Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Part One: Appellate Briefing from the Decisionmaker's Perspective
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's MCLE. My
- 0:09name is Connor Tucker. I'm chair of the appellate
- 0:12law section here at the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:15And I'm really delighted to introduce our speakers
- 0:18today in the first part of a two -part series.
- 0:22Our first speaker is MC Sangaila. She's a partner
- 0:26at Complex Appellate Litigation Group, where
- 0:28she has briefed and argued more than 170 appeals
- 0:31in areas including employment, class action,
- 0:34product liability, and constitutional law. She's
- 0:37handled appeals before the U .S. Supreme Court,
- 0:39several state supreme courts, and numerous federal
- 0:42and state appellate courts. Earlier in her career,
- 0:45she clerked for Judge Fernandez on the Ninth
- 0:47Circuit, where she taught, she has taught appellate
- 0:51law at UC Irvine, Loyola, and Whittier. and has
- 0:55written widely on appellate practice for the
- 0:57ABA and the CEB. She is also a creator and host
- 1:01of the award -winning podcast, The Porsche Project,
- 1:04which features conversations with leading women
- 1:06judges and lawyers. Twice named California Lawyer
- 1:10of the Year, she has earned dozens of honors
- 1:12for her advocacy and for her pro bono and community
- 1:15service. Melanie Gold is a partner at Complex
- 1:18Appellate Litigation Group. who spent more than
- 1:21three decades as a research attorney for California's
- 1:24appellate courts. She worked primarily with the
- 1:26justices of the fourth district court of appeals
- 1:29in San Diego and also with the sixth district
- 1:33and the California Supreme Court. Over those
- 1:36years, she analyzed thousands of briefs and petitions,
- 1:39advised justices on hundreds of appeals. and
- 1:42helped write nearly a thousand opinions across
- 1:44areas, including anti -slap, real property, employment,
- 1:48arbitration, and class action law. The work gave
- 1:52her a close view of how appellate courts actually
- 1:55decide cases. She's taught appellate advocacy
- 1:58at the University of San Diego and California
- 2:00Western, and she founded and chairs the San Diego
- 2:03County Bar Association's Access to Appellate
- 2:06Justice program. So you are in wonderful hands
- 2:09here for today. and I'll send it over to you,
- 2:12MC, to get started. All right. Thanks so much,
- 2:15Connor, for the introduction, and thanks to all
- 2:17of you for being here on our two -part journey
- 2:20on appellate brief writing and oral argument.
- 2:23And we framed this from the decision -maker's
- 2:27perspective. So next slide, please. Thank you.
- 2:33So yeah, so our approach in both of these parts
- 2:37of the seminar is to think about the decision
- 2:41maker and the purpose for which you're writing
- 2:44your brief and presenting your argument and really
- 2:47looking at it from the appellate courts and appellate
- 2:51justices and appellate research attorneys perspective.
- 2:55So, and obviously taking a fresh perspective
- 2:58from the trial courts and also thinking about
- 3:03putting together your brief in a strategic way
- 3:07and a strategic design that's unique to each
- 3:10case. So we're going to discuss various considerations
- 3:13today and your results may vary and your approach
- 3:17may vary depending on your case. We're just providing
- 3:21some ideas and some points of thought and consideration
- 3:25in organizing your brief and making the most
- 3:29of your arguments. I also wanted to touch briefly
- 3:33on just a little reminder of where we're at,
- 3:37sort of in the pyramid of courts. So we've got
- 3:40the trial courts, where the barrier to entry
- 3:43is relatively low. If you have a complaint, you
- 3:45file it on time. Now the trial court kind of
- 3:48has to hear your claims. And then the next level,
- 3:53a little bit narrower, is the intermediate court
- 3:55of appeal, which we'll be discussing today as
- 3:57well, which, again, in California and Ninth Circuit,
- 4:03you file a timely notice of appeal. You have
- 4:07an opportunity to file your brief at least, maybe
- 4:10a little different in the ninth than the state
- 4:12courts in terms of oral arguments. But then at
- 4:15the highest level above that and the smallest
- 4:18part of the pyramid is the discretionary courts
- 4:21of review. So the California Supreme Court, the
- 4:23US Supreme Court. And their role is different
- 4:27from the intermediate courts, which are in an
- 4:29error correcting role. You've got the Supreme
- 4:31Court's in terms of policy making and looking
- 4:35to decide conflicts or issues of statewide importance
- 4:39or nationwide importance. And so they get to
- 4:43decide whether they take your case or not. And
- 4:45so that's a different level of persuasion and
- 4:48different way of persuasion and a different kind
- 4:50of you know, golden ticket to get into those
- 4:53courts. So I think thinking about where you're
- 4:56at, you know, which level you're at and what
- 4:59their larger purpose is, and what you need to
- 5:02show in particular at the discretionary level
- 5:05to kind of get in the door is an important factor
- 5:09of context in thinking about the decision -maker's
- 5:13perspective. So I wanted to bring Melanie into
- 5:17this. Introductory discussion a little bit in
- 5:20terms of the standards of review and traditional
- 5:23air. Oh, OK. So we're going to talk about later
- 5:28details about the review standards of prejudicial
- 5:31error. Those are fundamental rules that you need
- 5:35to understand to fit your arguments in. But one
- 5:37thing I wanted to say in the beginning is about
- 5:40we're talking about persuasive appellate brief
- 5:42writing. And I want to say it's not just a technical
- 5:45skill that we can teach you the parts of the
- 5:47brief. It really reflects your thinking. So if
- 5:51your thoughts are jumbled, they'll come out jumbled
- 5:54on the paper. So if you're having a hard time
- 5:57writing, the best thing to do is to step back
- 6:01and reconsider what you really want to say. What
- 6:04are you trying to say? And it's what the justices
- 6:07and research attorneys do when deciding cases
- 6:09and writing opinions. So just keep that thought
- 6:12in mind as we're talking about the different
- 6:14parts of a brief. And I guess I'll hold off on
- 6:18the AI stuff towards the end, because I wanted
- 6:21to talk a little bit about that. And I think
- 6:24we were going to talk next about the audience.
- 6:28Yeah. OK. So I was going to spend a little bit
- 6:33of time on talking about the audience, because
- 6:36you're writing for an audience. And as we all
- 6:38know, you're You have to fit your arguments into
- 6:44the audience. So I'm going to do the state court
- 6:46of appeal audience. What happens very briefly
- 6:49and talk about what happens to a brief and then
- 6:52what are the implications of that. So what happens
- 6:55when a brief gets to the court of appeal? It's
- 6:57held until the case is fully briefed. It will
- 7:00then be randomly assigned to a chambers and the
- 7:03chambers will get the brief and the record. And
- 7:06at that point. In a lot of courts, a calendar
- 7:09deadline will be set. So the appellate court
- 7:13has much more time than a trial court, but it
- 7:15is like a conveyor belt with compressed time
- 7:18to review, analyze, and then decide the case.
- 7:22So within the chambers, a justice has two permanent
- 7:25attorneys and central staff attorneys available.
- 7:28Generally speaking, everybody does it differently,
- 7:31but a justice will assign each case to an attorney
- 7:34who will prepare a draft opinion. Few judges
- 7:38will drive will do that, but generally speaking,
- 7:40the attorneys are doing that and these are experienced
- 7:43attorneys pretty much. I'll talk about that in
- 7:45a minute, but. So the process varies between
- 7:48chambers and some attorneys work independently,
- 7:52just draft up an opinion. The other. Some of
- 7:55them are directed told do this and given a written
- 7:58memorandum more frequently. They were collaboratively
- 8:02with the justice as they're reviewing the record
- 8:04and writing the draft opinion. OK, so once the
- 8:07justice edits and is happy with the draft. It
- 8:11looks like an opinion, exactly like an opinion.
- 8:13It's not a memorandum in the city courts of appeal.
- 8:16And then he or she sends it out to the panel
- 8:19members. And then there's a different track if
- 8:22the oral argument is requested or not. And so
- 8:24we'll talk about that in the next session tomorrow
- 8:27about the oral argument, how that works. But
- 8:29so what are some of the implications from understanding
- 8:32these case processing procedures in the California
- 8:35Court of Appeal? The first is the absolute importance
- 8:39of your brief to the outcome. Initial decisions
- 8:42are made. A draft opinion that looks like an
- 8:44opinion is prepared. The brief is important.
- 8:47Secondly, the Court of Appeal justices have a
- 8:50professional attorney staff to help them scrutinize
- 8:54the brief and the record. So you need to support
- 8:57everything you say with factual or legal citations.
- 9:01And like in the trial court, they won't take
- 9:03your word for it. And they often do independent
- 9:06research. I would almost in every case do independent
- 9:08research. So you need to be very helpful. Third,
- 9:12and perhaps most important, although this may
- 9:16be obvious, the justices and their staff not
- 9:19only need to read a conclusion, reach a conclusion.
- 9:22They need to prepare a well -reasoned opinion
- 9:25explaining their conclusions, and they don't
- 9:27have a lot of time to do that. So what do they
- 9:30need from you? They need you to help them write
- 9:35the opinion. When the justices are reading briefs,
- 9:38they're not only thinking about the conclusion,
- 9:39they're thinking, how is this opinion going to
- 9:41be written? So you need to be informational rather
- 9:46than argumentative. The goal is to have the justices
- 9:49cut and paste your brief into their opinion.
- 9:52At the California Court of Appeal, information
- 9:55equals persuasion. It's the most effective tool
- 9:59for convincing the justices. And if you remember
- 10:01nothing else from this session, think about that
- 10:03when you're writing your next brief. Now, the
- 10:05point may seem obvious, but the majority of briefs,
- 10:08even experienced practitioners, don't do that
- 10:11or don't think about that. So let me just give
- 10:13you a quick example. If you say something in
- 10:15your brief like, for the trial court to have
- 10:17decided the light was green was an outrage and
- 10:20a blatant and astonishing disgrace and made absolutely
- 10:24no sense. That's not persuasive. Why? Because
- 10:28it's not informational. It's not something that
- 10:30justices are going to write in their opinion.
