Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D Classics-Elizabeth Hargrave
Transcript
- 0:02So five d D has been going for nearly five years now, and I'm
- 0:06sure many of you will have missed some of the early interviews because you weren't
- 0:10there at the beginning. I mean, why would you have been. So
- 0:13what I'm going to do is I'm going to release some classic episodes from some
- 0:18legends of the industry that you might have missed. And so I hope you
- 0:22enjoy these shows, and I hope you enjoy the brand new ones that come
- 0:26out every two weeks. So thank you for listening and enjoy. Out of
- 0:40the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:44waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:48at you, the sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:52of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:56that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:59still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 1:03shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 1:12Five Games for Doomsday as a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 1:15into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 1:21take five of their games with them. But which will they choose? My
- 1:25guests this week caused a huge splash in the gaming world with her first published
- 1:29game, Wingspan. It was featured in The New York Times and the cause
- 1:32of much Internet consternation when it sold out its first print run before it even
- 1:36hit shops. Alongside game design, she's worked in the field of American health
- 1:40and is a former employee of the US Department of Health and Human Services.
- 1:44She's also an advocate for greater visibility for women in gaming and hosts a database
- 1:48for female designers. My guest this week is Elizabeth Hargrave. Elizabeth, Welcome
- 1:53to the cabin. Thanks for having me. So to begin with, then,
- 1:57how difficult was it for you to choose the five games to take with
- 2:01you? It was horrible picking? Um, Yeah, I don't know how
- 2:09difficult was it. I feel like I had two or three that were like
- 2:14shoe ins, and then a long list of possibilities for the other slots.
- 2:20And I mean, what was the what was the requirement that you picked?
- 2:23Was it sentimental? Was it purely utilitarian? These are my favorite games?
- 2:28What was it there's definitely some some sentimentality. There's some older games on the
- 2:35list that I'm like, I'm still playing these games. They will probably last
- 2:38a while. And I didn't really check with you about what sort of doomsday
- 2:45scenario this was, but assumed that I should take games that my spouse will
- 2:49play with me. Well, I always like people to choose their own personal
- 2:53hell with regard to this. So my husband teaches foraging classes, so our
- 2:58friends often teach us that that will do better in the average apocalypse than most
- 3:02people we know. Yeah, well I was gonna, I was gonna.
- 3:05I usually ask people this. So, so if your husband teaches foraging classes,
- 3:09you know firstly which mushrooms are edible, and then which mushrooms will get
- 3:15you high enough to save you from the horrible realization of the post apocalyptic world,
- 3:19then right, right, And there's a couple around here that will kill
- 3:22you, so you know those ones are good to know too. And so
- 3:24you you live in the countryside, Yeah, do you do you feel like
- 3:29I'm actually I'm actually about a mile from the border of Washington, d C.
- 3:34Oh Okay, So would do you consider yourself a city person or a
- 3:38country person? Where do you feel most at home. I love being right
- 3:42on the edge. So we have a giant backyard, a big vegetable garden.
- 3:45But then I can, you know, walk to the subway and get
- 3:47right into the city. That's perfect for me. And so with regards to
- 3:53games, how do you how do you feel about them as objects? Because
- 3:57you know the doomsday comes, you can only take five games with you.
- 4:00Will you lament the loss of these objects, or you know, will it
- 4:03be part of you that feel sort of relieved to be unencumbered. That's a
- 4:08good question. I'm not too attached to them as as objects. I like
- 4:13having options, but I actually I don't have a super huge I'm not a
- 4:16collector. I don't have a huge collection of games. I tend to call
- 4:20it pretty frequently and like the feeling that everything on my shelf is something that
- 4:27I would be happy to play anytime. And where would you place yourself as
- 4:31a gamer? Do you do you like the heavy games? Do you like
- 4:33the medium games? I'll play most things. I can go pretty heavy,
- 4:41but I tend not to like to go super long. And really the only
- 4:47games that I don't like or social deduction? And why is that? Would
- 4:53you say? Are you a terrible liar. I'm a terrible liar, and
- 4:58I don't enjoy it. And I don't enjoy being clied too, which I
- 5:01discovered sort of playing a few rounds of things like The Resistance and just feeling
- 5:09terrible about it. So I want to go back to the beginning. So
- 5:14you said you moved around a beat as a child, but then you settled
- 5:16in Florida. Now, Florida has become something of a meme over the last
- 5:23few years on the internet. Is Florida as crazy as the Internet would have
- 5:28us believe? I think parts of it are. I was in a college
- 5:31town, so you know, the whole Florida man thing wasn't so strong there.
- 5:36But but yeah, there's some real people have different images of Florida,
- 5:43right, because you get Southern Florida, which is all retirees and a lot
- 5:47of money, and then you have Disney World in the middle of Florida,
- 5:51and then North Florida is really like deep South, like it might as well
- 5:56be Georgia for folks that that means that I think too, but so yeah,
- 6:03and then the University of Florida is in Gainesville, Florida, which is
- 6:06North Florida, so it's sort of this, you know, big university culture
- 6:12plopped down in the middle of otherwise quite rural backwoodsy Florida. And so he's
- 6:20I mean, he's Florida generally quite a conservative part of the world. Or
- 6:26you know, is the university town like all university times, you know,
- 6:29kids drinking too much and you know we all see spring break on the TV
- 6:33and everything right right, Gainsville is one of the more liberal parts of North
- 6:40Florida for sure. I mean, so the last several elections, the elections
- 6:46have actually been like down to the wire sort of overtime because the vote is
- 6:50so nearly split between Democrats and Republicans, a conservative and liberal with when it's
- 6:58statewide, it's a very divided state with a lot of different pieces to it.
- 7:04I mean, can you split is a Florida Democrat different to a California
- 7:12Democrat or a New York Democrats. That's a good question. Probably. I
- 7:17haven't lived there and long enough that I'm not sure I can say. These
- 7:19days, it seems the two parties have a fairly broad church. It's what
- 7:25it seems to me. Yes, yes, for sure, Florida Democrats probably
- 7:30on average, are less liberal than California or Earning or Democrats, which is
- 7:36a tradition in the South. I mean, the Democratic Party was very conservative
- 7:41for a long time down there. And so then you went on to you
- 7:44in a university and you studied public policy. So firstly, what does that
- 7:47entail? And secondly what drew you towards that area? Yeah, so public
- 7:55policy is sort of a conglomeration of things that might help you help decision makers
- 8:03in the government. So you do some statistics and some economics and some history
- 8:09and some you know, subject matter expertise in whatever you're interested in. I
- 8:16actually started out as a religious studies major in college and thought about becoming a
- 8:22Unitarian minister, but was realized at some point that I'm not really outgoing enough
- 8:30to be in that kind of position and wanted to be sort of more directly
- 8:37helpful and sort of hands on to making things better in the world. So
- 8:46I thought public policy might be that track. And you know, is this
- 8:52you know people study a sudden reasons. I studied acting because I have absolutely
- 8:56no desire to ever have any money at any points in my life. But
- 9:03is there a career there at the end of a public policy degree? Can
- 9:05you become a civil servant and lead quite a sort of comfortable, normal,
- 9:09solid life or is it, you know, full of ups and downs?
- 9:15It worked for me. I mean, the one thing that can be full
- 9:18of ups and downs is if you go the very political route, then then
- 9:22you know, you may be in and out of jobs more regularly. But
- 9:26civil service, if you're just taking a mainstream government job that's not a political
- 9:33appointment, then it can be a very stable line of work. And you
- 9:37studied areas like public health and issues surrounding poverty. What interested you about those
- 9:43areas? Are they just wanting to help people? Health really fascinates me because
- 9:50our healthcare system in the United States is so convoluted, but your personal health
- 9:58is like so fundamental to having a good life. And to the extent that
- 10:03people have issues that are unaddressed, and especially if there are issues just because
- 10:09they can't afford to get them addressed, that's really troubling. And you said
- 10:13you looked into areas of politic and how big is the gap between the richest
- 10:18and the poorest in America? Is it? Is it absolutely huge? Is
- 10:22it? Sort of you know, when we think of India, we see
- 10:24the big high rise buildings with the shanties built around the foot of them.
