Latest / Deep Dive / The Talent Paradox: Why Australia Wastes Skilled Migrants & The Children of Skilled Migrants
Transcript
- 0:00OK, so imagine you are managing a massive multibillion dollar
- 0:06manufacturing plant. Sounds pretty stressful already.
- 0:09Right. But imagine you scour the entire
- 0:11globe for the absolute best, most advanced, highly calibrated
- 0:16machinery available. OK, I'm with you.
- 0:18You spend incredible resources importing it, going through
- 0:21customs, you install it right in the center of your busiest
- 0:24production floors, and then you just leave a huge chunk of it
- 0:28completely unplugged. I mean, that's sounds like a
- 0:30fast track to bankruptcy, honestly.
- 0:32Exactly. It sounds totally irrational,
- 0:34like why go through all that effort to acquire premium assets
- 0:37just to leave them sitting idle? You're intentionally capping
- 0:41your own production capacity. You're just leaving immense
- 0:44potential on the table. And yet, when we look at one of
- 0:46the most robust economies on the planet, this is precisely what
- 0:50is happening. Not with machinery, obviously,
- 0:52but with human capital. Yeah, it's a massive
- 0:54inefficiency. Which brings us to our mission.
- 0:56For today's Deep Dive, we are cracking open a really
- 1:00fascinating paper from the OECD, the Organization for Economic
- 1:04Cooperation and Development. Specifically, we're looking at
- 1:07their regional development papers #39 and this one explores
- 1:10regional productivity, local labor markets, and migration in
- 1:14Australia. And it is a vital piece of
- 1:17research, honestly, because it forces us to look past those
- 1:21standard sweeping national. Headlines the big macro numbers.
- 1:25Exactly. It gets into the highly
- 1:27localized regional data. So it shows us not just the
- 1:30sheer volume of migrants in Australia, but exactly where
- 1:33they're choosing to settle, the highly specific human capital
- 1:37they bring and how they actually interact or, you know, fail to
- 1:40interact with the local economy. So our goal today is to uncover
- 1:44why Australia's migrant population is one of the most
- 1:46unique in the entire world. We're going to look at the truly
- 1:50bizarre paradox between their incredibly high education levels
- 1:53and their lower employment rates.
- 1:55That paradox is wild. It really is.
- 1:57And we'll also dig into the hidden gender dynamics that are
- 2:00secretly dictating the pace of local economies.
- 2:04OK, let's unpack this. By the time we finish sorting
- 2:07through this data, the way you think about how immigration
- 2:09actually shapes a nation's economic reality is going to
- 2:12fundamentally change. It really completely flips the
- 2:15traditional narrative. Yeah, but to even understand the
- 2:18nuances of their employment, we have to grasp the raw scale of
- 2:23migration in Australia first, right?
- 2:25Because that's the thing that really demands our attention
- 2:28right out of the gate. And the headline statistic here
- 2:30is what caught my attention initially.
- 2:32As of 2019, 30% of Australia's population is foreign born. 30%.
- 2:37Three out of every 10 people. I mean, that completely upends
- 2:41the usual assumptions we have about global migration hubs,
- 2:44especially since the OECD average sits at what, around
- 2:4814%? Yeah, roughly 14%.
- 2:50And this isn't some historical remnant either, right?
- 2:52It's an accelerating trend because back in 2000 that number
- 2:56was 23%. Yeah, to contextualize how
- 2:58staggering that is globally, out of all the OECD countries, there
- 3:02was only one nation with a higher migrant share than
- 3:05Australia, and that's Luxembourg.
- 3:07Luxembourg. Yeah, they're sitting at 47%,
- 3:09but Luxembourg is this unique, highly localized micro economy
- 3:14right in the heart of Europe. We're right.
- 3:16Sure, it's tiny. Exactly.
- 3:18When you look at the major traditional migrant receiving
- 3:21countries, Australia is operating in a league of its
- 3:25own, Canada is at 21%, Germany is at 16%, and the US, which is,
- 3:31you know, often considered the quintessential nation of
- 3:33immigrants, is trailing far behind at just 14%.