- 10:32Compare that with the court made a finding that
- 10:35the light was green. The only admissible evidence
- 10:38on this point showed that the light was red.
- 10:40Sight to the record. The law prohibits recovery
- 10:43to a plaintiff driving against a red light, cite
- 10:46the law. Maybe not convincing to a jury, but
- 10:49very convincing to an appellate court, yes. So
- 10:52we'll talk later about the extent to which you
- 10:54add emotional appeals, fairness or unfairness,
- 10:57but at the bottom, based on the way that the
- 10:59appeals are processed in the California Court
- 11:01of Appeal, they need objective facts from you
- 11:04and then explanation about how that applies to
- 11:07the case. Let the court make the inferences and
- 11:09reach conclusions without hitting it over the
- 11:11head about how terrible the error was. Two other
- 11:14quick things to note about the audience in the
- 11:16California Court of Appeal. First, if you attend
- 11:18any talk from any justice and you ask, how do
- 11:24I improve my briefs? They will say, make them
- 11:27shorter. And why? Is it because they don't like
- 11:30to read? Well, they do have a lot of things to
- 11:33read thousands of pages every month, but no,
- 11:36that's not really the core reason. The reason
- 11:38in my experience with talking to justices and
- 11:41research attorneys is that long briefs reflect
- 11:44lazy thinking. They contain empty phrases and
- 11:48confused logic rather getting to the point. The
- 11:51brief writer hides behind the words. So think
- 11:54about that when you're drafting and editing your
- 11:55next brief. Finally, the other thing about a
- 12:00defining feature of the California courts of
- 12:02appeal today is that there are many new justices,
- 12:06many of whom have no appellate experience, and
- 12:09even limited trial court experience. And so you
- 12:13need to think about that when you're drafting
- 12:14your brief. There are so many new court attorneys.
- 12:18For many years, everything was stable. The justices
- 12:21didn't move. They stayed and stayed and stayed.
- 12:23But suddenly, for reasons that we can talk about
- 12:25at some other time, that there has been major
- 12:28movement. And so you need to be aware of this
- 12:30and explain things in your brief, maybe more
- 12:33basic than you used to have to, and not assume
- 12:36familiarity or experience. So MC, do you want
- 12:41to take the federal? Sure. Oh, I'm sorry. Can
- 12:45you go back to the slide? We're not done yet.
- 12:46Thank you so much. So yeah, I mean, I think there's
- 12:50really two things that are the focus of our overall
- 12:54presentation here. and that kind of go across
- 12:59state and federal before I get into the sort
- 13:02of federal court audience, is first, you are
- 13:08writing to an audience who you were asking to
- 13:12do something for you. You're not writing to an
- 13:15audience to say, wow, that was a fabulous story.
- 13:18I enjoyed reading it. And it was really great
- 13:21to read it on the beach or whatever. No. asking
- 13:23the court to do something based on the story
- 13:27that you're telling them. And it really helps
- 13:30because they're writing an opinion from this.
- 13:32They're writing a result, both a reasoning and
- 13:36a disposition, which means what are they telling
- 13:39the lower court to do? They're sending it back
- 13:41to the trial court. What do you want them to
- 13:45tell the trial court to do? You know, number
- 13:47one, number two, number three. that this is one
- 13:50of the most important ways, I think, to help
- 13:53any appellate court, state or federal. Not only
- 13:58from my experience or Melanie's experience, but
- 14:01as Connor mentioned at the beginning, I have
- 14:04a podcast where I've interviewed, oh my God,
- 14:07like almost 100 appellate judges from around
- 14:10the country. And many of them have commented
- 14:14about this. We don't... Get enough from the from
- 14:19counsel in most cases telling us what do you
- 14:22want me to do if we agree with you? What do you
- 14:25want me to do because that is the ultimate? Point
- 14:30of the whole opinion the opinion is to direct
- 14:32a court to do something to you know Of course
- 14:36describe the law and provide guidance to to litigants
- 14:40But it's also ultimately, that's the bottom line
- 14:44of why they're writing an opinion. So that's
- 14:46an important thing to remember. You need to know
- 14:49your audience because you need to persuade your
- 14:52audience to come to a particular result that
- 14:55you want, that would be beneficial to your client,
- 14:57that would be beneficial to the law and all of
- 15:00that. And so understanding who is reading your
- 15:03brief, who is part of the decision -making process
- 15:06at both of these levels and what their particular
- 15:08roles are and sort of how the process works behind
- 15:11the scenes, it's important information for you
- 15:15to be able to persuade. So as Melanie talked
- 15:19about the state court scenario, the federal courts
- 15:24are different, similar in some ways, but different
- 15:27in others. They have, of course, staff also,
- 15:32but it's generally a rotating staff of one -year
- 15:36law clerks who are either recent New graduates
- 15:39or relatively recent graduates from law school
- 15:42who spend a year or two on the judges staff,
- 15:46and they are reviewing the cases alongside the
- 15:49judge and the panel of judges. And, you know,
- 15:55early motions are heard by a separate motions
- 15:57panel within the court that's rotating during
- 16:04the months. So if there's an early motion, it
- 16:07usually won't be with the merits panel unless
- 16:10it's deferred to them. And then unlike the California
- 16:14Court of Appeal, there are bench memos circulated
- 16:18by individual chambers to the rest of the chambers
- 16:21who are involved in the particular case, but
- 16:26there's certainly not opinions And there's not
- 16:30conferring back and forth on, other than discussion
- 16:35generally, maybe some comments about the bench
- 16:38memo or something like that. But the conference,
- 16:40the true conference that the justices or judges
- 16:43have on the Ninth Circuit is after oral argument
- 16:46in the room right behind the bench. So that's
- 16:50different from the Court of Appeal. And also
- 16:54different from the Court of Appeal in California
- 16:56is that you don't get oral argument unless the
- 17:00panel decides that it wants to hear oral argument
- 17:03from you. So in the Ninth Circuit, the brief
- 17:06is important for a different reason than the
- 17:08state court of appeal, which is that may be the
- 17:11only opportunity you get to really talk to the
- 17:13justices and present your client's case. So that's
- 17:19another important scenario. I do want to comment
- 17:23on some changes. As Melanie was talking about,
- 17:27changes of the guard in terms of the justices
- 17:31themselves on the state courts of appeal. There's
- 17:34certainly been a lot of movement in that regard
- 17:36in the past few years. So there are newer court
- 17:39of appeal justices sprinkled around the state.
- 17:44But there's also been a change in the federal
- 17:47court in the Ninth Circuit, some personnel changes,
- 17:51but more importantly, I think over time has been
- 17:53their perspective on who their law clerks are.
- 17:58Oh God, 20 years ago when I clerked and I were
- 18:01clerked for Judge Fernandez, I was extremely
- 18:04rare because I had some law firm practice experience
- 18:07when I came in as a law clerk. It was almost
- 18:09unheard of at that point in time to have additional
- 18:13experience. Now, the judges on the Ninth Circuit
- 18:18will definitely look for people who maybe have
- 18:22a district clerkship but also have a couple of
- 18:24years experience at a big firm before or any
- 18:27kind of practice before coming to the court.
- 18:31And so you have also sometimes some have designated
- 18:36sort of continuing clerkship positions. So there
- 18:39may be some clerks who are just coming for the
- 18:44one or two years and moving on with their careers.
- 18:47Some judges now have their own permanent law
- 18:50clerks. So one of their three clerks is permanent.
- 18:54So there's a change in that perspective, and
- 18:57I think a change in who that audience is, who's
- 19:01reviewing your briefs. So that's an important
- 19:03consideration to kind of see that trend or be
- 19:06aware of that trend. The court also has career
- 19:10law clerks up in San Francisco who handle the
- 19:14motions calendar and other aspects. So there's
- 19:18always been that hybrid, but within chambers,
- 19:21there is a change as well. So I also wanted to
- 19:24mention other audiences. We're talking about
- 19:27the decision maker audience, but there are other
- 19:31audiences involved in crafting the brief. The
- 19:34client, obviously, trial counsel who has perspectives
- 19:39to bring, important perspectives to bring to
- 19:42the case, and obviously, perhaps, concerns about
- 19:45a remand. What am I going to have to work with
- 19:48upon reversal? And they might want to have some
- 19:51say about that. And then there are other colleagues
- 19:56as well, who I put in the category of some cases,
- 20:00you don't just have the client and trial counsel
- 20:03and various in -house counsel if you're representing
- 20:06a company, but you also have perhaps consultants
- 20:10or other people that they want to weigh in. Sometimes
- 20:14in appellate cases, there'll be appellate advocates
- 20:21writing the brief at one firm, and then there'll
- 20:23be appellate consultants at another firm reviewing
- 20:27it and weighing in, or a retired judge weighing
- 20:31in and providing their comments, either at moot
- 20:33court or on the brief. So all of that mix is
- 20:38involved in writing the brief as well. And you
- 20:41can't ignore that. That is part of the process.
- 20:44But that whole group should be directed towards
- 20:48the decision maker audience and what they need
- 20:51to get the job done and what is the most persuasive
- 20:54brief to that audience. So you have to sometimes
- 20:57balance things, for example, if the client wants
- 21:00to see factually in the brief, but may be too
- 21:02extraneous to include if you want to have a thorough,
- 21:07fair approach towards the decision that you want
- 21:10from the court. So you have to balance all of
- 21:12those all towards the points that Melanie made
- 21:17and I've made about who your decision makers
- 21:20are, because that's ultimately what the client
- 21:21wants. The client wants to win, so what do we
- 21:24need to do to persuade? Okay, next slide. So
- 21:32we're going to, with that decision maker framework
- 21:36in mind, we're going to go through different
- 21:39parts of the appellate brief and kind of walk
- 21:43through, as I said, some of those decision -making
- 21:46junctures that you can come to and really ways
- 21:51of thinking about each of these parts of the
- 21:53brief and the role that they can play. So next
- 21:56slide, please. So we're gonna start with the
- 22:01table of contents. Not many people talk about
- 22:04the table of contents or, you know, mention this
- 22:08in a... persuasion, brief writing way, but it
- 22:11really is so important. It is the first thing
- 22:16I read when I get the other side's brief, if
- 22:20I'm writing a reply brief. It's the first thing
- 22:23that many judges and their staff read. It's the
- 22:27roadmap. What are the arguments in this brief?
