Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Top Trending Battles in Homeowner-Side HOA Law
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome, everyone. My name is Howard Gould. I'm
- 0:07co -chair of the real estate section for the
- 0:09Beverly Hills Bar Association. And I'm very happy
- 0:13to have you all come to the program today on
- 0:17Top Trending Battles in Homeowner -side HOA Law
- 0:21with our speaker, Michael Kushner. Before we
- 0:25begin, I want to give you a list of what upcoming
- 0:28programs are. At the moment, we are a program
- 0:30that's pretty far out. September 17th, so just
- 0:36next week, we're going to have our 2025 case
- 0:40law review by Anna Liu and Olivia Doppler. Elizabeth
- 0:45Dryden, my co -chair, is going to moderate that
- 0:47program. On October 23rd, we have a program on
- 0:52landlord insurance coverage for habitability
- 0:55claims in landlord tenant disputes with Steve
- 0:58Roucher, former president of Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:01and insurance agent Dan Fine. On November 3rd,
- 1:06we're doing something very timely in a program
- 1:10on SB 79, which is the transit -oriented construction.
- 1:16law that was passed that overrides a lot of local
- 1:20discretion in terms of where they put projects
- 1:23and how big the projects are. And projects can
- 1:26go up large projects very close to or next to
- 1:30single -family residences. And Sherry Bonstill
- 1:34of Greenberg Gloucester is going to speak on
- 1:36that program. And commercial mortgage broker
- 1:39Trevor Damon. Damien is going to speak and Joe
- 1:42Cobart will moderate that. In December, we don't
- 1:46have a program. My executive committee will be
- 1:48getting together for a holiday party. And just
- 1:51as a pitch, anybody who wants to be on the executive
- 1:54committee should contact the bar or email me
- 1:58hgoold at hgooldlaw .com. And we're happy to
- 2:02have more practitioners on our executive committee
- 2:05to plan programs. January 21, Jennifer Felton,
- 2:10who has spoken for us before, is going to talk
- 2:13about legal ethics when advising on documenting
- 2:16and resolving real estate matters. And she has
- 2:20a whole list of some interesting topics about
- 2:24conflicts of interest and other things that come
- 2:26up in those situations. And sometimes those are
- 2:29hard to recognize. February 18th is a program
- 2:33on real estate investments in conflict. We're
- 2:37going to talk about partition actions and receiverships,
- 2:40which come up when the owners of the real estate
- 2:43investment are not seeing eye to eye with each
- 2:47other. and our speakers, our attorney, Ori Blumenfeld,
- 2:50and receiver, Stephen J. Donnell. Stephen and
- 2:55his father before him have very long history
- 2:57as receivers in real estate matters, both in
- 3:01California and around the country. In March,
- 3:04we're planning a program on Quiet Title. It's
- 3:07an overview, sort of Quiet Title 101, by Nate
- 3:10Bernstein. Somewhere also, by the way, in February
- 3:15to April timeframe, I would anticipate we will
- 3:18do our annual program on reviewing the new California
- 3:21Association of Realtors, CAR. forms and other
- 3:25new things that may be happening at CAR. And
- 3:28again, we'll try to get Janet Gardner to join
- 3:30us for that program. April will do the 2026 case
- 3:35review, which we're doing the 2025 one here next
- 3:38week. In May, we're planning a program focusing
- 3:42specifically on arbitration clauses in real estate
- 3:45contracts, which obviously would apply more generally
- 3:48to sort of any kind of contract. But there are
- 3:50a number of sort of tricks and turns to take
- 3:53a look at in arbitration clauses, which usually
- 3:56people look at as sort of perfunctory, but if
- 3:59you end up in a dispute, they can be sort of
- 4:02profound in terms of how they affect the outcome
- 4:05of your real estate dispute. One other before
- 4:10I introduce Michael, we use the Q &A here for
- 4:13questions, not the chat. You can find a link
- 4:16to the program materials in the chat and some
- 4:18other announcements from the Beverly Hills Bar.
- 4:20But when you put in questions, please put those
- 4:22in the Q &A. We'll try to get to all those and
- 4:24we'll try to do them appropriately where they
- 4:26come up in the program if we're able to. So again,
- 4:30it's a pleasure to have Michael Kushner back
- 4:32with us. He's the founding and managing partner
- 4:35of MBK Chapman PC and a pioneer in homeowner
- 4:40side HOA law in California. And back in July,
- 4:43he gave a talk for us on the Davis Sterling Act,
- 4:46which was very informative. Mr. Kushner protects
- 4:51homeowners from abusive and mismanaged associations,
- 4:55representing homeowners in disputes involving
- 4:58what They consider abusive boards of directors,
- 5:01selective enforcement, illegal fines, architectural
- 5:05committee denials, records violations, and other
- 5:09forms of misconduct by HOAs or their management
- 5:13companies. He's developed his own proprietary
- 5:16legal systems that relate to enforcing the Davis
- 5:19-Stirling Act on behalf of homeowners. And he's
- 5:22the author of HOA Hell, California Homeowner's
- 5:25Definitive Guide to Beating Bad OHAs, which you
- 5:29can find on Amazon. Michael's a UC Berkeley grad
- 5:32and a UCLA School of Law grad. And Michael, thank
- 5:35you for joining us again. Well, thank you. That
- 5:38was a very nice introduction. I appreciate that.
- 5:41Let me share my screen with everybody first,
- 5:44and then I can kind of start this thing. I'm
- 5:47assuming everybody will be able to see that.
- 5:50Today, last time I did the presentation, it was
- 5:53very broad presentation. It was on the Davis
- 5:55-Stirling Act as a whole. But today, I wanted
- 5:58to do something that's a little bit more down
- 6:04to earth. These are the top, and it's going to
- 6:06be the top five trending battles that are super
- 6:09hot right now that are steeped or touch on HOA
- 6:13law in California. Here are the five battles
- 6:17we're going to cover today. what everybody calls
- 6:20Flock cameras. Flock's a private company, we'll
- 6:22get to that in a couple minutes, but it's become
- 6:24so synonymous with the brand, just like Jacuzzi
- 6:27and Spa, or Thermos and Vacuum model, that when
- 6:30people talk about Flock cameras, they're talking
- 6:32about the auto license plate reader cameras,
- 6:35and that's what ALPR cameras are. So I'm gonna
- 6:37refer to it as Flock, just because that's how
- 6:39a lot of people refer to it. But that's the most
- 6:42popular hot button topic right now in the state.
- 6:45And we've got some information today that you
- 6:48can hear nowhere else. And then another big one
- 6:52is e -bikes, e -scooters, and e -motorcycles.
- 6:54If you live in an HOA, you've probably seen kids
- 6:5713, 14, 15 years old racing through the neighborhood
- 7:00on e -bikes. I don't even see kids pedaling anymore,
- 7:03to be honest. Everybody seems to have one of
- 7:06these. And then the third issue is going to be
- 7:09HOA foreclosure spike. We are seeing a massive
- 7:12spike in foreclosures, even in communities with
- 7:16the median price of the homes in excess of a
- 7:19million dollars, which is something that is very
- 7:23counterintuitive. And there's a very good reason
- 7:26why that's happening. And we'll talk about that
- 7:27briefly. The next issue, and this has been very
- 7:31hot in the last week, is special assessments
- 7:34in the insurance crisis. I was on ABC News two
- 7:38separate times last week, Channel 7. because
- 7:41of these massive special assessments that hit
- 7:43two local Southern California HOAs. We'll talk
- 7:46about that. And then the disaster rebuilding
- 7:49rights, and specifically SB 625, which was a
- 7:52law that was passed after the huge Palisades
- 7:54fires, that's actually a really big win for homeowners.
- 7:58And it's brand new, so there's no court law on
- 8:01it yet. But it is a well -written law, and I
- 8:04think it's going to be really helpful. So let's
- 8:07start with the number one topic, the big hot
- 8:10button issue, which is these flock cameras. And
- 8:13this is basically license plate surveillance.
- 8:17And if you look at the slides and the link that
- 8:21is in the chat gives you a list or gives you
- 8:24a PDF of this entire presentation as well as
- 8:28a one page. resource sheet that links to a bunch
- 8:31of articles that I've written that touch on every
- 8:33one of the topics we're going to talk about.
- 8:34But all the staff sheets that you need from the
- 8:37Civil Code or the Code of Civil Procedure, whatever
- 8:39I cite today, you're going to see listed throughout
- 8:41and in that sheet. And look what happened there.
- 8:47We just had like a weird thing just happen. Sorry
- 8:49about that. So what's a flock camera? Well, flock
- 8:52camera, it's very different than your normal
- 8:54everyday surveillance camera. Okay, I've got
- 8:57surveillance cameras all over my house our neighborhood
- 9:00has surveillance cameras at the gates and a few
- 9:03other places Those are those just take what's
- 9:06being taped and and it's fed The data is fed
- 9:09to an isolated hard drive somewhere and it's
- 9:12controlled by one or more people and that's where
- 9:14it ends flock technology is extremely different
- 9:17and the biggest difference is is that anybody
- 9:21That has that is a user in that database the
- 9:25flock data has access to feeds from all over,
- 9:31even though it might not be where their cameras
- 9:33are. So for example, if let's say you have flock
- 9:36cameras in your neighborhood, and then there's
- 9:38a flock camera by the city or the county on the
- 9:43way to work. And then let's say near your office
- 9:46building, there's another flock camera somewhere.
