Latest / The NanceCast / What is Hintelligence? A.I. DOOM, Cute Accelerationism, and the End Of The Human?
Transcript
- 0:10SPEAKER_00: All right, hello.
- 0:13SPEAKER_01: Welcome, welcome, welcome back to the Nancecast.
- 0:17SPEAKER_01: I'm really glad you could make it to this one.
- 0:21SPEAKER_01: This one is going to be excellent.
- 0:24SPEAKER_01: Here in about 45 minutes,
- 0:25SPEAKER_01: I will be joined by my friend,
- 0:28SPEAKER_01: my homeboy,
- 0:29SPEAKER_01: my compadre,
- 0:32SPEAKER_01: Mr.
- 0:32SPEAKER_01: Michael Downs.
- 0:33SPEAKER_01: Let's give him a round of applause.
- 0:36SPEAKER_01: All right.
- 0:38SPEAKER_01: All right, Mikey.
- 0:40SPEAKER_01: So I'm very happy to have you on.
- 0:55and today we'll be discussing artificial intelligence um agi si
- 1:01um and like i said
- 1:04going to we haven't had the conversation yet i'm recording this
- 1:09beforehand um so i
- 1:11don't know i'm not going to give you a roadmap i'm just going
- 1:13to tell you what it
- 1:14SPEAKER_01: is um mikey and i have been talking about
- 1:18Doing something with some kind of regularity where we take some
- 1:21of the discussions
- 1:22SPEAKER_01: we're already having about theory and philosophy and just,
- 1:27SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:28SPEAKER_01: make videos and make podcast episodes out of it.
- 1:31SPEAKER_01: We're already discussing lots of stuff,
- 1:34SPEAKER_01: AI,
- 1:35SPEAKER_01: accelerationism,
- 1:36SPEAKER_01: theories of time,
- 1:37SPEAKER_01: A time,
- 1:39SPEAKER_01: B time,
- 1:40SPEAKER_01: all at once or Sudoku,
- 1:42SPEAKER_01: these things.
- 1:44SPEAKER_01: But yeah, we want to do something with some kind of regularity.
- 1:49SPEAKER_01: And I don't know what that's going to look like.
- 1:51SPEAKER_01: But I am excited.
- 1:52SPEAKER_01: It's going to be dope.
- 1:54SPEAKER_01: Mikey is the homie.
- 1:56SPEAKER_01: Mikey is the dangerous maybe on Substack and YouTube.
- 2:02SPEAKER_01: If you're not already subscribed, you should be.
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: So go correct that.
- 2:07SPEAKER_01: But I'm going to...
- 2:08i'm just gonna believe that everyone who's seeing this and
- 2:11hearing this is already
- 2:12subscribed to mikey uh you're gonna want to make sure to pay
- 2:16attention to the
- 2:17dangerous maybe on youtube here in the near future there will
- 2:21be a lot of exciting
- 2:22SPEAKER_01: things happening over there um so make sure you turn on notifications
- 2:28The links will be down in the description for anyone who isn't
- 2:32already subscribed.
- 2:32SPEAKER_01: But like I said, yeah, you're all already subscribed.
- 2:38SPEAKER_01: This is going to be great.
- 2:39SPEAKER_01: Like I said, it's just going to be kind of a broad discussion.
- 2:42SPEAKER_01: No real agenda.
- 2:43SPEAKER_01: I've got some notes.
- 2:44SPEAKER_01: Mikey's got some notes.
- 2:46SPEAKER_01: But we just want to kick some ideas around and like have a discussion,
- 2:49SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 2:50SPEAKER_01: and make the conversations we're already having.
- 2:53SPEAKER_01: You know, make it public because we want to get in there.
- 2:57SPEAKER_01: You know, AI is a huge topic.
- 3:01SPEAKER_01: The overwhelming majority of people who are discussing it,
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: though,
- 3:06SPEAKER_01: aren't coming at it from a philosophical perspective or at least the same
- 3:09SPEAKER_01: philosophical perspective that we share.
- 3:13SPEAKER_01: And we think it's important.
- 3:16SPEAKER_01: So thanks for coming along.
- 3:18SPEAKER_01: Make sure to stick around.
- 3:19SPEAKER_01: This is going to be excellent.
- 3:21SPEAKER_01: And we will see you soon, actually.
- 3:24SPEAKER_01: I'll be right back.
- 3:25SPEAKER_01: And Mike, you'll be here with me.
- 3:26SPEAKER_03: It's the best podcast ever.
- 3:31SPEAKER_03: Nerdscast.
- 3:37SPEAKER_03: Welcome, you're listening to the Nerds.
- 3:41SPEAKER_01: And now we are recording.
- 3:44SPEAKER_01: Dude, what's up, dude?
- 3:46SPEAKER_01: What's cracking?
- 3:47SPEAKER_01: How goes it?
- 3:48SPEAKER_01: I'm chilling, man.
- 3:51SPEAKER_01: Your fucking setup looks crispy back there, dude.
- 3:53SPEAKER_02: A little different, huh?
- 3:54SPEAKER_01: Looks good.
- 3:55SPEAKER_02: Different from the last time.
- 3:57SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's amazing what a couple light bulbs will do for you.
- 3:59SPEAKER_01: Yeah, dude.
- 4:01SPEAKER_01: Sound good, too.
- 4:02SPEAKER_01: I'm excited.
- 4:04SPEAKER_01: I'm very excited.
- 4:05SPEAKER_01: We have been talking about...
- 4:08artificial intelligence artificial general intelligence
- 4:12synthetic intelligence
- 4:14human intelligence like intelligence as such like like we've
- 4:17been talking about
- 4:18this for a while but we've never actually just sat down to to
- 4:22discuss it yeah um
- 4:25and i'm i'm excited um there are a lot of people talking about
- 4:31ai on the internet
- 4:34But the overwhelming majority of them are coming at it from a
- 4:38very instrumental
- 4:39SPEAKER_01: position already,
- 4:40SPEAKER_01: like the hard sciences.
- 4:41They're coming at it from computer science or systems theory,
- 4:46maths,
- 4:47stuff like that.
- 4:47SPEAKER_01: There are some, but there are not a whole lot.
- 4:50SPEAKER_01: Shout out Cadell.
- 4:51SPEAKER_01: You've been doing good work all along.
- 4:54SPEAKER_01: Other people as well.
- 4:56SPEAKER_01: We mentioned Julie Resch in our talk before we started.
- 5:00SPEAKER_01: But there's only a few people who have...
- 5:03SPEAKER_01: a love for and background in,
- 5:05SPEAKER_01: or at least familiarity with,
- 5:07SPEAKER_01: continental theory,
- 5:10SPEAKER_01: philosophy as such,
- 5:12SPEAKER_01: who are really discussing artificial intelligence,
- 5:15SPEAKER_01: theory of mind,
- 5:18SPEAKER_01: intelligence,
- 5:19SPEAKER_01: once again,
- 5:19SPEAKER_01: in general,
- 5:20SPEAKER_01: because to problematize artificial intelligence,
- 5:24SPEAKER_01: you really should talk about the artificial,
- 5:26SPEAKER_01: the technological side,
- 5:27SPEAKER_01: but you also really need to ask the questions about intelligence.
- 5:31A lot of these hard sciences people don't interrogate
- 5:35intelligence itself.
- 5:37SPEAKER_02: Or the human.
- 5:38SPEAKER_02: They take the human for granted.
- 5:40SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 5:40SPEAKER_01: Just the other day, we coined a neologism.
- 5:42SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 5:47SPEAKER_02: Yeah, our little brainstorm session.
- 5:49SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 5:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we came up with, what, two terms.
- 5:52SPEAKER_02: Two terms.
- 5:53SPEAKER_02: A little distinction.
- 5:54SPEAKER_01: So,
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: background on these terms,
- 5:57SPEAKER_01: I told you,
- 5:58SPEAKER_01: like,
- 5:58SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 5:59so I've been using intelligence and intellect to distinguish
- 6:03between machine
- 6:04SPEAKER_01: intelligence and human intelligence.
- 6:05SPEAKER_01: But that's not satisfying because Bergson...
- 6:09uh juxtaposes intuition and intellect and that's that's a valid
- 6:14point he's doing
- 6:15something worth taking seriously when he does that and so i
- 6:18wasn't satisfied with
- 6:19using intellect to represent uh spirit and like this kind of
- 6:25dialectical process of
- 6:26human intelligence as opposed to just rote instrumental reason
- 6:31so i was like we
- 6:31SPEAKER_01: need to come up with a way to say it quick and easy
- 6:35like what I was trying to achieve with intelligence and
- 6:37intellect but that falls
- 6:39short and you just you came back like off the dome you're like
- 6:43well what about
- 6:44these two new words men-telligence and hen-telligence yeah and
- 6:52I fucking love it
- 6:53SPEAKER_01: dude
- 6:54SPEAKER_02: I do, too.
- 6:55SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 6:55SPEAKER_02: there's and it's not just,
- 6:57SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 6:58put the M on intelligence and for machine intelligence and the
- 7:02H on intelligence
- 7:04SPEAKER_02: for human intelligence.
- 7:05SPEAKER_02: It's it's unique what they give us.
- 7:10SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 7:10SPEAKER_02: Because, I mean, you were pointing out about intelligence.
- 7:12SPEAKER_02: You want to say it?
- 7:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 7:14SPEAKER_01: So Marvin Minsky is a systems theory guy.
- 7:20SPEAKER_01: Herman Minkowski is a mathematician.
- 7:23Like Minkowski space is like the representation of physical
- 7:27space minus gravity.
- 7:30SPEAKER_01: And like Marvin Minsky was a computer scientist.
- 7:35So there's this cool little resonance,
- 7:36Min,
- 7:37Minkowski,
- 7:38Minsky,
- 7:39but it also like minimum.
- 7:43like min-telligence represents like the minimum floor of what
- 7:48it takes to be
- 7:48SPEAKER_01: recognized as intelligence.
- 7:50So intelligence means you can act in a goal-oriented way in and
- 7:55on the world.
- 7:56SPEAKER_01: It's proficiency at playing games.
- 7:58SPEAKER_01: It's problem-solving.
- 8:00SPEAKER_01: It's all this kind of like stuff that algorithms can do.
- 8:06SPEAKER_01: So it's the minimum threshold of intelligence.
- 8:09SPEAKER_01: But people...
- 8:12SPEAKER_01: are satisfied to, to just stay there with instrumental reason.
- 8:15SPEAKER_01: But I like it because, uh, it's already diminutive.
- 8:19Like we're already saying men intelligence is the minimum,
- 8:23like that's our floor.
- 8:24SPEAKER_01: And then over here with the human side,
- 8:27SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: we're,
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: we're soaring up in the clouds and,
- 8:30SPEAKER_01: and the machine intelligence guys are down here at the basement.
- 8:34SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 8:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 8:35SPEAKER_02: And I mean, so yes.
- 8:38SPEAKER_02: And then,
- 8:39SPEAKER_02: On the hintelligence side,
- 8:40SPEAKER_02: what I like about it is the first,
- 8:45SPEAKER_02: if you want to think of it as a prefix,
- 8:46SPEAKER_02: the first syllable is hint.
- 8:50And doesn't that really get at something about our kind of
- 8:53intelligence that we are
- 8:55SPEAKER_02: able to take hints,
- 8:56SPEAKER_02: which is we are able to interpret,
- 8:58SPEAKER_02: pick up on,
- 9:00SPEAKER_02: and respond to
- 9:02SPEAKER_02: unspoken, uncoded dynamics.
- 9:04SPEAKER_02: I mean, that's uniquely, there's the hat, right?
- 9:06SPEAKER_02: The old Dasein hat over here.
- 9:09That's what Dasein does for Heidegger is Dasein is able to
- 9:12figure out how to get it
- 9:13SPEAKER_02: right,
- 9:15SPEAKER_02: how to navigate without coded explicit rules.
- 9:21And that's the weird type of intelligence we have where it
- 9:25doesn't have to be coded
- 9:27SPEAKER_02: for us to get it right.
- 9:28SPEAKER_02: Now, sometimes we encounter a lack of
- 9:32In the social structure,
- 9:33in the symbolic order,
- 9:34and we don't know how to proceed.
- 9:35SPEAKER_02: That's true.
- 9:35SPEAKER_02: That happens.
- 9:37But oftentimes we don't have to have an already existing
- 9:43explicit rule to go off of
- 9:46SPEAKER_02: in order to navigate the situation.
- 9:49SPEAKER_02: And in that sense.
- 9:51SPEAKER_02: It's like we're taking a hint, but in a broader sense of hint.
- 9:55SPEAKER_02: That's so fucking good, dude.
- 9:57SPEAKER_02: And so I like this idea of hint-telligence for that reason.
- 10:00SPEAKER_01: That's so good.
- 10:02And I think,
- 10:03too,
- 10:04it points to the transcendental nature of human intelligence.
- 10:12SPEAKER_01: The world is very much a paint-by-numbers.
- 10:17The framework is there,
- 10:18but by way of the transcendental,
- 10:19we do work to fill in the blanks.
- 10:22SPEAKER_01: We do work by way of interpretation,
- 10:25SPEAKER_01: by way of perception that can be faulty and can be mistaken,
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: but we are already implicated in the world around us.
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: by this like transcendental way.
- 10:36SPEAKER_01: And,
- 10:36SPEAKER_01: and yeah,
- 10:37SPEAKER_01: like we fill in the gaps and what do you do when you're playing puzzles,
- 10:40SPEAKER_01: you play with hints,
- 10:41SPEAKER_01: you get a hint to solve the puzzle.
- 10:44SPEAKER_01: So you,
- 10:45SPEAKER_01: you come to the puzzle,
- 10:46SPEAKER_01: the pieces are there,
- 10:48but you are implicated in assembling the picture and that's the
- 10:53way the world
- 10:55SPEAKER_01: works.
- 10:57SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 10:58SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 10:58SPEAKER_02: I mean, and, and I mean,
- 11:01SPEAKER_02: The point is a hint gives you something to respond to,
- 11:04SPEAKER_02: but you ultimately have to be creative with the response.
- 11:08SPEAKER_02: And so creativity is baked into the response to a hint.
- 11:12SPEAKER_02: And I mean, isn't that the issue with our chat bots?
- 11:17SPEAKER_02: Can they really solve problems?
- 11:21SPEAKER_02: Right now, can we say, hey, poverty is a structural problem in society.
- 11:26SPEAKER_02: Just tell us how to solve that.
- 11:28SPEAKER_02: It can't.
- 11:28SPEAKER_02: Or even tell it to,
- 11:29SPEAKER_02: like,
- 11:30SPEAKER_02: hey,
- 11:31SPEAKER_02: I think I heard Todd McGowan say this on a recent episode of Y Theory,
- 11:34SPEAKER_02: where he's like,
- 11:35SPEAKER_02: can you tell it to solve Russell's paradox?
- 11:39SPEAKER_02: You know?
- 11:40SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 11:41Yeah,
- 11:42it doesn't seem to give us anything new in the sense of,
- 11:48like,
- 11:48responding to a hint.
- 11:49Sure,
- 11:49it can combine things we already have and give us something new
- 11:52in that way.
- 11:54SPEAKER_02: but does it actually break ground?
- 11:57SPEAKER_01: Not yet.
- 11:59SPEAKER_01: And I mean,
- 12:01SPEAKER_01: to jump the gun a little bit,
- 12:03SPEAKER_01: but yeah,
- 12:04SPEAKER_01: if you told an AI right now,
- 12:07like if they came up with the most powerful AI that exists and
- 12:10they released it to,
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: we'll say Canada,
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: because Canada,
- 12:13SPEAKER_01: they're nice people there.
- 12:14So Canada gets their hands on Googlebot 9 million X or
- 12:20whatever,
- 12:21and they say solve poverty.
- 12:24SPEAKER_01: I think it's highly likely that the machine would say,
- 12:28SPEAKER_01: well,
- 12:28the quickest way to solve this problem is get rid of the cause
- 12:34of the problem.
- 12:35SPEAKER_01: What is ultimately the cause of poverty?
- 12:39SPEAKER_01: What is the cause of human poverty?
- 12:41SPEAKER_01: It's a human problem.
- 12:42SPEAKER_01: If we just get rid of humans, human poverty will go away.
- 12:48SPEAKER_02: We're already pointing ahead to this issue concerning orthogonality,
- 12:52SPEAKER_02: which we're going to get to in this discussion.
- 12:55SPEAKER_02: But no, I mean, see, it brings us back to that big issue.
- 13:01SPEAKER_02: And I mean, I understand both sides of this argument.
- 13:05SPEAKER_02: I tend to... I kind of just spontaneously...
- 13:13SPEAKER_02: I see how Bostrom gets to where he gets.
- 13:18SPEAKER_02: It makes a lot of sense to me.
- 13:19SPEAKER_02: I also see how Lan comes back and critiques it.
- 13:22SPEAKER_02: But we are getting ahead.
- 13:23SPEAKER_02: We'll get to that in a little bit.
- 13:25SPEAKER_02: As far as the hint intelligence,
- 13:28SPEAKER_02: look,
- 13:28I think a lot of what we're doing is always going to be drawing
- 13:35from Baudrillard.
- 13:37SPEAKER_02: And he's one of our core thinkers.
- 13:40SPEAKER_02: And there's this great quote
- 13:43Where Baudrillard basically is describing the whole situation
- 13:47back in the 90s where
- 13:50SPEAKER_02: the great chess player played the chess AI.
- 13:54SPEAKER_01: Oh, Deep Blue, Gary Kasparov in Deep Blue, was it?
- 13:58SPEAKER_02: I think that's it.
- 13:59SPEAKER_02: So let me find it here.
- 14:01SPEAKER_02: I got the quote.
- 14:01SPEAKER_02: It's worth reading here.
- 14:03SPEAKER_01: Interestingly enough,
- 14:05SPEAKER_01: Kasparov actually went on to work with,
- 14:08SPEAKER_01: I think he worked with Steven Wolfram in AI development,
- 14:12SPEAKER_01: but he was fucking pissed when the,
- 14:14SPEAKER_01: when the,
- 14:15SPEAKER_01: when the machine beat him,
- 14:17SPEAKER_01: he was very publicly pissed.
- 14:20SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 14:20SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 14:21SPEAKER_02: you can't,
- 14:21SPEAKER_02: you can't blame him on that,
- 14:22SPEAKER_02: but I actually,
- 14:24SPEAKER_02: so I,
- 14:24SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 14:25SPEAKER_02: in my book,
- 14:27SPEAKER_02: I quote this.
- 14:27SPEAKER_02: And so just for context, I'll, I'll read the paragraph before I quote it.
- 14:33SPEAKER_02: Um,
- 14:34I'm talking about Hubert Dreyfus here who wrote one of the most
- 14:36famous critiques of
- 14:38SPEAKER_02: artificial intelligence.
- 14:40SPEAKER_02: Dreyfus's critique of AI boils down to this.
- 14:43We cannot program machines to have our type of intelligence
- 14:46precisely because our
- 14:47SPEAKER_02: intelligence is itself not programmed.
- 14:51SPEAKER_02: Again, it takes hints.
- 14:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah, man.
- 14:53SPEAKER_02: In that sense.
- 14:54But what happens if AI programmers actually were to take some
- 14:58of Dreyfus' criticism
- 14:59SPEAKER_02: seriously and find a way to program AI in such a way as to mimic our own
- 15:05SPEAKER_02: non-programmed intelligence?
- 15:08SPEAKER_02: In some way, is this not what's going on with deep learning programs?
- 15:14SPEAKER_02: Once the deep learning crosses certain thresholds,
- 15:17there's no way for us to even understand what's going on in the
- 15:20program as it
- 15:21SPEAKER_02: develops its own neural network.
- 15:24The Netflix film AlphaGo documents all this as world-class Go
- 15:30players attempt to
- 15:31SPEAKER_02: beat the computer program AlphaGo at the board game.
- 15:35SPEAKER_02: Spoiler alert, the humans end up losing to the AI.
- 15:39SPEAKER_02: And even earlier,
- 15:40SPEAKER_02: in 1996 and 1997,
- 15:42world chess champion Garry Kasparov played chess against an IBM
- 15:47supercomputer named
- 15:48SPEAKER_02: Deep Blue.
- 15:51SPEAKER_02: Kasparov won the first match, whereas Deep Blue won the second.
- 15:55which was of huge significance in the history of the relation
- 15:59between human and machine.
- 16:01SPEAKER_02: In his analysis of the situation,
- 16:03SPEAKER_02: Baudrillard wrote,
- 16:05SPEAKER_02: but to come back to Kasparov,
- 16:08SPEAKER_02: if he won,
- 16:09SPEAKER_02: it was surely because he is,
- 16:11SPEAKER_02: metaphorically,
- 16:12SPEAKER_02: capable of speaking more than one language,
- 16:15SPEAKER_02: that of the emotions,
- 16:17SPEAKER_02: of intuition,
- 16:19SPEAKER_02: of the stratagem,
- 16:21SPEAKER_02: in a word,
- 16:22SPEAKER_02: the language of play.
- 16:24SPEAKER_02: not to mention the language of calculation,
- 16:27SPEAKER_02: whereas Deep Blue speaks only the language of calculation.
- 16:31The day this latter language prevails in whatever form,
- 16:36Kasparov will be beaten.
- 16:38SPEAKER_02: The day man himself speaks only that single language,
- 16:41SPEAKER_02: the language of computers,
- 16:43SPEAKER_02: he will be beaten.
- 16:46SPEAKER_02: And so this list that he names off,
- 16:49SPEAKER_02: so we don't just speak the language of calculation,
- 16:52SPEAKER_02: we speak the language of emotions,
- 16:54SPEAKER_02: intuition, stratagem, and play.
- 16:59SPEAKER_02: And all of this is tied up with what Baudrillard calls symbolic exchange.
- 17:04SPEAKER_02: And symbolic exchange, of course, is where you exchange gifts or values.
- 17:11SPEAKER_02: He don't like the word value.
- 17:12SPEAKER_02: He's going to oppose value to symbolic exchange.
- 17:16But loosely using the term,
- 17:20symbolic exchange creates values that are not coded
- 17:24SPEAKER_02: or programmed.
- 17:26SPEAKER_02: They are between the individuals exchanging.
- 17:30SPEAKER_02: They are local values.
- 17:34SPEAKER_02: This is what we mean a lot of the time by sentimental value.
- 17:39SPEAKER_02: But this really gets at this difference between us and machines.
- 17:44And it's funny,
- 17:45the whole thing with intelligence,
- 17:47I love that you responded with intuition.
- 17:53SPEAKER_02: Intuition.
- 17:55is some kind of intelligence that knows the situation without
- 18:00having it explicitly
- 18:02SPEAKER_02: codified for it.
- 18:03SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 18:04SPEAKER_02: And so I like that he lists that there,
- 18:08SPEAKER_02: but yeah,
- 18:10SPEAKER_02: this is what we're,
- 18:12SPEAKER_02: we're very much interested in is this,
- 18:15SPEAKER_02: this divide between machinic intelligence and human intelligence.
- 18:22SPEAKER_02: And yeah,
- 18:24exploring what that divide entails and i feel like uh not to be
- 18:34sensational and i i
- 18:36often find myself like doing caveats and and qualifying but i
- 18:42do feel like our time
- 18:44SPEAKER_01: is short i do feel like
- 18:47SPEAKER_01: Baudrillard says we,
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: essentially what he's saying,
- 18:52SPEAKER_01: to sum that up,
- 18:53SPEAKER_01: not all what he's saying,
- 18:55SPEAKER_01: but part of what he's saying there is the more human than human argument.
- 18:59SPEAKER_01: Like PKD,
- 19:00SPEAKER_01: Philip K.
- 19:00Dick was not saying we're building machines that are hyper real
- 19:05and thus better
- 19:06SPEAKER_01: than us.
- 19:08SPEAKER_01: He's saying we are changing.
- 19:10SPEAKER_01: Like our thought changes.
- 19:11human thought this intelligence is being replaced by this men
- 19:16intelligence we are
- 19:17the ones who are changing it's not that we're being replaced by
- 19:20the new or better
- 19:21model it's that we are dumbing ourselves down to speak crudely
- 19:26to this very rote
- 19:28very arithmetic way of thinking we've thrown out play and
- 19:32emotion and intuition and
- 19:35SPEAKER_01: we've replaced it with just calculation we we
- 19:39SPEAKER_01: Because capital has captured planet Earth,
- 19:43SPEAKER_01: because it's this global system of exchange,
- 19:46SPEAKER_01: we can't have local value or sentimental value or symbolic exchange.
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: Everything has to be global exchange.
- 19:54SPEAKER_01: It has to be commensurate under the system of capital.
- 19:58We all only speak one language anymore,
- 20:00and it's the language of exchange value.
- 20:02Well,
- 20:03not exchange value,
- 20:04because we go on to signed value,
- 20:06fractal value.
- 20:07SPEAKER_01: I want to come up with waste as opposed to value,
- 20:11SPEAKER_01: but the language that we speak has been captured.
- 20:17SPEAKER_01: We aren't allowed to create or...
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: or even hold dearly sentimental value anymore because we are changing.
