Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #203 - Niki Sharma (BC NDP) / Kyla's Court with Kyla Lee
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is Van Color. Hey folks, my name is Mohama
- 0:24and this is Van Color, British Columbia's Bodified Culture and Politics TV talk show.
- 0:28Tonight, BC Attorney General Nikki Sharma is here to discuss how the province
- 0:32intends to compel social media companies like Facebook, Twitter and Tender to comply with
- 0:38new image sharing laws. But first, with municipalities across BC allowing adults to
- 0:44drink alcohol in parks, beaches and other public spaces, maybe we should refamiliarize
- 0:51ourselves with public intoxication laws just so we don't wind up in the drunk tank
- 0:56this summer. So let's kick things off with my counterpart on the Soapbox Social
- 1:00panel, which you can find on CBC radios on the Coast, with Gloria
- 1:03Macarenko, one of BC's most high profile criminal defense lawyers representing Acumen Law.
- 1:07She is Kyla Lee and this is Kyla's Court. Hi, Kyla him most
- 1:26so, nice to see you as always. Yeah, I can't believe we're
- 1:27not doing this segment on a beach with a beer. I know, right,
- 1:32budget constraints, but maybe next time. Maybe next time we'll do it
- 1:34at a different location. I gotta ask you. Obviously, in Vancouver this
- 1:38is a big issue where now you can drink some public beaches and public parks.
- 1:42Different municipalities have also allowed this, But when it comes to public intoxication,
- 1:48you can't actually be drunk in public, right, Yes, so you're
- 1:52allowed to have a couple of drinks in these permissible areas that municipalities have designated
- 1:57for public drinking, but you cannot have so many drinks that you end up
- 2:00at the point of intoxication. And legally, intoxication is a little bit difficult
- 2:06to define, but that's what I mean. Like, so, how who
- 2:08determines if you're publicly intoxicated? Basically, the police officer that might arrest you,
- 2:14they're going to look at you. They're going to assess your speech,
- 2:16your manner of walking, is your face flushed, are you glossy eyed?
- 2:21Do you reek of liquor? And are you behaving badly? If you're doing
- 2:23those things that are attracting attention to yourself, you're probably going to end up
- 2:27arrested for public intoxication. Now, would the administer a breathalyzer like they would
- 2:30like if you were driving. No, they don't have the power to do
- 2:34a breathalyzer to somebody who's not driving or hasn't been pactly driving a car.
- 2:38So they just do it based on their assessment of your physical condition, which
- 2:42can lead to a lot of concerns for people, for example, who may
- 2:45present is intoxicated because they're in medical distress because they're disabled, and they have
- 2:50symptoms that mimic those of intoxication. Right, and so this is where it
- 2:53gets complicated, right, Like, there's no particular checklist or criteria that has
- 2:58to be met in order to determine public intoxication. No, And what we
- 3:01hear a lot from police officers in court is, oh, you know,
- 3:04I deal with intoxicated people every day in the course of my work, so
- 3:07I'm capable of recognizing somebody who's intoxicated. Okay, But at the same time,
- 3:10we see police officers getting it wrong a lot. Thankfully, most people
- 3:15don't end up charged with tough park intoxications. They just end up spending a
- 3:19night at the police station or a couple hours until they get a sober ride
- 3:22home. Right, Okay, So it's not common that you would actually face
- 3:25criminal charges. No, you wouldn't face criminal charges. It's not a criminal
- 3:29offense. It's a provincial offense, so you can get a fine. You
- 3:31know, if it was really extreme, theoretically you can go to jail for
- 3:35up to six months. I don't think that that's ever happened. Usually it's
- 3:38sleep it off, released when you're sober. Is it weird to you that
- 3:42increasingly we can drink more in different public spaces. However, you can't be
- 3:47drunk in public. It is odd, but it makes sense. I mean,
- 3:52there's a safety risk that goes along with people being drunk, either that
- 3:54they will cause harm to themselves or cause harm to other people. And also,
- 4:00drunk people in public areas that lots of people use are kind of a
- 4:02nuisance. They are annoying. This is very true. I have a question
- 4:06for you. Let's say you're having a few drinks at a beach, and
- 4:11you have a few drinks, and you still have half a drink left in
- 4:14your red solo cup, and you and your friends are now going to walk
- 4:17over to a plaza where drinking in public is also allowed. In the transportation
- 4:24of that drink, that red solo cup which has some alcohol in it,
- 4:28is that legal? Like, are you allowed to do that? No,
- 4:30you're not allowed to transport open liquor except in a motor vehicle if it's not
- 4:35accessible to the driver and passengers. Okay, in public okay, So wait,
- 4:40if you're a passenger in a car, you can drink open liquor,
- 4:42no problem, No, you can. You can have open liquor containers in
- 4:46a car if they're not accessible to the passenger or the driver. Sorry moment,
- 4:51and even with the excitement, got it. I was just trying to
- 4:54figure out the law here. I'm trying to weasel my way around it.
