Latest / Ego and Other Things / 3 Questions That Shaped My Life: Ethics, Childhood, and Faith | Worldview Series
Transcript
- William: Dear Heavenly Father, I thank you for this opportunity to do this recording. I thank you for the opportunity to talk about philosophical ideas. Thank you for this opportunity just to speak or try to speak about these important topics with other people. Lord, I pray that you would bless this recording session. Lord, I know that I cannot make anything good out of it without you. And so I surrender this recording session into your hands. I ask that your Holy Spirit would do this recording through me and make good out of it where I cannot. Lord, I pray that those who watch this would be able to learn something, that I myself would be taught something by you through this recording. All this according to your will, Lord. In Jesus' name I pray. Amen. Alright, so now that we've gotten Through talking about my own story and the lessons that I've gotten out of that. The next question here, number two, is what questions about life had met have mattered most to me and why? With a sub question of who is asking those same questions right now. And I took some time to think about this question at work and kind of how I wanted to structure the video as well. And essentially I came up with three really large questions or even topics that really matter the most to me in my journey as a whole. and I think the way I'm gonna go about this is to talk about each question and then after each question talk about the kind of person who might be asking that question now and how the how asking those kinds of questions might actually be helpful to them. I think we can just get right into it. And would say that the the first major question, which is also gonna have a sub-question to it, but the first major question that has mattered to me really in my life, and it still matters to me very much today, is basically the question, how can we live a meaningfully good life? What does it mean to live a meaningfully good life? And this this concern over this question goes as far back goes as far back to my childhood, where even though my dad and my parents were moral hypocrites and abusive, my one of the things my dad said to me very early on in my life was You should always do the right thing no matter what. When the right thing is hard, you should choose the right thing over what is easy. When everybody is taking the easy road, you should take the right road, essentially. You should always put what is right above what is easy. And I remember that being something which has was was really impactful for me as a kid, or really stood out or seemed very wise. And it is a lesson which I've or it it's a phrase which I've carried me care has carried me throughout life, even beyond becoming aware of my father's evil and abuse, and the fact that he very often chose what was easy wither rather than what was right, and didn't even have a really good conception of what is right. So from a very early age there was a strong impetus to do the right thing even though it was difficult, but at the same time the right thing was pretty unclear. Meaning that the authorities in my life, my my parents, the people around me, they all had very different ideas of what it meant to do the right thing, what good was. My my parents were divorced before I couldn't really even remember. And I would go back and forth between them when I got a little bit older, and they would just tell me completely opposite things when it came to right and wrong. and how you should approach life and my this extended even to to my grandparents and the people around me. There was no center of absolute morality in my life. There was no certainty about what right and wrong was. And in fact, part of the the psychology of my childhood was trying to figure out the right thing so that I could do it so that my dad wouldn't punish me for doing the right thing. Now of course the standard of right and wrong was arbitrary. And the quest to find the right thing was was in that instance this red herring, right? the morality was for my my father and my parents a kind of cover or excuse for abuse rather than them actually being interested in being interested in what was right. To my parents, what was right was whatever was convenient for them, and whatever aligned with their prejudices, not something which they sought, they thought through. But this wasn't a realization that I would this wasn't a realization I would come to until I was much older. And so from a very early age, two things were combined: a heavy emphasis on morality and a heavy emphasis on doing the right thing, with no real certainty about what the right thing was. And So I think it was natural for me to begin asking myself and trying to figure out what the right thing was. And particularly When when I was younger, the right thing was just whatever your parents told you and you didn't really have the capacity to determine Whether what they were telling you was actually right or not. But as I became, as I grew to become a teenager and started to develop the capacity to compare moral standards and apply them to other people besides myself and ask myself, well, you know, are my parents following the same moral standards? Then this question became even more and more pertinent in my life. And it is a question which I still it still sits at the center of my entire philosophy. I often say that ethics is the center of my philosophy and that the other aspects of philosophy, whether