Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Future of the Privilege and Work Product Protection in an AI Age
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Mark Hoag, chair of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:06Association's AI in the Law section, along with
- 0:09my co -chair Amanda Harris. And I'm the founder
- 0:12of hoaglaw .ai, where I serve as fractional GC
- 0:16to AI first SaaS companies and tech startups,
- 0:20while spending my nights and weekends vibe coding
- 0:22all sorts of apps, because of course I do. I'm
- 0:25thrilled to announce and introduce our speaker
- 0:27today, Chris Suarez. So Chris is a member of
- 0:31Steptoe's intellectual property practice and
- 0:33a co -head of Steptoe's interdisciplinary AI
- 0:36data and digital working group. He's an outside
- 0:39the box thinker with a passion for helping clients
- 0:42understand and manage risks in high technology,
- 0:46particularly technologies in the computer software,
- 0:48hardware, and semiconductor domains. As an intellectual
- 0:53property litigator, he focuses his practice on
- 0:55patent, copyright, and trade secret trials and
- 0:58appeals before every level of the U .S. court
- 1:01system, including federal district courts, U
- 1:04.S. courts of appeals, the U .S. Supreme Court,
- 1:08the U .S. Patent Trial and Appeal Board, and
- 1:11other administrative tribunals. Chris's experience
- 1:14in district court litigation spans all phases
- 1:17of litigation, including overseeing fact discovery,
- 1:21taking and defending fact and expert depositions,
- 1:24arguing dispositive motions, claim construction
- 1:27and appeals, and examining witnesses at trial.
- 1:31So basically all the things. Chris's experience
- 1:34at the PTAB includes cross -examining witnesses
- 1:37and successfully arguing on behalf of his client
- 1:40at the oral hearing. All right, then. Well, let's
- 1:43get started. Chris, thank you so much for being
- 1:46here. Take it away, please. Yeah, no, thank you
- 1:48so much, Mark, for the warm introduction. It's
- 1:51awesome that you vibe code on the weekends. And
- 1:54really, really excited to be presenting here
- 1:57for the BHBA. I wish I were in Beverly Hills
- 2:00right now. DC will have to do for now. But it's
- 2:04great to be here and looking forward to talking
- 2:06about this timely topic. So I'm going to go ahead
- 2:10and share my screen. You know, and just so everyone
- 2:16knows, my email is on the first slide. You know,
- 2:20see Suarez at steptoe .com. If you have any questions
- 2:24or have any thoughts after this presentation,
- 2:27I'm happy to hear from you. But without further
- 2:30ado, would love to kind of go into the details
- 2:32here. And so what I'm going to cover is first,
- 2:37I'm going to talk a little bit about what privilege
- 2:39and work product is so that we all have a sense
- 2:43of that from our law school days. Then I'm going
- 2:46to go through the big cases, Happner and Gilbarco.
- 2:50That's why I'm sure most of you are here, because
- 2:52you want to hear about those cases and hear perspectives
- 2:54on what their implications are for your use of
- 2:57AI. Then I'm going to talk a little bit about
- 3:00ethical rules from the model rules of professional
- 3:03responsibility, because you should be aware of
- 3:06those and be thinking about those as you deal
- 3:08with these issues. And then finally, I'm going
- 3:11to provide some reflective thoughts on future
- 3:13implications that you might wanna be thinking
- 3:16about as we go through these issues. And so start
- 3:20off again, privilege in the work product generally.
- 3:25The privilege is something that's been in existence
- 3:27for a long time, but the seminal case, for those
- 3:30who don't recall from law school, it's certainly
- 3:32been a while for me, is Upjohn versus United
- 3:35States. And what's the point of privilege? It's
- 3:38really about full and frank communication between
- 3:41attorneys and their clients. So what it's protecting
- 3:45is these conversations between us as lawyers,
- 3:49our clients, and making sure that those don't
- 3:52see the light of day so that you can candidly
- 3:54discuss strategy and those sorts of things. And
- 3:56so that's why the communications must be for
- 3:58securing legal advice. And the privilege is only
- 4:03between attorneys or clients, and it's held by
- 4:05the client. And because the privilege is held
- 4:07by the client, that means it can be waived. And
- 4:11so how can it be waived? Examples are disclosure
- 4:15of information to third parties. If you just
- 4:18don't assert it, you might produce something
- 4:20that's privileged and to the other side, and
- 4:24you never say that's privileged, so that could
- 4:26be a waiver. And then placing information at
- 4:30issue in litigation. can be a waiver of privilege.