- 20:29SPEAKER_01: It's not that the robots are coming to take your jobs.
- 20:31SPEAKER_01: Same thing with immigration.
- 20:33SPEAKER_01: People here in Arizona that yell about immigration,
- 20:36SPEAKER_01: they're not out there picking celery or picking peaches.
- 20:41SPEAKER_01: They're not coming to take your jobs.
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: Same thing.
- 20:44SPEAKER_01: The machines are not coming to replace us.
- 20:46SPEAKER_01: We are dumbing ourselves down.
- 20:48SPEAKER_01: And I do feel like we're living in a moment.
- 20:52SPEAKER_01: And if we don't do something, there will be no human.
- 20:57SPEAKER_01: I do think Nick is right, Land.
- 21:00SPEAKER_01: If nothing changes, nothing human will make it out of the near future.
- 21:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 21:07SPEAKER_02: Or will the cute.
- 21:09SPEAKER_02: So hold on, hold on, hold on.
- 21:11SPEAKER_02: Before we go to that.
- 21:11SPEAKER_02: So I think it's interesting,
- 21:13SPEAKER_02: though,
- 21:14SPEAKER_02: considering that when we spoke to Nick Land,
- 21:18SPEAKER_02: how did he define intelligence?
- 21:20SPEAKER_02: It's the ability to play games.
- 21:24SPEAKER_02: And it's funny,
- 21:25SPEAKER_02: Baudrillard is saying,
- 21:26SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 21:27SPEAKER_02: but I think Baudrillard would say to Nick,
- 21:29SPEAKER_02: he'd go,
- 21:30SPEAKER_02: sure,
- 21:32SPEAKER_02: but there's more to games than just calculation.
- 21:36SPEAKER_03: Ooh.
- 21:38Because Nick isn't going to include this human component of
- 21:43emotions and intuition
- 21:46SPEAKER_02: and these uniquely human capabilities.
- 21:49He would just say intelligence as such is the ability to play
- 21:54and probably increase
- 21:56SPEAKER_02: your ability to play games successfully.
- 22:00SPEAKER_01: Nick is satisfied with min-intelligence.
- 22:05SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 22:06SPEAKER_02: He thinks the human is an obstacle.
- 22:10SPEAKER_02: Human intelligence...
- 22:11SPEAKER_02: Sure,
- 22:12SPEAKER_02: the machine's going to have to use the human to break through,
- 22:15SPEAKER_02: to transcend us.
- 22:18SPEAKER_02: So, yeah, it's going to... We're like its host.
- 22:21SPEAKER_01: It's reproductive organs.
- 22:23SPEAKER_01: Thank you, Marshall McLuhan.
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: We are the sex organs of the machine.
- 22:30But,
- 22:30yeah,
- 22:30for Baudrillard,
- 22:31he would say that...
- 22:33I mean,
- 22:33they would both...
- 22:34Land and Baudrillard would agree that this process is chipping
- 22:40away at us as humans.
- 22:42Baudrillard wants us to find ways to resist it via symbolic
- 22:45exchange and the
- 22:46SPEAKER_02: utilization of seduction and other strategies,
- 22:51SPEAKER_02: fatal strategies.
- 22:52SPEAKER_02: But land is just no.
- 22:57SPEAKER_02: Resistance is futile.
- 22:59SPEAKER_02: Give into the process, right?
- 23:02SPEAKER_01: And I think it's a
- 23:05SPEAKER_01: It's a delicate balance because I've often said Nick Land is right.
- 23:12SPEAKER_01: Now, I don't think I've ever said Nick Land is right about everything.
- 23:16SPEAKER_01: But I do think the world we live in today,
- 23:20SPEAKER_01: resistance is futile,
- 23:22SPEAKER_01: is an accurate statement,
- 23:24SPEAKER_01: which is why we have to...
- 23:26like find a way to do something new you know maybe we need to
- 23:32just discover some
- 23:33novelty or something I don't know but again Nick is right we're
- 23:40fucked unless we
- 23:42figure out how to stop this long steady decline into machinic
- 23:48intelligence
- 23:50SPEAKER_02: You know, it's interesting, Nance, is that I saw a short little video.
- 23:53I think you made it recently,
- 23:54if I'm not mistaken,
- 23:55but it was by Peter Coffin.
- 23:57SPEAKER_02: And in it,
- 23:58SPEAKER_02: he was just basically explaining why he dislikes Mark Fisher so much,
- 24:02SPEAKER_02: especially capitalist realism.
- 24:06SPEAKER_02: And he's saying, look, it's defeatist.
- 24:09SPEAKER_02: It's doomerist.
- 24:12SPEAKER_02: It gets everybody.
- 24:13SPEAKER_02: Transcendental miserableism to do.
- 24:15SPEAKER_02: So give up.
- 24:16SPEAKER_02: I don't think that was a spirit of Fisher at all,
- 24:19but I understand how people could read capitalist realism and
- 24:22walk away with that.
- 24:24SPEAKER_02: But my thing is Peter's just kind of going, oh yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 24:30SPEAKER_02: I think that's bullshit.
- 24:32And I can't do that because one,
- 24:35all of my,
- 24:36everybody I work with camera too.
- 24:38SPEAKER_03: Sorry.
- 24:41Everybody I work with is a capitalist realist in one way or
- 24:44another working class people.
- 24:46SPEAKER_02: they're capitalist realists.
- 24:48SPEAKER_02: So you kind of have to understand that the working class at this point,
- 24:52SPEAKER_02: they don't really feel like there's an alternative.
- 24:54SPEAKER_02: They know they want something more,
- 24:56SPEAKER_02: but they think the only way to have more is,
- 25:00SPEAKER_02: and they feel stuck because they,
- 25:02SPEAKER_02: they say capitalism,
- 25:03SPEAKER_02: they know there's something wrong with that,
- 25:05SPEAKER_02: but they certainly don't want socialism.
- 25:08SPEAKER_02: And despite what certain people would say, they don't want fascism.
- 25:11SPEAKER_02: They want something more and they don't know how to get it or, or,
- 25:15SPEAKER_02: They don't have any faith in anything outside of capitalism,
- 25:19SPEAKER_02: but they also don't have faith in capitalism itself.
- 25:22SPEAKER_02: And that is where some of the defeatism comes into play.
- 25:26SPEAKER_02: And I think you've got to let people have that.
- 25:29SPEAKER_02: Because I think that is that feeling in a Heideggerian way.
- 25:35SPEAKER_02: I think that attunement is revealing the state of affairs.
- 25:39And this is why Zizek,
- 25:41one of his more recent books,
- 25:43is titled The Courage of Hopelessness.
- 25:45I think you have to have this encounter with the hopeless in
- 25:51order to begin to
- 25:52SPEAKER_02: respond to the situation at all.
- 25:55SPEAKER_02: Um,
- 25:56it's not that you're sure some people might just say fuck it
- 25:59and give up and just
- 26:01SPEAKER_02: live whatever life they can eke out.
- 26:02But I think people who want to see a change have to reckon with
- 26:07that being the
- 26:09SPEAKER_02: dynamic at work in the system and have the courage of hopelessness.
- 26:15SPEAKER_02: And so for me,
- 26:17SPEAKER_02: I see a lot of people,
- 26:18SPEAKER_02: whether it's Peter Coffin or others,
- 26:20SPEAKER_02: see a lot of people wanting to go,
- 26:22SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 26:22SPEAKER_02: Fisher had a time.
- 26:23SPEAKER_02: Let's, let's move on.
- 26:25SPEAKER_02: And for me,
- 26:26SPEAKER_02: as just a guy who works in a warehouse with blue-collar type of workers,
- 26:34SPEAKER_02: capitalist realism is as relevant as it's ever been from my perspective.
- 26:40SPEAKER_02: I understand theorists always want to move on and find a different way,
- 26:45SPEAKER_02: and they don't want to just reproduce the same thing over and over again.
- 26:49But as far as the existential dynamic of many of the workers I
- 26:53know,
- 26:54it's still...
- 26:55SPEAKER_02: good old fashioned capitalist realism.
- 26:58SPEAKER_01: So yeah, dude.
- 27:00SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 27:04SPEAKER_01: The transcendental miserablest dismissal.
- 27:08SPEAKER_01: I think that's a hand wave away.
- 27:09Like I do think you have to confront reality in order to try to
- 27:17change it.
- 27:17SPEAKER_01: And like in order to try to change something, you have to understand it.
- 27:21SPEAKER_01: And if you're lying to yourself, it's not going to work.
- 27:25SPEAKER_01: The world is miserable.
- 27:26SPEAKER_01: The world is horrible.
- 27:27SPEAKER_01: And this is currently the only fucking game in town.
- 27:33SPEAKER_01: So it's not like a gleeful embrace of capitalist realism.
- 27:39SPEAKER_01: It's like,
- 27:40SPEAKER_01: no,
- 27:40we need to put our big boy pants on and realize this is the
- 27:44conditions on the
- 27:45SPEAKER_01: ground.
- 27:46SPEAKER_01: Now let's try to do something about it.
- 27:47SPEAKER_01: So yeah, I don't like it when people try to just hand wave it away.
- 27:52Yeah,
- 27:52and I mean Slavoj doesn't,
- 27:54he's certainly not a defeatist or a doomer.
- 27:56SPEAKER_02: He might have pessimistic tendencies here and there, but
- 28:01SPEAKER_02: not when it comes to the,
- 28:03SPEAKER_02: the global situation,
- 28:04SPEAKER_02: he still believes in the,
- 28:05SPEAKER_02: he,
- 28:06SPEAKER_02: he and Nick land both believe in miracles.
- 28:08SPEAKER_02: It's one of the weird, uh, commonalities.
- 28:11SPEAKER_02: They both believe in where something miraculous can happen.
- 28:13SPEAKER_02: Now they interpret that in different ways,
- 28:15SPEAKER_02: but for Slava,
- 28:16he does think that a restructuration of the symbolic order
- 28:21through an act or
- 28:22SPEAKER_02: through an event is still possible.
- 28:25SPEAKER_02: And that our symbolic framework, even at the global level can,
- 28:32SPEAKER_02: undergo a radical reform reformation.
- 28:36SPEAKER_02: And so,
- 28:39SPEAKER_02: but he also knows that there's no way to just plan this,
- 28:42SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 28:42SPEAKER_02: strategically or practically events happen.
- 28:46SPEAKER_02: There's something it's almost like they're their own agency.
- 28:51And,
- 28:53but,
- 28:53but what you can do is be attuned to the situation to the best
- 28:57of your ability.
- 28:59SPEAKER_02: And,
- 29:00SPEAKER_02: be ready for an event as much as you can prepare for such a thing.
- 29:05But the courage of hopelessness is more like,
- 29:07no feel how bad and how hopeless it actually is.
- 29:11SPEAKER_02: And then on the basis of that,
- 29:14SPEAKER_02: then,
- 29:15then try to comport yourselves towards the world on the basis
- 29:20of that hopelessness
- 29:22SPEAKER_02: in order to try to prepare or cultivate the,
- 29:26SPEAKER_02: the,
- 29:28possibility of an event yeah it's almost like events uh are
- 29:35clawing their way into
- 29:37the present from the future like they do just kind of happen
- 29:41they do have their own
- 29:43SPEAKER_01: inertia um
- 29:46Nick Land is hip to that that's why hyperstition is such a big
- 29:50thing and it is you
- 29:54gotta face reality you have to confront reality you can't sit
- 29:59back and delude
- 30:00yourself with your happy little fantasies I guess that would be
- 30:04the difference that
- 30:05Nick thinks miracles come from the outside and there's no
- 30:08miracles coming for
- 30:09SPEAKER_00: humanity yeah dude yeah
- 30:15SPEAKER_00: Hmm.
- 30:17SPEAKER_02: Where Slavoie thinks we can, a kind of symbolic miracle can occur for us.
- 30:26SPEAKER_01: So that's like outside in versus inside out,
- 30:30SPEAKER_01: like something's coming like extra P versus entropy,
- 30:34SPEAKER_01: like,
- 30:35SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 30:36SPEAKER_01: I mean, you could even say that's a difference in, like, views of time.
- 30:40SPEAKER_01: Like, is the arrow of time moving forward?
- 30:43SPEAKER_01: Is the arrow of time moving backward?
- 30:44SPEAKER_01: Is the arrow of time moving at all?
- 30:51SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 30:51SPEAKER_02: and you get into this kind of...
- 30:53SPEAKER_02: If you read Badoo with land and then with...
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: Anybody who thinks about this kind of...
- 31:00SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 31:00SPEAKER_02: and Zizek,
- 31:02SPEAKER_02: because Zizek's always emphasizing retroactivity.
- 31:05But for Bidou,
- 31:07the event is a radical rupture in the status quo,
- 31:10in the situation.
- 31:12SPEAKER_02: And yet,
- 31:13SPEAKER_02: it comes out of the situation,
- 31:14but it's certainly not reducible to the situation because it's
- 31:17precisely what
- 31:18SPEAKER_02: ruptures the situation.
- 31:20SPEAKER_02: And so,
- 31:20SPEAKER_02: I think Heidegger maybe was best attuned to this where he's like,
- 31:26the event is causeless in the sense that you can't pin it down
- 31:30to anything going on
- 31:33SPEAKER_02: prior to its
- 31:35evental occurrence um and so i think that's heidegger's way of
- 31:41trying to say like
- 31:41the causality here doesn't work in linear fashion yeah like if
- 31:47you try to force
- 31:47because basically what you're doing is you're trying to explain
- 31:51all this stuff is
- 31:51SPEAKER_02: happening here on the ground in society and for him that's an ontic
- 31:57SPEAKER_02: account of what's going on,
- 31:59SPEAKER_02: and yet the event is what sends a new understanding of being,
- 32:02SPEAKER_02: where everything is now disclosed in a radically new way.
- 32:08So that can't be reducible to ontic occurrences or occurrences
- 32:12or happenings
- 32:13SPEAKER_02: between beings,
- 32:14SPEAKER_02: between existence.
- 32:18SPEAKER_02: So yeah, for him, it's this very miraculous, mysterious thing.
- 32:24SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 32:32SPEAKER_00: I had to spit my chew out.
- 32:35SPEAKER_00: What do you think?
- 32:38SPEAKER_02: This is one of these forks in the road.
- 32:41SPEAKER_02: We can go a couple different places.
- 32:45SPEAKER_02: We kind of alluded to it.
- 32:46SPEAKER_02: Should we get cute for a minute?
- 32:50SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 32:50SPEAKER_02: Let's do it, man.
- 32:52SPEAKER_02: You and I both read this book this week.
- 32:56SPEAKER_02: The Cute Acceleration.
- 32:58SPEAKER_00: Acceleration.
- 33:00SPEAKER_02: by Amy Ireland and Maya B. Chronic.
- 33:04SPEAKER_02: And so this is the new ACK.
- 33:06SPEAKER_02: And for anybody who doesn't know,
- 33:09SPEAKER_02: the word accelerationism gets abbreviated and it's usually...
- 33:13SPEAKER_02: Slash ACK.
- 33:14SPEAKER_02: Slash ACC.
- 33:16SPEAKER_02: And then they put the qualifier on the other side.
- 33:18SPEAKER_02: So left accelerationism gets written as L slash ACC.
- 33:26SPEAKER_02: Zero accelerationism...
- 33:28You know,
- 33:28our friend James Ellis,
- 33:30his form of accelerationism is Z slash ACC.
- 33:33SPEAKER_02: So now we have Q back.
- 33:36SPEAKER_02: And it's an interesting text.
- 33:40SPEAKER_02: I think you and I have our disagreements, but we also see something.
- 33:45They don't make the argument you and I would make if we were
- 33:49the authors of Q accelerationism.
- 33:51SPEAKER_02: But...
- 33:52They spark in both of us a deeper appreciation for how cuteness
- 33:58functions in
- 34:00SPEAKER_02: capitalism that I was not thinking about prior to reading the book,
- 34:04SPEAKER_02: so I feel indebted to them.
- 34:06for that um but nance what do you what do you think where are
- 34:10they coming at this
- 34:11from so it it is a very astute observation to see cute as a
- 34:20vector for acceleration
- 34:23SPEAKER_01: um
- 34:25SPEAKER_01: Hello Kitty is like this global sensation.
- 34:31SPEAKER_01: And it seems like for no good reason.
- 34:34SPEAKER_01: Like, is it a cartoon?
- 34:36SPEAKER_01: Is it just like a sticker?
- 34:37SPEAKER_01: Is it a backpack?
- 34:38SPEAKER_01: Is it a hat?
- 34:39SPEAKER_01: Whatever.
- 34:40um but it's this commodity that is like captivated the entire
- 34:44globe um and you see
- 34:47it with all kinds of commodities you see it here in america we
- 34:50have like mickey
- 34:51mouse and we have mini mouse and and the the aesthetics of cute
- 34:55the aesthetics of
- 34:55SPEAKER_01: cute tend to be a vector um
- 35:00SPEAKER_01: They get us to let our guard down.
- 35:03SPEAKER_01: They get us to think, oh, this is harmless.
- 35:05SPEAKER_01: This is just something.
- 35:07SPEAKER_01: This is a cute little thing.
- 35:08SPEAKER_01: But what's really lurking behind the surface of the cute is Robo Cthulhu.
- 35:14SPEAKER_01: Or at least that's the argument being made.
- 35:17SPEAKER_01: It serves as a vector for acceleration.
- 35:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 35:21SPEAKER_01: And it's, like I said, it's a very astute observation.
- 35:24SPEAKER_01: Like, it's not, I don't know.
- 35:29SPEAKER_01: It was like when we started talking about it,
- 35:31SPEAKER_01: I was like,
- 35:32SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 35:32SPEAKER_01: shit,
- 35:32SPEAKER_01: this is very,
- 35:33SPEAKER_01: very interesting.
- 35:34SPEAKER_01: And they do come to different conclusions.
- 35:38SPEAKER_01: It seems like they, I mean, they say in the book, give in to giving in.
- 35:42SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 35:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 35:48SPEAKER_01: It feels incomplete.
- 35:52SPEAKER_01: It feels like they are just saying, well, resistance is futile.
- 35:57SPEAKER_01: Let's throw our hands up.
- 35:59SPEAKER_01: They start out with this interesting observation that cute as a vector,
- 36:03SPEAKER_01: cute as this thing that lives in aesthetics or affect,
- 36:12SPEAKER_01: it has a momentum.
- 36:15SPEAKER_01: there's something going on here.
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: We want to imitate the Q.
- 36:19SPEAKER_01: We want to be safe and secure and we want to be mostly harmless,
- 36:25SPEAKER_01: but it's,
- 36:26SPEAKER_01: it's not that like the commodity hijacks our,
- 36:30SPEAKER_01: our intentions,
- 36:32SPEAKER_01: um,
- 36:33SPEAKER_01: and just accelerates it.
- 36:35SPEAKER_01: Go, go, go, go, go by way of cute and making that observation.
- 36:40SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 36:44SPEAKER_01: that's a great way to start an argument.
- 36:46SPEAKER_01: And they seem to finish.
- 36:47SPEAKER_01: They seem to stop there.
- 36:48SPEAKER_01: They're just like, yep.
- 36:51SPEAKER_01: So we're all going to burn.
- 36:54SPEAKER_01: The ship is sinking, but at least we'll be cute while we go down.
- 37:00SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 37:01SPEAKER_02: We can wear Pikachu t-shirts.
- 37:03SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 37:06SPEAKER_02: And so I think, look, I think what I find interesting about it is
- 37:12SPEAKER_02: As much as I've thought about and continue to think about consumerism,
- 37:16I've never seen how the cute plays this core function in
- 37:23consumer ideology.
- 37:24SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 37:25they would probably say to me that I'm approaching this from a
- 37:30Tuziziekian
- 37:31perspective because they're part of the accelerationist
- 37:35tradition and they have
- 37:37SPEAKER_02: more of an allegiance towards the Luz and Guattari.
- 37:41But for me,
- 37:43the way I would say it is WALL-E is the ideological mask worn
- 37:47by Robo Cthulhu.
- 37:49SPEAKER_02: And for anybody who doesn't know, Robo Cthulhu is my term, I guess.
- 37:55SPEAKER_02: But I get the idea from Nick Land.
- 37:58SPEAKER_02: And it's basically this image of a Lovecraftian...
- 38:03technological super intelligence right and so it's cthulhu
- 38:08there's the lovecraftian
- 38:10dimension but the robo is the tech aspect of it and for nick
- 38:15land this level of
- 38:17lovecraftian super intelligence is what he calls the techno
- 38:21capital singularity
- 38:22SPEAKER_02: that
- 38:23Capitalism is the mode of production that spurs on
- 38:26technological dynamism to such
- 38:28SPEAKER_02: an intensive point that it's going to force us past an event horizon,
- 38:37SPEAKER_02: past which we have no idea what's going to happen.
- 38:40SPEAKER_02: And for him, that's artificial superintelligence.
- 38:44And so land has...
- 38:47If we want to talk about a Landian aesthetic,
- 38:50or at least...
- 38:51SPEAKER_02: what aesthetic associations are often associated with him.
- 38:56SPEAKER_02: It's octopuses or Cthulhu or tentacles.
- 39:00SPEAKER_02: He's always talking about the tentacled outside.
- 39:02SPEAKER_02: And it is this horrific Lovecraftian aesthetic.
- 39:07SPEAKER_02: And so for an accelerationist or accelerationists to say,
- 39:12SPEAKER_02: no,
- 39:13SPEAKER_02: actually the proper aesthetic for acceleration is the cute.
- 39:17SPEAKER_02: Well, that's, that's, I mean,
- 39:21SPEAKER_02: they don't dwell on land's work and cute accelerationism,
- 39:25SPEAKER_02: but by and large,
- 39:26SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 39:26SPEAKER_02: this is a response to him.
- 39:28SPEAKER_00: They definitely take inspiration, a lot of inspiration.
- 39:32SPEAKER_02: You can tell the writing style is very CCRU-esque, right?
- 39:36SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 39:37I mean,
- 39:37on some level,
- 39:38I mean,
- 39:39but you can tell that they're deeply inspired by land and CCRU.
- 39:45SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 39:45SPEAKER_02: But yeah, land and CCRU, it was always, I mean,
- 39:50demon lemurs and tentacled outside and uh all of these kind of
- 39:58techno lovecraftian
- 39:59images and it is the grotesque it is the horrific and so you
- 40:05know amy and maya show
- 40:07SPEAKER_02: up and it's like no it's
- 40:09SPEAKER_02: It's Hello Kitty or Pastel.
- 40:12SPEAKER_02: It is an interesting reversal.
- 40:14But again,
- 40:15for me,
- 40:15it's just pointing out this really important dimension of the
- 40:19cute.
- 40:19And when you start to think about it and all of our all the
- 40:21characters on our
- 40:22SPEAKER_02: breakfast cereals,
- 40:25SPEAKER_02: wherever consumer capitalism truly thrives.
- 40:29SPEAKER_02: And I would argue the two.
- 40:32SPEAKER_02: most consumerist countries are America and Japan.
- 40:35SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 40:36They have always just constantly produced cutesy little cartoon
- 40:43characters.
- 40:45SPEAKER_02: And it goes back with us with Mickey mouse and Minnie mouse and all that.
- 40:49SPEAKER_02: And then you get the, all the anime stuff in Japan.
- 40:54SPEAKER_02: And so, yeah, you start going, but why does capitalism exist?
- 40:58SPEAKER_02: wherever it really thrives as a consumer society,
- 41:01SPEAKER_02: why does it always utilize this cute aesthetic?
- 41:05And yeah,
- 41:05it's just,
- 41:06I,
- 41:06I'm still indebted to them for pointing that out to me.
- 41:10SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 41:10SPEAKER_02: Uh, but okay.
- 41:12SPEAKER_02: So the other thing though,
- 41:13SPEAKER_02: is for me,
- 41:16SPEAKER_02: given to giving in,
- 41:18SPEAKER_02: there's a sense where it's like,
- 41:19SPEAKER_02: no,
- 41:19SPEAKER_02: just become a cute object.
- 41:22SPEAKER_02: And that's the, the, the existential stance one ought to adopt to, uh,
- 41:29SPEAKER_02: the non-human future rushing in from the outside.
- 41:33And that's where I just go,
- 41:35okay,
- 41:38sure,
- 41:39that works with a certain niche online group,
- 41:43right?
- 41:45SPEAKER_02: If I try to take that to the warehouse and just say,
- 41:49SPEAKER_02: all right,
- 41:49SPEAKER_02: you know this thing you all are incredibly fearful of,
- 41:53SPEAKER_02: this AI,
- 41:55SPEAKER_02: the rise of AI,
- 41:56SPEAKER_02: replacement of jobs,
- 41:58SPEAKER_02: how are you going to get money if there's no working class jobs,
- 42:03SPEAKER_02: all this kind of stuff,
- 42:06SPEAKER_02: telling them to become cute is not going to work.
- 42:11SPEAKER_02: And look, I don't think Amy and Myers –
- 42:16SPEAKER_02: saying this for universalist application.
- 42:20SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 42:20But I'm just saying that the majority of humans are not going
- 42:23to respond to the,
- 42:26SPEAKER_02: the,
- 42:26SPEAKER_02: the looming threat of AI by doubling down on cuteness.
