Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / The Truth About Employee Engagement Measurement - We've Been Doing It Wrong.
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Sticky from the
- 0:13Inside, the employee engagement podcast
- 0:15that looks at how to build stickier,
- 0:18competition,-smashing, consistently
- 0:20successful organisations from the inside
- 0:22out. I'm your host, Andy Goram, and I'm
- 0:25on a mission to help more businesses turn
- 0:27the lights on behind the eyes of their
- 0:29employees, light the fires within them,
- 0:31and create tons more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe
- 0:42that's something worth going after and
- 0:44would like a little help and guidance in
- 0:46achieving that. Each episode, we dive into
- 0:48the topics that can help create what I
- 0:50call stickier businesses. The sort of
- 0:53businesses where people thrive and love to
- 0:56work, and where more customers stay with
- 0:58you and recommend you to others because
- 1:01they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:04So if you want to take the tricky out of
- 1:06being sticky, listen on. Okay then. Today
- 1:13I am shaking things up a bit with a
- 1:16conversation that might just challenge
- 1:18everything you think you know about
- 1:19employee engagement. If you've ever been
- 1:22involved in an employee engagement survey,
- 1:24you know the drill. Numbers go up,
- 1:27celebrations ensue, numbers dip, and it's
- 1:29time to scramble for a fix. They're now
- 1:32bored of bean bags. We clearly need more
- 1:35fruit and a new coffee machine. But here's
- 1:37the thing. What if chasing that elusive
- 1:40engagement score is actually taking us in
- 1:42entirely the wrong direction? My guest
- 1:45today is Nick Court, the founder and CEO
- 1:47of the People Experience Hub, and he's
- 1:49here to tell us why 2024 needs to be the
- 1:53year we go beyond the score. Nick believes
- 1:58that we've been so focused on those
- 2:01numbers that we've lost sight of what
- 2:02really matters, understanding their
- 2:04behaviors, experiences, and feelings that
- 2:07truly shape workplace culture. So let's
- 2:10get real. Are we simply ticking boxes and
- 2:13patting ourselves on the back for a high
- 2:15score? Or are we digging deeper to
- 2:17understand what's really driving, saving
- 2:19or stalling our people's engagement? And
- 2:22is even that the thing that we should be
- 2:25measuring? What, have we been doing it
- 2:27wrong all along? In today's episode, I
- 2:31hope we'll explore these questions and
- 2:33more. We'll unpack why the traditional
- 2:35approach to employee engagement might not
- 2:36be moving the dial like we think it is.
- 2:39After all, globally, engagement numbers
- 2:41haven't budged significantly in decades.
- 2:44Despite all the surveys, despite all the
- 2:45money that's spent on it's been, all the
- 2:47efforts. There's something somewhere isn't
- 2:50right. So what does it take to design to
- 2:53grow and maintain a workforce that's not
- 2:55just engaged but really thriving? How do
- 2:59we know what the key elements are to
- 3:02achieving that outcome and how we should
- 3:04we measure our progress in working our way
- 3:07towards that. So buckle up as I think
- 3:10Nick's about to flip the script on
- 3:11everything we thought we knew about
- 3:13engagement. Welcome to the show, Nick.
- 3:15Randy, welcome for having me on here. It's
- 3:18exciting. I'm excited and it is exciting.
- 3:20So, yeah, looking forward to jumping into
- 3:23this. Me too, mate. Me too. Now, before we
- 3:25start, just so everybody gets on the same
- 3:27page, just do us a favor, my friend. Just
- 3:29give us a little bit of insight into you
- 3:31and your background and perhaps the
- 3:32origins of the people experience hub. I
- 3:34came into the world of HR for a slightly
- 3:36different route to others, which is I came
- 3:38in from an operational background and I,
- 3:42more than that, I came in from actually
- 3:45from a trade union background. So I
- 3:48started my life working in a warehouse and
- 3:51I was a trade union rep for years and then
- 3:54I was a trade union. Fisher was a branch
- 3:56chair. So I got into the concept of how we
- 3:59should be treating people at work through,
- 4:01number one, experiencing it, and number
- 4:04two, supporting trade union members and
- 4:06Tesco employees. So I very much came into
- 4:09it that way. And I had the opportunity to
- 4:12go into payroll team. The HR director at
- 4:16the time said to me, you know more about
- 4:19our policies and procedures than so many
- 4:20other people do in the organization. And
- 4:22payroll is simply taking those policies
- 4:25and procedures and turning them into
- 4:27transactional elements like pay. So I did
- 4:30that, found out I had an affinity for
- 4:31payroll, affinity for HR systems, and from
- 4:36there I progressed. I then left and went
- 4:38for Associated british foods. So I got
- 4:40from retail into food manufacturing, where
- 4:44I looked after HR, shared services, reward
- 4:50benefits, global mobility, went from there
- 4:52to Carlsberg. Then I realized I've gone
- 4:56from a 400,000 person company to a large
- 4:59company to a 1800 person company. And I
- 5:03decided to set out on my own, went out and
- 5:05did a consultancy role, and then that's
- 5:07where the people experience hub concept
- 5:09came along. I sat with my business
- 5:11partner, Ben at the time. We were looking
- 5:13at, you know, what we felt was wrong in
- 5:15the world and or wasn't quite working,
- 5:19probably more than anything. And we said,
- 5:20one of the things around colleague surveys
- 5:22as people surveys is it feels a little bit
- 5:26like tail wagging the dog. Like the
- 5:28supplier of the survey is telling you how
- 5:32to do it, telling you what the measure is
- 5:34telling you the question to ask and not
- 5:38really understand the experience. And my,
- 5:40and that's where we went out to solve and
- 5:42that's where the people experience hub was
- 5:44born. Fantastic. And it's clearly doing
- 5:47great stuff. You've just received a
- 5:49finalist kind of nomination for the people
- 5:52pioneers for 2024. Congratulations on
- 5:54that. That's great. Culture pioneers. The
- 5:57Culture Pioneers award is for brand. So
- 6:00it's about, does our external brand and
- 6:02our internal brand match up when we walk
- 6:05the walk and talk the talk, do the two
- 6:07things come together? So delighted to have
- 6:10been a finalist for that. Oh, I think
- 6:12that, say, do gap is so important when it
- 6:14comes down to people and culture and
- 6:18really, really delivering this kind of
- 6:20thriving environment. We're hopefully
- 6:22going to talk about today. Now, back early
- 6:24in the day, I had your friend and
- 6:27colleague Rob Robson come on and totally
- 6:30blow my mind while asking him this very
- 6:32simple question, which I'll ask to you,
- 6:34which was a. From your perspective, Nick,
- 6:38when we talk about employee engagement,
- 6:41what are we referring to? So it's Rob.
