Latest / The Team House / Exfiltration From Libya | Andy Milburn | Ep. 286
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast if you're not already to support
- 0:07the channel is to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that
- 0:12start at just five dollars a month, and when you sign up, you
- 0:16get access to all of our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for
- 0:20that. I mean, we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers,
- 0:25but this is the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse
- 0:30channel and podcast if you'd like to, and we really appreciate that, So
- 0:35go and check us out at patreon dot com. Slash the Teamhouse, Special
- 0:44Operations, cobt Ops Asbiona, the Team House with Your Hopes, Jack Murphy
- 0:57and David Park. Hey, everybody, welcome to episode two eighty six of
- 1:06The Team House. I'm Dave Park. Jack Murphy is on vacation right now
- 1:10and we'd love to welcome our return guest, Andy Melbourne. Real quick,
- 1:15before we get into it, I just want to thank our sponsor for tonight.
- 1:19Tonight's show is sponsored by Better Help. That's Better h e LP,
- 1:25Better Help and you know mental health is something we talk about quite a bit
- 1:30on this show, especially for veterans, but really for anybody. And if
- 1:34anybody's ever shopped for a therapist, you know it could be time consuming,
- 1:37it could be challenging to find somebody you everppoort with, you know, who
- 1:42lives in your area, all types of different challenges. But everybody deserves to
- 1:49talk to somebody at some point. And if you ever talked to anybody,
- 1:53if you ever talked to a therapist or a professional before, you know that
- 1:57it can be very helpful when you do find that right that right fit.
- 2:02So Better Help, Uh, if you're thinking about starting therapy, give Better
- 2:08Help a try. It's entirely online. It's designed to be convenient, flexible,
- 2:14and suited to your schedule. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get
- 2:17masked with a licensed therapist and switch therapists any time for no additional charge.
- 2:23And for me, that's that's a big deal because again, like having rapport
- 2:28with therapists is one of the one of the biggest indicators of success, and
- 2:32so being able to sort of shop therapists and find one that's right for you,
- 2:37it's a really big deal. So stop comparing and start start focusing with
- 2:40Better Help. That's b E T T E r h E l P.
- 2:46Visit Betterhelp dot Com slash Teamhouse today and get ten percent off your first month.
- 2:51That's Better Help dot Com slash Teamhouse. Andy, Welcome back to the
- 2:59show. Love you man, We miss you. How are you doing?
- 3:01You guys are like gluttons for punishment every every week and then I think it's
- 3:07the fifth time on this I'm well, I'm very glad to be back,
- 3:13Dave, and I want to find out. I want to ask how you've
- 3:15been and how you've been the last year. But then these going to slide
- 3:19track me and say back to whatever he has on the script today. But
- 3:23give us a quick quick shot of yourself, Dave. What's going on in
- 3:27your life? Oh, what's going on in my life? You know I'm
- 3:30interviewing Dave. Yeah, No, it's fine. And you know, like
- 3:35you're a professional now your your show eyes on on this channel is you know
- 3:40you guys are are knocking it out of the park. No, this year
- 3:45has been a good year for me. You know, I did some tech
- 3:47advising on Netflix show, which was a lot of fun, a lot more
- 3:51fun than I ever thought it could be yeah, no kidding, like military
- 3:53tank, Yeah, military, and you know all the things from showing marine
- 4:00is how to blouset their boots to showing how you know, guys how to
- 4:02clear it. Yeah. So a little bit of surveillance here and there,
- 4:08and you know, no, betting down and tying your shoe isn't the right
- 4:12way to detect surveillance. But no, it's it's it's it's a very fun
- 4:16industry to be in when you work with actors and writers who really want to
- 4:20get right. And fortunately for the show I was working on, the actors
- 4:24and writers really wanted to get it right and listen to you, you know,
- 4:27and I think more and more that's yeah, because it's it's punny the
- 4:30way I mean, you know how veteran's are. It's like just one small
- 4:34thing in a movie. Well, even though the rest of the movie may
- 4:40be good. You know, a marine saluting inside with that is cover.
- 4:44You know a few good men, right, that sent everyone so so having
- 4:49that having someone who pays attention to that cool. Yeah, and it pays,
- 4:54I imagine, and you may have your foot in the doll. Yeah,
- 4:58think that That's what I'm hoping is the foot in the door. You
- 5:00know, the pay is good for sort of you know, when it's my
- 5:03first time and you know, and it's it's definitely it's like working on a
- 5:10team. It's like being an enlisted guy on a small team with an officer,
- 5:15because you know the director and the writers, they they have their vision.
- 5:17You say, when you say officer, it sounds like a swell word
- 5:23I only sometimes No, No, it's you know, there's the way to
- 5:30do it right, and there's the way. You're like this, I would
- 5:33never do this, I would never do this way. But if the director
- 5:36has a vision and their artistic vision and they want it to happen this way,
- 5:42it's like, Okay, I wouldn't do it this way, but if
- 5:44I were going to do it this way, this is how I do it.
- 5:46And you know, it's all about especially when you're a tech advisor,
- 5:49it's it's all about compromising. You know, it's about really just contributing and
- 5:55supporting the show the way you can. And at the end of the day,
- 6:00without getting eric and saying absolutely, I mean absolutely, you know,
- 6:03and at the end of the day, if you know the director wants something
- 6:06different, that's their vision. It's their baby, you know. Yeah,
- 6:11so yeah, it was. It's a lot of fun. So that's that's
- 6:15been the primary thing, and it's it's another it's another string to your bow.
- 6:20Well, what's the time quiver to your era? I mean, another
- 6:25goose in my flock crow and my murder? Yeah, many many And actually
- 6:30you know, uh, it was it's a front of the show trip who
- 6:33actually made the connection for me to get this. So m Trip. I'm
- 6:41not going to call it his last name, but I I you've probably met
- 6:43him before. Sorry, it definitely wasn't that Trip, but it was.
- 6:47But it was a front of the show trip who I think you've met before.
- 6:49He made the connection for me. Yea, there is no Trip mccolla.
- 6:55He does not exist. And then uh, and then the the primary
- 7:00the guy who brought me on, the primary tech advisor, Doug Pattison,
- 7:04Uh, former agency guy, very very cool guy who's done this quite a
- 7:10bit. So yeah, that's moosically word word of mouth. Good on you,
- 7:15Dave. Yeah, it feels like I mean, it's been a it's
- 7:17been a it feels like a year, but it's been around February since I
- 7:21last a year. It's been a long it's been a long year, but
- 7:26it's been you know, from my perspective, it's it's been very different than
- 7:30the year proceeding in Ukraine. But you know, like we were talking about
- 7:34before I came to the show, it's it's a year that I really needed,
- 7:40really needed to get my house in order. Yeah. Well, yeah,
- 7:45you guys have been doing you know, you and Jason been doing the
- 7:48Eyes on, which is going great, and I know you have various guests
- 7:51on. I can't really come on to be I guess that because you guys
- 7:55talk in depth about current events and I'm not really qualified talk about anything other
- 8:00than constructs. Actually you get there are by name requests, but Dave,
- 8:09because there are you know, I mean, you know how it is,
- 8:11whatever side we argue, there's going to be people who oppose. So it
- 8:16seems as though you are the universal Devil's advocates. So whatever side, Jason
- 8:22and I seem to be varying tools, specifically on Israel or whatever. You
- 8:26know. I mean, we try not to take signs, but the comments
- 8:30a voice why, I mean, we need to bring daveon to give another
- 8:31opinion, so just like I mean, dying to do that, but well
- 8:37I can come on and play like contrarian. I'll have no idea if I'm
- 8:43accurate or not, but I have no problem forming an opinion and sticking by
- 8:46it regards of any facts. As long as you say that beforehand, like
- 8:52preface it, You're okay, yeah, do whatever you want. Yeah,
- 8:54yeah yeah. So the you know, the one of the biggest things that
- 9:01kind of got me moving again after Mozart group was, you know, sadly,
- 9:11the incident on seven October, the end of course, the whole the
- 9:22horde of events that have occurred since then. So I got to a commission
- 9:28to write a book about it. And initially it was going to be about
- 9:33seven October, right, But then when I start, you know, I
- 9:39going back and forth with the publisher, I said, if I'm going to
- 9:41write about seven October, I've got to really, you know, write about
- 9:45why it happened and what led to it and and and in fact, you've
- 9:48got to go back to the late seventies really for that, you know,
- 9:52both within the IDF and and and weapon Israel. But I mean, certainly,
- 9:56if you're going to focus on idea failure is on seven October leading up
- 10:01to seven October, not just idef. But intelligence failure is you have to
- 10:05go back to the lead seventies, you know, and and and then and
- 10:09then of course, when when you're talking about uh Israel, Gaza, you've
- 10:16got to bring in his Bala, bring in his Molla, you know,
- 10:18Iran, Iran, And then you know what the United States is doing.
- 10:26And then of course the you know, the drone strike occurred when I was
- 10:28actually out in Israel, which is ironic because I've you know, I worked
- 10:35on a on a plan to defend Israel against threats such as that, and
- 10:39and I guess this was the ultimate test that the guy who worked on the
- 10:43plan to sit in televied during the attack. But you see what I'm saying,
- 10:46the as events continued, and then you've got this extraordinary and again,
- 10:52I mean, I absolutely it's very important to avoid being partisan in any way
- 10:56in this book. I just you know, I'm trying. I'm digging up
- 11:00and talking about facts, and that's very important. And such a highly emotional
- 11:05charged topics. Something either happened or it didn't happen, Right, I'm keeping
- 11:11opinions out of it. I'm going to let the reader make up their own
- 11:13opinions. And of course. You know, in the end of course,
- 11:16people say, well, you've chose to mention those facts are not those I
- 11:20mean, there's no there's no chance that I'm going to emerge from this with
- 11:24a reputation of strict objectivity. But I'm doing my best and mixed feelings.
- 11:31It is a it's a colossal topic. It's hard to escape from, you
- 11:37know, some days it's I mean, it's such a it's I'm finding it
- 11:46difficult to describe, perhaps maybe because of the legacy that you and I have
- 11:50from other conflicts, and perhaps we when we try and cover, or at
- 12:01least for me, when I try and write about a conflict, right,
- 12:05it's really difficult not to not to dwell on the reasons and the political failures
- 12:13that led to that, because we are all victims of that, right.
- 12:16So just and if you're not writing about that, then what are you writing
- 12:18about. I'm not interested in the adventure stories. You know. It's this
- 12:22tension next this between the military and the political leaders. But it's also how
- 12:30does an organization and again I'm keeping this as as objective as I can,
- 12:39but how does an organization as storied as heralded as the IDEF go from you
- 12:46know, having turned having now seventy three was a failure, Yes, undoubtedly
- 12:52it was a failure, but it's a political failure, right the you know,
- 12:56the IDEF responded extraordinarily, you know, after the first three days in
- 13:01the seventy three war, I mean, the IDF really won that war back
- 13:05in a sense. You know, there was a commission after the war that
- 13:09sure that that looked at why the Egyptians and the Syrians had both been able
- 13:15to surprise is Ralph tactical surprise, but the blame never devolved to the IDF.
- 13:20The IDF, you know, but it just it was an extraordinary story
- 13:22when you think about it, the mobilization of two hundred I mean back then
- 13:26it was like one hundred and forty thousand reservists within days, and turning the
- 13:31tide both in the north in the south against Egypt and Syria. It was
- 13:35in a sense to the high point of the Israeli army of the IDF.
- 13:39And there are those who argue for then onwards it started to go, you
- 13:45know, it started to lose direction and Lebanon, you know, the invasion
- 13:50of it, the the messing up, the problems with Lebanon, which began
- 13:56in the late seventies were kind of the we're also the beginning of the the
- 14:01unraveling of the IDF and the long occupation which became a nathma, and the
- 14:11occupation of eleven in between eighty you know, twenty years basically from eighty one
- 14:16eighty two to two thousand and one had had a debilitating effect on the on
- 14:22the IDF. You know, they became very focused on camera and surgeons,
- 14:26but they also became surprisingly very very risk averse. You know, there are
- 14:31a number of things and now I don't mean to bore you, and you
- 14:35have to have to read the book and it comes out, but the cultural
- 14:39atrophy of the IDF I'm writing about not it's not just because this happened in
- 14:46the IDF that you know, that would be an interesting historical, you know,
- 14:54narrative, But but what happened in the IDF, But easily, if
- 15:03it's not already happening, it could could also happen in other Western militaries.
- 15:07And indeed there are there are accusations that it is happening. So in the
- 15:11British and the US military is focus on the wrong things, a step away
- 15:18from war fighting, a risk aversion focused on careerism, all of these things
- 15:24that just you know, losing track mission command. The IDEF was supposed to
- 15:28embody mission command, and yet on seven October you get this awful situation outside
- 15:37the kibbutzes where commanders won't go in because they don't have orders, and civilians
- 15:43are getting slaughtered. And this is this is you know, there Israeli investigation
- 15:46on covering this outside Kublitz Bery you know which I which I visited the you
- 15:56know, the Hamas began killing people there at seven a m. And the
- 16:00first soldiers weren't in there until seven or eight hours later, you know.
- 16:06And Israel's a small country, so there are there were some serious failures,
- 16:11and there were found fundamental failures, you know. At the same time,
- 16:17I think it's only fair to say that these failures weren't weren't failures of human
- 16:23beings or failures of courage. They were failures of procedure, of process,
- 16:29and a lot of people showed too many people, most showed just incredible courage.
- 16:34On seven October, soldiers taking that is into their own hands, and
- 16:41many, many, most of them were killed because no one had any idea
- 16:45of what the situation was like it was a black hole. It's it's extraordinary
- 16:51and the most technically competent, one of the most technically advanced countries in the
- 16:56world that this total breakdown of communications occurred in such a small area, and
- 17:03a lot of it had to do with Hamas's planning. Yea, you know,
- 17:07they israelly sort of underestimated their ability or to take out all the communications
- 17:14modes. You know, the the hang lighted dudes. They you know,
- 17:18they weren't kind of like stormtroopers from the sky, wasn't. They were command
- 17:22and control dudes. They were up there directing the groups on the ground and
- 17:30the groups, you know, they and it was because of that, because
- 17:33they had guys up in the air, that they were able to direct one,
- 17:37you know, one column, I suppose onto the Nova Music Festival,
- 17:42because although they knew it was taking place, it wasn't on that list of
- 17:47targets. But when they were locked, they thought, you know, it
- 17:51was a target of opportunity, and so they do. So my point is
- 17:55that on this day, most extra anything happened. It seems like roles were
- 18:02reversed. You've got the idea, who is just paralyzed, you know,
- 18:07unable to make a decision, and then you've got Hamas making decisions on the
- 18:12fly directing forces. You know, I'm not And it was a real you
- 18:18know. I mean, there's there's so many ways why this was such a
- 18:22a a fundamental blow to Israel. You know, time and again is ready
- 18:30to said this country will never be the same, you know, And so
- 18:33what the kind of things that I'm talking about, aside from the savagery of
- 18:36the attacks that were so close to them, has changed society that beyond.