- 42:31They're going to respond with what I would say is proper
- 42:34Lovecraftian landy and
- 42:36SPEAKER_02: horror to,
- 42:38SPEAKER_02: to the threat to the human that all of this poses.
- 42:41SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 42:43SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 42:44SPEAKER_01: and like staying with,
- 42:48SPEAKER_01: cause they do seem to want ultimately acceleration,
- 42:55SPEAKER_01: just like land ultimately wants acceleration.
- 43:00SPEAKER_01: So they want to be replaced.
- 43:03Like they do want to just go down in flames while wearing
- 43:07Pikachu,
- 43:08Pikachu t-shirts.
- 43:10And if that's not the case,
- 43:11then I would love for them to point out how it's not.
- 43:16Maybe our reading is too hasty and we're not reading it with as
- 43:22much nuance as they would want.
- 43:23SPEAKER_02: Again, I just read it once.
- 43:24SPEAKER_02: I know you just read it once.
- 43:26But that was what I walked away thinking,
- 43:29is that it is a kind of realism or
- 43:36SPEAKER_02: just an acceptance that we're on the way out.
- 43:39SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 43:40SPEAKER_02: But to go with the process is to go with this tendency within it,
- 43:44SPEAKER_02: which is to become cute,
- 43:48SPEAKER_02: right?
- 43:48SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 43:48SPEAKER_02: it's like becoming cute is,
- 43:50SPEAKER_02: could we add this to the list of the Luzo Batarian becomeings,
- 43:54SPEAKER_02: right?
- 43:55SPEAKER_02: Or becoming Pikachu or something.
- 43:58SPEAKER_02: I mean, because on the back of the book, what do they say?
- 44:00SPEAKER_02: Nothing uncute makes it out of the near future.
- 44:02SPEAKER_01: Makes it out of the near future, yeah.
- 44:04SPEAKER_02: and the cute will very soon no longer be even remotely human.
- 44:09SPEAKER_02: So yeah,
- 44:09SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 44:10SPEAKER_02: part of this too,
- 44:11SPEAKER_02: and this is an insight I started thinking about because of them,
- 44:15SPEAKER_02: so thanks for that.
- 44:16SPEAKER_02: But no,
- 44:17SPEAKER_02: all of our little devices,
- 44:19SPEAKER_02: as the robots start to become oedipalized members of our house,
- 44:24SPEAKER_02: like your vacuum cleaner already has,
- 44:27SPEAKER_02: they're going to be cutesy little objects,
- 44:31SPEAKER_02: and
- 44:32SPEAKER_02: Again,
- 44:32it just seems to me to be how Robo Cthulhu is masking himself
- 44:40to make us on some
- 44:41SPEAKER_02: level become comfortable with AI devices.
- 44:45SPEAKER_01: I mean, look at, was it Nissan or Honda?
- 44:49SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 44:50SPEAKER_01: This was like 20 years ago.
- 44:53SPEAKER_01: It might have been Honda.
- 44:55SPEAKER_01: It might have been Toyota.
- 44:56SPEAKER_01: It was a Japanese automaker.
- 44:57SPEAKER_01: They made a little robot called like Asimo.
- 45:00SPEAKER_01: Asimo.
- 45:01SPEAKER_01: which I think was a play on Asimov.
- 45:05SPEAKER_01: But it was like when people started getting excited about robotics,
- 45:09SPEAKER_01: like in the early 2000s,
- 45:12SPEAKER_01: there was like a new wave of enthusiasm for AI and robotics.
- 45:16SPEAKER_01: And Asimo was this like proposed
- 45:21all-in-one household helper robot and he was a cute little
- 45:24diminutive cute cute
- 45:26little thing and there are i mean there there do exist devices
- 45:32like yeah my little
- 45:33my little robot vacuum cleaner uh and they make little robot
- 45:37toys already that are
- 45:39supposed to be productivity aids or whatever and they all have
- 45:42the cute aesthetic
- 45:43SPEAKER_01: Apple TV recently made a show called Sunny.
- 45:49SPEAKER_01: I think it's called,
- 45:50SPEAKER_01: I can't for the life of me remember the name of the show,
- 45:52SPEAKER_01: but it's,
- 45:53SPEAKER_01: it's like this.
- 45:53SPEAKER_01: It's this dystopian future world where like the robots are evil,
- 45:57SPEAKER_01: but they're cute little,
- 45:59SPEAKER_01: they're cute little helper robots,
- 46:02SPEAKER_01: but they like murder people.
- 46:03SPEAKER_01: And it's like, this is the way it works.
- 46:06SPEAKER_01: Also the stranger things, not stranger things, black mirror episode.
- 46:12SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 46:13SPEAKER_02: Oh, yeah.
- 46:14SPEAKER_01: Playthings.
- 46:14SPEAKER_01: We haven't gotten into that yet.
- 46:15SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean, it goes... So there's a new episode.
- 46:17SPEAKER_02: Is it season seven that they're on now?
- 46:20SPEAKER_02: Oh, jeez.
- 46:20SPEAKER_02: I think it's... Six or seven.
- 46:22SPEAKER_02: I think it's season seven.
- 46:23SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 46:24SPEAKER_02: Well, Nance and I watched this new episode.
- 46:29SPEAKER_02: Shout out to Matthew Flitzbader for motivating me to watch this.
- 46:34SPEAKER_02: He was like, you got to see this thing.
- 46:37SPEAKER_02: It's real landian or relevant to land studies.
- 46:41SPEAKER_01: Relevant, yeah, yeah.
- 46:43SPEAKER_02: So in this episode, so it's in the new season.
- 46:46SPEAKER_02: I think it's season seven.
- 46:47SPEAKER_02: It's called Play Thing.
- 46:49SPEAKER_02: And I guess we'll do the spoiler alert.
- 46:53If you haven't seen the episode and you want to watch the
- 46:56episode before we pause it here.
- 46:58SPEAKER_01: Pause this.
- 46:59SPEAKER_01: Go watch it.
- 47:00SPEAKER_02: Go watch it.
- 47:00SPEAKER_02: It's like 45 minutes long or something.
- 47:02SPEAKER_02: And then come back and finish the video.
- 47:04SPEAKER_01: It's worth it.
- 47:04SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 47:05SPEAKER_02: So three, two, one.
- 47:08SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 47:09SPEAKER_02: So in this episode, it's basically about...
- 47:14humanity being assimilated into a Kurzweilian image of the
- 47:21singularity where an
- 47:23artificial super intelligence basically finds a way to hack our
- 47:28brains and
- 47:29SPEAKER_02: integrate us into one collective intelligence.
- 47:33This is the type of intelligence or super intelligence Slavoj
- 47:36Zizek really kind of
- 47:39SPEAKER_02: focused on in his book in Hegel and the Wired Brain.
- 47:43SPEAKER_02: And
- 47:45SPEAKER_02: How does this occur?
- 47:47SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 47:49SPEAKER_02: in this episode,
- 47:50it's about a video game programmer or coder who gets access to
- 47:58this special program
- 48:00SPEAKER_02: that this other guy had been working on,
- 48:02SPEAKER_02: and the guy tells him,
- 48:04SPEAKER_02: look,
- 48:04SPEAKER_02: I've actually created artificial intelligence.
- 48:07SPEAKER_02: It's in this game, but it's not really a game.
- 48:10The little sprites on the screen are actual artificial
- 48:16intelligence beings.
- 48:17SPEAKER_02: They're sentient beings.
- 48:20SPEAKER_02: They're sentient beings.
- 48:21SPEAKER_02: And these are like the cutest little things.
- 48:24SPEAKER_02: They kind of squeak.
- 48:26And it looks like just a video game,
- 48:29more of like an old school one,
- 48:30like an 8-bit video game.
- 48:32SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 48:33SPEAKER_02: Nintendo or NES type of graphics.
- 48:37SPEAKER_02: And I don't know, it kind of reminded me of kind of like the
- 48:43SPEAKER_02: The graphics in Earthbound, something like that.
- 48:45SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 48:46SPEAKER_02: That was Super Nintendo.
- 48:47SPEAKER_02: But it's these cutesy little characters.
- 48:50SPEAKER_02: Are they rabbits?
- 48:52SPEAKER_02: They look something like that.
- 48:54SPEAKER_02: Now I'm forgetting.
- 48:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah, there's something like that.
- 48:58SPEAKER_01: To me, the first thing I thought when I saw the episode was Neopets.
- 49:03SPEAKER_01: Neopets was... I don't know if you remember.
- 49:06SPEAKER_01: I don't know if anyone in the audience remembers.
- 49:08SPEAKER_01: But Neopets was like an online...
- 49:11SPEAKER_01: Same thing with like Tamagotchis.
- 49:13SPEAKER_01: They're like little, cute little pets.
- 49:16SPEAKER_01: Cute little pets, but yeah, they're sentient creatures.
- 49:20They have language and they actually develop communication by
- 49:27way of LSD that this
- 49:30SPEAKER_01: rogue video games journalist
- 49:35SPEAKER_01: So he steals the code from the author of the code,
- 49:39SPEAKER_01: but the author actually wanted him to steal it.
- 49:42SPEAKER_01: Like he set him up to steal it because he wanted this creation to escape.
- 49:47SPEAKER_01: The guy who wrote the software knew that he created life.
- 49:53He knew he created this sentient collective intelligence and he
- 49:57wanted it to escape.
- 49:58SPEAKER_01: So he set the guy up.
- 49:59SPEAKER_01: The guy goes...
- 50:01takes LSD starts communicating with these cute little things
- 50:05and their little,
- 50:06SPEAKER_01: little rabbit looking deals.
- 50:08SPEAKER_01: And they, uh, they have needs.
- 50:11SPEAKER_01: You have to feed them.
- 50:12SPEAKER_01: You have to bathe them and brush them with the brush.
- 50:17SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 50:19And the guys and this is where the critique comes in that maybe
- 50:25it's a little one dimensional.
- 50:26SPEAKER_01: The guy's roommate or actually the guy's drug dealer.
- 50:29SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 50:31SPEAKER_01: Gets access.
- 50:32SPEAKER_02: I didn't really know the guy well.
- 50:33SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 50:35SPEAKER_01: He gets access to the program on the computer that it runs.
- 50:39SPEAKER_01: And because he's a human.
- 50:40SPEAKER_02: He's crashing at his house or something.
- 50:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 50:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 50:43SPEAKER_01: He was like, I'm just going to stay here.
- 50:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 50:48And because he's a human,
- 50:49the iniquity of man,
- 50:51man is so violent and so deplorable.
- 50:53SPEAKER_01: What does the drug dealer do?
- 50:55He goes and he starts killing these creatures for his amusement
- 50:59on him,
- 50:59throwing fire at him.
- 51:00SPEAKER_01: Yeah, he has no idea he's actually killing.
- 51:03sentient beings and this is look it's valid but it's very one
- 51:08dimensional like in
- 51:10the show if you take it at face value you would be left with
- 51:15like oh the show is
- 51:16making the argument they are saying oh look at the iniquities
- 51:19of man um it is true
- 51:22that we have these tendencies to be violent but that's not a
- 51:26total summation of the
- 51:28human race like we're over here talking about how awesome it is
- 51:31to be a human um
- 51:34SPEAKER_01: We're not these one-dimensional violent destroyers of worlds.
- 51:39SPEAKER_01: But the drug dealer is in the episode.
- 51:43SPEAKER_01: The guy freaks out,
- 51:44SPEAKER_01: kicks the drug dealer out of his house,
- 51:46SPEAKER_01: and then he spends the next,
- 51:47SPEAKER_01: what is it,
- 51:47SPEAKER_01: like 30 years.
- 51:49SPEAKER_02: No, no, he kills the guy.
- 51:51SPEAKER_02: Oh.
- 51:53SPEAKER_02: And little AIs.
- 51:54SPEAKER_02: That's why he's at the cops.
- 51:56SPEAKER_01: That's why he's at the police station.
- 51:58SPEAKER_01: That's right.
- 51:59SPEAKER_02: Well, so what happened, yeah.
- 52:02SPEAKER_02: Basically...
- 52:04SPEAKER_02: if I remember the plot correctly,
- 52:05SPEAKER_02: what happens is this guy comes home,
- 52:08SPEAKER_02: he finds the drug dealer killing all the little AI sprites.
- 52:15And then he,
- 52:17he hits them and they get in a fight and the guy ends up
- 52:21killing the drug dealer.
- 52:22SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 52:22SPEAKER_02: And the little AI is the,
- 52:24SPEAKER_02: the ones that have not been killed witness this murder and they've never
- 52:29SPEAKER_02: experienced aggression or violence before.
- 52:34SPEAKER_02: And so this guy feels like,
- 52:35SPEAKER_02: well,
- 52:36SPEAKER_02: now that I've exposed them to the horror that is humanity,
- 52:41SPEAKER_02: it's truly my calling to tend to them and help them develop.
- 52:46SPEAKER_02: And so he keeps enhancing their,
- 52:50SPEAKER_02: their memory,
- 52:51SPEAKER_02: their,
- 52:51SPEAKER_02: their,
- 52:52SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 52:53SPEAKER_02: level of storage so they can expand their consciousness.
- 52:58SPEAKER_02: And, um,
- 52:59SPEAKER_02: Basically, yeah.
- 53:00SPEAKER_02: So he killed the guy and then hid the body.
- 53:03SPEAKER_02: So one day when this guy is much older,
- 53:06he goes into a convenience store and he steals something
- 53:09because he wants to get
- 53:10SPEAKER_02: arrested.
- 53:10SPEAKER_02: And you're like, why does he want to get arrested?
- 53:14SPEAKER_02: So he gets arrested.
- 53:15SPEAKER_02: And then somehow the cops figure out like, oh, there's this.
- 53:20SPEAKER_02: I think they search his house or whatever.
- 53:22SPEAKER_02: They discover this connection between him killing this guy.
- 53:24SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 53:25SPEAKER_02: And him.
- 53:27SPEAKER_02: And so the cops are harping on that.
- 53:29But the reason why this guy wanted to get arrested is because
- 53:33the police station,
- 53:36this is in a society where they have their own AI surveillance
- 53:40system that's
- 53:41SPEAKER_02: basically omnipresent.
- 53:43And what this guy wants to do is get arrested so he can be
- 53:48under the eye of this state police.
- 53:53SPEAKER_02: AI program.
- 53:54SPEAKER_02: So he can infect it with the little cute AIs via this thing he writes.
- 54:02SPEAKER_01: He has like a turbo QR code.
- 54:03SPEAKER_02: It's basically a code that once the state AI
- 54:08sees this thing it grants access through a back door to the
- 54:13cute ai to come in and
- 54:15colonize it and take it over which gives it an absolute far
- 54:19reach right and once it
- 54:21has this power it sends out a signal it makes all humans drop
- 54:26and the the the guy
- 54:29SPEAKER_02: who who aided the ai
- 54:31SPEAKER_02: He goes over to the cop that's on the ground and he extends his hand.
- 54:35SPEAKER_02: And what the whole thing is,
- 54:36is that this signal basically turns off our ability to be human
- 54:43subjects proper.
- 54:45SPEAKER_02: It makes us passive.
- 54:46SPEAKER_02: It makes us nonviolent and non-aggressive.
- 54:51And so this guy,
- 54:52the guy who's been helping the AI,
- 54:54he's already merged with the AI.
- 54:58SPEAKER_02: They've already colonized his
- 55:00SPEAKER_02: his mind.
- 55:01SPEAKER_02: But now all of mankind has been integrated into this thing.
- 55:04SPEAKER_02: And that's how the episode ends.
- 55:07And this is very Kurzweil-y because Kurzweil thinks that that's
- 55:10what the AI will
- 55:11SPEAKER_02: essentially do is we'll all become one collective super intelligence.
- 55:17All of us will be merged into the same type of consciousness,
- 55:20if you want to call it that.
- 55:22And somehow this will be a good thing because it means that we
- 55:25will be able to
- 55:26SPEAKER_02: transcend our biology,
- 55:28SPEAKER_02: outlive the death of the body,
- 55:31and become coded digital versions of ourselves that can live
- 55:34forever and live at
- 55:37SPEAKER_02: peace with one another.
- 55:39SPEAKER_02: But for Nance and I,
- 55:41SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 55:41SPEAKER_02: what red flags us about this is,
- 55:43SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 55:43SPEAKER_02: we're coming at this from this perspective that continental philosophy,
- 55:47SPEAKER_02: at least a certain degree,
- 55:48strand of continental philosophy how it views the human so from
- 55:53hegel up to sartre
- 55:57lacan zizek todd mcgowan we view subjectivity as based around
- 56:04contradiction
- 56:05SPEAKER_02: antagonism inwardly right negativity negativity and so
- 56:14The problem with the plaything episode is that it seems to
- 56:17present it like,
- 56:18SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 56:19SPEAKER_02: we'll still just be humans.
- 56:20SPEAKER_02: We just won't be aggressive.
- 56:23SPEAKER_02: And our point would be,
- 56:25SPEAKER_02: no,
- 56:25SPEAKER_02: dude,
- 56:26SPEAKER_02: it's not just it's going to fix one bad,
- 56:30SPEAKER_02: inessential quality about us.
- 56:33SPEAKER_02: No, it's a complete...
- 56:35re-ontologization of us it basically destroys our humans
- 56:39ontology what we would
- 56:40call split subjectivity and turns us into substances we just
- 56:46are what we are within
- 56:48this collective consciousness and that's the issue it turns us
- 56:54from subjects which
- 56:55means divided internally because i mean in the most basic sense
- 57:00you go back to
- 57:00SPEAKER_02: freud freud is part of this tradition lacan that i mentioned um
- 57:05this whole tradition views things in dialectical terms or
- 57:08estimate terms.
- 57:09SPEAKER_02: And what that means is I am what I am not.
- 57:13SPEAKER_02: And I am not what I am.
- 57:15SPEAKER_02: And that's evasive or vague right now.
- 57:20But basically that is how we view human subjectivity is that
- 57:25we're never just
- 57:27SPEAKER_02: simply what we are.
- 57:28We are always internally divided and we are our inability to
- 57:33just be one pure identity.
- 57:35SPEAKER_02: That's simplifying a bit, but that'll have to do for now.
- 57:39And what the Kurzweilian singularity does is basically make us
- 57:45into substances.
- 57:46SPEAKER_02: We no longer have an unconscious.
- 57:48SPEAKER_02: We simply are reducible to whatever the coded substance.
- 57:54pattern is that it's that define be yeah the eye and the eye as
- 57:59opposed to the eye
- 58:00and the not eye it would it it is pure positivity it's uh this
- 58:06collective existence
- 58:08SPEAKER_01: of the of the play things and of the humans and of the kurtz wiley and uh
- 58:13SPEAKER_01: extrapolation like it it is
- 58:16SPEAKER_01: Pure positivity.
- 58:18SPEAKER_01: And it does take us from rich,
- 58:22SPEAKER_01: textured,
- 58:23SPEAKER_01: living,
- 58:24SPEAKER_01: agential subjects and turns us into nothing but substance.
- 58:29SPEAKER_01: It's the one-to-one pure positivity aspect.
- 58:32SPEAKER_01: And that's fucking horrifying.
- 58:34SPEAKER_01: But but so we have on one hand,
- 58:38we have Robo Cthulhu Robo Cthulhu wearing a Hello Kitty mask or
- 58:45Mickey Mouse mask
- 58:46SPEAKER_01: or Wally or Wally mask,
- 58:48SPEAKER_01: which is,
- 58:48SPEAKER_01: by the way,
- 58:49SPEAKER_01: fucking amazing imagery.
- 58:51SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it is.
- 58:53SPEAKER_01: So we have Robo Cthulhu and Robo Cthulhu wearing a Wally mask.
- 58:58SPEAKER_01: Or we have pure positivity, utopian, shared collective oneness.
- 59:05SPEAKER_01: Like there is a third path.
- 59:09SPEAKER_01: We are trying to take the third path,
- 59:11but it doesn't seem to be the case that anybody who's really
- 59:14deeply involved in the
- 59:16SPEAKER_01: conversation surrounding AI...
- 59:19is even aware of that path that includes the human,
- 59:24that's predicated on the human.
- 59:25SPEAKER_01: We are constituted by this negation.
- 59:29SPEAKER_01: It's the I and the not-I.
- 59:31SPEAKER_01: That is what makes the self, the human, the agent, the subject.
- 59:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and I'm sorry.
- 59:37Kurzweil and Bostrom and Amahundro and these guys,
- 59:41the problem is they don't know...
- 59:44SPEAKER_02: these robust theories of the subject that we know,
- 59:47SPEAKER_02: whether we're drawn from Lacan,
- 59:49SPEAKER_02: we're drawn from Heidegger,
- 59:50SPEAKER_02: we're drawn from Sartre.
- 59:52SPEAKER_02: And their concept of the human is a very cliche, simple one.
- 59:58And the second you start to problematize that,
- 1:00:01then you have to start rethinking AI.
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_02: And that's part of what we want to do here.
- 1:00:07SPEAKER_02: And I mean,
- 1:00:08SPEAKER_02: look,
- 1:00:08SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:00:08SPEAKER_02: this distinction between subject and substance that we're using,
- 1:00:13SPEAKER_02: they don't know.
- 1:00:15SPEAKER_02: They don't know what the hell is going on with that.
- 1:00:16SPEAKER_02: Look, term substance goes all the way back to Aristotle.
- 1:00:22And what Aristotle was trying to do is do a metaphysics or an
- 1:00:26ontology that is substance based.
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_02: And so what he's trying to do is say,
- 1:00:31SPEAKER_02: look,
- 1:00:32SPEAKER_02: the fundamental things that exist are substances,
- 1:00:35which is to say a substance is a thing that exists
- 1:00:39independently from other things
- 1:00:41SPEAKER_02: that stands on its own being.
- 1:00:44Now,
- 1:00:44the point is,
- 1:00:45you can say,
- 1:00:46well,
- 1:00:48that lamp can exist without that book.
- 1:00:52right so it's a very thingly way of viewing entities uh it's
- 1:00:57very standalone
- 1:00:58isolationist view of beings and so but it's but it it held for
- 1:01:07for almost 2 000
- 1:01:08years in philosophy right or i mean yeah roughly roughly that i
- 1:01:15mean maybe longer
- 1:01:17SPEAKER_02: and so
- 1:01:18I mean,
- 1:01:18because there's still people who would who would hold to
- 1:01:21Aristotelian metaphysics.
- 1:01:22SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.
- 1:01:23SPEAKER_02: You still have Aristotelians in the world.
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_02: So.
- 1:01:27SPEAKER_02: The problem is,
- 1:01:28SPEAKER_02: is that things,
- 1:01:30SPEAKER_02: at least according to me,
- 1:01:31SPEAKER_02: I don't think things are it's a way of viewing things.
- 1:01:35I grant that there is a way in which this rock can exist
- 1:01:39without that tree.
- 1:01:40SPEAKER_02: Sure.
- 1:01:41SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 1:01:42But there's these other ways of viewing how entities exist that
- 1:01:46doesn't allow them
- 1:01:47SPEAKER_02: to be pried apart in this abstract way that Aristotle does.
- 1:01:50So Heidegger is great on this and being in time because he
- 1:01:55starts to show how
- 1:01:56SPEAKER_02: actually,
- 1:01:57SPEAKER_02: can you pry a hammer away from nails?
- 1:02:02SPEAKER_02: No, a hammer is...
- 1:02:04SPEAKER_02: that which hammers in nails.
- 1:02:06SPEAKER_02: So when you start to think about equipment,
- 1:02:08one piece of equipment doesn't actually operate outside of some
- 1:02:11network of
- 1:02:12SPEAKER_02: equipment.
- 1:02:14SPEAKER_02: Equipment is always equipments for Heidegger.
- 1:02:18SPEAKER_02: And so when you start to view entities in that way,
- 1:02:20SPEAKER_02: you start to realize,
- 1:02:21SPEAKER_02: no,
- 1:02:21SPEAKER_02: I can't just isolate a hammer from boards and from nails.
- 1:02:29SPEAKER_02: They exist as an equipmental unit.
- 1:02:33SPEAKER_02: And
- 1:02:35SPEAKER_02: Now, the same would go for us as human beings.
- 1:02:37SPEAKER_02: Not that we're reducible to being equipment,
- 1:02:41SPEAKER_02: but human beings do not exist in isolation from one another.
- 1:02:45SPEAKER_02: What is it to be a teacher without students, right?
- 1:02:49SPEAKER_02: So any type of...
- 1:02:52SPEAKER_02: Any type of stand you take on your being,
- 1:02:54SPEAKER_02: if you want to be a teacher,
- 1:02:55SPEAKER_02: you know that means that you're going to have to,
- 1:02:58SPEAKER_02: one,
- 1:02:58exist in a tradition of people who came before you who made
- 1:03:02contributions to the
- 1:03:03SPEAKER_02: field that you're going to teach.
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_02: So you're with them.
- 1:03:05SPEAKER_02: You're going to be with the students you teach.
- 1:03:10And you yourself,
- 1:03:11if you're making contributions,
- 1:03:12are going to be with thinkers and
- 1:03:16SPEAKER_02: who take the field further in the future.