- 3:36Wow, just 14. It's a complete paradigm shift
- 3:40for anyone who assumes the US or Western Europe are the primary
- 3:44centers of modern global migration.
- 3:46Totally. But these millions of migrants,
- 3:49they aren't just evenly sprinkled across the Australian
- 3:51Outback, they are concentrating in very specific areas, which
- 3:54creates its own set of economic pressures.
- 3:57Yeah, the geographic clustering is intensely concentrated.
- 4:00The paper details exactly where these populations settle and
- 4:03there is a massive urban bias. How massive are we talking?
- 4:06Well, according to the data, 7 out of 10 foreign born
- 4:09individuals in Australia live in what are classified as large
- 4:12metropolitan regions. So cities with over 1,000,000
- 4:151/2 people. Right, like Sydney, Melbourne,
- 4:17Perth, Brisbane. So 70% of the migrant population
- 4:20is packed into these massive urban hubs.
- 4:24But wait, if the cities are getting that crowded, wouldn't
- 4:27basic supply and demand push native born workers or even
- 4:31newer migrants out into regional areas where jobs or housing
- 4:34might be like less competitive? You would think so, yeah, but
- 4:38the native born population is actually already much more
- 4:41dispersed. Yeah, only half of the native
- 4:43born population lives in those same massive hubs, and 24% live
- 4:48in remote regions, compared to just 12% of migrants.
- 4:52That's a huge difference. And the reason the migrants
- 4:55don't disperse is due to the compounding benefits of urban
- 4:58centers. When you arrive in a new country
- 5:01you need immediate access to things.
- 5:03Specialized job markets, international airports,
- 5:06specialized healthcare, and most importantly, pre-existing Co
- 5:10ethnic networks. Networks that can help you
- 5:12navigate the new system Exactly. Think of it like a gravitational
- 5:15pull, right? The biggest cities have the
- 5:17strongest gravity. They offer agglomeration
- 5:19advantages, meaning there's a clustering of businesses and
- 5:22services that just make everything more efficient.
- 5:24Yes, exactly. That massive gravity pulls in
- 5:28the newly arriving migrants, and it keeps them in a tight orbit,
- 5:31because leaving that orbit means losing your support network.
- 5:35Right, you lose the safety net. Meanwhile, native born citizens,
- 5:38they already know the language of the system, they have
- 5:40generational safety Nets, so they are much more evenly
- 5:43distributed across the solar system, so to speak.
- 5:47That gravitational pull analogy worked perfectly, yeah, because
- 5:50gravity doesn't discriminate. It just pulls in whoever is
- 5:52arriving, right? And that leads us to a crucial
- 5:55question. Who exactly is landing in
- 5:59Melbourne and Sydney right now and what kind of human capital
- 6:03are they bringing with them? Because the policy governing who
- 6:06gets to immigrate to Australia has fundamentally changed over
- 6:09the last few decades, hasn't it? Radically changed, yeah.
- 6:11Yeah. Up until the 1970s, migration to
- 6:13Australia was largely focused on general population growth, and
- 6:17it heavily favored European citizens.
- 6:19Yeah. But the data shows a massive
- 6:21shift toward a highly selective skills based process now.
- 6:24Yes, today migrants born in Asia actually dominate the foreign
- 6:28born population in almost all Australian states.
- 6:31Really. All of them.
- 6:33Well, the only exceptions are WA and Tasmania, where European
- 6:37migrants still make up about 40%, but across the board the
- 6:41modern Australian migrant is predominantly Asian born.
- 6:45OK, and here's where it gets really interesting.
- 6:47Because of that shift to a skills based point system,
- 6:51Australia has essentially engineered a massive brain gain.
- 6:54Oh, it's unprecedented. The education data in this OECD
- 6:58paper is remarkable. Almost 60% of the migrant
- 7:02population in Australia has attained A tertiary education.