- 10:30Is it a sort of similar situation in America? But I don't think it's
- 10:35as visible and as close in the United States as it is in a place
- 10:41like India, where you like get that strong visual standing in one spot.
- 10:46But it's a huge divide. I mean, there are a lot of people
- 10:50really struggling to make it, and the safety net has been under attack for
- 10:54a long time here, so the bottom is maybe not as as low as
- 11:01it is in a place like India, but still really people just scraping by.
- 11:09And then you know, we've got the Bill Gates and the Donald Trump's
- 11:11of the world, and below them a you know, significant class of folks
- 11:18that really don't have to worry about anything, and I assume don't pay an
- 11:22awful lot of tax so they say, I mean, I haven't really personally
- 11:28looked into it, but but yes, there are a lot of ways to
- 11:31to file your taxes and get out of paying a large percentage of your income,
- 11:37certainly paying less taxes than in most places in Europe. And you know,
- 11:43a big sort of issue in Britain at the moment is not those people
- 11:46sort of at the absolute bottom. But it's what we call the working poor.
- 11:50So people who have jobs and yet still have real difficulty making ends meet.
- 11:56Is that a factor for sure? And here healthcare plays a bit role
- 12:00in that. So you know, we've over the last supple several years during
- 12:05the Obama administration sort of tried to expand programs UM for low income people to
- 12:11get their health insurance covered UM to start trying to reach up into that sort
- 12:18of working poor segment that otherwise couldn't buy insurance in the marketplace because it's just
- 12:24too expensive UM. And and so that's sort of you know, having some
- 12:31income not being totally destitute can can really um can disqualify you from programs that
- 12:39help a lot and then make things feel even worse in some cases. So
- 12:45just moving off this area for a bit, Then when did games come into
- 12:48your life? And I mean did you did you? Did you play games
- 12:52as a kid or is it something that an interest that you acquired at a
- 12:54later date. Yeah, I mean I played a lot of mass market games
- 12:58as a kid, and a lot of card games, and then I think
- 13:05I first started playing hobby games about two thousand and five. I went on
- 13:07a retreat with a bunch of folks from my church and someone had brought a
- 13:13bunch of games. I know we played like Blackest and Carcotsone and Ticket to
- 13:18Ride. I don't remember what else. And I was totally hooked, and
- 13:24so it was an instant, an instant love affair. Then it's really interesting
- 13:28because you know, you look at the Dice Tower and you look at sort
- 13:31of a lot of people who talk about games in America, and it seems
- 13:33to it seems to be a theme going through sort of Christian America. There
- 13:41is playing board games and being a Christian some high linked in America in some
- 13:48way. That's a good question. I mean, I think a lot of
- 13:50people see it as sort of a wholesome thing, right, I'll keep the
- 13:52kids out of trouble or whatever. I don't know. I go to a
- 13:56Unitarian church, which is not particularly Christian or wholesome. So so, so,
- 14:01what is Unitarianism, um Ugitarianism, Well, it's Unitarian Universalism are sort
- 14:11of two branches that broke off of Protestant Christianity in the eighteen fifties, and
- 14:18um, so Unitarians challenged the dividity of Christ and UM just said, you
- 14:24know, there's one God, but we don't believe in the Trinity. And
- 14:26the universalists broke off and said, um, a good God would not condemn
- 14:33people to hell for eternity. We don't believe in hell. Um. And
- 14:37over time those two schools of thoughts sort of evolved and they merged into one
- 14:45organization in the nineteen sixties, that UM. So their tenants are basically like,
- 14:50everyone has the right to free search for their own truth and meaning in
- 14:56the world, that we're not gonna sort of assert a particular dogma that you
- 15:03need to believe in to be a member of the church. So you'll find
- 15:07atheists and theists mixing together, but just enjoying thinking about how to lead good
- 15:15lives, and a lot more emphasis on sort of the present moment and what
- 15:20we can do to be good people now, and not needing to agree on
- 15:26what happens after you die or what happened two thousand years ago. I mean,
- 15:31do you have fixed ideas on that, do you have a particular faith
- 15:35or do you vacillate from time to time. I do not have a lot
- 15:41of what most people would call faith. I'm a pretty scientific, pragmatic And
- 15:50so what does your church give you? Then? That I don't know,
- 15:54because it seems to me, you know, people got a church because they
- 15:58have a sort of dogmatic belief in something that they can link them. What
- 16:02does your church give to you that I don't know? Going to a pub
- 16:06doesn't or going to a board game evening doesn't mean it's a lot more reflective,
- 16:11right, So it's community in the same way that either of those is,
- 16:15but that you know, a moment to pause and reflect on what's important
- 16:22and feel connected to things without needing to put labels on what that connection necessarily
- 16:32is. So I want to go to your first choice now, and this
- 16:36is something you're not the first person to have cheated basically, is what I'm
- 16:40going to say. So you share this distinction, I think with Ryana Cannitzi,
- 16:44who chose the same thing, and a number of other people. And
- 16:45this is a standard deck of cards. So firstly, what are you taking
- 16:49these four? Is this for designing or is this for the plethora of games
- 16:55you can play? It didn't even occur to me to take them for a
- 16:57design. I am a designed any games that are based around a standard deck
- 17:03of cards. Um, yeah, I just I grew up playing a lot
- 17:07of Hearts and jin Rummy, and in college played spades like many, many
- 17:12games of spades every week, and learned Bridge my senior year or just after
- 17:18graduation from college because we had a housemate who knew bridge and knew that all
- 17:26of the spades players in the house would would struggle with their academics if he
- 17:30taught us bridge during the school year, so he taught that summer um.
- 17:36And you know, any of those games I would be happy to play anytime.
- 17:40I don't a lot because I hang out with a lot of board gamers.
- 17:44But um, they're just they're super easy to learn, they're um and
- 17:49they're fun to play. And so it's interesting that you say that, because
- 17:53I always think this. When I got into gaming, I sort of dispense
- 18:00with the traditional card game, and now I've got loads of games that I
- 18:03don't play enough. It seems, you know, I feel a bit guilty
- 18:07for pulling out a normal deck of cards. But do you think there's a
- 18:10resistance on the part of hobby gamers to playing these traditional card games or do
- 18:15you not find that. I don't know if there's a resistance, I've never
- 18:18tried. That's a good question, but yeah, I mean I think the
- 18:22thing that the standard card games are missing are like the beautiful art and the
- 18:27theming, which is something that is very important to me when I enjoy games,
- 18:33although not necessarily the ones I mean, I say it's important to me,
- 18:37but the ones on my list that's actually not a strong factor in why
- 18:41I like them for most of them, but certainly in terms of like breaking
- 18:47through and getting people's attention, I think that's becoming more and more of an
- 18:52expectation. And do you think there are any Because I've sort of become because
- 18:56I played a lot of trick taking games as a kid, I sort of
- 19:00become obsessed with sort of hobby trick taking games. But it's part of me
- 19:03that kind of thinks none of them as good as good as the ones you
- 19:07can play with a normal set of cards. Do you think there's any hobby
- 19:12trick taking game that has really elevated the form? I haven't. I haven't
- 19:18played that many hobby trick taking games. I would be curious to try more.