- 22:30What's the beef in this case? What is the story?
- 22:34It's the table of contents. which is the first
- 22:37entry point into the case. It's also, as Mel
- 22:41and I were talking and preparing for this, it's
- 22:44also for me, I personally, and maybe you'll find
- 22:48this helpful, I personally use the Table of Contents
- 22:51as kind of a guide or outline for the brief itself.
- 22:56That's the first thing I write once I have come
- 22:59to some firm conclusion about which issues I'm
- 23:03going to raise. and start putting together the
- 23:08brief. Because the table of contents should really
- 23:10tell the story of your brief. And it should tell
- 23:15it easily and pretty. So we're talking about
- 23:18formatting and obviously in the table of authorities,
- 23:24which relates to the table of contents, you want
- 23:27to cite your authorities in the format that is
- 23:34native to the court you're in. So Blue Book for
- 23:36federal court, California Style Manual for state
- 23:39courts. Why do you do that? Because it makes
- 23:41them feel comfortable, number one. And number
- 23:43two, it makes it very easy for them to just drop
- 23:46in parts of your brief into their opinion, which
- 23:49is the goal. So let's see. I'm going to give
- 23:56one example or a couple of examples of table
- 23:58of contents. But before I do that, I want to
- 24:00cover some fundamentals, I think, that will show
- 24:04up in these table of contents, which is first,
- 24:10you're you are telling a story. You're telling
- 24:12a larger story. You're telling the story of this
- 24:14case, but you're also telling a larger story
- 24:17of where this case fits in the stream of the
- 24:21law. So when I think of our job on appeal as
- 24:29describing where this case fits or should fit
- 24:33in the stream of the law. So there's the law
- 24:35is a stream that's naturally flowing and you
- 24:40are a rock that your case is a rock that goes
- 24:43into that stream. Should that rock allow the
- 24:48stream to continue to flow the way it is and
- 24:51unobstructed or should it? change the flow in
- 24:55some way of the law. And that fundamentally is
- 24:58always the question that you're addressing in
- 25:02an appellate brief, because that is how the justices
- 25:06are thinking about it too. They're like, are
- 25:09we sticking with what we've got? Are we allowed
- 25:11to not stick with what we've got, depending on
- 25:13what court we're in? And where does this fit
- 25:16within the larger set of the law, because I don't,
- 25:20especially at the Supreme Court levels, I don't
- 25:22want to make a decision that seems fair and right
- 25:25to this particular plaintiff, but creates a whole
- 25:29hornets nest of problems for other cases or creates
- 25:32a rule that is a huge departure from where the
- 25:37law is going and creates consequences for others
- 25:41that we either don't intend or don't want. That,
- 25:48when I say storytelling, that's not just the
- 25:52story of your facts in your case. That's more
- 25:54of a trial thing. Here you're talking about your
- 25:56case, but also, in doing so, making the court
- 26:03want to rule for you. And then the second part
- 26:05of it is presenting the law in a way that gives
- 26:11the court a path to rule for you. So I think
- 26:13of those two things as being put together in
- 26:16this. And you also want to think about in doing
- 26:20your table of contents, especially since this
- 26:22is the first stop for a lot of judges and their
- 26:25staff, you want to direct it towards clearly
- 26:29orient them about where you are in the case.
- 26:32Is this a trial court, a jury verdict that's
- 26:36being reviewed? Is this emotion? What phase are
- 26:43you asking the court of appeal to review it at?
- 26:47And that can show up in the table of contents.
- 26:50And then also thinking about what is the point?
- 26:53What do you want the court to do for you? Do
- 26:55you want the court just to get interested enough
- 26:57to take the case that is a discretionary review
- 27:01stage, a petition for cert or a petition for
- 27:04review? Or is this a merits briefing or briefing
- 27:07in the Court of Appeal where you want this brief
- 27:10to lead towards a very particular substantive
- 27:14result? So I thought I'd give just a couple of
- 27:19examples of different ways to do this. And I
- 27:21apologize that they're a little bit dense slides,
- 27:24but you can kind of pull them out and focus on
- 27:27them later if you like. Next slide. So the first
- 27:35example is from a Ninth Circuit brief as NAPALE,
- 27:40which we won. And you can see, first of all,
- 27:46the first thing I want to point out is the way
- 27:49typically we'll do this statement of facts is
- 27:52to make it present tense. And there's a purpose
- 27:55for that, which is to bring the court sort of
- 27:58immediately into the case. This is not something
- 28:01that's happened long ago. It's happening now
- 28:05as far as the court is concerned. And it's pretty
- 28:10brief, but tells the story of what's the factual
- 28:14reason we're here. Oh, the city has an ordinance
- 28:18on this particular house operated in violation
- 28:22of that zoning code. Oh, the city accommodated
- 28:27certain kinds of these homes, but nonetheless
- 28:29denied this application to operate. And then,
- 28:32oh, what happened? Oh, yes, the city was sued
- 28:35and the city won following a jury trial. Okay,
- 28:40so we know important things about the facts legally
- 28:43that the court of appeal will care about. Oh,
- 28:45I'm reviewing a jury verdict. I'm going to be
- 28:50a little more hands off in some degree for that
- 28:53as opposed to if it's a de novo review of a motion.
- 28:57And then the legal argument really walks the
- 29:01court through each of the key decisions that
- 29:05were made that the court. needs to decide, oh,
- 29:12there was a summary judgment and a renewed JMOL
- 29:15motion on this particular question. Okay, so
- 29:18the question of whether it's preserved or not,
- 29:20you can see that in the argument. And then, oh,
- 29:25we also have a reasonable accommodation argument,
- 29:27sort of we've broken them down into each thing,
- 29:29which helps the court realize, oh, these are
- 29:33all of the items I need to decide to decide this
- 29:36case. And then, I think of note here is responding
- 29:45to the other side, since this is Napali's site.
- 29:49The state also became involved in this case and
- 29:52intervened. So we have a whole separate section
- 29:55about new issues introduced by the state, you
- 29:58know, don't change anything. Basically, the first
- 30:01part is the legal argument about the arguments
- 30:03that were made or not made below by the party
- 30:06opponent. Then we've got grouped together after
- 30:10that nothing the state now says makes any difference
- 30:13to the outcome. And, you know, you should just
- 30:17affirm. So that's sort of the, the thinking of
- 30:20that organization, you know, as a Napoli in the
- 30:249th circuit. All right. Next example. I wanted
- 30:30to give an example of a discretionary review,
- 30:34you know, a cert petition. And what you're trying
- 30:38to show, your reasons to grant the petition,
- 30:42this is the purpose of the cert petition. Obviously,
- 30:46you want to kind of get the court oriented towards
- 30:49going your way if they grant review as well.
- 30:52So there's a little bit of a merits part. But
- 30:54you want to get them interested that it satisfies
- 30:56the criteria for Supreme Court review. And you
- 31:00also want to get them interested in your case,
- 31:03your particular parties. Here, again, we have
- 31:08very real -time description, present tense of
- 31:15these things that happened long ago. But before
- 31:19that, we have a background section on Holocaust
- 31:22-era artworks and recovery and kind of showing
- 31:25the scenario, the milieu in which these particular
- 31:29parties find themselves to also show that they
- 31:34are part of a larger story factually, but also
- 31:37a larger story legally. They are not the only
- 31:39ones that are going to have the problems that
- 31:42occurred in this case. And actually, strangely
- 31:44enough, continue to occur because the issue in
- 31:47this case had to do with how to apply the HERE
- 31:50Act, which extended the limitations period for
- 31:54Holocaust art recovery claims and other kinds
- 31:57of Holocaust recovery claims. And since this
- 32:00time, The Supreme Court did not grant review
- 32:03in this case. And since that time, Congress has
- 32:06amended the Here Act. And now there are more
- 32:08fresh arguments and there'll probably be another
- 32:10petition at some point about the new Here Act.
- 32:14So, you know, if you want to talk about the stream
- 32:16of the law, each of your cases is one in the
- 32:19stream. So, in here, we say, okay, look. We have,
- 32:25you know, a state law lodges defense has been
- 32:28determined to override a federal statute. Oh,
- 32:32federal statutes are right in the bailiwick of,
- 32:34you know, of Supreme Court review. And that seems
- 32:37really odd that a state court gets to override
- 32:40Congress, basically. And then the second argument
- 32:44or the second question for review being you know,
- 32:50is there some problem just procedurally? Did
- 32:53the court get into a factual assessment or not
- 32:56at this stage and should it have done so? And
- 32:58then you also see in the table for the main issue
- 33:01having to do with the interpretation of the federal
- 33:05statute is this case is an ideal vehicle for
- 33:08review. So you want to also show, you need to
- 33:10show, hey, it's a great issue and we also present
- 33:14it really nicely. Not only do we have sympathetic
- 33:17petitioners, but we also have a great vehicle
- 33:20for the legal question that we're asking you
- 33:23to review because that's often a reason why the
- 33:25court, well, not going to argue. All right. So
- 33:28next slide, I'm going to turn it over to Melanie,
- 33:31who's going to... Yes. We've only gone through
- 33:33a couple slides, so we're going to have to speed
- 33:35up a little. Yes. So thank you, MC. Fantastic
- 33:39thoughts. So I'm going to talk about introductions,
- 33:43which to me is maybe one of the most important
- 33:47parts of an appellate brief when you're a research
- 33:49attorney or a justice reviewing the brief. Why?