it's politics, whether it's metaphysics, whether it's epistemology, whether it's human nature, whether it's any of these kinds of things, all the interests in the other branches of philosophy have grown out of this central interest in in ethics and the question of how can I actually live a meaningfully good life? What does that look like? And while it began in An environment of confusing morality, of of trying to navigate childhood trauma, of the imposition of my parents. it would stick through it stick with me even as I grew and I was free from those environments, and I took on therapy. My interest in this question of ethics grew because I began to understand how important it was for life, how really central it is to life. I began to understand that. Much of what goes on in the world, whether good or bad, whether destructive or beneficial, begins in an ethical justification. It begins in a moral idea of what is right and wrong. We rarely ever act without some sense of what we think is right and wrong. We tend to do those things that we think are permissible, and we tend to avoid and condemn the things that we think are morally wrong. And this was reinforced by by later thinkers and philosophers that I ran into that emphasized how changing moral ideas could actually change people's behaviors. I'm not so sure that's the case anymore, but the point was to say that again to understand how much ethics and the notion of right and wrong and the notion of immoral and moral actually goes on to influence the world around us. In ways that we don't understand. The the vast majority of political disputes are really more abstract versions of ethical or value disputes, for example. And at the same time that I rec I began to recognize the importance of ethics role in the world and in my own life, I also began to recognize that most people had little to no understanding, little to no sophisticated understanding of right and wrong. It was not something that people often thought about. It was not something that people justified too deeply. In fact, people had oftentimes emotional and very personal convictions about right and wrong. And the very idea of challenging somebody's ethical beliefs was basically almost bordering on the line of offending them, so that there was not much rational discourse in the general population about morality. That could be, I mean, direct general discourse about morality. there are all these realms in which we talked about morality through these extra layers, like Politics is perfect example. But there wasn't much direct ethical conversation. But I found that direct ethical conversation in philosophy. And I was driven to try to find a sophisticated answer. I wanted the truth. I didn't just want the cultural assumptions of my society. I didn't just want what my parents had taught me. I just didn't, I didn't want just what my feelings were telling me, but I wanted to be able to. rationally justify my own ethical perspective because I wanted the actual truth of what it meant to to live a good life. I wanted the actual good life, not the prejudiced understanding of the good life. And I wanted the world to move towards that good. And I felt at the time that a rational under rational understanding of morality and ethics would be the key to actually improving the world. And I still think it's a significance today, it still sits at the center of my philosophy. I'm less I'm less optimistic about rational philosophical ideas really being able to change behavior. I think it helps in that department, but it doesn't ultimately overcome our own innate evil. philosophical ethics in one sense allows us to see the evil in the world, but doesn't necessarily allow us to fix that evil. And that's a a separate discussion, but this attempt to understand right and wrong, this surprise at the fact that right and wrong was not something which there was much rational discussion about outside of the realm of philosophy, and this realization that ethical ideas, there was not like a consensus to it, that much of this was just what people were taught and accepted, and that much of human behavior was not based on ethics, but was based in Practicality, that was based in subjective values, that was based in what is going to be best for me. All of this was surprising to me and continued to urge me on to figure out the ethical nature of right and wrong. And so I would say 80% of my philosophical inquiry has been focused on that kind of question. And the question has evolved over time, but at first it was the almost a question of What is the absolute universal objective standard of morality that absolutely every single person must follow? So I used to begin morality at the universal level, and it's slowly evolved over time to the question I would hasn't necessarily changed, it's it's grown into the question of how do you actually live a meaningfully good life. And that question I believe has much more of an individual bent to it. It starts with the individual rather than the universal and grows the universal out of the individual, which I think actually ends up being a much more productive kind of methodology. but we get into the details of that later. It's just to to highlight the fact that that this question has probably sat at the center of my philosophy and my worldview. The way that I approach the world is through the lens of is this ethically right or wrong? And that is usually the first question I ask about something rather than anything else. And even my again, my