- 4:33So like as a patent litigator, something we sometimes
- 4:38do is we say, hey, we got this opinion of counsel
- 4:41and this shows that our state of mind was a certain
- 4:45way in terms of patent infringement. So I may
- 4:47want to disclose that and put that an issue in
- 4:50the litigation. In that case, I may be voluntarily
- 4:53waiving privilege. So that can happen a few different
- 4:55ways. Now, how about work product? work product
- 5:00is a doctrine that was really ensconced in this
- 5:051947 Supreme Court decision, Hickman v. Taylor,
- 5:09and the general principle is that materials prepared
- 5:14by an attorney in anticipation of litigation
- 5:18are shielded from discovery. It involves mental
- 5:22impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal
- 5:27theories, but Work product generally is understood
- 5:30as being a bit broader. It can also cover materials
- 5:34prepared by, quote, agents of the attorney. So
- 5:38if you look at the federal rules of civil procedure,
- 5:41rule 26B4C talks about the fact that experts
- 5:46can have work product protection. And obviously
- 5:49as litigators, if we're hiring an expert and
- 5:52they're banding about strategy and creating documents,
- 5:57sort of in the lead up to their expert reports
- 5:59and so forth. We don't want those things to be
- 6:01discoverable. And opinion work product receives
- 6:06a higher level of work or work product protection
- 6:09and other types of documents. So if it's a opinions
- 6:12of counsel reflecting on, you know, the strategies
- 6:16and so forth, that often receives a higher level
- 6:18of protection. Now, as a as part of this intro,
- 6:21I want to make a quick point about pro se litigants
- 6:25and because this is going to be relevant when
- 6:28we get to the discussion of AI and rule 26 b3a
- 6:34of the federal rules of procedure says quote
- 6:37a party may not discover documents and tangible
- 6:41things that are prepared in anticipation of litigation
- 6:45or for trial by or for another party or its representative
- 6:52absent a substantial need now I've really placed
- 6:56emphasis on this by or for language, because
- 6:59if you if you read that literally, it seems to
- 7:03suggest that you can't discover things that are
- 7:06made by the party, which could mean it's not
- 7:09just the attorney. Right. And so some have argued
- 7:13that that means that there's a broader work product
- 7:15protection that applies to the client in addition
- 7:19to the attorney. But not all the courts actually
- 7:21agree on that. So but but I want you to be aware
- 7:23of the text of the rule. And so this is a very
- 7:27unsettled issue, but this rule is a reason why
- 7:31some people have interpreted Heppner differently
- 7:34or have thought the implications of Heppner are
- 7:37broader or narrower than they might actually
- 7:39be. And so let's talk about Heppner and Gilbarco,
- 7:43these two cases that most, I'm sure most of you
- 7:46have heard of Heppner, most if not all of you,
- 7:48some of you may have heard of Gilbarco, but the
- 7:51cases were both decided. pretty much on the same
- 7:54day and in two different courts, two different
- 7:59district courts, and give us a nice sort of compare
- 8:02and contrast to think about this issue of using
- 8:06AI and the risk of waiving privilege and what
- 8:09the future that's going to look like. And so
- 8:12let's start off with Heppner. I'm sure many of
- 8:16you have seen this. It was opinion by Judge Rakoff.
- 8:19He actually initially Issued the ruling from
- 8:22the bench on February 10th. So there was a hearing
- 8:26and in the hearing he said I'm you know, I am
- 8:30going to permit the discovery of these of these
- 8:36work product documents that were generated using
- 8:40AI and Basically, you had a criminal defendant.
- 8:44He was under investigation and he decided without
- 8:48consulting with his attorney, I'm going to use
- 8:50Claude, the public version of Claude, to see
- 8:53if there is anything interesting here in terms
- 8:56of strategies that I can avail myself of. And
- 8:59he, as a result of that, he generated 31 documents.
