Latest / Going Rogue with Lara Logan / Tragedy Over DC: One On One with Austin Roth | Episode 4
Transcript
- 0:00Austin: Blackhawk crew members don't really have
- 0:01Austin: the critical piece of information to
- 0:04Austin: understand that oh, there's an airplane
- 0:05Austin: that's not just gonna come straight in here
- 0:07Austin: and we're gonna go to the left of them and
- 0:08Austin: never cross paths Down runway one, down
- 0:11Austin: runway one, and then it's gonna take a hard
- 0:13Austin: turn to go into runway three, three and cut
- 0:15Austin: right in front of them.
- 0:16Austin: And they never heard that critical piece of
- 0:18Austin: information.
- 0:31Lara: Hello and welcome to another episode of
- 0:33Lara: Going Rogue with Laura Logan.
- 0:35Lara: So there was a lot of interest in the crash
- 0:39Lara: that happened at DCA Airport between a US
- 0:42Lara: Army helicopter Black Hawk helicopter and a
- 0:44Lara: civilian aircraft from American Airlines.
- 0:47Lara: But there are still a lot of questions
- 0:49Lara: about what happened and whenever there's
- 0:53Lara: something like this goes on, people have a
- 0:55Lara: lot to say about it, especially in the age
- 0:58Lara: of social media where anyone can say
- 0:59Lara: anything they want, anytime they want any
- 1:09Lara: time.
- 1:09Lara: But most people don't know anything close
- 1:10Lara: to as much as my guest today, who was
- 1:11Lara: driven to speak about this because he
- 1:14Lara: actually knew the instructor pilot aboard
- 1:16Lara: that aircraft extremely well.
- 1:18Lara: He was part of that unit, that was his unit.
- 1:20Lara: He was based there for many years and he
- 1:24Lara: also knew of the crew chief.
- 1:27Lara: He knew the crew chief in passing and he
- 1:30Lara: also knew the crew chief and the pilot by
- 1:33Lara: reputation.
- 1:34Lara: So we wanted to hear what he was upset
- 1:38Lara: about, what was frustrating for him about
- 1:40Lara: the coverage, and try to understand more
- 1:42Lara: about what could have happened there.
- 1:46Lara: So I would like to introduce you to Austin
- 1:48Lara: Roth.
- 1:49Lara: Austin, welcome.
- 1:50Lara: Thank you for making the journey out here
- 1:52Lara: to our little corner of flyover country in
- 1:55Lara: the great state of Texas.
- 1:57Lara: Yeah, on the compound.
- 1:59Lara: On the compound.
- 2:01Lara: Okay, we got honey here.
- 2:03Lara: We've got everything in place.
- 2:04Lara: We have the dogs behind the chair, okay, so
- 2:05Lara: got, we got honey here.
- 2:06Lara: We got, we've got everything in place.
- 2:06Lara: We have, we have the dogs behind the chair.
- 2:08Lara: Okay, so we're good to go.
- 2:08Lara: Um, austin, tell me, just for for people to
- 2:11Lara: understand, uh, why anything you have to
- 2:15Lara: say about this um is really relevant, they
- 2:26Lara: got to first understand who you are and um
- 2:27Lara: and so.
- 2:27Lara: So I know that you were in the army for 20
- 2:28Lara: years.
- 2:28Lara: I know you were a Black Hawk pilot for 20
- 2:29Lara: years.
- 2:30Lara: You were stationed at Fort Belvoir,
- 2:31Lara: virginia, which is where that team was
- 2:34Lara: stationed, right?
- 2:35Lara: So tell me about the unit and tell me about
- 2:37Lara: your role.
- 2:39Austin: So yeah, quick background on myself.
- 2:41Austin: I spent eight years in the infantry.
- 2:43Austin: After that I switched over to becoming a
- 2:45Austin: warrant officer pilot, so I put an
- 2:47Austin: application in for that, went to flight
- 2:49Austin: school, spent the next 12 years as a
- 2:51Austin: Blackhawk pilot Shortly after my first duty
- 2:55Austin: station, went back to be an instructor, so
- 2:57Austin: I was an instructor.
- 2:58Austin: After that I became a standardization
- 3:00Austin: instructor pilot, which is like an
- 3:01Austin: instructor pilot for instructor pilots.
- 3:03Lara: So that's as you're going.
- 3:04Lara: You're basically going up and up and up.
- 3:06Austin: You're pretty good pilot yeah well, I don't
- 3:08Austin: know about that, I'll leave that for other
- 3:09Austin: people to say.
- 3:09Austin: But I'm a pretty.
- 3:10Lara: Uh, I've got all the qualifications, uh, so
- 3:13Lara: I'm not everybody, I'm well qualified on,
- 3:16Lara: but when you were like when you train the
- 3:17Lara: trainers no, not.
- 3:18Lara: Not everybody becomes a standard instructor
- 3:20Lara: right, I mean that's, and there's different,
- 3:22Lara: there's different levels of pilots, which
- 3:24Lara: is something I didn't really understand.
- 3:25Lara: But you're an instrument evaluator, right,
- 3:28Lara: which is one kind of instructor, and then
- 3:30Lara: also explain the other two levels.
- 3:33Austin: Yeah.
- 3:33Austin: So you've got an instructor pilot which
- 3:35Austin: would be instructing kind of everybody at
- 3:36Austin: the unit for their.
- 3:37Austin: You'd be doing everything from evaluations
- 3:39Austin: to initial qualifications on new.
- 3:43Austin: You know, if you're going to do, for
- 3:44Austin: instance, firefighting, the instructor
- 3:46Austin: pilots would usually train that.
- 3:48Austin: So if you're going to do unit-specific
- 3:49Austin: stuff, they would be the trainers for that
- 3:51Austin: primarily.
- 3:52Austin: They're also the trainers of the new guys
- 3:54Austin: when they get there from flight school, so
- 3:56Austin: we call it progression, so they kind of get
- 3:57Austin: them spooled up on that individual unit's
- 3:59Austin: SOPs and techniques and all of that stuff
- 4:02Austin: Standard operating procedures, Standard
- 4:03Austin: operating procedures.
- 4:04Austin: So instructor pilots are responsible for
- 4:07Austin: that Standardization.
- 4:07Austin: Instructor pilots are kind of over the
- 4:09Austin: instructor pilots but then also operate as
- 4:11Austin: an instructor pilot.
- 4:12Lara: Well, and you also flew in Iraq and
- 4:15Lara: Afghanistan in combat.
- 4:17Austin: So I was in Iraq as an infantryman but I
- 4:19Austin: flew in Afghanistan in combat as a medevac
- 4:21Austin: pilot and what was that like?
- 4:26Austin: Number one, it was really rewarding,
- 4:27Austin: especially as a former infantry guy, having
- 4:28Austin: seen it kind of from the other side.
- 4:30Austin: Yeah, being on the ground, being on the
- 4:32Austin: ground, yeah, and having needed medevac
- 4:34Austin: before, not for myself but for friends, and
- 4:38Austin: so then to be on the other side of it as
- 4:40Austin: somebody providing that service, providing
- 4:42Austin: that assistance to the people on the ground,
- 4:44Austin: especially because you have kind of a good
- 4:46Austin: understanding of what they need and when
- 4:47Austin: they need it and what you're going to do
- 4:50Austin: how it's going to affect them potentially.
- 4:51Austin: You know, if I land in this direction, if I
- 4:52Austin: land in that direction, if I wait five
- 4:55Austin: minutes, would that maybe be better, would
- 4:56Austin: it maybe be worse?
- 4:58Austin: And with that background you can kind of
- 5:00Austin: develop that picture a little bit better, I
- 5:03Austin: think, than some pilots.
- 5:04Austin: And so I found it really rewarding.
- 5:06Austin: And then also I thought I think I was
- 5:07Austin: pretty good at it and certainly found it
- 5:10Austin: challenging and yeah, that's.
- 5:13Lara: I wonder if we were in Afghanistan at the
- 5:15Lara: same time.
- 5:15Austin: We definitely could have been.
- 5:17Austin: I was there 12 and 13.
- 5:19Lara: Yeah, I mean I came in and out in that time
- 5:23Lara: and I always remember what it was like
- 5:25Lara: being in combat.
- 5:26Lara: You know when someone is shot or you've
- 5:29Lara: been blown up.
- 5:31Lara: Waiting for that, there's nothing quite
- 5:33Lara: like seeing that medevac bird in the sky.
- 5:35Austin: Yeah, it's definitely like I said, having
- 5:37Austin: seen it from the ground before.
- 5:39Austin: Oh my, when you need it, you need it.
- 5:41Lara: Yeah.
- 5:41Austin: Five minutes ago or yesterday.
- 5:43Lara: Yeah, I mean, it's literally life and death
- 5:46Lara: at the in that moment.
- 5:46Lara: So those guys are like gods to you when
- 5:49Lara: you're on the ground.
- 5:50Lara: I mean they are right.
- 5:51Austin: But then you get in the unit and it's just
- 5:52Austin: normal guys, yeah, and it's just, and
- 5:55Austin: you're doing it and your friends are doing
- 5:56Austin: it, and it just becomes kind of normalized
- 5:58Austin: yeah, well, and so for you.
- 6:01Lara: I mean, who were you with when you were?
- 6:04Austin: deployed.
- 6:05Austin: I was with the 101st Airborne Division, so
- 6:07Austin: I was with the 50th Medical Company, which
- 6:09Austin: became Charlie Company 7101.
- 6:13Austin: So 7th Battalion, 101st Aviation.
- 6:15Lara: Okay, and then.
- 6:17Lara: But then you went to the 12th Aviation
- 6:19Lara: Battalion.
- 6:19Austin: Yeah, so I had a couple of different things
- 6:20Austin: I did in between.
- 6:21Austin: Then I went down as an instructor to Fort
- 6:22Austin: Rucker, I did a tour in Egypt and then from
- 6:26Austin: Egypt I went to Fort Belvoir.
- 6:28Austin: So my first standardization instructor
- 6:29Austin: pilot tour was in Egypt and then after that
- 6:31Austin: I went to Fort Belvoir in the same kind of
- 6:33Austin: capacity.
- 6:34Lara: Okay, so Fort Belvoir, virginia, 12th
- 6:36Lara: Aviation Battalion, is where the crew that
- 6:38Lara: was aboard the Black Hawk the day of the
- 6:41Lara: crash right, that's where they were from.
- 6:43Lara: So tell me what that unit is like and what
- 6:46Lara: it's like there.
- 6:47Austin: So it's very unique.
- 6:49Austin: It's set up in the way that kind of all the
- 6:50Austin: other helicopter battalions are set up, or
- 6:54Austin: specifically the Black Hawk battalions are
- 6:55Austin: set up in terms of manning and aircraft and
- 6:59Austin: all that.
- 7:00Austin: What's unique about it is its mission.
- 7:02Austin: So there's other VIP Blackhawk units
- 7:05Austin: throughout the Army, but at Fort Belvoir
- 7:08Austin: you've got an entire battalion, actually an
- 7:10Austin: entire brigade that's kind of dedicated to
- 7:11Austin: that mission.
- 7:12Austin: And then, as Pete Hegg said, the Secretary
- 7:15Austin: of Defense has said the continuity of
- 7:16Austin: government mission is another part of what
- 7:18Austin: they do.
- 7:18Lara: Continuity of government.
- 7:19Austin: Yeah, meaning if missiles are in the air or
- 7:22Austin: if anything bad is happening and certain
- 7:26Austin: people in the government have to go to
- 7:27Austin: other places, then that would be the
- 7:28Austin: continuity of government mission.
- 7:30Lara: So it's not just because continuity of
- 7:33Lara: government often comes up when you think of
- 7:35Lara: it in terms of changing from one
- 7:37Lara: administration to the next, but actually it
- 7:39Lara: means all the time.
- 7:41Austin: Yeah, in this context it means all the time,
- 7:43Austin: 24 hours a day.
- 7:45Lara: And this was apparently a continuity of the
- 7:48Lara: time.
- 7:48Lara: 24 hours a day, yeah.
- 7:50Austin: And this was apparently a continuity of
- 7:52Austin: government mission.
- 7:52Austin: Is that correct?
- 7:54Lara: This particular one was not.
- 7:54Lara: It was an evaluation, so it would have been
- 7:55Lara: it was a training flight.
- 7:56Austin: Yeah, and it's a little bit of again kind
- 7:57Austin: of getting into this the reason why it's so
- 7:58Austin: hard to understand, because there's a lot
- 8:00Austin: of terms that are used interchangeably
- 8:01Austin: different services can use them differently,
- 8:04Austin: and so one of those is it was a training
- 8:06Austin: flight.
- 8:07Austin: So basically, on one piece of paper you
- 8:08Austin: might have where it says it's a training
- 8:09Austin: flight, and that would be correct, but it
- 8:11Austin: was also an evaluation, so it's an
- 8:14Austin: evaluation flight as well.
- 8:15Austin: And specifically, this would have been the
- 8:17Austin: standardization night vision goggle
- 8:20Austin: evaluation.
- 8:20Austin: So there's three different evaluations you
- 8:22Austin: have to do.
- 8:23Austin: That's two of them.
- 8:24Austin: The other one would be the instrument
- 8:25Austin: evaluation, so an instrument flight
- 8:26Austin: evaluation, which is basically the night
- 8:28Austin: vision goggle.
- 8:28Lara: one would be what?
- 8:29Lara: Basically making sure that you are equipped
- 8:32Lara: to and experienced to train to fly that
- 8:35Lara: aircraft wearing night vision goggles.
- 8:37Lara: That's right.
- 8:37Austin: So every year every pilot in the army is
- 8:40Austin: going to go through kind of an annual
- 8:43Austin: proficiency check and that's going to be
- 8:45Austin: part of that evaluation, the night vision
- 8:48Austin: and standardization evaluations.
- 8:51Austin: Those are usually done concurrently because
- 8:53Austin: if you do it in the most challenging mode
- 8:55Austin: of flight, which is at night, then you can
- 8:57Austin: count those.
- 8:58Austin: For instance, if you do like an auto
- 8:59Austin: rotation where the helicopter is going down
- 9:01Austin: as if it doesn't have engine power, or if
- 9:04Austin: you're doing a roll-on landing where we
- 9:06Austin: bring it in, we actually roll onto the
- 9:07Austin: runway Anytime you're doing those things,
- 9:10Austin: if you do it at night, because that's more
- 9:12Austin: challenging, it counts for a day iteration
- 9:15Austin: of it.
- 9:16Austin: So you can do basically two evaluations for
- 9:18Austin: the price of one, and so that's what they
- 9:20Austin: were doing.
- 9:22Lara: And why specifically with night vision?
- 9:24Lara: I mean I've worn night vision before.
- 9:26Lara: I've looked through them many times on the
- 9:27Lara: battlefield.
- 9:28Lara: Yeah, I hate them.
- 9:30Lara: I mean, I understand the advantage they
- 9:33Lara: give you in combat, but they're not easy to
- 9:34Lara: wear.
- 9:35Austin: Yeah, so everything.
- 9:37Austin: It's really easy to think like, oh, I can't
- 9:38Austin: see, I put night vision on, I can see Must
- 9:40Austin: be better.
- 9:41Austin: Right must be better, but, as you were kind
- 9:41Austin: of describing, it's like I actually hate
- 9:43Austin: worrying.
- 9:43Austin: There's some limitations to them.
- 9:45Austin: Like any system, it's got limitations, and
- 9:48Austin: so what you're really evaluating is how do
- 9:50Austin: they operate when they've got some of those
- 9:51Austin: limitations?
- 9:52Austin: One of the limitations that night vision
- 9:53Austin: gives you is that you can only see 40
- 9:54Austin: degrees Right.
- 9:55Austin: So normal human eyesight you can see about
- 9:57Austin: 160 degrees give or take.
- 10:00Austin: So it's that peripheral vision that you
- 10:02Austin: lose, so you lose almost all of your
- 10:03Austin: peripheral vision and then you've got night
- 10:06Austin: vision on your face and you can see.
- 10:07Austin: We always describe it as if you look
- 10:08Austin: through a toilet paper roll.
- 10:10Austin: That's about the same kind of field of view
- 10:12Austin: as you would have.
- 10:13Lara: But then everything's greeny Grainy, sorry,
- 10:15Lara: greeny Greeny is a combination of grainy
- 10:18Lara: and greeny.
- 10:18Austin: Yeah, that's actually, it's an official
- 10:20Austin: term.
- 10:20Austin: I I'm going to submit that to the Army see
- 10:21Austin: if they can get that.
- 10:23Lara: Into the training manuals.
- 10:24Austin: Yeah, and actually in this case it might
- 10:25Austin: have not been greeny yeah, because they
- 10:28Austin: were likely using white phosphor, which
- 10:30Austin: means that it was white night vision, which
- 10:32Austin: has its own benefits and its own
- 10:34Austin: limitations.
- 10:35Lara: Okay, so with white, does it impact how you
- 10:40Lara: see light?
- 10:41Austin: It does, and there's arguments about why
- 10:43Austin: you would use different colors and what the
- 10:44Austin: kind of cost benefit is.
- 10:46Austin: Probably the biggest reason to use white
- 10:48Austin: phosphor is it is easier to see in really
- 10:51Austin: dark environments, and so if I was going
- 10:54Austin: back to Afghanistan, for instance, I would
- 10:56Austin: want white phosphor on, because you've been
- 10:57Austin: there before.
- 10:58Lara: It is dark, dark in some places in
- 10:59Lara: Afghanistan it's an electricity in as much
- 11:03Lara: of the country, as there is in the US, but
- 11:06Lara: that doesn't really apply at DCA.
- 11:07Austin: It doesn't, but you have to keep in mind
- 11:09Austin: that this is still Army equipment and so
- 11:12Austin: that's part of the Army procurement process.
- 11:13Austin: So if the Army in total is going to white
- 11:16Austin: phosphor, night vision goggles, then you're
- 11:18Austin: just going to end up with a white phosphor
- 11:19Austin: night vision at some point.
- 11:20Lara: Yeah, it's not going to be your choice.
- 11:21Austin: That's right.
- 11:22Austin: Yeah, it's not going to be your choice,
- 11:23Austin: that's right.
- 11:23Austin: Yeah, it's not going to be your choice.
- 11:24Austin: It's not going to be the unit's choice
- 11:25Austin: necessarily.
- 11:25Austin: You just get what they get because the Army
- 11:26Austin: is moving to that as their one type of
- 11:29Austin: night vision.
- 11:31Lara: This episode is brought to you by CHOC
- 11:33Lara: because, let's be honest, we need all the
- 11:35Lara: vitality we can get.
- 11:37Lara: The patriots over at CHOCcom are on a
- 11:40Lara: mission to save mankind from extinction.
- 11:43Lara: Are on a mission to save mankind from
- 11:44Lara: extinction one testosterone boost at a time.
- 11:46Lara: Fellas, your T-levels are dropping faster
- 11:49Lara: than approval ratings in DC, but don't
- 11:51Lara: worry.