- 33:54because you want the justices to read your brief,
- 33:58and a good introduction provides an entryway
- 34:01for the court to do so. So consider two houses,
- 34:05one with an open door, you see flowers, chocolates,
- 34:09delicious fruits, and a one that requires you
- 34:13to navigate a difficult maze, which you're going
- 34:16to walk into. If justices get lost in what you're
- 34:22trying to say in the introduction, they will
- 34:25put down the brief and read the other one first
- 34:29that doesn't have the maze. And so you have completely
- 34:33lost your chance to persuade the justices to
- 34:36be the first one, or if you're the respondent,
- 34:39but you need to invite the court into your brief.
- 34:44So how do you do this? The key to a good introduction
- 34:49From the court's point of view, I even experienced
- 34:54attorneys don't necessarily, appellate attorneys
- 34:55don't necessarily agree with me, but I'm telling
- 34:57you the audience what they want. Be concise and
- 35:01be clear, the two C's. Convey in simple and plain
- 35:05language what the case is about, what's the appellate
- 35:09issue, why the court should rule in your favor
- 35:11and what you're seeking. The introduction should
- 35:15succinctly introduce a stranger. somebody who
- 35:18knows nothing about your case, to the key parties,
- 35:20issues, and procedural posture. The court needs
- 35:23a big picture introduction, not a bunch of inside
- 35:26tedium, no matter how important you think the
- 35:29details are to the case. Draw the court in so
- 35:34they will understand your appeal and start thinking
- 35:37that something wrong might have happened. Make
- 35:40it interesting and readable so the court will
- 35:43want to continue reading the brief. Now this
- 35:45doesn't mean that you sacrifice complex ideas,
- 35:50but it means presenting your facts. Think of
- 35:52the elevator moment. Many of you may have gone
- 35:57to fancy legal writing classes and told to develop
- 36:00a theme in your introduction. That's absolutely
- 36:03true, but don't let these fancy techniques or
- 36:07theme development get in your way of providing
- 36:10the information the court wants and needs to
- 36:13be persuasive to get into the brief. Keep it
- 36:16simple, short, and understandable. So what's
- 36:21the style of the introduction? One word, simplicity.
- 36:25And really, this applies throughout the whole
- 36:27brief. Simplicity is crucial to a persuasive
- 36:31introduction. Quoting Chief Justice John Roberts,
- 36:35you want to take the judge by the hand and take
- 36:38him along with you. Think of it as spoon feeding.
- 36:44Use plain language, simple words, shorter sentences,
- 36:50short paragraphs. Have a non -lawyer, have a
- 36:53paralegal somebody read the brief and knows nothing
- 36:56about your case. Read the introduction. What
- 36:59are the biggest mistakes in an introduction?
- 37:02Starting in the middle. I'd say maybe 80 % of
- 37:05briefs do this. If you do this, you'll lose the
- 37:08justices because they're completely unfamiliar
- 37:10with your case that we talked about. They get
- 37:12the case. They know nothing about it. They have
- 37:14to, in a month or two, they have to figure it
- 37:17out and write it. So if you start in the middle,
- 37:19you've lost the justices. Remember when you first
- 37:23learned about the case? Or if you would tell
- 37:25somebody about the case, use that perspective
- 37:28to explain to the court. The second biggest mistake
- 37:31that you see a lot is being argumentative. Research
- 37:36attorneys do not find explicit argument in the
- 37:41introduction to be helpful. Why? Because the
- 37:43reader's not there yet. And if you're pounding
- 37:47the court or the research turning on the head
- 37:51with some argument, it's they're not going to
- 37:54accept it without reaching their own conclusion.
- 37:57Let the court reach that conclusion without explicit
- 38:00argument. I know we've all been told this, but
- 38:02think about when you're doing the introduction,
- 38:04show, don't tell. The fourth biggest mistake
- 38:08is too lengthy, repetitive, repeating the entire
- 38:12argument. It's nice because you don't have to
- 38:14put citations in the introduction. So a lot of
- 38:18times people want to just say their whole argument
- 38:20in the introduction. That is The judges get irritated
- 38:23with that because it's repeating and it's not
- 38:26effective because you're not citing just you
- 38:28know be summary a page is often I mean. There
- 38:32are complicated cases where I've had more than
- 38:34a page of introduction, but if you can aim towards
- 38:37a page, that's good. And then finally, having
- 38:40a contract style introduction, introducing every
- 38:43party, every cause of action using initials and
- 38:46acronyms are not helpful. So let's put some of
- 38:49these ideas in more concrete terms by considering
- 38:51some. Introduction examples. Most of these examples
- 38:55are from actual briefs, but changing the identifying
- 38:59facts. Some of them are extreme, but they demonstrate
- 39:02a point. So let's go to the next slide. Yes,
- 39:10so this one was actually from a brief. And it's
- 39:14how criminal briefs used to be, and a lot of
- 39:17civil briefs too. They think that you need to
- 39:20say every count, every cause of action, dates.
- 39:24This doesn't do what I said to do, is to briefly
- 39:27and succinctly say what the case is about, what
- 39:29the issue is, and what you want. And so let's
- 39:35go to... Let me see it's notice all the all caps
- 39:39to because that you when you read a novel if
- 39:42you have it all caps your eye stops. It's not
- 39:45easy and here and after Churchill. You don't
- 39:48have to say that so you can look at this later.
- 39:51I'm not going to keep on screen now, but you
- 39:52can see this is not a good introduction example
- 39:551 be the next slide, please. Is that's the same
- 40:00thing. I won't read it all, but a jury found
- 40:03defendant committed numerous crimes. That's one
- 40:05sentence with everything you said, including
- 40:07three burglary counts. The court imposed a 15
- 40:10year sentence. The court aired in denying defendants
- 40:13motion to suppress evidence found during a warrantless
- 40:16vehicle search. OK, that gives you a lot of information.
- 40:18The police officers based their search on stale
- 40:21information under settled Supreme Court authority.
- 40:23The search was unconstitutional. That is an effective.
- 40:27much better introduction than the first one.
- 40:30You can see that right off. Okay, let's go to
- 40:32example two. This illustrates plopping the justices
- 40:38in the middle and failing to give them context.
- 40:41And this actually was a brief, names are changed,
- 40:45but it had to do with, you can tell from just
- 40:48kind of skimming it, because that's of course,
- 40:51the justices when they're assigning the cases
- 40:53or when they're reading it, they first skim.
- 40:55And you know there's a easement problem, there's
- 40:58prescriptive easement, encumbrance, you know,
- 41:01some names down there, but you don't know anything
- 41:02about what happened. Where are you? Where are
- 41:04you? This is not going to be helpful. And actually,
- 41:08this case was about two neighbors fighting over
- 41:12a small triangle of property between their parcels,
- 41:16and the issue was historical use of that property.
- 41:18After reading this introduction, the justices
- 41:22are likely to throw down the brief and go to
- 41:24the other side, completely wasting your opportunity
- 41:27to inform. It just, it's not good. So let's go
- 41:31to example three. And this is an example of a
- 41:34contract style of introduction, which you see
- 41:37a lot as, you know, I'm talking about being a
- 41:39research attorney and seeing this. First of all,
- 41:42again, the all caps, you know, abbreviating plaintiffs,
- 41:46UCL, FDA. This is not helpful. It's not narrative.
- 41:50It's not explaining what happened. And so people
- 41:56do this a lot. Example 3B is an example of a
- 42:02better written for the same case. Go to the next
- 42:05slide. Plaintiffs. So you just say plaintiffs.
- 42:10You don't have to say all the names. File the
- 42:11class action alleging several statutory consumer
- 42:14claims causing personal injuries. OK. You know,
- 42:16that's what happened after the court gave plaintiffs
- 42:19leave. The plaintiffs filed an amended complaint,
- 42:22and they still didn't show that the claims were
- 42:26timely. And then plaintiffs admit they're aware
- 42:29of their injuries. And then the last sentence
- 42:32you note, the trial court erred to deny defendants
- 42:34demur without leave to amend. Now, there's many
- 42:37ways of doing it, but these two paragraphs encapsulate
- 42:40what you need to tell the court, easy to read,
- 42:43and it's clear. Let's go to the next one, respondents
- 42:50brief. Yes. So this one is an example. And many
- 42:54of these, I'm not going to read them all because
- 42:55this is a reply brief. Reply briefs are critical
- 42:59in the process of appellate decision -making
- 43:01because that's where you hone in on the real
- 43:03issues. But this first sentence, submit a brief
- 43:06permeated by overt remittance representations,
- 43:08patent misstatements, unabashed mischaracterizations.
- 43:11No. That's not telling you what the core issue
- 43:13is. And then you go down a little ways and they
- 43:16talk about ad hoc reasoning, argument by assertion,
- 43:19argument ad nauseam, generalization from non
- 43:22-existent evidence, red herring, straw man arguments.
- 43:25Okay, so the judges know that you've taken Latin
- 43:28classes, you took logic classes in college, but
- 43:31they don't really care about that. This is not
- 43:33helpful using fancy terms. They're not, you could
- 43:37say this whole thing in one sentence that the
- 43:40respondent relies on facts that are not in the
- 43:42record and engages in personal attacks. The purpose
- 43:47of the introduction and a brief is not to make
- 43:50you look smart, that you had really good classes
- 43:52in college. It's to make the judge feel smart.
- 43:55It's to make the judge feel like it understands
- 43:58he or she and it can reach a conclusion on its
- 44:01own. And in a reply, in both response, you have
- 44:05to be affirmative. Don't just attack the other
- 44:07side because the opinion, as we talked about,
- 44:10they need to write an opinion. So they need to
- 44:12be affirmative. Let's go to the next slide. And
- 44:15I'll just go over this quickly because the time
- 44:18is going by. This is just an example. You need
- 44:20to think about in the introduction and throughout
- 44:23the briefs how you're going to call the parties
- 44:25and putting initials like GMVNA is very unhelpful
- 44:30and sets back your brief because the judges have
- 44:33to remember who was that and I had one water
- 44:37resource case when I was there as a research
- 44:40attorney, I had a whole chart of all these initials
- 44:43that every time I read, I had to look at the
- 44:44chart. Who are they talking about? What are the
- 44:46initials? These parties know what they're talking
- 44:48about because they've gone through the trial.