- 9:48And then let's say there's flock at your building.
- 9:51Somebody that wanted to could track your entire
- 9:55trip from your home to your office by mapping
- 9:59out your geographic pattern, wherever you were.
- 10:03And by having AI do a little analysis, they could
- 10:06figure out what your average speed was. They
- 10:08could figure out over time how often you make
- 10:11that trip, what times you're usually at a certain
- 10:13point. The point being that privacy is out the
- 10:16window. And so it's not just the camera that
- 10:20captures your plate. Yes, it does that. But it's
- 10:23a camera that is accessible by data users anywhere.
- 10:28And one of the big proofs of that is, if you
- 10:30want to find out who has access to your license
- 10:33plate, there's actually websites. You can go
- 10:35on Reddit and look, or you can maybe Google it.
- 10:38I didn't try Googling it. I did on Reddit. But
- 10:40there's companies out there that you can actually
- 10:42put in your license plate and find out how many
- 10:44data feeds that you're on. That's how ubiquitous
- 10:47this is. It's a very big privacy issue. And that's
- 10:50why it's so hot. So, you think that the - Michael,
- 10:56one point on that is that in HHOA, the HOA will
- 11:01decide who actually has access to that, and therefore,
- 11:05it may only, you don't know who all it'll be,
- 11:07right? Who has access - No, no, it's much worse
- 11:10than that, and I'm gonna get to that, I promise.
- 11:12I will get to that. It is much worse than that.
- 11:15If, when it comes to surveillance cameras, Then
- 11:19whoever the HOA is giving access to has access
- 11:22for good or for bad when it comes to flock technology
- 11:25There are literally there could be tens of thousands
- 11:28of people that have access and you don't know
- 11:31And we're gonna talk about a new law that is
- 11:34gonna be proposed that'll change all of that
- 11:37But we'll talk about that shortly. So where I
- 11:40was heading was the Davis -Stirling Act is completely
- 11:42silent on the use of flock technology in private
- 11:48HOA communities. Now there is state law that
- 11:51governs flock cameras in California and that
- 11:54starts at 1798 .90 .51. But those are written
- 12:01largely for law enforcement and public entity
- 12:05government uses. There are some statutory controls
- 12:11built into these three major statutes here that
- 12:14do govern any usage including small organization,
- 12:18individual or private organizations. But for
- 12:20the most part, the big teeth in the law only
- 12:24covers public entities like the government and
- 12:27specifically law enforcement. And so the Davis
- 12:29-Stirling Act is silent. There is no notice rules,
- 12:32no access rules, no use limit. There's no requirement
- 12:36that anybody other than the board, those five
- 12:39individuals decide. And it gives homeowners no
- 12:43leverage and no rights. And hopefully, we're
- 12:47going to change that. So let's talk about the
- 12:50two pressure points that are there when it comes
- 12:52to personal liability and the Constitution. So
- 12:56when it comes to liability for a obvious misuse
- 13:01of flock data, at least the part that controls
- 13:04individuals, it's not just the HOA that's going
- 13:07to be liable. They will. But it's also going
- 13:09to be the individual. And that's because of the
- 13:11statute that's listed here, Civil Code 1798 .90.
- 13:14point 54, lets a person harmed by knowing the
- 13:18misuse sue the individual who caused it. So there
- 13:22is going to be personal liability. And when it
- 13:24comes to a board member that's caught under that
- 13:28statute, assuming that the judge decides to use
- 13:32his discretion and do the punishment, the business
- 13:35judgment rule will not apply. The targets under
- 13:39that statute is who's doing the searching. not
- 13:42the entity that he might be affiliated with.
- 13:44But if he'd be doing it within the course and
- 13:46scope of his duties, of course, under respondeat
- 13:48superior and agency theory, you do have liability
- 13:51against the HOA, but there is no business judge
- 13:54or real corporate shield there. There's also,
- 13:56of course, in California, we have constitutional
- 13:59protections that are founded article one, section
- 14:02one, the general right to privacy, which is helpful.
- 14:06But again, there's not much. You'll see that
- 14:10the teeth in this law, as it exists today, are
- 14:13virtually non -existent. So what did I mean when
- 14:17I talked about how anybody that has usage access
- 14:22can have access to your data? Well, these are
- 14:25real numbers. This is what's happening. The flock
- 14:27cameras aren't closed systems. They connect to
- 14:30a national network. Subscribers, even private
- 14:33parties, can search that network. So now there
- 14:39is a sharing ban. that is listed in the Civil
- 14:42Code 1798 .90 .55. And if you read it, you'd
- 14:45go, oh, that's great. Except it doesn't apply
- 14:48to private organizations, and thus it doesn't
- 14:50apply to HOAs. That's one of the ones that only
- 14:53applies to public entities, law enforcement.
- 14:57So here's what the reporting showed recently.
- 15:00In the last few months, there have been 4 ,000
- 15:03searches by local police agencies that are run
- 15:05on behalf of federal immigration authorities,
- 15:08ICE, whatever. Those were the ones that were
- 15:11actually written into the audit logs. So that's
- 15:14how often law enforcement is using this. Even
- 15:16with the laws in place that do control them,
- 15:19there are loopholes. And 30 cities, as a result
- 15:22of that statistic, 30 cities pulled out recently
- 15:25and canceled their FLOC contracts. HOAs, it's
- 15:29growing. The amount of HOAs that are signing
- 15:32up to an ALPR, Auto License Plate Reader System,
- 15:35like FLOC, is growing. while usage on large organizations
- 15:40or public organizations is somewhat stabilizing
- 15:43or shrinking. And that's the problem that that's
- 15:47why it's becoming an issue in HOA law, is more
- 15:50and more HOAs every day in California are adding
- 15:53these things. There are 65 ,000 HOAs in California
- 15:56covering over 14 million people. That is a lot
- 15:59of people and a lot of HOAs. Now, The problem
- 16:04I have with the current law, aside from the fact
- 16:06that it doesn't apply to everybody, i .e. HOAs,
- 16:10is that unlike many of the laws in the Davis
- 16:13-Stirling Act, the remedies are largely discretionary.
- 16:17The statutory penalty of $2 ,500 is completely
- 16:22discretionary. You could spend a lot of money
- 16:25litigating this case, prove the case, prove that
- 16:28your data was misused, win, and the judge could
- 16:31say, man, I'm not gonna. I'm not going to issue
- 16:33any statutory damages. Same with attorney's fees.
- 16:37Discretionary. Every other fee -shifting statute
- 16:39in the Davis -Stirling Act, and there are over
- 16:41a dozen, every one of them is mandatory. This,
- 16:44not part of the Davis -Stirling Act, is discretionary.
- 16:47And when it's discretionary, it doesn't exist.
- 16:50There are no protections. The teeth have been
- 16:53removed from this animal because any particular
- 16:57judge could decide not to utilize those teeth.
- 17:02There's a legislative fix that's gonna be in
- 17:04the works. It's gonna be called, we hope, the
- 17:08ALPR Data Transparency Act, and it's a law that
- 17:11I wrote. I worked a long time on it, and I wrote
- 17:14nine statutes that I'm hoping I'll get a sponsor
- 17:18for that'll be added to the Davis -Stirling Act
- 17:22that will do all of these things. I went, studied
- 17:27that law. and found all these loopholes and all
- 17:31the problems that I have. And I closed, in my
- 17:33mind, I closed all the loopholes and gave homeowners
- 17:36a lot more rights. So number one thing I wanted
- 17:38to do is I wanted to make sure that members had
- 17:41consent, that a board couldn't vote to install
- 17:44flock cameras without getting at least the majority
- 17:47of a quorum to vote in favor of the use of it.
