Latest / The WallBuilders Show / Constitution Alive, Section 4, Part 3
Transcript
- 0:07Rick Green: Welcome to the intersection of faith and politics.
- 0:09Rick Green: This is Wall Builders.
- 0:10Rick Green: Today we're going to get the conclusion of a three-part series out of our Constitution Alive series.
- 0:15Rick Green: In that Constitution Alive series we cover every amendment, every article.
- 0:19Rick Green: We walk you through the Constitution and give you the original intent.
- 0:21Rick Green: And this week we've been sharing with you section four out of Constitution Alive, which is about the Congress and this three-part series, if you happen to miss yesterday or the day before, you can go to our website right now at Wall Builders Live and grab it.
- 0:34Rick Green: But we're going to pick up right where we left off yesterday with Constitution Alive.
- 0:38Rick Green: This next clause there.
- 0:40Rick Green: If you're on page 12 where we're going through the enumerated powers, I know we don't like it.
- 0:44Rick Green: I don't like these trillion-dollar deficits, friends.
- 0:47Rick Green: I think they're immoral, I think they're wrong.
- 0:49Rick Green: Unfortunately they are Constitutional.
- 0:51Rick Green: That phrase says to borrow money on the credit of the United States they have.
- 0:55Rick Green: It's one of the powers we put in the bucket and of course we want them to be able to fight wars at some time you might have.
- 1:00Rick Green: You know how close we were to amending that part of the Constitution.
- 1:04Rick Green: We almost had a balanced budget, amendment 1999.
- 1:07Rick Green: Anybody know how close were we?
- 1:08Rick Green: "One You got it right there, ma'am.
- 1:10Rick Green: One vote, One vote.
- 1:13Rick Green: We could have had it with one more vote.
- 1:16Rick Green: Don't tell me your vote doesn't count.
- 1:17Rick Green: Every vote counts, every single time.
- 1:19Rick Green: I think we've got a good lot of momentum in the country right now.
- 1:22Rick Green: That's probably an amendment we can get done if we put enough support behind it.
- 1:25Rick Green: But anyway, it is obviously Constitutional for them to borrow money right now.
- 1:29Rick Green: Let's rein that one in.
- 1:30Rick Green: But here's the Commerce Clause.
- 1:31Rick Green: Okay, here's this next big loophole that they run through.
- 1:34Rick Green: I see three areas right here that the federal government has the power.
- 1:40Rick Green: We gave them, or loaned them, the power to regulate three areas of commerce.
- 1:45Rick Green: Now, regulate does not mean micromanage.
- 1:48Rick Green: Back then it meant to make regular.
- 1:51Rick Green: So it doesn't mean they get to micromanage it, it means they actually get to make it regular, which is back to this idea of general welfare.
- 1:58Rick Green: It's back to the idea of protecting the system itself.
- 2:01Rick Green: And in commerce, what's the system?
- 2:02Rick Green: You want to protect?
- 2:03Rick Green: The free flow of free enterprise, right?
- 2:05Rick Green: So in order to do that, we gave them the power to be the negotiators, if you will, in these three areas of commerce.
- 2:13Rick Green: Three areas only.
- 2:14Rick Green: Number one we said they can regulate commerce with foreign nations we already mentioned.
- 2:18Rick Green: We don't want 50 states negotiating with these countries and having 50 different treaties, so we let the federal government do that, fair enough.
- 2:26Rick Green: Second category, and among the several states, as Thomas said, that's Interstate Commerce.
- 2:32Rick Green: So that interstate commerce that crosses the state line, you could say that the federal camel knows is under the tent.
- 2:40Rick Green: We gave them, loaned them I'm sorry, loaned them the power to in some way make regular commerce across state lines.
- 2:47Rick Green: That doesn't mean micromanage.
- 2:49Rick Green: What it means is we're not going to let one state abuse another state in terms of free enterprise.
- 2:54Rick Green: For instance, in Texas we've really, over the last few decades, increased our agriculture in the area of vineyards and having wineries all around Texas and it's actually become a big part of our agriculture.
