Latest / Newcomer Pod / Going Evergreen (w/Hunter Walk)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome everybody. It's Eric newcomer here with
- 0:17dead cat. We've got Tom and Katie and
- 0:20we're super excited to have Hunter walk here of Homebrew.
- 0:25Venture, capitalists whose now, investing out of Their own
- 0:30money. I guess I'm curious to sort of
- 0:32get the story and a lively, Twitter presence.
- 0:36So a good opportunity to sort of get up to speed on.
- 0:40What's, what's going on in Silicon Valley?
- 0:44Money World Hunter. How's it going great?
- 0:46Hey friends. Thanks for having me.
- 0:48Yeah, one question. Is there a dead cat soundboard?
- 0:51Like, dude, you sound drunk? Would you like us to have a
- 0:56sound for you? Katie specifically.
- 0:58I don't know if you remember. But like, when you used to To
- 1:00drop big Tech Scoops, when you're at that part of the times
- 1:03I think I'd reply with like hashtag better bomb Twitter.
- 1:07I was wondering if we could get like a funk Flex bomb, drop for
- 1:11you. Here we are as in your can put
- 1:13that in. After the fact, it's like how
- 1:15Ronan Farrow posts on his Instagram story is like brace
- 1:18for impact, right before some other Hollywood, perv gets taken
- 1:22down. I feel like our Scruples on a
- 1:34copyright paranoia are low. So good with some audience fair
- 1:40use is a very gray area, so, right?
- 1:42You're an expert in. Yeah, we're going to get any,
- 1:44I'm curious tug YouTube and all that stuff from your old days
- 1:47to, for sure. For sure.
- 1:49The closest thing I think we have do a sound board as my
- 1:51fucking cat walking into the room and Writing to starting to
- 1:54opine a hedge will happen by the way, my doors, you know.
- 1:57Now, to be fair, your cat fucking would be an interesting
- 1:59sound or two. Yeah, no.
- 2:01She's that's next month. Yeah, that's yeah.
- 2:05That's a different audio. Everyone always criticizes are
- 2:07dead cat named, but I didn't think about that as the, you
- 2:11know, the little deaths that cat and on that note, hello,
- 2:16everybody? Yes.
- 2:17All right, so Hunter, yeah, why don't you just explain?
- 2:21Because I'm going to be honest. Eric doesn't want me to be
- 2:24honest anymore but things I didn't read Tom.
- 2:26Why don't you say? He doesn't know what's going on.
- 2:28No, he isn't gonna think I followed, I followed your
- 2:30announcement and, you know, Casey Newton's, you know,
- 2:33dutiful broadcasting of your announcement when you guys kind
- 2:36of changed the structure on Homebrew, why don't you just
- 2:39explain to our audience? Aka me what the new the new
- 2:43strategy is with Homebrew because I don't actually
- 2:45understand it. Absolutely, yeah and look, it's
- 2:47a little bit inside baseball, like, basically, we've been
- 2:49meaning to announce it this year.
- 2:51We were heading to a conference room.
- 2:53I knew there'd be a bunch of other VCS and everyone want to
- 2:55be like, how are things going, what's up with Homebrew?
- 2:57And as opposed to having the same conversation a hundred
- 3:00times were like, oh we gotta get this post out, then we realized,
- 3:02we didn't have any art for it. So 9:45 p.m. in La Sachin, my
- 3:07partner and I always share a hotel room and we travel.
- 3:09Its kind of the roommate thing. So we're like searching for
- 3:12thirty dollar clip art, which you can see in the post itself
- 3:15at home. Brew bring hundred Arena.
- 3:18Okay. So look, here's the background
- 3:20for people who probably, I don't assume most people have heard of
- 3:22Homebrew to begin with. So I'm a former product manager,
- 3:25who about 10 years ago with a friend and former colleague
- 3:28started in early stage Venture fund called, Homebrew named
- 3:32after the Homebrew Computer Club of the 1970s or early eighties.
- 3:36A tip backwards, we could talk about that naming.
- 3:38If you want later first 10 years, it's kind of very
- 3:41standard, right? We make eight to ten core
- 3:44Investments a year seed, stage companies, trying to do one to
- 3:46two million of their first 0 to 5 and then really sort of, you
- 3:50know, long-term investors. But for first three to five
- 3:52years, right? Their seats a series be kind of
- 3:55leaned in and be helpful. Try to help them build a
- 3:57foundation to be the best version of, you know, of what
- 4:00they can become. Because it's our business, we
- 4:02get to, you know, decide what we want it to be from the
- 4:05beginning, you know. Look, we didn't want to be
- 4:07Empire Builders. There was no plans for growth
- 4:09and no plans for succession right from the beginning.
- 4:11You said, you didn't want it to be a generational firm, right?
- 4:15Correct. Great multi.
- 4:17Yeah, no multi-generational. And look you own your business.
- 4:20Like you can always revisit that.
- 4:21But but I always think of us as an Operating model with a
- 4:24flexible business model. The operating model is the two
- 4:27of us working together spending most of our time with the
- 4:29founders. We back.
- 4:30Not going to conferences, not networking, not chasing the next
- 4:34hot white see deal. But the answer to the question,
- 4:37what do we want Homebrew to be for the next 10 years?
- 4:39We came up with an answer. That was a little bit different
- 4:41than I think a lot of our peers, a lot of our peers have grown
- 4:43quite significantly over the time.
- 4:45What Founders need has changed over the last, you know, eight
- 4:48nine, ten years. And so we said look, we're gonna
- 4:51if we don't want to grow, you know, why don't we actually A
- 4:53sort of stay the same or maybe even quote unquote, shrink
- 4:56right. Let's focus on what matters and
- 4:59that's being flexible enough to work with the founders.
- 5:02We care about in the easiest way possible that meant no longer,
- 5:06you know, having to have like an ownership Target.
- 5:08Well, you know, our piece fits so long as you want to sell, its
- 5:1015% of your company, it meant no longer like trying to figure out
- 5:14in advance how much are fun. Should be 100 million, 200
- 5:18million, 30 million, 40 million, like that.
- 5:20All when you're when you're building a spreadsheet, you
- 5:23know. A sort of manage manage a fund.
- 5:25You have to figure that stuff out in advance.
- 5:27So, we did two things. We said one, let's start out
- 5:31this fun for by actually just using our own money.
- 5:34I know this is an extremely personal question, but how what,
- 5:39how much money is that, or? How, how much money are you
- 5:42putting behind in? It's more about sort of saying,
- 5:45look, I've got enough where, like, I can forgo the salary, I
- 5:48can forego the, you know, the leverage on other people's
- 5:52dollars and I'm willing to Make the long-term bet that if we're
- 5:55writing checks together and you know taking a hundred percent of
- 5:58the risk by keeping 100% of The Upside like that's going to work
- 6:01out perfectly fine over time. And you know if it doesn't then
- 6:05you know whoa I got to figure out, you know what, you know how
- 6:08to resolve that. But I think we're basically that
- 6:10may be the easiest way to talk about.
- 6:11It is traditionally, most VCS are asked to do one percent of
- 6:17their fund. That's like the GP commit.
- 6:19What we are putting towards this effort, is more than the 1%.
- 6:23We used to do, you know of our Venture funds, right?
- 6:26So you know, people can sort of run the math and figure that
- 6:29out. What is it specifically about
- 6:30the Venture model that you were disillusioned by like was it
- 6:34going around to the LPS to the endowments?
- 6:37No, no I love. In fact they're great.
- 6:39We've always been really focused on a small number of endowments
- 6:42and Foundations who we, you know, I'm just, I'm sure we're
- 6:45going to figure out some way to continue to work with.
- 6:47Like there's going to be checks that are, you know, too big, you
- 6:50know, for us to write and companies that we've, you know,
- 6:52maybe back to We and, you know, SPV he's or that type of stuff.
- 6:55Also, a lot of them are actually working with us in screened, or
- 6:59a fund of funds that we created to help back emerging Managers
- 7:02from underrepresented segments. So we can, we can talk about
- 7:04that later. So definitely not the LPS.
- 7:06I think that the stuff that sort of, we were sort of scratching
- 7:10our head about was two things. One, there's lots of great
- 7:14reasons to use other people's money to build your business.