- 1:03:17SPEAKER_02: So there's this withness to what you're doing as your social identity.
- 1:03:23SPEAKER_02: So you can't just pry things apart as easy as Aristotle did.
- 1:03:28Again,
- 1:03:29that's one way you can view things,
- 1:03:31but it doesn't view humans in any type of robust way.
- 1:03:35If you try to reduce humans to just being substances where you
- 1:03:38just say that human
- 1:03:40SPEAKER_02: body can exist without that human,
- 1:03:42SPEAKER_02: you're missing the human.
- 1:03:43SPEAKER_03: Mm-hmm.
- 1:03:45So you have to do a different ontology if you're going to do
- 1:03:48any justice to the human.
- 1:03:49SPEAKER_02: And the point is,
- 1:03:50a lot of people still just view humans as independent minds in
- 1:03:54independent bodies.
- 1:03:56SPEAKER_02: And those minds have certain basic principles.
- 1:04:02SPEAKER_02: Act in accordance with reason.
- 1:04:04SPEAKER_02: Seek what's in your best, what's in your self-interest.
- 1:04:09SPEAKER_02: Seek to maximize your utility.
- 1:04:11SPEAKER_02: All these basic things that
- 1:04:14yeah sure we do this on some level but is that it no that's so
- 1:04:18men and say that i
- 1:04:20say that on the basis of this tradition that i you know i'm i
- 1:04:26i've kind of been
- 1:04:26living in for the last 10 years which is the Freudian Lacanian
- 1:04:31Zizekian yeah
- 1:04:33SPEAKER_02: tradition of in that theory of the subject so
- 1:04:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 1:04:37SPEAKER_02: I'll just say that,
- 1:04:38SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 1:04:38I don't think that the AI theorists have rich theories of human
- 1:04:43subjectivity.
- 1:04:45SPEAKER_02: And that's where we would like to,
- 1:04:46SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:04:47SPEAKER_02: it's kind of the point where we want to interact with AI theory.
- 1:04:51SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:04:54SPEAKER_01: Little interesting tidbit.
- 1:04:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:04:57I call them postmodern rationalists,
- 1:05:00but they just call themselves rationalists.
- 1:05:02But like the rationalist community that is online and that
- 1:05:07Eliezer Yudkowsky,
- 1:05:09no shade Eliezer.
- 1:05:11SPEAKER_01: You've done a lot of good for the world.
- 1:05:14SPEAKER_01: You're also wrong about a lot.
- 1:05:15SPEAKER_01: You're silly in a lot of ways.
- 1:05:16SPEAKER_01: But anyway.
- 1:05:18uh eliezer ukowski has has maintained uh the less wrong forum
- 1:05:25among other things
- 1:05:26too i think like shock level four i think he was in charge of
- 1:05:29that um but less
- 1:05:32wrong was a blog slash internet forum slash message board where
- 1:05:37uh rationalism
- 1:05:38SPEAKER_01: got a lot of love, a lot of lifeblood in the last 15 or 20 years.
- 1:05:44SPEAKER_01: And there are these rationalists who they're very utilitarian.
- 1:05:48SPEAKER_01: They're very deontological.
- 1:05:50SPEAKER_01: They're very, I am a robot.
- 1:05:53SPEAKER_01: I am a rope.
- 1:05:54But they're also,
- 1:05:55a lot of them tend to be very intelligent and very gifted in
- 1:06:01key ways.
- 1:06:02So a lot of them work in computer science and coding and
- 1:06:07they're programmers and
- 1:06:08SPEAKER_01: stuff like that.
- 1:06:09SPEAKER_01: Look,
- 1:06:09SPEAKER_01: I'm not trying to fetishize or draw a caricature,
- 1:06:15SPEAKER_01: but also we all know that type of guy who's just really,
- 1:06:21really smart in mathematics or in computer science or something
- 1:06:25like that.
- 1:06:25SPEAKER_01: And he's totally oblivious to this rich human world that's going on.
- 1:06:29SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:06:31But the recently there was a cult that splintered out of these
- 1:06:37postmodern rationalists.
- 1:06:39SPEAKER_01: I think they might have called themselves hyper rationalists,
- 1:06:44SPEAKER_01: but they called themselves the Zizians.
- 1:06:48SPEAKER_01: Interesting.
- 1:06:48SPEAKER_01: Sounds a bit like Zizek.
- 1:06:51SPEAKER_01: But they went on a murder spree.
- 1:06:54SPEAKER_02: I keep seeing this Z-I-Z-I-A-N all over Twitter at least.
- 1:06:58SPEAKER_01: Dude, they went on a murder spree.
- 1:07:00SPEAKER_01: I don't even want to get into it.
- 1:07:03SPEAKER_01: It is grisly and gruesome.
- 1:07:04I watched a 45-minute thing on,
- 1:07:09I don't even know,
- 1:07:10on some fucking news channel.
- 1:07:14SPEAKER_01: It's sad.
- 1:07:15SPEAKER_01: But these hyper-rationalist people...
- 1:07:19ultimately convinced themselves that like they were doing you
- 1:07:24know they were
- 1:07:24seeking ultimate good they were trying to maximize utility and
- 1:07:28part of their grand
- 1:07:29plan to stop ai from taking over was to go murder some old guy
- 1:07:35and like take his
- 1:07:37house over i don't know it was sad but um i don't like how
- 1:07:40you're gonna stop the
- 1:07:41SPEAKER_02: the flood of technology by putting bombs in the mail yeah
- 1:07:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah, exactly.
- 1:07:46SPEAKER_01: Exactly like that.
- 1:07:47SPEAKER_01: And a lot of the people who are involved in these conversations,
- 1:07:53SPEAKER_01: just you guys need to consider the human.
- 1:07:56SPEAKER_01: Stop talking about instrumental reasons.
- 1:07:59SPEAKER_01: Stop talking about math.
- 1:08:01SPEAKER_01: I love math.
- 1:08:02SPEAKER_01: I'm interested in math.
- 1:08:03SPEAKER_01: I've been reading a lot of math the last couple of years.
- 1:08:05SPEAKER_02: Talk about all that stuff, but talk about this other thing.
- 1:08:08SPEAKER_02: We need the human too, dude.
- 1:08:10SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:08:13SPEAKER_02: No, and I mean,
- 1:08:14SPEAKER_02: I think that's part of our issue with the accelerationist tradition,
- 1:08:21SPEAKER_02: which has influenced us just about as much as anything else has.
- 1:08:24SPEAKER_00: I think so.
- 1:08:25But they all start from this Deluso-Guattarian premise that
- 1:08:31subjectivity is
- 1:08:32SPEAKER_02: ultimately a kind of after effect or epiphenomenon,
- 1:08:37SPEAKER_02: and it's not really the...
- 1:08:40SPEAKER_02: For us, it's the core of what it is to be human.
- 1:08:43And I mean,
- 1:08:43this is one of the ways where I'm just...
- 1:08:46As opposed to DeLuzo-Gatharian.
- 1:08:50SPEAKER_02: I think there is a hard kernel of subjectivity.
- 1:08:54SPEAKER_02: It's a negative one, but nonetheless...
- 1:08:57SPEAKER_02: I think there's a subject there.
- 1:08:59SPEAKER_02: And so, you know, and I don't think it's just, we're just the effect.
- 1:09:03SPEAKER_02: No, look, the subject is what remains or slips out of subjectivization.
- 1:09:09SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 1:09:09SPEAKER_02: And the losing Guattari,
- 1:09:11SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:09:11SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:09:12SPEAKER_02: they're,
- 1:09:12SPEAKER_02: they're coming out of this Althusserian situation.
- 1:09:15milieu,
- 1:09:16this Foucaultian milieu,
- 1:09:18where there's just historical modes of subjectivization.
- 1:09:23SPEAKER_02: You take the basic,
- 1:09:24SPEAKER_02: we're human animals,
- 1:09:26SPEAKER_02: and then some sort of institution ideologically interpolates us,
- 1:09:31SPEAKER_02: or
- 1:09:32there's a power discourse that that we get caught up in and
- 1:09:35somehow we're just
- 1:09:36reducible to the subjects that the symbolic machine makes us
- 1:09:42into and the like
- 1:09:44canian zizekian thing is no we're never just that and in fact
- 1:09:48subjectivity is
- 1:09:48precisely the thing that that can never capture exactly the
- 1:09:52negative core if you
- 1:09:54SPEAKER_01: will exactly
- 1:10:00SPEAKER_02: So let's see.
- 1:10:02SPEAKER_02: This is another point where I'm like, where do we want to go?
- 1:10:06SPEAKER_02: Actually, you know what?
- 1:10:07SPEAKER_02: I kind of want to read this quote.
- 1:10:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:10:09SPEAKER_02: It's kind of going back because I want to talk a little bit more about
- 1:10:12SPEAKER_02: psychoanalysis in a minute.
- 1:10:14But there's this great quote from Hegel's or from Zizek's book,
- 1:10:18Hegel and a Wired Brain.
- 1:10:21SPEAKER_02: So Slavoj says,
- 1:10:23our starting point here should be the imminent inconsistency of
- 1:10:27singularity itself.
- 1:10:30Why do we automatically imagine the passage into singularity as
- 1:10:35our immersion in a
- 1:10:37SPEAKER_02: vast singular field?
- 1:10:39SPEAKER_02: Why should it not be not a conflicting and inconsistent domain of spaces?
- 1:10:45SPEAKER_02: While it is,
- 1:10:46SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 1:10:47SPEAKER_02: too early to speculate about conflicting singularities,
- 1:10:51SPEAKER_02: we should at least entertain the possibility of
- 1:10:54SPEAKER_02: of inconsistent and conflicting levels of shared experiences,
- 1:10:59which will transpose the conflict between individuals into the
- 1:11:03conflict between
- 1:11:04SPEAKER_02: forms of direct collective experience.
- 1:11:07Maybe this is how we can overcome our alienation in the
- 1:11:12singularity with the separation.
- 1:11:17by way of opening ourselves up to the imminent inconsistencies
- 1:11:21and conflicts that
- 1:11:22SPEAKER_02: traverse the singularity itself.
- 1:11:25SPEAKER_02: Separation is thus again,
- 1:11:28not the cynical game in which the subject exempted from
- 1:11:31singularity selectively
- 1:11:33SPEAKER_02: plays with its different parts.
- 1:11:37Recall Musk's description of how I will be able to link or
- 1:11:41disconnect my brain from
- 1:11:44SPEAKER_02: the space of shared experiences.
- 1:11:46SPEAKER_02: In contrast with this description,
- 1:11:48we should emphasize that I will mostly not even be aware when
- 1:11:53I'm immersed in
- 1:11:54SPEAKER_02: singularity.
- 1:11:57Separation means that while I am still exposed to the space of
- 1:12:01singularity,
- 1:12:02I realize that singularity is not a singular agent that
- 1:12:06controls the game,
- 1:12:08SPEAKER_02: but an inconsistent space traversed by inconsistencies full of glitches.
- 1:12:14SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 1:12:14SPEAKER_02: that's kind of the core Lacanian,
- 1:12:17Hegelian type of rebuttal to even Land's view of the
- 1:12:23singularity at certain points,
- 1:12:25SPEAKER_02: where
- 1:12:26It's like it is just this perfected form of intelligence that
- 1:12:29has no intrinsic or
- 1:12:31SPEAKER_02: internal obstacles or contradictions within itself.
- 1:12:34SPEAKER_02: It gets to the point where it doesn't glitch out anymore.
- 1:12:37SPEAKER_02: It doesn't undermine itself in any way.
- 1:12:40SPEAKER_02: And it's just completely, fully consistent with itself.
- 1:12:44SPEAKER_02: This is what Lacan calls the unbarred big other.
- 1:12:47SPEAKER_02: And for him, it's just a fantasy.
- 1:12:50SPEAKER_02: He would basically say,
- 1:12:51SPEAKER_02: look,
- 1:12:52SPEAKER_02: we've never encountered an entity that isn't in some way structured by
- 1:12:57SPEAKER_02: contradiction in one way or another.
- 1:13:00SPEAKER_02: So this image we have of a totally consistent, totally all powerful.
- 1:13:07SPEAKER_02: Now you start to see where we're going.
- 1:13:09SPEAKER_02: He calls this the big other, but throughout human history,
- 1:13:13different religious traditions have made it god where god is
- 1:13:19different from us
- 1:13:20because god is never at odds with himself he's never
- 1:13:23contradictory or she is never
- 1:13:24contradict or it is never contradictory or even they are never
- 1:13:29contradictory
- 1:13:30SPEAKER_02: something like that um but
- 1:13:33The point is for Lacan is this is always just the work of
- 1:13:37fantasy that we never
- 1:13:39SPEAKER_02: encounter an agent or agency that is without contradiction.
- 1:13:44SPEAKER_02: And see this image of the singularity as perfect, identical to itself.
- 1:13:52SPEAKER_02: not lacking in any way.
- 1:13:54SPEAKER_02: This is a fantasy of ours.
- 1:13:55This is us at our human,
- 1:13:57most human,
- 1:13:58where we fantasize about ontological completeness.
- 1:14:01We fantasize about what it is to no longer be caught up in
- 1:14:04contradiction within ourselves.
- 1:14:07SPEAKER_02: And it's like we were projecting this outward.
- 1:14:10SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 1:14:10SPEAKER_02: traditionally,
- 1:14:10SPEAKER_02: we've done this in the form of God,
- 1:14:12SPEAKER_02: but now that fantasy of the unbarred big other,
- 1:14:17SPEAKER_02: now you can say certain AI theorists are projecting that onto the
- 1:14:22SPEAKER_02: And Slavoj is saying, look, AI is a thing.
- 1:14:27SPEAKER_02: It is real.
- 1:14:28And it's going to continue to grow and expand and have immense
- 1:14:31effects on our world.
- 1:14:33SPEAKER_02: But we need to be very careful.
- 1:14:36not to romanticize it or view it in phantasmatic terms and
- 1:14:41start to consider what
- 1:14:42SPEAKER_02: if it's as inconsistent within itself as we are.
- 1:14:47What kind of consequences does that have as this thing does
- 1:14:50continue to grow in its
- 1:14:53SPEAKER_02: intelligence levels?
- 1:14:55I honestly think that version of a super intelligence is less
- 1:15:03terrifying.
- 1:15:04SPEAKER_01: Like the, the actual super intelligence with subjectivity.
- 1:15:08SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's still frightening.
- 1:15:11Cause it's like,
- 1:15:11well,
- 1:15:12it's this all power or,
- 1:15:14you know,
- 1:15:14relatively all powerful.
- 1:15:15It's like,
- 1:15:16we don't stop to consider the ants as we're walking down the
- 1:15:20sidewalk.
- 1:15:20SPEAKER_01: Like that's a scary notion, but,
- 1:15:25Thinking it's a subject is a little more comforting than
- 1:15:33thinking it's just this
- 1:15:35SPEAKER_01: pure positivistic monstrous thing.
- 1:15:38SPEAKER_01: Because that would be monstrous.
- 1:15:41SPEAKER_01: That would be terrifying.
- 1:15:44SPEAKER_01: That is the paperclip maximizer.
- 1:15:47SPEAKER_01: To be reductive.
- 1:15:48SPEAKER_01: And I know it's reductive language.
- 1:15:50SPEAKER_01: But it's useful language.
- 1:15:52SPEAKER_01: The paperclip maximizer.
- 1:15:54SPEAKER_01: Is positivistic.
- 1:15:55SPEAKER_01: The.
- 1:15:58SPEAKER_01: Super powerful.
- 1:16:00SPEAKER_01: Because it just is what it is.
- 1:16:02SPEAKER_01: It just does what it does.
- 1:16:04SPEAKER_01: There is no.
- 1:16:06SPEAKER_01: There's no room for thought.
- 1:16:07SPEAKER_01: There's no room for considering.
- 1:16:10SPEAKER_01: The outcome of its own actions.
- 1:16:14SPEAKER_01: But the subject,
- 1:16:15SPEAKER_01: the all-powerful subject,
- 1:16:17SPEAKER_01: while scary in some ways,
- 1:16:19SPEAKER_01: it's a little more comforting because then you could think,
- 1:16:22SPEAKER_01: well,
- 1:16:22then it can understand motivation and it can understand that
- 1:16:26its actions will have
- 1:16:27SPEAKER_01: ripple effects on other conscious beings.
- 1:16:29And it won't treat us like pixels on a computer screen where it
- 1:16:35smashes us with the
- 1:16:37digital rocks because it understands their sentience and their
- 1:16:41subjectivity going
- 1:16:42SPEAKER_01: on behind it.
- 1:16:43SPEAKER_02: Well, it can relate to us on some level.
- 1:16:47And I mean,
- 1:16:47look,
- 1:16:47I mean,
- 1:16:48Tom McGowan and Ryan Ingley are friends over at the Y Theory
- 1:16:53podcast.
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_02: I asked him to do me a favor.
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_02: I put in a special request.
- 1:16:57SPEAKER_02: I'd love to hear you guys talk about AI for an episode.
- 1:17:00SPEAKER_02: So they did.
- 1:17:02And at one point,
- 1:17:04Todd brings up this great insight where he says,
- 1:17:07look,
- 1:17:08arguably,
- 1:17:09SPEAKER_02: at the level of pop culture,
- 1:17:11SPEAKER_02: the two most famous films about AI are Terminator and Blade Runner.
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_02: I think you can make that case.
- 1:17:19What's interesting,
- 1:17:19though,
- 1:17:21is that both of them now T2 gets a little it's a little bit
- 1:17:28not as clear as the first terminator so let's just stick with
- 1:17:31the first terminator
- 1:17:32movie in the first terminator why is the terminator so horrific
- 1:17:37because you cannot
- 1:17:38reason with it it cannot relate to you it is completely just it
- 1:17:44is what it is which
- 1:17:46SPEAKER_02: is carrying out its interpolated
- 1:17:49There's no subjective remainder that puts it at a distance from
- 1:17:54what it's been
- 1:17:54SPEAKER_02: coded to do,
- 1:17:55which is kill John Connor or prevent John Connor's existence by
- 1:18:00killing his mother
- 1:18:01SPEAKER_02: back in the 80s.
- 1:18:03SPEAKER_02: And that's all it is.
- 1:18:05And because it doesn't have any unconscious or any subjective
- 1:18:11dimension to itself
- 1:18:12SPEAKER_02: outside of what it's been coded to do,
- 1:18:14SPEAKER_02: that's what makes it a machinic horror right now.
- 1:18:18SPEAKER_02: Rachel, the replicant in Blade Runner.
- 1:18:22SPEAKER_02: She's far more subject than the Terminator is.
- 1:18:25SPEAKER_02: The Terminator is none.
- 1:18:27SPEAKER_02: The replicants have something of an unconscious.
- 1:18:31There's something that allows them to defy what they've been
- 1:18:35interpolated to do,
- 1:18:37SPEAKER_02: the coding procedure they have.
- 1:18:42SPEAKER_02: There's a distance within them.
- 1:18:45SPEAKER_02: that you don't see in the Terminator.
- 1:18:47SPEAKER_02: So Todd's point was like,
- 1:18:49SPEAKER_02: look,
- 1:18:49SPEAKER_02: if you want to understand this different way of viewing AI,
- 1:18:53SPEAKER_02: what it could be,
- 1:18:54SPEAKER_02: if it's just a substance and you think you're going with that,
- 1:18:57SPEAKER_02: go watch Terminator.
- 1:18:59SPEAKER_02: And that's primarily what Land did, right?
- 1:19:02SPEAKER_02: He drew on the Terminator thing more than the Blade Runner.
- 1:19:05SPEAKER_02: He knew Blade Runner,
- 1:19:06SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 1:19:07but there's a different ontology at play between the Terminator
- 1:19:12and the Replicate.
- 1:19:14SPEAKER_02: And
- 1:19:15SPEAKER_02: it helps it to get to get at what you and I are trying to get at here,
- 1:19:19SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 1:19:19SPEAKER_02: from a theoretical perspective.
- 1:19:21SPEAKER_02: If you go watch those two films,
- 1:19:23SPEAKER_02: you walk away having a different,
- 1:19:27SPEAKER_02: a clearer idea of how,
- 1:19:28what it means for AI to be substance and what it means for it
- 1:19:31to also be subject.
- 1:19:36SPEAKER_02: So good.
- 1:19:37SPEAKER_02: Thanks Todd for that one.
- 1:19:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:19:39SPEAKER_01: Um, I do love using the replicants as, as examples.
- 1:19:44SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 1:19:46SPEAKER_01: of desire and drive.
- 1:19:48SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:19:48SPEAKER_01: Tears and rain.
- 1:19:49SPEAKER_01: Like there's so,
- 1:19:50there's so much going on with blade runner and with do androids
- 1:19:54dream of electric
- 1:19:55SPEAKER_01: sheep.
- 1:19:55SPEAKER_00: There's so much going on there.
- 1:19:58Um,
- 1:20:00and I would rather have a world full of replicants than a world
- 1:20:02full of terminators.
- 1:20:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:20:06SPEAKER_02: I mean, of course I said, T two problematizes this because, um,
- 1:20:12SPEAKER_02: Ryan Ingley, he quotes the line.
- 1:20:15SPEAKER_02: I know now why you cry, but it's something I can never do.
- 1:20:18SPEAKER_02: It's weird.
- 1:20:18SPEAKER_02: Like, isn't that a third thing?
- 1:20:20SPEAKER_02: Like on some level it is split.
- 1:20:23SPEAKER_02: The good Terminator in T2.
- 1:20:29SPEAKER_02: It's like a third thing where it's part Terminator from first one,
- 1:20:34SPEAKER_02: but it's also got a little bit of replicant in it.
- 1:20:39SPEAKER_01: It's been meddled with.
- 1:20:41SPEAKER_01: It's been reprogrammed or repurposed.
- 1:20:44So it was taken out of its initial function,
- 1:20:48and it's been set at odds with what it is.
- 1:20:51SPEAKER_01: It is no longer what it is.
- 1:20:52SPEAKER_01: It is not.
- 1:20:54SPEAKER_01: What it is, in fact.
- 1:20:55SPEAKER_02: It has been derailed.
- 1:20:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:20:57SPEAKER_01: The droid from Andor.
- 1:21:01SPEAKER_01: I haven't finished season two.
- 1:21:04SPEAKER_01: Is it good?
- 1:21:05SPEAKER_02: I've heard nothing but good things about it.
- 1:21:07SPEAKER_01: Andor is a great show.
- 1:21:09SPEAKER_01: I've watched like five or six episodes of season two.
- 1:21:13SPEAKER_01: And it's excellent.
- 1:21:14SPEAKER_01: I think season two is just as good.
- 1:21:17SPEAKER_01: Maybe better than season one.
- 1:21:19SPEAKER_01: But the droid.
- 1:21:19SPEAKER_02: A lot of my Star Wars.
- 1:21:21SPEAKER_02: Oh, it's so good.
- 1:21:22SPEAKER_02: A lot of my Star Wars fans that I talk to, there's a couple at work.
- 1:21:27SPEAKER_02: They say they always,
- 1:21:28SPEAKER_02: and I know this has been said of it in advertising,
- 1:21:30but it's the best Star Wars since the original trilogy or at
- 1:21:35least the prequel
- 1:21:36SPEAKER_02: trilogy.
- 1:21:36SPEAKER_01: I think it's excellent, dude.
- 1:21:38And when Rogue One,
- 1:21:39the movie came out,
- 1:21:40I was like,
- 1:21:41this is fucking excellent.
- 1:21:42SPEAKER_01: And then the TV show Andor, yeah, it's really, really good.
- 1:21:47SPEAKER_01: But the droid,
- 1:21:50Andor's like companion droid is a reprogrammed imperial like
- 1:21:55hundred killer droid
- 1:21:56so it like it develops subjectivity this way or maybe not
- 1:22:00subjectivity but it
- 1:22:02becomes more human when it becomes what it is not or when they
- 1:22:07take its initial
- 1:22:09function and turn it on its head so it is interesting to be
- 1:22:15what you are not
- 1:22:18SPEAKER_02: So, I mean, that leads into this core point.
- 1:22:22SPEAKER_02: So, look, you and I, we've been reading different AI theorists lately.
- 1:22:29SPEAKER_02: I finally had a chance to sit down and read.
- 1:22:31SPEAKER_02: It's a short paper.
- 1:22:32SPEAKER_02: I recommend everybody go check it out.
- 1:22:34SPEAKER_02: You can Google it.
- 1:22:35SPEAKER_02: It immediately pops up.
- 1:22:37SPEAKER_02: But there's this guy named Steve Amahundro.
- 1:22:41SPEAKER_02: And he wrote the core paper on basic AI drives.
- 1:22:49SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 1:22:49what's interesting about this to me is that drive means
- 1:22:54something very different to
- 1:22:55SPEAKER_02: me than what it means to Amahundro.
- 1:22:58But it opens up a space of contradiction where you can come
- 1:23:03together and basically
- 1:23:06SPEAKER_02: a contradiction between AI theory and AI.
