Latest / Politics By Faith w/Mike Slater / Scientist Warns: Big Tech Is Trying To REPLACE God With AI
Transcript
- 0:09America is the greatest country in the world.
- 0:11Welcome to our special Politics by Faith,
- 0:14the evolution of AI.
- 0:16Two wonderful guests coming up.
- 0:17We have a cosmologist
- 0:18and uh a wonderful
- 0:20preacher who did an awesome sermon on this topic
- 0:23not too long ago.
- 0:23I'm excited to talk to both of those people.
- 0:26How should Christians be thinking about and,
- 0:30and praying about
- 0:31the inevitable
- 0:33tidal wave
- 0:34of artificial intelligence?
- 0:36On our country
- 0:39It's a ton of money here too.
- 0:40Anthropic,
- 0:41one of these big AI companies,
- 0:42they may go public here soon.
- 0:43They're thinking about a valuation of $2
- 0:47trillion.
- 0:48Elon just
- 0:49hit the $1 trillion for the first time just the other day,
- 0:51and now we have a company that's gonna double that
- 0:53ton of money,
- 0:54ton of power.
- 0:55Ton of control.
- 0:56Like,
- 0:56and one of the controversies with anthropic
- 0:58is that
- 0:58our government
- 1:00department of war uses anthropic
- 1:02for aspects of our military.
- 1:04So there's a world where
- 1:06the military wants to drop a bomb and the woke people,
- 1:08whoever anthropic say no,
- 1:10we don't want you,
- 1:10we won't let you
- 1:12drop that bomb.
- 1:14There's a lot of variables here that we need to
- 1:16talk about when it comes to artificial intelligence or should I say
- 1:19super intelligence.
- 1:20Here's the president the other day at the
- 1:22United Nations.
- 1:24The United States also totally rejects any attempt to
- 1:27construct a globalist scheme to control
- 1:30for the artificial intelligence
- 1:33being spoken of
- 1:34so much now
- 1:36here and after officially called
- 1:38super intelligence,
- 1:40changing the name
- 1:41and that the use of the word artificial makes intelligence fake.
- 1:45It makes it sound fake and it is not fake.
- 1:48It's actually
- 1:50amazing.
- 1:51But we have to be careful.
- 1:53In fact,
- 1:53it is exactly the opposite
- 1:56of
- 1:56what it purports.
- 1:58From this point forward,
- 1:59all of United States documents and hopefully the world's will be changed to
- 2:04use the much more accurate term
- 2:07super
- 2:08as opposed to artificial.
- 2:10So it's
- 2:11super intelligence.
- 2:13In other words,
- 2:14welcome to the new world of super intelligence.
- 2:20Let's see if that goes.
- 2:21It sounds much better.
- 2:23It is much better and it's much more accurate.
- 2:26Let's see if I have any power.
- 2:30Uh,
- 2:32I prefer artificial.
- 2:34Because it is indeed artificial,
- 2:37not in the sense that it's fake because it's not fake.
- 2:38I mean you can
- 2:39type in something in artificial intelligence and real words come out or something.
- 2:42It's not fake,
- 2:43it's a real thing,
- 2:45but it's artificial.
- 2:46Uh,
- 2:46the
- 2:47etymology of the word artificial,
- 2:49it means,
- 2:50uh,
- 2:50the original definition means made by art or skill.
- 2:53Ours is the Latin word for art,
- 2:54so it's made by art or skill.
- 2:56It's not so much that it's fake,
- 2:58it just means that it's made by human hands.
- 3:02Which computers are.
- 3:02Computers are made by human hands.
- 3:05As opposed to our brain,
- 3:07which is made by God.
- 3:08God made our brains.
- 3:10Wisdom
- 3:11comes from God.
- 3:13Which is more important than intelligence.
- 3:15I wish we had super
- 3:16wisdom.
- 3:17That'd be a nice
- 3:18thing to have in America.
- 3:19It'd be nice to just have intelligence,
- 3:21if we had more intelligence.
- 3:22Let's start with intelligence before we go making
- 3:24the artificial kind.
- 3:26Here's the
- 3:27main thing I wanna talk about
- 3:29as we
- 3:29proceed here,
- 3:30and the main thing I'm gonna keep weaving in everything we talked about.