- 7:18If you're going to be multi-generational, I think you
- 7:19need to do that. You can't be tied to any one GPS
- 7:22Capital so like. You're investing in things where
- 7:25you really need to be a, the leader of that round and they
- 7:27need a lot of money. Like let's say, if you were
- 7:28starting a climate fund right now, I think you'd really want
- 7:32outside LPS because the the capital requirements of those
- 7:34companies might be significant, you know, if you can't afford
- 7:37look there's lots of people. Like we started a little bit
- 7:39later in our career if you're earlier and you need a fee
- 7:41structure, right? Like in order to pay the bills,
- 7:43in order to be able to bring on, you know, younger employees.
- 7:46Like that's a great reason to have outside money.
- 7:49If you're risk averse, which I'd say most VCS are and you don't
- 7:52want to necessarily put your own Capital At Risk in a meaningful
- 7:55way like, you know, outside, right?
- 7:57So none of that applies to us and so in that case it's like
- 8:00it's just not a tool we need the second is and we can talk more
- 8:03about this. I think there's a, you know,
- 8:06what do you want to call it a prisoner's dilemma right now
- 8:09where everybody every manager, every VC is being rewarded for
- 8:15increasing the velocity of their Capital deployment.
- 8:18Every firm is Raising faster, bigger management fees.
- 8:22I know you're at You're leaving management fees.
- 8:24That's really helped. Ease are concerned about this,
- 8:28but at the same time, the last few years a venture has been
- 8:31Fantastic. Four, Tops of top, endowments
- 8:33and Foundations, not just paper, markups, real returns.
- 8:37And so their models say, reinvest this, into those VCS
- 8:41and in fact, when they're VC's, come back faster, and with
- 8:43bigger and Sequoias, like, hey, you gotta, you know, you gotta
- 8:47come in, you gotta come in in this big way or like, you know,
- 8:49by take it or leave it and they're like, okay, we're going
- 8:52to take it. You've been great for us, right?
- 8:53Like the amount of money that just keeps flowing into.
- 8:56The Venture ecosystem is larger and larger.
- 8:57I think it actually is leading to venture capital, I guess.
- 9:02Sort of like funding their own continued commoditization of
- 9:05capital. Like what does it mean?
- 9:06When just everybody is like 300 400 500 million dollars, you
- 9:10know or billion dollar a um it just becomes this like race to
- 9:13deploy it, you know? And I think for us it was like
- 9:17that is not interesting. Like that is a that is a
- 9:21impediment to us being able to Make measured choices to work
- 9:25with who we want and to be aligned with those Founders,
- 9:28right? Like look big fun when you say
- 9:30like, you know was an interesting to you, do you mean
- 9:32that? It also is not to the benefit of
- 9:34the founders as well. Like is there a real net
- 9:37negative for the industry? Look I think there's lots of
- 9:39playbooks, right? I believe that if you have a
- 9:43very large fund, hundreds, millions billions of dollars.
- 9:46That's going to implicit lie and explicitly Define what a success
- 9:49looks like, right? Like, it's just math.
- 9:51It's just the physics of Adventure.
- 9:53If you have a billion dollar fund, you know, a 400
- 9:57million-dollar exit, you know, sucks if you have 50 million
- 10:00dollars into that company, I believe that if you were going
- 10:04to be a focused early stage investor, you should try to have
- 10:08the smallest fund possible to run your strategy because I
- 10:11think it's not about, you know, betting on Lower outcomes.
- 10:15It's not about playing defense first offense, it's about having
- 10:18the patience to give that company.
- 10:21The time to figure out what Of company.
- 10:24It's going to be and then using Capital to help back it not the
- 10:29race to. Well can you get to the next
- 10:31round and 12 to 18 months, you know?
- 10:33Or you know it looks like you're not an outlier type of stuff.
- 10:35Look we have you know multiple multi billion dollar companies,
- 10:40you know in our fund one, right? Some of those realized some of
- 10:43those Still on paper you guys are backer and chime Rach.
- 10:45I'm plaid Cruz Gusto, you know, honor a few more, every one of
- 10:51those companies had a different First one to three years.
- 10:55Some were straight and up to the right and exited for more than a
- 10:58billion within that time Crews, some of them were up and down,
- 11:01you know, chime may be the most valuable of those.
- 11:04They almost didn't get, you know, two of their funding
- 11:06rounds done. Like it took longer for that
- 11:08model to prove itself and work. Neo Banks and fintech wasn't hot
- 11:11yet, right? So I just don't think you can
- 11:15forecast the eventual success of a company by the slope of the
- 11:20curve early on, you have to be prepared to work with.
- 11:23Them to figure out who they are then use Capital to accelerate
- 11:27it and I think if you the larger your fund, I think the less
- 11:30patient you are, the more eager you are for write-ups.
- 11:33The more, you're going to be selective, you know, maybe
- 11:36adversely selective of companies that are telling you they're
- 11:39only up into the right. And I just think Founders need
- 11:42more choices. They need more choices of
- 11:44different types of capital and so, you know, we want to be one
- 11:47of those choices. I think that what you just
- 11:49described sounds great. The reality.
- 11:51I have a question about though because Once you have a company
- 11:54and you start raising money, Founders are going to start
- 11:57raising from people in addition to your firm also, when they
- 12:01start raising money, say in a series B and they get on that,
- 12:06you know, and they're put on that conveyor belt of.
- 12:08Okay, now you're expected to raise money in a certain time.
- 12:13You're supposed to expect you to have a certain kind of exit and
- 12:15a certain kind of growth like your approach.
- 12:18Seems to me like it would get snowed under by the reality of
- 12:22the rest of the See market. So how do you still provide that
- 12:25kind of like patience and time for Founders if they're just
- 12:29going to raise their Series, be from Sequoia, I'm sorry.
- 12:32Beyond this. Like mad conveyor belt.
- 12:34Absolutely. Well you picked a very
- 12:35interesting moment because I usually tell Founders that up
- 12:37until the series be they actually have some optionality
- 12:40like depending on who they take money from like they have the
- 12:43ability to sort of say, look, we can take one step backwards to
- 12:46take to step forward. Hey, this is good, but not
- 12:48great, let's try something different.
- 12:50I actually sort of, you know, generally say series B is where
- 12:52you've given. Yup, most of that optionality
- 12:55and you start to move towards something that says we now have
- 13:00to both figure out how to keep growing, what we're doing and
- 13:03what's going to be the next growth driver?
- 13:04Write that and hopefully in a quote-unquote, perfect world,
- 13:08the series B is coming at a point at, which the company is
- 13:11ready for that sort of capital and ready for that sort of
- 13:13challenge in the fast-paced world of company announced its
- 13:17series a and that starts to Leading inbound on the series B.
- 13:20And the terms are great. And you take Capital early that
- 13:22actually in Risk people sometimes like oh I just raise
- 13:24fifty million dollars ID risk my company I'm like no way.
- 13:27You just re risked it like you just set the bar you have to get
- 13:31to even higher and the second thing I'll say is like look we
- 13:34like I said under the old model where we'd beat around.
- 13:37I don't want to talk about fun strategy the whole time but like
- 13:39I want to make sure like I do understand it.
- 13:43Do you think you'll make more money with this one strategy?
- 13:45Like it's more an absolute dollars.
- 13:47Yeah. Then what then like going and
- 13:49raising a 500 million dollar fund.
- 13:51Absolutely not right. So I mean maybe You'll have a
- 13:53better eye are potentially. And who cares?
- 13:55What's so for, who cares about Ira?
- 13:57It's unclear. If I want, if I want to maximize
- 13:59dollars, I might have stayed at Google like, who cares about?
- 14:02Like look, there's two ways to look at this.
- 14:04I think stuff like there is the I am above a floor in my, like
- 14:08personal Comfort, which makes you know, which makes things
- 14:11that I can add to it, you know, great.
- 14:14I can, I can donate more money or like, maybe I can buy a
- 14:19vacation house, like, that's wonderful.
- 14:20But those aren't things. I'm going to optimize for You
- 14:23know, I've been so, you know, lucky fortunate privilege,
- 14:27whatever that like I'm looking at it as I think if we're good
- 14:30at it, we can do just fine. And if I'm not good at it, I'm
- 14:34not. I do I'm not creating myself a
- 14:35lifestyle that requires, you know, a seven-figure salary
- 14:39every year or so and so forth. I think, I think wealth, you can
- 14:41look at his, like a floor or ceiling look so long as I'm
- 14:44above floor. I'm fine.
