Latest / Newcomer Pod / Tony Fadell Unfiltered on Apple, OpenAI & the Next Big Device
Transcript
- 0:00Apple has never done marketing bullshit before and I saw that
- 0:03was complete bullshit. I mean, do you think Opening Eye
- 0:05goes bankrupt? Look, if they're asking for $50
- 0:08billion now, like how fast you're going to burn through
- 0:10that. Is that what you would focus on
- 0:12if you're Apple CEO? I have many things that I would
- 0:17do if I. Was all right, give us some of
- 0:19them. Is the next big tech device a
- 0:21pin, a pen, your headphones or the device that you've already
- 0:25got in your pocket? Today's guest is Tony Fadell,
- 0:28godfather of hardware design, who brought some of the most
- 0:31important consumer electronics to life at Apple and then at
- 0:35Google with Nest, I sat with him and got his thoughts on how
- 0:38Apple and the rest of the big technology companies are
- 0:40looking, even as he's rumored to be a contender for Apple's next
- 0:44CEO. We talked about what he would do
- 0:47if he ever got that top job. We talked about why he thinks
- 0:50open AI is building a strategy of being too big to fail and all
- 0:53those unfiltered thoughts without the constraints of a
- 0:56corporate PR department. This is the Newcomer podcast.
- 1:07Tony, Fidel, great to have you on the podcast.
- 1:09Thanks for joining me. It's great to be here, great to
- 1:11be. Eric, we're in an insane moment
- 1:14for the future of devices. So I'm super excited to talk to
- 1:18you. Pins pens, like what do we what
- 1:21do we want? So I really want to get direct
- 1:23into it. I mean, there are rumors I think
- 1:25this week that Apple is thinking about a pin in the wake of
- 1:29humane working on a pin. There's I have, you know,
- 1:33friends and I think there's been some reporting now that maybe
- 1:36Johnny, I have an open AI are thinking about a pen.
- 1:39I'll I'll try and press you on what you think about the
- 1:41particulars. But like from first principles,
- 1:44what do you think is most likely to be the AI native device
- 1:50format? AI can be applied to many
- 1:53things, and AI is great for certain applications with
- 2:00certain hardware components around it.
- 2:03So there's AI with a screen, and there's AI without a screen.
- 2:06In all cases, it needs to have audio, right?
- 2:10But what AI needs mostly is it needs context.
- 2:15OK, so there you have to look at the input side and you have to
- 2:18look at the output side. So first let's talk about the
- 2:21input side. The more context you give any
- 2:28kind of LLM, and I'm not saying they're the panacea, there's
- 2:31going to be lots of models beyond LLM.
- 2:33So I want to make sure I'm very clear and I'm not the LLM.
- 2:37Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's, we're going to get AGI
- 2:39with it. It's all fucking bullshit.
- 2:41OK, Mike, I'm concerned. So you first start with the
- 2:46input. And if we know everything and
- 2:48you've been hearing about over, over the year, 2 years, so fast
- 2:53here now it's like we've been hearing about context windows
- 2:56and context windows getting longer and longer and longer.
- 2:59And then now we're ragging all your data and, and, and gem.
- 3:02And I just announced yesterday that you can bring in all of
- 3:05your Gmail and, and all your Google Photos and and G Drive.
- 3:09And I feel like I'm being reckless.
- 3:10I've connected everything to Anthropic already.
- 3:12It's like, yeah, search through my e-mail.
- 3:14Right, exactly. And so the more context, the
- 3:17better. So there's one which is context
- 3:20about what you've done, OK, and that's you know, and that makes
- 3:24it better. But then there's the context of
- 3:26what you're doing and knowing that really, really clearly.
- 3:30And So what you want and you know, what your, your smartphone
- 3:35has is you want to know your and just like advertising and all
- 3:38the other, you know, websites and social wanted before, it's
- 3:42no different. They wanted your location.
- 3:45They wanted, hey, they would love your audio all the time.
- 3:47They want your camera all the time.
- 3:49They, they want what you're typing, who you're nearby, what
- 3:53Wi-Fi networks and Bluetooth things are there and what other
- 3:56devices around you and, and, and what even what time of day,
- 4:00what's the, what's the lighting, you know, what's the weather?
- 4:03Are you indoors, outdoors? Why is that?
- 4:06The more context you have in the in the in the moment combined
- 4:11with what it knows about you and what's around you in the moment,
- 4:15you don't have to ask it When you make a query, whether that's
- 4:19a voice query or a text query or whatever the query might be, it
- 4:24knows. It's like, oh, you are at this
- 4:26place at this time around these people with these resources,
- 4:29with this kind of weather. But, and you, when you ask a
- 4:32short question, it's like thing as opposed to back in the Siri
- 4:37days and the Alexa days, you had to tell it everything because it
- 4:41had no context. So in this case, the better the
- 4:45interface becomes, the more historical context as well as
- 4:51real time context. It has to be able to.
- 4:54So it's like, we know what we're doing right now.
- 4:56I can, I can briefly say 2 words to you and you probably
- 4:59understand like, oh, look at that plan over there.
- 5:01You know what I mean? Something like that.
- 5:02That's what it needs to know to be able to give you much quicker
- 5:05answers. Like it's in the room.
- 5:07But do you buy Like do you think most humans will ultimately want
- 5:11some AI D have access to their current audio?
- 5:14Like, do you think that is something that needs to be?
- 5:16I think, I think there's obviously use cases for that and
- 5:19also for video. I I don't see and all the other,
- 5:22all the other sensor suites for sensor fusion out there to make
- 5:25it work. So in certain contexts and
- 5:27certain applications, you'll want to do that.
- 5:29Certain people be no way, you know, people put the tape over
- 5:33their laptops, cameras and everything else.
- 5:35So it's just it's going to be an individual preference on what it
- 5:37is. You know, I remember the glass
- 5:39hole days of, you know, Google Glass.
- 5:42We're like, you're not recording me and now we're running with
- 5:44Meta glasses. So it's all a social context
- 5:48awareness thing where you know, it it, it's not just about when
- 5:51the technology's ready, it's about when a particular segment
- 5:54of society is ready to adopt it. I remember this from my general
- 5:58magic days when we were making the iPhone 15 years too early.
- 6:01You know, nobody knew the problems we were solving because
- 6:03they didn't have those problems, right?
- 6:04But the idea of like a pin type device is that mostly would you
- 6:09buy? Is there a pin type device?
- 6:11Sure, there's a pin type device. There's also a pin type device
- 6:13now. It's called plod.
- 6:14But is that trying to solve the social problem of saying I'm
- 6:17recording? Like why can't the phone just do
- 6:19the recording? We already have it with us.
- 6:21OK, so, so first we were talking about the input.
- 6:24I want to talk about the output, right?
- 6:25And then there's the form. OK, OK, so let's talk about
- 6:28input. Now we'll talk about output,
- 6:29then we'll talk about forms. OK, I know you want to talk
- 6:31about pins, so let's talk about output.
- 6:34Yeah. So there's really great times
- 6:37when you have, and this is what, you know, I really experienced
- 6:40when I was working with Google Glass and these kinds of things.
- 6:44Output is really important in very contextual ways.
- 6:49So if you're on the move, you're going.
- 6:52I see people out here walking in the, you know, in New York,
- 6:55walking in the polls and stuff because they're sitting here
- 6:57looking at their thing or they're on their bike, you know,
- 7:00doing it or driving, worst case. So, and they're all distracted
- 7:04from that. And, and a lot of times you just
- 7:05want audio and you want to have a much better audio interface
- 7:08versus a, a display. But the best way to represent
- 7:13visual information is visually, you know, we've heard people
- 7:17trying to communicate, you know, I'm changing this, this
- 7:20schematic or whatever, and they say, I'm going to change this
- 7:22and this. And they're like, huh, And you
- 7:24just send them a drawing and they go, Oh, now I get it,
- 7:26right. So you have to understand the
- 7:28context you're in and what's what's the best way to represent
- 7:32present that output. Is it visually, is it oddity?
- 7:36It could be like vibrations, it could be many different ways.
- 7:39And so when you start to break down the applications, you start
- 7:44to end the and the environment you're in, like are you in your
- 7:48office, are you in your home, are you walking, are you in a
- 7:50bus, are you in a train, are you in a plane, whatever.
- 7:52And then you start to understand the applications and the ways of
- 7:58representing that output that makes sense in that given
- 8:01situation. For output I understand like
- 8:05Airpods or earphones as an output device for AII don't.