- 7:0560%, yeah. We were talking about university
- 7:08degrees, advanced certifications, highly
- 7:11specialized training. That is a staggering
- 7:13concentration of knowledge. To put that in perspective for
- 7:15Ulyssing, only about 40% of the native born Australian
- 7:19population has attained that same level of education, right?
- 7:22And if you look at the average across all other OECD countries,
- 7:26the migrant education level is also hovering around 40%.
- 7:29So Australia is pulling in a demographic that is
- 7:31statistically much more educated than both their own citizens and
- 7:35the global average. And the regional data
- 7:37illustrates this even more sharply.
- 7:39I mean, look at the ACT, the ACT.
- 7:42OK, what's happening there? In the ACT, an astounding 8 out
- 7:46of 10 migrants have a tertiary education. 80%. 80%, It is an
- 7:51unbelievable density of human capital and even if we look at
- 7:55the other end of the spectrum, like WA, which has the lowest
- 7:59average for the country, one out of two migrants there still hold
- 8:03a tertiary degree. So even their lowest performing
- 8:06region is beating the OECD average.
- 8:09Precisely. Australia boasts the largest
- 8:11positive education gap between migrants and natives in the
- 8:14entire OECD. It is a massive 20 percentage
- 8:18point advantage for migrants over the NATO born workforce.
- 8:21OK, let's follow the logical progression of this.
- 8:24We have an enormous migrant population, they are heavily
- 8:26concentrated in the most economically dynamic large
- 8:29metropolitan cities and they possess a massive 20 point
- 8:33educational advantage over the native born workforce.
- 8:36If you are managing a company in Sydney and you have a pool of
- 8:39candidates where the migrants are statistically much more
- 8:42likely to have a university degree, you're going to hire
- 8:45them. Naturally, this highly educated
- 8:47city dwelling workforce should be absolutely dominating the
- 8:51Australian job market. That is the rational economic
- 8:54assumption, yeah. Yeah.
- 8:55If you have the best machinery, you plug it in and run it at
- 8:58full capacity. But the data reveals A baffling
- 9:01paradox here. Despite their massive
- 9:03educational advantage, migrants in Australia are actually less
- 9:06likely to be employed than the native born population.
- 9:09It's completely counterintuitive.
- 9:11It really is. The employment rate for migrants
- 9:13is 72%, while the rate for natives is 76%.
- 9:17And that gap isn't uniform when you look at where the gap is
- 9:20most severe. What's fascinating here is it's
- 9:23actually worst in those exact same large urban centers where
- 9:27the migrants are clustered. For example, in inner Melbourne,
- 9:31the native employment rate beats the migrant rate by a staggering
- 9:3517 percentage points. Wait, a 17 point gap in a major
- 9:39economic hub? I'm have to push back on this.
- 9:41How does a 20 point advantage in university degrees result in a
- 9:4517 point deficit in employment in the very cities where those
- 9:49degrees should be most valuable? It's a great question.
- 9:51Like, are the employers just not recognizing international
- 9:54degrees? Is it a language barrier?
- 9:56What is happening? You're hitting on a crucial
- 9:58friction point. The researchers broke down the
- 10:01employment gap by education level, and they found a really
- 10:04fascinating nuance. The gap isn't widest at the top
- 10:08and the bottom. The gap is actually widest about
- 10:119 percentage points among workers in the middle tier,
- 10:14those who only have a secondary education.
- 10:16Secondary education. So we're talking about high
- 10:18school diplomas, trade schools, basic vocational training, yes.
- 10:22Think about the mechanics of transferring skills across
- 10:25international borders. If you are a highly specialized
- 10:28structural engineer or a brain surgeon, the laws of physics and
- 10:32human anatomy are the same in Manila as they are in Melbourne,
- 10:35right? Your highly specialized tertiary
- 10:37degree translates relatively seamlessly.