- 11:52Lara: The male vitality stack is here to save the
- 11:55Lara: day, clinically shown to boost your free
- 11:57Lara: testosterone by 87% in just 21 days.
- 12:02Lara: That's right, 87%, which is about how much
- 12:06Lara: more manly you'll feel when you take it.
- 12:09Lara: Ladies, don't think we forgot about you.
- 12:11Lara: The Female Vitality Stack will help you,
- 12:14Lara: feeling energized, sharp and ready to
- 12:17Lara: handle whatever chaos comes your way.
- 12:20Lara: And, because we love America, you get a
- 12:23Lara: 17.76% discount for life.
- 12:26Lara: Just use my name, lara, at checkout.
- 12:30Lara: Cancel any time.
- 12:32Lara: But let's be real.
- 12:33Lara: Why would you Go to Chalkcom that's
- 12:36Lara: C-H-O-Qcom and tell them Lara sent you?
- 12:41Lara: So you know, the NTSB is very cautious,
- 12:45Lara: probably as they should be, and they said
- 12:48Lara: that there's no, this was a night vision
- 12:51Lara: goggle training flight.
- 12:54Lara: But they're not confirming that the crew
- 12:57Lara: was actually wearing night vision at the
- 12:59Lara: time.
- 12:59Austin: So I think they've done an update.
- 13:00Austin: Well, number one they actually said, hey,
- 13:02Austin: there's three types of evaluations.
- 13:03Austin: They actually said it incorrectly.
- 13:05Austin: I think that they said one was the annual.
- 13:07Austin: They're all annual evaluations, but then
- 13:09Austin: they omitted either night vision or stands
- 13:11Austin: I can't remember standardization.
- 13:13Austin: They omitted one of those.
- 13:14Austin: I'm sure they'll figure that out and then
- 13:15Austin: the final report will be correct.
- 13:17Austin: Um, but I think later on they did do an
- 13:21Austin: update to that when they released it
- 13:22Austin: initially.
- 13:23Austin: Um, and I kind of knew the whole time hey,
- 13:25Austin: what they need to be looking for is when we
- 13:29Austin: put the night vision on, we use the term
- 13:30Austin: aided and unaided, aided being when you've
- 13:32Austin: got your night vision on.
- 13:33Austin: And so, because they do have access to the
- 13:35Austin: cockpit audio, they were saying that
- 13:36Austin: there's nothing that they've been able to
- 13:38Austin: kind of forensically go through and see
- 13:40Austin: whether or not they had them on for sure,
- 13:41Austin: just because of how violent the crash was.
- 13:44Austin: But I knew kind of the whole time.
- 13:46Austin: Hey, what they're going to hear is they're
- 13:47Austin: going to hear aided.
- 13:48Austin: They're right front's aided, meaning the
- 13:49Austin: pilot on the right front of the aircraft,
- 13:51Austin: left front's aided, right rear's aided.
- 13:54Austin: That would mean them putting their night
- 13:55Austin: vision on.
- 13:56Austin: And then if you don't hear them say unaided,
- 14:00Austin: then you have to assume that they'd still
- 14:02Austin: be on, because from a training standpoint,
- 14:04Austin: that's what you'd expect people to do, and
- 14:07Austin: I think what they've come out and said is
- 14:08Austin: that they heard them say aided on the tape,
- 14:10Austin: meaning they put the night vision on, but
- 14:11Austin: they never heard them say unaided so their
- 14:14Austin: working assumption is that they had night
- 14:16Austin: vision on yeah, that would be my assumption
- 14:17Austin: as well okay, so there were the crew on the
- 14:21Austin: Black Hawk.
- 14:21Lara: There were three people.
- 14:23Lara: Let's go through them because you know them.
- 14:25Lara: Just explain, if you will like, how well
- 14:29Lara: you know them and sort of what that means
- 14:32Lara: to you.
- 14:33Austin: Yeah, so Andrew Eaves, the pilot command
- 14:36Austin: and instructor pilot of the aircraft, knew
- 14:38Austin: him extremely well, so I was there from
- 14:41Austin: 2020 until 2023.
- 14:45Austin: He got there just a few months before I did.
- 14:46Austin: As a matter of fact, the guy that replaced
- 14:48Austin: me in Egypt Did Andrew's initial
- 14:51Austin: qualification.
- 14:52Austin: So when he first got to the unit he did his
- 14:53Austin: initial training.
- 14:54Austin: We were trading pictures the other day
- 14:56Austin: Because he had a picture from when Andrew
- 14:58Austin: completed his initial training
- 14:59Austin: qualification at the at the unit and then
- 15:01Austin: he replaced me and then I went there.
- 15:03Austin: So I was only a few months behind Andrew
- 15:04Austin: from when he got to the unit, um, and then
- 15:05Austin: he replaced me and then I went there.
- 15:06Austin: So I was only a few months behind Andrew
- 15:07Austin: from when he got to the unit and then he
- 15:08Austin: left a few months before.
- 15:09Austin: I did three years as kind of a normal
- 15:11Austin: rotation at army bases, um, and so three
- 15:13Austin: years later he left, which was just before
- 15:16Austin: I retired Um, but we were together and
- 15:20Austin: COVID in that in that unit we had to spend
- 15:22Austin: kind of more time isolated together because
- 15:24Austin: of the nature of the VIP mission, all this
- 15:26Austin: other stuff, so you'd kind of be stuck in a
- 15:27Austin: room with just your crew, a lot, and so we
- 15:30Austin: spent a lot of time locked in a room
- 15:31Austin: together with just me and him and a crew
- 15:32Austin: chief, and then, you know, also going out
- 15:36Austin: and doing training, doing different
- 15:39Austin: evaluations, doing different missions.
- 15:41Austin: Probably the most high profile mission that
- 15:43Austin: that unit has flown certainly was high
- 15:45Austin: profile and that I flew he was my co-pilot
- 15:46Austin: for and I was the air mission commander for
- 15:48Austin: that with a flight of four Blackhawks and
- 15:50Austin: the secretary of defense, and so he was
- 15:53Austin: hugely trusted in the unit, even as a
- 15:55Austin: co-pilot, and then later on became a pilot
- 15:58Austin: in command.
- 15:59Austin: I did part of his pilot command evaluation.
- 16:02Lara: So when you evaluated him, how did he do?
- 16:05Lara: He did great.
- 16:06Austin: Yeah, I was kind of well known for,
- 16:08Austin: actually, one of my former crew chiefs from
- 16:11Austin: Egypt.
- 16:12Austin: I hope he sees this because he'll get a
- 16:13Austin: kick out of it.
- 16:15Austin: He started I have an alter ego when I'm
- 16:17Austin: doing pilot command evaluations and he
- 16:19Austin: started calling me Dallas Wrath.
- 16:21Lara: Why?
- 16:22Lara: Because you're so harsh so instead of
- 16:23Lara: Austin.
- 16:23Austin: Dallas instead of Roth, wrath, why?
- 16:24Austin: Because you're so harsh.
- 16:25Austin: So instead of Austin.
- 16:25Lara: Dallas yeah.
- 16:26Austin: Instead of Roth Wrath, because on annual
- 16:28Austin: evaluations I was I was going to be very
- 16:32Austin: straightforward.
- 16:34Austin: On pilot command evaluations, you were
- 16:36Austin: going to get put through the ringer.
- 16:37Austin: You were ruthless, I was ruthless, and so
- 16:39Austin: on pilot command evaluations, dallas Wrath
- 16:42Austin: came out and I was going to find it because
- 16:46Austin: part of it is you want to find where the,
- 16:48Austin: you want to find where the chinks in the
- 16:49Austin: armor are Sure, right, and so if you don't
- 16:51Austin: really put them through the ringer, um,
- 16:52Austin: you're not going to see those necessarily,
- 16:54Austin: and it could be something where they get it
- 16:56Austin: wrong this time.
- 16:57Austin: It's not something that, um, they
- 16:59Austin: necessarily have to.
- 17:00Austin: There's probably something they've never
- 17:01Austin: seen before, but now they've got the
- 17:03Austin: necessary kind of knowledge and they can go.
- 17:05Austin: Oh yeah, I do remember I've seen this
- 17:06Austin: before and it's not something that anybody
- 17:08Austin: else has ever done to them, and you can
- 17:09Austin: find that out in evaluation.
- 17:11Austin: And now they've got the experience that
- 17:12Austin: they need to get it right sometime later on
- 17:13Austin: down the line.
- 17:15Lara: Sure, You're not supposed to be Miss
- 17:21Lara: Congeniality.
- 17:22Austin: Yeah, so for me, pilot command evaluations
- 17:24Austin: again an annual evaluation, a little bit
- 17:25Austin: different person Pilot command evaluations
- 17:28Austin: it was going to get pretty exciting for the
- 17:31Austin: person being evaluated.
- 17:33Austin: What would you do Everything from?
- 17:37Austin: Because for the Army it really starts with
- 17:39Austin: the mission planning process, with the
- 17:41Austin: briefing process, and so they're even going
- 17:43Austin: through and doing briefings.
- 17:44Austin: And if they did not have every T-cross,
- 17:46Austin: every I-dotted, everything kind of perfect,
- 17:52Austin: they were going to get torn up and it would
- 17:53Austin: have to be pretty close to perfect.
- 17:54Lara: For me, to kind of let them through it.
- 17:55Lara: So how did Andrew do?
- 17:56Austin: Andrew did great.
- 17:57Austin: Yeah, I was actually reviewing some texts
- 17:58Austin: that we had from where he was, you know I
- 17:59Austin: was sending him what route I wanted him to
- 18:01Austin: fly, where I wanted him to go, what times I
- 18:03Austin: wanted certain things to happen, and he's
- 18:05Austin: asking all the right questions and, yeah,
- 18:11Austin: in terms of how he did, honestly maybe the
- 18:13Austin: best of pilot command evaluations I've
- 18:15Austin: given, if not right up at the very top.
- 18:17Lara: And not because he was your friend.
- 18:20Austin: No no.
- 18:21Austin: So, no, we were friends in a sense, but at
- 18:26Austin: the end of the day, I've still,
- 18:26Austin: positionally, was in a place where we were
- 18:29Austin: friends, but we weren't that good of
- 18:30Austin: friends, you know, when it comes to stuff
- 18:32Austin: like that.
- 18:33Austin: I was responsible for making sure that
- 18:34Austin: Chris operated safely and efficiently and
- 18:36Austin: all of that and that far surpassed any you
- 18:39Austin: know kind of friendliness.
- 18:41Austin: Or being friends that we had who's a better
- 18:42Austin: pilot Me or Andrew, yeah, friendliness.
- 18:43Austin: Or being friends that we had who's a better
- 18:44Austin: pilot Me or Andrew?
- 18:45Austin: Yeah, man Well, I'll put this out.
- 18:51Austin: If I had to have, if when I was a co-pilot
- 18:53Austin: because I have to compare myself to him
- 18:55Austin: when he was a co-pilot or when he was a
- 18:56Austin: pilot in command I would pick Andrew, just
- 19:00Austin: again like reviewing some of those texts,
- 19:01Austin: and he's like, hey, can I pick this up?
- 19:02Austin: I know you guys are on duty Days where he
- 19:04Austin: wasn't on duty.
- 19:05Austin: Hey, I saw you're on duty.
- 19:05Austin: You want me to go pick your guys gear up,
- 19:07Austin: your crews gear up.
- 19:08Austin: This guy would bake birthday cakes for
- 19:10Austin: people that were having birthdays.
- 19:11Austin: He would, and that's just not.
- 19:13Austin: That's not directly pilot related, but just
- 19:15Austin: in terms of kind of how far above and
- 19:17Austin: beyond Committed he was yeah, that's a
- 19:21Austin: great word for it how committed he was to
- 19:23Austin: the organization, to the unit, to his job.
- 19:27Austin: The other thing was he was far better at
- 19:29Austin: one thing in particular, not that I was bad
- 19:31Austin: at it.
- 19:32Austin: So standardization instructor pilots and
- 19:33Austin: instructor pilots we're a little bit like a
- 19:38Austin: human light that comes on when there's
- 19:40Austin: cockroaches out, because people know that
- 19:42Austin: when we're around, the other pilots know
- 19:43Austin: that we're gonna ask them questions or we
- 19:45Austin: might hear them talking about something,
- 19:46Austin: and then all of a sudden our ears perk and
- 19:47Austin: we're like hold on a second.
- 19:48Austin: That's not right.
- 19:49Lara: Yeah.
- 19:50Austin: And nobody wants to kind of be picked on,
- 19:53Austin: so to speak.
- 19:55Austin: I didn't think it was picking on them, but
- 19:57Austin: people feel that way sometimes, and so what
- 20:00Austin: happens is you walk into a room and a lot
- 20:02Austin: of times the new pilots or newer pilots
- 20:04Austin: will scatter and disappear, and so I tried
- 20:07Austin: to avoid doing that myself.
- 20:08Austin: I spent a lot of time in the we call it the
- 20:10Austin: stands shop, but where the instructor
- 20:11Austin: pilots and the standardization pilots are.
- 20:14Austin: You know, I wanted to.
- 20:15Austin: You know I wanted to be their friends
- 20:16Austin: because I wanted to know what they knew.
- 20:19Austin: And you give more information.
- 20:20Austin: You mentor people more if they're your
- 20:21Austin: friends.
- 20:22Austin: More information, you mentor people more if
- 20:23Austin: they're your friends.
- 20:24Austin: So I wanted to do that.
- 20:28Austin: But I think Andrew is even better at it.
- 20:29Austin: If I walked out into the planning kind of
- 20:30Austin: room that we had there, there would be
- 20:31Austin: certain people that might kind of disappear.
- 20:32Austin: He was not going to be one of them and he
- 20:34Austin: would definitely be one of the people that
- 20:35Austin: was in stands with the instructor pilots
- 20:38Austin: asking us questions.
- 20:39Austin: Again, just reviewing those texts, I was
- 20:40Austin: like I would have never asked, like, hey,
- 20:41Austin: you want to pick up your gear?
- 20:43Austin: And again, he was just doing it to pitch in,
- 20:46Austin: so I'd probably pick him over me.
- 20:48Austin: You know when we're at the same kind of
- 20:49Austin: point in our careers.
- 20:50Lara: Yes, yes, I see what you mean.
- 20:53Lara: It makes you feel sad because he was,
- 20:56Lara: obviously was just a great guy.
- 20:58Lara: Yeah, he was, so that's.
- 21:01Lara: Then it must be hard to see people judging
- 21:06Lara: him without really knowing or understanding
- 21:08Lara: what happened.
- 21:12Austin: Yeah, so it was really hard, I think.
- 21:15Austin: Initially, I think most pilots are willing
- 21:18Austin: to kind of withhold judgment.
- 21:21Austin: The digital age has changed that a little
- 21:23Austin: bit because everybody's opinion can be so
- 21:24Austin: kind of amplified and they are so easy to
- 21:26Austin: put your opinion out there.
- 21:29Austin: But crashes that I'd seen in the past.
- 21:30Austin: This wasn't really as much of a problem and
- 21:33Austin: then I was perfectly willing to just kind
- 21:37Austin: of sit back and like, let's let the
- 21:38Austin: investigation play out, let's just kind of
- 21:39Austin: let the information get out through the
- 21:42Austin: normal channels, because it can be really
- 21:43Austin: complicated about how these things happen.
- 21:47Austin: And then I started seeing online comments.
- 21:51Austin: You know, like these incompetent army
- 21:54Austin: pilots went out there and killed a bunch of
- 21:55Austin: people, or it's obvious what happened.
- 21:59Austin: You know they were off on altitude and
- 22:00Austin: that's how everybody got killed.
- 22:02Austin: They should have been at their altitude and
- 22:03Austin: they weren't off on their altitude.
- 22:04Austin: They were off on altitude and that's how
- 22:05Austin: everybody got killed.
- 22:05Austin: They should have been at their altitude,
- 22:06Austin: they weren't off on their altitude.
- 22:07Austin: Um or um, even outside of the online stuff,
- 22:09Austin: I think, um, there were two specific
- 22:11Austin: instances.
- 22:12Austin: Unfortunately, president Trump said
- 22:14Austin: something which, um, focusing on the DEI
- 22:17Austin: aspect of it, um, and I think it's like a
- 22:20Austin: lot of things president Trump says, um,
- 22:21Austin: like a lot of things President Trump says
- 22:22Austin: saying this as a Trump supporter where if
- 22:26Austin: you peel it down, you can go.
- 22:30Austin: Okay, there's a kernel of truth to that.
- 22:31Austin: But as soon as you say something, you kind
- 22:32Austin: of draw attention to it and not knowing the
- 22:36Austin: specifics of it.
- 22:37Austin: In this specific instance, I don't think
- 22:39Austin: that applies.
- 22:41Austin: Looking back at Rebecca Lobach, talking to
- 22:43Austin: friends of her, I know her commander very
- 22:44Austin: well.
- 22:44Austin: I know people that have trained her very
- 22:46Austin: well and she was the pilot she was the
- 22:47Austin: pilot being evaluated and then there was
- 22:50Austin: also a lot of comments about her
- 22:53Austin: specifically, a lot of, just frankly kind
- 22:56Austin: of crazy conspiracy type stuff.
- 22:58Austin: Yeah, because she was a woman, because
- 23:00Austin: she'd been a, a White House social aid
- 23:04Austin: things like that, and there was a lot of
- 23:05Austin: misinformation even about what that job is
- 23:07Austin: and about what she was doing, kind of in
- 23:08Austin: that capacity, and so it kind of put this
- 23:12Austin: spotlight on her.
- 23:13Austin: That I didn't think was fair and it was
- 23:17Austin: causing real damage to people that I knew
- 23:18Austin: in the unit, that knew her, that knew it
- 23:19Austin: wasn't fair but couldn't speak out because
- 23:21Austin: they're still in the military and I'm
- 23:22Austin: retired and I don't know her family.
- 23:25Austin: I've never, never met her family, but I can
- 23:28Austin: put you know, I was thinking about what,
- 23:30Austin: how my family would have felt if I were in
- 23:32Austin: her situation or vice versa, and at some
- 23:37Austin: point I just couldn't do nothing anymore to
- 23:40Austin: see friends and you know people that I
- 23:45Austin: could, I could relate to their position
- 23:46Austin: pretty well just kind of being drug through
- 23:48Austin: the mud in a way that I thought was unfair.
- 23:50Lara: Well, I mean, yeah, you just lost a family
- 23:54Lara: member, right?
- 23:55Lara: Somebody that you love and respect.
- 23:59Lara: I mean, even if they made a mistake, you
- 24:04Lara: want the reporting on that to be honest and
- 24:06Lara: to be right.
- 24:07Lara: I mean, maybe she didn't make a mistake,
- 24:10Lara: but when people jump to conclusions without
- 24:12Lara: really knowing anything, that can be brutal.
