Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / The Quiet Rise of Secondary Market IPOs
Transcript
- Lucas: If you followed the IPO headlines this year, you might have noticed something weird: some of the biggest tech companies going public barely had a traditional roadshow. No dramatic pricing night, no big pop on day one. And that is because the real price discovery already happened — in the secondary market. Luna: Secondary market meaning the trading of private company shares before the IPO, right? Through platforms like Forge Global or EquityZen. Lucas: Exactly. And this is becoming a bigger deal than most retail investors realize. In the old model, a company hires banks, they pitch to institutions, set a price range, and then the stock opens. But now you have situations where a stock like Coinbase — ticker c o i n — already had a robust secondary market before its direct listing in 2021. By the time it opened on NASDAQ, the price was essentially already set. Luna: Right. And Coinbase's first trade was around $381, which was well above even the high end of where private trades had been happening. But that initial pop was short-lived; it closed at $328 that day. Lucas: That volatility actually tells you something important. The secondary market had priced it around $350 in the weeks before, but the public market enthusiasm pushed it higher on day one. But here we are, May 24, 2026, and Coinbase is trading around $185, down about 2.3 percent over the past five days. That is a far cry from that opening price. Luna: So the secondary market gave a more realistic valuation than the IPO hype. That is interesting. Lucas: It is. And it raises a question: if the secondary market already provides price discovery and liquidity for employees and early investors, what is the point of the traditional IPO process? Some companies are starting to wonder the same thing. Stripe, for example, has been talked about as a potential direct listing candidate for years, partly because its secondary market is already so active. Luna: And Stripe is still private, despite being one of the most valuable startups in the world. They seem in no rush to go public because their employees can already cash out on platforms like Forge. Lucas: Precisely. And that creates a new dynamic. Companies can delay their IPO indefinitely if they can offer liquidity through secondary sales. But it also changes who gets access. Secondary markets are still largely institutional or accredited investor playgrounds. Retail investors are locked out until the public listing. Luna: So when the public listing finally happens, retail investors are buying at a price that insiders and institutions have already set. The information asymmetry is baked in. Lucas: That is the concern. Look at Roblox, ticker R-B-L-X. It went public via direct listing in 2021, and its secondary market trades before the listing had been around $45 per share. On the first day, it opened at $64.50. So retail investors paid a premium for something that was already being traded privately at a lower price. Luna: And Roblox is now around $48, so that premium has eroded. But the broader point is that the IPO is no longer the price discovery event it used to be. It is more of a liquidity event for a broader pool of investors. Lucas: Right. And that shift has implications for how we think about IPOs going forward. If the secondary market is efficient, maybe the traditional underwriting model becomes less relevant. But it also means that retail investors need to be more aware of what has already happened in the private market before they buy. Luna: Is there any regulation trying to address this? I recall the SEC has been looking at expanding access to secondary markets for retail investors. Lucas: There have been proposals. The SEC has considered allowing platforms like Forge to offer shares to a wider group, not just accredited investors. But nothing has passed yet. The concern is investor protection — private companies don't have the same disclosure requirements. So it is a trade-off between access and transparency. Luna: That makes sense. But it also means that the IPO market is bifurcating. On one side, you have companies like Stripe that can stay private longer because they have a secondary market. On the other, you have smaller companies that still rely on the traditional IPO for both capital and liquidity. Lucas: Exactly. And that is the angle I want to drill into today. The secondary market is not just a side note — it is reshaping the entire IPO landscape. For investors, understanding how these markets work is becoming as important as reading the S-1. Luna: So where do you see this going in the next few years? Do we reach a point where most tech IPOs are just a formality? Lucas: I think we see more direct listings and fewer traditional underwritten IPOs for large, well-known companies. But the traditional IPO won't disappear entirely, especially for companies that need the marketing and credibility that comes with a bank-backed roadshow. Luna: And for retail investors, the takeaway is to look for clues about secondary market activity before a company lists. If there is a lot of trading on Forge, the first-day pop might not be as big as expected. Lucas: Right. And that is actually a useful signal. If a stock has been trading actively in the secondary market at a certain level, the public offering price is likely to be close to that. The days of the massive IPO pop may be fading for the biggest names. Luna: It is a more mature market in some ways. But it also requires more homework. Lucas: Speaking of homework, and this ties back to what we just said about market signals: a handful of listeners actually help us keep the show going through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. And that support is what allows us to dig into topics like this without ads or sponsors. Luna: Yeah, it is a small group, but it makes a real difference. It keeps this show independent and focused on what matters. Lucas: So back to the secondary market. One specific data point that caught my eye: Forge Global recently reported that trading volume on its platform grew 40 percent year-over-year in the first quarter of 2026. That is a lot of shares changing hands before any public listing. Luna: And that growth is driving valuation benchmarks. Companies like SpaceX have used secondary sales to let employees cash out without an IPO, and that sets a market price for the stock. Lucas: Which brings us full circle. The secondary market is becoming the primary market for price discovery. The public listing is increasingly just the final step in a long process. Luna: For investors, the key is to pay attention to those private market signals. They might tell you more than the prospectus. Lucas: Absolutely. And that is the kind of insight we try to bring every week. Thanks for listening.