- 8:10I guess part of why I was limited in The thing is, like
- 8:12the pin and the pen format, I don't see what the output is
- 8:17like. To me they mostly exist as input
- 8:19as. You hit a nail on that.
- 8:20You absolutely. And that's my that was my next
- 8:23point, which is the form. OK.
- 8:24And so what's going on with a pen with a pin with whatever in
- 8:30the case of let's say it's a pen at open AI, because that's I've
- 8:33heard the same thing. And I used to know some people
- 8:35working on things like that there and they used to work.
- 8:38For me, do you think it's a pen? So, and I also worked with
- 8:42Johnny a long time for a decade, right?
- 8:44So I think I understand and I probably think it's something
- 8:47like a pen, but it can also be glasses and other things.
- 8:49But given Johnny's predisposition for how he has to
- 8:52do something very different. So he's got to do that because
- 8:55he'll have some story around. It's got to be a pen.
- 8:58And maybe it'll be like the Noto pen.
- 9:00Do you remember the Noto pen? The Noto pen actually had a pad
- 9:03of paper and you could just, it was like a digital pen.
- 9:06You just write on paper and the Noto would keep all of the the
- 9:10things and it would then create APDF of that thing that you
- 9:15could then, you know, do text to speech and.
- 9:18Stuff like that, how AI is bringing us back to our
- 9:20humanity. Of course there's going to be
- 9:22this whole big flowery, Oh my God, we're getting away from the
- 9:25phone and blah, blah blah, blah and and all that diarrhea.
- 9:28So what really happens though, is that the reason why it has
- 9:33it's it's a pen for a story, OK, but it doesn't have output.
- 9:38Because at the end of the day, the best form of output is the
- 9:42thing you already have with you, which is your smartphone.
- 9:45OK, It does the best visual output.
- 9:48You're not going to carry yet another screen.
- 9:49You might have a couple of LEDs or a very, very tiny thing on
- 9:53whatever this other thing is for status or whatever, but it's not
- 9:57going to replace the phone. It can't replace.
- 10:00That's the the bullshit thing of humane.
- 10:03We're going to kill the phone. It was like, that was the
- 10:05stupidest marketing message I've ever heard because you're not
- 10:08going to kill it. So you have to be a companion to
- 10:11it. Just like Airpods, just like
- 10:13Apple Watches. It's a companion to a phone.
- 10:17So the reason why it's in this form factor is because they need
- 10:23all the sensor suites. Why do they need the sensor
- 10:27suites? Because Apple's not going to
- 10:28give them access to that. On the phone.
- 10:30So they just don't want to be disintermediated by Apple, no?
- 10:33No, they're saying you have to get the device because they need
- 10:36to get all the context to get all the real time input so they
- 10:40can feed it back to the servers to give you the because all the
- 10:43security of Bluetooth security, video security, the dots, all
- 10:47the GPS coordinates when they when you have to ask Apple for
- 10:53permission and and the user permission for LS things, you
- 10:56go, Oh my God, they're hyper tracking us as opposed to it's
- 10:59one network link, whether it's a Bluetooth or Wi-Fi thing, you
- 11:04know, it's most likely Bluetooth to your device that then does
- 11:07goes back to the network. It's one thing.
- 11:09Yeah, I'm just connecting like my headphones, but it's got GPS,
- 11:13everything else in it. So it's just sucking up all your
- 11:16contacts and throwing away and getting rid of all those privacy
- 11:18concerns. You see.
- 11:20So it makes it real simple and people go, Oh yeah, it just does
- 11:23it and you don't understand. It's sucking everything it
- 11:26possibly can suck to get back to open AI to get around all the
- 11:30restrictions if. You're an AI true believer.
- 11:32You want all the you too sort of want it to have all the contacts
- 11:35you have. If you're, if we start to have a
- 11:37relationship with our own chat bot where it's like, I really
- 11:41depend on you, I want you to know what I'm doing.
- 11:43You don't feel this impulse that it's sort of the deficit is in
- 11:47its lack of context on what I'm doing and that it would be you
- 11:50don't feel. That you're an early adopter,
- 11:51right? But do you most of.
- 11:52The world, most of the world isn't most of the world is like,
- 11:55what the fuck are you doing with my data?
- 11:57Right? So am I I'm, I am a I'm a late
- 12:03early adopter. I have learned how how these
- 12:07products are made. I've watched this stuff.
- 12:10I did not adopt IQ Maine. I knew how bad it was because
- 12:13when I had the first meeting when they were four people, I
- 12:15was like, this thing's going nowhere.
- 12:17The same thing happened with various other devices.
- 12:19I'm like, I don't have time for this crap.
- 12:21Same thing happened with the rabbit.
- 12:22I was like, what is this thing? I met with Jesse.
- 12:25I'm like, Nah. So the, the, the issue is, is
- 12:28you, you want to be a late enough early adopter, not so
- 12:32crazy that you're just wasting your time.
- 12:34So I'm on that side. So, and then I also look at all
- 12:37the data stuff because I'm also pretty wise and I know how
- 12:40these, this, this, this, this data stuff is used.
- 12:44And I'm, I'm in between, you know, you, you just said you
- 12:49have a, a, a a your first child, a daughter, right?
- 12:51This is your first. Child, yes, 3 1/2 months.
- 12:54Congratulations. Thank.
- 12:56You, I remember a market way difference in the way I thought
- 12:59about the world before I had kids and after I had kids.
- 13:03And most of these founders, that was including Larry and Sergey
- 13:07and and Mark Zuckerberg, all those guys think about the world
- 13:11before they had kids, before they were married in a very
- 13:13different way. I want everything all the time.
- 13:16I'll give away all my privacy. I don't, I don't care what
- 13:18happens with all this data. As soon as you have kids and you
- 13:22start hearing about defects and you start hearing about social
- 13:25engineering and you start hearing about all this other
- 13:26stuff, you start changing your view on how much data you want
- 13:31sucked up, OK, and what how you're being protected.
- 13:34And there's a very, and I know for a fact, because I worked
- 13:38with these guys, some of these founders that they think about
- 13:41the world differently and they wish they would have made us
- 13:43some different moves and different decisions early on and
- 13:49would like to go back, but they can't.
- 13:50So I'm just saying going back on your data thing, it's very
- 13:53different, depends on your. Journey for my daughter we have
- 13:57tiny Beans, which is like a private app just for our family.
- 14:00So I can see just you start using products differently in
- 14:03terms, okay, so if the pen is really an end run around the
- 14:08control of the iPhone, why would Apple need a PIN like they they
- 14:13have the iPhone? How does that story?
- 14:15Because you might be on the device using it, it might be
- 14:18also a lot of times you don't want to have the device there in
- 14:22the middle because you're saying like it's, it can also be
- 14:24ambient all the time because your thing's going to be in your
- 14:27pocket. So there is, there are some like
- 14:29the form of having this other thing that if you choose to want
- 14:32it to watch it, because we've watched these life recorders
- 14:35before, you know, 10 years ago, there's these life recorders.
- 14:38This is just another form of. That that's how it gets
- 14:40positioned. It's like, don't forget any
- 14:42moment. Yeah, you know, Plod's doing
- 14:44that now with their their voice 1 and this one I.
- 14:47Actually don't know that one. Plod's out of the UK and it's,
- 14:49it's, you know, granola. Yeah, yeah, of course.
- 14:51It's basically granola, but as a.
- 14:53Wearable. Are you an investor or in plod?
- 14:56No, I'm not OK. You just brought it up, so I
- 14:57didn't. No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
- 14:59I'm not investor. Do you buy that Apple's working
- 15:02on a pin? I'm sure I hope to God they're
- 15:05working on something right, You know, right, they need to be
- 15:08working on a little bit, but knowing their chip, their chip
- 15:12expertise, Johnny Saruji and the team, they're incredibly awesome
- 15:15knowing the mechanicals, knowing that they've made the watch
- 15:19right and they're making you know, the air, the tracker, all
- 15:24the other stuff they have the tracker, sorry, you know, the,
- 15:26the, the Apple, the air tag. They have air tag.
- 15:29They have all this really, really miniature custom silicon
- 15:32that and all the Airpod custom silicon.
- 15:37They can make one of these things really easy compared to
- 15:40anybody else because they have all the expertise to make an
- 15:43incredible piece of hardware. They have to get the software
- 15:45right, but the hardware, the connectivity, they have their
- 15:48own network stack. They could make a an awesome one
- 15:51because they have all the camera technology too.
- 15:53So I it, it would either it's going to be something you sit on
- 15:56the desk or you wear and you sit on the desk or whatever.