- 17:53And it would only be good for five years and
- 17:56another vote would have to happen. So it's going
- 17:58to have its own sunset clause. I built in purpose
- 18:01limits that the scans could only be used to report
- 18:04crimes or safety threats or things like missing
- 18:08children or stolen car or who had access to the
- 18:11gate or for legal process, not for fines, not
- 18:15for toes and not for any HOA discipline. So not
- 18:20to be used it to catch. people that are speeding
- 18:23or not to be used to catch somebody who might
- 18:26have a commercial sticker on their car. I don't
- 18:30want that kind of imposition and violation of
- 18:33privacy to be used as a weapon against the homeowners
- 18:36unless there's been some sort of crime or health
- 18:38or safety issue. I built in a strong 30 -day
- 18:42retention window that the data has to die within
- 18:4530 days except for narrow exceptions. For example,
- 18:49if there's a demand for preservation of evidence,
- 18:51or an active investigation or active litigation,
- 18:55then there would be a retention mandate. Query
- 18:59transparency. Every time a director or a manager,
- 19:05and I have disclosure controls there as well,
- 19:08but every time somebody authorized was accessing
- 19:11the HOA's data, that person would have to log
- 19:16on by name and write their purpose or click down
- 19:19on the dropdown for their purpose each time they
- 19:23logged in. Why are you looking at this? The amount
- 19:25of abuses we're seeing from ex -spouses has been
- 19:29astronomical. And this touches base on people
- 19:32that are not only protected under California's
- 19:37laws that are designed to protect abused spouses,
- 19:42but also people that are subject to DV orders,
- 19:46domestic violence orders. And so there's a lot
- 19:49of transparency that can be built into the law
- 19:51that I wrote. Disclosure controls. There's no
- 19:54selling or sharing. That national network gets
- 19:57turned off because the HOAs will be mandated
- 20:00that in their contract, the flock company cannot
- 20:04allow access to anybody outside of the HOA. That
- 20:07would shut down the entire network problem and
- 20:10make it like a private surveillance camera. And
- 20:13I changed the remedies. The remedies are much
- 20:15bigger. There's a $2 ,500 statutory violation
- 20:18and there's up to a $25 ,000 per incident damages
- 20:23violation and mandatory attorney's fees, all
- 20:29of it mandatory, none of it discretionary. So
- 20:32let's cross our fingers. I'll be introducing
- 20:33that in October to three legislators. And somebody
- 20:40put on the comment here, I've been flocked .com.
- 20:44I don't remember if that's the one I looked at,
- 20:47but they're out there. And thank you for that,
- 20:49Gabriel. Michael, let me raise one issue there.
- 20:53On the 30 -day retention, let's say there's been
- 20:57some crime committed, but it's not discovered.
- 21:00Or somebody's been gone for 30, 60 days, got
- 21:03burglarized, and they say, well, gee, I want
- 21:05to use this information to find out who came
- 21:08in and out of the community. Most communities,
- 21:11a lot of them are not gated. There's no record
- 21:13of it. The flop camera would have that. But if
- 21:15they're gone, 30 days or they don't discover
- 21:18something for a while, that information is all
- 21:20gone. No, it's not gone. It's not accessible
- 21:23by the HOA. So what would happen in that situation
- 21:26is that the HOA or law enforcement or whoever
- 21:29would contact FLOC and say, all right, we need
- 21:33you to go and make this data accessible to us
- 21:36for a period of time. So the data is not gone.
- 21:39It just, the HOA loses access to it. Okay, and
- 21:43remember, built into the contract will be a lot
- 21:46of controls on flock and they won't be able to
- 21:48release that. It won't be available on their
- 21:50database. It'll have to be backdoored and secure.
- 21:54So they'll have it, but after 30 days, unless
- 21:57there's a preservation of evidence demand that's
- 22:00served before that, the HOA will lose access
- 22:02to the data. Thank you. The next issue, and this
- 22:07is a very big one for the reasons that we'll
- 22:09talk about in a minute, is e -bikes, e -scooters,
- 22:11and e -motorcycles. Interestingly enough, I was
- 22:13walking with a friend yesterday. I have two Belgian
- 22:16Malinois that are trained to tack dogs, and I
- 22:19often work with a decoy. My dogs will bite the
- 22:26person with the suit on, and we practice. I was
- 22:28walking with a friend of mine yesterday to take
- 22:30my dogs out for some of their practice. And three
- 22:34kids, probably about age 10 to 12, were zooming
- 22:37by us on the sidewalk at probably 20 miles an
- 22:41hour on these e -bikes. And it was funny, because
- 22:43I said, you know, tomorrow I'll be talking about
- 22:45that. And they were going on and off the curb
- 22:47into the street without even looking both ways.
- 22:50No cars were there, thank goodness. But boy,
- 22:52oh, boy, it just so happens the two people I'm
- 22:56walking with are both emergency room doctors.
- 22:58And the conversation we had was you should see
- 23:01how many of these kids we see come in the emergency
- 23:03room now. This is a growing problem. These bikes
- 23:07are so popular now that they outnumber, at least,
- 23:10and this is anecdotal, but they outnumber the
- 23:12old fashioned bikes that you have to pedal to
- 23:15go anywhere. Now these e -bikes all have pedals,
- 23:19but the kids aren't using them. They're using
- 23:22the gas pedal. And so here's why it's such a
- 23:26big deal. There are three classes of e -bikes,
- 23:30and then there's something called e -motorcycle.
- 23:33Let's get rid of the e -motorcycle for a second.
- 23:35E -motorcycle is an actual motorcycle. It's just
- 23:37not a Harley. It doesn't have the sound. It's
- 23:40an electric motorcycle. They can be over, or
- 23:45they are over 750 watts, and most of them go
- 23:49at least 60 miles an hour. Some of them go over
- 23:52100. Now, the one we're going to be talking about
- 23:55that's been in the news is the Suron Ultra. That
- 23:57one has a top speed of 60. But you get from 0
- 24:01to 60 very quickly. And in order to ride an e
- 24:04-motorcycle, it's like riding a Harley. You have
- 24:07to have a driver's license, first of all. And
- 24:10not only that, but you have to have a motorcycle
- 24:12license. It used to be called a Class 2. I don't
- 24:16know what they call it today. I have the old
- 24:18-fashioned one back from the 80s when I got mine,
- 24:20and it's Class 2. But I don't know what they
- 24:22call it today. We're going to set your motorcycles
- 24:25aside for a second. We know that's what's relevant
- 24:27in the news story. So I want to talk about the
- 24:29class 1 and 2s and the class 3s. Class 1 and
- 24:322 is defined as a pedal assisted bike with a
- 24:37throttle that can go up to 20 miles an hour.
- 24:40And there's no age or any kind of restrictions
- 24:43other than the helmet law. Kids under 18 have
- 24:47to wear a helmet. That's pretty much it. Anybody
- 24:49can ride a class 1 and 2. They're very easy to
- 24:54go in and modify. Sometimes it can be done with
- 24:57a tightening of a screw or a switch. And on some
- 25:00models, it can be done on the internet or by
- 25:02an app. That is illegal for anybody under the
- 25:06age of 18 to modify their e -bike to go beyond
- 25:10the 20 miles an hour or to turn off the pedal
- 25:13assist. Class 3 bikes go up to 28 miles an hour.
- 25:17You have to be 16 to ride a Class 3. You don't
- 25:21have to have a driver's license. You don't have
- 25:24to have a motorcycle license, but you have to
- 25:25be over the age. We have to be 16 or older to
- 25:28ride one. Why is this so important? There really
- 25:32is only an eight mile an hour difference between
- 25:34the two. Why is this so important? Well, I'll
- 25:40get to that in a minute. So let's first talk
- 25:42about what HOAs can do to regulate these, and
- 25:45then we'll talk about why the classifications
- 25:46are important. HOAs, Obviously, if you live in
- 25:50one, you know that HOAs have vast authority to
- 25:52control their common areas. If you've got private
- 25:56streets, if you've got landscaping, if you've
- 25:59got little green belts or pool areas or tennis
- 26:04courts, they can govern what activities are done
- 26:07in those common areas. They can't control what,
- 26:11if you live in Koto and you've got two or three
- 26:13acres and you're riding on your property, HOA
- 26:16can't control anything. They have no say. But
- 26:19as soon as you leave and you go into the common
- 26:21area, they have a right to pass rules. And under
- 26:244350 of the civil code, rules have to be reasonable.
- 26:28Well, to the extent that your HOA is simply mirroring
- 26:33California law, it's going to be per se deemed
- 26:35reasonable. And you're not going to get any mileage
- 26:39out of a rule that's just tracking California
- 26:43law. California law is what established those
- 26:46three classes. and which establish the age limitations.
- 26:51Class 1 and 2, there is no age. Class 3, there
- 26:53is. And so if an age away rule exists to mandate
- 26:58that those laws be followed and they turn it
- 27:00into their rule, it's going to be enforceable.
- 27:02The helmet rule is also going to be enforceable.
- 27:06We'll talk about that in a moment because for
- 27:09a different reason, it can even reach adults.
- 27:11So let's talk about why those classes matter.
- 27:13And this is why. Because District attorneys across
- 27:19the state have made public announcements that
- 27:21they are going to prosecute people who allow,
- 27:26we're talking about parents here for example,
- 27:27who allow their children to illegally ride a
- 27:32class of e -bike that they're not allowed to
- 27:34ride or they modify to take it out of that class
- 27:36and somebody gets seriously injured or killed.
- 27:41The tragedy that I wanna talk about is this Orange
- 27:43County case that occurred in April, just a few
- 27:46months ago. There was a 14 -year -old boy that
- 27:49was riding an e -motorcycle in this case. It
- 27:52was called the Suron Ultra B. Puts out 16 times
- 27:56the power any e -bike does and goes about 60
- 27:59miles an hour. So this kid had been riding this
- 28:02e -bike for a while and was stopped by police
- 28:04months before April of this year. And the police
- 28:07had a long conversation with this kid's mother.