- 9:04And I want to be clear with some things up front,
- 9:08because first, if you look at the second bullet
- 9:10here, the courts ruling in the case, answered
- 9:16a question of first impression nationwide, or
- 9:18at least appeared to answer that question. And
- 9:20it was very narrow whether when a user communicates
- 9:24with a publicly available AI platform in connection
- 9:28with a pending criminal investigation, are the
- 9:31user's communications protected by attorney -client
- 9:34privilege or the work product doctrine? And the
- 9:37answer the court said was unequivocally no. But
- 9:40I want to be clear that the question presented
- 9:42is very narrow. It's about a publicly available
- 9:46AI platform. And the key here was you had the
- 9:5131 documents, right? The conversations were with
- 9:55Claude. They were not with an attorney. And there
- 9:58was no suggestion from counsel to do this. He
- 10:02prepared reports that outlined defense strategy
- 10:05and outlined what he might argue. And after the
- 10:08client decided to do this on his own, then he
- 10:11shared the documents with counsel and later asserted
- 10:14privilege and work product. All those facts are
- 10:16key here. And so the court said, I'm going to
- 10:21start with the privilege. Okay. So there's a
- 10:23privilege ruling and a work product ruling on
- 10:26the privilege. The documents were not privileged
- 10:29for several reasons. The first being Claude is
- 10:32not an attorney. Okay. Now, obviously some are
- 10:35trying, some might argue in the future that an
- 10:37AI platform is an attorney, but as of now, Judge
- 10:40Rakoff and most of the bar I think would agree
- 10:43and AI platform is not itself an attorney, right?
- 10:45And so discussing legal issues between two non
- 10:48-attorneys is not privileged because there's
- 10:50no attorney -client relationship between an AI
- 10:53user and Claude. So that was the first basis
- 10:56for no privilege. The second basis was the communications
- 11:01memorialized in the AI documents were not confidential.
- 11:05Now this is not without some controversy. I've
- 11:09seen some postings on LinkedIn and elsewhere
- 11:11that, you know, don't agree with this. But from
- 11:15the court's perspective, looking at the privacy
- 11:18policy that was operative for this public version
- 11:21of Claude at the time, that the privacy policy
- 11:27made clear that the inputted data was used to
- 11:30train Claude. And so that data was taken in as
- 11:33an input. And the policy said, we're going to
- 11:36use that data. And so it goes into what I call
- 11:39the soup of the AI for purposes of training,
- 11:42which means it could be output by Claude at some
- 11:45later point in time. And so you've kind of given
- 11:47it away according to the privacy policy. And
- 11:51Anthropic also had a clause in their privacy
- 11:54policy that said they can disclose the information
- 11:58you input into the AI to other third parties
- 12:02for purposes of law enforcement and other things
- 12:05of that nature. And so that's something you're
- 12:07going to have to think about. If you're using
- 12:09a version of some publicly facing AI tools, what
- 12:14does the privacy policy say and what are the
- 12:16implications of that? And of course, one theme
- 12:18of this that I'm building to that I'll repeat
- 12:21several times is that ideally any client who
- 12:25uses this stuff is using a private enterprise
- 12:30version that is not training on the input of
- 12:32data. That is a way to avoid a lot of these problems,
- 12:36doesn't avoid all the problems, but it helps
- 12:37avoid some of the problems. And so that's the
- 12:41first two reasons. The third and final reason
- 12:44that the court said was a close call was that
- 12:47in the court's view, Heppner did not communicate
- 12:50with Claude for actually obtaining legal advice.
- 12:54And his argument, Rakoff's argument here was
- 12:57that there was no direction from counsel to use
- 13:00Claude. And Claude has a disclaimer and it says,
- 13:03hey, I'm not a lawyer. I don't provide formal
- 13:05legal advice. Now, the way the court analyzed
- 13:09this third factor sounds a little like how he
- 13:12analyzed the first point, but he did recite it
- 13:16as sort of an independent reason. So that's Heppner
- 13:20on privilege. On work product, He said no work
- 13:26product protection either. And I think part of
- 13:30the part of this I think is that we need to consider
- 13:33is that again, Ray coughs in the Southern District
- 13:36of New York. He's applying Second Circuit precedent,
- 13:40right? And so he cited this in Ray grand jury
- 13:44subpoena and in the Second Circuit work product
- 13:47is quote, not generally promoted by shielding
- 13:50from discovery materials and an attorney's possession.
- 13:54that were prepared neither by the attorney nor
- 13:57its agents. So that is a proposition in a presidential
- 14:01case in the Second Circuit, which seems to suggest
- 14:05that work product is focused on attorneys and
- 14:08agents and not on what the client does himself
- 14:12or herself. And that seems to somewhat contradict
- 14:15or at least go against the plain text of of that
- 14:18rule of civil procedure that I mentioned earlier.