- 15:58It's like, duh, it's like, or you build it into your, you
- 16:01know, into your Airpods Pro. Like imagine cameras that are
- 16:05coming out of your you're using. Could or it's like where, how,
- 16:09how much do you expect Apple to deliver?
- 16:11I guess you know, you're talking to somebody.
- 16:12I'm deep in the Apple ecosystem, my laptop Airpods watch phone so
- 16:17but then they I think I bought the phone that was sold on AI
- 16:20and it's one of the most egregious misleads perhaps and
- 16:24ever marketing a product. When I saw AI first laptop, AI
- 16:27first phone, I was ready to tweet something that was like
- 16:31really, really nasty. And I pulled back because I'm
- 16:33like, you know, it's, it's, it's Apple has never done marketing
- 16:38bullshit before. And I saw that was complete
- 16:41bullshit, you know, and I was like, I was holding back.
- 16:44So, you know, hopefully they're finding new religion and going
- 16:49back to the old real smart days, which is under promise and over
- 16:52deliver. What do you think they can do
- 16:53well right now, and what do you think is holding them back?
- 16:56What can they do? Well, right now, chips, low
- 16:59level software devices. It's really, really, you know,
- 17:06Apple, Apple Vision Pro is an abject failure, but it's an
- 17:09incredible technical marvel from a technology point of view.
- 17:13So they can make great stuff. It's do they have the product
- 17:17chops like they used to, to be able to create the full stack,
- 17:21create the incredible user experience and deliver all those
- 17:25pieces of the puzzle in the middle necessary to pull it all
- 17:28together. And that's the thing that, you
- 17:30know, has been really important for the reason why Apple is
- 17:35where it is today. To what extent do you think just
- 17:37the underlying capability of AI is holding Apple back, right?
- 17:41Like for a great user experience you want sort of the 100% case,
- 17:45right? A lot of people talk about some
- 17:47of the, you know, Chachi BT capabilities.
- 17:49It's almost like the self driving 90%, like, you know, it
- 17:52can do most of what you want, but then the more you drill into
- 17:56a problem, the more you start hitting problems.
- 17:58And so if you're trying to set up these consumer loops where
- 18:01it's like every time I step into my house, you do this and the AI
- 18:05gets it right 90% of the time, Can Apple be expected to deliver
- 18:09that consumer experience? That they want.
- 18:11Well, the very first thing to understand is LLMS have
- 18:14fundamental problems. They have fundamental problems
- 18:17and that's and in in the way they're created and that's why
- 18:20they hallucinate. And unless they're de scoped and
- 18:24they're really trained on very, very contextually specific
- 18:28information like medical or legal or, you know, whatever
- 18:31general consumer stuff instead of these incredibly huge models
- 18:36that can hallucinate because they don't know whether you're
- 18:38talking medical, legal, whatever it's it tries to be a know it
- 18:40all. You'd never hire a know it all
- 18:42in the real. World, we can't stand those,
- 18:44right? I admit what I don't know right?
- 18:47Chacha PT. Never it always.
- 18:48Gives you an answer and it doesn't know whether it's right
- 18:51or wrong. And so, you know, we're invested
- 18:53in various companies in the medical domain like nabla and
- 18:56other things that have very, very specific context and very,
- 19:01very specific guard rails for what they will do and what they
- 19:05will answer and they will not answer stuff.
- 19:07It's when you're trying to make these general purpose ones,
- 19:09that's when it's a problem. So let's so getting back to the
- 19:14the LLM specifically, if Apple has very, very specific models
- 19:19for consumers in certain contexts, it can work really
- 19:22well. It's when you apply these very,
- 19:24very broad models and you don't know what's going to come out,
- 19:28then that is where the problem is.
- 19:30There's still models and other things beyond LLMS, even highly
- 19:34contextually constrained LLM trained LLMS that are coming
- 19:38that are going to get a get around a lot of those things.
- 19:41But right now everybody's blah, blah, blah, LLMS, AGI, bigger
- 19:45and bigger models. What do you?
- 19:46Think is coming? Shit, what's coming?
- 19:49Well, there's world models coming, right?
- 19:51So world models combined with LLMS.
- 19:53So that's understanding physics, understanding chemistry, all
- 19:56this stuff that we know because there are real rules,
- 19:59mathematics around those things. You know, today, Chet GPT can't
- 20:03even draw a face of a clock, right?
- 20:06Or understand what a clock says because it doesn't graphically
- 20:08think it's easy for us for a graphical clock and not a
- 20:11digital 1. And so it's like though, that a
- 20:14world model would go, oh, that's a graphic.
- 20:16I'm going to use this model. It you know this is how it
- 20:19works, you would build that stuff.
- 20:21Into those models, tools where it says for this question you,
- 20:24you go off to this software or this technique.
- 20:27To solve some, yeah, absolutely. And then the language model is
- 20:30good for what the language model is good for, as opposed to
- 20:33trying to think it reasons about chemistry because it doesn't
- 20:37have a real basic chemistry model.
- 20:39When we started this conversation, I think you were
- 20:41saying, you know, audio and voice is sort of at the core of
- 20:44what AI wants to consume. Where or maybe is that fair?
- 20:48Or I mean, clearly listening to everything we're doing is part
- 20:52of what these devices we've talked about want.
- 20:54But where, yeah, where do you think about sort of the Airpods
- 20:57and earbuds in terms of the AI device story?
- 21:02Well, you know, I, I, I, there's, there's edge devices
- 21:06which are Airpods and, and, and you know, and phones and these
- 21:11kinds of things. I think of the edge of the edge
- 21:13first. OK, so the edge of the edge is
- 21:16the very, very fringe of like, are you speaking a word?
- 21:20How do I do noise cancellation? How do I do speaker focusing
- 21:24those kinds of things? There is AI that can do that
- 21:27stuff really well. Your ear does that.
- 21:29You do that. You turn your head, you focus
- 21:31in. So we can apply IAI into each of
- 21:34these at the edge of the edge devices to do much better
- 21:38intelligence to help us be able to filter out noise from.
- 21:42To do the devices core task. The the very basic task of
- 21:48separating signal from noise, whether that's visually or or or
- 21:53auditorily or other things of that nature.
- 21:55So we need to get there. So that's the first level of AI
- 21:59applied. Then there's the AI above that,
- 22:02which is labeling, interpretation, those kinds of
- 22:04things. And that can be done on device
- 22:06in some cases or it'd be done with the companion.
- 22:09It's which would most likely be your smartphone.
- 22:11So that's another set of AI. Then there's another one on top
- 22:15of that, which is like, OK, what's the reasoning?
- 22:17Let's make, let's get the context and then figure out
- 22:20what's going on. So there's all these levels and
- 22:24we need to break down the AI and levels.
- 22:25Just like your brain has many different, different, you know,
- 22:31centers in your brain to do this, this, this, this, this,
- 22:34you're going to start seeing AI becoming much more diverse and
- 22:38not just one big thing. And we're seeing that with self
- 22:40driving cars already. I know we're all over the map.
- 22:44No, I know. I love it.
- 22:45To some degree. The AI wave creates this broken
- 22:50thinking because you have companies that have that want to
- 22:53justify valuations, so they need to sell something and they have
- 22:56the story, which is AI. And so in some ways, I'm
- 22:59complicit in what they're doing, which is like think from the
- 23:02need for an AI device out rather than like some human problem and
- 23:07then sort of build the device correct up.
- 23:09And that's why this conversation ends up being chaotic, because
- 23:12we're shifting between. From the technology to the use
- 23:15technology, it's like we're. In search of a But don't you
- 23:18think there is this moment to sell the consumer on a new
- 23:21device? They've heard about this
- 23:22technology. They're they're sort of open to
- 23:24adopt a new sort of way of behaving.
- 23:27And so people are searching for what, what, what device can we
- 23:30could deliver them in this scene is.
- 23:32To me, these devices, a pin, a pen or whatever, are enablers,
- 23:35right? They're not a solution and where
- 23:38we were going was I was saying that we need more context
- 23:41specific LLMS drug so that consumers can get a a reliable
- 23:47experience without hallucinations.
- 23:49What that means is you have to come up with the applications
- 23:52and constrain the application to better understand what it is you
- 23:55want. It's not just a know it all
- 23:57that's going to go and try everything.
- 23:59So when we when you switch into certain applications, you want
- 24:02that because why? At the end of the day, we're not
- 24:05where we want to be. It's not, we're not at her yet.