- 3:10Rick Green: Well, California obviously huge in that right.
- 3:13Rick Green: Well, Texas legislature cannot pass a law that says well, you really want to help these guys with these vineyards in Texas be able to do better in their sales so Texans can't buy California wine anymore.
- 3:22Rick Green: We're going to impose a blockade.
- 3:25Rick Green: That's why we want a commerce clause in the Constitution so that the federal government can say to Texas no, you can't do that.
- 3:31Rick Green: We want the free flow of commerce because we believe in the free market and we believe that if you allow that free market to flow, everybody's going to be better off.
- 3:38Rick Green: So that's a legitimate function of the federal government.
- 3:41Rick Green: And then the last category, with the Indian tribes.
- 3:43Rick Green: So you've got sovereign Indian tribes.
- 3:45Rick Green: You ought to have the nation of the United States negotiating with them, and not all these individual states in terms of commerce.
- 3:50Rick Green: So there's your three categories Foreign nations, interstate commerce and your Indian tribes.
- 3:56Rick Green: So I'm just curious, why is it, if I'm going to put a new bathroom in my house let's say I'm going to do a little remodeling, I'm going to add a new, I'm a remodel bathroom If I call up Joe, the plumber up there in Ohio and I say, hey, Joe, would you come in and do my bathroom for me?
- 4:11Rick Green: And he says yes, he's going to come, so he's going to bring in tools.
- 4:13Rick Green: He's going to bring in some guys.
- 4:14Rick Green: I got some interstate commerce going on now, right, so the feds actually have an opportunity to make regular this transaction.
- 4:22Rick Green: What if my wife says you know, honey, I was looking online and they've got this beautiful fancy you know Fufu toilet in France that I want to order.
- 4:32Rick Green: It's only $1,200, baby I, you know I'm and she's going to order this thing from now.
- 4:37Rick Green: Now the federal government's got an international right.
- 4:39Rick Green: We got a foreign nation involved, so now they can make regular the transaction of my remodel in my house.
- 4:49Rick Green: Have you noticed the vacuum of leadership in America?
- 4:52Rick Green: We're looking around for leaders of principle to step up, and too often no one is there.
- 4:57Rick Green: God is raising up a generation of young leaders with a passion for impacting the world around them.
- 5:03Rick Green: They're crying out for the mentorship and leadership training they need.
- 5:06Rick Green: Patriot Academy was created to meet that need.
- 5:09Rick Green: Patriot Academy graduates now serve in state capitals around America, in the halls of Congress, in business, in the film industry, in the pulpit, in every area of the culture.
- 5:18Rick Green: They're leading effectively and impacting the world around them.
- 5:21Rick Green: Patriot Academy is now expanding across the nation, and now is your chance to experience this life-changing week that trains champions to change the world.
- 5:28Rick Green: Visit www.
- 5:29Rick Green: patriotacademy.
- 5:29Rick Green: com for dates and locations.
- 5:31Rick Green: Our core program is still for young leaders 16 to 25 years old, but we also now have a citizen track for adults.
- 5:37Rick Green: So visit the website today to learn more.
- 5:39Rick Green: Help us fill the void of leadership in America.
- 6:50David Barton: This is David Barton with another moment from America's history.
- 6:50David Barton: What is the purpose of government?
- 6:50David Barton: Founding Father Oliver Ellsworth believed he knew.
- 6:50David Barton: Oliver Ellsworth was a delegate at the Convention which formed the Constitution and later he became the Chief Justice in the US Supreme Court.
- 6:50David Barton: Concerning the purpose of government, Oliver Ellsworth declared, "the primary objects of government are the peace, order and prosperity of society.
- 6:50David Barton: Yet how are these goals to be achieved?
- 6:50David Barton: Ellsworth explained, to the promotion of these objects, good morals are essential.
- 6:50David Barton: Institutions for the promotion of good morals are therefore objects of legislative provision and support and among these, religious institutions are immanently useful and important.
