Latest / new renaissance capital / Bitcoin as a Catalyst for a New Kenya w/ Robert Kirubi
Transcript
- 0:00Ownership of something that compounds in its value is how you build wealth.
- 0:05So people, from a Kibera perspective to whatever level of society that you sit in,
- 0:12you can buy this globally liquid asset and hold on to it
- 0:15and have your ownership compound and create wealth for you.
- 0:19It could be somebody spending a million dollars on it.
- 0:21It could be somebody spending 110 shillings every month out of their pay packet.
- 0:26They both have this equal access to it.
- 0:30Hello, hello, hello. What is going on, everybody? Frank here, joined today by a very special guest
- 0:40coming to us from Nairobi, Kenya, Robert Kirubi. Robert was, honestly, it just came to mind as I'm
- 0:48coming up with this introduction here, is one of the first people, I think one of the earliest
- 0:52people from the whole continent of Africa that I followed on X. So I actually learned a lot about
- 0:57what was happening, especially in Kenya, from Robert early on. I say that maybe five, six years
- 1:03ago or something like that, something along those lines. But anyway, Robert, super, super happy to
- 1:08have you with me here. You are just a tremendous addition to the ecosystem in Kenya. And I know
- 1:15that you do an incredible amount of work behind the scenes. And I just wanted to make sure your
- 1:18voice was heard very clearly. So happy to have you here as a guest today. How's everything going?
- 1:22everything's good Frank thank you very much and indeed yeah we physically met at the ABC in Nairobi
- 1:29the African Bicco Conference in Nairobi that's when we first physically met but yeah you were
- 1:34slightly quicker it was a member we met quickly in Amsterdam in Amsterdam yeah yeah yeah that's it
- 1:41that's it so yeah you're one of the many people that I uh when I fell down the rabbit hole I used
- 1:47to follow on X and during COVID and learned a lot from people like yourself.
- 1:52So, yeah, that's appreciated.
- 1:53And thank you.
- 1:54Well, I appreciate that.
- 1:55Yeah, I was saying in terms of Kenya, I think you and Rufus were the first two people from
- 1:58Kenya that I followed.
- 1:59So that's right.
- 2:00And Kenya, it's been so it's been such a beautiful thing to witness.
- 2:03And I think that this is one of the reasons I really wanted to have this conversation.
- 2:07There's all these talks of like, what is Bitcoin country and blah, blah, blah.
- 2:10But if I had to really choose, I mean, maybe not one country, but if I had to say there's
- 2:15the top three Bitcoin countries, Kenya is up there. You have the Gridless Project headquartered
- 2:20there. You have educational programs like Bitcoin Dada and The Core. You have cool programs like
- 2:26EcoBits. There's really an infinite amount. I don't really want to run down a huge list because
- 2:30I know I'm going to miss certain ones. But there's just so much going on there. You had the Africa
- 2:34Bitcoin Conference there in 2024. So much really, really good stuff happening. And what's great
- 2:39about it is that it's all very much bottom up. It's all community based and, well, I mean,
- 2:46it's a little bit bigger than that, something like grid list. But I think it's really,
- 2:50it's exciting to see what's transpired in Kenya, especially over these last four or five, six years.
- 2:56But at the same time right now, Kenya is also, the government is crafting this VASP law. And I
- 3:02have to be honest, I've done a little bit of research on this. I'm not super familiar with
- 3:06what's in there. I've seen some mixed reactions to what's being proposed, and I wanted to break
- 3:10this law down a little bit today to see what it might mean for continued Bitcoin adoption in Kenya.
- 3:16So maybe start with a broad overview. Where are we at with the VASP law right now, and what does
- 3:20it look like for the time being? It's been a couple of years that the VASP law has been discussed and
- 3:27public participation going on and proposals and drafts put out there for the public to react to.
- 3:32where we are right now is the law, the regulations have been gazetted and that happened perhaps three weeks ago, four weeks ago.
- 3:42So it's law. So it's going to be in place as of November.
- 3:46And that's when they'll start to expect what needs to happen against that regulation to really be live and everything else.
- 3:53So I think there's a lot of people at this moment making decisions, doing what they need to do so that they are compliant as of November the 4th.
- 4:02So, yeah, there's a lot of work going on.
- 4:03But, yes, we finally have regulations in place now.
- 4:06It's moved from central bank telling all the commercial banks, don't touch this.
- 4:12Don't interact with businesses that are engaged in this business.
- 4:16It wasn't a law.
- 4:18It wasn't a regulation.
- 4:19It was a circular memo from the central bank to commercial banks.
- 4:22And with that, they were able to just to say, no, we can't do anything with this.
- 4:25Of course, as you've just said, there's been a lot of activity at local level, bottom-up level kind of thing going on.
- 4:32And that is that's happening and will continue to happen.
- 4:34But we have a regulation now.
- 4:36So now it's people now move from it's a scam, the usual FUD that you get around stuff like Bitcoin and cryptocurrency to.
- 4:46All right.
- 4:47It's legal now.
- 4:48We've actually got regulations and gazetted and everything else.
- 4:50Now, what do we do with this?
- 4:52Yeah, super, super exciting.
- 4:54I guess the biggest question in my mind, obviously, it's important for people to look at this through a clear lens and to not
- 5:02think Bitcoin is a scam and all that.
- 5:03But again, the big question in my mind is,
- 5:07will the community based programs all of the bottom up adoption will it be impacted by these laws and how so The main way they would be impacted so the regulations really focus on the supply side of the ecosystem so to speak
- 5:24So the Binances, Coinbases, Luna, Strike, and everybody else.
- 5:28So they all need to comply with some heavy, well, not heavy regulations, but there's some things that they need to comply with,
- 5:34particularly licensing fees being a legal entity within the country etc etc but you holding bitcoin
- 5:42in self-custody that's not impacted at this point okay just just where you go get it from
- 5:49and how you report against it but yes you can purchase bitcoin hold it okay one of the things
- 5:57that i've been super conscious of when it comes to regulation is whether or not a certain moat is
- 6:01created and whether that hurts startups. So we have a great company like Tando in Kenya,
- 6:06where you can spend from your lightning wallet and it settles over the M-Pesa network, which is
- 6:10their mobile money system in Kenya. Would it be harder for companies like that now to get started
- 6:16because of maybe a lot of paperwork or bureaucracy that they need to deal with? I say that also as a
- 6:21New Yorker, where we have the bit license, which is very expensive for companies to acquire. It
- 6:25takes years usually for them to acquire. Is it going to create a sort of moat for the bigger
- 6:29players that you know kind of gives them a bit more of a little bit more protection for them to
- 6:35operate and make it harder for the smaller guys or not so much no i think there will be some some
- 6:41friction for the local uh startups that have already been in place today so tanda for example
- 6:46will have to get a license as a payment processor okay um but thankfully the the licensing fee went
- 6:53from 50 million shillings down to 10 million shillings it's still a burden yeah um and yes
- 6:59I'm sure there will be sandboxes and all that kind of thing that they would need to go through for final licensing approval.
