Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Gag Order May Be Restored in Part
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: The argument went an hour longer than scheduled as a
- 0:14Speaker 2: DC Federal Appellate court weighed whether to put back in
- 0:17Speaker 2: place a gag order that barred Donald Trump from comments
- 0:21Speaker 2: that target prosecutors, potential witnesses, and courts staff in the
- 0:26Speaker 2: federal election subversion case. Trump's lawyer John Sower argued that
- 0:31Speaker 2: the former president has an absolute First Amendment right to
- 0:34Speaker 2: talk about the case, especially because he's running again for president.
- 0:39Speaker 3: The order is unprecedented and it says a terrible president
- 0:43Speaker 3: for future restrictions on corpor political speech. This is a
- 0:47Speaker 3: radical departure from the only cases that have considered this
- 0:49Speaker 3: particular form of restriction and restriction on a criminal defenderical
- 0:54Speaker 3: campaign for public office, and it does so in the
- 0:56Speaker 3: context of a hotly contested campaign for the high office
- 1:00Speaker 3: in the United States and America.
- 1:02Speaker 2: But the three judges seemed skeptical of the absolutist arguments
- 1:06Speaker 2: he was making. Judge Patricia Millett made a distinction between
- 1:10Speaker 2: campaign speech and speech aimed at derailing or corrupting the
- 1:14Speaker 2: criminal justice process.
- 1:17Speaker 1: I'm not tunning out everyone who speaks for only. This
- 1:20Speaker 1: does only effect no one's shutting down and everyone's. It
- 1:22Speaker 1: is only affecting the speech temporarily during a criminal frile
- 1:26Speaker 1: process by someone who has indicted as a felon. No
- 1:28Speaker 1: one here is threatening the First Amendment.
- 1:30Speaker 2: Broadly, there's limited legal precedent for restricting speech of political candidates,
- 1:36Speaker 2: and the stakes are high given the volume and intensity
- 1:39Speaker 2: of Trump's public comments about the case and the massive
- 1:43Speaker 2: public platform he holds. Joining me is Joshua Castenberg, a
- 1:47Speaker 2: professor at the University of New Mexico Law School and
- 1:50Speaker 2: a former judge in the US Air Force. Trump's lawyer
- 1:54Speaker 2: pushed an absolutist argument that Trump's speech can't be restrict
- 2:00Speaker 2: did at all.
- 2:01Speaker 4: Well, so a person does not have the right to
- 2:05Speaker 4: try to affect or alter the outcome of a trial
- 2:09Speaker 4: by intimidating witnesses, intimidating judges, intimidating jurors. But they do
- 2:16Speaker 4: have a right to defend themselves in the court of
- 2:18Speaker 4: public opinions. And there's an old case on point called
- 2:22Speaker 4: Bridges versus California, where a labor leader named Harry Bridges
- 2:27Speaker 4: was accused of trying to chill a jury chill a
- 2:31Speaker 4: prosecution against him, and Bridges was held in contempt. You know,
- 2:36Speaker 4: Harry Bridges was not the most popular of individuals among
- 2:40Speaker 4: the powers that be because he was the president of
- 2:42Speaker 4: the Longshoreman's Union and in the midst of the depression
- 2:46Speaker 4: had engaged in some strike activity. He did, to a
- 2:50Speaker 4: certain degree, do what Trump is doing now, which is
- 2:54Speaker 4: take his case to the public. The difference, though, is
- 2:57Speaker 4: that Bridges was conveying to the public that the longshoreman
- 3:04Speaker 4: would go on strike again if the prosecution didn't back
- 3:08Speaker 4: off on him. That's fundamentally different, though, than these hints
- 3:12Speaker 4: of direct threats to jurors, to the judge, to the prosecutor.
- 3:16Speaker 4: So it's not a slam dunk case for the former president.
- 3:21Speaker 4: On the other hand, he does have First Amendment rights,
- 3:24Speaker 4: and he has the rights to make political speech, and
- 3:26Speaker 4: so the gag order has to be crafted very narrowly
- 3:30Speaker 4: because his right to make political speech includes his right
- 3:33Speaker 4: to object to being prosecuted for a case that he
- 3:36Speaker 4: believes and some of his followers believe, is being done
- 3:41Speaker 4: to affect the presidential election against him.
- 3:43Speaker 2: Trump's attorney said the test was whether there was a
- 3:46Speaker 2: clear and present danger resulting from his speech. But the
- 3:51Speaker 2: judges said that Supreme Court President requires there be a
- 3:55Speaker 2: balancing test that weighs First Amendment rights against protecting the
- 3:59Speaker 2: entire tegrity of a trial by restricting some of the
- 4:02Speaker 2: defendant speech. Are the judges writer, or is the defense
- 4:06Speaker 2: right right?
- 4:07Speaker 3: Oh?
- 4:07Speaker 4: The judges are right. Here's the thing. You can have
- 4:10Speaker 4: an absolutist view of the First Amendment, but when you
- 4:13Speaker 4: become a defendant or a witness in a criminal case,
- 4:17Speaker 4: your First Amendment rights do not include putting fear into
- 4:22Speaker 4: the judicial process. And that's where the balancing test comes up.
