Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Airbnb Used Photography to Raise Its Take Rate
Transcript
- Lucas: So back in 2011, Airbnb was still a pretty scrappy operation. They had maybe 50,000 listings globally, and a lot of those listings had terrible photos — dim lighting, cluttered rooms, photos taken on early smartphone cameras. The quality was all over the place. Luna: And that directly hurt conversion, right? If you're a guest scrolling through, a bad photo makes you swipe past. Lucas: Exactly. So Airbnb did something unusual. They decided to send professional photographers to hosts' homes for free. They'd schedule a shoot, a trained photographer would show up, take 20 to 30 high-quality photos, and upload them to the listing. No cost to the host. Luna: That's expensive at scale. You're paying a photographer for each shoot, plus travel time. How many listings did they do? Lucas: By 2012, they had over 2,000 photographers covering cities around the world. They eventually photographed something like 60 percent of all active listings. The cost per shoot was around $100 to $150. That's a big upfront investment. Luna: But I'm guessing the payoff came through higher booking rates. Lucas: Absolutely. The internal data showed that listings with professional photos booked two to three times more often than similar listings with amateur photos. And those hosts could charge 10 to 20 percent more per night. So the incremental revenue for Airbnb — through their commission — was massive. Luna: Let's do the math. A listing that might have booked 20 nights a year at $100 per night, with a 3 percent take rate, that's $60 in commission. After the photos, maybe it books 40 nights at $115. That's $138 in commission at 3 percent. More than double. Lucas: Right, but the really clever part is what they did with the take rate. At that time, Airbnb was charging hosts a 3 percent commission. But as the professional photography program proved its value, Airbnb gradually raised its host commission to 5 percent, then to 6 percent in some markets. They could argue that the photos were increasing host revenue far more than the commission increase. Luna: So it wasn't a unilateral price hike. It was framed as a value exchange. You get more bookings, you pay a bit more. Lucas: Exactly. And hosts went along with it because they saw the numbers. A host getting an extra $1,000 a year in bookings isn't going to leave over a 2 percent commission increase that costs them maybe $20. The elasticity of supply was low because the service was demonstrably creating value. Luna: This is actually a really smart way to raise take rate without losing supply. Instead of just announcing a fee increase, you bundle it with a service that increases the host's revenue. Lucas: It's a classic strategy in two-sided marketplaces. You find a friction point on one side — in this case, bad photos reducing bookings — and you solve it in a way that lets you capture some of the value you create. The key is that the solution has to be measurable. Airbnb could show hosts: before photos you had X bookings, after photos you have Y. Luna: But wasn't it risky? What if the photos didn't actually boost bookings? Or if hosts didn't want strangers in their homes? Lucas: It was a bet. But they had early evidence from a pilot in New York and Paris that it worked. And they made it opt-in, so hosts who didn't want photographers could skip it. Over time, though, the data was so compelling that many hosts felt they had to participate to compete. Luna: That creates a kind of arms race. If every listing in your neighborhood has pro photos, your blurry iPhone shots look even worse. Lucas: Exactly. And that's part of what made the program sticky. It wasn't just a nice to have; it became table stakes. Which is great for Airbnb, because they're not just selling a booking platform — they're selling a marketing service that hosts depend on. Luna: So the take rate increase was really a reflection of the platform's growing power. But it also required a huge upfront cost. How did they fund it? Lucas: Initially, they raised venture capital. The program was expensive — tens of millions of dollars. But investors saw the logic: spend $100 to acquire a listing that generates maybe $200 in incremental commission per year. That's a great return. And the photos also improved the guest experience, which drove demand. Luna: It's interesting that they didn't charge hosts for the photos upfront. They could have made it a paid service from the start. Lucas: That would have killed adoption. Hosts wouldn't pay for something they weren't sure would work. By making it free, Airbnb removed the friction and got massive scale. Then they recouped the cost through higher commissions over time. It's a classic freemium model applied to a marketplace service. Luna: I wonder if smaller marketplaces can copy this. If you're a niche marketplace with 5,000 listings, can you afford to send photographers? Lucas: It's harder. You need density to make the photographers' time efficient. A photographer might shoot three or four listings in a day in a dense city. If your listings are spread out, the cost per shoot goes up. But there are cheaper alternatives now — ai enhanced photo editing, virtual staging, even host training programs. The principle still works: improve the quality of supply to justify a higher take rate. Luna: So the lesson isn't necessarily 'hire photographers.' It's 'find the biggest quality gap in your supply and fix it, even if it costs money upfront.' Lucas: Exactly. And measure the impact. If you can show sellers or hosts that your intervention increases their revenue by 20 percent, you can raise your commission by 2 percent without losing them. The key is to tie the fee increase to the value created. Luna: This also relates to trust. Professional photos signal that the listing is legitimate. A blurry, poorly lit photo makes you wonder if the place is a dump or a scam. High-quality photos reduce that uncertainty. Lucas: Right. In a two-sided marketplace, trust is a form of liquidity. The more trust buyers have, the more transactions happen. And professional photos are a trust signal that's relatively cheap to produce at scale. Airbnb essentially outsourced trust-building to photographers. Luna: It's a nice example of a platform investing in its own ecosystem. Not every marketplace has the capital to do that, but the ones that do can create a moat. Lucas: Yeah. And it's worth noting that other marketplaces have copied this. Uber doesn't send photographers, but it does send professional drivers to train new drivers. Etsy offers listing optimization guides. The principle is the same: help your supply side succeed, and you can charge them more for the privilege. Luna: It's funny — we talk about take rates as this abstract number, but behind it there's usually a story about solving a real problem. In this case, the problem was 'my photos are terrible and I don't know how to fix it.' Lucas: And that's what makes a marketplace work. You're not just matching buyers and sellers; you're providing the tools that make the match successful. The take rate is the fee for that toolkit. Luna: Before we wrap, I want to mention something. We do this show every week, and it's ad-free. The reason we can keep it that way is that a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small group, but it covers the basics — hosting, research, a little coffee. Lucas: It's true. If you find these deep dives useful, that's the way to keep them coming. No pressure, but it helps us stay independent and focus on the numbers that matter. Luna: Anyway, back to the economics. So Airbnb's photography program was a classic example of investing in supply quality to unlock pricing power. It cost millions, but it paid for itself many times over. Lucas: And it allowed them to raise take rates gradually without sparking a revolt. That's the holy grail for marketplace operators: increase your cut without decreasing the number of transactions. Luna: So if you're building a marketplace today, what's the equivalent of professional photography? What's the one service you could offer that would make your sellers' lives easier and your platform more valuable? Lucas: That's a good question. For some, it might be inventory management software. For others, it's shipping logistics. The answer depends on where the biggest pain point is. But the model is the same: find the friction, solve it, and share the value. Luna: And measure everything, so you can prove the ROI to your suppliers when you raise your rates. Lucas: Exactly. Airbnb had the data. That's what made it work. They didn't guess — they knew. Luna: Alright, that's a good note to end on. Thanks for listening — we'll see you next time.