Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How the Debt Ceiling Became a Foreign Policy Issue
Transcript
- Lucas: You know, when we talk about the national debt, it's usually about arithmetic — spending, taxes, interest costs. But there's a whole other dimension that doesn't get enough attention: the fact that our biggest creditors are also our geopolitical rivals. Luna: You mean countries like China and Japan? Lucas: Exactly. Japan and China are still two of the largest foreign holders of U.S. Treasuries, even though both have been trimming their positions for years. And as of the latest Treasury data, foreign holdings have dipped again — that's a trend that's been running for the better part of a decade. Luna: So what's driving that? Is it purely about returns, or is there something more strategic going on? Lucas: Returns matter, sure. But when you look at the last few years, geopolitics has started to bleed into the bond market in ways we haven't seen before. The sanctions on Russia after the invasion of Ukraine made a lot of central banks rethink the safety of dollar assets. If Washington can freeze Russia's reserves, the thinking goes, what stops it from doing the same to someone else? Luna: That's a sobering thought. And it's not just China and Japan — even allies are diversifying. Lucas: Right. We saw that in the gold-buying boom that started in 2022. Central banks around the world were buying gold at the fastest pace in decades, and the implicit message was that the dollar's monopoly as a reserve asset is no longer a given. Luna: So how does that affect the national debt specifically? I mean, we still have to borrow trillions every year. Lucas: It affects the price we pay for that borrowing. If the pool of willing foreign buyers shrinks, the Treasury has to offer higher yields to attract whoever's left. And we're seeing that in the long end of the curve right now. The 30-year Treasury is yielding around 5.2 percent — that's up from just over 5 percent a couple months ago. Luna: And a higher 30-year yield means the government pays more interest on every new bond it issues, and it also raises the cost of refinancing existing debt when it matures. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a structural problem, because the national debt is now over 39 trillion dollars. Even a small increase in the average interest rate translates into tens of billions of extra interest expense every year. That's money that either comes out of other programs or gets added to the deficit. Luna: And the deficit is already running hot. The July numbers showed a surge to the highest level since 2021. Lucas: That's right. The government spent a lot more in July than it took in, and that's happening while the Federal Reserve is still running off its balance sheet. So the Treasury has to sell more debt to the public just to cover the day-to-day shortfall, and that supply is hitting the market at a time when foreign demand is cooling. Luna: So it's a double whammy — more supply and less demand from abroad. Lucas: That's the core of the issue. And the thing is, it's not just about the numbers on a screen. It's about trust. When foreign buyers step back, it's often a signal that they're losing confidence in the US fiscal trajectory — or in the political system's ability to manage it. Luna: And that trust is hard to rebuild once it's broken. Lucas: Look at the debt ceiling standoffs we've had in the last few years. Each time the US flirted with default, foreign buyers noticed. And even though we always managed to resolve it, the memory lingers. It's like a smear on the credit rating. Luna: So the debt ceiling isn't just a domestic political drama — it's becoming a foreign policy issue. Lucas: That's a great way to frame it, actually. Because every time the US comes close to defaulting on its obligations, it sends a signal to the rest of the world that the world's safest asset isn't as safe as they thought. And that's not something you can fix with a quick legislative patch. Luna: And it's not just the debt ceiling. The political polarization around fiscal issues makes it hard to even talk about long-term solutions. Lucas: Right. So we have this feedback loop: political dysfunction increases the perceived risk of US debt, foreign buyers demand higher yields, higher yields make the debt harder to service, which feeds back into more political dysfunction. And the end result is that the cost of borrowing slowly ratchets upward. Luna: And that's a spiral we could see play out in real time. Just look at the 10-year yield — it's been hovering around 4.6 percent, which is high by any standard of the last two decades. Lucas: And the spread between the 10-year and the 2-year is still positive — about 48 basis points. That's not a recession signal, but it's also not the kind of yield curve you'd see in a rock-solid economy. Luna: So let's talk about the foreign holders specifically. Who's actually selling, and who's buying? Lucas: Japan is still the biggest foreign holder, but they've been gradually reducing their holdings for years. China has been doing the same, and they've actually been shifting some of their reserves into