Latest / Kublai Khan and the Mongol Rule of China — Fexingo History / Kublai Khan's Failed Invasion of Annam and Dai Viet
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Kublai's failed invasions — Japan, Java, Burma, Champa — but one that really gets overshadowed is his repeated attempts to conquer Dai Viet, what we now call northern Vietnam. The Trần dynasty held him off not once, not twice, but three times, and they did it with tactics that would make any modern guerrilla commander proud. Luna: Wait, three times? I thought it was just once or twice. Lucas: Most people only remember the big ones in the 1280s, but the first invasion actually happened in 1257, before Kublai even declared himself khagan. His brother Möngke was still Great Khan, and he ordered a campaign to open a southern front against the Song Dynasty. The Mongols were already in Yunnan, having conquered the Dali Kingdom in 1253, so Dai Viet was the next logical step. Lucas: The commander was Uriyangkhadai — Subutai's son, if you can believe that. Same family as the legendary general who helped conquer the Kievan Rus'. He led a force of about 30,000 men south from Yunnan into Dai Viet in late 1257. Luna: Subutai's son — that's a serious pedigree. What happened when they crossed the border? Lucas: The Trần king at the time was Trần Thái Tông, and he tried to meet the Mongols in open battle near the capital, Thăng Long — modern-day Hanoi. It did not go well. The Mongols crushed the Vietnamese army, and the king fled south, abandoning the capital. The Mongols sacked Thăng Long in January 1258. Luna: So they took the capital — that sounds like a victory. Lucas: On paper, yes. But the Vietnamese had a plan. They'd already evacuated the city, taken all the food, and left nothing for the invaders. The Mongols were deep in unfamiliar territory, the climate was brutal — humid, hot, diseases they weren't used to — and supply lines from Yunnan were stretched thin. Within a week, Uriyangkhadai decided to pull out. He left a garrison, but the Trần regrouped, counterattacked, and the Mongols were gone by spring. Lucas: After that, the Trần agreed to a tributary relationship with the Mongols — sending tribute every three years — but it was really a face-saving measure. They never actually submitted to Mongol administration. Luna: So the first invasion ended with a nominal surrender, but the Trần kept their independence. Lucas: Exactly. And then, in the 1280s, after Kublai had become khagan and launched his invasions of Japan and Champa, he decided to deal with Dai Viet for good. The pretext was that the Trần were supposedly harassing Mongol supply lines to the Champa campaign. Actually, Kublai had ordered the Trần to let his troops pass through their territory to attack Champa from the north, and the Trần refused. That was enough for war. Lucas: So in 1284, Kublai sent his son, Prince Toghan, in command of a massive land army — 300,000 men, by some Chinese accounts — while a naval fleet sailed from the coast. The plan was a pincer movement: the army would march south from Yunnan, and the fleet would sail up the Red River to meet them at Thăng Long. Luna: That sounds overwhelming. What was the Trần response? Lucas: The Trần had a new commander, and he's the real hero of this story: Trần Hưng Đạo. He was a prince of the royal family, and he'd been preparing for years. He knew he couldn't beat the Mongols in a pitched battle, so he used scorched earth — abandoned the capital again, burned the rice fields, poisoned the wells, and retreated into the countryside. The Mongols took Thăng Long in early 1285, but it was a ghost town. No food, no supplies, and the Vietnamese constantly harassed them with hit and run attacks. Luna: So they took the capital, but again, they couldn't hold it. Lucas: Right. And while the army was bogged down, Trần Hưng Đạo launched a counteroffensive. The decisive battle was at Chương Dương, near the coast, where the Vietnamese navy attacked the Mongol fleet and destroyed it. Without naval support, the land army was cut off. By summer 1285, the Mongols were in full retreat, and Prince Toghan barely escaped with his life — he had to flee through the jungle, losing thousands of men to disease and ambushes. Luna: I can't believe Kublai tried again after that. Lucas: He did. The third invasion came in 1287. This time, Kublai sent an even larger force — again, under Prince Toghan, because apparently the prince