pursuit and my discovery of things in in epistemology and metaphysics and human nature and philosophy of mind and these other branches are for the purposes of answering ethical questions. Not really, I'm not so much interested in the nature of True and false for the sake of itself, but for the sake of ethics. I'm not so interested in the nature of the real and the unreal, for itself, but for the sake of ethics. I'm not so much interested in phenomenology for its own sake, but for the realm of ethics. And I still believe that Pursuing philosophical ethics is the is the best secular way of understanding evil in the world, of understanding yourself and of living a better life. I believe there is no better tool than philosophical ethics for actually leading a good life, in terms of the secular perspective. In terms of who is asking this kind of question, I would say that this is probably one of those perennial questions in society as a whole. Most people ask this question at some point in their life, like, what does it mean to do the right thing and the wrong thing? They just don't necessarily go to the depths of trying to rationally justify it. But I think it's a particularly urgent question in our time because All of the traditional centers of authority on that question are are fading away. Religion is no longer forced on the society as a whole, and the the religious traditions, even within particular branches, like I can speak for Christianity, you know, there are a number of different denominations, there are a number of different ways to interpret the word and the authority of the word. It's not always clear what the ethical intent or direction of the Bible is. Or what Christ's teachings always mean. There's certainly debate about that. and there is a truth to it, and I believe there is an absolute truth to it, but it's a problem of imperfect people trying to understand a perfect word. But the point is to say that there is no longer it's not like we have the Catholic Church that says this is the absolute doctrine that you must follow, and if you don't, we're going to torture and kill you. which I I view as an advancement in society. but the I view it as at a as advancement that morality is not legislated through force and violence on people, either through the Catholic Church or through the state. Well, to the the state does it still to a degree, but the point is to say that there are no there are no centers of moral authority that are forced on people through violence anymore. And so people are free to And one sense experiment with or determine their own moral standards, particularly in the West. And that's good in the sense that people are free, but it's bad in the sense that there is no central authority on what is right and wrong. And so people don't have a firm footing, right? most people believe that morality is either subjective or relative, meaning that either right and wrong is either determined by the individual and what they f they feel and think, or it's determined by their society. But there's all kinds of problems with both of those perspectives because you could have an individual who believes something like murder or theft or violence is right and and therefore justify their what what most people would consider to be destructive actions based on their own subjective feelings. And this can extend to societies. We look at somebody A nation like Nazi Germany and the society as a whole was approving of the kinds of violence and destruction and genocide and evil that was going on in that country. And it would har it would be hard to say from the relative position that the Nazis were bad if you hold that a your moral standards are dependent on your society. And I think we should be able to say that some a place like Nazi Germany is evil and that they're Should be some kind of universal or objective morality, but there's all kinds of difficulties in determining what that objective morality is. And And so I believe that the vast majority of people do not have a strong foothold on what is right and wrong. They don't have a strong foothold on how they should live their lives. And again, they live their lives at this level of practicality, this level of, you know, what can what's the best I can get out of it? They live their lives based on the the changing norms of society. You know, one day they hold this belief, but then they see the the the opinion of the mass is going the other way and they change that belief. And so morality has become this thing that gets just tossed around. It becomes we've lost the plot. We've lost an understanding of what it means to have a good society or to live a good life, or what evil is. We've lost the ability in in some ways to condemn what is clearly evil. And part of that is out of this growing desire in many places for for for tolerance. We want to Sit with a subjectivist and relativist moral position because we don't want to needlessly condemn things which are not actually evil, but that we are condemning out of prejudice or social conditioning or or whatnot. But I believe that we can combine a sense of tolerance, a sense of you might say, sensitivity to other people's beliefs with an objective moral standard. Now that's difficult project. But what I would say is that the only secular hope that people have for finding the true morality is through reason, through philosophical reason. It's not going to come by the opinions of the masses, which can oftentimes be violent, evil, and destructive. It's not going to come from