- 19:23Actually, I mean the standards, you know, Hearts and Spades,
- 19:27those have been honed over how many years that people have been playing them.
- 19:33I don't know how much the rules shifted or if they were sort of or
- 19:38are the Spades and Hearts that we play the way that it was first designed
- 19:44or did they evolve over time? I don't know. I feel like they're
- 19:47games that have stuck around for a reason, you know, and maybe evolved
- 19:52to the point that they really had that staying power. So you said you
- 19:56didn't think about taking these as design mine aids. So as as the Humble
- 20:03playing card never factored into your design consideration then, and do you think you
- 20:07might use them in the future. Yeah, they haven't yet. I wouldn't
- 20:11rule it out if I had something that where it seemed like they would be
- 20:15useful, But I just haven't started a design that sort of fit into that
- 20:21structure. So I want to go on now and talk about your work for
- 20:26the government. So you worked for the US Department of Health and Human Services.
- 20:30What was your job there? I think my official title was that I
- 20:36was the special assistant the Assistant Secretary for planning an evaluation and what what What
- 20:44did that involve? Trying to fit it onto a letterhead? I assume,
- 20:48yeah, right, I did a little bit of whatever needed doing for that
- 20:56person and the office of the Assistant preteria for planning an evaluation was like an
- 21:03office that did a lot of analysis work trying to sort of look at data
- 21:11and figure out solutions to policy issues that were going on. So while I
- 21:18was there, the Children's Health Insurance Program passed, and I did a lot
- 21:23of the work leading up to that, sort of analyzing how many children in
- 21:26the United States don't have insurance, what are their income levels, what are
- 21:32sort of the common health issues that children are having that if they did have
- 21:37more access to insurance might be less of an issue, or coming up with
- 21:45data like that to help convince people that expanding insurance to more children would be
- 21:48a good thing. And then I also worked a lot on the Medicare program,
- 21:55reviewing regulations. So Medicare and the US is the program that sort of
- 22:00the elderly and people with disabilities. So yeah, I did a lot on
- 22:10regulations related to nursing homes and post acute care of things like that. We
- 22:15in Europe especially, we kind of look upon the American health system with some
- 22:21sort of amusement. I mean, because in some quarters the term universal healthcare
- 22:27is a negative term. I mean, what is the issue with the American
- 22:34health system? Why is there such obstructionism to making sure everyone has access to
- 22:41healthcare? I don't know. I feel like it's a combination of sort of
- 22:45business interests that don't want to be stepped on or regulated, alongside just this
- 22:55really strong libertarian streak of people not one the government to do more than the
- 23:02bearer. Minimum. Healthcare has such a weird history in the US. So
- 23:07during World War Two there were wage controls to try to fight inflation during wartime,
- 23:18and because businesses couldn't raise wages, large companies started offering health insurance as
- 23:25an added benefit that would sort of get around the wage controls. And then
- 23:30that just became a thing that a lot of unions looked for in their contracts,
- 23:36and eventually it just became this huge private industry to provide these insurance benefits
- 23:42to folks. And now there's a lot of money in it. And do
- 23:47you have envisage your time? I mean, certainly not in the next two
- 23:51years, and if the next election goes poorly for subsequent four but do you
- 23:56ever envisage your time where there is something akin to sort of European style universal
- 24:02healthcare in America? Or will it always be this sort of patchwork system,
- 24:06and again it seems to be an aspect of the American culture which which punishes
- 24:10the pool. I mean, do you think that's true. I mean,
- 24:12it certainly makes it harder to so, I mean especially sort of the middle
- 24:19class, even more than the port because now, so we have a program
- 24:22called Medicaid that covers poor people in most states, but then, like like
- 24:29what you're talking about before, being just above the cutoff for that program then
- 24:32means that you're facing really high expenses. And that's sort of where are most
- 24:37uninsured folks in the States are sort of in that low middle income bracket.
- 24:45So do I think it could ever get to universal insurance? In fits and
- 24:49starts, we make little bits of progress. So you know, under Obama
- 24:53there was we passed a bunch of subsidies for folks sort of in that middle
- 24:59in come Brackett that I think it would be hard to take away now,
- 25:04And so like each little piece that you add to the puzzle, once people
- 25:11have something, it's really hard to take it away. I mean, how
- 25:17doing like sweeping just like throw everything away and replace it with something else.
- 25:22Like that's just not how policy happens in the United States. And it's fun
- 25:26to dream about, but I can't see it actually happening. I mean,
- 25:32what did obamacad do? Was it? Was it? I mean, was
- 25:37it revolutionary? Did it change a lot for you know, the average American
- 25:41on the street, or was it a very small sticking plaster over a very
- 25:45large wound A little bit of both. I mean, it covered a lot
- 25:51of people that didn't have coverage anymore, but it pretty much built on things
- 25:53that were already there, and it relied on states to do some of it,
- 25:59and so like you get this patchwork also of like some states implemented things
- 26:03and others didn't. So it expanded how far up the income scale states could
- 26:11go with the Medicaid program for poor people. And then it created subsidies for
- 26:17folks above that income level to buy insurance on the private market. And so
- 26:23the insurance on the private market part was sort of new, but really just
- 26:29like putting money into the existing business of private insurance in the States. So
- 26:37in that sense, it wasn't particularly revolutionary, even though it has helped a
- 26:41lot of people buy insurance that couldn't afford it before. And you don't think
- 26:45Trump will be able to roll and all that stuff. Back then, I
- 26:49mean, they've been trying for a bunch of years and they haven't been able
- 26:52to actually do it. And so when we were talking over Twitter about sort
- 27:00of your bio and stuff, you said that you were in Washington on September
- 27:03eleventh, two thousand and one. What was it like being working in government
- 27:10on that day? Yeah, so I was working in the Senate. Then
- 27:15I was in a conference room in sort of an interior room. We had
- 27:22no idea what was going on until someone in the meeting I was in got
- 27:25a phone call from a friend of hers checking on her, and we were
- 27:27like, oh, should we be worried about something? And I went back
- 27:32to my office and it had been evacuated, so we left. I walked
- 27:36over to a friend's house that lived on Capitol Hill because there were all these
- 27:38rumors about like things blowing up in Washington, d c. Which you know,
- 27:45the Pentagon was a ways away from Capitol Hill. But so there was
- 27:48a plane that came down there, and then there was a plane that crashed
- 27:52in Pennsylvania because the passengers took it over that they think was headed for the
- 28:00Capitol or the White House. They're not sure. So yeah, it was
- 28:06pretty freaky I mean, did you did you feel in danger at any point?
- 28:14Yeah? Yeah, it was I mean, no one knew what was
- 28:18going on, and it was really the cell phone lines were totally jammed.
- 28:23You couldn't get through to anyone on the phone because everyone was trying to make
- 28:29calls all at the same time. And um, yeah, it was just
- 28:33it was a big day of uncertainty. And we hunkered down at my friend's
- 28:37house and watched TV all day and just you know, footage from mostly from
- 28:44New York City, just over and over and over again. Um, there's
- 28:48a lot less attention to to DC, but it was a pretty weird time
- 28:52to be in DC for sure. And you said you had an event with
- 28:56some weaponized anthrax, right. So then that October there was a case someone
- 29:07sent several letters through the mail to various media outlets and politicians that had anthrax
- 29:18in them, and one of them got sent to my boss, and the
- 29:22mail room was right outside my office, so that the several people in the
- 29:29office tested positive for having been exposed to anthrax and we all get to take
- 29:33really long courses of antibiotics. So that was you know, that was right
- 29:38on the Tales of the Twin towers and the Pentagon and DCU was still kind
- 29:45of under lockdown, and that was a whole other traumatic experience on top of
- 29:51it. So my office got like everything and it got insinerated. Basically,
- 29:56it was a total like a biological I don't know what you call it.