- 4:26Speaker 4: Trump's attorneys are citing to Oliver Wendell Holmes Junior's a
- 4:29Speaker 4: clear and present change er test that he created in
- 4:32Speaker 4: a dissent after World War One. That test has nothing
- 4:36Speaker 4: to do specifically with a defendant on trial. That test
- 4:41Speaker 4: has to do with general life speech that's made an
- 4:44Speaker 4: opposition to some government program, and in that case it
- 4:48Speaker 4: was the draft in World War One. That test has
- 4:51Speaker 4: nothing to do specifically with a defendant on trial. That
- 4:56Speaker 4: test has to do with general life speech that's made
- 4:59Speaker 4: an opposition into some government program, and in that case
- 5:02Speaker 4: it was the draft in World War one.
- 5:05Speaker 2: Judge Millett also posed some questions about the potential that
- 5:09Speaker 2: Trump would try to intimidate witnesses, and she used the
- 5:13Speaker 2: example of former Vice president Mike Pence.
- 5:16Speaker 1: Let's assume former Vice President Mike Pence is going to
- 5:20Speaker 1: testify and it's the night before his testimony. Couldn't the
- 5:27Speaker 1: defendant tweet out, Mike Pence can still fix this. Mike
- 5:34Speaker 1: Pence can still do the right thing if he says
- 5:39Speaker 1: the right stuff tomorrow. First of all, is that communicating
- 5:42Speaker 1: with the witness?
- 5:43Speaker 3: Okay, it's just broadcasting a statement of core political social
- 5:47Speaker 3: media likely.
- 5:48Speaker 2: Not trying to protect a witness from intimidation seems like
- 5:53Speaker 2: perhaps the most important reason for a gag order before
- 5:57Speaker 2: a trial.
- 5:58Speaker 4: Yeah, so try to intimidate a witness from testifying to
- 6:03Speaker 4: the truth. What I would say on that is, if
- 6:06Speaker 4: there's evidence that he's trying to affect pensive testimony from
- 6:11Speaker 4: not testifying truthfully, then you've got an obstruction of justice.
- 6:15Speaker 4: In order to prevent a perversion of the judicial process,
- 6:18Speaker 4: the judge would be in her right or his right
- 6:23Speaker 4: to issue a ruling a gag order on the individuals.
- 6:27Speaker 4: So I think the question from the judges and the
- 6:30Speaker 4: right in that particular case. But you know, Trump is
- 6:33Speaker 4: very good at saying one thing and then just saying, well,
- 6:37Speaker 4: you misinterpreted me. And I have a right to speak
- 6:39Speaker 4: my mind and I have a right to campaign for office. Well,
- 6:43Speaker 4: both of those are true. He certainly has a right
- 6:46Speaker 4: to speak his mind, and he certainly has a right
- 6:48Speaker 4: to campaign for office. But he doesn't have a right
- 6:52Speaker 4: to pervert the judicial process. And that's where the balancing
- 6:56Speaker 4: test comes in.
- 6:57Speaker 2: It looked to me like this was a narrowly tailored order,
- 7:00Speaker 2: but they did suggest it was broad and that there
- 7:03Speaker 2: was a distinction between threats and harassment of prosecutors versus
- 7:08Speaker 2: threats to witnesses or jurors.
- 7:11Speaker 4: Yeah, they were commenting on Jack Smith's tough skin, and
- 7:15Speaker 4: the general public would know who Jack Smith is right now.
- 7:18Speaker 4: And he's in a different role because he's a prosecutor
- 7:21Speaker 4: than being a juror or a witness. And you know,
- 7:24Speaker 4: what there is is a mindset, and it's a mindset
- 7:27Speaker 4: that has come in regarding prosecutors that prosecutors.
- 7:31Speaker 5: Have to have thick skins.
- 7:32Speaker 4: They're going to get accused of things, including in court
- 7:35Speaker 4: sometimes by defense counsel, and they can't fire back, and
- 7:40Speaker 4: I think that's what's going on here. I mean, Jack Smith,
- 7:44Speaker 4: I don't think has presented any real evidence yet, and
- 7:48Speaker 4: maybe there is evidence there that Trump's statements have resulted in,
- 7:52Speaker 4: you know, a real chill to the ability of the
- 7:55Speaker 4: prosecutors to do their job as ethical prosecutors. I suppose
- 8:01Speaker 4: what you could make the argument on is that today,
- 8:06Speaker 4: when someone liked Donald Trump or someone of public importance
- 8:12Speaker 4: makes an allegation against someone else, in the world of
- 8:15Speaker 4: artificial intelligence, in the world of people being able to
- 8:19Speaker 4: mask who they are as people in terms of their
- 8:23Speaker 4: real identity, you get all kinds of nasty emails and
- 8:27Speaker 4: phone calls and bots thrown your way. I've experienced that
- 8:31Speaker 4: I gave a very neutral comment to the New York
- 8:34Speaker 4: Times in twenty and seventeen or twenty and sixteen about
- 8:39Speaker 4: boie Bergdal and all I did was give a history
- 8:43Speaker 4: of the charge that he was charged with, which was
- 8:45Speaker 4: desertion also in the face of the enemy and the like.