- 14:45And I'm going to optimize for other things or like, there's
- 14:47always a next number to get. I also wrote a blog post saying
- 14:50we don't talk enough about money, real enough, and Silicon
- 14:53Valley, right? It's a bunch of hand waving
- 14:55esac. You're basically saying you've
- 14:57made enough money. That you that you are wealthy
- 14:59enough that you don't need to optimize for wealth anymore.
- 15:02I can defer salary, I can defer a salary assume that I'm going
- 15:06to continue to be a relatively good investor and keep that
- 15:09upside in lieu of a salary but it's like makes true that if I
- 15:12make zero money that if I make zero dollars from now on it
- 15:16would be bad, right? Like yeah if but but but if it's
- 15:19lumpy and variable, that's okay. Yeah.
- 15:22And maybe you're seeing Bet that they're very rich in Silicon
- 15:25Valley. It's a weird thing.
- 15:26Like right look, I'm Silicon Valley.
- 15:28Middle class, right. Like which I winking lie.
- 15:30Joke is, you know, only like a multi multi-millionaire.
- 15:33You're not a cent a millionaire, but like shit.
- 15:36I mean, look, I was at, I was a Google from 2003 to 2012.
- 15:41If like, if I wasn't a millionaire from that, like I
- 15:43did something really wrong, but you're sweet.
- 15:47I mean, you had a 90 million dollar Fund in 2018, right?
- 15:50And now, you're saying like you're committing to more that
- 15:53you're To have more than your 1% stake before.
- 15:55So like you're going to be investing, like a million
- 15:58dollars are dating, get them order of magnitude.
- 16:00Here, it's we'd have wheat. So the way that I sort of
- 16:03describe it because we literally don't have a number is Sasha.
- 16:06And I each like mentally committed, you know, sort of
- 16:09like a number for the first one or two years and then as we,
- 16:13which is mostly going to be deployed.
- 16:14So like I think 80% of our checks are going to be like
- 16:17hundred K to 500k checks and then I think 20% will be later
- 16:20or larger. And so if we do like, let's say
- 16:22we do Ten twelve of those a year.
- 16:24Like I don't know where it averages out, but you can sort
- 16:26of like, figure out a low number, right?
- 16:28A high number, right? Like, that's that's what I
- 16:30think, you know, that's what I think we've committed.
- 16:32And then, as we see how that's doing as we hopefully continue
- 16:37to realize, like we have only seen, you know, we're in the
- 16:39carry-on fund one, and will continue to hopefully, you know,
- 16:43be able to return dollars to our investors and ourselves as that
- 16:45portfolio continue to mature. It's still too early to know how
- 16:48funds, two and three are going to be.
- 16:49I mean we're confident in it. But right, you know our goal is
- 16:52to Cycle recycled dollars, we see from the previous Homebrew
- 16:56funds into this new model, right?
- 16:58So like I'm we are dipping into our savings to get it started
- 17:02and then as money comes back, there may be richer in the
- 17:05future given our current portfolio and I am right, I am
- 17:09right. So, like I am going to be poorer
- 17:11in the near term then richer again.
- 17:13That's the goal. Well, that's just investing.
- 17:16Do you think? I mean look, you're obviously
- 17:17doing this as you're describing it because you feel it is, you
- 17:20know, fulfilling to your soul as to how you want to.
- 17:23A raft with these companies, I'd like to stay in the, if there's
- 17:25a 2 by 2, that's like low happiness, happiness, low
- 17:28success, High success. I much rather be I much rather
- 17:31focus on the being in the happiness with higher low
- 17:36success. Then the success with the higher
- 17:38low happiness and I believe that we can stay in the upper right
- 17:42quadrant of high happiness, High success.
- 17:44In this model, I think if we grew to 500 million, we'd still
- 17:48have a chance to stay in the success, but I believe we'd be
- 17:51deprecating the happiness, right?
- 17:53So but I guess I don't like managing people.
- 17:55I don't like you know having to do a bunch of internal politics.
- 17:58I don't like having to, you know, hobnob with other
- 18:01investors and if we had like 300 500 of those like anybody who's
- 18:04grown their fund over the last few years from, you know the 50
- 18:07million hundred million to the 300 million, 40 million, 500
- 18:09million, lots of wonderful, wonderful people, their lives
- 18:12changed, so dramatically and will be changing.
- 18:15So dramatically especially if the markets get choppy.
- 18:18Like I have no interest in spending my time and energy like
- 18:22justifying my A half a billion dollar fund, I just want to work
- 18:25with Founders, do you think the valley would operate more
- 18:29successfully or you know with a higher happiness quotient if
- 18:32more funds operated in the same way that you do because like
- 18:35this rush to increase fun sizes, it seems like it's fulfilling
- 18:39you know a need which is that there is money to deploy from
- 18:42the LPS. It tends to pervert the
- 18:45incentives. A lot of times of helping to
- 18:47successfully grow these companies.
- 18:48You know, you can build a reasonably sized company.
- 18:51Maybe that's profitable that doesn't need to Raised so many
- 18:53rounds of funding. But once you know, the
- 18:55incentives get put in there because of the types of
- 18:57investors. Everything sort of changes, I
- 18:59guess? What I'm asking is you think
- 19:00more fun Should operate like you guys are it's hard question.
- 19:03Because look what I want to be clear is we're not changing the
- 19:07bar for an investment like I'm still expecting Venture scale
- 19:11outcomes as part of our you know quote unquote you know Homebrew
- 19:14Evergreen portfolio. It just it just so means that
- 19:17like, if something doesn't, you know, get there, it still might
- 19:22be meaningful to us. Because it's our own money and
- 19:24we're keeping 100% of the Returns on Silver.
- 19:26There's also a lot of amazing work being done in, you know,
- 19:28being done in climate being done in bioscience, you know, nuclear
- 19:31fusion that like my model is not helpful for, right?
- 19:35Like you need people For Better or For Worse, you know, throwing
- 19:39hundreds of millions of dollars against those things and that's
- 19:41wonderful. People think that, you know,
- 19:43venture capital is just like fungible fuel, it's not it's
- 19:46Rocket Fuel, like it's not car fuel, it's not motorcycle fuel,
- 19:51you know, it's not RV fuel, all Which are like perfectly fine
- 19:54Vehicles if you wanna if Ike you're piloting that vehicle,
- 19:57like don't put rocket fuel in your vehicle, like it will
- 20:00destroy your vehicle, but like if it is a rocket, you know.
- 20:04It is a great Capital choice but yeah, your repeal that rocket
- 20:08fuel right? Yeah, yeah, okay.
- 20:11So, do you think that the types of Founders have changed about a
- 20:15decade ago, basically up until like probably the pandemic.
- 20:19What we thought of as a Silicon Valley entrepreneur Was pretty
- 20:24much a stereotype even if it wasn't a white guy was somebody
- 20:29who loves to work all the time. And I hate this phrase but who
- 20:33loves to Rise & Grind and just wants to go, go, go, go.
- 20:35Go, but what you're saying is that there's sort of an
- 20:38acceptance of a wider array of funding choices.
- 20:42You can have different kinds of companies with different kind of
- 20:44growth speeds. Are we seeing entrepreneurs
- 20:46change? Are we seeing the number of
- 20:48entrepreneurs went away? Now, that sort of like we've
- 20:51seen this first class. This like, you know, the sort of
- 20:55mid teens companies either succeed or not.
- 20:59We're seeing them all get sold off, you know.
- 21:00Yeah, we're kind of seeing the one that didn't succeed, really
- 21:03not succeed. So like are we seeing a
- 21:04different kind of founder? I think I'm an optimist in this
- 21:07scenario because I think you know, early stage Venture is
- 21:11probably still underfunded on a global basis, right?
- 21:14Like it's overfunded periodically in a particular,
- 21:16ZIP code or area code, you know, or like you know, particular
- 21:19idea but I think as software driven businesses No Marc
- 21:24Andreessen, says software eats the world.
- 21:25I sort of flattened that little bit to software enables the
- 21:27world that feels nicer but the that's why.
- 21:29And that's why I'm not a billionaire, the nicer side of
- 21:33Martin exercise. Yeah.