- 7:05So there will be some friction for the local guys.
- 7:08Obviously, the bigger exchanges, some of these things to be a payment processor, et cetera, is pocket change for them.
- 7:13So it'd be a lot easier for them to get into the market from that perspective.
- 7:17Okay, interesting.
- 7:18And generally speaking, does the government see any opportunity in this?
- 7:23Obviously, bringing everything kind of above board, making it all legitimate.
- 7:26There's going to be tax revenue, maybe more incentive for businesses to set up shop to serve Kenyans and all of that.
- 7:32Or is the government still kind of reluctant to see this kind of technology adopted on a broader scale?
- 7:39And I say that because people might be thinking, well, why would the government, why would it get put into regulation if the government was all that against it?
- 7:46But the reality is that what we often attribute to malice is sometimes a lack of education about the opportunities that some of this might unlock.
- 7:53So how do you think the government, generally speaking, I know it's not a monolith, but how do you think the government is looking at this industry developing within the Kenyan borders?
- 8:01I don't think they're against it. I don't think there's a fear of it now.
- 8:06There's clear understanding now that cryptocurrency is something that's out there.
- 8:11It's in the wild and it needs to be sort of understood to a degree.
- 8:16Africa and Kenya, let's speak about Kenya, has a certain specific set of circumstances that they need to deal with.
- 8:23The IMF, FATF, we're on the gray list and we're trying to get off that gray list as soon as we can because that makes access to credit that much harder if we're on the gray list.
- 8:33And obviously one of the conditions to get off the gray list to get more money is that you need to have proper regulations in place for cryptocurrency.
- 8:41Now, I can assume or I can guess or have my own personal feeling that people are being told, do this.
- 8:49You need to have regulations and laws in place.
- 8:51You need to be able to monitor these flows.
- 8:54And we're not encouraging you to really get involved in this.
- 8:57But we have stable coins and stable coins are a major part of the ecosystem today.
- 9:04And within the country, in the crypto Web3 environment, so to speak, I think everybody understands what tokenization is and what that could bring from a financial inclusion perspective, you know, tokenizing property, land, stocks, etc.
- 9:19So from that perspective, there's a desire to see what we can do from that aspect.
- 9:27When it comes to Bitcoin purely, I think there's a lot of education still to be done.
- 9:33And I guess we'll touch on that a little bit.
- 9:35It's still a speculative asset.
- 9:37It's held as an investment.
- 9:39And we just to make sure that you're protected as an investor in Bitcoin.
- 9:43When you go buy from a Binance or any other exchange, that there's protections in place.
- 9:48And that's what the the vast regulations are in place for.
- 9:52OK, it seems seems like a fairly logical step and not necessarily a bad thing.
- 9:57I mean, people should feel, I guess, secure.
- 9:58The average person who's coming to this isn't coming to this because they're looking to get involved in some sort of Wild West situation.
- 10:04They want to buy something that's going to hold some value for them and they should feel protected in that process.
- 10:09I want to zoom out just a teeny bit here and talk about how Kenyans sort of view technological development, especially maybe as it pertains to money.
- 10:18So M for those who aren familiar is the mobile money system in Kenya It a mobile money system that allows you to make payments I think without it actually it a good question without even a bank account So I think you could just have the M account You don need the bank account You do need a national
- 10:33ID from what I understand. It's not like you'd be able to go there without an ID. Okay, cool.
- 10:38So M-Pesa was kind of a really cool new invention. Actually, I have to double check out how far back
- 10:44it goes, but it was something that was adopted in East Africa. And East Africa kind of led the
- 10:48with this idea of mobile money. Kenya in particular, right? Because now, but it's also
- 10:54in now like Tanzania, some of the other surrounding countries as well, if I'm not mistaken.
- 10:58It's spreading out to more African countries, correct?
- 11:01Okay. So Kenyans, I think, and I've interviewed many people across the continent in Africa,
- 11:06there's a certain astuteness and a certain willingness to embrace new technology,
- 11:12especially when it comes to financial technology. Do you think M-Pesa kind of maybe primed Kenyans
- 11:18for something like Bitcoin? Is it easier to understand because they already have this concept
- 11:25of sort of just exchanging something with a balance on your phone, you know, paying for
- 11:29something with a balance on your phone? Yes and no. And personally, again, my personal opinion,
- 11:37I think more no than yes. Yes, we understand how to move value, money, that we understand what
- 11:45money is, which is the Kenya shilling, the US dollar. And I can understand a stable coin.
- 11:50But Bitcoin, for whatever reason, tends to get people struggling a little bit. It's always about
- 11:57what is it and how does it work and who's in control of it. And, you know, what happens if
- 12:03something, you know, if I'm holding Bitcoin and something happens, what happens? How do I
- 12:06get recourse on that? Bitcoin is still, there's a big education still to happen.
- 12:11and it's really been interesting
- 12:13the ground up
- 12:15is taken to it much quicker
- 12:17because there's a definite need
- 12:20in a community like Kibera where Afrobit
- 12:21is located and everything
- 12:23most of your viewers will understand who Afrobit
- 12:25is or where they are. If you don't mind Robert
- 12:27let me just quickly say too you can also go back
- 12:30this second season that we started with this
- 12:32podcast there's a gentleman named Ronnie Maduida
- 12:34who I interviewed. Afrobit
- 12:35is the largest informal settlement I believe
- 12:38on the whole continent of Africa
- 12:40So it's a place where I think about 600,000 people live, very low socioeconomic status.
- 12:46Many people there.
- 12:47I mentioned something, a national ID earlier.
- 12:49You need to be a Kenyan resident to have this without it.
- 12:52You cannot use M-PACE the system.
- 12:54You also can't get other goods and services.
- 12:55So Bitcoin becomes a bit of a monetary and financial lifeline for those who want to transact
- 13:00digitally or even store some value over time.
- 13:03And in Kibera, there's a circular economy.
- 13:06I actually hesitate to call it that because it's much more than that.