- 28:10It lasted about a half an hour. How do I know
- 28:12that? Because it was on video. The police were
- 28:15wearing their There are chest cams at the time,
- 28:18and all of this video was preserved. This mother
- 28:22was a single mom, 14 -year -old boy. She was
- 28:25told, hey, I'm not sure if you're aware of it,
- 28:28but what you bought your son wasn't an e -bike.
- 28:30It was an e -motorcycle. Because a lot of kids
- 28:32will tell the parents what they want. The parents
- 28:34don't know what they're looking at. I can understand
- 28:36that, OK? But this mother was told, this is an
- 28:39e -motorcycle. You have to be 16. You have to
- 28:41have a motorcycle license. Your son is 14. He
- 28:44cannot ride this. If we're letting you off now
- 28:47with just a ticket, but if it happens again,
- 28:49we're going to, we're going to, you know, we
- 28:50have the right to impound that vehicle. And by
- 28:53the way, e -motorcycles are considered motor
- 28:55vehicles in the state of California, just like
- 28:58a car, a truck or a Harley. There's no difference
- 29:01when it comes to the law and the use of a license.
- 29:04So this kid is out there riding his Suran Ultra
- 29:08B again, doing wheelies in the street, and he
- 29:11hits an 80 year old man. The man is brought to
- 29:17the hospital, was touch and go for a while and
- 29:19died within a week of being put into the ICU.
- 29:27Todd Spitzer, Orange County District Attorney,
- 29:29issued a long public opinion about this and they
- 29:35are prosecuting this mother for manslaughter,
- 29:39or actually aiding and abetting manslaughter,
- 29:42and several other felonies. So we've got a child
- 29:45whose life a 14 year old whose life's ruined
- 29:49because he's gonna live with the fact that he
- 29:52By mistake, of course, but he killed somebody
- 29:54you're gonna have a mother who is at the very
- 29:57least gonna spend a Fortune fighting to keep
- 30:02herself out of jail for god knows how long and
- 30:05then of course that mother if that mother is
- 30:08convicted May not be able to be there for many
- 30:11years of her son's life She's a single mom. So
- 30:15that's going to affect both of them. And then,
- 30:17of course, you have the family of this poor 80
- 30:19-year -old or 81 -year -old. And that person's
- 30:23grandkids, person's kids, all have lost a family
- 30:27member because of something so dumb. So why do
- 30:30those classes matter? Because although this specific
- 30:33case dealt with an E motorcycle, Todd Spitzer
- 30:37and one of the district attorneys in one of the
- 30:41Northern California counties, and I can't remember
- 30:43which one, but it's in the linked article that
- 30:45I included in the resource list with your materials,
- 30:50has indicated that they will prosecute any parent
- 30:55whose child is riding an e -bike that has either
- 30:59been modified in violation of the law or is a
- 31:02class three and the person's too young to ride
- 31:04it and somebody gets hurt or killed, they're
- 31:06gonna prosecute there. So those classes matter.
- 31:09If you're a parent or if you represent a parent
- 31:12whose kid has got an e -bike, make sure your
- 31:15clients know they should know what class of e
- 31:18-bike they're buying their kid for Christmas.
- 31:20Because if the kid's under 16, it better be a
- 31:22one or a two. And if not, they cannot buy it
- 31:27for their kid because everybody's facing legal
- 31:29liability here. Now, Another big reason why this
- 31:36has hit the news lately is because there was
- 31:38a rash of cheap batteries that were coming from
- 31:42China, and I think Pakistan was one of the countries,
- 31:47that were these very cheaply made lithium ion
- 31:50batteries. For those of you who know anything
- 31:53about lithium ion batteries, when there's a fire,
- 31:55they burn extremely hot, much hotter than a normal
- 31:59fire, and You cannot put these fires out with
- 32:04water. If you spray water on a lithium -ion fire,
- 32:08the water will carry the fire elsewhere. It doesn't
- 32:11put it out, it spreads it. That's why a Tesla
- 32:14fire would be so dangerous. Well, these lithium
- 32:18-ion batteries were just combusting. Somebody
- 32:23leaves it plugged in too long, somebody leaves
- 32:26it overcharged and it gets too hot and it...
- 32:29It goes up in flames. Well, if you're living
- 32:31in connected housing, like a condo, that fire
- 32:34is now going to spread to the building. So a
- 32:37lot of HOAs have said you cannot charge lithium
- 32:39ion batteries in your unit. You have to charge
- 32:43them somewhere else. And they've even given created
- 32:45areas and common areas away from structures.
- 32:48So those are going to absolutely be enforceable
- 32:50rules. We've had some clients that wanted us
- 32:53to challenge them. And we said, no, we're not
- 32:55going to challenge them because we already can
- 32:57tell you it's objectively reasonable. Okay? So
- 33:01in addition to the fact that HOAs can just, they
- 33:05can track state law, they can pass rules that
- 33:08are reasonable. Health and safety, fire prevention
- 33:11is per se reasonable. And there is a rational
- 33:16connection between these cheaply made lithium
- 33:18ion batteries and fires. And therefore HOAs are
- 33:21always going to be able to pass rules. And more
- 33:24and more of them are every day, banning them
- 33:26from being inside your unit. Now, where we go
- 33:32with helmets? Well, California law, vehicle code
- 33:3521212 states that anybody under the age of 18
- 33:40must wear a helmet when riding a skateboard or
- 33:43a bike or an e -bike. And so any HOA that has
- 33:49a rule saying kids riding in our communities
- 33:53in the common areas must wear helmets. It doesn't
- 33:56matter if you as a parent don't like the helmet.
- 33:58HOAs has a right to pass that rule. And if your
- 34:01kid's gonna ride in the common area, the kid's
- 34:03gonna have to abide by the rule. But there's
- 34:07a way, and some HOAs have done this. Some HOAs
- 34:10have extended the helmet rule to adults, people
- 34:12over 18. And that rankles a lot of people. I'm
- 34:17an adult. I grew up in the 80s. I don't want
- 34:20to wear a helmet when I'm riding a bike. I never
- 34:21did when I was a kid. I don't want to do it now.
- 34:23Your age joy has a right to force you to do it
- 34:25in the common areas, but not because of state
- 34:29law. There is no state law that mandates an adult
- 34:31wear a bike helmet. What they can do is say,
- 34:34look, when you're riding in the common area,
- 34:36we've got liability. If somebody falls and as
- 34:38it sustains a serious brain injury, we're going
- 34:42to get sued, which means that our insurance is
- 34:44going to kick in. That affects everybody. It
- 34:46affects our insurance rates, it affects our future
- 34:51deductibles and our future ability to be able
- 34:53to obtain that insurance anyway. So for that
- 34:57purpose, for health and safety purposes, HOAs
- 34:59can pass these laws, and those are going to be
- 35:02deemed enforceable. And we're seeing HOAs do
- 35:05that now. So that's why. I want to let you know,
- 35:11Michael, that this is subject two of five, and
- 35:13we're at 106. This is saying that again? I'm
- 35:17just giving you a time check. Okay. Well, I'm
- 35:20sorry. How much longer do we have? We've, uh,
- 35:22we're at 106. Okay. All right. I'll speed up
- 35:25a bit. Let's talk about the foreclosure spike.
- 35:28We are seeing in our, in our office and we represent
- 35:31more homeowners, uh, than any other law firm
- 35:34there. There's three H homeowner side law firms
- 35:36in the state of California. The founding partners
- 35:38are the other two all worked for me and learned
- 35:41HOA law for me and formed their own firms. We're
- 35:44the only three out there. I created this niche.
- 35:46We are the most, probably got the most HOA clients
- 35:50of any firm. And we, colloquially, or at least
- 35:54this is just our, what we're seeing in the last
- 35:57year and a half is a massive spike in foreclosures
- 36:01in well -to -do communities. And why is that?
- 36:04Well, real quick, Civil Code 5700 lets HOAs enforce
- 36:08recorded liens 30 days after recording by a trustee
- 36:11sale. Assessments only, you cannot do a non -judicial
- 36:16foreclosure or trustee sale on a fine. You can
- 36:20only do that on a lien, a recorded lien, and
- 36:25if it's a result of an assessment, special or
- 36:29general, okay? And that's what 5710 basically
- 36:33says. 5710 says, look, HOAs that are trying to
- 36:36collect on special assessments or general assessments
- 36:39that are unpaid can utilize the same shortcut
- 36:43that that mortgage, you know, the banks use,
- 36:45which is a non -judicial foreclosure. Of course,
- 36:49those don't involve any judges, any hearings.
