Latest / The So What? / Investment: Pulling It All Together
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to this So What podcast, which I'm very happy to announce just won
- 0:14gold in the politics and opinion category of the inaugural South African podcast awards
- 0:21which happened in October of 2024.
- 0:26In these conversations, political economic analyst JP Landman discusses the issues uppermost
- 0:31in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:34You can find a written version of this content on JP's website jplandman.co.za.
- 0:41I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:50This discussion accompanies the newsletter dated 21 November 2024 with the title, Investment
- 0:57Pulling It All Together.
- 1:00It's information laden, so I would recommend that you look at the written version as well
- 1:05to digest the numbers.
- 1:08The website again, it's jplantman.co.za.
- 1:11JP, so investment in South Africa, the overall picture?
- 1:18The overall picture is that in 2023 we invested just over a trillion rand, that is the public
- 1:26sector and the private sector combined, and one must see that one trillion rand investment
- 1:31in the context of an economy which is about seven trillion rand big.
- 1:36So one looks at an investment to GDP ratio of 15%, that is the standard measurement worldwide.
- 1:42And how does that compare internationally?
- 1:45It probably compares with a range of countries, but if we compare it to what we would like
- 1:50to do in South Africa, then we certainly need more.
- 1:54The now defunct National Development Plan used to talk about the 25% ratio, 10% by the
- 2:00public sector and 15% by the private sector.
- 2:04Now at 15% we are not close to that number.
- 2:07And that number is relevant Ruda, because several ministers in the government of national
- 2:12unity, DA ministers as well as ANC ministers, have spoken about converting or transforming
- 2:19South Africa into one big construction site.
- 2:22So what we want to do in this note is to see how that is going.
- 2:26And 15% is not enough to get us to one big construction site.
- 2:30That number of 15 will have to increase.
- 2:34You say two sectors, public and private.
- 2:38What's the ratio between those two?
- 2:40Additionally, the public sector contributed about a third of investment in the country
- 2:45and the private sector two thirds.
- 2:47In the last couple of years that ratio has changed.
- 2:50The public sector ratio went down.
- 2:53In 2023 it came to about 28% and private sector investment came to 72%.
- 3:00So there's been a tilt away from two thirds, one third to about 72, 28.
- 3:07And you think, you believe that the private sector investment is really important.
- 3:14What do you base that on?
- 3:15I base it on a new report that was published by Professor Philippe Berger, who is the Dean
- 3:21of Economics at Freestead University and a very, very competent macroeconomist.
- 3:27And he did a lot of research recently for UNWINDER, which was published not long ago.
- 3:35And he found that for every 1% increase in the ratio of private sector investment to
- 3:41GDP for every 1%, economic growth increases by 0.67% per annum.
- 3:49Now that's an enormous dividend to spend 1% more and you get 0.67% more in economic growth.
- 3:57That's really an enormous dividend.
- 4:00In contrast, he found that public sector spending, particularly by SOEs, is almost statistically
- 4:07insignificant.
- 4:09In other words, you can increase public sector to investment to GDP ratio, but you won't
- 4:16get a statistically significant dividend in terms of growth.
- 4:20Now this sounds very bleak and so on, but it ties up with common sense.
- 4:28If you think ESCOM building Madhupi or building Kusili, how long that took, what the overspending
- 4:37was, how much money in the end it cost, and what is the return that you get.
- 4:42You compare that with a private company building a solar farm, for example, what it cost, the
- 4:47speed of finishing the project and what you get back.
- 4:50Then it makes perfect sense.
- 4:51We know that the private sector in general is more disciplined and more efficient in execution
- 4:59than the public sector.
- 5:00Not always, but in general.
- 5:02So in that sense, Philippe Berger's numbers are not a surprise.
- 5:07With that said, let's start with public sector investment.
- 5:12We are all aware of budget austerity in these times.
- 5:16What does that mean for investment from the public sector?
- 5:19Well, the interesting thing here is the truism is that if you have budget austerity or your
- 5:24budgets are cut, the first item to be cut is capital expenditure.
- 5:28The interesting thing is that is not happening at the moment.
