Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Are Using Insider Selling Windows
Transcript
- Lucas: So Bending Spoons had its first day of trading yesterday, July first, and it surged 40 percent on an eighteen billion dollar IPO. That's a huge pop. But here's what I find interesting — the conversation around that IPO has been all about the company's business model, which is fine, but nobody's talking about what happens next for the insiders who just got a lot richer on paper. Luna: You're talking about the lockup period and when they can actually sell, right? Lucas: Exactly. The lockup is typically 180 days for a traditional IPO. But more and more post ipo companies are being strategic about how they structure insider selling windows — not just the lockup, but the windows after that. And it matters because the way insiders sell can make or break the stock's trajectory in the first year. Luna: Give me an example. How does a company like Bending Spoons think about this? Lucas: Well, let's start with the lockup itself. The standard lockup prevents founders, executives, and early investors from selling any shares for a set period — usually 180 days. But some companies are now using shorter lockups, like 90 days, to signal confidence. The idea is: 'We're not afraid of the market sooner.' But if you shorten the lockup too much, you risk a wave of selling right after the IPO, which tanks the stock. Luna: So it's a balancing act. You don't want to lock people up so long that they're desperate to sell the day it ends, but you also don't want a flood of shares hitting the market right away. Lucas: Right. And that's where insider selling windows come in. After the lockup, companies typically have blackout periods around earnings — insiders can't trade during those — and then open windows after earnings are released. But sophisticated companies are now designing those windows deliberately. For example, they might open a window for just a few days, or they might stagger windows for different groups of insiders. Luna: I've seen some companies use Rule 10b5-1 plans to schedule sales automatically. That way, insiders can sell a predetermined number of shares at predetermined times, and it doesn't look like they're timing the market. Lucas: That's a huge piece of it. Rule 10b5-1 plans were designed to let insiders trade without the appearance of insider trading. But in the post ipo context, they're also a communication tool. If a founder sets up a 10b5-1 plan to sell a significant chunk over the next year, the market reads that as a signal. It can be a negative signal if the plan is aggressive — like selling 20 percent of their stake — or a neutral signal if it's modest. Luna: So what's the current trend? Are we seeing more or less insider selling in the first year after an IPO? Lucas: According to data from the first half of 2026, about 70 percent of new IPOs have at least one insider selling within the first six months after the lockup expires. That's up from about 55 percent five years ago. And the volume is increasing too. The average insider sells about 15 percent of their stake in that first year. Luna: I wonder if that's partly because the IPO market has been so strong. Companies like Bending Spoons are coming out at high valuations, and insiders want to lock in gains. But if too many sell too fast, it could spook the market. Lucas: That's exactly the risk. And that's why we're seeing more companies use secondary offerings — where the company itself sells shares on behalf of insiders — as a way to manage the process. Instead of insiders selling individually on the open market, the company does a single offering, often at a slight discount, and the shares are absorbed by institutional investors. It's cleaner and less disruptive. Luna: Right, and that sends a different signal. If the company orchestrates a secondary offering, it looks like a planned event. If insiders sell on the open market, it can look like they're bailing. Lucas: Exactly. And there's another layer: the timing of these secondary offerings relative to earnings. A company might schedule a secondary right after a strong earnings report, when the stock is up, to maximize the price insiders get. That's what some of the big tech companies have done. For example, Apple, which trades at around 294 dollars today, has seen insiders sell over one point two billion dollars worth of stock in the past quarter alone — but mostly through pre-planned 10b5-1 plans. Luna: So Apple insiders are selling, but it's not a panic. It's just diversification. That's a key distinction for investors to understand: insider selling isn't automatically bad. It depends on the context. Lucas: Right. The context is everything. If you see a CEO selling 90 percent of their stake right after the lockup expires, that's a red flag. But if they're selling a small percentage on a regular schedule, that's just normal portfolio management. The problem is that many retail investors don't distinguish between the two. Luna: So what should a post ipo company do to educate the market about its insider selling windows? Is there a best practice? Lucas: The best practice is transparency. Companies should disclose their insider trading policies clearly in the IPO prospectus