- 6:50David Barton: Founding father Oliver Ellsworth believed government could never reach it's g oals apart from the help of religious institutions.
- 7:35Rick Green: What happens if Joe the Plumber calls me and said sorry, I've got 15 tea parties I'm speaking at this month, ain't no way I can get down there to do your bathroom, you're going to have to find somebody local, so I can't get Joe the Plumber from Ohio so I hire Joe Smith from down the road in Dripping Springs, Texas.
- 7:35Rick Green: He's going to come do it, no tools come from out of state, no labor coming from out of state, we don't have Interstate Commerce going on anymore.
- 7:35Rick Green: My, gorgeous, brilliant , amazing wife as always happens makes a brilliant decision and says, you know, honey that would be really foolish of us to by that 1200 dollar toilet from France when Lowes has one for 79 dollars and it's going to work just fine.
- 7:35Rick Green: So being as brilliant as she is, we decide we are going to do that, we don't have France involved anymore.
- 7:35Rick Green: No more international commerce, no more foreign nations.
- 7:35Rick Green: So we don't have foreign nations, we don't have interstate commerce, Why is it that the federal government gets to tell me how much water has got to go through my toilet, what kind of light bulbs I got to have in my bathroom, how wide my door has got to be?
- 7:44Rick Green: I mean, it's ridiculous.
- 7:46Rick Green: It must be because Joe Smith, there next door is Choctaw, or because, thank you, somebody got that one, or because I'm part Comanche.
- 7:55Rick Green: I'm assuming, because of me having some Comanche blood, that the federal government has decided that my any transaction is with an Indian trust, surely that I can't figure it out, because there is no reason for the federal government to have anything to do with the commerce that is not fitting into any of those three categories.
- 8:11Rick Green: And you know what's really sad?
- 8:13Rick Green: The courts got this right for a long time.
- 8:16Rick Green: They slapped Congress down, slapped their hand for years when they would try to expand, open up the lid, get a new power, expand and do commerce that was not in those three categories.
- 8:27Rick Green: And then all of a sudden they started kind of rubber stamping what would come out of Congress.
- 8:32Rick Green: You remember why?
- 8:33Rick Green: It was FDR.
- 8:34Rick Green: He had the switching time saved nine.
- 8:37Rick Green: He was going to pack the court and all this stuff.
- 8:39Rick Green: And all of a sudden they decided well, you know, we said a little while ago, minimum wage, you couldn't do that because that doesn't fit into the commerce clause.
- 8:45Rick Green: But now we're going to let you do that.
- 8:46Rick Green: And then they started letting them regulate this and regulate that.
- 8:49Rick Green: And now you know how bad it's gotten.
- 8:51Rick Green: It's gotten so bad that the Wickard V Filburn case this is where a guy is farming, he is raising his own crops, he is not selling them to anybody, he's consuming them himself.
- 9:04Rick Green: He's not buying them from anybody.
- 9:06Rick Green: So there's no commerce here, right?
- 9:07Rick Green: I mean, this would be like you having a garden in your backyard.
- 9:10Rick Green: He's not buying, no commerce.
- 9:13Rick Green: Our court said the federal government could come in with all the way to the Department of Agriculture on this guy and say you have to obey all of our, we can regulate everything you're doing because it's commerce.
- 9:24Rick Green: And you say, well, how is it commerce that's not crossing state lines?
- 9:27Rick Green: How is it commerce if he's not even selling anything?
- 9:29Rick Green: And he's not buying anything.
- 9:30Rick Green: They say, well, you know, had he bought those crops down at the farmer's market, it might have affected the price of commerce, I mean the price of those crops.
- 9:38Rick Green: Had he sold his crops down at the farmer's market, it might have affected the price.
- 9:44Rick Green: And therefore this is somehow going to have some you know some related.
- 9:48Rick Green: If you could connect enough dots, it will impact interstate commerce.
- 9:51Rick Green: Friends, that's where we are.
- 9:52Rick Green: That's how far we've gone from the plain language.