- 5:31The 2024 budget is giving us a three-year projection of capital expenditure, public sector
- 5:38infrastructure spending, and over the three years it comes to 943 billion rand.
- 5:44That is about 29% higher than the three-year cycle that we've just got behind us.
- 5:52So if you compare three years with three years, what you see is the 29% increase.
- 5:57That's a huge increase.
- 5:58It beats inflation by a comfortable number, and it tells you what the political priorities
- 6:03are.
- 6:04So that old truism that when there's austerity, you cut capital expenditure, is certainly
- 6:09not holding.
- 6:11And I think that's a very encouraging sign.
- 6:14And if you say public sector, what does that mean really?
- 6:17Who gets to spend this money?
- 6:19Yeah, indeed.
- 6:21It's a massive sector.
- 6:22First of all, it's around about 36 national departments.
- 6:26Between them they have about 116 agencies.
- 6:29Think for example, Sunroll that builds roads.
- 6:33That is one agency.
- 6:34Think the Independent Electoral Commission, when they need to install new computer equipment
- 6:40or whatever.
- 6:41That's an agency of government, an agency of a national department, and they will spend
- 6:46money.
- 6:47Then the second category is you've got the nine provinces.
- 6:49The third category is you've got about 257, 258 local authorities.
- 6:56They spend money.
- 6:58And then lastly, you've got PPPs, where a government agency is doing a particular project,
- 7:04but they're doing it in partnership with a private company.
- 7:07So it's really everything that you can think of in the bigger public sector of South Africa.
- 7:13Where do SOEs fit in?
- 7:15SOEs are also part of that.
- 7:17In fact, SOEs are the biggest single player.
- 7:21They spend about 40% of the 943 billion.
- 7:26Then they followed by municipalities with about 23%.
- 7:29Then provinces in the third place with 20%.
- 7:33Then only the government departments and their agencies at 16% and then PPPs with about 2%.
- 7:40So the biggest player is the SOEs.
- 7:44You say that, of course, these numbers tell us nothing about quality of spending with
- 7:49corruption, poor planning, et cetera.
- 7:51And we'll get to that in a moment.
- 7:53But I first want to focus on the public-private partnerships.
- 7:57Only 2% of this investment.
- 7:59So do they really matter?
- 8:01Yes, they do matter because they give you a much better quality outcome.
- 8:05As we put it in the note, they punch above their weight when it comes to quality.
- 8:10And again, we know that intuitively you can just compare driving on a toll road to driving
- 8:17on a provincial road and you see the difference.
- 8:21Toll roads are normally PPPs and they're much better maintained, much better condition than
- 8:26what provincial roads are.
- 8:28So there is definitely a qualitative difference.
- 8:32PPPs have not taken off in South Africa over the last decade or two, except for national
- 8:38roads.
- 8:39In national roads, we've been quite successful in building a large number of PPP projects,
- 8:44but not wider than that.
- 8:46It looks if that is changing now.
- 8:49Why?
- 8:50Because there are a couple of interesting PPPs going on.
- 8:52There's one going on to revamp and rebuild one military hospital in Twane.
- 9:00It's a big project.
- 9:01There are also proposals out to the moment from the Western Cape government to redo the
- 9:08Tigerburg Hospital down in the Western Cape, also on a PPP basis.
- 9:14And then the third example are six border posts between South Africa and its neighbors
- 9:19here in the subcontinent, which are being revamped and rebuilt with private sector money.
- 9:24So those are examples of PPPs.
- 9:26So it looks as if there's a bigger movement in that direction.
- 9:31A very interesting little PPP, it's a small one, it's only about 120 million rand, was
- 9:37conducted between the Mpumalanga Tourism and Parks Agency and the British Aspenal Foundation,
- 9:44which is a charity foundation, to redevelop the Los Cobdam Nature Reserve.
- 9:50Now, as I say, it's a small amount, it's only about 120 million, but it will run over
- 9:5525 years and the infrastructure will be upgraded like roads, fences, staff accommodation and
- 10:02field ranger facilities.