- 13:08It's an educational initiative and it's helping some of the people in the community to become developers.
- 13:14It's a really amazing grassroots effort to not only educate people as to what Bitcoin is, but to help find opportunities within the Bitcoin ecosystem for them.
- 13:23So please go back and check out that episode.
- 13:25But Robert, please continue.
- 13:25Just want to make sure people are up to date there.
- 13:28Yeah, I think where there's a real need for purchasing power, once they understood that on the ground in a community like Kibera,
- 13:37they picked up on it real fast. Once you move up the society hierarchy and people with good jobs,
- 13:45bank managers, whatever it might be, you have a bit of a harder time on really getting people to
- 13:51understand what is Bitcoin and how does that help me? I have investments, I have savings,
- 13:55I get a yield from my stocks and my special funds and everything else. So there is that
- 14:01thing that you need to kind of work through in terms of that education. I recall speaking with
- 14:07somebody from a bank not so long ago at a conference or after a conference and he was
- 14:12going on about you know we're going to go after the young bank we need to provide them services
- 14:16we need to do a b c d and after he spoke in the networking session sort of saying
- 14:21there's there's a whole community in kibera that uses bitcoin day to day
- 14:27and you will never see that business come across to you and it really shook the ground his
- 14:33foundation he's like i don't understand what are you talking about i said they've been doing this
- 14:37for three or four years now, they understand what it is.
- 14:40It's not a speculation.
- 14:41It's not an investment.
- 14:44This is real money, and it's helping them preserve their purchasing power.
- 14:48People are able to pay for school uniforms.
- 14:50People do their groceries.
- 14:51People can pay their school fees, et cetera, et cetera.
- 14:54And that led to further discussions with the bank.
- 14:58But there is quite a bit of more to be done around educating the wider society
- 15:04and corporates and SMEs.
- 15:05do you feel i feel like kibara there's been this really remarkable reaction to it and i'll say this
- 15:12i early on thank you thanks to you while i was in kenya in 2024 you said please go visit this
- 15:18project and i had i wrote a piece about it for forbes and i think that that attracted a little
- 15:23bit of attention to the project and the bbc eventually came and did a four minute special
- 15:27on a little uh little clip on it and then um i think associated press or reuters that are right up on it as well And it so powerful because once you especially once you see it with your own two eyes it puts Bitcoin in a totally new light for you You could feel the way it
- 15:44empowering people. It's something that if you were to be against it, I would really have to
- 15:49question how good of a person you were. I don't mean, I'm just joking there. But I think, but it's
- 15:53a really beautiful thing that's happened there. And it's not just magic. As I mentioned, the
- 15:57gentleman, Ronnie Maduida earlier, he's been a community organizer in Kibara for a long time.
- 16:04So people are being guided and they're being educated and they're being helped and they're
- 16:08having their hand held and all the stuff that needs to come with this educational process and
- 16:12this empowerment process. So it's not just magic, but I think it is this amazing case study that's
- 16:17becoming a bigger and bigger case study. And here's what this, this is what this technology
- 16:22can actually empower. This is what it can actually do for you. Do you feel like within Kenya,
- 16:27is that message getting out there more and more?
- 16:30I know globally it surely is,
- 16:32but within the people that sort of need to hear this,
- 16:34some of the people who you just mentioned,
- 16:35are there more and more instances
- 16:36of either administrators, policymakers,
- 16:40people who are working at a bank,
- 16:42whatever it is, hearing about this
- 16:43and sort of having to pay attention as a result?
- 16:47I'm doing my utmost best
- 16:48to take as many people as I can over there.
- 16:51Poor Ronnie has to deal with everybody coming in
- 16:53and saying, can I come next week?
- 16:54Can I come next week?
- 16:55and we need to keep building upon that and i think there's a there's there's a wider way that
- 17:00we can manage that other than me trying to drag people in there but once people do go in there
- 17:05it's the impact on them is really it's visible it's the and and again running has to do with
- 17:13people coming in going well i can't believe this has been going on we never heard about it
- 17:17i need to help can i do this can i do that so in that sense it's gaining traction one person at a
- 17:24time and it's growing outside of that community and outside of the wider global Bitcoin community
- 17:29as well, which is for me really key that we get as many people to understand what this
- 17:35asset is and what it can do for our country in many different ways.
- 17:40So that's been a joy to see that.
- 17:42But I'm trying to see how I can ramp up those efforts and be now we have the regulations
- 17:47in place.
- 17:48What more can we do in different ways?
- 17:50Amazing.
- 17:51Very cool.
- 17:52Yeah, I do feel for Ronnie.
- 17:53I was just messaging with him the other day.
- 17:55I think he's such a gentle, kind soul.
- 17:58I don't think he loves a ton of attention or anything.
- 18:00But at the same time, I'm sure he's happy to have the visitors, the support.
- 18:04I just don't know how he does it all over the course of a day.
- 18:06And I hope he has the support that's necessary because he's truly, he's just a wonderful, saintly human being.
- 18:13I want to zoom out a little bit there.
- 18:14You've said that Bitcoin can help on many different levels or multiple ways in Kenya.
- 18:18And you recently shared something you'd written with me.
- 18:22I think that was geared a little bit more towards maybe how Bitcoin could catalyze more infrastructure development within Kenya.
- 18:31And that might sound like a stretch to people, but for those who are maybe unfamiliar, you have the Gridless project that's based in Kenya that also operates in Kenya.
- 18:39And something like what Gridless is doing is mining Bitcoin with hydroelectric power.
- 18:43They're a buyer of last resort for these stations along the river and they're along rivers in rural Africa and rural Kenya.
- 18:50and they're in two other countries as well.
- 18:53And what it's doing is kind of incentivizing
- 18:55the build out of more energy production.
- 18:57And you did reference Gridless
- 18:58in this piece that you shared with me.
- 19:01And I get this sense that you look at Bitcoin here,
- 19:05like it could have this potential.
- 19:07You could almost supercharge
- 19:08something like what Gridless is doing
- 19:10or maybe apply it more broadly.
- 19:11I'm not sure exactly you didn't spell it out.
- 19:14But what are some ways aside from just this idea
- 19:16of maybe financial inclusion,
- 19:18like we're seeing in Kibera,
- 19:19What are some broader ways that maybe Bitcoin can help with infrastructure development in Kenya?
- 19:25Yeah, I think I'm trying to, I'm trying to, Bitcoin is such a multifaceted asset.
- 19:33And yeah, class of 2020, we all understand it as money.
