Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Negotiate a Job Offer Without Losing the Offer
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's talk about the moment when you get a job offer, you're excited, and then you stare at the number and think, 'Is this it?' Luna: Yeah, and the panic that sets in when you realize you actually have to negotiate—or decide not to. Lucas: Right. And according to a 2024 survey from the site Levels.fyi, about 84 percent of candidates accept the first offer without negotiating at all. That's a huge missed opportunity, because employers typically expect you to push back a little. Luna: So most people leave money on the table purely because they're afraid the offer will get pulled. Lucas: Exactly. And the fear is real but usually overblown. A well-handled negotiation—where you're respectful and data-driven—very rarely causes an offer to be rescinded. In fact, a 2023 study from the Journal of Organizational Behavior found that recruiters actually rated candidates who negotiated as more competent on average. Luna: Huh, so negotiating signals confidence, not greed. Lucas: That's the finding. But the key is how you frame it. If you come in with 'I need more money because I have a bigger rent now' — that's not persuasive. But if you say 'Based on my experience and market data, I believe a salary of X is more aligned with the role' — that's a business conversation. Luna: What about the fear that they'll just move on to the next candidate? I've definitely felt that. Lucas: It happens, but it's rare. Most companies have invested significant time interviewing you. They want you. The cost of restarting the search is much higher than a few thousand dollars. Let me give you a concrete example. A listener named Sarah wrote in—she's a product manager at a mid-size SaaS company. She got an offer for a senior PM role at a competitor for one hundred and ten thousand base. Luna: And she thought it was low? Lucas: She had done her homework. On Glassdoor and Levels.fyi, the median for that role at companies of similar size was one hundred and twenty-five to one hundred and thirty. So she had a number. She also knew the company had a strong culture and offered good equity, so she wanted the job. Luna: So what did she do? Lucas: She called the recruiter—never over email for the initial ask—and said, 'I'm very excited about this opportunity and I think I'd be a great fit. Based on my research of comparable roles, I was hoping the base could be closer to one hundred and twenty-five. Is there flexibility on that?' She didn't threaten, didn't cite a competing offer she didn't have. Luna: And the recruiter said… Lucas: Recruiter came back the next day with one hundred and twenty thousand plus a fifteen thousand dollar signing bonus. So she got a fifteen percent increase on base, plus the bonus, just by asking one question. Luna: That's a great outcome. And she got the signing bonus too, which is often easier for companies to add because it's a one-time cost. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a key point—you don't have to negotiate only salary. You can negotiate signing bonus, relocation, start date, remote flexibility, even title. Sometimes companies have rigid salary bands but more flexibility on one-time items. Luna: I think people also forget about negotiating for a later start date, which can be valuable if you want a break between jobs or need to give a longer notice. Lucas: Absolutely. And remote flexibility is increasingly negotiable too. A 2025 survey from FlexJobs found that 37 percent of job offers initially listed as hybrid could be renegotiated to fully remote if the candidate asked. You just have to make the case for productivity. Luna: So the advice is: ask, but ask with data and enthusiasm. Lucas: Right. And always keep the tone collaborative. You're not demanding—you're problem-solving together. Say something like 'I want to make this work, and I think this adjustment would make the offer more competitive. Can we explore that?' Luna: I love that. And you know, this kind of practical, no-hype career advice is exactly why people listen to this show. We don't have sponsors, we don't push products—just real conversations. If you find value in episodes like this, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep it ad-free and focused on what matters. Lucas: Yeah, and we really appreciate that. Now, back to Sarah's negotiation—one thing she did right was she didn't negotiate over email first. She called. That made it personal. Luna: Why is a call better than email? Lucas: Because tone is everything. On email, your request can sound demanding or curt. On a call, you can convey enthusiasm, gratitude, and your reasoning all in tone of voice. Plus, you can hear the recruiter's reaction and adjust in real time. If they say 'We have no room on salary,' you can pivot to asking about a signing bonus or extra vacation days. Luna: That makes sense. So the rule is: do the initial ask verbally, then follow up in writing confirming what you agreed. Lucas: Exactly. And if you must do it by email, keep it short. Here's a template: 'Thank you so much for the offer. I'm very excited about the role and the team. Based on my experience and market research, I was hoping we could discuss the base salary. Is there flexibility to move toward X?' That's it. Luna: No long justification paragraphs. Lucas: No. And don't apologize. I hear people write 'I'm sorry to ask for more'—don't do that. You're not sorry. You're advocating for your value. Luna: What about when you have another offer? How do you use that without seeming like you're playing games? Lucas: Be transparent. Say 'I have another offer on the table, but I'd prefer to join your team. Is there room to improve the offer to help me choose?' You're not bluffing—or if you are, don't get caught. But honestly, if you have a real offer, use it. It's the strongest leverage. Luna: And if they say no to everything? Then what? Lucas: Then you have a decision. Is the job worth taking at the offered number? If yes, take it gracefully. If not, you can politely decline. But never threaten to walk away unless you're truly willing to. And if you do walk, leave the door open—say 'I hope we can stay in touch for future opportunities.' You never know. Luna: So the big takeaway is: negotiate, but do it with data, enthusiasm, and a collaborative tone. Lucas: And remember—most offers are negotiable. The worst they can say is no. And if they say no, you're no worse off than if you hadn't asked. But if you don't ask, you're leaving money and benefits on the table 84 percent of the time. Luna: That stat again. 84 percent. Don't be part of that majority. Lucas: Exactly. Next time, we'll talk about what to do if you accept a job and then get a better offer two weeks later. That's a tricky one. Until then, good luck negotiating.