- 9:56Rick Green: I mean, is anybody confused by those three categories, anybody confused by the plain language of the Constitution?
- 10:02Rick Green: And yet, because we've gone away from what these guys told us to do, we no longer interpret that language by what they said.
- 10:09Rick Green: We let some judge somewhere else, twist it a little bit, then twist it a little more, then twist a little more.
- 10:15Rick Green: You know how bad it is now?
- 10:16Rick Green: The whole idea of taking healthcare through the commerce clause?
- 10:24Rick Green: The federal judge that initially said it was unconstitutional, he said the reason is because not only did Wickard V Filburn allow us to regulate commerce or regulate activity that was not commerce, not only did it go so far as to allow us to regulate activity that was not commerce, what this law does is it allows us to regulate inactivity that is not commerce.
- 10:49Rick Green: And do you get how bad that is?
- 10:51Rick Green: That means we can regulate anything you do or don't do, and that's what the court said was such a bad idea.
- 10:59Rick Green: And, by the way, one good thing that came out of the Supreme Court decision on healthcare is that Justice Roberts actually said no to using the commerce clause for healthcare.
- 11:10Rick Green: So he put the brakes on this slippery slope.
- 11:13Rick Green: We've gone with the commerce clause.
- 11:14Rick Green: That was one of the good things that came out of it.
- 11:16Rick Green: In fact, he said, "the path of our commerce clause decisions has not always run smooth, but it is now well established that Congress has brought authority under the clause.
- 11:26Rick Green: Wait a second well established by whom?
- 11:28Rick Green: So a retired English teacher in the room?
- 11:31Rick Green: Is it whom?
- 11:31Rick Green: Or who?
- 11:32Rick Green: Well established by whom?
- 11:33Rick Green: Let's just go with whom, because it makes it sound smart, I don't know.
- 11:36Rick Green: Well established by whom?
- 11:37Rick Green: I mean just because the courts have said that the commerce clause gives broad discretion to Congress, that doesn't mean it's so.
- 11:46Rick Green: That doesn't mean that's what these guys wanted and when you go back to what they said, they did not want it to give them broad discretion.
- 11:54Rick Green: So I completely disagree with the Chief Justice on this.
- 11:56Rick Green: It is not well established.
- 11:58Rick Green: It may be thought in their minds or well established in their circles, but not these guys who sat in this room.
- 12:06Rick Green: They'd be standing up and saying, oh no, you got that one entirely wrong.
- 12:10Rick Green: In fact, the other four, the four justices that dissented in the healthcare decision, said this about how far this was going to go if we allowed this kind of expansion of the government.
- 12:19Rick Green: This is Scalia, Alito, thomas and Kennedy.
- 12:23Rick Green: "To go beyond that meaning going beyond what happened in Wicked v Filburn, to go beyond regulating commerce activity that is not commerce under the Constitution, but to even go even further than that they said, "and to say that the failure to grow wheat.
- 12:39Rick Green: So remember what was happening in the case.
- 12:40Rick Green: This guy was growing wheat and consuming it, so there was an activity happening and the feds decided that that was an activity they could regulate.
- 12:47Rick Green: What they're saying is now we're going to go beyond even that and say that the failure that the failure to grow wheat so now we're not growing wheat ".
- 12:56Rick Green: .
- 12:56Rick Green: and the failure to grow wheat, which is not an economic activity or any activity at all, nonetheless affects commerce.
- 13:03Rick Green: So now this guy doesn't even grow his wheat, doesn't sell it down the street, and so now we're going to be able to regulate him.
- 13:09Rick Green: They said "that is to make mere breathing in and out the basis for federal prescription.
- 13:16Rick Green: It extends federal power to virtually all human activity.
- 13:21Rick Green: That's four of our Supreme Court justices saying this is gone way too far.
- 13:26Rick Green: We're using the commerce clause or, frankly, any part of the Constitution to regulate people just for breathing in and out.
- 13:33Rick Green: That's their words.
