Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Li Lu: When to Sell?
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine holding a single investment for 22 years.
- 0:04Which I mean, most people can't even hold one for 22 weeks.
- 0:07Right. Exactly.
- 0:08But imagine you do. And over that time, the
- 0:11company's internal sales just explode, like from 1 billion to
- 0:16a trillion. A literal thousandfold increase
- 0:19in fundamental value. Yeah, but here's the catch.
- 0:22Along the way, the market panics and cuts the stock price in half
- 0:26not once, but eight separate times, and at one point it
- 0:30completely craters, plunges by a terrifying 80%.
- 0:34Yeah, that's brutal. So the question for you
- 0:36listening is, you know, would you have the stomach to hold on,
- 0:39or would your own biology basically force you to sell the
- 0:43greatest investment of your life at the exact wrong moment?
- 0:46I mean, it's the ultimate stress test, really.
- 0:49We are wired by millions of years of evolution to flee from
- 0:53immediate pain, right? And perceive danger.
- 0:55Right, the whole fight or flight thing.
- 0:57Exactly. When we see an 80% drawdown in
- 0:59our portfolio, the hunter gatherer part of our brain, it
- 1:02literally treats it like a physical threat, like a tiger in
- 1:05the bushes. So the logic of a 30 year
- 1:07compounding horizon, just you know, it evaporates survival
- 1:11instincts completely takes over. Which is wild to think about.
- 1:14And that's exactly what today's deep dive is all about.
- 1:17We're decoding that internal battle.
- 1:19And we have a really incredible source for this.
- 1:21We do. We are looking at a master class
- 1:24and separating market hallucination from fundamental
- 1:27reality. It's sourced from a translated
- 1:30transcript of highly regarded lecture given at Peking
- 1:34University's Guanggua School of Management.
- 1:35Delivered by a legendary family asset manager, which is just
- 1:38fascinating. Yeah.
- 1:40And the mission here for us is to strip away all the dense
- 1:43financial jargon. We want to uncover the actual
- 1:45mechanics of when to sell, how to survive those catastrophic
- 1:49price drops, and why the sources framework of a three-point O
- 1:54civilization completely rewrites how we should view global market
- 1:58chaos. I should add, you know, the
- 2:00speaker uses these sweeping macroeconomic concepts
- 2:03throughout the lecture, touching on geopolitics, civilizational
- 2:06shifts, all of that, right? But it is vital to understand
- 2:09that they are using this macro lens specifically to diagnose
- 2:13the microscopic psychological flaws of the individual
- 2:16investor. That's a great point.
- 2:17We're examining these frameworks impartially, you know, not to
- 2:21take any sort of political stance, but really just to
- 2:22understand the underlying mechanics of capital allocation.
- 2:25Precisely. So where should we start?
- 2:28Let's start with honestly the most agonizing decision any
- 2:32investor faces. I mean, we spend so much time
- 2:35analyzing when to buy, but the psychological torture really
- 2:38begins when you have to figure out when to sell.
- 2:40Oh. Absolutely.
- 2:41Selling is so much harder. Right.
- 2:43Well, the speaker lays out a strict 3 part framework for
- 2:47this, and the first 2 rules seem purely driven by ruthless logic.
- 2:51So reason number one. Yeah, you realize you made a
- 2:54mistake. Which requires a massive, and I
- 2:56mean massive amount of intellectual honesty.
- 2:59Yeah, admitting you were wrong is never fun.
- 3:00It's not, but if the foundational thesis of why you
- 3:03allocated capital to an asset is proven wrong, the framework
- 3:06dictates an immediate exit, like right now.
- 3:09You don't just hold on hoping the market will magically
- 3:11inflate the price so you can break even.
- 3:13No, you don't. And the mechanism here is
- 3:16opportunity cost. Every single day your capital is
- 3:20tied U in a broken thesis. Is a day.
- 3:22It isn't compounding in a functional 1.
- 3:24Exactly. It's dead money.
- 3:26OK. So that makes sense.
- 3:27The second reason to sell is finding a better opportunity,
- 3:31but it seems there's a pretty heavy caveat there in the source
- 3:33material. Yeah, you aren't just jumping
- 3:35ship because you know another stock is trending on social
- 3:38media. Right.
- 3:39You are mathematically weighing the downside risk versus the
- 3:43upside potential of the new asset and comparing that to your
- 3:46current holding. Yes, and if the math heavily,
- 3:49heavily favors the new asset, then you make the switch.