- 6:45And, you know, I'm going to be careful
- 6:47here because I don't want to be. I don't
- 6:48be competing against, you know, what. What
- 6:50Rob does. Rob, you know, Rob is. Rob's far
- 6:53more intelligent than I am. Okay? I'm a. I
- 6:57feel my intelligence comes through my
- 6:58feet. You know, it comes, like, where I
- 7:00am, where I'm walking and all that stuff
- 7:02and my life experience. So when I think
- 7:05about employee engagement, I really. I
- 7:08understand if I'm engaged in something,
- 7:09right? I understand that. When I go into a
- 7:13shop, am I more engaged in Coke or Pepsi?
- 7:17Right? I know what I'm engaged in. I know
- 7:19how I feel that day. And I think that we
- 7:24can risk over complicating what is
- 7:27effectively. What is engagement? The
- 7:29answer is, well, what does an engaged
- 7:31employee look like in your organization?
- 7:33What does an engaged employee look like to
- 7:36you? What does someone who is engaged,
- 7:37what does their behavior look like? What
- 7:39do you expect somebody who's engaged to
- 7:41do? You expect them to be responding and
- 7:44responsive. You expect them to advocate
- 7:48and be advocating. You expect them to
- 7:53align with what you're doing. And we got
- 7:56to think that engagement ultimately is a
- 8:01set of things, but ultimately, it's about
- 8:04motivation. When I walk past three
- 8:07restaurants on the high street, which is
- 8:09the one I'm most engaged with, which is
- 8:10the one that gives me a great experience,
- 8:11and experience leads to engagement. So I'm
- 8:14deliberately, by the way, keeping this
- 8:16vague, because the problem of locking
- 8:21engagement down to one thing and then
- 8:23going at it means that we are going at a
- 8:28social norm, and we are ignoring any
- 8:31differences that there may be in the
- 8:33world. And we are. When we go at a social
- 8:36norm, think about what social normative
- 8:38groups are. We end up at a risk of what is
- 8:42employee engagement for white middle aged
- 8:45men? And what we have to look at is an
- 8:49engaged employee is likely to do the
- 8:52following things. It's likely to behave
- 8:54like this, and it's the behaviors we're
- 8:56looking for. So I've deliberately not
- 8:58answered your question. You have answered
- 8:59my question. You've just done it
- 9:01differently to Rob. Rob, you know, just
- 9:03absolutely did my brain in, in a good way.
- 9:07Yeah. And what you've done is you've
- 9:09taught my language, Nick, which is
- 9:11amazing. I'm not comfortable with. And
- 9:14maybe this is the problem. I mean,
- 9:16measurement is going to be at the heart of
- 9:17what we end up talking about today,
- 9:20because we can talk about alignment and we
- 9:22can talk about behavior and we can talk
- 9:24about differences. Somewhere in there,
- 9:27organizations are trying to measure
- 9:28something, and we, the fewer things we
- 9:31measure, I guess the more comfortable we
- 9:32feel. Oh, it's that thing. Right. But if
- 9:36that is the case, what are we doing wrong
- 9:38at the moment? Because I mentioned, and
- 9:41depending which survey you look at,
- 9:43numbers go up, numbers go down. I think
- 9:45it's reasonably well understood that
- 9:47globally, that number's been pretty
- 9:49static, pretty stagnant right around
- 9:51engagement. Organizations are different,
- 9:54countries might be different. Globally,
- 9:56it's not really changed much. So what's
- 9:59wrong? What's happening with this
- 10:00measurement thing? What are we doing
- 10:01wrong? Nick? I think there's no harm in
- 10:06having a concept of engagement and having
- 10:08a concept of a number to help us
- 10:10understand if we are heading in the right
- 10:13direction. And I think ultimately that's
- 10:16what's been lost. And if we were to go to
- 10:19an organization, let's go. We'll go to
- 10:21hello fresh Hellofresh. That has a huge
- 10:25technology arm, a huge commercial business
- 10:29arm, and then a huge production arm. And
- 10:32you were to talk to them about what does
- 10:33employee engagement look like? It must
- 10:35look different in different parts of their
- 10:36business. To then have an overarching
- 10:43measure that tries to span all of that is
- 10:45almost impossible just in one
- 10:47organization. So what we see going wrong
- 10:50is that theres a couple of things, I
- 10:52think. So number one is chasing the
- 10:55benchmark. So the benchmark becomes the
- 10:58score, the score becomes the goal, and the
- 11:02obsession on the goal becomes the driver
- 11:04of behaviors. And if all you have to do is
- 11:09increase your engagement score from 72% to
- 11:1273%, then what will you do? And will you
- 11:14do it in a sustainable way? And will you
- 11:16do it in a way that is understood by
- 11:20everybody? And will you declare that when
- 11:23you get to 74%, because the benchmark
- 11:26provided by the wisdom in the world, which
- 11:32is the data that people have decided to
- 11:34share, will you then stop? And ultimately,
- 11:39you can't sit there and say, we're going
- 11:41to design an experience that people are
- 11:42going to interact with for 8 hours a day,
- 11:4510 hours a day, 12 hours a day, and do it
- 11:47in the same way that a retailer may design
- 11:50an experience for somebody who's going to
- 11:52come in once a week, it's different. So
- 11:54that whole customer experience and
- 11:56employee experience, we can learn so much,
- 11:57we can learn a bit. But designing
- 12:00something that's going to take a third of
- 12:02people's lives and be so influential is
- 12:05something you can't stop when you hit the
- 12:07goal. And I think that's one of the big
- 12:10problems, is employee engagement. Creates
- 12:13an employee engagement benchmark, which
- 12:15locks people into a concept of engagement,