- 8:48Speaker 5: And I got a.
- 8:50Speaker 4: Dozen or more kind of hate emails that my way.
- 8:53Speaker 4: And it was hard to tell whether they were real
- 8:55Speaker 4: people in the United States or bots doing it, but
- 8:59Speaker 4: they seem to know enough about me based on a
- 9:01Speaker 4: public bio to do that. And I've talked to prosecutors,
- 9:04Speaker 4: and I've talked to a couple of judges who've said
- 9:07Speaker 4: on cases that involve people of real important significance, and
- 9:13Speaker 4: they say it's become routine that they get harassed. And
- 9:16Speaker 4: so I think Jack Smith's side has a point that
- 9:20Speaker 4: when Trump argues that you know, he's being prosecuted as
- 9:25Speaker 4: a political vendetta and he's going to go after Jacksmith,
- 9:27Speaker 4: he encourages his people to do that, that there really
- 9:31Speaker 4: is a threat to the judicial process, and that means
- 9:33Speaker 4: there's a threat to democracy. But the judges are supposed
- 9:37Speaker 4: to maintain and protect the integrity of the judicial process.
- 9:41Speaker 4: And I think out of this some of the gag
- 9:44Speaker 4: order will survive, but some of it will be narrowed.
- 9:47Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 9:48Speaker 2: Do you think the narrowing will be basically taking the
- 9:51Speaker 2: prosecutors out of the equation.
- 9:54Speaker 4: Yes, I think that's where the narrowing will be, and
- 9:56Speaker 4: they'll go back to the traditional model of the prosecutor
- 10:00Speaker 4: to have a tough skin and is in a different
- 10:02Speaker 4: position altogether.
- 10:04Speaker 2: Although we do know that all the prosecutors involved in
- 10:08Speaker 2: these criminal and civil cases have said that they've been
- 10:11Speaker 2: threatened and their staffs have been threatened. So now the
- 10:14Speaker 2: defense says, if they lose this, they're going to go
- 10:17Speaker 2: to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has the option
- 10:20Speaker 2: of taking the case or not taking the case. Do
- 10:22Speaker 2: you think the Supreme Court will take a gag order
- 10:25Speaker 2: case like this?
- 10:27Speaker 4: I don't think the Supreme Court will take a gag
- 10:30Speaker 4: order case. Normally, we are talking about the former president
- 10:35Speaker 4: who is campaigning to be president, and that does make
- 10:39Speaker 4: it somewhat different. I would say it's a fifty to
- 10:42Speaker 4: fifty chance they will on the one, and the Supreme
- 10:45Speaker 4: Court doesn't want to set a precedent in terms of
- 10:48Speaker 4: gag orders. They would set a president in terms of
- 10:50Speaker 4: a contempt finding. But you know, you've got a former
- 10:54Speaker 4: president running once more for president, and this has an
- 10:58Speaker 4: unusual constitutional aspect to it. Beyond the power of the judiciary.
- 11:02Speaker 4: It has the unusual aspect of how does a candidate
- 11:06Speaker 4: who's running for office the nation's highest office, have to
- 11:11Speaker 4: be confined in his speech while facing criminal trials. It's
- 11:16Speaker 4: almost like it invites the separation of powers analysis to it.
- 11:21Speaker 2: It's once again unprecedented, which we've said so many times
- 11:26Speaker 2: with respect to Trump.
- 11:28Speaker 4: You know, it reminds me in a way of a
- 11:31Speaker 4: case involving judicial power and the presidency, but it's not
- 11:35Speaker 4: quite it's not really on point. But it's a nineteen
- 11:38Speaker 4: twenty four case called ex Parte Grossman. Grossman was a
- 11:43Speaker 4: bootlegger in Chicago and found guilty of contempt in front
- 11:49Speaker 4: of Judge Kennesaw Mountain Landis, who you know, is sort
- 11:52Speaker 4: of famous for later becoming the first commissioner of Major
- 11:55Speaker 4: League Baseball, and the contempt or was simply because Landis
- 12:02Speaker 4: ordered him to stop making and selling booze and he
- 12:04Speaker 4: wouldn't do it. On the very first day of Calvin
- 12:08Speaker 4: Coolidge's presidency, after Harding dies and Coolidge gets born in
- 12:12Speaker 4: Coolidge pardons Grossman, and Grossman was a contributor to the
- 12:18Speaker 4: Illinois Republican Party, So you can kind of understand how
- 12:21Speaker 4: this happened. It was one of the very first things
- 12:23Speaker 4: Calvin Coolidge did. Landis made the decision that because a
- 12:28Speaker 4: contempt finding wasn't a conviction in the classic sense, but
- 12:32Speaker 4: rather was to uphold the power of the judiciary over
- 12:35Speaker 4: miscreants who violate judicial orders, that Coolidge didn't have the
- 12:40Speaker 4: authority to issue a pardon. It goes up to the
- 12:43Speaker 4: Supreme Court. The Supreme Court decides that a president has
- 12:48Speaker 4: really unique authorities that are broad. And when I think
- 12:53Speaker 4: about that case, and I think about Trump running for
- 12:56Speaker 4: the office of the presidency, I would say, normally the
- 13:00Speaker 4: Supreme Court wouldn't take up even come close to taking
- 13:02Speaker 4: up a gag order, but in this case they might
- 13:05Speaker 4: because it does involve the power of the presidency.