- 36:51Judicial foreclosure is still an option available,
- 36:53but that's the same everywhere. It's a lawsuit
- 36:56to foreclose. Now... Michael, would this require
- 37:00that the CCNRs actually provide a lien and foreclosure
- 37:04process? Not technically, okay? This is statute
- 37:11-driven. HLAs that... have the power to collect
- 37:17and enforce, which they do under the Davis -Stirling
- 37:19Act, except there's one exception, the very,
- 37:22very old CCNRs from like 45 years ago, if they
- 37:27haven't been amended, which I've never seen one
- 37:29that wasn't, they are the only ones that would
- 37:31lack that authority. And because of that, they've
- 37:33all been amended. That's why I've never seen
- 37:34one. But for everybody else, and that means for
- 37:37your intensive purposes, 99 .999 % of the time,
- 37:41that is not an issue. It's a statute -driven
- 37:44basis, and HOAs can foreclose, but there are
- 37:49a couple of ceilings on there, a couple of triggers.
- 37:52Number one, there's something called the 1 ,812
- 37:55-month rule. They cannot foreclose on a special
- 37:58assessment of less than $1 ,800. So you can't
- 38:02go and take somebody's house because they owe
- 38:04you $1 ,798. And to get to that number, that
- 38:08has to be pure assessment. You cannot calculate
- 38:10in that number attorney's fees, interest, late
- 38:13fees, and costs. It has to be actual assessment.
- 38:17So if there's a $300 a month assessment and a
- 38:20person hasn't paid in six months, there's your
- 38:22$1 ,800. Now they can foreclose, but not before
- 38:25that. Or 12 months. If the assessment has remained
- 38:30unpaid for 12 consecutive months, then the $1
- 38:33,800 a floor goes out the window and they can
- 38:36foreclose. Again, it has to be an assessment,
- 38:38can't be a fine, okay? But just like under Civil
- 38:42Code 2924 at SAC, Davis -Stirling Act is very
- 38:47clear and the courts in interpreting it have
- 38:48been very clear that the procedures have to be
- 38:51strictly followed. Every dot has to be, or every
- 38:54I has to be dotted and every T has to be crossed.
- 38:56So if anybody misses one thing, one notice, They
- 39:02didn't send the notice via certified mail. They
- 39:06do it one day too late. They have to start over.
- 39:09There is no, eh, it's an innocent mistake. There's
- 39:12no such thing as a minor error. And there's no
- 39:17such thing as, well, if the error doesn't actually
- 39:19make a difference, it wouldn't have made a difference.
- 39:20It doesn't matter. No. Strict liability. So you
- 39:24have that. And we talked about that here. I could
- 39:26skip this. Again, fines don't count. And we'll
- 39:33also skip this part. The interest on there is
- 39:36higher than normal. There are so many exceptions
- 39:40to our usury rules. It's actually the exceptions
- 39:42are the rule and the rule is the exception. But
- 39:46HOAs can collect up to 12 % annual interest as
- 39:49opposed to 10, in addition to late charges and
- 39:53attorney's fees. Another big issue with assessments
- 39:58and failure to pay is Fannie Mae and Freddie
- 40:01Mac. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac back the vast
- 40:03majority of loans. They have very strict guidelines
- 40:06on what can result in somebody's HOA being delisted.
- 40:11And if that happens, unless somebody's paying
- 40:13cash, nobody's selling because nobody can finance
- 40:15a loan. That means no buyer can come in and nobody's
- 40:18going to sell except to a cash buyer. Well, if
- 40:21you get delisted, you're screwed. Well, if more
- 40:25than 15 % of your members are 60 days or more
- 40:30past due, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac can delist
- 40:33you. I have articles on that, so I won't spend
- 40:35more time on that. Now there is that gauntlet
- 40:37we were talking about, those very strict dot
- 40:40your I cross your T's. This is them. 30 days
- 40:44certified mail notice before you can record with
- 40:47an itemized statement and bold faced warning
- 40:49and all their disclosed rights. And there's a
- 40:52list in the statute to the rights that they have
- 40:54to be told about. And you have to disclose them.
- 40:57And the statute even gives you a guidance as
- 40:59to how you should put it. That's 5660. 5665 is
- 41:03the homeowner's right to a payment plan meeting.
- 41:06They can request a meeting, say, I need a payment
- 41:08plan. And they can do that within 15 days. The
- 41:12HOA board must agree and must hold that meeting
- 41:15within 45 days in private, an executive session
- 41:18with that homeowner. 5670, HOA must offer. IDR.
- 41:24Everybody knows they have the IDR rights. They
- 41:26have to disclose it under the 5 ,300 disclosures
- 41:29that go out every year. But they specifically
- 41:32have to do it again every time they're going
- 41:34to record a lien or attempt to foreclose. You
- 41:37have to jump through the IDR. And all it is is
- 41:40you have a right to IDR. Here's what that is.
- 41:42Here's how you do it. 5 ,673. The HOA, this was
- 41:46something that was being abused a lot in the
- 41:49past. Late people H2As were turning these decisions
- 41:52over to the management companies and management
- 41:54companies were making these decisions. Statute
- 41:56came around and said, no, no, no, this has to
- 41:57be a board meeting. It has to be voted on by
- 42:00the board and only the board can implement this.
- 42:03And then the 5675 recorded notice has to provide
- 42:07the exact amount, a legal description, the owner
- 42:10and the itemized statement has to be attached.
- 42:13Bottom line, under 5690, if an H2A skips any
- 42:17of these, They have to start over, it's done,
- 42:20gone, adios, and there's no such thing as a Scrivener's
- 42:23Air. Now, another unique thing that is different
- 42:27from the normal 2924 mortgage or banking foreclosure,
- 42:32non -judicial foreclosure, is that with a non
- 42:36-judicial foreclosure under the Davis -Stirling
- 42:38Act, homeowners still have a right to remediate
- 42:41or redemption. I'm sorry, not remediate, redemption.
- 42:43They have a right of redemption or 5715. So for
- 42:4790 days after a sale date, the homeowner can
- 42:51still get their property back even after it goes
- 42:54to sale, usually by the HOA because it's going
- 42:57to be a bid, a creditor's bid, but they can get
- 43:00it back within 90 days if they meet the qualifications
- 43:04for the redemption, which is they have to have
- 43:07ready money. pay in full all fees, costs, interest,
- 43:10and the amount, the overdue past amount of the
- 43:14assessment. Once that is done, when that happens,
- 43:195685 says the HOA has only 21 days to properly
- 43:24release that lien, which means that they have
- 43:27to record a satisfaction or a paying off the
- 43:30lien. If they don't, they are going to be held
- 43:33liable for clouding title. And Unlike other commercial
- 43:40debts, 5735 says H -ways can't sell these. This
- 43:44is an H -way homeowner debt, and it stays there
- 43:47forever. Somebody's asked if the H -way does
- 43:49a non -judicial trustee sale, would it be affected
- 43:51by AB 2424, Simica 2924, the trustee can't sell
- 43:57the home? No, that does not apply to a Davis
- 44:01-Stirling Act sale, and it's probably because
- 44:04of the 90 -day redemption right. but that's just
- 44:07a guess. Okay, 2924 or the Davis -Stirling Act,
- 44:11to the extent that there's a conflict between
- 44:13the two Davis -Stirling Act will control over
- 44:15the 2924 at SEC series. Good question though.
- 44:21All right, next issue, special assessments in
- 44:23the insurance crisis. So what's a special assessment
- 44:26or what's the difference between a general assessment
- 44:28and a special assessment? You have to understand
- 44:30that so you can understand what a special assessment
- 44:32is. General assessment is a synonym for your
- 44:34regular dues. Most HOAs, people pay them monthly.
- 44:38Sometimes you pay them quarterly. You get a deal
- 44:40if you do that. In my HOA, I pay it quarterly.
- 44:43And I get a certain percentage off for doing
- 44:46that. So your regular dues are what's called
- 44:49a general assessment. Special assessments are
- 44:52typically these one -time assessments that are
- 44:54designed to pay for something specific, some
- 44:57operational cost, or there isn't enough money
- 45:00in the operating fund or in the reserve account
- 45:02to pay for maintenance, repair, or replacement
- 45:05of a common area component, and we need money
- 45:08and we need it quick, and the only place to get
- 45:10it is from you guys, so pay up. So that's a special
- 45:13assessment. Now the H .O .A. or the David Sterling
- 45:16Act allows an H .O .A. to raise the regular assessment,
- 45:20that monthly due, without getting any permission
- 45:23or a stay from the homeowners. 20 % every year.
- 45:28So if your HOA dues are $300, your HOA can do
- 45:32a no -look raise just by the board of directors
- 45:34meeting and agreeing for next year to 360. And
- 45:39then 20 % the next year and the next year. And
- 45:41that's how that would work. Anything over that
- 45:43would require a secret ballot election of the
- 45:46membership. And all it would take to pass that
- 45:48would be a majority of a core. When it comes
- 45:51to special assessments, The line is 5 % of that
- 45:55year's budgeted gross expenses. If you live in
- 45:58a very large HOA, like let's say the Master HOA
- 46:02in Coto, which has a couple thousand homes, then
- 46:05that's going to be a rather large budget. So
- 46:07let's say you're dealing with a million dollar
- 46:09budget. Well, 5%. You do the math. Anything over
- 46:16that number, anything over, what is it, $5 ,000?