- 24:15Austin: Well, and every bit of information has kind
- 24:17Austin: of come out subsequently, which,
- 24:19Austin: unfortunately what happens is when it first
- 24:21Austin: comes out.
- 24:22Austin: Everything is in the media.
- 24:23Austin: Everybody's paying a lot of attention to it.
- 24:25Austin: They're kind of laser focused on it.
- 24:27Lara: Yeah, that's.
- 24:28Lara: You know when that light happens and the
- 24:30Lara: news cycle is consumed with that event.
- 24:32Austin: And they're forming their opinions at that
- 24:34Austin: point?
- 24:34Lara: Yes, Because that's when most people are
- 24:36Lara: hearing about it and talking about it, and
- 24:38Lara: thinking about it.
- 24:39Austin: That's right and then over time the
- 24:40Austin: interest starts to wane Absolutely.
- 24:43Austin: You know, unless you're directly related to
- 24:45Austin: the situation, then the interest kind of
- 24:46Austin: goes down.
- 24:48Austin: But your opinion?
- 24:49Austin: Was formed here when you didn't have as
- 24:49Austin: much information.
- 24:50Austin: And now the information is coming out, but
- 24:52Austin: your interest is dropping off.
- 24:54Lara: Yeah, it reminds me of when they came out
- 24:55Lara: right after the Orlando nightclub shooting,
- 24:58Lara: which was that gay nightclub that was shot
- 25:00Lara: up and they dragged a guy out and put him
- 25:03Lara: on television and said he was the gay lover
- 25:04Lara: of the shooter, and all this stuff.
- 25:06Lara: And, of course, a few weeks later, when the
- 25:08Lara: FBI said, no, this guy never even met the
- 25:10Lara: shooter, had nothing to do with him, never
- 25:12Lara: communicated him.
- 25:13Lara: None of that is true.
- 25:14Lara: In fact, it wasn't even an attack that was
- 25:16Lara: motivated by what they said.
- 25:20Lara: It was a terrorist attack.
- 25:21Austin: Yeah, but unfortunately those opinions are
- 25:23Austin: there and if you talk to some people 10
- 25:25Austin: years after that incident they would still
- 25:27Austin: have that same opinion Like oh yeah, I
- 25:28Austin: thought there was this one thing.
- 25:29Austin: You're like no, it was debunked like a week
- 25:30Austin: later, but their opinion was already formed.
- 25:32Lara: Sure, and in fact there are political
- 25:35Lara: operatives and political figures who know
- 25:38Lara: precisely how to take advantage of that
- 25:41Lara: attention cycle.
- 25:42Austin: Yeah, and I don't think that you know, pete
- 25:46Austin: Hegseth has come out and said, talking
- 25:49Austin: about the altitude, there were a lot of
- 25:52Austin: other factors that if the altitude was off,
- 25:54Austin: which the NTSB is not even willing to say
- 25:56Austin: at this point, we can go into kind of why
- 25:57Austin: that is, you know, but had come out and
- 26:01Austin: said that and it's like again, it focuses
- 26:03Austin: now on the altitude.
- 26:03Austin: On the altitude yeah, as opposed to all of
- 26:05Austin: the factors that led up to the last four or
- 26:08Austin: five minutes of that crash.
- 26:09Lara: Yeah.
- 26:09Austin: Because that's when you really have to
- 26:10Austin: start looking is how did we get to that
- 26:11Austin: point?
- 26:12Austin: It started four or five minutes before that,
- 26:13Austin: or even started back in the risk assessment
- 26:15Austin: process, or a number of other things that
- 26:17Austin: you could talk about that led up to that
- 26:19Austin: particular.
- 26:20Austin: So is that a factor?
- 26:21Austin: It certainly could be, but again, it just
- 26:23Austin: focused everybody's attention on that and
- 26:24Austin: so it became.
- 26:26Austin: What I've been trying to tell people is
- 26:29Austin: it's good to have a simple understanding of
- 26:31Austin: something, but you don't want to be
- 26:32Austin: simplistic, and so if you have a simplistic
- 26:36Austin: understanding of something, it's kind of an
- 26:37Austin: oversimplified version of it, and to go
- 26:41Austin: laser focused on one particular thing, in
- 26:42Austin: this case the altitude especially as early
- 26:45Austin: on, without really knowing.
- 26:46Lara: Without really knowing so okay, wait, let's
- 26:49Lara: get into the altitude and the crash and the
- 26:50Lara: specifics of that in a minute, but what I
- 26:52Lara: just want to finish out first is everyone
- 26:55Lara: who was on that helicopter that day.
- 26:57Lara: So there was Andrew Eves who was the
- 26:59Lara: instructor of doing the evaluation, and
- 27:02Lara: then you had Rebecca who was the pilot and
- 27:05Lara: then the crew chief, right?
- 27:07Lara: So how, Ryan?
- 27:09Austin: Ryan O'Hara.
- 27:10Lara: Yeah, and you knew Ryan in passing.
- 27:13Austin: Yeah, I knew him in passing.
- 27:13Austin: We were briefly in the same company.
- 27:16Austin: I was kind of on my way towards retirement
- 27:18Austin: so I was spending less time there, and then
- 27:19Austin: he went to another company.
- 27:20Austin: After that he's what's known as a
- 27:24Austin: standardization instructor, which is why
- 27:24Austin: there was also some initial misreporting
- 27:26Austin: about him being a pilot as well, because
- 27:28Austin: I'm a standardization instructor pilot,
- 27:30Austin: he's a standardization instructor, and so I
- 27:32Austin: think it'd be really easy to kind of
- 27:33Austin: misunderstand what those are and that
- 27:36Austin: they're not actually related.
- 27:38Austin: And so what he was is that they're in kind
- 27:40Austin: of the crew chief infrastructure.
- 27:42Austin: You have a crew chief and then you have a
- 27:44Austin: flight instructor which is a instructor for
- 27:47Austin: crew chiefs, and then above that you have a
- 27:48Austin: standardization instructor, which is the
- 27:50Austin: same position as a standardization
- 27:51Austin: instructor pilot, just for crew chiefs, and
- 27:54Austin: so he was a standardization instructor.
- 27:55Austin: So he is a very experienced, very
- 27:57Austin: professional, you know, heavily relied upon
- 28:01Austin: crew chief.
- 28:02Austin: You know, like I said, essentially
- 28:04Austin: commiserate with what the senior station
- 28:05Austin: instructor pilots do.
- 28:07Lara: And you said specifically that you knew
- 28:11Lara: Ryan and Rebecca by reputation.
- 28:13Lara: So what was their reputation, stellar?
- 28:16Austin: Yeah, again, that's another part.
- 28:18Austin: Since I didn't really know them myself, I
- 28:19Austin: could kind of see what was going on in
- 28:21Austin: terms of you know we're still active in
- 28:22Austin: chat groups and friends with those guys and
- 28:25Austin: immediately we're all talking and everybody
- 28:29Austin: that I've talked to has has given very high,
- 28:33Austin: has very high regard for both of them.
- 28:36Austin: I really with Ryan, I knew him more because
- 28:40Austin: the other crew chiefs would talk about him
- 28:41Austin: a lot and so I knew him in passing, but
- 28:43Austin: then I always, whenever kind of a question
- 28:45Austin: would come up, it would be like ah man, I
- 28:46Austin: don't know.
- 28:47Austin: Hey, what do you think?
- 28:47Austin: I don't really know.
- 28:48Austin: And this is among the flight instructors,
- 28:49Austin: you know they kind of hang out in our
- 28:50Austin: standardization instructor.
- 28:52Austin: They kind of hang out with the instructor,
- 28:53Austin: pilots, and so, hey, I don't really know, I
- 29:00Austin: don was through events like that.
- 29:01Lara: Yeah, which is obvious that you know.
- 29:04Lara: People respected him then and relied upon
- 29:07Lara: him because he was good.
- 29:08Austin: Yeah, he was very good, had a great
- 29:10Austin: reputation, rebecca Becca Lobach so Becca
- 29:16Austin: was.
- 29:19Austin: I don't think I've ever heard anybody talk
- 29:22Austin: as highly about somebody just as a person
- 29:26Austin: and as an officer so not warrant officer
- 29:28Austin: but officer um, as much as I've seen people
- 29:31Austin: talk about Becca Lubach just in terms of
- 29:34Austin: how much she cared about her job One kind
- 29:35Austin: of anecdotally um, another standardization
- 29:38Austin: instructor was telling me um, that they
- 29:40Austin: were around her and they were, they were
- 29:41Austin: talking and um, this happened several times
- 29:44Austin: and they would just be talking about
- 29:45Austin: general aviation stuff, about Blackhawk
- 29:47Austin: stuff, and she'd be around.
- 29:49Austin: This is pretty common, like I was
- 29:50Austin: explaining with Andrew, where it's like the
- 29:51Austin: instructor pilots are kind of in the room
- 29:52Austin: and you're trying to learn from them, and
- 29:53Austin: she would actually go hold on a second and
- 29:57Austin: she would run and run back and she'd come
- 29:59Austin: back with a notebook and she'd be like okay,
- 30:09Austin: look, start talking again and would write
- 30:10Austin: down everything that they were saying so
- 30:11Austin: she could review it later.
- 30:12Austin: I don't think I've ever said anything that
- 30:13Austin: made somebody want to write it down that
- 30:13Austin: much and I definitely don't remember ever
- 30:14Austin: having somebody do that enough that I took
- 30:16Austin: note of it.
- 30:16Austin: I'm not saying that it never happened Like
- 30:17Austin: I should probably write that down, but I
- 30:19Austin: can't ever remember it happening frequently
- 30:21Austin: enough where it's like she's known for
- 30:24Austin: writing down everything you say because she
- 30:25Austin: wants to be able to retain it and she wants
- 30:26Austin: to learn it and, like, really be a master
- 30:28Austin: of her craft.
- 30:30Austin: Um, I also know she was relied upon the
- 30:32Austin: battalion they'd gone through some
- 30:34Austin: inspections and they had an inspection
- 30:35Austin: coming up and she was heavily relied upon
- 30:38Austin: to kind of get the unit in this one
- 30:39Austin: particular way ready for that inspection.
- 30:41Austin: Because they knew she was really good at
- 30:42Austin: kind of reading the regulations and it
- 30:44Austin: wasn't something that they had a lot of
- 30:46Austin: kind of institutional knowledge to draw on.
- 30:49Austin: So they needed somebody that could just
- 30:50Austin: read and understand and adapt quickly and
- 30:52Austin: so she was brought in specifically to do
- 30:54Austin: this one kind of job prior to this unit
- 30:56Austin: inspection.
- 30:58Austin: So I know her commander very well talked to
- 30:59Austin: him, she was very well liked, thought well
- 31:03Austin: of as a pilot and, yeah, loved baking
- 31:08Austin: apparently.
- 31:09Austin: I heard she'd bring cookies all the time.
- 31:13Lara: Well, so okay, you know the unit, you know
- 31:20Lara: the job and for you it's hard to see this
- 31:24Lara: happen.
- 31:24Lara: You've flown the aircraft those same
- 31:25Lara: aircraft for 12 years, but at the same time,
- 31:31Lara: over 60 people died on that airplane and it
- 31:35Lara: crashed right into them.
- 31:37Lara: So somebody's got to be accountable,
- 31:39Lara: somebody's got to be responsible, and
- 31:40Lara: people want to know how it happened.
- 31:42Lara: How could this have happened, right?
- 31:44Lara: So, um, from your point of view,
- 31:49Lara: incompetence wasn't the issue, because can
- 31:52Lara: you even survive in those jobs at that
- 31:55Lara: level if you're incompetent?
- 31:56Lara: I mean, is that even possible?
- 31:59Lara: There's a lot of people that get away with
- 32:00Lara: incompetence in their jobs.
- 32:01Lara: Yeah with degrees.
- 32:02Austin: I mean where it's like, you know, maybe not
- 32:04Austin: as good or whatever, but just like straight
- 32:06Austin: incompetence.
- 32:07Austin: But I would say there's a lot of crashes
- 32:08Austin: that I'm very familiar with, not just
- 32:11Austin: rotorcraft but also, you know, fixed-wing
- 32:13Austin: as well.
- 32:14Lara: Yeah.
- 32:17Austin: But specifically crashes that I'm aware of,
- 32:18Austin: that I know the people involved in the
- 32:19Austin: crash where I'm you know have kind of a
- 32:20Austin: better understanding of for various reasons,
- 32:23Austin: and I go, oh man, good guy, good dude, he's
- 32:28Austin: incompetent in that moment.
- 32:29Lara: Bad decision.
- 32:31Austin: Yeah, moment that was incompetent, or even
- 32:34Austin: over a period of time.
- 32:34Austin: You know, one of the things you'll hear
- 32:35Austin: kind of in aviation is most crashes come
- 32:40Austin: back to a well, we kind of all knew that
- 32:42Austin: that guy was going to get into that crash.
- 32:44Austin: We kind of all knew something would happen
- 32:45Austin: at some point.
- 32:46Austin: There's a lot of especially military
- 32:48Austin: aviation crashes where, because we do
- 32:50Austin: things that civilians aren't allowed to do,
- 32:52Austin: but we do have to have some capacity to do
- 32:54Austin: them, but sometimes people take some a
- 32:56Austin: little more leeway with that, and so then
- 32:59Austin: you have instances where they say, hey, we
- 33:00Austin: always knew, because of his attitude or
- 33:02Austin: because of the way that he flew, or he was
- 33:04Austin: always kind of pushing the envelope, we
- 33:06Austin: always knew this was going to kind of
- 33:08Austin: happen.
- 33:08Austin: So it wasn't really a surprise to the
- 33:09Austin: people in the unit.
- 33:11Austin: That happens all the time.
- 33:14Lara: But now this happens.
- 33:15Lara: But now this happens and people want to
- 33:17Lara: know whose fault it was.
- 33:18Austin: Yeah, so was it their fault?
- 33:21Austin: So fault is a hard thing to say.
- 33:23Austin: There's going to be a lot of different
- 33:24Austin: layers to it.
- 33:26Austin: You know there's a couple different ways to
- 33:28Austin: think about it.
- 33:28Austin: You can think about it in terms of an
- 33:29Austin: accident chain.
- 33:31Austin: Sometimes we'll say where it's, like, hey,
- 33:32Austin: an accident chain is a series of events.
- 33:33Austin: If you remove one of those chains then the
- 33:35Austin: accident doesn't happen.
- 33:37Austin: You know, at this point, further down, Um,
- 33:39Austin: and that could be a million different
- 33:40Austin: things.
- 33:40Austin: It could be one small mistake where it's
- 33:42Austin: not incompetence, and that's we may talk
- 33:44Austin: more about that.
- 33:45Austin: Um, where you go, oh man, I could see
- 33:47Austin: myself making that small mistake.
- 33:49Austin: That doesn't mean it's incompetent, it
- 33:50Austin: doesn't mean it was, it could have been a
- 33:51Austin: mistake.
- 33:52Austin: But those are two kinds of different things.
- 33:54Austin: I make mistakes in aviation all the time.
- 33:56Austin: I don't think you've.
- 33:58Austin: I wouldn't want to fly with somebody that
- 33:59Austin: said they never made a mistake because
- 34:00Austin: they're not telling the truth.
- 34:01Lara: Yeah because there's so much to do.
- 34:03Lara: It's impossible that you're always going to
- 34:05Lara: be right.
- 34:05Lara: That's right, but those mistakes are-.
- 34:08Austin: It's how you recover, right, it's how you
- 34:10Austin: recover, but never rise to the level of
- 34:12Austin: incompetence where you go.
- 34:13Austin: Oh, hey, I got a little bit off on altitude,
- 34:14Austin: or hey, I did miss a radio call, or you
- 34:17Austin: know.
- 34:18Austin: Or I misjudged the wind.
- 34:19Austin: Misjudged the wind.
- 34:20Austin: Yeah, hey, that landing was a little bit
- 34:21Austin: rougher than I'm used to.
- 34:23Lara: I've had a few of those.
- 34:24Austin: Hey, I've had landings where I go.
- 34:26Austin: Yeah, that was my best one, right?
- 34:27Lara: Yeah.
- 34:31Austin: Yeah, I need to.
- 34:32Austin: Yeah, it made a mistake and now it's
- 34:34Austin: experience.
- 34:35Lara: But this was shocking because, first of all,
- 34:40Lara: it was captured on camera.
- 34:42Lara: Secondly, it's a super busy airport.
- 34:44Lara: People fly in and out of there all the time,
- 34:46Lara: so a lot of people are familiar with it.
- 34:48Lara: And then, thirdly, you just don't see this
- 34:51Lara: happen all that often.
- 34:52Austin: That's, I think the biggest factor is just
- 34:54Austin: how infrequently it does happen.
- 34:56Austin: Right, Because if you kind of look back at
- 34:59Austin: the data to say how often are aviation
- 35:01Austin: accidents, especially commercial aviation
- 35:02Austin: accidents, how often do commercial aviation
- 35:04Austin: accidents happen where there are actual
- 35:07Austin: casualties involved, where people die as a
- 35:10Austin: result of?
- 35:10Lara: it Right.
- 35:11Austin: It just doesn't happen in the last 20 years.
- 35:14Lara: You think about.
- 35:15Lara: I mean because I've flown for 35 years.
- 35:17Lara: I've flown all over the world and all over
- 35:18Lara: this country and you see aircraft all the
- 35:21Lara: time.
- 35:21Lara: You know how busy the skies are.
- 35:24Lara: And sometimes you think to yourself it's a
- 35:25Lara: miracle there aren't more accidents, but
- 35:28Lara: there's a very efficient system that's in
- 35:30Lara: place.
- 35:31Lara: And I mean you can shed some light on this
- 35:34Lara: for me.
- 35:34Lara: But my understanding, particularly post
- 35:38Lara: 9-11, when you are dealing with areas like
- 35:41Lara: Washington DC, and not just Washington DC,
- 35:44Lara: we're not talking about Dulles Airport or
- 35:46Lara: BWI Baltimore Airport just a little further
- 35:49Lara: away in Maryland.
- 35:49Lara: There You're talking about DCA.
- 35:52Lara: So you are close to the city, you are close
- 35:55Lara: to the White House, you are close to the
- 35:56Lara: white house, you are close to the head of
- 35:57Lara: the defense intelligence agency that's
- 35:59Lara: headquartered in alexandria, virginia.
- 36:01Lara: You see it, when you take over land at dca,
- 36:05Lara: you are right.
- 36:06Lara: By all those national monuments I mean the
- 36:09Lara: number of guns almost across the street
- 36:11Lara: counter terror, that's right yeah in fact,
- 36:13Lara: that's the closest right going into dca.
- 36:15Lara: You drive right by it most of the time, so
- 36:18Lara: you have this area of the country which is
- 36:21Lara: concentrated I mean you talk about national
- 36:24Lara: security threats concentrated in a tiny
- 36:27Lara: space that is DCA.
- 36:30Lara: Plus, it has shorter runways, some of them
- 36:33Lara: right.