- 13:08Speaker 2: Donald Trump has presented more issues over the power of
- 13:12Speaker 2: the presidency, probably than any other president in history. Thanks
- 13:16Speaker 2: so much, josh That's Professor Joshua Castenberg of the University
- 13:21Speaker 2: of New Mexico Law School.
- 13:23Speaker 5: We need a president who's going to restore law and
- 13:26Speaker 5: order in the United States of America.
- 13:29Speaker 2: Texas Governor Greg Abbott endorsed Donald Trump on Sunday, focusing
- 13:34Speaker 2: on the hardline immigration policies that have played a role
- 13:37Speaker 2: in both their political careers. The border is a centerpiece
- 13:41Speaker 2: of Abbot's agenda in an escalating fight with the Biden
- 13:44Speaker 2: administration over immigration, The three term governor has approved billions
- 13:48Speaker 2: of dollars in new border wall construction, authorized razor wire
- 13:52Speaker 2: on the banks of the Rio Grande, and bust thousands
- 13:55Speaker 2: of migrants to democratic led cities, and Abbot is expected
- 13:59Speaker 2: to sow on what would be one of Texas's most
- 14:01Speaker 2: aggressive measures to date, a law that allows police officers
- 14:05Speaker 2: to arrest migrants suspected of entering the country illegally and
- 14:09Speaker 2: empowers judges to effectively deport them. Joining me is immigration
- 14:14Speaker 2: law expert Leon Fresco, a partner at Holland and Knight.
- 14:17Speaker 2: He's expected to sign Greg Abbott one of the harshest
- 14:21Speaker 2: anti immigration laws. It makes it a state crime to
- 14:25Speaker 2: cross into Texas from another country without papers. Is that
- 14:29Speaker 2: basically what it is or is there more to tell
- 14:30Speaker 2: about what it is?
- 14:31Speaker 5: Actually? That's basically the law. The law is intended to
- 14:34Speaker 5: give the state of Texas the ability to basically stop
- 14:38Speaker 5: a legal immigration into Texas by allowing state and local
- 14:43Speaker 5: police officers the ability to arrest someone that they've witnessed
- 14:47Speaker 5: crossing the border and telling them you have two options.
- 14:50Speaker 5: Go back, which would be their preferred option. They don't
- 14:53Speaker 5: actually want to put people in jail because of what
- 14:55Speaker 5: a huge resource constraint that's going to be. But the
- 14:58Speaker 5: second option is to say, if you don't go back,
- 15:01Speaker 5: we're going to put you in jail for this misdemeanor
- 15:03Speaker 5: that we've created, which is called crossing the border illegally
- 15:07Speaker 5: and during the State of Texas. Now having said that,
- 15:11Speaker 5: the state of Arizona tried this same thing in twenty
- 15:15Speaker 5: eleven twenty twelve, and that's what led to the famous
- 15:18Speaker 5: Supreme Court case called Arizona versus the United States, where
- 15:22Speaker 5: the Supreme Court decided that that was preempted by federal law.
- 15:27Speaker 5: So you couldn't pass a law like that because only
- 15:30Speaker 5: the federal government had the ability to punish this kind
- 15:34Speaker 5: of unauthorized immigration. And the theory at the time was
- 15:39Speaker 5: that the conflicts between what states might do and the
- 15:42Speaker 5: federal government could lead to all of these unforeseen public
- 15:46Speaker 5: policy outcomes and foreign policy outcomes, that it was very
- 15:50Speaker 5: important that the United States speak with one voice and
- 15:53Speaker 5: one comprehensive strategy visa the immigration It may be that
- 15:59Speaker 5: now that the Justice have changed in composition because the
- 16:02Speaker 5: only guaranteed vote you would have for the Arizona case,
- 16:07Speaker 5: Justice Roberts did vote on the side of the federal
- 16:10Speaker 5: government in the Arizona case. So you know, Justice Roberts
- 16:13Speaker 5: will not probably decide to overturn Arizona but then you
- 16:18Speaker 5: probably also have Justice Brown Jackson and Justice Soda Bayor
- 16:22Speaker 5: and Justice Kagan. Justice Kagan at the time had been
- 16:24Speaker 5: recute because he's been working on this matter as Solicitor General.
- 16:28Speaker 5: But you'd assume those four would vote to uphold Arizona.
- 16:32Speaker 5: And then the question is going to be, well, we
- 16:34Speaker 5: know Thomas and Alito already voted to allow states to
- 16:39Speaker 5: have this immigration authority, so nono. The question is, well,
- 16:42Speaker 5: what about Kavanagh Borsa, said Cony Barrett, And that's where
- 16:45Speaker 5: it's gonna matter. Will vote three vote to overturn the
- 16:51Speaker 5: Arizona law, And the question is how will they do it,
- 16:55Speaker 5: because there's a broadway and a narrow way to do it.