the opinions of individuals, which can often be violent and destructive. It's not going to come from Some authority just proclaiming it on people and then forcing them to live it according to on the basis of force and violence, because that ultimately just comes down again to somebody's subjective values or the subjective values of a culture. And so if there is a universal and objective morality, it's going to come through reason. And I even bel I believe that there is is e a secular path to understanding those kinds of things. Ultimately, I believe that I'm a Christian and I believe that Jesus Christ, God, the Holy Spirit, the Trinity together have the moral truth. But in the Christian walk, it is not so much of a matter of you become a Christian and then you know the absolute moral truth. It is that you become a Christian and you become discipled by Jesus, who through your lifetime leads you closer, leads you into the moral truth. We say that the Holy Spirit leads us into all truth. and so if you want the if you want to get to the full and absolute moral truth, then I believe you have to become a disciple of Christ. But even that's a lifelong process. But if you are not a believer, the secular the only secular way I believe is philosophy and philosophical reason. I believe that by studying ethics from a rational perspective, you can get much closer to the ethical truth than you would otherwise. And they will have a much greater benefit for goodness in your own life and goodness in the world than you would otherwise. Than you would going off of mere cultural or subjective prejudice. And so I think this is a question that can be asked by anybody. I think it's a it's a question that is pertinent to anybody because at the at the at the time we do not have a center of morality anymore. there is no central authority. And so all that is left is for the individual to use their reason to try to try them, to try on themselves or with community with other rational thinkers to develop a coherent understanding of right and wrong that they can apply to themselves. and apply to the society around them, insofar as they're not going to lean into Christ as the ultimate teacher. the second question that I have asked, and in some ways this could be seen as a subset of how do you live a good life, but it's distinct enough and large enough in my own in my own philosophy that I I think I can mention it separately here, which is the the concern over childhood. And The concern over childhood being two things. One, how does our childhood experiences, whether good or bad, affect our lives later on and affect society as a whole? Do certain parenting practices or patterns as a whole affect the ideas and particularly the ethical ideas of a society at large and how it functions? And how it views the world. There's a in the first place, a structural question. Structurally, how do our experiences in childhood, how do our relationship, how do how is it that we relate to children affect the world around us ultimately? And I believe it is one of those realms that is significantly underestimated. I think we significantly underestimate the impact of how our parenting practices goes on to shape our our people's perspectives as they grow up in adults and how those perspectives have ramifications at a societal level, politically, but also just socially in general. And not only that, but I think that we significantly underestimate how our own childhood experiences, how we were raised, goes on to affect our perspectives and ideas, what we think about and what we don't think about, what we avoid thinking about for the sake of avoiding confronting certain childhood experiences. I'm not going to get super into detail in here, but that is one of the major themes that I think about, that I apply to my own philosophy and thinking about questions. particularly philosophical, particularly political and existential questions. And again I think it is one of those questions that is Highly underestimated. Even with all the focus that we have on it nowadays, I still believe it is strongly underestimated. In fact, I think that our childhood and our childhood experiences are the main driver of what we actually think and avoid and our perspectives and our prejudices as adults. I think it is a main molder of adult minds. And while it is something that can be combated in the sense that If we want to be more objective, I believe that examining our childhood is one of the major keys to that objective perspective. there is also a major, I believe, importance in taking your childhood experiences seriously, particularly your feelings, and being, you might say, authentic towards yourself and other people with those childhood experiences, which we have a really hard time doing this, doing in this society, particularly with our parents. particularly in a non-confrontational way or non-abusive way, an empathetic way. And so that would be one half of that question. The other, or the one half of a the question of the focus, how do childhood experiences affect us individually and socially? But the other side of that question is more the question of how do we ethically relate to children, knowing that they were uniquely vulnerable class of society. Knowing that children are completely dependent on adults for absolutely everything, knowing that they often perceive us as kind of like gods, as as all-powerful beings who have ultimate control over their life and their direction, how can we ethically relate to children that respect that