- 3:33God is in control of everything.
- 3:35Proverbs 19:21,
- 3:36Many are the plans in the mind of a man,
- 3:39but it is the purpose of the Lord
- 3:41that will stand.
- 3:42Remember that.
- 3:44My first specific point is
- 3:45the missing ingredient of AI.
- 3:48These
- 3:49big tech AI people,
- 3:50they're mostly atheists,
- 3:51they worship the self.
- 3:52They think they are God.
- 3:54They believe that they've created something
- 3:56that rivals or can defeat
- 3:59the human mind and in some ways they're right,
- 4:01like a computer beat the world chess champion back in 1997.
- 4:04OK,
- 4:05fine,
- 4:05but
- 4:06when it comes to
- 4:08the mass
- 4:10producing
- 4:10or processing power and all that
- 4:13computation ability,
- 4:14yeah,
- 4:14the computer can beat the human mind,
- 4:16but what computers cannot
- 4:17do.
- 4:20And can never do
- 4:22I have a soul.
- 4:23That's what makes it
- 4:24artificial.
- 4:25It's soulless.
- 4:26In the end,
- 4:27it's just zeros and ones.
- 4:29And Ameri uh people
- 4:31are so much more than that.
- 4:33But the big tech people don't believe in God.
- 4:35They don't believe in creation.
- 4:37So they don't believe in the soul.
- 4:39So they're always gonna be missing the most important ingredient
- 4:42of life.
- 4:44The soul
- 4:46They think the most important ingredient in life is the brain.
- 4:49So they're like,
- 4:49oh,
- 4:49we're gonna make a brain,
- 4:50we're gonna make a machine that's better than the brain.
- 4:52It's more processing power than a brain.
- 4:54Like,
- 4:54all right,
- 4:55congratulations.
- 4:55That's not what makes a person a person.
- 4:57It's not what makes a person a human.
- 4:59Christians know that's the soul.
- 5:01That's what makes us in the image of God.
- 5:03If we were merely zeros and ones and calculators,
- 5:05then computers have already won.
- 5:07Praise God we're more than that.
- 5:10So AI is missing the thing that makes us human.
- 5:12Very important to know that.
- 5:14And to
- 5:16Be grateful for that.
- 5:18Don't forget,
- 5:20God's in control of everything.
- 5:21Psalm 1153 says,
- 5:22our God is in the heavens.
- 5:24He does all that he pleases.
- 5:26Their idols
- 5:27are silver and gold,
- 5:28the work of human hands,
- 5:30artificial
- 5:31things.
- 5:33Second point,
- 5:33AI is an idol.
- 5:36In the way,
- 5:36in the sense that it's something people put trust in.
- 5:38People trust AI
- 5:40as if it's a source of authority,
- 5:42because we've been told for many generations now that the Bible is not
- 5:47a source of authority.
- 5:48So people are
- 5:50in a
- 5:51tizzy
- 5:52trying to find
- 5:53something,
- 5:54trying to find
- 5:55a quest to find something they can rely on,
- 5:59and AI has emerged as the ultimate arbiter of truth.
- 6:04But we're always looking for something like for a while it was science.
- 6:06The science says,
- 6:08remember that?
- 6:08It was always the science says and you're just supposed to take that as gospel.
- 6:12And then with global warming hoax and COVID,
- 6:14that's not a source of authority anymore.
- 6:15You don't hear anyone ever talk about the science anymore.
- 6:18But you'll hear people say,
- 6:19oh,
- 6:19AI says.
- 6:21Have you ever used it though?
- 6:23Have you used AI
- 6:24and you ask it a question and you know the answer it gives is wrong?
- 6:27And I'll,
- 6:28I'll,
- 6:28I'll be like,
- 6:29that's not
- 6:29the right quote or something.
- 6:31And
- 6:31it'll say,
- 6:32oh,
- 6:32you're right,
- 6:33I was wrong.
- 6:35AI will say whatever it needs to say
- 6:37to make you happy.
- 6:40Because it's all about worshiping you.
- 6:42It's what idols are really all about.