- 18:42I mean, I've been going to Israel since I was a teenager, you
- 18:45know, in the early eighties, and it is the atmosphere there is is
- 18:51very different than anything before. So all of this is it. It's incredibly
- 18:56interesting right about. But it weighs on you too, you know, weighs
- 19:00on you. The the you know, the loss of life period, regardless
- 19:11of nationality or background or ethnicissity. The loss of life is horrific, you
- 19:17know, and just like in every war, the vast majority of people killed
- 19:21or not combatants, you know, and that is that's a tragedy, that's
- 19:26you know, period. I mean, so yes, as a military guy,
- 19:30I'm writing about that aspect of it, but I'm also writing about the
- 19:33cultural part, and without being too clumsy about it, the analogy is there
- 19:40implicitly that yes, this happened to the Israelis. I'm not talking about,
- 19:45you know, seven October the events themselves happening elsewhere, although they easily could.
- 19:52But I'm talking about kind of the slow atrophy of culture within Western militaries.
- 20:00And no, I'm not you know, some kind of like weird extreme
- 20:03right being free who's talking about, you know, the collapse of Western civilization.
- 20:10But I am saying that it is that it is something that is a
- 20:14little bit concerning. You've been tracking, theyve you guys have been tranking the
- 20:18discussions within the military of the last decade, right since you got out.
- 20:22Morale is not high in the US military. It's lower than it was during
- 20:26the Wars when we were doing multiple deployments. Yeah. So you know,
- 20:32it's interesting because I feel as though you specifically, and on this show,
- 20:38we tried to prove present and i'll say fair and balanced, but we try
- 20:45to deal with the realities of a situation. And that was used against you
- 20:49by you know, dirtbags like Max Blumenthal and whatnot. When when we talked
- 20:53about Ukraine, because at no point did you condone what Russia was doing.
- 21:03At no point did you were you ever simping for Russia or or advocating,
- 21:08or were you saying that Ukraine was this evil that needed to be eliminated.
- 21:12You pointed out some specific issues. And and it's interesting how sort of in
- 21:18this uh binary, sort of black and white world, right, where if
- 21:25somebody wants to hear something, so you know, people will probably take sound
- 21:29bites out of what you're saying, or take sound bites out of what's your
- 21:30book, and and they like and they like to attribute it's it's like nine
- 21:36to eleven, right, it was nine to eleven was a massive intelligence failure
- 21:40on the part of the United States. We know who these we knew who
- 21:42these people were, h you know they we had clocked them, you know,
- 21:47our our intelligence apparatus, our law enforcement apparatus, and yet we had
- 21:52failed to to stop what they were doing. And and also one could say
- 22:00from the same type of oversight, you know that something so audacious, right,
- 22:04something so audacious couldn't possibly happen. And so people want to take the
- 22:11idea that a a an intelligence, law enforcement or military system can break down,
- 22:19And it can break down at one level. It can break down at
- 22:23a mid level officer who refuses to believe reports given to him because they seem
- 22:29fantastical and he doesn't want to be the idiot passing up ridiculous reports and people
- 22:38happened, David. Yeah, And people will take those facts and either then
- 22:45develop a conspiracy from it that it was you know that we let nine to
- 22:48eleven happen, you know, Israel let October seventh happen, these types of
- 22:52things, or they will you know, or they will say that conspiracy rather
- 23:00than just simply incompetence, right right. It's like, remember up the ninety
- 23:04eleven that was this conspiracy theory that it was you know, the US had
- 23:08actually stage managed it and was doing all these other things, et cetera,
- 23:12et cetera. Oh yeah, and I remember an agency guy coin if if
- 23:18fucking only we could do all that well, I mean I remember one of
- 23:22the big conspiracies was that it was like a special Forces team or a CIA,
- 23:26you know, paramilitary team that had gone in and planned expokess. And
- 23:30it's sort of like to anybody who thinks something like that, it's like,
- 23:36in order to pass a conspiracy that big, you know, for the president,
- 23:40right, or Cheney or whomever to go to an a team and go,
- 23:44hey, you twelve guys, I want you to be responsible for the
- 23:47dests of up to like ten thousand Americans and for everybody to go Roger that
- 23:52right. It's just it's so ludicrous. But you know, you know why
- 23:56conspiracy theories like that flourished because most Americans have no idea what the American military
- 24:03is about, right. Most Americans don't even know anyone in the military,
- 24:07right. I mean, think about the conversations you have on the plane,
- 24:11Hey, what do you you know? I'm in the Marine corners and oh
- 24:14hey, yeah, listen, my my nephew was in the Air Force reserves,
- 24:18you know, and you're like, okay, but that you know,
- 24:22that trying to find some common ground, right, and it's often very distant,
- 24:26and I think so it's quite easy for them to imagine that. Yeah.
- 24:30And it's the same thing we're seeing now with a lot of the you
- 24:33know, the conspiracy theories that are coming out of you know, October seventh,
- 24:36that like the Israeli government intentionally allowed you know, this to happen or
- 24:41allowed it to continue it's like it's military chains of command break down, especially
- 24:51when they have not been flexed, when they have not been exercised for a
- 24:55long period of time. It's like it's sort of like when you go out
- 24:57on patrol, right when you're when you go out on patrol and in a
- 25:03non permissive environment, after three nights or four nights of that, if you
- 25:07keep going out on patrol over and over and over again, when something goes
- 25:12down, you're not ready for it because you cannot stay on earth, you
- 25:18know. And that is actually part of that, that was part of the
- 25:22plan, you know, I mean a mass mass did not think that they
- 25:26could keep this secret, you know, the plans for an attack. What
- 25:33they thought they could keep secret was the actual date and time when it was
- 25:37going to happen, so that they could still achieve technical surprise. But they
- 25:41I don't think they thought believed that they could achieve strategic surprise the way that
- 25:45they they did because there were so many reports and they must have known as
- 25:52reports were going in from this what are called the Israeli called the spotters.
- 25:56The spotters are generally women conscripts eighteen nineteen twenty years old, and their job
- 26:03throughout Their enlistment is to is to monitor screens, you know, the essentially
- 26:10the CCTV within Gaza, and each one of them gets to know, you
- 26:15know, an area, a couple of blocks, two or three blocks,
- 26:18they know the people on that block and everything. It's an extraordinary system of
- 26:22technical surveillance. It's like nothing in the world. But it failed. And
- 26:26the reason why it failed was not because those soldiers failed. They were making
- 26:30the reports. I mean, this is all the Israeli newspapers had dug this
- 26:37up and in you know, transcripts from radar reports. Everything they had reported,
- 26:45the hang gliders, they had reported rehearsals, full scale rehearsals, and
- 26:51then the morning of and naho Oz if you you know, the record of
- 26:57the reports began at six thirty. You know, they described that watching her
- 27:03mask gather on outside the bounce where they're supposed to be, just right right
- 27:11below the security cameras, looking up at the security cameras as though they knew
- 27:14where they were, and the soldiers call it's the it's a battalion from the
- 27:23Golani Brigade, and the battalion commander comes along and he fires tear gas at
- 27:30these guys you know, on the other side, and he says that that
- 27:33that'll take care of him, and he goes back and she's like, she
- 27:37gets on the phone and says, no, it hasn't taken care of them.
- 27:41That's still they're still coming. And she was ignored, you know,
- 27:44because the battalion commander was like, yeah, she's just you know, so
- 27:48hysterical women. Yeah. Yeah, but but but honestly, it probably had
- 27:53nothing to do with her being a woman. It probably had to do with
- 27:56her being absolutely junior conscript eighteen years old. Junior right, yeah, hundred
- 28:02percent. But on the other hand, they've been given a job and they
- 28:06were they were doing their job, and they were doing well. Sadly,
- 28:08they were unarmed, and so when they had one rifle between twenty women,
- 28:14and so when Almas broke in, they pretty much you know, had free
- 28:18run. They could kill or kidnap as they wish. I mean, these
- 28:22are you know, these they collectively, these are not individual errors. I
- 28:33mean, or rather, all these individual mistakes collectively suggest that there was something
- 28:38culturally wrong within you know, the IDF for this to have to have happened.
- 28:44I mean, obviously there was something culturally wrong. It happens all the
- 28:48time, right, intelligence? You know this is intelligence professional, right,
- 28:51It's you can have the best civiliance equipment in the world and the best collectors.
- 28:57But if if the guys on the receiving and not, if their minds
- 29:00aren't open to that possibility, as you point out, then it's all wasted.
- 29:06And that's really you know, they know one, no one thought everyone
- 29:08was so so lulled by this narrative that Hamas lacked the sophistication or the intent
- 29:18to do harm, you know, beyond a few rockets. Right, So
- 29:22when can we expect your book? Ah? Well, you know it's going
- 29:29to be two to three months before I finished the manuscript. The problem is
- 29:33that the news keeps going on, right, So what does you know?
- 29:37What does an end? To be honest with you, I'm enjoying. I'm
- 29:41enjoying the writing. You know, writing is very cathartic for me. You
- 29:45know, I know you you know you probably have I know you do have
- 29:48activities that that you rely on to kind of get your headspaced back. And
- 29:55writing is what I do, yes, pt and everything, but you know
- 29:59it is when you to your mind still wonders, but writing absorbs me,
- 30:03and and it helps to write about a conflict that I'm not involved in directly.
- 30:08I started to write about Ukraine and I just found it too difficult.
- 30:11I couldn't. You know. Maybe a year or two I will be able
- 30:18to. But it does. I think this is helping writing. It's I
- 30:22don't know, it's difficult to explain, but it's not. The other thing
- 30:26is I think it's quite interesting. I don't I don't hear of anyone else
- 30:30doing this right now. I think it so, so there may not be
- 30:34a lot of competition if I get a book out, you know, because
- 30:37everyone's kind of waiting for some kind of resolution. But who knows when that's
- 30:41going to occur, and who knows what the resolution is going to be,
- 30:45So you know, my book's going to be point in time, you don't
- 30:48think. But anyway, I don't think that Mas will just return all the
- 30:51hostages and that'll be it. I don't know. I don't think that'll be
- 30:56it. No, they've and I don't, you know, sadly, I
- 31:00I'm not optimistic that many hostages left alive. Yeah, you know, if
- 31:07any just like you know, sadly, right now, in the least and
- 31:14just the same thing in Ukraine. It's it's hard to see a good outcome.
- 31:19I mean anytime, not just anytime soon, but but a good outcome.
- 31:23Yeah, better than than before the wall, right right, right,
- 31:29better than starting what you know, speaking of Ukraine for people who have watched
- 31:33you know, any of the episodes that you've been on prior. You know,
- 31:38one of the things we talked about was Mozart Group in the work you
- 31:41guys were doing over there, and then you know, Mozart Group ran into
- 31:47some some challenges. Yeah, and and some of those challenges, uh came
- 31:53personally back to you. Do you do you want to talk about those at
- 31:57all? Yeah? Yeah, yeah, absolutely, you know, and the
- 32:01risk of hope not boring the audience just to you know, kind of go
- 32:06back in times so three, it was it almost three years ago, twenty
- 32:12early twenty twenty two. What am I talking about two years ago? It
- 32:15was over two years ago early twenty twenty two. Came on the teamhouse in
- 32:21January, right a month before the invasion, and we all opined that there's
- 32:27no way that Russia would invade Ukraine, right And then of course it happened,
- 32:31and I got a I wangled a job as a as a freelance reporter,
- 32:37right for task and purpose. Freelance was so that they weren't responsible for
- 32:44me if I got lacked. It was a term. It was. In
- 32:47other words, freelance benefited them, but not me. You know, I
- 32:52wrote for them. But no, don't get me wrong. Task and purpose
- 32:53was great to me, and and down the line was even better than better
- 32:59to me when they stood up and helped me to defend this lawsuit. But
- 33:02anyway, so I ended up going out there, got into got made it
- 33:08to Kiev a very bad time. This was early March of twenty twenty two,
- 33:13and the Russians were on three sides of Kiev and within artillery range.
- 33:17I mean they were pounding the suburbs. You heard it all the time,
- 33:22and that was a sense of I mean you remember, everyone thought Kiev was
- 33:25done. No one thought thought the city would hold out. And within Kiev
- 33:31itself was this extraordinary. The exodus had already taken place, so about two
- 33:37thirds of the population had left, but for the third that were left,
- 33:42they were getting ready to fight. And Zelenski had given the word to hand
- 33:46out AK forty seven's on the street to any male between eighteen and like forty
- 33:52five and so that's what they were doing, you know. I mean,
- 33:55guys were just grabbing aks and heading to the suburbs the Russians and uh and
- 34:02and a senior as a colonel special operations colonel I knew from before the war.
- 34:09It was one of the few regular Ukrainian officers who was tasked with preparing
- 34:15these guys to defend Kiev. And he asked, you know, he asked
- 34:20for my help. And I happened to be able to get out some guys,
- 34:25some marines from the States, a couple and then there were a couple
- 34:30in anyway, bottom line is here we are in Kiev in March, is
- 34:32the Russians closing and we've got a small group of marines. Coincidentally, they
- 34:37tend to be marines. One of them was a Kiev resident, he Andy
- 34:43Bain, and he became kind of the guy that we depended on quite a
- 34:47bit as we set up the Mozart group. The Mozart group, by the
- 34:51way, just evolved as we started to train these people. And this is
- 34:55what it was like. I mean, it's insane when I described the people
- 35:00think I'm exaggerating, you know, we we would get we would have five
- 35:04days to train a cohort of guys, you know the girls, and they
- 35:10were it workers, students, lawyers, you know anything that soldiers and none
- 35:17of them needn't handle the weapon. Five days to get them ready, no
- 35:21ship to go and find the Russians. And so what do you teach them
- 35:23in five days? You know, we did basic weapons handling. That was
- 35:28key. We had to take them to shoot, and that was becoming as
- 35:30it is because every time we started shooting, the Russians had spotters everywhere,
- 35:36and so every time we started shooting on the range, very round would start
- 35:39coming in, very very quickly. So it was literally a two way tay
- 35:44range. A lot of the unusual training restrictions, but the one thing that
- 35:51kept us going was just the just the indomitable spirit of these of these people
- 35:58who were volunteering to fight for their city. Can you imagine, Dave,
- 36:02if you know what I mean, just overnight, you know New York,
- 36:06maybe New York's bad example, Chicago, and you had the enemy at the
- 36:12gates, and just think about it. All these people have never ever dreamed
- 36:16of joining the military. Now that's what they that's their goal, because they
- 36:21want to fight for their country, you know, for their homes. I
- 36:23mean literally, you know, I came across a family mother, father and
- 36:32you know, nineteen year old son, all armed to the teeth, ready
- 36:36to defend their house, you know, in northern Kiev. And they only
- 36:42just for example, with Chicago, probably most American towns of cities, is
- 36:47you probably don't need to worry about passing out so many aks. Like,
- 36:52yeah, that's true, the benefit of the benefit of the Second Amendment,
- 36:57right, But I gotta tell you, I gotta tell you one story about
- 37:00one of these guys. And he came back. He came back about two
- 37:07weeks. He was on our first cohort and he'd been a student and he
- 37:09could not handle a weapon. You know, he kept pointing at that people
- 37:15was flagging people. Well, he came back to, you know, to
- 37:21go through the weapons part again, but he'd already been in combat, and
- 37:25you know we're talking about him. So how do you what did you do
- 37:28if you, you know, if you don't like carrying a weapon? He
- 37:30said, well, so the officer gave me a bag of grenades to carry
- 37:35around and they're pretty easy to use. You just you know, he goes,
- 37:40he goes, so I yeah, that's that was good. I mean,
- 37:43the Russians were all close, so it was easy. I didn't have
- 37:45to shoot him. I just threw grenades. I'm like, I'm thinking his
- 37:50in saying, yeah, it was so convenient. It was, you know,
- 37:52they were they were right up close to us. It was was most
- 37:55people would go, holy shit, you know, it was close combat the
- 37:59first time. And he said, but you know, I guess the grenades
- 38:05are expensive, so I got to come back and learn how to use the
- 38:07weapon, you know, And and we were teaching them how to use we
- 38:09didn't have any javelins. You know, the news about the javelins, the
- 38:16coverage was far greater than their use. You know, a lot of anti
- 38:22handheld anti tank weapons, but a lot of them were Eastern European manufacturer.