- 10:04A particular emphasis of this PPP is that they would like to include public and private
- 10:09land inside an enlarged Los Cobdam Nature Reserve.
- 10:14Their ambition is to make it bigger than the Palansberg Reserve.
- 10:17So it's a unique form of a PPP.
- 10:21So one thing that will lift the quality of investment spending is working with the private
- 10:29sector in the shape of PPPs.
- 10:32What else has government done?
- 10:33What other kind of guardrails have they put in place?
- 10:36Another one which was put in place quite a while ago in 2016 already is the BFI, the
- 10:42Budget Facility for Infrastructure.
- 10:45And what it basically is, is public sector institutions that we spoke about earlier can
- 10:51apply, they can tender to have projects that they want to do, to have those projects financed
- 10:58through the budget.
- 10:59But then they've got to meet certain criteria for preparation, for technical specifications
- 11:05and also for execution.
- 11:06Where does this live?
- 11:08In Treasury?
- 11:09It lives in Treasury, absolutely.
- 11:11Now in the eight years since 2016, we've now had this year the seventh bit window.
- 11:18One was missed in 2020 with COVID, I think.
- 11:22And what happened in October this year, last month, the Minister of Finance announced that
- 11:27instead of having one bit window a year, once only, we will now have bit windows on a continuous
- 11:34basis.
- 11:35So that should ensure a bigger supply of projects that can be evaluated and if approved, will
- 11:42give you a bigger pipeline.
- 11:45So the Budget Facility for Infrastructure, the BFI, do two things.
- 11:50First of all, they've got, as I've said, stringent technical requirements for the project.
- 11:55You cannot just jump in and say, I want money for a school or I want money for a hospital.
- 12:00You've got to show that you're capable of planning the project properly, budgeting it
- 12:05and so on.
- 12:06But the second thing it does is to mobilize private sector money to finance that project.
- 12:12Now if you look at the numbers for 2024, what you see is that 66.9 billion Rands worth of
- 12:19projects have been approved and 52% of that money comes from the private sector.
- 12:2738% comes from the budget, from the state, from the taxpayer and another 10% from third
- 12:33parties.
- 12:34So there's a distinct tilt to involving private sector funds and thereby enlarging the pool
- 12:41of money that's available.
- 12:43So this 66.9 billion Rand will be spent on 14 projects and if I just give you an idea
- 12:50of what they are, it's social housing projects, about 14,000 housing units, five water and
- 12:57sanitation projects all over the country, six revamped border posts that I've already
- 13:03referred to and student housing projects on four university campuses involving some 10,000
- 13:10units.
- 13:11So you're talking fairly substantial projects.
- 13:14So are these also PPPs?
- 13:17Do they overlap?
- 13:18Yes, there is an overlap.
- 13:21It can very well be an overlap.
- 13:23You may find that what starts off as a BFI project could end up being a PPP, but they're
- 13:29not necessarily the same.
- 13:31The governance arrangements normally differ.
- 13:34So you may find that a particular public sector still runs the project, although they have
- 13:39to do it with their private partners.
- 13:42But yes, there can be an overlap.
- 13:44Where do the infrastructure fund and infrastructure South Africa fit in?
- 13:50The infrastructure fund is a new innovation that came in 2018 when President Ramaphosa
- 13:54became president.
- 13:55It was his baby.
- 13:57He was an officer about three months when he said that he wanted to establish an infrastructure
- 14:01fund.
- 14:02The intention was to blend public and private money, take some money from the taxpayers,
- 14:08take some money from the private market.
- 14:10You blend it.
- 14:11That brings the cost of finance down, but at the same time it enlarges the pool of finance.
- 14:16He was particularly keen on it in 2018.
- 14:20It took two years to operationalize it.
- 14:22It just took time in the public sector and it became operational in 2020.
- 14:28Currently there are 31 projects under preparation by the infrastructure fund and infrastructure
- 14:36SA, and it includes schools in the Northern and Eastern Cape, as well as hospitals in
- 14:41Malanga and the Free State.
- 14:43Now let me just say that's the infrastructure fund.
- 14:46Where does infrastructure SA fit in?