- 13:33Rick Green: That's how far we've allowed it to go, friends.
- 13:35Rick Green: Now commerce is supposed to be free enterprise.
- 13:39Rick Green: The more we micromanage it, the less freedom we have.
- 13:43Rick Green: The more we force people into the marketplace, the less freedom we have.
- 13:47Rick Green: And Jefferson had a great quote on this.
- 13:49Rick Green: He said "the pillars of our prosperity are the most thriving when left most free to individual enterprise.
- 13:56Rick Green: " When we regulate to the point of micromanaging, when we force people into the marketplace, we're not left free to individual enterprise, are we?
- 14:06Rick Green: That's how far we've gone and the reason we hadn't been reading it.
- 14:09Rick Green: We haven't studied it, we haven't looked at what the real meaning behind those words actually are.
- 14:16Rick Green: That's why what we're doing is so important, because see if you and I can go back to what these guys actually did and said, if we can learn what they really intended, and then we can go back home and we can share it with our friends and family.
- 14:29Rick Green: If we can use this knowledge in the decisions we make about who we elect to go to Congress, if we can begin to get young people to understand this and someday run for Congress, then we can get members of Congress that understand these things and we can rein this thing in.
- 14:43Rick Green: We can turn it back folks.
- 14:45Rick Green: We can get Congress back into its proper bucket, if you will, with the lid on it.
- 14:51Rick Green: We'll just do our duties as citizens.
- 14:57Tim Barton: Hi, friends, this is Tim Barton of WallBuilders.
- 14:59Tim Barton: This is a time when most Americans don't know much about American history or even Heroes of the Faith and I know oftentimes for parents we're trying to find good content for our kids to read and if you remember back to the Bible, the book of Hebrews, it has the Faith Hall of Fame where they outlined the leaders of faith that had gone before them.
- 15:14Tim Barton: Well, this is something that, as Americans, we really want to go back and outline some of these heroes, not just of American history, but heroes of Christianity and our faith as well.
- 15:22Tim Barton: I want to let you know about some biographical sketches we have available on our website.
- 15:25Tim Barton: One is called the Courageous Leaders Collection and this collection includes people like Abigail Adams, Abraham Lincoln, Francis Scott Key, George Washington Carver, Susanna Wesley, even the Wright Brothers, and there's a second collection called Heroes of History.
- 15:37Tim Barton: In this collection you'll read about people like Benjamin Franklin or Christopher Columbus, Daniel Boone, George Washington, Harriet Tubman, friends the list goes on and on.
- 15:45Tim Barton: This is a great collection for your young person to have and read and it's a providential view of American and Christian history.
- 15:51Tim Barton: This is available at wallbuilders.
- 15:52Tim Barton: com that's www.
- 15:54Tim Barton: wallbuilders.
- 15:54Tim Barton: com.
- 16:02Rick Green: Constitutional Alive means that this document is still alive.
- 16:05Rick Green: It is still applicable today to our lives.
- 16:08Rick Green: I believe we can get to those big changes and they will restore our Constitutional Republic if we bring them in.
- 16:15Rick Green: But to get to those we have to dive into the details.
- 16:18Rick Green: And it makes me think about why the founders got so detailed, for them to sit in that hot room and sweat it out and actually go through line by line, like you said earlier, post office, post roads and all these specific details.
- 16:30Rick Green: Why did they do that?
- 16:31Rick Green: Why not just have one general statement that said government can do whatever is necessary to protect us.
- 16:35David Barton: They had a real distrust of power.
- 16:37David Barton: They had been through it themselves with the king but they've also been through it in the scriptures.
- 16:41David Barton: John Adams, for example, is one that in multiple letters talks about Jeremiah 17.9 as the basis for why they separated powers.
- 16:49David Barton: Because the scripture says 'the heart of man is desperately wicked.
- 16:52David Barton: Who can know it?
- 16:53David Barton: ' In other words, if you leave man to his own devices, it will turn bad.
- 16:56David Barton: So they distrusted government because they distrusted man.