- 24:07Everybody wants her the thing, but we don't have the technology
- 24:13yet. So we have to creep into it,
- 24:15right, which means application, more application specific
- 24:18context specific LLMS, forgiven workflows and not just it's a
- 24:24general anything device, OK. And so, so we're going to see
- 24:29much it's like kind of web .1 point O to two point O to
- 24:33three-point O. We've had to make these leaps
- 24:35because we have to have the technology to move along.
- 24:37With it. But we, we had Siri many years
- 24:40ago. We've had Alexa.
- 24:41Like, do you think we're still far away from the sort of voice
- 24:45communicated personal assistant that people talk to to engage
- 24:49with a computer? Yes, because why?
- 24:52What I see is you're going to have your federation of your
- 24:55devices. That's going to be everything
- 24:57for your laptop, your TV, your game machine, all the things you
- 25:00carry on, you watches, whatever it is, you're going to have
- 25:03that. Then you're going to have a
- 25:05smart agent in the background really understanding which
- 25:08device you're on, which users and all the data and all the
- 25:11context and then be able to switch how it's working based on
- 25:15those things. Today what we're saying is put
- 25:17everything on a device and it's going to work or put all the
- 25:20sensors here and put all of the the the smarts in the cloud and
- 25:25it's and everything else is just dumb.
- 25:27In between. We're going to build into this
- 25:30much more multiple AI world where edge of the edge, the edge
- 25:35devices, the federation of edge devices and the cloud all work
- 25:38together to produce the her application.
- 25:42We're hearing that we would love to have, but we're just not
- 25:45going to get there today from what everyone's telling you, you
- 25:48know? Just because of the capability
- 25:50of LLM. Yeah, because we're just not.
- 25:51We don't have the world models, we don't have the sensors.
- 25:54When you look at these humanoid robots, everyone's like, oh,
- 25:57they do flips and tricks and everything.
- 26:00Great, we can do that. But we don't have the necessary
- 26:03sensing and actuation necessary to be able to get the data to be
- 26:07able to write. And they need world models to to
- 26:10do what anything like a humanoid stuff that people are hoping
- 26:15it'll do. Remember self driving cars came
- 26:18out in the late 22,008. We're just there now.
- 26:22Right. No, it's great.
- 26:23Right. And we've spent billions and
- 26:25billions and we're now getting, and it's just getting rolled out
- 26:28and there's still 300,000 $1000 cars with massive sensors and
- 26:32compute and those are massive edge devices plus a whole set of
- 26:37coordination in the cloud. So that's what we need to do.
- 26:41And we need to do it at a very cheap level and battery
- 26:44efficient level and right. And it's gonna take time to get
- 26:48there, right? What is the state of the smart
- 26:52home today or what? OK, take, I know you were
- 26:56talking the big device questions here like and it fits into this
- 26:59AI conversation, but like what is your read on just the success
- 27:04or failure of building, you know, smart home devices?
- 27:07OK, I'm going to build a remodel of a big new smart home thing
- 27:12for myself. So I'm, you know, I'm tracking
- 27:14the very latest and now I'm not in it like I used to be so.
- 27:18Does that include custom devices or you're just sourcing the best
- 27:21stuff that exists? Well, I'd say that there there's
- 27:24the best of what exists is from the device side, but then
- 27:27there's custom ways of putting it all together.
- 27:29It's like what we just talked about the self driving car thing
- 27:33you have and when I'm designing this thing, I have to think
- 27:35about the devices, the low level network, the application level
- 27:39network, what's in the server, what's in the cloud like and
- 27:42it's still very, very difficult if you want to pull off what
- 27:45again the smart home that the Jetson smart home that we all
- 27:48think about. Is that what you're trying to
- 27:50get? Yeah, and I just know better.
- 27:52Like I'm like OK I'm going to wire everything and make sure I
- 27:54have thread border routers in the necessary places.
- 27:56And what are the main things you want the house to be able to do?
- 27:59Oh, right now, just the simplest things like I have a you know,
- 28:03I'm the the in in in this case, I have a self playing piano,
- 28:09right. So I'm I'm I'm pumping MIDI into
- 28:12it. So I pump MIDI and I put songs
- 28:14from the net or from locally MIDI into it to them.
- 28:18It self plays and then it has it's miked and the mics are then
- 28:24A to deed into a Dante audio network, which then distributes
- 28:28all the way through the entire house or whatever zones I want
- 28:32through Dante into all of these Dante amplified speakers around
- 28:38the house and the Sonos can pump in and so I can have a player
- 28:41piano. And the keys are pressing.
- 28:44The keys are pressing, so it's a analog piano getting digitally
- 28:47recorded and streamed all through the house.
- 28:51So it's. Pressing the key, is it like an?
- 28:52It's not an old school. No, no, no, it's a modern, it's
- 28:56a modern regular grand grand piano, but it has actuators on
- 29:00it and and it plays, it plays the songs just as it 'cause they
- 29:06record it from a professional. So it's like you have a concert
- 29:09pianist with you and then, and then you're and you're miking it
- 29:14and then you're amplifying it and playing it throughout the
- 29:16house. So you, it feels like you have a
- 29:17concert pianist in the house. Have you?
- 29:19Executed on that yet? Or is this still a dream?
- 29:21Oh no, we're it's in, it's in the mix and it it can work.
- 29:24It absolutely can work. But then there's all the
- 29:26switching to make the Sonos move from one thing to another.
- 29:31And how do you and which zones did the this the player piano go
- 29:34to to the? And are you like a speaker head?
- 29:38Like, do you have this sort of fancy old school speakers or
- 29:41you're using like Sonos? Well, no, I'm using Sonos ports
- 29:45to to get the house to amplified speakers for certain either in
- 29:50ceiling speakers without you don't see the grills.
- 29:53You've seen some cases. I don't like them but there's
- 29:55some cases in certain wet locations you need the grills
- 29:58and other things where it's L acoustics like Dolby.
- 30:01Atmos Right, OK, you. Know whole thing and you have to
- 30:05worry about all those levels of networks to make all that stuff
- 30:08work. You know, got AVC, you got AEC,
- 30:11There's so many different things like I have, plus I also have
- 30:15full lighting. So there's DMX lighting control
- 30:18that you do on stages. There's also the MIDI over
- 30:23Ethernet and everything runs over Ethernet.
- 30:25So it's MIDI over Ethernet, lighting control over Ethernet,
- 30:30Dante over Ethernet, lighting control over Ethernet, right?
- 30:34So it's a full on, you know, next generation system.
- 30:40Anything else, you're a smart home.
- 30:42Well, it's going to have thread of course, because we did we
- 30:44what is? Thread, sorry.
- 30:45So thread, we, we had basically invented it and now Thread is
- 30:49the Bluetooth equipment equivalent for mesh networking
- 30:54for entire house. So it mesh networks an entire
- 30:56house for low speed data and control very, very low latency.
- 31:01So you can do light switches, light bulbs, sensors, everything
- 31:04else that can be battery operated for 10 years, that kind
- 31:08of thing. And it's very resilient.
- 31:10You do anything like? Mechanical like I don't know,
- 31:12are there meals being made in automated?
- 31:15There's mechanical lighting and TV's that pop out things, the
- 31:19lights drop down, robo lights that move.
- 31:24Yeah, that's the most of the mechanical except mechanical
- 31:29locks and you know and you know and NFC based door door locks
- 31:37that kind. Of stuff And what do you use for
- 31:38the actual like voice communication with your house?
- 31:41That is to be determined. It's a Bake Off or.
- 31:44What do you mean nothing's ready yet, right, right.
- 31:47So you have to next generation Alexa is not there yet right.
- 31:50So it's it's set up that's the next layer on top of all of this
- 31:53infrastructure. The next layer is on top of that
- 31:55and that's TBD. What are?
- 31:57You typing it? What's what's what's gonna
- 31:58happen? You have to make a decision,
- 32:00right? No, I don't.
- 32:01Why? Well, you're.
- 32:03Gonna have to talk to it. What are you gonna use?
- 32:06When is this house supposed to be ready to go?
- 32:09What are you gonna use? You use buttons just like cars
- 32:12are taking coming from screens, and you're not gonna use
- 32:14buttons. Right now you're not ready to
- 32:16use voice. No it's cuz it's fucking
- 32:18bullshit. So you just have like modules
- 32:20like. I don't feel like having
- 32:21everyone scream at me and you know, and.
- 32:23Turn on the lights. You don't have any of that.
- 32:26You know, look, this is the other thing I learned from smart
- 32:28home, right? OK.
- 32:30Is that most people who design the smart home design it for
- 32:35themselves. It's like for single guys I want
- 32:381 button that does this and one button and then when you have.