gold. But it's not just those two. Even countries like Saudi Arabia, which have traditionally been steady buyers, have been less active. Luna: Is there anyone stepping in to fill the gap? Lucas: Domestic institutional buyers — pension funds, insurance companies, and yes, the Federal Reserve — have been absorbing more of the supply. But that has its own limits. If the Fed is shrinking its balance sheet, it's not adding to its holdings, and private investors can be fickle. Luna: So what's the long-term picture? I mean, we're talking about the dollar's reserve status potentially eroding. Is that something we should be worried about imminently? Lucas: No, not imminently. The dollar is still the dominant reserve currency by far. But the trend is in the wrong direction. And every year that we ignore the debt problem, we're basically betting that the world will keep buying our bonds at whatever price we demand. That's a risky bet. Luna: And you know, it's interesting because we always talk about the debt in terms of what it means for future generations — higher taxes, lower growth, maybe less public investment. But there's also an external dimension: the loss of prestige and influence that comes with being a debtor nation. Lucas: That's a really important point. When you're the world's biggest debtor, you're in a weaker position diplomatically. Countries that hold your debt have leverage over you, even if they don't overtly use it. And that's a fundamental shift from the post-World War II era when the US was a creditor nation. Luna: So maybe the real cost of the national debt isn't just the interest payments — it's the loss of autonomy. Lucas: I think that's the deeper story. And it's one that's hard to quantify, but it's real. We're seeing it play out in debates about sanctions policy, about export controls, about everything from trade to technology. Luna: And you know, that's something our listeners might not think about when they hear 'national debt' — it's not just a fiscal issue, it's a national security issue. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why we keep coming back to it. We want to help people understand that this isn't just a number that goes up and down. It's a reflection of the country's position in the world. Luna: And you know, thinking about that, it reminds me of something. We do this podcast because we believe these conversations matter. And it's possible because we've decided to keep it ad-free. If you've found that valuable, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that keeps us going. Lucas: Yeah, we don't run any ads, and that's a deliberate choice. Every listener who chips in helps us stay independent and focused on the issues that matter. No pressure, but if you're in a position to help, we'd appreciate it. Now, back to the numbers. Lucas: So let's dig into what the Treasury's latest refunding announcement tells us. They've been trying to extend the average maturity of the debt, but that means issuing more long-term bonds — and that's where the demand question really bites. Luna: So they're stuck between a rock and a hard place: if they issue more short-term debt, they're exposed to refinancing risk; if they issue more long-term debt, they need to find buyers for it. Lucas: And right now, the market is telling us that long-term buyers are demanding a higher premium. The 30-year yield at 5.2 percent is a sign that investors want more compensation for taking on the risk of holding US debt for three decades. Luna: And that's a risk premium that's partly a reflection of the geopolitical environment we've been talking about. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just about the current level of debt. It's about the trajectory. The Congressional Budget Office projects the debt to gdp ratio to keep climbing — it's already at 122 percent and rising. And that's under current law, which assumes certain tax and spending policies stay in place. But we know they won't. So the reality could be even worse. Luna: So what would reverse this trend? I mean, is there any realistic path to stabilizing the debt to gdp ratio? Lucas: The honest answer is that it would require significant changes to both tax and spending policies. Either raise taxes substantially, cut benefits like Social Security and Medicare, or some combination. And those are politically very difficult choices. Luna: But if we don't make those choices, the market might make them for us. Lucas: That's the risk. And the longer we wait, the more painful the adjustment will be. We saw a preview of that in the UK a few years ago with the pension fund crisis, and in the US with the regional banking turmoil in 2023. Those were just tremors, but they show what can happen when interest rates move against you. Luna: So the bottom line is that the national debt is not just an economic issue. It's a diplomatic one, a national security one, and ultimately a test of whether our political system can handle long-term challenges. Lucas: And that's the frame we'll keep coming back to. Thanks for being with us today. We'll continue this conversation next time, but for now, keep looking at the numbers — and the world behind them.