Latest / Film And Whiskey / West Side Story (1961) / Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban Single Malt Scotch ft. Patrick H. Willems
Transcript
- 0:00In 1961, MGM Studios gave us a colorful mirage of dancing in
- 0:06delight that hid within it a deeply dramatic story that
- 0:10touched the nerve of the American public.
- 0:13In 2026 we try a whiskey finished in pork barrels so Ruby
- 0:19red they match the hues of this film.
- 0:22Brad. The film is West Side Story.
- 0:26The whiskey is Glenn Moringy, Quinta Rubin.
- 0:29And we'll review them both. This.
- 0:31Is the film and whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:54podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:57glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:00I'm Brad Gee. And this week, Brad, we are
- 1:03looking at a movie that I could not be more excited to talk
- 1:07about, 1961's West Side Story. I, I don't, I was going to try
- 1:14to like bury the lead a little bit here, Brad.
- 1:17I don't think it's possible for me to do that.
- 1:19Played a little, played a little dour.
- 1:22Yeah, I'm not going to. I'm not going to do it.
- 1:23I have to just get my feelings on this movie out immediately
- 1:26and we can just interrogate them as we go because.
- 1:29I I expect that you'll just like, burst out and dance then,
- 1:31correct? I was going to jump and reach
- 1:35for the sky as I did this, but you know, I'm seated, So what?
- 1:37What are you going to do? A couple years ago, the BFI
- 1:42Sight and Sound Pull was released for this decade and for
- 1:46some reason they did not ask for my list or input on that.
- 1:50So I was a little bummed. But in the wake of that, there's
- 1:53a podcast out there called the Contra Zoom Podcast, and they
- 1:56did a really cool thing where they asked a couple 100 critics
- 1:58and podcast hosts to put their lists in if you were going to
- 2:02give your sight and sounds list. And the more I thought about it,
- 2:05I was like, I want to find 10 films that are representative
- 2:09not just of my love for movies, but of like, everything I think
- 2:13cinema can accomplish. And I got real heady.
- 2:17And like, the French New Wave worshipped John Ford.
- 2:20Like, like, that's what I was thinking about.
- 2:21What kind of movies could I bow at the altar of?
- 2:25And the more I thought about it, the more I was like, I think
- 2:281961's West Side Story might be one of the 10 greatest films
- 2:33ever made. And it was a shocking conclusion
- 2:36to come to. And then I watched it this time,
- 2:39Brad, And I am absolutely validated and vindicated in that
- 2:43opinion. And that's the gauntlet I'm
- 2:45throwing down for us today, Brad.
- 2:47And if that level of enthusiasm wasn't enough, we felt like we
- 2:52just needed to add to it. Because for a movie as dynamic
- 2:57and just wild and awesome as this, Bob and I can't do it just
- 3:02this alone. So we brought our wonderful,
- 3:05incredible, outstanding friend of the show, Patrick H Williams,
- 3:09on Patrick. Welcome back man guys, it's a a
- 3:13pleasure to be here once again. We're so glad to have.
- 3:17You. This is episode #6 for Patrick.
- 3:21What? We're gonna have to just give
- 3:23you like a 1099 here soon, man. You've been on.
- 3:26Here a lot dude, I, I I was oh, you know what's funny I was
- 3:30thinking about this today I, I, I was reminded of my very first
- 3:36appearance on the show, which I believe, correct me if I'm
- 3:40wrong, wasn't even discussing a movie.
- 3:42It was just like an interview about like my at the time,
- 3:46fairly brief career because I've been coming on the show for many
- 3:48years, but I remember you guys sent me it.
- 3:55It was like, you know, obviously, you know, shocker to
- 3:58hear there was whiskey on the episode and you sent me like a
- 4:02collection of it was. I mean this is what we all
- 4:04tasted on the episode, but it was like a a set of a few
- 4:07different whiskeys from 1 brand. I cannot remember the brand.
- 4:10I don't expect you guys to because you've had a lot of
- 4:13whiskey on the show, but but they were like smaller bottles
- 4:17and and I remember one of them was a was a barrel proof and we
- 4:22were all like, oh, wow, this is intense when we'd like take a
- 4:24little sip of it and on my my bar cart in my living room.
- 4:28I still have a bit left in that bottle from the first time I was
- 4:33on the show. Yeah, man, still there.
- 4:37I maybes still good. Does it go bad?
- 4:43I mean, you, it takes a while, yeah.
- 4:46But anyway, it's still it's still there.
- 4:48I saw it there, thought of you guys and happy to be back once
- 4:52again. And also I I just, I just while
- 4:56you were doing the intro, I pour.
- 4:58I opened the bottle of Glenn Morangi Morangi.
- 5:04Do we know which one? Glenn Moringy?
- 5:07It It's it's it's a Scotch, of course.
- 5:10Yeah. Come on.
- 5:11So I opened the bottle of Glenn Moringy and I poured myself a
- 5:14glass. Haven't tried it yet, but I will
- 5:16wait until that part of the show.
- 5:18OK, well, thank you for teasing it.
- 5:20It is a whiskey that we notoriously love and the reason
- 5:24that we're drinking it today, our listeners already know how
- 5:26much we love it. But what we're doing this season
- 5:29of the show, it's season #10 for film and whiskey.
- 5:31So folks, if you're new to the show, welcome in.
- 5:33You picked a banger of an episode to start with.
- 5:36This is the 10th season of the show in which we are revisiting
- 5:39every movie we watched in season #1 because we were little baby
- 5:43podcasters back then. The audio quality is not great.
- 5:46And you know, we've come a long way.
- 5:48We're 350 movies almost in now, Brad.
- 5:51We've done 500 plus whiskeys. I'd like to think that we have a
- 5:54little bit of experience under our belts.
- 5:56So it's time for us to revisit those initial reviews.
- 6:00May I? And that means we get to
- 6:01revisit, please. In Season 1, how did you select
- 6:05these movies? Because when I was looking at
- 6:06the list of like when you sent it over, like, hey, which one do
- 6:09you want to do? I was like, yeah, kind of a
- 6:11random list of movies. Yeah, it's funny you say that
- 6:14'cause it was like I made a list of like 100 or 150 movies that I
- 6:18was like, it was like essential movies for Brad to see.
- 6:21I think it was like 300 movies, Bob.
- 6:23Wait, that that was it? Movies that Brad had not seen
- 6:26that was like, that's exactly. What it is?
- 6:28And then it was a random.org, you know, randomize this list
- 6:32and there's season one baby. We've talked about this because
- 6:35if it was like 2025 when we started the podcast, we would
- 6:39have gone to ChatGPT and been like give us the most marketable
- 6:44mix of 32 from this list and we'll SEO friendly.
- 6:48No, Yeah, we just. You wouldn't do that because
- 6:50you're cool. Well, obviously.
- 6:53We in the in the words of Ice, we keep Cooley Cool Boy and
- 6:59Brad, that is my segue into talking about this movie today.
- 7:02We're talking about West Side Story, a movie about which I
- 7:05have already thrown down this gauntlet.
- 7:07We are going to get to Patrick's thoughts on the movie, but
- 7:10before we get there, we have to get to Brad's thoughts on the
- 7:12movie and that means it's time for our first segment of the
- 7:15day, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 7:18movie plot with only 60 seconds sticking on the clock, so let's
- 7:21go ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call
- 7:25Brad explains. Brad explains is the part of the
- 7:28show where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has
- 7:31just seen often for the first time.
- 7:33Now obviously this is at least Brad's second time seeing this
- 7:37film, seeing as we did it back in 2019.
- 7:40Brad, it's been about seven years since we've watched this
- 7:43movie for the podcast. Have you experienced West Side
- 7:46Story in any capacity in the interim?
- 7:49I came very close to watching the Spielbergian take on it a
- 7:55few years back, but I just never quite got around to it.
- 7:59I still want to watch Spielberg's version.
- 8:04That was what, 21 or 22? One, Yeah. 21, yeah.
- 8:08So I, I need to get back to it. I I have full intentionality to
- 8:11do it. But no, I have not returned to
- 8:13it, although I think of it fondly often.
- 8:17Well, that's good news because I think of it fondly often too,
- 8:19Brad, and I'm I'm holding you to that standard now.
- 8:22Now, what this means is that you have to break down the plot of
- 8:25this movie with full spoilers. So folks, if you have never
- 8:28seen, listened to, heard of West Side Story or the attenuating
- 8:33Broadway musical or the play upon which it is based known as
- 8:37Romeo and Juliet, I would highly recommend that you go
- 8:39familiarize yourself with all those sources and then come back
- 8:42and join us for the rest of this episode.
- 8:44Brad, you get 60 seconds to spoil this movie and go.
- 8:48West Side Story is a film that follows 2 main characters, Tony
- 8:53and Maria, as they try to overcome the division of hatred
- 9:00that exists between Maria's Puerto Rican family and extended
- 9:05family and Tony's Italian gang life.
- 9:10And at the end of it, Tony dies. Wow.
- 9:14I am pretty sure Tony's Polish. They call him a polock at many
- 9:17points they I. Guess they do, but let let's be
- 9:20real on they're all portrayed. I'm just going to say probably
- 9:26not the least problematic ethnic crossing we get in this movie is
- 9:30that Tony looks Italian and is presented as Polish.
- 9:33That's that's a fairly innocuous 1.
- 9:35There's a lot more. So they're they're white guys in
- 9:38New York who talk New Yorkie. And I feel like culturally,
- 9:42everyone just kind of associates that with Italian Americans.
- 9:46Yeah. It's.
- 9:47It's kind of the. Truth.
- 9:48Why aren't these guys wearing wife beaters and gold chains?
- 9:51This doesn't seem. Vigo, Vigo Mortensen from the
- 9:55Green Book. Exactly.
- 9:58You know what, Patrick? This might actually be a good
- 9:59place to start. So this is obviously filmed
- 10:03mostly on sound stages, but there's some key moments where
- 10:06they film in and around the real New York, most notably in the
- 10:10opening montage, which starts by helicoptering over Manhattan and
- 10:15downtown Manhattan and then slowly, slowly, slowly moving
- 10:19out of Manhattan until you get into.
- 10:22It's all set in Manhattan. Oh, is it the West side?
- 10:25OK. So it's the West side of
- 10:26Manhattan? So you so Bob, you've seen the
- 10:29Spielberg? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:32So do you remember it? So the Spielberg remake, again,
- 10:35it's like, it's not like a radical departure, but the the
- 10:40Spielberg remake makes it a little bit more explicit about
- 10:44exactly where it's set because the also I live in New York and
- 10:48so obviously I'm gonna be a bit more familiar with the
- 10:51locations. But the opening shot of the
- 10:55Spielberg version, it starts and I promise I will not talk about
- 11:00the Spielberg one too much, but it starts on like like a bunch
- 11:04of rubble, like a like a building has has been knocked
- 11:06down. Clearly there's like gonna be
- 11:07construction there. And the camera cranes up and
- 11:10passes a sign that says coming soon, Lincoln Center.
- 11:15Yep, this, this all takes place around the Upper West Side of
- 11:21Manhattan, around 66th St. So yeah, it, it is all in
- 11:27Manhattan. This is basically the site of
- 11:29like like the area that was being a lot of it being torn
- 11:33down and was going to be rebuilt as the, you know, pretty fancy
- 11:38like Upper West Side Lincoln Center area, which of course is
- 11:42interesting because Leonard Bernstein, composer is so
- 11:45associated associated with Lincoln Center.
- 11:48And so, yeah, anyway that so basically it starts lower down
- 11:52the helicopter shots and then it kind of goes Uptown to this
- 11:56area. That makes a lot of sense.
- 11:58I. I promise I will not be like the
- 11:59New York guy too much on this. Actually, no.
- 12:03You know what throws me off, though, too, is at one point in
- 12:07the helicopter montage, they go over a baseball stadium.
- 12:10And I'm pretty sure that at this point, Shea Stadium had not been
- 12:13opened yet. And Yankee Stadium is obviously
- 12:17in the Bronx, so I'm like, I don't know where this is or what
- 12:19stadium this is. It's got to be 1 of, you know,
- 12:22wherever the Mets played, I guess before Shay became a
- 12:24thing. But who knows, man.
- 12:27Patrick, do you have any sports related insights for us?
- 12:29I, I'm not, I'm not an expert there.
- 12:34I'm, I'm, I'm sorry, but I, I, I will say it.
- 12:37I, I, I do know it was a big deal that this was one of the
- 12:40first musicals to ever like shoot on location.
- 12:43That was just not a thing that happened on it anything and and
- 12:48yeah, a a a lot of the the the prologue is is on location and
- 12:55looks good looks really it. Looks real good man.
- 12:57I hear, I will say. Though about this, go ahead,
- 12:59Brad. My struggle was that because
- 13:02most of it is shot on sound stages, the transition from
- 13:06those helicopter shots to the sound stages felt very drastic
- 13:12to me. I don't know how you guys felt
- 13:14about it, but to me it felt just like.
- 13:16I mean the the but the first locations after the helicopter
- 13:19shots are real locations. Oh, are they they're.
- 13:22Like the basketball court and stuff like that where they're
- 13:24all the like the 1st 10 minutes is basically all real locations.
- 13:28OK? It's just that it's shot in that
- 13:32this is the thing I'm we're gonna, you know, talk more about
- 13:36the visuals in this movie, but it's just that like, it's that
- 13:39incredible Technicolor look where it's just like it, it, it
- 13:45looks like it, it's just such an incredible like movie reality
- 13:50where it's like, like, even though it's on relocations, it
- 13:52doesn't look like real life. But it's a thing that I was I
- 13:56was thinking about because in the during that prologue,
- 14:01there's a lot of a lot of the shots are like, just like middle
- 14:06of the day, like sunlight directly overhead shots and
- 14:11generally this. I'm so sorry to get technical
- 14:14about like cameras, like right away on the episode.
- 14:17But but it was the thing that I was thinking about during the
- 14:20prologue. So with, with digital sensors
- 14:23and like digital cinematography, digital cameras, which is what
- 14:26the majority of like movies and TV are shot on nowadays.
- 14:30The hardest thing to make look good with digital is just
- 14:34exterior day photography. Just like if you, you look at
- 14:39any movie that comes out now and it's like, why does every scene
- 14:42where people you look at like a wicked and it's like, why does
- 14:46it look like garbage whenever they go outside during the day?
- 14:51And this is, is so expensive. And it's just a thing that that
- 14:54is the, the thing that like is so tough with digital and, and
- 14:57you know, film is a lot more forgiving there.
- 15:00And you look at the prologue where it's, and it's also like
- 15:04generally in cinematography, it's like you want, if you're
- 15:06shooting exterior day scenes, you want to shoot like early in
- 15:09the morning or later in the day when the sun is like lower in
- 15:12the sky, when it's directly overhead, it has harsh shadows,
- 15:16It's unflattering. It doesn't look good.
- 15:18The prologue of a Side Story they're shooting with like
- 15:22midday sun, sun directly overhead, the time of day that
- 15:26is going to look bad and it looks incredible.
- 15:30And a lot of it does come down to just like the way that like
- 15:34Technicolor of the era looked. Where it's like this is just
- 15:38this is taking the unflattering like reality, like what it would
- 15:42look like on set. And just like the the way these
- 15:46cameras interpret it makes it this like magical movie reality
- 15:51with these like rich colors and and yeah.
- 15:54And so that's the thing. It's like it is shot on real
- 15:56locations in just the middle of the day.
- 15:59This was like gritty filming at the time.
- 16:01And it and, and we look at it now and it's like, wow, this is
- 16:04just like just some magical fantasy alternate reality.
- 16:08I'd, I'd be curious to hear the thing that popped into my head
- 16:12as you were talking about that. And you know, maybe it's the
- 16:15setting and and everything, but I feel like do the right thing
- 16:18has a similar like. Really.
- 16:20Bright middle of the day, but it still comes across very bright
- 16:24and. It well, I think.
- 16:25Like engaging. Yeah, that's a great comparison
- 16:28point because it's this, it's this interesting blend of
- 16:32realism and and kind of dream like stylized sets that still
- 16:37accentuate the kind of New York that they want to go for.
- 16:40Like it may not be exactly what the real New York looks like,
- 16:43even though they are incorporating real sets at some
- 16:45points. And I think especially in that
- 16:47prologue, they do such a good job of kind of boxing you in to
- 16:53the neighborhood that you're going to be enclosed in.