- 14:21But again, that's what the law is in the Second
- 14:23Circuit. according to Judge Rakoff. So that was
- 14:26part of the basis. And so then he said, even
- 14:29if AI documents are prepared, quote, in anticipation
- 14:32of litigation, they were not, quote, prepared
- 14:35buyer at the behest of counsel and did not reflect
- 14:38the counsel strategy. And so really the ruling
- 14:43in Heppner for work product came down to Claude
- 14:47is not the agent of an attorney. There was no
- 14:50direction from the attorney and therefore no
- 14:53work product. Doesn't matter to the court that
- 14:56it's done by the by the client. And that last
- 15:01quote goes to the heart of it. While it is true
- 15:03that the work product doctrine may apply to materials
- 15:05generated by non -lawyers, the Second Circuit
- 15:08has repeatedly stressed the purpose of the doctrine
- 15:10is to protect lawyers' mental processes. So that
- 15:15was really fundamental to Heppner. And so in
- 15:18Heppner, again, no privilege, no work product.
- 15:22The client's efforts to use AI are discoverable.
- 15:28But now we've got another case, Warner v. Jill
- 15:31Barco. And this is Eastern District of Michigan.
- 15:36The opinion came out February 10th, 2026, which
- 15:39is the same day, again, that Rakoff had the hearing
- 15:41before he issued the opinion a week later on
- 15:44February 17th. And so, and Warner, the court
- 15:49denied a request for production of information
- 15:52concerning use of third -party AI tools in connection
- 15:56with the lawsuit and the court here said the
- 16:01information is not discoverable because under
- 16:04this rule 26 b3a of civil procedure a party may
- 16:09not discover documents and tangible things that
- 16:12are prepared in anticipation of litigation or
- 16:14for trial by another party or its representative
- 16:18So the emphasis in the italics here is in is
- 16:22in the original. Okay, I didn't add it myself.
- 16:25And this is underscoring that the court here
- 16:29felt that this rule means that if a party is
- 16:33using AI and doing things anticipate an anticipation
- 16:38of litigation, that stuff should not be discoverable.
- 16:41So you can see kind of the split here between
- 16:44the Eastern District of Michigan judge and Judge
- 16:46Rakoff. The court also said the information sought
- 16:51was not relevant and even if marginally relevant
- 16:55is not proportional to the needs of the case.
- 16:59And there was no evidence there that the plaintiff
- 17:02violated a PO by uploading confidential documents
- 17:05into AI. Now I've done some investigation into
- 17:08this case. It seemed that there was a bunch of
- 17:11deposition discovery that was going on where
- 17:14one side was basically trying to see if the plaintiff
- 17:17was pulling shenanigans or putting confidential
- 17:20information into AI that would have violated
- 17:23a protective order. And so that was the sort
- 17:25of thrust of why this AI stuff was being sought
- 17:29here. And so that context is somewhat relevant
- 17:32to maybe why the court was somewhat annoyed that
- 17:35there was an effort to get these AI materials.
- 17:41I think the court kind of viewed this effort
- 17:44to get the AI documents sufficient expedition.
- 17:47And so that is relevant. And, you know, look,
- 17:50I think something to reflect on from that is
- 17:53that, yes, the work product and Privilege analysis
- 17:57is relevant, but you gotta think about the context
- 17:59too and think about the relevance and proportionality
- 18:02because that might be an independent basis to
- 18:05say this is discoverable even if technically
- 18:08there might have been some argument about privilege
- 18:10waiver or work product or what have you. So something
- 18:14to think about there. And the final bullet, you
- 18:18know, I just point out that the court said there's
- 18:21no waiver because waiver has to be. a waiver
- 18:25to an adversary or in a way likely to get an
- 18:29adversary's hand and AI programs are just tools
- 18:33and not people. And so from a technical standpoint,
- 18:36I think there's a fair argument that even if,
- 18:40you know, yes, you're training on the data. um
- 18:44you're providing it to a third party in Claude
- 18:47like is there is there a realistic possibility
- 18:50that that information is actually going to get
- 18:52into the hands of your adversary or actually
- 18:54be output identically to a third party not necessarily
- 18:58and so i think the court was somewhat appealing
- 19:01to that logic and then there's also another discussion
- 19:04that's going on in the in the bar about well
- 19:07Why should we be treating these AI tools much
- 19:10different than something like Microsoft Word?