- 4:57And also, so to be clear, you can't t sport that red solo
- 5:00cup or that open beer bottle from place to place, even if you don't
- 5:03drink in between. Yeah, you can't possess open liquor containers in public places
- 5:08except where there's exceptions in place. Okay. This is very interesting on the
- 5:12topic of transportation. We are seeing more and more self driving cars and self
- 5:18driving vehicles. Can your self driving car be a designated driver? No,
- 5:25it cannot. In fact, the BC government just passed legislation to deal with
- 5:30self driving vehicles and we now have bands on self driving cars in British Columbia
- 5:34wholesale wholesale whether you're sober. Okay, Yeah, Wholesale bands on self driving
- 5:41features of cars, like things that are short of cruise control are not allowed
- 5:45in British Columbia. We will see regulations in the future, but I don't
- 5:47anticipate that the government is ever going to let people just let your car be
- 5:51the DD. Okay, but is that a technology thing like the technology hasn't
- 5:58reached the capacity to fully in a sentient way transport you from a to B.
- 6:02Well, certainly the technology is not there yet. But the other concern
- 6:06is there are situations and in which the technology is not going to be able
- 6:11to make the moral decision. And there's also the risk that with any technology,
- 6:14no matter how advanced it is, it could fail. And at that
- 6:16point you need to be aware. You need to be able to be capable
- 6:19of taking over the controls of the car, preventing an accident and driving safely.
- 6:24And if you're drunk and you're in the driver's seat, you're not in
- 6:26a position to do that. That's fair. Setting aside motor vehicles, what
- 6:29about things like bikes or cycles? Are you allowed to cycle if you are
- 6:34legally drunk or would be drunk? Consider drunk if you were driving a vehicle.
- 6:39Well no, because you would be intoxicated in a public place. Oh
- 6:42okay. There are also provisions of the Motor Vehicle Act that apply to bicycles
- 6:46the same as they would apply to cars. So, other than a few
- 6:49specific exceptions, all of the laws under the BC Motor Vehicle Act also apply
- 6:54to people operating bicycles. So there is sort of a general prohibition on cycling
- 6:58without due care and attention or without reasonable consideration, which would encompass drunk cycling.
- 7:02Fair enough, and I do think it deserves emphasis. When you can
- 7:06drink in public, there's only permissible areas where you can drink it. It's
- 7:10not everywhere in public and Vancouver are Greater Vancouver. Yes, it has to
- 7:14be an area that's been enacted by a by law or under the park Board
- 7:16regulations, under the Vancouver Charter, or a private home a care home that
- 7:21allows it. Certain locations that are designated for the sale of liquor. Those
- 7:28are really the only places you can consume alcohol in public. Well, thank
- 7:30you for clarifying this, Kayla. Always a pleasure, no problem, folks.
- 7:34One of the most prominent criminal defense lawyers in British Columbia. She is
- 7:38Kyla Lee. Now stick around because after some business, how will the government
- 7:43of BC compel tech companies from TikTok to only fans to comply with the province's
- 7:47new laws to ensure that someone's intimate photos are not shared online without consent?
- 7:54BC Attorney General Nikki Sharma will be here to explain. Up next, Welcome
- 8:03back to this is Van Color. Back in March, the BC government enacted
- 8:07the Intimate Images Protection Act, which streamlines the process for any individual to remove
- 8:13intimate images of themselves that have been shared online without their consent, consent itself
- 8:18being revocable here. It also allows victims of this kind of sexualized violence to
- 8:24claim relief without proof of damage when an image is distributed or even threatened to
- 8:28be distributed without their consent. But in order for those images to be taken
- 8:33down, isn't cooperation needed from social media and adult content companies? Well here
- 8:39to explain as the Attorney General of BC and Minister of Justice, she is
- 8:43Nikki Sharma, and this conversation is supported by Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey,
- 8:50distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely Shelter Point Okay, Minister Sharm, thanks for being
- 9:00on the show tonight. Thanks for having me. It's great to be here.
