Latest / The Vegan Report / Are Social Media Undermining Vegan Advocacy?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, this is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:06Today we are talking about social media and their bad influence on vegan advocacy efforts.
- 0:14I know we have already touched on the topic back in episode 32 of the show with our good
- 0:21friend George Martin.
- 0:23But this episode is a solo episode.
- 0:27For this episode I took the time to write down my thoughts regarding social media in
- 0:33an article published in the magazine The Animal's Voice.
- 0:38And for today I wanted to read the article out loud.
- 0:43I wanted to share with you my very unpopular arguments regarding this very important issue.
- 0:52This is definitely a first for the show, I promise to get back to the usual interview
- 0:57format of the podcast as soon as next week.
- 1:02But for now I present you our social media undermining vegan advocacy.
- 1:08A few months ago Mark Zuckerberg revealed that one of his favorite pastime is to create
- 1:15some of the highest quality beef in the world.
- 1:19Indeed he keeps a cattle of wagyu and Angus beef on the Hawaiian island of Kauai.
- 1:27He decided to raise them with a diet of macadamia nuts and beer.
- 1:34The media coverage of this story has been lighthearted and positive.
- 1:40One fortune article was titled, Mark Zuckerberg says his daughter thought that I was a cattle
- 1:46rancher for a while thanks to his unusual hobby in Hawaii.
- 1:53Yet camouflaged by the amused tone of journalists hides a heartless cruelty.
- 2:00The sad reality of dozens of captive-sensitive beings who are misfed nuts and poisoned with
- 2:08alcohol in anticipation of a violent and unnecessary slaughter.
- 2:14In addition to ethical concerns there is the worry of environmental destruction.
- 2:20As a matter of fact cattle ranching plagues the fragile ecosystem of Hawaii, provoking
- 2:26deforestation, soil degradation and biodiversity loss.
- 2:32However the question I want to raise in view of this situation is, can vegans depend on
- 2:39this man and his company Metta to advance the animal rights mission?
- 2:46Explicitly is it wise for this movement to rely on an unsympathetic private platform
- 2:53with a long record of content censorship?
- 2:57And even more broadly, can vegans depend on social media at all to efficiently advance
- 3:05their cause?
- 3:07Anecdotes of people adopting veganism because of a YouTube video or a Reddit post can be
- 3:14counted by the thousands.
- 3:17Yet there is no major study examining the true impact of vegan content on social media.
- 3:24No researcher has asked pertinent questions such as, are those anecdotes accurate?
- 3:32Are we conflating social media engagement with making meaningful change?
- 3:38For every person who has been receptive to the vegan message, how many have been put
- 3:44off?
- 3:45Have social media users become desensitized to the hyperactivity of vegans online?
- 3:53To the point there is no hard evidence justifying the hundreds of thousands of dollars habitually
- 4:01spent by animal rights organizations and activists on social media campaigns.
- 4:08Unfortunately the cost of a social media presence for veganism is more than monetary.
- 4:16Alarmingly the social media ecosystem is quickly deforming the vegan movement beyond recognition.
- 4:24In 1944, veganism was first defined as the principle of the emancipation of animals from
- 4:31exploitation by men, and to seek an end to the use of animals by men for food, commodities,
- 4:40work, hunting, vivisection and by all other uses involving exploitation of animal life
- 4:48by men.
- 4:50It is a clear and uniting ethical stance focused on the liberation of animals.
- 4:57Yet most social media activity related to veganism is a witch brew of pseudoscience
- 5:04peddling, nutrition quackery, trend chasing, snake-all salesmanship, new age confusion
- 5:12and personality cults.
- 5:14An idiotic world which gravity field has brought down one of the most enlightened ethical philosophy
- 5:22to the mud of a fad diet.
- 5:26An expected outcome from platforms that reward popularity indiscriminately of any quality
- 5:33or safety standards.
- 5:36After losing credibility and reputation at the hands of virtual gurus, veganism can count
- 5:43on identity politics and echo chambers to lose its universal appeal.
- 5:50Since being captured by the intersectionality paradigm, the vegan message of compassion
- 5:56is prevented from appealing to independent, moderate and conservative crowds.
- 6:03For instance, try making the right-wing argument for veganism without encountering a barrage
- 6:11of dislikes, downvotes and angry comments from vegans.
- 6:17Then there is the social media addiction that has consumed the time, attention, energy,
- 6:24creativity and passion of too many animal advocates.
- 6:30It is a compulsion disguised as activism which pushes people into an emotional spiral of
- 6:38burning outrage, hindering obsessions, mindless reactions and crazed fits.
- 6:46It is an unequivocal demonstration that algorithms and not principles or strategy are piloting
- 6:55the vegan movement.
- 6:57At the same time, there is a great need for vegans to think outside the social media box
- 7:05and make a real life and offline contribution to the fight for animal liberation.
- 7:12For example, Liz White, a long-time activist and the leader of the Animal Protection Party
- 7:19of Canada, shared with me in an interview that
- 7:23If we really want things to change for animals in Canada, we have to do the politics.
- 7:52On Facebook, the Animal Protection Party of Canada has about 8,000 followers.
- 8:00Yet at the time of writing this article, the party only counts 12 candidates.
- 8:06A staggering ratio of one candidate for every 1,500 followers.
- 8:15But nothing surprising here.
- 8:17This is just one more project in a long list of original and impactful initiatives that
- 8:25fail to pull vegans away from the orbit of social media.
- 8:32In the Netflix documentary The Social Dilemma, the phrase If you're not paying for the product,
- 8:39you are the product is heard multiple times.
- 8:43At the end, it is important to remind ourselves that however inspiring, necessary and powerful
- 8:52vegan content can be, from a business perspective, it will never amount to being more than a
- 8:59lure for consumers whose private data is exploited by big corporations.
- 9:06Putting aside all societal debates, any individual should clearly see their interest in taking
- 9:14a wise distance from greedy platforms which have no regard for mental health or privacy.
- 9:44.