- 38:25But that doesn't matter. The point is that these guys were getting close enough
- 38:29to destroy Russian tanks, you know, in that healthy and euphoric stage of
- 38:35the war. But it wasn't euphoric in Kiev. It was pretty fucking scary,
- 38:39you know, it really was. And we were every day kind of
- 38:45having a discussion. What we were having a discussion about when to cut bait,
- 38:51you know, I mean, we didn't want to be trapped in the
- 38:53city. That would have been bad time. It's like, you guys aren't
- 38:59there as merci or armed combatants. No you are there. No, we're
- 39:01not. Yeah, we are just training at this point. And uh,
- 39:09but it became difficult to leave psychologically, I don't you know, it came
- 39:15so that it was never a question of us leaving. And I think we
- 39:20just got too caught up in it. You can't just walk out on something
- 39:23like that, you know. And and then when the Russians were pushed back,
- 39:30we actually I was with one of the the first units to clear through
- 39:36Butcher. Uh. So you know when they found the bodies. I mean
- 39:40it's not like I found the bodies, but they were they were there,
- 39:44still just lying out there. When when we got up there, it was
- 39:47pretty pretty horrific. And it was first kind of glimpse, uh, you
- 39:52know, for me sadly, you know, I mean we've seen lots of
- 39:57bodies before the massacre. I mean, it was it was shocking, but
- 40:04I but the but the effect on the Ukrainian soldiers was it was fundamental.
- 40:07I mean it was it was really you could tell it that it changed them
- 40:15and the war was a the war from the start. I mean, it
- 40:21seems absurd to talk about any war has been vicious, but yes, you
- 40:24know, this is a particularly vicious one. And you have to look at
- 40:27some of the history there to understand how and why. And that is why,
- 40:34you know, I mean, and bear in mind, I mean,
- 40:36I was risking my life for Ukraine. But I came on the team house
- 40:39and did say, look, Ukraine has to adhere to the walls of law
- 40:45of war because I mean, for one, I don't want to be involved
- 40:49in helping decide you know this, we can't do that, right, that's
- 40:52committing atrocities. And and you know I said, which I didn't think was
- 41:00controversial. Well, of course the Ukrainians, I mean, they happen in
- 41:04every wall, you know. Of course, the committing I mean, and
- 41:07I quoted, you know, I quoted a couple. I mean, they're
- 41:10putting prisoners on TV. You may think it's harmless, but it's a violation
- 41:15of that Geneva convention. And the point is you have to be squeaky clean
- 41:20when you I mean, you don't have to be squeak clean, but you
- 41:22got to be better than your rapistry, right, and if you're going to
- 41:24highlight what your enemy is doing, you've got to make sure that you had
- 41:28hitted the wolves. That was number one. When you're taking somebody off the
- 41:31street and training them up in a matter of three to five weeks days,
- 41:38days, right, you know, days? Sorry, Laura pland wolfare yeah,
- 41:45like like everybody may know, hey, don't pull the fingernails out of
- 41:52you know, your your detainees or your POW's, but they may not know
- 41:55that, hey, you can't put them on TikTok. Yeah, and you
- 42:01know what I said, I mean, you remember this, what I said
- 42:06was uncontroversialized And yes I did say, of course, you know there there
- 42:12are reports of atrocities. That was number one. Number two is I became
- 42:21very frustrated with the level of corruption and bad leadership, not not across the
- 42:30board, but in certain units, certain commands, and the guys who were
- 42:35suffering were the soldiers on the front, you know, I mean, think
- 42:37about it. Some criminal things were happening as far as you know, I
- 42:40mean where ammunition was going or cold weather clothes, and this was affecting the
- 42:45guys that we were working with day in day out. Of course, I
- 42:50was angry about it, and I spoke about it, and and of course
- 42:55I spoke about it after drinking whiskey with you guys. Has tended to happen.
- 43:01So the chorus, you know, the peanut chorus. He mentioned what
- 43:07was his name, Max bluemuthal right, yeah, you know number one.
- 43:15So here's the weird thing, So blue myouthall is you know, he's a
- 43:19left he's left wing, et cetera, et cetera. But the weird thing
- 43:22is he supports Russia. I mean, you know, it's it's kind of
- 43:29the the far left and the far right converge here in the support of Putin
- 43:35and and so you know, and Bluementthal, I I have heard has connections
- 43:42with right, you know, I mean, he has worked there. I
- 43:46don't know, it doesn't matter, I don't I don't really care about bluemuthal
- 43:51In fact, he did me a favor. But because I don't think it
- 43:55wasn't him who started the attacks. It was a guy named Peter Mass mb
- 44:01A s now. Peter Mass is the editor of the Intercept Right and uh
- 44:08has a long history and kind of yellow journalism and very very anti US military
- 44:15rot skathing. I'm pretty sure the Intercept published at least one article by John
- 44:21Walker Lynd. He did, yeah, yeah, yeah, who I know
- 44:27is a personal hero of he wants. I mean, you know, okay,
- 44:31we're out, so so Peter mass is, you know, I mean,
- 44:37he's he's one of these guys trendy, trendy left, but doesn't always
- 44:45write honestly about the military. That's always very you know, looking for an
- 44:49angle to attack us. Sure and so sure enough when when the first American,
- 44:54one of the first Americans, gets killed out there, it wasn't with
- 44:58the Mozart group. He was saying he was a volunteer and he is missing,
- 45:05and which is usual there, you know, I mean that the number
- 45:08of missing people, I mean, it's such a maelstrom and the effect the
- 45:14way that both sides are using arteria, but particularly the Russians, means that
- 45:17you have a lot of people who are just blown into smithereens and never found.
- 45:22So that could have happened to him. We didn't know there were rumors
- 45:27he'd been captured by the Russians. It turns out that he had been,
- 45:30and we think, well, he's dead, but he was probably killed after
- 45:36being captured by the Russians. Fell into the hands wounded. But in any
- 45:40case, he was missing, and his a friend had called me, who
- 45:47was friends with his parents, to say, hey, can you and he
- 45:51can you find out anything about what had happened. So we were trying to
- 45:53find out, you know, we were with the Legion. We did a
- 45:58lot of you know, I mean, we knew those guys who work with
- 46:00him for amount, so we you know, we we were talking to the
- 46:05people who'd been with him, but he you know, they they'd gone out.
- 46:07They they they had a plan to hit a te seventy two. They
- 46:15were they were rumbled before they could take a shot, and they got split
- 46:17up and this guy. The others made it back, but this guy didn't.
- 46:22Anyway, Peter Mask called me and said, hey, and he can
- 46:28you just verify that, you know, this guy got an other than honorable
- 46:32discharge from the Marinkles and can you tell me what that could be? For
- 46:37drugs or something like this. So he was digging up dirt on this guy
- 46:40before we could even find his body, before we could you know, even
- 46:44had a chance to tell his parents. And you know, I basically told
- 46:47Master funk Off and and then this is where I think what really triggered him.
- 46:53I sent out a tweet going, hey, masks, you know he
- 46:58was still looking for this guy. By the way, Peter Mass just you
- 47:00know, came up with this ship. So if you see him publish this,
- 47:05fucking just ignore it. You know, it was a tweet basically like
- 47:07this, ignore this stupid shit. You know everything that we're hearing. This
- 47:12guy died in you know, brave, brave circumstances. We can forget why
- 47:16he left the marine corpse surely until we find his body. But mass Mass
- 47:22was evidently not happy about that because that tweet surprisingly picked up like fifty thousand
- 47:31views, So a lot of people knew about the intercept and Peter Mass and
- 47:37we're not happy. But next thing, I know, so a number of
- 47:43things started happening, and you probably remember one was the the Wagner group the
- 47:50Pregosion got involved and started threatening personally threatening me, threatening us, And you
- 47:59know, we were told that they had and they did have teams out there.
- 48:02They were killing people behind the lines. You know, whether they were
- 48:06targeting us or not, I don't know, but it doesn't but they were
- 48:08definitely targeting us with missiles to the extent that no less than four hotels either
- 48:15we were staying in or had just left, were hit by missiles on the
- 48:17same day. So so you know, the kind of the the bullseye was
- 48:24was getting narrower and narrow The Russians were getting more and more loitering munitions aloft,
- 48:34which which are just terrifying things. But the point is too that loitering
- 48:38munitions, as you've seen, I mean, these fpvs, when when they
- 48:44decide to get you, they will get you, right, you know,
- 48:46and so and and at very little cost. So until that point, you
- 48:52know, I'd been able to make this calculus that here we can continue doing
- 48:57what we're doing, driving you know, into bargmert through artillery barrages in soft
- 49:02skin vehicles to take people out and it's risky, but it's acceptable because we
- 49:08are not being targeted personally. There's no way you know, the we and
- 49:13as soon as we see a drone, we're out of there. You know,
- 49:15any any sense that that that we're allowing the enemy to identify us and
- 49:22target us, or that we we have we've met their target priority list right
- 49:30and their engagement criteria. When it started to become evident that that was happening,
- 49:37I got I was getting increasingly concerned, you know, and it was
- 49:44because there was no safety there. There was no The o r M was
- 49:49off the charts, I mean, medical attention, evacuation, all of that
- 49:54would have been on us. You know, the Ukrainian military was barely able
- 49:59to hold ground at the time. Operational risk management it's this ridiculous process that
- 50:07the US military. Well it's not ridiculous, I mean, but but it's
- 50:12become a ridiculous process. The concept is absolutely valuable, all right, you
- 50:16got it, an assessment of risk before you do a mission. Right,
- 50:19But of course we break it down PowerPoint style, you know, into traffic
- 50:23lights and make it a worthless exercise. But but but the point is,
- 50:31you know, you couldn't. We We did have an r M process,
- 50:36but it was you know, it was marginal. It was like, yeah,
- 50:39we're not going to go in entering an active s RIIK. But then
- 50:43we but then we broke that rule once when we you know, when we
- 50:45got a call from a family that a desperate need of being pulled out.
- 50:52So I realized it was an extraordinary feeling of responsibility, far more so than
- 50:58anything I'd had in the military, because in the military you've got all that
- 51:01infrastructure behind you. Yes, you're a commander and you may get people killed
- 51:06because of your decisions, but everything to that point in your career has prepared
- 51:09you for that, and the whole system is there to support you, you
- 51:14know, in your decision making. But here, no, we were,
- 51:17you know, as we were out hanging and being responsible for this, responsible
- 51:24for bringing in funds. I was working really hard to bring in funds at
- 51:30the time that that was one of the hardest things about it. And I
- 51:32started to think, shit, I am working my ass on to get money
- 51:37in so that we can risk our lives in a country that is not ours.
- 51:42You know, these thoughts were starting to swell around in my mind at
- 51:45the time, you know. And meantime, you know, we get two
- 51:52vehicles that are destroyed by artillery, I mean mine's artillery. We get one
- 51:58of our guys fragged lightly but enough, and you know, in the arm
- 52:01and so all the things. Yeah, if I and then we get attacked
- 52:10by n s U twenty five and and and get caught in a grad strike
- 52:17on the same day, and my hands are shaking so much by then,
- 52:23I can't get I can't open my hotel room in the evenings. You know
- 52:28what I mean, I'm it's not it's it's like nothing. It's it's worse
- 52:31than Fallujah, you know, I mean Fallujah was you know, I had
- 52:37a you had a weapon, you had your buddies behind you, you had
- 52:43you know, even though it's there's fighting going building up the building and knowing
- 52:45the bad guys waiting for you, there was a processor system. There was
- 52:50support. If you got franking, you you were out of there, right.
- 52:53And most of all, this is the hardest thing, you know,
- 52:58in Flujah, there was a It was all an institutional system that put people
- 53:06under me. It was supposed to happen, I guess for me. The
- 53:10Mozart group was something that evolved. It was tremendous, but it wasn't worth
- 53:15losing anyone, right, And when do you make that decision to pull the
- 53:21plot? I don't know. I mean I didn't have to because Blumenthall and
- 53:24Andy Bean and Peter Mass made it for me. Thank you, thank you.
- 53:30And by the way, yeah, so Andy Bean was sadly a former
- 53:36marine is a FORUR marine reservist. He he when I say reserve is sorry
- 53:46that they got me off my attention. But you know, basically has been
- 53:52sitting in Kiev since he was a captain working at the embassy, you know,
- 53:55and made colonel that way, he was doing things. Let me just
- 54:02say this, he was doing things that we started started to make us feel
- 54:06suspicious, and we got increasingly suspicious, and we were worried about the money.
- 54:10He was less than open about that, and it eventually you know,
- 54:15you know, you probably don't know me day, but I don't. I
- 54:19don't suffer fools badly. I mean, I don't suffer. I suffer fools
- 54:22badly, and I don't. I'm not good at hiding things. And so
- 54:28eventually I blew up at this guy. I mean, not physical, you
- 54:31know, it's just like just get the fuck, you know, get away
- 54:37from us. We want blah blah blah. I forget what the discussion is
- 54:40about. He wanted us to he wanted us to buy him out for five
- 54:45million dollars. This is like a gurentleman. We couldn't he you know.
- 54:51They basically he's training. It's an n g O. It's a nonprofit I
- 54:57know, and he wants so he has this to sy that he's going to
- 55:00lead it. He'll edge me out and he's going to lead it. He's
- 55:04pissed because I've insulted him, and he's He's going to show me. And
- 55:07so he brings this lawsuit against me and were you know, this was kind
- 55:14of the final straw. So once he brought the lawsuit, then of course
- 55:17donas are not going to contribute. And and we had a like three guys
- 55:23who had volunteered to help us, right former marines, and they got so
- 55:28stooked by the lawsuit. They were our board, they handled all our funds,
- 55:31they pent, they became paralyzed with fear over this lawsuit. So we
- 55:36lost any all access to our finds and we came to an end. And
- 55:43not only that, but well all this was going on a former marine guy
- 55:51really pains me that these these bad actors of four Marines, you know,
- 55:54being and but but they're both reservists. Okay, so they're not it's not
- 55:59like the Ral Marines. I'm going to get criticize, I'm kidding. But
- 56:05anyways, so after you know, the invasion of Ukraine entered this other marine.