- 6:44It's itching ears.
- 6:45That's out of 2 Timothy.
- 6:47We'll talk about that with the pastor
- 6:49coming up in a little bit,
- 6:50but the Bible
- 6:51talks about that and it talks about itching ears,
- 6:53right?
- 6:53People telling you what you wanna hear to make you feel good.
- 6:56That's what
- 6:57AI does,
- 6:58and we trust it way too much.
- 6:59There's a survey that was done among Christians.
- 7:0161% of Christians
- 7:03say that they completely or somewhat trust AI when
- 7:05it comes to asking a question about life.
- 7:07You can see in this chart here it's
- 7:09different aspects of life,
- 7:10financial questions,
- 7:11health questions,
- 7:12stuff like that.
- 7:13But what's noteworthy about the survey,
- 7:14a couple of things,
- 7:15is that even among practicing practicing Christians,
- 7:18trust is high in every category.
- 7:20It's above 50% in every single
- 7:22category they ask.
- 7:23But among pastors,
- 7:25it's about 10%.
- 7:2710% of pastors trust AI.
- 7:29That's good.
- 7:30I mean,
- 7:30it's 10% too high,
- 7:31but that's good.
- 7:32What the pastors need to do though
- 7:33is express that hesitation with their congregations.
- 7:36Because people who go to church need to have
- 7:38just as much hesitation as the pastors do.
- 7:42I guess some good news of the survey is that among these Christians,
- 7:4470% are concerned about AI misinterpreting scripture,
- 7:48which is crazy because if you,
- 7:49if you're concerned that it's gonna misinterpret scripture,
- 7:51why would you not also be concerned that it's gonna misinterpret your financial
- 7:54advice that it's gonna give you?
- 7:56And by the way,
- 7:57of course it's gonna misinterpret scripture,
- 7:59cause who's programming it?
- 8:04You can't trust it.
- 8:04Garbage in,
- 8:05garbage out.
- 8:07AI is made with human hands.
- 8:09Human hands that
- 8:10hate God.
- 8:12It's,
- 8:13it's scouring the internet for everything that's been
- 8:14written on the internet about the Bible,
- 8:16and then it's gonna spit it out to you
- 8:17as if it's true.
- 8:19We trust that?
- 8:20No,
- 8:21don't trust idols.
- 8:23And said praise God that he's in the heavens and he
- 8:26Does all that he
- 8:27pleases.
- 8:28Don't forget God's in control.
- 8:30Job 42:2.
- 8:31I know that you can do all things
- 8:34and that no purpose of yours
- 8:36can be thwarted.
- 8:38Third point I want to make before we get going is it's all about the money,
- 8:41these predictions about AI taking all of the jobs.
- 8:45I thought that for a while,
- 8:46but I'm not so sure about it anymore.
- 8:48Two reasons.
- 8:49First,
- 8:50the people who make
- 8:52People who run these AI companies,
- 8:53they have an incentive to say that they're going to take everyone's jobs
- 8:58because they need to raise money.
- 9:00And the way for them to raise a lot of money,
- 9:01which they need a lot of money,
- 9:02is to tell the would-be investors that
- 9:07Their productivity potential is very high.
- 9:10OK,
- 9:10it's like,
- 9:11why should I give you money?
- 9:12Oh well,
- 9:13it's gonna do everything.
- 9:15So if you invest
- 9:16With us,
- 9:16you're gonna make so much money because it's gonna take all the jobs,
- 9:20right?
- 9:21So they have an incentive to exaggerate,
- 9:22that's what I'm saying.
- 9:25I don't know what's gonna happen when it comes to disruptions,
- 9:27a lot,
- 9:28like a lot for sure,
- 9:30probably on an industrial revolution-like scale.
- 9:33But a doomsday scale,
- 9:35I don't know.
- 9:36I don't know.
- 9:36My,
- 9:36my point here though is that it's all about money,
- 9:38and money is power.
- 9:41And
- 9:43They're gonna be very successful when it comes to that.
- 9:45A $2 trillion evaluation for anthropic.
- 9:50But I know ultimately they won't be successful.
- 9:53Because
- 9:54none of what they're doing is done
- 9:55to glorify God.