- 12:17which locks people into six questions that
- 12:19are the engagement questions. And then we
- 12:22chase the benchmark. And what we do is we
- 12:25limit ourselves on things that are not
- 12:28engagement. So what does an organization
- 12:30want? Employee engagement. Of course it
- 12:32wants employee engagement. That's a nice
- 12:34measure of are people motivated? Are they
- 12:36engaged? They want their people to be
- 12:39well, right? So well being must be a
- 12:42measure of an outcome. They want people to
- 12:44be innovative, they want people to be
- 12:46ready for change. They want people to be
- 12:51motivated and motivational. They want
- 12:53people to be productive. So there's so
- 12:55many things that they want for their
- 12:58people and of their people, that
- 13:00engagement can only ever be a small subset
- 13:01of that. So there's a real risk that says,
- 13:04when engagement is the only score you're
- 13:06chasing or the only goal in town, you're
- 13:09racing to the benchmark and you're
- 13:12comparing yourself, hello, fresh is
- 13:14comparing themselves to Sainsbury's and
- 13:17comparing themselves to Barclays and
- 13:20comparing themselves to different
- 13:22industries, across different groups with
- 13:24different experiences. When, if you just
- 13:25ask the question, what do we want of our
- 13:29people? What do we need to give them? What
- 13:31does an engaged person look here, look
- 13:33like here? And what are our expectations
- 13:39of outcomes like innovation, change,
- 13:41readiness, and well being, you start
- 13:43asking far broader questions. And, you
- 13:47know, if my original answer to what is
- 13:48engagement is vague, that's because
- 13:53engagement is vague. It's nebulous as a
- 13:56concept. And therefore, trying to chase it
- 14:00sometimes can feel like you're batting
- 14:01away at clouds and mist, especially if
- 14:04you're chasing. The wrong things,
- 14:06especially if we're going down the wrong
- 14:08paths, if the information or the data
- 14:10we're getting, I guess, isn't nuanced
- 14:12enough, isn't asking the right sort of
- 14:14questions, to get the outcomes that we're
- 14:16looking for and that people need. And I
- 14:18think also this point and the dangers,
- 14:21perhaps discuss a bit more about the
- 14:23dangers of being obsessed with a score is
- 14:27that this isn't like a PlayStation game. I
- 14:29don't, I don't think that I've got to 75.
- 14:33Therefore I've completed engagement.
- 14:35Right. What's the next game? Because this
- 14:38is an ongoing quest, right? Involving in
- 14:42culture. It's a never ending thing. You've
- 14:44constantly got to work on it, to keep it,
- 14:46to maintain it, to grow it. People come in
- 14:48and people go, things change, dynamics
- 14:51change. Right? It's, it's a, it's a living
- 14:53beast. So even the context of engagement
- 14:57must change over time with business focus
- 14:59changing and industry changing. Yeah, it
- 15:02has to. When you look at the most
- 15:05innovative organizations or innovative
- 15:08brands, what do they do? They buck the
- 15:10trends. They go different, they do more,
- 15:15and they obviously need to understand what
- 15:17they want to be. But if your focus is only
- 15:19on engagement, then your focus can't also
- 15:22be on being a better business, on helping
- 15:25our people create a better business for us
- 15:27and our customers and our stakeholders.
- 15:30And I think there's a broader set that
- 15:32needs to be looked at here. And ultimately
- 15:36we can also get into the concept that is
- 15:39to HR. Have a seat at the table. So where
- 15:42does employee engagement sit within an
- 15:44organization? Typically, the transactional
- 15:47running of surveys and starting to pull
- 15:49strategy sits within the HR of the people
- 15:51teams. My experience when we have stood up
- 15:54in front of boards and we talk about
- 15:57engagement because it is such a nebulous
- 16:00concept, because no one can say, when you
- 16:02do this, you get that it's about, well, we
- 16:06must increase our engagement score. And
- 16:09it's like, well, what's important to you?
- 16:10And when you say to a CEO or a CFO, we can
- 16:15improve retention, we can increase
- 16:19productivity, we can improve motivation,
- 16:21we can increase advocacy. Your promoters
- 16:23and your internal organization, it's more
- 16:27solid. But our obsession with wrapping all
- 16:29of that up into one concept of engagement
- 16:32has become quite high. And I think if
- 16:37organizations were focused on designing
- 16:39the experience for our people to deliver
- 16:42for our customers and consumers, you end
- 16:45up with the 1950s thinking of the service
- 16:48profit chain. There's a bit of me still
- 16:52rose tinted glasses that just loves the
- 16:54concept of the service profit chain.
- 16:55Right? I think it lives and breathes and
- 16:59we can overcomplicate things or try and
- 17:01change them. That's still at the heart of
- 17:02it all. Happy employees, happy customers,
- 17:05happy shareholders. Off we go. All good. I
- 17:09wonder whether some of this, some of this
- 17:13measurement issue is a quest for
- 17:18simplicity driven by communication above
- 17:20all else rather than actual outcome. So we
- 17:24need to be able to tell people what, how
- 17:27engaged people are in this business.
- 17:28Therefore we need something really
- 17:30simplistic and the easier we can make it
- 17:33to understand as in a number well then
- 17:36more people will comprehend what is the
- 17:38reality is something that doesn't do
- 17:39anything that probably has just more
- 17:41questions. Maybe even something like net
- 17:44promoter score is like the devil, right?
- 17:47We've got this one number. It tells us
- 17:49everything. What on earth does it tell us?