- 9:03So before we get into the legislation itself, when we talk about intimate
- 9:07images as per the legal term, what are we talking about here, Well,
- 9:13it's a really broad definition and it involves any image that could be altered,
- 9:16also that of you that's intimate in the sense where it shows like a
- 9:20part of your body, it shows an act, it shows something that's intimate
- 9:26and would be considered intimate, and you had an expectation of privacy while it
- 9:28was being taken, so right, And so I guess that expectation of privacy,
- 9:33or perhaps even the sexualized nature of the imagery is really important because it
- 9:37doesn't even matter if the image itself is artificial. Right, It could be
- 9:39a deep fake or a repurpose photo, or a sort of a likeness that
- 9:43looks real. Right, Yeah, and I think that that's something that is
- 9:46increasing. Right, people are able to alter images in a way that could
- 9:50be like part of you, but it's used in a way that you didn't
- 9:52consent to or approven and in the sexualized way. Right. And that broad
- 9:56definition is essentially by design. So you're trying to capture perhaps future technology that
- 10:01maybe we're not we're seeing. Yeah, we really took a look at everywhere
- 10:05that similar types of legislation have been enacted, and we looked into it and
- 10:09we wanted to just be as broad as possible and like to your point,
- 10:11really keeping up with the fact that it's an ever changing space when it comes
- 10:16to technology. So we want the kind of broadest protection possible for people.
- 10:20So explain the process to me. If someone is in the unfortunate position of
- 10:24having their intimate images or videos shared online without their consent, Now they're not
- 10:30going through the court, they're going through a tribunal system, Like, how
- 10:31does it work from step one to the end? Yeah, we took a
- 10:35lot of care in designing a process that was victim informed and trauma informed.
- 10:39And the idea is is that you can come forward first on an online portal,
- 10:45so something that's twenty four to seven, you can do it on your
- 10:48iPhone and you can make an application to this civil resolution tribunal. So we're
- 10:52using we're setting up a whole website that we'll also have resources for you because
- 10:56we know that oftentimes, particular with young people, there can be a lot
- 11:00of misplaced shame and embarrassment and feeling like you had something to do with it,
- 11:07even though it's not your fault. So we wanted to make it as
- 11:09easily accessible as possible. So the ideas you get once the portals up and
- 11:13running, you can go online. You can make an application to the Civilization
- 11:16Tribunal to say, hey, there's an image of me that's being distributed without
- 11:20my consent. I want it taken down, and then a tribula memor will
- 11:24take a look at the application. You can do it with or without notifying
- 11:26the perpetrator and can give you an order that says that person has to stop
- 11:31disturbing in it take it down. I can give you an order saying that
- 11:33the Internet intermediary, so whatever platforms using it cast to take it down.
- 11:39So it really helps to give that power back to the victim from that type
- 11:43of victimization. And I guess when we think about this, there could be
- 11:48things that maybe are not completely public, right, Like I'm thinking of I
- 11:52don't know, we chat or WhatsApp or certain Facebook groups that aren't like completely
- 11:56public, but there may be a lot of people in those groups. So
- 12:00does this also cover that totally. It's it's also broad in what it covers,
- 12:05so it could also just be I mean, this is very antiquated,
- 12:07but it could be like a printed version of the picture. Oh really,
- 12:09Okay, so it's not just not just limited online because the idea is is
- 12:15that you didn't consent. It's an intimage, image of view. It could
- 12:16be an altered image, and you want it stopped. Right, And when
- 12:20can we see this website up and running and functional. Well, we're working
- 12:24on it right now, and I think the earliest we're hoping as early as
- 12:28possible, but the kind of latest is in twenty twenty four, so January,
- 12:31early twenties. And is that also when the tribunals themselves will that's right,
- 12:35Okay, that's right, Well, that will all be running. That's
- 12:37why just recently I reached out to some of the bigger social media platforms because
- 12:43it's so key that they be unnoticed that this is coming, that they get
- 12:46it orders against them. And so it's really part of us setting up this
- 12:50process to making sure that you know, my job is attorney generals to make
- 12:54sure that people NBC are protected, particularly from these bigger forces. Right,
- 12:58So we need to do everything that we can to protect people from this type
- 13:01of really devastating impacts. So that's my question. In your role as the
- 13:05Attorney General of BC, how are you able to compel these social media giants
- 13:11right whether it is meta Facebook or you know, Tender or only fans like,
- 13:16how how can you force them to take down this content? Yeah,
- 13:20so we have used in this legislation every tool that we have under provincial legislation
- 13:26and potential court system to maximize our ability to basically hold them to account.
- 13:31I issued a letter a couple of weeks ago to the bigger names saying that
- 13:35these orders could be against you up to the point of that if they don't
- 13:39take reasonable steps to act so d D India indexing the picture, taking it
- 13:43down, stopping of distribution, then they could face monetary damage. They could
- 13:48somebody could go after them in court for fine. So we wanted to make
- 13:52it super clear and I wanted them to know that this is coming and they
- 13:54could be liable in court for not complying. It's been interesting with the response
- 14:01because we've met with Google already, I think Pornhub has reached out to meet
- 14:03with me. We're really trying to make sure that there. It's very clear
- 14:07that we want this to be done quickly because the longer this stuff is up,
- 14:11the more harm is done for people. One of the things that we're
- 14:13told, and I think that we continue to tell the next generation of online
- 14:18users as well, is that if it's on the Internet, it's there forever
- 14:22right. And that is quite a scary thing that sometimes despite all the best
- 14:24efforts, there will still be traces or images that you might not want there.
- 14:28So ultimately, like don't doesn't, the punishment for the perpetrators have to
- 14:33be very severe in order to match basically the damage that is done here.
- 14:39Yeah, And that's another part of this work is that if you are the
- 14:43victim of this step, I think you can take your perpetrator to court,
- 14:46right, you can get monetary damages against them for the harm that's done.
- 14:50So the minute I introduced this legislation, I was sure to put like any
- 14:52perpetrator on notice right then in BC the minute the day that I introduced it.
- 14:58If you're distributing somebody's imag without their consent, you could be responsible for
- 15:01paying them for the harm done from distributing that. And we want to make
- 15:05it very clear to them that there are consequences for this type of behavior.
- 15:11I know we're you're only responsible for you know, what happens in BC,
- 15:15But is there a push to maybe have something like this at least on a
- 15:16national level where you know, someone just can't run to Alberta or neighboring province
- 15:20and escape this sort of punishment. Yeah, so have We do have some
- 15:24tools in our court system to just kind of apply things outside of our jurisdiction,
- 15:28and we're maximizing that. But you know, I think it is part
- 15:31of the work that we all have to do as governments is to keep up
- 15:35with these bigger international forces that are having, like causing real harm to our
- 15:39people, right, that people are suffering from. And so the more that
- 15:43we work together with other jurisdictions, the more of an impact it has.
- 15:46Like I'm very looking forward to meeting with these bigger companies that have cross border
- 15:52power and saying to them that we expect you to comply with BC's laws.
- 15:56We expect you to take down these images, and I'll keep at it until
- 15:58they do. And I think if all of us do that, you know
- 16:00we're gonna we're gonna make sure that they comply, right, that's y're not
- 16:04bigger than bigger than a government's job to protect their citizens. When it comes
- 16:10to social media in particular, I feel like, and I guess this is
- 16:12less of a legal question but more of your opinion. I feel like one
- 16:15of the key problems is there is this aspect of anonymity, right, so
- 16:19people can go on and not you don't know who they are, and they're
- 16:22posting vile things, whether it's hate or sexualized imagery against people's consent. You
- 16:27know, wouldn't it be so much easier if everyone had to somehow registered before
- 16:33they could be on like a Facebook or you know, a big social media
- 16:36network. Yeah, interesting concept. So the fact being like they would have
- 16:40to disclose who even if it's a fake name, it like somebody knows who
- 16:42they are, or just I don't know, register some sort of idea or
- 16:45something because or a phone number, I suppose, and I think some sites
- 16:48are doing that. But I feel like if if you had your name attached
- 16:52to everything you posted, that may deter you from posting. I mean,
- 16:56it would change the nature of the Internet, I feel I mean, you're
- 17:00a big personality online too, and I'm a public person and you know,
- 17:03what it's like out there, right, yeah, it's and people say all
- 17:08these kind of things that you just wouldn't tolerate in person, Like you would
- 17:11never say that to somebody if they could identify you. So I think you
- 17:14have Like that's a good point, Like what is the way to bring up
- 17:18the kind of level of protection in an online space because we spend a lot
- 17:21of our time online? Right Well, I definitely appreciate you taking those steps
- 17:23and thank you for your time tonight. Great to be here, Thanks for
- 17:26having me absolutely, folks. She is BC Attorney General and Minister of Justice
- 17:32doing great work to ensure our laws keep up with technology. She is Nikki
- 17:36Sharma. Big thank you to Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey for supporting local conversations
- 17:41and local content. Now up next, you may have heard about the coroner's
- 17:45inquest into the horrific death of Miles Gray, But has anyone truly been held
- 17:49accountable for this homicide? Let's talk about it up next, Welcome back to
- 18:00This is Van Color. Before I get into my commentary tonight, I want
- 18:03to talk about Miles Gray as remembered by his loved ones. Miles was a
- 18:07son, a brother, a gentle soul. According to his sister, family
- 18:12was important to Miles, as he would often meet his sister and cousins for
- 18:15Sunday brunch in the city. Professionally, Miles worked in heavy duty construction in
- 18:21Vancouver for years until he chose to move to Seashelt to be closer to the
- 18:26outdoors, which was a part of his everyday life growing up in Powell River.
- 18:30He bought a florist supply business on the Sunshine Coast that had been founded
- 18:33by his uncle. The business would keep him connected to Vancouver as he made
- 18:38regular deliveries to the Lower Mainland. His family described him as positive, compassionate,
- 18:45funny and easygoing. Miles Gray loved making his friends and family laugh.
- 18:51To close out tonight's show, Let's Take a Moment. In twenty fifteen,
- 19:03Miles Gray died in an interaction involving ten Vancouver Police officers. Earlier this month,
- 19:08eight years after his death, a public inquest determined Miles's death to be
- 19:14a homicide, with injuries including ruptured testicles or fractured eye socket, a dislocated
- 19:18job, broken rib, a broken nose, a broken voice box, and
- 19:22bleeding in his brain. Miles did not die of natural causes, as Vancouver
- 19:26Police originally claimed. No. Miles was beaten to death by Vancouver Police officers,
- 19:33who claimed they subdued Miles with such force because Miles was animalistic and superhuman.
- 19:38They claimed he appeared to be on drugs and he died of excited delirium.
- 19:42Except Miles wasn't on drugs, and he was strong but not superhuman,
- 19:48and excited delirium is junk science, you know, hogwash. Miles, who
- 19:52was unarmed, may have been suffering from a manic episode, but it's not
- 19:56clear why he was beaten to death by co It's also not clear why.
- 20:02According to several of the officers involved in beating Miles to death, VPD officers
- 20:07were told by their union not to make notes about the homicide president at the
- 20:11time or union reps. Tom Stamatakus the current president of the Canadian Police Association
- 20:18and Ralph Kayser's the current president of the Vancouver Police Union. So, according
- 20:22to the VPD themselves, the VPD deliberately withheld evidence in a homicide. You
- 20:29could say Vancouver Police orchestrated a cover up, given that the information obtained from
- 20:33the inquest can't be used to criminally prosecute the VPD officers who committed homicide or
- 20:40those who allegedly covered it up. You could say the Vancouver Police gamed the
- 20:45system. Given how all the officers involved still work for the VPD, one
- 20:51even being a use of force expert and another with the Car eighty seven program
- 20:55from mental health situations, you could even say the Vancouver Police got away with
- 21:00murder. Folks. That's our show. Thank you so much to Kyla Lee
- 21:11and BC Attorney General Nikki Sharma for their time tonight, and special thank you
- 21:17and well wishes to Margie Gray and the Gray family. For more, This
- 21:19is Van Color. Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Check Media's YouTube
- 21:25channel, and the check plus app. For now, though, this is
- 21:27Van Color and I'm Moamir are telling you that in a province where you can
- 21:30be anything, be colorful. Peace,