- 14:49After a year or two it became clear that the biggest stumbling block in government infrastructure
- 14:54spending is the quality of preparation and the quality of oversight of the project.
- 15:01The skills simply does not, certainly did not exist in the public sector.
- 15:06So infrastructure SA was created as an agency to help that.
- 15:12They've got a team of professional people.
- 15:14In the budget this year 600 million rand was allocated for technical skills inside infrastructure
- 15:20SA and they can then help to plan projects, to inspect them properly, to get them running
- 15:27and to look after the implementation of those projects.
- 15:31So the fund is about money.
- 15:32Infrastructure South Africa is about skills and the two work together.
- 15:37Will it please also help water and sanitation?
- 15:39Yes, I think indeed it will, included in the numbers that we talked about, the 943 billion
- 15:46and included in the BFI are public projects on water.
- 15:51But let's just dig a little bit deeper into it because it is such a big deal.
- 15:57Overall there are 11 projects countrywide across seven provinces which total about almost
- 16:06140 billion rand for water.
- 16:09And I'll give you just the big ones.
- 16:12The biggest single project is 42 billion rand for the Lesotho Highlands phase two to deliver
- 16:18water to Gauteng, Gauteng and North West.
- 16:22The completion date for that is 2028.
- 16:24This project has been considerably delayed.
- 16:26There were allegations of corruption and so on, but it looks as if it's now firmly on
- 16:31track.
- 16:32A second set of projects coming to about 46 billion rand is free projects in KwaZulu-Natal
- 16:39for bulk water supply in that province.
- 16:42It will help the South Coast in particular.
- 16:45Water is a problem in the South Coast and these free projects should help with that.
- 16:49The completion date there is between 2027 to 2032.
- 16:55And a third one, which is also an interesting project because this moves towards PPP, is
- 17:00the Wollifant River project Mpumalanga, which is a joint effort between the mining company
- 17:06Glencor, the platinum mining company Amplats and government.
- 17:11And it will involve 400 kilometers of pipelines and provide 250 million liters of water per
- 17:18day.
- 17:19It's equal to about one third of the total consumption of Cape Town.
- 17:24Now you can see that it's a joint effort between two mining companies and government.
- 17:29And they're busy negotiating at the moment with 10 local and international banks to finance
- 17:34that.
- 17:35They're putting that movement of private capital into a public project.
- 17:40Their completion date is expected to be 2030.
- 17:43So there's a strong movement around water to improve bulk water supply.
- 17:50I think the country can take comfort from that.
- 17:54But it still has to come from the big pipe to the little pipe in my bathroom.
- 17:59What happens with the final mile or the last mile?
- 18:02How do they put it?
- 18:03You're quite right.
- 18:04The water has slipped between the reservoir and the tap.
- 18:09The bulk water supply we've spoken about, the problem is municipalities and distribution
- 18:14systems.
- 18:15And we know that that is in quite a bad shape.
- 18:19So what has happened is that the government has put up a water office in the development
- 18:25bank.
- 18:26It is modeled on the IPP office, the Independent Power Producers Office, that did quite good
- 18:31work around renewable energy, basically copying that copy and paste.
- 18:37And the idea with the water office is that they must help municipalities, which as we've
- 18:43seen earlier is quite a big spender.
- 18:45They've got to help municipalities to fix their water affairs.
- 18:50Now the head of the water office is Mr. Johan Libbe.
- 18:54And he had a very interesting interview.
- 18:57He said the water office has begun to mobilize private sector financing for water projects
- 19:02in Etiquini, Mangahung, Buffalo City, Nelson Mandela Bay and Twane for the replacement
- 19:09of leaking municipal water systems, which are resulting in high levels of non-revenue
- 19:15water.
- 19:16We're all aware of the problem of non-revenue water and for that you've got to fix leaks.
- 19:21To fix the leaks you need money.
- 19:23So that's where the water office comes in.
- 19:26But Johan Libbe warns, he says it takes time.
- 19:28It is not something that happens overnight.
- 19:31On the larger projects it takes 12 to 18 months to properly structure the projects.