- 19:13If I'm using that, if I'm using Google Docs,
- 19:16which is a cloud based tool, you know, is that
- 19:18risking waiver if there's a privacy policy, you
- 19:21know, so looking to those other types of technologies
- 19:24and thinking about AI as a tool arguably has
- 19:28some sort of connection to pre existing technologies
- 19:31like Microsoft Word and some of those things.
- 19:32So that's another sort of. point of discussion
- 19:35i think we're having in the bar right now but
- 19:37hopefully this has allowed you to see the sort
- 19:40of contrast that exists between the heppner decision
- 19:44um and and another decision And again, we don't
- 19:47have any circuit precedent on this. And so obviously,
- 19:51we have to be mindful of the privilege waiver
- 19:53and the work product waiver risk. And we need
- 19:55to tell our clients to not go crazy in a rogue
- 20:01way to use AI without discussing with attorneys.
- 20:05But at the same time, we should make it clear
- 20:08to our clients that the law is still very open
- 20:10and unsettled in this area. And so this is exciting
- 20:14and interesting, but we've got a long way to
- 20:16go to so we officially know what the results
- 20:19going to be. So the last two things I want to
- 20:24talk about before wrapping up are just first,
- 20:26I want you to be aware of some of the ethical
- 20:28rules that I think are implicated by these decisions.
- 20:31And then again, at the end, I'm going to talk
- 20:33about some next steps to think about. The ethical
- 20:38obligations you should be aware of that you may
- 20:42have heard about before, these are all in the
- 20:44ABA model rules, include first the duty of competence.
- 20:49Model rule 1 .1 in its comment eight, eight indicate
- 20:53that lawyers should understand the benefits and
- 20:56risks associated with AI assisted technologies.
- 21:00And so you need to know about the risks and the
- 21:03benefits and you need to be informed of that.
- 21:05That's why we have CLEs like this. So we all
- 21:07continue to stay informed. Another thing to understand
- 21:11is that there's a duty in the ethical rules around
- 21:14confidentiality, right? You know, client information
- 21:17should be kept confidential. And so clients should
- 21:20understand, hey, I might be releasing my information
- 21:24to a third party or at least to the AI vendor
- 21:28if this AI vendor is going to be collecting my
- 21:32data for purposes of training pursuant to its
- 21:34privacy policy, right? So I need to be aware
- 21:37of that. I need to be aware of what type of AI
- 21:39system I'm using, whether it's in some sort of
- 21:42protected walled garden or not. And as lawyers,
- 21:45we have duties to inform our clients of the risks
- 21:49of things not being kept confidential. I've even
- 21:53had clients who might get excited to take work
- 21:56product they receive from outside counsel and
- 21:58say, oh, I want to test out how outside counsel's
- 22:01work is. And I'm going to run that through some
- 22:04AI to see if I like the work product. Well, if
- 22:06you're doing that and you're not doing it in
- 22:09an AI that's enterprise grade and private, your
- 22:13own client can be making a significant mistake
- 22:15there. So we got to inform them of those risks.
- 22:18Another one I want to emphasize is duty of supervision.
- 22:22This has become relevant in light of all the
- 22:23hallucinating cases. We've heard about hundreds
- 22:27of them now in the US. It's honestly crazy just
- 22:31how many of these we're seeing. And you need
- 22:34to make sure that you're supervising junior attorneys,
- 22:38supervising your experts. There's been situations
- 22:42where an expert in AI from Stanford in a Minnesota
- 22:47case actually had fake citations in that case
- 22:51and it's because there wasn't supervision. When
- 22:54it comes to these privilege waiver risks, you
- 22:56also need to be thinking about how are you supervising
- 22:59your agents, your vendors, what they're putting
- 23:01into the AI, are they taking work product and
- 23:05feeding it in because there's some third party
- 23:07vendor or support team of your expert who doesn't
- 23:10realize what they're doing, right? So like we
- 23:12got to talk to our clients about this, but we
- 23:14got to talk to the whole circle of people we
- 23:17work with and especially the senior attorney
- 23:20on the case needs to be. supervising it effectively.