- 3:53But here's the thing. Both of those scenarios,
- 3:55admitting a fundamental error or finding a genuinely superior
- 3:59risk reward profile, they're actually relatively rare.
- 4:03Which brings us to the third reason.
- 4:05And this is where the speaker drops a massive warning label
- 4:08for everyone. The big trap.
- 4:09Yeah, the third trigger for selling is extreme
- 4:13overvaluation, which on paper sounds super simple, right?
- 4:18Just sell when the price gets too high.
- 4:20Sounds easy enough. But the source material argues
- 4:23that over valuation is overwhelmingly A psychological
- 4:27trap. It's intimately tied to this
- 4:30universal human defect in how we perceive time.
- 4:33Right. We just we magnify the short
- 4:35term anomaly and completely discount the long term
- 4:38compounding. It's like, I was thinking about
- 4:40this earlier, It's like jumping off a high speed train because
- 4:43you think it's moving a bit too fast, only to watch it disappear
- 4:46into the horizon while you're just standing there waiting on
- 4:48the platform. That's a great analogy.
- 4:50And by the time you try to buy another ticket, the price is
- 4:52completely skyrocketed because the company just kept growing.
- 4:55That perfectly captures the distortion.
- 4:57Yeah. We look at a stock price that
- 4:59has surged over, you know, maybe a few quarters, and our recency
- 5:03bias just screams that the trajectory is unsustainable.
- 5:06We freak out. We completely freak out.
- 5:08We obsess over the next earnings call or the current news cycle
- 5:12and we lose all sight of the decade long runway.
- 5:16The speaker argues that if you've done the excruciating
- 5:19work of finding a Holy Grail company.
- 5:23Right, a Holy Grail. Selling it simply because it
- 5:25feels temporarily overvalued is basically the most devastating
- 5:29mistake an investor can make. Let's clarify the mechanics of a
- 5:32Holy Grail company, just to be precise.
- 5:34According to this framework. Good idea.
- 5:36So we are talking about a business possessing A continuous
- 5:40durable competitive advantage. It has a massive runway for
- 5:43future growth and, crucially, it generates an exceptional return
- 5:47on invested capital. Yeah, it doesn't just make
- 5:49money, it reinvest that money internally at incredibly high
- 5:52rates. It's a compounding machine.
- 5:54And those machines are exceedingly rare.
- 5:56Oh, unbelievably rare. The speaker emphasizes that in a
- 6:0030 year investing career, you might only uncover a handful of
- 6:04these generational, perfectly aligned opportunities, like
- 6:06maybe 3 or 4. Yeah, only a handful.
- 6:09Yeah, so the trap of overvaluation is that you throw
- 6:12away your seat on this rare compounding machine just to
- 6:16relieve some short term psychological discomfort.
- 6:20You cash out feeling like an absolute genius for locking in a
- 6:23game. Right, but then you encounter
- 6:25the anchoring bias strap. Oh, explain that.
- 6:28Well, say you sell a truly great company at $50.00 because you
- 6:31thought it was overextended, but the underlying business just
- 6:35keeps growing and the stock quickly hits $80.
- 6:39OK, Human nature dictates that your brain will absolutely
- 6:43refuse to buy it back at 80. You are permanently anchored to
- 6:46your exit price of 50. So you tell yourself you'll just
- 6:49wait for a dip. Exactly.
- 6:50And while you wait on the platform, like in your train
- 6:52analogy, the company's internal value creation continues to
- 6:56accelerate. It goes to 100, then 200.
- 6:58And you end up permanently locked out of the greatest
- 7:01compounding engine of your life just because you couldn't zoom
- 7:04out your timeline and tolerate a little valuation friction.
- 7:08It's tragic, honestly. So the golden Rule is
- 7:11essentially to never let go of a great company.
- 7:14But that brings us back to the nightmare scenario we open the
- 7:18episode with. The 80% drop.
- 7:20Yes, it's easy to preach long term holding when the line is
- 7:23moving up into the right, but what is the actual mechanism for
- 7:27surviving a stomach churning, portfolio destroying market
- 7:31crash without losing your mind? Well, the lecture moves from
- 7:36theory to the brutal reality of market cycles right here.
- 7:39It introduces the Circle of competence as the ultimate
- 7:43survival tool, the. Circle of competence.
- 7:45Yeah, the speaker uses Berkshire Hathaway as a baseline managed
- 7:49by arguably the most disciplined capital allocators in history,
- 7:52right? Yet even Berkshire has seen its
- 7:54stock drop by over 50% three or 4 * / 6 decades.