- 36:34Lara: I mean you need to be specially trained and
- 36:37Lara: specially certified to land there.
- 36:40Austin: Yeah, well, in terms of airline pilots, you
- 36:42Austin: know all airline pilots in theory could
- 36:43Austin: land there, but there are a lot of
- 36:44Austin: additional controls that happen in that
- 36:46Austin: area.
- 36:46Lara: There are additional controls there and
- 36:48Lara: there are very specific routes.
- 36:51Lara: That is one of the most controlled
- 36:53Lara: airspaces in the United States of America,
- 36:56Lara: so for it to happen there is really
- 37:00Lara: shocking.
- 37:01Austin: Yeah.
- 37:02Lara: This will truly be the golden age of
- 37:05Lara: America.
- 37:06Lara: That's what we have to do.
- 37:09Lara: Here's a message from our partner, dr Kirk
- 37:11Lara: Elliott.
- 37:12Lara: Something big is happening in the markets
- 37:15Lara: so big I have to bring your attention to it.
- 37:18Lara: On February 3rd this year, president Donald
- 37:20Lara: Trump and Treasury Secretary Scott Besant
- 37:23Lara: signed an executive order to create a
- 37:26Lara: sovereign wealth fund committing to
- 37:28Lara: monetizing the assets of the US balance
- 37:30Lara: sheet.
- 37:31Lara: Meanwhile, the Bank of England is running
- 37:33Lara: out of gold so desperate they're paying 16%
- 37:37Lara: a month just to borrow it.
- 37:39Lara: And where is all that gold?
- 37:41Lara: Going Right here to the US, with a drastic
- 37:44Lara: increase in metal shipments to CME Comics'
- 37:47Lara: vaults.
- 37:48Lara: Is President Trump preparing to repatriate
- 37:51Lara: and monetize America's gold?
- 37:54Lara: Elon Musk and former Congressman Ron Paul,
- 37:56Lara: through Doge, are planning an audit of the
- 37:59Lara: gold in Fort Knox.
- 38:01Lara: Major news for the silver market 80% of all
- 38:05Lara: refinery-bound silver comes from Mexico.
- 38:08Lara: With American silver refineries already
- 38:10Lara: facing a three-month backlog, this could
- 38:13Lara: send prices soaring overnight.
- 38:16Lara: President Trump is the catalyst for these
- 38:18Lara: historic economy-shifting events.
- 38:20Lara: A three-month backlog this could send
- 38:21Lara: prices soaring overnight.
- 38:22Lara: President Trump is the catalyst for these
- 38:23Lara: historic economy-shifting events.
- 38:24Lara: As he says, we are entering the golden age
- 38:25Lara: of America.
- 38:25Lara: Take advantage of Trump's golden age by
- 38:28Lara: owning the asset that has the potential to
- 38:30Lara: back our currency.
- 38:32Lara: Call Kirk Elliott Precious Metals today to
- 38:35Lara: reposition your portfolio into gold and
- 38:38Lara: silver at 720-605-3900, or visit
- 38:44Lara: lauralogangoldcom.
- 38:47Lara: What did you think when you first saw the
- 38:50Lara: news?
- 38:51Lara: What was the first thing that went across
- 38:52Lara: your mind?
- 38:54Austin: Well the first thing that I heard reported
- 38:56Austin: was that it was yeah.
- 38:57Austin: The first thing that I heard reported was
- 38:58Austin: that it was a police helicopter.
- 39:00Lara: That's right, it was confusing Again.
- 39:02Austin: It's like, immediately the reporting out of
- 39:05Austin: the gate is kind of not right.
- 39:08Austin: And so I actually initially went, oh man,
- 39:11Austin: well, did a moral come out on that later,
- 39:13Austin: or whatever.
- 39:13Austin: And then I didn't think too much about it.
- 39:14Austin: And then the tech started rolling in,
- 39:16Austin: saying what?
- 39:18Austin: From friends at the unit.
- 39:19Austin: Hey, did you hear about it?
- 39:21Austin: Did you know what's going on?
- 39:25Austin: Wasn't one of ours?
- 39:25Austin: Just to give a little more context, what I
- 39:27Austin: did is I reached out to a friend that was
- 39:29Austin: still there and I just said, hey, was it
- 39:33Austin: our guys Meaning?
- 39:33Austin: Was it the company that I used to be in?
- 39:35Austin: Andrew, at that time the accident aircraft
- 39:37Austin: was actually in a different company than I
- 39:38Austin: was in, and so I wanted to know was it
- 39:42Austin: Alpha Company, the company that I was in?
- 39:44Austin: Because if it wasn't, it was high
- 39:45Austin: likelihood I wouldn't know the pilots.
- 39:47Austin: You know.
- 39:47Austin: Obviously you can't talk about who it is
- 39:48Austin: specifically and everything.
- 39:50Austin: And he said, no, it was, you know other
- 39:52Austin: company.
- 39:53Austin: And so I kind of went, okay, good, not good
- 39:56Austin: in the sense you don't want to be anybody,
- 40:00Austin: but you never want it to be your own
- 40:03Austin: friends.
- 40:03Austin: And then shortly thereafter I started
- 40:04Austin: getting texts hey, here's who it was, and
- 40:07Austin: so it was unexpected.
- 40:08Austin: I didn't know that Andrew had gone to that
- 40:09Austin: company.
- 40:15Lara: So, that's kind of how it was.
- 40:17Austin: how I found out Was that a gut blow when
- 40:18Austin: you found out it was Andrew, especially
- 40:19Austin: when you think it's not, when you think
- 40:20Austin: it's not going to be your guys.
- 40:21Austin: Yeah, when you think it's not going to be
- 40:22Austin: your friends.
- 40:23Austin: You think okay, and you kind of yeah, you
- 40:25Austin: kind of go to bed.
- 40:25Austin: Actually, I was in bed, so I kind of found
- 40:28Austin: that out.
- 40:28Austin: Okay, it's in the other company I worry
- 40:31Austin: about here in terms of being people that I
- 40:32Austin: know, and then went to bed and then, while
- 40:35Austin: I was in bed, I got you know more
- 40:37Austin: information.
- 40:38Austin: Um, yeah, it's a gut blow.
- 40:40Austin: Um, yeah, especially kind of in the way
- 40:42Austin: that that that happened.
- 40:43Austin: Um, and then watching kind of the rollout
- 40:46Austin: from there, especially because when you see
- 40:47Austin: that it's somebody that you know is so high,
- 40:49Austin: so high quality, um, you know that it's not
- 40:52Austin: going to be just incompetence, meaning hey,
- 40:55Austin: well, this is one of those situations where
- 40:57Austin: it's like we all kind of knew this guy was
- 40:58Austin: dangerous, where I'm like, well, you can
- 41:00Austin: write that off right away, he's not.
- 41:03Austin: And then further kind of as more
- 41:04Austin: information came out, seeing like how that
- 41:07Austin: situation played out, applying it to myself
- 41:10Austin: and I think this is true of certainly
- 41:12Austin: everybody at the unit that I've talked to
- 41:13Austin: that I served with at the time, that's out
- 41:14Austin: now or that's still there, we look at it
- 41:16Austin: and we go.
- 41:17Austin: Man, I could have had the same thing happen
- 41:19Austin: to me because the situation was complicated.
- 41:23Lara: What was so complicated?
- 41:25Austin: Well, so the first thing that happened is,
- 41:29Austin: as they're coming down there, keep in mind,
- 41:30Austin: this is a normal event for them in terms of
- 41:33Austin: the training that they were doing, the
- 41:34Austin: evaluation that they're doing, a normal
- 41:35Austin: event for them in terms of the training
- 41:36Austin: that they were doing, the evaluation that
- 41:37Austin: they're doing.
- 41:38Austin: This is very normal.
- 41:38Austin: This is a.
- 41:38Austin: This is a every you know, Monday, Tuesday,
- 41:40Austin: Wednesday, Thursday, Friday if there's guys
- 41:41Austin: going out and doing stuff, just like this,
- 41:44Austin: crew members going out and doing this kind
- 41:45Austin: of stuff, so this is a normal day.
- 41:46Austin: When I kind of saw the route, I went oh,
- 41:48Austin: they're coming back from, they're coming
- 41:50Austin: back from training.
- 41:50Austin: I know exactly where they are and that's
- 41:51Austin: where we'd usually come back and in that
- 41:54Austin: direction they're going home.
- 41:55Lara: they're going home for the night, they're
- 41:56Lara: done and that's something I just want to
- 41:58Lara: point out is that these routes there are
- 42:01Lara: routes in and out of every airport, every
- 42:03Lara: base, I mean, and these are specific,
- 42:06Lara: well-known, standardized routes that
- 42:08Lara: everybody uses, which is part of how you
- 42:11Lara: keep it safe yeah, and actually at that
- 42:12Lara: unit you actually have to spend more time
- 42:14Lara: there when you first get there flying with
- 42:16Lara: an instructor yeah um, then you ordinarily
- 42:18Lara: would in the army because it's so
- 42:19Lara: complicated.
- 42:20Austin: So even though when I got there I have a
- 42:23Austin: lot of other experience coming in there,
- 42:25Austin: I'm one of the most experienced people in
- 42:26Austin: the unit and I still had to spend more
- 42:29Austin: hours flying with another instructor just
- 42:30Austin: to get you kind of used to the routes and
- 42:32Austin: everything.
- 42:36Austin: But by the time you're through that, and
- 42:37Austin: especially as you go for the next couple of
- 42:38Austin: years, you get really used to the area and
- 42:40Austin: so a few different things that happen in
- 42:42Austin: this scenario.
- 42:44Austin: So Tower at some point calls PAT-25, so
- 42:47Austin: that's their call sign, pat-25 being the
- 42:50Austin: Blackhawk.
- 42:51Austin: So they call PAT-25 and say, hey, your
- 42:53Austin: traffic is a CRJ just south of Wilson
- 42:57Austin: Bridge at 1,200 feet descending.
- 43:02Lara: And the CRJ is for the civilian plane.
- 43:05Lara: That's right.
- 43:05Lara: The American Airlines flight.
- 43:06Austin: Yeah, so it's actually PSA Airlines and
- 43:08Austin: they actually go by Blue Street call signs.
- 43:11Austin: So Blue Street 5342 would have been their
- 43:12Austin: call sign that they were using on the
- 43:14Austin: radios.
- 43:14Austin: It's an American Airlines flight number.
- 43:15Austin: So Blue Streak 5342 would have been their
- 43:19Austin: call sign that they were using on the
- 43:20Austin: radios.
- 43:21Austin: It's an American Airlines flight number.
- 43:21Austin: And so, looking at the point where that
- 43:22Austin: radio call was made, hey, you need to be
- 43:23Austin: looking for traffic.
- 43:23Austin: This is their location.
- 43:24Austin: The helicopter, essentially, is on the
- 43:25Austin: opposite end of the runway, so the
- 43:25Austin: airplanes are coming in to land on the
- 43:27Austin: runway.
- 43:27Austin: The helicopter is beyond the runway, on the
- 43:30Austin: other side of the airport, and so, from the
- 43:35Austin: helicopter's perspective, again, it's at
- 43:36Austin: night.
- 43:36Austin: They're wearing night vision, more than
- 43:38Austin: likely.
- 43:39Austin: You're looking straight down the runway and
- 43:40Austin: you're seeing not just the airplane that
- 43:42Austin: you need to be looking at, but also every
- 43:44Austin: other aircraft that's landing on that
- 43:46Austin: runway, which, because of night vision, you
- 43:50Austin: can see aircraft for 50 or a hundred miles,
- 43:52Austin: ones that aren't even going to land there,
- 43:53Austin: ones that are going to go land to go land
- 43:55Austin: at Anacostia Bowling, are going to go land
- 43:56Austin: at Andrews, which are both there, that are
- 43:58Austin: going to go land at Davis and Army Airfield,
- 44:00Austin: where you're going back to, you can see all
- 44:02Austin: of that.
- 44:03Lara: And what do you see?
- 44:04Lara: Is it mainly the lights?
- 44:06Lara: It's the lights, yeah, and I know people
- 44:08Lara: have said there was the lights of Crystal
- 44:10Lara: City right.
- 44:11Lara: That was behind that.
- 44:21Austin: Yeah, that does play into it, but that
- 44:22Austin: plays into it later on.
- 44:22Austin: So initially, you can look out and you can
- 44:23Austin: just see this line of aircraft, and so
- 44:24Austin: you're going to pick out the light that you
- 44:25Austin: think is the one that they're talking about
- 44:26Austin: and focus on that one, and you know that's
- 44:27Austin: the one that you're supposed to avoid.
- 44:28Austin: Okay, so then Andrew requested visual
- 44:31Austin: separation, which?
- 44:33Lara: is what.
- 44:33Austin: Which just means I can see them.
- 44:36Austin: Hey, air traffic control, you don't need to.
- 44:38Austin: You don't really need to pay as close of
- 44:39Austin: attention.
- 44:39Austin: You don't need to be responsible for making
- 44:41Austin: sure we don't hit each other.
- 44:42Austin: Because I can see them, I can avoid them.
- 44:44Austin: Okay, which that was a pretty standard
- 44:47Austin: procedure there.
- 44:48Austin: As long as you could see the aircraft,
- 44:50Austin: you'd request visual separation.
- 44:51Austin: It's a way of kind of taking some of the
- 44:52Austin: burden away from air traffic control,
- 44:54Austin: because they're super busy as well.
- 44:56Lara: And you're letting them know that in the
- 44:58Lara: aircraft we see what you're talking about
- 45:00Lara: that's right, yeah, traffic and side
- 45:01Lara: request visual separation.
- 45:02Lara: But is it possible, he was looking at a
- 45:04Lara: different aircraft.
- 45:05Austin: I would say almost 100% likely.
- 45:08Austin: So I think that probably what happened is
- 45:10Austin: they picked out the wrong aircraft because
- 45:12Austin: part of that air traffic control
- 45:14Austin: communication the last part of it was they
- 45:16Austin: said, talking about the airplane that
- 45:18Austin: they're supposed to be going to is circling
- 45:20Austin: to land three three.
- 45:21Austin: So the runway that they're kind of looking
- 45:22Austin: down is runway one.
- 45:24Austin: Yes, that was the more commonly used runway
- 45:27Austin: because it's 7,200 feet long.
- 45:29Austin: Runway three three is only 5,200 feet long.
- 45:31Lara: So it's more challenging.
- 45:48Austin: Yeah, so it's more challenging down runway
- 45:52Austin: one.
- 45:52Austin: They're expecting that aircraft to land
- 45:54Austin: runway one because that's what we would
- 45:55Austin: usually see.
- 45:55Austin: Matter of fact, I never one time saw an
- 45:58Austin: aircraft land on runway three three while I
- 45:59Austin: was there.
- 46:00Austin: It's not because they weren't I can go into
- 46:01Austin: more detail about that later but they're
- 46:04Austin: kind of already preloaded for, because
- 46:05Austin: that's what I've always seen.
- 46:06Austin: And that last part, circling the land three,
- 46:08Austin: three was actually cut off in the Blackhawk.
- 46:17Austin: So what do you mean?
- 46:18Austin: It was cut off.
- 46:18Austin: So the NTSB reported that that part of the
- 46:19Austin: communication was not recorded by the
- 46:21Austin: Blackhawk, meaning it can be, for any
- 46:22Austin: number of reasons, where their traffic
- 46:23Austin: controller set it, but due to antenna
- 46:26Austin: position or atmospheric conditions, or, you
- 46:28Austin: know, there's a limited number of radio
- 46:30Austin: frequencies that we use for aviation and so
- 46:33Austin: there there's duplicates.
- 46:35Austin: But that could be a duplicate one that's a
- 46:36Austin: hundred miles away and just somehow it's
- 46:39Austin: uncommon but occasionally will get picked
- 46:41Austin: up by your radio and you don't actually
- 46:43Austin: hear what they say, but it just cuts your
- 46:46Austin: ability to hear them off.
- 46:47Lara: What are the chances of that happening?
- 46:48Austin: Very, very, very small.
- 46:50Austin: Yeah, so very small.
- 46:52Lara: But it's confirmed by the NTSB from the
- 46:54Lara: recordings from the flight launch.
- 46:55Austin: That's what the NTSB is saying right now is
- 46:57Austin: that, based on the, they're calling a
- 46:59Austin: cockpit voice recorder.
- 47:00Austin: My understanding it's really not a cockpit
- 47:02Austin: voice recorder per se, because it's not a
- 47:03Austin: microphone, it's just.
- 47:04Austin: It's a different system.
- 47:05Austin: But essentially that last part of the
- 47:08Austin: communication was never received by the
- 47:09Austin: Blackhawk and they may never know why that
- 47:12Austin: is, but it does happen.
- 47:12Austin: And they may never know why that is, but it
- 47:13Austin: does happen.
- 47:14Austin: It's relatively rare.
- 47:15Austin: But in that moment the chances of it
- 47:17Austin: happening too, where it's that last little
- 47:21Austin: critical bit of the information in this
- 47:23Austin: particular scenario, that it's a helicopter,
- 47:24Austin: like all of that, is just again one of the
- 47:27Austin: chances, infinitely small, but it did
- 47:29Austin: happen.
- 47:30Austin: And so now the Blackhawk doesn't really
- 47:32Austin: have the, the Blackhawk crew members don't
- 47:34Austin: really have the critical piece of
- 47:36Austin: information to understand that, oh, there's
- 47:38Austin: an airplane that's not just going to come
- 47:39Austin: straight in here and we're going to go to
- 47:41Austin: the left of them and never cross paths Down
- 47:44Austin: runway one, down runway one, we're going to
- 47:46Austin: stay over the river, they're going to stay
- 47:47Austin: over their side of the river and we're
- 47:48Austin: never going to cross paths.
- 47:49Austin: They're missing the critical, which now
- 47:52Austin: means there's actually an airplane that's
- 47:53Austin: going to cross their path once to go over
- 47:54Austin: to the east side of the river and then it's
- 47:56Austin: going to take a hard turn to go into runway
- 47:58Austin: 33 and cut right in front of them, and they
- 48:01Austin: never heard that critical piece of
- 48:02Austin: information.
- 48:04Lara: So what happens next right after that?
- 48:08Austin: Yeah, so the next thing that happens in the
- 48:10Austin: sequence of events, the CRJ, the American
- 48:12Austin: 5342, they continue their approach.
- 48:18Austin: They just when they get about at the bridge
- 48:20Austin: they start to break off and turn over the
- 48:23Austin: kind of Eastern shore over Maryland, and
- 48:26Austin: they're still descending.
- 48:28Austin: The Blackhawk is slowly getting closer and
- 48:29Austin: closer and closer to kind of the point of
- 48:32Austin: impact.
- 48:34Austin: Another thing that usually would happen to
- 48:35Austin: us there's a place called Haines Point.
- 48:37Austin: It's actually on the helicopter route
- 48:38Austin: charts.
- 48:38Austin: It's depicted on there If you're looking at
- 48:42Austin: kind of a map of the area.