- 16:58Speaker 5: The narrow way would be to say, look, this is
- 17:01Speaker 5: completely consistent with federal immigration laws. So just like a
- 17:06Speaker 5: state can punish drugs, so does the federal government. We
- 17:09Speaker 5: don't tell states you can't punish illegal drugs in your
- 17:13Speaker 5: state because the federal government punishes illegal drugs. No, we
- 17:17Speaker 5: allow them to work in fandom to do this, and
- 17:20Speaker 5: so that might happen as if they say, look, these
- 17:23Speaker 5: are not inconsistent. These are completely consistent. So only in
- 17:26Speaker 5: that scenario that permitted, or they may actually do something
- 17:32Speaker 5: very broad and say that the Constitution doesn't in any
- 17:37Speaker 5: way prevent state from having immigration laws, and that would
- 17:40Speaker 5: sort of take us back to the beginning of immigration laws,
- 17:43Speaker 5: to the eighteen eighties where that issue was litigated and
- 17:47Speaker 5: the court said, well, even though there's nothing in the
- 17:50Speaker 5: Constitution that explains this, we still must assume because there's
- 17:55Speaker 5: no way you can have a federal government if it
- 17:57Speaker 5: can't control immigration. So maybe this will not be the case,
- 18:02Speaker 5: and they will go back to the pre eighteen eighty
- 18:04Speaker 5: view that if the sting is not written in the Constitution,
- 18:07Speaker 5: that means that the states have the ability to regulate
- 18:09Speaker 5: it in addition, and so that may happen here and
- 18:13Speaker 5: there may be an ability for the states to actually
- 18:15Speaker 5: enforce them a grace law. So we'll see how broadly
- 18:18Speaker 5: or narrowly, or perhaps not at all. The Arizona case
- 18:22Speaker 5: from twenty twelve is changed.
- 18:24Speaker 2: The last term, though, wasn't there a surprising ruling against Texas?
- 18:29Speaker 2: And I think it was Missouri.
- 18:31Speaker 5: So there was two cases and they had split views.
- 18:34Speaker 5: There was one case involving the Texas prosecutorial discretion standards,
- 18:40Speaker 5: where the Supreme Court said, look, Ice is allowed to
- 18:43Speaker 5: have a prosecutorial discretion memo, and the federal government can't
- 18:47Speaker 5: be sued for not prosecuting people within this prosecutorial discretion
- 18:53Speaker 5: memo that states won prosecuted. It's not up to the
- 18:56Speaker 5: states to determine who the federal government should prosecute. So
- 19:00Speaker 5: that's different than they can the states take matters into
- 19:03Speaker 5: their own hands. So what we know based on last
- 19:06Speaker 5: year that the states cannot dictate who the federal government
- 19:10Speaker 5: needs to prosecute. But now we would have a second issue, well,
- 19:13Speaker 5: can the states take matters into their own hands and
- 19:15Speaker 5: prosecute if the federal government doesn't. And so there was
- 19:18Speaker 5: a case called Kansas versus Garcia that was a little
- 19:22Speaker 5: bit of a deviation from Arizona for the purposes of
- 19:25Speaker 5: employment verification, where they said the state of Kansas could
- 19:29Speaker 5: prosecute people who had used fake identities to get jobs
- 19:34Speaker 5: because of the reason of immigration. And there had been
- 19:37Speaker 5: an argument in that case that it was prehisted, and
- 19:40Speaker 5: the court said, no, it's not pre emptant. The state
- 19:42Speaker 5: of Kansas could prosecute people who use faith forms to
- 19:46Speaker 5: get jobs, even if it was an immigration reason for
- 19:50Speaker 5: using the faith form. And so it will be very
- 19:52Speaker 5: interesting to see whether they continue to go down that
- 19:56Speaker 5: route of the Kansas case to allow states to take
- 19:59Speaker 5: manners of to their own hands, or whether they just
- 20:02Speaker 5: uphold Arizona and not allow this to happen.
- 20:06Speaker 2: Immigrants groups are said that they're going to oppose this,
- 20:10Speaker 2: that it's unconstitutional, they say it's discriminatory and it will
- 20:14Speaker 2: victimize people of Latino descent.