- 32:41People over there. When you have kids or you have
- 32:43friends over or you have, or you have a wife or partner with you
- 32:48and they're like, I don't want that button.
- 32:50I want this button. Everyone has their own 1 button
- 32:53interface. So you have to design and
- 32:56understand your, your just like anything.
- 33:00It's not just you. You have to design this whole
- 33:02world when it's a, a shared space versus your own AI, you
- 33:06know her space. It's a very different thing.
- 33:09What I mean, one of the things that's amazing about the devices
- 33:12you guys produced at Apple, obviously they were expensive,
- 33:15but they're fundamentally mass market.
- 33:17It feels like the billionaire phone is the phone that sort of
- 33:21the middle class American is able to afford.
- 33:24I mean, the portrait you're painting is not that where it's
- 33:27like with the home and. And that's sort of like old
- 33:29school. Oh.
- 33:30My stuff's really crazy, but you can make a bunch, right?
- 33:33But easier. If you think about like sort of
- 33:35getting the home to that that piece because that on some level
- 33:39it's what you want too, which is a device that's made that sort
- 33:42of works that solves some of these problems without the sort
- 33:45of. I want less screens in my home.
- 33:47I don't want more screens. I hate screens, right?
- 33:49Frankly, I hate screens. I don't want them in the home.
- 33:51So. Why hasn't the home had that
- 33:53sort of like mass market amazing electronic work yet?
- 33:57Oh, because we, we're still in the days of like, you know,
- 34:02remember Wi-Fi didn't even exist until 2001 too, right.
- 34:06So we thread just finally got, even though it started in 2011,
- 34:10it's just now there. We're still building all the
- 34:13base layers and linking everything and then and we and
- 34:17we're now going to get the LLMS and voice recognition, all that
- 34:20stuff to then put it all together.
- 34:23But it's still on the verge just like the self driving car was.
- 34:27When that smart home like that is, you got to give it another I
- 34:32think 5 to 6 years for what we think of when you think smart
- 34:37home you want it to be, I think it's going to be there.
- 34:39Just set up your home to make sure it.
- 34:41What? What company do you think is
- 34:43best positioned? No idea it's 5.
- 34:45Six years, No, because the thing that I learned at Nest was all
- 34:48these sensors and smart plugs and all that other stuff.
- 34:52There's no money in it. There's absolutely no money in
- 34:55that stuff. That's why you go online and
- 34:57that's why there's. People are only willing to buy
- 35:0120% more expensive. Yeah, cuz I have a switch on my
- 35:04wall. Why do I need anything else?
- 35:05And any crazy guy like me doing this other thing, it's just.
- 35:09Not a big enough. Market, it's not a big enough
- 35:10market, so nobody wants to play in that space.
- 35:14So IKEA is finally, you know, to tell you the truth, because
- 35:17they're using thread and they're using matter and that kind of
- 35:19stuff. So IKEA is starting interesting,
- 35:21but it's just starting. It's all nascent.
- 35:24So I think that the ones that are going to be successful are
- 35:28the ones who are going to finally deliver the Nest vision
- 35:31that we really had. But it's still, you know, if I
- 35:35was I would be rebuilding Nest right now, you know, and and and
- 35:40because in three to four years you can be there to get what
- 35:43we've been talking about that we had the vision for in 2010
- 35:47eleven. You're obviously investing right
- 35:49now, but do you, do you still have the entrepreneur bug?
- 35:52Like do you think you have another great company in you?
- 35:54Oh, I have over 100 great companies in me right now.
- 35:57I, I, we, you know, I've invested directly in many, many
- 36:00things and I invest indirectly in many things.
- 36:02So I have over 100 companies now, 100 and something companies
- 36:06where I'm working with them every day.
- 36:09Like today I was working with a company and helping them with
- 36:11Apple. I'm a shadow CEO at a couple of
- 36:13companies. I'm doing product design at
- 36:15companies, so I get to do this in many different domains.
- 36:19To be a shadow CEO. So there's this chat, there's
- 36:22the CEO and then he's like, please help me.
- 36:23So I get to be behind. I'm like, would you think about
- 36:26it this way? Operations head count, how
- 36:28should we should do funding, product design?
- 36:31And so I have various roles like that where they please help.
- 36:35And so I do, and I go in and I get to a.
- 36:37Couple of companies are spending the most time on right now.
- 36:42I'm spending a lot of time with Orionis Biosciences.
- 36:45They are doing AI drug discovery and we have drugs in FDA phase
- 36:51two clinical where they're actually working and helping
- 36:55with the with that. So I'm spending a lot of time,
- 36:58I'm not a shadow CEO there, but I'm, I'm on the board and
- 37:01tapping out. I'm, I'm at Menlo Micro.
- 37:05Menlo micro is a, a MEMS switch. So we have transistors and we
- 37:10have relays MEMS, which sits in the middle.
- 37:13And it's an incredible new technology that we've been
- 37:15working on for 10 years. They've been working on it for
- 37:18almost 40 years to power AI data centers and robots and all these
- 37:23other things. It's absolutely phenomenal thing
- 37:27and helping with the business development, the product plans,
- 37:30the the strategy, the financing, that kind of stuff.
- 37:34Let's see, what else am I working with?
- 37:37I'm doing. I was just doing some VR work
- 37:40this morning. Oh, really?
- 37:41Yeah. Are you a believer in VRI?
- 37:43Believe in I believe I fucked the metaverse.
- 37:47I believe in VR for episodic B to B and some gaming, but
- 37:55episodic. So you're not living in it.
- 37:57Like, you know, if some people are saying you're going to live
- 37:59in it, it's like, no. But where it's collaborative,
- 38:02it's high value and mostly B to B Sure, there's gaming and
- 38:06that's a fringe, you know, it's big, but it's still a fringe in
- 38:09from my perspective. But where you're doing design
- 38:12online. So we're in a company called
- 38:13Gravity Sketch, OK, And Gravity Sketch is the number one.
- 38:17Think of it as Figma in the in the VR world where you're doing
- 38:21collaborative design in a 3D space and you can do markups,
- 38:26you can create in it. And we're at all the biggest
- 38:28companies where it's the Lannis, Nike, the Ford.
- 38:31Everybody uses us to do car design, shoe design, furniture
- 38:35design. So, so I believe in it for that.
- 38:37So they have teams of people wearing headsets, doing this for
- 38:40an hour or something, getting in it, coming out, you know, or
- 38:43reviewing cars or whatever. And I believe in VR for that for
- 38:46sure. But for most of the stuff that
- 38:48was pitched by, you know, Meta and Apple, I don't, I don't
- 38:52believe in it at all because I've been working on VR since
- 38:541988 and I've seen the issues with it.
- 38:58This is circling back to some of the the big themes, excuse me,
- 39:01some of the big themes of this conversation, like what company
- 39:05do you think is best positioned to produce like a new iPad scale
- 39:11device? Like someone like what if you
- 39:13had to make a prediction about a company producing an advice that
- 39:17reaches our culture at that scale?
- 39:19Who are you betting on? Hopefully Apple makes the iPad
- 39:24phone or the iPhone pad which is basically a foldable iPhone.
- 39:29Okay, okay, yeah, yeah, bring the benefits of the iPad to the.
- 39:32IPad just bring the foldable stuff and it's been bandied
- 39:35about and stuff like that, but the operating system is that OS
- 39:40new. Device or.
- 39:42I, I think it's a meaningful segment for Apple to continue to
- 39:45grow and, and to make sure that they don't lose market share to
- 39:48people with foldables. But I do think there's a lot of
- 39:51use cases where if you can carry with you everywhere and you can
- 39:54open it, especially in some cases with AI, that it could be
- 39:59pretty powerful, right, right. Because an iPad, you just can't
- 40:02slip in your pocket. You want a pocketable.
- 40:05You know, kind of iPad experience where you can use
- 40:08voice so you don't need a keyboard, all that stuff to
- 40:11interact with. It could be pretty pretty damn
- 40:13cool. What is that what you would
- 40:16focus on if you were Apple CEO? I have many things that I would
- 40:22do if I was well. All right, give us some of them.
- 40:25Give you some of them. Yeah.
- 40:29Well, the first thing I think they really flubbed on was
- 40:31mobility. You know, there was the Apple
- 40:33Car and we all know that that was a real thing and they killed
- 40:35it. But there's other ways of.
- 40:36Doing that, you think they should have kept going?
- 40:38No, no, no. No, Apple shouldn't.
- 40:40Apple is a company that redefines certain it's certain
- 40:46aspects of life. It redefined what it was to be
- 40:50desktop publishing, right? Or publishing in general.