- 17:51I mean it's a great example because the
- 17:54guy who invented NP's, the net promoter
- 17:58score, regrets doing it. He's publicly
- 18:03came out and said he regrets creating the
- 18:05one score you need to manage your
- 18:07business, which is net promoter. Would I
- 18:09recommend this company to my friends and
- 18:10family? And that means from a consumer
- 18:13perspective it wasn't long before people
- 18:16co opted that into the enPs, the employee
- 18:19net promoter score. And so it's like, okay
- 18:22so you are Nike with millions of consumers
- 18:25and millions of data points and you want
- 18:26to get one question but you employ 1000
- 18:29people but you now want to try and take
- 18:31that same concept to a thousand people.
- 18:33Would I recommend this as a great place to
- 18:35work? And are you a detractor or a
- 18:37promoter? When you look at McKinsey you
- 18:41look at someone else talking about NP's.
- 18:45The one danger of NP's is it asks what
- 18:48would you do? Not what did you do? What do
- 18:51you do? What would you do? It's a
- 18:54measurement of your perceived intent to do
- 18:57something, not your opportunity to do it.
- 19:00So it doesn't ask you do you have the
- 19:02opportunity to recommend someone to this
- 19:04brand or this organization? It says would
- 19:08you if you had the opportunity, not did
- 19:11you and have you in the last however long
- 19:14and then takes you away from the rest of
- 19:17your business. So when you see businesses
- 19:19that have struggled who have these
- 19:21measurements they don't understand but we
- 19:23have a good NP's or a good enps and it's
- 19:26like. But that's not the only thing. Yeah,
- 19:30you can't measure every part of your
- 19:32people, you know, and your people KPI's
- 19:35based on whether they would recommend you
- 19:37as a great place to work. There's a number
- 19:39of pitfalls there I think with the
- 19:42measures. Look, I've, I've used emps. You
- 19:44know, I'm not, I'm not here trying to sort
- 19:45of like say I haven't. I have, but I guess
- 19:48I've seen the light on those sort of
- 19:49things. But also like as a, if I'm doing
- 19:53facilitation work, right, let's say I'm
- 19:54doing, I'm running a leadership
- 19:56development course. There's a survey at
- 19:58the end of that program for all the
- 20:00delegates to take and, you know, was it
- 20:02engaging and fun and all those sort of
- 20:04good questions are coming through. I know
- 20:06if I've had a really challenging group and
- 20:09I've had to challenge them to get them to
- 20:11think, to move forward, I know more often
- 20:13than not in the moment my scores may be
- 20:16lower than I would like because it's been
- 20:17an uncomfortable session. However, I also
- 20:22know that six months down the line I get
- 20:25emails from people saying, you know, that
- 20:27time I didn't like you very much for
- 20:29pushing me. Actually, I'm now kind of
- 20:30seeing why. You and I've recommended you
- 20:32to ten people who revived that. It would
- 20:34be great. And I think this is the
- 20:35important thing when we talk about
- 20:37something like NP's is the difference
- 20:40between the question you're asking and the
- 20:43measurement you apply. And this is which
- 20:45wells back into this, which is I don't
- 20:48have any problem at all with asking
- 20:51somebody, would you recommend us to your
- 20:53friends and family as a great place to
- 20:55work? If we had a vacancy, would you refer
- 20:58your friend to come and work here? Its a
- 21:00great indicator of engagement. Its a great
- 21:03measure of that. But I have a real issue
- 21:05is probably this eleven point scale that
- 21:08says, are you a detractor or a promoter?
- 21:10Is it plus 50 -100 because it gives no one
- 21:14anything to go on. You know, the third
- 21:17thing is it cannot be your only score. My
- 21:22experience of the training that I had with
- 21:23you, the environment was one that was
- 21:26conducive to learning to change. The
- 21:29materials I had that I had to work with
- 21:31enabled me to take part. The preemptive
- 21:35work enabled me to understand what's
- 21:37happening. Was it uncomfortable? Maybe.
- 21:40Would I recommend you ask me again in six
- 21:42months? Yeah, you know, all of that stuff
- 21:45is good, but you got to look at it in the
- 21:46round to understand the full experience.
- 21:49Absolutely. And so that's, that's what I
- 21:51want to kind of drill into. So we've
- 21:54talked about outcomes and trying to
- 21:57understand the various outcomes or even
- 21:58the specific outcomes that we're looking
- 22:00for to sort of see, well, is the business
- 22:02in the people inside the business
- 22:06thriving? Have they got an opportunity to
- 22:08do their best thing, bring them, bring
- 22:09their best self, share their efforts, you
- 22:12know, contribute in some sort of way? So
- 22:16in the quest for simplicity, maybe we've
- 22:19gone down the wrong path. Right. Maybe
- 22:20we're starting to look at okay measures,
- 22:23not the most useful measures, because we
- 22:26haven't really thought about the outcomes
- 22:27that we're looking for. And so maybe.
- 22:30Maybe we're doing. Employing agent wrong.
- 22:32You know, maybe we've led down a garden
- 22:34path, and if we. We follow the wrong
- 22:37scores and the wrong measures, we're going
- 22:39to do the wrong things. And so, in the
- 22:43work that you're doing, which, from what I
- 22:46have seen out there, is different. And
- 22:49even back in the day, when I talked to
- 22:51rob, this stuff was being thought about
- 22:54and trialed and tested, but now it's out
- 22:58there. I want you to tell us about the.
- 23:04The PX three model, the sort of think,
- 23:06feel, do model. What is it? What is it
- 23:10attempting to do, and how does it work? PX
- 23:15three looks effectively at broader
- 23:18concepts than engagement. So it looks at
- 23:21outcomes, people outcomes. So, if you
- 23:23think about the three levels we're looking
- 23:24at, I'm going to go 3213 is people
- 23:29outcomes. And, of course, you can have a
- 23:31rolled up engagement measure in that. But
- 23:33ultimately, we're looking at things like
- 23:37outcomes like retention, intention to
- 23:39stay, motivation, well being. Can people
- 23:44be well in your organization? And
- 23:48innovation, readiness for change. So, all
- 23:50of these things are outcomes. And when we
- 23:53think about outcomes, you got to think
- 23:55about the things that are desirable for
- 23:59your people as an organization, because,
- 24:00you know, when these outcomes happen, you
- 24:02do well as an organization, so you're
- 24:05winning. And the outcomes you want for
- 24:07your people because you care about them,
- 24:10you want your people to be well, not just
- 24:12because when they're well, they'll do more
- 24:15productive work, because, you know, that
- 24:17that's ultimately might be someone feels
- 24:18like that organization, but, you know, a
- 24:21caring organization wants their people to
- 24:22be well. They want their people to be
- 24:24motivated. They want their people to be
- 24:26ready for any change that's coming. Yeah.