- 21:34So that leads me to believe that like, wow, maybe what we're
- 21:37seeing actually is the byproduct of like, you know, industrial
- 21:39capitalism, becomes technology capitalism, and businesses
- 21:42everywhere are being built with software and, and, you know, so
- 21:44and so forth. So I actually think there's tons
- 21:46of opportunity and that is not just because there's tons of
- 21:49capital available, like it's because there's tons of people
- 21:52who want to be entrepreneurs. And and as you know, as there
- 21:55are even in some cases out of desperation as there are fewer
- 21:59stable long-term job options, you know, maybe that
- 22:02incrementally continues to push people towards like, well,
- 22:04stability is actually building my own thing or, you know, or
- 22:06now, I can solve, I can use software to solve, you know, a
- 22:09problem for a business that predates, the PC, you know,
- 22:11agriculture, you know, construction all these
- 22:14industries that are really embracing software out of both,
- 22:17you know, opportunity necessity. I do believe that creates more
- 22:22and Foreign entrepreneurs. And I think some of the axioms
- 22:25that are now true, that maybe would have been disputed 10
- 22:29years ago or just like, you know, sort of cliche, 10 years
- 22:32ago now, true, or like good businesses.
- 22:34Can be built anywhere, right? Like, I think that was already
- 22:36happening in the last few years. Sort of proved that geography
- 22:39itself, you know, may not be sort of a limiting factor people
- 22:44used to say things like you know, and entrepreneurs can look
- 22:46like anybody right? And then you know, flash a
- 22:49portfolio page and they didn't look like anybody.
- 22:51You took a particular one type of then put them into a Gann
- 22:54with a bunch of like, you know, a i generated images that were
- 22:57all kind of like, oblong versions of the same person and
- 22:59like, oh look, but I do think that's changing, maybe not fast
- 23:03enough but like, I mean, I know in our portfolio.
- 23:05You know, we've always been sort of like, I think 50% or more of
- 23:08our companies have as at least one female founder, you know,
- 23:11that type of stuff and so it's happening.
- 23:13But do you still, you chase archetypes.
- 23:15I mean, oh, great question. Like these Charles Hudson.
- 23:18You know, had this tweet, like VC is a weird business if you
- 23:21look at it as a 2d business check.
- 23:23Sighs stage, it looks broadly competitive.
- 23:25If you add a third dimension, preferred founder Ike archetype.
- 23:29It becomes hyper competitive among small groups of peers and
- 23:33not competitive at all outside of that group.
- 23:35And you also wrote sort of about mission-driven Founders and how
- 23:40that wasn't always a great archetype.
- 23:41So, I guess how do you think about sort of still chasing or
- 23:45maybe you don't, but chasing founder archetypes, in a world
- 23:48where you're trying to have more diverse just just just to
- 23:51correct. I said, Ed, I love
- 23:53mission-driven. Founders.
- 23:54Here are some of the places that they get themselves into trouble
- 23:57As Leaders, okay? And, and the ways that that they
- 24:00can avoid or address those because I love mr.
- 24:03Dhanraj, I also wrote something. That basically talks about
- 24:05consent is my is my job as an investor, a rocket fuel.
- 24:09Investor is my job to find and win consensus steals, or is it
- 24:14to find and bet on non-consensus ones?
- 24:17And it's funny you ask that question to different people and
- 24:19some will be like more people than I expected say.
- 24:24It's a good strategy. It's like what's the hot start
- 24:26up right corner, keep raising. And what do I mean by consensus?
- 24:29Consensus is, you know, pattern matching archetypes working in
- 24:32an area that people understand with some social proof, you
- 24:35know, on the cap table a little bit of momentum.
- 24:37Those have traded off the charts, right?
- 24:39So like that's where prices have gone up.
- 24:41So dramatically, non-consensus startups, people who don't
- 24:45pattern match. Some of the archetypes are
- 24:46talking about working in industries that aren't yet
- 24:49trendy Adventure or are out of favor in Venture.
- 24:51Those actually are where the quote unquote.
- 24:53Deals are still meant, you know, Stu still exists.
- 24:55If you want to be a smaller fund.
- 24:56Like, otherwise, if you're if you're underwriting to 2 x, 3 x
- 24:59returns, you know, and you're just trying to win the consensus
- 25:03deals and they the the outcomes are bigger than ever then.
- 25:05Fine go and continue to pattern match.
- 25:07I guess. I would say that any archetype
- 25:10that is both well understood and correct is eventually going to
- 25:15see the prophet? Multiple back to the investor
- 25:19compressed because that's where the competition occurs.
- 25:23So, yes, it's sort of reasonable fund strategy to say.
- 25:28I have an eye of archetypes that are correct, but not yet, widely
- 25:32understood that I'm going to invest in because that is the
- 25:35true definition, maybe of contrary it, right?
- 25:37Like contrarian is not, you know, investing in people who
- 25:40dropped out of college, right, you know, like maybe it was
- 25:43when, you know, Peter and others did whatever but like that's not
- 25:46contrarian. Now like contrarian is not going
- 25:49into YC like that, you know, that that that's Harvard.
- 25:53Now, right, like to have it. So do you have an archetype
- 25:56these sort of this become more consensus?
- 25:59Since you started or I have personality traits that I care
- 26:02about? I have, I have found her traits
- 26:05that I care about maybe more than the average Venture
- 26:07investor because a, they're matched to the type of people, I
- 26:12enjoy getting up and, and working on behalf of putting
- 26:14sweat and and reputation behind and agenda dollars and two.
- 26:18I think they were sort of the trade-offs that come with those
- 26:21are things that I think we can help solve.
- 26:23You know, help them versus, you know, risks that, I'm not that
- 26:27I'm not good at the risking, right?
- 26:28And so, what I've always said is like I'm happy to have teams
- 26:32that don't have a technical founder, but have, you know,
- 26:35technology awareness. They're going to bring the
- 26:37technology in house but it's not like the two Founders are
- 26:39technologists. Now we have plenty that are
- 26:41right. So it's not a it's not a
- 26:43bifurcation is just hey I'll look at those.
- 26:45How about I respond to? I respond to every cold email,
- 26:48right? Like I don't care about warm
- 26:50introductions and networks as an archetype.
- 26:53I think a lot of the best folks, you know, are outside of
- 26:56networks. Now, that doesn't mean that they
- 26:58like, you don't have to prove that they can do something
- 27:01interesting. I, those cold emails are best
- 27:04when they include, like a link to a demo of something.
- 27:07They built or product that a customer is ready using rather
- 27:09than just like, you know, hey fun me and I'll build this,
- 27:12right? I am perfectly happy to back
- 27:15people who don't have a traditional educational pedigree
- 27:18in a so they like one of one of the examples in our first fund
- 27:21that like will stick with The longest and maybe in some ways,
- 27:25I'm proudest of was in the construction space, a company
- 27:28called building connected to Founders again, not part of the
- 27:31network, not Stanford, not Facebook, cold email, we LED
- 27:34their seed round. I sat on their board, they
- 27:36raised up to a b round, they had a growth term sheet on the table
- 27:40and also a 300 million dollar acquisition from Autodesk for a
- 27:43bunch of reasons. You know, we were perfectly
- 27:45happy to support them going on. I think there are scenarios
- 27:48where it could have been a multibillion-dollar business,
- 27:50but I think they correctly for themselves decided did that
- 27:53selling to Autodesk was the right thing because they haven't
- 27:56because I didn't over capitalize the company and because they
- 27:58were good investors around the table that was meaningful for
- 28:02every investor it returned half our fund because you know, got
- 28:05it got in early concentrate, early stage, it changed the
- 28:08founders lies multi-generationally.
- 28:10You know, one of them started a fan of started a foundation.
- 28:13A scholarship at his high school to send people to college came
- 28:16from an area where, you know, college wasn't the default.
- 28:19The Next Step type of stuff he benefited from something like
- 28:21that prior early. Chloe is all made out, you know,
- 28:24well because the company had over diluted one of the founders
- 28:26did a year at Autodesk, handcuffs are off, you know,
- 28:29went and now a CEO of another thing.
- 28:30The other one is still there. Leading a thousand people,
- 28:32right? I am so and, you know, look, I
- 28:35have a lot of problems with the way, our governments working
- 28:37different types of things in equality, but like that, for me,
- 28:39was a heck. Yeah.
- 28:40Capitalism moment, right? Because where else, can a guy
- 28:43who worked in construction for a few years and his technical
- 28:46buddy? You know, decide that they're
- 28:48going to step away from jobs? Not because they have trust
- 28:50funds and not but because they like have an urgent problem,
- 28:52they want to solve. Solve for an industry that, you
- 28:54know, has been ignored by people, you know, coming out of,
- 28:58you know, maybe some more traditional colleges
- 28:59universities or even worse, targeted, just because it's big
- 29:03and quote-unquote broken. And the sales people can go
- 29:05interface with the construction folks.
