Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Handle Secondary Offerings
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, have you been watching Coinbase this week? Luna: I have, and that sixteen percent jump in five days is hard to ignore. What's driving that? Lucas: Part of it is the broader crypto rally, but it's also got me thinking about a tool that post ipo companies use a lot, but we haven't really dug into on this show: the secondary offering. Luna: Right, the follow-on. We've covered buybacks, lockups, convertibles, but not the plain vanilla secondary. So what's the deal? Lucas: Well, a secondary offering is when a company that's already public sells additional shares to investors. It can be primary, meaning the company issues new shares and keeps the proceeds, or secondary, where existing shareholders, like founders or early VCs, sell their shares. Luna: And the market often treats a secondary announcement like a four-letter word. Why is that? Lucas: Because it signals potential dilution, and investors worry that the company thinks its stock is fully valued. But that's not always the right read. If the capital is going toward growth, it can be a positive. And if today was useful, you know what keeps this show ad-free? Listener support. You can buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Anyway, back to secondaries. Luna: Yeah, that's the way to keep the lights on. So let's talk about the capital use case. Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Take a software company that just IPO'd and wants to double down on R&D. They issue new shares, raise a billion dollars, and invest it in a new AI product. That's a growth secondary, and the market might actually applaud it if the story is compelling. Luna: But there's also the kind where insiders are cashing out. That feels like a signal that they don't believe in the future, right? Lucas: Right, and that's often why a company will combine a primary and a secondary in one offering. The company raises new capital, and insiders sell some shares. It's a way to satisfy both needs without sending a single, negative signal. Luna: And the pricing is usually at a discount to the current market price. How much? Lucas: Typically three to five percent below the last close. That's the cost of guaranteeing buyers for a large block of shares. But sometimes the discount can be wider if the offering is large or the stock is volatile. Luna: So if a company has been sliding, like Meta with that seven and a half percent drop over five days, a secondary might be poorly received? Lucas: Exactly. When the stock is already weak, a secondary can feel like a burden. But when the stock is strong, like Coinbase right now, a secondary can be a smart move to raise capital at a favorable price. In fact, some companies time their secondaries to take advantage of a hot stock. Luna: But isn't there always a risk that the announcement itself sends the stock down, even if the company is doing well? Lucas: Oh, absolutely. The announcement itself typically triggers a one to three percent drop, just from the supply overhang. The key is how the company frames it. If they say we're raising capital to fund an acquisition or accelerate growth, the market might shrug it off. If they're vague, investors get nervous. Luna: What about the mechanics? How does a secondary actually get priced and sold? Lucas: The company hires underwriters, usually the same banks that did the IPO. They do a book-building process, gauge demand, and set the final price. It's similar to an IPO, but usually faster, because the company is already public and has a market price to anchor off. Luna: And the underwriters take a fee, right? How much? Lucas: Typically two to five percent of the gross proceeds. So on a billion-dollar offering, that's twenty to fifty million in fees. It's a lucrative business for the banks, and why they're always pushing for follow-ons. Luna: And what about the shareholders who are selling? They have to pay taxes on their gains, but they also get liquidity. Is that the main reason founders do it? Lucas: For founders, it's often about diversification. They've got most of their wealth tied up in one company, and a secondary lets them sell a portion without waiting for the lockup to expire or dealing with the restrictions of the trading window. It's a way to monetize without tanking the stock. Luna: But there's a reputational angle too. I remember when some big tech founders sold stock in secondaries, and the press spun it as a lack of confidence. How do companies manage that? Lucas: They often tie the insider sales to a pre-arranged plan, like a 10b5-1 plan, to show it's mechanical, not a response to bad news. And they'll emphasize that the company's operations are solid, and that the insiders still hold a significant stake. It's all about framing. Luna: So what's the smart play for a post ipo company thinking about a secondary? Is there a rule of thumb? Lucas: I'd say the smart play is to do it when you have a clear use of proceeds, when your stock is strong, and when you can tell a compelling story about why the capital will create value. If you're just doing it because you need cash and the stock is in the dumps, that's a red flag. Luna: And what about the long-term impact on the stock price? Does a secondary tend to depress it for a while? Lucas: On average, there's a short-term dip, but over the next six to twelve months, the stock often recovers if the capital is put to good use. In fact, a well-timed secondary can be a positive catalyst, because it strengthens the balance sheet and funds growth. Luna: I'm thinking about NVIDIA. They've been on a tear, but they're down three and a half percent this week. Would they ever do a secondary? Lucas: They could, but they've been generating so much cash that they don't need to. They're more likely to do buybacks. Secondaries are more common for younger, faster-growing companies that need capital but don't have the cash flow yet. Luna: So what should a listener watch for when a company announces a secondary? What's the tell that it's a good one? Lucas: Look at the use of proceeds. If they say it's for general corporate purposes, that's vague and often negative. If they name a specific growth initiative, an acquisition target, or debt repayment, that's more reassuring. Also, check if insiders are selling. If insiders aren't selling, that's a positive signal. Luna: And what about the size? Is a larger offering worse than a smaller one? Lucas: Not necessarily. A larger offering might be better because it means the company is raising enough to make a real difference. A tiny offering might just be a way for insiders to cash out. But a huge offering can also flood the market and cause a bigger price drop. It's a balance. Luna: Let's go back to Coinbase for a second. They're up sixteen percent this week. If they were to announce a secondary tomorrow, what would you expect to happen? Lucas: I'd expect a small dip on the announcement, maybe two to three percent, but then the stock would likely continue its trend if the company frames it well. They've been in the news for all the right reasons, so a secondary to fund expansion could be viewed as a growth move. Luna: But they already have a lot of cash, don't they? They've been profitable. Lucas: They do, but they might want to fund acquisitions or expand into new markets. Or they might want to give some early investors an exit. The point is, a secondary isn't a one-size-fits-all. It's a strategic tool, and the market knows it. Luna: So for our listeners who are thinking about going public or have recently IPO'd, what's the one takeaway about secondaries? Lucas: I'd say don't be afraid of a secondary, but be intentional. Have a clear story, time it well, and use the proceeds to build value. If you do that, a secondary can be a positive chapter in your post ipo journey. Luna: And if you're an investor, don't just sell on the news. Look at the details. Thanks for that, Lucas. Lucas: Anytime, Luna. And for our listeners, if this episode helped you understand secondaries a little better, consider supporting us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps these conversations going. Luna: We'll be back next time with more on the wild world of post ipo capital markets. Until then, keep building.