- 16:59David Barton: They distrusted man, and so man is not naturally good.
- 17:02David Barton: You have to corral him and get him to do the right things.
- 17:05David Barton: It's kind of funny.
- 17:07David Barton: Who teaches two-year-olds to lie?
- 17:09David Barton: It just comes naturally, you don't have to.
- 17:11David Barton: Who teaches?
- 17:12David Barton: I mean, there's 43 toys in a room and the kid can have anyone, but if the sister picks up that one, that's the one who taught him.
- 17:19David Barton: Who taught him selfishness?
- 17:21David Barton: That's just part of human nature, and so they understood the nature of man.
- 17:25David Barton: That look, there are ways you can learn self-control, but there are other times you have to exert control, because they've seen all the stuff that happened in France.
- 17:33David Barton: They've seen Robespierre and all the stuff that went with that.
- 17:36David Barton: They've seen that revolution in Greece.
- 17:37David Barton: They've seen all these revolutions and they've been under British history themselves, watching what's happened with the different kings, whether it was William and Mary or whether it was Mary, Queen of Scots totally different approaches.
- 17:47David Barton: So they knew history, they knew the character of man and, as John Adams said, they knew the Bible.
- 17:53David Barton: Therefore, we separate powers and we're really specific.
- 17:56David Barton: We're not going to just tell you general categories, we're going to tell you what you can do.
- 17:59David Barton: And the other reason is you remember when we were talking earlier about battle plans and battle maps?
- 18:03David Barton: You can get up there.
- 18:04David Barton: Yeah, looking at the birds, you really get here.
- 18:05David Barton: So we're up here and we understand that we also are creating a federal republic which shares power with lower-level entities, and that's the state and communities.
- 18:16David Barton: And so, just as we have to separate power horizontally, we separate between the judiciary and the executive and we separated over here with the legislative.
- 18:26David Barton: And, by the way, not only do they separate powers, the Federalist Papers said that they gave each branch constitutional arms, a self-defense.
- 18:34David Barton: In other words, if that branch starts doing something you're supposed to do you can fight back.
- 18:37David Barton: You've got the tools and your tools.
- 18:38David Barton: Now I will just about guarantee you you asked the congressman today name me five tools you have to fight back against the judiciary and they can't tell me a thing.
- 18:47David Barton: But the Constitution gave each branch tools to fight back.
- 18:51David Barton: Name me five tools you have against an overreaching executive.
- 18:54David Barton: Name me five whatever it is, the other branches don't know that anymore, and so the founders are very specific about it.
- 19:00David Barton: What a waste, because it really is a brilliant battle plan that the founders put in place to keep these different and they wrote it all down.
- 19:05David Barton: And I'm sure if they were here today they'd say are you all illiterate?
- 19:09David Barton: Why aren't you using what we gave you?
- 19:10David Barton: Are you lazy?
- 19:11David Barton: I mean, this room is filled with their writings and their own line, by the way.
- 19:16Rick Green: I mean these things- Was it a secret meeting that they didn't expose all the secrets?
- 19:20Rick Green: They gave us all the secrets.
- 19:22David Barton: Here it is, All their discussions and the constitutional Convention.
- 19:25David Barton: They're right here, and those were private discussions at the time, so they could be very candid, but they made the public but then they came out and said here's what we've got for you in Franklin, and here's a lot the public could be-.
- 19:32David Barton: So it's real simple stuff.
- 19:34David Barton: But what happens is we also have a separation of powers, not between three branches, but between the levels of government, and that's federalism.
- 19:40David Barton: Hey, federal government, there's only certain things you can do.
- 19:43David Barton: And, by the way, state governments here's what you can do, and local governments, here's what you do.
- 19:47David Barton: And so that bicameralism of horizontal separation and branches and then the vertical separation powers that Thomas Jefferson talks about, are very significant.
- 19:57David Barton: So what they did, understanding all of the components that have some jurisdiction of this, they said okay, we're going to tell you specifically what Congress can do, what the president can do and what the judicial branch can do.