- 10:41Conversely, if you're working in low skill manual labor, those
- 10:44skills also translate easily. But that middle tier
- 10:48electricians, nurses, teachers, specialized trades, that is
- 10:52where the friction is highest. Let's go back to our factory
- 10:55metaphor. It's like importing $1,000,000
- 10:58machine from Germany, but the plug doesn't fit Australian
- 11:01electrical outlets exactly. The machine is perfectly capable
- 11:05of doing the work, but because you lack a $50 adapter, it just
- 11:08sits there. That is exactly what happens in
- 11:10this case. The adapter is highly specific.
- 11:13Local licensing, fluency in local regulatory language and
- 11:17pre-existing professional networks.
- 11:19OK. That makes sense.
- 11:20An electrician from another country might know exactly how
- 11:23to wire a house, but the building codes, the voltage
- 11:25standards, the safety certifications in Australia,
- 11:28they're an entirely different language.
- 11:29So they have to spend years retraining.
- 11:32Yes, retraining and navigating bureaucracy just to prove what
- 11:35they already know. Native born citizens don't have
- 11:38that friction. They learn the regulatory
- 11:40language natively. OK, that makes mechanical sense.
- 11:43The middle tier credentials get lost in translation which drags
- 11:46down the employment numbers for that specific group.
- 11:49Right? But even considering that
- 11:51secondary education struggle, the overall numbers still seem
- 11:54deeply skewed. A4 point gap nationally, A 17
- 11:58point gap in inner Melbourne. Despite that massive advantage
- 12:02in university degrees, the math still doesn't balance out.
- 12:05It doesn't. So is there a specific
- 12:07demographic within the migrant population that is carrying the
- 12:11weight of this statistical drop? There is, and this is the core
- 12:15revelation of the OECD paper. When you slice the data by
- 12:18gender, the mystery resolves itself entirely.
- 12:21Oh, the employment gap is almost entirely driven by female
- 12:24migrants. Walk me through how snark that
- 12:26divide actually is. Let's look at the men first.
- 12:29For male migrants compared to native born men, the employment
- 12:32gap is practically non existent. It's a mere 0.5 percentage
- 12:35points. Wow.
- 12:36Just half a percent, yeah. Statistically speaking, male
- 12:40migrants are employed at virtually the exact same rate as
- 12:44their native counterparts. They are navigating the
- 12:46credential friction and finding work.
- 12:49But for women, the native migrant employment gap explodes
- 12:53to over 8 percentage points. So the men are plugging into the
- 12:56local economy just fine, but the women are hitting a massive
- 13:00systemic wall. Yes, and we need to be very
- 13:03precise about what kind of wall this is, because in economics we
- 13:06differentiate between the unemployment rate and the labor
- 13:09force participation rate. OK, so this isn't primarily a
- 13:12story about unemployment exactly.
- 13:14Meaning it's not a story about migrant women actively sending
- 13:17out resumes and just getting rejected by employers.
- 13:19No. Unemployment measures people who
- 13:21are actively looking for a job but can't find one.
- 13:24Labor force participation measures whether people are
- 13:26engaged in the workforce at all, whether they are even on the
- 13:29playing field. And this is where the Gap truly
- 13:31live. Yes, migrant women's
- 13:33participation rate hovers between 66 and 69%.
- 13:36Meanwhile, native born women are participating at a rate of 73 to
- 13:4077%. This is a vital distinction.
- 13:43If they aren't even participating, it means the
- 13:46Australian economy is sitting on a massive reservoir of of
- 13:50untapped economic potential. Huge potential.
- 13:53We've established these women are highly educated.
- 13:55They make up a huge chunk of that 60% tertiary educated
- 13:58statistic. They are living right in the
- 14:00economic centers, the big cities, but they're essentially
- 14:03sidelined. So what does this all mean?
- 14:06Why? What is the mechanism pushing
- 14:09them out of the workforce entirely?
- 14:11It's a compounding friction. You have to look at the
- 14:14intersection of being a woman and being a migrant first.