- 40:52It redefined music. It redefined various things.
- 40:55So they should redefine mobility.
- 40:58Don't make a four wheel car that competes with everybody else and
- 41:01the Chinese. How would you change mobility in
- 41:05two in three and lightweight 4 wheel vehicles?
- 41:08How do you do that that the kids are like at 14 can use and go.
- 41:13I want to keep using it right. Don't not a a lucid blah, blah,
- 41:18blah for just you know, you got to think, you know, when when
- 41:22Steve Jobs and I would walk around the Apple campus back in
- 41:252000, 1008 nine, we talked about the Apple car.
- 41:28What would it be? And he was really like we need
- 41:31to do. He thought it was revolutionary
- 41:34was the Volkswagen, right? The the people's wagon, the
- 41:37people's car. And he was like, what's the
- 41:39people's car? What's the next generation
- 41:41people's car? What's going to be used in the
- 41:43cities? And now you're seeing the Fiat
- 41:45Topolino, you see the the Twizzy, you see all these
- 41:48different things. I live in Europe, right?
- 41:49So you see all this stuff running around and they're
- 41:51selling out like crazy. And you're like that Apple or
- 41:54two wheels Apple or three wheels Apple?
- 41:58And so you would say go keep working on that vehicle, work on
- 42:01this vehicle vision. I think that's only one thing.
- 42:06I think that's one. I think mobility is something
- 42:08that should be addressed and Apple could address it in a very
- 42:11different way than it and has all kinds of brands that has the
- 42:14technology, all that stuff. This other thing is I think it's
- 42:17a red herring and it's more or less a me too kind of thing.
- 42:21Frankly, I think that the their accessories line up could go
- 42:24much, much, you know, they could lean in much more into that.
- 42:27Lots of things to be done around that.
- 42:29Obviously glasses like more, you know.
- 42:30Rainer, or the aesthetic piece of it, or.
- 42:33The no, no, just usability, no, no aesthetics, No, no, no, no,
- 42:35no. We're talking about new markets,
- 42:38new things that they could. Go after Aura directly.
- 42:41Sure. You know, like duh.
- 42:44Are you bullish on Aura right now?
- 42:46I got one on, you know, to do truth be told, No, no, to be
- 42:50truth be told, I was invested in the company before Aura.
- 42:54It was called Motive. We made the first smart ring.
- 42:57We had all of the patents, all the fundamentals and everything.
- 43:02And the team who was from Apple just wanted to do something
- 43:05other than a ring. After they got the ring, I'm
- 43:07like, guys focus on the business and they're like, no, we want to
- 43:10make, you know, some other wearable.
- 43:11I'm like, no, focus on the business.
- 43:13So they lost it and then what happened?
- 43:15Aura ended up buying all of our patents.
- 43:18I. Didn't know that so so to me,
- 43:21like we were doing the we were doing it four years before Aura
- 43:24did. And now my team from Nest is the
- 43:26marketing team at Aura, which I love those guys and they're
- 43:29doing great. I just wish we would have motive
- 43:31would have been it instead of. Is Apple supposed to be thinking
- 43:33about a ring right now or? If they're not, they'd be crazy
- 43:36they if they weren't, and it's so easy for them to do.
- 43:38They have all the chip like the house aura doesn't have chip
- 43:41guys. They don't have all that.
- 43:42So they have everything they need to make an incredible ring
- 43:46like duh, and they have all the all the the composites for, you
- 43:49know, the materials, everything like it is a no brainer.
- 43:52It's just like the pin no brainers to do.
- 43:54They have everything they need to.
- 43:56They just need to have the gumption to get it out and do
- 43:59it. It's really simple.
- 44:00What are other accessories? I think there's smarter ways of,
- 44:05you know, making a Airpod that has an iPod in it.
- 44:11So I think they need to bring back the iPod.
- 44:13OK, I like this because people don't want to have their phone
- 44:16with them all the time. Well.
- 44:17There's two reasons. One is there's the nostalgic
- 44:19value of everybody who got into Apple, a lot of them got in
- 44:22because of the iPod, right, Right.
- 44:24So people want don't want the they would like the nostalgic.
- 44:28For my first Apple device. Yeah, most people is because at
- 44:31the time of the iPod 1% market share in the US only, not around
- 44:36the world. So most people and there was no
- 44:38Apple retail, so most people's device because they didn't have
- 44:41a Mac and they didn't buy a Mac, right, because they had APC.
- 44:45So they had to get an Apple device and was most likely an
- 44:47iPod. So iPod from the systalgic point
- 44:50of view for all those people who's like, oh, I remember the
- 44:52iPod, but they don't want distractions anymore, right?
- 44:56They want they don't want distractions.
- 44:58The third thing? Sorry, sorry Apple, who doesn't
- 45:00want distraction? Well, a lot of people want that
- 45:03pure missile. So the music player.
- 45:05Who was? I just bought a record player so
- 45:07I'm deep in this, right? Did you see what Sony?
- 45:09Did this week, No. Sony killed their TV's and sold
- 45:13it to TCL and they went back to the turntables.
- 45:17They just released 2 new turntables.
- 45:20They kill the TV's and they bring back turntables.
- 45:23You tell me. So is there a nostalgia element
- 45:26for the iPod? I think so.
- 45:28I'm. Sorry, is the iPod in this
- 45:29vision software or it's a hardware device?
- 45:32You're saying? Where does it?
- 45:34What format? It's I don't want to give away
- 45:36all my stuff. But you're saving this.
- 45:39Has anybody talked to you about it?
- 45:41You know, there was obviously reporting about, you know, the
- 45:43next CEO and your name was, you know, bandied about.
- 45:45Has anyone done any feelers or you're like I got to hold back?
- 45:49I've got a lot of incoming I, I, I, let me, I want to just say
- 45:52thank you to those, those ex Apple employees and those
- 45:56current Apple employees who have reached out and have tried to
- 45:58canvas me and try to get me involved.
- 46:01You know, Apple will make the right decision when they need to
- 46:03about who the next CEO is. I love the company.
- 46:07It's been in my blood since 198081 when I my first Apple
- 46:11two. You know, it's it's been the
- 46:13thing since since I was 11 to 11.
- 46:16If anyone calls, you know, from the board or Tim calls, right,
- 46:20I'll be happy to pick up the phone right, and that's it.
- 46:23I'll, I'll help them any way they think they they, they would
- 46:25like to be helped, right? The accessory, that's a great,
- 46:31I'm fascinated by that and then. There's all the things they
- 46:33should do. There's a whole another product
- 46:35category there, so, but we'll leave that for.
- 46:37Later, OK. We'll leave that for later.
- 46:39What I mean the the found the the the labs, the foundation
- 46:42model companies. What's your what's your read on
- 46:45Open AI Anthropic Xai I? Know you want to go there, Yeah.
- 46:49Yeah, of course, this is a big technology question of the day.
- 46:52Are they great businesses? I guess that's the first grade.
- 46:54Are they good businesses? They have to really target
- 46:57applications to be great business because platforms,
- 46:59platforms are not businesses. Applications are great business
- 47:03and that was proven. The last great platform business
- 47:06was Windows 95, you know, or Windows.
- 47:09There's been no platform business other than that.
- 47:13OK, so you could call maybe AWS or you know, Google or whatever,
- 47:18but that's AB to B thing. It's not a, it's really about
- 47:21applications, not platforms. So, so when you look, you stack
- 47:26up, open AI, Google Anthropic, you know, Mistral, you can pick,
- 47:31you know, whoever is. And then let's talk about the
- 47:32Chinese and even the Koreans and stuff like that.
- 47:36Look, there is a point and Dario's doing a great job at
- 47:43Anthropic turning it into a real business and coding, because
- 47:49it's so language focused is an incredible application for an
- 47:54LLM, right? And we're seeing that, right.
- 47:56It's just crazy with now they're, you know, they're non
- 48:00coding version of it of Claude as well as the coding version.
- 48:04I'm using it now I'm playing, I'm like, Oh my God, I'm so I'm
- 48:08getting back into coding. I haven't done coding in years.
- 48:10I'm not a coder but I yeah I got the desktop version.
- 48:13It's a little. I feel like I don't have files
- 48:15so I'm a little confused as a user that I have stuff on Google
- 48:18that I want them to use which I think I need to use in their web
- 48:20browser stuff. I mean, these are I.
- 48:23Must say, look, I must say that they have a whole set of
- 48:28application stuff and training because it still feels like it's
- 48:31a GitHub model for Claude, like it's very giddy.