- 46:23Right? Was that 50? How about the math guy? But
- 46:25anything over the 5 % of the budget of gross
- 46:27expenses has to go to secret ballot with the
- 46:31homeowners. And a lot of homeowners, depending
- 46:34on what it is, they might pass it, they might
- 46:36not. And I don't have time today to talk to you
- 46:39about what happens when they don't pass it. But
- 46:41that is an interesting scenario and that does
- 46:42happen. So there is one little wrinkle that is
- 46:49stalled right now in the Senate. in California,
- 46:53but it's SB 1007. What they're seeking to do,
- 46:56and this would only affect the regular assessments,
- 46:59it has nothing to do with special assessment.
- 47:02It's seeking to lower that 20 % down to 8%. Right
- 47:06now, that's stalled in committee, and it doesn't
- 47:09look like it's gonna get through in the next
- 47:11month and a half or so. And so that's probably
- 47:14gonna die this year, but it'll probably be back
- 47:16again. but I mention it because it is still alive.
- 47:20I checked it a week ago and it was still alive
- 47:24a week ago. So special assessments are going
- 47:30through the roof. And there's two big reasons
- 47:32why. The first reason is the insurance crisis
- 47:36in facing California is everywhere, right? Every
- 47:40Californian, HOA or not. but especially in HOAs.
- 47:45Homeowners that live in non -HOA -governed communities
- 47:49have their own insurance unless they're in a
- 47:51fire zone and they can't get insurance in which
- 47:53place they're on the fare plan. But typically,
- 47:56if you have your own insurance, there you are.
- 47:59When you're living in HOA, there's common area,
- 48:02which means the HOA is going to have an insurance
- 48:04policy. It's called the master policy. And then
- 48:06homeowners will have their own policy. So now
- 48:08you've got two policies. There is an insurance
- 48:11crisis in this state affecting everybody. And
- 48:16there are four forces that are driving premiums
- 48:20up through the roof. And I'm not talking about
- 48:23modest increases in premiums. We've seen HOAs
- 48:27that were paying, let's say, $25 ,000 a year
- 48:30for a policy, and the next year was $110 ,000
- 48:33for the same coverage or less. We're talking
- 48:36two, three, four times more in one year. We've
- 48:39seen that now is that everywhere? No, but it's
- 48:42more and more common So there are four forces
- 48:45that are doing that they're driving these premiums
- 48:47up one of them involves the fair plan, okay as
- 48:53The fires in California demonstrate we've had
- 48:56some devastating fires the PG &E fires from several
- 48:59years ago But most recently the palisades uh
- 49:02fires that occurred in at the beginning of 2025
- 49:05that um you know malibu the palisades in fire
- 49:09basically parts of outer los angeles burned down
- 49:13thousands of thousands of thousands of homes
- 49:15were destroyed entire communities were gone in
- 49:18the palisades i went to law school at ucla i
- 49:21used to coach soccer in the palisades i remember
- 49:24going to gelsons i remember practicing at pallie
- 49:26high school all gone okay well more and more
- 49:31areas in California being designated these fire
- 49:34zones. And a lot of the big insurers, like State
- 49:37Farm, and farmers are pulled out entirely of
- 49:41insuring for that kind of disaster, for fires.
- 49:45They pulled out entirely. They aren't even offering
- 49:47insurance anymore at all. They're gone from the
- 49:49market. Well, that's when the state's fair plan
- 49:53kicks in. Now the states, I go into one of my
- 49:56articles about the history of the fair plan.
- 49:57It deals back with the Watts riots. That's where
- 50:00it stems from. You can read about that if you
- 50:03click on one of the links I gave you. But the
- 50:05fact is the fair plan is that last resort state
- 50:09mandated or state controlled insurance policy,
- 50:13which is monumentally expensive, but at least
- 50:16you don't lose everything because if your house
- 50:18goes up in flames, you're going to get something.
- 50:20but you're going to pay much more. I'm in the
- 50:23area that burned in the palace. The fair plan
- 50:25is limited to three million dollars, which in
- 50:28some of these areas wasn't enough. It also doesn't
- 50:31carry all the same buckets of coverage that you'd
- 50:33have in a normal policy. Just for structure,
- 50:36which is why people have to get separate policies.
- 50:40They're called wraparound policies to cover slip
- 50:43and falls and, you know, loss insurance for,
- 50:48you know, if you have a robbery. The fair plan
- 50:50will cover structure. It'll cover a fire, destroys
- 50:53the structure. We'll cover that. When it comes
- 50:55to single -family homes with that maximum of
- 50:57three million, when it comes to the buildings,
- 50:59there's a $20 million max. But it's still very
- 51:03limited. But more than that, you pay much more
- 51:07for so much less coverage than you got on the
- 51:10private market. I'm lucky. I live in San Juan
- 51:12Capistrano, and I have private insurance. I don't
- 51:15know how. because parts of San Juan are fire
- 51:18zone, but I guess I'm not in one. And I have
- 51:21private insurance, and I've talked to friends
- 51:22that live a few miles from me that are under
- 51:24a fair plan, and they pay three times more than
- 51:26I do, and my coverage is infinitely better. So
- 51:29knock on wood for that. The driving force here
- 51:35is what the insurance crisis is fueling is special
- 51:40assessments, because at HOA, even a well -managed
- 51:44one is not It is not unreasonable for them not
- 51:47to have been able to foresee that their rates
- 51:52could quadruple in one year. That's not normal.
- 51:56And so you have so many HOAs that are just being
- 52:00left flat -footed. Now, again, I'm talking about
- 52:02this could be any of them. These could be the
- 52:04HOAs that are under the fair plan or HOAs under
- 52:07private insurance. Those rates are skyrocketing.
- 52:12And the only way to fund them for many, many
- 52:15HOAs is special assessment. And so some of these
- 52:20massive special assessments that we've seen are
- 52:23a result of the insurance crisis. When I say
- 52:25massive, that's my word and my own definition
- 52:28that I use in my articles, anything over $20
- 52:30,000 per household, I call massive, okay? We've
- 52:34seen, and we'll talk about this in a minute,
- 52:36in the news lately. I'm gonna go ahead and skip
- 52:39the history of SB 326, otherwise known as California's
- 52:43balcony law. I'm going to skip that because you
- 52:45can read about it on your own. And this is why
- 52:50I'm bringing it up, is in addition to the insurance
- 52:53crisis resulting in a massive spike in special
- 52:58assessments, the balcony inspection and reserve
- 53:01pressure have resulted in a lot of special assessments.
- 53:06And that's because this balcony law required
- 53:08the completion of an inspection by a licensed
- 53:13architect or a license structure or civil engineer,
- 53:17no later than January 1st, 2025, of exterior
- 53:21elevated elements, which is basically any structure
- 53:25over six feet off the ground that's cantilevered
- 53:27and partly made of wood, even if it's an interior,
- 53:30okay? Which is pretty much, if you know California
- 53:33construction, everything we own, other than big
- 53:35commercial buildings, every house I've ever seen
- 53:37has got wood underneath, right? They're all wood
- 53:39-framed. So every house, every building, that's
- 53:43got balconies or elevated walkways is going to
- 53:46be subject to 326, the balcony law. Well, part
- 53:49of that lies, okay, these inspections have to
- 53:51be done, and that's because this law was passed
- 53:54as a result of a disaster that occurred in Berkeley.
- 53:57Years later, that thing, that apartment complex
- 53:59in Florida that collapsed, sandwiched, very similar,
- 54:03okay? So SB 326 said get these inspections done
- 54:07and... These licensed inspectors, if they recommend
- 54:10that things have to get done or that things are
- 54:12a dangerous condition, you HOAs are on notice,
- 54:15you better get it fixed. So these inspections,
- 54:18for the most part, have been done by, I would
- 54:19say, 65 % of the HOAs in California. We have
- 54:23a large percentage that are not compliant with
- 54:25the law. The ones that are, a lot of them have
- 54:28found themselves with recommendations from these
- 54:32licensed experts. Architect, civil engineer,
- 54:35structural engineer, that's it. that have said
- 54:37these have to get repaired or replaced immediately.
- 54:40An HOA that doesn't do that could be on the hook,
- 54:42those directors could be on the hook for manslaughter.
- 54:44So they are specially assessing like crazy. And
- 54:48that's what we saw in the news just twice last
- 54:50week. A local HOA in San Clemente just issued
- 54:55a special assessment to all of its members of
- 54:57$26 ,000 per household. That might seem like
- 55:01a lot to you and it is. Write us a check, give
- 55:03us 26 grand, all 400 of you. Okay, that might
- 55:07seem like a lot to you. And again, it is, but
- 55:10not compared to the average we're seeing. But
- 55:13that one was specifically for balconies, or at
- 55:15least partly for balconies, because of this balcony
- 55:18inspection. And later that week, I made the way
- 55:22in Torrance, $49 ,000 per household, $19 million
- 55:29repair project, of which a few million of it
- 55:32related to balconies. It is a big problem. And
- 55:37HOAs, most badly run HOAs and some well -run
- 55:43HOAs have found themselves flat -footed. Why?