and then in their quarterly filings. They should also announce any 10b5-1 plans proactively. Some companies now include a dedicated 'Insider Trading' section in their investor relations page. And they train their investor relations team to answer questions about insider selling on earnings calls. Luna: That's interesting. I've heard of companies getting ahead of the narrative by framing insider selling as part of the founders' long-term financial planning. For example, 'Our CEO is selling 5 percent of his stake to diversify his personal holdings and pay taxes.' That seems to work. Lucas: It does. And it's honest. The key is to avoid surprises. If the market expects an insider to sell, it's much less disruptive than if a filing suddenly appears showing a huge sale. That's why the smartest post ipo companies map out their insider selling windows months in advance and communicate them clearly. Luna: Let's talk about the Bending Spoons case specifically. They had that huge pop yesterday. What would you expect their insider selling strategy to look like? Lucas: Given the size of the IPO — eighteen billion dollars — and the 40 percent first-day gain, insiders are sitting on enormous paper profits. I would expect a 180-day lockup, but with a secondary offering in the works for shortly after the lockup expires. That way, they can sell a significant block of shares in an orderly way, and the market can absorb it without a panic. Luna: And if they don't do that, what's the risk? Lucas: The risk is that when the lockup expires, a bunch of insiders sell at once, and the stock drops 20 percent in a week. We've seen that happen with other high-profile IPOs. Remember when a certain social media company's lockup expired and the stock lost half its value in a month? That's the nightmare scenario. Luna: Yeah, I remember that. So it's in the company's interest to manage the process. But what about smaller IPOs? Do they have the resources to do secondary offerings? Lucas: Often not. Smaller companies might rely on 10b5-1 plans or even just hope that insiders sell gradually. But the trend is toward more structure, even for smaller IPOs. Investment banks now offer 'lockup advisory' services to help companies plan the windows. It's becoming a standard part of the IPO prep. Luna: That makes sense. It's really about managing the signal. And speaking of signals, I noticed that among the Magnificent Seven, insider selling has picked up this quarter. Microsoft insiders have sold about 800 million dollars worth, and Tesla insiders over a billion. Lucas: Right, but those are mostly through 10b5-1 plans. The market barely reacts because it's expected. That's the goal for any post ipo company: make insider selling a non-event. Luna: So if you're an investor in a newly public company, what should you look for? Lucas: First, check the lockup period length. Shorter lockups can be a positive signal, but not always. Second, look for any announced secondary offerings or large 10b5-1 plans. Third, pay attention to the pattern of insider sales after the lockup. If it's gradual and consistent, that's fine. If it's a spike, dig deeper. Luna: And if you're a founder or executive at a post ipo company, what's your top piece of advice? Lucas: Plan your windows before you go public. Don't wait until the lockup is about to expire. And communicate your plan to investors. The worst thing you can do is surprise the market with a flood of insider sales. A little transparency goes a long way. Luna: You know, speaking of transparency and planning, this kind of analysis is exactly why we do these shows. And if you find these conversations useful for what you're building or running, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps them going. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Yeah, it really does make a difference. We keep the show ad-free and focused on the stuff that matters — like insider selling windows — and listener support is what makes that possible. So thank you to everyone who chips in. Luna: Absolutely. So back to the topic — I want to ask about one more thing. What about companies that use share buybacks to offset the dilution from insider selling? Is that a common strategy? Lucas: It is, and it's a smart one. If insiders are selling, the company can repurchase shares in the open market to keep the share count stable. That's what some mature tech companies do. But for post ipo companies with limited cash, it's harder. They might use a buyback program funded by the IPO proceeds, but that's rare. More often, they just let the dilution happen and hope the market doesn't care. Luna: And does the market care? I mean, if the company is growing fast, maybe it doesn't matter. Lucas: In my experience, the market cares more about the signal than the actual dilution. If a founder sells a big chunk but the company is beating earnings, investors look the other way. But if the company is struggling and insiders are selling, that's a double whammy. So the key is to time the sales with good news. Luna: That's a good note to end on. Plan ahead, communicate, and align insider sales with strong performance. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. That's all for this episode of Tech IPO Conversations.