- 19:37You don't want to rush through a project and then put it out to the market and then the
- 19:40private sector shoots a full of holes.
- 19:43So it takes time, but the institutional infrastructure is there.
- 19:47The people are there.
- 19:49It should lead to an improvement over time, particularly in the big metros.
- 19:54What difference will it make to involve the private sector?
- 19:56Well, the private sector by definition brings discipline.
- 19:59There's money that is advanced.
- 20:02That money must first of all...
- 20:04And it's their money, it's not tax money.
- 20:06It's not amorphous tax money.
- 20:10That money must earn a return and it must be repaid.
- 20:14So you immediately have financial discipline, which we clearly don't have in a lot of our
- 20:19municipalities.
- 20:22And this notion of financial discipline was given a huge boost last week.
- 20:27Got very little notice in the media, but what happened was that Treasury has agreed to withhold
- 20:34payments to municipalities of their equitable share.
- 20:38Equitable share is simply the money which is allocated from the national budget to help
- 20:42municipalities.
- 20:44They will hold back those equitable share payments from municipalities who have debt
- 20:49with water boards.
- 20:50Now that's a very, very encouraging development.
- 20:54Imagine if we can do the same thing with electricity.
- 20:56Now needless to say, the municipalities affected will be up in arms and it will ruffle their
- 21:04feathers, but it is clearly the right thing to do.
- 21:08And as I've said, if one can repeat that arrangement with electricity, it will lead to a big improvement.
- 21:15The Department of Water and Sanitation must get the credit here.
- 21:18They lobbied for this change.
- 21:20They've been lobbying for the last year and Treasury has now agreed.
- 21:23So it's a step forward.
- 21:27So we've now talked about projects initiated by the public sector, even if it's not fully
- 21:33paid for by them.
- 21:36What about the private sector?
- 21:37What about private sector investment?
- 21:39I've said it so many times, I sound like a broken record or a stuck CD or whatever
- 21:45the modern equivalent will be.
- 21:49But mining 100 years ago was the investment frontier.
- 21:54That is what made South Africa modern.
- 21:56Now it is energy.
- 21:59And if one looks at the numbers, they are really quite astonishing.
- 22:03If we can just take an overview of energy generation, up to date, we've got 8,000 megawatts
- 22:10of new capacity, most of it renewable capacity, which have been contracted to sell to the
- 22:17grid and that brought an investment of 270 billion.
- 22:22It's a huge amount of money.
- 22:23That's the past.
- 22:24That's behind us.
- 22:25What is going on right now as we talk is a bit window.
- 22:29Bit windows is something which is driven by the government.
- 22:32It carries a government guarantee and you work through official processes.
- 22:38So it's basically a 10 that the government puts out.
- 22:42Bit window 7 for 5,000 megawatts, a bit window for 650 megawatts of batteries and then a
- 22:49bit window for 2000 megawatts of gas, presumably in Richards Bay.
- 22:55The estimated investment here is 180 billion grand plus, according to the budget review.
- 23:03But what has happened since 2022, since President Ramaphosa deregulated the electricity market
- 23:11is that there's been a huge swing from public procurement to private procurement.
- 23:16Private procurement simply meaning private companies doing their own thing, putting up
- 23:20a solar farm, putting up a wind farm, entering into contracts to buy power from people who
- 23:26have a solar farm or buy power from people who have too much power.
- 23:31That deregulation of the industry really made a huge difference.
- 23:36What we currently have on a table or should I say in the pipeline is 22,500 megawatts
- 23:43of projects with an estimated investment value of 390 billion grand.
- 23:49We're talking huge amounts of money here and this will carry on.
- 23:54I mean, essentially we're building a new electricity system in South Africa.
- 23:58You know, we mustn't forget that ISCOM has already determined way back that of the 14
- 24:05coal-fired power stations, eight will close down by 2034, 2036.
- 24:11And is that still true in spite of political opposition?
- 24:14Yes, yes.
- 24:15Some units in some power stations were given permission by the government to close down
- 24:21later.
- 24:22So they will close down later, but it's still within the 2034 timeframe.