- 7:58And then there's the speaker's own experience with BYD, which
- 8:01we touched on at the start. Right.
- 8:02Holding for 22 years, suffering 7 or 8 drawdowns of 50% and one
- 8:06plunge of 80%. I have to play devil's advocate
- 8:09here though. Go for it.
- 8:10If I'm holding a stock and it craters by 80%, isn't it
- 8:14entirely rational to panic? I mean, how does a normal person
- 8:18tell the difference between holding a misunderstood genius
- 8:21company and riding a sinking ship into the abyss?
- 8:26What mechanism causes a stock to drop 80% while its actual
- 8:30fundamental sales are growing astronomically?
- 8:33It is the classic difference between a weighing machine and a
- 8:37voting machine. OK, unpack that.
- 8:39In the short term, the market is voting based on sentiment, macro
- 8:43level terror, liquidity crunches, institutional panic,
- 8:47you name it. If hedge funds are facing margin
- 8:49calls across their entire portfolios, they liquidate
- 8:52everything, including great companies.
- 8:55They just need to raise cash. So the price of DUID in that
- 8:58moment was completely disconnected from the reality of
- 9:00its factory floors. So.
- 9:01The stock price isn't reflecting the company's value at all.
- 9:04It's reflecting the psychological breakdown of the
- 9:06other participants in the market.
- 9:07Boom. Exactly.
- 9:09And that is exactly where the boundary of your knowledge, your
- 9:12circle of competence, is pushed to the absolute limit.
- 9:15It's tested at the edge of a Cliff.
- 9:17Yes, the speaker argues that you only discover the true perimeter
- 9:21of your understanding when you are staring into that abyss.
- 9:26When the stock is down 80% and the financial media is declaring
- 9:29the company dead, do you possess a deep enough understanding of
- 9:33how that business physically generates cash to just ignore
- 9:37the noise? Right, because if your
- 9:38conviction is borrowed, like if you bought in because a pundit
- 9:41liked it or because the chart looked pretty, an 80% drop will
- 9:44break your resolve instantly. Instantly, you will capitulate
- 9:47at the exact bottom. Only an intrinsic mechanical
- 9:51understanding of the business's value creation prevents that
- 9:54panic. But psychological attitude alone
- 9:56isn't enough, is it? The source material highlights a
- 9:59really critical structural rule that makes this mental
- 10:03resilience possible in the first place.
- 10:05This is so important. The speaker is adamant,
- 10:08absolutely adamant about operating with 0 leverage.
- 10:11Your leverage. No borrowing.
- 10:12This is a vital point for everyone listening because we
- 10:15all understand the mathematics of leverage, right?
- 10:17It multiplies your gains, but the speaker is pointing to the
- 10:20psychological trap. Yeah, when you borrow money to
- 10:23invest, you aren't just amplifying your returns, you are
- 10:26voluntarily stripping away your own agency.
- 10:28That is the core danger. Exactly.
- 10:31If you own the asset outright, an 80% drop is just a test of
- 10:35your patience and your analysis. It hurts, but you survive.
- 10:38But if you are leveraged, an 80% drop triggers forced
- 10:42liquidations. Your broker does not care about
- 10:46your 10 year thesis or the company's underlying sales
- 10:49growth. They just sell.
- 10:50It they sell it, the leverage removes your option to be stoic.
- 10:54You are forced to realize the loss, which transforms a
- 10:57temporary market hallucination into permanent wealth
- 11:00destruction. So surviving a crash really
- 11:02requires 2 pillars. A structural pillar where you
- 11:05refuse to use leverage, ensuring you can never be forced out of
- 11:09your position, and a psychological pillar build an
- 11:12obsessive commitment to learning which ensures you won't force
- 11:15yourself out of the position out of sheer panic.
- 11:18That's a perfect summary. The market functions as this
- 11:20ruthless examiner of human nature.
- 11:23If you are faking your understanding, the volatility
- 11:25will eventually smoke you out. So what's the solution?
- 11:27The only sustainable defense mechanism is relentless lifelong
- 11:32learning. The speaker shares a really
- 11:34remarkable anecdote about Charlie Munger to illustrate the
- 11:37depth of this required compounding.
- 11:39I love this part. Munger apparently bought a stock
- 11:42at the age of 99, but he was executing on an industry he'd
- 11:45been actively studying for 60 to 70 years.
- 11:48I always find these stories fascinating, but they usually
- 11:51lack the why. Like why is a 99 year old making
- 11:54a new allocation? Right.
