Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Strategic Civility in Family Court: Turning Opposing Counsel's Bad Behavior Into Strategic Advantage
Transcript
- 0:03All right, everybody. Well, welcome to Strategic
- 0:07Civility in Family Court, Turning Opposing Counsel's
- 0:10Bad Behavior into Strategic Advantage. I am Ryan
- 0:13Wetteking, co -chair of the HBA's Family Law
- 0:15Section. Family Law Section is sponsored by White
- 0:18Zuckerman, Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company,
- 0:21Soberlink, and Our Family Wizard. White Zuckerman
- 0:24provides a wide variety of resources to complete
- 0:27almost any project, large or small. They also
- 0:30provide traditional accounting and tax practice
- 0:33services, we invite you to contact them to discuss
- 0:35your specific accounting needs and learn how
- 0:38they can be of service to you. Learn more at
- 0:41WZWLH .com. SoberLink provides objective real
- 0:46-time data that can be used to reduce disputes
- 0:48over alcohol consumption, leading to less conflict
- 0:51in custody cases. To help ensure smoother negotiations
- 0:55for a more efficient legal process, consider
- 0:57using SoberLink's trusted alcohol monitoring
- 0:59system to eliminate hearsay and protect your
- 1:02client's best interests. With an unprecedented
- 1:04combination of features, including advanced reporting,
- 1:07facial recognition, tamper -resistance real -time
- 1:09results, and customized testing, the discrete
- 1:11system has been the leader in remote alcohol
- 1:15monitoring since 2011. Learn more at soberlink
- 1:18.com. For five decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 1:22Company has been the only California -based company
- 1:25to continuously provide lawyers throughout the
- 1:27state with professional liability insurance coverage
- 1:30Their experience and expertise are complimented
- 1:34by the fact that Lawyers Mutual is directed by
- 1:36a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:40rates with competitive premiums for a wide range
- 1:42of practices, including family law. Learn more
- 1:45at lawyersmutual .com. Last but not least, our
- 1:49family wizard is a co -parenting platform designed
- 1:51to help families communicate more effectively,
- 1:53to reduce conflict, and to create reliable court
- 1:57admissible records. Features like tone meter,
- 2:00AI, shared calendars, expense tracking, and in
- 2:04-app audio and video calling help support compliance
- 2:08and better outcomes for families navigating custody
- 2:10matters. Last, I will note that our family law
- 2:16section meetings are held on the third Wednesday
- 2:20of each month. So our next BHBA Family Law Section
- 2:26meeting will be held on Wednesday, July 22nd.
- 2:28Those meetings begin at 4 .30 p .m. It's a great
- 2:31opportunity to kind of get the state of Department
- 2:362. We hear from Judge Kaufman. You will also
- 2:40hear from a leading family law attorney on what
- 2:45we call our family law tidbit, which is like
- 2:47a five, 10, 15 -minute CLE on a a topic each
- 2:53month. So it's a great opportunity to network,
- 2:56to learn the latest down at Department 2, and
- 3:01to maybe learn a little bit each month with a
- 3:06group of your peers. So we invite you to join
- 3:09us for our monthly family law section meetings.
- 3:12And if you can't make it, send an associate.
- 3:14It's important that your firm is up on the state
- 3:18of the art. So with that, I'm delighted to introduce
- 3:21our speaker, Noel Guth. Noel Guth is a California
- 3:25civil litigator and founder of the Law Offices
- 3:27of Nicole, excuse me, Noel Guth. PC, practicing
- 3:32family law, estate planning, personal injury,
- 3:35medical malpractice, and mass tort litigation.
- 3:37She is licensed in California and Washington
- 3:39D .C. and all of California's federal courts.
- 3:43She's been named a Daily Journal top family law
- 3:45attorney for 2026 and a Best Lawyers Once to
- 3:50Watch honoree since 2023 across six practice
- 3:53areas. She writes a monthly family law column
- 3:55for the Daily Journal and practices statewide
- 3:57from Yuba City and Sutter County. Now, let's
- 4:01get started. Noelle. Noelle, does look like your
- 4:09audio is a little bit out for a second. Can we
- 4:12try to adjust the microphone again? Yes. Does
- 4:17that help? Can you say a sentence for us, please?
- 4:23My name is Noelle Gooth, and I'm honored to be
- 4:26presenting today. Perfect. All right, let's try.
- 4:30Let's, all right. Let's see. Here we go. All
- 4:36right. Looks like we should be ready to go. All
- 4:43right. Good afternoon, everyone. I would like
- 4:45to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 4:49sponsoring this CLE this afternoon. And I would
- 4:52like to thank all of the attendees for spending
- 4:55your lunch hour with me. This lecture, excuse
- 5:00me, this Continuing Legal Education seminar is
- 5:05going to be a talk on strategic shift. This is
- 5:09not an ethics lecture. So we will dive in two
- 5:13ways. that you can shift your practice when opposing
- 5:17counsel is not acting in the most civil manner
- 5:20and streamline the litigation for your clients
- 5:24so that everything proceeds effectively, cooperatively,
- 5:28and as cost effectively as possible. So I'd like
- 5:34to start by saying what used to look like zealous
- 5:36advocacy in the courtroom years ago now reads
- 5:40to the bench as poor case management. We're going
- 5:44to talk about what we as family law practitioners
- 5:47can do about that. Can you move to the next slide,
- 5:51please? So the first slide is just some background
- 6:00on myself. You have already heard that. Again,
- 6:03my name is Noelle Guth. I am the founder of the
- 6:06Law Offices of Noelle E. Guth PC based out of
- 6:09Sutter County, California. I do work remotely
- 6:12on a statewide platform, so I have worked in
- 6:15virtually every jurisdiction in the state of
- 6:18California and have a lot of experience in those
- 6:21courts. Today's discussion is adapted from an
- 6:25article I recently wrote and had published in
- 6:27the Daily Journal, explaining how civility is
- 6:30such an important area that is often overlooked,
- 6:34not only by family law practitioners, but by
- 6:36legal professionals in general. and how that
- 6:39can have a negative effect for your own clients,
- 6:42but also on the court system overall, and shift
- 6:46the perception that the judge handling your case
- 6:49has not only of you, but the emphasis that the
- 6:53judge will put on whether or not to hear motions
- 6:57or fully read pleadings in the future. Unfortunately,
- 7:01when judges get high volumes of emails and motions
- 7:06being filed, that at the outset of matters, it
- 7:10can affect whether or not the judge spends the
- 7:12time on your filings in the future. So we want
- 7:16to ensure that from the outset of the case, we
- 7:18are doing everything in our power, one, to be
- 7:21civil, but two, enlist the court's help to put
- 7:25procedures in place to really streamline cases
- 7:28and ensure that we are acting in a civil manner,
- 7:31but also that opposing counsel is treating us
- 7:34as such. Next slide, please. So by the end of
- 7:41this hour, you will be able to recognize the
- 7:46judicial shift in civility. Most judges have
- 7:50come from areas that aren't necessarily a family
- 7:53law background, and it's showing in the way they
- 7:56are hearing and adjudicating cases. Most have
- 7:59little tolerance for gamesmanship, and they do
- 8:04not want to deal with counsel on either side
- 8:07of a consistent bickering back and forth. Number
- 8:11two, we're going to learn how to use the toolkit
- 8:16that's available to us. Case management orders,
- 8:20early stipulations that you can reach with opposing
- 8:23counsel on issues. Early mediation to flush out
- 8:27the real areas of contention, joint statements,
- 8:30the list goes on as to what's available to us
- 8:34to effectively streamline those cases for our
- 8:37clients and ensure that there's just no room
- 8:39for muddying the waters or instability. Number
- 8:43three, I want to teach you how to respond strategically
- 8:47when you have someone on the other side who is
- 8:50not the most civil towards you, whether that
- 8:53be in emails, in phone calls, or in filings to
- 8:57the court. And the last one, this is very important
- 9:00not only to protect yourself and the oath that
- 9:03you've made to the bar. bar administration, but
- 9:06also to protect your client because they are
- 9:09the ones that really suffer when there is instability
- 9:12on either side of a litigation. Next slide, please.