- 56:10He's he's working for a an NGO or his volunteer, but basically he
- 56:16just wants to get in on the action. He you know, he's you
- 56:20know how it is, They've all the fucking questers come into to prove themselves
- 56:25or pretend they're doing something when they really aren't. And and Kiev became a
- 56:30Petri dish of these, not so much Kiev as Leviv because Leviv was really
- 56:36safe, so it became a Petri dish or that he's you know, all
- 56:39these guys who do everything to look hard, but be hard, you know,
- 56:44I mean, they're not. They want to appear tough, guys covered
- 56:47in tattoos and you know, special Forces t shirts and everything. And every
- 56:52night they get drunk. And you know, I'm not kidding you. I
- 56:57saw Westerners carry the sniper, you know. I saw one guy carry a
- 57:00snipermife into a bar. I mean, why the fuck? Why why would
- 57:05you do that? You know, drop holsters, the whole works. I
- 57:07mean, but they don't go near combat. They're hanging out lit. So
- 57:10one of these dudes is partying while we're up in Kiev. You know,
- 57:15they're all drinking, and he a girl alleges said he rapes her, all
- 57:21right, and and she does. She goes to the police, both Ukraine
- 57:27and Poland. She's held by a journalist and he's beaten her. You know,
- 57:31I mean it's she's young, quite a young girl. She's fragile,
- 57:37she's had, you know, some mental problems in the past. So it
- 57:42was just her bad luck, you know, she was a genuine volunteer,
- 57:45her bad luck to run into this guy. Michael Ryan booke she was an
- 57:51American or she was she was, Yeah, she's an American. Yeah,
- 57:54but the FBI has no jurisdiction because it was on Ukrainian soil. So he
- 58:01allegedly rapes her, beats her. She you know, she is taken across
- 58:07the border by friends and they go to you know, report at the embassy
- 58:12and doctors. I get a call in Kiev. I'm a little bit distracted,
- 58:17but I get a call. No, not a call. It was
- 58:22a marine. One of our guys says, hey, Andy, there's there's
- 58:27a you know, he told me a story. There's a girl alledging that
- 58:30a former marine raped her. Blah blah blah, and the Ukrainian police wanted
- 58:34us to get the word out. And it was a guy who headed up
- 58:37Task Force Yankee Dan in LVIV, good guy, former Chicago cop, who
- 58:44then contacted me and said, yeah, man, we think he may be
- 58:46running for Kiev. Can you keep your eye out, uh? And I
- 58:51said, yeah, I can do more than that. I can write about
- 58:52this. You know, I'm a tree journalist, So I wrote. I
- 58:55wrote an article about it. Very you know, we researched nothing in there
- 59:02that that that that was scerless at all, just saying, you know,
- 59:07he's the Ukrainian police are offer and true, and this guy had made an
- 59:12allegation of great true. Anyway, he escapes across the border. He pays
- 59:19a cab driver to die. You know, it's not difficult to dodge to
- 59:22checkpoints to get across into Poland back then and makes it back to the States
- 59:27and sues me for thirty million dollars. Sues me and Task and Purpose for
- 59:31thirty million dollars. So this hits me when I get back from Ukraine,
- 59:36and I'm by the way, I'm not in a good state by then.
- 59:37I mean, I'm I mean, Dave, you know, I've I've had
- 59:42some some personal tragedies I was I was dealing with anyway, and you know,
- 59:47like all of us, I'm a little scrambled by experiences of deployments we
- 59:52went through. And then Ukraine was a ballbuster for me. And it because
- 59:59on the on the evacuation missions when we said, you know, that was
- 1:00:01the part that became really dangerous, so evacuating civilians from the bombed out areas.
- 1:00:07You know, I did feel as though I should be on those missions
- 1:00:10since it was the worst thing that we were doing. But it did take
- 1:00:15a toll on me too, you know, I took a toll on my
- 1:00:16nerves. I mean, it's not and I didn't realize it because it's like
- 1:00:22the frog and the water, right. You know, you're drinking a little
- 1:00:24bit more, you're shaking more, you you know, but but you're locked
- 1:00:30in. You know, you can't what are you going to do? You
- 1:00:32can't just not you can't stop doing it. So bottom line is Hols in
- 1:00:38a bad stay. And I come back and I'm facing this lawsuit thirty million
- 1:00:42dollars and no, and I've got twenty days they come and serve me the
- 1:00:46summons. By the way, this will make your laugh to it. Maybe
- 1:00:49not. So I'm getting death threats around then too. I don't know if
- 1:00:52you remember that, but I'm getting death threats from Russians, from Ukrainians by
- 1:00:58the way, No Ukrainians who are in Ukraine. Ukrainians who have fled elsewhere
- 1:01:00in Europe are giving me, threatening me, threatening my life because I criticized
- 1:01:05Ukraine. I can figure that one out anywhere there in Ukraine. So what
- 1:01:09what was the name of this guy who loved this lawsuit against you? If
- 1:01:14you want to say his name, Michael Ryan Booke? Yeah, D you
- 1:01:17know, I'll show you. D will show you a picture. I'll show
- 1:01:21I'll show a picture and it will kind of tell you everything about him.
- 1:01:24But thirty million dollars. So and Michael Ryan Burke lives in the United States,
- 1:01:30correct, he does. Yeah, he lives in Missouri. But the
- 1:01:32FBI had no authority to an I had no juristic jurisdiction because it wasn't on
- 1:01:38a military base. See I didn't realize this. But unless there's some kind
- 1:01:43of I suppose, you know, there's an agreement, so like a soap
- 1:01:45agreement, or it occurs on a area where the FBI has jurisdiction, like
- 1:01:52the US embassy, you know, or a or a US base, or
- 1:01:57a ship or an aircraft. But because it was in Leviv, yeah,
- 1:02:01they had no jurisdiction. So he knew that. And Michael Ryan Burke sued
- 1:02:08you for thirty million dollars you and ten twenty million dollars to write in an
- 1:02:13article about an alleged rape, exactly. And and and so this story gets
- 1:02:17better, right, I mean, it gets worse and it gets better.
- 1:02:21So they they served me the summons in the middle of the night, three
- 1:02:25o'clock in the morning. So you can imagine I'm getting all these death threats,
- 1:02:30and my door they'll starts ringing off, you know, off the just
- 1:02:36beer at three in the morning. And so what do I do? What
- 1:02:38do you think I do? G you grab your gun, grab my gun,
- 1:02:43and I go down the side of the hall, you know, don't
- 1:02:45turn on the lights, and and I look through, you know, the
- 1:02:47window, and it's it's clearly it's a woman, you know, fat glasses
- 1:02:52and she's got peepers in her hands. I open it. Yeah, it
- 1:02:55was a you know, summons, and it gave me twenty days to reply.
- 1:03:01But no lawyer would take my case, Dave, because they're like,
- 1:03:05oh, man, you screwed, I swear, you know I And so
- 1:03:08the clock was ticking and if I can't find a lawyer, it's going to
- 1:03:15be a default judgment against me. Right, I mean thirty million dollars.
- 1:03:19I was like, the fuck. So I am really sweating, and the
- 1:03:22last minute I do get a lawyer, and of course he wants to retainer,
- 1:03:28and you know, I do that. I have no money left after
- 1:03:31the Mozart group, by the way, because I've been paying the dudes for
- 1:03:34the last month when they you know, crush the money. So I take
- 1:03:38out you know, I take out a second mortgage basically too for her fees.
- 1:03:45And then and then my luck starts changing. Turns out Task and Purpose
- 1:03:49has decided to defend the lawsuit too, all right, and I'm partly covered
- 1:03:52by insurance. But it's a pathetic amount, you know, It's like it's
- 1:03:57based on nineties legal rates. But still it's a moral boost to me that
- 1:04:02that Task and Purpose is saying, hey, we believe that that he researched
- 1:04:06this story. We're not going to pay this dude off. Now. The
- 1:04:11editor of Task and Purpose had taken the article down, and that was I
- 1:04:15think a mistake, because that emboldened him. He thought, ah, yeah,
- 1:04:18they're not certain about this, so now I'm going to bring the lawsuit.
- 1:04:21And but but when they started to research it, somewhere that initial assessment,
- 1:04:30someone thankfully said, hey, I think Melbourne, you know, I
- 1:04:33think we I think he did his research and I think we should defend this.
- 1:04:38No one asked me. It was strange, but anyway, I'm very
- 1:04:41grateful that they did, and they fought the lawsuit, and you know what,
- 1:04:45thank God, because they had enough money to go back to Poland Ukraine
- 1:04:48uncover all these records, photographs of her bruised, you know, doctor's descriptions
- 1:04:55of what you know had happened, the embassy, the fact that the she
- 1:05:00reported at the embassy, the embassy had tried had contacted him and said,
- 1:05:04hey, the FBI liaison here needs to see you. He had ignored that
- 1:05:08and headed back to state. So, you know, he had been a
- 1:05:11bad actor at every turn. And if he wasn't guilty of rape, he
- 1:05:15sure is her acted as though he was guilty of rape. And someone beat
- 1:05:19that girl up and put her in the hospital, you know. And so
- 1:05:24all this started happy and I started feeling thank God, but it's still you
- 1:05:28know, And it took a year, but it was dismissed. It took
- 1:05:31a year because the ambulance chasing lawyer had a stroke and collapsed and can now
- 1:05:38only Blinker's eyes. So they brought in another ambulance chaser. But you know,
- 1:05:45all that caused delay, and delay is expensive for me, and delay
- 1:05:48is not good for your nerves when you're facing thirty million, thirty million dollars
- 1:05:54that would have finished me. Of course, I had declared bankruptcy, my
- 1:05:57kids, you know, a college fund, the house, everything gone,
- 1:06:01everything I was. I was facing ruin and then at the same time there
- 1:06:09was kind of a backlash of you know that you remember that the team house,
- 1:06:13it had the fact that I was I was appear drunk, but I
- 1:06:18think I think it's better say I wasn't drunk. I was absolutely jet lagged.
- 1:06:23I've been at thirty six hours without sleep. To remember that. I
- 1:06:27yes, you guys, and in fact that discussion was, you know,
- 1:06:31we if you go back, we weren't downing the whiskeys. At that point,
- 1:06:38I was, I was exhausted and I was angry. But unfortunately it
- 1:06:42was given the moniker of you know, drunken mercenary. Uh, you know,
- 1:06:46it tells the truth about Ukraine, as though it was right fence right,
- 1:06:51and it was it was very selective sound by It's like, yes,
- 1:06:56you're telling one truth. But but again it's not a binary world that that
- 1:07:02Ukraine is doing everybody, all the soldiers in Ukraine are doing all these things,
- 1:07:08and Russia and Russians are just being saints. It's like you have two
- 1:07:13very contentious forces going against each other. It's very personal. People are fighting
- 1:07:18for their homes. And do people sometimes step out of line and need to
- 1:07:24be like put in check one percent? Yes, they do, like eve,
- 1:07:28even in the even in the US where we have a professionalized military and
- 1:07:32we are taught the laws of land warfare and you know, and and whatnot,
- 1:07:39we still run into these issues. Yeah, that's right. So you
- 1:07:42can imagine guys off the streets fighting with that families behind them, right,
- 1:07:45can you imagine it? Literally, your your kids and families behind you.
- 1:07:50Your you're calculus, You're calculus for your own survival changes. And it is
- 1:07:56true probably you all, you know, you're simple for the enemy. You
- 1:08:00lose all of it because those guys, you're the only thing between those guys
- 1:08:06in your family. We've never been in that position, right, And and
- 1:08:12it was an existential threat, unlike you know, say Hamas to Israel,
- 1:08:16I mean Russia was invade in Ukraine. So yeah, all of those things.
- 1:08:20But but yeah, I think Michael Michael Ryan Burke turns out he's a
- 1:08:28reservist. He's staff sergeant was something. I think he even made sergeant major.
- 1:08:33I don't know, but he's he he kind of drifts around from you
- 1:08:42know, job to job and makes a big deal like a lot of these
- 1:08:45reservestsuf I have. You know, I've done super secret stuff and I had
- 1:08:49this clearence in that his his testimony is their position was you know, it's
- 1:08:56the usual, just like well, it's interesting even if the FBI didn't handle
- 1:09:02even if the FBI didn't have jurisdiction, didn't like an I s or somebody
- 1:09:09have jurisdiction. No, no, because he's not he's not even I mean,
- 1:09:15he's not an active reservist. He wasn't wearing a uniform he was.
- 1:09:17You know, I say, yeah, no, one absolutely, it is
- 1:09:21what it is, you know what I mean. In the end, at
- 1:09:24the end of the day, I don't waste time with anger, I really
- 1:09:30don't. This dude is going to have This dude is in a far worse
- 1:09:32state than me. So this guy, this guy, now all of your
- 1:09:36audience, hopefully will be a larger one. It knows that Michael Ryan Burke
- 1:09:41was was not only accused the rape, but accused the rate whether it appears
- 1:09:45to be quite a bit of evidence to support that accusation to the point where
- 1:09:48his lawsuit against you was dropped, dismissed, was just on all counts.
- 1:09:56And so you know, he's got to live with that, right you imagine,
- 1:09:59I mean, he's rapist, alleged rapist, right, and even's gonna
- 1:10:01hate that guy. So I don't want to be him for a moment,
- 1:10:05and I don't want to, you know, think about him. I'm sorry,
- 1:10:10what was his name again, Michael Ryan Book And that's like b u
- 1:10:16r k e bu b u r b u r k E. Yeah,
- 1:10:21I just want to make sure you know, yeah, he pretends to be
- 1:10:25religious. But but if you know anyway enough enough, he's so. But
- 1:10:33the point is that a rapist and a can do this, you know,
- 1:10:40bring a lawsuit, cost me a fortune and then walk away and it doesn't
- 1:10:46cost him at buck because you know, lawyers, these guys are doing it
- 1:10:50pro bono. They cost his lawyer, his his health, you know,
- 1:10:56And I can't I can't feel sorry for it about that it was my thirty
- 1:11:00million boxes, my whole future. I can't feel sorry that his lawyer collapsed
- 1:11:04with the stroke. And you know it's the explaining why I should be at
- 1:11:10the end of the ground. Maybe it's a little bit of God's punishment,
- 1:11:13you know, But yeah, I don't ways, I mean, I don't
- 1:11:15like Mass, Mass and Blumenthal. I mean these people are you know that
- 1:11:23the flotsam and jets and they're not you know, they're not substantive people.
- 1:11:28Right, Mass isn't even a good writer, and that's his job. Yeah,
- 1:11:33right, better than him. Well, and and you mentioned that this
- 1:11:39uh, this Burke guy had he'd even claim that you had gone so far
- 1:11:44as to try to take out a hit on him and he had. Yeah.
- 1:11:46Yeah, so that was so so when the defamation suit started going south,
- 1:11:53his law you know when it when they when they dug out the police
- 1:11:58reports. Uh, his lawyer took a new tactic and said, look,
- 1:12:03my my client's called PTSD because Melbourne's this is quote Norman's reputation that you know,
- 1:12:15he he used his resources. I'd get what it was, intelligence,
- 1:12:18special forces, blah blah blah. It's proven to be ruthless and no problem
- 1:12:23with killing people before, uh, only when my country told me to do
- 1:12:30so. And you know, right and right. But anyway, so so
- 1:12:39he sided down this part of and and unbelievably, uh, his lawyer,
- 1:12:45you know, threw that out as a as a serious claim that he was
- 1:12:49affected. You know, they dug up his medical reports and oh my god,
- 1:12:53blah blah blah blah. So I was able to prove that at the
- 1:12:57time, I mean, I was able to show from a letter from the
- 1:13:00State Department that we never carried weapons, that we were not a musclimary bloot.