- 16:54So like, they're kind of at one point on top of like a trash
- 16:57heap and throwing vegetables at somebody.
- 17:00But there's this amazing shot of Bernardo and two of the other
- 17:04sharks. And the entire backdrop of the
- 17:07shot is like a like a tenement building that you can't even see
- 17:10the sky. It's just the building behind
- 17:12them. It's one of my favorite shots in
- 17:14the history of movies. It it's, it's one of the
- 17:17greatest images like ever put on film.
- 17:20And, and I remember watching like years ago watching like DVD
- 17:26extras about the making of the movie.
- 17:28And I remember for that shot they dug a hole in the street to
- 17:33get the camera at ground level to get that one shot I which was
- 17:39again a thing that was not done at the time.
- 17:43Right. And but you look at it now, it's
- 17:44like truly like that shot. Like I, I have the like 50th
- 17:49anniversary collector's edition Blu-ray set which comes with a
- 17:53bunch of like, like also this movie isn't on 4K yet, you know,
- 17:57released the 4K. Insane.
- 17:59The the, the 20th, the 50th anniversary was like in 2011,
- 18:06like like, but anyway, but but it comes with like the this set
- 18:09of like like mini like posters of the movie, like like replicas
- 18:12of like posters of like from the time.
- 18:14And a bunch of the posters that were produced and released
- 18:17around the world were just of that shot.
- 18:21Like that's how iconic it is. There's like, that shot is so
- 18:24good. Let's make it a poster.
- 18:26Yeah. Well, and to Brad's point, too,
- 18:28there are also these stylized elements that get worked in
- 18:31immediately, even in that opening prologue.
- 18:34So the very first time that Bernardo gets caught by a group
- 18:39of jets and you know, they chase him off and they're making fun
- 18:43of him and you can kind of see the rage start to boil up in
- 18:46him. He's like in an alleyway and you
- 18:48can see the walls on either side of him are not painted bright
- 18:52red. And then he just spins out a
- 18:54frame and spins into a new frame and throws his hand against the
- 18:58wall. And it's a bright red
- 18:59background. And it works freaking incredibly
- 19:03because it's just everything about this movie, Brad, from the
- 19:06choreography to the way the sets are painted to the way it's lit
- 19:10is just meant to it. It's the one of the most
- 19:12expressionistic movies I can imagine.
- 19:15It's everything these characters are either internalizing or
- 19:19externalizing. When that comes out of them, it
- 19:22spills all over the walls around them and it's just like, here's
- 19:26the movie that you're going to be experiencing for the next 2
- 19:291/2 hours. If you're not on board with
- 19:31this, if you're not on board with gang members like plieing
- 19:34down the street and coming up against bright red walls, you're
- 19:37in for a long 2 1/2 hours. Get on board.
- 19:40And I just love that they kind of throw the gauntlet down like
- 19:42that. Yeah, I was going to say that
- 19:44even the choreography, there's no small movement in this movie.
- 19:50Like it is all they are literally reaching for the skies
- 19:54with almost every single movement.
- 19:57That it is a expressive, that it evokes deep emotion and throws
- 20:04it up against whatever the the the canopy of this film is at
- 20:08every single moment. I think this might be a good
- 20:10point. Let's let's get this
- 20:12conversation out of the way. You know, we had to do this with
- 20:15like Brokeback Mountain. And you, you have to like set
- 20:18time aside to be like the gay cowboy movie thing.
- 20:20You got to address it. It's reductionistic like the
- 20:23shape of water. It's the the lady has sex with
- 20:25the fish. It's it's way more than that.
- 20:27And I feel like West Side Story, the reductionistic thing about
- 20:31this is like, I can't get around to the idea of gang members
- 20:35dancing like this. And the more I think about it,
- 20:38first of all, like expand your horizons a little bit, folks,
- 20:41like this is not that hard to do.
- 20:42This is a. Movie 2026.
- 20:45Come on, gang members can dance too.
- 20:48But you know, Brad and I were talking about this.
- 20:50We were texting each other earlier.
- 20:52And Brad, you were saying that that's still kind of a barrier
- 20:54to entry for you. And I, I understand that.
- 20:56But I also think that there's something about how
- 21:00expressionistic those sort of outbursts of dance are that if
- 21:04they were doing dances that were more realistic to the kind of
- 21:07people they are, like if they set this movie in 2026 and these
- 21:12guys are like break dancing, it's it's more appropriate to
- 21:16the kind of people that they are.
- 21:18But I still don't know if it if it exudes that sense of joy and
- 21:22openness. And like, we own this street the
- 21:26way that Jerome Robbins choreography does.
- 21:29Like yes, it's not tough guy behavior, but it's actually more
- 21:32true to the characters I think. Well, when you consider it that
- 21:36it is not what they would do, it's the emotions of what's
- 21:40going on inside them, then like, yeah, the dance makes sense.
- 21:43I think the first 30 minutes of this movie felt like we were
- 21:50trying to fit a bunch of dis disparate pieces together.
- 21:57And it comes together eventually when the conflict really ignites
- 22:01and the The Jets and the Sharks, when you when you realize that
- 22:07all of the bright visuals, all of the huge choreography, all of
- 22:11the over exaggerated language that they use is a way of
- 22:16covering up and expressing really deep, dark, dangerous
- 22:22things that are happening. Once that starts to come clear
- 22:26that they're actually talking about killing each other, I
- 22:29think that's when the movie starts to come together for me.
- 22:32And that's why the first like opening scene when you have
- 22:35these guys who are like tough gang members who are playing
- 22:38down the street. It's kind of like, I don't know
- 22:40if I'm on board with this yet, but once you get that, you get
- 22:43that realization like, oh, this is a musical's way of saying
- 22:49these are teenagers who are going to kill each other.
- 22:53That's when it all really started to come together for me.
- 22:57Patrick I'm, I'm curious, you know, because Brad said the 1st
- 23:0030 minutes were like the biggest barrier to entry for him.
- 23:03I think for me, actually the last bit of this movie might be
- 23:05the weakest part for me. The very ending is incredible,
- 23:09but I think it gets a little blocked down in in plot
- 23:11mechanics towards the end and kind of hurtling towards that
- 23:13climate rumble. Yeah, that.
- 23:16OK. I was going to ask you, like, if
- 23:17there's a part of this movie that doesn't work for you, what
- 23:21stretch might it be? It sounds like you and I are
- 23:23kind of in the same spot here. Yeah, I, I, I mean, I don't
- 23:27think I've I've I've actually like given like my general take
- 23:29on the movie, which is I, I love it so much.
- 23:36I it is this this is this is actually my favorite musical.
- 23:41Let's go. This is an like, so OK, here's
- 23:46here's my big take on West Side Story.
- 23:49And then I, I was thinking about this as I was re watching it
- 23:51today. So you know, the, the music is
- 23:56by Leonard Bernstein. This is you could make a, a
- 24:00strong case that this is the greatest music written in the
- 24:0520th century. This is just like just the music
- 24:08alone is just one of the most, I think, staggering artistic
- 24:12achievements in the history of mankind.
- 24:14It is just like, it is just just the score, the, the, the like,
- 24:21the, the like the songs, every bit of music for like 2 1/2
- 24:24hours is, I think, just one of just like some of the best music
- 24:28of all time. And, and so this music is, I'm
- 24:32sorry, this movie, obviously the, you know, Broadway show
- 24:34before it. And then the movie, The movie is
- 24:37basically a ballet set to some of the greatest music ever
- 24:41written. And as I'm watching it again
- 24:46today and I've seen this movie many times, I'm thinking and,
- 24:48and I'd already just been thinking about this recently,
- 24:52just like with like other stuff where I'm like genuinely like,
- 24:56like there's no like objective answer to like what is like the
- 25:02greatest achievement in cinema or what is the point of cinema
- 25:05or anything like that? But I what I, what I was
- 25:07thinking about a lot while watching this is like, I think
- 25:10like one of, if not the most significant, most important
- 25:15things that cinema does is simply just the combination of
- 25:22movement and light and color synthesized with music.
- 25:28And this movie does that beyond just telling the story.
- 25:33This movie synthesizes the greatest music ever written with
- 25:39some of with with just some of the most astounding capturing of
- 25:45movements and color and light of all time.
- 25:49And there are just multiple sequences in this movie where
- 25:53I'm just sitting. And I've seen this so many times
- 25:54before. I'm sitting here in my living
- 25:55room and I'm just like getting full body chills, like coming
- 25:59close to tears just because of like what I'm watching and
- 26:04hearing. Not even because I'm like, I'm
- 26:06so absorbed the story just just just like the, the, the sheer
- 26:11like sensation of of this as like an audio like visual
- 26:16experience. It is.
- 26:18It's so staggering, which is why, and I promise I won't break
- 26:22it up too much. It seems insane that like, I do
- 26:26actually think the Spielberg version is almost an improvement
- 26:31in every way. I think it might be even better.
- 26:33Oh man. Wow.
- 26:36I, I, I, I think, I think the, the Spielberg movie was my
- 26:39favorite film of 2021. I, I would periodically while re
- 26:43watching this today, I would like finish a sequence and be
- 26:45like, OK, I'm just gonna like pop in the 4K disc of the
- 26:48Spielberg 1 and now watch his prologue and I'd be like, damn,
- 26:53yeah, his prologue is even better.
- 26:55And I OK so. Let me let me push back on this
- 26:58because I I let let's get this conversation out of the way too.
- 27:01I want to talk just a little bit about the Spielberg version.
- 27:03You have to and let it lead into a conversation about Robert
- 27:07Wise, who I think deserves more conversation than he gets,
- 27:10generally speaking. So the Spielberg version for me
- 27:13doesn't work as well as this movie and it's damn good.
- 27:17Like it's Steven Spielberg making West Side Story with Tony
- 27:20Kushner writing the script. Like, what do you come on?
- 27:22It's going to be baseline 7 1/2 movie.
- 27:24Like, you can't get worse than that.
- 27:26I have long said that the reason musicals aren't as good as they
- 27:31used to be is because people forget that the most dynamic
- 27:35thing you can do with a camera in a musical is to sit it still
- 27:41and just pan or track along with the movement of the dancers.
- 27:46Like if you watch the old MGM musicals, especially in, you
- 27:48know, Academy ratio, it's like, here you go, Gene Kelly, here's
- 27:52a a broomstick and you're going to dance around now.
- 27:55And the entire number is just like Stanley Donnan's, like, I'm
- 27:57going to set a camera right here.
- 27:59We're going to kind of go like this.
- 28:00And we're going to go like this and we're going to go on a
- 28:02horizontal plane. And that's the whole scene.
- 28:05And there is so much emphasis on the movement of bodies and it's
- 28:09not being accented with hard cuts and it's not being
- 28:14accentuated with dramatic push insurance or swoops.
- 28:18And Spielberg, I love the guy, but like, he's the king of the
- 28:22wonder. And he's the king of like, I am
- 28:24moving this camera and we're exploring the space with the
- 28:27camera. And I think that there are
- 28:29sometimes in in the new West Side Story where that is like a
- 28:32revelatory experience. And I think that there are
- 28:34sometimes where it actually takes away from the dynamism of
- 28:38the choreography. And I also, just like Yanish
- 28:42Kaminsky, also love the guy. There's something about his
- 28:46digital cinematography. Wait, Yanish doesn't shoot
- 28:49digitally? Is it all film?
- 28:52It's all film. Well then it's.
- 28:53It's got to be the color grade then, man, because like, there's
- 28:55something about the way this movie is shot that has like,
- 29:00it's just like this patina of artificiality that I couldn't
- 29:05crack in a way that, like, the 61 version, which is like,
- 29:09significantly more artificial, draws me in.
- 29:13I don't know what it is, Patrick.
- 29:14Maybe you can speak to it a little bit, but yeah.
- 29:18I don't. Well, well, I mean like, like, I
- 29:19mean, Yanish has his thing that he does that not everyone loves.
- 29:25I tend to love it. I think Wes, I think the 2021 W
- 29:28Side Story is some of the best work he's ever done.
- 29:32Where it's also, I mean, it's similar to what we're saying
- 29:34about the original 1, where like it's not going for realism at
- 29:37all. But but it's like I again, I was
- 29:40re watching sequences from it today where just the way he like
- 29:44blasts in like additional sunlight, like like he's able to
- 29:49have like exterior day scenes where people still have like
- 29:53perfect glowing edge lights because he has such control over
- 29:57everything. But I but yeah, it, it, it is
- 30:00especially like more, it's a more stylized look than, you
- 30:04know, most modern movies. But I just just again, it's,
- 30:09it's a, it's a simple like my, my all of my takes on the
- 30:13Spielberg one are largely just like, you know, me repeating
- 30:17stuff that I feel about the 61 version as well.
- 30:20Where it it's just like, oh, right.
- 30:22In this sequence, I just levitate because it is just so
- 30:26staggeringly put together and like it's, you know, I think it
- 30:32like America in the 61 version might be my favorite one in I
- 30:37mean it, it's my favorite song in, in, in the film.
- 30:40And I think this has like probably like 6 or seven of the
- 30:43best songs ever written for a musical.
- 30:45But and then the Spielberg version of America is staged so
- 30:51differently. Like it's outside in the streets
- 30:55in the middle of the day. And I, I, I and so we, it, it
- 31:01feels so distinct, but also just what like the like the
- 31:05escalation of that sequence and, and, and also his Spielberg's
- 31:08ability to just know when to hold on a wide shot of people
- 31:12dancing, a thing that no one has done in a musical in basically
- 31:17in 50 years. Is it just like, I, I, I, yeah.
- 31:21And then also, so like, I, I think his stage of the musicals
- 31:24is just like staggering genius level stuff.
- 31:28And but then it's also like, I think narratively the Spielberg
- 31:321 improves in in many ways over the 61 version, whether it's
- 31:40like just moving around some of the songs, like the way it moves
- 31:43up cool, the way it handles the post rumble stuff.
- 31:49And then also just like the way it like it, it deepens Tony's
- 31:52character, the way it, it gives the Puerto Ricans like more of a
- 31:55culture and lets them speak in unsubtitled Spanish.
- 32:00It the, the way it handles like anybody's it, it, it, it makes
- 32:04so many smart choices where I'm just like, damn, they took my my
- 32:07favorite musical and action and made something that doesn't
- 32:11because it's tough. You can't just be like, oh, now
- 32:15you don't need the original anymore because this one is so
- 32:17good. Because what like the Spielberg,
- 32:19the Spielberg 1 is still in conversation with the original
- 32:23because there there's stuff in it that's that's also like
- 32:25pretty similar. And so you can't have that
- 32:28without the original. And I just, I truly love them as
- 32:31like companion pieces to each other.
- 32:34And, and I promise I will not keep being like, well, in the
- 32:37Spielberg, won't they do this? But like, but we have to talk
- 32:40about it because it is like what it was what it was at now it
- 32:43just seemed like a psychotic thing to do.
- 32:45It's like this is like, you know, like, like just everyone
- 32:51agrees this is like one of the top five musicals ever made and
- 32:53you're going to remake it. And also you're not going to do
- 32:56a wildly different thing. You're not going to like, change
- 32:58the setting. No, you're just going to kind of
- 33:00do it again. And, and yeah, and, and I and,
- 33:06and he did it. And also, you know, it's good to
- 33:08have like, a Maria that's not a white woman in brown face.
- 33:14OK, so we will also get to that conversation.
- 33:17I want to talk a little bit about Robert Wise, the director
- 33:20of this movie. And you know, to be fair, there
- 33:22are Co directors of this film. So Jerome Robbins is the guy who
- 33:26conceived, right? Well, he he conceived of West
- 33:29Side Story. He's a director and
- 33:31choreographer on Broadway. He brings the Broadway show to
- 33:33life and then gets hired to Co direct this film.
- 33:37And apparently on set Robins directed the bulk of the musical
- 33:43numbers and he was in charge of choreographing them obviously
- 33:46too. And all the dancers say that he
- 33:48was like a a pain in the ass to work with, but he was like the
- 33:51best experience they ever had. He's such a perfectionist though
- 33:54that as he's shooting these numbers, they're getting more
- 33:56and more over budget. And so by the time he got about
- 33:5960% of the musical numbers shot, he gets fired off of the movie.