- 9:20So as you can see from this slide, there are
- 9:24generally 2000 filings per judicial position
- 9:28in California courts. Many of you will see that
- 9:33filings are weeks behind, you'll submit them
- 9:36to the court, you're not getting things filed
- 9:37stamped back, sometimes two, three, four weeks,
- 9:40and that's just because the caseloads are so
- 9:43large. That gives you a little bit of perspective
- 9:47on what the judges do and do not have time for.
- 9:50They do not have time for gamesmanship. When
- 9:54you forget something or opposing counsel has
- 9:56not planned something out well, it's not an emergency
- 9:59for the court to address it. It may be for us
- 10:02and our clients, not only for malpractice reasons,
- 10:05but also family law is very high anxiety, high
- 10:10energy. Everything is an emergency because you're
- 10:13dealing with someone's life, very intimate parts
- 10:16of their life, their children, their marriage.
- 10:19And so they want things done on an expedited
- 10:21basis and that's not always possible. I want
- 10:25you all to keep in mind that the efficient attorney
- 10:29wins the room. And what I mean by that is if
- 10:32you are well organized, you have CMOs in place
- 10:36to streamline discovery issues, incivility, bickering
- 10:42back and forth, superfluous motions being filed,
- 10:45the judge will look more fondly on you and be
- 10:49more willing to accommodate your position in
- 10:52court. And then keep in mind that sometimes clients
- 10:57will want not only the most zealous advocate,
- 11:00which we have an opportunity to be, but they
- 11:03also want that bulldog in the courtroom. Which
- 11:06is great in a lot of instances, but sometimes
- 11:10winning can cost you the war. And what I mean
- 11:12is filing a motion that you know you're going
- 11:15to succeed on just to get the win and prove a
- 11:18point isn't doing the best for your client. It's
- 11:21costing them time. It's costing them money. So
- 11:24if we have procedures in place ahead of time
- 11:26to be able to avoid that motion practice, you
- 11:29are doing the best job for your client and the
- 11:32court will appreciate that. Next slide, please.
- 11:40So what counts as bad behavior from the bench's
- 11:44perspective? As we all know, a lot of times family
- 11:48law clients cannot or family law case participants
- 11:52cannot afford legal counsel, so they proceed
- 11:55in pro -per. The judge is not supposed to, but
- 11:58they generally do treat pro -pers differently
- 12:01than attorneys. ProPERS don't have a great idea
- 12:06of what is required of them. Oftentimes, their
- 12:10filings become very accusatory, attacking, and
- 12:15they will undertake motions and things that just
- 12:18waste the court's time. It's very important when
- 12:21you're dealing with a ProPERS on the opposite
- 12:23side that you, at the outset, set expectations
- 12:27and boundaries and try to put stipulations in
- 12:31place. to really streamline what needs to be
- 12:34done, have a clear planning of the issues that
- 12:38are before you, and you can really gauge whether
- 12:41or not this person is going to be incredibly
- 12:43difficult and adversarial and fight you on every
- 12:46turn, or if they are going to be cooperative.
- 12:49I had a recent case where husband originally
- 12:53was represented by counsel, was non -responsive
- 12:56to her. She filed a motion to withdraw. The matter
- 13:00went to trial. We got the orders, but then he
- 13:03refused to sign the judgment documents. He refused
- 13:06to overturn paperwork we needed turned over in
- 13:09order to have his pension divided. His emails
- 13:12were quite vile to the point of saying, you know,
- 13:16your emails mean nothing to me. I laugh when
- 13:18I read them. There's nothing you can do to force
- 13:21me to do this. Well, I quickly addressed that
- 13:24by. very kind emails back to him explaining his
- 13:28obligations, then was able to attach those to
- 13:31a motion showing just his deliberate refusal
- 13:36to actively engage, having Ella soar. Appointed
- 13:40by the court to sign off on documents and pretty
- 13:43much proceed without him. So by creating that
- 13:47track record of being cooperative, being the
- 13:51one that is conciliatory whenever he is trying
- 13:54to kind of ruffle feathers and not engage to
- 13:58get orders in place from the court that not only
- 14:00required him. to participate, but when he wouldn't
- 14:04do so, had someone else step in and allowed Moon
- 14:08Schwartz and Madden to prepare the quadros, allowed
- 14:11me to send them off to CalPERS, I was able to
- 14:14quickly resolve this for my client in a situation
- 14:17where that would not have been possible otherwise.