- 20:17Speaker 5: Well, I think the question will be a matter of implementation,
- 20:20Speaker 5: and the Supreme Court has not been too kind to
- 20:23Speaker 5: these facial challenges where we assume upfront that the brunt
- 20:29Speaker 5: of the enforcement is going to be toward Latino immigrants
- 20:32Speaker 5: and not talking about who's coming, because obviously people if
- 20:35Speaker 5: they're coming from Mexico into the United States and from
- 20:39Speaker 5: the Western Hemisphere, are more likely than not going to
- 20:42Speaker 5: be from a Western Hemisphere country, which might be deaned
- 20:45Speaker 5: the Latino Hispanic country. Sure, but that's not what they
- 20:48Speaker 5: mean by racial profiling here. They mean what about if
- 20:52Speaker 5: they didn't actually see the person crossing, but they just
- 20:55Speaker 5: assume minutes later by based on how someone looks that
- 20:59Speaker 5: they were someone who just crossed the statue. Doesn't prevent
- 21:03Speaker 5: this kind of arrest and so this should be the
- 21:06Speaker 5: kind of statues that should be enjoined because it is
- 21:09Speaker 5: too prone to this kind of racial abuse, where people
- 21:12Speaker 5: who look a certain way are more likely or less
- 21:15Speaker 5: likely to be viewed as someone who just crossed the
- 21:18Speaker 5: border than somebody who looks a different way. The Supreme Court,
- 21:21Speaker 5: even in the Arizona case, but in many other cases
- 21:24Speaker 5: since then, has basically taken the tact of saying, don't
- 21:29Speaker 5: come to me with these theoretical claims. If this is happening,
- 21:32Speaker 5: who wants it starts happening, and then will address it
- 21:36Speaker 5: then and will decide whether this is too much of
- 21:39Speaker 5: a radical law because of the way its being implemented.
- 21:42Speaker 5: It's to continue to be allowed to be implemented, but preemptively.
- 21:46Speaker 5: We're no longer going to sort of start facially striking
- 21:49Speaker 5: down these laws when we have no idea how they're
- 21:52Speaker 5: going to be implemented.
- 21:53Speaker 2: Lenn is part of this just messaging that Texas is
- 21:57Speaker 2: trying every way it can to message don't come to
- 22:01Speaker 2: Texas because this will take years to get through the system.
- 22:04Speaker 5: Right. I think if the courts are being faithful to
- 22:08Speaker 5: the President, then yes, they have to enjoin the law,
- 22:12Speaker 5: and then let it work its way up to the
- 22:14Speaker 5: Supreme Court. Now having said that, the Supreme Court may
- 22:17Speaker 5: somehow lift a say and say, hey, there's a likelihood
- 22:21Speaker 5: of success here. I don't know if they do that
- 22:23Speaker 5: on a rapid basis, or if they'd wait all the
- 22:25Speaker 5: way through before they would do something like overturn a
- 22:28Speaker 5: prior president. I would assume they'd wait all the way through,
- 22:32Speaker 5: and they'd keep to say all the way through, and
- 22:34Speaker 5: so the actual briefing on the merits, which as you say,
- 22:37Speaker 5: will take years. But I do think it's fair to
- 22:41Speaker 5: say that if this law were to actually go into effect,
- 22:44Speaker 5: and you were to actually put the choice to people,
- 22:47Speaker 5: hey do you want to spend time in jail or
- 22:49Speaker 5: do you want to just go back to the port
- 22:50Speaker 5: of entry where you could try again in a different state.
- 22:54Speaker 5: I don't know how many people might think that second
- 22:56Speaker 5: choice would be a benefit to the state of sixes.
- 22:59Speaker 5: And so it does lead you to think that, yes,
- 23:03Speaker 5: Texas is doing it partly for politics, partly to show
- 23:06Speaker 5: they're doing everything they can, partly to make set the message.
- 23:10Speaker 5: All of that. They're still doubts. But I do also
- 23:12Speaker 5: think that if this were ever to be implemented. It
- 23:15Speaker 5: certainly might change the calculus that somebody has when they're
- 23:19Speaker 5: crossing the post of crossing in a different location.
- 23:23Speaker 2: Coming up next, we'll look at how US Customs and
- 23:25Speaker 2: Border Protection is paying a data broker for powerful surveillance
- 23:30Speaker 2: tools to monitor immigrants and others in the country. This
- 23:33Speaker 2: is Bloomberg. I've been talking to immigration law expert Leon
- 23:37Speaker 2: Fresco of Holland and Knight about some of the unique
- 23:39Speaker 2: ways Texas is fighting immigration. I mean, Texas seems to
- 23:44Speaker 2: come up with idea after idea. Remember the boys in
- 23:48Speaker 2: the Rio Grande y did they just remove those voluntarily?
- 23:52Speaker 2: What happened there?
- 23:53Speaker 5: That's still in litigation right now. The buoys were first
- 23:57Speaker 5: ordered to be removed, but then the Pellet course, the
- 24:00Speaker 5: Fifth Circuit did say then that they can keep the
- 24:03Speaker 5: buoys while the challenges continue. And so, yeah, some have
- 24:07Speaker 5: been removed, but some are still there, and those I
- 24:11Speaker 5: don't think that are still there are going to be
- 24:13Speaker 5: removed until there's an actual order requiring those to be removed. Now,
- 24:17Speaker 5: are they effective?
- 24:18Speaker 3: Not?
- 24:19Speaker 5: Because there's other parts of the river that are not
- 24:21Speaker 5: very wide where the buoys are not cannot be used.
- 24:25Speaker 5: And also there's ways to get around these booys, et cetera.
- 24:28Speaker 5: But having said that, all of these things are being
- 24:31Speaker 5: done to create symbols and barriers both figurative and literal,
- 24:36Speaker 5: to drive to send these messages that a lawful migration
- 24:41Speaker 5: into Texas is not welcome. But I do agree in
- 24:45Speaker 5: terms of the bang for your buck or the impacts
- 24:48Speaker 5: of what you're getting, that these buoys are certainly not
- 24:51Speaker 5: the best use of Texas's resources.