massive power imbalance, which is a part of the nature of being a parent or being an adult in relationship to being a caregiver in relationship to a child? I think there are special moral rules that apply to the parent-child relationship that don't necessarily apply to the adult-adult relationship. And I believe that children stand as today perhaps the greatest victims in our societies. They're the ones with the least protection, the least rights, and the least just relationship to them. I believe they are constantly overlooked and discriminated against. They are constantly belittled and disempowered because they don't have the ability to resist the power of adults. And when I say children, I don't just mean like little children. I mean like essentially from birth to to eighteen, like that whole cohort of Children who are still dependent on the adults around them for the sake of survival. And those dynamics and that question of how do we ethically relate to children feeds into that sense of how our childhood experiences actually affect us individually and socially as an adult. But it's it is not enough to say to it is not enough to take the problems of childhood and only use them to fix adult problems, but to look seriously at the situation. And asked. How can we fix the childhood relationship? How can we change our attitudes towards children in a way that is more that is much That is more ethically sound and fair and just given the wide gap of power between adults and children. Who is asking the same questions, I would say that If you were a person who has experienced an abusive childhood experience and you've seen how that affects your life, you would probably be the most interested in how this ends up fleshing out, even just beyond your own individual experiences, but onto the the broader society and interested in that in like the ethical differences between how we treat children versus how we treat adults and really getting, I would say, the tools to be able to rise to the defense of children who are being mistreated, which happens on a regular basis. but I would also say if you are not a person who who if you are a person who believes that you had a you know perfectly fine childhood and you don't think about how childhood affects yourself or the the world around you all that much, you might benefit from from thinking about these questions more because again, I think it we are we significantly underestimate the degree to which childhoods affect us, especially as They are being the first kinds of experiences that we have. And you might say the place where the baseline expectations of the rest of the world and the rest of our lives become established. And they could be modified and changed. And and if there's a lot of work that then that that goes through those those baseline expectations can be modified and changed. But it ends up being such a struggle and you end up s living such a an amount of life, I guess you could say, before that. That it goes on to affect your life regardless of whether you see it or not. And not only that, but what I have found is that a lot of people say, I had a perfectly fine childhood. They are often getting to that point because they have they have been incentivized to block out their real experiences as children for the sake of survival, for the sake of maintaining peace and their relationship with their parents and their family. That's not always the case, but it does happen a lot more than you think. I've had plenty of conversations with people who said, I had a perfectly fine childhood. You dig into it a little bit, you talk with them a little bit, and you find instances of physical and verbal and emotional abuse that they hadn't thought about in years because they had, in one sense, blonde it out. And there are there are good reasons for that. Why that why that happens. One of the things I talk about on this channel is one of the things I talk about in my philosophy. but It is worth looking into at the very least. Because if you explore your own childhood and you don't find anything like that, then that's great. there are instances of good parenting out there, there are instances of good family dynamic there. but if you think about the idea of exploring your childhood and it brings a kind of sense of anxiety or a sense of fear, or even a sense of almost like defensiveness, why would I do that? That might be a signal that there might be things there that would be worth looking into. And it's important that we get the truth of our childhood because the truth of our childhood is not only a part of our life. We don't want to have a fantasy about that. We want the truth of ourselves, but our childhoods inevitably go on to affect the rest of our lives. And it's not so simple as saying as you don't simply wake up and become a different person. There's a continuity between who you are and your childhood experiences, there's a strong connection there. And for anybody who would be interested in that, I would recommend the works of Alice Miller, Lloyd Damas in particular, as strong those who talk about those dynamics in a very strong way, though I would say I have my own unique perspective here. And then I would say the third major question that is mattered. In my life, most of me is a more more recent question for sure. before it would have said the dynamic between authenticity and survival. But that question, while it is a significant question, it's it can kind of be put under the subsection of how do we live a meaningfully good