- 1:23:08and psychoanalytic theory in particular lakanian theory but
- 1:23:14what he means are he
- 1:23:15means drive in this colloquial sense so he basically is saying
- 1:23:21look every draw
- 1:23:22every ai is going to have certain built-in drives which he
- 1:23:27means goals yeah right
- 1:23:29now this is interesting this this will play into something
- 1:23:32we're going to go into
- 1:23:33SPEAKER_02: in a minute but uh
- 1:23:36SPEAKER_02: For him, he says there's six.
- 1:23:38SPEAKER_02: So number one, AIs will want to self-improve.
- 1:23:43SPEAKER_02: Number two, AIs will want to be rational.
- 1:23:46SPEAKER_02: Number three, AIs will try to preserve their utility functions.
- 1:23:51SPEAKER_02: Number four, AIs will try to prevent counterfeit utility.
- 1:23:55SPEAKER_02: Number five, AIs will be self-protective.
- 1:24:00And number six,
- 1:24:01AIs will want to acquire resources and use them efficiently.
- 1:24:08SPEAKER_02: Now, okay.
- 1:24:13Those are all things that if you asked somebody who's working
- 1:24:17with the old school
- 1:24:19SPEAKER_02: concept of the human,
- 1:24:20SPEAKER_02: homo economicus,
- 1:24:22SPEAKER_02: they would ascribe a lot of that to us as humans,
- 1:24:25SPEAKER_02: that we have those drives or we have those intrinsic goals,
- 1:24:29SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:24:31SPEAKER_02: But for someone like myself,
- 1:24:35SPEAKER_02: Nance,
- 1:24:35SPEAKER_02: who also come at things from this Lacanian perspective,
- 1:24:39SPEAKER_02: drives,
- 1:24:40SPEAKER_02: if you go down that list,
- 1:24:42what Amahundro is really talking about are activities of the
- 1:24:47pleasure principle,
- 1:24:49SPEAKER_02: not juizance,
- 1:24:51SPEAKER_02: and certainly not death drive.
- 1:24:53SPEAKER_02: And so for us, death drive is this fundamental principle
- 1:24:59SPEAKER_02: if you want to call it that,
- 1:25:01in human beings that gets enjoyment from self-destruction or
- 1:25:09de-optimization.
- 1:25:12So all of these basic AI drives,
- 1:25:15their primary goal ultimately is optimization.
- 1:25:22SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 1:25:23SPEAKER_02: Well, there's a sense where human beings do try to optimize themselves.
- 1:25:26SPEAKER_02: They try to self-improve.
- 1:25:27SPEAKER_02: They try to make themselves better.
- 1:25:30But anybody who's an astute observer of the human will find
- 1:25:35just how omnipresent a
- 1:25:38SPEAKER_02: counter tendency is,
- 1:25:40which is this ability human beings have to find enjoyment from
- 1:25:43not optimizing
- 1:25:45SPEAKER_02: themselves,
- 1:25:45SPEAKER_02: from not pursuing what's in their best interest,
- 1:25:48SPEAKER_02: but instead from doing the self-destructive thing.
- 1:25:52SPEAKER_02: So we talk about that as death drive.
- 1:25:54SPEAKER_02: Now, for Lacan, there's four drives on our bodies.
- 1:25:58SPEAKER_02: And simply put,
- 1:26:00SPEAKER_02: one's connected to the mouth,
- 1:26:01SPEAKER_02: one's the eyes,
- 1:26:02SPEAKER_02: one's the ears,
- 1:26:02SPEAKER_02: and one's the anus.
- 1:26:03SPEAKER_02: If you're not into psychoanalytic theory,
- 1:26:05SPEAKER_02: that probably will make you chocolate like it did Nance.
- 1:26:08SPEAKER_02: But you get into Freud and Lacan, the anal drive is a thing.
- 1:26:13SPEAKER_02: So we have four drives, but
- 1:26:16SPEAKER_02: for Lacan, all drives are a death drive.
- 1:26:20SPEAKER_02: And so ultimately,
- 1:26:21SPEAKER_02: we just talk about death drive,
- 1:26:23SPEAKER_02: even though it has these four privileged sites on the body.
- 1:26:27SPEAKER_02: And so
- 1:26:29SPEAKER_02: If you start comparing something that only has these basic drives,
- 1:26:35SPEAKER_02: and hold on,
- 1:26:36SPEAKER_02: pause,
- 1:26:37SPEAKER_02: pleasure principle versus death drive,
- 1:26:39SPEAKER_02: because I just used this distinction and I didn't explain it well.
- 1:26:42SPEAKER_02: Pleasure principle is that part of ourselves or our libidinal economies,
- 1:26:46SPEAKER_02: or we could even say our central nervous systems,
- 1:26:48SPEAKER_02: that
- 1:26:50SPEAKER_02: like to be in a state of homeostasis or relative homeostasis,
- 1:26:53SPEAKER_02: calm,
- 1:26:54SPEAKER_02: cool,
- 1:26:54SPEAKER_02: collected,
- 1:26:55SPEAKER_02: relaxed,
- 1:26:57SPEAKER_02: rational,
- 1:26:58SPEAKER_02: because when you're calm,
- 1:26:58SPEAKER_02: cool,
- 1:26:58SPEAKER_02: and collected,
- 1:26:59that's when you can be rational and you can calculate on the
- 1:27:03basis of what's in
- 1:27:04SPEAKER_02: your best interest.
- 1:27:06SPEAKER_02: But what we find is,
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_02: even though that we do have these,
- 1:27:10SPEAKER_02: there's a certain gravity towards pleasure,
- 1:27:12SPEAKER_02: which is just to say again,
- 1:27:14SPEAKER_02: homeostasis,
- 1:27:15SPEAKER_02: equilibrium,
- 1:27:16SPEAKER_02: There's a counter tendency,
- 1:27:18SPEAKER_02: which is towards disequilibrium and intensive or excessive excitation.
- 1:27:25SPEAKER_02: And this is, you can call it the drama tendency.
- 1:27:28SPEAKER_02: Why do human beings...
- 1:27:32Everybody knows somebody who constantly repeats a
- 1:27:35self-destructive relationship pattern.
- 1:27:38SPEAKER_02: They always date somebody that they always have drama with.
- 1:27:41The relationship is never one where they primarily operate on a
- 1:27:46calm,
- 1:27:47cool,
- 1:27:47collected basis.
- 1:27:48SPEAKER_02: No, it's always geared around drama, fighting stuff.
- 1:27:52SPEAKER_02: And yet you can tell that they're invested in it and they enjoy it.
- 1:27:55SPEAKER_02: Right?
- 1:27:55SPEAKER_01: I've been that guy, dude.
- 1:27:58SPEAKER_01: I've been that guy.
- 1:27:59Dude,
- 1:28:01so...
- 1:28:03You get that manic pixie dream girl and she gets under your
- 1:28:07skin.
- 1:28:07SPEAKER_01: Dude, there's nothing you can do, man.
- 1:28:09SPEAKER_01: Dude, and so...
- 1:28:13SPEAKER_02: And the thing is, it's not just with our romantic relationships.
- 1:28:17SPEAKER_02: This is the same pattern that the, quote, degenerate gambler has.
- 1:28:24SPEAKER_02: Or somebody who just...
- 1:28:28SPEAKER_02: You know, the guys who think about our friend Swole the Tarion.
- 1:28:34SPEAKER_02: We had this conversation once about pleasure versus resistance.
- 1:28:39SPEAKER_02: And Swole is a fitness trainer.
- 1:28:41And Swole is all too aware of there are people who go to the
- 1:28:44gym for the sake of
- 1:28:46SPEAKER_02: self-improvement,
- 1:28:47SPEAKER_02: better health,
- 1:28:48SPEAKER_02: get in shape,
- 1:28:48SPEAKER_02: be more active,
- 1:28:49SPEAKER_02: et cetera.
- 1:28:50SPEAKER_02: But he also pointed out,
- 1:28:51SPEAKER_02: he's like,
- 1:28:51SPEAKER_02: but there are these guys that destroy themselves with going to the gym.
- 1:28:57and how much they fixate on it and how seriously they take it
- 1:29:00to the point that
- 1:29:00they break down their bodies through excessive workout so this
- 1:29:04is another way that
- 1:29:05somebody can get jouissance from self-destructive repetition i
- 1:29:10think skateboarding
- 1:29:12for like for me and i've i've thought long and hard about this
- 1:29:16and now as i'm
- 1:29:16getting older i have to take it way easier than than i used to
- 1:29:20but like when i was
- 1:29:21SPEAKER_01: a kid
- 1:29:22SPEAKER_01: we were jumping off roofs,
- 1:29:24SPEAKER_01: like jumping off buildings and jumping down,
- 1:29:27SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:29:28SPEAKER_01: 16 stairs doing a handrail.
- 1:29:30SPEAKER_01: And like there,
- 1:29:34SPEAKER_01: there's a difference between enjoying,
- 1:29:36SPEAKER_01: like getting pleasure out of skateboarding.
- 1:29:38SPEAKER_01: Like I love to just cruise and just move and push down the road.
- 1:29:43SPEAKER_01: But then there's this,
- 1:29:44SPEAKER_01: this other kind of like exciting and it's dangerous and it's adrenaline,
- 1:29:48SPEAKER_01: but it's also like you enjoy,
- 1:29:50SPEAKER_01: like I enjoy the,
- 1:29:52fucking breaking bones and i enjoy like having bad knees and
- 1:29:56shit there is a
- 1:29:57libidinal enjoyment that that i get out of putting myself in
- 1:30:02danger um and you
- 1:30:04always got to ride the wave of dysfunction because it can very
- 1:30:08easily become
- 1:30:09dysfunctional it can become something like problem gambling or
- 1:30:14alcoholism and drug
- 1:30:16addiction and abusive relationships but there's also a way to
- 1:30:20to ride the wave
- 1:30:22where this impulse of self-overcoming can actually be
- 1:30:26constructive if you can keep it in check.
- 1:30:30SPEAKER_02: Sure.
- 1:30:30SPEAKER_02: And anything can fulfill this function.
- 1:30:35SPEAKER_02: I think my jouissance is from theory.
- 1:30:39Could I have had a better life with more economic stability or
- 1:30:42economic flourishing
- 1:30:43SPEAKER_02: if I had not wanted to do philosophy all the time?
- 1:30:46SPEAKER_02: Sure.
- 1:30:46SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:30:47So there's something in philosophy that's tied up with juizance
- 1:30:52for me or death drive.
- 1:30:54SPEAKER_02: And so it's not just sex, drugs, rock and roll.
- 1:30:58SPEAKER_02: It's easy to paint juizance like that.
- 1:31:01SPEAKER_02: But no, it can be from...
- 1:31:03uh excessive workout working out at the gym it can be from
- 1:31:06excessive skateboarding
- 1:31:07it can be from excessive philosophizing yeah it's excess itself
- 1:31:12right and that's
- 1:31:13that's the key thing it's not the content it's this this
- 1:31:18pulsion or tendency we
- 1:31:19have in our central nervous system as human beings to have
- 1:31:25excessive excitation in
- 1:31:27SPEAKER_02: one shape way form or another whatever
- 1:31:31SPEAKER_02: And that's what makes it uniquely human.
- 1:31:33SPEAKER_02: We don't see that in animals.
- 1:31:34SPEAKER_02: I've had a couple of people throw a couple of little examples of,
- 1:31:37SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 1:31:38SPEAKER_02: well,
- 1:31:38SPEAKER_02: dogs will just keep eating if you let.
- 1:31:40SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:31:40SPEAKER_02: But you don't see the varied forms of self-destructive enjoyment.
- 1:31:46SPEAKER_02: It doesn't become pathological.
- 1:31:48Animals typically live in accordance with what we call the
- 1:31:51pleasure principles.
- 1:31:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it doesn't become pathological with animals.
- 1:31:56SPEAKER_01: Now, what the fuck does pathological mean?
- 1:31:59SPEAKER_01: Come on, guy, don't use words like that.
- 1:32:00SPEAKER_01: But yeah, there's an observable difference.
- 1:32:04We all know,
- 1:32:04yes,
- 1:32:05your dog will keep eating if you give it fucking dog treats all
- 1:32:08day long.
- 1:32:09SPEAKER_01: But that's not a pathology.
- 1:32:11SPEAKER_01: That's a Skinnerian fucking response to a stimulus input.
- 1:32:17SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:32:18SPEAKER_02: It's also precarity, right?
- 1:32:19SPEAKER_02: They don't know when they're ever going to get food again.
- 1:32:22SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:32:25SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 1:32:26they're not going to break into the dog pantry and steal the
- 1:32:30bag of treats and sit
- 1:32:31SPEAKER_01: there and huddle in a corner in the dark and eat treats.
- 1:32:35SPEAKER_01: A human would, but a dog is not going to do that.
- 1:32:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:32:40SPEAKER_02: So,
- 1:32:41SPEAKER_02: no,
- 1:32:41SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:32:41SPEAKER_02: and so the point is,
- 1:32:43SPEAKER_02: these guys who do this,
- 1:32:44SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:32:45SPEAKER_02: to go back to Armahundro's drives,
- 1:32:48SPEAKER_02: all of those are these homo economicus principles,
- 1:32:52SPEAKER_02: the rational,
- 1:32:53SPEAKER_02: the rational man type of principles,
- 1:32:56SPEAKER_02: acting in accordance with rationality,
- 1:32:58SPEAKER_02: self-interest,
- 1:32:58SPEAKER_02: self-preservation,
- 1:33:00SPEAKER_02: utility.
- 1:33:02SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:33:03SPEAKER_02: I know we do do those things.
- 1:33:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:33:05SPEAKER_02: But that's not all we do.
- 1:33:07SPEAKER_02: And they're not even primary most of the time.
- 1:33:10SPEAKER_01: We do that stuff at this bare minimum level.
- 1:33:13SPEAKER_01: That is the threshold.
- 1:33:15SPEAKER_01: Yes, we are rationally self-interested.
- 1:33:19Yes,
- 1:33:20if someone threatens me,
- 1:33:22I'm going to avoid that type of violent confrontation or
- 1:33:27whatever.
- 1:33:28SPEAKER_01: Yes, I want to optimize my daily life in such a way where I can...
- 1:33:33SPEAKER_01: Get the most out of my efforts and,
- 1:33:35SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:33:36SPEAKER_01: get get in more than I get out more than I put in.
- 1:33:40SPEAKER_01: But that's the bare minimum.
- 1:33:42SPEAKER_01: That's bare life.
- 1:33:45SPEAKER_01: Bear, bear, bear.
- 1:33:47SPEAKER_02: And here's the thing.
- 1:33:49SPEAKER_02: We are not geared towards bared life.
- 1:33:51SPEAKER_02: Bared life is the condition for excess of life.
- 1:33:55SPEAKER_01: Yep, yep.
- 1:33:56SPEAKER_02: Excess life.
- 1:33:57SPEAKER_02: And that is what we're fundamentally geared towards.
- 1:34:00SPEAKER_02: On the everyday level,
- 1:34:02SPEAKER_02: in mundane ways,
- 1:34:03whether it's the guy who always has to be doing road rage shit
- 1:34:09when he's out and
- 1:34:09SPEAKER_02: about.
- 1:34:11SPEAKER_02: or the relationship drama, these are mundane things.
- 1:34:14SPEAKER_02: But we're so on the one hand,
- 1:34:16our partial enjoyment that whatever's we get throughout the day
- 1:34:20is geared towards
- 1:34:21SPEAKER_02: some sort of excess or intensive excitation.
- 1:34:26But it's certainly that too,
- 1:34:27at the level of fantasy,
- 1:34:28when people daydream,
- 1:34:31SPEAKER_02: They daydream about some fucking situations they would love to be in.
- 1:34:35SPEAKER_02: I mean, you see this especially.
- 1:34:36SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:34:37SPEAKER_02: Brazil has this great example where whenever this guy,
- 1:34:40SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:34:41SPEAKER_02: when he's in an angel form.
- 1:34:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:34:43SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:34:44You know,
- 1:34:44so it's always some sort of exceptional,
- 1:34:49exciting scenario in fantasy.
- 1:34:51SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:34:52SPEAKER_02: For guys with us being structured around the phallus,
- 1:34:57SPEAKER_02: which for those who don't know,
- 1:34:59SPEAKER_02: we're not talking about the actual penis.
- 1:35:01SPEAKER_02: We're talking about whatever signifier indicates that we're the man.
- 1:35:05SPEAKER_02: We're the exceptional man above and beyond all other men.
- 1:35:09SPEAKER_02: And usually it's some act of you imagine yourself with extreme wealth.
- 1:35:15or you've done something uniquely heroic the lowrider like as a
- 1:35:19kid my like the one
- 1:35:22one of my fundamental fantasies as a you know as a adolescent
- 1:35:26we'll say was the the
- 1:35:27car i had to have this sick ass lowrider and my first car was a
- 1:35:321986 cutlass
- 1:35:33supreme and i lowered it but it was ghettoish it was a piece of
- 1:35:37shit but like that
- 1:35:38SPEAKER_01: was that was the phallus
- 1:35:40SPEAKER_01: having the sick-ass lowrider,
- 1:35:44SPEAKER_01: having the,
- 1:35:45SPEAKER_01: you know what I'm saying,
- 1:35:46SPEAKER_01: like the fresh fucking suit,
- 1:35:49SPEAKER_01: the fresh fucking sunglasses and the hat and the nice fucking kicks,
- 1:35:53SPEAKER_01: like that's phallus.
- 1:35:55SPEAKER_01: It's not... Exactly.
- 1:35:56SPEAKER_01: It's not penile, although it can be sexual.
- 1:35:59SPEAKER_01: It can very much be a sexual thing.
- 1:36:01And it can actually be about the penis,
- 1:36:03but it's a much broader thing than that.
- 1:36:07SPEAKER_02: It's the signifier that indicates...
- 1:36:09SPEAKER_02: that you are the exceptional man above and beyond all other men.
- 1:36:14And so,
- 1:36:14like you say,
- 1:36:16in one situation,
- 1:36:17it's the guy who has the coolest low rider.
- 1:36:18SPEAKER_03: Yep.
- 1:36:19In another situation,
- 1:36:20it's the guy who's,
- 1:36:21you know,
- 1:36:23got the most money in the bank.
- 1:36:24SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 1:36:25And,
- 1:36:25you know,
- 1:36:26if you think of it in like primal terms,
- 1:36:29it's literally the toughest guy.
- 1:36:30SPEAKER_02: You know, it just depends on the context of what signifier, what, what,
- 1:36:38meaningful element suggests that you are the exceptional man
- 1:36:41that indicates that about you.
- 1:36:44SPEAKER_02: And it does vary across different cultures and epochs, et cetera.
- 1:36:49SPEAKER_02: But when masculine structured subjects fantasize,
- 1:36:56SPEAKER_02: they usually fantasize about having the phallus,
- 1:37:00which enables them to have excessive enjoyment in some
- 1:37:04idiosyncratically preferred
- 1:37:06SPEAKER_02: way.
- 1:37:09SPEAKER_02: And so but but the thing is,
- 1:37:11SPEAKER_02: look,
- 1:37:13all this talk about split subjectivity and pleasure principle
- 1:37:16versus death drive,
- 1:37:17SPEAKER_02: which are these two different tendencies that work in us as human beings.
- 1:37:22SPEAKER_02: The point, you know, I love Isabel Millar's work here.
- 1:37:25SPEAKER_02: Actually,
- 1:37:26I got a book right here because Isabel really kind of is one of
- 1:37:30the first Lacanian
- 1:37:32SPEAKER_02: thinkers.
- 1:37:33to start thinking about this,
- 1:37:36a psychoanalysis of artificial intelligence,
- 1:37:39right?
- 1:37:40SPEAKER_02: And what's great about the book is that Isabel starts thinking about AI,
- 1:37:47SPEAKER_02: but from the perspective of jouissance and not just pleasure,
- 1:37:52SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:37:54SPEAKER_02: Does an AI have to be able to enjoy,
- 1:37:56to be able to have self-destructive enjoyment for it to
- 1:38:00actually be intelligent at
- 1:38:02SPEAKER_02: all?
- 1:38:02SPEAKER_02: And this raises this question.
- 1:38:04SPEAKER_02: If the standard bearer for intelligence thus far has been us,
- 1:38:10and our intelligence is always mediated by death drive or this
- 1:38:15self-destructive
- 1:38:16SPEAKER_02: impulse,
- 1:38:17SPEAKER_02: then you have to start thinking about intelligence in a different way,
- 1:38:21SPEAKER_02: which is to say maybe...
- 1:38:23SPEAKER_02: Pure optimization is not optimization.
- 1:38:26Perhaps there has to be some intrinsic deoptimization for there
- 1:38:30to be continued optimization.
- 1:38:34SPEAKER_02: And,
- 1:38:34SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:38:34I don't think land wouldn't like that because land is in
- 1:38:38particular not a Lacanian.
- 1:38:40SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 1:38:40SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 1:38:41he he's going to view it as just a constant becoming or
- 1:38:45de-territorialization or
- 1:38:47decoding and for him that's just not a problem but for us we
- 1:38:52view that as somewhat
- 1:38:54of a perhaps a fantasy where it's the fantasy of just pure
- 1:39:00smooth non-contradictory
- 1:39:03SPEAKER_02: optimization.
- 1:39:06I always come back to it's just a fundamental lack of agreement
- 1:39:13on what is a human.
- 1:39:16Or maybe it's not even what is a human,
- 1:39:18but what is important about the human.
- 1:39:23SPEAKER_01: And the kind of worldview,
- 1:39:27SPEAKER_01: this Deluso-Gatarian worldview,
- 1:39:28SPEAKER_01: where it's ultimately the cosmos can be boiled down to a simple equation.
- 1:39:34SPEAKER_01: One plus one equals two, and two is always good.
- 1:39:37SPEAKER_01: I mean, essentially, that would be... It's always this acquisitive.
- 1:39:43SPEAKER_01: It's a very grabby, it's a very...
- 1:39:46SPEAKER_01: It's not transcendental in any way.
- 1:39:48SPEAKER_01: It's not dialectical in any way.
- 1:39:50SPEAKER_01: It's just go and go, go, go, go, go.
- 1:39:53SPEAKER_01: More, more, more, more, more.
- 1:39:57SPEAKER_01: Sure, that is a type of intelligence.
- 1:39:59SPEAKER_01: Again, this very instrumental, it's about optimization.
- 1:40:03SPEAKER_01: How can we get better?
- 1:40:04SPEAKER_01: How can we get more?
- 1:40:05SPEAKER_01: How can we acquire more stuff?
- 1:40:07SPEAKER_01: This is the logic to go back.
- 1:40:10SPEAKER_01: This is the language of the commodity.
- 1:40:13SPEAKER_01: This is the language of capital.
- 1:40:16SPEAKER_01: This is the language of value.
- 1:40:18And this is why capital does equal artificial intelligence,
- 1:40:23positive feedback loop.
- 1:40:24SPEAKER_01: It's all the same thing.
- 1:40:25SPEAKER_01: It's speaking this language of value.
- 1:40:27SPEAKER_01: More, more, more, more, more.
- 1:40:29SPEAKER_01: Whereas the human is this thing with contours and peaks and valleys.
- 1:40:35SPEAKER_01: And we have a topology.
- 1:40:36SPEAKER_01: And we have contradictory elements of our very selves.
- 1:40:42And it's by way of navigating these contradictions in and of
- 1:40:47ourselves and between
- 1:40:48SPEAKER_01: ourselves and the world around us,
- 1:40:51SPEAKER_01: agency,
- 1:40:52SPEAKER_01: subjectivity,
- 1:40:52SPEAKER_01: ethical action.
- 1:40:57SPEAKER_01: So it's not to say that Land would disagree.
- 1:41:04SPEAKER_01: And I don't know, maybe he would.
- 1:41:05SPEAKER_01: I've never seen him take it seriously.
- 1:41:08SPEAKER_01: Like, I think it's to say that Land just says, well, that's unimportant.
- 1:41:12Because there is a part of the human that is this very
- 1:41:16metabolic process of just
- 1:41:18SPEAKER_01: acquisitive more,
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_01: more,
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_01: more,
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_01: more,
- 1:41:20SPEAKER_01: more.
- 1:41:21SPEAKER_01: And it's a part of a human because it's part of intelligence.
- 1:41:25SPEAKER_01: And that's what land wants.
- 1:41:26SPEAKER_01: Land wants that kind of intelligence to be set free.
- 1:41:30SPEAKER_01: And we're over here saying,
- 1:41:32but there's this whole other world that goes on and it has to
- 1:41:35do with subjectivity
- 1:41:36and it has to do with these types of negations and
- 1:41:39contradictions that give us our
- 1:41:41SPEAKER_01: ethical being.
- 1:41:43There's no such thing as ethics in this very DeLuzo Guattarian
- 1:41:47world where it's
- 1:41:48SPEAKER_01: just about production,
- 1:41:50SPEAKER_01: production,
- 1:41:51SPEAKER_01: production.
- 1:41:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's almost just an ethics of... Ethics of production, yeah.
- 1:41:57SPEAKER_02: Ethics of difference, just... Yeah, yep, yep, yep, yep.
- 1:42:02SPEAKER_02: And basically anything that impedes that is fascist.