- 44:49But the research attorney, the justice does not.
- 44:53Association, if you're representing the neighborhood
- 44:55association, it's great. You're talking about
- 44:56neighborhood association or association. Try
- 44:59to stay away from plaintiff and appellant, because
- 45:00that's not how the courts use those abbreviations.
- 45:06And then just very quickly, there are three Gs.
- 45:08OK, let's say there's minors. There's three Gs
- 45:11in the case. I've seen people call them in parentheses
- 45:14GRS, GLS, GNS, GS1, GSN. That is like so hard
- 45:18to understand. Instead, call them brother, neighbor,
- 45:21friend, something like that. Think about an easy
- 45:23way. You're helping, just as MC said, you're
- 45:26helping the judges make a decision, make it easy
- 45:28for them. The final example slide I have is,
- 45:32next slide, please. And this is an example of
- 45:37humor, using humor. With apologies to Dorothy
- 45:39and Toto, we don't appear to be in California
- 45:41anymore. Courtesy of the repetition filed by
- 45:44the Smith Corporation, we have been transported
- 45:45to a dreamlike world in which law and facts are
- 45:47so distorted as to be almost unrecognizable.
- 45:51I put this here, it's generally recommended to
- 45:54not... be used this kind of approach very sparingly
- 45:57to be kind of funny or to use this approach.
- 46:01But in this case, it actually worked well. Other
- 46:05than the names, this was filed by a current justice
- 46:08of the Court of Appeal when he was an attorney.
- 46:13And he filed this. And later on, he was told,
- 46:16much later, by the justices that this really
- 46:19worked, that it caught their attention, and it
- 46:21was really effective. So if you feel, you know,
- 46:24you think hard about it, but if you want to be
- 46:26creative and want to try to be funny, it might
- 46:29work. So think about it, talk to your colleagues
- 46:31about it. Okay, I'm going to hand off to MC to
- 46:36briefly talk about narrative introduction, a
- 46:40kind of a different way. Next slide, please.
- 46:45Thanks, Melanie. Yeah, I put sort of the last
- 46:48introduction point and this introduction point
- 46:50as sort of the the extra credit or the layering
- 46:55on top of the very fundamentals that Melanie
- 46:58had been talking about in terms of an effective
- 47:01introduction. Once you've got those together,
- 47:05you can start getting a little fancy with this
- 47:07kind of stuff. So the humor part, and now a more
- 47:11creative narrative approach I'm going to give
- 47:13an example of. I think the correlation between
- 47:17both of these, if you're going to do something
- 47:19creative, is to think about, again, in that prior
- 47:23example, the analogy to Dorothy and Toto in The
- 47:29Wizard of Oz was directly related. He got very
- 47:33quickly from that to the problem. The problem
- 47:37is they've got the law wrong. That's not how
- 47:39it works in California. And that is the point
- 47:42of the brief. So if you're going to do something
- 47:44like this, don't belabor it and just have it
- 47:47be very tied to the point you want to make. So
- 47:51this other variation of creativity is telling
- 47:57the story, connecting it to a larger issue. And
- 48:02let me just move to the example of the next slide.
- 48:08So this relates back to the table of contents
- 48:11that we saw the cert petition in the Zuckerman
- 48:15versus Metropolitan Museum of Art case. And this
- 48:19is part of the introduction. And to the left
- 48:23is actually a picture of the introduction of
- 48:26the brief itself, where the question at issue
- 48:30is ownership and return of the Picasso painting
- 48:36that is pictured in this photograph of the living
- 48:40room of the relatives of the petitioner. We situate
- 48:48this and show how it was part of their family,
- 48:51was part of their collection, and basically we'd
- 48:53like to be back there again. This has been done
- 48:59also really well by Randy Schoenberg in the Maria
- 49:03Altman case in the district court and the complaint
- 49:06that he filed. Same kind of thing, the background
- 49:08in the very beginning is really the story. By
- 49:11the time you're done with this part of the introduction,
- 49:14you want to rule for these people. And you see
- 49:19what's gone on in the Holocaust, but you also
- 49:24see how it's tied together. Here you see while
- 49:28they were forced to sell it this this painting
- 49:31in order to buy their freedom to to to leave
- 49:35countries that were either taken over influenced
- 49:38by the Nazis and and then the next part of it
- 49:42is that. The Met had very sophisticated ability
- 49:47to figure out the true ownership of this and
- 49:50chose not to do so. And so then that leads to
- 49:52the question of their ability to get a return
- 49:56now. So I think that idea of just different types
- 49:59of creativity, you're putting a photograph, which
- 50:01I will say was an exhibit. In the particular
- 50:04case, it was from the record that we could include
- 50:10in the brief. pictures, photos, things like that,
- 50:13sometimes graphs that illustrate things better
- 50:17than just a narrative can, those can pop out
- 50:20and help the court understand the issue very
- 50:24quickly and move forward. And sometimes those
- 50:27are things you can use in the body of the brief,
- 50:28but in the intro. Okay, next slide. So we're
- 50:33moving on from the intro to the statement of
- 50:36facts. I know we spent a lot of time on the introduction,
- 50:38but I think that we've covered a lot of the key
- 50:40principles in the intro that equally apply to
- 50:44the rest of the brief. And so as Melanie pointed
- 50:50out, you want to be accurate, right? You want
- 50:52to maintain your credibility with the court.
- 50:54So you want to make sure that whatever part of
- 50:56the record that you're citing to support your
- 50:59factual proposition is correct, is accurate,
- 51:02actually supports what you're saying, and you're
- 51:05not overstating things or citing to something
- 51:08that you happen to know because you handled the
- 51:11case in the trial court, but for some reason
- 51:13it just never ended up being in the trial itself
- 51:17or in the trial court record. And then again,
- 51:21the same principle of you're moving towards a
- 51:24particular persuasion. are focused on, as Melanie
- 51:29gave great examples for the introduction, same
- 51:31thing in the statement of facts. You're focused
- 51:33on moving the court towards a particular direction
- 51:36on a particular issue, but you are not going
- 51:40to completely bury or hide or ignore bad facts.
- 51:45There are ways to address them. There are ways
- 51:48to have them be in a dependent clause or whatnot
- 51:51instead of the primary part of a brief. And then
- 51:55also the same thing of you want to acknowledge
- 51:58that issues were preserved or not preserved.
- 52:02Nobody raised this issue below, but that's okay.
- 52:05This court can decide it because it's a pure
- 52:08legal issue on undisputed facts. We don't need
- 52:10to develop any more facts in this case. You have
- 52:12the facts you need, even though nobody may have
- 52:15made this particular argument. So those are important
- 52:19things to kind of come clean about, but in a
- 52:23way that's still persuasive. All right, next
- 52:25slide. And this, I think, is reminiscent of some
- 52:31of the things that Melanie walked through as
- 52:33well in terms of you're telling a coherent story.
- 52:37You are persuasive, but somewhat objective. You
- 52:40can't completely just present your side of the
- 52:43case and not the other side's. This is something
- 52:45we often see even at the designation of the record
- 52:48stage. One side will only designate the things
- 52:51they filed and their side of the case and their
- 52:53story and things that are good for them. But
- 52:56that's very nice, but it's not nice for the Court
- 52:59of Appeal because they need to see, you know,
- 53:01the whole thing, what actually happened and make
- 53:04a decision based on all of the presentation,
- 53:07not just one side's presentation of what happened.
- 53:12And again, that are that may be a little bit
- 53:16different than than what you would argue in the
- 53:18trial court. And also to be aware of. Always
- 53:25that you're complying with the standard of review
- 53:28that you're sometimes signaling to the court
- 53:30that you're doing that sometimes if there are
- 53:32a lot of different issues, maybe 3 or 4 issues
- 53:35presented, all of which have different standards
- 53:37of review, but 1. it was a substantial evidence
- 53:40question, you might want to signal in a footnote,
- 53:44in the statement of facts, we are presenting
- 53:48these facts in accordance with the substantial
- 53:52evidence standard of review and briefly recite
- 53:54that. And then, of course, continue to tell an
- 53:57interesting story. So Melanie is going to have
- 53:59some of her signature examples that she's going
- 54:02to share with you now for statement of facts
- 54:05briefing. Next slide. The next slide. And I just
- 54:09want to say that in the factual section, before
- 54:11we get to this, be objective. It is not the place
- 54:15to argue. Because the courts, if you ask justices,
- 54:19what is the biggest mistake is argument in the
- 54:22statement of facts. They just want to know what
- 54:24the facts are. You could deal with problems later.
- 54:27State the facts accurately. And as research attorneys
- 54:30tell me, cite to every, tell the court where
- 54:35to find what you're saying. Okay, so this is,
- 54:39there's different ways, being objective, but
- 54:41there's different ways of telling your story.
- 54:43Now these, the next two slides very briefly are
- 54:47an example of how to tell your story in a way
- 54:51that's objective and at the same time persuasive.
- 54:54And this is the two, this slide and the next
- 54:56slide are from the same case, the same standard
- 55:00of review from two different opinions in the
- 55:03same case. The first one, Wait, turn back, please.
- 55:06Go back. I think you went ahead. Yeah, go back
- 55:10to the next one, please. Go back to the next
- 55:13slide. Yes. OK. So this first slide is from the
- 55:17Eighth Circuit. And the next one is going to
- 55:19be from the California Supreme Court. This is
- 55:22the case to whether the defendant was trapped
- 55:24into buying pornographic materials. Go back to
- 55:28this next. I'm sorry. Stay on that slide from
- 55:31before, please. Go back. Yes, no, go back. That's
- 55:36going forward. Go back to the 8th Circuit opinion.
- 55:40Okay, stay there until I... Yeah, thank you.