- 48:43Austin: It's a little island that's just kind of
- 48:45Austin: south of the harbor.
- 48:47Austin: In that area it's kind of the last.
- 48:49Austin: It's the island's closest to the airport.
- 48:51Austin: Haines Point's the southern tip of that
- 48:53Austin: island and so what would typically happen?
- 48:56Austin: There's a reason why I said I never
- 48:57Austin: actually physically saw anybody land there
- 49:00Austin: is because air traffic control would
- 49:01Austin: typically hold us at Haines Point and so
- 49:04Austin: when you're north they would just make a
- 49:05Austin: call.
- 49:06Austin: You know, pat, whatever hold at Haines
- 49:08Austin: Point, they wouldn't even necessarily tell
- 49:10Austin: you why you're holding.
- 49:12Austin: And when you're at 200 feet and you're
- 49:13Austin: trying to hold, especially at night, a lot
- 49:15Austin: of other factors, that's a low altitude for
- 49:17Austin: anybody.
- 49:18Austin: For helicopter it's still low altitude, um,
- 49:20Austin: so your hands are pretty full, so you're
- 49:21Austin: not really worried about why I need to hold.
- 49:23Austin: I'm just worried that I do need to hold,
- 49:25Austin: and so you're.
- 49:26Austin: You're busy, kind of turning there in
- 49:27Austin: circles.
- 49:27Austin: I know guys that would slow back to a hover,
- 49:30Austin: um, which comes with its own difficulties.
- 49:32Austin: It's kind of just a dealer's choice.
- 49:34Austin: I could see an argument for either one of
- 49:35Austin: those, sure, but because of that you never
- 49:38Austin: really see anybody land runway three, three
- 49:40Austin: and you never crossed that path when
- 49:42Austin: they're landing runway three, three.
- 49:44Lara: Because you're, because you're staying
- 49:45Lara: there, you're holding.
- 49:46Austin: Because you're holding in this place.
- 49:47Austin: That's about a mile North.
- 49:49Austin: So that was my experience.
- 49:50Austin: I don't know if that was a rule or not.
- 49:51Austin: You know I don't have a reason to suspect
- 49:54Austin: that it was, but I do know that that was
- 49:55Austin: what was commonly done and that again, just
- 50:00Austin: it would reduce your kind of situational
- 50:02Austin: awareness to what the airplanes do when
- 50:03Austin: they're landing 3-3.
- 50:04Lara: But you don't know if that's what happened.
- 50:05Austin: No, I don't this evening, so that's, that's
- 50:12Austin: you speculating, so I know that for a fact.
- 50:14Austin: I don't know what the rule actually says,
- 50:17Austin: so I wouldn't say that this is a case where
- 50:18Austin: anybody necessarily did anything wrong.
- 50:21Austin: In this event, the controller likely just
- 50:23Austin: thought they've got visual separation, not
- 50:25Austin: knowing that that last critical bit of
- 50:26Austin: information was cut off.
- 50:27Austin: There's no way for the controller to know,
- 50:28Austin: because he said it.
- 50:29Lara: Yes, so this is a key point in the
- 50:32Lara: investigation.
- 50:33Lara: We have some video here of the.
- 50:36Lara: This should be from the tower right.
- 50:39Lara: Traffic 2 is up for runway.
- 50:41Lara: Can we listen to this and just see what
- 50:43Lara: your thoughts are on it?
- 50:45Lara: This is the tower telling the helicopter
- 50:48Lara: crew that there's traffic just south of the
- 50:51Lara: Woodrow Bridge.
- 50:56Austin: That's right.
- 50:56Austin: So it says PAT-25, telling them where the
- 50:58Austin: traffic is.
- 50:58Austin: Now, keep in mind, pat-25 is due north of
- 50:59Austin: runway one.
- 51:00Austin: They're looking down the runway and they're
- 51:01Austin: seeing those other aircraft.
- 51:04Austin: What you can't really see on here is that
- 51:05Austin: there's a bunch of other aircraft Every
- 51:06Austin: three miles basically, there's another
- 51:08Austin: airplane also lined up to do an approach to
- 51:11Austin: runway one.
- 51:14Austin: So that's what they're looking at.
- 51:16Austin: They're looking at a series of lights and
- 51:17Austin: trying to pick the right light out.
- 51:18Austin: But that last part and it's on here it says
- 51:19Austin: setting up for runway three, three.
- 51:21Austin: I hear it as circling runway, circling
- 51:24Austin: runway three, three.
- 51:26Austin: Either way, it's essentially the same bit
- 51:27Austin: of information.
- 51:28Austin: That's the part that's cut off, that last
- 51:31Austin: part, so there's.
- 51:32Austin: So they would be making the assumption that,
- 51:34Austin: oh look, they're all set up for runway one.
- 51:36Austin: They must be coming into land runway one.
- 51:39Austin: They lose that last bit of critical
- 51:40Austin: information.
- 51:41Austin: And so the way that the helicopter routes
- 51:43Austin: there route four follows the eastern
- 51:45Austin: shoreline the airplanes go straight into
- 51:49Austin: land on runway one and kind of never cross
- 51:51Austin: over the helicopter route after they cross
- 51:53Austin: the bridge.
- 51:54Lara: Okay, let's play it and see what happens
- 51:56Lara: here this difference proof.
- 52:00Austin: American 1630 tower will be one lot boy
- 52:02Austin: chapter up for only three.
- 52:03Austin: This has one small funnel.
- 52:04Austin: Yes, that's where the visual separation is
- 52:06Austin: approved.
- 52:06Austin: The controller's probably thinking, okay,
- 52:08Austin: they can see them, they're going to avoid
- 52:09Austin: them, but he doesn't know that that last
- 52:10Austin: bit of information was cut off.
- 52:15Austin: So it's likely at this point pat 25 is
- 52:16Austin: looking at the aircraft behind them which
- 52:20Austin: is going to land on runway one, and they
- 52:22Austin: don't know that there's another aircraft
- 52:23Austin: circling the land, runway three, three, who
- 52:26Austin: they're getting closer to and at this point,
- 52:28Austin: if you can pause it for one second, that
- 52:32Austin: terrain um, if you've been there before, I
- 52:34Austin: think it's Colonial Heights there, but
- 52:37Austin: there's rising terrain there.
- 52:38Austin: You've also got more lights along the shore.
- 52:41Austin: There's the Ferris wheels right there, the
- 52:45Austin: casino is there, and so you've got rising
- 52:47Austin: terrain.
- 52:48Lara: You've got all the stuff.
- 52:48Lara: Yeah, the MGM Grand is right there.
- 52:50Austin: And so the CRJ is slowly kind of descending
- 52:54Austin: closer to those things, or even to a point
- 52:55Austin: where they'd be, from the helicopter's
- 52:57Austin: perspective, potentially below them but at
- 53:00Austin: the very least real close to them.
- 53:02Austin: If they're looking at the wrong aircraft
- 53:04Austin: and thinking it's the correct aircraft now
- 53:07Austin: at this point, that's probably in their
- 53:08Austin: night vision for the most part.
- 53:10Austin: Meanwhile, the other aircraft that's going
- 53:12Austin: to eventually hit them, or vice versa, is
- 53:15Austin: outside, on the peripheral vision, where
- 53:16Austin: they can only see through their unaided
- 53:18Austin: night vision, and it's working its way kind
- 53:22Austin: of further away from their central field of
- 53:24Austin: view, which is making it more difficult to
- 53:26Austin: pick up Included.
- 53:28Austin: It's down closer to the lights and all
- 53:29Austin: these other factors.
- 53:31Austin: And so at this point it would be really
- 53:33Austin: hard, missing that key piece of information,
- 53:35Austin: to look over there and try to find them,
- 53:38Austin: and they're not even necessarily trying to
- 53:41Austin: find them because they think they're
- 53:42Austin: looking at the the right aircraft.
- 53:44Austin: And then, if you continue, plan it, it gets
- 53:45Austin: more complicated.
- 53:54Austin: All right, and if you could pause that for
- 53:55Austin: one more second?
- 53:57Austin: So he said do you have the CRJ in sight Now?
- 53:58Austin: Keep in mind, from a helicopter, with
- 54:00Austin: airplanes, and these speeds, with lights
- 54:01Austin: facing you, they're all just lights.
- 54:03Austin: So to say that it's a CRJ, because there
- 54:04Austin: are actually two different types of
- 54:05Austin: airplane there.
- 54:07Austin: One's a CRJ and one's an Airbus 319.
- 54:10Austin: There are two different kinds of airplanes
- 54:11Austin: but they're all just lights to the
- 54:12Austin: helicopter crew, especially with night
- 54:14Austin: vision on Sure kinds of airplanes.
- 54:14Austin: But they're all just lights to the
- 54:15Austin: helicopter crew, especially with night
- 54:16Austin: vision on.
- 54:16Austin: It's just, you know, you've, you've seen
- 54:17Austin: traffic before with night vision on, and so
- 54:18Austin: I'm sure you can read it Like all you see
- 54:19Austin: is the headlights, you don't know what's
- 54:20Austin: behind them, and so even if they were
- 54:23Austin: looking to say it's a CRJ, that's not
- 54:25Austin: really critical or helpful information.
- 54:27Austin: Um, where it is would have been helpful
- 54:30Austin: again, but the controller doesn't know.
- 54:32Austin: They missed that critical part of
- 54:33Austin: information before, and now he's asking to
- 54:35Austin: confirm.
- 54:36Austin: The reason is because they got a collision
- 54:37Austin: alert inside, uh, inside the tower, which
- 54:39Austin: is on their radar.
- 54:40Austin: So that's the controller seeing a kind of
- 54:42Austin: like a beeping red light and an alarm
- 54:44Austin: that's going off saying hey, there's this,
- 54:45Austin: two aircraft are getting too close together,
- 54:47Austin: and so the controller now is going oh, I
- 54:49Austin: gotta say something again.
- 54:51Austin: I never was asked again if I had aircraft
- 54:54Austin: in sight there, so that would be highly
- 54:56Austin: unusual, and so I would suspect that at
- 55:02Austin: this point in the PAT-25, they're probably
- 55:03Austin: going.
- 55:03Austin: Huh, that's kind of weird.
- 55:04Austin: I've never.
- 55:05Austin: You know, that's unusual.
- 55:06Austin: They would ask us if we have them in sight,
- 55:08Austin: but again they're looking at the wrong
- 55:10Austin: aircraft.
- 55:10Austin: Also, the part that says pass behind was
- 55:12Austin: also cut off.
- 55:14Austin: In this case it was cut off because in a
- 55:17Austin: Blackhawk the way that you key the mic, the
- 55:19Austin: microphone or the radio is by pulling on a
- 55:22Austin: trigger.
- 55:22Austin: Okay, I've had it happen to me before.
- 55:27Austin: Almost every pilot I know has had this
- 55:28Austin: happen before, where you hear air traffic
- 55:31Austin: control talking.
- 55:32Austin: But you were about to say something.
- 55:33Lara: Yes.
- 55:34Austin: And so you step on each other.
- 55:35Austin: And you kind of step on each other, yeah,
- 55:37Austin: and just, you're not quick enough, your
- 55:38Austin: mind can't think and do everything and your
- 55:39Austin: fingers kind of already moving.
- 55:40Austin: And so you briefly kind of step on each
- 55:42Austin: other and so, in this instance, that's what
- 55:44Austin: happened.
- 55:44Austin: The other one, we don't know why.
- 55:45Austin: This one, we do know why, it's because they
- 55:47Austin: did intended to, and from their, from their
- 55:48Austin: mind, I would imagine, they're looking at
- 55:57Austin: this other craft.
- 55:58Austin: They're like, well, yeah, I was, I'm gonna
- 55:59Austin: pass behind them.
- 56:00Austin: A matter of fact, we're never going to
- 56:01Austin: cross paths yeah um, not really an issue,
- 56:04Austin: and but they may have had a where they're
- 56:06Austin: like hey, I wonder if our situational
- 56:07Austin: awareness is where it should be.
- 56:09Austin: So there's a reason they're asking me again
- 56:10Austin: right it, just it's it's unusual, but it's
- 56:13Austin: not um completely clear but it's not
- 56:16Austin: completely clear about why they're asking
- 56:18Austin: and so, again, this will all come out
- 56:21Austin: further investigation with the NTSB about
- 56:22Austin: what the conversation was in the cockpit.
- 56:25Austin: But this is going to play into the altitude
- 56:28Austin: situation right now.
- 56:28Austin: So you can see it says 003 on there, that's
- 56:31Austin: 300 feet.
- 56:33Austin: I'm not an expert on the way that the, the
- 56:35Austin: radar, reports everything, but it is.
- 56:36Austin: It is essentially a rounded up number.
- 56:39Lara: uh, to kind of oversimplify it so pat, two,
- 56:41Lara: five zero zero three kilo, so that's saying
- 56:44Lara: 300 feet I see and the crj is at 500 feet
- 56:46Lara: at this point and so that's kind of like
- 56:48Lara: the plane is higher, it's above the, the
- 56:50Lara: plane's higher and it but it's descending
- 56:51Lara: to come into land on that runway that runs,
- 56:53Lara: uh, to run to the northwest there.
- 56:55Lara: Which one?
- 56:57Austin: So there's one runway that's more or less
- 57:00Austin: straight up and down.
- 57:01Austin: There's a smaller one that's going
- 57:02Austin: northwest, like that.
- 57:04Austin: So they're going to make a left turn to
- 57:06Austin: land on that shorter runway, north and
- 57:08Austin: northwest.
- 57:09Lara: Okay, so let's play it and see what happens.
- 57:16Austin: So again, they approved visual separation.
- 57:18Austin: But PAT-25 is looking at the wrong aircraft,
- 57:20Austin: likely at this point.
- 57:29Austin: Yeah, so at that point both of those
- 57:30Austin: aircraft are in the water at this point.
- 57:44Lara: Is that where it happens?
- 57:45Lara: Yeah, they're right there.
- 57:47Austin: Yeah, so that replay of it has already
- 57:49Austin: happened at this point.
- 57:52Austin: So another thing that happened that's not
- 57:54Austin: shown on this.
- 57:54Austin: I've seen it in a few other places where
- 57:56Austin: I've seen it's kind of where there's more
- 57:57Austin: breadcrumbs, if you will, kind of left by
- 57:59Austin: the aircraft and it also shows their
- 58:00Austin: airspeeds.
- 58:02Austin: It looks to me I don't know if this is 100%
- 58:04Austin: going to be the case or not, but it looks
- 58:06Austin: to me like the Blackhawk slows back from a
- 58:08Austin: hundred knots, so a hundred nautical miles
- 58:10Austin: per hour, a hundred knots to probably 80.
- 58:14Austin: So as they get close and they get asked the
- 58:16Austin: second time about about then they slow back
- 58:22Austin: to 80 knots.
- 58:22Austin: There's a lot of good reasons for that.
- 58:23Austin: A hundred knots and 80 knots are two very
- 58:24Austin: normal Blackhawk speeds for a variety of
- 58:25Austin: reasons.
- 58:26Austin: I'm not going to go into the details but
- 58:27Austin: but they would be normal, comfortable air
- 58:29Austin: speeds for a Blackhawk.
- 58:30Austin: One of the things that you do as a
- 58:31Austin: helicopter pilot if you're not sure about
- 58:33Austin: what's happening in front of you, is you
- 58:35Austin: slow back.
- 58:36Austin: Sure, hey, let me build myself some more
- 58:37Austin: time.
- 58:37Austin: I'll build myself some.
- 58:39Austin: You know time buys you options.
- 58:41Austin: Yeah, right, so I'm going to slow back to
- 58:55Austin: 80 knots here and maybe it doesn't even
- 58:56Austin: articulate it.
- 58:56Austin: Maybe she does, but starts to slow back and
- 58:59Austin: then, kind of, the third option would be
- 59:01Austin: you start to realize that it's a little bit
- 59:03Austin: tense or situation and big muscles beat
- 59:06Austin: little muscles, and so as you start to get
- 59:08Austin: tense you know humans just- in general,
- 59:09Austin: we're all familiar, I think, with you start
- 59:11Austin: to get tensed up.
- 59:12Austin: Well, if you're flying a helicopter and you
- 59:13Austin: start to have that kind of sympathetic
- 59:15Austin: muscular response and you pull back on the
- 59:19Austin: controls a little bit, in any of those
- 59:21Austin: scenarios where you're intentionally
- 59:23Austin: slowing back or you unintentionally pull
- 59:25Austin: back on the cyclic a little bit, you're
- 59:26Austin: going to climb.
- 59:28Lara: But what you know for sure is that that
- 59:31Lara: helicopter slowed down.
- 59:33Austin: That's what it appears to me, based on some
- 59:35Austin: other stuff outside of here that I've seen,
- 59:37Austin: and so it looks like they slowed back and
- 59:39Austin: that would be a really unfortunately.
- 59:42Austin: Is it possible to hold it right at 200 feet?
- 59:43Austin: It is.
- 59:45Austin: It's difficult to do if you're flying right
- 59:47Austin: at the max altitude that you can be at to
- 59:49Austin: begin with.
- 59:49Austin: It is difficult to do to do if you're
- 59:51Austin: flying right at the max altitude that you
- 59:53Austin: can be at to begin with.
- 59:54Austin: It is difficult to do but it can be done.
- 59:55Austin: But again, this is one of those where I say
- 59:56Austin: this isn't some level of incompetency, this
- 59:59Austin: is a level of, honestly, a pretty normal
- 1:00:01Austin: execution of that particular kind of
- 1:00:03Austin: maneuver if you will.
- 1:00:05Austin: In the abstract, the Army allows a plus or
- 1:00:07Austin: minus 100 feet in that maneuver.
- 1:00:09Austin: Sure, because that's what your altitude
- 1:00:11Austin: allowance are.
- 1:00:11Austin: Now this case, 200 feet, is a maximum
- 1:00:13Austin: altitude for those routes.
- 1:00:15Austin: Um, so you kind of don't have anywhere to
- 1:00:17Austin: give if you make a mistake yes, you've gone
- 1:00:19Austin: outside of the, the maximum allowance if
- 1:00:21Austin: you're flying at 200 feet yeah.
- 1:00:23Austin: So that's where I see that altitude.
- 1:00:25Austin: If it gets off by you know, 50 or 100 or
- 1:00:27Austin: 150 feet, I would would go.
- 1:00:29Austin: Okay, not the best execution of that, but
- 1:00:31Austin: it's also where I go.
- 1:00:32Austin: If I put myself in that seat I'm like, well,
- 1:00:33Austin: I can't say that like I've always gotten it
- 1:00:35Austin: exactly right.
- 1:00:35Austin: And if I start that maneuver at my max
- 1:00:37Austin: altitude, the chances of me getting off
- 1:00:39Austin: there, it's a fairly high probability that
- 1:00:43Austin: that'll happen.
- 1:00:44Austin: So again, not bad piloting, but it is a
- 1:00:47Austin: little bit of a mistake, right?
