Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Is B.C.'s carbon tax more expensive than the federal carbon tax? (Dr. Kathryn Harrison)
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is MoMA Miir and this is Van
- 0:19Kuller, British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. Ahead of Earth
- 0:24Day on April twenty second, It's all about the environment tonight. The trucker
- 0:29from Merritt BC who blew the lid off a potential government grant corruption scandal,
- 0:34will be here to talk about how American governors are courting his clean tech company
- 0:39to move down to their states. But first, how can we talk about
- 0:43the environment in this country without talking about the carbon tax? Our first guest
- 0:48tonight will unpack it for us. A professor of political science at the University
- 0:52of British Columbia with a focus on climate and energy policy, and a member
- 0:57of the VC Climate Solutions Council and Canadian Climate Institute, she is doctor Catherine
- 1:03Harrison. Doctor Harrison, thanks so much for being here tonight. I'm happy
- 1:06to be here. So simple question, hopefully it's a simple answer. What
- 1:10is the carbon tax actually taxing? It's taxing fossil fuels proportionate to how much
- 1:17carbon pollution they produce. Okay, now, most people feel the carbon tax
- 1:22when they fill up their tank at the gas station. So on a per
- 1:26leader basis, how much are British Columbians paying at the pump when it comes
- 1:30to the carbon tax. Seventeen point six cents okay, and that went up
- 1:34by three point three cents on April first. Okay. Now we have our
- 1:40provincial carbon tax, which was actually instituted in two thousand and eight, but
- 1:44then there was a federal carbon tax that was brought in in twenty nineteen.
- 1:49So I'm curious, is the tax rate the actually is the same between the
- 1:53federal tax and the provincial tax? Is it applied to different things? What
- 1:57are the differences? So the scope is exact actly the same. Both the
- 2:01provincial one and the federal one have two parts, one for industry and one
- 2:06for households and small businesses. And in fact the federal one was based on
- 2:12the scope of the BC carbon tax, which was their first. The price
- 2:16per ton of CO two is also identical, So you're paying the same at
- 2:21the gas station, whether it's the federal carbon tax or the provincial carbon tax
- 2:23exactly okay. Are there any differences? Then? There are the main differences
- 2:29between BC and the federal carbon tax, which applies in eight other provinces has
- 2:34to do with the rebates. What happens to the money after it is collected
- 2:38at the pump or on people's gas bills. Who gets more of a rebate
- 2:43than British Columbians or people who are paying the federal carbon tax people who are
- 2:47paying the federal carbon tax. In most places, the BC carbon tax rebates
- 2:53are different in a few respects. Not all of the money back is given
- 2:58back in rebates. Two thirds of it is spent on climate action things like
- 3:04subsidies for heat pumps and electric vehicles, and about forty of it on transit
- 3:10investment, so that's different. The federal government gives it all back. Not
- 3:15everybody gets a rebate. Everybody gets a rebate and the same rebate in federal
- 3:20tax provinces. In BC it is only low and middle income households, and
- 3:24the amount is greater for lower income households than middle income. And then the
- 3:30wealthiest don't get a rebate. When you say lower income households, that's in
- 3:35British Columbia. They get a bigger rebate. Lower income households in British Columbia
- 3:39get a bigger rebate than middle income households. But the average household in BC
- 3:45compared to say, Ontario, which is comparable in that there's very clean electricity.
- 3:52So people aren't paying as much carbon tax as they would be in Alberta,
- 3:55BC and Ontario. British Columbians and fans only a four at ninety thousand
- 4:01dollars a year income would be paying about four hundred dollars more a year federally
- 4:06or provincially they would federally. Wow, now I'm seeing a lot of BC
- 4:12politicians talking about axing the tax. So can the province of British Columbia just
- 4:17get rid of its own carbon tax? It can, but if so,
- 4:21the federal government would step in and apply the federal carbon tax. That's the
- 4:25way the federal legislation is written that it establishes a consistent national benchmarks up to
- 4:31provinces if they want to do it themselves, but if they don't, the
- 4:34federal government will step in. The difference would be if there is a conservative
- 4:40government elected federally and they ax the tax as they have promised to do.