- 24:27So just think about it, you've got 14 power stations serving the country now without load
- 24:32shedding.
- 24:33You close eight of them down.
- 24:34You've got to replace that capacity.
- 24:36It's going to be a huge investment.
- 24:40And that is just all on the generation side.
- 24:43If you move to transmission, a very similarly bullish picture emerges.
- 24:49What do we know?
- 24:50We know that transmission is a problem for generation.
- 24:53We know that it's a choke point.
- 24:55So what is needed to fix generation?
- 24:57Well, depending on what timeframe you talk about, it's between 200 billion and 390 billion
- 25:04depending whether you talk five years or 10 years.
- 25:08So the National Transmission Company, which has now been taken out of ESCOM and is a self-standing
- 25:13company has got 112 billion around earmarked over the next five years specifically to build
- 25:21new infrastructure, transmission infrastructure.
- 25:24Now to unlock more funds, same story again.
- 25:26So that's from the budget?
- 25:28Well, it's basically from the ESCOM balance sheet.
- 25:32Yeah, it's from the ESCOM board, in this case the transmission company balance sheet, with
- 25:37probably some help from the budget.
- 25:40To unlock further funds, government has authorized the independent power producers office to
- 25:44wonder drove the renewal program to run a pilot program to procure the first private
- 25:52independent transmission project.
- 25:55So it's completely new terrain for us in South Africa.
- 25:58You've got a transmission line, it serves a number of producers and consumers, but it's
- 26:03built by not by the state monopoly, it's built by a private entity.
- 26:09Sounds a bit like a toll road.
- 26:10Yeah, I think that's a good comparison.
- 26:13It's a good comparison.
- 26:14Now a new credit guarantee vehicle, which was developed with the help of the World Bank,
- 26:20will support this pilot project.
- 26:22What it basically means is that the private sector that comes in to provide the money
- 26:26will enjoy some guarantee on their funds that they advance, but the state will not be on
- 26:33for a 100% guarantee, which is still the case with the older generation projects, and one
- 26:40wants to move away from that.
- 26:41You want to move away from state guarantees where people must assess the risk and take
- 26:45it and collect the profits, but also live with the losses.
- 26:50Nevertheless, this transmission pilot project provides for a credit guarantee, which balances
- 26:57between the private companies and the government, and that should help to generate many more
- 27:02funds, much more funds for building transmission projects.
- 27:08If we just look at where we are, I've already said that the National Transmission Company
- 27:15is looking at 112 billion rands worth of projects over the next 10 years.
- 27:21Currently they have 31 projects in construction now, which will release about 16,000 megawatts
- 27:28of connection capacity, and then by 2034, six years later, they want to do another 30
- 27:35projects to connect 40,000.
- 27:38So you're looking at 56,000 megawatts of transmission capacity over the next 10 years.
- 27:45That's a significant investment.
- 27:46It is a significant improvement that will come to the transmission grid.
- 27:51I don't know if this works, but how does that compare with the whole system at the moment?
- 27:57No, it's substantial.
- 27:59We haven't invested a lot of money in transmission in the last 10 years and even longer.
- 28:05In fact, I think, if I remember correctly, last year, less than 100 kilometers of transmission
- 28:11lines were built.
- 28:13The numbers that we're talking about here, you're talking about 1200 to 1400 kilometers
- 28:18of transmission lines per annum.
- 28:21So it's a huge step up in terms of building new capacity.
- 28:26You've been saying green is the new gold.
- 28:29So you still see that happening?
- 28:31Oh, absolutely.
- 28:32You know, if we try and pull all these numbers together, because they're all over the show,
- 28:37basically we need 1.5 trillion rand for the next.
- 28:42The official timeframe is five years, but let's make it five to seven years, 1.5 trillion
- 28:48to execute all these projects and help with the energy transition.
- 28:54And then in the period after that, the next decade, we will need 3 trillion rand.
- 28:59And these are enormous amounts of money, if you think of the size of our economy.
- 29:04Where will that money come from?
- 29:05Well, we've discussed that before.
- 29:07It'll be a combination of public money, private money, philanthropic money, aid assistance
- 29:13from the developed world, and so on.