- 19:38And that's where we all go straight away.
- 19:40Money, purchasing power, number go up, et cetera, et cetera.
- 19:44But it is such a multifaceted asset.
- 19:46asset and it's taken me a little while to get to the place and space that I am now thinking about it
- 19:51and I'm trying to find ways to bring it bring it to the attention of a wider community kenyan
- 19:57community outside of saying the word money which is sensitive and it triggers depending on who you're
- 20:04speaking to in the context you're in it does trigger certain reactions so bitcoin mining I
- 20:09think is a really good way to get people to engage more deeply with okay well what mining bitcoin a
- 20:16you have to explain what does mining Bitcoin actually mean and what you have to do.
- 20:20And then going through the whole economics thing.
- 20:23Kenya's blessed with geothermal energy.
- 20:25A lot of it still sits underground.
- 20:28I was working with Eric and some other people not so long ago,
- 20:31and we were talking about what it costs to dig a geothermal mine.
- 20:37And just to dig the hole is $6 million, hoping to find some steam.
- 20:42If you don't, you cap it, you move to the next section,
- 20:45you'd spend another six million dollars.
- 20:47So, you know, you do that two, three, four times,
- 20:50and people just stop looking.
- 20:52Now, the energy is there.
- 20:53Everybody knows it's there.
- 20:54It's not that easy to find.
- 20:55Obviously, I'm learning this as well at the moment.
- 20:57But if you do find it,
- 20:59then you start to build out what needs to happen
- 21:01to gather that energy,
- 21:03build up the infrastructure,
- 21:05put up the lines,
- 21:07offtake it to the local or the national grid, etc.
- 21:11There's time, there's money
- 21:12that needs to be spent to do that.
- 21:14And getting people to understand
- 21:15how Bitcoin will jump right in,
- 21:18dig the hole, find the steam,
- 21:19and we'll put the miners on top of that and monetize this energy from day one,
- 21:23which helps your economics for the wider and broader perspective of developing that geothermal field.
- 21:30So just trying to get people to understand that.
- 21:34Bitcoin is not the destination.
- 21:36It helps the economics of how we need to develop this energy that we have as a natural resource in the country.
- 21:42The moment a better paying customer shows up, Bitcoin picks up or just switches off slightly,
- 21:49and you get more revenue from AI.
- 21:53Many data centers that will spread around Kenya,
- 21:56will spread around Africa.
- 21:57You don't need the huge data centers
- 21:59that you have in the US.
- 22:00And we can be the inference edges
- 22:02for somebody sitting in Africa
- 22:06or even in Europe or wherever.
- 22:07You've got a simple AI request.
- 22:09It doesn't need to go to the big data center
- 22:11that Google has out in the US.
- 22:13It can be channeled through to inference nodes across Africa
- 22:17and you get the same results, et cetera.
- 22:20So the people are starting to understand this.
- 22:24And I'm just trying to make sure that the message
- 22:26and the discussion about what Bitcoin is
- 22:28and what it can mean outside of the money discussion,
- 22:31how else we can take this.
- 22:32And national development is something
- 22:35that I think is really important
- 22:36and on everybody's mind at the moment
- 22:38with the elections coming up next year in July, August.
- 22:41Okay.
- 22:42And is the idea here that maybe national development
- 22:45is a priority and that it can happen
- 22:47without maybe incurring taking on more debt because i know um the idea is let's stay away
- 22:53from these world bank or imf loans right how can we use what we have so we could take bitcoin mining
- 22:58say it becomes a buyer of last resort and just for the audience to kind of explain that term
- 23:02is saying so like for example with gridless when they go to a hydroelectric plant on a river in
- 23:08rural kenya they say hey do you have any excess electricity okay great you do we'll buy that from
- 23:13you but we don't want to we're not going to start running our minds at full you know running our
- 23:17miners at full blast in the morning when people are getting ready for work or at night when they
- 23:20need the light or the energy for their children to do their homework or something like that so
- 23:24we'll shut down when people need the energy and we'll turn it up when people don't so at night
- 23:29for example we could turn on the miners and we can we can mine with uh we could turn this flowing
- 23:33water into into bitcoin essentially um i think that this idea is still a relatively new idea to
- 23:41to most people in the world, especially here in New York or in the United States, people
- 23:45hear Bitcoin mining or data centers and all they think of is an energy suck versus an energy
- 23:50catalyst. So I'm curious. I know that you do try to have meetings with people who are
- 23:55major stakeholders, people, administrators, policymakers. Are they starting to come around
- 24:00to this idea that it can be a catalyst or is it still relatively new or too fringe of
- 24:05a notion for them to fully grasp or get on board with yet?
- 24:08I hope it's not a fringe idea.
- 24:14But people still need to, I think you're one of the first people that's had a chance to look at my paper and kind of review it.
- 24:21I'm still figuring out how I need to get that published and where and how and give the most attention.
- 24:28I'm hoping it triggers these discussions though, for sure.
- 24:31Got it.
- 24:31So one of the quotes that you had here, so you said in the paper, Kenya cannot wait until it's wealthy to build infrastructure.
- 24:40Two questions there. What infrastructure do you think is most needed right now?
- 24:45And then how do you sort of see the pace of that infrastructure being built?
- 24:49Meaning, so it's like, is it in your mind, is it sort of a grid list thing where it's like, OK, what where do we have sort of stranded energy or where can we start monetizing some stranded energy?
- 24:59And then how does that necessarily subsequently lead to the build out of whatever infrastructure is then needed?
- 25:05I think we've touched on this a little bit earlier in this discussion, but energy is a clear, clear need in the country, across the country to help us industrialize.
- 25:18We need to be manufacturing more in-country and not just extracting raw materials, coffee, tea, minerals, whatever it might be, exporting them.
- 25:29And then buying them back in and the value for that natural resource ends up sitting outside of Kenya, etc.
- 25:36We need to be able to move the country along the value chain and do this.
- 25:40But that takes time and it definitely takes money and it definitely takes resources.
- 25:45And Bitcoin as the buyer of first resort can help monetize and give people time to breathe, to build out all of that that comes after.
- 25:56AI is just one aspect but a fully developed geothermal field with energy being able to come out in a financially economical way without having massive loans behind it and debt that going to have to be paid back over 20 25 years and just being able to mine Bitcoin
- 26:16A, the Bitcoin is naturally mined, locally mined, and it stays in the country.
- 26:23But it's a globally liquid asset.
- 26:26So we need hard currency, whatever it might be.