- 30:02It's totally like sealed off and shut down and destroyed. And we had to
- 30:07work out of different offices for months. And I mean, how long did
- 30:11it take. I mean, you said you looked in the Senate, how
- 30:14long did it take to get back to normal after September the eleventh? I
- 30:18mean with the ramifications felt. I mean obviously around the world in terms of
- 30:22public policy, in terms of simply getting on a plane, you feel it
- 30:26every day, But how did it feel there was it was there a palpable
- 30:30sense of tension for ages I try to remember how. I mean, there
- 30:33were like fighter jets play so there were no commercial flights for what for a
- 30:37couple a week, a couple of weeks, I don't remember exactly, but
- 30:41there were fighter jets and helicopters going overhead all the time. I mean,
- 30:44it was really it felt like martial law or something for a little while.
- 30:51And then yeah, so when my office in one of the Senate office buildings
- 30:56got shut down, I ended up working in some swing space right off the
- 31:00floor of the Senate and so it was it was a strange time. I
- 31:08mean, so the whole you know, going to war over it and just
- 31:17being right thereof off the Senate floor while all that was going on was definitely
- 31:22sort of a heightened sense of this, this is different. It was definitely
- 31:30different for months. And you being a sort of a genuine person who's worked
- 31:37in real American politics, when you see things like The West Wing and these
- 31:41kind of TV shows that are set in Washington, how realistic are they And
- 31:45to what degree is that sort of back room bartering and stuff just a fabrication
- 31:52of the TV writers. M That's a really good question. The West Wing
- 31:57is really the only one that I watched which I loved because it's I feel
- 32:00like the West Wing is like this idealization of everything. I think there's a
- 32:06lot of truth in it, but then everyone is much better spoken and can
- 32:09actually get things done, and in real life you feel like you're beating your
- 32:16head against the wall a lot more of the time and just trying to get
- 32:21like tiny little incremental things done. But it's you know, as far as
- 32:30a TV representation of it, it's not untrue. It's just idealized. And
- 32:37I mean and I mean, do do people on the other sides of the
- 32:40aisles hate each other or is that purely sort of posturing for the Senate?
- 32:47And do they go off to bars and have drinks together and talk about the
- 32:52business and things. I think it has gotten much worse over time. When
- 32:57I was there, there were a few people on the other side of the
- 33:00aisle that I was kind of friendly with, but mostly it was very segregated.
- 33:05My understanding is that, you know, ten or twenty years before I
- 33:10was there, so like in the sixties seventies, there was more sort of
- 33:15socialization among the members and the staff. I think the members used to socialize
- 33:22a lot because they used to be much more stuck in Washington, and as
- 33:29plane travel became cheaper and easier, folks get out of town every possible second
- 33:35that can. And it has a lot of people think that has has broken
- 33:39down some of the the social structure of the institutions. And do you think
- 33:46that filters down into society when you see the politicians fighting and being and offering
- 33:54each other no sort of professional what I'm looking for a professional courtesy. Do
- 34:01you think that reflects on the public and can that be sort of an origin
- 34:07of the division that we see in wider society. Yeah, I think it
- 34:13is related to some extent. I don't know if it's the driving force behind
- 34:16it, but I think people will say things about other politicians that they don't
- 34:24that they aren't friendly with, that they would never say to someone that they
- 34:28were going out and having drinks with after the end of the day. And
- 34:35in general, do you think most of the people there are just trying to
- 34:37do the best with what they can or are there some real crooks there?
- 34:42Would you say? I think it's mostly people trying like they really truly believe
- 34:49on both sides of the aisle that their worldview is going to help people.
- 34:55That is one thing that even though I've been super volved in politics and have
- 35:00very deeply held views about what I think is right and the best way to
- 35:07make things better, I really do believe that it is possible to hold views
- 35:14that are diametrically opposed to mine and still be a good person and hold them
- 35:19for you know, legitimate reasons and just have you know, different ideas and
- 35:27be using different data about about what's the best way to fix things. So
- 35:32I want to go on night to your next game. And this is a
- 35:36classic, This is Castles of Burgundy. So why are you taking this one
- 35:39with you? It's just a really solid game and one that has made it
- 35:45to my table more than most, and I am still happy to break it
- 35:51out quite a bit. It plays great at two players. I did I
- 35:55don't think I mentioned in my own or all how did I picked my games?
- 36:00But my spouse is definitely less of a gamer than I am, and
- 36:06so you know, the question of what games is my spouse willing to play
- 36:08with me is is a harder one, and this is one that he enjoys
- 36:13as well. I think it was the first game that I played that did
- 36:24dice in a way where there is still randomness, but you're not necessarily going
- 36:30for higher or lower and each number has its own value to you that um,
- 36:38you know, sometimes you might really want to four and sometimes you might
- 36:42really want to one, but it's not that you always want sixes, that
- 36:45they're always better than anything else. And that kind of blew my mind when
- 36:49I first played it. I mean, what do you think Stephenfeld offers as
- 36:54a game designer? What do you think? What do you think it's really
- 36:57good about him? And all their elements to his game design that annoy you,
- 37:01frustrate you, will make him unattractive to play. He tends to have
- 37:08a lot going on in his games, a lot of different routes to victory,
- 37:16a lot of ways to earn points, which can be good and bad.
- 37:23So I have played Steffenfeld games where I feel like they went too far
- 37:30in that direction, where there's just too much to keep track of, too
- 37:35many options to parse on every turn? What should I be doing? I
- 37:40feel like Castles of Burgundy is sort of in a sweet spot where there is
- 37:45a lot going on and there are a lot of you always have a lot
- 37:47of options, but it never feels too much to me. And I mean,
- 37:52do you people? I think this is his highest ranked game on BGG
- 37:58and a lot of people say that it's his best. Firstly, do you
- 38:01think that's true? And secondly, why do you think people hold this game
- 38:06in such regard. I don't know if I've played enough of them to say
- 38:08that. Whether I agree that it's his best, it's definitely my favorite out
- 38:13of the ones that I've played. Yeah, And I really do think it's
- 38:19that sweet spot of like always having interesting decisions to make, but not so
- 38:24many options that you feel overwhelmed by it for me, that's and and there's
- 38:31something so satisfying about finishing your little areas on the board. Like people love
- 38:39building things and feeling like they've completed things, And I think that's possibly one
- 38:45reason that it's it's such a satisfying game to play. And there's that nice
- 38:53feeling of like there's some you can finish off really quickly, and then there's
- 38:57some that you're building towards through the whole game. There's just a lot of
- 39:04nice little balancing features like that. And do you think he's influenced you at
- 39:08all as a designer? That's a good question. Not consciously, I've never
- 39:14got, oh, I'm want to do this thing the way that stefan Feld
- 39:16does it. But I mean, I think to a certain extent where all
- 39:20designers are probably influenced by the games, especially the ones that we play more
- 39:25frequently. It just becomes part of how your brain works and sort of your
- 39:31bag of solutions to problems that you can pull from, you know, and
- 39:37without necessarily always saying oh, Steffen Feld did it this way, and Castles
- 39:43of Burgundy that's an option, and it's just like, oh, that's a
- 39:45thing you can do. But and so I want to move on night to
- 39:50your designing. So when did you start designing games? So you said you
- 39:53got into playing games in two thousand and four. When did that transmogrify into
- 39:59designing? Probably at twenty fourteen, I want to say, twenty thirteen,
- 40:04twenty fourteen. Um, it's really a conversation with some friends of mine about
- 40:10why do we always play all these games that are about things that we don't
- 40:15care about, including Castles of Burgundy and some other games on my list that
- 40:24you know, as much as I appreciate things like Castles of Burgundy that are
- 40:30you know, just great games, and it doesn't really matter what the theme
- 40:35is, I would rather play that same game with a theme that I love
- 40:38or something that I care about. So I decided to try and make a
- 40:44game that was about something that I cared about. And was it a natural
- 40:49progression for you to start designing when you decided to go on and make something
- 40:54about the thing you love? Did it come easily or was there a lot
- 40:59of spadework and a lot of failures before you made something that you were happy
- 41:04with. So Wingspay was the first thing I tried making, and I just
- 41:09kept working on it for years until it got to a place that I liked
- 41:13it. So yeah, it was a lot of work. And so it
- 41:16came out this year. So that's twenty nineteen. You said twenty fourteen,
- 41:22So you were designing it for basically five years then, yeah, although my
- 41:29part of it was really wrapped up sort of this time last year. It
- 41:34takes a long time to get a game physically to market after it has been
- 41:39designed. And I mean, so now you've got some more stuff which will
- 41:45come to later that's coming out this year. So now you're sort of a
- 41:49seasoned published game designer. What do you think your strengths are as a designer?