- 23:24And then, and then finally, duty of communication,
- 23:26we need to be consulting with clients about how
- 23:29the clients objectives are accomplished. And
- 23:31if they want to be consulting AI to achieve those
- 23:34objectives, perhaps that's okay. But we need
- 23:37to have a window into how that's being done.
- 23:39That that's super important. So finally, in the
- 23:44last five minutes, I have before I take any questions
- 23:48people have is to talk about future implications
- 23:52of this that you might want to be thinking about
- 23:54both for yourself and for your clients. And so,
- 23:58you know, first, the law is going to be uncertain
- 24:02in this area. And the same is true for the litigations
- 24:07of generative AI and copyright. I'm sure many
- 24:09of you are following those litigations, right?
- 24:11There are 80 -some litigations involving the
- 24:14use of AI training data in connection with copyright.
- 24:17We have decisions, for example, in the BARTs,
- 24:20the entropic case from Judge Alsip. We also have
- 24:24a decision in the Cadre v. Meta case. But other
- 24:29than those decisions, We have no circuit level
- 24:32precedent and no other precedent on the use of
- 24:35generative AI and training data on the copyright
- 24:37in the copyright context. So to here, we don't
- 24:41have any circuit level precedent on this work
- 24:45product and privilege waiver issue. And so just
- 24:48keep in mind, the law is gonna be uncertain.
- 24:53Second, you know, in any engagement, I would
- 24:55just make sure you're advising the client on
- 24:57the risk of discoverability of their generative
- 25:00AI use. They might be excited to use it. It might
- 25:02save them some time, might save some money to
- 25:05use AI, but they cannot assume the information
- 25:09that they're putting in or the documents they're
- 25:12creating are going to be protected automatically.
- 25:16There are risks and so... you know, conversations
- 25:18need to be had about what AI tools that are being
- 25:21used, what privacy policies are being used, when
- 25:25you're using the AI tools, is it at the direction
- 25:27of the lawyer or is it just something they're
- 25:30doing rogue as in the case of Heppner? Like all
- 25:32of those things need to be discussed so that
- 25:35we can make sure that we're above board on this.
- 25:39Third, it's really important that if, the clients
- 25:44are using AI in connection with litigation thoughts
- 25:48or impressions or whatever. Ideally, those uses
- 25:51would be directed by attorneys or at least, you
- 25:55know, an outgrowth of conversations with attorneys
- 25:58so that that can be connected and tied back to
- 26:01the privilege. That would be the ideal. Next,
- 26:06again, those privacy policies are relevant, at
- 26:10least according to Judge Rakoff. And so As an
- 26:13attorney, you should be aware of the privacy
- 26:17policies that are at issue in the generative
- 26:20AI tools you're using. You should know that,
- 26:22frankly, for the tools you're using in your organization.
- 26:25But you certainly need to make sure you know
- 26:28about what your clients are using and what those
- 26:31privacy policies look like. analysis is gonna
- 26:37increasingly be important, especially if Judge
- 26:40Rakoff's opinion sort of carries the day going
- 26:42forward. And then, and as I've alluded to several
- 26:48times already, you're gonna wanna probably make
- 26:51sure enterprise or paid versions of the GEN .ai
- 26:53tools are being used. I can tell you from experience
- 26:57that pretty much every unpaid version of a generative
- 27:00AI tools is gonna train on the data. That's the
- 27:03benefit of the bargain you get for getting it
- 27:05for free. That's why it's not technically free.
- 27:09And so you want to err on the side of enterprise
- 27:14or paid versions. And you want to ideally keep
- 27:18the inputs and outputs in a safe walled garden
- 27:22that's maintained under lock and key. And you
- 27:25want to make sure that your client's data is
- 27:28maintain in segregated fashion from other data.
- 27:31You don't want to commingle data either, right?
- 27:33So that's another big issue there. And then as
- 27:38I alluded to previously also, the oversight and
- 27:42communication isn't just with the client here.
- 27:45Like I have worked with several clients who haven't
- 27:50given much thought about how are our vendors
- 27:52using AI. How are experts using AI? How are these
- 27:56other third parties using AI? And you have to
- 27:59really run down that chain. You really have to
- 28:02go back and look at the agreements with these
- 28:04third parties. Like, does your expert retainer
- 28:07agreement have something about AI and how it's
- 28:09being used? You'd be amazed at how few people
- 28:12have actually revised their expert engagement
- 28:14letters, right? And there's also a similar exercise
- 28:18should be done with the vendors. Does it mention
- 28:21AI? you know, and doesn't mention how the AI
- 28:25is going to be used. Same with your agreements,
- 28:28you know, you might have outside council guidelines
- 28:31with your, if you're an outside council like
- 28:34me, you might have outside council guidelines.