- 20:12David Barton: Now, does that mean that there's not other stuff to be done?
- 20:14David Barton: No, there definitely is.
- 20:15David Barton: But that's why we give you the 9th and 10th Amendment.
- 20:17David Barton: And the 10th Amendment says anything we didn't specifically give to Congress belongs to the states.
- 20:22David Barton: We gave 18 areas to Congress.
- 20:24David Barton: That means 4,ooo,432 areas belonging to the states.
- 20:27David Barton: That's part of the verbal separation power.
- 20:29David Barton: People in the Bay look at that and say, well, they didn't say we couldn't do it.
- 20:32David Barton: Yeah, they did.
- 20:33David Barton: The 10th Amendment set up.
- 20:34David Barton: We didn't tell the governments if they'd do it and they can't.
- 20:42Tim Barton: Hey, this is Tim Barton, with WallBuilders, and, as you've had the opportunity to listen to WallBuilders Live, you've probably heard the wealth of information about our nation, about our spiritual heritage, about the religious liberties, about all the things that makes America exceptional.
- 20:55Tim Barton: And you might be thinking as incredible as this information is, I wish there was a way that I could get one of the WallBuilders guys to come to my area and share with my group whether it be a church, whether it be a Christian school or public school or some political event or activity.
- 21:08Tim Barton: If you're interested in having a WallBuilders speaker come to your area, you can get on our website at www.
- 21:13Tim Barton: wallbuilders.
- 21:13Tim Barton: com and there's a tab for scheduling and if you'll click on that tab, you'll notice there's a list of information from speakers' bios to events that are already going on, and there's a section where you can request an event to bring this information about who we are, where we came from, our religious liberties and freedoms.
- 21:32Tim Barton: Go to the WallBuilders' website and bring a speaker to your area.
- 21:39David Barton: This is David Barton, with another moment from America's history, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently overturned the jury sentence of a man convicted of the brutal murder of a 71-year-old woman because the prosecuting attorney had mentioned a Bible verse in the courtroom.
- 21:53David Barton: Yet consider what happened in the 1778 case Respublica v John Roberts.
- 21:58David Barton: Thomas McKean, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, was the chief justice of that court and, addressing John Roberts after the jury had sentenced him to death for treason, McKean told him "You will probably have but a short time to live Before you launch into eternity.
- 22:12David Barton: It behooves you to repent of your evil deeds, to be in cessant in prayers to the great and merciful God, to forgive your manifold transgressions and sins, to teach you to rely upon the merit and passion of a dear redeemer.
- 22:23David Barton: This prominent founding father actually delivered a salvation message to the defendant in the courtroom.
- 22:30Speaker 3: For more information on God's hand in American history, contact Wall Builders at 1-800-8-REBUILD.
- 22:42David Barton: The 9th and the 10th amendments, same with the people.
- 22:44David Barton: You know, we told the government what they could do, but people, you got everything else that you could do.
- 22:48David Barton: So that's why they were very specific in what they did.
- 22:51David Barton: That's why they gave us constitutional tools of self-defense.
- 22:54David Barton: And the problem we have is, if you were looking for a loophole and you talked about the loophole, so the General Welfare Clause and the Commerce, you will find a way to bust the intent of what it is.
- 23:04David Barton: I don't care what the intent is, I want a loophole so that I can get around it.
- 23:07David Barton: Yeah, you'll change the meaning of words, do whatever it takes to get around it.
- 23:10David Barton: And John Dickinson, who was not only a guy who put the Declaration together, but he's a guy who also signed the Constitution, one of the founding fathers.
- 23:18David Barton: He talked about how dangerous that is when you start looking for loopholes and how it changes everything.
- 23:24David Barton: And I'll just read here from his work.
- 23:26David Barton: He says, "nothing is more certain than that the forms of liberty may be retained when the substance is gone.
- 23:34David Barton: In other words, you still got a Constitution, but it doesn't work anymore because you've had a heart transplant.