- 41:52What are you good at? And what are you not so good at?
- 41:57That's a good question. What are I'm not sure I've been doing it
- 42:02long enough to know. I mean, I've been doing it for five years.
- 42:06I should know, but I don't know my strengths. I think that
- 42:20I am good at seeing things in play tests that are not working and realizing
- 42:28that they're not working and coming up with things to change. I am not
- 42:34as good as some other designers I think at seeing ahead of time how things
- 42:39are going to play out. Do you do you think that's a matter of
- 42:43experience though, because items it seems to me what happens in your head is
- 42:50very different to what happens in the wild. Now. Yeah, And it's
- 42:52one of the pieces of advice that I give to new designers all the time.
- 42:57It's like you have to get it out of your head on to the
- 43:00table like that. You may have fantastic ideas, but there is going to
- 43:06be something in there that doesn't work the way you expect it to for some
- 43:12reason, and you really can't see it until you just make a physical prototype
- 43:16and start playing with it. So we'll move on then to your next game.
- 43:22And frankly, I'd have been disappointed had you have not chosen this one.
- 43:25And this is Wingspans. So I mean, you said you wanted to
- 43:29make a game that you loved about a subject that you loved. Are you
- 43:32a birdwatcher? Are you a sort of nature person? Do you get out
- 43:36there with the binoculars and look at thrushes and things? I do, Yes,
- 43:43I am both a birdwatcher and a more generally nature loving person, because
- 43:47there there was a big sort of revolution about ten years ago in Britain on
- 43:52British TV, and an ex comedian did this birdwatching program and it's sort of
- 43:59caught on British TV and it was a really big thing, and they'd have
- 44:01they'd have little mini cameras in nests and all of that sort of stuff,
- 44:06so you can see the chicks growing in things. What is it about?
- 44:10Explain the fascination to me. I mean, first of all, they're just
- 44:15beautiful creatures, right, But the process of birdwatching is enjoyable to me,
- 44:25first of all because I just enjoy being outside and I enjoy learning things about
- 44:32what I'm looking at. And before I was a birder, I was a
- 44:36big plant person as well, and I'm also a mushroomer, and I just
- 44:40for all three I enjoy learning specifically what I'm looking at. I feel much
- 44:49more connected to the outdoors when I know what everything is. So if you're
- 44:54going on a hike and you don't know any specific species of anything, it's
- 45:01all just sort of an undifferentiated green blob, right. But once you start
- 45:07knowing some of the trees and the plants, or the bird songs or anything
- 45:12any little piece of it. You just it's then like you're seeing old friends,
- 45:19like you know what you're looking at and hearing, and it makes it
- 45:22a totally different experience. So if I hear a crow, I understand that,
- 45:30I recognize that. If I hear a cuckoo, I recognize that everything
- 45:34else sounds exactly the same to me. How long, well, how long
- 45:37does it sort of take to develop that sort of nuance and understand, Oh,
- 45:43that's a thrush, that's a nightingale, that sort of thing. Oh,
- 45:46I mean, I've been birding for ten years at least, and I
- 45:49still especially because birds aren't singing all year long. They're really most active in
- 45:54spring. Every spring, I have to relearn a lot of them. And
- 46:00my husband is retains more of them from year to year than I do.
- 46:06It's just the way his brain works. So you know, it helps that
- 46:08I go out burning with him and he knows it is something that you can
- 46:12learn. And the one trick for me that I have learned is that I
- 46:17retain the connection between the song and the bird better if I actually get my
- 46:22eyes on the bird while it is singing for some reason that makes the connection
- 46:29between the sound and the visual and then I remember it much better. And
- 46:34what's the process? I mean, do you have a big compendium of birds
- 46:37that you take out with you? Do you? Is there an app?
- 46:40Now? And so has the digital world invaded your sort of bucolic paradise then?
- 46:50So I still really enjoy hard back or you know, hard copy bird
- 46:57guides, and if I'm going somewhere a where I don't know the birds,
- 47:01I will usually still pick up a copy of a of a hard hard copy
- 47:08of a of a field guide. But there are great apps. Merlin is
- 47:14a free app that's put up by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology UM, and
- 47:19I believe they have UM. You can download birds sort of buy regions so
- 47:24you don't have to download the whole world at once. But you know,
- 47:29when I went to Belize and Guatemala this winter, UM, you could download
- 47:37sort of that pack of birds for your phone, and then you've got the
- 47:42bird songs and photos and descriptions of them that you can use to look things
- 47:49up. The song and having the songs in there is huge because a lot
- 47:55of times you will hear a bird and not get a really good look at
- 48:00it, and being able to confirm what you saw by what you're hearing is
- 48:07definitely a part of getting a lot of species down. I mean, so
- 48:14I clearly have demonstrated I know nothing about birds or bird watching, but I
- 48:17assume I'm taking I'm trusting you that wingspan is sort of scientifically pretty exact and
- 48:24pretty rigorous. Was it important to you that the game be that Yeah,
- 48:30I mean, so I wanted it to be real birds. And once I
- 48:34was doing real birds, I didn't feel like I could put anything that was
- 48:37patently untrue on the cards, right, So then I had to look up
- 48:45all the real information about them and use that. And so what was the
- 48:52road to getting it published? And I mean, if I was, if
- 48:59I was publishing a game, my brain doesn't work in that way, so
- 49:01it's never gonna happen. But if I was, I mean, Stonemeyer would
- 49:05be almost a dream destination for a game. So what was the road to
- 49:08getting it published? And how did you feel when stone Meyer picked it up?
- 49:14Yeah? So I pitched it at gen Con in twenty sixteen, which
- 49:17was the year that Scythe came out. Stone Meyer was just becoming more of
- 49:24a big deal as I was pitching it, which is sort of an interesting
- 49:32phenomenon, but yeah, I looked at the list of all the publishers that
- 49:40were going to be at gen Con that year and went through a lot of
- 49:45them, sort of looking at their catalogs of games trying to figure out who
- 49:50would be interested in the game about birds. Ruled out anyone that had lines
- 49:57that were all, you know, high fantasy, science fiction and stuff,
- 50:00because I figured they just wouldn't be interested. But you know, for example,
- 50:04stone Meer had Fitticulture, which is sort of a real world, modern
- 50:09times game about something kind of lovely. I thought that there was an outside
- 50:19chance that they might be interested, so I gave it a shot, and
- 50:22actually that year. I don't think stone Meyer does this anymore. But they
- 50:25had to set up a pitch meeting with them. You just grabbed a half
- 50:32hour slot that was like an event that you could sign up for gen Con,
- 50:37just like signing up to play a scheduled game at gen Con. So
- 50:43I didn't have to convince them ahead of time that they were interested in meeting
- 50:46with me. I just grabbed a slot. The other two publishers I met
- 50:52with, I did sort of email back and forth to set up a meeting
- 50:54and told them what the game was and yeah, and so all three of
- 51:01them sort of gave me notes on the spot this is, you know,
- 51:06things you ought to think about. And then Jamie was so the one that
- 51:09reached out to me afterwards and said, Okay, what do you think about
- 51:14the feedback that we gave you? What would you do to implement some of
- 51:19those things? And that started our long development process of sort of back and
- 51:27forth by email, working on improving it to the point where it got published.