- 55:47Failure to maintain. These balconies are like
- 55:50roofs. They're going to last forever. They're
- 55:52going to last for 30 years. We don't have to
- 55:53pay attention. We don't have to reserve. And
- 55:55then years tick by, and suddenly, you don't have
- 55:58money to fix it. And there's no way to get that
- 56:01money other than to specially assess. So because
- 56:04this law brought it to the forefront and made
- 56:07it a mandatory inspection, and those inspections
- 56:10have results that have to be a buy -to -buy,
- 56:13do this, do that, H2As have no choice now. This
- 56:17has become a huge issue, but we have just a few
- 56:21minutes for your last topic. Yeah. Okay. So moving
- 56:25on. And I'll say... Tell your clients this. I'm
- 56:30not going to pay the assessment. It's illegal
- 56:32or they violated the law. Don't do that. Always
- 56:35pay, then challenge. You don't waive anything.
- 56:37You don't have to put anything on a memo check,
- 56:40but you have to pay an assessment. Even if you
- 56:42are positive it's illegal, it was done by fraud,
- 56:45it's a result of embezzlement, and there's really
- 56:47no reason to do it. It doesn't matter. It has
- 56:49to be paid, then challenged. All right. Just
- 56:52remember that, OK? Let's see. I won't go into
- 56:58attacking a proper, an improper assessment. Let's
- 57:02see. Why is my thing is freezing? Sorry about
- 57:05that guys. All right. And let's just go into
- 57:07disaster rebuilding, okay? As a result of the
- 57:11Palisades fires, SB 625 was passed by the state
- 57:14of California. And here's what it did. And it's
- 57:17amazing because it's mostly in two statutes,
- 57:204752 and... 4766 are the two big ones. And what
- 57:24it basically, what people were finding was my
- 57:27HOA, you know, a lot of rules change between
- 57:29the time that my house was built and the time
- 57:32I now have to rebuild either my entire house
- 57:35or a large portion of my house. And now they're
- 57:37making all these demands on me and I can't do
- 57:39it. And it's taking forever and they keep coming
- 57:43back to the table and they keep denying my plans,
- 57:45denying my plans. Now they want me to have a
- 57:48smaller footprint. Now they want me to have a
- 57:49larger setback. Now they don't want me to block
- 57:51somebody's view. Legislators said no. That's
- 57:55it. We're done with that, okay? It renders void
- 57:58any governing document that prohibits or has
- 58:01the effect of prohibiting a homeowner from building
- 58:04substantially similar home to what they had before.
- 58:08Sub -tech two, modern code requirements like
- 58:10earthquake fitting and all that. and gas lines
- 58:14and all that stuff. Sure, you got to do the health
- 58:16and safety stuff, but HOA rules? Gone. You cannot.
- 58:21It doesn't matter if your aesthetics has changed.
- 58:23Too bad. You're done. It prohibits and has the
- 58:28effect of prohibiting is very powerful language
- 58:30in that statute. Basically, if a homeowner wants
- 58:33to build a home that is pretty much like the
- 58:35other one, they get to, and it goes further.
- 58:39They can actually build it. up to 110 % of the
- 58:42prior footprint. So they can actually increase
- 58:45it in height or width a little bit up to that
- 58:4810 % extra. And the HOA can't do a damn thing
- 58:52about it. Even better, it's fast track now. There's
- 58:55no such thing as playing the long game for the
- 58:58HOA to tie to outspend or force the other side.
- 59:01You know, this person who's lived through a massive
- 59:03fire to have to suffer and deal with this HOA.
- 59:06It's ministerial deadline driven. There's no
- 59:09discretionary review. They have 30 days to determine
- 59:13whether the application is complete or not. If
- 59:16it is, they must tell you every way that it's
- 59:18not. If it's not, I'm sorry, if it's not, they
- 59:21have to tell you every way that it isn't. If
- 59:23it is, they got to tell you it's complete. If
- 59:25they don't tell you anything, it's deemed complete
- 59:28within 30 days. So it's automated. They have
- 59:3145 days to approve. or issue a full written revision
- 59:35request, meaning they can't do what a lot of
- 59:38HOAs do in a non -disaster situation, which is
- 59:41tell you a couple of objections. You go fix them,
- 59:43redo it, and they give you a couple more that
- 59:45weren't on the original. You do those. You submit
- 59:47again. They give you a couple more. No. Peace
- 59:49bill is out the window. 45 days, full revision
- 59:53request. If they don't name it, it doesn't have
- 59:55to be revised. And every standard they use has
- 59:58to be objective. There cannot be. It has to be
- 1:00:01the standards that were in place other than Code
- 1:00:04compliant or health and safety. It has to be
- 1:00:06the objectives or the standards have to be those
- 1:00:10that were in place when the structure was destroyed.
- 1:00:12Not new rules that they might pass in the interim
- 1:00:15in order to move the goalposts. Cannot do that.
- 1:00:18Okay. So really big teeth there. There's one
- 1:00:22or two things that just I know we're a little
- 1:00:24late on this, but you better what you submit
- 1:00:27has to be complete. I don't think you're going
- 1:00:29to get away with submitting something incomplete.
- 1:00:33Yeah. But the HOA have to tell you it's not complete
- 1:00:36within that time period. So if you put in, if
- 1:00:39you don't follow the architectural guidelines
- 1:00:43rules as, you know, we need the drawing plans,
- 1:00:46we have to have this, we need to have the scope,
- 1:00:48we need the materials. If you skip something,
- 1:00:50the HOA in that time period has to say, hey,
- 1:00:53you're missing this. They don't have to tell,
- 1:00:55they don't have to give any more detail now,
- 1:00:56but they have to state all the things that are
- 1:00:58missing. Now it's on to the homeowner again.
- 1:01:00It flips the page back to the homeowner. This
- 1:01:03is to prevent the HOA from, when the homeowner
- 1:01:06does that, playing that game. So that it takes
- 1:01:08you two years to get your house built again.
- 1:01:10That's what this statute was designed for. The
- 1:01:12homeowner also can't play games and submit something.
- 1:01:16Of course not. No. The statute doesn't reward
- 1:01:19the homeowner for games, which just prevents
- 1:01:21abuse by the HOA. Homeowner still has to abide
- 1:01:24by the governing documents. but they don't have
- 1:01:27to abide by whatever rules are now in place if
- 1:01:30it would prevent them from building the house
- 1:01:32they had before. What it was supposed to do is
- 1:01:34get homeowners back to where they were the day
- 1:01:36before the fire. That's the goal. Plus 10%. Plus
- 1:01:4110%, yes. And that goes to size and height. And
- 1:01:46by the way, in California, there's no right to
- 1:01:49a view unless you have it in writing through
- 1:01:52the governing documents. A lot of oceanfront
- 1:01:56properties have view rights built in. But under
- 1:02:00this new law, the view rights aren't going to
- 1:02:03be respected unless the view rights are specific
- 1:02:07enough. So it can't be homeowners living on the
- 1:02:11bluff must have a view of the lake. That won't
- 1:02:14fly. It has to be a meets and bounds or a percent
- 1:02:18measurement or feet and inches kind of rule for
- 1:02:22it to pass muster under the statute. Okay, moving
- 1:02:26on. And again, I'm skipping through some stuff
- 1:02:28because we've got to go through this. Temporary
- 1:02:31housing is protected under the new law. It allows
- 1:02:33homeowners to live on an RV, even if RVs are
- 1:02:36normally banned, for a period of time while construction
- 1:02:40is going on so they don't have to go and fund
- 1:02:42another household. So if the family wants to
- 1:02:44live on an RV on their burned down property while
- 1:02:47it's being rebuilt, they can. Okay? And of course,
- 1:02:52there's a mandatory fee shifting provision built
- 1:02:56into the statute here. And it is one way, meaning
- 1:03:00the homeowner wins, homeowner gets attorney's
- 1:03:02fees and costs. If the HOA wins, they don't get
- 1:03:05anything unless the homeowners lost it was frivolous,
- 1:03:09and then they only get costs, never fees. So
- 1:03:12it does change the calculus and it disincentivizes
- 1:03:16a bad HOA. from fighting all the way when it
- 1:03:19comes to something like this. In all, I think
- 1:03:22it was actually a well -written statute. Now,
- 1:03:25it is brand new. It hasn't been litigated yet.