- 1:13:05And I had been in fact classified as a whatever five or one C
- 1:13:12three, you know, which is a charity. So unlikely that a group
- 1:13:16of our charitable volunteers were hunting this guy down to kill him, right,
- 1:13:21But that was his claim anyway. But the point is, Dave, that
- 1:13:27this put I mean, you know, I I would rather have faced death
- 1:13:31again almost they then then, I mean, then go through that fear of
- 1:13:39losing my family's livelihood, right, you know, because in the end,
- 1:13:44that's kind of what we when when we leave, I mean that we we
- 1:13:48we want that to be our legacy, right, that that our family is
- 1:13:51better off than we were and they're okay, And if we don't do that,
- 1:13:56it kind of makes our lives a failure. Yeah, it's been hard,
- 1:14:00but that's that's the way I was feeling, and it was it was
- 1:14:02really that was in free fall. And the other thing I've noticed is you
- 1:14:06really find out you're when you when you've got two lawsuits against you, because
- 1:14:12Bain's was dismissed too, by the way. Bain, by the way,
- 1:14:15is very lucky we didn't bring a lawsuit against him. We have people lining
- 1:14:18up who want to bring a lawsuit against beIN to include and not just for
- 1:14:24financial stuff, but but we had sex stuff too, But that's another you
- 1:14:29know, I leave it, leave that all aside. Yeah, I'm not
- 1:14:32interested in pursuing anyone. I want to get on with my life. And
- 1:14:38but it has changed me, has changed me. I think for the better.
- 1:14:42I'm going to make it for the better. Well, I mean everything
- 1:14:45else. Yeah, I mean, you know, we we've been I mean,
- 1:14:51you were on early on the teamhouse, like you've been here for a
- 1:14:56long time and we love seeing your journey. You know, we've talked your
- 1:15:01book, When the Tempest Gathers, your biography. I have spoken at great
- 1:15:10length of how much I truly loved your book, and if anybody has not
- 1:15:14read it, I think it's a It is a phenomenal book about an officer
- 1:15:20during wartime and the questions one asked themselves about am I a good leader?
- 1:15:32Am I a bad leader? Am I making the right calls? Because I
- 1:15:35think those are things that anybody who has been in a leadership position in war
- 1:15:39time, you know, it's easy to tell the no shit there. I
- 1:15:42was number one man in the door Stories because when it's just you, if
- 1:15:48you're alive to talk about it, then you made the right decision that day.
- 1:15:53Right when you're an officer or a senior enlisted and you are making those
- 1:16:00calls for other people that you are deciding whether or not somebody goes home,
- 1:16:08and again you can go from zero to hero or hero to zero in one
- 1:16:15decision. And sometimes those decisions seem obvious to people when they Monday morning quarterback.
- 1:16:24And sometimes it's a decision you make on the fly, go left,
- 1:16:29go right, go straight, but you got to go somewhere, and there's
- 1:16:32no way to know what the right decision is. In your book, really,
- 1:16:41along with your own biography, in the book, the personal tragedies that
- 1:16:45you faced outside of the military. It is a very introspective, very in
- 1:16:51depth and very like human look into the military and into leadership that it's very
- 1:17:03hard to find in modern war literature. I think that's really I mean,
- 1:17:10it's tremendously kind of you to say that, Dave, and I appreciate it
- 1:17:14really from the you know, the first time I came home this podcast,
- 1:17:17which was five years ago, by the way, and I remember you guys
- 1:17:21were very supportive the book. It was, by the way, it just
- 1:17:28won the the it's called the Eugene Slash. It's the Marine Corps Marine Corps
- 1:17:34Heritage Association Award for best Biography in the last three years because they counted the
- 1:17:42paperback version which just came out. Yeah, I mean, you know,
- 1:17:46because as a Marine number one, there's this this kind of a mental obstacle
- 1:17:56before you even think about writing about your experiences, right, you know what
- 1:18:00I mean that there's it's something about our ethos in the Marine Corps. It
- 1:18:04is very different and I'm not derogating other services. It's just, you know,
- 1:18:08it really does the belief that you subsume yourself to the whole of the
- 1:18:14Marine Corps. Right, and so remember when MARSK, when that was first
- 1:18:18discussion about MARSC starting, or when DEBT one and no it wasn't. Yeah,
- 1:18:27it was that one because Rumsfelt was so do you remember RUMs Felt?
- 1:18:30I apparently had a discussion with commandant the Marine Corps back then. I'm trying
- 1:18:34to remember who it was Conway. I think no, not going you know,
- 1:18:39it wasn't Comway. It was maybe Jones, it doesn't matter. But
- 1:18:43but uh but but in that discussion, you know, he was talking about
- 1:19:00sorry, I totally totally lost my where will we daved? Well, you
- 1:19:03know you were talking about you were talking about the formation of DEBT one or
- 1:19:08MARSK. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, no, I'm sorry. Yeah,
- 1:19:11right, So rum Stat told the commandant or the commandant said, hey,
- 1:19:15we don't we marines, we don't do we don't do selection, right,
- 1:19:18you know, we're all marines, so I mean, we're all elite
- 1:19:21and and run Stot said, no, you need to do selection. But
- 1:19:26my point is that's kind of the feeling that we have is you know,
- 1:19:28hey, you're a marine. That's all you need, right, you don't
- 1:19:30need to write a book. But but as you you know, as you
- 1:19:33commented, I've been through you know, I lost my daughter and I just
- 1:19:39come back from to do rough deployment. And and the fact that that deployment
- 1:19:43was rough had nothing to do with the Islamic State. I had everything to
- 1:19:46do with the US Army conventional chain of command. And I was, yeah,
- 1:19:54I was in a state of angst. I'd compumpmentalize this tragedy during my
- 1:19:58deployment. Now I confronted with it, and writing was the one escape I
- 1:20:02could find. And I sat down and wrote or you know, two to
- 1:20:09three hours every morning, and afterwards I always felt better. You know,
- 1:20:12even when I was going to work, I would get up early and write
- 1:20:15for an hour and then at the end of the day, and just getting
- 1:20:19in that routine I really think helped me. You know, you very wisely
- 1:20:26talked about counseling at the beginning of this. When I was on active duty,
- 1:20:28I never went to counseling, but that was my that was my former
- 1:20:33counseling was writing. It was cathartic, but to your point. Yet,
- 1:20:40you know, if you having made a decision to write about a book,
- 1:20:43you've got to be honest, and that is the hardest part, you know,
- 1:20:48the first couple of drafts. You know, I showed it to friends,
- 1:20:50and a good friend of mine, Worth Parker, said he, look,
- 1:20:54do you want this to be just kind of a hey, really cool
- 1:20:59leadership, you know, narrative and story or do you want to do you
- 1:21:03want people to know what it's really like, really like to lead in a
- 1:21:08shitty place like Karma. You know, when your orders are not always very
- 1:21:13clear. Then you know, your brigade headquarters is like eighty miles away and
- 1:21:19you're getting hit every day. And by the way, you're being told to
- 1:21:23turn over to the Rockies in six months and you're out of that, you
- 1:21:26know, I mean, these are not these are not lessons that you can
- 1:21:30answer from right from the book right and that is where you own your commission,
- 1:21:35you know, in places like that. And one of the things is,
- 1:21:39even though you did grow up to join the marine, the American Marine
- 1:21:44Corps, you grew up with you know, as as a brit with what
- 1:21:49we would think of a classical education. So you know, so yes,
- 1:21:56you eventually joined the crayon eating brigade. But but but there, but there,
- 1:22:02but there's an eloquence and and and uh and a love of words behind
- 1:22:10your writing that really expresses a lot of that. Well, you know,
- 1:22:14I think so my parents, God bless them. I mean my my parents
- 1:22:19who were products of the second one ward they met from the Second War.
- 1:22:23In fact, my father's British and it was met my mother while he was
- 1:22:28on liberty in New York, you know, as a as a reversal to
- 1:22:30the many Gis who are coming over and married US women. But I mean
- 1:22:36British women. But my point is they really really wanted me to have a
- 1:22:41head start in British society, and so they sent me to a very very
- 1:22:45exclusive school. I was expelled from that school, spent a year in the
- 1:22:50Philippines for my but but then was accepted back to another school and was feeling
- 1:22:58bad enough by this time, I'm having disappointed my parents that I wanted to
- 1:23:01do well, and so I you know, I so my point is I
- 1:23:05had a tremendous education. I went through the British schooling system, university,
- 1:23:13law school, and then enlisted as a private in the Marine Corps. You
- 1:23:17remember boot camp, right, how how just how childish boot camp is?
- 1:23:25Right? But it does the Marine Corps. I mean, how old were
- 1:23:28you when you went through boot camp. It's nineteen oh, I see,
- 1:23:30you're pretty much a kid anyway. Yeah, but it does an a Marine
- 1:23:33Corps boot camp compared to any other I can't speak to Air Force boot camp,
- 1:23:38but I can speak to it's a well, Army and Navy. But
- 1:23:41but Marine Corps boot camp does. They don't call it boot camp in the
- 1:23:44athols, it's just it's same and I mean it's basic training. In the
- 1:23:47Army it's or yeah. But but Marine Corps boot camp does something that the
- 1:23:54other services don't do as well, which is create marines. Like like it
- 1:24:00breaks you down to the point of when your drill instructor is walking you across
- 1:24:08the parade grounds to your graduation on that final day and he says, you're
- 1:24:12going to go in there and some officer that doesn't know you is going to
- 1:24:15be the says that he's proud to be the first to call you United States
- 1:24:18Marines. You know that's bullshit. He goes, I'm the one, and
- 1:24:23this is a guy who's been calling you, you know, maggot, shithead
- 1:24:28and dirt bag and all this, you know, the entire Like, the
- 1:24:30Marine Corps does that in such I think an effective way to create that you
- 1:24:35know, sort of that that camaraderie that has spree of corps. You know,
- 1:24:42they have that down to a science. And yeah, you know,
- 1:24:45I mean I was young. I wasn't as young as as you know.
- 1:24:49I had a year out in the world, which isn't a lot, but
- 1:24:54but it's hard to even remove yourself from that when, you know, when
- 1:25:00when it's done so effectively, Yeah, it's I mean, it is basically
- 1:25:08a boot camp, relies on the same indoctrination techniques as the you know,
- 1:25:14Chinese and the Korean War with prisoners. In fact, there was comments by
- 1:25:19prisoners of the Chinese that that, you know, that dreatment reminded them a
- 1:25:25little bit of boot camp. By that, I mean, you know,
- 1:25:28the constant chanting, the repetition. I mean, it's all in doctrination.
- 1:25:33But if you are a little bit older as I was twenty four, and
- 1:25:36you've had some experiences, then that part of it becomes quite tiresome, right,
- 1:25:42Yeah, yeah, for sure. I mean even worse than than being
- 1:25:46dogged on the quarter deck because I had you know, I had no problem
- 1:25:50with physical thinness. I had no problem with being away from home, but
- 1:25:55I found you know, I found the constant, just childish games, mentally
- 1:26:00wearing. You know. It was such relief, isn't it to get to
- 1:26:04the rifle range? And yeah, right and now and now you've got something.
- 1:26:09It's you and the rifle, you know. And the way the Marine
- 1:26:13Corps does that is is so beautifully designed, you know, they as you
- 1:26:17point out, you've broken down in first phase and when you get to the
- 1:26:19rifle range, you are in listened mode. And and all the punks who
- 1:26:26thought they were great shots, you know, and I went hunting with Daddy.
- 1:26:30Turn out turns out that they invariably are not the best at handling weapons.
- 1:26:33And so a lot of these kids who you know, maybe grew up
- 1:26:36in inner cities or even you know, women who never fight a weapon in
- 1:26:42their lives, turn out to be expert shots. And it's the first thing
- 1:26:46that they've achieved at boot Camp's yeah, that's one thing you do a boot
- 1:26:50camp that you don't get nowhere else is like that. How long was the
- 1:26:55snapping in? Was it a week or two weeks? Just just a week?
- 1:26:58Yeah, yeah, nothing but snapping in. But then that first shot
- 1:27:02down the range, down range, I mean first shot there was a four
- 1:27:05but at least I knew I was near that, you know, I was
- 1:27:08astounded, and you know, at two hundred meters because even you know later
- 1:27:14two hundred meters seems like not a great distance, but when you are first
- 1:27:17time shooting, that's a small round ball. And then when you go back
- 1:27:20to the and DS what snapping in is and so one of the things you
- 1:27:26know, and that was without sites. I mean, we didn't remember that
- 1:27:30was now now they all I don't know why why did they qualify with with
- 1:27:34sites? There was something about learning to shoot with iron sights back at five
- 1:27:40hundred meters where you can barely see that front tip, you know, and
- 1:27:44you know just to lay it against the man shaped target and when it does
- 1:27:47so, it just covers up that black completely. You know, that that
- 1:27:50feeling, that memory, it stays with you for life, and it teaches
- 1:27:55you you don't you don't have to be taught about marksmanship again. Right up
- 1:28:00to going through them, No, no, and so D asked what snapping
- 1:28:03in was. And for people who hadn't been, who hadn't been Marines,
- 1:28:06because they don't do this, I don't remember them doing in the army.
- 1:28:10I don't think they did. But you spend like a week of basically dry
- 1:28:15firing, where you learn the sling, the sling positions for each you know
- 1:28:19how to create that tension with the sling in uh what was it, the
- 1:28:25standing, the kneeling, the sitting, and the prone and and you spend
- 1:28:31a week doing nothing but dry firing on barrels, which, believe it or
- 1:28:40not, is a huge advantage when you actually go to to start shooting.
- 1:28:45To put that in, to put that in context, right, so you
- 1:28:49can imagine San Diego or Paras Island and you are outside six seven hours and
- 1:28:58all you're doing with your weapon, and you've got it. You've got a
- 1:29:00tight loot sling right on your on your upper arm, and you are just
- 1:29:05practicing, by the numbers, dry firing your weapon. It is the most
- 1:29:11incredibly boring, painful thing. But yeah, I mean the Marine Corps knows
- 1:29:16how to teach how to shoot, and you think about it, Dave twenty
- 1:29:19thousand. Twenty thousand recruits go through basic training every year ninety eight percent qualification
- 1:29:28rate. Now I don't know how they're doing this, but sixty percent expert.
- 1:29:32I mean, they it's really you know, they of course they're shooting
- 1:29:38with with scopes. That's why I think is you know, that kind of
- 1:29:41skews the statistics a little bit. You want us purists want to go back
- 1:29:45to the basic because you can always teach someone to shoot with a scope.
- 1:29:48Sure, but you can't go back and teach someone to shoot with iron science.
- 1:29:53Yeah, or rather you have to write yeah, yeah, no,
- 1:29:56that's true that you know, learning side alinement, side pictures or things like
- 1:30:00that are are an important part of that process. But maybe they think that
- 1:30:03you know, you have a scope, you'll always have a scope, you
- 1:30:05know, an acog or an eotech or whatever it is you do. I
- 1:30:09don't know, but doesn't it doesn't it bother you a little bit? It
- 1:30:13does, But I also try not to be like the grumpy old man.
- 1:30:16It's like, well back to my day, you know what I mean?
- 1:30:19You know, yeah, like the like the guy who gets sold upset because
- 1:30:24the Sikhs are allowed to wear you know, turbans while in uniform, or
- 1:30:28or it's like you know, when I was a diver, it's like you
- 1:30:30know, it's like, well, if you didn't do a walk in a
- 1:30:34mark five you know, uh, you know, with with the big rig,
- 1:30:39then you don't know how to dive. It's like, well, nobody
- 1:30:41uses Mark five anymore. You know, It's just it was. It was
- 1:30:44a rite of passage. Yeah, but people have to keep dragging it up
- 1:30:48with sure. I mean I do though think that again, I think that
- 1:30:54learning how to shoot with ironsight's first. It is an important fundamental and foundation.