life? And you know, we'll talk maybe we'll talk get into that in different different video or whatnot. But the major question which I have been dealing with a lot more. Recently, and that's taken up a lot more of my energy and time. is is is a Christian one. It's it's the one of how do I Follow Jesus Christ? How do I be a disciple of Jesus Christ? How do I reflect Jesus Christ to other people? And this is about my relationship with Jesus as an all-loving, all-powerful, all-good creator who is bringing me along, transforming me, and bringing me into the kingdom of God. How do I relate to Jesus Christ and how do I relate to other people as a Christian, as a disciple of Christ, as a follower of Christ? That is a pretty complex question. As I said before, the Bible is a complex, it is both a complex book and a simple book at the same time. It's very interesting in that way. But being a Christian can at times be very complicated. You can have a lot of questions. The Bible is not always. clear to us as imperfect people, even though it is a perfect book and out and contains the absolute truth of our lives and how we should live our lives and how we should be. It is something we progressively learn about as Christians throughout the rest of our life and come to embody more and more over time as we learn more and as Jesus teaches us and disciples us. And discipling literally means to follow. means to walk in the footsteps of the the rabbis of Jesus' time would have disciples and and the rabbis being the Jewish teachers would have disciples and the students you would be picked by a rabbi and as a student of the rabbi you would follow the rabbi around seeing what the rabbi did as a way to learn about the righteous kind of life. But Jesus, he is the he is our perfect rabbi, he is our perfect teacher, he is our Our perfect priest, if you will. And so as disciples of Jesus, our goal is to try to follow Jesus where he leads us and mimic what he does, because he is the perfect representative of what it means to live a good life, what it means to love others, what it means to love God, what it means to be to be righteous. But there's a lot of questions in between, right? And and so a lot of my my thoughts have been around. theolo theology about different passages in the Bible, about what it means to again be a disciple of Jesus Christ, how it how do you relate as a Christian to a fallen world around you? How do you go about surrendering yourself to God? What is the Holy Spirit? There's so many interesting questions that are involved in that journey, which I talk about because they impact my day-to-day life. Not only that, but they're the most important questions I think to ask at all. What is my relationship to God and how do I follow Jesus Christ in my life? Those are the most important questions I think that you could ask. And the great thing about being a Christian is that. When we put our faith in God, He gives us the Holy Spirit. He gives us God within us. And ultimately, it is the Holy Spirit which leads us into truth inevitably. Inevitably. In the sense that whereas philosophy, I have to depend on my own mind, which is imperfect and broken and selfish and can lead me off track. In Christianity, I don't depend on myself, I depend on God. And God is perfect. God is all powerful. God loves me. God is all good. And so I can have a complete assurance and peace that He is leading me where I need to go. Even if it doesn't live up to my expectations, even if it isn't what I think it should be. I know that God knows because He's God. In terms of who's asking the same kind of questions like that, well, hopefully every genuine Christian, every Christian who has put their faith in Jesus Christ is hopefully asking those kinds of cr of questions out and trying to live that out in their life. And I think that, you know, my while my individual journey may not speak to your individual journey in terms of where God is leading you, if you are, you know, a fellow Christian, I think that you can can relate to that journey over time. And perhaps seeing my journey and seeing my perspective on these kinds of things might enlighten you. And they're at the very least topics you can bring to the Holy Spirit to go and discover for yourself and to learn for yourself as both of us try to follow Jesus Christ. But as for the non-believers who might be interested in this channel for the philosophy and psychology and the childhood and all that kind of stuff. I can definitely see how maybe it might be jarring, maybe it might be out of the blue for me to talk about God, to talk about Jesus, to talk about my relationship with him, to talk about how he's discipling me. And what I wanna say to that in terms of, How do I relate my Christianity to non-believers, essentially, right? To to atheists who might be interested in this channel and might even be interested in these spiritual kinds of questions and Christian kinds of questions. And basically the way I would relate to you is to tell you in the first place that I was a strong atheist, a strong, rational, philosophical atheist for the vast majority of my life, up until about two years ago. My faith is at this point something relatively recent. And before before two years ago, when I came to faith in Jesus, I believed that God was impossible. I believed that if God existed, he was evil or destructive or at the very least indifferent to us. And so in that sense, I can relate to the atheist position, particularly the philosophically atheist position. And I