- 29:07We don't want to like we're not going to get our hands dirty.
- 29:09Like this is a guy who's like hands, you know, grew up hands
- 29:11dirty and was able to build something that the industry
- 29:14wanted that you know was not a hundred billion dollar, actually
- 29:19a billion dollar acquisition by somebody that was later written
- 29:21down to zero because it was a The pan.
- 29:23Like, you know, it's been doing great for Autodesk and were able
- 29:27to take economics away from it. That like, you know, now like
- 29:30fundamentally, they would not have been able to do in anything
- 29:33other than like, entrepreneurs. I'm and by the way, because we
- 29:37take a concentrated, early-stage reproach.
- 29:38Like I said, I can actually have it be a home run for us, you
- 29:41know, not just a single double like, uh, okay.
- 29:45We got one X our money back, you know, I guess we'll make it
- 29:47somewhere else, right? Like, I love those, I would
- 29:49never give up the opportunity ability.
- 29:53To like support and back, those Founders, you know, you know,
- 29:55just to sort of, you know, Chase the chase.
- 29:58What everybody else is doing speechless.
- 30:01I love it because that's like the such a much.
- 30:11Oh, I'm sorry for the industry. Oh yeah, let's talk about this,
- 30:14you know. So I have like I have companies
- 30:17in the portfolio that thankfully now like are starting to get
- 30:19coverage, but like any time people want to be like, oh, hey,
- 30:23Meet. Let me, let me write a takedown
- 30:24of this, like, halfway interesting company orders.
- 30:27I get the most feedback on. We're not necessarily negative
- 30:29stories, you know, I wrote a story about a school, like a
- 30:33coding Academy, that just very unusually accepted students who
- 30:38didn't have a lot of money who didn't have any background in
- 30:39Tech and the story itself. Go, I had tons of incoming.
- 30:45First of all, people who wanted to fix.
- 30:46Also, there are also people who were not business, you know, New
- 30:50York Times, Like business section readers, who are happy P
- 30:53to hear that. Something was happening in
- 30:54Silicon Valley, that wasn't atrocious, and then third of
- 30:57all. I wrote that story years ago and
- 30:59I just got a note from somebody saying, oh, I remember this
- 31:02person, you wrote about he was living in his car while he was
- 31:05going to the school. He went to Hobart and I don't, I
- 31:08mean, he was homeless, when he went yeah Burton and he was the
- 31:10leader of the story, he has an extraordinary job.
- 31:13Now, he works, you know, for so great.
- 31:15I can't say which three-letter agency, but he's doing very
- 31:18well. Right?
- 31:19Look, I love it. That's like I do think we love
- 31:21those stories. I don't want it.
- 31:23People think we are look how I'm not a hey Tech doesn't tell
- 31:25enough Goods you know protect price doesn't do enough.
- 31:27Good stories you only one but I'm also a whole truth to power
- 31:30hold true that repair. Right?
- 31:31Like, you know, I think the biggest challenge our industry
- 31:34faces, is it sees? Its it continues to see itself
- 31:37as an underdog when it's actually the railroad Barons,
- 31:40right? Like kind of goes back to that
- 31:42idea that like nobody in Silicon Valley wants to admit just how
- 31:44rich they are. It's like they kind of want to
- 31:46admit it by being like hey I sit Courtside or I do this or I have
- 31:51this crazy house but they don't want to like be 0.
- 31:53Open about the fact that they have basically fuck you money
- 31:56and they can live almost completely outside of well, even
- 31:58outside of the democratic support, that it was, or that,
- 32:01it was somehow, our, it was its Noble, like, it's Noble money.
- 32:04That's how that money is more noble than, right then other
- 32:07because well, but if it went to like, you know, a teacher's
- 32:10right? Well, it's the same way.
- 32:11I think I'll write founder is getting nostalgic about the
- 32:13early days or times where they were just hanging out in a small
- 32:17office, just trying to make it work because you know, obviously
- 32:20their precarious relatively But you are able to focus more on
- 32:25the mission, what you think permission is rather than, you
- 32:28know, trying to please your investors.
- 32:30And I feel like, you know, the same thing kind of comes up and
- 32:32criticizing their critical Tech stories.
- 32:34It just like, weren't we having so much fun when it was all
- 32:37about, you know, highlighting funding announcements.
- 32:39Yeah, I'd say the two things I had the two things I do.
- 32:42Wish when it comes to reporting, is I do wish that and I think
- 32:47the, I think the longer somebody's in it either, they
- 32:50understand this or they actually move further away from It, I
- 32:53wish folks could actually embed within.
- 32:55I wish folks had done a start-up or could embed in with a
- 32:57start-up because often what sort of like perceived as a specific
- 33:03choice. You know, is sort of more like
- 33:04at at worst an unintended consequence.
- 33:06I would love by the way. So work out of any New York City
- 33:10startups office for a month. I work out of my home, so I'm
- 33:13happy, right? Have you have you asked, have
- 33:15you put that out there? All right.
- 33:17Well, I'm throwing this out on the podcast.
- 33:19Yeah, we were on a start-up with the information, but but I would
- 33:23Right. And look at it but the people I
- 33:25would like to do that. Kind of story.
- 33:27I mean I would love to I would also argue that the three of us
- 33:29did work out of a startup. I mean we actually do you think
- 33:34we're going to do two things? This, when this podcast drops we
- 33:37are going to find Erica started. Yes.
- 33:39Second. Ya what I'll say about?
- 33:41Kate about the information is I think Jessica one of Jessica's
- 33:44early columns was like what? I Now understand, you know,
- 33:49working at a startup that I didn't understand when I was
- 33:51covering that right? Look just Something like like
- 33:54sometimes like, oh I used to take every product, you know,
- 33:56get a cancelled as like, oh, this is so, you know, this is
- 33:58smoke. I gotta find the fire.
- 33:59Something must be really wrong and like, I've had to now, I've
- 34:02had to cancel products sometimes just because, like, you got to
- 34:04focus or this or that, it's right.
- 34:06Not, you know, it's not scanned, you know, like a few things.
- 34:08And, but obviously also, you know, doesn't mean that like
- 34:11every sort of perfect and should be treated with kid gloves and
- 34:13like, you know, that type of stuff, you know, I look back at
- 34:17work, I don't know if you want to get to the YouTube stuff, but
- 34:18like, I look back at YouTube and like there were things that I
- 34:23did not recognize, you know, they were, they were second
- 34:26order effects that some of the choices we made that were not
- 34:29obvious to me at the time. I don't know if any sort of
- 34:34quote unquote process changes would have made them more
- 34:37apparent to me. I do firmly believe, and we
- 34:39tried as best. We could to have a product team
- 34:42that looked more like our user base, then Google demographics,
- 34:45let's say. But I also believe that like,
- 34:48actually, the way to sort of, you know, anticipate unintended
- 34:52consequences would say. Say is in team composition to
- 34:55demographics that like the more diverse more diversity
- 35:00Geographic, you know, class-based ethnicity, whatever.
- 35:04The right the right facing is that you have on your product
- 35:07team and the more that those people are out to speak and
- 35:11bring their experience to that. I think the more likely you are
- 35:14to sort of debate anticipate and properly like you know, judge
- 35:18how your product is going to be used, right?
- 35:20Like the everything is gamergate, you know, now, right?
- 35:22Like it, If you didn't, if you don't know what that is, or you
- 35:24didn't experience it or so and so forth.
- 35:26Like you're building a social product.
- 35:27You should probably understand right as your, as your worldview
- 35:29evolved or I, you know, I know you some but not I think of you,
- 35:33you know, from your Twitter presence and like you're like
- 35:36sort of good liberal in Tech world, right?
- 35:40Or did you see yourself that way or like?
- 35:42I feel like there's sort of a lot of night might not my exact
- 35:45tagline. No, you wouldn't.
- 35:48Would you yesterday, I sort of like to be.
- 35:52See. I thought Funniest TV series.
- 35:54What that's all about that. That was the threat.
- 35:59I was the Lobos. Yeah.
- 36:00And you just a great your often, like I feel like, you know,
- 36:03there's this a lot of these Tech platforms had sort of a very
- 36:07like sort of, you know, Free Speech was the by word.