- 14:20Often attorneys are judged more harshly by judges
- 14:24because... We should know better. We went to
- 14:26law school. We've all had moments where we've
- 14:30wanted to fire off a nasty gram to someone on
- 14:34the other side because what has been written
- 14:36to us is just oftentimes very horrible and vile.
- 14:41But you need to sit there and really think, is
- 14:43it worth it for you to actually send that back?
- 14:46If you need to take a break, type it out in a
- 14:50text box on your computer, save it for yourself,
- 14:52there was your vent, never ever send them back.
- 14:56Remember everything that you send to opposing
- 14:59counsel or anyone in your case besides your client
- 15:02is ripe for the taking before a judge. And always
- 15:06write your emails and respond with professionalism,
- 15:09cooperation, and kindness. A closing counsel
- 15:13could have been having a bad day. That could
- 15:14just be their personality. But you want to be
- 15:17as cordial as possible and keep the court on
- 15:20your side. Next slide, please. I do want to remind
- 15:28everyone that as of April of this year, we all
- 15:32signed an oath to the court saying that we would
- 15:35act with civility. If you did not check that
- 15:37box and sign that document, your bar admission
- 15:41has been temporarily suspended until you do sign
- 15:44it. and the bar is looking very closely at whether
- 15:49or not we act with stability towards one another
- 15:51to opposing counsel, to pro -PERS and to our
- 15:55clients. So please, please keep that in mind.
- 15:58Courts are becoming increasingly aware that incivility
- 16:02is becoming a money issue for our clients as
- 16:05well. There are two recent court decisions that
- 16:08have reduced attorney fees for attorneys where
- 16:13they have found the attorney acted incivily.
- 16:16And so it's very important that we keep that
- 16:19in our minds. Years ago, The playbook was aggressive,
- 16:26vitriolic correspondence between council. You
- 16:29were there to fight it out at all costs and do
- 16:31everything you needed to win for your client.
- 16:34Several last minute ex parte applications so
- 16:37you would catch opposing council off guard and
- 16:39they wouldn't have time to prepare and respond
- 16:41to your motions thinking that was a win. Lots
- 16:44of gamesmanship in discovery still happens. Hiding
- 16:48the ball, a lot of that has been addressed by
- 16:51discovery rules requiring us to clearly organize
- 16:55pleadings, to be sure that we point out documents
- 16:59that are directly responsive to what's being
- 17:03asked of us. Sometimes you still get the blurbs
- 17:07of non -compliant discovery, but that is no longer.
- 17:11no longer typical in court. A lot of times family
- 17:17court 271 sanctions were more readily available
- 17:21in the past. Now judges are not so inclined to
- 17:25grant them because they find that ordering 271
- 17:29sanctions actually can frustrate the settlement
- 17:32process further. So you are less likely to get
- 17:36271 sanctions. At the beginning, middle of the
- 17:40case, sometimes you can get them at the end.
- 17:42I'm finding more likely than not you don't get
- 17:45them at all. Now, the strategic response to that
- 17:49traditional playbook is to always prepare a professional
- 17:54and concise written record. Like I said a moment
- 17:57ago, everything that you send is right for turning
- 18:01into the court. Keep that professional cooperative
- 18:05because that is an advantage to you and your
- 18:08clients. Plan your case management upfront. Within
- 18:13a week or two of dealing with opposing counsel
- 18:15and knowing the issues before you, you are going
- 18:18to have a very good idea of what opposing counsel
- 18:22is like if you've never worked with them before,
- 18:25if you're able to clearly point out issues that
- 18:28you can work together on at the outset to get
- 18:31those out of the way for your clients so that
- 18:33those big picture issues that are more difficult
- 18:36to address have the forefront and take up most
- 18:39of the case. We're not fighting at the outset
- 18:42of who's going to get which car, who's going
- 18:45to pay for A and B when parties are already driving
- 18:48them. That's already been resolved for now. We'll
- 18:50deal with that later. I highly recommend early
- 18:54mediation for issue framing. Because of the mediation
- 18:58privilege you can go into a mediation or any
- 19:02sort of ADR. And you don't have to worry about
- 19:06your thought process being disclosed or used
- 19:08against you later on, but you can really use
- 19:11early mediation to pinpoint where the areas are
- 19:15that you need to spend the most time not only
- 19:17with your client, but areas that you can also
- 19:20quickly wipe off the table with opposing counsel.
- 19:24I highly recommend early mediation or at least
- 19:26some sort of. early mediation type briefing that
- 19:31you can exchange with opposing counsel because
- 19:33it is going to streamline your entire case and
- 19:37help you move through issues much more quickly
- 19:39and cost effectively. I recommend that you do
- 19:43not seek those 271 sanctions or other sanctions
- 19:47right off the bat. Be very strategic of when
- 19:50you ask for sanctions. Motion to compel where
- 19:54they're pretty much guaranteed to your client
- 19:56are great examples of that. Do not ask for sanctions
- 20:00that are highly, highly up to the court's discretion.
- 20:04You are very unlikely to get them these days.
- 20:06Go for sanctions where the statute says shall
- 20:11instead of may. That is going to be your guide
- 20:14of whether or not to ask for sanctions early
- 20:16on. If possible, try to bifurcate issues that
- 20:21will reduce conflict pressures as you go forward.
- 20:25And that's really going to help you Again, move
- 20:29your case forward in the most effective and civil
- 20:31way for your client. Here, I want you all to
- 20:38be aware that civility is a power move. Civility
- 20:44is tied to fee reasonableness. That was the recent
- 20:49decision in Carton. There is an unpublished SNCC
- 20:53case that says lack of professionalism is a lower
- 20:57showing of skill for attorneys. You want to be
- 21:00professional. You want to be as zealous as you
- 21:03can, but do it in a kind and cooperative way.
- 21:09There are three recent cases on this, they were
- 21:13three different angles, but they all have the
- 21:15same message. The bench has been told and is
- 21:19acting on the idea that civility is professional
- 21:22competence. Please keep that in mind. Those carton
- 21:26and SNCC decisions that I just cited flip the
- 21:29old assumption, this old traditional playbook
- 21:31before us. We used to assume aggressive lawyering
- 21:35meant higher fees were justified. Now appellate
- 21:38courts say just the opposite. Next slide, please.