- 24:28So there's a balance there between
- 24:30organizational needs and organizational
- 24:33wants for their people. So there's a
- 24:35balance there. Number three. Number two is
- 24:38the felt experience that comes under feel.
- 24:40So where number three is outcomes, which
- 24:43is what are people likely to do? Do.
- 24:47Number two is the felt experience. And
- 24:51this is how do people feel? And here,
- 24:53where we. What we put in here are things
- 24:55like the feelings of autonomy, belonging,
- 24:59the feelings of connection and enjoyment.
- 25:03So if you think about these as meeting the
- 25:06fundamental human needs that we have. And
- 25:10number one is the perceived environment.
- 25:13So this is the think part of think, Phil,
- 25:15do. And the perceived environment is how
- 25:18people perceive the environment around
- 25:20them. I think. I believe that my manager
- 25:24cares for me. I think that the
- 25:26communications are adequate. I think that
- 25:28I receive recognition. I think as an
- 25:31organization, we're doing everything we
- 25:32can to be sustainable. And what this
- 25:36allows us to do is it allows us to take a
- 25:40concept then, which is we can draw a line
- 25:43between those. Because the only thing you
- 25:45can do as an organization is tackle the
- 25:48area of think. So when you look at that
- 25:53and you go, how do people think is the
- 25:56only area that I can influence? You can't
- 25:57tell people how to feel, and you can't
- 26:00demand an outcome for long. Maybe you can
- 26:03demand an outcome in a real controlled
- 26:05environment. Not sustainably, no. So the
- 26:09two things you can't control, we measure
- 26:11and we understand, and then we measure the
- 26:13thing you can control, because that's the
- 26:14lever you can pull. So when we say, think,
- 26:17feel, do, we're now able to do that. And
- 26:20why did we go down this route? Rather than
- 26:23a classic way of measuring engagement or
- 26:26looking at standard approaches, which are
- 26:30all fine as well in their own space, it
- 26:34was because it gave us richer. So we see
- 26:36this as the next evolution. We see this as
- 26:40the model, the framework of engagement
- 26:43plus one, you know, and if you look at
- 26:46what other people are doing, what we saw
- 26:48was you'd end up with this huge list that
- 26:52said, people who feel they belong are
- 26:54twelve times more likely to be engaged.
- 26:58Okay? I don't, I can't tell them how to, I
- 27:01can't demand they feel that they belong. I
- 27:03can't demand that. So how does that work?
- 27:05And then they'd say things like, people
- 27:06who enjoy their job are more likely to be
- 27:08engaged. People who feel connected are
- 27:10more likely to be engaged. And when you
- 27:12looked at the list, and it was a stacked
- 27:14list, so it was a nice stacked list of the
- 27:17questions and concepts we asked, then what
- 27:20we saw was all of those felt experience.
- 27:24The feelings just came straight up to the
- 27:27top. Of course they do. Feelings are
- 27:29important. Feelings drive us. Feelings
- 27:30drive us every single day, but they're
- 27:32things that an organization can't do
- 27:34anything about. So the concept of PX three
- 27:37Thinkfield do is actually to say to
- 27:39organizations, it's important to
- 27:40understand the feelings. But let's show
- 27:43you what you can actually do. What can you
- 27:46actually influence? What can you change?
- 27:48Put more resources in it, change training,
- 27:51physically, change the environment? What
- 27:53can you change that will best predict an
- 27:55outcome? And we end up then with a model
- 27:57that says, if you want your people to do
- 28:02something, they should feel this and they
- 28:05should think that, which. I think is this
- 28:08is the big difference between what you
- 28:11might call a traditional survey, which is
- 28:14why I want you to come on and explain this
- 28:15stuff today. Because to me there's a
- 28:18couple of things I want to just make sure
- 28:22I understand. Firstly, the clear, obvious
- 28:24thing for me is there's the emergence of
- 28:26why outcomes happen, which is really what,
- 28:31if we think about it, it's really what we
- 28:33want. Out the back of any, any survey,
- 28:35whether it's engaged or not, I want. Do
- 28:37you know what, I want to know why
- 28:38something's happening. Please not. I just
- 28:41want to know something is happening. I
- 28:42want to know why something's happening.
- 28:45And the three levels just talked about get
- 28:47to a point of understanding why something
- 28:50is happening. Right. Which should then
- 28:53inform where you go and put your focus and
- 28:55your energy. Yeah, definitely. And I
- 28:57think, like, if you think about the
- 28:59concept you just talked about, which is
- 29:02understanding the why. So if you think
- 29:04about something like when, when somebody
- 29:05releases a statement of fact, which is
- 29:09their fact, which is according to our
- 29:12data, belonging is super important in an
- 29:16organization and people who feel they
- 29:18belong are more likely to be engaged, then
- 29:21where do we put our efforts and resources?
- 29:23We put our efforts and resources into
- 29:26things that we think might impact the
- 29:28feeling of belonging. So we might do we
- 29:31start, you know, we do more diversity
- 29:34training, we might do something around
- 29:39changing our recruitment approach,
- 29:40changing our policies, we might do some
- 29:43stuff around training, development,
- 29:46whatever that might be, but we might do
- 29:49some things around gender pay gap, we
- 29:52might do this stuff and ultimately we're
- 29:54tackling diversity to drive up belonging.
- 30:01And that's laudable, by the way. So that
- 30:03is something every organization should do.