- 26:28We've got that optionality now.
- 26:30We don't have that today in many different reasons.
- 26:34And then while that's there and it's funding the build out of a little town or city,
- 26:42a manufacturing hub, SCZ zones, whatever it might be, Bitcoin is helping to monetize that
- 26:50infrastructure build. And once that's in place and people move in, you understand that all that
- 26:55takes time. And then it takes time, even when they're in there, it takes time for profits to
- 27:00be made, for profits to be reinvested, taxes to be paid. Bitcoin is with you on that entire journey
- 27:06and helping to soften, shorten the time frame
- 27:10that you get those returns back
- 27:12and also help mitigate us going into further debt
- 27:16that we really don't need as a country at this moment
- 27:18and giving us an option that we've never had before
- 27:22over our 63 years as an independent country.
- 27:25It gives us some sovereignty, optionality,
- 27:28and now we can go to the external world
- 27:30and we've got some leverage now.
- 27:32Asking for loans, but we're no longer,
- 27:35listen, we really need some money to help pay for the government activity or for whatever else to build roads or whatever it might be.
- 27:41We now have some leverage and optionality that we can now face the world as a sovereign country.
- 27:46Amazing. Super, super cool.
- 27:47Another thing that you touched on a few different times in the paper was this concept.
- 27:52Excuse me, this concept of the wealth that gets produced, making sure that it affects people,
- 27:58you know, that it gets into homes and that the average Kenyan citizen feels the impact of this
- 28:04wealth being produced and kind of gets their piece of it, if you will. What does that look
- 28:09like in your mind? So let's just say Kenya goes through this process of re-industrializing or
- 28:15just industrializing in some ways. And as you said, you don't have to export goods and then
- 28:20re-import, like export raw materials, then re-import them. You could just kind of do more
- 28:23of the production within the Kenyan borders.
- 28:27How the issue in my mind, what I see here is sort of like, OK, well, maybe the corporations
- 28:33will start making some more money or maybe depending on how these partnerships are put
- 28:38together, if there's public private partnerships or something along these lines, maybe the
- 28:41government makes more money.
- 28:42How does it end up reaching the people, though, in your mind?
- 28:46So first and foremost, we have regulation now and ownership of something
- 28:53that compounds in its value is how you build wealth.
- 28:57So people from a Kibera perspective
- 29:00to whatever level of society that you sit in,
- 29:04you can buy this globally liquid asset and hold on to it
- 29:08and have your ownership compound and create wealth for you.
- 29:11It could be somebody spending a million dollars on it.
- 29:13It could be somebody spending 110 shillings every month
- 29:16out of their pay packet.
- 29:19They both have this equal access to it.
- 29:21When it comes to the larger topic of what we just talked about in terms of industrializing the country and building out, we have a huge amount of graduates come out of local universities every year and they walk into a market where there isn't enough productive capacity for them to fit into.
- 29:39So what you end up finding is that a lot of people will go to Europe, will go to America, will go to Australia to get a job.
- 29:48And they need to do those jobs outside the country.
- 29:51A, they're earning a harder currency than a shilling.
- 29:53They remit that money back to Kenya for their parents, grandparents, their siblings to help them get through the day-to-day or build houses or invest in property and everything else.
- 30:03I think we should be aiming to lower the number of people that have to go out of the country for those reasons and have that productive capacity inside of Kenya.
- 30:16Now, if we build out energy, we don't have to take loans to build roads, whatever it might be.
- 30:21And that lessens the need for the country to tax people so much and so highly, which impacts SMEs, corporates and everybody else.
- 30:31and you end up with the existing organizations either shutting down
- 30:36or finding creative ways to cut their costs,
- 30:39not recruit so many more new people.
- 30:41And here comes AI.
- 30:42We're going to use AI instead of junior people in these roles.
- 30:46So there's a lot of things going on here.
- 30:47And again, Bitcoin doesn't solve everything at all,
- 30:51but it's a tool and it gives optionality
- 30:54and it needs patience and time and very clear thinking
- 30:58and direction for it to actually build out what I'm talking about.
- 31:02So that eventually my nieces my nephews and any grandchildren that may come about from them walk into a very different Kenya than people going through right now Yeah amazing stuff And so in the piece you did mention attracting human capital to Kenya
- 31:21That's not so much bringing people in, but keeping them there versus seeing the brain
- 31:25drain that's going on.
- 31:26Perfect.
- 31:27Perfect.
- 31:28Okay.
- 31:28Very, very cool.
- 31:30I'm happy for all your guests.
- 31:31I'm happy for all your audience to come into Kenya as well.
- 31:33I was going to say, yeah.
- 31:35Come and build.
- 31:36We need you.
- 31:37It is a fantastic place.
- 31:38I highly recommend it.
- 31:39So please keep that in mind.
- 31:42One of the, you had a quote that you're a very profound thinker.
- 31:46I think the audience has probably caught on to that already, but they had a quote here
- 31:49that I want to touch on as well.
- 31:51Coordination is therefore not administration around productive infrastructure.
- 31:56It is part of productive infrastructure.
- 31:59I was hoping maybe you could break this quote down a little bit.
- 32:02I think it's quite profound.
- 32:04And when I think about the term coordination, obviously, I think about think about markets and we and, you know, price is the way that we sort of coordinate society.
- 32:13But I'm wondering what exactly you were getting at here and if it was more if it was potentially more profound than maybe this idea of Bitcoin mining being something that where you have sort of an energy buyer of last resort.
- 32:29Was there something more to this particular quote?
- 32:31it's actually the next piece that i'll be writing i just sort of drafted some notes
- 32:36earlier today let's use the vasp regulations as an example of this
- 32:42so the regulations got gazetted and everybody saw that and very clear this is legal this is in place
- 32:50and there's certain rules from a supply perspective that we need to follow to be
- 32:54compliant with this regulation now. If I'm a corporate on Monday morning, I look at that,
- 33:01I read the paper and I get today's news and I'm just like, okay, great. Okay. This is now in place.
- 33:05I'm aware of Bitcoin and cryptocurrency. I know my kids talk about it and everything else.
- 33:10Now, what do I do? How do I go from Gazette to my business, actually having Bitcoin on the treasury,
- 33:18being compliant uh how does the tax authority look at this what would my auditors do when they
- 33:26come audit me uh once a year to do my my financial auditing how will they look at this on my treasury
- 33:31my balance sheet um what does a capital markets authority what what do they need to see how would
- 33:37they react to this so there's all these elements between regulation and a use case being live
- 33:44that today I'm not in place.