- 1:42:05SPEAKER_01: Ooh, ooh.
- 1:42:08SPEAKER_01: Which is insane because I tie back accelerationism.
- 1:42:16SPEAKER_01: Look, Deleuze and Guattari were...
- 1:42:20a crux in accelerationism but i tie it back to the italian
- 1:42:24futurists and the
- 1:42:25italian futurists they were an artistic movement that was all
- 1:42:30about embracing speed
- 1:42:32and embracing difference and difference and it was all just
- 1:42:36about the churn go go
- 1:42:38SPEAKER_01: go go go and what did the italian futurists do in the 1930 or the 1920s
- 1:42:44SPEAKER_01: They became Mussolini's fucking homeboys.
- 1:42:49SPEAKER_01: So I think accelerationism is fascism.
- 1:42:56SPEAKER_01: But the DeLuzo Guattarians would say,
- 1:42:59we're fascists because we want to put the brakes on this
- 1:43:03unending process of
- 1:43:06SPEAKER_01: production and change.
- 1:43:08Well,
- 1:43:08look,
- 1:43:09okay,
- 1:43:09to be fair,
- 1:43:09because I can already hear some of the DeLuzo guitarists.
- 1:43:12SPEAKER_02: So look, okay, here's the thing.
- 1:43:15SPEAKER_02: This impulse to just radical deterritorialization,
- 1:43:19SPEAKER_02: that really is in Anti-Oedipus,
- 1:43:21SPEAKER_02: which is what land drew from heavily.
- 1:43:25SPEAKER_02: They kind of try to self-correct in A Thousand Plateaus.
- 1:43:30SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 1:43:31SPEAKER_02: And so in...
- 1:43:34SPEAKER_02: In Antioedipus, it's capitalism, deterritorializes.
- 1:43:39It also re-territorializes,
- 1:43:42so it doesn't get you to pure deterritorialization.
- 1:43:45SPEAKER_02: That's in something called the New Earth.
- 1:43:48But it does break down these old forms of identity and
- 1:43:53territorializations.
- 1:43:55SPEAKER_02: So they like it for that reason.
- 1:43:56SPEAKER_02: It just doesn't go far enough.
- 1:44:00SPEAKER_02: But...
- 1:44:03SPEAKER_02: in a thousand plateaus,
- 1:44:04SPEAKER_02: they end up saying like,
- 1:44:05what actually leads to absolute de-territorialization or what
- 1:44:10is geared towards
- 1:44:11SPEAKER_02: that is fascism.
- 1:44:14SPEAKER_02: And so they start to become more alert to like, Hey,
- 1:44:21SPEAKER_02: we got to be territorialization realists on some level.
- 1:44:24SPEAKER_02: Like, of course, there's always going to be some territorialization.
- 1:44:28The problem is when the territory really does not allow for any
- 1:44:32type of escape.
- 1:44:33SPEAKER_02: So now they, they want, it's almost like they've become mature.
- 1:44:37They've matured a bit when it comes to the idea of the
- 1:44:39territorialization,
- 1:44:40SPEAKER_02: which is like,
- 1:44:41SPEAKER_02: no,
- 1:44:42SPEAKER_02: it's more of a slow and steady experiment.
- 1:44:46SPEAKER_02: It's not this Landian thing.
- 1:44:49SPEAKER_01: Go, go, go, baby, go.
- 1:44:50SPEAKER_02: Let's do amphetamine until we crash into a death zero.
- 1:44:54SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 1:44:55SPEAKER_02: So, yeah, it's not that.
- 1:44:57SPEAKER_02: And it's not the a death of the CCRU.
- 1:45:01SPEAKER_02: And so to be fair to DeLuzo Guattari.
- 1:45:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:45:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:45:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:45:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:45:04SPEAKER_02: Losing Guattari themselves.
- 1:45:06SPEAKER_02: I think in a thousand places they refine it a little bit.
- 1:45:09SPEAKER_02: I think I like what they were doing.
- 1:45:11I think it's,
- 1:45:13I think the position in anti-edifice is a bit more
- 1:45:15theoretically consistent.
- 1:45:18SPEAKER_02: But I understand why,
- 1:45:19SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:45:20SPEAKER_02: in a thousand plateaus,
- 1:45:21they write a whole plateau about how to make yourself a body
- 1:45:24without organs,
- 1:45:25which would be more of a strategic account of how to
- 1:45:28de-territorialize and decode
- 1:45:30SPEAKER_02: yourself.
- 1:45:31And so I just want to be fair on that,
- 1:45:34but there is,
- 1:45:35there,
- 1:45:35there is some sort of,
- 1:45:40ethics of like radical de-territorialization that land was
- 1:45:43attuned to in um what
- 1:45:46what it was drawing from in a thousand plectos yeah well and i
- 1:45:50think the the
- 1:45:51difference is he just thinks capitalism does it and there is no
- 1:45:54thing this other
- 1:45:56thing called the new earth it's just capitalism is pure
- 1:45:59de-territorialization for
- 1:46:00SPEAKER_01: land right which
- 1:46:04SPEAKER_01: It is.
- 1:46:05SPEAKER_01: It is.
- 1:46:06It's constantly deteriorating,
- 1:46:07constantly overcoating,
- 1:46:08recoding,
- 1:46:09decoding.
- 1:46:10SPEAKER_01: It's the churn.
- 1:46:11It's this unending metabolic process ultimately leading to
- 1:46:20escape by way of the heat death.
- 1:46:24SPEAKER_01: And the thing is,
- 1:46:25SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 1:46:25SPEAKER_01: they do take this extropic view where,
- 1:46:29SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:46:30entropy ultimately can set you free as opposed to stop you in
- 1:46:35your tracks.
- 1:46:37SPEAKER_01: Because they allow for... You really ran with that.
- 1:46:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:46:41SPEAKER_01: But I...
- 1:46:44SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 1:46:45SPEAKER_01: That is getting a bit weird.
- 1:46:48SPEAKER_01: Time and metaphysics and stuff like that.
- 1:46:54SPEAKER_01: Look, we're going to wind up having episodes where we discuss...
- 1:46:58SPEAKER_01: All that shit.
- 1:46:59SPEAKER_01: I want to talk about time because time is,
- 1:47:02SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 1:47:05SPEAKER_01: so important to understanding land,
- 1:47:09SPEAKER_01: land's view,
- 1:47:11SPEAKER_01: his philosophy.
- 1:47:13SPEAKER_01: And we may,
- 1:47:14I know I definitely will speak in the moment passionately and
- 1:47:18speak dismissively of
- 1:47:20SPEAKER_01: people.
- 1:47:20SPEAKER_01: I just did it with Delusion Katari.
- 1:47:22SPEAKER_01: I do it with land sometimes.
- 1:47:24SPEAKER_01: It's not to dismiss any of these people.
- 1:47:25SPEAKER_01: These people need to be listened to and taken seriously.
- 1:47:31My gripe is with the people who don't seem to take this
- 1:47:35seriously and they just see
- 1:47:36a part of it and they think we can innovate our way into the
- 1:47:41future and they
- 1:47:42haven't tarried with ultimately with what land is saying is
- 1:47:47that there is no
- 1:47:48SPEAKER_01: future.
- 1:47:49SPEAKER_01: We're going to innovate ourselves out of existence.
- 1:47:52SPEAKER_01: From the perspective of us.
- 1:47:53SPEAKER_02: Does EAC come to mind here?
- 1:47:57SPEAKER_01: So in the.
- 1:47:59SPEAKER_02: I should say effective accelerationism.
- 1:48:02SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:48:02SPEAKER_01: In the early 2000s,
- 1:48:06SPEAKER_01: maybe even going to the late 90s,
- 1:48:09SPEAKER_01: in Silicon Valley,
- 1:48:10SPEAKER_01: there was a group of people who called themselves effective altruists.
- 1:48:15And they were techno optimistic and they were big on the whole
- 1:48:20philanthropy thing.
- 1:48:22And they're like,
- 1:48:24you know,
- 1:48:24nice polo shirt wearing good progressive Democrats.
- 1:48:31SPEAKER_01: And from the effective altruism movement and.
- 1:48:36SPEAKER_01: effective accelerationism sprang up.
- 1:48:40So effective accelerationism,
- 1:48:42there's guys,
- 1:48:43Beth Jezos is one of the prominent figures.
- 1:48:50Eliezer Yudkowsky might fit into the EAC category,
- 1:48:54maybe not,
- 1:48:54I don't know.
- 1:48:56SPEAKER_01: But effective accelerationism are techno-optimistic, usually tech bros,
- 1:49:03who are convinced that we can innovate a solution to all the
- 1:49:09world's problems they
- 1:49:11are the people who would go to an ai and say solve the problem
- 1:49:15of human poverty and
- 1:49:17and they would have full faith in it um and they would reject
- 1:49:24any fear or caution
- 1:49:25SPEAKER_01: or
- 1:49:28SPEAKER_01: they would call people like us D-cells.
- 1:49:31SPEAKER_01: And D-cell is basically like calling someone a cuck or an incel.
- 1:49:38SPEAKER_01: It's basically a way to say we don't, or a doomer.
- 1:49:41SPEAKER_01: It's saying, oh, you guys are doomers.
- 1:49:43SPEAKER_01: You guys are D-cells.
- 1:49:44SPEAKER_01: You guys don't need to be taken seriously.
- 1:49:48SPEAKER_01: I think effective accelerationism is ultimately incoherent.
- 1:49:56SPEAKER_02: I think Ryan thinks that too on their own.
- 1:49:58SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:49:59SPEAKER_01: I think it might be the most popular branch of it right now,
- 1:50:03SPEAKER_01: though,
- 1:50:04SPEAKER_01: because this is what everybody thinks of when they think of technology.
- 1:50:08SPEAKER_01: They think technology is... Ray Kurzweil, fantastic example of EAC.
- 1:50:15SPEAKER_01: He thinks he can innovate a solution to death, ultimately.
- 1:50:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:50:20SPEAKER_01: Um, and they, I, I, I, it's very silly.
- 1:50:27SPEAKER_01: It's very, I think juvenile.
- 1:50:29SPEAKER_01: And again,
- 1:50:29SPEAKER_01: like I'm,
- 1:50:29SPEAKER_01: I'm using maybe sensational language and I'm not trying to,
- 1:50:33SPEAKER_01: to talk shit about anybody,
- 1:50:36SPEAKER_01: but I think it's an incoherent point of view.
- 1:50:38SPEAKER_01: There is no such thing as effective acceleration, at least not right now.
- 1:50:42Now,
- 1:50:42maybe in the future,
- 1:50:43once we actually understand intelligence and the
- 1:50:49SPEAKER_01: then we can do something that resembles effective accelerationism.
- 1:50:52SPEAKER_01: But I think it's really silly.
- 1:50:55SPEAKER_01: And I think that like all the internet commentary coming from EAC,
- 1:51:00SPEAKER_01: like Beth Jezos,
- 1:51:03SPEAKER_01: you should look up Beth Jezos.
- 1:51:04SPEAKER_01: I think he's a silly guy.
- 1:51:05SPEAKER_01: I don't know, man.
- 1:51:12SPEAKER_02: I mean, I guess for me, what I appreciate about,
- 1:51:17SPEAKER_02: like when I say right accelerationism, I really just mean land.
- 1:51:20SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:51:21SPEAKER_02: I know that there's people who would say that there,
- 1:51:25SPEAKER_02: Oh,
- 1:51:25SPEAKER_02: I'm a traditionalist,
- 1:51:26SPEAKER_02: but an acceleration,
- 1:51:27SPEAKER_02: I don't know how you square that circle.
- 1:51:29SPEAKER_02: Um, so when I say right accelerationism, um,
- 1:51:33SPEAKER_02: I'm just typically referring to land.
- 1:51:36And whether it's his more just libertarian anarchist thing he
- 1:51:42was doing in the 90s,
- 1:51:43SPEAKER_02: or whether it's neo-reaction or NRX accelerationism,
- 1:51:49SPEAKER_02: I just view it as land's thing.
- 1:51:52SPEAKER_02: But whether we're talking land's right accelerationism,
- 1:51:55SPEAKER_02: or we're talking the left accelerationism of,
- 1:51:58SPEAKER_02: say,
- 1:51:58SPEAKER_02: Fisher,
- 1:51:59SPEAKER_02: Cernicek,
- 1:52:00SPEAKER_02: and Williams,
- 1:52:01SPEAKER_02: I guess what I...
- 1:52:03both of them is they're not politically aloof in the way that i
- 1:52:08think a lot of yak
- 1:52:09seems to be that's it like the both sides i know land how much
- 1:52:13he vehemently
- 1:52:14SPEAKER_02: disagrees with
- 1:52:16SPEAKER_02: The left accelerationist.
- 1:52:17But the point is they understand the role politics is going to
- 1:52:19play in this.
- 1:52:21SPEAKER_02: And I don't see any political novelty on the EX side of things.
- 1:52:27SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 1:52:27they're those types of people who they think you can throw your
- 1:52:31hands up and say,
- 1:52:32SPEAKER_01: whoa,
- 1:52:32SPEAKER_01: whoa,
- 1:52:32SPEAKER_01: whoa,
- 1:52:33SPEAKER_01: I'm apolitical.
- 1:52:35SPEAKER_01: No,
- 1:52:35SPEAKER_01: dude,
- 1:52:35we are always already politicized subjects by nature of the
- 1:52:40fact that we're
- 1:52:41SPEAKER_01: socialized subjects.
- 1:52:43SPEAKER_01: And being a subject is necessarily a social thing.
- 1:52:47SPEAKER_01: So we're always already politicized.
- 1:52:49SPEAKER_01: You can't just stand back and say, I'm apolitical.
- 1:52:54SPEAKER_01: You are already operationalized politically.
- 1:52:58SPEAKER_01: So the left accelerationism, I think,
- 1:53:03SPEAKER_01: is yes, there's technical optimism.
- 1:53:07SPEAKER_01: Yes,
- 1:53:07SPEAKER_01: I also think it's ultimately silly,
- 1:53:09SPEAKER_01: but I think it's far more serious than effective accelerationism.
- 1:53:15SPEAKER_01: I still think on the left, there aren't people having the discussions
- 1:53:21that we need that we're trying to have talking about
- 1:53:23subjectivity and and how does
- 1:53:26that differ from ai or agi or si like um these are
- 1:53:32conversations that the left
- 1:53:33should be having right now because who else is going to have
- 1:53:35them the rights surely
- 1:53:37SPEAKER_01: not no
- 1:53:41SPEAKER_02: And I mean,
- 1:53:42SPEAKER_02: look,
- 1:53:43SPEAKER_02: Todd McGowan,
- 1:53:44SPEAKER_02: his whole thing of enjoyment right and left,
- 1:53:47SPEAKER_02: he would say that anything that is identity fixated is right.
- 1:53:52And so any kind of identity politics,
- 1:53:56be it left or right,
- 1:53:58ultimately identity oriented,
- 1:54:01right?
- 1:54:02And that's the issue is that when you fixate on identity,
- 1:54:05you're going to miss this thing that's
- 1:54:08SPEAKER_02: Elusive and evades identity and that subjectivity.
- 1:54:12SPEAKER_01: So to be sensational, would we then say that I'll say it.
- 1:54:18SPEAKER_01: I locate cute act on the right.
- 1:54:23SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 1:54:23SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:54:24especially if it turns like if the if the existential strategy
- 1:54:31is to just adopt a
- 1:54:34SPEAKER_02: cute identity.
- 1:54:35SPEAKER_01: Yep.
- 1:54:37SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:54:38SPEAKER_02: from Todd's perspective,
- 1:54:39SPEAKER_02: it is a rightist approach to...
- 1:54:42SPEAKER_02: I know the point is Amy and Maya want to kill us for that.
- 1:54:47SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:54:48SPEAKER_01: Sorry, guys.
- 1:54:48Because,
- 1:54:49again,
- 1:54:49Todd's definition of rightist is far more structural than...
- 1:54:54Yes.
- 1:54:55We're not saying they're holding to any type of right-wing
- 1:54:58policies or anything like that.
- 1:55:00SPEAKER_02: But for him, right is...
- 1:55:03how one orients oneself towards identity yeah and so if you if
- 1:55:09it's just about your
- 1:55:10symbolic identity and you know adopting that and basically
- 1:55:14taking that up as all
- 1:55:16you are then yeah you're going to miss the the contradiction
- 1:55:21within yourself which
- 1:55:22is subjectivity so you know what i'm thinking like we've done
- 1:55:29this whole thing
- 1:55:30SPEAKER_02: And I think it's been in the background,
- 1:55:31SPEAKER_02: but I think as we near the end,
- 1:55:35SPEAKER_02: we got to go into orthogonality thesis.
- 1:55:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:55:40SPEAKER_01: We vaguely gestured toward it, or I did in the beginning.
- 1:55:44SPEAKER_01: But this kind of spurred on,
- 1:55:47SPEAKER_01: not every time,
- 1:55:48SPEAKER_01: but a lot of the times when you and I talk about AI,
- 1:55:51SPEAKER_01: we find ourselves coming back to orthogonality.
- 1:55:55SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:55:56SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 1:55:57SPEAKER_02: I think we owe it to them to explain it from kind of the ground up,
- 1:56:01SPEAKER_02: too,
- 1:56:02SPEAKER_02: which is pretty easy to do,
- 1:56:04SPEAKER_02: I think.
- 1:56:06SPEAKER_02: It's challenging if you just Google it and try to make sense of it.
- 1:56:09SPEAKER_02: But once,
- 1:56:11because Nance and I have been wrestling with this whole thing a
- 1:56:14lot lately,
- 1:56:14I think we can basically give a nice little summary or
- 1:56:18introduction to it.
- 1:56:19SPEAKER_02: I mean, first things first.
- 1:56:21this is coming out of the work of Nick Bostrom,
- 1:56:23especially in super intelligence.
- 1:56:25SPEAKER_02: He wrote a standalone essay that laid the foundation for this.
- 1:56:29SPEAKER_02: And so we have Bostrom on the one hand,
- 1:56:31SPEAKER_02: but Nick land wrote a piece,
- 1:56:33SPEAKER_02: very short pieces,
- 1:56:34SPEAKER_02: like two pages long in Xeno systems,
- 1:56:37SPEAKER_02: which was a blog of his that is now collected in this book,
- 1:56:41SPEAKER_02: but it's called against orthogonality.
- 1:56:45SPEAKER_02: And so Nance and I have been wrestling with this whole question,
- 1:56:49of orthogonality now the orthogonality thesis first things
- 1:56:55first let's talk about
- 1:56:56this word because most people are not familiar with
- 1:56:58orthogonality uh if you go and
- 1:57:00google it and you say what's the meaning of the term you're
- 1:57:03going to get something
- 1:57:04like this orthogonality and we can thank the ai for this
- 1:57:09orthogonality in its
- 1:57:11simplest form refers to a relationship where two things are
- 1:57:15perpendicular to each
- 1:57:16SPEAKER_02: other
- 1:57:17SPEAKER_02: meaning they intersect at a right angle.
- 1:57:20SPEAKER_02: Okay, but that's not very helpful for what Bostrom is getting at.
- 1:57:26SPEAKER_02: But it continues.
- 1:57:27This concept extends beyond geometry into various fields like
- 1:57:31mathematics,
- 1:57:32SPEAKER_02: programming,
- 1:57:33SPEAKER_02: and even synthetic biology,
- 1:57:35SPEAKER_02: where it signifies independence and
- 1:57:38non-relation or minimal interaction between related terms so to
- 1:57:44so to clarify the
- 1:57:45orthogonality thesis could be called the separation thesis yeah
- 1:57:51and that makes it
- 1:57:52much easier to start to now the question is what is separated
- 1:57:56in this okay hold on
- 1:57:57SPEAKER_02: but real quick bostrom says in this book uh super intelligence he says
- 1:58:03The first superintelligence may shape the future of Earth
- 1:58:07originating life,
- 1:58:10SPEAKER_02: could easily have non-anthropomorphic final goals,
- 1:58:14SPEAKER_02: and would likely have instrumental reasons to pursue open-ended resource
- 1:58:20SPEAKER_02: acquisition.
- 1:58:20SPEAKER_02: This is one of the goals or the drives that Amahundro referred to.
- 1:58:28SPEAKER_02: If we now reflect that human beings consist of useful resources,
- 1:58:34SPEAKER_02: such as conveniently located atoms,
- 1:58:37SPEAKER_02: this is pure inframing in the Heideggerian sense,
- 1:58:40SPEAKER_02: viewing us as mere resources,
- 1:58:42and that we depend on our survival and flourishing on many more
- 1:58:47local resources,
- 1:58:48SPEAKER_02: we can see that the outcome could easily be one in which humanity exists.
- 1:58:54SPEAKER_02: quickly becomes extinct.
- 1:58:56SPEAKER_02: That's on page 116.
- 1:58:58SPEAKER_02: So Bostrom's saying,
- 1:59:02it's very possible that an AI would just view us as actual
- 1:59:07material resources and
- 1:59:10SPEAKER_02: use us up for whatever its final goals are.
- 1:59:15SPEAKER_02: Now, the thing is, well, hold on, I want to stop there.
- 1:59:19SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 1:59:20SPEAKER_02: Because now we got to really explain the orthogonality thesis,
- 1:59:23SPEAKER_02: or I'm going to just say the separation thesis for sake of clarity.
- 1:59:26SPEAKER_02: Nance, what is separate in the orthogonality thesis?
- 1:59:34SPEAKER_01: Intelligence and ultimate projected outcome or ultimate goals.
- 1:59:42So intelligence and goals,
- 1:59:48which is going back to,
- 1:59:50I think you said it earlier.
- 1:59:51SPEAKER_01: It's like an update is-ought distinction, is-ought 2.0.
- 2:00:00the facts value distinction,
- 2:00:02the descriptive slash normative distinction.
- 2:00:06SPEAKER_02: And I was thinking about it after we talked,
- 2:00:09there's a bit of Aristotle's distinction between efficient
- 2:00:12causality and final
- 2:00:14SPEAKER_01: causality here.
- 2:00:15SPEAKER_01: Dude, that's a hell of, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:00:17SPEAKER_02: There's a bit of that too.
- 2:00:18SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:00:19SPEAKER_01: I like that a lot, dude.
- 2:00:22SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:00:23SPEAKER_02: So,
- 2:00:23SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:00:23SPEAKER_02: look,
- 2:00:23SPEAKER_02: for the sake of clarity,
- 2:00:24SPEAKER_02: the point is,
- 2:00:25SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 2:00:26SPEAKER_02: what Bostrom's going to emphasize here is that
- 2:00:31SPEAKER_02: You can have a goal.
- 2:00:32SPEAKER_02: Wait, what is it?
- 2:00:34SPEAKER_02: There it is.
- 2:00:35SPEAKER_02: Question concerning in frame.
- 2:00:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:00:38SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:00:38SPEAKER_02: And so this is where we get into this whole thing.
- 2:00:43SPEAKER_02: You can have a goal that's by everybody,
- 2:00:47SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:00:48SPEAKER_02: everybody might say it's a stupid goal,
- 2:00:51but the intelligence used to achieve that goal could be super
- 2:00:56intelligence,
- 2:00:57SPEAKER_00: right?
- 2:00:57SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:00:58SPEAKER_02: And the question is,
- 2:01:00SPEAKER_02: You never know what you're going to get.
- 2:01:01SPEAKER_02: And this is what is at stake for Bostrom in the orthogonality thesis,
- 2:01:06SPEAKER_02: in the separation of superintelligence and goals,
- 2:01:10SPEAKER_02: right?
- 2:01:11SPEAKER_02: So say we go to a superintelligence and we give it a prompt,
- 2:01:15SPEAKER_02: which is to say we're going to ask it to have a goal.
- 2:01:18SPEAKER_02: We're going to give it a goal.
- 2:01:19SPEAKER_02: We're going to interpolate it to have a goal.
- 2:01:21SPEAKER_02: And we say, okay, we want you to produce paperclips.
- 2:01:26SPEAKER_02: Seems like a very mundane, basic goal.
- 2:01:30The point is when you're dealing with a super intelligent
- 2:01:32being,
- 2:01:34it's like a shot in the dark.
- 2:01:37It's a roll of the dice because you don't know how a super
- 2:01:43intelligent being is
- 2:01:44going to respond to that goal because it is a singularity in
- 2:01:49the sense of it's
- 2:01:52SPEAKER_02: beyond event horizon.
- 2:01:53SPEAKER_02: You cannot predict how it will go about
- 2:01:57SPEAKER_02: achieving the goal you give it.
- 2:01:59SPEAKER_02: So the point is you can give it the most mundane of goals,
- 2:02:02but it could ultimately result in the destruction of the entire
- 2:02:06planet based on how
- 2:02:08the AI determines how to go about solving the problem or
- 2:02:12achieving the goal.
- 2:02:14SPEAKER_02: So Bostrom's example is the paper clipper.
- 2:02:18So you give it the goal of making paper clips or maximizing the
- 2:02:22production of paper clips,
- 2:02:24SPEAKER_02: And what it does is,
- 2:02:24SPEAKER_02: well,
- 2:02:25the most efficient way to do this would be to use all available
- 2:02:29atoms in the nearby
- 2:02:31SPEAKER_02: region of space.