- 4:45And I just want to reiterate, but if we were on the federal carbon
- 4:48tax, we would have more rebates then for more people and perhaps at a
- 4:54higher rates. Is that right? Yeah, everybody would get rebates, which
- 4:57they don't in BC, and I think on average most people would get more
- 5:03money back. And so what I'm also hearing is that BC can't even lower
- 5:08its current carbon tax. It has to stay at that threshold. It has
- 5:11to stay federally, it has to stay at that level. Okay. In
- 5:14fact, one of the things we learned when BC acted first in two thousand
- 5:18and eight and no other provinces followed suit is that it was really challenging to
- 5:21be the only province that was taxing industry and business. And so BC froze
- 5:27its carbon tax until the federal government stepped in and now we follow the national
- 5:32schedule. Now, the big question is there any evidence to show that the
- 5:36carbon tax is actually reducing greenhouse gas issues? There is, okay, and
- 5:43a lot of it comes from British Columbia. When BC adopted its carbon tax,
- 5:46it was this brilliant situation for economists because we had one province with a
- 5:51carbon tax and a whole bunch of other provinces with consistent data without a carbon
- 5:56tax. Right, and so there been by my accountab fifty studies that found
- 6:00that BC's carbon tax lowered emissions below what they otherwise would have been, didn't
- 6:05hurt the economy, was fair. But what we also know is that we
- 6:10can't get the kind of emissions reductions that were committed to at thirty dollars a
- 6:15ton. That's why we need that steadily increasing price schedule right now. Has
- 6:20the carbon tax actually made things more expensive? Because on its face you look
- 6:26at it and you go, yeah, of course the price of fuel is
- 6:28up, so the price of transportation is up. Has it really made everything
- 6:31from groceries to housing way more expensive? Not way more expensive? So I'd
- 6:36say yes and a no on that one. Yes in the sense that if
- 6:41the products people are buying were produced using fossil fuels, that will increase the
- 6:46price of those products, as it should. It then gives people incentives to
- 6:50purchase products that are less carbon intensive. But even with the tax and the
- 6:58pass through from other products, most households naturally are getting more money back in
- 7:03rebates than they are paying, So you know, yes, in that the
- 7:08prices of things go up a little bit. No, in the sense that
- 7:11most people are getting more money in their pockets that will help them afford right
- 7:15those slightly higher prices. I feel like it's almost a case of people just
- 7:18not recognizing that they're getting that rebate, right. I often hear from people
- 7:23who do get the rebate and they go, well, I never got mine.
- 7:26It's there is a very high level of misunderstanding in provinces that are subject
- 7:30to the federal tax, where everyone's getting a rebate. About twenty percent of
- 7:35households think that they are getting more money back than they're paying, when in
- 7:40fact the reality's eighty percent. So part of the acts the tax campaign is
- 7:46to emphasize the costs and not talk about the rebates, and so people tend
- 7:50to forget that they're getting money back. They don't check if only one adult
- 7:55gets the money each household check with their spouse and say did you get deposit
- 8:01every three months? And so there's really a lot of miss information, a
- 8:05lot of misunderstanding. Doctor Harrison, thank you so much for unpacking the carbon
- 8:09tax and for explaining it a little more for us. Thank you. You're
- 8:11very welcome, folks. That was UBC's doctor Catherine Harrison. Now, after
- 8:16some business, he pulled back the curtain on government grants, which put a
- 8:20high profile accounting firm in hot water, which prompted VC's Auditor General to investigate.
- 8:26But missing in this story are the incredible things that his clean tech company
- 8:30is accomplishing. I'll talk to Chase Barber of Edison Motors up next