- 34:03Robert Wise is like you're the guy now.
- 34:05You got to finish this movie now.
- 34:08Robert Wise to his credit brings Jerome Robbins back for the edit
- 34:12and they they kind of Co edit the movie together.
- 34:14Robert Wise gets his career started in Hollywood as an
- 34:17editor. You may know him from editing a
- 34:19little movie called Citizen Kane in 1941.
- 34:23Then he becomes a director of his own.
- 34:25He makes sci-fi classic The Day the Earth Stood Still in the
- 34:28early 1950s. He makes this movie, he does The
- 34:31Haunting in 1963, another horror classic, and then he's like, you
- 34:35know what? Let's do West Side Story Part 2,
- 34:37but with a bigger budget. We're going to make The Sound of
- 34:39Music now and then he makes what may be pound for pound, the most
- 34:44beautiful movie I've ever seen with The Sound of Music.
- 34:47The opening 30 minutes of The Sound of Music.
- 34:50There's a shot, Brad, and we talked about it in that episode.
- 34:54It's in the opening number where Maria's up on the hill singing
- 34:57the Sound of Music and she just kind of like weaves in and out
- 35:01of a group of trees. And it's filmed from inside the
- 35:04tree line. And the trees are like in
- 35:06silhouette, but everything outside is not.
- 35:07And it's like, it's like the John Ford Searcher shot but done
- 35:11with trees. And it's like, I it's, it's mind
- 35:14blowing. And Robert Wise does not get the
- 35:17credit he deserves for some of the visuals that he is
- 35:20responsible for putting into the cinema lexicon.
- 35:24We've already talked about the shots in this movie.
- 35:26I just think, guys. You know, also, Bob, you're not
- 35:29going to leave about the the final major installment in his
- 35:33filmography. Now which one's that?
- 35:37Star Trek The Motion Picture. Oh well, of course I forgot that
- 35:41was Robert Wise. Not even The Wrath of Khan We're
- 35:44talking about Star Star Trek One, baby.
- 35:46That's, that's the, that's the final thing where I'm like,
- 35:48that's like a different era of movies where he did that and
- 35:53it's just like, it's a crazy filmography.
- 35:55And then you tack that on at the end.
- 35:58Right. But I mean, like, how else do
- 36:01you bookend a career that kick starts with Citizen Kane?
- 36:04It's got to be Star Trek The Motion.
- 36:06Picture. Well, there's.
- 36:07There's no other way to go out. It's just one of those things
- 36:09where, you know, he he's like an early precursor to people, you
- 36:14know, like a Richard Donner or something where it's like, yeah,
- 36:17they they they can do kind of do everything that they're not an
- 36:22auteur. You, you don't know what a
- 36:24Robert Wise movie is, but it's like, oh, right, this guy is
- 36:29just a very good filmmaker and a good storyteller and can adapt
- 36:33his approach to the material And and it's like, right, can make a
- 36:38landmark horror movie, landmark sci-fi movie.
- 36:41And then two of the greatest, most iconic, most enduring
- 36:45musicals of all time. Yep, to to me, I feel like, and
- 36:49I I say this hopefully in the best taste possible.
- 36:52I feel like the patron St. of that type of director is Robert
- 36:55Rob Reimer like. Oh, oh, yeah.
- 36:58Yeah. No.
- 36:58Rob Reimer, a perfect example. Yeah, right.
- 37:01How would you look at those movies and be like, oh, yeah,
- 37:03obviously the same guy, you know, made like, Spinal Tap and
- 37:05Misery. Yeah.
- 37:06Yeah. Exactly.
- 37:08They share so much DNA. Yeah, I mean, and.
- 37:11And with Robert Wise, you know, guys, we haven't talked about
- 37:14the movie like the guts of the movie at all.
- 37:16Like we haven't talked about any of the weird cultural issues
- 37:19we're going to talk about. We haven't talked about the
- 37:21Romeo and Juliet adaptation or really the music or any of that,
- 37:24because I wanted to dedicate this front part to just kind of
- 37:27gushing about the cinematic experience of this movie.
- 37:31Bob, you texted me like halfway through and you were like, Brad,
- 37:35this is a religious experience. It is I see that as an actively
- 37:40religious person, Brad, like watching this movie, Patrick
- 37:45picked this movie and I'm so happy that he did because he
- 37:47made a a YouTube video a couple years ago, a video essay that
- 37:51was called something like what makes a movie cinematic?
- 37:55And it's it was about like trying to define what it means
- 37:59for something to be cinematic. And when Richard Baymer meets
- 38:05Natalie Wood at the dance and they have this crazy
- 38:08impressionistic, like everybody else gets smudged except them,
- 38:12they go into this ballet where the whole thing fades to black.
- 38:16And then he starts the Maria number and it's it's a rear
- 38:20projection behind him. It's not even a set.
- 38:22It's like a it's a it's a movie going on behind him that is so
- 38:26fake. And he's clearly just walking in
- 38:29place. And then it fades to a a purple
- 38:32hued New York street and then it cuts outside to a set and the
- 38:36whole thing is so over saturated that these colors are just
- 38:39bleeding into each other. And it ends with him walking in
- 38:43front of this like green stained glass factory or something.
- 38:48And it is the most euphoric, orgasmic release of a shot.
- 38:53Brad. Like, I don't know how if you
- 38:56love movies and you watch a scene like that, I don't know
- 38:59how you don't like just end that by having by needing a
- 39:03cigarette. It's that good, dude.
- 39:04Have you, Bob? Have you ever seen this in a
- 39:06theatre? Yes, it was my.
- 39:10I have not and I really really want to.
- 39:13They did a Fathom event of it a couple years ago and my my
- 39:16oldest son was like 4 years old and we have a movie theatre 5
- 39:20minutes from our house and I was like this is going to be his
- 39:24first movie in the theatre and I am going to arrange for my wife
- 39:27to pick him up at intermission before the stabby bits start and
- 39:32so. I don't believe they live
- 39:35happily ever after. He was like, this is the most
- 39:38fun, joyous movie. These, I'm sure these people
- 39:41learn how to get along, after all.
- 39:42But yeah, Patrick, to your point, man, seeing it in the
- 39:45theater is just it's next level. I know.
- 39:46Well, this is the thing. Like, I, I, I, I live in New
- 39:49York. We have like a million Rep
- 39:50theaters that play like everything all the time.
- 39:53Like how that, that said, I'm, I'm now flashing back to like,
- 39:58Oh yeah, yeah. I mean, you see of the, of the
- 40:00moving image definitely like has played this on 70mm and I just
- 40:03missed it. But I it, it, it, I mean, it's
- 40:06one of those things it's like it like if you live in New York and
- 40:09like you haven't seen like Lawrence of Arabia on 70, it's
- 40:13like, don't worry about it. It'll it'll play again in six
- 40:15months. Like you know you're going to
- 40:18see it eventually. Brad I'm curious because I don't
- 40:20think I could have talked about like the cinematic experience
- 40:24this way when we started this podcast.
- 40:25It's one of those things, you know, I, I grew up in a
- 40:30Pentecostal church and they used to talk about the Holy Spirit
- 40:34and how to explain it to people. And one, I remember one guy,
- 40:38his, his patented phrase was it's better felt than Telt.
- 40:42And I think that that is like a perfect way of explaining the
- 40:47cinematic experience. Like, I don't really know how to
- 40:49explain something being cinematic.
- 40:51And then it's like you watch West Side Story and it's like
- 40:54you get it now. I was going to say, you can't
- 40:56describe Gandalf and Amer riding down the hill with the blast of
- 41:02light and defeating the Urakai. You have to experience it like
- 41:06that's that is cinema. And and I'm with you, man, West
- 41:10Side Story has it in spades. And like I said, it's once you
- 41:15pair the audaciousness of the movie with the emotional depth
- 41:20of like what's actually happening within the story, that
- 41:24once you kind of pair those two things together, this movie
- 41:28falls into that like Golden Valley of Capital C cinema in a
- 41:34way that you just sit back afterwards and you're like, man,
- 41:38I just had nachos. I just had sex.
- 41:44I'm about to have nachos. It's the best thing in my life.
- 41:47This is this is weirdly the second time in a week I have
- 41:50heard people bring up that part in the movie.
- 41:53What if a movie that most people I think doesn't forget exists?
- 41:58Yeah, yeah, yeah. I remember.
- 42:02Those. That's one of those moments that
- 42:04you're like Adam drivers going places.
- 42:07I don't know where he's going, but.
- 42:09He's the man. Do comedy again.
- 42:12Line reading of the century. Brad, we, we are due for a break
- 42:15here in a minute and I think this is the best time to get
- 42:18this little tidbit out because there's really going to be no
- 42:20other appropriate time. You mentioned Lord of the Rings.
- 42:23We just released an episode folks, on the Lord of the Rings
- 42:2525th anniversary. So I'd love for you to go back
- 42:28and listen to that after this one.
- 42:29There is a connection, Brad, to West Side Story.
- 42:32OK, if you remember the dance at the gym and the real goofy
- 42:37looking guy that comes out and he's like, all right, boys and
- 42:39girls. That man's name is John Astin,
- 42:44who would go on to be Gomez Adams in The Addams Family and
- 42:48more importantly to sire Sean Astin, also known as Sam Wise
- 42:53Gamji. So Sean Astin's dad makes an
- 42:55appearance in West Side Story. Brad.
- 42:57We we didn't talk about this in Lord of the Rings at all.
- 43:01I still just can't get the idea out of my head.
- 43:04That said, the man who played Sam Wise Gamji, also played the
- 43:09brother in 501st dates where he's where?
- 43:15Sorry, 50. 500 is way too many first dates.
- 43:18We just reviewed 500 Days of Summer.
- 43:20I think it was in my, it was in my brain.
- 43:23Did you do a A season on just like number movies?
- 43:27That's a great idea. That should be the next one.
- 43:29We'll do 51st dates and then 300.
- 43:32It'll be great. Yeah, just do them in escalating
- 43:36like like. Numerical order, yeah.
- 43:39I mean, look, you know, you've got now like 428 Blank Slater
- 43:44movies, so you have a lot to work with.
- 43:46Yeah, we'll we'll have to end with Bob's favorite movie of all
- 43:51time, 2001 A Space Odyssey. Yes, Yeah, yeah.
- 43:55Perfect. All right, Brad, I think it is
- 43:58time for us to get to a break and I, I don't mean to rush us
- 44:01into one here, but I am super excited to drink this whiskey.
- 44:04So what do you say we take a trip over to Scotland and try
- 44:07some Glenmorengy? Bob, I'm so excited that I've
- 44:10already drank my entire glass so.
- 44:14Let's get to it. Let's get to it, man.
- 44:22All right, so today we are returning to one of our all time
- 44:25favorite whiskeys on this podcast.
- 44:27Brad and I, I know I'm I'm giving it a high bar to measure
- 44:30up to, but back in 2019, we were working our way through a
- 44:35sampler pack of small bottles of Glenn Moringy.
- 44:39Because let's be honest, our budget for this podcast was
- 44:41zero. And we're like, look, a sample
- 44:43pack that's four weeks of whiskey right there.
- 44:45And so we worked our way through the Glenn Moringy lineup and in
- 44:49the 3rd, I believe the third one we tried was the Glen Moringy
- 44:53Quinta Ruben 12 year. Now this is a Scotch whiskey
- 44:57that is finished in Ruby port casks.
- 45:00And at the time it was a 12 year Scotch.
- 45:02It has since been replaced with a 14 year age statement.
- 45:06And Brad, I don't think we've gotten back around to trying the
- 45:0914 year. So I'm really excited to dive
- 45:11into this and see, you know, just based on our memory, does
- 45:14the two extra years of aging before the finishing in Ruby
- 45:18port casks help this a little bit now?
- 45:21Just really briefly, Brad, what are your, what are your
- 45:23recollections of Kinsa Reuben? Oh my gosh.
- 45:25The, the big thing I remember was that it cost like $52 back
- 45:30in the day. And it felt like it was the
- 45:34absolute best value in the world of whiskey because it, it was
- 45:37very approachable. It had a lot of really nice
- 45:41honey flavors. It had a little bit of that
- 45:43raisiny grape influence from the port and at the price it was at
- 45:48for a well aged Scotch, I just remember being blown away.
- 45:53Now I do have one bit of bad news for you Bob, but I'm very
- 45:59disappointed. I was looking on the Glenmorengy
- 46:02website today and in the four in the little 4 pack it had like
- 46:06the regular 12 year the the Kintoruben and it also had the
- 46:15nectar. Do you remember what it was
- 46:17called, Bob? Well, well, a French speaker
- 46:21like you, Brad, would call it the nectar.
- 46:23Duh. Glen Moringy has officially
- 46:28changed the name of Nectar to the Nectar.
- 46:35No. 100% gold. Yes.
- 46:39It's not golden nectar dude. That's 100% because of you.
- 46:43They got so mad at you butchering the French language
- 46:46that they were like, we're just changing the name of this.
- 46:49Probably. No, while we're butchering
- 46:50things, Brad, I falsely remembered that this was
- 46:55finished on Pedro Jimenez Sherry casts, which I think is a that
- 46:58might be the La Santa that does that.
- 47:00And I was going to make some some comparison about how, you
- 47:04know, this represents the melding of of cultures the same
- 47:07way that West Side stories should have.
- 47:09And that's not even true because this is Ruby Port we're looking
- 47:11at today. Now, Patrick, you're going to
- 47:14join us for this review today. I think this is at least the
- 47:16second time you've tried whiskey with us.
- 47:18I know that you are partial, I mean, to all kinds of whiskey,
- 47:21but you're historically an Irish whiskey drinker.
- 47:24I mean where? Are you at on Scotch?
- 47:26That's mostly. Loyalty toward my people.
- 47:28Sure, sure. Yeah, I'm not actually saying
- 47:32it's superior to Scotch. I, I, you know, I, I, I love
- 47:37not, not like I, I love plenty of bourbons and scotches and
- 47:42Japanese whiskeys and yeah. Is is what you're trying to say
- 47:47is I love Scotch. Scotchy Scotch.
- 47:50Scotch, Scotch, Scotch, Scotch into my belly.
- 47:53Yeah, Yeah, I think. I think that's what I'm saying.
- 47:57All right, so guys, let's dive in here.
- 47:59Glenn Moringy is a Highland Scotch whiskey.
- 48:02Now there are many, many Scotch producing regions, five major
- 48:05ones, but we typically think that space side Scotch is kind
- 48:09of the most delicate and and floral.
- 48:12And then if you kind of want to step one step up in intensity,
- 48:15you go to the Highland region. There's a little bit more of
- 48:17that kind of like char ashiness at the back of it.
- 48:20You get a little bit of that kind of burn.
- 48:22It's not obviously it's not peated the way that Isla Scotch
- 48:26would be. And so it's a nice kind of
- 48:28middle ground entry point region into drinking Scotch.
- 48:32And this one being finished on port is going to have a ton of
- 48:34that sweet character too. Brad, we've already given a few
- 48:37nosing and tasting notes on this, but let's go ahead and
- 48:40dive in in earnest. What are your nosing notes on
- 48:43the Quinta Reuben The. The nose for me has all sorts of
- 48:48just really nice fruit flavors going on.
- 48:52It's got a bit of a Peach vibe. There's a lot of raisins that I
- 48:56think you're getting because of the poor influence.
- 48:59It has like a honey drizzle that I really like.
- 49:02And then the longer I spent with it, it reminded me of like, not
- 49:06a nutty, but like a milk chocolate covered toffee.
- 49:10That just was a really, really beautiful note for me.
- 49:15I, I still love this Bob. It's a nine out of 10 on the
- 49:18nose. Yeah, dude, sometimes when I'm,
- 49:22when I'm nosing whiskey it, I try to pair it with like mental
- 49:26images. And there's like 2 movie related
- 49:31images that this brings up to me.
- 49:32And one of them is like the very beginning of Walt Disney's
- 49:37Pinocchio when Jiminy Cricket like takes 1 coal out of the
- 49:41fire to warm his ass with. And there's just this, like
- 49:45there's just this deep amber glow to that coal.
- 49:48And it's like, that's the amber that's in the nose of this.