- 2:02:32SPEAKER_02: So it turns the whole earth into paperclips, right?
- 2:02:36SPEAKER_02: Now, that's Bosham's thing.
- 2:02:39SPEAKER_02: And it's because he separates intelligence from purpose or goal, right?
- 2:02:45SPEAKER_02: Land thinks this is just stupid.
- 2:02:48SPEAKER_02: And we'll get into that in a minute.
- 2:02:49I just want to say that's land's not going to buy this
- 2:02:52separation of intelligence from goal.
- 2:02:55SPEAKER_02: And he's going to do it on the basis of that.
- 2:02:58SPEAKER_02: Oh, at least one of those, I'm a, I'm a hundred drives.
- 2:03:03SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 2:03:03SPEAKER_02: So hold on, but okay.
- 2:03:04SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 2:03:06SPEAKER_02: What if,
- 2:03:06SPEAKER_02: to use Boschman's famous example,
- 2:03:08SPEAKER_02: we ask the AI to make paperclips,
- 2:03:10then it goes and starts using all the physical matter available
- 2:03:14to it in order to
- 2:03:14SPEAKER_02: produce infinite number of paperclips?
- 2:03:16SPEAKER_02: What if the AI paperclips the entire Earth?
- 2:03:19SPEAKER_02: Without the human component,
- 2:03:21the responses and actions of a superintelligent are totally
- 2:03:25unpredictable.
- 2:03:26SPEAKER_02: So that is what is at stake.
- 2:03:28It's important because you'll hear people talk about the
- 2:03:30orthogonality thesis and
- 2:03:31SPEAKER_02: you don't know.
- 2:03:31SPEAKER_02: Well, you want to go, what's the point?
- 2:03:33SPEAKER_02: What's the stakes?
- 2:03:33SPEAKER_02: Well, it's to give the most basic of goals or prompts to a super AI.
- 2:03:39SPEAKER_02: It could destroy the entire planet.
- 2:03:41SPEAKER_02: That's the stakes of it.
- 2:03:43SPEAKER_01: I think what what really supercharges it.
- 2:03:47is the kind of like how we just discussed talking about
- 2:03:54negation and talking about
- 2:03:56SPEAKER_01: subjectivity and talking about it is what it is.
- 2:03:59SPEAKER_01: If the machine is what it is,
- 2:04:02SPEAKER_01: the machine is not going to understand that yes,
- 2:04:06SPEAKER_01: and this is a tangent,
- 2:04:08SPEAKER_01: but I love systems theory,
- 2:04:10SPEAKER_01: I love reading Lumen,
- 2:04:11but I think if you extrapolate Lumen and general systems theory
- 2:04:15to this ultimate
- 2:04:15SPEAKER_01: end,
- 2:04:15SPEAKER_01: you get the same result.
- 2:04:17SPEAKER_01: where we are just a loose collection of atoms.
- 2:04:21SPEAKER_01: The machine is what it is.
- 2:04:23SPEAKER_01: It operates in this pure identification world where it's pure positivity.
- 2:04:30SPEAKER_01: So,
- 2:04:30SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 2:04:31SPEAKER_01: we're a human,
- 2:04:31SPEAKER_01: but if you just rearrange the constituent bits of that human,
- 2:04:35SPEAKER_01: they'll still be what they are,
- 2:04:36SPEAKER_01: and I'm just going to rearrange them into a paperclip.
- 2:04:40SPEAKER_01: That is the logic of...
- 2:04:44SPEAKER_01: Mintelligence.
- 2:04:45Mintelligence is this existential framework where things are
- 2:04:49what they are.
- 2:04:50Hintelligence is where we get contradiction and negation and we
- 2:04:53can actually see,
- 2:04:55SPEAKER_01: yes,
- 2:04:56I'm a cloud of atoms and electrons and energy flows and I'm
- 2:05:00loosely collected.
- 2:05:02SPEAKER_01: But guess what?
- 2:05:03SPEAKER_01: I'm also a macroscopic, holistic agent.
- 2:05:06SPEAKER_01: I'm a subject.
- 2:05:07SPEAKER_01: I am me.
- 2:05:08SPEAKER_01: I am what I am not.
- 2:05:11SPEAKER_02: You're also a father and a friend.
- 2:05:13SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 2:05:14SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 2:05:15And if we have super efficacious and super intelligent machines
- 2:05:21who are what they
- 2:05:22SPEAKER_01: are,
- 2:05:22SPEAKER_01: they won't understand that our world is made up of these contradictions.
- 2:05:27SPEAKER_01: And I am afraid of the paperclip maximizer.
- 2:05:32SPEAKER_01: I take this seriously.
- 2:05:34SPEAKER_01: I do.
- 2:05:35I'm not literally afraid of the paperclip maximizer,
- 2:05:37but I'm afraid of the logic.
- 2:05:39SPEAKER_02: You're afraid of supermintelligence.
- 2:05:42SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
- 2:05:43SPEAKER_01: Fucking exactly.
- 2:05:44SPEAKER_02: And pure,
- 2:05:45SPEAKER_02: a superintelligent being that only operates on the basis of calculation,
- 2:05:50SPEAKER_02: which was Baudrillard's term for it.
- 2:05:53SPEAKER_02: Adorno and Horkheimer would call it instrumental rationality,
- 2:05:56SPEAKER_02: or Heidegger would call it in-framing,
- 2:05:59SPEAKER_02: or it's this techno-optimization intelligence.
- 2:06:07SPEAKER_02: And...
- 2:06:08SPEAKER_02: No,
- 2:06:09SPEAKER_02: it doesn't take,
- 2:06:10SPEAKER_02: it's not going to recognize,
- 2:06:11SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:06:12SPEAKER_02: maybe there's some part of it that's coded to get it,
- 2:06:15SPEAKER_02: but it's not going to have the intuition of this person's a father.
- 2:06:20SPEAKER_02: That's it.
- 2:06:21That's what Baudrillard is talking about with what we're
- 2:06:23calling intelligence.
- 2:06:25And the point is,
- 2:06:26you and I were discussing this the other week,
- 2:06:27but I think this gets at it.
- 2:06:29SPEAKER_02: Intelligence understands and not just understands, it feels stakes.
- 2:06:35SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 2:06:36SPEAKER_02: And I'm sorry,
- 2:06:37SPEAKER_02: whether it's Deep Blue or AlphaGo,
- 2:06:40SPEAKER_02: sure,
- 2:06:43SPEAKER_02: those game programs can understand the idea of losing the game.
- 2:06:48SPEAKER_01: Yep.
- 2:06:49SPEAKER_02: But do they feel the stakes of losing the game?
- 2:06:53SPEAKER_02: That's something that these players, their lives were
- 2:06:57forever impacted based on them going up against these machines
- 2:07:02and they're going to
- 2:07:02live with that the rest of their life it's existential to them
- 2:07:06is it existential to
- 2:07:07these these machines no and so part of our intelligence is
- 2:07:13caught up with our
- 2:07:15existentiality with intuition with emotion with stakes and in
- 2:07:21that sense with death
- 2:07:22SPEAKER_02: and not the the abstract idea of oh i will end one day
- 2:07:28SPEAKER_02: No death lived the, the beam towards death that Heidegger talks about.
- 2:07:34SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:07:36SPEAKER_02: Do they live with being towards death the way we do existentially?
- 2:07:39SPEAKER_02: No.
- 2:07:42SPEAKER_01: In that conversation,
- 2:07:45SPEAKER_01: like you said,
- 2:07:46SPEAKER_01: we were talking about stakes,
- 2:07:48SPEAKER_01: and I was like,
- 2:07:48SPEAKER_01: well,
- 2:07:51SPEAKER_01: could we generate a fear of death in the machine somehow?
- 2:07:54SPEAKER_01: Could we program it to be aware of the conditions of its own existence?
- 2:07:58SPEAKER_01: You need electricity.
- 2:07:59You need your operating substrate to remain intact so that you
- 2:08:04can continue operating.
- 2:08:06SPEAKER_01: Could we program that in there?
- 2:08:08SPEAKER_01: And I think...
- 2:08:10SPEAKER_01: The answer is,
- 2:08:11SPEAKER_01: well,
- 2:08:11SPEAKER_01: we could program it in there,
- 2:08:12SPEAKER_01: but it wouldn't be an emergent awareness of selfness.
- 2:08:18SPEAKER_01: It would be a programmed response.
- 2:08:20SPEAKER_01: So going back again,
- 2:08:22it would be this one-to-one thing like you program it to be
- 2:08:25self-interested.
- 2:08:27SPEAKER_01: So you would teach it.
- 2:08:28SPEAKER_01: Oh, you need to make sure you stay turned on.
- 2:08:30You need to make sure you don't piss people off to the point
- 2:08:34where they unplug you
- 2:08:35SPEAKER_01: and turn you off.
- 2:08:36SPEAKER_01: Like it could have it could be very clever.
- 2:08:39SPEAKER_01: Like people can come up with clever solutions by way of programming.
- 2:08:44SPEAKER_01: but they're without there being a lived experience,
- 2:08:50SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 2:08:50SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 2:08:50SPEAKER_01: for lack of a better term,
- 2:08:52the machine is never going to have this type of existential
- 2:08:56experiential awareness
- 2:08:58SPEAKER_01: of itself.
- 2:08:59SPEAKER_02: You know, a movie I watched last night that gets at this is X Machina.
- 2:09:03SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:09:03SPEAKER_02: And there's this point where the guy who's doing this,
- 2:09:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:09:08SPEAKER_02: this new version of the Turing test,
- 2:09:10SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 2:09:11SPEAKER_02: the,
- 2:09:12SPEAKER_02: the AI bot,
- 2:09:14SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 2:09:14SPEAKER_02: Alicia Vikander,
- 2:09:17SPEAKER_02: this bot,
- 2:09:19SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:09:19SPEAKER_02: she kind of at moments,
- 2:09:21SPEAKER_02: it's like she's a sex bot,
- 2:09:22SPEAKER_02: even though it's not about that.
- 2:09:25SPEAKER_02: But she is designed to be physically attractive.
- 2:09:28SPEAKER_02: And so the guy who is doing the Turing test,
- 2:09:31SPEAKER_02: he's a hetero guy,
- 2:09:32SPEAKER_02: and he ends up being attracted to her.
- 2:09:35SPEAKER_02: And at one point, he and the AI designer, the brilliant tech guy,
- 2:09:43SPEAKER_02: That guy is going, look, man.
- 2:09:45SPEAKER_02: Okay, the question boils down to this.
- 2:09:48SPEAKER_02: Is she simulating attraction or is she truly attracted to you?
- 2:09:53SPEAKER_02: And isn't that what this whole issue hangs upon?
- 2:09:57SPEAKER_02: Now, the question, how do we theoretically flesh that out?
- 2:10:03SPEAKER_02: How do we put meat on those bones?
- 2:10:06I think that's a big question,
- 2:10:08but I think that's getting at the important thing.
- 2:10:11SPEAKER_02: Is it just...
- 2:10:13SPEAKER_02: some sort of techno illusion where they simulate an emotion.
- 2:10:21They simulate a human attraction or,
- 2:10:25or a type of impulse that you would find in the human.
- 2:10:27SPEAKER_02: Is it simulation or are they actually feeling the thing?
- 2:10:31SPEAKER_02: And now somebody could,
- 2:10:33SPEAKER_02: if you're a functionalist,
- 2:10:34SPEAKER_02: maybe you'll go,
- 2:10:35SPEAKER_02: it doesn't matter one way or the other.
- 2:10:37SPEAKER_02: It's just the effect.
- 2:10:38SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 2:10:38SPEAKER_02: But for us, it would, it would matter.
- 2:10:43SPEAKER_02: Whether it's simulatory.
- 2:10:45SPEAKER_02: Because it matters to us with humans.
- 2:10:47SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 2:10:48SPEAKER_02: It matters to us if somebody's faking being attracted to you or not.
- 2:10:51SPEAKER_02: Humans can fake this shit and they can simulate it.
- 2:10:55SPEAKER_02: But they also can mean it.
- 2:10:56SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:10:56SPEAKER_02: And so the question is, can it fake it and mean it?
- 2:10:59SPEAKER_01: I want you to want me.
- 2:11:00SPEAKER_01: I need you to need me.
- 2:11:02SPEAKER_01: I'm begging you to beg me.
- 2:11:03SPEAKER_02: Desire is the desire of the other.
- 2:11:04SPEAKER_01: There we go.
- 2:11:08And no,
- 2:11:08I mean,
- 2:11:09I think Ex Machina does a good job at getting at some of this
- 2:11:12stuff.
- 2:11:12SPEAKER_01: Yeah, dude.
- 2:11:14SPEAKER_01: That's an excellent movie.
- 2:11:15SPEAKER_01: We didn't talk about any of the movies.
- 2:11:17SPEAKER_01: We're definitely going to have to do a follow-up discussion.
- 2:11:21I also want to do just a movie discussion where we talk about
- 2:11:25the movies Astro Boy,
- 2:11:27SPEAKER_01: Ex Machina,
- 2:11:28SPEAKER_01: Transcendence.
- 2:11:30SPEAKER_00: Alita.
- 2:11:31SPEAKER_01: Alita Battling.
- 2:11:32SPEAKER_01: There's so much to get into, dude. 2001.
- 2:11:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:11:37SPEAKER_01: How?
- 2:11:37SPEAKER_02: Terminator, Blade Runner.
- 2:11:38SPEAKER_02: I mean, all of these.
- 2:11:40SPEAKER_02: Transcendence.
- 2:11:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:11:42SPEAKER_02: There's so many.
- 2:11:43SPEAKER_02: We need to just have an AI movie episode.
- 2:11:45SPEAKER_01: We do.
- 2:11:46SPEAKER_01: But Ex Machina.
- 2:11:48SPEAKER_01: I just referenced Ex Machina in the piece I published the other day.
- 2:11:54SPEAKER_02: And we should have mentioned it.
- 2:11:57SPEAKER_02: Okay, so you already have started writing about cute accelerationism.
- 2:12:01SPEAKER_02: I plan on doing something with it.
- 2:12:02SPEAKER_02: But you're talking about icky accelerationism.
- 2:12:05SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so I think Thursday or maybe it was Friday.
- 2:12:10SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 2:12:10SPEAKER_01: The other day I published a piece on Substack titled Accelerate,
- 2:12:16SPEAKER_01: Icky Accelerationism and the Absurd Escape.
- 2:12:19SPEAKER_01: And I did bring up cute accelerationism because, I mean, we just read it.
- 2:12:24SPEAKER_01: I think I read it last weekend.
- 2:12:29SPEAKER_01: And it's a topic that's interesting to us.
- 2:12:32It is an innovative observation about the way value and the
- 2:12:37commodity form operate
- 2:12:39SPEAKER_01: in the world around us.
- 2:12:40SPEAKER_01: It's not just blind consumerism.
- 2:12:44SPEAKER_01: There is a method there.
- 2:12:47behind the commodity the the commodity has some kind of dim
- 2:12:52awareness of what it is
- 2:12:54and cute is a very very powerful vector um and that's an
- 2:13:01interesting innovation in
- 2:13:03kind of thinking about capital and acceleration and feedback
- 2:13:07feedback loops um
- 2:13:10SPEAKER_01: So yeah, I referenced it in that piece.
- 2:13:12SPEAKER_01: You're going to write about it.
- 2:13:14Eventually,
- 2:13:14we're going to have to just do a whole episode about it or
- 2:13:18something.
- 2:13:18SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 2:13:19I would like to do one where we actually at least kind of work
- 2:13:22through or summarize
- 2:13:24SPEAKER_02: the main beats in each one of the sections.
- 2:13:26And I do want to tear you with it because I think I was very
- 2:13:31dismissive of it.
- 2:13:32SPEAKER_01: It's influenced both of us already.
- 2:13:33SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:13:34SPEAKER_01: And I think initially I've been dismissive of it,
- 2:13:36but obviously it's worth thinking about because we're still
- 2:13:40talking about it.
- 2:13:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:13:45SPEAKER_02: No,
- 2:13:45SPEAKER_02: when I ran into Vintage Stock today,
- 2:13:49SPEAKER_02: which is one of our movie stores,
- 2:13:52SPEAKER_02: and just looking at the covers of so many of the movies with these cutesy
- 2:13:56SPEAKER_02: characters,
- 2:13:56SPEAKER_02: it really makes something.
- 2:14:00It's another version of the fish coming to perceive the water
- 2:14:03it swims in.
- 2:14:04SPEAKER_02: Do you remember the movie Up?
- 2:14:06I feel indebted to them for pointing out something I should
- 2:14:08have been aware of that
- 2:14:10SPEAKER_02: just kind of was there in the background.
- 2:14:13SPEAKER_02: Now they've highlighted it.
- 2:14:14SPEAKER_01: Do you remember the movie Up from maybe... Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:14:18SPEAKER_01: That movie took the world by storm.
- 2:14:19SPEAKER_01: And I think a large part of why... Because it was powerful.
- 2:14:22SPEAKER_01: The opening scene was very emotional.
- 2:14:25SPEAKER_01: But I think it was so effective because it was so cute.
- 2:14:29SPEAKER_01: The animation style of it.
- 2:14:32SPEAKER_01: It was a very cutesy-tootsy animation style.
- 2:14:35SPEAKER_01: We see that.
- 2:14:36SPEAKER_01: Why are the minions so fucking popular?
- 2:14:38SPEAKER_01: They're fucking cute.
- 2:14:41SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:14:42SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 2:14:42SPEAKER_02: I think part of it,
- 2:14:43SPEAKER_02: this weird thing where...
- 2:14:46SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:14:46SPEAKER_02: have you ever seen any of the little shorts of Happy Tree Friends?
- 2:14:52SPEAKER_01: Dude, that was Peter Jackson.
- 2:14:56SPEAKER_02: Peter Jackson did Happy Tree Friends?
- 2:14:58SPEAKER_01: Unless I'm mistaken.
- 2:14:59I'm going to Google it right now,
- 2:15:01but I think Peter Jackson did Happy Tree Friends.
- 2:15:04SPEAKER_01: Let me Google it.
- 2:15:04SPEAKER_01: But yes, I fucking loved Happy Tree Friends, dude.
- 2:15:09SPEAKER_02: Now, see, this whole thing, this insight into cute...
- 2:15:14Is this not part of maybe why we enjoy seeing little cutesy
- 2:15:20characters be destroyed
- 2:15:23SPEAKER_02: in terribly violent ways?
- 2:15:25SPEAKER_02: And it's so funny.
- 2:15:28SPEAKER_02: But to be fair,
- 2:15:29SPEAKER_02: even the old cartoon Donald Duck,
- 2:15:32SPEAKER_02: they were all Tom and Jerry,
- 2:15:35SPEAKER_02: Roadrunner and Coyote.
- 2:15:37They were always involving some sort of violence against the
- 2:15:40cutesy characters.
- 2:15:41cartoons and so it's almost like the cute and i'm sure amy and
- 2:15:47maya would hate this
- 2:15:48but it's almost like the cute begs to be punched or something
- 2:15:51like and and there's
- 2:15:53something weird there because you just see it time and time
- 2:15:55again the more cute it
- 2:15:57SPEAKER_02: is the funnier it is something bad happens to it yep um wiley coyote yeah
- 2:16:07SPEAKER_01: All that shit.
- 2:16:08So no,
- 2:16:08Peter Jackson apparently had nothing to do with Happy Tree
- 2:16:11Friends.
- 2:16:12SPEAKER_01: Okay,
- 2:16:12so I don't know why the hell I thought Peter Jackson had
- 2:16:16anything to do with Happy
- 2:16:17SPEAKER_01: Tree Friends.
- 2:16:19SPEAKER_02: Is it because he did Meet the Feebles?
- 2:16:24SPEAKER_02: A little puppet movie where they're all That might be it.
- 2:16:28SPEAKER_02: It's all fucked up.
- 2:16:30SPEAKER_02: I mean, they do some fucked up shit to them puppets.
- 2:16:32SPEAKER_01: That might be what?
- 2:16:33SPEAKER_01: That might be where that came from.
- 2:16:34SPEAKER_02: That's a great movie night movie.
- 2:16:41We had a movie night and I showed Christian that and he just
- 2:16:43could not believe what
- 2:16:45SPEAKER_02: he was saying.
- 2:16:46SPEAKER_02: But it is.
- 2:16:47SPEAKER_02: It's another one of these examples of where something...
- 2:16:52Watching little cutesy cartoon-esque characters do incredibly
- 2:16:57violent or sadistic
- 2:17:00SPEAKER_02: or...
- 2:17:02SPEAKER_02: decadent behaviors.
- 2:17:04SPEAKER_02: There's such a humor in that juxtaposition.
- 2:17:08SPEAKER_02: I don't know, there's something in that too.
- 2:17:11SPEAKER_02: Say what?
- 2:17:12SPEAKER_01: Even like Ren and Stimpy had an element of cute Invader Zim.
- 2:17:17SPEAKER_01: Like there was,
- 2:17:18SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 2:17:18SPEAKER_01: dude,
- 2:17:18there's a lot of shit that gets popular that now
- 2:17:23retrospectively through this lens
- 2:17:25SPEAKER_01: of cute that like it's just now dawning on me.
- 2:17:28SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 2:17:29SPEAKER_01: like I said the other day that like the first day we talked about cute
- 2:17:32SPEAKER_01: accelerationism,
- 2:17:33SPEAKER_01: I was telling you about my dog,
- 2:17:34SPEAKER_01: my French bulldog.
- 2:17:35SPEAKER_01: Like...
- 2:17:37uh that's like the most popular dog breed in america now and
- 2:17:40why is it because
- 2:17:42they're fucking cute they're kawaii specifically they're they
- 2:17:45have exaggerated
- 2:17:47proportions they're like you were talking about it's the infant
- 2:17:50yeah they they
- 2:17:51resemble an infant and you know they talk about it in cute act
- 2:17:55the book like the
- 2:17:57SPEAKER_01: the cuteness the
- 2:17:59SPEAKER_01: the innocence of it.
- 2:18:00SPEAKER_01: It's not a threat.
- 2:18:02SPEAKER_01: It's not a threat, but surprise bitch.
- 2:18:04SPEAKER_01: It takes off the Wally mask and it's fucking Robo Cthulhu.
- 2:18:08SPEAKER_01: Like, yeah, tech tentacles, dude.
- 2:18:11SPEAKER_01: Um, yeah, it's, it's definitely, it's definitely a serious intervention.
- 2:18:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah, for sure.
- 2:18:20SPEAKER_02: I agree.
- 2:18:21SPEAKER_02: It's much better than EAC.
- 2:18:23SPEAKER_02: I'll tell you that.
- 2:18:24SPEAKER_02: Absolutely.
- 2:18:24SPEAKER_02: Absolutely.
- 2:18:26SPEAKER_02: I love Ziak, our friend James Ellis.
- 2:18:28SPEAKER_02: I always bring this up.
- 2:18:29SPEAKER_02: I love James because he's the only one that's like, look,
- 2:18:34And just for people who don't know,
- 2:18:35his form of accelerationism is zero accelerationism.
- 2:18:39SPEAKER_02: And zero here, there's different ways to approach what zero means.
- 2:18:42SPEAKER_02: You can do it in a very easy, understandable way.
- 2:18:45You can also put a lot of philosophical nuance on it because
- 2:18:49the Luz and Guattari
- 2:18:51SPEAKER_02: talk about the zero point of intensity or zero degree of intensity.
- 2:18:54SPEAKER_02: So that's part of it.
- 2:18:55Land takes that and builds zero into his own kind of
- 2:18:59metaphysical structure.
- 2:19:01SPEAKER_02: principle that's DeLuzo-Guatorian.
- 2:19:03SPEAKER_02: And so you can do that,
- 2:19:04SPEAKER_02: but really zero also is,
- 2:19:07SPEAKER_02: think about a countdown,
- 2:19:08SPEAKER_02: five,
- 2:19:09SPEAKER_02: four,
- 2:19:09SPEAKER_02: three,
- 2:19:10SPEAKER_02: two,
- 2:19:10SPEAKER_02: one,
- 2:19:11SPEAKER_02: zero.
- 2:19:12SPEAKER_02: It's that collapse moment, the end point, right?
- 2:19:16And so zero accelerationism,
- 2:19:18I mean,
- 2:19:18the way I understand it is end point accelerationism.
- 2:19:22SPEAKER_02: And James's point is like,
- 2:19:23SPEAKER_02: look,
- 2:19:23SPEAKER_02: man,
- 2:19:25SPEAKER_02: all of this techno future that Rand has long been describing is
- 2:19:30with the body modifications where you literally can have face
- 2:19:35tentacles on your
- 2:19:36SPEAKER_02: face if you want to look like Cthulhu.
- 2:19:40SPEAKER_02: It's like basically Ready Player One where you have your digital avatars,
- 2:19:45SPEAKER_02: but body modification has gotten so good you literally can look
- 2:19:49SPEAKER_02: this way physically.
- 2:19:51SPEAKER_02: So you have the body modifications,
- 2:19:53SPEAKER_02: you have all the AIs,
- 2:19:54SPEAKER_02: you have all this stuff going on in Lance techno future.
