, but we're at time now, frustratingly. So, if
- 22:26someone wanted to get in touch with you about the things we've
- 22:30talked about today, where's a good place to do that and what
- 22:33does make a message that you will respond to?
- 22:36Brett Marchand: Email me? Brett.marchand@pluscompany.com
- 22:39that's the best way. And don't try and sell me something, and
- 22:43I'll respond. I promise.
- 22:44Tom Ollerton: Brett, I really appreciate your time. Thank you
- 22:46so much.
- 22:47Brett Marchand: Yeah, me too. Thanks, Tom.
- 22:55Tom Ollerton: hi, just before you go, I'd really appreciate it
- 22:59if you could take the time to write a review of the shiny new
- 23:02object podcast on Apple podcasts or iTunes, or whatever it's
- 23:06called these days, or whichever podcast provider you use. We're
- 23:10at any podcast. So it would go a long way for us. If you could
- 23:13just share the Word and give us a bit of a support on those
- 23:16channels. That'll just be fantastic if you haven't got
- 23:19time. That's also cool. And yeah, if you could tell your
- 23:21colleagues about the podcast, and also, if possible, don't
- 23:24forget to subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback. If
- 23:28you'd like to speak on the podcast or be a guest, or you
- 23:31think I'm asking the wrong questions, anything, I'd be
- 23:33super interested to hear what you think. So please email me at
- 23:37Tom at automated creative.net, that's Tom at I'm not gonna
- 23:43bother spelling it anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so
- 23:46much.