- 21:46So we can zoom through this slide. This is not
- 21:49another 271 talk. As I said, courts are not inclined
- 21:54to give 271 sanctions as freely as they used
- 21:58to be. So I recommend following the methods laid
- 22:03forward in this presentation rather than diving
- 22:05for those first. Next slide, please. So oftentimes,
- 22:16being aggressive in court can backfire in...
- 22:19on us. There are often red flags that annoy the
- 22:23bench, such as serial request for order filings
- 22:26on overlapping issues. When you file requests
- 22:29for orders, make sure they are clear and intentional.
- 22:32When you file a response to a request for order,
- 22:36don't use that as your opportunity to ask for
- 22:38everything under the sun for your client. File
- 22:41your own requests for orders on specific issues.
- 22:44If you cannot meet with opposing counsel and
- 22:47resolve them at the outset. Be very strategic
- 22:51in what you ask the court for relief on. Please
- 22:55do not file excessive ex parte motions without
- 22:58true emergencies. I have dealt with opposing
- 23:01counsel where anytime she didn't get the answer
- 23:03from me that she wanted right out of the gate,
- 23:06within a day or two, I was getting served with
- 23:09notice she was going to be filing an ex parte
- 23:11motion. When no true emergency existed on the
- 23:14issue, there is a time and a place for ex parte
- 23:17applications and weekly filings are not it. Again,
- 23:22vitriolic correspondence and back and forth bickering
- 23:25with opposing counsel is not going to win you
- 23:27any fans, especially not from the judges bench.
- 23:31Do not threaten 271. It's likely not going to
- 23:34get you anywhere with opposing counsel and more
- 23:37so with the court. Do not lead into the hide
- 23:43the ball, discovering objections, just to make
- 23:46objections. Be very, very clear and intentional
- 23:49about what you're objecting to. A lot of times,
- 23:52even if you object, it still requires a response
- 23:55because you likely have information or documents
- 23:58that are responsive. Do everything you can at
- 24:00the outset to try to get that discovery released.
- 24:04Otherwise, it's just going to create a delay
- 24:07and motion practice that could have been avoided
- 24:09for your client. Please try to plan your filings
- 24:15as much as possible. We all have very heavy caseloads.
- 24:20Things sometimes can get lost in the weeds. But
- 24:22if you really sit down at the outset of your
- 24:24case and flush out the issues, you can have a
- 24:27pretty good timeline before yourself. that you
- 24:31can adjust to know what you need to file and
- 24:34when and preempt what might be filed by opposing
- 24:38counsel to keep the process running clearly,
- 24:41smoothly, and kindly. Next page, please. As I
- 24:50mentioned earlier, Civility is now required.
- 24:54We all signed California rule of court 9 .7.
- 24:59We state as an officer of the court, I will strive
- 25:02to conduct myself at all times with dignity,
- 25:05courtesy, and integrity. Every active licensee
- 25:10must annually declare and adhere to this oath
- 25:12language. Enforcement began April 1st of this
- 25:16year. Like I mentioned, attorneys who failed
- 25:20to file this declaration get rolled as inactive.
- 25:22This is a real consequence and we should all
- 25:25take this new oath very seriously. Next slide,
- 25:29please. So here are three cases that I mentioned
- 25:39earlier. Excellent Carton stands for the proposition
- 25:43that excellent lawyers are civil. SNCC is an
- 25:47unpublished decision, but found lack of professionalism
- 25:51is a lower showing of skill by attorneys. And
- 25:55Reid versus Google told us all to focus on the
- 25:59objections that really count. In that case, the
- 26:02California Supreme Court encouraged parties to
- 26:04raise only meritorious evidentiary objections
- 26:07or face informal reprimands or formal sanctions.
- 26:12That is something that you really need to be
- 26:14aware of over objecting. is its own liability
- 26:17not only to you, but to your clients. Civility
- 26:21is credibility. Credibility is persuasiveness
- 26:25and persuasiveness is getting what your client
- 26:28wants. So what do you actually want to do with
- 26:32this in your next case? Next slide, please. So
- 26:40five tools that you can deploy before and instead
- 26:43of that 271 sanctions motion that's not going
- 26:46to get you very far. One, case management orders.
- 26:50Two, early mediation. Three, joint statements
- 26:54of issues. These are really, really helpful.
- 26:57Anytime you could do a joint statement with opposing
- 26:59counsel, one, you're dividing the work, but two,
- 27:03you really get a good rapport with opposing counsel.
- 27:07and can flush out what needs to be focused on,
- 27:10not only for your client, but for the case as
- 27:13a whole. Four, bifurcate where possible. Diffuse
- 27:17those worst issues first. And five, keep your
- 27:22evidentiary objection protocols reined. Every
- 27:26one of these is a tool you can deploy today.
- 27:29The law is already there. What's new is being
- 27:32sure that you use it deliberately. It's not always
- 27:35an intentional practice, but I hope you will
- 27:38make it one. So let's start with the most important
- 27:41one. Next slide, please. Case management orders.
- 27:49These are your biggest tool. If there is one
- 27:52thing you take away from today, this is it, case
- 27:56management orders. A lot of family law attorneys
- 27:59don't ever use these. Case management orders
- 28:02are used all the time in larger litigations.
- 28:07Multidistrict litigations, for example, there
- 28:09could be hundreds of case management orders.
- 28:12They are a really, really useful practice for
- 28:15you to set timelines in place that are ordered
- 28:18by the court. Oftentimes, the courts won't assist
- 28:22with how you manage. the case is going forward.
- 28:26If a meet and confer deadlines are set, when
- 28:29witness and exhibit lists need to be exchanged,
- 28:32whether or not you do individual or joint statements
- 28:35of issues before hearings, you can ask the court
- 28:38to order you to do all of this. If at the outset
- 28:42of your case or early on, even in the middle
- 28:44of the case, if you find opposing counsel is
- 28:47just becoming increasingly difficult, first try
- 28:50to try to reach stipulations with opposing counsel.
- 28:54I sent an email last week, for example, where
- 28:57it was uncovered that father in one of my cases
- 29:01has a pretty severe mental health background
- 29:04that he was not forthcoming about. The only reason
- 29:07I was aware of it is because I ask all of my
- 29:10clients at the outset of Family Matters to download
- 29:15all of their text message history with their
- 29:18spouse. I have them send that to me. Usually
- 29:22if they have iPhones, it's a program called iAmazing.
- 29:25They have a similar platform for Android devices.
