Latest / Beyond the Ballot AZ / Changing the Constitution
Transcript
- 0:02We understand that women can hold office.
- 0:07We've just elected a female governor.
- 0:10But to honor that moment,
- 0:12we want our Constitution to explicitly be inclusive.
- 0:17How does our Constitution stay relevant in a rapidly changing world?
- 0:21Today,
- 0:21the nuances of language and amendments that affect Arizonans.
- 0:28You're listening to Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 0:31I'm Gina Roberts,
- 0:32Voter Education Director at the Arizona Clean Elections Commission.
- 0:35And I'm Tom Collins,
- 0:36Executive Director.
- 0:38So we sort of fell down this rabbit hole when we were pitching an episode on Rose Moffitt,
- 0:42who was the first woman to hold the position of Secretary of State and later on Governor of Arizona.
- 0:48Our research dug up a 1988 state amendment that removed language that said only men were eligible for state office.
- 0:56But that amendment actually came a few months
- 0:58after Moffat had already succeeded to the governorship.
- 1:01And I think it's important to say here that this was really more of a social and political change.
- 1:06I mean,
- 1:06strictly,
- 1:07legally speaking,
- 1:09there was language from a 1912 amendment that had already given women the right to hold public office in Arizona.
- 1:15So the drive to make this change was one driven by social and political motives.
- 1:20Exactly.
- 1:20Arizonans stood up and they said,
- 1:22this is not something that I want written in my constitution.
- 1:26But that leads us to an intriguing question.
- 1:28How does our legal framework deal with conflicting language?
- 1:35We are here with Professor Aaron Scharf,
- 1:38who is the Willard H.
- 1:39Pedrick Distinguished Research Scholar at the
- 1:42Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law at Arizona State University.
- 1:45Professor Scharf,
- 1:46thanks for joining Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 1:49Thanks for having me.
- 1:51So this episode is about a change to.
- 1:54I think what we might call archaic law in the Arizona Constitution.
- 1:59And one of the things that comes up in this story is the fact that you had some conflicting language in the Constitution about who was eligible to serve as governor and these other executive offices.
- 2:12So how does that kind of thing work out in law typically?
- 2:17So conflicts within bodies of law happen all the time.
- 2:23There are conflicts between constitutional law and legislative-made law,
- 2:30statutory law.
- 2:32And there are also conflicts within constitutional law and legislative-made statutory law.
- 2:39And generally speaking,
- 2:41the higher the level of authority wins.
- 2:44So if a statute conflicts with the Constitution,
- 2:48the Constitution wins.
- 2:50And then within...
- 2:52law that is operating at the same level.
- 2:56So a statute that conflicts with another enacted statute by the legislature,
- 3:01or a constitutional amendment that conflicts with other language of the Constitution enacted by the people,
- 3:08at least within the context of the state of Arizona,
- 3:11the latter in time enacted provision prevails.
- 3:15There's also a desire to try to read these things harmoniously.
- 3:19But sometimes they can't be.
- 3:20And I think we're talking today about a time when they just can't be read harmoniously.
- 3:23Right,
- 3:24right.
- 3:24I mean,
- 3:24apparently there was some effort to do that.
- 3:26And that sort of gets into the next question.
- 3:28In other words,
- 3:29you had an effort by the
- 3:32Arizona Attorney General's office to try to harmonize language in the state constitution about eligibility.
- 3:38But what the folks behind this amendment ultimately concluded was that it was important that the Arizona Constitution speak clearly about.
- 3:48eligibility.
- 3:49And so maybe you could talk a little bit about how that kind of policy or political need sometimes drives change,
- 3:58even where the law or tradition or both have in fact changed,
- 4:02but the language hasn't caught up.
- 4:04What does that mean to a state,
- 4:06to a government,
- 4:06to the body of law,
- 4:08and frankly,
- 4:08to the voters to try to bring the law together and up to date?
- 4:12I think this is just such an interesting story.
- 4:16It is very clear that the people of Arizona wanted women to participate in the body politic fully.
- 4:27And that's like one of the fascinating stories about Arizona statehood,
- 4:30right?
- 4:30That we didn't include this in our state constitution originally because there was concerns about us actually becoming a state.
- 4:37And so the very first time the people of Arizona have the opportunity to use this amazing power to change the constitution.
- 4:45They do so and they say women can vote and women can hold office.
- 4:49And women historically do vote and hold office in Arizona,
- 4:52right?
- 4:53I work at the Sandra Day O'Connor
- 4:55College of Law.