- 1:31:00But again I try not to get so caught up in the well they're
- 1:31:03not doing it right. I mean, it's the Marine. They know how
- 1:31:06to teach it. Listen, I think bout can. I think the Marine
- 1:31:11Corps is basic training much better now than when I went through. I mean,
- 1:31:15you know, I get it it. I mean when this was back
- 1:31:21in the eighties and so you know, I mean you went through paras Island,
- 1:31:26right, I know I went through Sando eighty nine. Oh okay,
- 1:31:29okay, I'm sorry, but but you know, back in the even back
- 1:31:34in the eighties, which isn't that long ago, Third Battalion paras Island was
- 1:31:40off the charts as far as you know, just breaking the sop. It
- 1:31:45was. It was standard. And I am not you know, I'm not
- 1:31:50exagerating. I was, you know, I was. I was deed and
- 1:31:56hard enough that I threw up, you know, by biodron instructor who was
- 1:32:01on the Marine Corps boxing team, so he knew how to hit. Sadly,
- 1:32:04you know, I had bear him no no ill feeling he was.
- 1:32:10I still remember him sadly he called himself just a few years ago. But
- 1:32:15but my point is that that was kind of the norm. You know,
- 1:32:17I've got a scar here from from having my my head ground into or just
- 1:32:26my forehead ground into the side of my rack, for not doing hospital corner
- 1:32:30correctly. Do these things make us better? I doubt it. You know,
- 1:32:35that's the thing. I think that a lot more attention is spent now
- 1:32:40on actually teaching people things right, infantry skills, things they need to know.
- 1:32:46You know, we've talked about your time in the Marine Corps and after
- 1:32:51a lot. One story that I think we touched upon one time but really
- 1:32:55didn't go into detail was Libya and your your ex Phil from Libya. Can
- 1:33:03you can you can you lay this out? Give us give us yeah?
- 1:33:06Yeah, the before absolutely. Yeah. So So the year is twenty eleven,
- 1:33:14right, it's the Arab Spring, and I'm at Socks Special Special Operations.
- 1:33:19No I'm not. I'm at Soccure Special Operations Command Europe. As that
- 1:33:24sucks later and I am you know, I'm a lieutenant colonel action officer in
- 1:33:30the J three. But at socks soccure back then. As you know,
- 1:33:34in a lot of te socks special operations commands, you have a team that
- 1:33:42is always on standby right in case something happens within the ao R. They
- 1:33:45want to be able to say, hey, we've got a team down there
- 1:33:48in soft guys with communicators, blah blah blah. And you know, typically
- 1:33:51it's a feel great officer, a communications guy, and two or three other
- 1:33:56guys, and that's they're kind of the nucleus if the TESC then needs to
- 1:34:02send in a you know, a headquarters or a GTF or they're expected just
- 1:34:09to represent the DESARC by themselves. So anyway, Libya, Libya is coming
- 1:34:15to ship. It's getting bombed. Gaddafi is Gnafi's forces are holed up in
- 1:34:23Tripoli and rebel forces are closing in on the capitol. The capital is getting
- 1:34:28hit by artillery. Twenty thousand Sudanese workers are trying to get out through TRIPLEI
- 1:34:34Airport. It is chaos. Militia are beating them back and the European Union
- 1:34:44mounts a NEO basically European unions. No no, no, no, no,
- 1:34:49no, let me let me get that straight. Actually there was a
- 1:34:51British The British really spearheaded it and they commanded it with they headquarters from pj
- 1:35:01HQ. They sent it out to Malta and then it tended and then European
- 1:35:06it was kind of European Union nations that formed the nucleus around that. So
- 1:35:11it wasn't a new EU operation. It was a British operation with the kind
- 1:35:15of a loose affiliation of European nations supporting it. Thank you. Can you
- 1:35:20tell us what a NEO is, Andy, Yeah, it's a non non
- 1:35:25combatant evacuation operation. So within Tripoli itself there were tens of thousands of foreigners
- 1:35:32who needed to get out and the city was, you know, extremely dangerous.
- 1:35:38The US embassy had already left. They wasted no time. They got
- 1:35:42down to malten and then realized that there were a lot of US citizens left
- 1:35:46behind. I mean like thousands, you know, a lot of them living
- 1:35:48in Americans And so a task force was set up in d C connecting these
- 1:35:57people who are still left in TRIPLEI with the State that palm and who was
- 1:36:00saying, hey, sorry, you know but if you head to the airport,
- 1:36:02be able to find your way out. Well, Socure, headed by
- 1:36:09General Repass at the time, is buying with sock Ath. Right. Remember
- 1:36:15Special Operations Command Africa had just started under guy named General Hass, General Repass,
- 1:36:20General Hass. They're both Green Berets, but they hate each other and
- 1:36:26so they don't coordinate. You know, I mean it's you've seen this,
- 1:36:29Dave, right, it's just kind of unprofessional behavior, right, you know
- 1:36:32what I mean. Crisis and you've got two headquarters that are competing instead of
- 1:36:38collaborating, and you you want the other guy to drop the ball so that
- 1:36:42he looks like that's right. Yeah, So you know Libya is in Africa,
- 1:36:45right, but Malta, where the operation is is in Europe. So
- 1:36:49you can see there's clear there's there's ad buying lane and Repass is, hey,
- 1:36:55this is our ball game and you can't support it that and you cal'm
- 1:36:58deputy commander, send me down there, and you know with instructions, Hey,
- 1:37:01this is you know, this is Yukom's game pretty much. So at
- 1:37:08least we have we we obviously have staken it so you know, keep us
- 1:37:14informed. Well, I get there and the Brits turn to us right away
- 1:37:18because we're Americans, right, we must come with all the resources. But
- 1:37:21it's just me and the radio operator because the other dude missed this light.
- 1:37:29But what we do have is we've got a long list of people that we
- 1:37:32want evacuated because we're in contact now with the State parmitent DC and they're like,
- 1:37:38hey, can you get these people out? And so we've got all
- 1:37:41these European countries offering their their aircraft or you know, the military aircraft by
- 1:37:47into triple and we're trying to get Americans on those aircraft. Right, So
- 1:37:53it's kind of reverse all the roles. It's not the US's backbone. We
- 1:37:56are, you know, we're kind of party crashes and we're trying I mean,
- 1:38:00but but you know, everyone's supportive. Everyone wants to get all the
- 1:38:03foreigners out of that. But every country is probably going to give their own
- 1:38:09citizens priority. And that becomes an issue because we we I'm on the phone.
- 1:38:16We get one other person out to help us, who's from Sarkath.
- 1:38:20Right. Female turns out to my memorane and she's very useful too. She's
- 1:38:25manning the phone with the State Department, and so they're giving us names and
- 1:38:29numbers. We're contacting those people in triple and giving them directions to the airport
- 1:38:33in Tripoli, and then we're working with the guys you know around us to
- 1:38:40to make sure that the you know, the flight's going in, uh know,
- 1:38:45that they're picking up these these Americans. Right It's it gets incredibly complicated
- 1:38:49because no foreigners can make it through to the tarmac because of all the you
- 1:38:55know, Ganafi's goons. So we need to start sending guys in diplomats to
- 1:39:00help escort people out to the planes. Otherwise they're just not going to get
- 1:39:03out. And things are really turning to ship now. You know, you're
- 1:39:06getting artillery land around the airport that off these guys are getting increasingly belligerent and
- 1:39:12aggressive, and desperation level among those you know, people trapped in the building
- 1:39:19and the airport building is also rising. And you've got these twenty thousand Sudanese
- 1:39:25still surrounding the whole area, just ramping up the tension, and there's and
- 1:39:30they're starting to you know, get froggy and flight with the militia into this
- 1:39:36into all of this comes an American family, right, and I get a
- 1:39:43call. They've got you know, two kids, blah blah blah, and
- 1:39:46I'm talking them in to the airport and at the same time trying to get
- 1:39:53them a flight. And there's you know, there's a Bulgarian plane that is
- 1:40:00supposed to you know, pick them up, but something happens they're forced to
- 1:40:03leave. And so this this family stranded. Well, we've got an Italian
- 1:40:08flight coming in. But the problem is now that there are no diplomats volunteering
- 1:40:14to help her school people out because it is becoming really hazardous. So the
- 1:40:17brit said, hey, we'll put some of our guys in. You know,
- 1:40:21we'll give the British embassy vests military guys, and but we we could
- 1:40:27use an American right because these are Americans. So I said, okay,
- 1:40:31you know, I'll go, but I'm not. I can't wear an American
- 1:40:34vest. Fucking I'm not coming out, so you know, give me a
- 1:40:39British one. So I did. So I went in with the British Embassy
- 1:40:42you know, vest and everything, and it looked legit by some This is
- 1:40:47where it started to turn weird. So we we landed. Uh, and
- 1:40:51it's exactly as expected, you know it is. It's like mad Max.
- 1:40:57I mean, there's these dudes tearing around the tarmac in in uh tech technicals,
- 1:41:01yeah, with you know, flags, yelling weird shit, you know,
- 1:41:08obviously hostile towards us, but but keeping but aware that you know,
- 1:41:13we are protected to some extent. But then as we you know, I
- 1:41:19start walking towards the tarmac, the I mean towards the airport buildings with these
- 1:41:23two other breads and these good offye militia guys intercept us, and they they
- 1:41:30start talking to the other two. The other two have they do have legitimate
- 1:41:35ID cards, right Obviously I don't. So they get so they let them
- 1:41:41go on and they're like, why do you haven't I said, look,
- 1:41:42I don't know. I'd left back there, so you're British blah blah blah,
- 1:41:45and they started. One of them had lived in London. Of course
- 1:41:48it's Louis, you know, living ins in London, and no kidding,
- 1:41:55he started asking me where I had lived, blah blah blah. Unfortunately,
- 1:41:59I mean I have them in London. They clearly he knew it very well
- 1:42:01and he knew really spookling a new kind of the area where I had been.
- 1:42:08But but I passed. I seem to pass that test because he was
- 1:42:11like, yeah, yeah, okay, good to go. You ask me
- 1:42:13what football team I support? Whatever? We you know, we fist bumped
- 1:42:16and I walked onto the building and there's a Bulgarian diplomat there and I said,
- 1:42:25hey, do you know where the Americans are? There's an American family
- 1:42:28I'm looking for because I was. I was really worried. But that was
- 1:42:31a big mistake because I said it out loud, obviously and it was overheard,
- 1:42:36I think, because I think that's why. As we walked back,
- 1:42:41so the American family was there and and we got them out. The Bulgarian
- 1:42:48led them out to the plane and I was following and the same the same
- 1:42:54Canafi dudes come back and they they stopped right in front of me and they
- 1:42:58just said, get in the get they they've changed their athletics has changed to
- 1:43:02get in the GEP. I went, why, you know, I'm paid
- 1:43:05this and I'm going to go back with these guys and like you you're not
- 1:43:09You're an American and I went no, no, no, we already talked
- 1:43:13about this and I and now I'm edging towards the plane because my heart's just
- 1:43:16hammering, and one of them makes a grab at me, and I just
- 1:43:20I run, you know everything, I knew they wouldn't start. I didn't
- 1:43:27know. I didn't think they were going to start shooting because the plane was
- 1:43:30there, and you know, so I run up the tailgate. There's Italians.
- 1:43:33It's an Italian plane. H Bulgarian wine left, there's an Italian plane.
- 1:43:40There's Italian soldiers on the tailgate. There's about four or five soft guys
- 1:43:45and I just run past them. And they've got weapons, but there's there's
- 1:43:48no way they're going to you know, hundreds of and I but I just
- 1:43:55say, you know, I say hey quickly, they hey, they're after
- 1:43:57me. I'm just gonna hang out here for a bit. Well they you
- 1:44:01know, I get on the plane. They don't come on the plane.
- 1:44:04And I figured it because it's Italian. And remember Libya has a strange relationship
- 1:44:10with the Italians. It's kind of love hate, but it's very close at
- 1:44:13this time, and Gadaffi in particular is hoping to have an escape laws with
- 1:44:16the Italians. So I think that's why they didn't storm the plane or you
- 1:44:19know, drag me off. But we're waiting there, and they surround the
- 1:44:24plane, you know, these other they call in, you know, other
- 1:44:28vehicles, and they it's getting dark and they put on their lights and they're
- 1:44:31just like yelling and come on out, and some of it in English.
- 1:44:35We're gonna get you, motherfucker. And I'm just sitting there feeling. First
- 1:44:42of all, I'm feeling like a coward a little bit because I'm among women
- 1:44:46and children. I run onto a plane, but you know, I no
- 1:44:50regrets. I mean, that's self preservation. I had to do that,
- 1:44:55otherwise I would have disappeared forever, you know. And I knew that they
- 1:44:59might hold up plane, but I knew they weren't going to execute, you
- 1:45:01know, or do anything to the people on the plane. But I knew
- 1:45:04too it was my only chance Saturday that if I left that plane, I
- 1:45:08was done for. You know. It wasn't like I would show up again
- 1:45:11somewhere, right, yeah. Yeah. But it was getting you know,
- 1:45:15I was thinking, what's going to happen? Are they're going to let it
- 1:45:17take off? You know, It's just awful feeling. And the pilot came
- 1:45:25back and sat down. I thought, shit, he's going to keep me
- 1:45:29off this plane, which I off. Just refuse and you know, I
- 1:45:32explain what's going on, he said, to my great relief, he said,
- 1:45:35well, don't get off the plane. You know, this is Italian,
- 1:45:40this is Italian soil. They're not going to come on. We'll wait
- 1:45:43it out. They got to let us go sooner or later. I'm like,
- 1:45:46okay, I hope you're right. But the ramping up and the noise
- 1:45:49outside it doesn't sound, you know, too good, and it sounds frankly,
- 1:45:54so they're going to storm the plane. And why wouldn't they, you
- 1:45:57know, I mean, there's no there's no government left, there's no repercussions
- 1:46:00that they just come on and grab me. And I think they're starting to
- 1:46:02think through this because they're getting nearer. And then the pilot comes back and
- 1:46:09he says, hey, I've got authorization too. You know, I reported
- 1:46:14this. I had to report out my chain of command because I can't make
- 1:46:16it back to Malta now in time. I've got to go back to Rome.
- 1:46:19I've been told to pay, you know, to let us let us
- 1:46:25take off, and he goes, I got to you know, water cash
- 1:46:28here. He had a whole bag. Clearly they anticipated some kind of issue,
- 1:46:33and he walked off, you know, he's escorted by the militia dudes
- 1:46:39into the office and he's he goes off with one of the soldiers when they
- 1:46:45you know, the Italian soldiers, and he's gone for an eternity. And
- 1:46:53he comes back eventually, and he says, okay, we're in the clear.