- 55:43No. Oops, okay. Oops. Yes, please stay there.
- 55:48Don't move it. Okay, so when... This is the 8th
- 55:50Circuit. When police searched a California pornography
- 55:53bookstore... They discovered the defendant had
- 55:56ordered two magazines featuring photos of nude
- 55:59adolescent boys in a brochure listing stores
- 56:01selling sexually explicit materials. And later
- 56:04on in this paragraph, they talk about the materials
- 56:06had oral anal sex and heavy masturbation. Not
- 56:09surprisingly, the court confirmed the conviction.
- 56:12That was their first paragraph. Now, please go
- 56:15to the next slide. This is People versus Jacobson
- 56:17in the Eighth Circuit. We'll go to the United
- 56:19States Supreme Court opinion. And this same case,
- 56:23same facts, but they start out with, in February
- 56:251984, petitioner, a 56 -year -old veteran turned
- 56:29farmer. who supported his elderly father in Nebraska,
- 56:33ordered two magazines and a brochure, not from
- 56:35a pornography bookstore, from the California
- 56:37adult bookstore. And it goes on without explicitly
- 56:41identifying the oral sex, all that. And not surprisingly,
- 56:45this court reversed on the conviction. So study
- 56:50those as a good example of ways to be objective,
- 56:54state the facts, but tell your story. So I think
- 56:58I'm going to the next one is I'm going to go
- 57:02to please go to the next slide. Okay, and so
- 57:07I think I'm going to skip this one because we're
- 57:09running out of time. We have a lot more to get
- 57:11to, but this talks about the importance of discussing
- 57:15only relevant facts. This came from an actual
- 57:17brief names changed, but there's so much in here
- 57:21about the father in law and the cousin and the
- 57:23purpose and no wonder where. None of that had
- 57:26anything to do with the issue which concerned
- 57:29flight, the instructing on flight after a crime,
- 57:32whether that constitutes guilt. This was really
- 57:35irritating to the justices. They'll start writing
- 57:38these facts that if they're important and they
- 57:41find out none of them were relevant, and it's
- 57:43not even a story you need to tell. So let's go
- 57:46to the next slide, please. OK, so we're going
- 57:50to start legal argument. Keep in mind, okay,
- 57:55so the three elements of persuasive argument,
- 58:00logos, ethos, and pathos. And I'm going to go
- 58:03very briefly on this because you've all studied
- 58:05this in law school and other classes, but logical
- 58:08reasoning is the backbone of a brief, of course,
- 58:11because It's the backbone of the court's written
- 58:13opinion, as we talked about. Court must engage
- 58:16in legal reasoning to reach its conclusion. But
- 58:18the other elements are important, and you really
- 58:21need to think about those. Ethos, the advocate's
- 58:25credibility and accuracy. Be straightforward
- 58:28and honest with the court. The court always looks
- 58:31at who the attorneys are, and they have long
- 58:34memories. So if you're not straightforward, if
- 58:36it's not in this case and the next case, they
- 58:38will remember that. Honest, citing to the right.
- 58:43Pathos is more, is kind of a really interesting
- 58:47issue, which many attorneys, experienced appellate
- 58:51attorneys debate. Alone, it will not persuade
- 58:55fairness and unfairness of what happened. But
- 58:59it can, it can make a difference in a case. So
- 59:03don't ignore it. Don't say this was unfair, but
- 59:06show it. Show it by your facts. And I'm just
- 59:09going to quickly talk about a case where I had
- 59:13with the justice, the results felt really unfair.
- 59:17But the appellant raised an issue that just wasn't,
- 59:19it was a discretionary ruling. It wasn't going
- 59:21to get anywhere. So what the justice asked me
- 59:24to do is take more time. Delvin see if you can
- 59:28find something. So I spent a week looking and
- 59:31I found a legal issue. We found a legal issue
- 59:34and we ultimately identified it. It hadn't been
- 59:37briefed. We asked for it to be briefed. We asked
- 59:39the parties to file supplement briefs to address
- 59:42the issued oral argument and the court ended
- 59:44up reversing. And I think a lot part of it is
- 59:48the unfairness of what happened without. the
- 59:50attorney saying is unfair. So that's just an
- 59:52example of a way that that can matter. Next slide.
- 59:59We're still in the legal argument and MC is going
- 1:00:01to take this one. Yeah, thanks, Melanie. Yeah,
- 1:00:05I mean, I think one way to think about another
- 1:00:08way to think about what Melanie was just talking
- 1:00:10about is you know, making the court want to rule,
- 1:00:13sort of the emotional part, the pathos part,
- 1:00:16wanting to rule for your client, and then providing
- 1:00:19a good pathway to do so that does not do violence
- 1:00:23to the law overall in order to rule for your
- 1:00:25client. So those are sort of the two main points
- 1:00:30to think of, I think, in briefing. So an important
- 1:00:35part of the legal argument, of course, is issue
- 1:00:38selection, right? Sometimes you know, your initial
- 1:00:42list might be many. You know, it could be six
- 1:00:44or seven issues or something like that. Resist
- 1:00:47the urge to have multiple issues. Generally,
- 1:00:51no more than three to four issues, even less
- 1:00:55than that if you can help it because more than
- 1:00:59that looks like, you know, maybe a scattershot
- 1:01:01approach. And then within those, you want to
- 1:01:04prioritize your issues, the strongest ones, and
- 1:01:08that may cause you to jettison some of those
- 1:01:11or figure out how you want to order it and how
- 1:01:15you want to walk the court through it. One suggestion
- 1:01:18I want to make with this before turning it over
- 1:01:21to Melanie again is that sometimes you can think
- 1:01:26about different ways of ordering the brief that
- 1:01:29help direct the court. So for example, if you
- 1:01:31have one. that would result in total reversal
- 1:01:37and no new trial for your client. And then you
- 1:01:40have other issues that would result in a partial
- 1:01:42new trial or a new trial. Consider putting first
- 1:01:47the legal issue that results in the whole case
- 1:01:51going away forever. because that is the best
- 1:01:54result that your client obviously would want.
- 1:01:57And also, if the court agrees with you on that
- 1:01:59point, perhaps the court doesn't need to decide
- 1:02:02or delve as much into the other issues. And you
- 1:02:05can kind of tell the court, if you agree with
- 1:02:07me on this, stop reading here. And that sort
- 1:02:12of is the roadmap for the brief. So I'll turn
- 1:02:15it back to you, Melanie. Oh, okay. Just in criminal
- 1:02:18practice, if there's any criminal practitioners
- 1:02:20here, you do have to raise every issue, and particularly
- 1:02:23if it's a federal -based issue for later for
- 1:02:25habeas. So you still have to prioritize them.
- 1:02:29So just a caveat to that in selecting issues.
- 1:02:32Selecting in civil cases, less is more because
- 1:02:37the time that the research attorney has, if you
- 1:02:40give fewer, they'll have more time to research
- 1:02:42and focus. If you give a lot, They give a little
- 1:02:45bit of time, so it's kind of like institutionally.
- 1:02:48That the small the focusing issues is helpful.
- 1:02:52Okay, so on the next slide please. Okay, so.
- 1:02:58The standard of review, and I'm going to talk
- 1:03:00about the basics. This is beyond that. We could
- 1:03:03give a two -hour presentation on the standard
- 1:03:06of review, but we'll start with just kind of
- 1:03:08going over it because you need to think about
- 1:03:10this for the court. This is what the court's
- 1:03:13thinking about when you're drafting your brief.
- 1:03:15So what is a standard of review? It's a standard
- 1:03:19by which the court reviews an asserted error.
- 1:03:23The standard measures the degree of deference
- 1:03:27that an appellate court will give to trial court
- 1:03:32determinations. And there's a line. It goes from
- 1:03:35a lot, almost complete deference, to none. And
- 1:03:42appellate courts take these standards very seriously.
- 1:03:45And their analysis is viewed through these prisms.
- 1:03:48You have to understand that it's very common
- 1:03:50for justices and research attorneys to comment
- 1:03:53after reading an appellate brief. This must have
- 1:03:56been the trial attorney because he or she wants
- 1:03:58to retry the case. Your brief needs to identify
- 1:04:02the discrete legal errors under the specific
- 1:04:06review standards and you need to understand that.
- 1:04:08So although it's beyond the scope, I'll just
- 1:04:11very briefly go over these three. De novo, independent
- 1:04:14review, no deference at all to the trial court,
- 1:04:20primarily questions of law, contract interpretation,
- 1:04:23statutory construction. Second one, substantial
- 1:04:25evidence, very deferential. The court will affirm
- 1:04:32if it's a factual question, unless no evidence
- 1:04:35at all to support. If you're an appellant, it's
- 1:04:39a huge uphill battle to prevail. And why? Because
- 1:04:43the courts assume that the trial court or the
- 1:04:46jury are able better to evaluate the credibility
- 1:04:50and the tone and everything of the witnesses
- 1:04:54or the whole trial. It's there's a lot of deference
- 1:04:57given there as opposed to de novo, which it's
- 1:05:00the courts of appeal are the experts in the law
- 1:05:03and then abusive discretion is similar to substantial
- 1:05:07evidence. It applies more to procedural questions.
- 1:05:10But if the court relies on a wrong factor and
- 1:05:12exercising discretion, that could be a solid
- 1:05:15basis for reversible error. So. So if you're
- 1:05:21the appellant. You want to find a de novo review
- 1:05:25legal issue. If you are the respondent, you want
- 1:05:29to characterize an issue as just substantial
- 1:05:31evidence. So the standards of review are not
- 1:05:38set in stone, so you can make arguments on them,
- 1:05:41but you want to be thinking about that. And a
- 1:05:45couple of just quick things about the standard.