- 29:30clearly downloads every single communication
- 29:32in reverse chronological order. They are in a
- 29:35format that you can use as exhibits, and I read
- 29:38through them. In reading through the history
- 29:40of this client's exchanges with her estranged
- 29:43husband, there were things said that were very
- 29:46obvious mental health flags, husband admitting
- 29:49to alcoholism that wife necessarily wasn't aware
- 29:53of. husband admitting to some suicide attempts
- 29:57that wife hadn't witnessed, but they were all
- 30:01in his own words. What I was able to do was pin
- 30:05site those communications to opposing counsel.
- 30:09This dissolution has only been pending about
- 30:11three weeks. point out to him, you may not be
- 30:15aware of this. This is a clear safety issue for
- 30:17the child involved. I know we both have that
- 30:21child safety at the forefront. Before this becomes
- 30:25evidence for the court, or it has to be brought
- 30:28up in family court services mediation, because
- 30:31as most of you know, most courts ask, are you
- 30:34aware of any mental health history of opposing?
- 30:37party? Are you aware of any substance abuse history
- 30:40of opposing party? And your clients are supposed
- 30:43to answer that honestly. Instead of putting that
- 30:46all before the mediator that can be put then
- 30:49into a recommending mediation report and get
- 30:51before the court, you can send emails to opposing
- 30:54counsel as I did and say, can we put these stipulations
- 30:57in place? Here's one through five that I propose.
- 31:02Husband, father remains in therapy. Two, he enrolls
- 31:05in sober link. Three, he does a check -in on
- 31:08every visit after the child goes to bed so that
- 31:11we can be sure he's sober, something of the like.
- 31:14And get I was able to get father to agree to
- 31:17three of the five terms that I proposed and we
- 31:20have some really strong safeguards in place already
- 31:22for visitation and this hasn't even gone to mediation
- 31:25yet. So the mental health and substance abuse
- 31:27doesn't need to go before the court for any adjudication
- 31:31and the parents are. collaboratively working
- 31:34together through council to put custody and visitation
- 31:37in place, where that could have been a very nasty
- 31:40battle before a judge, that issue is already
- 31:43off the table. You have a lot of options and
- 31:47you can get very creative on what you can ask
- 31:49the court to do for you. If you have already
- 31:54gone through one round of discovery and found
- 31:58You are just not getting the answers you want
- 32:00and it's evidence you're not going to. Lead with
- 32:03a CMO on a discovery schedule with enforceable
- 32:06dates. That way you can move quickly towards
- 32:10evidentiary based sanctions if necessary because
- 32:13you already have the order in your hand that
- 32:16says what you have to do by what date. This eliminates
- 32:20that last minute gamesmanship and gets you what
- 32:22you need quicker and more cost effectively. You
- 32:27can issue sanctions warnings through the court
- 32:30under two code sections, both 177 .5 and 271.
- 32:36Once you get those warnings tied into a case
- 32:39management order, you have built the record for
- 32:42later if opposing counsel's compliance fails,
- 32:46and you are much more likely to get those sanctions.
- 32:50under those code sections, then you would have
- 32:53been ahead of time because the court has already
- 32:55made them orders. So I bring a proposed CMO to
- 33:00almost every contested case now. Even if the
- 33:03court doesn't adopt it verbatim, I've anchored
- 33:06the discussion and let opposing counsel know
- 33:08that I'm serious in how I'm going to address
- 33:11these things going forward. I want you all to
- 33:15know that the materials packet that you've been
- 33:17given has sample CMO language that you can adapt
- 33:20to your case. So whether or not you have a CMO
- 33:24yet, mediation can do real work for you early.
- 33:28So I want to address that topic next. So let's
- 33:31move to the next slide, please. Appropriate mediation.
- 33:39So mediation is no longer just a settlement vehicle.
- 33:42It is a case management vehicle for your client.
- 33:45It has four purposes. Discovery framing, issue
- 33:50narrowing, a safe place for you to vent, and
- 33:54it shapes your client expectations. A mediator
- 33:58who knows the bench can deliver hard truths to
- 34:02your client more credibly than you can. Use that
- 34:05to your advantage. Oftentimes our clients now
- 34:08are running to chat GPT to see their success
- 34:11on things or, you know, I talked to my friend
- 34:13who went through a divorce five years ago and
- 34:15this happened for them. So they assume that's
- 34:18what's going to happen in their case. As we all
- 34:20know, very unrealistic that what chat GPT says
- 34:24or what their neighbor did five years ago is
- 34:26going to pan out in their case. If they hear
- 34:28it from a retired judge, for example, or another
- 34:32neutral, they are much more likely to believe
- 34:35them. and take you more seriously later on, and
- 34:38they'll have more clear expectations of their
- 34:40case going forward. A realistic mediator can
- 34:44calibrate your clients in ways that we just can't.
- 34:49Judges often offer early mediation or will grant
- 34:52it if you ask for it in a case management order
- 34:56or through a request for order. Next slide, please.
- 35:02So whether or not you mediate, please always
- 35:05make your disputes crystal clear to the judge.
- 35:09Do that very clearly through a joint statement
- 35:13of issues. You want to force specificity from
- 35:17opposing counsel. You want to clear those boilerplate
- 35:20filings and you want to narrow the fight for
- 35:23your client. The vague version of what you need
- 35:28from the court is support is at issue. We've
- 35:32all written this. Stop writing it. Support is
- 35:35at issue in almost every family law case. The
- 35:38court knows that. What about support is at issue?
- 35:42Please be specific. List those discrete disputes.
- 35:48Income calculation is going to be a problem.