- 4:56And before Justice O'Connor was the first woman on the Supreme Court,
- 5:00she was a member of the Arizona state legislature and elected to state office.
- 5:04as a woman,
- 5:06thanks to this amazing 1914 constitutional amendment that gives suffrage and the right to hold office.
- 5:13But that amendment didn't change other language in the constitution that suggested in order to hold office,
- 5:20you were a male.
- 5:21And that is actually consistent with a lot of law in this country that's written at least using the male pronoun.
- 5:32So you can read lots of,
- 5:34I also write about tax law.
- 5:35A lot of the federal income tax code talks about his income.
- 5:41And generally the way we harmonize this is we just say,
- 5:43oh,
- 5:43well,
- 5:44what we really mean by his is inclusive of either him or her today,
- 5:50potentially all gender expression.
- 5:52We should read the male language as somehow gender neutral.
- 5:58That is sort of longstanding interpretation of...
- 6:02many kinds of law is for us to do that.
- 6:05So just to take that point,
- 6:07Professor Scharf,
- 6:08there's a provision in the Arizona Code that purports to do that operation,
- 6:12right?
- 6:12To say that his and her,
- 6:14for example,
- 6:15are equivalent no matter what the underlying statute might say.
- 6:19And I think that's what's so extraordinary about the second moment of constitutional amendment,
- 6:26which is it's the people saying,
- 6:29we understand that
- 6:31women can hold office.
- 6:33We've just elected a female governor.
- 6:37But to honor that moment,
- 6:38we want our constitution to explicitly be inclusive.
- 6:44And it is a moment of inclusivity in the context of a constitution that is thought about and struggled with,
- 6:52how inclusive it wants to be.
- 6:55And I think it's a really exciting constitutional moment.
- 6:58Continuing in that vein.
- 7:00Professor Scharf,
- 7:01I wonder if you could talk a little bit about the Arizona Constitution and the role of direct democracy in it.
- 7:07You know,
- 7:07not every state,
- 7:08although a lot of states,
- 7:10allow voters to directly amend the Constitution like we do.
- 7:14Maybe you could talk a little bit about that in context for us.
- 7:17It's one of the reasons I love studying state constitutional law and Arizona constitutional law specifically.
- 7:24The federal constitution is all but impossible to amend.
- 7:27We've amended it.
- 7:28only a handful of times because the process is really difficult.
- 7:33The people of Arizona,
- 7:35when they enacted the Arizona Constitution,
- 7:37when we became a state,
- 7:39wanted our Constitution to be much more a living document,
- 7:43responsive to the people,
- 7:46and were deeply committed to the idea of democracy and the sovereignty of some concept of the body politic of the people.
- 7:56and
- 7:57There are a number of ways the Arizona Constitution is committed to direct democracy.
- 8:01We have more statewide directly elected officials than any state in the country.
- 8:06We've just added a new one.
- 8:09But we also have this power and we do regularly exercise it to amend our Constitution to say,
- 8:14look,
- 8:15our basic rules for how we govern ourselves aren't working.
- 8:19We're going to change them.
- 8:21And we do it almost every election cycle.
- 8:27You,
- 8:27as an Arizona voter,
- 8:28have the power to change the Constitution.
- 8:31There are a few ways that amendments can be made.
- 8:33The first is a citizen-initiated process.
- 8:36The second is a legislative process,
- 8:38which is essentially what we saw here with Rose Moffitt.
- 8:41Right,
- 8:41and for a citizen-initiated process,
- 8:43the Arizona Constitution requires valid signatures from 15%
- 8:48of qualified electors to place an initiative proposing a constitutional amendment on the ballot.
- 8:53So for 2026,
- 8:55that would be
- 8:55383,923 signatures.
- 9:00And the person or organization putting forward the initiative must file these signatures with the Arizona Secretary of State's office at least four months prior to the next general election.
- 9:09If you get enough signatures,
- 9:10then the amendment will be placed on the next general election ballot.
- 9:14So we'll see here for 2026,
- 9:16if there are going to be constitutional amendments initiated by voters,
- 9:20they're going to have to start circulating their petitions.
- 9:23And they'll have to file them by July 2nd,
- 9:242026.
- 9:26We have the steps for preparing an initiative linked in the show notes.
- 9:30Thanks for listening to Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 9:32I'm Tom Collins.
- 9:33And I'm Gina Roberts.
- 9:34Tap the plus icon on your podcast app to follow the show so you know as soon as we release new episodes.