- 33:48Interesting.
- 33:49So how do you coordinate those two endpoints
- 33:52to actually have somebody, a CFO and a CEO
- 33:56of a Kenyan corporation go,
- 33:59everything's in place.
- 34:01I have no point with the taxman, the government,
- 34:03CMA, central bank, my commercial bank.
- 34:06I know what I need to do.
- 34:08I can organize myself internally as an organization.
- 34:10I understand how I need to reset.
- 34:12some how do I look after keys?
- 34:15What are keys?
- 34:16How do we manage all of that kind of thing?
- 34:18And how do I show my investors
- 34:20that the Bitcoin that I say we have on the balance sheet
- 34:23is actually in the balance sheet?
- 34:25And it's safe and it's secure.
- 34:27All those pieces of the puzzle now need to be put together
- 34:30to then really drive adoption
- 34:32at a level above Kibera and Afribit levels.
- 34:36Right, right.
- 34:38That's coordination.
- 34:39How do you coordinate all those government institutions
- 34:41and departments so that everybody's in the same book and in the same page so that we don't do
- 34:47something with my with pwc but the tax man doesn't know about it and he's going to come down hard on
- 34:52me or my commercial bank once they understand that i'm keeping money in bitcoin on my treasury seat
- 34:57my accounts get shut down the coordination between all those elements is what's missing
- 35:02okay understood so it was actually i'm very glad i asked that question i interpreted it slightly
- 35:07differently but i think that um you're 100 right in that i think even in the united states here as
- 35:13we're seeing um more regulation come into the fold and you know this you know bitcoin broader
- 35:20crypto system get turned into something less taboo and more just like an everyday thing it doesn't
- 35:25mean people are so ready to accept it because i think the biggest thing that i hear from people is
- 35:29i don't want to do something wrong and then one maybe made a huge tax bill at some point or or
- 35:34report something incorrectly so as people kind of stay away from it for that reason so i think um
- 35:40there does need to be a massive amount of coordination but i think that
- 35:43it there's there's a lot of education there there's uh there's a lot that's necessary there so
- 35:49i know that i assume that you'll be a part of that i wish you the best of luck because i think it's a
- 35:55it's a really difficult thing to do it brings to mind a lot with bitcoin you know education on
- 36:00whatever levels you're doing it. It's not that it's a thankless job, but there's no Bitcoin
- 36:05central office that pays you to do that education. So oftentimes it's done with your own time,
- 36:10your own energy. So I appreciate the fact that you are taking on that responsibility because I know
- 36:15it a lot One other big point that I wanted to touch on is this idea of Bitcoin can catalyze the build out of infrastructure but then Bitcoin sort of leaving that infrastructure build out as a customer is not some sort of invitation that bitcoin has failed it actually
- 36:35it's actually bigger than that it's some indication that the infrastructure has succeeded so
- 36:40the bitcoin is the catalyst the buyer of last resort the infrastructure gets built as you're
- 36:44mentioning with let's say like taking the risk of digging a geothermal hole first thing you do is
- 36:49is mine some Bitcoin with it.
- 36:50But eventually that power ends up getting used to power,
- 36:53I don't know, a tea production plant in Kenya
- 36:55or something along those lines.
- 36:58How quickly, that to me just seems like something
- 37:02that it's a no brainer.
- 37:04How quickly do you think that that messaging
- 37:06will get across to people that it's like,
- 37:08look, we're just coming in with the Bitcoin thing.
- 37:10We're doing this thing.
- 37:11But the idea here is a more infrastructure rich Kenya,
- 37:15a more productive Kenya.
- 37:16Do you feel like you need to, is the gridless model enough to show people that that can work?
- 37:22Or do you feel like you need some wins in some different spheres as well?
- 37:26I think Eric and gridless would be quite happy to have that discussion with anybody today.
- 37:32They're spread out across a number of countries now and opening up new countries.
- 37:36And they've proven the model.
- 37:38You know, I think somebody building a remote off the grid hydro plant somewhere
- 37:45was looking at a 20-year return on investment.
- 37:50Eric comes in and that return is down to seven years, so to speak.
- 37:56And he's got all the numbers to show how that happens and what it means.
- 38:00And people pick up on that real fast.
- 38:03And initially it starts with, just give me the dollars, Eric.
- 38:07I don't know what you're doing with this thing, Bitcoin.
- 38:09And then you get two years into that process and it's like,
- 38:12listen, can we talk about the Bitcoin as well now?
- 38:14So it's just it's been a process for grid list over the last four or five years going through this.
- 38:19But they've shown that this is what happens.
- 38:23Yeah, it's do you feel also it's I was I was in D.C. recently talking about grid list and the people who are more into Bitcoin that do work in the policy world in D.C. are familiar with it.
- 38:37But what blows my mind is that it's not a bigger story globally.
- 38:41And we have seen the likes of, I think CNBC, I think Mackenzie Sagalos was there. There has been some people noticing it. But to me, it sort of surprises me that it hasn't become a bigger story because it just seems like a no brainer.
- 38:57Do you feel that some of it, and I'll give you some context, I say that half in the context of like, I live in New York State, where we have, we had a two year moratorium on Bitcoin mining in New York State, if it wasn't done with 100% renewables, which is fine, I prefer that it's done with renewables anyway.
- 39:13But we also have a data center moratorium in the works now. And I think and what's crazy about a place like New York is we don't even produce our own energy, energy bills in New York are super expensive, we import energy from Canada.
- 39:23And we do have, there is some hydro energy in upstate New York that we could be utilizing.
- 39:29Is it, what do you think is stopping this story from becoming a bigger story?
- 39:34And also, does it, do you think it would maybe help in your work as someone who's educating stakeholders in this,
- 39:42if we saw a broader adoption of this technology with this particular use case?
- 39:48It definitely will help with broader adoption in this use case for sure.
- 39:53But I think we're still, I know we spend a lot of time on X or Noster and other areas talking about Bitcoin.
- 40:02But we're really talking to ourselves.
- 40:05And I think about my journey.
- 40:06I ignored Bitcoin in 2013.
- 40:08I ignored it in 2017.
- 40:10And if COVID lockdown was really bad for me for many reasons, but it was also really good because it gave me the time to really just dig into this.
- 40:19And it was Gigi's 21 lessons that got me down the rabbit hole.
- 40:25And I had time on my couch on my own in my apartment and just going all the way through and following everybody out there that's probably a part of your audience today and learning from everybody.