- 35:50There's an imputation issue here. The duration
- 35:53of the marriage is iffy. One party saying A,
- 35:56another saying B. It was very close to 10 years,
- 35:59but not quite 10 years. Whether or not there's
- 36:02bonus income that needs to be considered. If
- 36:06the bonus incomes needs to be a true up later
- 36:09on. All of this are things that should be pointed
- 36:12out very clearly to the court at the outset so
- 36:15that you as the practitioner can shape what needs
- 36:18to be done. Opposing counsel is aware of what
- 36:21you plan to address, but the court is clear of
- 36:24it very, very early on. Next, this forces specificity,
- 36:32creates accountability, and often becomes the
- 36:34settlement framework. Try to include a joint
- 36:38statement of issues requirement in your proposed
- 36:42case management orders. The joint statement of
- 36:45issues and the case management order will reinforce
- 36:48each other. Use them. They're symbiotic. It's
- 36:51to your advantage. If opposing counsel seems
- 36:56that they would never agree to this, file a unilateral
- 36:59statement of issues for the court. If they refuse
- 37:03to engage in a joint statement of issues, The
- 37:06court reads that too. You've tried to be collaborative,
- 37:09you've tried to work on this, and the court will
- 37:12be aware of who's on the side more likely to
- 37:16resolve things, who is on the side more likely
- 37:18to make it more difficult for them, and that
- 37:21will work to your advantage. It, one, builds
- 37:23credibility with the judge. But two, the judge
- 37:26will come to your case from then on with a different
- 37:29lens. They may be more inclined to focus on pleadings
- 37:34that you filed that are much more clear, whereas
- 37:37they are not as clear and more vitriolic from
- 37:40opposing counsel. Again, that is two tools that
- 37:44you can use to move your case along faster. Next
- 37:47slide, please. Tools four and five, again, kind
- 37:54of go hand -in -hand, your bifurcation and your
- 37:57evidentiary objection protocols. So bifurcation,
- 38:07these are where we're going to separate contentious
- 38:10issues for sequential resolution. Early on, bifurcate
- 38:14status from property division. bifurcate custody
- 38:17from support, bifurcate valuation date disputes
- 38:20early, and use partial progress on those issues
- 38:24to build settlement momentum. You can never decide
- 38:28property division without determining status.
- 38:31You can never resolve support without knowing
- 38:33who's going to have custody. Most know bifurcation.
- 38:38It's very, very underused. Diffuse your worst
- 38:42issues first. Again, status, custody, evaluation
- 38:46dates. Status bifurcation is psychologically
- 38:49powerful for our clients. Once your party is
- 38:53single again, their emotional temperature drops.
- 38:56They are more likely to want everything else
- 38:58to be resolved because they already have their
- 39:01single life they are working towards moving on.
- 39:04That's going to make things easier for you, for
- 39:07your client, and for opposing counsel. Your evidentiary
- 39:12objection management. It's newer. It is less
- 39:15familiar to a lot of practitioners and especially
- 39:18their clients. Some courts now order, meet and
- 39:22confers on objections before the court will rule.
- 39:25It's required under a lot of statutes. So please
- 39:29try to do. meet and confers early on, try to
- 39:34stipulate two things with opposing counsel as
- 39:37much as you can. It's going to get you a lot
- 39:39farther than contested motion practice. The certification
- 39:44under penalty of perjury feature in evidentiary
- 39:47objections is what gives them teeth. So now let's
- 39:51see what this looks like when you actually face
- 39:53a hostile situation. Next slide, please. Here
- 39:59is a hypothetical. Let's take a minute to pause
- 40:03and read this scenario together. Opposing council
- 40:07representing party A sends snarky aggressive
- 40:10emails, refuses to meet and confer in good faith.
- 40:15Party A has filed numerous overlapping requests
- 40:18for orders. Let's walk through our very strategic
- 40:22response. Next page, please. So here's what I
- 40:32do and why. This is four moves in order that
- 40:36will reset your case. As I mentioned early on,
- 40:40hold the line in writing. Respond to snarky or
- 40:44vitriolic emails with professional, concise,
- 40:46and factual correspondence. Every reply is evidence.
- 40:51Make sure your correspondence helps you and your
- 40:54client. Two, document the obstruction. always
- 40:59create a clear paper trail of good faith meet
- 41:02and confer attempts, unanswered correspondence
- 41:04and specific requests that have gone ignored.
- 41:08I now build a timeline for myself early on to
- 41:13where I can track. I'm not going to remember
- 41:15every email. I print them. I create my timeline
- 41:18and they go right into a dated file so I can
- 41:21quickly reference in the event that I need to
- 41:24file a motion. I have it all at my hands. Then
- 41:28file a request for order that includes a proposed
- 41:32case management order. Attach a detailed proposed
- 41:35order. Set forth the meet and confer requirements
- 41:39that you need, whether or not you need those
- 41:40joint statements I discussed, a discovery schedule,
- 41:44an early settlement conference, anything you
- 41:47can do to get orders from the court will benefit
- 41:50you down the line and it will benefit your client
- 41:53and save them a ton of money. The last step is
- 41:57to frame what you're doing as a solution, not
- 42:01a complaint. A lot of times when opposing counsel
- 42:04feels like you're attacking them or the way they
- 42:06practice, the way they've been doing it for 30,
- 42:0840 years or five if they're newer, they don't
- 42:11like feeling like they're not doing it up to
- 42:14your standard or that you're judging what they're
- 42:16doing. Again, frame it as a solution to an issue.
- 42:20The parties would benefit from judicial case
- 42:22management to streamline resolution and reduce
- 42:25costs. You're helping opposing counsel help their
- 42:29client. In turn, you're helping yourself and
- 42:31your client. But above all, you are helping the
- 42:34judge. The result of doing these things very
- 42:38strategically is you've just imposed structure
- 42:41in your case. You've exposed gamesmanship if
- 42:44it exists on the other side. Your client is the
- 42:47one that comes across organized and reasonable,
- 42:51and either outcome you get from the judge favors
- 42:53you because you've done everything to protect
- 42:56yourself and protect your client in this situation.
- 43:02So the sequence of these events, I want to emphasize,
- 43:05is not interchangeable. It is very important
- 43:09you do them in order. Hold that line in writing.
- 43:13Document the obstruction. File the RFO asking
- 43:17for structure, not retribution. Again, frame
- 43:20it as a solution. The judge sees a problem solver,
- 43:23not a complainer. You are not avoiding sanctions
- 43:27practice by doing this. You're setting it up
- 43:30properly so that when you do invoke that sanctions
- 43:33practice, the court is ready to grant relief.
- 43:36This works because the bench has changed. Next
- 43:40slide, please. Know your bench. The rules of
- 43:47the game have changed. Newer judges bring criminal,
- 43:51civil, and other backgrounds to the courtroom.
- 43:54They have different civility expectations. I
- 43:58want to walk through this table very quickly
- 44:01and show those cultural shifts in the courtroom.
- 44:07First, posturing signals poor planning. Aggression
- 44:11equals lower skill. That's the SNCC case. You
- 44:14don't want the courts to think you're incompetent
- 44:17because all you do is fight with opposing counsel.