- 51:31And so how different is it now from that twenty sixteen pitch? Quite
- 51:37different for sure. Yeah, we worked on it for gosh year and a
- 51:44half, back and forth really, and yeah, one of the thing that
- 51:52we worked on the most, or sort of the core of the changes,
- 51:54was really amping up the engine building aspect of it, and everything else that
- 52:00changed was sort of in service of that. And so it's been the undeniable
- 52:07sort of hit of twenty nineteen. I guess there's two questions here. Firstly,
- 52:15does that surprise you that there's such an appetite for sort of a realistic,
- 52:20sort of science based game. And secondly, were you surprised that kind
- 52:23of how annoyed people got that they weren't They weren't able to get hold of
- 52:29it for two months. So the fact that it was a big hit was
- 52:31definitely a big surprise. I mean, because guy, get into game designed
- 52:36right, everyone says, there's no money in it, You're you're a good
- 52:38game, sells five thousand copies, you know, be happy if you make
- 52:43it to that point. So that was sort of what I had in my
- 52:49head all along in terms of realistic expectations for a game like I thought it
- 52:57was good, but there's never a guarantee that other people will think. You
- 53:00know, there's plenty of good games that never quite hit for one reason or
- 53:05another. So that was definitely a surprise. And with the theme, you
- 53:13know, I think the bird theme has ended up helping Wingspan a lot.
- 53:17I think it appeals to a lot of people. But there was a good
- 53:22chance that it could have gone the other way, and people, hardcore gamers
- 53:29who don't care about birds could have said, that's ridiculous, we're not interested.
- 53:35I think enough gamers were willing to give Stonemeyer a chance when they said
- 53:40this was a good game. That then the words started getting out of like,
- 53:46oh, yeah, even if you're not interested in birds, check this
- 53:50one out. But then I think themes about nature just naturally appeal to people,
- 53:57even if they don't think they're nature e people. It's soothing and pretty
- 54:01and something that I think most people naturally want to engage with. I mean,
- 54:10those eggs are insanely beguiling when you have a board covered with them that
- 54:16I don't know whether you get them in America, but there's the thing we
- 54:19get in England called mini eggs, and you only get them at Easter,
- 54:22and they look and they're sort of chocolate eggs with sort of sugar coating,
- 54:27and they look exactly like the eggs in Wingspan. Yeah, I had never
- 54:30had them before, but you can get them here at Easter time. I
- 54:32don't know how long that's been true, but my grandmother used to buy me
- 54:36the Cadbury eggs, the bigger ones with the gooey middle. That's kind of
- 54:40disgusting and amazing at the same time. But I had never heard the mini
- 54:45eggs. And yet, So were you surprised that people were so indignant that
- 54:51they couldn't get hold of the game and have you did you did you get
- 54:54any grief. I assume Jamie got a lot of angry people. Did that
- 54:59filter down to you at all? Not too much. I mean I got
- 55:02the question a lot of like how can I get my hands on this?
- 55:05But not any anger. And I don't know if Jamie felt like it was
- 55:13a lot of anger as much as there was a small element of anger and
- 55:17a lot of just like when can we get it? When can we get
- 55:21it? Without anger or attached to it. But Yeah, the thing that
- 55:27mystifies me the most or the people that were like thinking that this was somehow
- 55:31part of some grand strategy on Stonemer Games part to like manufacture a shortage,
- 55:37which is just terrible business sense. Like you don't want to have an article
- 55:43in the New York Times, which by the way, was like not pitched
- 55:45to them by us, like they reached out to us. You don't want
- 55:50to have an article in the New York Times and then not have copies available
- 55:54to sell to people immediately when they read that article. There's no gar and
- 56:00tea that they're going to come back a month or two later when the game
- 56:01is available again and then buy a copy. Right. It's just not a
- 56:07good strategy. Did not have enough available. It was definitely not, I
- 56:12mean a purposeful shortage. And so to wrap up on wingspoon, then do
- 56:17you have a favorite bird? So one of my favorite birds in real life
- 56:24is called a rosyet spoonbill. I think you guys in Europe have like a
- 56:29European spoonbill that's white. It has so both spoonbills have this crazy long beak
- 56:35that actually has like a spoon shaped thing on the end of it. It's
- 56:38flat and it's good for picking up crustaceans, I think, and so like
- 56:45crazy beak. Plus the rosy at spoonbill here in the America's is bright pink.
- 56:52So it's just it's like a wonder of evolution, Like how does this
- 56:55thing exist? I don't know. So I want to go on now to
- 57:00talk about sort of women in games and sort of your contribution to it.
- 57:06So you have a database of female designers on the website on your website,
- 57:10why did you start this? I got invited to several events that I could
- 57:16not attend and got asked, you know, what are who are other women
- 57:22that we could invite? And got tired of putting together the same list over
- 57:28and over again, but also got tired of In media accounts about Wingspan,
- 57:35a lot of articles said things like that I was one of the only women
- 57:39designers of game of board games, which is just not true. I am
- 57:45now one of the more successful women, Like I'm one of very few that
- 57:51are in the top two hundred on BGG, but I'm not one of the
- 57:57only ones. There's like almost two hundred women on that list now with published
- 58:02board games around the world. So yeah, I just wanting to use my
- 58:08fifteen minutes of fame to help elevate some other people and get some more word
- 58:13out about women doing great stuff, and to try and sort of normalize the
- 58:17idea that all game designers are not guys. I've had a lot of experiences
- 58:25going out to play testing events and gaming events in general where I am often
- 58:30one of very few women, and that can be uncomfortable. And I've never
- 58:40been treated badly in ways that I perceived were because I was a woman,
- 58:45but even just being in an extreme minority or having people be surprised that I'm
- 58:53there is uncomfortable, and I'd like to make it a little easier for other
- 59:00folks. And I mean, do you think I mean there's obviously these factors
- 59:05do you think women have a disadvantage in the gaming world. And I don't
- 59:09really want to talk about as gamers, because that's also an area, but
- 59:13as professionals entering, as designed, as as artists, as you know,
- 59:19people who as publishes, all of these sort of aspects. I mean,
- 59:22there's a lot of work out there about unconscious bias. I don't perceive that
- 59:27there are a lot of publishers that are consciously discriminating, although it's certainly possible.