- 1:05:47Don't discuss the actual standard at length,
- 1:05:50like, the nova what it is it's a question of
- 1:05:52law you know the courts know it the courts you
- 1:05:54know write a paragraph about what you know but
- 1:05:56a lot of people will put pages of what substantial
- 1:05:58evidence is and that's not helpful and you've
- 1:06:01wasted your your time and then don't state it
- 1:06:05and forget it don't state the standard review
- 1:06:07and just go on and make your arguments use your
- 1:06:10make your arguments in the language of the standard
- 1:06:13of review you know so say that some you know
- 1:06:16that they're that legally that is on an independent
- 1:06:19review so keep that in mind when you're making
- 1:06:22the arguments, and be thinking about the standard
- 1:06:24of review and the trial court in every portion
- 1:06:27of your brief from facts, as MC said, and also
- 1:06:31talking to your client about whether to bring
- 1:06:33an appeal. Many times we talk to our clients,
- 1:06:36say that, look, the only issues here, it's hard
- 1:06:38to get them to understand. The only issues here
- 1:06:40are factual issues, substantial evidence. It's
- 1:06:43very unlikely that you'll fail. So let's go to
- 1:06:48the next slide. All right. So as Melanie mentioned,
- 1:06:56standard review is super important. You want
- 1:06:58to keep it in mind at all times and sort of live
- 1:07:02the standard of review in your brief. Don't just
- 1:07:04recite it and leave it. I wanted to address a
- 1:07:09couple of things here in terms of legal authority
- 1:07:11and sort of the use of that in the legal argument.
- 1:07:17Now, the first principle is leveraging your best
- 1:07:21authority. And what your best authority is differs
- 1:07:24depending on where you are, right? Obviously,
- 1:07:27you're like, hey, if I'm in the Intermediate
- 1:07:31Court of Appeal and there's something coming
- 1:07:35out in a good direction for me and it's binding
- 1:07:38in some way on the court, then I can use that.
- 1:07:41That would be great from a jurisdiction that's
- 1:07:43binding. But in doing that, you have to say,
- 1:07:46well, what court am I in, for example, because
- 1:07:49if you're in the Ninth Circuit, if another panel
- 1:07:52has concluded something a certain way, then another
- 1:07:55panel, unless you're en banc, has to accept that
- 1:07:59within the Ninth Circuit. So that's a really
- 1:08:01great authority to use to say, hey, another panel
- 1:08:04has already decided this and you're bound by
- 1:08:06it. If you're in the California Court of Appeal
- 1:08:08and you say, oh, I have another decision, even
- 1:08:10by this same panel, yes, it might be persuasive,
- 1:08:13certainly, to that panel. But maybe even that
- 1:08:17panel can change its view. There is no horizontal
- 1:08:20stare decisis in California. So that authority
- 1:08:22may be better in the Ninth Circuit than in the
- 1:08:27Court of Appeal. So what's best depends on where
- 1:08:31you find yourself. Also, of course, don't be
- 1:08:35an ostrich about negative authority. If there's
- 1:08:37some authority that goes another way, you want
- 1:08:39to be the first one to explain it about why it
- 1:08:43may or may not or should not affect the outcome
- 1:08:45in favor of your client. You don't want the court
- 1:08:48to discover it on its own or for the other side
- 1:08:51to be your friend on the other side to be the
- 1:08:54first one to address it and therefore undermine
- 1:08:56your credibility and get the first crack and
- 1:08:59analyzing that authority. The other principle
- 1:09:03I think that a lot of appellate lawyers use and
- 1:09:06I use as well is using parentheticals. So if
- 1:09:11you cite a case and a particular pin site, if
- 1:09:14there is a great quote or there's a good summary
- 1:09:18of what that case is about that you can put in
- 1:09:21the parenthetical, that's often helpful rather
- 1:09:25than just a couple of citations to cases where.
- 1:09:28there's no orientation to the court about what
- 1:09:30they're about or why you're citing them other
- 1:09:33than the general principle you are using. OK,
- 1:09:41Melanie, I want to turn it back to you. I don't
- 1:09:43know if you want to say one more thing. Just
- 1:09:45following up on that parenthetical, it's very
- 1:09:48unhelpful if you say it proposition. You cite
- 1:09:51a case, and then you put in a parenthetical exactly
- 1:09:54what you just said. I mean, if there's something
- 1:09:57interesting to say in the parenthetical, but
- 1:09:59don't just repeat what you said if that case
- 1:10:01supports it. So I talked to several research
- 1:10:04attorneys about, OK, I'm talking to all these
- 1:10:07wonderful people. What's something about legal
- 1:10:10argument that you really don't like? And they
- 1:10:12talked about that don't go into detailed facts
- 1:10:15of other cases unless it's legally it's important
- 1:10:19that another case reach the same conclusion.
- 1:10:22attorneys will want to talk about the facts,
- 1:10:25even when the standard is substantial evidence
- 1:10:27or abusive discretion. The law is clear. The
- 1:10:30question is what the court did. And so reading
- 1:10:34a brief with a lot of detailed facts about what
- 1:10:41happened in each particular case, it's very complicated.
- 1:10:45It's not that persuasive. And it's just, especially
- 1:10:48how a lot of attorneys kind of explain them,
- 1:10:51very confusing. And it doesn't move the brief
- 1:10:54forward very well. So if you're going to, there
- 1:10:56are times when you really need to explain the
- 1:10:58facts of a case, if it's really on point and
- 1:11:00it's a legal issue. But many times it's overused.
- 1:11:05So we can go to the next slide. Okay, so I'll
- 1:11:11just very briefly, because I know we're getting,
- 1:11:13we are over time, need, discuss need for Prejudice
- 1:11:17section, okay. So, even if you show error under
- 1:11:20the proper standard review, you do not necessarily
- 1:11:23prevail. You must show one more thing, prejudicial
- 1:11:26error. Prejudicial error means the error mattered
- 1:11:29to the result. It's a constitutional requirement.
- 1:11:32And the general rule is the reasonably probable
- 1:11:35standard. So, just from the court's point of
- 1:11:38view, decision -maker's point of view, it's critical
- 1:11:40for you to include in the brief. It's a very
- 1:11:43frequent Reason for affirmance, if you're the
- 1:11:46appellant, it's not that hard to find an error
- 1:11:48because trials are long and there's often errors,
- 1:11:52but it's very difficult to find an error that
- 1:11:54would have changed the outcome. So how did the
- 1:11:57decision -maker approach the prejudicial error
- 1:11:59issue? There's many different factors. They look
- 1:12:01at the evidence, the arguments, the jury instructions,
- 1:12:04the jury questions, the verdict form, the opening
- 1:12:06and closing arguments, which it's important to
- 1:12:08make sure you have a reporter for both those
- 1:12:10opening and closing for the prejudice issue.
- 1:12:12Um. But really, it comes down to, and I was taught
- 1:12:16this by Justice Howard Weiner, who I worked in
- 1:12:19his chambers, it comes down to a judgment call.
- 1:12:22So what Justice Weiner used to do when we had
- 1:12:25an issue about clear error, but is it prejudicial?
- 1:12:28He would call me and the other research attorney
- 1:12:30into his chambers. And we have a freewheeling
- 1:12:32discussion about all of these different factors.
- 1:12:35And would it have been back to the result? So
- 1:12:37it's kind of a holistic approach. And you, as
- 1:12:40the attorney, need to help the justices marshal
- 1:12:43those facts, make the best argument you can.
- 1:12:47And it's almost like this is the time where you're
- 1:12:49kind of making that argument. You're being argumentative.
- 1:12:52You're putting all those things together for
- 1:12:54the court. But it is, at basis, it's a judgment
- 1:12:57call. So I'm going to go to the next slide. Yeah,
- 1:13:04and we recognize we're a few minutes over, but
- 1:13:06we want to give you a little bonus information
- 1:13:09of appellate advocacy after the opinion, thinking
- 1:13:14about rehearing petitions and petitions for review
- 1:13:17or petitions for cert. Before we do that, I saw
- 1:13:20that there was one question in the Q &A about
- 1:13:24tables of contents. and whether they're helpful
- 1:13:28or we would recommend including them even in
- 1:13:31short briefs. If you're doing points and authorities
- 1:13:33in the trial court, maybe it's eight pages or
- 1:13:36something like that, is a table of contents helpful?
- 1:13:41Melanie's nodding and I'm nodding, so we would
- 1:13:43say yes, because that is a roadmap to your brief.
- 1:13:46And I'll say, I wear another hat as an arbitrator
- 1:13:52for AAA, and I get short briefs like that. We
- 1:13:57have, you know, short merits briefs or other
- 1:14:01things like that, and I find it really helpful.
- 1:14:04It's still a really helpful roadmap, no matter
- 1:14:06how short your brief is, to kind of volunteer
- 1:14:09and provide that to the court. Okay, back to
- 1:14:11Melody. And that goes to the theme of spoon feeding
- 1:14:15the judge, and especially the trial judges are
- 1:14:18so overwhelmed. I've heard them say just give
- 1:14:20me what's going on very plainly and clearly.
- 1:14:24And that's not often done because we read the
- 1:14:27trial court briefing. OK, so rehearing. You get
- 1:14:30an unfavorable result, even though you've done
- 1:14:32all these good things. You've been objective.
- 1:14:35You've been good. You provide the information.
- 1:14:37After reading the opinion and possibly having
- 1:14:40a glass of wine, you ask yourself, hey, I want
- 1:14:43a petition for a hearing. They got it completely
- 1:14:45wrong. Well, if it's just to disagree with the
- 1:14:48outcome, it's probably not worth your time or
- 1:14:51client's money. The court has already considered
- 1:14:54it. And institutionally, it's a conveyor belt.
- 1:14:57They're not going to. They almost never change
- 1:15:00their minds on a rehearing petition, maybe once
- 1:15:03a year at most. Even that's probably too much.