- 1:00:48Lara: Okay, let me ask you the dumb person's
- 1:00:51Lara: question.
- 1:00:52Lara: Okay, just from watching that video, what I
- 1:00:58Lara: think a lot of people saw is you're always
- 1:00:59Lara: looking at that as a civilian and wondering
- 1:01:04Lara: why can't they just see what's in front of
- 1:01:06Lara: them?
- 1:01:06Austin: Yeah, so that goes back to some of the
- 1:01:09Austin: limitations we talked about with night
- 1:01:10Austin: vision Sure, where you're looking through a
- 1:01:12Austin: 40-degree field of view, where you think
- 1:01:13Austin: you've got the thing you're supposed to be
- 1:01:14Austin: looking at, where air traffic control is
- 1:01:16Austin: drawing your attention to that thing, even
- 1:01:18Austin: by mistake, but they were kind of used to
- 1:01:19Austin: that.
- 1:01:20Austin: Yeah, they were kind of used to that.
- 1:01:21Austin: But once it's drawn your attention in,
- 1:01:23Austin: because you lose that peripheral vision and
- 1:01:25Austin: because you don't have peripheral vision as
- 1:01:27Austin: much.
- 1:01:31Lara: If that's the case, right, that's the case.
- 1:01:32Lara: It's not for certain, but yeah, but it's
- 1:01:34Lara: just the thing that's confusing here, and
- 1:01:35Lara: maybe it's a question of timing, yeah, but
- 1:01:37Lara: you've, what you see is the black hawk
- 1:01:39Lara: heading straight for a plane, and you're
- 1:01:42Lara: wondering why the hell I mean isn't the top
- 1:01:45Lara: of a back yeah why could they not just see
- 1:01:48Lara: what was in front of them?
- 1:01:49Austin: yeah, well, so from the black hawk
- 1:01:50Austin: perspective, you know some of the things
- 1:01:51Austin: I've described, but also descending into
- 1:01:53Austin: the lights.
- 1:01:53Austin: Another thing is, again you having looked
- 1:01:56Austin: through night vision before, when lights
- 1:01:58Austin: are facing you, they're super bright.
- 1:02:00Austin: But if that car turns a little bit now, you
- 1:02:01Austin: can tell what kind of car it is.
- 1:02:02Austin: The lights are way less bright, and so in
- 1:02:04Austin: this scenario, the jet is actually turned
- 1:02:07Austin: slightly away from the Blackhawk, and so
- 1:02:09Austin: it's not, and so its lights would be, by
- 1:02:10Austin: comparison, dimmer than the ones that are
- 1:02:13Austin: coming straight at it yes.
- 1:02:14Austin: The other issue from the jet's perspective
- 1:02:16Austin: about why didn't the jet see number one.
- 1:02:18Austin: The NTSB is saying that they think that the
- 1:02:20Austin: jet did see about one second before impact.
- 1:02:22Lara: Because they heard some indication.
- 1:02:25Austin: Yeah, they said there was an auditory
- 1:02:27Austin: indication in the cockpit.
- 1:02:28Austin: I don't know exactly what was said it
- 1:02:29Austin: sounds like something was said, but also
- 1:02:30Austin: they went to full deflection.
- 1:02:31Austin: It's probably another OPE, yeah something,
- 1:02:34Austin: but they went to full deflection.
- 1:02:35Austin: I've never one time gone to full deflection,
- 1:02:37Austin: so that means you were startled and really
- 1:02:40Austin: trying to what is full deflection?
- 1:02:42Lara: That means when you're pulling as hard as
- 1:02:43Lara: you can, meaning you want to pull back as
- 1:02:45Lara: the airplane?
- 1:02:46Lara: Will go.
- 1:02:46Lara: It's awful.
- 1:02:47Austin: But because of that, airspeed jet engines
- 1:02:49Austin: have a spool of time, a bunch of other
- 1:02:50Austin: factors, one second before impact.
- 1:02:53Austin: It's not going to do very much for you.
- 1:02:56Austin: They did everything they could do.
- 1:02:58Austin: It's just because of those factors.
- 1:02:59Austin: There's not much.
- 1:03:00Austin: But I would say in terms of the airplane
- 1:03:02Austin: not being able to see the helicopter
- 1:03:03Austin: because of the way they were coming in on
- 1:03:05Austin: that approach it would be virtually
- 1:03:07Austin: impossible with this big left turn in they
- 1:03:09Austin: have to look at a helicopter that's
- 1:03:10Austin: essentially below them, kind of out, where
- 1:03:15Austin: there's parts of airplane.
- 1:03:16Austin: There's not windows there, and so they're
- 1:03:19Austin: making this big turn in.
- 1:03:19Austin: They're under the impression that anybody
- 1:03:20Austin: there air traffic control has told them to
- 1:03:22Austin: avoid them and all of that.
- 1:03:23Austin: They've kind of only heard one half of that
- 1:03:25Austin: conversation because they're on different
- 1:03:26Austin: frequencies.
- 1:03:27Lara: Well, that's the other thing, yeah, is that
- 1:03:35Lara: now ntsb has to go and take those different
- 1:03:36Lara: conversations right and piece them back
- 1:03:37Lara: second by second to look at them, to
- 1:03:38Lara: understand what each person was hearing?
- 1:03:39Lara: The only person who was hearing both
- 1:03:40Lara: conversations was air traffic control.
- 1:03:41Lara: That's right.
- 1:03:42Lara: Yeah, um, and so you know what's amazing to
- 1:03:45Lara: me?
- 1:03:46Lara: I know these guys deal with this kind of
- 1:03:48Lara: stuff all the time and obviously you, you
- 1:03:50Lara: know you can't panic on the job, but the
- 1:03:52Lara: guy's pretty like even keeled the entire
- 1:03:56Lara: time.
- 1:03:56Austin: Yeah Well, this is.
- 1:03:57Austin: It just gives some indication of just the
- 1:03:59Austin: familiarity with the area.
- 1:04:01Austin: What's really frankly impressive to me is
- 1:04:04Austin: what happens afterwards and we got to hear
- 1:04:05Austin: a little bit of that, but just the, they
- 1:04:07Austin: immediately go into telling other aircraft
- 1:04:09Austin: to do go-arounds, telling other aircraft to
- 1:04:15Austin: go to different places, right, um, and
- 1:04:16Austin: they're not.
- 1:04:16Austin: They're not panicky, they're not screaming
- 1:04:17Austin: they're not flustered, you know they're.
- 1:04:18Austin: Clearly there's a more, there's a level of
- 1:04:19Austin: intensity with their voice, sure, um, where
- 1:04:21Austin: it picks up a little bit, um, but from the
- 1:04:24Austin: moment of impact all the way through
- 1:04:25Austin: everything that happened after that, it
- 1:04:26Austin: seems to me like air traffic control did
- 1:04:28Austin: excellent job, um, of maintaining control.
- 1:04:30Lara: You don't have the luxury right of coming
- 1:04:32Lara: apart in that moment because there's so
- 1:04:35Lara: many other planes and you have a lot of
- 1:04:38Lara: responsibility riding on you.
- 1:04:40Lara: And now you have a catastrophic incident,
- 1:04:42Lara: and that's only going to make things more
- 1:04:44Lara: stressful.
- 1:04:46Austin: In aviation I always say you have to have a
- 1:04:47Austin: memory of a goldfish, right?
- 1:04:49Austin: Because if I made a mistake here, I can't
- 1:04:51Austin: let it compound, right.
- 1:04:53Austin: So I just have to kind of forget about it
- 1:04:55Austin: and maybe we'll debrief it, we'll talk
- 1:04:57Austin: about it later on, but I have to let it go
- 1:04:58Austin: and move on and just try to continue to do
- 1:05:01Austin: better and better and better.
- 1:05:02Austin: That's also true of our traffic controllers,
- 1:05:04Austin: where whatever happened before there might
- 1:05:06Austin: not be anything they can do about that, but
- 1:05:07Austin: but how they um, you know how they're able
- 1:05:09Austin: to execute.
- 1:05:10Austin: What they need to do now is going to impact
- 1:05:12Austin: people in the future so, okay, if I were to
- 1:05:16Austin: boil it down.
- 1:05:17Lara: Listening to you, right, I know from
- 1:05:20Lara: speaking to you before that you would never
- 1:05:23Lara: get ahead of the investigation, and that
- 1:05:26Lara: there's so many complicating factors that
- 1:05:28Lara: you know the devil is always in the details,
- 1:05:31Lara: right and so, and you know, even altitude
- 1:05:33Lara: itself is not simple, because it could be
- 1:05:35Lara: altitude.
- 1:05:35Lara: There's so many complicating factors, the
- 1:05:36Lara: devil is always in the details, right, and
- 1:05:37Lara: even altitude itself is not simple, because
- 1:05:38Lara: it could be altitude above sea level,
- 1:05:39Lara: altitude above ground level, the different
- 1:05:41Lara: levels of altitude that were cited the
- 1:05:43Lara: instructor, pilot saying one, the pilot
- 1:05:45Lara: saying something else can be explained away
- 1:05:47Lara: if the helicopter was descending at that
- 1:05:49Lara: time, yeah, and so, once you get into it,
- 1:05:52Lara: there's a lot of detail that changes your
- 1:05:55Lara: perspective.
- 1:05:56Lara: But at the end of the day, right now, when
- 1:05:57Lara: you sit back, based on what you know about
- 1:06:00Lara: the unit, about the area, about the flights,
- 1:06:02Lara: about the aircraft and about what happened,
- 1:06:05Lara: is you're leaning towards just the fact
- 1:06:07Lara: that they were.
- 1:06:09Lara: It was that part of the radio traffic that
- 1:06:12Lara: was not transmitted or heard.
- 1:06:14Austin: I would say it's kind of a holistic system
- 1:06:15Austin: failure, where there shouldn't be an
- 1:06:17Austin: opportunity, where, if you miss this one
- 1:06:19Austin: little bit of critical information.
- 1:06:21Austin: Or when I actually heard it the first time,
- 1:06:22Austin: I didn't know that they'd missed it, but I
- 1:06:23Austin: thought, man, it'd be really easy to
- 1:06:25Austin: misunderstand that.
- 1:06:26Austin: Not meaning I didn't hear it, meaning I
- 1:06:35Austin: just didn't understand exactly what they
- 1:06:36Austin: said.
- 1:06:36Austin: I heard what they said but I didn't
- 1:06:37Austin: interpret it right.
- 1:06:37Austin: Yes, it'd be really easy to do that based
- 1:06:38Austin: on hey, I always see them land runaway one,
- 1:06:39Austin: so I'm always kind of expecting that, and
- 1:06:40Austin: then they say wrong way, three, three.
- 1:06:41Austin: But I don't exactly process it, that's what
- 1:06:43Austin: I initially thought it happened, which
- 1:06:44Austin: again is a whole reason for why you have to
- 1:06:46Austin: withhold judgment.
- 1:06:47Austin: But then as soon as I saw the more recent
- 1:06:49Austin: NTSB update that said that part was cut off
- 1:06:51Austin: for the Blackhawk, I was like oh, now, that
- 1:06:53Austin: makes sense, there's nothing, there's no
- 1:06:56Austin: way to kind of regain your situational
- 1:06:57Austin: awareness from there, but to complicate
- 1:06:59Austin: matters because of the fact that we
- 1:07:00Austin: normally be held north at Haynes Point,
- 1:07:02Austin: which procedurally would seem to be a
- 1:07:04Austin: better way to do things.
- 1:07:07Austin: Now, there might be a hundred different
- 1:07:08Austin: reasons why that controller didn't, in this
- 1:07:10Austin: moment do it.
- 1:07:11Austin: So I would hesitate to say like, oh, this
- 1:07:12Austin: controller did a bad job, or the controller
- 1:07:14Austin: broke the rules, cause I'm not, I'm not
- 1:07:16Austin: aware of any rules that were that were
- 1:07:18Austin: broken.
- 1:07:18Austin: Um, you know, that'll come out in the
- 1:07:20Austin: investigation.
- 1:07:20Austin: If there was a policy that said they were
- 1:07:22Austin: supposed to hold there, um, but it appears
- 1:07:25Austin: that again, the controller, where it's like
- 1:07:26Austin: you know, would have been good to have more
- 1:07:27Austin: information.
- 1:07:28Austin: Yeah, but it looks to me like they did give
- 1:07:29Austin: what they're required to give.
- 1:07:31Austin: But again it's this whole kind of procedure
- 1:07:33Austin: to get down there, the route itself.
- 1:07:36Austin: To further complicate things, the chart
- 1:07:39Austin: says you're supposed to fly at the highest
- 1:07:40Austin: altitude, so would it have been good if
- 1:07:43Austin: they were at a slightly lower altitude?
- 1:07:46Austin: Yeah, it would have.
- 1:07:47Austin: Would have been good if they were never
- 1:07:48Austin: allowed to cross on that route when
- 1:07:51Austin: aircraft are landing 3-3 on runway 3-3.
- 1:07:54Austin: Yeah, that would have been good.
- 1:07:55Austin: So to me it's kind of a bigger system
- 1:07:58Austin: failure that was relying on all these
- 1:08:01Austin: little individual instances that you have
- 1:08:02Austin: to get right when, if you just take one of
- 1:08:06Austin: them out and the accident doesn't happen,
- 1:08:08Austin: you know if they're allowed to fly at a
- 1:08:09Austin: lower altitude and there's some nuance to
- 1:08:10Austin: that conversation.
- 1:08:11Austin: But you know, when I was in the unit it was
- 1:08:15Austin: certainly put out, and I would agree with
- 1:08:17Austin: the position, that you should fly at the
- 1:08:19Austin: highest altitudes unless weather or ATC
- 1:08:23Austin: tells you to fly lower.
- 1:08:24Lara: And so again they were doing what they
- 1:08:25Lara: thought they were supposed to be doing and
- 1:08:29Lara: what you're talking about here, just for
- 1:08:30Lara: people who don't know, the context is that,
- 1:08:34Lara: given the nature of the area, the
- 1:08:37Lara: sensitivity of the buildings that are
- 1:08:40Lara: around there, the national security issues,
- 1:08:42Lara: the busyness of the airport, right, the
- 1:08:44Lara: amount of traffic that's there that there
- 1:08:46Lara: are at certain, on certain routes, at
- 1:08:50Lara: certain levels, you're restricted.
- 1:08:54Lara: Right, it's restricted airspace, so you are
- 1:08:56Lara: restricted to certain, to obeying certain
- 1:08:58Lara: rules, right, and part of that is, at a
- 1:09:02Lara: certain point you can't go above 200 feet,
- 1:09:05Lara: you can't go below it, Below it, yeah, what
- 1:09:08Lara: it says on the helicopter route chart.
- 1:09:09Austin: It actually says helicopters are expected
- 1:09:12Austin: to fly at the highest of the altitudes
- 1:09:15Austin: unless?
- 1:09:16Austin: And the two things that it allows you to
- 1:09:17Austin: deviate from would be weather and ceilings.
- 1:09:20Austin: So in other words if the weather's too bad,
- 1:09:22Austin: which?
- 1:09:22Austin: at 200 feet wouldn't really ever happen, or
- 1:09:26Austin: is directed by air traffic control, and so
- 1:09:30Austin: you should be flying at the maximum
- 1:09:31Austin: altitude on the route.
- 1:09:35Austin: Again, now, because of all the way that
- 1:09:37Austin: everything else played out, it doesn't
- 1:09:38Austin: really give you anywhere to go.
- 1:09:39Austin: So if you don't execute that precisely and
- 1:09:42Austin: get it right, then you're automatically
- 1:09:45Austin: going to be off.
- 1:09:46Austin: That's right.
- 1:09:46Austin: So it's kind of like it's maybe not the you
- 1:09:49Austin: know.
- 1:09:50Austin: Should that have been written a different
- 1:09:51Austin: way?
- 1:09:51Austin: Is that really what the FAA wanted us to do?
- 1:09:52Austin: Because that's what they wrote?
- 1:09:55Austin: You know, I'm not really sure, but to me
- 1:09:56Austin: it's a, it's kind of a whole picture where
- 1:09:58Austin: all of these little things happen, that if
- 1:10:00Austin: they don't happen that way, you know, if
- 1:10:06Austin: they hear that they're landing runway three,
- 1:10:08Austin: three little bit, and then they release,
- 1:10:10Austin: and then it never happens.
- 1:10:11Austin: Um, if they're allowed, if, if the chart
- 1:10:13Austin: says that they can fly at a lower altitude,
- 1:10:14Austin: would, would they have flown?
- 1:10:15Austin: Or picked a different altitude instead of
- 1:10:17Austin: 200 feet?
- 1:10:17Austin: Would they've been 100 or 150 and not
- 1:10:20Austin: climbed up high enough to hit the airplane?
- 1:10:21Austin: Yeah, that's certainly possible.
- 1:10:23Austin: Um, you know, if at the last minute they
- 1:10:25Austin: got a little more fidelity, uh, from air
- 1:10:28Austin: traffic control in terms of which airplane
- 1:10:29Austin: they're supposed to be looking at, hey,
- 1:10:31Austin: your traffic's, you know, 10 o'clock,
- 1:10:34Austin: confirm traffic inside, or something like
- 1:10:35Austin: that.
- 1:10:35Austin: Again, I don't think the controller
- 1:10:36Austin: necessarily did anything wrong there, but
- 1:10:39Austin: you know, would have been helpful, yeah, so
- 1:10:42Austin: there's like all of these little things
- 1:10:43Austin: that piece together that just it didn't
- 1:10:47Austin: work in that moment.
- 1:10:48Lara: So sort of like a perfect storm.
- 1:10:50Austin: It was a perfect storm.
- 1:10:51Austin: Yeah, Because you could have that happen a
- 1:10:53Austin: million times and it could be just fine.
- 1:10:55Austin: And yeah, just one time it happens.
- 1:10:57Lara: Okay, so I got to tell you something when I
- 1:10:59Lara: did a little bit of homework.
- 1:11:02Lara: You could call it and talk to a few people,
- 1:11:06Lara: so I'd be curious to know your thoughts on
- 1:11:09Lara: this.
- 1:11:10Lara: So I'd be curious to know your thoughts on
- 1:11:12Lara: this.
- 1:11:12Lara: Some of the folks that I know who work in
- 1:11:14Lara: intelligence were tracking they regularly
- 1:11:25Lara: systematically track conversations among
- 1:11:26Lara: certain bad actors and those networks, and,
- 1:11:28Lara: especially when there is a catastrophic
- 1:11:30Lara: event of any kind, you know they're
- 1:11:32Lara: immediately, uh, hyper focused on whether
- 1:11:35Lara: they hear any chatter, because it's an,
- 1:11:37Lara: it's a?
- 1:11:39Lara: It's one of the first questions that comes
- 1:11:41Lara: to mind.
- 1:11:41Lara: Right, you have something so unusual happen,
- 1:11:44Lara: especially involving a military aircraft in
- 1:11:46Lara: such a sensitive?