- 30:04You shouldn't have any practices in your
- 30:07business that exclude people. Why would
- 30:09you want to do that? But when we look at
- 30:12the data and we say actually using a multi
- 30:16step model, when people feel they belong,
- 30:20it's because they're recognized, it's
- 30:23because they have great recognition, they
- 30:24have appreciation, they are appreciated at
- 30:26their work, it is because their manager
- 30:30cares about them. So line manager
- 30:32capability and attitude is very important
- 30:34to someone feeling they belong, it's
- 30:37because they receive the communication
- 30:38they need to do their job at the time they
- 30:40need to do their job. So they are kept up
- 30:43to date. You respect me enough to keep me
- 30:45up to date on what we're doing. And when
- 30:48you look at that and you go, that makes
- 30:51sense. We're complex individuals. I want
- 30:53to know that I work for an organisation
- 30:54that values diversity. I want to know, I
- 30:56work for an organisation that is actively
- 30:59challenging its things like gender, pay
- 31:01and owing on a program. I want that, but
- 31:05when I feel I belong, it's because I'm
- 31:08treated with respect, I'm recognized when
- 31:10I do good work, and I feel like the
- 31:13environmental factors celebrate. So it's a
- 31:17different path that somebody would go on
- 31:19to influence something we want for our
- 31:22people. And when you mentioned before in
- 31:26the 321123 layers, we talked about
- 31:31belonging here as one factor. Now, are
- 31:34those factors standard in every survey, or
- 31:40are you looking at what an organization is
- 31:43struggling with, trying to achieve,
- 31:45wanting to achieve? Are those things
- 31:47flexing? Are there some core things that
- 31:48are always there that occasionally bring
- 31:51some other things in? How's that work? So
- 31:54flexibility within a framework is probably
- 31:56the best mantra for PX three. So it's the
- 31:59framework that allows you to have
- 32:01confidence, that you can benchmark, that
- 32:02you can understand how you are against
- 32:04other people and how you are in your own
- 32:07organization. The felt experience is very,
- 32:11is probably the area that we are locking
- 32:14more than anything, because concepts of
- 32:17belonging, autonomy, connection, and
- 32:19growth don't really change much. And
- 32:22there's not that many questions you need
- 32:23to ask in that space. So what we do is we
- 32:28take, what are the outcomes you're looking
- 32:29for for your people? What does an engaged
- 32:31employee look like here? What are the
- 32:33outcomes you want? Where, you know, we're
- 32:35an innovative organization, I want to
- 32:36drive innovation. So how do we do that and
- 32:41what we then look at with our
- 32:42organization? So we create those outcomes
- 32:44they're looking for. We then go and look
- 32:45at their environmental. Do they have any
- 32:47concerns? Do they have anything that they
- 32:49think already is worrying them? That we
- 32:52can start exploring with our surveys and
- 32:55with our data, we start bringing that
- 32:57through, and we will then work with our
- 33:00organization to create the right survey to
- 33:03do that. Now, surveys have limitations. So
- 33:05surveys cannot be your only employee
- 33:07listening tool. No, not at all. You have
- 33:09to give your people a voice in many
- 33:11different channels. But surveys allow you
- 33:13to capture data and then analyze that
- 33:16data. And PX three, ultimately is a
- 33:19predictive analytic solution. So we are
- 33:22looking to best predict what environmental
- 33:26factor will predict a positive outcome. So
- 33:30I can give you an example of that if
- 33:31that's helpful. Yeah. If we look at
- 33:35something like intention to stay, what we
- 33:39can pull through from that for an
- 33:41organization is, and this is the top level
- 33:43of our data, we can say something like, if
- 33:46you want your people to do, if you want
- 33:48your people to stay, they should feel that
- 33:52they can reach their full potential, they
- 33:54can develop their career, and they belong,
- 33:56and they should think that senior leaders
- 33:59care about people. Good work is
- 34:01recognized, success is celebrated, and
- 34:04they're kept up to date. And what we can
- 34:07effectively turn this then into as a
- 34:08formula, we've got one client, hospitality
- 34:10client, who calls it their formula, and
- 34:13they go out to people and say, this is our
- 34:16retention formula. Yeah. So these are the
- 34:18things that environmentally drive
- 34:21retention. These are the, you know,
- 34:23there's eight things. These are the four
- 34:24things that are low scoring. These are the
- 34:26four things that are high scoring, the
- 34:28high scoring ones. We are going to
- 34:30celebrate, we're going to protect, we're
- 34:31going to get out there and say, well done
- 34:32to. Everyone's doing it well, the four
- 34:35things that are not so great for us as an
- 34:37organization, those are the things that
- 34:39we're going to take action on. So if you
- 34:40think about addictive analytics, then
- 34:44leads to action in the right place for the
- 34:48right outcome. And what we can then do is
- 34:52really target that down and say to people,
- 34:54if you want this, go do this. So none of
- 34:59that 40 questions, let's tackle the lowest
- 35:02scoring. It's 40 questions. And these are
- 35:05the four that you really need to work on
- 35:07in central London restaurants different in
- 35:10Manchester. So three of the four are the
- 35:12same, but there's another one that's
- 35:13creeped in. So in Manchester, go and do
- 35:15this and start really flipping that round
- 35:18a little bit. I think that's the thing
- 35:19that I like about this whole concept,
- 35:22because to me it feels different. Because
- 35:25it feels like future action focused as
- 35:29opposed to a retrospective view of what's
- 35:32happening or happened. Yeah, definitely.
- 35:35And. And because it's broader than
- 35:38engagement, what we're finding is when we
- 35:40are sitting in front of boards, so we're
- 35:43often representing our data and our
- 35:46insights in front of the boards for our
- 35:49clients, we're finding that the naturally
- 35:52cynical people, apologies to every CEO and
- 35:54CFO out there right now, but the naturally
- 35:57cynical people for engagement are suddenly
- 36:00engaged in what we're telling them.