- 29:16But people that I speak to generally do not see money as the big problem.
- 29:21The much bigger problem is having bankable projects that can be executed that are credible
- 29:28on which you can put money and take a wager.
- 29:31That is where the bigger problem lies.
- 29:33The problem doesn't lie with money.
- 29:36And that's human capital.
- 29:39That's human capital, it's skills.
- 29:41That's why things like the budget facility are important, things like infrastructure
- 29:45South Africa.
- 29:46We've got to build up the skills base that can again underpin a huge infrastructure drive.
- 29:52If we get to sow what in the first place, there has to be more investment, it sounds
- 29:58like.
- 29:59If we want to turn the country into a construction site, yes.
- 30:04Turning the country into a construction site is the political ambition.
- 30:08The current 15% of GDP being spent on investment is not enough.
- 30:12We've got to get that number up.
- 30:16How do you get the number up?
- 30:17You can only get it really up by involving more capital from the private sector.
- 30:22And here I think the change in government attitude that we've seen since about 2018-2019
- 30:28is a very important change.
- 30:30Government used to work with the concept of pre-scrub assets, not government so much,
- 30:34but ANC.
- 30:35There's been a distinct move away from that.
- 30:38The emphasis now is on involving private money, linking it up with public money, and thereby
- 30:44enlarging the pool of funds.
- 30:46That is happening and I would expect that trend to continue over the next couple of
- 30:50years.
- 30:52The important thing is, as I've said, a pipeline of projects.
- 30:55That's what it's all about.
- 30:57And that's why the work of the budget facility and the work of infrastructure, SA, are important.
- 31:02They're building up more and more projects.
- 31:04I'm quite sure not enough.
- 31:06One year complaints from the financial sector that there are not enough of these projects,
- 31:11but there's certainly more than what there was.
- 31:13And I think that's the trend to watch.
- 31:16And the other trend that you highlight in your So What?
- 31:21Is the diminishing role of SOEs in the context of this shifting political atmosphere.
- 31:27Yes, absolutely.
- 31:28Look, the SOEs, it's a simple reality of state capture that they are now in a bad shape.
- 31:35ESCOM basically can't undertake any investment projects.
- 31:40Neither can Transnet.
- 31:41Transnet will probably have to get some support from the FISCUS, like ESCOM is getting.
- 31:47So they're not going to have huge infrastructure projects.
- 31:50And that's why that number has come down from two-thirds, one-third to 72%, 28%.
- 31:56I think that's the reality.
- 31:58And then the question is, so who will take their place?
- 32:01And the answer is the place will be taken by joint public and private partnerships and
- 32:07financing.
- 32:08And how would you summarize that, the So What about the practicalities of making it happen?
- 32:14Well, as I've said, it's all about a credible pipeline, which we see is being built and
- 32:20will probably the pipeline will get bigger and bigger as we go on.
- 32:24And what that will do, quite apart from money, is it should help with discipline and it should
- 32:29help with better management, as we've seen with toll roads.
- 32:33When money flows and there's somebody responsible for collecting it, but also responsible for
- 32:39performance, there's accountability.
- 32:43And that I think will help to change the public infrastructure in South Africa.
- 32:48And of course, the more you change the public, the more confidence there is in the private
- 32:51sector.
- 32:52The more confidence there is in the private sector, the more they're willing to put in
- 32:56another machine or put up another factory or undertake some kind of an expansion somewhere.
- 33:02These things feed on each other.
- 33:06And of course, we wouldn't have been here.
- 33:09That's one of those big South African ironies.
- 33:11We wouldn't have been here if we didn't have the pain of load shedding and the pain of
- 33:14water shedding.
- 33:16Load shedding and water shedding is helping to push our body politic towards involving
- 33:21more private sector and involving more money and more expertise from the private sector.
- 33:29Thank you very much.
- 33:30Fascinating.
- 33:31Thank you.
- 33:32Thank you for listening to the So What podcast.
- 33:37If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating and please
- 33:42consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 33:46Also tell your friends.
- 33:48And remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at jplandmann.co.za