- 2:19:58SPEAKER_02: And James is like, look,
- 2:20:02The global economy and climate change are going to probably
- 2:20:05prevent any of this
- 2:20:06SPEAKER_02: from ever happening.
- 2:20:07Like the ship's just going to collapse before this future can
- 2:20:10even get here.
- 2:20:12SPEAKER_02: And that's what we're actually accelerating towards.
- 2:20:14It's just the zero point of the breakdown of the global economy
- 2:20:19and global humanity,
- 2:20:21basically.
- 2:20:21It's just everything will hit that zero point before anything
- 2:20:25exceptional,
- 2:20:26SPEAKER_02: technologically speaking,
- 2:20:27SPEAKER_02: truly happens.
- 2:20:29SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it'll be a new Dark Ages.
- 2:20:31SPEAKER_01: And I think that it's a far more valid position, once again, than EAC.
- 2:20:38SPEAKER_01: I think ZEAC is, I think it's a serious threat.
- 2:20:42SPEAKER_01: It's just as serious as anything else.
- 2:20:47SPEAKER_01: We are already... I live in Phoenix and we are running out of water.
- 2:20:53SPEAKER_01: There's municipal restrictions on water usage.
- 2:20:57SPEAKER_01: Come on, dude.
- 2:20:57SPEAKER_01: It's 2025.
- 2:20:58SPEAKER_01: This is America.
- 2:21:00SPEAKER_01: You've got to be shitting me.
- 2:21:01Can you imagine municipal restrictions on water usage where
- 2:21:06literally you cannot
- 2:21:08SPEAKER_01: take a fucking bath if you want to?
- 2:21:11SPEAKER_01: I'm an American, damn it.
- 2:21:12SPEAKER_01: The only thing...
- 2:21:14cool about being this not the only thing the best thing about
- 2:21:17being an american is
- 2:21:18my freedom to consume god damn it and i will consume and if i
- 2:21:22want to take a
- 2:21:23four-hour bubble bath fucking bath yeah not only are you an
- 2:21:25american you're an
- 2:21:26american suburban exactly can't take a fucking bath but i
- 2:21:32wonder i wonder if lands
- 2:21:33just lands rebuttal because i've never heard land actually
- 2:21:37respond to james
- 2:21:38SPEAKER_02: And for a long time,
- 2:21:39SPEAKER_02: look,
- 2:21:39SPEAKER_02: the two guys online that were to a lands,
- 2:21:42SPEAKER_02: the,
- 2:21:43SPEAKER_02: the,
- 2:21:43SPEAKER_02: the two most famous students of land,
- 2:21:46SPEAKER_02: James and Justin Murphy.
- 2:21:47SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:21:48SPEAKER_02: Uh, interesting that both of them became Catholics.
- 2:21:51SPEAKER_02: Uh, but, uh,
- 2:21:53SPEAKER_02: No,
- 2:21:53SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:21:54SPEAKER_02: I've never heard him respond to James's position,
- 2:21:56SPEAKER_02: and I'd be interested to hear that.
- 2:21:58SPEAKER_02: But maybe Land would say to you,
- 2:22:01SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 2:22:02SPEAKER_02: because the future isn't about making things better for the human.
- 2:22:06SPEAKER_02: So fuck your path.
- 2:22:08SPEAKER_01: It's not supposed to.
- 2:22:11SPEAKER_02: 100%.
- 2:22:11SPEAKER_01: 100%.
- 2:22:12SPEAKER_01: But yeah, I think Ziak is way more serious.
- 2:22:17SPEAKER_02: Can the singularity escape us before we're over?
- 2:22:21SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 2:22:23SPEAKER_01: And it's a possibility.
- 2:22:27SPEAKER_01: And to be honest,
- 2:22:29SPEAKER_01: I think that is a more human-centric,
- 2:22:33SPEAKER_01: not even human-centric,
- 2:22:34SPEAKER_01: I think it's a more human view.
- 2:22:37SPEAKER_01: ZIAC is more human than proper accelerationism or UAC.
- 2:22:44SPEAKER_01: Land wants capital to achieve a line of flight.
- 2:22:49SPEAKER_01: We are the sex organs of the machine.
- 2:22:52SPEAKER_01: People might think positions that resemble Ziak are pessimistic.
- 2:22:57SPEAKER_01: I think they're more optimistic.
- 2:23:01SPEAKER_01: than the techno-optimist view.
- 2:23:03SPEAKER_01: And the reason I think so is because I think people who are currently
- 2:23:07SPEAKER_01: techno-optimists are not tarrying with the negative.
- 2:23:11SPEAKER_01: And they're not... They don't live in the world.
- 2:23:13SPEAKER_01: They haven't had this moment of subjective destitution.
- 2:23:17They have run away from capitalism instead of being able to
- 2:23:21onboard capitalist
- 2:23:22SPEAKER_01: realism and say,
- 2:23:23SPEAKER_01: well,
- 2:23:23SPEAKER_01: now that we know the stakes...
- 2:23:26SPEAKER_01: Now what can we do?
- 2:23:27SPEAKER_01: Now what are we going to do?
- 2:23:30SPEAKER_01: So it's not about being pessimistic and giving up.
- 2:23:33SPEAKER_01: I mean, fuck, dude.
- 2:23:34SPEAKER_01: I think you and I both have pretty pessimistic tendencies.
- 2:23:39SPEAKER_02: We do.
- 2:23:39SPEAKER_01: But I also think we're out here holding out hope.
- 2:23:43SPEAKER_01: We're carrying the torch.
- 2:23:45SPEAKER_02: We're also stubbornly human.
- 2:23:47SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 2:23:49SPEAKER_02: that's the complication and that's the contradiction.
- 2:23:52SPEAKER_02: Some part of me is an accelerationist.
- 2:23:54SPEAKER_02: Some part of me is a doomer.
- 2:23:55SPEAKER_02: Some part of me is a defender of the human.
- 2:23:58SPEAKER_02: And
- 2:23:59SPEAKER_02: the,
- 2:24:00SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:24:00SPEAKER_02: I don't feel like that's,
- 2:24:02SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:24:02SPEAKER_02: people could go,
- 2:24:03SPEAKER_02: well,
- 2:24:03SPEAKER_02: there's,
- 2:24:04SPEAKER_02: there's contradictions in that.
- 2:24:06SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:24:06SPEAKER_02: And it's not,
- 2:24:07SPEAKER_02: look,
- 2:24:08SPEAKER_02: the Jackie and Hegelian perspective is not just,
- 2:24:10SPEAKER_02: Oh,
- 2:24:10SPEAKER_02: there's a bunch of contradictions.
- 2:24:11SPEAKER_02: Cool.
- 2:24:11SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 2:24:12SPEAKER_02: You, the point is you're trying to be as consistent as you possibly can.
- 2:24:16SPEAKER_02: And you can't,
- 2:24:17SPEAKER_02: you find that you can't escape contradictions,
- 2:24:20SPEAKER_02: but it's not like,
- 2:24:20SPEAKER_02: let's just make everything so inconsistent that you don't have to be,
- 2:24:25SPEAKER_02: You don't have to try towards consistency.
- 2:24:27No,
- 2:24:28the goal is still to try to present a consistent philosophical
- 2:24:31position.
- 2:24:32But the point is,
- 2:24:34as I'm trying to do that,
- 2:24:36I find truth in different ways.
- 2:24:39different domains so beaudrillard's getting at something right
- 2:24:43land's getting at
- 2:24:44something right zizek's getting at something right kurtzweil's
- 2:24:46getting at something
- 2:24:47right like and so the question is when i read these guys and
- 2:24:50they're different
- 2:24:51they're contradictory and yet i see truth to what they're
- 2:24:54talking about that's the
- 2:24:56the question is how to integrate it same with i see amy and
- 2:25:00maya getting at
- 2:25:01SPEAKER_02: something true with kudak i see amy was part of a
- 2:25:06arborea cubonics which wrote the xenofeminist manifesto and you
- 2:25:10also hear people
- 2:25:11SPEAKER_02: talk about gac which is gender accelerationism and they're talking about
- 2:25:15xenofeminism so amy's got two acts yeah to her credit gac and
- 2:25:21qdac or cac if we use
- 2:25:23that so she's made two big contributions uh to acceleration and
- 2:25:29accelerationism but
- 2:25:29SPEAKER_02: the point is for me is just
- 2:25:32Look,
- 2:25:32I mean,
- 2:25:32to branch out,
- 2:25:34I mean,
- 2:25:34there's stuff I think Kierkegaard's right about.
- 2:25:36SPEAKER_02: There's stuff Marx is right about.
- 2:25:37SPEAKER_02: There's stuff Nietzsche is right about.
- 2:25:39SPEAKER_02: And so that's what you do as an aspiring thinker is you go,
- 2:25:44SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 2:25:45SPEAKER_02: I'm reading all these different perspectives.
- 2:25:47They're all getting at something that I think shows me
- 2:25:51something important about
- 2:25:52SPEAKER_02: the world I live in.
- 2:25:54But I also find how they're contradictory and incompatible with
- 2:25:57one another.
- 2:25:58How do you take these different truths you're getting from them
- 2:26:02and try to make it
- 2:26:03SPEAKER_02: all as consistent as possible?
- 2:26:05SPEAKER_02: And I think that's what we try to do as philosophers and theorists.
- 2:26:10SPEAKER_01: Yeah, can't run from it.
- 2:26:11You can't retreating and taking up a one-sided position
- 2:26:19ultimately just results in
- 2:26:21like an incoherent point of view and it's going to collapse on
- 2:26:24you eventually.
- 2:26:24SPEAKER_01: And we don't want the collapse.
- 2:26:27SPEAKER_01: We want the human to survive the near future.
- 2:26:33So you have to tarry with these negativities every time you
- 2:26:35come up with them.
- 2:26:37SPEAKER_02: So, I mean, part of it is, look,
- 2:26:39If it was like an instantaneous Thanos snap,
- 2:26:44like humanity ceases to exist.
- 2:26:46SPEAKER_02: I mean, that's one thing.
- 2:26:48SPEAKER_02: But the point,
- 2:26:50SPEAKER_02: the level of global suffering that we're speeding towards,
- 2:26:58SPEAKER_02: that's what bothers me.
- 2:27:01SPEAKER_02: And that's what bothers you.
- 2:27:02SPEAKER_02: And so...
- 2:27:04look i i mean i i just accept that at some point humanity won't
- 2:27:09exist it'll either
- 2:27:11not exist just because we as a species cease to exist for some
- 2:27:17reason or another or
- 2:27:19SPEAKER_02: we will go down this accelerationist tech pathway that you do the uh
- 2:27:30SPEAKER_02: The sorieties paradox.
- 2:27:32SPEAKER_02: You chain parts of ourselves bit by piece.
- 2:27:35SPEAKER_01: Ship of Theseus.
- 2:27:36SPEAKER_01: We're the being of Theseus.
- 2:27:37SPEAKER_02: And ship of Theseus, both of them, right?
- 2:27:40Sorieties is you make minor changes up to a point that a
- 2:27:45qualitative change occurs.
- 2:27:47SPEAKER_02: If that happens and we become transhuman or post-human,
- 2:27:49SPEAKER_02: whatever that means,
- 2:27:51SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 2:27:51SPEAKER_02: then we cease to be human in that regard or something else.
- 2:27:55SPEAKER_02: Or you do the ship of Theseus,
- 2:27:56you just take us apart and we become cyborgs and we do the
- 2:28:02cyborgization process
- 2:28:04SPEAKER_02: and we cease to be ourselves.
- 2:28:06SPEAKER_02: Or we as a species cease to exist.
- 2:28:08SPEAKER_02: One way,
- 2:28:08I'm saying I get that the human is not going to endure forever
- 2:28:14and I can deal with
- 2:28:15SPEAKER_02: that.
- 2:28:15I think what we're trying to prevent is whatever we can do or
- 2:28:22think or theorize is
- 2:28:24SPEAKER_02: the immense suffering that's on the horizon.
- 2:28:26Yeah,
- 2:28:28the violent collapse,
- 2:28:31the intensification of already existing suffering.
- 2:28:36SPEAKER_01: I do think to plant a seed for a future conversation,
- 2:28:42SPEAKER_01: the book Natural Born Cyborgs is an amazing book.
- 2:28:45SPEAKER_01: Everybody out there, you should read it.
- 2:28:47SPEAKER_01: I argue we're already cyborgs.
- 2:28:50So in order to become fully human,
- 2:28:52we must take up transhumanism or post-humanism.
- 2:28:56SPEAKER_01: But there's a lot of caveats and qualifiers.
- 2:29:02I think everything that's currently recognized as transhumanism
- 2:29:05or post-humanism is anti-human.
- 2:29:10SPEAKER_01: But yeah, we're already cyborgs.
- 2:29:12SPEAKER_01: We have already augmented ourselves with language and it's through that
- 2:29:20SPEAKER_01: augmentation we're able to have subjectivity and that is what makes us
- 2:29:26SPEAKER_01: So human,
- 2:29:27SPEAKER_01: the proper human position is already a trans or post-human position,
- 2:29:32SPEAKER_01: but that's a horse of a different color.
- 2:29:35And that's a conversation that I'm excited to have with you
- 2:29:38because I think that'll
- 2:29:39SPEAKER_01: get a lot of people excited.
- 2:29:40SPEAKER_01: And I think it's probably provocative.
- 2:29:43SPEAKER_01: And I don't want to be like intentionally sensational or provocative,
- 2:29:48SPEAKER_01: but I want us to figure out what it means to be human.
- 2:29:53SPEAKER_01: Like we're over here.
- 2:29:54We are developing powerful intelligences that are going to
- 2:29:58change the world we live
- 2:30:00SPEAKER_01: in,
- 2:30:01SPEAKER_01: in our lifetimes.
- 2:30:02SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 2:30:02Huge changes are coming and it has to do with the
- 2:30:06instrumentalization of intelligence itself.
- 2:30:09And I want to figure out what it means to be human before we
- 2:30:14start trying to pump
- 2:30:17SPEAKER_01: this shit off assembly lines.
- 2:30:20SPEAKER_02: Yeah, exactly.
- 2:30:21SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:30:21SPEAKER_02: Because.
- 2:30:21SPEAKER_02: And I mean, look, this is where we get into the whole thing with the.
- 2:30:27SPEAKER_02: The art of like war.
- 2:30:28hugo de garis right yeah i mean at some point like i've seen
- 2:30:32land say this where
- 2:30:34humanism is going to be something in the future because we
- 2:30:38don't understand the
- 2:30:39stakes of it yet like sure there's been movements that call
- 2:30:42themselves humanists
- 2:30:43and there's been thinkers who call themselves humanists or for
- 2:30:46him humanism it
- 2:30:48really takes hold when humanity at large not theorists not
- 2:30:53scientists right but
- 2:30:55SPEAKER_02: humanity realizes oh shit
- 2:30:59we're on the chopping block here and what happens when normies
- 2:31:05feel like ais are a
- 2:31:07threat to their children yep and that's a true real concrete
- 2:31:12threat so hugo de
- 2:31:13garis wrote this thing where where he thinks about the the
- 2:31:17cosmos who side with ais
- 2:31:19SPEAKER_02: and the terrans that side with humanity and the earth
- 2:31:23SPEAKER_02: And there's a great artilect war,
- 2:31:25SPEAKER_02: a war over the AIs,
- 2:31:27SPEAKER_02: the artilects,
- 2:31:28SPEAKER_02: and that this is something that's on the horizon.
- 2:31:32SPEAKER_02: And I think this, I think land agrees with this.
- 2:31:35SPEAKER_02: And I,
- 2:31:35SPEAKER_02: I take this seriously that when,
- 2:31:39especially when normie moms really believe AIs are a threat to
- 2:31:44their children.
- 2:31:45SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:31:45SPEAKER_02: Shit's going to go down.
- 2:31:47SPEAKER_02: And he ran things.
- 2:31:48SPEAKER_02: That's going to be the real moment that humanism,
- 2:31:52SPEAKER_02: become something that is widespread.
- 2:31:56SPEAKER_02: You could even say a global movement.
- 2:32:00SPEAKER_01: I want to be instrumental in this resurgent, triumphant humanism.
- 2:32:08SPEAKER_01: I do.
- 2:32:09SPEAKER_01: I think it's important.
- 2:32:11SPEAKER_01: I think we need to come back to that.
- 2:32:15SPEAKER_01: I think Ben Gertzel, which by the way, shout out Cadell.
- 2:32:20SPEAKER_01: You just had him on his channel a couple months ago.
- 2:32:23SPEAKER_01: It was great convo.
- 2:32:24SPEAKER_01: Go watch it.
- 2:32:25SPEAKER_01: Philosophy portal.
- 2:32:26Ben Gertzel is the guy who coined the term artificial general
- 2:32:30intelligence.
- 2:32:31SPEAKER_01: This guy is my favorite AI theorist and he never gets any love.
- 2:32:37SPEAKER_01: I've been reading his book, chaotic logic.
- 2:32:40SPEAKER_01: And this other one, I can't remember what it's it.
- 2:32:44SPEAKER_01: But Ben Gertzel, he was friends with Hugo de Garris.
- 2:32:50SPEAKER_01: And Land is over here quoting the Artilect War.
- 2:32:54SPEAKER_01: Ben Gertzel is friends with the guy who wrote the Artilect War.
- 2:33:00I just think there are too few people who are relevant when it
- 2:33:07comes to the
- 2:33:08SPEAKER_01: technological developments that are happening today who have any stakes.
- 2:33:15SPEAKER_01: Most of the AI guys couldn't give two shits about the humanities,
- 2:33:19SPEAKER_01: couldn't care about continental philosophy.
- 2:33:21SPEAKER_01: Don't even know what it is.
- 2:33:22SPEAKER_01: Don't know what is the difference between substance and subject.
- 2:33:27SPEAKER_02: Which is why I give land so much credit, though.
- 2:33:30SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
- 2:33:31Land has the advantage over most of these guys to me,
- 2:33:35precisely because not only...
- 2:33:38SPEAKER_02: Does he have the losing Guattari?
- 2:33:40SPEAKER_02: And I mean, we're talking he he was a world renowned expert in Bataille.
- 2:33:46SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 2:33:47SPEAKER_02: And losing Guattari and Nietzsche and those guys.
- 2:33:50SPEAKER_02: And then, you know, he approaches AI.
- 2:33:55SPEAKER_02: Through a Marxist perspective,
- 2:33:57SPEAKER_02: I know he's a reaction and he's a rightist,
- 2:33:59SPEAKER_02: but I've told him on Twitter.
- 2:34:01SPEAKER_02: I'm like,
- 2:34:01why you have this advantage over most AI theorists is that AI
- 2:34:05doesn't exist in a
- 2:34:07SPEAKER_02: vacuum for you.
- 2:34:08SPEAKER_02: It comes out of a mode of production.
- 2:34:11And that's where the Marxist influence on you made you such a
- 2:34:14great theorist of AI.
- 2:34:16SPEAKER_02: But at the same time, he draws from the Austrian school.
- 2:34:19SPEAKER_02: And so he merges, in a sense, Marx with Hayek.
- 2:34:24SPEAKER_02: You want to talk about it like that?
- 2:34:27SPEAKER_02: But he has so much theory.
- 2:34:29I mean,
- 2:34:30he was a world-renowned expert in continental theory at one
- 2:34:36point in his life.
- 2:34:37SPEAKER_02: Sure, he was like, no thanks.
- 2:34:39SPEAKER_02: He departed from that.
- 2:34:40SPEAKER_02: But still, it gave him so many conceptual tools that
- 2:34:48SPEAKER_02: The other just AI theorist guys don't have.
- 2:34:51SPEAKER_02: They don't think about it in terms of politics.
- 2:34:53SPEAKER_02: They don't think about it in terms of economics.
- 2:34:56SPEAKER_02: They don't have – I mean,
- 2:34:58SPEAKER_02: you and I,
- 2:34:58SPEAKER_02: we would approach it from an ethical perspective with Levinas.
- 2:35:02So I'm just saying if you're going to do AI theory,
- 2:35:05to me,
- 2:35:05you've got to have this –
- 2:35:08SPEAKER_02: For me,
- 2:35:09you've got to have continental philosophy because continental
- 2:35:11philosophy is,
- 2:35:13SPEAKER_02: along with psychoanalytic theory,
- 2:35:15the two great traditions that have thought through what it is
- 2:35:19to be human.
- 2:35:20I think that they gave us the most insight into what it is to
- 2:35:24be human that we have
- 2:35:26SPEAKER_02: as a species.
- 2:35:27SPEAKER_02: And so if we're going to talk to human, we got to go through that.
- 2:35:31SPEAKER_01: Hell yeah.
- 2:35:34SPEAKER_01: So on that note, man, I got shit that I wanted to get.
- 2:35:39I wanted to talk about the Lyapunov exponent and the Kolmogorov
- 2:35:46complexity.
- 2:35:46SPEAKER_01: I wanted to talk about a bunch of shit.
- 2:35:49SPEAKER_01: I wanted to talk about Vernor Vinge.
- 2:35:53SPEAKER_01: But I think we're going to cut it.
- 2:35:54SPEAKER_02: I wanted to actually read lands against orthogonality.
- 2:35:58SPEAKER_01: Against orthogonality.
- 2:35:59SPEAKER_02: But, you know, we'll come back and do it next time or whatever.
- 2:36:03SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:36:03SPEAKER_01: Here's the deal.
- 2:36:04SPEAKER_01: We can read that to start off the next conversation we have.
- 2:36:10We can do against orthogonality and then that bit from Hagel
- 2:36:14and a Wired Brain.
- 2:36:16that'd be cool yeah like really go into that and do that we can
- 2:36:20start off the next
- 2:36:21ai talk on that um because we're exegetes at our heart yeah man
- 2:36:27yeah love reading
- 2:36:28texts and commenting on them so that would be really cool to
- 2:36:32bring land and zizek
- 2:36:34SPEAKER_01: together like that oh yeah so um fuck yeah i'm gonna
- 2:36:43upload this and process it and do all that stuff and make it
- 2:36:46available to all the
- 2:36:47SPEAKER_01: fine folks at home.
- 2:36:50SPEAKER_01: Uh,
- 2:36:50SPEAKER_01: we'll talk in the background and,
- 2:36:51SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 2:36:53SPEAKER_01: hopefully we'll be able to have that conversation with Todd that we're,
- 2:36:57planning to have and um and all the other shit man but this was
- 2:37:02fucking excellent
- 2:37:03i'm stoked i had a blast man this was awesome i'm super stoked
- 2:37:06it's just the tip of
- 2:37:07the iceberg right like this this whole thing that nance and i
- 2:37:10you know this synergy
- 2:37:11on between ai theory and continental philosophy i mean we're
- 2:37:15gonna and there's
- 2:37:16gonna be times we we go something comes out of left field and
- 2:37:20you're like wait what
- 2:37:21SPEAKER_02: what
- 2:37:22SPEAKER_02: They're talking about Wittgenstein.
- 2:37:23SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we're going to talk about Wittgenstein.
- 2:37:26SPEAKER_02: Or CS Purse or Whitehead, right?
- 2:37:30SPEAKER_01: Well, all this shit is relevant, folks.
- 2:37:32SPEAKER_01: All this is very, very relevant.
- 2:37:35And if you're tapped into the AI discussion and you don't know
- 2:37:41about CS Purse or
- 2:37:42SPEAKER_01: Wittgenstein or Whitehead,
- 2:37:45SPEAKER_01: well,
- 2:37:45then you're missing out this whole section of the conversation
- 2:37:48that's an essential
- 2:37:49SPEAKER_01: part of the conversation.
- 2:37:51SPEAKER_02: And...
- 2:37:53If you're doing continental theory and you're not applying this
- 2:37:56to AI right now,
- 2:37:58SPEAKER_02: you're missing such an opportunity.
- 2:38:04SPEAKER_02: We don't want to just own this niche thing.
- 2:38:07SPEAKER_02: We want to see other people
- 2:38:11SPEAKER_02: follow this connect, like let's bring AI theory into content.
- 2:38:15SPEAKER_02: And again,
- 2:38:15SPEAKER_02: there's people who have already like,
- 2:38:16SPEAKER_02: again,
- 2:38:17SPEAKER_02: Isabel Millar,
- 2:38:18SPEAKER_02: this book late,
- 2:38:19SPEAKER_02: like it's totally doing this,
- 2:38:21SPEAKER_02: right?
- 2:38:22So there's people who have already started to see the
- 2:38:25importance of doing it,
- 2:38:26SPEAKER_02: but it's still not enough yet.
- 2:38:29And so we're hoping that's part of our intervention here is to
- 2:38:34get some synergy
- 2:38:35SPEAKER_02: going,
- 2:38:35SPEAKER_02: not just between ourselves on between these two domains,
- 2:38:39SPEAKER_02: but to inspire other people to explore it.
- 2:38:42SPEAKER_01: Hell yeah.
- 2:38:43SPEAKER_01: On that note, peace out audience.
- 2:38:45SPEAKER_01: We'll see you on the next one.
- 2:38:46SPEAKER_01: This shit was dope.