- 44:20Rule compliance is your baseline expectation.
- 44:23Clarity and organization persuade, and sanctions
- 44:27are your last resort tool. Take time to research
- 44:32new judicial officers. Look at their background.
- 44:35Read tentative rulings if your court offers them.
- 44:38The bench will reveal itself and it's going to
- 44:42give you very good insight on how to move forward
- 44:45with these strategic things you can put in place
- 44:49to streamline your case. Let's tie all of this
- 44:52together. Next slide, please. So the key takeaways,
- 44:59just a quick recap. Civility is not just ethical,
- 45:05it's strategic. It's required by Rule 9 .7. You
- 45:10signed an oath when you administered your Pager
- 45:13Bar dues this year. Carton and SNCC cases monetize
- 45:17civility, and the bench will reward it with credibility.
- 45:21This is a huge advantage to you, not only for
- 45:24your current case, but all cases in the future.
- 45:26Case management tools give you control. There
- 45:30are family code statutes and rules of court that
- 45:33hand you real authority to structure your chaotic
- 45:36litigation. Next, early mediation frames your
- 45:40case. It is not just settle it. Use it to narrow
- 45:43issues, shape your client's expectations, and
- 45:46prevent predictable crises. Next, help the judge
- 45:50help you. Be on the organized, reasonable side.
- 45:54Overloaded documents, which are in many counties
- 45:57these days, reward clarity and punish chaos.
- 46:01Please be the clear, concise one that is on the
- 46:04judge's good side. Last, don't just react. Proactively
- 46:08structure your case. Every case management order
- 46:12you propose as a 271 motion, you will not need
- 46:17to file it later. You've already laid the groundwork
- 46:20and opposing counsel will be on board with what
- 46:23you are presenting. They will know if they're
- 46:26bad behavior. And if you have to resort to that
- 46:28271 sanction, you have already done so. Last
- 46:32slide, please. The bottom line, in an era of
- 46:40overloaded dockets and increasingly sophisticated
- 46:43benches, the power move is not aggression. It
- 46:47is strategic professionalism. Remember, civility
- 46:51builds credibility, credibility earns trust,
- 46:55and trust wins cases. That is all for today,
- 47:01but I would love to take your questions. It looks
- 47:10like we have quite a couple of questions so far
- 47:13just to start us off. Do you submit proposed
- 47:16CMO at any stage of the litigation or at only
- 47:19certain phases and matters? So I recommend that
- 47:24you keep those case management orders as your
- 47:26go -to tool at any stage of litigation. It's
- 47:31very helpful if you can file them at the outset
- 47:34once you get a read on opposing counsel or the
- 47:36case as a whole. A lot of times you don't see
- 47:39the true colors of people until you're down in
- 47:42the trenches months in. So you can really use
- 47:45them at any time. It's very, very important that
- 47:49you are Surgical and what you ask for in those
- 47:53case management orders, they are going to be
- 47:55a huge advantage to you at any stage of the litigation.
- 47:59Obviously not a week before trial, but while
- 48:02you're in the trenches on flushing out issues
- 48:05and before you go to any settlement, I highly
- 48:07recommend that you do that, especially before
- 48:10you engage in multiple rounds of discovery. Great,
- 48:16thank you. And then I have another one. I like
- 48:19the idea of bifurcation, but when I have it tends
- 48:22to result in a longer fight over property division.
- 48:26Would love to know your thoughts. So this has
- 48:29not been my experience. As I mentioned when we
- 48:32were on that slide, a lot of times people are
- 48:36very eager just to have status over with. I find
- 48:41that that lingering limbo of, I'm still married,
- 48:45but we're separated, but not legally separated
- 48:47and not together. It really clouds how people
- 48:50come into what to do with their assets. When
- 48:54they've already bifurcated status, a lot of the
- 48:58stuff you can then explain to the client is just
- 49:01stuff. No one's going to leave this divorce happy.
- 49:05You already have your new life before you, you're
- 49:08single, let's move on and just resolve the property
- 49:11disputes. Nine times out of 10, I have found
- 49:15that that helps with property division and does
- 49:18not hinder it. Your experience may be quite different.
- 49:22If you come across a case, feel free to email
- 49:24me and reach out about, I'm happy to help you
- 49:27craft some language for your client to nip that
- 49:29perception in the bud and help them move towards
- 49:32dividing their property. All right, thank you.
- 49:40And let's see. Let's see here, it looks like
- 49:44we're... If I go ahead and search here, oh, there
- 49:49is a question. Perfect. All right, when you have
- 49:52opposing counsel not disclosing assets and schedule
- 49:54of assets and debts, then not providing information
- 49:57in response to informal and formal discovery
- 50:00requests when no motion to compel was filed,
- 50:03has had two different attorneys. What do you
- 50:05suggest if opposing council is not willingly
- 50:08providing information related to workers comp
- 50:11claims, which may have a CP interest cash out
- 50:15of PTO or other employment, et cetera. Penis.
- 50:21Most of the time you can read early on, just
- 50:23as you have, whether or not opposing counsel
- 50:26is going to be forthcoming with information.
- 50:28A lot of times it's not opposing counsel, it's
- 50:30their clients. Clients who believe that, you
- 50:34know, my husband or wife has no interest in my
- 50:36workman's compensation claim. I'm the one that's
- 50:38injured. I'm the one living with these things.
- 50:39Don't give them any information on that. I had
- 50:42a recent situation with a CalPERS case. Husband's
- 50:46not only getting a pension, but also some sort
- 50:48of disability benefit. He had no issue with wife
- 50:51taking half of his pension. He wanted her to
- 50:53get none of the disability because he was the
- 50:55injured one. Refused to give any documents, subpoenas
- 50:59will go a long way. If you then don't get that
- 51:02third party subpoena response, you have a lot
- 51:05more at your disposal for third party non -compliance
- 51:09and sanctions. Companies don't want to engage
- 51:12in a litigation fight. They don't want to pay
- 51:14outside counsel to do discovery disputes. get
- 51:17as much as you can through subpoenas early on.
- 51:21A lot of times I will just do subpoenas for financial
- 51:24documents and information, even if there hasn't
- 51:27been a discovery dispute yet, because I don't
- 51:30know what I don't know until I get the documents.