- 1:11:47Lara: area and that's their job, Okay.
- 1:11:50Lara: So what did they find?
- 1:11:52Lara: Well, a lot of celebrating.
- 1:11:56Lara: Obviously, that's not surprising, yeah.
- 1:11:59Lara: But then and I want to find the exact words
- 1:12:02Lara: here Then the conversation quickly turned
- 1:12:07Lara: Let me find where I wrote it down To what
- 1:12:11Lara: they said was coming next, which was SeaTac.
- 1:12:18Lara: And I said what is SeaTac?
- 1:12:20Lara: Do you know what SeaTac?
- 1:12:20Austin: is.
- 1:12:20Austin: I do know what SeaTac is, I'm sure you do,
- 1:12:22Austin: I'm sure you know.
- 1:12:23Lara: Now, I do know now, but you could probably
- 1:12:25Lara: explain it better than me.
- 1:12:27Austin: Yeah, seattle Tacoma International Airport
- 1:12:29Austin: yeah.
- 1:12:29Lara: Okay.
- 1:12:30Lara: So, right after that happened, the traffic
- 1:12:33Lara: that was picked up and when I say bad
- 1:12:36Lara: actors, I was specifically.
- 1:12:38Lara: What do you mean by bad actors?
- 1:12:40Lara: And what they talked about was well, states,
- 1:12:44Lara: foreign adversaries, states, but also just
- 1:12:49Lara: to make sure that, right, you know the way
- 1:12:51Lara: they describe it is advanced, persistent
- 1:12:55Lara: threats.
- 1:12:57Lara: So these are, you know, the kind of groups,
- 1:12:59Lara: hacker groups that you know from their
- 1:13:04Lara: actions tell you that they're working with
- 1:13:08Lara: state adversaries, but you can't quite
- 1:13:11Lara: prove it, because all of this is happening
- 1:13:13Lara: in the cyber realm, where it's very easy to
- 1:13:15Lara: mask where these are coming from.
- 1:13:17Lara: And, in fact, one of the reasons it's
- 1:13:19Lara: particularly difficult for us to figure
- 1:13:21Lara: this stuff out is because President Obama,
- 1:13:24Lara: as one of his last actions, gave away
- 1:13:27Lara: control of the internet to a group, an
- 1:13:29Lara: international consortium, which included
- 1:13:32Lara: many of these state adversaries.
- 1:13:34Lara: Right, I mean, that's a fact.
- 1:13:35Lara: People can go and look it up.
- 1:13:37Lara: I knew at the time when it happened, I
- 1:13:39Lara: reported on it.
- 1:13:40Lara: You know, repeatedly people kind of gloss
- 1:13:42Lara: over it as if it doesn't matter, which is
- 1:13:44Lara: just amazing to me in some ways, because it
- 1:13:47Lara: matters so much.
- 1:13:48Lara: But one of the things when you give up
- 1:13:49Lara: jurisdiction and you give up control over
- 1:13:51Lara: the internet, you make it easier for bad
- 1:13:54Lara: actors to mask their tracks in the cyber
- 1:13:58Lara: world and so you know, and the signatures
- 1:14:02Lara: that they leave behind, right is, those are
- 1:14:04Lara: the things that we track.
- 1:14:07Lara: So they made it much harder to track that
- 1:14:08Lara: when they gave up jurisdiction.
- 1:14:10Lara: But there are other ways still to look at
- 1:14:13Lara: these things.
- 1:14:14Lara: And so what they documented in real time
- 1:14:18Lara: was chatter on these, as they call them,
- 1:14:21Lara: bad guy networks, where there was a lot of
- 1:14:24Lara: celebrating, and then they said SeaTac will
- 1:14:26Lara: be next, and then what happened a week
- 1:14:29Lara: later?
- 1:14:30Lara: Do you know?
- 1:14:31Austin: No.
- 1:14:32Lara: At that airport there was a collision on
- 1:14:36Lara: the runway.
- 1:14:37Lara: Oh, with the yeah Well not really a
- 1:14:41Lara: collision, but with a two, the tail of one
- 1:14:46Lara: aircraft.
- 1:14:46Lara: You know, as they were, one aircraft was
- 1:14:48Lara: moving taxiing.
- 1:14:49Austin: Yeah, I mean, what I can say is that, um
- 1:14:53Austin: and probably your intelligence sources
- 1:14:54Austin: would say this too a lot of times when,
- 1:14:56Austin: when something like this happens, there's a
- 1:14:58Austin: uh again, I'm not an intel guy, this is,
- 1:15:00Austin: this is more of a lay person speaking here
- 1:15:03Austin: um, there is a high uh degree of chatter.
- 1:15:07Austin: That happens, sure, and there's a lot of
- 1:15:09Austin: people trying to take credit for things.
- 1:15:10Austin: Sometimes when you find out later there was
- 1:15:12Austin: no credit, yeah, for anybody to you know.
- 1:15:14Lara: Oh yeah.
- 1:15:15Austin: Everybody wants to take credit for
- 1:15:16Austin: something like that.
- 1:15:16Lara: Oh, you mean kind of like when the Taliban
- 1:15:18Lara: used to say they killed 270 Americans.
- 1:15:21Austin: Yeah.
- 1:15:21Lara: And there wasn't one dead on the raid.
- 1:15:23Austin: Yeah, or you know A lot of instances where
- 1:15:27Austin: that happens.
- 1:15:28Austin: So I wonder if there were other airports
- 1:15:30Austin: mentioned as well.
- 1:15:31Austin: But we're not focused on that because we
- 1:15:32Austin: found out that SeaTac something happened
- 1:15:34Austin: there.
- 1:15:34Austin: But what I can say for sure in both of
- 1:15:36Austin: those instances that there was no ability
- 1:15:38Austin: for any hacker network or anything.
- 1:15:41Austin: Just on the Blackhawk side because again
- 1:15:43Austin: that's where my expertise lies I saw a lot
- 1:15:45Austin: of comments about could they have taken
- 1:15:47Austin: over the helicopter, for instance, and the
- 1:15:49Austin: answer is no.
- 1:15:50Austin: The helicopter's technology is like
- 1:15:51Austin: straight out of the 60s and 70s.
- 1:15:52Austin: It failed in 1978.
- 1:15:55Austin: It hasn't significantly changed in any way.
- 1:15:56Austin: There is no way because that's pre-internet.
- 1:15:59Lara: Essentially there's no way for anybody to
- 1:16:02Lara: take over that helicopter, which would be a
- 1:16:03Lara: kind of spoofing right.
- 1:16:06Lara: Yeah exactly, you would be sending data to
- 1:16:08Lara: that aircraft.
- 1:16:09Lara: That does not match reality.
- 1:16:11Austin: That helicopter is analog.
- 1:16:13Austin: There is no way to spoof any— Even the GPS.
- 1:16:15Lara: The altitudes.
- 1:16:16Austin: Well, the GPS, that's another conversation.
- 1:16:18Austin: It is possible, but they were on route.
- 1:16:19Lara: But you're talking about the altimeter, but
- 1:16:20Lara: they were on—yeah.
- 1:16:21Lara: The altimeter, specifically, which measures
- 1:16:22Lara: the altitude right Exactly, since that's
- 1:16:23Lara: the main— which is a different thing to the
- 1:16:25Lara: GPS.
- 1:16:26Austin: That Also the NTSB has said they were en
- 1:16:27Austin: route, yes, and so they were the only thing
- 1:16:31Austin: that you could potentially do, but were
- 1:16:33Austin: they at the altitude that they were
- 1:16:34Austin: supposed to be at?
- 1:16:34Lara: Maybe they were, maybe they weren't.
- 1:16:35Lara: That's right.
- 1:16:36Austin: So is GPS spoofing possible?
- 1:16:38Austin: Yeah, I've been GPS spoofed before in other
- 1:16:40Austin: countries, but is that a thing that can
- 1:16:44Austin: happen In theory?
- 1:16:45Austin: Did that happen here?
- 1:16:46Austin: It wouldn't appear so because they were
- 1:16:47Austin: where in.
- 1:16:48Austin: It wouldn't appear so because they were
- 1:16:49Austin: where.
- 1:16:49Austin: In terms of X Y axis, they were where they
- 1:16:50Austin: were supposed to be.
- 1:16:51Austin: It's the Z axis that's in question.
- 1:16:52Lara: Right.
- 1:16:53Lara: So if they had been moving on a different
- 1:16:55Lara: route, you would have then looked at the
- 1:16:58Lara: GPS data, yeah, but even then the pilots
- 1:17:02Lara: are flying generally visually there.
- 1:17:03Austin: Andrew's been there for this is going on
- 1:17:05Austin: his fourth year.
- 1:17:07Austin: You know you fly over the river there, so
- 1:17:08Austin: it's not something that like.
- 1:17:09Austin: When I look at that number one, there's no
- 1:17:10Austin: possibility to take over that aircraft.
- 1:17:11Austin: Number two spoofing it wouldn't have any
- 1:17:13Austin: impact, and so I think whatever credit if
- 1:17:16Austin: anybody tries to take credit for that you
- 1:17:17Austin: can just chop that off.
- 1:17:18Austin: That is not what happened here.
- 1:17:20Austin: 100% that is not what happened here.
- 1:17:23Austin: Even if there were attempts, it just
- 1:17:25Austin: wouldn't be possible.
- 1:17:26Lara: And when you say never.
- 1:17:27Lara: So you know, because I'm a journalist, I'm
- 1:17:29Lara: always trying to look at words like that.
- 1:17:31Lara: Right Because Well, hopefully you'll notice
- 1:17:33Lara: I haven't said never or at all.
- 1:17:35Lara: Well, you said, that could never happen.
- 1:17:36Austin: That could never happen in that particular,
- 1:17:39Austin: in the way that this, that particular
- 1:17:41Austin: series of events and a crash at that
- 1:17:43Austin: location could never be attributed to
- 1:17:45Austin: somebody taking over the aircraft, over the
- 1:17:49Austin: aircraft, that particular aircraft, because
- 1:17:51Austin: again, we're talking about specifically the
- 1:17:52Austin: Lima model.
- 1:17:52Lara: So a UH-60L a.
- 1:17:52Austin: Lima model Blackhawk, because the Lima
- 1:17:54Austin: model Blackhawk lacks kind of the upload
- 1:17:56Austin: capability and also the ability to get any
- 1:17:58Austin: of that information into the flight
- 1:17:59Austin: controls or into the instruments.
- 1:18:01Austin: It's just the way they're designed.
- 1:18:02Austin: Right now it's not possible because,
- 1:18:05Austin: frankly, because it's really old technology.
- 1:18:08Lara: Yeah, which is, in this case, may have been
- 1:18:10Lara: a good thing.
- 1:18:11Austin: Yeah, it may have been a good thing,
- 1:18:11Austin: certainly if that's a concern where you
- 1:18:13Austin: know you don't want people to have the
- 1:18:14Austin: ability to do that.
- 1:18:15Austin: Now, on a broader sense, that's not
- 1:18:18Austin: possible in virtually any airplane ever or
- 1:18:21Austin: any helicopter ever where you can just
- 1:18:23Austin: digitally take it over.
- 1:18:24Austin: I'm not going to say that that's never
- 1:18:25Austin: going to be possible.
- 1:18:27Austin: Um, you know, people have seen, hey, there
- 1:18:29Austin: is in fact DARPA has a Blackhawk that can
- 1:18:32Austin: fly itself, which is kind of like an
- 1:18:33Austin: advanced technology segment of the DoD
- 1:18:36Austin: where they do have a Blackhawk that can fly
- 1:18:38Austin: itself.
- 1:18:39Austin: But that's one specific Blackhawk that's
- 1:18:40Austin: been kitted and retrofitted with all kinds
- 1:18:43Austin: of other technology.
- 1:18:44Austin: So it's easy to kind of take that
- 1:18:45Austin: information and then apply it in this
- 1:18:47Austin: scenario, uh, incorrectly, if you will so
- 1:18:53Austin: when you say that it's not possible, it is
- 1:18:55Austin: possible with ships.
- 1:18:58Lara: So why is it not possible with aircraft?
- 1:19:00Austin: it is possible with ships.
- 1:19:01Austin: I don't.
- 1:19:01Austin: I don't know as much about ships, but I do
- 1:19:03Austin: know that is possible.
- 1:19:03Austin: But I think they're kind of remotely
- 1:19:05Austin: controlled sometimes, uh-huh, um, because
- 1:19:07Austin: their crews, you know, they go with the
- 1:19:09Austin: skeleton, you put it on course you put it
- 1:19:10Austin: on course and then the crew can go to sleep,
- 1:19:12Austin: is my understanding.
- 1:19:13Austin: And so you are able to kind of control it
- 1:19:14Austin: from a centralized control facility?
- 1:19:17Austin: Yes, that is not the case in aviation today.
- 1:19:21Lara: So when you're flying a Black Hawk and you
- 1:19:23Lara: have all those instruments, are any of
- 1:19:28Lara: those instruments besides the GPS hackable?
- 1:19:32Austin: No.
- 1:19:33Lara: Well, that's a good thing.
- 1:19:34Austin: Yeah, not in terms of, like you know,
- 1:19:36Austin: hacking them as in real time or anything
- 1:19:39Austin: like that.
- 1:19:40Austin: Like are there, you know systems that you
- 1:19:42Austin: can.
- 1:19:43Austin: You know malware is always an issue and
- 1:19:45Austin: obviously sometimes the systems get updated
- 1:19:46Austin: in different ways.
- 1:19:47Austin: That is possible.
- 1:19:48Lara: But that would be kind of a different
- 1:19:50Lara: scenario.
- 1:19:50Lara: What do you mean by that?
- 1:19:51Austin: Well, certainly like China, for instance,
- 1:19:55Austin: has had places where they've been able to
- 1:19:56Austin: put malware into certain components.
- 1:20:01Lara: Well, I'm glad you raised that because,
- 1:20:03Lara: that is what people in the Intel world are
- 1:20:06Lara: particularly concerned about is that so
- 1:20:08Lara: many of these parts are manufactured in
- 1:20:12Lara: China and the Chinese are inside our
- 1:20:16Lara: electronic systems yeah, I mean, I do think
- 1:20:18Lara: that it's a, it's a concern, it's something
- 1:20:19Lara: we should should certainly kind of take
- 1:20:21Lara: note of and be trying to prevent that.
- 1:20:22Austin: We are trying to prevent you know I'm sure
- 1:20:24Austin: there are people in the Pentagon right now
- 1:20:26Austin: trying to prevent that kind of stuff, but
- 1:20:29Austin: again, is that even having that capability
- 1:20:31Austin: where we have seen them do it they still
- 1:20:34Austin: wouldn't have the ability to take over the
- 1:20:35Austin: aircraft.
- 1:20:35Austin: That aircraft doesn't even have autopilot.
- 1:20:38Austin: So there's no aside from a human we call
- 1:20:41Austin: them meat servos, right.
- 1:20:43Austin: So you know there's a human that has to
- 1:20:45Austin: move those controls, and so that's just an
- 1:20:48Austin: additional kind of in this case, a safety
- 1:20:51Austin: feature, if you will.
- 1:20:51Austin: That would prevent that from being possible,
- 1:20:55Austin: because you need a human, at the end of the
- 1:20:56Austin: day, to move the controls.
- 1:20:58Austin: So if you're going to try to crash in an
- 1:20:59Austin: airplane, you still have to get a human to
- 1:21:00Austin: do that, and so that's why I can say like,
- 1:21:02Austin: in this particular instance, that's
- 1:21:04Austin: definitely not the case.
- 1:21:05Austin: There's all these other factors that would
- 1:21:06Austin: lead me to believe this is how it could
- 1:21:08Austin: have happened, but I can say for sure that
- 1:21:10Austin: it was not any kind of control being taken
- 1:21:13Austin: over by somebody else or anything like that.
- 1:21:15Austin: That's one of the things that I heard
- 1:21:16Austin: online that kind of made me start speaking
- 1:21:17Austin: out as well.
- 1:21:18Lara: What about all the people that said, oh,
- 1:21:20Lara: this came from the CIA and this follows the
- 1:21:22Lara: flight path of helicopters going into the
- 1:21:25Lara: agency up to Langley?
- 1:21:27Austin: Yeah, so I mean, obviously you can look on
- 1:21:29Austin: a map and figure out where all that is.
- 1:21:34Austin: This was a training flight, again, I know
- 1:21:36Austin: that, all the people on the aircraft.
- 1:21:41Austin: Now I would say, if you look at the mission
- 1:21:43Austin: of that unit maybe you could ascertain why
- 1:21:44Austin: training in certain places.
- 1:21:45Austin: Again, I don't know that they landed in
- 1:21:46Austin: Langley or didn't, but you could make some
- 1:21:47Austin: assumptions about why they may or may go
- 1:21:49Austin: into certain places, even on training
- 1:21:50Austin: flights.
- 1:21:52Lara: Is it normal to be that route is normal for
- 1:21:55Lara: training flights, right that?
- 1:21:57Austin: route is very like.
- 1:21:57Austin: I said, it's a normal Tuesday.
- 1:21:59Austin: I can't remember what day of the week, but
- 1:22:00Austin: it was normal.
- 1:22:01Austin: Whatever day of the week it is, that is a
- 1:22:02Austin: normal day of the week for them.
- 1:22:04Austin: That is the most kind of vanilla mission
- 1:22:05Austin: that they do is go out and fly on the
- 1:22:06Austin: helicopter routes.
- 1:22:08Lara: And where did it take off from?
- 1:22:10Austin: I think it took off from Davidson Army
- 1:22:12Austin: Airfield.
- 1:22:12Austin: So they took off from 12th Aviation
- 1:22:14Austin: Battalion, fort Belvoir, and then inside of
- 1:22:17Austin: Fort Belvoir you've got Davidson Army
- 1:22:18Austin: Airfield.
- 1:22:20Austin: So again, that's where the 12th Aviation
- 1:22:21Austin: Battalion is.
- 1:22:22Austin: That's where the flight originated from.
- 1:22:25Austin: They may have done some stuff kind of
- 1:22:26Austin: otherwise en route that I'm not aware of
- 1:22:29Austin: any of that stuff.
- 1:22:30Austin: But again, had they that would potentially
- 1:22:32Austin: be normal for them, but flying the
- 1:22:34Austin: helicopter routes themselves, taking off
- 1:22:35Austin: from Davidson, flying around the helicopter
- 1:22:37Austin: routes, super normal flight.
- 1:22:39Lara: Now one of the things because people raised
- 1:22:41Lara: the CIA right One of the things that's
- 1:22:44Lara: obviously very common in that world is you
- 1:22:46Lara: can be a training flight but also be put
- 1:22:48Lara: down as a support mission.
- 1:22:51Austin: Yeah, that is possible I guess, but I can
- 1:22:53Austin: say that I never saw that there.
- 1:22:55Austin: When I say that's possible, I guess I'm
- 1:22:56Austin: saying for other organizations to do that.