- 24:54Speaker 2: Unlike New York City's mayor who went down for a
- 24:57Speaker 2: visit and really didn't send out a message don't come sure.
- 25:01Speaker 5: I mean, look, at the end of the day, all
- 25:03Speaker 5: of these folks really have come together, and if they
- 25:07Speaker 5: all were to rally sort of around two topics. Number
- 25:11Speaker 5: one is, if you do pass whatever screaming we're going
- 25:14Speaker 5: to end up giving you, you still have to have
- 25:17Speaker 5: some sponsor who's going to take care of you, who's
- 25:20Speaker 5: proven and is vetted before you can be released from custody.
- 25:24Speaker 5: I think that will make a huge difference in terms
- 25:26Speaker 5: of where all of these folks are going and why
- 25:29Speaker 5: they're all coming, because right now people aren't coming expecting
- 25:31Speaker 5: to be taken care of by local government, which is
- 25:34Speaker 5: a sea change from where it was number one, but
- 25:36Speaker 5: number two. I do think you have to raise the
- 25:39Speaker 5: standard to give people some higher standard that they have
- 25:43Speaker 5: to be rather than just articulating a formulaic asylum claim,
- 25:47Speaker 5: there has to be the idiosyncratic claim that you make
- 25:51Speaker 5: has to have some reasonableness to it, where it seems
- 25:56Speaker 5: like at least you have given clear and convincing evidence
- 25:59Speaker 5: that if your account is correct, that you will win.
- 26:03Speaker 5: I think is a better standard than just saying that
- 26:07Speaker 5: your account, if we get more information later, is an
- 26:12Speaker 5: account that allows you to stay in the country. Meaning
- 26:15Speaker 5: you could just say I was politically persecuted in my
- 26:19Speaker 5: country and leave it at That should not be enough.
- 26:22Speaker 5: You should have to lay out your entire story, and
- 26:25Speaker 5: then the point is, well, okay, if this story is corroborated,
- 26:29Speaker 5: sort of the way a complaint works in a federal lawsuit.
- 26:32Speaker 5: If this is corroborated and that means you'd win, then
- 26:35Speaker 5: you can say. But if you can't lay out a
- 26:38Speaker 5: claim that, if corroborated, would not win, you probably shouldn't
- 26:43Speaker 5: be allowed to say.
- 26:45Speaker 2: Leon. Let's turn now to US Customs and Border Protection
- 26:49Speaker 2: paying a data broker Lexis Nexus Special Services nearly sixteen
- 26:54Speaker 2: million dollars for a five year contract for access to
- 26:58Speaker 2: a suite of surveills tools including social media monitoring, web
- 27:04Speaker 2: data such as email address and IP address locations, real
- 27:08Speaker 2: time jail booking data, facial recognition services, and cell phone
- 27:12Speaker 2: geolocation data analysis tools.
- 27:16Speaker 5: So for the last few years, the Department of Homeland Security,
- 27:19Speaker 5: both ICE, Immigration of Customs Enforcement and CBP UF put
- 27:24Speaker 5: some Border Protection have been purchasing as much privately available
- 27:29Speaker 5: data as possible. And the reason is threefold. Basically, the
- 27:34Speaker 5: first thing that they're trying to do is they're just
- 27:37Speaker 5: trying to figure out where people are because there are
- 27:40Speaker 5: so many people that are being released into the United States.
- 27:43Speaker 5: And then at con big it's for various reasons they
- 27:46Speaker 5: don't show up the court, or they rip off their ankle,
- 27:48Speaker 5: bracelet or whatever. And when I really need to find
- 27:52Speaker 5: these people or CBP through its investigative arms, then they
- 27:56Speaker 5: can find them. And this can be through all kinds
- 27:58Speaker 5: of things such as your license play was read on
- 28:01Speaker 5: a red line, or you ordered a pizza, or you
- 28:05Speaker 5: bought some movie or whatever it is that you ended
- 28:08Speaker 5: up doing that ended up getting attracted by a private
- 28:10Speaker 5: vendor and all of that private information is being bought
- 28:15Speaker 5: and purchased by the government, which is perfectly legal be
- 28:19Speaker 5: private industries get your consent theoretically whenever you're checking those
- 28:23Speaker 5: boxes that you don't want to check, but they're forcing
- 28:25Speaker 5: you to check to order a pizza or to buy
- 28:28Speaker 5: something out a sore online or whatever it is you're doing.
- 28:31Speaker 5: And they're collecting all of this data and they're doing
- 28:34Speaker 5: it to a try to find people b The other
- 28:37Speaker 5: thing they're trying to do is to determine if people
- 28:39Speaker 5: are violating the terms and conditions of their non immigrant visa.