- 1:15:06They just don't. I had one case where we had
- 1:15:10three decades where we did grant one. And that
- 1:15:14was because we identified the wrong standard
- 1:15:16of review. And we granted hearing under the different
- 1:15:20standard of review. There was actually a different
- 1:15:22result. So that was good, but that's one in 30
- 1:15:25years. So there's some circumstances where you
- 1:15:29must file a rehearing petition, though. And that's
- 1:15:32if you're planning to file a California Supreme
- 1:15:34Court petition for review. And there's a fact
- 1:15:38that's wrong or unsupported in the Court of Appeal
- 1:15:42opinion. You have to raise that in the rehearing
- 1:15:44petition, or you're bound by that fact. In the
- 1:15:48petition for review in the California Supreme
- 1:15:49Court. Now, there also are a couple circumstances
- 1:15:52where you might want to raise it, even if you're
- 1:15:54not going to bring a petition, even if that circumstance,
- 1:15:57if an argument was raised in the briefs, but
- 1:16:00the court didn't address it. You should you should
- 1:16:03raise it and the court will then probably address
- 1:16:06it, but probably they will not grant a rehearing.
- 1:16:09They'll just modify the opinion and that's usually
- 1:16:11happens when you ask for a hearing. If there
- 1:16:13was a mistake, they will modify, but. but have
- 1:16:16the same judgment. Or if the court ruled on an
- 1:16:20unbriefed issue, that's really important. If
- 1:16:22the court ruled on something, you didn't get
- 1:16:24a chance to brief it, definitely bring a petition
- 1:16:26for review for that, and the court may allow
- 1:16:29additional briefing. As a practical matter, it
- 1:16:31must be filed 15 days after the opinion is filed,
- 1:16:34and rehearing petitions get decided really quickly.
- 1:16:37They go on the top of the pile. The biggest,
- 1:16:40my final thing on this one is the biggest mistake
- 1:16:42is attacking the justices or the trial judge,
- 1:16:46failing to adhere to your ethical duties. And
- 1:16:49as I said, justices have long memories. And I,
- 1:16:52I can't tell you how many times, cause you're
- 1:16:54frustrated. You've drank that glass of wine and
- 1:16:57you're just like, I, they got it wrong. And you,
- 1:17:00and you kind of attack them and. Justices talk
- 1:17:04about that. You hear that a lot, chatter about,
- 1:17:07oh, did you see that petition for rehearing?
- 1:17:09That was not appropriate, and it angers them.
- 1:17:13It's not going to move anything forward. You're
- 1:17:15not being persuasive. So be professional. Just
- 1:17:18write that down before you start writing it.
- 1:17:20Be professional. OK, then getting to this California
- 1:17:23Supreme Court petition for review, very rarely
- 1:17:27granted, less than 5%. Probably closer to 2%.
- 1:17:32The petition must be filed within 10 days after
- 1:17:35the court of appeals decision becomes final and
- 1:17:37usually becomes final 30 days after it's issued.
- 1:17:43Grounds for review in the California Supreme
- 1:17:45Court are different. Look at rule 8 .500B and
- 1:17:50focus only on those grounds. Don't focus on,
- 1:17:53oh, there was a terrible error because as MC
- 1:17:56said, it's not an error correction court. The
- 1:17:59two most important things you have to talk about
- 1:18:01is resolve conflicts among the Court of Appeal
- 1:18:05and settle an important question of law. So focus
- 1:18:09on that. I worked at the California Supreme Court,
- 1:18:11and I did some of the memos for the petitions
- 1:18:15that we get. And if it's just error, it's just
- 1:18:19we say, yes, there might have been a mistake,
- 1:18:21but this is not a reason to take it. So it's
- 1:18:23very unhelpful just to focus on the error. just
- 1:18:28a little tiny footnote there are some they call
- 1:18:30them rescue missions where maybe once every five
- 1:18:33years the court will be like oh this was terrible
- 1:18:35in this case so they'll take it and they'll decide
- 1:18:38it but i wouldn't depend on that and i wouldn't
- 1:18:40without the other two elements an insider tip
- 1:18:44the court has issues they want to address but
- 1:18:48they're looking for the proper vehicle they want
- 1:18:51a case that cleanly presents an issue and where
- 1:18:53briefing will be helpful so Many moons ago, I
- 1:18:57worked on a big case and at the trial and the
- 1:18:59senior attorney dropped a few claims during the
- 1:19:03trial and I couldn't understand it. But later
- 1:19:04I figured out he was thinking to the California
- 1:19:06Supreme Court. He wanted to bring this issue
- 1:19:09and he wanted it to be clean. And he actually
- 1:19:11did it and he got a bedrock Supreme Court opinion
- 1:19:14having to do with the scope of a tort duty. He
- 1:19:17was thinking about that at the trial level, how
- 1:19:19to make a clean record for this issue. And also
- 1:19:23in terms of the proper vehicle, the courts will
- 1:19:25consider the quality of the briefing in the review
- 1:19:28petition. And it wants good briefing at the substance,
- 1:19:32so don't just slap it together and consider getting
- 1:19:35an expert appellate consultant to help you if
- 1:19:38you really think that's an issue. Alternatively,
- 1:19:40you can ask for depublication. And if you, if
- 1:19:44you're answering it, it's optional, but when
- 1:19:46you're answering a petition for a review in the
- 1:19:50California Supreme Court, you want to make sure
- 1:19:51you're not like, oh, this is a big case. Make
- 1:19:53it, oh, this is just a, you know, this is a small
- 1:19:56case. This is not something you're going to be
- 1:19:57interested in. This is not a good vehicle. There's
- 1:19:59many procedural issues you're not going to want
- 1:20:01to deal with. So that's just kind of some, some
- 1:20:05general things. Okay. So MC, do you want to talk
- 1:20:09about the federal court after the opinion? Sure.
- 1:20:12Next slide. Please. Thank you. Yeah, I mean,
- 1:20:16I like that last point, Melanie, of sort of this
- 1:20:19is not the case you're looking for. It's like
- 1:20:21a little Star Wars. These are not the droids
- 1:20:23you're looking for. If you're answering the petition,
- 1:20:27you don't want the court to take this particular
- 1:20:28case, even if they're interested in the general
- 1:20:30issue that's presented in that case. So I'll
- 1:20:35just highlight a couple of things about post
- 1:20:39-opinion advocacy in the Ninth Circuit and the
- 1:20:42US Supreme Court. In the Ninth Circuit, you have
- 1:20:46the option to ask for panel rehearing and or
- 1:20:51en banc. You can ask for both in the same petition.
- 1:20:55And the en banc process allows you to ask for
- 1:21:01things that you couldn't ask at the panel level,
- 1:21:03which would be, hey, there's a conflict with
- 1:21:06the Supreme Court, or there's a conflict with
- 1:21:09either other opinions in the circuit, which there
- 1:21:12shouldn't be, or there's a split with other circuits.
- 1:21:15In other words, getting out of that horizontal
- 1:21:21stare decisis problem by going to the en banc
- 1:21:25court and asking for a larger percentage of the
- 1:21:28court to review your case. So there's somewhat
- 1:21:35similar criteria on the error of fact or law
- 1:21:39for rehearing in the State Supreme Court or State
- 1:21:42Court of Appeal too, as Melanie mentioned. And
- 1:21:45then moving on to the next court, U .S. Supreme
- 1:21:48Court Review, obviously it's focused on federal
- 1:21:51issues, federal questions. And conflicts between
- 1:21:56different circuits or issues of again, exceptional
- 1:22:00importance that maybe this federal court is the
- 1:22:031st, 1 to address it, but it's a really important
- 1:22:05issue. And the court should move sooner rather
- 1:22:09than later to to get a uniform standard for.
- 1:22:14the nation. And for cert petitions, it's generally
- 1:22:19a 90 -day deadline, but you can ask the circuit
- 1:22:23justice to extend that time period for you for
- 1:22:28various reasons, whether you have more clients
- 1:22:31to ask or to review the petition, and also reasons
- 1:22:39you would not state in the motion for extra time,
- 1:22:43but which frequently are the case, you either
- 1:22:46need more time to get amicus together to file
- 1:22:48a brief in support of you, or also you want to
- 1:22:53get out of the dreaded October, first week in
- 1:22:58October, consideration of conference by the court.
- 1:23:02So that's when all the new lock works come in
- 1:23:04and when all of the petitions that have been,
- 1:23:07you know, rolling around the court during the
- 1:23:10summer, are all heard together. So you'd rather
- 1:23:13not be in the very first conference that the
- 1:23:16new law clerks are handling, and at which so
- 1:23:20many petitions are being considered at once.
- 1:23:22So sometimes you want to get the timing such
- 1:23:25that you wouldn't be in that unfortunate position.
- 1:23:30But depending on the circuit justice for your
- 1:23:32circuit, the Ninth Circuit is Justice Kagan,
- 1:23:35and she's relatively reasonable about extensions.
- 1:23:40All right, so that was our little bonus and thanks
- 1:23:43for sticking with us on the bonus period and
- 1:23:48just sort of another point I made earlier, but
- 1:23:54we want to reinforce, you know, have your conclusion
- 1:23:57in whatever brief it is on the merits or on rehearing
- 1:24:02or search petition or petition for review. clearly
- 1:24:06ask for what you want. You want review to be
- 1:24:08granted. You want remand for a new trial on certain
- 1:24:14issues. You want reversal with directions to
- 1:24:19under judgment in your favor. What is it that
- 1:24:21you have spent all this time briefing in the
- 1:24:24court looking at? What do you want the court
- 1:24:25to do for you? That's something to be clear about
- 1:24:29in your conclusion of whatever brief you file
- 1:24:31at whatever stage. So thanks so much for joining
- 1:24:35us. And if you have any other questions, please
- 1:24:40feel free to follow up with us or email us. I
- 1:24:43didn't see any other questions. Oh, wait, I see
- 1:24:45there's another, maybe another question. Oh,
- 1:24:48thank you. All right. Thank you for the thank
- 1:24:50you in the Q &A. So thanks so much, everyone,
- 1:24:54for joining us. Those who are joining us live,
- 1:24:57bright and shiny after Labor Day weekend, we
- 1:25:00appreciate you. And yeah, please follow up with
- 1:25:04us if you do have any other questions.