- 49:52It's that. And it's like the Jurassic Park
- 49:55mosquito is like that's the, that's the amber I'm getting on
- 49:59this, man. It's, it's just so rich and
- 50:01decadent. There's toffee there.
- 50:04There's definitely some dark stone fruit like a plum, prune,
- 50:07Raisin going on. It's just like you're imagining
- 50:11these kind of cascades, cascades of like butterscotch that are
- 50:14going to come off of this. It's a 9 1/2 out of 10 for me,
- 50:17Brad. You just pulled from the
- 50:21recesses of my latent memory a childhood image of Pinocchio.
- 50:28Jiminy crickets, ass. That's my nose on this whiskey,
- 50:32Patrick. It's over to you now, man Jesus
- 50:35Christ. So look, guys, I, I talk about
- 50:40movies professionally. I don't talk about whiskey
- 50:43professionally. This is I'm just feeling now
- 50:46like anytime I have done like I like a wine tasting are like a
- 50:54like, you know, fresh brewed coffee tasting where I'm like, I
- 50:58don't, I don't know how to talk like my, I, I am just not
- 51:03trained at at, at like at reading my palate or even now my
- 51:08just like my, my sense of smell and interpreting and and being
- 51:14able to articulate it. I will say I, I generally agree
- 51:21with everything you guys are saying.
- 51:22I did, you know, I've got that there.
- 51:25There is definitely the sort of like, you know, warm amber
- 51:30feeling from from that there There is the sort of like like
- 51:35the slight like fruity honey scent, but I have nothing to to
- 51:41like original to contribute to this.
- 51:44I am so bad at this. Why did I ask?
- 51:46Well, here's the here's the whiskey part too.
- 51:48I guess there's. One way that I would, I would
- 51:50encourage you to do this, Patrick, is just you've tried
- 51:52Scotch before. Yeah.
- 51:54Let's let's map this on a one to 10 in relation to the other
- 51:57scotches that you've tried. And like, is it approaching the
- 52:01upper levels of that or is it like somewhere in the middle?
- 52:05What? What?
- 52:05Are are are we talking just the nose right now?
- 52:09Just the nose for now. Yep.
- 52:12I'm also, it's funny, I I haven't, Yeah, I'm usually, I
- 52:15feel like I I usually keep like either Irish whiskey or bourbon
- 52:19stocked in my apartment. I'm not not you.
- 52:23I don't have like a go to Scotch, although that said it
- 52:27might be this one now but I'm just.
- 52:30Expanding your horizon. Yes, I will.
- 52:32You know what I'm going to say, Nose.
- 52:34I'm going to go with 8.5 out of 10 because I don't feel
- 52:40comfortable going higher than that because I'm like what am I
- 52:44talking about? That's a fair and risk averse
- 52:47number. I like it, Brad.
- 52:49Let's let's jump into the taste here 'cause this thing is just
- 52:51freaking phenomenal. Yeah, I I'm, I'm sticking at a
- 52:55nine out of 10 on the pallet. For me, this is like a light
- 53:00roast coffee. The honey sticks around the the
- 53:04Peaches almost turns a little bit more stone.
- 53:08I don't know, the flavor transforms into like a pear vibe
- 53:12for me. It's a little less sweet and a
- 53:15little more out of whatever. It's not savory, but whatever
- 53:20pear is more of than Peach, that's what it is, Patrick.
- 53:24I also don't always do so nice with my words.
- 53:28Brad, I think, I think you're doing very well.
- 53:30Oh, thank you so much. And but there is a nice gentle
- 53:33sweetness to this that reminds me of like a fresh simple syrup
- 53:37that you just made off the stove.
- 53:39So this like has a really pleasant, not overpowering, but
- 53:45just a good pleasant envelopes you in the warmth of its
- 53:51niceness kind of palette that I'm I'm at a nine out of 10
- 53:54again on. Yeah, I'm going to be at a 9 1/2
- 53:57again. Like, I don't think that this is
- 53:59the most complex whiskey we've ever tried, Brad, but it is like
- 54:03right down the middle. It's perfect for someone that's
- 54:05just getting into Scotch because it's got a ton of sweetness to
- 54:08it. And and the fruit notes that are
- 54:10there. It's kind of like, you know,
- 54:11like when you're eating a plum or an app or any kind of stone
- 54:14fruit and you're trying to get flesh off of the seed at the end
- 54:18and it's just a little bit more bitter than the rest of the
- 54:20flesh. It kind of reminds me of that.
- 54:22Like I get notes of apricot here, but it's not super
- 54:25decadent or like super sickly sweet apricot.
- 54:28It's it's dark stone fruit. I get a little bit of red wine
- 54:31on this, obviously. And then there's just a few
- 54:34waves of I get butterscotch here.
- 54:37I get the, you know, like if you've ever had not like
- 54:40chocolate covered nuts or, or fruits, but like the yogurt
- 54:42covered ones. Yeah, it reminds me of that a
- 54:45little bit. And I really do like that.
- 54:47There's like that layer of like fattiness to it.
- 54:50It's freaking good, man. 9 1/2 for me.
- 54:52Patrick, how you feeling about the about the actual palate, the
- 54:55taste, the experience? It's really it, it's it's really
- 55:00nice. There is like it's sweet, but
- 55:02not too sweet. It's smooth, but not too it's it
- 55:06still has like a bite to it. It's still, it's like, you know,
- 55:11it's like you've had like a spoonful of, of hot soup that is
- 55:16just not too hot. So like you're still at like,
- 55:22oh, wow. I'm like, yeah, I'm like feeling
- 55:24like it like in my whole head, but it's not uncomfortable.
- 55:28And so, so, so it, it makes you like not want to rush it, but
- 55:33then just actually sit and kind of like savor each like, you
- 55:38know, each sip thinking about the, the flavors you're
- 55:44experiencing. Again, like Bob, I don't the way
- 55:47the, the language you used to describe that.
- 55:52And, and again, I, I like you're saying, I'm like, Oh yeah,
- 55:55that's, that's pretty good. I never in a million years would
- 55:57I have thought of like, you know, fattiness our our stuff
- 56:02like. I Patrick, I look at you and I'm
- 56:04like, I see a guy that's never weighed more than $1.60 and
- 56:08really I'm more than I. I'm just saying you, you've got
- 56:14very thin and athletic built. I got to.
- 56:16Dig deep into like my fat guy history and I pulled notes from
- 56:20like all the candies I ate when I was a kid and like I there's
- 56:24an encyclopedic memory of fruit by the foot and stuff like it's,
- 56:28it's OK, man, I get it. No, it's like, I, I like food, I
- 56:32cook and all of that. I will say I'm just amazed that
- 56:35like, wow, the image I'm giving is, is weighing under 160 lbs
- 56:42because I, you know, I don't, I, I'm like, I'm like, I haven't
- 56:45weighed. I haven't weighed 160 since I
- 56:47was to be clear, I weigh. Is that weird?
- 56:51I shouldn't talk about my weight on like publicly.
- 56:54It's OK. Now I weigh like in.
- 56:56Any case? Yeah, OK.
- 56:57But yeah, but Brad, I'm basically I've been in the one
- 56:5965170 range since I was like 17 and.
- 57:04It's never. And listen, you guys, you guys
- 57:06look great. Thanks in any case.
- 57:08Bob, so do. You, Patrick.
- 57:10And you're also thank you so much and, and the, the, the, the
- 57:12lighting and everything, it's like it's really working for
- 57:14you. Thank you so much, man.
- 57:16What's your score and the taste here, Patrick?
- 57:18I love this episode guys. I just gotta say it.
- 57:20Taste. I'm smashing that 9 button baby.
- 57:239 button. All right, Brad, finish.
- 57:25I'm gonna, I'm gonna breeze through this a little bit here.
- 57:28I still think it's darn good. It's long lasting.
- 57:30It doesn't tip too bitter for me.
- 57:32You definitely get a little bit of that.
- 57:34Sort of like Scotchy. What's the word like
- 57:40unsweetness? Like it's not bitter.
- 57:41It's just like it. It's it's a herbaceous,
- 57:45herbaceousness for sure. I don't know that it's a huge
- 57:49drop off from the other parts of the experience, but I think if I
- 57:53had to pick one of these three categories that's the weakest,
- 57:55it's this one. I'm still going to give it a
- 57:57nine man. This is just like a Scotch that
- 57:59was genetically engineered in a lab for my palate.
- 58:03Yeah. Can I say a thing that's been
- 58:05interesting about the experience of drinking?
- 58:06It is remind me of where you guys are.
- 58:12Ohio. Ohio, right?
- 58:14How cold is it in Ohio right now?
- 58:18It's. Getting bitter.
- 58:19It's like like 9°. We're literally on the cusp of
- 58:22like a 2 foot downfall of yeah it's a new wild.
- 58:27We're not going to get that much snow, but like, it's got like
- 58:30today it's cold tomorrow it's going to be brutally cold And
- 58:34then Sunday is our big snow day, which I'm, I'm like, you know,
- 58:39if we bring 6 inches, we'll be lucky.
- 58:41I, I, I would love 2 feet, but, but basically I, I, I went out
- 58:46to like run some errands, like in the neighborhood, you know,
- 58:51walking around like shortly before I came on to do this and
- 58:57I realized when I'd, when I would sip the whiskey and I was
- 58:59like, oh, just being outside for a bit, basically like chapped my
- 59:04lips. And so each sip of this has like
- 59:07my, my top lip just like buzzing.
- 59:10Not, it's not painful, but I'm just like, it is.
- 59:13It has been a physical experience where I'm just we're
- 59:16like, that is a major part of each sip of this whiskey just
- 59:19due to coming in from the cold. So, yeah, so that it's hard to
- 59:24separate that part out because that would normally be it all.
- 59:28Right, Brad and Patrick, this is going off the rails.
- 59:31We need a score on the finish here.
- 59:33Where are we out on the finish? Finish.
- 59:34I'm gonna go. I'm gonna go with an 8.5.
- 59:37Dude, 8.5 for me it's it turns into a little bit of like a sour
- 59:41tart cherry. The pear sticks around, there's
- 59:45barley. It gets for me, the fattiness
- 59:48comes through on the finish. It turns into like a little bit
- 59:50of a salted butter. 8 1/2 I think balance wise I'm actually
- 59:55going to drop down just a little bit.
- 59:56I'm going to say this is an 8 out of 10 balance and that like.
- 1:00:00The reason it comes up that high is because I think it it takes
- 1:00:04all the flavors it's shooting for and nails it.
- 1:00:08The reason it's not any higher is because it's not a very
- 1:00:10complex Scotch. Like we've had some wild
- 1:00:14scotches that give you the whole panoply of experience.
- 1:00:18This one is not that, but in a very good way.
- 1:00:21So I think I'm at an 8 out of 10 on balance.
- 1:00:24Yeah, balance is hard because when you're only doing like one
- 1:00:27or two notes, I feel like you can artificially inflate your
- 1:00:31balance score because it's like, Oh yeah, I picked those notes up
- 1:00:34all the way through. And and that's great because you
- 1:00:37don't get that sort of roller coaster variance that we get
- 1:00:40sometimes, Brad, you know, from the nose to the taste to the
- 1:00:43finish. I do think that this is not a
- 1:00:45super complex whiskey, but I also think that it's like what
- 1:00:48it's doing, it's damn good at. And I still think I'm going to
- 1:00:51be at a nine out of 10 on this. Yeah.
- 1:00:55I, I, I think I'm going 8.5 again, just being conservative
- 1:00:58because I'm like, you know, I don't want to go too high and
- 1:01:01then try 20 more whiskeys and be like, shit.
- 1:01:03I I really. Felon score haunts me, I know,
- 1:01:08but. But it but it really is.
- 1:01:10It's just like, like I've just been sitting here just sipping
- 1:01:12away on it and it's just like, it is like it feels like rich
- 1:01:15and sweet and each one is satisfying.
- 1:01:18And the more I drink it, the more I'm less like, yeah, I
- 1:01:21will. Once I finish this bottle, I
- 1:01:24will buy more. Yeah.
- 1:01:27Oh, it is crushable. This, this is the thing.
- 1:01:29That's why I have to come back on this podcast all the time.
- 1:01:31Because like the other times when you guys have like sent me
- 1:01:36a whiskey, I've gotten like hooked on it.
- 1:01:39Like when you sent me the Sexton, I was like, oh, I like I
- 1:01:44got my mom into that. Let's go.
- 1:01:46Yeah, now whatever. I visit my parents, they've got
- 1:01:49a bottle there at their place. Well, here's another one that
- 1:01:53you can introduce your parents to.
- 1:01:55And Brad, that gets us into into the value score.
- 1:01:59Now we always judge value by what we can buy this for in the
- 1:02:01state of Ohio, mostly because Ohio is a state controlled
- 1:02:06liquor Bureau. So they set the price and then
- 1:02:08that's the price it is across the state, which is great.
- 1:02:10You don't have like super high markups from store to store.
- 1:02:14So Brad, what is this retailing for in the state of Ohio?
- 1:02:17This is retailing for $69.99. Wow, OK.
- 1:02:23Which is a down a little bit. It had gotten up to like, I
- 1:02:26think the last time I saw it, it was like $77.
- 1:02:29Yeah. It was like $80, which is is
- 1:02:31pushing the upper limits of what I would pay for this.
- 1:02:34Yeah. So you said it's at what is it
- 1:02:36now, 68? 70 dollars $70 Yep.
- 1:02:40This is an 8.5 out of 10 on value for me Brad.
- 1:02:44I like I was ready to come down if it was in the 80s range but
- 1:02:48like for 70 bucks I can't think of many this is. 70 bucks in
- 1:02:52Ohio I I just searched for this on Uber eats and I can get it
- 1:02:59delivered to my apartment for 65.
- 1:03:03Yeah, there you go, man. Let's go in New York City,
- 1:03:07famously an expensive place. Yeah, Now I will say, Bob, one
- 1:03:13of my favorite things to do, especially with older films, is
- 1:03:17whenever they mention a dollar amount, I immediately go to
- 1:03:22inflation calculator and look up like, how much is George Bailey
- 1:03:28going to make if he takes this offer from Potter and I every
- 1:03:35year? I'm like, babe, that'd be like
- 1:03:37him going from making 58,000 a year to 350,000 a year and she
- 1:03:43puts up with it and is like, what?
- 1:03:45That's crazy. In 2019 when we first priced
- 1:03:49this out it was $52. Do you know what $52 in 2019
- 1:03:54could is is inflated to? Today I do $6068.
- 1:04:01What so it really has not risen at all that which is great to
- 1:04:04hear. I mean it's, it's adjusted with
- 1:04:06the market. Yep, I, I was.
- 1:04:10I was very happy to see that. I I'm with you, man.
- 1:04:13I think this is just a stunning value in the world of Scotch.
- 1:04:17It like that part of you that wants things to be as cheap as
- 1:04:20they used to be. Still, I'm like, oh, we had $52.
- 1:04:24That was a great price. I actually have a great memory
- 1:04:28the morning that we unknowingly at the time, the morning that we
- 1:04:35were going to have our second child, that evening, my wife
- 1:04:39went into labor, a buddy of mine texted me and was like, hey, I
- 1:04:44found a bottle of Quinta Rubin on sale for $48.
- 1:04:47Do you want 1? And I was like, yes, I want that
- 1:04:51bottle of Quinta Rubin. And that's the last bottle of
- 1:04:53Quinta Rubin that I bought. And so I still feel very proud
- 1:04:57that I bought a bottle for $48 the day that my the day before
- 1:05:01my second child was born. Have you told your child about
- 1:05:04this? I haven't.
- 1:05:06I should my my mother hates this.
- 1:05:10But my kids will see me taste whiskey and take notes and stuff
- 1:05:13and they always ask to smell it. So I'm always like, yeah, sure
- 1:05:18you can smell the whiskey. My 5 year old will smell like,
- 1:05:21you know, smells like apples. Have they ever asked to try it?
- 1:05:30I I have very clearly from the start been like this is a daddy
- 1:05:34drink. Oh yeah.
- 1:05:36And we don't. It's the thing where like, I
- 1:05:37remember when I was maybe like 12, I think, oh, it was like on
- 1:05:43New Year's Eve, my family was going over to like a friend's
- 1:05:46house and, and, and one of the people there was Scottish and
- 1:05:51they were like, oh, as you enter the house, you know, like have
- 1:05:54you have a sip of Scotch. And my parents were like, yes,
- 1:05:57it's, it's a sip. The kids can do it.