underst I very much understand why people do not believe in God. and What I can offer to you is really just the perspective that I have developed on that. I can I can share with you my perspective on God, my perspective on Jesus, my perspective on my my journey towards faith with him, and how I integrate my philosophy with religion, philosophy with spirituality, philosophy with with Jesus, how do I reconcile reason of faith? I can tell you my perspective on that. I don't really have an eye to convert. The reason being that Which I might not I might I know that might sound strange because I'm also an evangelist, or I I I also go and do evangelism where I share the gospel with people, but there is something which I know, which is that insofar as another person comes to faith in Jesus, insofar as a relationship between you and Jesus begins, it will not come from me. If you if you go on to have faith, it will not come from me. I can share the gospel, I can share my story, I can share about my thoughts about Jesus and what he means and who he is, I can share you my thoughts about God, right? I can do all that, but I can I am not the person who converts people. I am not the person who brings people to faith in Christ. Only God is capable of. Growing faith in you. Only God is capable of giving you faith. In fact, you're not even capable of giving you faith. I certainly was not capable of giving myself faith. Only God can do it. And only God does do it. And so I don't feel this pressure to like convince you of of having faith in Jesus. I don't feel this urgency that I have to convert you or you're gonna you're gonna be eternally separated from God. I certainly would love for you to experience relationship with Jesus, but ultimately I know that God is in control. Ultimately I know that God is the one who brings people to faith. And ultimately I know that faith must be something which is freely chosen. And so There is no pressure for me to convert. And there's no desire for me to I don't know, intellectually corner you into belief in Jesus. So I believe I can say that this is a space where if you are spiritually curious, or even if you're a philosophical, a strong philosophical atheist like I was, that this is a place where you could safely explore those concepts with another person. And not only that. But if you are a strong philosophical atheist, I want you to know that I approach my life through the aspect of a reason. And I am n I am both I am both willing and able to engage on that level with you about Jesus, about God, about all these kinds of spiritual things, about faith, right? so don't feel like you can't, you know, because I'm I'm I I'm a believer in in Jesus that you know can't bring your best philosophical arguments to to bear on any of these kinds of of of kinds of conversations. I would love that. I would encourage it actually. And I very much understand it. I've been a part of that world. I was part of that world for a very long time. So But anyway, yeah, I was gonna say I'm gonna say that that those are there are a lot of different questions that have shaped my life. I've I've scratched the surface here, but those were I would say three of the major ones. The question of how do we live a meaningfully good life, a question of how do we how do childhood experiences affect us and how do we relate to children as a particularly vulnerable class of people, and how do we become true disciples of Jesus Christ? Those the three major questions that have mattered to me the most in my life. And I believe there are a wide variety of people who can benefit from asking those kinds of questions. The the answers to those questions that I give on this channel, ultimately they're they're my own answers. They're questions I've come to on the basis of my own reason. And I believe very strongly that For you to come to a true belief on your own, you must do the work of reason yourself. You can't depend on me for that. You can't depend on anybody else for doing your thinking for you. You can't depend on all these external authorities. You have to be able to use your own mind to come to the real truth of things. And so I invite you to come with me on that journey. Not to, not for me to be your teacher, not for me to tell you the answers. I'm not even capable of that. And I'm not sure people necessarily even expect that. I'm just putting it out there because I've definitely I my I personally have gone through the feeling of clinging on to a thinker because they sp they connected to me powerfully. And What I really want to emphasize with all this kind of thing, with all these kinds of things, for many of you, this won't be hard, but for for other people, I am not the teacher. I am not the guy with the answers. I am not the ultimate authority on any these questions. I'm one person who is trying to work them out and is still trying to work them out, trying to do the it live, trying to do it vulnerab vulnerably, trying to do it with as much. enthusiasm as I can, but trying to do it. Not the guru, not the teacher, not the guy with all the answers. And so first and foremost, I would encourage you for all these kinds of things to think through them yourself, to ask yourself these kinds of questions and reason towards your own conclusion. Because that is the only way that you yourself can possess the truth and not simply be puppet to the perspective of others. So with all that being said, if you made it to the end of the video, thank you so much for watching and I'll talk to you next time.