- 36:03Because when you say to a CFO that the
- 36:06number one cost challenge you have from a
- 36:08people perspective is retention, it's
- 36:11costing you somewhere between three and
- 36:1310,000 pounds for every lever. More if you
- 36:15look at some broader data. But let's fix
- 36:17around that. It's costing you over a
- 36:20million pounds a year for the headcounts
- 36:21that you're losing. And we can actually
- 36:25show you what best predicts intention to
- 36:28stay and where you're scoring low on that
- 36:30best prediction. The last time we did this
- 36:33presentation, CFO sat there and said, this
- 36:35is a game changer. I know how to help my
- 36:39HR team. I know how to help my colleague,
- 36:41my chief people officer when they're
- 36:44asking for budget and they're asking for
- 36:46training and development budget, line
- 36:48management, development budget. This
- 36:51company has just showed us that line
- 36:54management capability and training is a
- 36:57retention driver. There we go. And that's
- 37:00in most organizations. That is a huge
- 37:03number, relatively speaking. Right. That
- 37:06the cost of ineffective retention or
- 37:10turnover or poor leadership, meaning
- 37:13you're losing people. Whatever. This is
- 37:14what I mean about getting under the why
- 37:17and really focusing on. Actually we've got
- 37:19this big number that's costing us in lost
- 37:22productivity or turnover of people, having
- 37:24to retrain the basics, all that kind of
- 37:26good stuff. This will absolutely pay back
- 37:29dividends, right? Yeah. And we don't want
- 37:32to throw out the baby at the bathwater.
- 37:36Let's be dead honest with everyone.
- 37:38Engagement is an amazing concept. It's a
- 37:40known concept. We are never going to move
- 37:41away from the terminology of employee
- 37:44engagement, but moving to what does an
- 37:47engaged employee look like here really
- 37:49matters. And being your organization. I
- 37:53saw a statement about the problem with
- 37:56external benchmarking, of any
- 37:57benchmarking, is it's race to mediocrity,
- 38:00because you are an exceptional
- 38:02organization that wants to do exceptional
- 38:04things, and yet you're comparing yourself
- 38:07to the broadest average out there. So what
- 38:11you're doing is you're racing to the
- 38:12middle. Yeah. And if everyone's doing
- 38:14that, then all we're doing is you might as
- 38:15well not have 100 amazing, innovative
- 38:19brands and organizations. You might just
- 38:20have one Uber organization. And it's not
- 38:24what organizations need or want. So I
- 38:27think, yeah, I think we got to go
- 38:30different. And clearly you are. You've
- 38:32mentioned the benchmark thing a couple of
- 38:34times because you provide a benchmark,
- 38:36right within PX three. My question is
- 38:39always in these things, people are fixated
- 38:41with having a benchmark, and I flip flop
- 38:45myself between, well, it's interesting to
- 38:47see what other people are doing, but
- 38:48really we want to focus on what's going on
- 38:50here. What is your attitude towards
- 38:53benchmarks? Are they in PX three because
- 38:55you feel clients want them and need them,
- 38:57or do you really believe in them? I'm
- 38:59going to be dead honest. Wear my heart on
- 39:01my sleeve, Andy, on this, which is the
- 39:03best benchmark you can possibly have, is
- 39:05your internal benchmark. As a company,
- 39:08this is how we have performed. As an
- 39:10organization, this is how we have
- 39:11performed. And within our organization,
- 39:14some people are beating that, some people
- 39:16are on it and some people are under it. So
- 39:19let's understand those that are beating
- 39:21the benchmarking internally, what are they
- 39:24doing differently? What can we learn? How
- 39:26can we take what they do into other areas?
- 39:28The people that are lower in it, what are
- 39:30they doing differently? What could be the
- 39:32influence? Internal benchmarking is a
- 39:35learning, it's a growing benchmark. It is
- 39:38that whole race to be exceptional.
- 39:41Everything about your organization drives
- 39:43you forward. External benchmarking, we
- 39:46didn't have it in our platform for
- 39:50probably 80% of our existence. And we put
- 39:54it in because it was a sales enabler,
- 39:58because when we were going out and talking
- 39:59to people, we were going into tenders, we
- 40:02were going into rfps requests for
- 40:05procurement, we were going to stuff, and
- 40:06they said, can you do external
- 40:09benchmarking? And trying to explain to
- 40:11somebody that we don't, because you've
- 40:15lost them. And what we found was some of
- 40:20the advice I had is you've got to always
- 40:22be educating, you've always got to be
- 40:24taking people forward. And we've done some
- 40:28work recently with a client who had
- 40:30probably the best case for external
- 40:33benchmarking. And their view was, if I am
- 40:39dropping against an external benchmark,
- 40:41that maybe I was on the external
- 40:44benchmark, it helps me understand, is it
- 40:48because we have a systemic issue within
- 40:50the UK that is affecting everybody? Or is
- 40:54it something in my organization that is
- 40:55only my organization or our industry?
- 40:58Maybe. And the answer to that individual
- 41:03was, that's actually a really good way of
- 41:05looking at external benchmarking. But you
- 41:06are not the norm. That's a very mature way
- 41:09of looking at it, which is to understand,
- 41:12but it's not my key driver and I think
- 41:14that's the problem. It's how are we doing
- 41:16against everyone else? We're doing okay.
- 41:19Well then we just don't need to put any
- 41:20more budget into that. Well then tomorrow
- 41:23you can have a problem then. That is it,
- 41:25isn't it? That is the thing. So my view
- 41:28has changed on benchmark over the years.
- 41:31But to be clear, external benchmarking
- 41:34came into our organization to help our
- 41:38sales and marketing team open doors, not
- 41:41to help our clients be better. And it's a
- 41:47hard thing to talk about because if I was
- 41:49here as a marketing individual, I would be
- 41:51sitting here going, hey, Andy, having the
- 41:54right blend of external benchmarking,
- 41:56internal benchmarking enables you to use
- 41:58our platform to understand where you are
- 42:01both within your industry and our client
- 42:05base, and internally where you can
- 42:07improve. That's the sales pitch, right?
- 42:09Yeah, but I would expect nothing other
- 42:11than honesty and realness from you, which.