- 1:46:57Let's get off. Let's take off. And it goes front and we
- 1:47:00we you know, we start to he starts to wind up the engines and
- 1:47:05everything. We start to move, and then these bustards come out and block
- 1:47:10the plane again, and clearly they've decided whatever the fuck happened back then,
- 1:47:15it doesn't apply to them, right, And there was some other other argument
- 1:47:20that going on up front, with the pilot yelling out of the window,
- 1:47:25and some reason, the jeeps pulled aside and we took off and someone you
- 1:47:32know, they one of the crew members next to me, the load master,
- 1:47:38you know, because I was just like, oh, thank god,
- 1:47:40And the load master said, hey, man, you know Italian. He
- 1:47:43didn't say man, he said, hey, there is still there's an eighty
- 1:47:45eighth bread. We've got word that that we we are that shots were taken
- 1:47:54earlier and I forget what the system was. And at you know, the
- 1:47:59Bulgarian plane is taken off. So we we're concerned about this. I'll think,
- 1:48:01fund wish you hadn't told me that, But nevertheless, you know,
- 1:48:04I mean, when we get the work, we're outside Libyan airspace. I
- 1:48:09I just I've never felt relief like that, you know, I mean I
- 1:48:12was I thought my career was over, but I didn't care, Yeah,
- 1:48:15because you know, I was under orders, all of us around the orders.
- 1:48:17No Americans would would go into Libya and I wouldn't have except you know,
- 1:48:25I mean, this was one of those situations. What are you going
- 1:48:27to do? What's anyone going to do? I mean, leave the family
- 1:48:29there. I mean it's you know, that's is that there were a lot
- 1:48:33of Americans in Libya, both Libying Americans and like American nationals, you know,
- 1:48:42like straight up American national Not that Libyan Americans aren't, but you know
- 1:48:45what I mean, but but you know they can't blend in. That's that's
- 1:48:48really. But we have we have the one hundred and seventy third of the
- 1:48:53China. That is that is really you know, they are supposed to be
- 1:48:57a you know, I don't want to say a special operations unit, but
- 1:49:01they're but they're they're supposed to be right there at the peak of that to
- 1:49:05be able to respond to those threats quickly. You have fifth cores. I
- 1:49:11think in Germany you have tenth Special Forces, you have third Special Forces.
- 1:49:15Why, if there's a way to do this without being political, why in
- 1:49:24a in a non combatant evacuation scenario like that, when the MBSC has already
- 1:49:30d D mound, why is our government leaving all these Americans to It's yeah,
- 1:49:36it's an absurd It seems like an absurd decision, Dave. You know
- 1:49:42when you think about all the things that we've taken risk for in our lives,
- 1:49:46and most of those most of those risks involved, I didn't know,
- 1:49:51taking an objective doing ex but the tactical tasks not saving American lives right right,
- 1:49:59and and so there is no it. I find it extremely frustrating that
- 1:50:03then I'm in this situation where we really could have used dudes with weapons doing
- 1:50:09what we are trained to do, secure the area, you know, established
- 1:50:14the evacuation assembly points and all of this stuff. But we didn't. And
- 1:50:21I think we looked, you know, I felt embarrassed at times being an
- 1:50:28American there because we were we were begging off of others, you know,
- 1:50:33to carry our load. Basically. Yeah, yeah, I'm not embarrassed to
- 1:50:38be an American, you know. I know what you mean though, that
- 1:50:42it's it's sort of like they're going into these situations. How come we aren't.
- 1:50:46Yeah, we wanted say something out of it, we needed we needed
- 1:50:49something out of it, but we weren't prepared to Roger about resources for me.
- 1:50:55And sorry, and and and we're talking here specifically. We're not talking
- 1:51:00about some you know, random US objective. We're talking about saving actual American
- 1:51:06lives, of pulling them out of out of these perilous situations. Yeah,
- 1:51:14there's really very there can be very few less ambiguous missions than than a neo.
- 1:51:21Uh right, but you know, I so, so it didn't end
- 1:51:26my career. I ended my career events, but but but it could well
- 1:51:31have. And uh and and thanks to Repass and a few other people,
- 1:51:35thanks to the ambassador actually, because what what happened? You know? So
- 1:51:43I the plane landed in Rome, right, I'm supposed to be back in
- 1:51:46Malta. I'm supposed to be reporting the Defense attache every evening giving her an
- 1:51:51update. But I'm not I mean now in Rome and it's midnight, and
- 1:51:56worse than that, news has already got out that there was an American on
- 1:51:59the ground in Tripoli. But something happened in my favor that was almost inconsequential,
- 1:52:08and that was earlier in the day when a Bulgarian well I'm sorry earlier,
- 1:52:13yeah, earlier in the day, as I was walking when I first
- 1:52:18got off the aircraft, before the Bulgarian aircraft got off, there was an
- 1:52:23argument going on over there, and I walked over and it was it was
- 1:52:28a group of five or six people dressed in traditional African dress trying to get
- 1:52:33on the plane, and the Bulgarians were saying, hey, no, you
- 1:52:36know you're not blah blah blah blah. But I spoke to the you know,
- 1:52:41the kind of the one of these guys, and apparently it was the
- 1:52:44ambassador to Sierra Leone and his diplomatic party, and the Bulgarians didn't speak very
- 1:52:48good English, so they didn't understand, so I explained it. Anyway,
- 1:52:51This happened in I don't know, thirty forty five seconds, and they let
- 1:52:56them on the plane and that's when I went on, Well, this guy,
- 1:53:00God bless him. You know. He gets back to Malta and the
- 1:53:03first thing he does he calls the US ambassador, who he knows, and
- 1:53:09he says, thank you so much for sending that guy health there to you
- 1:53:14know, he was a life saver. He got us out of there.
- 1:53:15We probably wouldn't have got out there. Sent ambassadors like an American, are
- 1:53:19you sure? And so the ambassador calls in the defense attash and says,
- 1:53:25do we have Tell me we don't have an American on the ground in Tripoli
- 1:53:30and uh and and the defense attache, who's still a fering, said,
- 1:53:38sir, I know, we don't. Andy Morman is at the at the
- 1:53:43Neo Center, we don't have anyone in Marta. Yeah. But then she
- 1:53:46walked out and she thought, hm hmm. She thought about it that evening.
- 1:53:53The next morning, she drove out in the Neo Center and asked and
- 1:53:57asked where I was at that moment. I'm not lying. I walked in
- 1:54:00the other door. I just caught an early flight from Rome landed in Malta.
- 1:54:04I looked like dog shit, you know. It was a one shave
- 1:54:08and talking and I walk in the other side of the door, and she
- 1:54:10goes, she's just silent and beckons and she goes, Okay, don't even
- 1:54:16tell me a story, just tell me the truth. And she goes,
- 1:54:19were you and tripley? And I went yeah, and she goes, are
- 1:54:23you out of your mind? You know, you know you're going to be
- 1:54:26lucky to get away with Article fifteen. Blah blah blah blah, anyway,
- 1:54:30the whole and she goes back to the embassy and goes into the ambassador and
- 1:54:40says, I'm so sorry, sir, you know I was wrong. We
- 1:54:43did have an American underground. To his credit, he doesn't lose his mind.
- 1:54:47He says, is he okay? And Jane goes, yeah, he's
- 1:54:51back here, and he goes, well, good, thank him. That's
- 1:54:56all they need to know. And that was it. And then much later
- 1:55:00I got a I mean about a week later, when I was on the
- 1:55:02way to the airport, I got a call from the embassy saying, Hey,
- 1:55:08I'm just wondering if you have time available now, because the ambassador would
- 1:55:12love to meet you. Like how often does an ambassador do that? Oh,
- 1:55:15I've just got empty time. I'm like, oh, you know,
- 1:55:17I want to see that dude, something like shit, I said in my
- 1:55:20end trouble, and you know it's like he said, no, no,
- 1:55:25no, he just wants to he wants to thank you. You can thank
- 1:55:29him, and you know, I really appreciate it. So that that guy
- 1:55:32who's nameless is a hero to me. And General repasses too, because of
- 1:55:39course he had heard about it when I got back. But it went no
- 1:55:43further when you know, Yukom, I believe the Yukon deputy command in you
- 1:55:47and repassed new but it. Yeah, so so when you were deployed from
- 1:55:54soccure, you were sent to Malta, which is where you were supposed to
- 1:55:58park your ass. That's right, and that's exactly coordinate, uh and receive
- 1:56:03any Americans. But there was nobody on the ground in Tripoli, and that
- 1:56:12was the missing piece. Yeah, So what were what we were doing to
- 1:56:15begin with, David, is we were using the Irish and Swedes and the
- 1:56:19Brits, so they had diplomats in the building and it and but then the
- 1:56:26Swedes, you know, the Swede said it was too dangerous for them,
- 1:56:30and then we were counting on the Irish to help the you know, the
- 1:56:33the Americans on this one flight, but like two hours before they got the
- 1:56:41word that they were they weren't allowed to go back into TRIPLEI either. It
- 1:56:45was just becoming too too dangerous. Uh And and so you know, it's
- 1:56:49two Brits and they had to deal with a ton of other civilians. That
- 1:56:56wasn't anyone who would spend the time locating these Americans. You know, as
- 1:57:00it happened, I didn't really need to locate them. You know, as
- 1:57:03it happened, they probably would have been Okay, I've got to be honest
- 1:57:05about this, But I didn't know that. Sure, you know, I
- 1:57:09didn't know that. And and I've been talking to I being the one talking
- 1:57:13to them, I being the one assuring them, you know. And so
- 1:57:16when when that link, when that touch point of hey, this Irish diplomat
- 1:57:20is going to meet you here his names, when that guy disappears, you
- 1:57:25know, I'm unless it's me, I don't have trust in the process,
- 1:57:30right, They're going to come out too many bad things are happening all that
- 1:57:33time. And why, I mean, why did the Europeans. I know
- 1:57:39you mentioned the relationship between uh Libya and it's particularly Goodafi and Italy, but
- 1:57:47why did Bulgaria. Why did these other European countries. Yeah, that's a
- 1:57:54good question. I was going to ask if if it was because because you
- 1:57:59know, for a while, we led godoffy on right the United States.
- 1:58:01We're like, hey, if you get this stuff squared away, you're okay.
- 1:58:08And Gadaffi went out of his way to get squared away and felt,
- 1:58:13I think he felt like the US that he was in, he was in
- 1:58:16okay with the US. He had done, he had complied to everything that
- 1:58:19we had asked him to do. And then we basically said, okay,
- 1:58:24you know what, good job, screw you were out. Yeah, and
- 1:58:28so was there was there like a bit of of contention then with with with
- 1:58:33United States military and diplomats. None, that's all nothing but the most professional
- 1:58:43and and you know, it's just a great group of guys, David,
- 1:58:47those guys like you and me. I mean, that's what made this operation
- 1:58:50fun because it was ald military dudes from different countries, right, making shit
- 1:58:57happen, without a plan, without formal structure. It was literally, hey
- 1:59:01i've got a plane coming in, you know the Irish guy. This actually
- 1:59:05happened. Hey we've got the Prime Minister's plane he's given it to us for
- 1:59:10this evacuation mission. We're flying it in just outside Tripley and we'll pick up
- 1:59:15this French family, you know, who's driven out there in a car and
- 1:59:19fly back. And this is like an a sesna, you know. Yeah,
- 1:59:23I mean, people are using all kinds of aircraft just to get civilians
- 1:59:27out. And and the fact that no one was saying, well, we
- 1:59:30can't do that, blah blah blah. It was it doesn't matter, It
- 1:59:32doesn't matter what nationality. By what I meant though, or what I was
- 1:59:35asking Andy, was you know, obviously Bulgaria, Ireland, these other countries
- 1:59:41could send their people in even Yeah. But but was there a reason that
- 1:59:46that the US like you as a when when they thought that you were,
- 1:59:49you know, a US soldier or diplomat. Was there a reason why the
- 1:59:54US was singled out? Is it because Goadaffi felt that like the US had
- 1:59:58stabbed him in the back. Were these other euro Pink countries were given a
- 2:00:01little bit more leeway? That's a really good question. You know, I
- 2:00:04hadn't I hadn't thought about that. But but what you just said is is
- 2:00:10is right? Of course, you know, I mean, we I think
- 2:00:15are the way we let things happen with Gadaffi was foolish, very foolish and
- 2:00:23after pretty much like yeah, lined up to what we had asked them to
- 2:00:27do. Yeah, and uh and and I think we lost a lot of
- 2:00:32Ustan Yeah, you know, I mean it was kind of the twenty eleven
- 2:00:35We lost a lot of sta anyway with the Syria red line stuff. Yeah,
- 2:00:41we were slow to react in Libya. We reacted in the wrong way.
- 2:00:45We weren't, you know. I mean it's yeah, and so the
- 2:00:48the they not it the neo was from the US perspective was you know,
- 2:00:55it was a the US did nothing except for US. I mean, uh,
- 2:01:00but I don't you know, all that just seems to be been washed
- 2:01:04away, No one really, right, I mean, Libya is still a
- 2:01:10mess. Yeah, it's it's been causing problems since well since twenty eleven.
- 2:01:18Actually, yeah, I'm still curious about sort of the turn and policy and
- 2:01:24we made towards Godafi, you know. And the thing is, like Gadafi
- 2:01:28was no angel, just like Saddam was no angel. Like but but waiting
- 2:01:32for an angel to arise in some of those countries is you know, you
- 2:01:39you you look for stability, and you look for the people that. Yeah,
- 2:01:43that's you know, we mirror image too much then we we we think
- 2:01:46that everyone all they need is jet to Sonia democracy and they'll be happy.
- 2:01:50But you know, in the hierarchy of needs is you know, food and
- 2:01:55water and security and uh, you know, we saw that in a rock
- 2:01:59right off the invasion, right and we thought everyone would be ecstatic that Sadom
- 2:02:02was gone that actually they missed the security, well they would rather they were
- 2:02:08ecstatic at first, and then when there was no running water and no power
- 2:02:12and you know, you know people, you know, you don't blame countries
- 2:02:16for having sort of this short term memory when they're when they're back to sort
- 2:02:21of living like peasants. You know, it's like, yes, Saddam is
- 2:02:26a dictator, but the chance that that is going to affect my life is
- 2:02:32minimal compared to you know, everybody shares this common kind of Yeah, yeah,
- 2:02:40that's right. The sense the feeling of anarchy is is far more dislocating
- 2:02:48than the feeling of living within a tyranny. Sure, and esoty political states.
- 2:03:00Conditions mean nothing when you are when you're struggling with those basics. Yeah,
- 2:03:05I think that's a really interesting point. Dave. Yeah, hey do
- 2:03:09do we do we have any questions on Patreon? Okay, So first off,
- 2:03:14Jesse Oda, thank you very much for subscribing to the channel. We
- 2:03:15really appreciate. And Corbyn, thank you very much. How do you see
- 2:03:19the US adapting to a more multi polar world? Mm hmm, well,
- 2:03:29I'd like to see US adapt at all. You know, I think I
- 2:03:33think I'm pausing his or not just saying something vacuous. You know, we
- 2:03:44we we bemoan the kind of the lack of US leadership in the world,
- 2:03:50but the world still looks to the US leadership, you know. I mean
- 2:03:56after Gaza, after seven October, you know, no one cared what Putin
- 2:04:01or China had to say. Everyone was rooted to you know, what is
- 2:04:05the US going to do? And I mentioned that because I think that's a
- 2:04:11clear reminder that whatever we may think, you know, and there's talk now
- 2:04:15of potentially more isolationist approach, but whatever we may think, the world does
- 2:04:20still look to US leadership. And I, for one thing, that's a
- 2:04:24good thing, and I for one thing that we should provide that leadership.