- 28:37If you're in -house and you're supplying outside
- 28:39council guidelines, you might want to be thinking
- 28:41about how you adapt those outside council guidelines
- 28:45for purposes of avoiding these privilege waiver
- 28:47risks. And the last comment I want I do want
- 28:52to make is about pro se litigants, because again,
- 28:55the law is kind of unsettled in this area. And,
- 28:59you know, intuitively, it would seem that, you
- 29:02know, pro se litigants who don't have the resources
- 29:06to afford enterprise grade AI and who are, you
- 29:11know, trying to sort of figure out their case
- 29:14in anticipation of litigation. You know, I do
- 29:17wonder if The law is going to have a place for
- 29:21them in terms of maybe having some sort of exception
- 29:24for for pro se, because if the if the if if the
- 29:29Ray cough decision is applied to pro se litigants,
- 29:32I could see that having bad implications on the
- 29:35bar and for pro se litigants. That's just my
- 29:36personal opinion. Of course. Um, but, um, that's
- 29:40sort of an open issue and, and, and for those
- 29:43of you who may work with pro se or do pro bono,
- 29:46uh, work in your practice, um, that's just something
- 29:49we're going to have to keep an eye out for. Um,
- 29:52because, you know, pro se litigant doesn't have
- 29:53a lawyer. Um. If they're waiving privilege and
- 29:58work product protection based on these prompts,
- 30:01that might be unfair to them. And it's something
- 30:03that I think we're going to have to have a conversation
- 30:06about in the bar. So with that being said, I
- 30:11do see I'm at my time. I don't know if there's
- 30:14any questions in the chat. Let me just check
- 30:17if there are. OK, there's one question in the
- 30:21chat. So I will answer that before we wrap up.
- 30:24um so um so mark you asked the question about
- 30:30um you know doesn't uh of his own volition conflate
- 30:34initiative with purpose um yeah it's an it's
- 30:39it's an interesting point um i i look i think
- 30:43the reason why i think heppner did the did the
- 30:47of his own volition um rake off wrote the of
- 30:50his own volition is because it's so centered
- 30:52on the attorney's role in both privilege and
- 30:55the work product protection. And so I think Raycoff's
- 30:59view is that in the second circuit, basically
- 31:01work product protection and privilege is an outgrowth
- 31:05of the attorney. And so I agree with you that
- 31:11the purpose of what the um person was doing the
- 31:14client was doing likely did relate to litigation
- 31:17strategy and was for that purpose um but you
- 31:20know i think he rake off exalts this view the
- 31:23lawyer has to direct it so if you go rogue um
- 31:26then then you're going to risk waiving the privilege
- 31:28and work product protection but i i do see your
- 31:31point i mean and i think that's why the warnerville
- 31:33vehicle barco case interpreted that rule more
- 31:37broadly as also applying the clients and said,
- 31:40no, no, no, I'm not going to I'm not going to
- 31:42allow this stuff out. So so yeah. So anyway,
- 31:45I think it's a great question. And because I'm
- 31:49at time, I'm going to wrap it up. But I will
- 31:52just say. Um, you know, again, I'm happy to ask
- 31:55any questions, um, or answer any questions over
- 31:58email. My email is C Suarez at step toe .com.
- 32:02I also do have a newsletter I send out on AI
- 32:05musings, um, that I send out from time to time.
- 32:07So if anyone who's listening is interested in.
- 32:10receiving that newsletter, just feel free to
- 32:12drop me a line at C. Suarez at SEPTO .com. And
- 32:16I would be more than happy to send you my thoughts
- 32:18on random AI topics from time to time, as well
- 32:22as to answer any questions you might have about
- 32:25this particular issue. But with that being said,
- 32:29I'm really thankful for the opportunity to present
- 32:32here to the BHBA. I'm grateful for the invitation
- 32:35and look forward to hearing from some of you.
- 32:39Thanks again for the opportunity. Have a great
- 32:41day, everyone. This concludes today's presentation.
- 32:45Thank you so much, Chris, for an excellent presentation,
- 32:47and thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 32:49great day, everybody. Take care, everyone.