- 42:13Is what we've got, which is 100%. What
- 42:15we're looking for. Right. We don't want to
- 42:18hoodwink anybody. I think this is the
- 42:19thing about trying to understand this
- 42:21stuff. I think the point about internal
- 42:23benchmarking is great and it really plays
- 42:25back to the here inverted commerce piece
- 42:28that you talked about within the survey.
- 42:29What's going on within the marketing team,
- 42:31what's going on within the procurement
- 42:33team, what's going on within finance?
- 42:35Here's what matters. How are we performing
- 42:37and how do we get better? And from what
- 42:39I've heard today, this is all about
- 42:41getting under the skin of how do we get
- 42:43better at delivering the outcomes that we
- 42:45need as individuals within an organization
- 42:47and an organization as a whole. If we can
- 42:49get closer to that stuff, we're going to
- 42:51be in better places. You know that
- 42:54expression I'm going to get this wrong.
- 42:55It's something like the most important
- 42:57person in the room or the highest paid
- 42:58person in the room or something like that.
- 43:00Their view tends to weigh down everyone
- 43:03else's action. If a CEO says it would be
- 43:07really interesting to understand how
- 43:08people with blue eyes felt, then everyone
- 43:11would leave that meeting going to people
- 43:13going do we have the data? Do we need to
- 43:15get the blue eye reports? And the CEO then
- 43:17wasn't expecting anything but theyve said
- 43:19it and its happened. And I think most HR
- 43:23people are absolutely on board with the
- 43:26whole internal benchmark and is where its
- 43:28at. The people who have made a throwaway
- 43:31comment tend to be the CEO, which is what
- 43:33are we putting on our annual statement as
- 43:35our engagement score? How do I know if
- 43:38thats good? And then somebodys turned
- 43:41around and said well, well, ill create a
- 43:43benchmark for your CEO and then, then it
- 43:46becomes industry and it becomes an
- 43:48industry and it becomes unhelpful. So we
- 43:51need CEO's to start asking questions like
- 43:55how are we doing against the outcomes we
- 43:57want. What a great question. What a great
- 44:00question. And leads us nicely, I say
- 44:03nicely most sadly into the bit of a show I
- 44:06call Sticky notes Nick, where I'm looking
- 44:08to try and get a bit of a summary on the
- 44:10things that we've talked about. And by the
- 44:11way, I've loved it. Absolutely loved it.
- 44:13We talked earlier about distilling things
- 44:16down to a single number and how dangerous
- 44:17that could be in this case. If we're
- 44:21trying to find out, find out what's going
- 44:23on and how we can take steps to delivering
- 44:26some of these outcomes, what three pieces
- 44:28of advice that you could fit on three
- 44:31little sticky notes would you leave for
- 44:32the listeners today, my friend. So I put a
- 44:36statement on a sticky note that says, we
- 44:38want to enable outputs. We have to
- 44:41understand inputs with a little bracket
- 44:44that says output alone is not the goal.
- 44:48Nice. Sticking at number two is probably a
- 44:52memoir, which is simply engagement equals
- 44:56what an engaged employee looks like here,
- 44:59not from a trade magazine, not from a
- 45:02supplier. What does engaged employee look
- 45:04like here? And my third one is actually a
- 45:08quote from Rob, which is, it sticks with
- 45:14me because it's powerful, or I think it's
- 45:16powerful, which is helping people think
- 45:19about culture and employee experience.
- 45:21People experience. So culture is felt by
- 45:26the group and experience is felt by the
- 45:30individual. And if people can remember,
- 45:35the culture we have here as an
- 45:37organization is widespread and I'm
- 45:40designing experiences for the individuals.
- 45:43They then start thinking about the
- 45:45individual needs, the individual wants,
- 45:48desires. What are they giving up for their
- 45:50time at an organization? What are we
- 45:52giving back to them? So design the
- 45:54experience, aim for the culture, design
- 45:58with the individual, aim for the group.
- 46:01And there I am again, something from
- 46:03robbins up blowing my mind. What a. What a
- 46:06marvelous end to the mind blower. He is a
- 46:09mind blowing, my friend. Nick, it's been
- 46:10brilliant to have you on. Thanks so much
- 46:12for. Well, for the honesty and showing
- 46:16that there's a different way to do this
- 46:17stuff. I've absolutely loved it. If people
- 46:18want to find out a bit more about PX three
- 46:21and the people experience hub, where
- 46:23should they go. So they can head over to.
- 46:25We're quite present on LinkedIn, so they
- 46:27can head over to LinkedIn, search for the
- 46:28people experience hub and we're there. I'm
- 46:31Nickor and you can find me on there as
- 46:34well. Our website is Pxhub IO. So you can
- 46:40head over to there and you can access all
- 46:42of our things like ebooks. We've got a.
- 46:45We've just released our insights report.
- 46:49So September 24 Insights report has just
- 46:52dropped that SAR 2024 report that's on the
- 46:55website. There's loads of resources there
- 46:57around what we do. And if anyone wants to
- 46:59reach out, the contact details are all
- 47:02there on the website as well. We're quite
- 47:05a community collaborative organization, so
- 47:07we love to talk to people about what
- 47:09they're up to that you are. And I will put
- 47:11all of that stuff in the show notes.
- 47:12People can find it. Nick, thanks so much
- 47:14for coming on, my friend. I love what
- 47:16you're doing and more power to you, my
- 47:18friend. Amazing. Thank you, Andy. Take
- 47:20care, my friend. Okay, everyone, that was
- 47:22Nick Court. And if you'd like to find out
- 47:24a bit more about him or any of the things
- 47:25we've talked about today, please check out
- 47:27the show notes. So that concludes today's
- 47:34episode. I hope you've enjoyed it, found
- 47:36it interesting, and heard something maybe
- 47:39that will help you become a stickier, more
- 47:42successful business from the inside going
- 47:44forward. If you have, please like comment
- 47:47and subscribe. It really helps. I'm Andy
- 47:51Goram and you've been listening to the
- 47:53Sticky from the Inside podcast. Until next time, thanks for listening