- 2:04:28You know, we can bemoan that we can say, oh, we're better
- 2:04:30off by ourselves and we're not the world's policeman. Or we can say,
- 2:04:33hey, we're a superpower and this is kind of our responsibility and we need
- 2:04:39to suck it up and do it, you know. And because it's not
- 2:04:43as though we can just become a wallflower. You know, we are there.
- 2:04:47People have expectations, and if we don't meet those expectations, then we
- 2:04:53are worse off than before and we're losing our position. I know that sounds
- 2:04:57like a very facile thing to say, but I yes, suddenly, but
- 2:05:01that understanding, that understanding that we are the United States is still looked to
- 2:05:09as a leader whatever whatever dross. You know, we may be hearing about
- 2:05:15the non aligned countries and this and that. Yes, yes, the world
- 2:05:19is not as aligned as it was during the Cold Bowl. Yes the US
- 2:05:24is not you know, such a clear polar position of leadership as it was
- 2:05:30during the Cold bull Those times are gone. We need to adapt, but
- 2:05:32we are still expected to leave. It's interesting too, because you know,
- 2:05:36we talk about isolationism from sort of a political perspective or a sort of a
- 2:05:44policy perspective, right in the sense of if if a new president is elected,
- 2:05:51Will they become a more conservative president or whatever? Will they become more
- 2:05:56isolationists. But we also look at isolations from a perspective of I think during
- 2:06:02this administration we've lost eleven embassies in the last three and a half years,
- 2:06:09which leads to its own type of isolationism. Right, yeah, I mean
- 2:06:14not not putting, not bolstering the State Department, right, I mean the
- 2:06:21State Department is under resource that I think as is. You know, I
- 2:06:26don't mean to go down this road, but my point is that diplomacy,
- 2:06:31diplomacy is how we exert leadership, is how we demonstrate leadership. So we
- 2:06:35should be really, really cognizant of who we put in those positions, both
- 2:06:42political appointees and the guys that you know, the kind of ethos within the
- 2:06:45State Department, who we put in charge of the State Department. It'll be
- 2:06:50interesting interesting to see what So I agree, I agree with you. It's
- 2:06:57not a political decision, oh we're going to be isolatedious or not. It's
- 2:07:00it's kind of where do you stack your talent, where do you put your
- 2:07:04your your focus of the tension, right, And if we are going to
- 2:07:11be isolationist way or if we are going to cut ties more with the world,
- 2:07:15then why do we have such a massive military, right? You know,
- 2:07:19I mean these are uh. I I don't get like you, Dave.
- 2:07:26I don't get wound out by these these questions. I don't let politics
- 2:07:31get me in a state of you know, the same state of anxiety that
- 2:07:38that I see many people in. But I do, Yeah, I've obviously
- 2:07:42I have concerns. I'm just the cynic, you know. I mean,
- 2:07:44after honestly, after the after after watching Cabul fall the way it did,
- 2:07:49right, you know, it's I'm not focused on the mistakes in the last
- 2:07:55two years. I'm looking at just directtional list foreign policy of the last two
- 2:08:01decades, basically right, right, and and honestly, you know, the
- 2:08:07the uh you know, you talk about the the not the weakening of the
- 2:08:13IDF per se, or the weakening of the US military per se, but
- 2:08:18the weakening of the politicians and the policies. And we see that in the
- 2:08:22West or in America, going back since Vietnam, this idea of the troops
- 2:08:28on the ground can do everything you ask them to. They they they can.
- 2:08:31They can exceed in body count, they can exceed in objectives taken,
- 2:08:37but without a political plan, without an idea of what victory looks like,
- 2:08:45and without a political will, regardless of the administration and the politic you know,
- 2:08:50the the Republican or Democrat or whatever party you want to say, where
- 2:08:56where does that? Where does that leave soldiers in the United States military or
- 2:09:01the British military. Are the idea in these in these sort of Western leaning
- 2:09:05countries, are these these liberal democracies? I would say that it's really,
- 2:09:16you know, it this almost I mean, it would be a very boring
- 2:09:20book, but it's it almost invites the book to be written about it,
- 2:09:22because I do have feelings that the US military, and I probably the only
- 2:09:30fair to say that this applies to to other Western militaries is carries a lot
- 2:09:37of dead weight. Let me just put it that way. And you know,
- 2:09:39I'm not talking about private Smucket Telly. You know you can't do three
- 2:09:43bullets. I'm just I'm saying that. I mean, think about it,
- 2:09:46twenty eight thousand people in the Pentagon. We should be solving we should be
- 2:09:52you know, cold fusion, world hunger. But I think I think those
- 2:09:58of us have been in the military, see how so much of that talent
- 2:10:03gets wasted in process, right. I mean, this is what I'm saying
- 2:10:07is that the US military has become a bureaucracy. It has to be a
- 2:10:13bureaucracy. But the problem is that a bureaucracy I think has sapped its war
- 2:10:16fighting ability. And I can't show proof for that, but I can tell
- 2:10:22you anecdotally that that among officers, even combat arms officers, I encounter,
- 2:10:33even in the Marine Corps, a very high concern for risk, you know,
- 2:10:41a very a focus on risk. So you know, so they almost
- 2:10:46became center stage finding reasons not to do things rather than to do things.
- 2:10:54And you know, this became even among other otherwise very competent, talented officers
- 2:11:00kind of became the norm. It's it is rare to come across truly innovative
- 2:11:07feeling, innovative thinking in the military, Dave, wouldn't you agree, Yes,
- 2:11:11outside and it's not I mean, it's not that it doesn't exist.
- 2:11:16It's not that there are not n c os and officers that are capable of
- 2:11:20innovative thinking. It's that it's that somebody has to approve their plans, and
- 2:11:26and whoever is approving their plans has a career that they're worried about and how
- 2:11:33they look and look. I don't know what happened in the IDF with with
- 2:11:37the with the officers that ignored the intelligence, but we know that in Afghanistan
- 2:11:43and Iraq, I don't think one officer over the rank of five suffered from
- 2:11:50decisions made or are lies told or I can't think of the single officer who
- 2:12:00was fired for tanctical incompetence. Correct, Now, officers were fired when people
- 2:12:07got killed for you know, in fire support negligence, right, yes,
- 2:12:13right, but not for tactical but general who went out there and basically made
- 2:12:18no headway during the war but said the adway was being made, none of
- 2:12:22them got fired. Yeah, yeah, that's very It's very true. I
- 2:12:26mean, it's it. The investigations looked at processes, right, but they
- 2:12:37didn't look at culture, right. And I think I think culture had a
- 2:12:41lot to do with our failure in Afghanistan. And I think, you know,
- 2:12:45it's lack of It was lack of honesty. You know, we always
- 2:12:48pride ourselves on integrity, but we were dishonest with ourselves again and again and
- 2:12:52again, commander to commander to commander every time. Oh hey, this place
- 2:12:58was ship when we came in. But you know we kind of turned it
- 2:13:01around in the air, and you know all these place names that we thought,
- 2:13:07uh, noble milestones of our success, you know, you name it
- 2:13:13Cargol to our Gomen. Yeah they're meaningless, of course, you know they
- 2:13:22were, and they were and that they were always in Teliban Teliban, hence
- 2:13:28we were printing it. Yeah. And the thing is we went to this
- 2:13:31to this sort of metrics or measurable war where you know, when you have
- 2:13:35people like Scott Man and these other people out there who are conducting these village
- 2:13:39stability operations that are showing they're they're showing progress, but that type of progress
- 2:13:46doesn't brief as well as how many bodies you stacked, That's right, Yeah,
- 2:13:52it is. So then their programs get shut down, you know,
- 2:13:54the cornerstone of counter grill operations get shut down where these direct action missions are.
- 2:14:01It's where it's at. I couldn't agree more. You know, it's
- 2:14:05the same thing with the Combine Action Civil I'm sorry, the civil action program
- 2:14:11in Vietnam. Right, the brand division tremendously successful, but but it was
- 2:14:20it got none of the publicity, you know, none at all. And
- 2:14:26those guys didn't get any of the kind of the glory, right, I
- 2:14:30mean, do you see do you see camp battle streamers on? Yeah,
- 2:14:35we had one of the CAP guys on our show, did you Yeah,
- 2:14:41And it was an it was an exceptionally successful program. But it's one of
- 2:14:46those things that hey, look, stability, stabilizing an area. It's boring.
- 2:14:52It's boring. Yeah, it's mundane, it's hard work, and success
- 2:14:56means it's quiet. Yeah. Yeah. And when you about, uh,
- 2:15:01the CAP program, you know, they were essentially simil Affairs guys. I
- 2:15:07mean, they were infantry guys, they were all they'd all been in hard
- 2:15:11combat and and in fact, the guys coming out of Casan while the CAP
- 2:15:16has kind of a you know, it's, hey, this is going to
- 2:15:18be a little easier. But it wasn't easy because it was during the time
- 2:15:22when when the villagers were coming under continuous attack and those CAP and the CAP
- 2:15:28guys were taking heavy casualties and they were there's a lot of heroic actions took
- 2:15:33place with you know, the Silver, the the CAP platoons and you know,
- 2:15:41the popular forces, the rough puff village protection guys. It's but you're
- 2:15:46right, a really and and and this, and despite all the failures in
- 2:15:54Vietnam, here was the nugget of success. Just the same in Afghanistan.
- 2:16:01But we'll ignore those, right, we didn't learn right, We did learn
- 2:16:05from camp, but we tried to implement it again. We not just in
- 2:16:09Afghanistan, but the Marine Corps did in Iraq with some success, you know,
- 2:16:13but focused focus not so much on the on the agriculture, but but
- 2:16:22embedding, you know, with the police, but also helping local the local
- 2:16:26economy. You know, the Marine Corps doesn't have our own civil affairs guys,
- 2:16:28so it was our you know, it's basically our company, commanders and
- 2:16:33sarchal. We're doing this. Two more questions real quick. I am corporate,
- 2:16:37Thank you very much. We still provide an opportunity to build a better
- 2:16:39future, as opposed some places simply impose a future on you. Yeah.
- 2:16:48I mean, I'm in the United States for a reason. I'm an immigrant.
- 2:16:52I chose to be here, and I choose to be here now,
- 2:16:56and and it's yeah, for all the reasons you guys. Yeah, it's
- 2:17:01absolutely you can. You can still craft your way to the American dream.
- 2:17:07That's really whoever you are right there, unless you join the military. Well,
- 2:17:13I mean, I think honestly, honestly, I I you know,
- 2:17:22I ate at the buffet of the US military, and I had a great
- 2:17:24time everywhere I went. I think it really depends on your attitude there.
- 2:17:28There is a certain amount of luck to what leadership you get wherever you're at,
- 2:17:31Like, leadership can make a huge difference. But I loved everything that
- 2:17:35I did. I embraced everything that I did. There were plenty of learning
- 2:17:37opportunities that I pursued. You know, you know, you can go to
- 2:17:43the military and just do your time and be bit you about it and get
- 2:17:48out and go to college or whatever. But you know, the military opportunity
- 2:17:52and then and then miss it the rest of your life. Sure, sure,
- 2:17:56and then poor people silly with stories about your voyears marine cool. Yeah,
- 2:18:01No, I mean I I would you never hit me. I mean,
- 2:18:05I've being critical of the marine coll but you know I feel the same
- 2:18:09way as you. I mean, I wouldn't have changed. I wouldn't have
- 2:18:11traded it for anything. But the critical isn't isn't from a character assassination point,
- 2:18:18like you know, the Bloomin dolls and these people like that. It's
- 2:18:20like my family. If you love something, you want it to be what
- 2:18:24it can be, and and the critique comes from a place of love,
- 2:18:30and it can be better than what it is or what it was. Yeah,
- 2:18:35you know, Andrew Dunbar, thank you very much. What are your
- 2:18:39thoughts on the rumblings of North Korea troops in the Ukraine? I? Ah,
- 2:18:46I've heard is rumblings. Have you heard anything more than than that.
- 2:18:50I haven't seen an article. Yeah, you know what, nothing would surprise
- 2:18:56me at this stage. Have you seen what is true? What has happenings?
- 2:19:00The Russians have been press s ganging other nationalities into fighting in Ukraine,
- 2:19:07the Nepalese and then in one incredible case, Indians a bachelor party. And
- 2:19:15this is kind of sad, but now most of us would not choose to
- 2:19:18go to Moscow for a bachelor party, but evidently in the Russians have been
- 2:19:26advertising in India or various trips to include, uh, you know, setting
- 2:19:33up bachelor party divide with the you know, Eastern capitals at a cut price
- 2:19:39rate. Where there's a reason why it's cut prices. These gentlemen found out
- 2:19:43as they ended up in Ukraine. You know, they got they showed at
- 2:19:46the Bachelor party, blah blah blah cors of the evening, they all get
- 2:19:50arrested for something trumped up and then they they find themselves fighting in Ukraine and
- 2:19:56they only get out of it when the Indian Embassy is informed. I mean,
- 2:20:00it's you can't make the shut up. He doesn't. It's sort of
- 2:20:03like it's just getting your people. It's sort of like getting a modeling contract
- 2:20:07out of the UAE, right, It's like approach with caution. Yeah,
- 2:20:11yeah, exactly. So yeah, so Andy, that's it for the questions.
- 2:20:18I mean, we we really we love you, we love having you
- 2:20:20on. We really appreciate it. Well, it feeling is mutual, and
- 2:20:26I hope, I hope Board your your audience. He always end up talking
- 2:20:30quite well. Don't look at that. That's me, man. I'm like,
- 2:20:33without Jack here to keep me on in line, man, I I'll
- 2:20:35ramble all night. No, it was a great, great discussion and cutos
- 2:20:41to Teamhouse and to your audience and eyes On. Yeah, please makes the
- 2:20:48magic happen on both shows. Oh bless you. That's right. He is
- 2:20:54the don't forget, don't forget to check out eyes On, don't forget to
- 2:20:56check out Andy's book. The linker is in the description. Oh yeah,
- 2:21:01please find my book. Yes, I I highly, highly recommend his book.
- 2:21:05It doesn't matter even if you were not somebody who normally reads military literature
- 2:21:13or or reads I mean going out to all our marine friends out there.
- 2:21:18No, but even if you're not somebody who normally reads, this is a
- 2:21:20very human story. Think of the life of Pie in fatigues, and I
- 2:21:28cannot help that. We need to end this now. That is the light.
- 2:21:31Yeah. Uh so Jack will be back next week. Military version of
- 2:21:39Pine Yeah yeah. Jack will be back next week. So for those of
- 2:21:45you who have been bored because of my narration, uh, he'll be back
- 2:21:50to guide us and thank you very much. We really appreciate it. Check
- 2:21:54out out eyes On check out uh when the Tempest gathers. Also the page
- 2:22:00on the Patreon Patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Yes, next week episodes.
- 2:22:09I'm checking to see who we have for next week. Hold on one
- 2:22:11second, I'm sorry, Um, we have David fil fielding. Jack read
- 2:22:22his book very excited. I don't know what he does or anything, but
- 2:22:24I'm sure it's military or intelligence related. I hope outstanding introduction. Thank you,
- 2:22:33it was you have to write that one down, all right, everyone,
- 2:22:37all right, thank you everybody. We really appreciate it. See you
- 2:22:43next week.