- 36:10It like, read it back in the day.
- 36:12There was such like that long period where there was like, no,
- 36:15you know, we don't want to moderate, we want to have an
- 36:17open platform. I mean, YouTube is still like
- 36:21pretty loose. But then, you know, I feel like,
- 36:25yeah, it's been sort of the the mainstream Democrats who have
- 36:29been much more pronounced but I don't, I don't know how to pull
- 36:31it. I mean, obviously, I tend to
- 36:33vote Democrat but like, I don't know how to, I don't know how to
- 36:36counter. I don't know how to categorize
- 36:37myself in sort of the same way that you did.
- 36:39But here's what I'll say about you too, and, and those sort of
- 36:42close supporter of AOC weren't you.
- 36:45I remember seeing you sweet positively.
- 36:46Yeah, I helped. Yeah, I saw China and our spouse
- 36:49right? Somehow crazy.
- 36:50That do the first. We'll look, I think Even outside
- 36:53of whether you agree with all her policies that like she is an
- 36:57archetype for a type of leader that we need to see unlike you
- 37:01know, both sides of the aisle and also I grew up in Queens.
- 37:04718 born 516 raised. So I was at YouTube from 2007 to
- 37:10end of 2012. These people said, when you
- 37:12leave Google, I'm like, well, my heart kind of left in middle of
- 37:142011, my daughter and a 2012, but but it was great.
- 37:18I was, so I was the first product lead post-acquisition
- 37:21working, you know, for Chad and Stuff like that.
- 37:24I think there were a few things. I believed about YouTube, then
- 37:26that were atypical. And some of them have become
- 37:31more normalized. Some of them are still debatable
- 37:34and I think the things I believed and, and tried to build
- 37:37it to the product tried to build into the team were, that we are
- 37:41not quote unquote and agnostic platform, right?
- 37:45That like the oh, well, we're not immediately.
- 37:47I wouldn't call some Media company either.
- 37:49But like if you have terms and conditions and Community
- 37:52standards, That are anything beyond just what is minimally
- 37:55legally required? You are already making editorial
- 37:58decisions, you're making decisions about what sort of
- 38:00content you want on the platform.
- 38:01So on so forth to say that like you're neutral is is not true.
- 38:04And I think that's fine. I also tried to build out with a
- 38:08great policy team build out policies that were
- 38:12principle-based and then we could evolve the definitions
- 38:15because it's very hard to do the reverse.
- 38:18It's very hard to have enough like case law to where you can
- 38:20perfectly right. You know what?
- 38:23There's always gonna be gray area and I think the clearest
- 38:25thing is like, here is the type of service we are trying to
- 38:28build. You know, if you do things that
- 38:30like defaults are these boundaries, like there might be
- 38:33consequences, here are some examples of that, but people are
- 38:35going to come up with new examples, right?
- 38:37And you can't wait a year to then update it, like, you have
- 38:39to try to address it in the moment.
- 38:41So I think it's okay to actually like create some expectations of
- 38:45how people of what's okay. And then, you know, reviewing of
- 38:49all those over time and sometimes it's okay to be wrong,
- 38:51like we were wrong, about some stuff like What?
- 38:53I'll tell you one second and the third that I've always believed
- 38:55in because I was at Second Life and AdSense before is, I've
- 38:58always believed and this Chad believe this too.
- 39:00I mean thankfully because I couldn't have got it done on my
- 39:03own was that you know, likes and retweets are not payment and
- 39:07that creators, you know, deserve payment for their creativity and
- 39:10audience. And that if you are not doing
- 39:13that, as a platform at the best case scenario, you're leaving a
- 39:17strategic hole. Open for somebody else to do it.
- 39:19Worst case scenario. You are exploiting people and I
- 39:22never Ever wanted to exploit. I never wanted to work for a
- 39:25company that exploited people. So Katie just real quick.
- 39:28We always had the question of like, policy made in the Bay
- 39:32Area. You know, sometimes in the East
- 39:34Bay, depending upon where we were sitting like is East Bay
- 39:37policies, you know, like good for the world, right?
- 39:40And so, for example, there were certainly geographies especially
- 39:44ones that we didn't operate in, but we're available in that
- 39:46sometimes asked you to do things to content.
- 39:49Mostly take down that we did not abide by because we We weren't
- 39:53commercial operating their, their country, we didn't believe
- 39:55in those principles, you know, it was more towards the Free
- 39:58Speech, but when we were operating in a country, we
- 40:00really did have to understand. Like, okay, we've got people on
- 40:03the ground, their employees on the ground.
- 40:04Like, if we're going to be operate, commercially in this
- 40:08country, what is right, what is wrong?
- 40:10I'm gonna, I'm probably gonna get a load of this wrong.
- 40:11Apologies to any Thai people but like it's, it's, it's it's out
- 40:15of humility. If I remember correctly, like
- 40:17there was, you know, this thing in Thailand, where the
- 40:20government asked us to take down some videos that were I'm like
- 40:23photoshop's of you know like bare feet on the heads of very
- 40:28influential or maybe even religious you know our political
- 40:31tie figures to us. That looks like you know, know
- 40:35where I could take this down. Like that's like free speech and
- 40:38it's silly but then you'd sort of start to see those videos
- 40:40getting flagged and they weren't getting flag from like
- 40:43government IPS like they're getting Flack from actual users
- 40:46and you'd look for the reasons that are like.
- 40:47This is actually like this actually is offensive like you
- 40:51know to us and I don't want to Go vagina was like, well, now we
- 40:54understand that people but like there was enough Grassroots and
- 40:57so we didn't take it down but we did put up an interest.
- 40:59Yeah. We've created a new type of
- 41:00interstitial that was basically like this complies with our
- 41:03terms of service but users in your country find it
- 41:05objectionable for the following like you know category since and
- 41:08people could click through and so like we want.
- 41:10But trust me like the first thing you know that we thought
- 41:13was like skepticism and dismissiveness, right?
- 41:15And we learned like no like if you're going to have a global
- 41:19footprint Global responsibilities, you have to
- 41:21sometimes realize that Your first assumptions or what you're
- 41:25comfortable with or what you're uncomfortable with does not
- 41:27match you know, your community where they are.
- 41:31And so make those tough decisions, right?
- 41:34Thigh like the 60 philosophically.
- 41:36I'm so curious about this because I think the biggest tech
- 41:39companies have decided that in general.
- 41:42What they'll do is they'll comply with the laws and in some
- 41:46ways, the Norms of the companies in which they operate.
- 41:49But at what point does a big tech company have to decide.
- 41:52Okay. Okay, we cannot really comply
- 41:55with either of those things, it doesn't work for us.
- 41:57And does that mean that the idea of a global tech company,
- 42:02especially consumer-facing is something?
- 42:04We'll see chipped away out over the next few years.
- 42:08My answer is like, I don't know, I think that there is a
- 42:11perfectly viable path that basically says, we are going to
- 42:17operate on each country's laws and there is a set of red lines.
- 42:21There's a minimum Set of like yeah of things that need to be
- 42:24in place for us to operate in that country.
- 42:26So like some some set of choices if there's a bunch of different
- 42:29toggles like some combination of those toggles based on Country
- 42:33law mean, that we are going to forego operating in that
- 42:37country. And that will be more granular
- 42:39and broader than just the China issue, right?
- 42:42Like, historically this has been, like the China issue.
- 42:44Is it worth trying to operate there because, you know, you can
- 42:47change from within and it's a big, you know, big Market
- 42:50opportunity, or is it a quagmire?
- 42:52Are you have to compromise too many of your stated values
- 42:55around user privacy or, you know, freedom of expression, you
- 42:59know, and information to, you know, to spin up your service.
- 43:02So I do think we're going to, hopefully see you.
- 43:04No more companies being deliberate about what those
- 43:06choices are and maybe denying their services to countries that
- 43:13seem to be not good actors. Right.
- 43:15But I don't know. Like this is, this is, this was
- 43:17a tough one. But anyone who builds Global
- 43:19Services like has to has to think through this obviously,
- 43:22right? It was like, Wow but it's, you
- 43:24know. But again, like I don't feel bad
- 43:26for companies doing with this. Like this is, you have trillion
- 43:29dollar market caps, like, you have, you know, Executives who,
- 43:32you know, this is what you signed up for, right?
- 43:34Like, but that's I mean, that's the thing.