- 59:35And I actually talked to one woman at the end of last year who
- 59:39was in a game design contest that was sort of publicly judged, where one
- 59:43of the judges, who is an established publisher successful publishers, said some things
- 59:50to her that were not acceptable. So there are definitely people that are being
- 59:57sort of overtly biased. But there's also a lot of work out there in
- 1:00:02general, in many different fields about the unconscious bias that a lot of people
- 1:00:09have. And I do think it's possible that that's at work, and it's
- 1:00:13really hard to test, but I think it's helpful for people to keep in
- 1:00:16the back of their minds that that is a possibility. I think another thing
- 1:00:21that happens is that a lot of publishers, reasonably so, are much more
- 1:00:28interested in publishing games by people that already have a successful track record as designers,
- 1:00:34as published designers, and that just reinforces the games get published by the
- 1:00:39same types of designers that have already gotten published. And so if we ever
- 1:00:45want to get more people of color and more women published, you have to
- 1:00:50have publishers that are willing to break out of that and take risks on new
- 1:00:53designers. I mean, what does Because there's a lot of talk about in
- 1:01:00all fields at the moment about representation, What does representation do? Why is
- 1:01:07it a good thing? Why should we care about it? I mean,
- 1:01:09I think ultimately, representation in games is gonna make it's going to broaden the
- 1:01:16field of gamers. So I'm walking in to a gaming event that is more
- 1:01:25men than women, and then I sit down to play games, and over
- 1:01:29and over every game that I play is all male characters, and thank god,
- 1:01:37we're moving away from male characters plus women in bikinis like that, it
- 1:01:45just makes it that much worse and that much less likely that I'm going to
- 1:01:50keep coming back. Whereas if I walk into this event and I'm one of
- 1:01:58the only women there, but the games have lots of women in them,
- 1:02:02or are about other subjects that are interesting to me, don't necessarily represent people
- 1:02:09at all. That's going to be a very different feel. I mean,
- 1:02:15is it fundamentally about feeling that there are people like you who share your interests?
- 1:02:23Yes, and see you know, and being more interesting games that are
- 1:02:29about things that I'm interested in, including people that I want to see.
- 1:02:36And I think it's interesting because I've been thinking a lot about sort of Twitter
- 1:02:39and how toxic the internet can be, and how the way I see myself
- 1:02:46sometimes acting and certainly people who I've met who act in sort of a way
- 1:02:53on Twitter that I think you would never sort of do that face to face.
- 1:03:00And yet Twitter is often used as an analog for real life. Do
- 1:03:02you think we make a mistake in thinking that Twitter is really what people think?
- 1:03:13That's a good question. I mean, there's a lot going on on
- 1:03:15Twitter besides what you actually think. There's a lot of sort of presenting a
- 1:03:19public persona that can get in a way of saying what you actually think.
- 1:03:23And then there's the sort of so that's a more positive side of it,
- 1:03:29right, so that may not involve being mean to people that you may still
- 1:03:32not be saying what you actually think. And then the negative side of it
- 1:03:37is you know that people are much more much less inhibited online than they are
- 1:03:45face to face in face to face interactions. I was praising myself for much
- 1:03:50worse than I got when Wingspan came out, and part of it maybe that
- 1:03:53I just subscribe to the right blocklists. But I'm is really concerned because I
- 1:04:00know women who are active in sort of content creation in board games who've had
- 1:04:08horrible things said to them. I was really bracing myself that that might happen
- 1:04:14with Wingspan, but I really it hasn't come to pass. So I don't
- 1:04:18know why not, but I'll take it. It's really it's it's really strange.
- 1:04:23I think it's something to do with content creation when your face is out
- 1:04:27there and your voices out there people, and also there's a feeling of ownership
- 1:04:32and people feel like they can criticize, and sometimes that criticism is eloquent,
- 1:04:38and sometimes that criticism is base, you know. Yeah, And I wonder
- 1:04:42also if I don't sort of get some benefit of having sort of the protective
- 1:04:45aura of Jamie Stegmeyer associated with me, and certainly, you know, The
- 1:04:54community that he has created on the Facebook page for WINGSPA is just amazing and
- 1:05:01so positive, and there's like almost five thousand people out there right now.
- 1:05:06So that's been like the best of social media board game world to be participating
- 1:05:16in that and just to be hearing from people every day who are enjoying the
- 1:05:20game, and that's been great. So your next game then is Race for
- 1:05:26the Galaxy. So why this one is opposed to Role for the Galaxy.
- 1:05:30M Yeah, I've only played Role for the Galaxy once. I had already
- 1:05:34been playing Race for the Galaxy, I think for years when I tried Role
- 1:05:40for the Galaxy and it just felt totally wrong to me. But I think
- 1:05:43because I started with Race, I don't know, I have probably played Race
- 1:05:51for the Galaxy more than any other game. It's such a sweet, quick,
- 1:05:56little two player game. My husband and I play it all the time.
- 1:06:00Um, you know, I don't will do a lot of the best
- 1:06:02two out of three kinds of things. So, yeah, there's something I
- 1:06:11enjoy about the cards more than the dice that, even though the cards are
- 1:06:16also very random, that dice really feel uncontrollable to me. And and you
- 1:06:21know they always say that the big problem with Race for the Galaxy is the
- 1:06:25opacity of its icons and things. Is this unfair or because i've this is
- 1:06:30a game I'm ashamed to say I've never played myself. Is that unfair?
- 1:06:34Isn't an unfair criticism? Or is it a pain in the art to learn?
- 1:06:39I think it's totally fair. It's like learning a whole new language.
- 1:06:43It's it's a ridiculous learning curve. And I have a lot of friends that
- 1:06:45aren't willing to put in the effort, But I don't know. For whatever
- 1:06:50reason, I did, and I really enjoy it. And you said this
- 1:06:55is the game that you played the most, and also you said that you
- 1:06:59know games that you play influence your design. Have you ever consciously lifted elements
- 1:07:05from Race for the Galaxy or ideas ways of solving problems or do you think
- 1:07:10it's snuck in there subconsciously. I think that the first versions of Wingspan were
- 1:07:17very consciously related to Race for the Galaxy for sure, because it's you know,
- 1:07:24card based engine building. Yeah, definitely, definitely some relation, and
- 1:07:30it makes me smile when reviewers mentioned that they see the relationship, but it's
- 1:07:34it's it's there for sure, and you know, how do you feel about
- 1:07:40sort of designers of these games? Do you see these because I went I
- 1:07:45remember my first essen and I met Vlada Hivattle and it was crazy and I
- 1:07:48felt, you know, completely starstruck. Do you have that similar feeling towards
- 1:07:51designers of the games that you love? And have you Have you met the
- 1:07:55designer or race for the Galaxy for instance, and or would you like to
- 1:07:59and would you feel star struck by it? I have not met the designer
- 1:08:04race for the Galaxy. I would love to. I yes, I have
- 1:08:10felt very star struck by people. So like I go to UNPIEV every year
- 1:08:13in Baltimore and lots of designers come out to that, and um, until
- 1:08:19this year, I was sort of, you know, totally unknown, totally
- 1:08:24star struck. And then this year it was such a different experience to have
- 1:08:29you know, known designers coming up to me and going, oh my gosh,
- 1:08:31it's so good to meet you. I'm like, oh my god,
- 1:08:38did you feel like saying how dare you? I've been here for years.