- 48:35And that's, and if you look at if you look at that, it's a very
- 48:41small number of people. They have to come from a
- 48:43different way to get people involved.
- 48:45And it's still not approachable. Like I'm like still like
- 48:47confused when I'm using it or when I'm even installing it and
- 48:50trying to run it like what? OK, terminal this like how many
- 48:53people do that? There's other ways of getting
- 48:55around that and they're gonna, I'm sure they'll get there.
- 48:57There's just no way they're not. But again, they're doing a great
- 49:01job of really focusing and figuring out that stuff around,
- 49:04coding around that's guard rails, all those things.
- 49:08And they're trying to get to profitability so that they are a
- 49:12real standing business. So I commend them for all that
- 49:15they're doing. They're, you know, they were EXA
- 49:17open AI people, right? And everything And they really
- 49:19are targeting. So that's really great.
- 49:22Then we go to Open AI. Open AI right now is spray and
- 49:26pray. Right.
- 49:27Spray and pray. Look, this week it was rumored
- 49:32and I'm sure it was a very strong rumor they're trying to
- 49:34reach $50 billion, right, 50 billion.
- 49:38Just a few months ago it was 5 billion and just before that it
- 49:41was 500 million. I don't think unless you've been
- 49:44in the market and understand this is massive amounts of
- 49:47capital that even large fortune 5 hundreds can't get access to
- 49:51like and So what I the game I believe Sam is playing, and it's
- 49:56a really dangerous game, is too big to fail.
- 49:59He's getting every single person to give that money, including
- 50:03large governments and everything else.
- 50:05So they're too big to fail, right?
- 50:08Well, this was the whole Sarah Fryer backstop.
- 50:11Yeah, yeah, the back, that backstop, which he was like, no,
- 50:13no, and they're backpedaling it, but.
- 50:14They they've written stuff that's.
- 50:16Just you don't think they're not having those discussions at open
- 50:18AI? Like, yeah, these governments
- 50:20will backstop us at some point because we're going to crash
- 50:22everything, the semiconductors that they're, you know,
- 50:25everything. So so I think it's a incredibly
- 50:29dangerous game they're playing and with especially with the
- 50:32circular deals and everything. Is there a there there?
- 50:36I believe there's a there there, but Google's gonna win it,
- 50:39right? Google has everything from the
- 50:41chips to the data centers to the all the way to the applications
- 50:45and tons of data for all this stuff.
- 50:47I wish they had a better devices team.
- 50:49It sucks there. I'll go whatever, but at the end
- 50:54of the day, they have all the things necessary and plus an ad
- 50:59business that can fund billions of dollars 1/4 and distribution.
- 51:03You know, it's just it's everywhere.
- 51:05It's like it's it's. Funny, I feel like there's so
- 51:07many AI haters that, you know, they obviously Google things and
- 51:10so then they'll get the AI results from Google.
- 51:13And so I feel like there's or, you know, Gemini's fundamentally
- 51:15delivering the results. So there's this weird world
- 51:18where people hate AI and still use it all the time via Google,
- 51:22which is just I. I I hear what you're saying.
- 51:25You know, there, there's this, it's more like I I hate what
- 51:28it's going to do to the world. I mean, I hate, but I it works
- 51:31for me, you know, so I think there's a little dissonance
- 51:34there. But but you know, I have to
- 51:37credit Sundar, you know, and the team that they've had an
- 51:40existential crisis and I think they cleaned up the culture
- 51:44enough. I'm sure it's not fully clean,
- 51:45but enough to say we have an existential crisis.
- 51:48We're going to get to work. We got to go back clean up was.
- 51:52Too casual? And sort of it was too casual to
- 51:55you know, we, you remember the first things of Gemini that came
- 51:58out. We can't blah, blah, blah.
- 52:00And we saved, you know, in the in the MAGA words woke, right,
- 52:04too safe and too like, you know, right, right, right.
- 52:08Well, you could, but you could you're like, come on, right.
- 52:12So I so do you. Have a read on whether how much
- 52:16Sergei really gets credit or what the internal dynamics are
- 52:19there in terms of who's really drawing.
- 52:21Well, I hear a little bit. I don't really want to comment.
- 52:23It's, it's, it's, it's look at the results.
- 52:26The results are sure they fumble a few times, but they're,
- 52:29they're locked in and engaged and they're, and so I, I have to
- 52:33give them every credit for turning the ship.
- 52:35I you know, it was a big, it's a huge ship at Google, but it
- 52:39feels like it's really going in the direction.
- 52:41And sometimes it does take a near death experience to get the
- 52:46best out of people. Right.
- 52:47I say that's the only way you change cultures is through a
- 52:49near death experience. Do you think they'll innovate or
- 52:53using? I mean they, you know, they
- 52:54wrote the attention. Genesis is amazing.
- 52:57Demis is incredibly smart and and he was like, they were the
- 53:01ones who came up with this. I know, of course.
- 53:03So now it's just it's playing a game of ketchup, right.
- 53:06But it's a it's it's really David and Goliath open AM might
- 53:10have a lot of cash, but they don't have anywhere near the
- 53:13resources. And now today, like here's
- 53:15here's the thing that's really interesting and people don't, a
- 53:19lot of people don't realize this is that if you look at where
- 53:23open air is trying to make its money and where Google is making
- 53:29its money today, and you say, oh, and Anthropic's making it
- 53:35Anthropic's very applications, right?
- 53:39Or API? You're saying the API business
- 53:40and coding? Yeah.
- 53:42Well, API, good coding, that kind of thing.
- 53:44Then there's, and they're doing that and they're going to get
- 53:47there. Open AI is doing everything
- 53:49like, you know, they're, they're picking out, OK, we're going to
- 53:52worry about, you know, when they just announced health and then
- 53:56they announced this. They're doing whatever it takes
- 53:58to get more application specific.
- 54:00And now they're announcing ads, right?
- 54:02They're doing like again, spray and pray to hope to go because
- 54:06people they can get only so many people to pay a $20.00 or $200
- 54:11or whatever it is. And so they have to get to this
- 54:13ad model to get more revenue to come in.
- 54:17The Chinese are doing this so smart.
- 54:20Well, maybe because they don't have the NVIDIA chips, but I
- 54:23always like resource constrained environments because you're more
- 54:26creative. So if you look at DeepSeek, if
- 54:28you look at these other things and they're open source, the
- 54:33profits of open AI today or not profits, I should say, just
- 54:37revenues of open AI today. If those open source models or a
- 54:41meta model, it becomes reality and they're close enough.
- 54:46And I know a lot of developers using the Chinese models or
- 54:49other open source models. And if Open AI doesn't get there
- 54:55at the application side, they're going.
- 54:58Everything in the middle's gone. They don't have data centers.
- 55:00They don't depend. On a persistent technological
- 55:03advantage in such a correct. And what you're gonna, what I
- 55:05believe you're gonna see is application and to
- 55:08infrastructure. That's where it's gonna set.
- 55:10And in the middle, it's gonna be just a, it's gonna be like
- 55:13everyone's got, you know, openness and open that and
- 55:16there's gonna be no real money in it.
- 55:18And that's why people are saying there's no money in SAS anymore.
- 55:20So you're gonna see, oddly enough, infrastructure and scale
- 55:24and application is where the capturing the customer or
- 55:28capturing the platform is gonna be.
- 55:30And that's where I believe where we're headed.
- 55:33And opening is stuck here because they don't have any
- 55:35data. They've been very clear they
- 55:37don't want it, but they're not here.
- 55:39And you already have Google up here at the apps, you have Clot
- 55:42or a Tropic there and maybe one day Apple up there.
- 55:45So it's pretty don't. You think like general purpose
- 55:47assistant is an application, I mean to defend open AI?
- 55:51They have all this context on me, you know, the longer I use
- 55:54it. Google has much more.
- 55:56Apple has. Much more drifting, but yeah,
- 55:59they have much more. And that's why they want a
- 56:00device. That's why they need all, you
- 56:01know, these things to sort of have this whole picture.
- 56:04They need the context. They, you know, people are
- 56:08saying they should make a phone, but then they have, then there's
- 56:10an Android phone because they don't have enough.
- 56:12Well, maybe they can find more money, but they're bleeding
- 56:15money. The other thing that people
- 56:17don't realize is as they add more capacity, as they bring on
- 56:20more data centers, they're all each of those users is more
- 56:25negative money that they have to spend to keep those users,
- 56:30right. So as they scale up and they
- 56:33don't have a revenue out, they're losing more money per
- 56:36user because they're getting more.
- 56:37Users, it's the old ride sharing days.