- 43:35I mean, the negotiation at some point isn't really so much
- 43:38between the user. You know, the companies and the
- 43:40government sits between the companies and their investors
- 43:43because the expectation is that you do operate in all these
- 43:45countries because you need to continue grow, you know, can you
- 43:48grow your user base and extracting?
- 43:50What, you know, this is actually that users I would, I To take a
- 43:53set of notes on things, I needed to accomplish during this
- 43:55podcast, and I forgot to do that.
- 43:57But now you just prompted me because we're audio not video.
- 43:59Usually, during video podcast, I change my hat and Hoodie a few
- 44:03times to different to promote different portfolio companies.
- 44:06Okay, you know, you're supporting so I figure I'm gonna
- 44:08have to do that audio audio wise.
- 44:11So I happen to be a personal investor in a company called
- 44:13long-term Stock Exchange that are gree started, which is about
- 44:16giving companies a chance to list in a place where you And
- 44:23bias towards maybe even create voting struggle, sort of put
- 44:28proposals together that we reward investors who are going
- 44:32to be long-term holders and allow you to think long term,
- 44:35right? Still, very nascent.
- 44:37There's some companies that have pledged, you know, to be on
- 44:39their a sauna. So and so forth but like I am
- 44:41actually hopeful that there is going to be investor structures
- 44:45that better match against like you know and not just be corpse
- 44:49that better match against you know sort of the types of
- 44:51trade-offs. You're talking about Tom I'll
- 44:53tell you one thing. So I always this is I always say
- 44:55the sort of jokingly but I also kind of not joking.
- 44:58So like my solution to this issue of like what Facebook yo
- 45:02what truth is being discussed on Facebook and like you know, it's
- 45:06safe in Menlo Park but not great in Sri Lanka.
- 45:08We're were the sort of you know quote unquote, Facebook me, Adam
- 45:12are right, wasn't it? Yeah.
- 45:13So here's my joke, not joke, kind of thing.
- 45:16Like take the Facebook's executive team or even better
- 45:19like board of directors, it is going to change, you know,
- 45:21annually. But like Shirley Jackson The
- 45:23Lottery like once a year. One of you is going to have to
- 45:27make your major life choices based upon what the average
- 45:30Facebook user believes, right? So if the average Facebook user
- 45:33believes that vaccinations, you know, are fake, because that's
- 45:37what's been spread, like, you can't get vaccinated or let you
- 45:40know, basically how do we like, you know, it's obvious joke but
- 45:43like it's the sort of the question about when, when
- 45:46leadership of these companies essentially are in an Elysium
- 45:49that is so distanced from the The downstream impacts and
- 45:54downstream consequences that their products are are
- 45:59influencing these. It's almost as if they had to
- 46:01live under it. They would want a nudge.
- 46:03These people to have used that they found palatable or not
- 46:06palatable that lower like the more amenable to their
- 46:10lifestyle. I mean, you see that three
- 46:11people to dislike downplay the ideas and not allow them to be
- 46:14the most prominent ideas, but it's an interesting Twist on.
- 46:18You're trying to make something that normally is position is
- 46:21elitist that the I would try to direct how people think and
- 46:26you're sort of saying well if the elites want to live under a
- 46:28the world they're creating they should have to have to suffer it
- 46:32or is that just what you think? That's sort of like the Khan
- 46:35Academy. Somebody's a writer to me.
- 46:42It's like the idea that Ben Shapiro and like Dom, Boingo, or
- 46:45whatever, I don't even know, but like these people are like it.
- 46:49Is that In the world to me, if you would
- 47:05agree with this would be is evidence enough that something
- 47:08is broken with the platform. Why would you want to create a
- 47:11product where the thing you're building audience for is like
- 47:15Ben Shapiro? I don't know.
- 47:17I feel like that's sort of a. Problem.
- 47:20Like, just the same way, I wouldn't want to run Fox News.
- 47:22Have Tucker Carlson me by my banner show.
- 47:25I wouldn't want to own a tech company and have like these
- 47:28really dumb. Conte, conservative, content,
- 47:31creators, be sort of the top output at that, I'm putting out,
- 47:35or do you have what he would unique Jew hate.
- 47:37You hate 43% of America. Is that what you're saying
- 47:40there? He does.
- 47:41Yeah, I grew up in another area so it is right.
- 47:46Yeah yeah. I mean they're yeah enjoy Rush
- 47:48Soros dollars Rush Limbaugh is like was terrible.
- 47:52And you know people are very responsive, you know, they
- 47:55listen to what what you put out and that's why it matters, what
- 47:58Elites like pump out to the world.
- 48:00And I think I just I think the distance between you know the
- 48:04experience of the quote-unquote average person and the 1% is
- 48:07like you know the quote the greatest threat to stability,
- 48:09right. And the fact that I can look, I
- 48:11don't know the guy but I believe that, you know, there are people
- 48:14like Peter teal who like, you know, sort of are calculating
- 48:17enough that like look the chaos ladder is going to benefit me
- 48:21and if things go to shitty I have Of money to insulate
- 48:23myself, the chaos, that, you know, Bannon created, right,
- 48:27like and maybe that's maybe that's really, you know, maybe
- 48:30he's playing 7D chest for a better brighter, glorious shared
- 48:34future. But like, that's what I worry
- 48:36about. Like I worry about when some of
- 48:37our, some of our billionaires, you know, can sort of insulate
- 48:41themselves from the challenges of the world, and I have nothing
- 48:44against billionaires in general. So, I liked, I liked when our
- 48:48Industries billionaires were just awkward and not assholes,
- 48:51and they were just kind of like, Nerdy trying to figure out what
- 48:55to do with their money, going to basketball games and getting
- 48:58awkwardly video. Dancing around, it's fine.
- 49:01Yeah, I know. I look, how do I think it's a,
- 49:03it's a fascinating point in in Agra and I see, you know, I
- 49:07during that during the back and forth.
- 49:08I mentioned this. But like, you know, covering
- 49:10Uber there was always, I don't know if Travis did this Eric
- 49:13Kidd, you can tell me, but, you know, dhara makes deliveries
- 49:16from time to time, you know, because he wants to see what the
- 49:18average user you know. Deliver person.
- 49:21It's like and you know, maybe at the That kind of changes some of
- 49:24the benefits that they give them or subsidies or things like
- 49:27that. But you know, it's do you think
- 49:30there would be a substantive difference?
- 49:32If, you know, Susan with Jackie was in a country that has been
- 49:35overrun by misinformation YouTube's.
- 49:39And the, I mean, maybe she has been, I don't know.
- 49:42I used to spend time in the review, the flag video review,
- 49:45Q, fairly like, I don't remember if I did it.
- 49:48Monthly or quarterly, I don't like overstate it, but I would
- 49:50do that because I felt like it. It was unfair to ask, you know,
- 49:56I don't care if they're in contractors employees.
- 49:58Would it was unfair to ask you human beings to, you know, look
- 50:02at flag videos which we know could have some very bad things
- 50:05in it. If the product managers and if
- 50:08the leadership only saw it as statistics on a piece of paper
- 50:12or like, you know, when people are when you get the stuff
- 50:15that's like, oh well, you know, Facebook says, 99.8% of, you
- 50:18know of post, didn't contain beheadings, you know, you're
- 50:21like wait, hold on. Like point two percent like
- 50:23that, still hundreds of thousands of be Hetty.
- 50:26Oh, watch that live streams of and not to pick on them because
- 50:29you know, this was this was a YouTube thing and I saw, you
- 50:32know, I saw just about everything but child porn and
- 50:34that's because child porn is actually pretty easy to filter
- 50:38out algorithmically because it's one of the areas where like
- 50:42content fingerprinting is shared amongst companies and so on.
- 50:44So worth it does mean it's probably just means it just
- 50:47means like it actually didn't get to the, to the but I saw be.
- 50:51I saw, I saw, you know, I has beheadings.
- 50:53I saw all different types of graphic poor.
- 50:56I you know, and like having to watch you having to see the
- 51:01things you cannot unsee. I do think creates a different
- 51:06visceral impact upon the leadership of these companies,
- 51:09than just seeing it in text as a summary report and trying to,
- 51:14you know, sort of debate. Well, you know, should we put
- 51:16resources on making that number go up or down, you know, or
- 51:19should we put more money on Advertising?
- 51:21You know, right away, that matters.
- 51:22I'm a social media Elite worried about, you know, having to live
- 51:27under the ideology that I'm programming into the masses.