- 23:40David Barton: You took the heart out of it and placed it with something else.
- 23:42David Barton: He said nothing is more certain than that the forms of liberty may be retained when the substance is gone.
- 23:47David Barton: He said in government as well as in religion.
- 23:49David Barton: And then he makes a direct quote, "the letter kills, but the spirit gives life.
- 23:52David Barton: Now that's a direct quote out of 2 Corinthians 3-6, and he notes it's right out of the Bible.
- 23:58David Barton: He says that works in government just like it is in religion.
- 24:00David Barton: If you forget, for example, that in religion, Jesus, in dealing with the Sabbath law, said hey guys, don't forget, the Sabbath was made to serve you.
- 24:08David Barton: You weren't made to serve the Sabbath.
- 24:09David Barton: Well, you can get so into Sabbath laws that it becomes a bondage on your back.
- 24:14David Barton: Instead of you getting the rest you need to become something that's your slave driver.
- 24:18David Barton: He said in government it's the same way.
- 24:19David Barton: Because you've gotten caught up in the legalistic letter of the law instead of the spirit of the.
- 24:23David Barton: What do you do?
- 24:24David Barton: And so, same thing.
- 24:25David Barton: If you get caught up in the actual wording of the general welfare clause and if I tweak my nose just the right direction, if I tilt my shoulder a little, I can find an interpretation.
- 24:34David Barton: No, remember the spirit of the general welfare clause, which you get by studying all this, which you get by studying all that and which you laid out very clearly.
- 24:41David Barton: I mean you add all the founders quotes on it.
- 24:43David Barton: Don't try to squeeze a new meaning out of this, but go to the, because when you do, he says, "in government as well as in religion, the letter kills but the spirit gives life.
- 24:53David Barton: And if you go to that literal, word by word interpretation instead of what they were trying to give, you will kill the Constitution, you'll kill the country, you'll kill freedom, you'll kill prosperity, you'll kill all those things we enjoy.
- 25:04David Barton: And that's why the founders are so good about being so specific in so many areas, so that we get the principles, apply the principles and have the same result that we've had for 200 years.
- 25:12Rick Green: Alright, we're going to keep walking through those specifics.
- 25:14Rick Green: The great thing here is we're getting some tangibles.
- 25:16Rick Green: I mean these are real areas where you can restore that liberty.
- 25:20Rick Green: If you go back to that original meaning, it's kind of neat.
- 25:22Rick Green: It's not just this oh, study the Constitution, we're finding specific areas.
- 25:24Rick Green: We go, oh, we can fix that area right there now that we know what the intent was, we go to our Congressman and say, hey, let's get this thing right.
- 25:31Rick Green: So we're going to get into more of those specifics.
- 25:33Rick Green: Our hope is that you are getting excited and realizing that we can restore this Constitutional Republic.
- 25:39Rick Green: In the next chapter we'll finish out Article 1, section 8 and those enumerated powers and we're going to take some questions from our audience in Philadelphia when we come back on Constitutional Alive with David Barton and Rick Green.
- 25:48Rick Green: Well, that's it, folks.
- 26:04Rick Green: Thanks for joining us today.
- 26:05Rick Green: This three-part series has ended.
- 26:07Rick Green: Today it's Constitutional Alive.
- 26:09Rick Green: That was Section 4, covering the Congress.
- 26:12Rick Green: Actually, section 5 also covers the Congress.
- 26:14Rick Green: It took two full sections to do that and talk about those enumerated powers.
- 26:17Rick Green: Sorry, we couldn't share more with you today, we're out of time, but if you go to our website at WallbuildersLive.
- 26:22Rick Green: com, you can get the entire three-part series we have shared with you this week right there online and share it with your friends and family.
- 26:30Rick Green: Get them educated about the true intent of the Constitution and what the Founders intended for the proper role of our Congress to be, what the federal government's actual jurisdiction should be under the Constitution.
- 26:40Rick Green: You can find out more at our website at Wallbuilderslive.
- 26:43Rick Green: com.