- 1:22:58Lara: Yeah.
- 1:22:59Austin: You know, I don't know that 12th Aviation
- 1:23:00Austin: Battalion does that.
- 1:23:01Austin: I never saw that while I was there.
- 1:23:03Austin: You know there was, and also I can say I
- 1:23:05Austin: never flew to Langley while I was there.
- 1:23:07Austin: Yeah, I flew to Langley while, I was there.
- 1:23:08Austin: Yeah, I can say that unabashedly.
- 1:23:09Austin: As far as I know, I never took anybody from
- 1:23:11Austin: the CIA.
- 1:23:12Austin: It's a military mission.
- 1:23:14Austin: Yeah, you're supporting military customers.
- 1:23:17Austin: For the most part, you know Secretary of
- 1:23:18Austin: Defense on down, and so predominantly
- 1:23:21Austin: generals, secretary level positions, that
- 1:23:25Austin: kind of thing.
- 1:23:25Austin: Cia's got their own assets to move them
- 1:23:26Austin: around.
- 1:23:29Lara: I would assume it seemed like there was
- 1:23:32Lara: just a spate of things going wrong with
- 1:23:33Lara: aircraft around that time and since then.
- 1:23:37Lara: Is that just because things are being
- 1:23:39Lara: highlighted, or is it real?
- 1:23:41Austin: Yeah, I think that's one of the things
- 1:23:43Austin: that's going to really have to be
- 1:23:44Austin: scrutinized in the investigation, because
- 1:23:46Austin: obviously people are paying more attention
- 1:23:47Austin: to now.
- 1:23:48Lara: There's the Delta that flipped over in
- 1:23:49Lara: Canada.
- 1:23:50Lara: There's that aircraft.
- 1:23:51Lara: It's just like.
- 1:23:53Lara: It just feels like.
- 1:23:54Lara: Suddenly you're looking at it thinking
- 1:23:56Lara: should I be flying?
- 1:23:57Austin: Yeah, I mean, I think in general again, if
- 1:23:58Austin: you kind of talk about the probability,
- 1:24:01Austin: this is one spike on otherwise a very good
- 1:24:04Austin: trend that we've had for the last 20 or so
- 1:24:06Austin: years in terms of aviation, or so years in
- 1:24:08Austin: terms of aviation.
- 1:24:09Austin: You know, I crossed we ate before we sat
- 1:24:12Austin: down to talk and I was there when we were
- 1:24:14Austin: picking up the food and crossed the road
- 1:24:16Austin: four or five, six times that is, I also
- 1:24:23Austin: flew in today.
- 1:24:23Austin: Of those two things, crossing the road four
- 1:24:24Austin: or five or six times was far more dangerous
- 1:24:25Austin: to my life than getting on the airplane
- 1:24:26Austin: that I got on to fly up here, not even
- 1:24:28Austin: close, and getting in the car to drive from
- 1:24:30Austin: where I was to get to, um, you know, to the
- 1:24:32Austin: studio far more dangerous than getting on
- 1:24:34Austin: an airplane.
- 1:24:35Austin: In terms of probability, um, you know, I
- 1:24:37Austin: think there has been a um kind of
- 1:24:39Austin: microscope put on it because of um,
- 1:24:41Austin: specifically because of the path to five
- 1:24:43Austin: crash.
- 1:24:43Austin: I think that drew a lot of attention to it.
- 1:24:46Austin: Um, and then the Delta crash.
- 1:24:47Austin: Again, you've got a lot of number one, the
- 1:24:52Austin: ability to record these things and put them
- 1:24:54Austin: out on the internet and kind of everybody
- 1:24:56Austin: sees it really quickly, and so it becomes
- 1:24:58Austin: kind of sensationalized.
- 1:25:01Lara: It's also so catastrophic right.
- 1:25:02Lara: And catastrophic yeah the thing is that you
- 1:25:04Lara: could say don't want people die slipping in
- 1:25:06Lara: their bath, you know than car accidents or
- 1:25:10Lara: whatever.
- 1:25:10Lara: But it's not like you have a good chance of
- 1:25:11Lara: surviving when you slip in your bath.
- 1:25:12Lara: You know then, even then you know then car
- 1:25:13Lara: accidents or whatever.
- 1:25:13Lara: But but it's not like you have a good
- 1:25:14Lara: chance of surviving when you slip in your
- 1:25:15Lara: bath and it's you know, you, you crash.
- 1:25:18Austin: Well, but apparently you know, if you look
- 1:25:20Austin: at the crash in Toronto, everybody survived.
- 1:25:22Austin: So it looks, it looks really horrible.
- 1:25:25Austin: Which is unusual for aircraft, and it is
- 1:25:27Austin: really unusual, obviously, but everybody
- 1:25:29Austin: survived.
- 1:25:31Austin: So again, like, if you just look at the
- 1:25:32Austin: probabilities, it's still a very, very safe
- 1:25:34Austin: way of traveling.
- 1:25:34Lara: Yes.
- 1:25:35Austin: I think you know, obviously we talked about
- 1:25:37Austin: the.
- 1:25:37Austin: There was an incident the day before with a
- 1:25:39Austin: pad aircraft in DCA.
- 1:25:41Austin: As it relates to that stuff specifically, I
- 1:25:43Austin: think there's a lot of analysis that's
- 1:25:44Austin: going to have to be done.
- 1:25:45Austin: You mean, for another Black Hawk, Another
- 1:25:47Austin: Black Hawk?
- 1:25:47Lara: Helicopter, another Blackhawk helicopter,
- 1:25:48Lara: Another Blackhawk.
- 1:25:49Austin: Yeah, that happened the day before where
- 1:25:49Austin: there was kind of another incident when it
- 1:25:51Austin: was supposedly close to an aircraft that
- 1:25:54Austin: chose not to land.
- 1:25:55Lara: But they were separated by a thousand feet.
- 1:25:57Austin: They were.
- 1:25:57Austin: They had some vertical separation.
- 1:25:58Austin: But I think kind of in the analysis the
- 1:26:00Austin: NCSB is going to have to do is how often
- 1:26:04Austin: were there close calls happening like this
- 1:26:06Austin: Because of the different frequencies a
- 1:26:08Austin: Blackhawk could cause?
- 1:26:09Austin: A close call could cause an aircraft to do
- 1:26:10Austin: a go-around or all these different things
- 1:26:13Austin: could cause we didn't talk about TCAS, but
- 1:26:15Austin: basically cause the airplane system to
- 1:26:18Austin: notice that there's a helicopter down there
- 1:26:20Austin: to tell the airplane to climb.
- 1:26:22Austin: It would be entirely possible, because
- 1:26:24Austin: you're not on the same radio frequency that
- 1:26:25Austin: you'd never know as the Blackhawk that you
- 1:26:27Austin: caused those.
- 1:26:28Austin: So another question is going to be what was
- 1:26:30Austin: the reporting like and how often were these
- 1:26:31Austin: incidents happening?
- 1:26:32Austin: Because if they were happening with
- 1:26:34Austin: increased frequency, if you look at DCA,
- 1:26:37Austin: they had a million passengers go through
- 1:26:39Austin: there in a year in 1946.
- 1:26:41Austin: By the 80s it was 16 million, now it's over
- 1:26:45Austin: 20 million and so you've just had this kind
- 1:26:47Austin: of exponential increase in the use and
- 1:26:50Austin: frequency of airplanes going to DCA.
- 1:26:51Lara: It's my favorite airport.
- 1:26:51Lara: If I'm going to DC, it's right by the city.
- 1:26:54Lara: Why would you fly in there?
- 1:26:56Lara: Yeah?
- 1:26:57Austin: And so I'd kind of want to put that across
- 1:26:59Austin: and then do the analysis and say hold on,
- 1:27:01Austin: were we having a lot of collision alerts on
- 1:27:02Austin: the radar?
- 1:27:03Austin: Were we having a lot of resolution?
- 1:27:06Austin: Advisories is what it's called when the
- 1:27:08Austin: airplane gets to climb or is told to climb.
- 1:27:11Austin: Advisory is what it's called when the
- 1:27:12Austin: airplane gets to climb or is told to climb.
- 1:27:14Austin: Were there a lot of those?
- 1:27:15Austin: Was there an increasing frequency?
- 1:27:15Austin: Were they happening at specific times of
- 1:27:17Austin: day?
- 1:27:17Austin: And then, furthermore, beyond that, were
- 1:27:20Austin: those being collated and were they being
- 1:27:21Austin: reported to the army and to the rest of the
- 1:27:23Austin: department of defense?
- 1:27:24Austin: Because if you're ignorant of it, if you
- 1:27:27Austin: don't know that it's happening, then it's
- 1:27:28Austin: hard for you to do anything about it.
- 1:27:29Lara: Right, then you're not going to fix it.
- 1:27:31Lara: Okay, so can you give me a sense of what is
- 1:27:34Lara: the feeling inside the unit?
- 1:27:35Lara: I mean, um, that's pretty bad, it is.
- 1:27:38Austin: Yeah, I mean, I think because of the
- 1:27:40Austin: increased level of scrutiny.
- 1:27:41Austin: You know, because if it's just the three
- 1:27:44Austin: crew members, this is on the news for a day
- 1:27:46Austin: or two and then maybe some people hear
- 1:27:48Austin: about it but maybe not.
- 1:27:50Austin: You know, again, I've lost a lot of friends
- 1:27:51Austin: in aviation accidents.
- 1:27:53Austin: I've certainly been in the army for long
- 1:27:55Austin: periods of time where there were accidents
- 1:27:57Austin: and you could just see that there was some
- 1:27:59Austin: level of interest.
- 1:28:00Austin: You know kind of, but even sometimes family
- 1:28:01Austin: members kind of wouldn't have known that it
- 1:28:02Austin: happened.
- 1:28:03Austin: You know and this is coming from somebody
- 1:28:05Austin: that's a Blackhawk pilot, and so sometimes
- 1:28:07Austin: you might get a text hey, was this you, um?
- 1:28:09Austin: But then a day or two everybody's kind of
- 1:28:10Austin: forgotten about it, um and again.
- 1:28:12Austin: Even sometimes my own family members would
- 1:28:13Austin: be like oh, I didn't know that there was a
- 1:28:14Austin: Blackhawk crash, you know, but um.
- 1:28:17Austin: So in this one it's unique because there's
- 1:28:20Austin: also 64 other people involved, um, who were
- 1:28:24Austin: killed, and so that just really turned up
- 1:28:27Austin: the level of scrutiny.
- 1:28:28Austin: Number one, because the amount of civilians
- 1:28:30Austin: when you have a military and this isn't
- 1:28:31Austin: totally unprecedented.
- 1:28:32Austin: I think there's been four to six incidents
- 1:28:34Austin: where there's been mid-air collisions with
- 1:28:35Austin: military aircraft and civilian aircraft.
- 1:28:37Austin: It's just been a long time, and so, because
- 1:28:40Austin: commercial aviation has become so safe,
- 1:28:42Austin: everybody's particularly interested in this.
- 1:28:44Austin: Because it's a military aircraft, it's a
- 1:28:45Austin: civilian aircraft, everybody's particularly
- 1:28:47Austin: interested and because 64 innocent people
- 1:28:50Austin: died.
- 1:28:50Austin: Yeah, because 60, I mean I would say 67
- 1:28:52Austin: innocent people died.
- 1:28:57Austin: It was just, you know, a difficult
- 1:28:59Austin: circumstance, and so the level of scrutiny
- 1:29:02Austin: and the level of visibility in national
- 1:29:03Austin: media was turned so high up.
- 1:29:07Austin: And again, because of kind of the things
- 1:29:08Austin: that drove me onto this show and onto other
- 1:29:12Austin: shows and started speaking out out where it
- 1:29:13Austin: was like, oh, this incompetent crew or some
- 1:29:16Austin: of the um, you know, even stuff like, oh,
- 1:29:19Austin: you know, becca low box, why would they
- 1:29:20Austin: pull her social media off?
- 1:29:21Austin: And I'm like, well, I could see where my
- 1:29:22Austin: family would pull my social media off,
- 1:29:23Austin: there's something on there.
- 1:29:24Austin: But like, why give anybody fodder?
- 1:29:27Austin: Um, you know, and making comments about,
- 1:29:30Austin: you know, her serving as a White House
- 1:29:32Austin: social aid, which was did not take her away
- 1:29:34Austin: from her job duties, did not make her a
- 1:29:36Austin: worse pilot.
- 1:29:36Austin: Or about her, specifically Becca Lobach's,
- 1:29:41Austin: the time that it took her to make pilot
- 1:29:42Austin: command, which was actually a pretty normal
- 1:29:44Austin: amount of time that it took to make pilot
- 1:29:45Austin: command.
- 1:29:45Austin: And so there were all these like kind of
- 1:29:47Austin: arrows being shot at all the crew members,
- 1:29:52Austin: um, and again, because there was a
- 1:29:53Austin: simplistic take, which is they're off an
- 1:29:55Austin: altitude, everybody died.
- 1:29:56Austin: Um, that I think was was wrong.
- 1:29:58Austin: Not necessarily at that, but for patients
- 1:29:59Austin: not important.
- 1:30:00Austin: But there's a lot of more Um, and so they
- 1:30:03Austin: were just watching all these kind of uh
- 1:30:05Austin: arrows being shot at their, at their dead
- 1:30:07Austin: friends, um, and so morale was pretty bad.
- 1:30:13Austin: You know, I was quoted an article and my
- 1:30:16Austin: brother read it, and then he read the
- 1:30:17Austin: online comments and texted me back right
- 1:30:19Austin: away and said if you haven't read the
- 1:30:21Austin: online comments, don't.
- 1:30:23Austin: And I said well, what are people saying?
- 1:30:26Austin: And he goes.
- 1:30:27Austin: I've never seen people.
- 1:30:29Austin: I've never seen people say the kinds of
- 1:30:31Austin: things they're saying about the military
- 1:30:32Austin: right now or about military members.
- 1:30:36Lara: That must have been the New York Times
- 1:30:37Lara: article.
- 1:30:40Austin: A number of.
- 1:30:41Austin: I don't think it's unusual because there's
- 1:30:43Austin: other media that I've looked at and I have
- 1:30:44Austin: looked at the comments on so New York Times.
- 1:30:46Austin: I don't think they're unique in terms of
- 1:30:48Austin: the kind of vitriol the public was putting
- 1:30:50Austin: out.
- 1:30:50Lara: What were you quoted as saying?
- 1:30:52Austin: Not, I think it was.
- 1:30:53Austin: I honestly don't, I don't remember.
- 1:30:54Austin: It was again just specifically about the
- 1:30:57Austin: routes or something like that.
- 1:30:58Austin: I think it was about the risk, just general
- 1:30:59Austin: risk.
- 1:31:00Lara: Right.
- 1:31:01Austin: But he wasn't talking about my comments
- 1:31:03Austin: specifically.
- 1:31:03Austin: He was just saying the comments from the
- 1:31:04Austin: public on the article.
- 1:31:06Austin: Because the article was about a bunch of
- 1:31:07Austin: other stuff as well and I saw comments out
- 1:31:10Austin: there about some of the stuff.
- 1:31:11Austin: Just like everybody knows what happened.
- 1:31:12Austin: These people weren't competent, they killed
- 1:31:14Austin: everybody.
- 1:31:15Austin: That kind of attitude that was out there
- 1:31:18Austin: and that stuff was getting back to the unit
- 1:31:21Austin: and getting back to their friends and,
- 1:31:23Austin: worse than that, family.
- 1:31:25Austin: You know people in the military were tough,
- 1:31:26Austin: we can take it, you can tell, because they
- 1:31:29Austin: all kept their mouth shut because that's
- 1:31:31Austin: what good soldiers do they just let it roll
- 1:31:34Austin: off their back and they deal with the blows.
- 1:31:38Austin: But worse than that is the family members
- 1:31:42Austin: who I think are still hearing stuff like
- 1:31:44Austin: that and are still aware of it.
- 1:31:45Austin: And it's particularly painful for them.
- 1:31:49Lara: Well, I need to let you go because you have
- 1:31:51Lara: a flight to catch and I know it was
- 1:31:52Lara: important to you to make sure that
- 1:31:54Lara: everybody knows that you're not speaking on
- 1:31:57Lara: behalf of the DOD or any airline or company
- 1:32:00Lara: or anything else, these are your personal.
- 1:32:03Lara: This is your personal choice and these are
- 1:32:04Lara: your personal views, based on you know what
- 1:32:08Lara: you feel in your heart.
- 1:32:10Austin: Thank, you yes.
- 1:32:11Lara: And that you wanted to speak up for people
- 1:32:13Lara: who are not necessarily in a position to
- 1:32:16Lara: speak for themselves.
- 1:32:16Lara: That's right.
- 1:32:18Lara: I mean, I learned a lot from you.
- 1:32:20Lara: I'm sure a lot of other people will, and I
- 1:32:23Lara: just thank you.
- 1:32:24Lara: I just want to say thank you.
- 1:32:25Austin: Thank you for extending the invitation and
- 1:32:26Austin: for having me.
- 1:32:27Lara: Well, and you came all the way out here and
- 1:32:31Lara: that's important because you know I mean
- 1:32:37Lara: right or wrong, and maybe you'll be right
- 1:32:38Lara: about everything.
- 1:32:38Lara: The investigation will come out and back
- 1:32:39Lara: you up and maybe there'll be other things
- 1:32:40Lara: we don't know about right.
- 1:32:41Lara: That can still come out.
- 1:32:42Lara: But, either way, having people with
- 1:32:45Lara: knowledge and experience add their voices
- 1:32:48Lara: to the debate, because you know that public
- 1:32:51Lara: square is here to stay and it does a lot of
- 1:32:53Lara: good.
- 1:32:54Austin: Yeah, I hope so.
- 1:32:54Lara: But the way you mitigate any of the
- 1:32:57Lara: downsides is for people who know to speak
- 1:33:00Lara: up.
- 1:33:00Lara: So it's great to meet you, Austin.
- 1:33:02Lara: I really appreciate it.
- 1:33:03Austin: Thank you very much for having me.
- 1:33:04Lara: Dare I say fly safely on your way home,
- 1:33:08Lara: yeah thank you.
- 1:33:09Lara: Yeah, thank you so much.
- 1:33:10Lara: Okay, so thank you for watching Going Rogue
- 1:33:11Lara: with Laura Logan on your way home.
- 1:33:11Lara: Yeah, thank you.
- 1:33:11Lara: Yeah, thank you so much.
- 1:33:11Lara: Okay, so thank you for watching Going Rogue
- 1:33:13Lara: with Laura Logan.
- 1:33:15Lara: I think I'm supposed to say something about
- 1:33:17Lara: where you can go at this point,
- 1:33:19Lara: lauralogancom.
- 1:33:20Lara: Look on the website.
- 1:33:21Lara: I'm the worst salesperson in the world, but
- 1:33:23Lara: I do appreciate your support.
- 1:33:26Lara: Take care.