- 1:05:59And, and I remember having that sip when I was like 12 years old
- 1:06:03and being like, this is a horrible.
- 1:06:06This is. The.
- 1:06:07Worst thing in the world, who would ever want to drink this?
- 1:06:12And let me tell you, for several years, like I was in no rush to
- 1:06:16to be like swiping Scotch from the liquor cabinet.
- 1:06:19I would, I would, I would tell people like whiskey is the most
- 1:06:23repellent substance known to man.
- 1:06:26It should be illegal to drink that it's so bad.
- 1:06:29So I'm just saying if you, I don't know.
- 1:06:32Here. Here we are a few decades later.
- 1:06:35Yeah, Also as not a parent, I'm not going to be like, hey, yeah,
- 1:06:38give your kids some alcohol. Yeah, it'll be fun.
- 1:06:42It'll it'll teach them good lessons.
- 1:06:43Yeah. I'm I I will say nothing.
- 1:06:45I'm just saying that was a thing that I experienced as a child.
- 1:06:48My, my kids will ask me when they can have it and my wife
- 1:06:53will be like, you know, when you're like 16 to 18 and I'll be
- 1:06:56like, you know, like when you're 12 or so.
- 1:07:00And here's the thing. Chances are at 12, they're not
- 1:07:04going to like it. Amen.
- 1:07:07Goddess, there are certain times where the conversation gets off
- 1:07:10the rails a bit. And I think to myself, is this
- 1:07:12Patreon content or is this the world doesn't need to know that
- 1:07:17Brad's giving his kids whiskey at 12 contents, And I'm really
- 1:07:20toeing that line right now. So I think perhaps what we
- 1:07:24should do is let's get Patrick's score on the value and then
- 1:07:28we'll give our final scores here.
- 1:07:30On the value boys, I'm I'm going with A9 seeing, seeing the like,
- 1:07:36oh, in, in, in a, you know, expensive ass New York City.
- 1:07:40I can get this for 65 bucks. I'm yeah, oh, I'm, I'm going to
- 1:07:45get more of this. Cheaper cheaper than the Midwest
- 1:07:49prices. So I I.
- 1:07:52Like what's going on there? Nothing.
- 1:07:54Nothing is cheaper here. The cost of living is the only
- 1:07:57thing we had on you guys and now we've lost that.
- 1:08:00It's unbelievable. Haha yeah, it Zoron's New York
- 1:08:04has already taken effect. This this this only changed in
- 1:08:07the last three. Weeks, right, exactly.
- 1:08:12All right, Brad, I am coming out to a incredibly high 45.5 out of
- 1:08:1850 on this bad boy. Now for some context, the 35 out
- 1:08:24of 50 mark is where we typically would start giving something a
- 1:08:27thumbs up and like a soft recommendation.
- 1:08:29If you hit a 40, it's kind of a no brainer. 45 is rarefied error
- 1:08:34around here. And yes, it's it's boosted by
- 1:08:38the value score for sure. But I just think all around, I
- 1:08:41cannot think of a better kind of like starter Scotch for somebody
- 1:08:45to get into if you are looking to get into Scotch like stamp of
- 1:08:49approval on this one for sure. Absolutely, If you really want
- 1:08:52to get in in the most cost effective way, go buy Monkey
- 1:08:58Shoulder. It's like 35 bucks.
- 1:09:00It's a blended Scotch. It is delicious.
- 1:09:03If you want to get into the single malt world, though, that
- 1:09:07there's nothing better than Kinto Reuben.
- 1:09:09I am coming out to a 42 out of 50, which still is like I, I
- 1:09:15don't know about maybe 15% of our whiskeys that we review come
- 1:09:20out to a 40 or higher. Yeah.
- 1:09:23Like. It's not a lot, so for me this
- 1:09:27still stands up as one of the absolute best whiskeys we've
- 1:09:30had. It is one of the absolute best
- 1:09:33introductory scotches. This is 2 thumbs up all around.
- 1:09:37Patrick, where are you coming out?
- 1:09:39I end up with a 43.5, which is again, I'm on the lower end only
- 1:09:46because I'm being conservative, being I, I, I would call myself
- 1:09:51a, a moron when it comes to whiskey, an enthusiastic moron.
- 1:09:58And so this is me being like, I think this is.
- 1:10:01Great. Diet, but I will never go up to
- 1:10:05like an educated whiskey connoisseur and be like, this is
- 1:10:09the best thing you're ever going to drink because I probably, I
- 1:10:12don't know what I'm talking about, but I'll just say I
- 1:10:15personally likes this a lot. We have had whiskeys that cost
- 1:10:19thousands of dollars. That are.
- 1:10:21Delicious. And I think that you you go
- 1:10:25through like, the bell curve of like, pretentiousness when you
- 1:10:28get into something like drinking whiskey and you want to, like,
- 1:10:30chase the expensive bottles. And then on the other side of
- 1:10:33it, you're back to drinking the stuff you drank when you
- 1:10:35started. And you're like, oh, yeah, this
- 1:10:37$50 bottle of Scotch is, is all I want to drink anymore.
- 1:10:40And maybe you appreciate it more now.
- 1:10:42Yeah, 100. Percent, you really do.
- 1:10:44Yeah. So you've gotten.
- 1:10:45Like happy as a. Sponsor on this show, right?
- 1:10:48Oh, absolutely. Season.
- 1:10:51Two, we had a we had a few friends send.
- 1:10:54Us a bunch. Of there's a fancy lineup of
- 1:10:57whiskey called B Tac Buffalo Trace Antique Collection that
- 1:11:01they also own. Pappy and I, I just spent like
- 1:11:0610. Episodes in a.
- 1:11:07Row trashing B.Tech, not that it's bad, it's very good
- 1:11:12whiskey. But just.
- 1:11:14The marketing and all all the stuff behind it and it.
- 1:11:17So it is pretty much a running joke at this point that Buffalo
- 1:11:20Trace will never sponsor this show.
- 1:11:25Never, never. I don't know.
- 1:11:27Maybe, maybe they're desperate for your approval now.
- 1:11:30They. Might be that that's that's the
- 1:11:32game. I'm ready for you.
- 1:11:33Next that Glenn Moore and G changed the.
- 1:11:35Name. All right, well guys, you know
- 1:11:39who else is an enthusiastic? Moron.
- 1:11:41Tony in West Side Story. So guys, it's back.
- 1:11:44It's time for us to get back into talking about this movie.
- 1:11:47What do you say, Brad? Let's get to it, Bob.
- 1:11:54All right, everybody. That was Glenn Moringy, King to
- 1:11:57Ruben. 14 year old single malt Scotch What what an incredible
- 1:12:03experience. A true A.
- 1:12:04True chef's kiss. Yeah, yeah, absolutely, man.
- 1:12:07You know what else is an absolute?
- 1:12:09Chef. 'S kiss of an experience, Bob.
- 1:12:12I can only imagine Brett. 2. Facts and a falsehood.
- 1:12:16Brad is going to. Try to stump you.
- 1:12:19Ball 2. You are right and what is wrong?
- 1:12:252 facts and a falsehood. 2 facts and a falsehood is the part of
- 1:12:29the show where Brad presents me. With three items as fact about
- 1:12:32the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 1:12:36Brad, I have had a very up and down season at 2 facts and a
- 1:12:40falsehood. You really should patch yourself
- 1:12:42on the back for how often you've been able to trip me up, and
- 1:12:45that includes times where we have had a guest host picking
- 1:12:48with me. We have been LED astray multiple
- 1:12:50times this season. We have been LED astray.
- 1:12:54We, we being. Me and the guest.
- 1:12:56Oh, OK. Now.
- 1:12:57Patrick has seen this movie in his words a lot of times and so
- 1:13:02I I feel pretty confident today. Now you may undercut that
- 1:13:06confidence with some really out there trivia, but now again, for
- 1:13:10the context for listeners, if I take Patrick's advice about
- 1:13:15which one of these 3 facts is actually a falsehood and we get
- 1:13:19it right, I am only credited with one win.
- 1:13:22But if we get it wrong, I am given 2 losses in the loss
- 1:13:26column which will dig me just an insurmountable hole this season.
- 1:13:30So Patrick, the pressure is on a little bit here.
- 1:13:33OK, Brad, hit me with those two facts.
- 1:13:37And a falsehood. Fact number.
- 1:13:39One Rita Moreno stated that her. Line reading of Don't You Touch
- 1:13:43Me? After The Jets attack, Anita was
- 1:13:46her imitating her then boyfriend Marlon Brando.
- 1:13:51Brando noticed this at the film's premiere.
- 1:13:54Fact #2 Rita Moreno nearly didn't get the role of Anita,
- 1:13:59with multiple other stars such as Barbara Luna being offered
- 1:14:03the role. In the end, many of the other
- 1:14:05stars were too similar to Natalie Wood, and Moreno offered
- 1:14:08a personality that better fit what they were looking for.
- 1:14:12Fact #3 Not only are Natalie. Wood and.
- 1:14:15George Shakiris wearing make up to look more Puerto Rican.
- 1:14:21Rita Moreno, who actually is Puerto Rican, had to wear the
- 1:14:24same make up to match their skin tone.
- 1:14:27She later said that West Side Story was the worst example of
- 1:14:30this in her career, saying that it was like mud caked onto her
- 1:14:34skin. Man, there was a really, really
- 1:14:38good documentary. A couple years ago about Rita
- 1:14:40Moreno that I watched and she talked, you know, fairly fondly,
- 1:14:45but frankly about West Side Story.
- 1:14:46She also talked about dating Marlon Brando.
- 1:14:48What a wild relationship that must have been.
- 1:14:52I you know #3 sounds. I I'm just gonna assume number.
- 1:14:563 is true, Patrick, I don't. Believe I have.
- 1:14:59Heard about #3 before I'm. OK, I would bet on that being a
- 1:15:05fact. I don't know who was the the
- 1:15:08other star you mentioned. In fact #2 Brad, that was going
- 1:15:11on, or Luna. I don't know who that is, nor
- 1:15:15do. I.
- 1:15:17This sounds like a Brad G made. Up person to me?
- 1:15:19I'm not sure. Wow, Patrick, I'm circling.
- 1:15:24One and two here. I'd love to hear your thoughts
- 1:15:26on which one you. Think might be the falsehood.
- 1:15:28I lean toward 2 because I'm less familiar.
- 1:15:32With I as in there's a person, I, I'm not.
- 1:15:35Familiar with in there? While I'm like, I'm aware of
- 1:15:39Marlon Brando and they dated and so there's already stuff I'm
- 1:15:46aware of in there. So yeah, I.
- 1:15:52Again, I've got to say. Every time I'm on the show, when
- 1:15:55this segment comes on, I'm always I, I got, I got.
- 1:15:58I got to give it up to Brad for writing some pretty convincing
- 1:16:04lies, because I think usually. When I'm on, we don't.
- 1:16:11Get it right? No.
- 1:16:13We don't. That is very meaningful to me.
- 1:16:16We have had guests come on. Here and trash my intelligence.
- 1:16:21Really. Yes.
- 1:16:23Well. That's.
- 1:16:24Why I'm? Your number one.
- 1:16:26Returning guest that's right, that easily my favorite.
- 1:16:31Brad, I'm just going to, I'm going to throw my lot in with
- 1:16:33Patrick here. I do think it's either one or
- 1:16:37two, I really couldn't tell you. Which one it?
- 1:16:39Is though, so I will also say that number 2 is the falsehood
- 1:16:43here, and we'll lock that in #2 Patrick, you are.
- 1:16:49Just on a streak, you've redeemed yourself That that is
- 1:16:52the falsehood. Let's go, Barbara Luna.
- 1:16:57Is. A actress who tried out for West
- 1:17:02Side Story. However, she was like in Star
- 1:17:06Trek episodes and a few other things throughout the 60s, had a
- 1:17:09few movie roles. But she she was didn't.
- 1:17:13She was. No, Yeah, that's right.
- 1:17:17I think guys. That that might.
- 1:17:18Be a great. Segue into.
- 1:17:20Talking about the cast of this movie, guys, I mean, I don't
- 1:17:23know where if you want to start at the top with our two leads or
- 1:17:25if you want to start with the supporting performances.
- 1:17:28I, I mean, let's go ahead. Let's start with the supporting
- 1:17:31performances 'cause we're already talking about Rita
- 1:17:33Moreno and the two supporting actors here.
- 1:17:36And by the two, I mean Rita Moreno and George Shakiris both
- 1:17:40win Academy Awards for this movie.
- 1:17:43And you know, we will get around to the George Shakuris of it all
- 1:17:46and and him being painted a different color.
- 1:17:49I still think they're pretty well deserved Oscars.
- 1:17:52They're both just incredible charismatic, like scene stealing
- 1:17:57performances in this movie. Brad, who do you want to start
- 1:18:01by talking about here? Oh man, I mean I my like.
- 1:18:06Little thing that the another thing I love to say to my wife
- 1:18:09every year when I watch a Christmas movie is when I'm
- 1:18:13watching White Christmas and she is dancing at the cabaret.
- 1:18:20After she. Quits the musical George
- 1:18:23Shakiris is one of the guys that she dances with and every year
- 1:18:27I'm like they he West Side Story this is like.
- 1:18:32This is like. 10 years before. That and she's like.
- 1:18:35What? And it's the wild.
- 1:18:39Thing. About.
- 1:18:39That he was playing Riff. On in the West Dash production
- 1:18:45before this. And then they're like, oh, his
- 1:18:47dark complexion. Maybe he should play.
- 1:18:50You know, Bernardo, it is that they are like, look, I'm putting
- 1:18:55aside for a moment. We'll return.
- 1:18:57To it. The problematic racial elements
- 1:19:01of the casting and make up in this movie.
- 1:19:04George Shakiris gives an like incredible performance.
- 1:19:08He is so he's he is electric in this.
- 1:19:12It's like the aforementioned shot in the prologue that Bob
- 1:19:15you brought up earlier on when he just turns back to the wall
- 1:19:20and you get in this close up where he just like like looks
- 1:19:24down the barrel of the camera and then just, you know,
- 1:19:27perfectly in tune with the music, just like pounds his
- 1:19:30first on the wall. It's like you look at that shot
- 1:19:34and the way he holds a close up and it's like, oh, well, that's
- 1:19:36a movie star right there. It's like, I like, I don't, I
- 1:19:40don't know why he did not like. Become like a.
- 1:19:44Like full on movie star, but this but like he's so lately he
- 1:19:49he's like obviously like an A spectacular dancer.
- 1:19:53I mean the the prologue dance at the gym America, just the the
- 1:19:59way he moves it is is it's astounding.
- 1:20:04It's again, this is like this is watching him dance is like, Oh
- 1:20:07yeah, this is what cinema is about.
- 1:20:09But it's also just like, the intensity of like, his stare.
- 1:20:13Is like the way cause OK, the thing about West Side Story in
- 1:20:17any version of of the show, it it is I think the fact of West
- 1:20:21Side Story and I say this, this is my favorite musical.
- 1:20:24Tony and Maria are the least interesting characters.
- 1:20:27Thank you. Yep, that's that's I was
- 1:20:29talking. That's just.
- 1:20:29Talking to Brad about this. Before you got on.
- 1:20:31That's every musical. Though the leads of a musical
- 1:20:34are almost guaranteed, especially if they're romantic
- 1:20:37leads, to be the least compelling characters in that
- 1:20:39musical, right? These are two young dummies
- 1:20:43where. Where they're like, we don't
- 1:20:44want to fight, we just want to hang out and we're in love.
- 1:20:48And Tony wants to, like, unload, like, boxes of Coca-Cola and
- 1:20:54stuff like that. And it's like, right.
- 1:20:55Yeah, no. Riff is like the exciting one.
- 1:20:59Riff rocks. Also, can we just point out that
- 1:21:02Tony and Riff both end up in Twin Peaks, which is so crazy?
- 1:21:06Yes. Yes.
- 1:21:07It's incredible here. OK, let's.
- 1:21:10Get back to George Shakuris for a minute.
- 1:21:11Because I, I want to tread a little bit lightly with how I
- 1:21:14phrased this, because as a very, very white man, you by the look
- 1:21:20of me and the everything else of me, this, this is like.
