Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Stock Buybacks During Lockup Expirations
Transcript
- Lucas: If you're building or running a tech company that went public in the last couple of years, you've probably got a lockup expiration on your calendar — and you're probably a little nervous about it. Luna: Right. Because on that day, all those employees and early investors who've been sitting on restricted stock can finally sell. And the market knows it. Lucas: Exactly. Lockup expirations are one of the most predictable — and most feared — events in a post ipo company's life. I've seen studies showing that on average, stocks drop 3 to 4 percent on lockup day. But some companies have figured out a way to blunt that impact. Luna: And the tool is share buybacks. Buying back your own stock right when a wave of insider selling is about to hit. Lucas: Yeah. It sounds counterintuitive — you're using corporate cash to buy shares from your own employees and VCs as they exit. But when it's done well, it can stabilize the stock, signal confidence to the market, and actually reduce the net dilution from the lockup release. Luna: So how does it work in practice? Walk me through an example. Lucas: Let's take a fictional but realistic scenario. Say a company goes public at $30 a share, has a standard 180-day lockup, and by the time lockup expires the stock is trading at $45. Insiders — founders, early employees, venture funds — are sitting on a huge amount of shares they've been waiting to sell. Luna: And the market knows roughly how many shares are coming. It's all in the S-1 filings. Lucas: Right. So short sellers might pile on ahead of the lockup date, expecting a drop. The company's stock could get hammered even before the actual insider sales begin. Luna: And that's where the buyback comes in. The company announces a repurchase program — say $100 million — and starts buying shares in the open market around the lockup expiration. Lucas: Exactly. But timing is everything. Most companies don't just flip a switch on lockup day. They work with their investment bank to execute the buyback under Rule 10b-18, which provides a safe harbor from accusations of market manipulation. Rule 10b-18 limits how much you can buy each day — no more than 25 percent of the average daily trading volume — and restricts when you can buy, like not in the last 10 minutes of the trading day. Luna: So it's not a fire hose. It's a controlled, steady stream of buying to absorb the selling pressure. Lucas: Exactly. And some companies get even more creative. They'll announce a buyback a few weeks before the lockup expiration, so the market knows they're committed. That can actually front-run some of the short interest and reduce the volatility when the lockup actually hits. Luna: Let's talk about the real-world data. Does it actually work? Lucas: There's a really interesting 2025 paper from researchers at MIT and Columbia that looked at 400 post ipo lockups between 2018 and 2024. They found that companies that executed buybacks within a 10-day window around the lockup expiration saw their stocks drop only 1.2 percent on average, compared to 3.8 percent for companies that didn't buy back. Luna: So it cuts the negative impact by about two-thirds. That's not nothing. Lucas: Not at all. And the effect was even stronger for companies with higher insider ownership and for those that announced the buyback program well in advance. The study also found that the companies doing these buybacks tended to have stronger free cash flow and higher revenue growth — so the market saw it as a credible signal, not desperation. Luna: Which makes sense. If you're burning cash and you announce a buyback right before your lockup, people might wonder if you're just trying to prop up the stock for insiders to cash out. Lucas: Right. Credibility matters. The buyback only works as a signal if the market believes the company can afford it and that management's incentives are aligned with long-term shareholders. Luna: So what about companies that don't have the cash? Are there alternatives? Lucas: Some companies use accelerated share repurchase programs, or ASRs, where they borrow from a bank to buy back shares immediately and then pay the bank back over time. That can be a way to front-load the buyback even if you don't have all the cash on hand. Luna: But that adds financial risk, obviously. And it's a more complicated transaction. Lucas: Yeah. For most post ipo companies, the simpler approach is just to set up a 10b5-1 trading plan for the buyback, which automates the purchases and keeps the company from having to make daily trading decisions. Luna: And we've seen some high-profile examples recently. I'm thinking of the 2025 IPO of that enterprise software company — I won't name it — but they had a lockup expiration in January of this year and they were very public about their buyback plans. Lucas: Yeah, that's the one I'm thinking of too. They announced a $500 million buyback about three weeks before the lockup expired, and they executed it over the course of two months. The stock barely budged on lockup day, while a competitor that went public around the same time and didn't buy back saw a 12 percent drop. Luna: It's a nice little edge. And it's something that boards and CFOs should be thinking about early, not a week before the lockup expires. Lucas: Totally. And that's actually a great segue to something I wanted to mention about this show. You know, we deliberately don't run ads on these conversations. The whole Fexingo Business network is ad-free by design. Luna: Yeah, we've always felt that if these insights are useful for what you're building or running, the last thing you need is a commercial break in the middle of it. Lucas: Exactly. If you want to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just if it's valuable to you. Luna: And it keeps the show going without any sponsor interference. Lucas: Alright, back to buybacks. So one more nuance I think is worth discussing: the disclosure angle. Luna: What do you mean? Lucas: Companies have to be careful about what they say and when they say it. If a CFO hints at a buyback during a quiet period or before material information is public, they could run into Regulation FD rules. So the communication strategy around the buyback is almost as important as the execution. Luna: And there's also the risk of sending the wrong signal. If you announce a buyback and then don't execute it — or execute only a tiny fraction — the market will notice. Lucas: Right. There was a famous case in 2022 where a company announced a $1 billion buyback right before its lockup expiration and then only bought back $50 million over the next six months. The stock got crushed, and the CEO had to answer tough questions on the next earnings call. Luna: So commitment and follow-through are key. It's not a PR stunt. Lucas: No. And that's why the best CFOs I've talked to treat the lockup buyback as a capital allocation decision, not a marketing event. They model the impact on earnings per share, they consider the opportunity cost of using cash for buybacks versus R&D or acquisitions, and they communicate clearly with the board. Luna: Let me ask you this: Are there any downsides to the buyback approach from the employee perspective? Lucas: Yeah, actually. Some employees might feel like the company is using cash to buy back stock from VCs and founders — who are usually the biggest sellers at lockup — instead of investing in the business or paying higher salaries. There can be a morale issue if it's not handled transparently. Luna: That's a fair point. Especially if the stock price doesn't actually benefit from the buyback because the selling pressure is too strong. Lucas: Right. And the academic evidence suggests the buyback works best when the selling pressure is moderate — not when insiders are trying to dump 40 percent of the company in a single week. Luna: So it's a tool, not a silver bullet. Lucas: Exactly. The best approach is to combine the buyback with other measures: having the underwriter facilitate block trades, using a directed share program to match buyers and sellers, and communicating the company's long-term strategy clearly. Luna: And for companies that are still in the pre ipo planning stages, this is something to think about before the S-1 goes out. Lucas: Absolutely. I think every company that's thinking about going public should have a lockup buyback plan in their IPO playbook. It's one of those things that seems optional until you're in the middle of it, and by then it's too late. Luna: Good advice. And on that note, I think we've given our listeners a lot to chew on. Lucas: Yeah, I hope so. Next time, we'll talk about how post ipo companies use stock buybacks during lockup expirations in international markets, where the rules are different.