- 14:18You have the standard friction. We discussed the difficulty of
- 14:21transferring middle tier credentials.
- 14:23The adapter problem. But then you layer on the
- 14:25friction of gender expectations. If a migrant family arrives and
- 14:29the husband's credentials transfer more easily, or he
- 14:32enters a male dominated trade, the economic incentive is for
- 14:36him to work. Meanwhile, the woman faces the
- 14:39enormous cost of local childcare.
- 14:42Native born women often have a generational safety net.
- 14:45Grandparents or extended family who can help with childcare.
- 14:49Migrant women, by definition, have left that safety net
- 14:52behind. So if you have a master's degree
- 14:55from your home country, but the local market doesn't immediately
- 14:58recognize it, and childcare in Sydney cost an exorbitant amount
- 15:02of money, and you have no family nearby to babysit, the
- 15:06mathematical calculation for your family might just be that
- 15:08it's cheaper for you to stay home.
- 15:10Precisely. It becomes economically
- 15:12irrational to work and there's a psychological tool there as
- 15:15well. Honestly having advanced degrees
- 15:17but being told you need to start from scratch in an entry level
- 15:19position to prove yourself. Yeah, that's demoralizing.
- 15:22It can lead to severe discouragement, causing highly
- 15:25qualified women to simply opt out of a system that refuses to
- 15:28easily accommodate them. So we have a migrant population
- 15:31that is highly educated, overwhelmingly located in major
- 15:34cities, but unevenly employed due to this compounding friction
- 15:38on women. How does this actually affect
- 15:40the bottom line of the Australian economy?
- 15:42Does leaving this much highly calibrated machinery unplugged
- 15:46drag down the whole factory? This is where the researchers
- 15:49looked at regional productivity. And the fascinating thing is,
- 15:52despite this glaring gender gap in participation, the Migrant
- 15:56Engine is still an absolute powerhouse.
- 15:59Really. The OECD paper shows that in the
- 16:0220/16/2017 financial year, migrants generated 112 billion
- 16:07Australian dollars in total personal income. 112 billion.
- 16:11Yes, which equates to 13% of the entire national income.
- 16:16Wow. So even operating at a deficit
- 16:18of female participation, they are a massive economic driver.
- 16:22But the researchers went a step further.
- 16:24They wanted to measure how migrants impact the actual
- 16:26efficiency of the regions they live in.
- 16:28OK. And the data shows a very clear
- 16:30roductivity correlation. Regions with higher shares of
- 16:33migrants tend to have much higher labor productivity.
- 16:36On average. If a region increases its local
- 16:38migrant share by just one percentage point, it is
- 16:40associated with a labor productivity jump of 14190
- 16:44Australian dollars per worker. OK, wait, how do they even
- 16:47isolate that number? Because if the migrant
- 16:49population is statistically 20 points more likely to have a
- 16:53university degree, of course they're going to have higher
- 16:56salaries and generate more output.
- 16:58Are the researchers just capturing the fact that educated
- 17:01people make more money? That is the exact question
- 17:04economists ask, and is why the methodology here is so rigorous.
- 17:08The researchers use an econometric model to control for
- 17:12the skill composition of the region.
- 17:14Essentially, they mathematically leveled the playing field.
- 17:17Exactly. They ran a regression model
- 17:19holding education cost of basically asking the data.
- 17:23If we compare 2 regions with the exact same level of education,
- 17:26but one have a higher share of migrants, what happens to
- 17:29productivity? So they mathematically remove
- 17:31the educational advantage to isolate the raw economic value
- 17:35of being a migrant. What did they find?
- 17:37Even when you remove the educational advantage entirely,
- 17:40the mere presence of a higher migrant share still correlates
- 17:43to a $780 boost in regional productivity per worker.
- 17:47Just having a diverse migrant rich workforce organically
- 17:51boosts the efficiency of everyone in that area by nearly
- 17:55$800 per worker, regardless of the education level.
- 17:58Why does that happen mechanically?