- 1:21:24You know, like like a. Blizzard.
- 1:21:26On screen right now, this is the the What is the whitest podcast
- 1:21:31board. It's not my place to say.
- 1:21:34What is and is not? Racially.
- 1:21:36Insensitive. And the fact that you have a
- 1:21:38white person playing this role is in itself racially
- 1:21:41insensitive. Now, given that, what?
- 1:21:45Really astounds me is. Like when you look at other
- 1:21:49white people who are playing. Different races.
- 1:21:52And ethnicities at this time in Hollywood, Like a year after
- 1:21:57this, Breakfast at Tiffany's comes out featuring Mickey
- 1:22:00Rooney in the most offensive performance ever committed to
- 1:22:04film. Like when white people do other
- 1:22:07races at this time and prior in Hollywood, they are giving in to
- 1:22:12stereotypes. And it's not even necessarily
- 1:22:14like the overt stereotypes. It's just what white people
- 1:22:18thought about these races. And for George Shakiris to give
- 1:22:22not just the committed performance he does, but to give
- 1:22:25it the level of sensitivity and dignity that he does, just the
- 1:22:31sheer fact that he gives a performance that layered and
- 1:22:34nuanced is incredibly unique in Hollywood at this time.
- 1:22:38And I think that it deserves mentioning.
- 1:22:41And I'm not going to, like, give the guy a parade because he
- 1:22:44played another human being with the dignity that all human
- 1:22:47beings deserve to be played with.
- 1:22:48But like, it's worth noting. This is really unique at this
- 1:22:52time in Hollywood. Yeah.
- 1:22:54Just the fact that like obviously.
- 1:22:56They should have cast a Puerto Rican actor in the role.
- 1:23:00There is still brown face going on, which is bad, but it is.
- 1:23:04But again, this was like a time when that was just really
- 1:23:07standard. Like no one questioned that.
- 1:23:10And, and, and it's like, yes, they should not have cast him,
- 1:23:14but because of the time and the circumstances and all of that,
- 1:23:18it is somewhat. OK, maybe not commendable, but.
- 1:23:24Like he did like clearly. Like want to?
- 1:23:29Give a sensitive, nuanced, like accurate portrayal of a person
- 1:23:35from this culture. And and again, the bar was so
- 1:23:40low at the time that it's like, you know, for this could be so
- 1:23:47much worse. This could be so much worse.
- 1:23:51It's still, it's still a thing that you have to be like I, you
- 1:23:55know, like it's, it's, you know, disappointing, but it's like,
- 1:23:58again, it's like, it's a movie from 1961.
- 1:24:01It could be Breakfast at Tiffany's, but it's not.
- 1:24:03I think the fascinating thing for me is essentially what?
- 1:24:07We're saying is it's really hard to impose 2026, not necessarily
- 1:24:15moral, but standards. Standards.
- 1:24:17To something from 19. 61 and it doesn't.
- 1:24:20Mean you don't look back and go like, I think the fascinating
- 1:24:23thing is that he still portrays what was probably true back then
- 1:24:29of the gender divide of like a very conservative gender outlook
- 1:24:35on how the Puerto Rican men view the Puerto Rican women.
- 1:24:40And that like in the in the America song with which I think
- 1:24:43is just like a fascinating look back into what life was like for
- 1:24:48women back then. And I the, the reason I bring
- 1:24:51that up is to say, I think that this movie was a very
- 1:24:56progressive movie at the time. And that was like, that's like
- 1:25:00the the observation is to say for the time this was moving us.
- 1:25:08Towards a. Place of understanding that the
- 1:25:13reason George Shakuris's performance is compelling is
- 1:25:18because he doesn't focus on the and I'm using air quotes as I
- 1:25:23say this for those of you who are just listening the Puerto
- 1:25:26Rican of it all he focuses on the human being of it all and
- 1:25:31like any human being from any race who cares about his sister
- 1:25:37and is nervous about a new country that they are living in
- 1:25:41and the effect it would have on their sister would feel how he
- 1:25:45feels when she just falls head over heels in love with a
- 1:25:50somebody who doesn't understand their culture day one of living
- 1:25:54there like that human experience feels honest and raw and real
- 1:26:00and you you kind of relate with with Bernardo as he's struggling
- 1:26:04through these things regardless of George Shakuris skin color
- 1:26:10well I think that the the American number is.
- 1:26:13Really the key to. Under a understanding like the
- 1:26:17racial politics of this movie, but also why I think this movie
- 1:26:20works so well. And it's because it is.
- 1:26:24I mean, just like fundamentally preaching a sermon about the
- 1:26:28American dream and where it fails people and race in America
- 1:26:32and violence in America and how all of that is wrapped up into
- 1:26:35what America is. And I think in a lot of ways,
- 1:26:38this is the quintessential American musical.
- 1:26:42Like, I can't think of anything else I could think of musicals
- 1:26:44that I might enjoy a little bit more than this.
- 1:26:46But like this, this is a movie and a musical about the American
- 1:26:51experience in a way that very few others are.
- 1:26:54And the reason that it works so well in the American number is
- 1:26:58that I think in less talented, less qualified, less deft hands,
- 1:27:04it becomes way preachier and way more didactic about like what
- 1:27:09they're trying to get across. It would be like doused in
- 1:27:13exposition. It would be someone standing on
- 1:27:16a soapbox and delivering A soliloquy.
- 1:27:18And by putting it in the context of this very upbeat song, but
- 1:27:23making that song be a back and forth and then adding the
- 1:27:27additional layer of like, it's a back and forth where they're
- 1:27:30just kind of like couples having fun with each other and like
- 1:27:34ribbing each other. But what they're what they're
- 1:27:37getting at is a really harsh truth in reality.
- 1:27:41But the framing of it goes down so easily that I think an
- 1:27:45audience watching this in 1961 is able to internalize the
- 1:27:49message of that song so much more easily than if they had
- 1:27:53done kind of like the Stanley Kramer, you know, somebody gets
- 1:27:58behind the dock in a courtroom and delivers an impassioned
- 1:28:02speech. It works better because of how
- 1:28:04they frame it in this movie. Yeah.
- 1:28:06I mean it just working off of the very like I don't I don't
- 1:28:09want to. Say simple, but just of like
- 1:28:10the, the pretty rock solid framework of Romeo and Juliet,
- 1:28:15It's like, OK, it's in the test of time.
- 1:28:18Yeah, we we've got one of the canonical texts of Western
- 1:28:21culture and we're going to work from that.
- 1:28:24But then and just the simple thing of like, you know, Bob,
- 1:28:27the Stanley Kramer comparison is like a perfect one because it's
- 1:28:30like, especially at the time, like well-intentioned
- 1:28:33progressive movies were often like, OK, this is going to be
- 1:28:36about white people encountering another culture and we're going
- 1:28:43to see it through their eyes and learn that it's OK to like it.
- 1:28:47Which again, at the time, it's still a step in the right
- 1:28:50direction, still commendable. But just like West Side Story
- 1:28:53taking like the basically taking the approach of no, this is just
- 1:28:58split evenly between these two cultures.
- 1:29:01And like, half the movie is, you know, white native born New
- 1:29:06Yorkers, half of it is Puerto Rican immigrants.
- 1:29:09We're going to give them equal screen time.
- 1:29:12They're going to like all the Puerto Ricans.
- 1:29:15They will have conflicts within themselves.
- 1:29:17They will be as nuanced and just like regular as the human
- 1:29:22beings, as all of the white characters.
- 1:29:25And this is just the standard for the movie.
- 1:29:27Again, talk about this. In 2026, it shouldn't feel like
- 1:29:31a big deal. But going back to that time, it
- 1:29:36was I, I will say. I I was watching.
- 1:29:41A I'll I'll give credit where credit is due.
- 1:29:44I was watching the YouTube channel Sideways that like
- 1:29:47focuses very heavily on musicals and like the technical aspects
- 1:29:53of the notes being played. And what he pointed out that I
- 1:29:57thought was fascinating was that The Jets, like light motif
- 1:30:01theme, the music that plays for them throughout the entire
- 1:30:06musical is actually, it's never not present when they are on
- 1:30:12screen. And it's used as the like hatred
- 1:30:17theme that like represents this like anger and hatred.
- 1:30:21And it plays when they're making fun of Officer Krupke and, and
- 1:30:26they're not even interacting at all with the the Sharks.
- 1:30:29They're talking about their own upbringings and stuff.
- 1:30:31And and it's like there's this hatred inside of them.
- 1:30:35The only people who don't have the hatred theme play for them
- 1:30:39is the sharks. Like you look at America,
- 1:30:43there's nothing related to that. And yet when you look at is it
- 1:30:50called cool it or Cool Cool? Yeah, when you look at Cool It.
- 1:30:55Has elements. Of that Jets.
- 1:30:56Hatred theme in it. When you look at the officer
- 1:31:01Krupke and the Lieutenant, what's the lieutenant's name
- 1:31:05shrank shrank when they come on to the scene, The Jets hatred
- 1:31:10theme plays and guess what happens?
- 1:31:14They're you know, yes, they're trying to put down all the kids,
- 1:31:17but they're also pretty racist towards the Puerto Ricans.
- 1:31:20And so within the musical structure, it seems like they're
- 1:31:25creating this idea without communicating it verbally, which
- 1:31:29is what I love. They are communicating this idea
- 1:31:32that, like, the Puerto Ricans are just defending themselves.
- 1:31:36They are strangers in a new land trying to make the best of it.
- 1:31:39And even when the Puerto Ricans are not present on screen, The
- 1:31:44Jets are still thinking about it and still finding ways to, like,
- 1:31:48embody that hatred. And I think it's a really subtle
- 1:31:51way of saying like, yeah, there there's a lot of problems in
- 1:31:56America, and these immigrants probably aren't one of them.
- 1:32:02Yeah. Well, and I think that's a great
- 1:32:04jumping off point to talk. About Rita Moreno as Anita in
- 1:32:08this movie, because it's just like, like by far the best
- 1:32:11performance in the movie. And I, you know, right before we
- 1:32:13pressed record, I'm talking to Brad and I'm like, it's, it's
- 1:32:17like watching LeBron play against a bunch of rookies.
- 1:32:20And that's not to say that like anyone else in this movie is
- 1:32:22bad. Like some of them are quite
- 1:32:24good. The way that you look at a
- 1:32:26rookie in the NBA and you're like, that dude's going to be an
- 1:32:28All Star one of these days. But also like you're playing
- 1:32:30with LeBron James and there's just moments where she's so far
- 1:32:35ahead of everybody in terms of acting and dancing and
- 1:32:39everything she does is just the most dynamic performance.
- 1:32:45But I will say, Patrick to to the Steven Spielberg version of
- 1:32:49this, there is one addition in the Spielberg film that I feel
- 1:32:53like is the best possible thing they could have done.
- 1:32:56Is it putting De Marino in the movie?
- 1:32:59Yeah. Well, Rita.
- 1:33:00Moreno is in the movie she plays.
- 1:33:01Doc Brad, There's a gender swap and she plays the Doc well.
- 1:33:05She plays Doc's widow, who is. Puerto Rican.
- 1:33:09And then it it's again, I think it's a great choice.
- 1:33:11It's like Doc had been white and there had she, she had had this
- 1:33:15same kind of relationship years earlier.
- 1:33:19So when she's like talking to Tony, you know, she's like
- 1:33:22speaking from experience about like what he's in right now.
- 1:33:26And also she sings somewhere and and again, Brad, I'm excited for
- 1:33:33you to watch the Spielberg one because it's like, I can't like
- 1:33:36even if you don't like it as much, there's no way you won't
- 1:33:40think it's good if you like the original.
- 1:33:42But it but it is just like seeing the way, just like the
- 1:33:46the way they like recalibrate things the way they like, like
- 1:33:49the way they totally change the way cool is like placed in
- 1:33:53there, the way it's like different people singing that
- 1:33:56song. It's I'm excited.
- 1:34:00It it's it's a. Cool movie.
- 1:34:01That that should have been a. Big hit when it.
- 1:34:03Came out and I'm I'll always be bummed it wasn't.
- 1:34:07I think one of the additions that they do that is.
- 1:34:10Really brilliant is the. Last, basically the last thing
- 1:34:13Anita says in the movie. And so it's the same as in this
- 1:34:15movie, you know, she goes to deliver the message to Doc's
- 1:34:18candy store and almost gets raped and gets caught.
- 1:34:23You know, the The Jets get caught at the last moment and
- 1:34:26she's humiliated and she's been assaulted and she does the whole
- 1:34:30thing about like, I wouldn't even spit on you if I was
- 1:34:32walking past you. But they in Spanish.
- 1:34:35She turns around and she, like, rejects America and says, you
- 1:34:41know, yo, soy Puerto Rican, and then, like, walks out.
- 1:34:45And it is the perfect conclusion to that character's tragic arc
- 1:34:49because throughout the entire movie, she's the optimistic one
- 1:34:53in the relationship with Bernardo about the American
- 1:34:56dream. She doesn't want to go back
- 1:34:57home. She likes the idea of buying
- 1:34:59things on credit. She likes the idea of, like,
- 1:35:01riding around in a car and getting these things.
- 1:35:04And she's ultimately the one that's the most crushed by the
- 1:35:07reality of America. And I think that it's just it's
- 1:35:09such a brilliant touch. Now, having said that, Rita
- 1:35:13Moreno doesn't get that line in this movie.
- 1:35:15But watching her deliver that final moment, especially in 1961
- 1:35:21when you're still, you still have the sensors in place for
- 1:35:23the most part. Like it's a it's a shocking
- 1:35:26moment and she's her face is smudged up and like, it's just,
- 1:35:31it's such a gut punch. And I think that's the reason
- 1:35:34she wins the Oscar. Like, that's the Oscar clip.
- 1:35:36And she freaking brings that home, man.
- 1:35:39Yeah. I mean, she's got she kind of
- 1:35:41for a. Supporting role.
- 1:35:43She does have the the trickiest stuff to play and it's like, you
- 1:35:48know, because she has to be like.
- 1:35:50Almost a mother. Figure to Maria like a mother
- 1:35:52slash sister figure, you know, a a love interest to Bernardo.
- 1:35:57She is like like America it you know, it's it's a duet, but like
- 1:36:03she's driving it. She gets like the dramatic
- 1:36:07climax right before the dramatic.
- 1:36:09Climax. Yeah, it's just, I mean, it's a
- 1:36:14thing where like, obviously Rita Moreno, like in her 90s, her
- 1:36:18career is still going strong. You know, she's Dominic
- 1:36:22Toretto's mother now. She's an 80 for Brady, a movie
- 1:36:28that is shockingly pretty fun. Oh, I've seen it.
- 1:36:33I just want to think that she's still Anita in.
- 1:36:36All of those movies but like this.
- 1:36:40This is such a *. Making performance.
- 1:36:43That she should have become like one of the biggest stars in the
- 1:36:46industry from this. It's just it is.
- 1:36:49I mean Bob the the LeBron playing against.
- 1:36:53Like amateurs. Is like, I'm not going to go
- 1:36:56that far because I'm like, everyone else is still like, you
- 1:37:00know, very good. Everyone else especially, like
- 1:37:03when it comes. Yeah, like.
- 1:37:04It's not like it's all. Like bad performances and then
- 1:37:08one star, but she steals the movie.
- 1:37:14Yeah. And now I do.
- 1:37:15Think if there's one person. That comes closest to stealing
- 1:37:18it from her. Maybe this is just me.
- 1:37:21Russ Tamblyn as Riff is incredible.
- 1:37:25First of all, look, the guy is like 30.
- 1:37:26Years old and he's playing a. Teenager, what are you going to
- 1:37:29do that them's the brakes? However, the athleticism of this
- 1:37:34guy is like it's sneaky athletic too.
- 1:37:36He's like the guy, you know, if we're going to keep the
- 1:37:38basketball references going here, Brad, he's like the guy at
- 1:37:41the Y, like the pick up guy that you don't think is going to be
- 1:37:43any good. And then just like everyone's
- 1:37:45exhausted chasing him around. It's little things like the way
- 1:37:49he climbs up on the on the pipe during jet song and then flips
- 1:37:52around backwards, gets his feet out from under him and then does
- 1:37:56another flip and lands. Or when they're at the the dance
- 1:37:59at the gym and he just does like a running flip in the air for no
- 1:38:02reason. There's there's so many athletic
- 1:38:05gymnastics feats and, and coupled with like, it's just a
- 1:38:09really good performance. Too.