- 51:30Like what, what is the lever that I pull to make sure that I
- 51:34can still take the vaccine? Or, I don't know.
- 51:37Do you, what do you think? I mean, there are certain moves
- 51:39that would seem to bias things just politically versus see more
- 51:44neutral, or, I don't know. Do you have like a prescription?
- 51:48The first is diverse teams anticipate, you know, sort of
- 51:52the outlier use cases, so have diverse teams.
- 51:55The second is the senior Executives at social media
- 51:58companies should be exposed to and occasionally do the job of
- 52:02the lowest level folks who are often the content reviewers.
- 52:05If you are just seeing, you know, sort of reports and
- 52:09statistics and not actually understanding what people are
- 52:11dealing with. You know, I think you lose
- 52:13empathy for it. The third is that we have to
- 52:16maybe come to grips that. In some of these companies that
- 52:18they're not software. Margin companies, write
- 52:20software, margin means, high margin He used to make a CD-ROM
- 52:24of a, you know, of a Excel, you know, whatever.
- 52:27Distributed in shrink wrap boxes and there are no marginal costs
- 52:30of, you know, each new each new box outside of the cardboard and
- 52:34that's what our that's what investors and Wall Street, you
- 52:36know, sort of demand. And so as a result in these
- 52:39sorts of services trust and safety is staffed.
- 52:42As a cost center, it's a drain on margin and so you want to
- 52:45minimize trust and safety minimize can customer support to
- 52:50not put your software margins at.
- 52:52Risk. And so I think it is a vector
- 52:55for, you know, when we talk about regulatory, you know, I
- 52:57think there's actually some interesting questions about, are
- 53:00you Staffing, trust and safety and responsiveness to different
- 53:03types of flagged content and so on and so forth, you know,
- 53:06proportionate to your Content Volume.
- 53:08So that the worst types of things that are occurring, you
- 53:10know, on the system aren't live for hours days weeks, while they
- 53:16crawl through multiple tiers of support and so on so forth.
- 53:19And so like no, I don't want real time.
- 53:22Evaluation of every YouTube video, right?
- 53:24It doesn't scale and perpetuity but I think that there's this
- 53:28question about our we Staffing to the level of public good or
- 53:32we Staffing to the level of, you know, a margin structure that
- 53:36we've convinced ourselves, these companies should have even if it
- 53:39creates more negative externalities you know for the
- 53:42world. You know what's interesting
- 53:43about that specifically though is that listening in on Facebook
- 53:46earnings call Ducks was you know he was signaling for a long time
- 53:51that they were going to be making Being a multi-billion
- 53:53dollar investments in their trust and safety teams and it
- 53:56would have a material impact on profits.
- 53:58And from my understanding of it, that didn't affect the company's
- 54:01valuation too much. I mean, the thing that really
- 54:04tanked, Facebook was when it was a pure business problem, right?
- 54:07Yeah. When they look and this is, I
- 54:08think over the last year to this is change a little bit as
- 54:10because I think I think it's become, you know, I've been.
- 54:13Yeah. Right.
- 54:14So like Susan, you know, the Nook, I'm sure there's been more
- 54:17growth in, you know, over the last few years on these teams
- 54:21than there were in the first year.
- 54:22To 15 to 20 and that's a good thing and I think that's frankly
- 54:25been that that that wasn't internally motivated, right?
- 54:28I think that came in response to press scrutiny, regulatory
- 54:32scrutiny, you know, contractor complaints, that type of stuff
- 54:35and it's great. So maybe like, you know, maybe
- 54:37we're halfway there already but you know, if you were going to
- 54:40look and say what's, you know, for the next generation of these
- 54:43sorts of things for the, for the metaverse, you know, whatever.
- 54:45Like you know, what are some standards to evaluate whether
- 54:48they're likely to go you know stay on the rails or go off the
- 54:51rails. It's you know, Are you
- 54:53developing trust and safety in a way that scales to an
- 54:57experienced goal or, you know, or to a to a margin goal.
- 55:01We have to let you go. But like, I mean one thing the
- 55:04media companies do is assess, you know, like sources is this
- 55:08person, generally honest, or if I run an op-ed page, you know,
- 55:12are they making strong arguments?
- 55:14You know, there's like this human assessment of the quality
- 55:18of the product that you're putting out, right?
- 55:21And so if your ex Expanding and certainly for like the top sort
- 55:26of traffic generators on a platform, it's not a big enough
- 55:30set. It's a small enough set that,
- 55:32you know, it's knowable to those social media platforms.
- 55:34I mean, do you think they should apply media level standards,
- 55:39like actual quality filters? I never liked using the word
- 55:43quality for me, especially say it at YouTube, quality refers to
- 55:47bitrate not, not contest that cause shows your orientation,
- 55:52that it Still funny mommy on user-generated.
- 55:54Yes. An engineering problem rather
- 55:56than it's like we are a media business and have the main thing
- 55:58we should care about is second line that sense.
- 56:00YouTube know. I think that I think that I
- 56:02think that the classic gatekeeper definitions of media
- 56:05are a subset of the type of content that deserves to exist
- 56:08in be seen in the world. And so that trying to, you know,
- 56:11suggest that those are the, you know, aspirational markers.
- 56:15In terms of, you know, even subject is is fundamentally
- 56:19wrong and Miss judges, you know, the question about What people
- 56:22are interested in the community standards?
- 56:25The business model, the incentive system does that also
- 56:28mean that then we should run to sort of like lowest common
- 56:30denominator in terms of people's, you know, people's
- 56:33interests. No, I think that we have a
- 56:35responsibility to think about that.
- 56:37I'm glad to see for example, that the companies have said you
- 56:40have sort of re-engineered, hopefully their algorithms to
- 56:42say like, well, oh stuff that's Rising quickly.
- 56:44And popularity, you know, end has a bunch of controversy
- 56:47around it, maybe we should slow that down, you know, until we
- 56:51have a chance to look at it rather than then accelerate it
- 56:53to the point where we get a clear enough signal on whether
- 56:56it's really bad or not, right? Like I think those are the smart
- 56:58engineering choices, right? I also think by the way quickly
- 57:01to Eric's point that I also think, you know when we apply
- 57:04media levers level standards, here we tend to bias towards the
- 57:08narrative that media finds acceptable and not acceptable.
- 57:12And for example, when it comes to anti-vaxxer content obviously
- 57:15and rightfully, we are incensed by the reality that there's so
- 57:18much anti-vaxxer stuff that gets disseminated through Facebook
- 57:21and YouTube. Twitter, but like, you know, the
- 57:23current war in Ukraine right now.
- 57:26I would bet if we look at this period, maybe five ten years
- 57:28from now, we were Awash in misinformation, we are Awash in
- 57:32propaganda, Ukrainian propaganda, telling stories of
- 57:36heroism and and people surviving and, and, you know, people on an
- 57:40island. That's hold the Russians to fuck
- 57:42you. And then, and then apparently
- 57:43got killed that got wide distribution that had, you know,
- 57:47was as false as anything to do with anti-vaxxer content, but
- 57:50because it is, you know, in In the service of a narrative that
- 57:54we largely agree with which is that the ukrainians are victims
- 57:57of the Russian, you know, Russian aggression here.
- 57:59We're okay with. And it's funny to me that we're
- 58:01not seeing that much anger right now, at Twitter, I mean, I find
- 58:04Twitter almost unreadable these days when it comes to stuff
- 58:07about Ukraine because I'm just like, I don't believe this shit.
- 58:10There's no way I, you know, and I don't think anyone's vetting
- 58:12it because people don't care because it sounds good to them.
- 58:14There's a note in your positive crane.
- 58:16Truther Birds aren't real. I see ya.
- 58:20Look, I changed the way I use Twitter.
- 58:22Lately because I don't really have a point here, other than
- 58:24just like like saying media and standards as some sort of high
- 58:28level of of truth that we should all adhere to.
- 58:30We should just acknowledge the fact that like sometimes media
- 58:32standards or what people want to hear, you're ready for my outro,
- 58:35you ready for my outro line. Yes, Tech doesn't like to admit
- 58:38making mistakes and the Press overcorrects on the last one
- 58:41they made totally amazing. I agree with that.
- 58:46Thank you. Thank you so much for coming on.
- 58:52Silicon Valley, goodbye, goodbye.
- 59:02Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 59:05Goodbye. Silicon Valley, goodbye,
- 59:01goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 59:03Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.