wanted redemption, or Kublai was just stubborn. The plan was similar: land army from Yunnan, a huge fleet of about 500 ships carrying supplies and troops. Lucas: But Trần Hưng Đạo had learned from the previous campaigns. He let the Mongols advance, let them take Thăng Long again — for the third time — and then he struck at their logistics. The most famous battle was on the Bạch Đằng River in 1288. It's a river that flows into the sea near Hải Phòng, and it's the same river where, centuries earlier, the Vietnamese had defeated another Chinese invasion. Luna: The Bạch Đằng River — I've heard of that. They used stakes? Lucas: Exactly. Trần Hưng Đạo had iron-tipped wooden stakes driven into the riverbed at low tide, hidden underwater. He then sent a small fleet to lure the Mongol ships into the trap. At high tide, the stakes were submerged, so the Mongol ships sailed right over them. But when the tide went out, the stakes ripped through the hulls. The Mongol fleet was wrecked. Thousands of men drowned or were captured. Prince Toghan barely escaped again — this time, Kublai was so furious he banished him from court for life. Luna: That's incredible. And after three failed invasions, Kublai just gave up? Lucas: Not exactly. He considered a fourth invasion in the early 1290s, but his advisors talked him out of it. The cost was too high, and the benefits too low. Instead, Kublai settled for a tributary relationship — the Trần sent tribute, but they never submitted to direct Yuan rule. In fact, the Trần king, Trần Nhân Tông, even refused to come to Kublai's court in person, sending envoys instead. Kublai threatened war again, but by then he was old and ill, and he died in 1294 without ever conquering Dai Viet. Luna: For someone who built the largest contiguous empire in history, Kublai really struggled with Southeast Asia. Lucas: He did. And it's a pattern — the Mongols were a steppe cavalry power, and they had real trouble adapting to tropical environments. The disease, the humidity, the jungles, the rivers — it all worked against them. Plus, the Vietnamese were just incredibly resilient. Trần Hưng Đạo is still a national hero in Vietnam, and for good reason. Lucas: You know, speaking of things that keep going despite the odds — this show is a lot like those Vietnamese defenses. We keep making episodes because listeners like you support us. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing that makes a big difference. And it keeps the podcast ad-free. Lucas: Exactly. So, back to the story — one of the most interesting aspects of this whole conflict is how the Trần dynasty used diplomacy alongside military resistance. After the 1288 defeat, Kublai sent a peace mission, but the Trần played hardball. Lucas: They agreed to send tribute, but only if the Mongols recognized their sovereignty. They even offered to send a golden statue of a general — Trần Hưng Đạo — as a peace offering, but it was a symbolic gesture. The Mongols never actually occupied Dai Viet. Luna: So the Trần managed to play the tributary system to their advantage. Lucas: Exactly. They understood that the Mongols cared more about submission than actual control. As long as they sent gifts and acknowledged Kublai's supremacy in name, they could keep their independence in practice. It's a strategy that many kingdoms used, but the Trần executed it perfectly. Lucas: And there's a coda to this story. After Kublai's death, his successor Temür Khan — his grandson — actually considered another invasion of Dai Viet in 1295. But the Trần sent a tribute mission, and Temür accepted it. The peace held. Dai Viet remained independent for another 300 years, until the Ming dynasty invaded in the 15th century. Luna: So the Mongols, for all their power, couldn't hold onto Southeast Asia. It's a humbling reminder that even the greatest conquerors have limits. Lucas: Absolutely. And the Trần victory wasn't just a military success — it shaped the Vietnamese identity. To this day, Trần Hưng Đạo is revered as a symbol of resistance. The battle of Bạch Đằng is taught in every school. It's a story of a small nation using intelligence and terrain to defeat a superpower. Luna: I love that. It's such a different narrative from the usual Mongol success stories. Lucas: And that's what makes history fascinating — the moments where the expected outcome doesn't happen. The Mongols were supposed to roll over Dai Viet, but they didn't. And that's worth remembering.