- 1:38:11Yeah, it feels to me like this was nearing the end of.
- 1:38:15Like the dancer body in movies where there was a few of the and
- 1:38:21we're getting into the the chorus essentially.
- 1:38:24But like some of The Jets, some of the Sharks that you're like,
- 1:38:28they still have that like Fred Astaire, Gene Kelly kind of
- 1:38:31look. And when you watch them dance,
- 1:38:34you're like, yeah, no, they they didn't mess around with dance in
- 1:38:39the 40s and 50s when they were training and coming up.
- 1:38:42Because I just don't feel like you see people like that
- 1:38:45anymore. And I think that Russ is the
- 1:38:48epitome of that throughout the movie.
- 1:38:51Yeah, it's obviously he's not doing like he doesn't have
- 1:38:53quite. The the dramatic scenes that
- 1:38:56that like Rita Moreno has to play, but his thing is basically
- 1:39:00just like, it's like charisma and agility.
- 1:39:03Cause like you need the charisma.
- 1:39:04Oh, you do. Yeah.
- 1:39:05It was like I believe. This guy as.
- 1:39:07The leader of The Jets, he rocks.
- 1:39:12Yeah. It it's also one of those crazy
- 1:39:13things where it's like, it's funny to see, like, who did or
- 1:39:16did not do their own singing? It's like Russ Hamblin sang in
- 1:39:19other movies. Why didn't they let him do his
- 1:39:22own vocals here? No, what's funny is I and I
- 1:39:25remember seeing this on like the DVD.
- 1:39:27Extras. He cut a take of the Jet song
- 1:39:30and then they were like, not good enough.
- 1:39:32And then they hired another guy to sing kind of off key anyway.
- 1:39:36Yeah, so it's like, what? How bad must his take have been
- 1:39:40that it wasn't useful? I.
- 1:39:42Know, I know. Also a thing.
- 1:39:45I'm sorry. To keep bringing it up, but
- 1:39:46like, Brad, I'm excited for you to see Mike Feist as as as riff
- 1:39:50in the Spielberg one because that was all like like that was
- 1:39:53one where I'm like, oh, this is a very different thing than what
- 1:39:57Ross Damplin was doing. But also like and.
- 1:40:01And also that character gets it's it's like a a slightly
- 1:40:04media role in that one, but it's like, oh right.
- 1:40:07This is like a star making thing like this.
- 1:40:09Yeah like that that was like I was like who is this guy and put
- 1:40:14him in everything now and. And so but.
- 1:40:17But yeah, I mean the the the. I mean, look, I think the thing
- 1:40:20about West Side Story is the three most fun roles.
- 1:40:25The three best roles are. Always going to be Anita,
- 1:40:28Bernardo and Riff. 100%'s it. Yeah.
- 1:40:32Well, and I think that. Like with the rust hamblin.
- 1:40:34Thing You actually do get some great dramatic moments, but you
- 1:40:37have to kind of look on the fringes a little bit.
- 1:40:39And for me, there's this one scene.
- 1:40:41It's the scene where they're having the war council at Doc's
- 1:40:45candy store, and then Shrink comes in and he's already kind
- 1:40:49of flexed his racist muscles a little bit when he kicks the
- 1:40:51Puerto Ricans off of the playground in the first scene.
- 1:40:55But he goes all out in this scene and he looks at Bernardo.
- 1:40:58And is just. Like it's your word against mine
- 1:41:01and I have a badge. And there's a shot that they cut
- 1:41:05to kind of from Shrink's point of view, and it's looking
- 1:41:09slightly down on Bernardo. And then you see Russ Tamblyn
- 1:41:13sitting at the table behind him. And it's this great reminder
- 1:41:18that everybody in this movie who's not, you know, a, a police
- 1:41:22officer or Doc is a teenager. Because there's this kind of
- 1:41:25sheepish, like, he's afraid in that moment.
- 1:41:28Like Riff is afraid in that moment because a grown up person
- 1:41:33is doing this thing and he's not going to say anything because
- 1:41:37ultimately he's getting the same thing that he wants.
- 1:41:40But there's this all through the movie.
- 1:41:42There's this interesting dynamic of like, yes, we're fighting
- 1:41:46with each other, but this is not the adults fight.
- 1:41:49And when the adults try to impose upon us or impose rules
- 1:41:53upon us, like we'll stick together to get rid of the
- 1:41:57adults so that we can continue to have our beef.
- 1:42:00And it like, there's just something about the way that
- 1:42:04Russ Tamblyn plays that in that moment, the sort of
- 1:42:07sheepishness, sheepishness and, and scared demeanor of a
- 1:42:13teenager that I just, I really, really loved his performance
- 1:42:16this time around. And I I have to say I'm, I'm
- 1:42:20with. You 100.
- 1:42:21Percent on Russ Stanlon. I think that Simon Oakland as
- 1:42:28Shank is terrifying in that scene.
- 1:42:32I mean, he has this gravitas and power about him that separates
- 1:42:39him from the Officer Krupke of it all, where it's like, yeah,
- 1:42:42Krupke is somebody that, yeah, you understand why he's a joke
- 1:42:47in popular media for decades to come.
- 1:42:50There's like a terrifying power about Shank in that scene that
- 1:42:56you understand why The Jets don't like him, the Sharks don't
- 1:42:59like him, that he is this universally despised character
- 1:43:03that almost, it almost reminds me of like a Nurse Ratchet like
- 1:43:09type of power that it he can hold over a group of disparate
- 1:43:14people. I mean, just a great performance
- 1:43:17in just a few small pieces throughout the film.
- 1:43:20Do you remember Brad? We've seen him in one other.
- 1:43:23Movie that we've watched for this podcast.
- 1:43:27Give me a second to be I'm going to tell you what it is.
- 1:43:29It's the year. Before this.
- 1:43:31And what an insane 1-2 punch. He shows up in the last five
- 1:43:37minutes of Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho.
- 1:43:40And he is the, like, a psychiatrist that comes in and
- 1:43:43explains everything about Norman Bates and like how he thought
- 1:43:48that he was mother and all that. So he goes from that to this
- 1:43:50movie in back-to-back years and then does nothing else that I've
- 1:43:54seen after that. That's that's incredible.
- 1:43:58Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right.
- 1:44:01Well, we've talked. About pretty much everybody else
- 1:44:02in the movie except for our two leads.
- 1:44:04So guys, it's time for us to get around to Natalie Wood and
- 1:44:07Richard Baymer. Now, let's start with Natalie
- 1:44:10Wood because she is at this time really the only real star in
- 1:44:15this movie. She was a a pretty famous child
- 1:44:17actor. Obviously she has a tragic death
- 1:44:20a couple decades after. Yeah, let's let's really get
- 1:44:22into that. Guys.
- 1:44:24Do you have any theories about? What?
- 1:44:25What happened? Bob's Conspiracy Corner is is in
- 1:44:28full view now. Natalie Wood is like, a, an
- 1:44:31interesting case study here because, like, she doesn't do
- 1:44:34her own singing. She's not a natural dancer, and
- 1:44:38they don't give her a lot to do as Maria for 95% of the movie.
- 1:44:42And then the very last scene, I'm like, oh, yeah, that's why
- 1:44:46you hire Natalie Wood. Like it.
- 1:44:48It almost justifies casting her just to get that last three
- 1:44:52minutes of the movie out of her. Yeah, it it is a funny thing
- 1:44:57'cause like. You know, we we've already said
- 1:44:59that Tony and Maria, you know, not the most interesting part of
- 1:45:03the movie. And a a lot of Maria in this
- 1:45:07movie is like, oh, this is like a a nice child having her like
- 1:45:13first experience, like, you know, with like an infatuation.
- 1:45:18And also the music and the visuals are doing a lot of the
- 1:45:23heavy lifting there. Like when she and Tony first
- 1:45:26meet, like, you know, Bobby already talked about this, You
- 1:45:29know, when you know, the IT turns into that the everything
- 1:45:32else kind of like blurs out as it just becomes like the two of
- 1:45:35them. And it's like, oh, right, This
- 1:45:36is not, no, not to like, you know, discount the actors, but
- 1:45:40like, you know, this is not about acting, right?
- 1:45:44Now this is. This is the music and visuals
- 1:45:47telling the story and, and, and also like, you know, Maria has
- 1:45:53one famous song. Well, OK, you know, she's got
- 1:45:57multiple songs, but like, I think of her songs, there's one
- 1:46:01Maria song that is like OK, 2 Maria songs that are OK, fairly,
- 1:46:07fairly iconic, but like. Tony.
- 1:46:10Has more. Yeah, Tony has.
- 1:46:14Like 3. But and so, but, yeah, so like,
- 1:46:18Maria's like they're doing her thing.
- 1:46:19She's fine until you get to the final scene and then she brings
- 1:46:24it. And then it's like, OK, you know
- 1:46:26what? You're look, you are landing the
- 1:46:29plane here. Yeah.
- 1:46:31And. And she has to.
- 1:46:33Yeah. And and.
- 1:46:34She nails it when she looks around.
- 1:46:37And. Just, like, is, like, silently
- 1:46:40screaming at them all. And just, like, announces that
- 1:46:44hate in her heart. You're just, like, you're there
- 1:46:47with her. You're crying.
- 1:46:49It's powerful. Yeah.
- 1:46:52Well, and then you've got kind of like the inverse.
- 1:46:54Of that with Richard. Baymer, who's like, it's kind of
- 1:46:58unfortunate because I think that he is the worst actor in this
- 1:47:01movie and yet he does kind of exactly what you need Tony to
- 1:47:06do. He's charming as all get out.
- 1:47:07I'm never having a bad time with Tony.
- 1:47:11And like, you know, when they asked him to do some of the
- 1:47:14dramatic beats, like when Doc comes down and gives him the
- 1:47:17false information about Maria's death and he has to kind of
- 1:47:19react to that. It's like, you know, I would
- 1:47:21have liked another take of, of some of those moments and
- 1:47:24gasping for air and running through the streets yelling for
- 1:47:27Chino. But like I, I think I had a
- 1:47:31better time with Tony. Than I did with Maria.
- 1:47:34For most of this movie, but I would also say like I think
- 1:47:38Richard Baymer is a worse actor then Natalie Wood.
- 1:47:41Is that fair to say, Brad? I mean, I don't think you're
- 1:47:43wrong. I think this is a place.
- 1:47:45Where story matters, and I, I. Think that.
- 1:47:51If you make the Maria Tony love story just a little more
- 1:47:55believable, I think it benefits their performance because and
- 1:48:01all you have to do is like spread the movie out to take
- 1:48:05place over six months rather than 48 hours.
- 1:48:10That's all you have to do. And it's it feel I, I don't
- 1:48:13know, I'm not a scriptwriter. It feels pretty easy to like put
- 1:48:17in some natural like indicators of like it starts in the spring
- 1:48:22and then these scenes happen in the summer and then now in the
- 1:48:25fall we're getting to the rumble.
- 1:48:27And even like the fight between the two gangs feels more
- 1:48:31believable if you just give a few indicators that this is
- 1:48:33happening over a period of time. And so I think if if you make
- 1:48:38the love story more believable between the two of them, the
- 1:48:43little bit of scene chewing that you get in the love story of of
- 1:48:48Tony and Maria feels a little more breathable, a little more
- 1:48:52like, yeah, I know these are two young kids who despite their,
- 1:48:56you know, families, their cultures are falling in love
- 1:49:00with each other. But there's something about the
- 1:49:0248 hours of it all that makes me be like as you're not a good
- 1:49:07enough actor. To.
- 1:49:09Make me believe that, you guys. Truly fell in love in the last
- 1:49:1248 hours. It is so little time.
- 1:49:16It's one of those. Things where where I'm like.
- 1:49:18I feel like, you know, it's like a theater or movie thing where
- 1:49:22it's like we're we're going to compress time a lot and just go
- 1:49:26with us, even though this would never happen in in such little
- 1:49:28time. But yeah, it, it, it's a thing
- 1:49:30like to talk about Richard Baymer, who again, it is like
- 1:49:36whenever I watch this now, I'm just like, I can't believe that
- 1:49:38is Ben Horn from Twin Peaks. That's just like, it's so nuts.
- 1:49:44But but but but like to once again invoke the Spielberg one.
- 1:49:50I I remember like when the Spielberg one came out, a thing
- 1:49:54that I would, you know, hear people say constantly, is that
- 1:49:58like, oh man, it's great, except for Ansel Elgort and putting
- 1:50:02aside anything about like him, him as a person, but like he
- 1:50:05would constantly get brought up as like the weak link and, and I
- 1:50:09was always like, guys, I think he's fine.
- 1:50:13And the because Tony, Tony is always the least interesting
- 1:50:17character. That's it.
- 1:50:19It's like, you know what, he wasn't amazing in the 61
- 1:50:23version. It's like Tony is just kind of
- 1:50:26like this lunkhead who is like kind of nice and and falls in
- 1:50:32love and doesn't have a lot going on internally.
- 1:50:36And, and my thing with Tony is always like, can he pull off?
- 1:50:41Something's coming. And Maria?
- 1:50:43Oh, he can. Cool.
- 1:50:45Yeah, Tony works. That's that's basically like
- 1:50:49like those are the songs where the, the, the, the where it's
- 1:50:52like those are two of the crucial songs in the film.
- 1:50:56Like something's coming is, you know, is the I Want song and
- 1:51:02and, and Maria, which is, which is again, it's like less the
- 1:51:05actor's performance and more the music and what is happening
- 1:51:10visually convincing us that this person is in love.
- 1:51:14But also he's got to sing the song.
- 1:51:15And I'm like, well, Richard Bammer doesn't actually sing the
- 1:51:17song, but he has to look like he's singing the song.
- 1:51:21But but but that's the thing. I'm like, Oh yeah, if they can
- 1:51:24pull that off, and if the two of them can pull off tonight
- 1:51:27together, then I'm like, then it works that then, then, well, I
- 1:51:31think you guys, you've hit on something too.
- 1:51:34Where like their characters. Are not helped by the way that
- 1:51:37this compression of time is a is a real what's the word Brad, not
- 1:51:46asset liability to. The way this movie.
- 1:51:49Ends and like it's almost like I wish that they'd either compress
- 1:51:53time more so that like their desperation to get away was like
- 1:51:57I bought bus tickets earlier today.
- 1:51:59We have to get out of town right now.
- 1:52:01Are you coming with like there needs to be something there
- 1:52:04because he he murders her brother.
- 1:52:07He goes to her house. She's like you.
- 1:52:10Murdered my brother. And he's like, yeah, he also
- 1:52:13murdered Riff. And she goes, I didn't know
- 1:52:15that. Let's have sex.
- 1:52:17And like, that's, that's like literally it, it, it, it, it
- 1:52:21doesn't happen any longer than that.
- 1:52:23Like there's there's the suspension of disbelief.
- 1:52:25I like, I want to. I know this is a.
- 1:52:27Musical. I know it's heightened.
- 1:52:29I want to suspend my disbelief, but when she immediately
- 1:52:34forgives him after he confirms that he killed her brother, I'm
- 1:52:38just like. And there's so many little
- 1:52:40things they could do, you know, like, 'cause right after.
- 1:52:42That Anita comes in, catches them, and then they sing the
- 1:52:46song about like, you know, when you love somebody, you accept
- 1:52:50them for who they are. They're basically singing Sale
- 1:52:53of Thee, right? I mean, yeah, it's.
- 1:52:55When we were talking at the beginning.
- 1:52:57About how the like the post rumble section is like the the
- 1:53:03weakest part again, like, you know, the weakest part is in it.
- 1:53:07It's like everything else is like transcendent and the and
- 1:53:11and this and and this is not and so this is not like a major
- 1:53:15criticism, but I think like the the main weakness there is just
- 1:53:22that this is a stretch with major.
- 1:53:26Dramatic things. Happening without songs like the
- 1:53:31first. Like. 90 minutes of the thing
- 1:53:35are like. Wall to wall.