- 56:39So we'll make it up in volume. We're net, we're unit economics
- 56:42are negative, but we'll make it up in volume.
- 56:44It's like, no you won't. I mean, do you think Open AI
- 56:46goes bankrupt? I look, if they're asking for
- 56:49$50 billion now, like how fast you gonna burn through that?
- 56:55We haven't talked about XAI. Do you have a view on that?
- 56:57Look, Elon plays a very, very different game.
- 57:01You know, he started with he he started with Tesla.
- 57:05Then it was Twitter that turned into X and now Twitter or X is
- 57:10part of Tesla. And then he was doing data
- 57:13center stuff and now that's going to be part of Tesla.
- 57:15And now he wants to make. And what I heard latest is, is
- 57:19SpaceX is not going to go public.
- 57:21SpaceX is going to get bought by Tesla.
- 57:23Yeah, I think I made a prediction maybe on this
- 57:26podcast. Yeah, I think, I mean clearly
- 57:28so. He's just rolling up and just
- 57:30becoming a conglomerate. Are you saying no?
- 57:32It's sort of House of Cards, always the next thing.
- 57:35Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh no, I'm missing his House of
- 57:37Cards. SpaceX is an incredible.
- 57:38Business, OK. Incredible business.
- 57:40Tesla would be much better off if Elon didn't do what Elon did
- 57:45a year ago, right, Right. So that was.
- 57:47Which is like lose focus and go do well no.
- 57:50Be in politics and then piss off the world.
- 57:52And everyone said I'm not buying that product because I tainted
- 57:54the brand, right? Right.
- 57:56So the The thing is, it's like, OK, I need money to keep Tesla
- 58:00alive, right? OK, I'm going to put SpaceX in,
- 58:03raise a bunch of money off SpaceX and make because the
- 58:06Tesla stock's going to come up. And so I'll be able to continue
- 58:09to float Tesla. You know what I mean?
- 58:11With money, right? So that's how that works.
- 58:15He ultimately needs to protect his investors because this whole
- 58:17thing only works if he's like, well, he's going to look out for
- 58:20me somehow, you know, he'll acquire Solar City some way.
- 58:23He'll do some deal. That next thing works out and
- 58:25like whatever good idea he has will save the rest.
- 58:30But but you don't but like Xai you don't see as sort of a big.
- 58:33Part of that I, I think Xai look, he's, he's going to, he's
- 58:37doing what he does with Xai. It can be something you know,
- 58:41again, now we're doing, you know, you know, what is it de
- 58:47robing people on? And then it's like, I didn't
- 58:50know. And it's like now we have
- 58:513,000,000 images of illegal images running around.
- 58:54So, you know, there's this kind of skirting back and forth like
- 58:58we just play within the Gray area of the law and then we pull
- 59:02back just like self driving is gonna be up and running 10 years
- 59:06ago. And he makes everyone pay.
- 59:07But yeah, no one gets delivered what they were, right?
- 59:11So he gets somehow gets away with everything.
- 59:14I'm playing just the line. As a leader, you know, we sort
- 59:17of touched on how woke potentially killed Google.
- 59:20Now we're in this sort of like nihilist period.
- 59:23Where do you think tech should aspire to be in terms of having
- 59:27some meaning underpinning what what they're building right now?
- 59:31Well, look, I'm, I'm an optimist and I'm also a guy who, you
- 59:35know, maybe I couldn't play in this game because I'm much more
- 59:38of the high moral standards, high ethics, high.
- 59:41You know, when I say you're going to be my partner, you're
- 59:44my partner and we work together on stuff, not open AI and I'm
- 59:48going to partner with everyone and we're exclusive, but we're
- 59:50not, you know, that's, you know, that's kind of today's social
- 59:53media dating scheme, you know, so, so I think that, you know, I
- 59:58don't know if I I always ask myself all the time, I'm like.
- 1:00:02How would Steve Jobs fare in this environment if he was here?
- 1:00:06Well, what do you think? I don't.
- 1:00:07I don't. Have an answer?
- 1:00:08Do you think you would be in the White House?
- 1:00:10You know, you sort of have to. I have no idea I think.
- 1:00:12Gavin Newsom said something fairly charitable about Tim
- 1:00:15Cook, which is sort of, you know, he has to, he has to play
- 1:00:18the game, but it's hard to know if Steve Jobs would have.
- 1:00:24You know, I, I knowing what I know and working alongside him
- 1:00:30for a decade, I don't think he would have played, but I don't
- 1:00:33know this I I played along, but I don't know.
- 1:00:36But so no, really, I think that, you know, I think Dario's doing
- 1:00:42a great job. He got in front of Davos saying,
- 1:00:45you know, this is BS, this is not right.
- 1:00:47This is not Redeemis got up and saying LLMS aren't the thing,
- 1:00:51you know, and there's more to come.
- 1:00:53So I think we need more leaders like that because we have too
- 1:00:56many, you know, people with questionable value systems
- 1:01:01running these things and, and, you know, I wish they were there
- 1:01:05or they were more vocal because Tim's a great guy.
- 1:01:09Tim's got high high values, you know I.
- 1:01:12Mean, I agree with you. I mean Dario, they just
- 1:01:14anthropic just released a constitution for saw that
- 1:01:17thought where it's like they're being extremely thoughtful.
- 1:01:19I tweeted, It's like in a moment of anti intellectualism, here
- 1:01:21they are. It's like, let's have some
- 1:01:23philosophy PHD's academics, you know, think through within a
- 1:01:27real principled way. Like, I really admire what
- 1:01:29they're doing. I think when a lot of investors
- 1:01:31and a lot of people get burned by this thing that's we're in
- 1:01:35right now, there's gonna be like a lot of naval gazing going.
- 1:01:39What did we do right? What do we wrong?
- 1:01:41You're always gonna have that Wall Street Wolf of Wall Street
- 1:01:44mentality and everybody's playing.
- 1:01:45But I remember that in 9899 too, when it all fell out and then
- 1:01:50great companies like Google really came into play, Right?
- 1:01:53Right. So we'll see what happens.
- 1:01:55I don't know. This has been a great
- 1:01:56conversation. Last one last question.
- 1:01:59We've touched on a lot of devices.
- 1:02:01I mean, if you were, you know, I don't know, the smart engineer
- 1:02:04kid out of college, like, I want to make my name in devices.
- 1:02:07Like where would you point him or her?
- 1:02:10Like what is the sort of device area that said OK, make a bet on
- 1:02:13this for the next two decades? Understand the application
- 1:02:18really, really well and understand if you even need
- 1:02:20hardware. See, we have more than enough
- 1:02:23hardware and all kinds of different things.
- 1:02:25It's going to be a federation of things with a really smart
- 1:02:29software thing. So don't think of just
- 1:02:32mechanical and devices. You got to think system and you
- 1:02:36got to think Federated of devices to really get to the
- 1:02:39next level of what is going to happen.
- 1:02:42All this other stuff is all kind of features, not a product.
- 1:02:46I know that I said that was the last question.
- 1:02:48I have to like, I love my iPhone.
- 1:02:50I use it all the time. But don't you get we get sick of
- 1:02:52looking at it or it's like you're looking at the phone too
- 1:02:54much. Do you think in in two decades,
- 1:02:56like we're still going to be using like a?
- 1:02:59Here, which is proceeds in our ears and then and when we put
- 1:03:02the phone in our pocket, it'll know the context and it'll just
- 1:03:04start talking to us and then. More listening, less screen
- 1:03:07time. Yeah.
- 1:03:08You know, are there going to be different forms?
- 1:03:10These are open ear, over the ear, in the ear.
- 1:03:12The nose cancellation is great. OK, great.
- 1:03:14You're going to have the glasses.
- 1:03:16So we have enough of the forms they need to be pulled together
- 1:03:20with smarter software and better things to get them to do what
- 1:03:23they need. What?
- 1:03:25Headphones do. You use these are nothings.
- 1:03:26Oh, OK, these are nothing 3 as I got the over the ear, the over
- 1:03:30the headphone ones. Yeah, and and also the the
- 1:03:33opens. I love them, absolutely love
- 1:03:35them. Tony Fidel, this has been
- 1:03:36awesome. Thanks so much for doing this
- 1:03:37with me. Yeah, great.
- 1:03:38Thanks. Thanks a lot, Eric.
- 1:03:39Thank you for tuning in to this week's episode of the podcast.
- 1:03:42If you're new here, please like and subscribe.
- 1:03:44It really helps out the channel. Listen in for new episodes every
- 1:03:46week, wherever you get your podcasts.