- 11:55You'd think he'd just be relaxing.
- 11:57Exactly. But the logic only makes sense
- 11:59if you reframe what compounding actually is.
- 12:03We always focus on the capital compounding, but Munger was
- 12:05utilizing the compound interest of his own pattern recognition.
- 12:09That's a great way to frame it. He wasn't hoping for a quick
- 12:11flip. He was acting on 7 decades of
- 12:14distilled understanding about how that specific industry
- 12:17operates. So the real secret isn't just
- 12:20compound interest on your money, it's compound interest on your
- 12:24knowledge. Precisely.
- 12:25And the speaker provides a very grounded pathway for developing
- 12:29that kind of pattern recognition.
- 12:31How so? The advice is to start simple.
- 12:34When you are building your framework.
- 12:35Look for assets that are objectively cheap, buy them,
- 12:39hold them, and use the margin of safety provided by that low
- 12:42price to just study how the business functions across
- 12:45different economic environments. So you are essentially using the
- 12:49low purchase price to buy financial protection while using
- 12:53the holding period to buy wisdom.
- 12:55Yes. You don't start by trying to
- 12:57untangle a multinational conglomerate with complex
- 13:00derivative exposure, right? Right, that's a recipe for
- 13:02disaster. You start with a simple business
- 13:04model, build your analytical muscles, and only graduate to
- 13:08those rare Holy Grail compounding machines once your
- 13:12circle of competence is actually battle tested.
- 13:14This internal compounding of wisdom is ultimately what
- 13:17prepares you for the micro level chaos, because while we spend a
- 13:20lot of time analyzing the micro mechanics of single companies,
- 13:24the markets panic often stems from massive systemic shifts.
- 13:27Oh, definitely. And this is where the source
- 13:29material expands into an incredibly ambitious framework
- 13:32regarding what the speaker calls the three-point O civilization.
- 13:35Yes, the three-point O civilization and the statistics
- 13:39he gives here are just staggering.
- 13:40They really are. The speaker categorizes human
- 13:43economic history into civilizational phases.
- 13:46The three-point O phase represents are modernized, hyper
- 13:50connected, scientifically and economically driven state.
- 13:53OK. But the critical data point he
- 13:55presents is that currently only about 10% of the global
- 13:58population has fully transitioned into this 3 point O
- 14:01state. Meaning 90% of the globe is
- 14:03still undergoing the painful, disruptive transition exactly
- 14:07that contextualizes so much of the global friction we see.
- 14:10The speaker notes that the United States possessed a
- 14:12massive geographic and historical advantage here.
- 14:15Yeah, it was a vast, largely unified landmass capable of
- 14:18absorbing diverse populations. It basically acted as an
- 14:22unprecedented practice ground for developing the mechanics of
- 14:25this 3.0 civilization. And from watching this practice
- 14:27ground evolve, the speaker identifies an iron law of
- 14:30modernization. He posits that the global
- 14:32economy, driven by the relentless pursuit of efficiency
- 14:35and value creation, inevitably drives toward a single,
- 14:39integrated global market. It is a gravitational pull that
- 14:43cannot be permanently stocked. But wait, how does that square
- 14:46with the reality we see every day?
- 14:48I mean, we are constantly reading about trade wars,
- 14:51massive tariffs, supply chain decoupling, geopolitical walls
- 14:55going up. It feels like the world is
- 14:57actively fracturing, not integrating.
- 15:01It does feel that way, but the speaker directly addresses this
- 15:04friction by explaining the unstoppable nature of capital
- 15:08and trade. He argues that the underlying
- 15:10economic incentives are simply too powerful for political
- 15:13borders to contain. OK, So what happens when
- 15:16barriers go up? Well, when two major powers
- 15:19erect tariffs against each other, the trade doesn't
- 15:22actually stop. It reroutes third party nations
- 15:25naturally emerge as intermediaries to facilitate the
- 15:27flow of goods and capital. It's arbitrage.
- 15:30Completely if there. Is a massive profit to be made
- 15:32by connecting a producer and a consumer?
- 15:35The market will find a way through, over or around the
- 15:37political rocks in the stream. Capital flows like water.
- 15:40That is exactly the mechanism he is describing.
- 15:43The great friction of our era is basically a problem of velocity,
- 15:47economic growth, technological advancement, and capital
- 15:50integration. They compound at hyper speed,
- 15:53but human institutions, our cultures, our religious
- 15:56frameworks, the way we organize into nation states, they change
- 16:00at a glacial pace. So you have a hypervelocity
- 16:04economic engine bolted onto a slow moving political chassis,
- 16:08and the resulting vibration from that mismatch is the
- 16:10geopolitical tension we experience every day.