- 1:53:37Bangers and and it's like song after song and it's like, oh,
- 1:53:41these are the greatest songs ever written and like they are
- 1:53:46communicating so much. And then when they have to, and
- 1:53:49this is this is also a thing that I think I've seen lots of
- 1:53:54musicals like like stumble here where it's a thing even in like
- 1:54:00like original movie musicals from the past like 15 years that
- 1:54:05are big hits that I like anything from like Frozen to La
- 1:54:10La Land. I think like my like major
- 1:54:14criticism of both of those movies is that they need one
- 1:54:17additional song in like around the like 2nd and to third act.
- 1:54:23They like they have like they they like kind of forget to be
- 1:54:27musicals for a big stretch. And and in West Side Story, I'm
- 1:54:31like this stretch where you got a like like a lot of plot and a
- 1:54:37break from songs. Maybe a song could smooth?
- 1:54:43This over. And see, I I kind of disagree
- 1:54:48because for me. The the section right after that
- 1:54:52is where Anita goes to docs, the assault happens, and then the
- 1:54:56end of the movie happens. And like, that's songless.
- 1:54:58And it's really compelling. And for me, it's the scene where
- 1:55:01they're like, you know, in the bed chamber, they've just had
- 1:55:04sex. You know, they sing There's a
- 1:55:06place for us. And then Anita comes in and
- 1:55:08sings the song with Maria about like, we love our men and what
- 1:55:11are you going to do? And it's the songs that get in
- 1:55:14the way of the dramatic progression for me because like,
- 1:55:19I feel like you need even one line from Anita somewhere in the
- 1:55:23movie where she acknowledges like Bernardo's going to get
- 1:55:27himself killed. But I can't help but love him
- 1:55:30anyway. Because for me, it's it's the
- 1:55:33mental hurdle of her being like this guy standing in front of me
- 1:55:36just murdered my soon to be husband.
- 1:55:40But you know, what are you going to do?
- 1:55:42Like there's there's no point of commonality.
- 1:55:45Like Natalie Wood's just like, you don't understand.
- 1:55:48I love him. Don't you love anybody?
- 1:55:49It's like, yeah, you just. You just murdered him.
- 1:55:51Do you remember that? Like it's like my if I'm being
- 1:55:55really charitable. My thing here is like, until
- 1:55:59now, they kind of didn't consider that anyone could die
- 1:56:03in this conflict. They weren't killing each other.
- 1:56:07It was almost like this stupid childish thing of like, oh,
- 1:56:11you're running around and throwing rocks and, and I'm
- 1:56:14like, again, I'm not, I'm not sure I even believe this.
- 1:56:18Actually, I don't think I do, but I'm going to say it anyway.
- 1:56:20It's like they're all because this is such a short amount of
- 1:56:24time. It's like they are all.
- 1:56:26In shock. That people actually died from
- 1:56:30this, that no one is really being rational, are thinking
- 1:56:34through things because they had like had not even considered
- 1:56:38that death was like on the table.
- 1:56:40This this like doesn't feel real.
- 1:56:44I don't know. This is It's a musical.
- 1:56:46And and they got to get they. Got to get a lot of story in
- 1:56:48there fast and also there's so many songs that there's only so
- 1:56:51much story to fit in around songs.
- 1:56:54I think my favorite thing that they do in this movie.
- 1:56:57That's different from the Broadway show.
- 1:56:58Is they? They take the song cool and they
- 1:57:01move it from act one and Riff sings it before the rumble, and
- 1:57:05they move it to after Riff's death, and Ice sings it to get
- 1:57:09everybody else chilled out after the fact.
- 1:57:11And that is a song that like, you know, we're using the
- 1:57:13parlance of the late 50s and everyone's saying, you know,
- 1:57:16keep Cooley cool boy. And like, it sounds lame.
- 1:57:19But the way that it's used dramatically in this movie, I
- 1:57:23think it's like it's the key to making the second-half work
- 1:57:27because like you get that great little scene right before that
- 1:57:29with baby John and Arab where baby John's crying and he's
- 1:57:34like, what you like, there's a genuine moment of like, why are
- 1:57:36you crying? You know?
- 1:57:37And, and they're both trying to process their feelings and they,
- 1:57:40they do that by suppressing their feelings with the song.
- 1:57:43Cool. Which is why I get so pissed off
- 1:57:45about what happens with Maria and Anita after that, 'cause I'm
- 1:57:48like, what is your, I don't even understand your process here.
- 1:57:51It makes no sense. Brad, I'd love to hear your
- 1:57:55thoughts on on the, you know, not the finale necessarily, but
- 1:57:59like that last third of the movie, because for me that was
- 1:58:02the weakest part of the film. But it sounds like for you it
- 1:58:05wasn't quite as weak as that opening bit.
- 1:58:07I mean, I I think that would you include in the last?
- 1:58:103rd The scene where Anita is. I mean, I took it to be that she
- 1:58:16does get raped. They, you know, they, they stop
- 1:58:19it and it's a musical. And they're not going to show.
- 1:58:21It, but essentially the way they're implying it through
- 1:58:24dance. Sure.
- 1:58:24Yeah, they're implying it through dance.
- 1:58:26And just the way she walks. Out and the way she holds
- 1:58:29herself is so fragile and strong.
- 1:58:33It just I it, it just feels very intense as to what, regardless,
- 1:58:41regardless I like. For me, that scene.
- 1:58:46Is what holds up that final third of the movie.
- 1:58:51It's what holds up what Chino does at the end of the film.
- 1:58:55You're like, yeah, they're, they're not just fighting for
- 1:58:59little things anymore. They're fighting for their
- 1:59:02honor, for their their very lives.
- 1:59:07And then you get Natalie Wood. Just freaking.
- 1:59:10Knock A. Grand Slam out of the park at
- 1:59:12the end of the film. So I, I think the movie ends
- 1:59:15relatively well. I do agree that some of the
- 1:59:18pacing falls apart and a lot of it is kind of due to the story
- 1:59:23beats. But I, we, we've gone over that.
- 1:59:25I'm, I'm kind of with you on that, Bob.
- 1:59:28Well, I think that's a good place for us to transition to
- 1:59:31our. Last segment.
- 1:59:32Of the day, which we call Let's Make it a Double.
- 1:59:35We're near the end of the episodes of Things Listening To.
- 1:59:38The film and whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 1:59:41this one, even if it's struggle. It's the final segment of the
- 1:59:44day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:59:45Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:59:48movie to pair. Up with this one.
- 1:59:49To make the perfect double feature, I'm going to keep this
- 1:59:52as short and sweet as I possibly can.
- 1:59:54We've mentioned it 85 times already.
- 1:59:56You're going to pair this up with the Steven Spielberg remake
- 1:59:59of this from 2021? I don't really know what else I
- 2:00:02could pick for this, but Brad and Patrick, I'm all ears on
- 2:00:06your double feature recommendations.
- 2:00:08Brad, do you want to go first? Sure.
- 2:00:12Yeah, I. I was.
- 2:00:13Thinking about movies that fit this realm of people living in
- 2:00:19America trying to deal with a raw hand or a raw deal and
- 2:00:27making the best of a situation and fighting against things they
- 2:00:31can't control. And I landed on Fences with with
- 2:00:36Denzel. Oh, that's a good one.
- 2:00:38Directed by Denzel as well, Right.
- 2:00:40Yes, and. Also if it's another stage.
- 2:00:44Play adapted into a movie. It just feels like a lot of
- 2:00:47things from Fences would fit with what we're looking at here
- 2:00:51in West Side Story set in the similar era.
- 2:00:55Also just and to to use your LeBron like you got Denzel.
- 2:01:02And it's not that there's not other good performances in the
- 2:01:05movie. But.
- 2:01:05He. Carries the show.
- 2:01:07It's it's just him and Viola Davis.
- 2:01:09Like acting. You know, just it's, it's just
- 2:01:12like two faces on the Mount Rushmore of acting.
- 2:01:16Yes, exactly. That's a great thing, man.
- 2:01:19All right, Patrick, how about you?
- 2:01:20So. A thought that I.
- 2:01:21Had while watching the movie today is I'm I'm.
- 2:01:24Looking at being like is this the best?
- 2:01:29The color. Red has ever looked in a movie.
- 2:01:34There is so much use of red, whether in the sets or the
- 2:01:39lighting or the costumes, and it looks incredible.
- 2:01:43And I'm going to make an argument for another movie.
- 2:01:46But Brad. Hold up a SEC.
- 2:01:51And as I'm thinking about. This I'm like this might be.
- 2:01:54The best use of the color red in film history, with the exception
- 2:02:00of my pick for my double feature, which is Powell and
- 2:02:04Presburger's The Red Shoes. Oh, that's a good one, because
- 2:02:07it's also a a just another. Movie that.
- 2:02:10Is it's not a musical, but it is a movie about ballet and it is
- 2:02:17also. Right up there.
- 2:02:20With the best ever synthesis of music and movement and color in
- 2:02:30cinema history. And so it's not even quite the
- 2:02:32same genre, but it's like, look, you're getting, you're getting
- 2:02:35like, I don't know, like 4 hours or so of just the greatest red,
- 2:02:41the richest red you've ever seen with some of the best music
- 2:02:46humans have ever composed. So Brad, what's your red movie?
- 2:02:48I have not I've not seen your your.
- 2:02:52Pick so I I can't compare it. I would argue that and I
- 2:02:57wouldn't even necessarily say it's better.
- 2:02:59I would argue that up there you would have to put in mood for
- 2:03:02love. Oh yeah, I, I, I thought about.
- 2:03:07That, but also consider the red shoes has red in the title.
- 2:03:11It does. It's about a red option.
- 2:03:14We did have a long. Talk about red and green in
- 2:03:17Vertigo as well. Oh, and that was it.
- 2:03:19That's true. There's there's we've got some
- 2:03:20good red movies, I guess as well.
- 2:03:22I mean also there's. Like.
- 2:03:24My favorite Dario Argento. Movie Deep red also where the
- 2:03:29red is all red. Blood red in the in the title.
- 2:03:32Yeah, but but but. Truly like if you haven't seen
- 2:03:35the red. Shoes a contender along with in
- 2:03:38the mood for love for like I would put though if I had to
- 2:03:41rank like what are the 10 best looking movies ever made?
- 2:03:45These are in there. Yeah, just just just blind by
- 2:03:49the criterion. 4K of. Of the red shoes and and then
- 2:03:53looks like you know thank me later guys you know what else is
- 2:03:56one of the best looking movies of all time 19. 61's West Side
- 2:04:00Story and it's time for us to give final scores on these guys
- 2:04:04guys before we do that top. Three songs go Oh, OK.
- 2:04:12America's number one. Maria's number 2 and then
- 2:04:19probably. Something's coming.
- 2:04:20I like I sing the ACT 1 songs a lot more than anything from Act
- 2:04:242. I am going to cop out and say
- 2:04:27what Bob? Said I here's here's my hot
- 2:04:30take. I don't like cool at all.
- 2:04:36Brad, I'm excited for you to see the Spielberg version.
- 2:04:38Because cool is completely different.
- 2:04:41OK, That is like the biggest change.
- 2:04:43Cool is like an action scene in that one.
- 2:04:46I like that. I would enjoy There's a gun
- 2:04:49involved. Yeah, it's.
- 2:04:50Good. Yeah, it's it's a.
- 2:04:52Cool change. My top three are America.
- 2:05:00Something's coming. Tonight, Quintet.
- 2:05:04Oh dude. It's so good and.
- 2:05:06Then the smash cut to the the fence.
- 2:05:08At the rumble and it's red. That's incredible, the red
- 2:05:11filter. That then cuts out.
- 2:05:13It's Oh my God, there are so there's so also the way tonight
- 2:05:18quintet begins with just like silhouetted like like buildings,
- 2:05:24red filter. It's just black and red.
- 2:05:26It is. Oh God, it's so good.
- 2:05:29It's so good and and and. Then.
- 2:05:31Oh my God, you know, and then just got a wood cleaning out the
- 2:05:35window and the orange is so. Saturated that it's like blown
- 2:05:38out. It's just yeah man, guess what
- 2:05:41guys, this is a 10 out of 10 movie and I will hear no debate
- 2:05:44on that. So that's my score.
- 2:05:46I do think that that stretch of 10 minutes really pulled me out
- 2:05:51of the movie. But like the 1st 3rd of this
- 2:05:54movie is as close to like an orgiastic experience as one
- 2:05:58could have watching a film. So like it's a tent.
- 2:06:00I don't know. I don't care what anybody says
- 2:06:01it's a tent. Brad Patrick, where Where are
- 2:06:04you at 10? Out of 10, I yeah, I I assume I
- 2:06:08get. It it's like, this is not a
- 2:06:10science. Yes, the movie is imperfect, but
- 2:06:14it is also like, you know, the highs are so like, you know,
- 2:06:19stratospherically high that that it's like, you know, cinema
- 2:06:24doesn't really get as good as this.
- 2:06:29I I am with you. Guys, I love this.
- 2:06:32Movie. I am going to give it a 9.5.
- 2:06:35It's not. It's not quite a 10 on
- 2:06:37devastating. A huge blow to West Side Story.
- 2:06:43Them in Buffalo Trace. What are they going to do
- 2:06:45without Brad G's? Approval West, Robert Weiss will
- 2:06:51drown his sorrows. In in Buffalo Trace.
- 2:06:54Right. Exactly.
- 2:06:56Well, listen, we. We have.
- 2:06:57Almost gone as. Long as the film.
- 2:06:59Itself, you could, if you cut out the intermission, you could
- 2:07:01probably play this as a DVD commentary track and it would be
- 2:07:04damn good. We want to say thank you to our
- 2:07:07friend Patrick Williams for hanging around with us for this
- 2:07:09long. Patrick, it's always a joy and a
- 2:07:11privilege to have you here. Tell the people what you're
- 2:07:13working on and where we can find you.
- 2:07:15OK, cool. So I'm on a break between
- 2:07:17seasons of my show. We'll be back at some point late
- 2:07:22February, early March. We'll see.
- 2:07:25But yeah, go go check out the Patrick H Williams channel on
- 2:07:27YouTube or Nebula, where I talk about movies.
- 2:07:32You know, it's scripted, so it's more like eloquent and coherent
- 2:07:35than this. And and available exclusively on
- 2:07:40the platform Nebula. Go watch my 30 minute short film
- 2:07:44The Dinner Plan. It's a fun time and heavily
- 2:07:50involves the color. Red.
- 2:07:53Let's. It sure does.
- 2:07:55I have. I have.
- 2:07:56Watched it sponsored. By the color.
- 2:07:58Red. The color red, the art
- 2:08:01department and I had a had long. Conversations.
- 2:08:03About how are we? Utilizing the color red.
- 2:08:07Well guys, have you even seen the red shoes come?
- 2:08:09On man. Guys, I, I will unashamedly.
- 2:08:14Say, as a Nebula subscriber for multiple years now, it's a great
- 2:08:20platform, lots of great creators, Patrick obviously
- 2:08:24being one of them. You should go check it out.
- 2:08:27Nebula's pretty dope. Thank you.
- 2:08:29I really appreciate that. Yeah, that's the pull quote,
- 2:08:32Nebula. Pretty.
- 2:08:34Dope, pretty dope guys. If you would like to learn more
- 2:08:37about film and whiskey, you can find us on any of our social
- 2:08:40media platforms. Let us know what you think of
- 2:08:42the film West Side Story. You can find us on Facebook,
- 2:08:46Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 2:08:51We also have a Discord server where we talk about movies.
- 2:08:54And whiskey and all sorts of stuff going on in life.
- 2:08:58If you want to join the conversation, you can find a
- 2:09:00link to our server at the end of every single one of our show
- 2:09:03notes. Don't forget about our Patreon
- 2:09:06page, Patreon dot. Com slash film.
- 2:09:08Whiskey, where you can subscribe at three different tiers, you
- 2:09:12get bonus episodes, you get longer episodes, you get video
- 2:09:15episodes. We would love to have you join
- 2:09:18our community at patreon.com/film.
- 2:09:21Whiskey, Brad, we are coming back next week to hold up West
- 2:09:26Side Story against the film that IMDb tells me is the greatest
- 2:09:29movie ever made, 1994's The Shawshank Redemption.
- 2:09:34So join us for that one next Tuesday.
- 2:09:37But until then, I'm Bob Book, I'm Brad Gee, and we'll see you
- 2:09:41next time.