- 1:03:28It will be litigated, and the courts will eventually
- 1:03:30tell us what the law says, okay? And we think,
- 1:03:35this is me, I'm the royal we, I think this is
- 1:03:38where it's gonna, these are the four issues I
- 1:03:41think are gonna hit the challenge. The effect
- 1:03:43of prohibiting, what does that mean? How far
- 1:03:45does that reach? Cost burdens, delay tactics
- 1:03:47are obvious, but the outer edge, I don't know
- 1:03:50what that means. That's gonna get addressed at
- 1:03:52some point. The objective versus subjective views.
- 1:03:55The thing I just talked about about a view, objective
- 1:03:58view rights are protected. Subjective view rights,
- 1:04:01even in writing, are not. Fixed height or elevation
- 1:04:04caps are gonna be objective. They'll survive.
- 1:04:07Unreasonable obstruction clause. A lot of people
- 1:04:11think they have view rights because of unreasonable
- 1:04:12obstruction. They do. Unless it's under this
- 1:04:15statute and to rebuild, they might not. So the
- 1:04:18high value coastal views are going to drive this
- 1:04:21fight. And we don't know how that's going to
- 1:04:23come out. Setback conflict. Rebuild. When the
- 1:04:28house was built, there was a four foot setback.
- 1:04:29That setback's now three feet. What does that
- 1:04:31mean? Don't know. We don't have an understanding
- 1:04:35yet because that statute didn't address that
- 1:04:38effectively. And then local HOA versus local
- 1:04:40permitting. The interaction between an HOA's
- 1:04:43ministerial review in a city and the county permitting
- 1:04:46is not well addressed in the statute. So we don't
- 1:04:49know where one authority ends and the other's
- 1:04:51gonna or takes over. So those are the four areas
- 1:04:54I think are gonna be the litigated ones. I'm
- 1:04:56ready to take questions from anybody now. I've
- 1:04:59got a couple on here. Should I read these? Yeah,
- 1:05:02there's two questions. Let me throw in one thought.
- 1:05:04It's not exactly HOA versus member, but if you
- 1:05:08had a view and the state has said somebody can
- 1:05:13build 10 % up and you just lost your ocean view
- 1:05:15because of that query, whether the state is going
- 1:05:18to get sued because they've interfered with a
- 1:05:21contract, which is a CCNR. They've impaired private
- 1:05:23contracts or it's a taking. And that may be something
- 1:05:26the state never thought about when they passed
- 1:05:28this. And our firm does not handle lawsuits against
- 1:05:32the sovereign. So I actually don't know what
- 1:05:34any of those sovereign laws are. I'm not even
- 1:05:35sure if a state can be sued for that. But if
- 1:05:38it could, yes, I could see that happening. I'm
- 1:05:41sure some of our listeners here do that sort
- 1:05:43of law. We don't, and I don't know the law there.
- 1:05:45But that is a matzoh ball. And by the way, there
- 1:05:51might even still be an argument that the person,
- 1:05:53if it's an objective view right, That's still
- 1:05:56going to be protectable. I don't think somebody
- 1:05:58can build the 110 if it blocks an objective view,
- 1:06:01right? But a subjective view, right? Maybe. OK,
- 1:06:05now we have somebody that asked, is an insurance
- 1:06:06a routine operating expense? Does this mean an
- 1:06:09HOA can only do a special assessment once for
- 1:06:12insurance increases and then must increase its
- 1:06:14regular assessments to cover increased insurance
- 1:06:17expense in future fiscal years? No, they can
- 1:06:19do as many special assessments as they want,
- 1:06:21but anything Cumulatively over a period of a
- 1:06:25year. That's over that five percent They have
- 1:06:26to get secret ballot permission from the homeowners
- 1:06:29a majority of a quorum So lots of H ways pass
- 1:06:32multiple special assessments where they have
- 1:06:34to go to the homeowners What you might be talking
- 1:06:38about is whether or not a routine operating expense
- 1:06:41like an insurance New insurance payment falls
- 1:06:44under an emergency exception And I didn't talk
- 1:06:47about the emergency exception, but it does not
- 1:06:50there are three ways you can get an emergency
- 1:06:53exception to the, yes, this is a special assessment
- 1:06:56above 5%, but no, we're not going to go to the
- 1:06:59members. One of them is court order. Two is it
- 1:07:02affects, it's a major expense that affects the
- 1:07:05health and safety of the community. You have
- 1:07:08a tree that's about to fall and go through a
- 1:07:10building to kill people. If it's going to be
- 1:07:12more than 5%, they don't need your vote, but
- 1:07:14there are requirements that must be put in the
- 1:07:16minutes. They have to public, publicize the purpose
- 1:07:19of it, and it has to be put out in the open and
- 1:07:23in the minutes itself. So that would fly into
- 1:07:26the second one. Then the third one, and by the
- 1:07:28way, that second one talks about operational
- 1:07:31expenses and repair and maintenance. The third
- 1:07:34one doesn't require health and say just an extraordinary
- 1:07:37expense that couldn't have been anticipated before
- 1:07:40that budget was passed. But it does not apply,
- 1:07:44notwithstanding what some HOA side law firms
- 1:07:47have published. It does not apply to operational
- 1:07:49expenses like a premium. It only applies to repair
- 1:07:52and maintenance. The word operate, which was
- 1:07:55in subsection B of that statute, is not in subsection
- 1:07:59C. It used to be, and it was amended three or
- 1:08:02four years ago, and they took the word operate
- 1:08:03out. So operation expenses are gone. Why is that
- 1:08:07important? If you were asking about whether or
- 1:08:09not insurance being a routine expense could be
- 1:08:12covered under an emergency exception to pass
- 1:08:14a special assessment, the answer is no. If you're
- 1:08:17asking about whether or not they can issue multiple
- 1:08:19specials, yes. But it's likely going to require
- 1:08:22a member vote. And it's pretty easy when you're
- 1:08:24just trying to get a majority of the court. The
- 1:08:27next question is, few rights. Change in the law
- 1:08:30sounds unconstitutional for California jurisprudence.
- 1:08:34Is Pacific Legal Foundation working on this?
- 1:08:36Great question. And again, I have no idea. It's
- 1:08:39not went its way through the courts yet. I don't
- 1:08:41know. It might be part of this law to be deemed
- 1:08:43unconstitutional. I have no idea. But I guarantee
- 1:08:47that's going to be part of it. Michael, when
- 1:08:50you say judgment was your first exception, you
- 1:08:53gave before that court order. What if it's a
- 1:08:57judgment against the association, which could
- 1:09:00they then do a special assessment to get that
- 1:09:02pain? That's not a court order. So somebody is
- 1:09:06going to go and execute on the common areas and
- 1:09:08the board can't do anything about it. Good luck
- 1:09:10with that. The reason I say that is because there's
- 1:09:14a provision on the Davis Sterling Act that says
- 1:09:16that the common area. cannot be separated under
- 1:09:20any circumstances from the private separate interests.
- 1:09:25In other words, whatever the common area is in
- 1:09:28your HOA, some HOAs have much more than others,
- 1:09:31okay? Whatever that common area is cannot be
- 1:09:35divorced, cannot be rendered from all the separate
- 1:09:40interests. So if you have 500... members in your
- 1:09:44age away, everybody owns a one 500 piece of the
- 1:09:47common area, right? Their separate interest that
- 1:09:49they own can't be separated from that one 500.
- 1:09:53So when you take all 500, you have 500 500. That's
- 1:09:56the whole. So how are you going to sell part
- 1:09:58of the common area? It's not going to happen.
- 1:10:01So the judgment creditor is going to be limited
- 1:10:03to having somebody go sit at the bank and see
- 1:10:06what comes into the bank account. which is a
- 1:10:09great way to do it because the money comes in
- 1:10:11regularly. Because the Davis -Stirling Act requires
- 1:10:14and H -O -A board members have a fiduciary duty
- 1:10:16to collect sufficient money to operate their
- 1:10:20expenses and to take care of, maintain, replace,
- 1:10:23and repair the common areas. And they have to
- 1:10:25have two bank accounts at least. You have to
- 1:10:27have at least an operating account and a reserve
- 1:10:29account. So if you want to levy on those accounts,
- 1:10:33money will come in regularly because those dues
- 1:10:34are paid every month. quarter, however your HOA
- 1:10:38works. So HOAs are not judgment -proof, but you
- 1:10:42cannot foreclose on the common area and say,
- 1:10:44I now own the park. Or the clubhouse. Or the
- 1:10:49clubhouse. Or I own the pool. Thank you very
- 1:10:53much for coming back again. Very interesting
- 1:10:55information and obviously very current and we
- 1:10:59appreciate you coming back to the Beverly Hills
- 1:11:01bar and thank you. I apologize for speeding through
- 1:11:04this. I tend to get more. I tend to think I have
- 1:11:07more time than I do. So yeah, but all this stuff
- 1:11:11is discussed at length on my website in my libraries
- 1:11:14tab under fact sheets. I've got them for everything.
- 1:11:16So I published three times a week and so it's
- 1:11:19all out there. Thank you again and thank you
- 1:11:23everybody for coming. I appreciate it. Thank
- 1:11:25you.