- 18:00It speaks to the positive spillover effects of cognitive
- 18:03diversity. When you inject people into a
- 18:06local economy who were trained in completely different
- 18:08regulatory, cultural and educational environments, they
- 18:12bring new problem solving approaches.
- 18:14That makes total sense. They break local groupthink.
- 18:17They bring access to international networks and
- 18:19supply chains that native born workers might not have.
- 18:22They stimulate local demand in varied ways.
- 18:25They literally make the entire regional economic engine run
- 18:29hotter and more efficiently because they approach the work
- 18:31differently. Why should you care about this?
- 18:34Because it proves a fundamental lesson.
- 18:35Simply importing talent is not enough.
- 18:38Australia has arguably the most educated migrant pool on earth.
- 18:41They are doing the incredibly hard part, attracting the
- 18:44absolute best and brightest global talent.
- 18:46They really are. And that talent is undeniably
- 18:49driving up local productivity and injecting hundreds of
- 18:52billions of dollars into the economy.
- 18:54Yet despite all of that success, they are leaving a massive
- 18:58amount of economic potential on the table because of that eight
- 19:01point participation gap for female migrants.
- 19:04It is a profound lesson in the mechanics of integration.
- 19:08Bringing people into the country is only step one.
- 19:11Integrating them into the labor market, removing the friction
- 19:14around childcare, translating middle tier licensing seamlessly
- 19:18and providing networks for professional women is Step 2.
- 19:22Australia is showing us what the ceiling looks like when Step 2
- 19:24isn't fully realized. Let's briefly recap the scope of
- 19:27what we've unpacked here today. We started with the sheer scale
- 19:30of Australia's migration. A massive 30% of the population,
- 19:34completely dwarfing traditional hubs.
- 19:37We saw how the origins have shifted, engineering an
- 19:39incredible 60% tertiary education rate that gives
- 19:43Australia a 20 point brain gain advantage.
- 19:45A huge advantage. But then we hit that baffling
- 19:48employment paradox. Lower overall employment for
- 19:51migrants, driven almost entirely by the compounding friction
- 19:55pushing female migrants out of the labor force.
- 19:58Highly educated women living in big cities but sideline from the
- 20:01economy because the adapter doesn't fit.
- 20:03And yet, Despite that massive inefficiency, the cognitive
- 20:06diversity the migrant population still manages to organically
- 20:10boost regional productivity by hundreds of dollars per worker,
- 20:14proving their immense underlying value to the nation's bottom
- 20:17line. It's a story of incredible
- 20:19economic success mixed with frustratingly untapped
- 20:22potential. As we wrap up this deep dive,
- 20:25there is one final thought we should explore.
- 20:27We talked a lot about the gravity of those massive cities,
- 20:30the Sydney and Melbourne pull, and how that urban concentration
- 20:33creates a lot of the friction around childcare costs and
- 20:36middle tier competition. Yeah.
- 20:37And this raises a critical question about the future of how
- 20:40we work. The data we've looked at relies
- 20:42heavily on the physical clustering of talent, but if we
- 20:45consider the global shift toward remote and distributed work, we
- 20:49have to wonder if the rules of gravity are changing.
- 20:51Oh, interesting. If physical clustering in giant,
- 20:54expensive cities becomes less necessary, will highly educated
- 20:58migrant women in remote or regional areas finally be able
- 21:02to bypass those local barriers to entry?
- 21:04Could the laptop be the ultimate equalizer for migrant
- 21:07integration? If the friction is geographical
- 21:10and network based, remote work might allow them to close that
- 21:13participation gap without having to fight through the specific
- 21:16bottlenecks of the local urban job market.
- 21:19It's definitely something to think about.
- 21:21If the factory machinery is unplugged because it doesn't fit
- 21:23the local physical outlets, maybe the Internet is the
- 21:26universal adapter. Keep questioning the data around
- 21:29you, look for the hidden friction in your own
- 21:31organizations, and we'll see you next time.