- 1:08:42It's only now I'm successful. I mean, there is a little bit of
- 1:08:45that, right, but I'll take it. I won't complain. So I
- 1:08:51want to talk now about the future. So you've got games coming out this
- 1:08:57year, I believe, So so what have you what have you got come
- 1:09:00in the future. Yeah, So May twenty eighth will be the kickstarter for
- 1:09:04Tussy Mussy, which is eighteen card game that was inspired by this Victorian fad
- 1:09:15related to giving people flowers, and people call it the language of flowers,
- 1:09:19like assigning meaning to the specific flowers that you gave to people. So in
- 1:09:26the game, you're giving flowers to the people you're playing with, but you
- 1:09:31give one card face up and one card face down, and they have to
- 1:09:34decide which when they keep in which one they give back to you. And
- 1:09:40eventually you end up with a little collection of flowers that score based on what
- 1:09:44else is in your collection. So some cards may be much more valuable to
- 1:09:48you than to other players, depending on what you already have. And as
- 1:09:54you do this sort of it's sort of is split. You choose right,
- 1:09:57and you have to sort of try and figure out this person's offering me this
- 1:10:01thing face up. Is it because they think that's the one I want and
- 1:10:04they want the one that they put faced down, or is the thing that's
- 1:10:08faced down actually the one that's better for me, and that's why they're not
- 1:10:11showing it to me. A lot of that dynamics. So that was the
- 1:10:15way that I tried to sort of squeeze more decision making and sort of intrigue
- 1:10:23out of a deck that's only eighteen cards. And do you have any of
- 1:10:28the sort of bigger box games any magnum opus is if that's the plural in
- 1:10:33the future, So not a magnum opus, but sort of a gateway level
- 1:10:39game that I just signed with eighteg. The working title is Mariposas, which
- 1:10:45means butterflies in Spanish. It's about monarch butterflies and their migration from Mexico to
- 1:10:50North America, which happens every year. So it's you're moving butterflies around in
- 1:10:55a map, collecting flowers and making more butterflies and then racing back to Mexico
- 1:11:00in the fall. So that'll be out hopefully sometime in twenty twenty. The
- 1:11:04date's not exactly set. Yeah, And so it seems to me that you
- 1:11:09like to make games that have a grounding in science. I mean, do
- 1:11:14you think this is an underused topic in gaming and do you see it happening
- 1:11:20more in the future. I think just in the last few years, you've
- 1:11:25been seeing more and more of them there, and there's been some great ones
- 1:11:30that have come out in the last few years. It was very interested to
- 1:11:32see the game Endangered that was just on Kickstarter. I did the voiceover for
- 1:11:38the Kickstarter video actually hashtag humble bragg And you know, there's the stuff Genius
- 1:11:45Games has been doing for many years now with super like stem teaching games,
- 1:11:54and some of those are, you know, good games in their own right,
- 1:11:58But I think their market is really the classroom, and I love seeing
- 1:12:01things that are busting out sort of inter being people, not necessarily caring whether
- 1:12:10itever gets used in a classroom, but just using the subject matters as things
- 1:12:15that might also be of interest to gamers. And so, what do you
- 1:12:21want to achieve as a game designer? And because because you still work within
- 1:12:27the field of health, I guess you still have a day job. I
- 1:12:30mean, do you envisage any time in the future being a game design a
- 1:12:33full time or do you still want to keep it as a sideline so essentially
- 1:12:39doesn't turn into as much of a job and you're going to hate it.
- 1:12:43I mean there's that danger, right, I don't think I'm still trying to
- 1:12:45find that balance. I'm definitely I've been part time in my day job for
- 1:12:48a long time. But you know, regardless of how Wingspan has done,
- 1:12:51I've been pretty fortunate to be able to do that just because of how I
- 1:12:57can structure my consulting game because I like to travel and do other things as
- 1:13:03well, and so the trick has really been keeping game design contained so that
- 1:13:12because it's always been something that I thought of more as a hobby, that's
- 1:13:15allowed to fill up a lot of my spare time. Now right now,
- 1:13:19the struggle for me has been okay, it really does. It is starting
- 1:13:25to feel more like its own job, and I need to be more conscious
- 1:13:30of creating boundaries and treating it like a job that fits that still leaves me
- 1:13:36time to do other things. And so Wingspan hasn't enabled you to retire yet.
- 1:13:44Then I could probably retire if I wanted to separate from Wingspan having happened,
- 1:13:49but I haven't done it yet. So I want to go on then
- 1:13:54to your last game. And this is between two castles of Man King Ludwig.
- 1:13:58Now I own castles of Mad King Ludwig. I own between two cities.
- 1:14:03Why should I try this game. This game has replaced both of its
- 1:14:09predecessors for me in what way, So it keeps some of the things that
- 1:14:16I love the best about both of them and gets rid of others. So
- 1:14:21I love the working with your two neighbors aspect. Between two concept is something
- 1:14:30I really enjoy, and it keeps set from between two cities, but then
- 1:14:33it keeps some of the really interesting scoring mechanics and set collection from between two
- 1:14:43castles of mad King Ludwig. And then the thing it does that the um
- 1:14:48I like better than either game is that the views of the castle rooms are
- 1:14:57as if you're in the room looking at the things in it instead of top
- 1:15:00down. So the art is beautiful, and it gets rid of the auction
- 1:15:06from between two castles, which some people love, but I feel like with
- 1:15:11the people that I play with, it just slows the game down so much.
- 1:15:15And the wonderful thing about the between two model is that there's almost no
- 1:15:20downtime because it's simultaneous play, and yeah, that's just lovely, especially for
- 1:15:29bigger groups of people. And this game, you know, it's stable,
- 1:15:33made to wingspan the most Stonemayer games. Do you think there's a unifying character
- 1:15:38to Stonemayer's games, I don't know. I mean, they're all visually very
- 1:15:44appealing to me. And one of the ways the stonemare articulates what they're looking
- 1:15:54for in games that are pitched to them is they want event games that would
- 1:15:59be like the media game that you might organize a game night around. They're
- 1:16:04not interested in filler games, and so that's sort of a weight and a
- 1:16:14length more than anything more specific than that, but it does make their games
- 1:16:23feel more similar to each other than a than a company that tries to have
- 1:16:28some fillers and some super heavy games. And then I just think and Euphoria
- 1:16:38sort of in that science fiction dystopia world that is more common among board games,
- 1:16:43but even then it's it's sort of a unique take on that theme.
- 1:16:46And then viticulture is a very unusual theme. Scive is its own whole world.
- 1:16:54It's not sort of high fantasy tropes or anything like that. And then
- 1:16:57Between two Castles is this very very whimsical theme but based on a real world
- 1:17:02thing. So even theme wise, maybe they do have something in common,
- 1:17:10or at least they're each out of the ordinary in their own way. So
- 1:17:15one last question, then you're driving to the cabin fleeing the apocalypse driving out
- 1:17:19of Washington, DC, and you go around a corner. The back door
- 1:17:25of the car flies open. Four of the games fly out down a Ravinea,
- 1:17:30swept down a river, and are Gone forever? Which gained your hope
- 1:17:34is lying on the backseat of the car. I think I have to say
- 1:17:39a wingspan. I felt bad even including it. You said you would have
- 1:17:44been disappointed. But it feels weird right to like say, you want your
- 1:17:46own game more than any other, but you know, not even just for
- 1:17:51the gameplay, but just as like this piece of my life work. I
- 1:17:56spent so long working on it, it feels like this amazing achievement, Like
- 1:18:00how can I not keep that brilliant? Well, if people want to get
- 1:18:05hold of you, how would they go about doing that? I am pretty
- 1:18:10active on board game Twitter at e Liz Hargrave, so e l i Z
- 1:18:15Hargrave, and I mentioned the Facebook page for Winspy, and I also check
- 1:18:23in their most days. There's lots of people talking about the game there.
- 1:18:28Elizabeth Hargrave, thank you very much. Thank you, And if you want
- 1:18:31to suggest a guest, or if you want to say something nice about the
- 1:18:34show, or if you want to say something horrible about the show, you
- 1:18:38can contact me on at five Games for Doomsday. On Twitter, you can
- 1:18:42send me an email at five Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com. You
- 1:18:45can give a rolling donation to help support the show at patreon dot com forward
- 1:18:49Slash five g f D or a onetime PayPal donation at the bottom of the
- 1:18:55website five Games for Doomsday dot com, And if you fancy looking swanky,
- 1:19:00can buy a T shirt tepublic dot com, Forward Slash user forward Slash five
- 1:19:03Games for Doomsday, and trust me, you won't see better designs in the
- 1:19:08whole of the board game world, or probably the world that remains. And
- 1:19:14if I haven't had to deny my affiliation to escape the bureaucratic eagles and then
- 1:19:18the swarms of people who bore me, I'll see you in two weeks for
- 1:19:23another five Games four Doomsday