- 28:43Speaker 5: So that might be, for instance, if you're a student
- 28:46Speaker 5: and you're supposed to be studying, let's say at the
- 28:48Speaker 5: University of Texas at Austin, and everything about you shows
- 28:52Speaker 5: that you are purchasing everything and then traveling and doing
- 28:56Speaker 5: everything is in Los Angeles, then the idea is, well,
- 28:59Speaker 5: maybe you're not actually studying at the University of Texas.
- 29:02Speaker 5: Maybe you're in Los Angeles and you're working, and we
- 29:05Speaker 5: have that event of this, and so that's the second
- 29:09Speaker 5: thing it's being used for, is to determine visa compliance.
- 29:13Speaker 5: And then the third thing it's being used for is
- 29:15Speaker 5: to determine this sort of web of associates to try
- 29:20Speaker 5: to link up different people in different cases. But the
- 29:22Speaker 5: government is suspicious about one person, to try to find
- 29:26Speaker 5: as many webs of where you're intersecting, and the more
- 29:30Speaker 5: a person intersects with sort of other bad people at
- 29:33Speaker 5: five or six degrees a level that you say, oh boy,
- 29:36Speaker 5: this person has associates XYZ, and then XYZ have associates
- 29:41Speaker 5: YZW and they're all intersecting. Then that's alerting the government
- 29:47Speaker 5: that it needs to either revoke a visa or de
- 29:49Speaker 5: i of visa or come get you because you're a
- 29:52Speaker 5: dangerous person. So that's what this evidence is being used for.
- 29:56Speaker 2: So why is just Future's Law, a legal nonprofit serving
- 30:01Speaker 2: marginalized communities suing Lexis Nexis Risk Solutions. Is that over
- 30:07Speaker 2: individual state privacy laws?
- 30:09Speaker 5: Well, the problem is there's all these different privacy laws
- 30:12Speaker 5: and all the different states and privacy advocates politically, so
- 30:17Speaker 5: let's start with that, just the political aspect first. There,
- 30:20Speaker 5: Please tell any of people who say, look, the government
- 30:22Speaker 5: shouldn't be doing this, shouldn't be accumulating all of this information.
- 30:25Speaker 5: Who knows how it's being used? Is it being safeguarded?
- 30:29Speaker 5: So there's all of those complaints which are understood. Those
- 30:32Speaker 5: are generally good government sort of complaints. And you know,
- 30:35Speaker 5: it just depends what year you want to live in,
- 30:38Speaker 5: and you want to live in a year where all
- 30:40Speaker 5: of that cat isn't out of the bag already, I understand,
- 30:43Speaker 5: and you know, the people who are always pushing back
- 30:46Speaker 5: on that are understood. But sort of now here at
- 30:50Speaker 5: the end of twenty twenty three, you start thinking to yourself, boy,
- 30:53Speaker 5: that cat not only is out of the bag, that
- 30:55Speaker 5: cat is in a different state than the bag at
- 30:58Speaker 5: this point. So I wonder what the complaces now, And
- 31:01Speaker 5: then yeah, these are these state laws. You have different
- 31:04Speaker 5: states that require different levels of consent before people's data
- 31:08Speaker 5: can be purchased, and so people will too if they
- 31:12Speaker 5: can determine that a state law was violated for the
- 31:15Speaker 5: purpose of privacy, because CBP may have bought data or
- 31:20Speaker 5: used data that wasn't consented to for a specific purpose,
- 31:23Speaker 5: and so that is a reason that you can see
- 31:27Speaker 5: and so people are always monitoring that. But that's a
- 31:30Speaker 5: very sort of detailed data oriented thing, because different data
- 31:33Speaker 5: can be used for different purposes and has to have
- 31:36Speaker 5: different level of disclosure, and so all of this is
- 31:40Speaker 5: on a very state by state and data by data basis.
- 31:44Speaker 2: When you come into this country, you're immigrating here, and
- 31:47Speaker 2: let's say you go through the system, do you sign
- 31:49Speaker 2: anything that consents to monitoring.
- 31:51Speaker 5: Well, it's not that you sign anything, because there's a
- 31:54Speaker 5: lot of foreign nationals who are told don't sign anything,
- 31:57Speaker 5: and so many of them don't even sign anything. But
- 31:59Speaker 5: it's not actually in the law. It's in the statute
- 32:02Speaker 5: and in the regulation that if you get relief from detention,
- 32:06Speaker 5: you can be released under any terms and conditions that
- 32:09Speaker 5: the Department of Homeland Security beings appropriate. And so it's
- 32:14Speaker 5: just the act of releasing someone from immigration detention that
- 32:19Speaker 5: automatically creates the legal duty to comply with any terms
- 32:22Speaker 5: and conditions that I want.
- 32:24Speaker 2: Once again, Leon, I have to say, I don't know
- 32:26Speaker 2: how you keep up with all of this. Thanks so
- 32:29Speaker 2: much for being on the show. That's Immigration Law expertly
- 32:32Speaker 2: on Fresco, a partner at Honda Night. And that's it
- 32:35Speaker 2: for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you
- 32:38Speaker 2: can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg
- 32:40Speaker 2: Law podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 32:44Speaker 2: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law,
- 32:50Speaker 2: and remember to tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every
- 32:52Speaker 2: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 32:56Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg