Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Navigating Sustainability: Tackling Embodied Carbon in Construction
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:08Welcome to the Engineering Influence podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:14And today we're going to be delving into a topic that is of great interest to
- 0:19our member firms who are designing in the built environment,
- 0:23especially increasingly for both private and public clients.
- 0:27And that is the issue of embedded carbon, dealing with sustainability,
- 0:32embodied carbon, and really just a question of how is the industry addressing
- 0:37carbon reduction in the built environment?
- 0:41And to really focus in on this, we're really pleased to be joined by Kelly Roberts.
- 0:46She is the Principal and Managing Director of the Atlanta Structures Group for Walter P. Moore.
- 0:52And she is also the leader of the firm's Sustainable Design Practice Group.
- 0:57Kelly, thank you for joining us.
- 0:59Thanks so much for having me. Now, I really want to focus in on this report
- 1:04that was put out by Walter P.
- 1:06Moore on Embodied Carbon Insights for Industry Impact, which is available on the Walter P.
- 1:12Moore website. That really is a very good dive into the subject and includes
- 1:19case studies and examples of not just issues related to design, but also materials,
- 1:26concrete and low-carbon concrete and mass timber and the like.
- 1:30But Kelly, for those who might not be completely familiar with the issue itself,
- 1:36can you define embodied carbon and how it's become a central focus for governments
- 1:43in dealing with approaches to environmental policy and carbon reduction? Sure.
- 1:49So embodied carbon refers to the greenhouse gas emissions measured in carbon
- 1:53dioxide equivalents, so CO2E, that result from the life cycle of building materials.
- 2:00So in our industry, it's the carbon emissions that are associated with the raw
- 2:04material extraction, transport, manufacture,
- 2:08construction, the entire process of all the materials that are used for the
- 2:13construction of buildings, roads, bridges, and really anything else.
- 2:19So it's probably important to note here at the beginning that I'm a structural
- 2:25engineer, and I work in commercial architecturally driven building design.
- 2:29So I do a quite quite a bit more vertical work than horizontal.
- 2:33So I have a pretty buildings focused point of view.
- 2:37So I will say my my point of view is is largely the building industry.
- 2:41But the reason why it's become such a central issue for governments is really
- 2:47every year, 66 billion square feet of buildings are constructed.
- 2:52And the embodied carbon emissions of that construction is approximately 3.8
- 2:56billion metric tons of CO2 per year. So it's a huge amount of carbon.
- 3:00In fact, the building industry in general is responsible for 40% of the world's
- 3:06CO2 emissions, with operations associated with those buildings making up the
- 3:11majority of those emissions.
- 3:14And until the last 10 years or so, embodied carbon had not been getting as much
- 3:19attention as operational carbon because it wasn't as big of an impact, or so we thought.
- 3:24Operation was always driving a bigger piece of the pie.
- 3:27So up until about 10 years ago, this is where the focus was driving down operational carbon.
- 3:33It also impacts people's pocketbooks, operational carbon does,
- 3:36operational energy does. So this is where a lot of the focus was.
- 3:41But the critical issue regarding embodied carbon specifically is that it occurs
- 3:45before the building opens. It never gets reduced.
- 3:49No future efficiency will drive down embodied carbon.
- 3:52You can't add solar panels. We can't clean the grid and make up for the embodied
- 3:56carbon that we sunk into those buildings.
- 3:58So because embodied carbon happens up front, over the next 30 years,
- 4:03embodied carbon will actually account for half of new construction carbon, according to the IPCC.
- 4:08So as we approach 2050 and we try to decarbonize the building industry,
- 4:14we can't get there without focusing on this big piece of the pie.
- 4:19And for me, you know, as a structural engineer, much of the embodied carbon
- 4:23in a building is contained in the materials I specify every day in concrete,
- 4:28steel and wood products.
- 4:29You know, those are the high carbon materials that dominate the embodied carbon of a building.
- 4:33So driving down the impact of those materials, that's where my big focus lies in sustainable design.
- 4:39It's a huge issue. It really is because, you know, to your point,
- 4:44you know, really it is a question that that embodied carbon in buildings is there.
- 4:49It's not something that can be dealt with after the fact.
- 4:52Once the building is constructed, there it is. And, you know,
- 4:56governments around the country and around the world are trying to deal with
- 5:00this, urban planning, reuse of buildings or compared to new construction.
- 5:05There seems to be a number of pathways, policy pathways that governments seem
- 5:10to be addressing the issue. And
- 5:11your report kind of outlines a matrix of a systemic or materials approach.
- 5:17Can you kind of describe that matrix of policy pathways and how governments
- 5:23are choosing to address the issue of embodied carbon? Yeah, sure.
- 5:28So there are really four main pathways for policy with both prescriptive and
- 5:34performance pathways for material and system level approaches.
- 5:39So you have prescriptive material and performance material approaches and then
- 5:45prescriptive system and then performance system level approaches.
- 5:49That's basically the outline there.
- 5:52Material level prescriptive pathways generally focus on things like percent
- 5:56recycled content, as we saw in previous versions of LEED,
- 6:00or specific sourcing requirements for materials such as sustainably certified
- 6:05wood. Those are prescriptive material pathways.
- 6:09But material-level performance pathways, like a buy-clean policy,
- 6:14typically require material-specific reductions to high-impact structural and
- 6:18architectural materials like concrete, steel, and aluminum.
- 6:23So you're focusing on things like structure
- 6:25and facade, but you're doing performance-based material pathways.
- 6:30And then there's system-level performance pathways that are focused on whole-building
- 6:35lifecycle assessment, or what we call WBLCA.
- 6:38So those typically require a percent reduction from a baseline building.
- 6:43And if you're not familiar with whole building lifecycle assessment,
- 6:47it's an ISO governed process that quantifies the environmental impacts of an entire building,
- 6:53including at least the structure and enclosure over its entire lifecycle from cradle to grave.
- 6:59So looking at all of the materials that are in the building and looking at those
- 7:04materials over their entire life cycle and looking at the building over its entire life cycle.
- 7:09So looking at different policy. So that would be included in a system level performance pathway.
- 7:16So looking at different policy types, a lot of them use a combination of these
- 7:22policies to address reductions.
- 7:25Jurisdictions like California came up with Calgary that use a lot of these different
- 7:30types policies to address reductions.
- 7:33Yeah, there doesn't seem to be, and to your report, it kind of calls this out
- 7:38that there's not a one-size-fits-all approach to this, that it's not a question
- 7:43of either or, but instead in the report's view,
- 7:48a both and approach instead of either or is probably the best course to take on this.
- 7:56Can you explain that a little bit more as well?
- 7:59Yeah, so we're definitely advocates that if you're going to enact any type of
- 8:03policy that it consider at a minimum performance pathways.
- 8:07And we are big advocates for system level performance pathways,
- 8:11since those would typically be considered the most robust and comprehensive.
- 8:16So those are the all encompassing that look at everything for the whole building
- 8:20over its entire lifecycle. There isn't a one size fits all and buy clean policies,
- 8:25which are material performance pathways, are very useful for low carbon material procurement.
- 8:30And they send a clear message to manufacturers about moving the industry forward.
- 8:35So there are definitely places for both types of performance type pathways.
- 8:40So, yeah, we are in the both-and camp if policies are going to be enacted but
- 8:46are wary of any policies that would be disincentivizing the whole building lifecycle
- 8:52assessment because we think it is the most robust.
- 8:55Looking at the built environment as it stands, there's been a push,
- 8:59especially during COVID and after COVID, really the realization that there are
- 9:04so many buildings right now that are either empty or are facing a situation
- 9:10where the workforce of yesterday is not required,
- 9:14you know, hasn't had the same requirements of the workforce today.
- 9:16Hey, Walter P. Moore, you've gone hybrid.
- 9:19We also went hybrid. And actually, at the beginning of the pandemic,
- 9:23we signed a lease at a new building to build out a new space.
- 9:27With a lot of this in mind, we hired a firm specifically, I think it's the same
- 9:32firm that worked on your Washington, D.C.
- 9:33Headquarters, actually, to figure out how this space should be oriented to a
- 9:40hybrid workspace and to really look at the whole life cycle of the operation there.
- 9:47You notice a lot of buildings are going under renovations or they're being redeveloped
- 9:54to serve another use than the building was originally designed to have.
- 9:58For urban planners looking at the question of building new and incurring that
- 10:04new cost of potentially,
- 10:06you know, that carbon sink into new construction, or really just how do we take
- 10:11what's already here and do a renovation in such a way where we have a limited environmental impact?
- 10:18How does water be more, you know, how do you look at that? You talked about
- 10:22materials, and it seems as though engineers need to be, it's kind of the artisanal
- 10:27approach almost to engineering.
- 10:28You have to not only look at the materials, but you have to look at exactly
- 10:31where those are sourced and how they are manufactured because that also accounts
- 10:36for the carbon footprint of that building.
- 10:39How do you approach that question of new building versus redevelopment and then
- 10:43how did the materials that you specify for that redevelopment?
- 10:46Yeah, sure. You know.
- 10:49The greenest building is the one that's already constructed.
- 10:52And so I think that we've seen a lot of focus on repositionings and conversions.
- 10:58So I think that urban planners are definitely looking at those within the building stock.
- 11:05And there's definitely been a push for that in recent years.
- 11:10So incorporating the carbon impacts of demo and renewal into the overall analysis
- 11:15of new development can help cities select optimal sites for redevelopment and retention.
- 11:21And we suggest that cities compare and assess the carbon impact of necessary
- 11:25upgrades to meet current codes compared to new construction.
- 11:28And then also considering the building envelope.
- 11:32So looking at the whole thing and looking at the buildings as a carbon sink that have already been.
- 11:38Created, but, you know, specifically looking to hybrid work and how we're approaching
- 11:44it, you know, like many firms like yours, we've adopted a hybrid work model
- 11:50and are not in our office spaces every day.
- 11:52So we've been, you know, looking at how we're using our workplaces differently
- 11:55and have been undergoing renovations in order to optimize those spaces for, for hybrid.
- 12:02So our carbon report actually highlighted what we did in our Washington, D.C. office.
- 12:07And on that renovation, we really wanted to understand our carbon impact.
- 12:12So we performed an interior's LCA.
- 12:15So historically, interior LCAs haven't really been done very much.
- 12:20And interior spaces have been overlooked in discussions about embodied carbon
- 12:24emissions because we're looking at the big ticket items like concrete and steel and wood.
- 12:28And we're looking at these bigger ticket items. And so it's as there's been
- 12:32less of a focus on doing interiors LCAs, but we wanted to do it on ours because
- 12:37we wanted to really understand all the materials that we're working with now
- 12:41that we were working with some interiors materials.
- 12:44And it really informed us about the importance of starting the conversation
- 12:50early and using an embodied carbon as a performance metric throughout the entire design process.
- 12:55We saw in that LCA that one of the most impactful ways to reduce carbon is through
- 13:01material reuse and circularity.
- 13:04On that project, through furniture reuse alone, we achieved a 23% reduction
- 13:09in global warming potential than if we had purchased all new furniture.
- 13:14And I think that was eye-opening about the importance of reuse around designing
- 13:19around the pieces that you already have,
- 13:22which is not as common in a redesign to really take stock and inventory of what
- 13:29you have and find new places for it in your redesign.
- 13:32So I think LCAs are becoming, you know, increasingly integral part of the design process in general.
- 13:40And hopefully the availability of impact data for interior components will increase
- 13:46so that we can see more interior LCAs done on projects. That's a really important point.
- 13:53An interesting point you raised because historically, it's always been seen
- 13:57as, okay, we're going to get a new office space.
- 13:59So it's a new opportunity to have a clean page.
- 14:02So we're going to buy everything new, everything that we have,
- 14:05we're going to replace, and we're going to build out exactly what we need.
- 14:09And it makes more sense to take stock of the existing assets that you have.
- 14:13And to your point, design around what you already have.
- 14:16So you're not looking at purchasing all new items because everything has an
- 14:22economic, as an environmental footprint down from printers to paper to chairs
- 14:27to everything else to really save that by reuse.
- 14:31And I guess, you know, it's not a very American way of looking at things, is it?
- 14:35We're so set on new next, you know, let's out with the old in with the new that
- 14:42we need to figure out a way where we can actually create that balance.
- 14:46So that's very interesting. You know, I can't remember if we went to that detail on our redesign.
- 14:52We did look at the materials. We did look at, you know, how we were going to
- 14:56actually consume power,
- 14:57you know, how were the HVAC systems going to be operating, all the way down
- 15:02to kind of the overall, you know, structure of the floor that we have that is
- 15:07really compared to the office that we had before,
- 15:10which was your typical kind of DC office where it was, you know,
- 15:15everybody was in a closed-off space with one or two main hallways going to an
- 15:20open space that has a lot less material definitely had a benefit.
- 15:26I do want to go into the issue of materials, and there are two that you call out in the report.
- 15:31A good case study that you have is the Intuit Dome, which was newly constructed
- 15:36and took advantage of low-carbon concrete.
- 15:40Had a podcast not too long ago of a member of the American Concrete Paving Association
- 15:46who is on the kind of researching board on low-carbon concrete.
- 15:51Kind of go into that as a material option. where does it stand right now and
- 15:56how was that used with the Intuit Dome to really reduce that structure's body
- 16:01carbon during construction?
- 16:03Yeah, so the thing about concrete is that it's one of the world's most prevalent
- 16:08materials and the second most used substance on earth after water.
- 16:13Unfortunately, it's also one of the most impactful materials to our environment.
- 16:18It accounts for up to 8% of the world's global CO2 emissions.
- 16:22But what's interesting about concrete is that although it's made of coarse and
- 16:28fine aggregates, water, admixtures, and cement, it's the Portland cement component
- 16:34of concrete that accounts for its large carbon footprint.
- 16:37In fact, up to 96% of the CO2 emissions in a concrete mix are attributable to the cement content.
- 16:44And that's due to both the incredible heat required to make the clinker and
- 16:49also as part of the natural chemical reaction of the process.
- 16:53So whenever you're looking at trying to reduce the carbon footprint of a building,
- 16:59you have to consider concrete and optimizing the cement content of the mixtures
- 17:05and then looking at any cement replacement.
- 17:08So the example that we put in our report was Intuit Dome, as you mentioned.
- 17:13And Intuit Dome is the new home of the LA Clippers and is located just across
- 17:18the street from SoFi Stadium, which is another one of our projects.
- 17:22The owners of Intuit wanted this project to be climate positive.
- 17:27But back in mid-2021, when we were designing this, the prevailing strategies
- 17:33in SoCal for generating low-carbon mixed designs were,
- 17:37really relied on supplementary semititious materials like fly ash,
- 17:42we call them SEMs, to replace the cement content.
- 17:45But then there was a critical Caltrans standard specification that allowed the
- 17:51use of Portland limestone cement or PLC or Type 1L, all those things are the same thing.
- 17:58Type 1L cement is a blended cement that's covered by ASTM C595.
- 18:03And Type 1L cement typically has 5 to 15 percent of its makeup comprised of
- 18:09limestone instead of clinker.
- 18:11This results in type 1L cement having a lower carbon emission than typical Portland
- 18:18cement since up to 15 percent of it has been replaced by natural and unprocessed
- 18:23materials unlike clinker.
- 18:26So going back to the project story of Intuit Dome,
- 18:30that Caltrans spec change not only provided an opportunity for us to explore
- 18:36optimizing our SCMs, but also open up additional avenues to assess the optimal cement choices.
- 18:45So during that mixed creation, only one of the six cement plants in California
- 18:50was producing type 1L cement.
- 18:52But really the entire team decided that that's the way that we should go.
- 18:58And following a lot of successful implementations and things like the foundations.
- 19:04The decision was made on the project to predominantly use type 1L cement.
- 19:09So that transition plus the use of orca aggregate, which is an aggregate that's
- 19:14trucked down from the Pacific Northwest to California,
- 19:18that all resulted in a, I think, 25% average reduction in the embodied carbon
- 19:25of the concrete placed at Intuit Dome.
- 19:28So I think overall, that is a significant reduction for the overall concrete.
- 19:34And that's based on a comparison to a baseline for the regional,
- 19:39I think, the regional NRMCA benchmarks.
- 19:44How beneficial was it to have a client that was also dedicated to making the
- 19:51stadium climate positive,
- 19:54in allowing you to have the flexibility to test and evaluate different forms
- 19:59of concrete to get a 25% reduction.
- 20:04It seems as though you need to have an active partner on the client side to be able to say,
- 20:08yes, I am invested in this, and I do want to have my structure come out to be
- 20:14climate positive or as close to climate positive as possible to give you the
- 20:18flexibility and freedom to explore those things.
- 20:21How important was that in that project?
- 20:25Yeah, that's critical on that project and every project where we're trying to
- 20:28do something, where we're trying to move the needle, right?
- 20:31Having a client that is on board, that's interested, that's willing to try new
- 20:37things, to take some risks, to allow any time in the schedule, to try new things,
- 20:44that's everything. thing.
- 20:47It's very difficult for us to push strategies up.
- 20:52As structural engineers, we can be sometimes lower on the totem pole of all
- 20:59the people in our project.
- 21:00So it's pretty difficult for us to do things on our own.
- 21:03We do try all the time to be doing things on our own, even if a client is not
- 21:07specifically requesting it.
- 21:08But we can absolutely make bigger gains and move the needle more when we have
- 21:13an owner client who is willing to go the mile with us, that is willing to go
- 21:18down the rabbit holes, that's willing to explore the strategies.
- 21:22That is extremely important. It's one of the reasons why we put out things like
- 21:27our carbon report, so that we can get the story out there to more people,
- 21:31to, you know, kind of spread the, you know, spread the love,
- 21:35spread the ideas, you know, spread our thoughts out into the universe.
- 21:39Yeah, absolutely. And, And, you know, another material that you mentioned in
- 21:44the report is one that I personally really like, and that's mass timber,
- 21:48which I think we're seeing a resurgence of,
- 21:51hopefully, which is a great material because it's, you know,
- 21:57naturally, this is naturally a carbon sink.
- 21:59You have its ease of construction as a material.
- 22:04It speeds up construction. It's beautifully aesthetic. I mean,
- 22:08it's just amazing what you can do with mass timber now.
- 22:11Where do you see that fitting in? Do you think that the mass timber market's
- 22:16going to be something that's going to be growing, given the fact that it has
- 22:19so many positives for sustainability?
- 22:22Absolutely. I mean, I think the mass timber market has been growing exponentially
- 22:26in the United States as we see more and more projects consider using mass timber
- 22:31as the structural system.
- 22:33People love the feel and look of natural wood.
- 22:37So I think we're just drawn to it as humans.
- 22:41We've seen several mass timber buildings pop up around Atlanta where I live,
- 22:47and I'm actually working on a mass timber and steel hybrid project over in Alabama.
- 22:52Our carbon report actually featured the Anderson Ball classroom building at
- 22:57Indusinto College in Texas.
- 23:00And when it opened in 2021, that
- 23:03three-story building became the largest instructional building in the U.S.
- 23:06Made from Mass Timber at about 120,000 square feet.
- 23:10So very large Mass Timber instructional building.
- 23:14And I think it's been extremely successful. By all accounts,
- 23:18the university is extremely pleased and the students are pleased.
- 23:23It's a space that people really, really enjoy.
- 23:26And what's great about that story is not only did Musing Mass Timber align with
- 23:32the college's sustainability goals, but it also accelerated the overall project
- 23:36schedule due to the prefabricated nature of mass timber.
- 23:41So it was really a win-win. And I love project stories that can be a win-win on all sides.
- 23:49I think that's when you get into true sustainability.
- 23:52And really, with modern design practices, really the limits on mass timber as
- 23:59a building material really have been lifted.
- 24:02There are multi-story structures and, like you said, the three-story large classroom
- 24:08building that can be done in mass timber now.
- 24:12It really is limitless on what you can do with it, especially if you combine
- 24:17it with steel, structural steel, and other materials to complement. Oh, yeah, absolutely.
- 24:22I mean, I think that we've seen a lot of development in codes,
- 24:25and specifically the IDC, that allow more use of mass timber.
- 24:29There's all the categories now for type four, type four, and then type four A, B, and C.
- 24:35So there's a lot more flexibility in using mass timber now.
- 24:39And I think that's allowing designers to kind of push the limits and see what's
- 24:44possible in multiple market types.
- 24:48Yeah, absolutely. Well, Kelly, the report's great.
- 24:51I really encourage anyone out there to go to the Walter P. Moore website to
- 24:55download the report. We'll put a link in the description on the show notes.
- 24:59And not only this report, but there's a wealth of thought leadership that Walter P.
- 25:03Moore has on its website that is, of course, focused on sustainability and green
- 25:08building principles, but many other subjects.
- 25:10Is there anything we didn't cover that you want to make sure our audience knows
- 25:13before we wrap up? I would just encourage everyone to, you know,
- 25:17start small on your projects.
- 25:19Start just by understanding what's in your building, understanding or in your
- 25:23project, you know, start to understand your carbon.
- 25:27If you are brand new to this, there is a lot of information available on SC
- 25:322050's website. FC 2050 is the Structural Engineer's Commitment to Reducing
- 25:37Embodied Carbon by 2050.
- 25:39And there is an embodied carbon calculator on that website, and there's just a ton of resources.
- 25:44So if you're brand new to this and you're just trying things out,
- 25:47go to that website and you'll find a wealth of resources to get you started.
- 25:51Fantastic. Again, Kelly Roberts with Walter P. Moore. Thank you so much for
- 25:55joining us today on an exciting topic.
- 25:57Look forward to having you on again on this, especially as, you know,
- 26:01who knows? We have a lot more happening in Washington. Maybe we'll have some
- 26:05more incentives on using low-carbon concrete or mass timber.
- 26:09I know we have a couple of members of Congress in the House that are advocates of mass timber.
- 26:16And hopefully we can have some movement on that. So we'll be happy to have you back on the show.
- 26:21Yeah, would be happy to. Thanks. Fantastic. And again, this has been the Engineering
- 26:25Info's podcast from ACEC. We'll see you next time.
- 26:29Music.