- 16:13That's a really vivid way to put it.
- 16:15And the speaker urges investors to view this friction through a
- 16:18wide historical lens. He points to China's journey
- 16:21since 1840. Right over a century and a half
- 16:24of massive traumatic modernization and civilizational
- 16:27shifting, moving hundreds of millions of people through
- 16:29industrial and technological revolutions.
- 16:31Exactly. When you scale your perspective
- 16:34to encompass a civilizational shift of that magnitude, the
- 16:37daily anxieties over specific tariffs or political squabbles,
- 16:40they start to look very different.
- 16:42So if this global market integration is an iron law, does
- 16:46this mean as investors we just shouldn't sweat the daily
- 16:49geopolitical headline so much? He.
- 16:51Literally categorizes the current geopolitical and
- 16:54economic tensions as a storm in a teacup.
- 16:57A storm in a teacup, Yeah. From the vantage point of a
- 17:00multi decade capital allocator, the civilizational March toward
- 17:04a 3.0 global market is an unstoppable underlying current.
- 17:08The political headlines are just the surface waves.
- 17:11The trend doesn't care about the new cycle of the week.
- 17:13That is an incredibly grounding framework.
- 17:16It takes the emotional sting out of the macro panic.
- 17:19If the underlying trend of global integration is an iron
- 17:22law, then our job isn't to predict every geopolitical
- 17:25pivot. Our job is to find the companies
- 17:27that will harness that underlying current.
- 17:29Which brings us to the speaker's closing metaphor.
- 17:32It's a beautiful synthesis of this entire philosophy, really.
- 17:36After traversing these massive global frameworks, his final
- 17:39advice shrinks everything back down to the individual.
- 17:42He warns against trying to fish in the biggest lake.
- 17:44Right. The massive lake where every
- 17:47institutional algorithm and millions of retail investors are
- 17:50crowded together, fighting for the exact same marginal
- 17:54advantage on the most covered stocks in the world.
- 17:57Instead, find your own quiet pond.
- 17:59Yes. You do not need to understand
- 18:02every macroeconomic shift or decode the future of every
- 18:06complex industry to compound wealth successfully.
- 18:09You simply need to fundamentally, deeply understand
- 18:12the mechanics of your own small circle of competence.
- 18:15Find a pond you understand better than anyone else and fish
- 18:18there. Find your quiet pond.
- 18:20I think that is the perfect distillation of the value
- 18:22investing mindset. And for those of you listening
- 18:25who are ready to expand your own circle of competence and map out
- 18:28your pond, I want to share some vital resources from our
- 18:31community. Highly recommend.
- 18:32To access more advanced researchers, applications and
- 18:35our latest published personal intelligent multi agent Deep
- 18:37Value Intelligence. Welcome to explore and join Deep
- 18:40Values AI community. Also to track total market
- 18:44temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 18:46iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 18:49Those are great tools. And as always, a quick
- 18:51disclaimer, all analysis is based on publicly available
- 18:54sources and may be subject to revisions or differing
- 18:57interpretations. All content from this channel is
- 19:00for educational and research purposes only and does not
- 19:03constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 19:07before making investment decisions.
- 19:10If you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 19:12investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel,
- 19:16Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 19:18Much appreciated. Really, equipping yourself with
- 19:21those tools and refining your mindset is the only defense
- 19:24against the volatility. The market will inevitably test
- 19:27the boundaries of your conviction, but a structural
- 19:30understanding of value ensures you won't break.
- 19:33Absolutely. And I want to leave you with one
- 19:35final thought to process. Today we spent this entire deep
- 19:37dive analyzing how our biggest flaws investors is magnifying
- 19:41short term pain while completely shrinking the long term value of
- 19:44an asset. Right, the time illusion.
- 19:46Yeah, we panic during an 80% drawdown and sell our best
- 19:50compounders. But how does that psychological
- 19:53defect apply outside your portfolio?
- 19:56Like, look at the rest of your life.
- 19:57What relationships, what difficult skills, or what
- 20:00ambitious personal goals are you undervaluing right now?
- 20:03That's a deep question. Are you on the verge of
- 20:05abandoning something with massive long term potential just
- 20:08because you are caught in a temporary, painful drawdown?
- 20:12Sometimes the most profitable thing you can do in markets and
- 20:15in life is zoom out, trust your fundamental analysis and simply
- 20:19hold on.