- 51:32And if I already have a packet from Wells Fargo,
- 51:35for example, and see that the parties had nine
- 51:37case nine. It's open, excuse me, but wife only
- 51:42knew of two and husband only disclosed three.
- 51:44One, they may not have been aware of them or
- 51:46their signatory on another account, but I have
- 51:48the full picture. Sometimes you will run into
- 51:51roadblocks where husband or wife is on an account
- 51:55with a third party. So the bank will completely
- 51:58redact documents. I've gotten a packet from Wells
- 52:01Fargo where every single item in the file was
- 52:04redacted to the point I had no idea what was
- 52:06going on. But at least I knew there were some
- 52:08accounts there and I was able to then pinpoint
- 52:11opposing counsel and ultimately get an order
- 52:13from the court where they had to overturn all
- 52:15of those documents. It was innocuous. It was
- 52:19something as simple as a child was on the account
- 52:21and it was actually theirs. But wife refused
- 52:24to turn anything over because she thought she
- 52:26had the advantage in keeping that hidden. And
- 52:29sure enough, there were assets in there that
- 52:30were commingled with son's account that were
- 52:33relevant to the divorce. And I only knew it because
- 52:35of the packet of redact. documents that I got
- 52:37from Wells Fargo. So use your subpoenas as much
- 52:41as you can. That third -party discovery is really,
- 52:44really crucial. All right, I've got another one.
- 52:49How do you handle a judge that tolerates incivility?
- 52:57They are not inclined to address those issues.
- 53:01Maybe they were co -counsel with someone who's
- 53:04been practicing in an area for years or. They
- 53:07they have a different relationship with some
- 53:09of the attorneys and it can cloud whether or
- 53:11not it's not supposed to, but it can cloud whether
- 53:14or not sanctions are granted. Again, you'll find
- 53:17situations where judges are not inclined to order
- 53:20those 271 sanctions to either party just to make
- 53:23it fair and just so they don't have to address
- 53:26it. It does happen. That's why you don't ask
- 53:29for those sanctions at the outset. You do everything
- 53:32possible to make it so that the judge has to
- 53:35order them. in the future. It's not discretionary.
- 53:39You have built those CMOs out. You have orders
- 53:42already in place. Then when you show that opposing
- 53:45counsel has violated an order of the court, something
- 53:49that they agreed to do or that the court is telling
- 53:51them they have to do, the court... their hands
- 53:54are a little bit more tied to order those sanctions
- 53:56that you're asking for. So if you're very strategic
- 53:59in doing those four steps that I laid out for
- 54:01you, if you have to resort to sanctions later
- 54:04on, you are much, much more likely to get them.
- 54:10All right, and let's see. When you receive communication
- 54:13from opposing counsel loaded with insults directed
- 54:15to you or your client, do you just ignore it
- 54:17or do you make an effort to refute it at all?
- 54:20Generally do not. There are some really good
- 54:25books that I'm happy to share with anyone if
- 54:27you have a problem with just letting it roll
- 54:29off your back. A lot of times when you respond
- 54:32to those things, it's going to create anxiety
- 54:34for you. One, not only because you're reading
- 54:37these things, you're going to get defensive.
- 54:39What you can fire off can be heat of the moment.
- 54:43Like I said, open that text box, type up your
- 54:45response, save it for yourself, never send it.
- 54:48Let them go. An example, I had put in an email
- 54:53to opposing counsel on a case. Your client's
- 54:56spousal support was delinquent. It had been four
- 54:58days past due. I received an email saying, spousal
- 55:02support was received today. Let's say it was
- 55:04day six and it was not delinquent. Delinquent
- 55:08means it was never sent. Well, as we all know,
- 55:12delinquent means late. All I did was address
- 55:14that back and say, you know, great, I'm glad
- 55:17it was sent. We can both agree it was a few days
- 55:19late. Please remind your client it's due by this
- 55:22date. I addressed. Very, very kindly, but not
- 55:26directly the little dig that I had used something
- 55:29incorrectly, but just let it roll off. Make those
- 55:33correspondence clear and concise. Kill them with
- 55:36kindness. It's the best for you on a personal
- 55:39level, on a professional level, and the judge
- 55:41will look very, very highly upon it. All right,
- 55:49it looks like we've got one more question. Being
- 55:51new to this area, I have observed deposing counsel
- 55:53submit false statements through ex parte applications
- 55:56that read very persuasively and successfully
- 55:58misled the court. What advice might you offer
- 56:01to address these tactics with the court? Do a
- 56:06really good job. If you know something is false
- 56:08that's been filed with the court on an ex parte
- 56:10basis, if you get an unfavorable ex parte ruling
- 56:13based on those untruths, you can file your own
- 56:17motion to have those set aside and clear the
- 56:20record. So for example, if they're saying, you
- 56:22know, husband says ABCD and wife is alienating
- 56:26husband from the children, but you have a completely
- 56:29different story. A lot of times this is where
- 56:31those communications from your client come into
- 56:34play. you'll have a record showing, no, I gave
- 56:37the children, from wife's perspective, I gave
- 56:39the children whenever he asked for them, or I
- 56:41accommodate these calls, or he just never calls.
- 56:44So follow up with your own motion if necessary.
- 56:49First, of course, try to meet and confer with
- 56:51opposing counsel and build the record in writing.
- 56:54Hold that line, like I said, that's always step
- 56:56one, meet and confer, point out the untruths.
- 56:59If you can, correct them. with writings that
- 57:04you have, evidence that you have, and if you
- 57:06cannot resolve it, that's when you file your
- 57:08motion asking the court to set it aside and point
- 57:11out all of the error in opposing counsel's ways.
- 57:20All right, it looks like that's it for questions
- 57:22today. Do you have any other any other closing
- 57:25statements you'd like to make, Noelle? I would
- 57:28like to again thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 57:31for sponsoring this CLE today and all of you
- 57:35for spending your lunch hour with me. Again,
- 57:38if you have any specific questions come up today
- 57:41or in the future, feel free to email me. My email
- 57:45address should be on the court materials, but
- 57:48you can also look up Noelle Guth on the State
- 57:51Bar website, and I am happy to work with you,
- 57:53answer your questions, send you samples. I believe
- 57:56that we all benefit when we can work together
- 57:59as co -counsel in the field of family law. what
- 58:03makes one of us stronger makes all of us stronger
- 58:06and it benefits us and our clients. I hope you
- 58:08all have a great afternoon.