- 40:35Time.
- 40:38Money is a great thing.
- 40:40And if people can see how they can make money with us, often the wrong perspective and lens when it comes to Bitcoin, people pay attention.
- 40:48So if we can do something with the energy use case, I think, and people see how quickly money comes about from doing this, then you get them on board and then you can go down that long rabbit hole journey.
- 40:58Understanding the assets and what it is and what it can do and it's multifacets, et cetera, is where we really need to start focusing on people who are outside of our global Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 41:09them. Stop talking to ourselves and start really talking to people outside because as more countries
- 41:15pass legislation, there's going to be a need for us to really be out there and welcoming them and
- 41:21holding their hands and walking through this process. So I think it's just a matter of time.
- 41:26It's taken, Eric, four or five years. And I think over the next four years, you're going to hear a
- 41:30lot about gridless. Well, one of the things I just saw him post something on LinkedIn yesterday,
- 41:36I think he's doing something with the Rockefeller Foundation.
- 41:39He's also aligned himself with some other foundations and organizations of that magnitude.
- 41:45So it seems like we're maybe getting to that cusp of maybe this sort of rhetoric, this sort of strategy just sort of enters a more mainstream discourse.
- 41:53And obviously, we'll have him and the Gridless team to thank.
- 41:57So I think we're moving in that direction.
- 42:00I guess to quickly touch on this, I don't want to go too far down the rabbit hole.
- 42:04But also, I think in a certain way, you're up against some interesting forces here.
- 42:08And I don't want to get too kind of taboo with this comment. But again, the IMF and the World Bank continue to operate because they can continue to put countries in an excessive amount of debt. And if this becomes a way for countries to maybe circumvent that and not have to go into that debt, do you feel like, you know, do we see pushback on that level?
- 42:25It's like, you know, I'm not it's not trying to get conspiratorial. We just know sort of this is the way the world works. Or do you think that generally speaking, you know, people, I don't know, higher up at these levels?
- 42:37They're not it's not monolithic, right? It's there are some people who do really want to see development happen in a way that feels most sustainable for countries and to give countries their sovereignty, as you talked about having Kenya be more sovereign.
- 42:49Do you feel like that's going to what I was referencing or alluding to? Do you think that becomes part of the fight or not so much?
- 42:54Is that more of just, I don't know, an adversarial mindset, kind of being in the Bitcoin space for too long sort of way of thinking?
- 43:00I think we're trained that way in the Bitcoin system.
- 43:03Yeah. And it's something that I'll touch on in my coordination piece when I get that written up.
- 43:11But what I'm starting to understand is people aren't necessarily just evil.
- 43:17I don't think they are evil. They work in institutions, in a company department, whatever it might be.
- 43:25they have a mandate they have kpis they have a reason to be in that role and they're behaving
- 43:33rationally now the fact that the world is so interconnected um and nobody sees the whole
- 43:39picture or whatever you know whatever that might be so individual actors will act perfectly rational
- 43:45and and the outcome isn't great the imf has a role to do you know the fiat system is the fiat
- 43:53system and it works the way that it works by design and they're a key element of making sure
- 43:59that that works the way that it works and having this radical thing come from the outside that will
- 44:06have could have an impact on the overall system and cause you know some negative damage on certain
- 44:13aspects if it's not managed in the right way they're behaving rationally in within the system
- 44:18and what they're supposed to be doing not necessarily that they're out there trying to
- 44:22be evil about it i don't i try to get away from the i was there fully before this but i'm trying
- 44:30to balance my my thinking around some of these things and understand what drives this you know
- 44:34process as it is today so yeah again it's my what i think my role is is to really try and educate as
- 44:45many people and government institutions and corporates whatever it might be about what this
- 44:49asset is and what it means to them and how much money they leaving on the table if they really don try to learn and engage on it So local banks for example there is no reason wholly for Eric and Gridless to fly to California to Silicon Valley to raise money when we have
- 45:08so much money in the country sitting in pension funds and banks and everything else for him to
- 45:13be able to tap in locally and have people invest in Gridless and again circulate the money locally
- 45:21as opposed to external investors sitting out there.
- 45:26So the people don't understand the asset.
- 45:28They don't understand what mining is.
- 45:29They don't understand the further picture
- 45:30that in my document that you have.
- 45:32They don't see that.
- 45:34So I think that's the education that needs to happen.
- 45:37Okay.
- 45:38Across Africa, across Africa.
- 45:41Yeah.
- 45:42Well, I think in a lot of ways,
- 45:44I mean, there's some other very bright spots
- 45:46across Africa in terms of Bitcoin adoption.
- 45:49and like I said, even Gridless itself operates in three different African countries.
- 45:55So I think, but at the same time, I think Kenya is sort of setting the pace, if you will.
- 45:59I mean, there's a lot, like I said, from the ground up level, projects like AfroBit, BitcoinData, Gridless.
- 46:05There's just so much exemplary work being done in the country that I think a lot of people will end up pointing to it.
- 46:11And I say this, I don't say it lightly.
- 46:13Oftentimes when I speak with the likes of Lorraine Marcel or leaders of these communities,
- 46:17it's the history books will remember them, not the Bitcoin history books, the history books will
- 46:22remember them. Because I think we all know what it's like to be some of the first people out to
- 46:27start talking about this stuff. There's a lot of blowback from the authorities, from family members,
- 46:32from everything else. You're a scammer, you're this, what happened? I mean, I was a college
- 46:36professor before doing all this. So everybody thinks I've completely lost my mind. And it's
- 46:40hard. It's hard to kind of blaze that path. But I think what you're doing is the right way to
- 46:44approach it. It's, you know, we have to figure out ways to integrate this in ways that it has
- 46:49real world impacts. And I think to your point, you referenced this, you referenced or you make
- 46:56such a point throughout the paper that you wrote. There's just one last thing I'd like to maybe
- 47:00politely challenge you on. And you talked about this idea of using this technology,
- 47:08as we talk about Bitcoin mining, for example, to catalyze certain things,
- 47:13but that in and of itself is not the destination.
- 47:17But at the same time, Bitcoin in some ways is the destination.
- 47:21You know, in some ways it's the destination.
- 47:25Well, it's not that it's the destination, but at the same time,
- 47:28it can't be abstracted out of the equation completely
- 47:30and that certain people in, let's say, Kibana are using it as money.
- 47:33So there's this weird thing to kind of explain to people,
- 47:36which is like, look, the mechanics of it, the way Bitcoin mining works can be used here as part of a broader infrastructure play.
- 47:42But at the same time, whether you're talking about a corporate treasury, you know, a company engaging with it in Kenya or people using it on the ground,
- 47:49it does need to be understood on those levels as well.
- 47:52Do you feel like the VASP law coming into place in November, do you think it will accelerate the process of people learning about Bitcoin on all fronts?
- 48:08Now do you think because it official maybe people are a little more comfortable asking questions asking for the help of someone like yourself Do you think it will have that sort of effect I hope it does drive people to ask questions now of me and others in the Bitcoin space But I think
- 48:26I'm not I'm not 100% aligned with the VASP regulation as as it's written.
- 48:33Okay. Everything's been mashed together as cryptocurrency and we apply chemotherapy to
- 48:39everything and at the same way so there is something else that i i am trying to work on in
- 48:44terms of there is a taxonomy to the cryptocurrency ecosystem uh there's different functions of the
- 48:51different coins within that system um and they all have a different risk profile and you need
- 48:56to focus on regulating around those risk profiles i think that'll that'll come eventually at some
- 49:03point. So yeah, it's going to take a lot more talking, pushing out pieces, bringing people
- 49:13together, having workshops around real life use cases, and showing people what to do.
- 49:21Understood. I apologize. You were cutting out a teeny bit there, Robert, but I got the majority
- 49:25of that. So I'm sorry if my reaction... No, that's okay. You're good. So yeah, I think that that is
- 49:30important is there going to be any room for you to get in there is can there be an addendum or
- 49:35an amendment made to the existing law for for that taxonomy or for those differentiations to be
- 49:40included because again treating everything just as cryptocurrency to think about a meme coin the
- 49:46same as bitcoin the same as a stable coin it it breaks my brain as somebody who's far down this
- 49:50rabbit hole we need we need that stuff to be differentiated is there going to be space for
- 49:54that differentiation to occur in some sort of uh critical sense or like on a legal level
- 50:00I hope so. But again, that's where we come back to really pulling people together, really making the gridless case and what the energy use case is all about and showing those financials and economics around that one.
- 50:13and those corporates that are happy to work with me
- 50:19in terms of I really want to understand
- 50:21and I want to do this on my balance sheet, so to speak.
- 50:23So if you already have a corporate that's doing that
- 50:25and putting themselves forward like that,
- 50:27it makes it a little bit easier to pull in different people into a room
- 50:30and go, right, how do we get from point A to point Z?
- 50:34You're all involved in that process.
- 50:36What's in place today?
- 50:38What can we do to fix that?
- 50:40What's a genuine hole?
- 50:41We have nothing in place that would really make this step go from A to this.
- 50:46And who would be responsible for doing that?
- 50:48So it is something I'm working on with a colleague, Kimberly Sandra.
- 50:54We're trying to pull this workshop together.
- 50:56Eric is mentoring and supporting and coaching in the background.
- 50:59So we'll see what we can do over the next few months to really get those things going and publish the findings, follow up.
- 51:06It's a lot of work.
- 51:07As you said earlier, we're the front line in this.
- 51:10In this, with the guys coming out the trenches and trying to run 100 meters without getting killed.
- 51:15It's us, but somebody has to do it.
- 51:18Agreed.
- 51:18And there's a certain sense of as difficult and challenging as it can be.
- 51:25I think there's some fun in it as well.
- 51:27There's some fun to being on the frontier and to being there.
- 51:30Because when you do have a win it like oh okay I pushed I widened the boundary I pushed the boulder a little bit further up the hill And I did that on behalf of the Bitcoin community And it funny it like to the to the people to my friends who are a bit more let say like far left leaning politically
- 51:51you know i try to explain them like you you would you'd be blown away at the sense of community how
- 51:56much when people do something for this space how much they feel that they're doing it for the
- 52:01broader space because i don't think i think that sense of wanting to play that part um
- 52:09when there's no real financial compensation to do it aside from the fact that you're maybe
- 52:14protecting your own bitcoin holdings or whatever it but that's you know that's kind of abstract
- 52:18um you know it's it's a really beautiful thing that there are people around the world trying to
- 52:23do that work so i commend you for doing it and i appreciate your sitting down to talk about it
- 52:29because as i said i know you're having a lot of these conversations more quietly and i think it's
- 52:33uh it's high time that maybe more people heard about the work that you're doing um at the same
- 52:38time totally respect your privacy and and all that stuff so i apologize if i was prodding you
- 52:42too hard to do but i do appreciate it yeah no the pleasure is all mine i appreciate the platform
- 52:48yeah no i was gonna say i appreciate the platform um as you say it's time for this message to really
- 52:55get out i may not articulate it perfectly but i will give my my whole being to to this topic and
- 53:03i'll do what i need to do to support whoever i need to support to help them do what they need to do
- 53:08to bring this out. Kenya, Africa in general, really needs to understand this asset and move
- 53:14us along. We can't be beholden to a US dollar and all the other things that we're beholden to
- 53:23at this point. And we've got a lot of work to do. And this is one way, one tool that can really help
- 53:30us get further along that journey. I appreciate it. Robert, thank you so much for your time.
- 53:36to everybody listening.
- 53:37I hope you appreciate Robert as much as I do,
- 53:40or at least to some degree,
- 53:41you appreciate him
- 53:42because he's doing really amazing work.
- 53:43And I think he's not only setting an example
- 53:45within Kenya and for Kenya,
- 53:48but I think,
- 53:49I hope that this encourages you
- 53:51to maybe have some conversations
- 53:53outside of the Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 53:56We, you know, a lot of people,
- 53:57it's a very small industry,
- 53:59people who just work in Bitcoin.
- 54:00So all of us are sort of interfacing
- 54:03with people outside of this system frequently,
- 54:05maybe whatever corporation you work for, if you work in policy or you work in government,
- 54:11you're a local administrator or something along those lines.
- 54:14If you do believe in this technology, I think we're at a point now where it's left this stage of being taboo,
- 54:21but now we need to show people the real world impacts that it can have.
- 54:25So again, I hope that that's one of your takeaways from this.
- 54:28Robert, we really appreciate the work you're doing.
- 54:30Thank you so much for taking the time to do this.
- 54:32and I hope to see you in person again
- 54:34somewhere else in the world this year, my friend.
- 54:36I hope so.
- 54:37Thank you, Frank.
- 54:38Thanks, everyone.
- 54:38My pleasure.
- 54:39We'll talk soon, everybody.
- 54:40Take it easy.
- 54:41Bye.