- 9:58Genesis 11:3.
- 10:00And then they said to one another,
- 10:01Come,
- 10:01let us make bricks
- 10:02and burn them thoroughly.
- 10:04Right,
- 10:05so they,
- 10:05they have a new technology.
- 10:06This is a technological advancement.
- 10:10They used to use like they used to have like
- 10:12mud.
- 10:12They used to make bricks from mud
- 10:14and it would,
- 10:14it would melt or the mud would,
- 10:16you know,
- 10:16get wet or whatever and it wasn't good for building tall buildings,
- 10:19but now they have this technological
- 10:21advancement
- 10:22way better than sun dried mud bricks.
- 10:24This new building material,
- 10:26it's gonna last forever.
- 10:27So what do we do with it?
- 10:27Let's build a tower.
- 10:29Then they said,
- 10:30come,
- 10:30let us build ourselves a city and a tower
- 10:33with its top in the heavens,
- 10:34and what?
- 10:35Let us make a name
- 10:36for ourselves.
- 10:38Were they doing it to glorify God?
- 10:39Nope,
- 10:40they were doing it to glorify themselves.
- 10:42And God
- 10:43had other plans because God
- 10:45is always in control.
- 10:48In the midst of this
- 10:49tech revolution that we're living in right now.
- 10:52I'd like to go back to Joseph.
- 10:54Joseph's brothers,
- 10:55of course,
- 10:55sold him into slavery.
- 10:56Joseph ended up #2 top dog in Egypt.
- 10:59And then when he met his brothers again,
- 11:01they had the great line.
- 11:03As for you,
- 11:03you meant evil against me,
- 11:05but God meant it for good.
- 11:08To bring it about that many people
- 11:10should be kept alive.
- 11:12I believe the people running AI are doing it for evil,
- 11:14or at least they're amoral
- 11:16about it all.
- 11:18We
- 11:19should pray
- 11:20that God uses this
- 11:22for good.
- 11:24The people running,
- 11:25building AI,
- 11:26no way are they doing this to glorify God.
- 11:29They don't even think he exists.
- 11:30They think they're God.
- 11:32But we can glorify God
- 11:34and all the things we do with it.
- 11:35I wanna go to a very smart person,
- 11:37Doctor Brian Keating.
- 11:39He is an experimental,
- 11:40I wanna say cosmetologist,
- 11:42but that's because I'm not a smart person.
- 11:44He's a cosmologist
- 11:45at UC San Diego and he's the host of the show.
- 11:48Into the Impossible with Brian Keating.
- 11:50Doctor Keating,
- 11:51how do you do,
- 11:51sir?
- 11:52Very well.
- 11:53It's good to be with you,
- 11:54and you could say cosmetology.
- 11:55You look very handsome.
- 11:56You're very handsome and you have good hair and that's what cosmetologists do.
- 12:00But actually,
- 12:01yeah,
- 12:01they do have they do.
- 12:04They have a prefix.
- 12:05I was gonna say what percentage of people call you a cosmetologist,
- 12:08uh,
- 12:09more than call me an astrologer,
- 12:11which I'm also not,
- 12:12OK.
- 12:14Fair enough.
- 12:15Um,
- 12:16let's chat about AI.
- 12:17Um,
- 12:18you made a reference earlier that AI is
- 12:20like the Tower of Babel.
- 12:22Say more,
- 12:23what are their similarities?
- 12:25Well,
- 12:26you know what's interesting in the Torah and the Old Testament,
- 12:28ah,
- 12:28in the Bible,
- 12:30that the Tower of Babel is a very famous story,
- 12:32but it's always
- 12:34mentioned without mentioning that in the actual Hebrew in the original,
- 12:38it's actually always the city and the Tower of Babel.
- 12:41In other words,
- 12:41there's an association between the technology
- 12:44and the inhabitants and the population,
- 12:46both the population that creates it.
- 12:48That desires it,
- 12:50that seeks to
- 12:52actually,
- 12:52as it says,
- 12:53make war with God,
- 12:55to be as one with one voice,
- 12:57etc.
- 12:58and the city,
- 12:58the inhabitants,
- 12:59and the,
- 13:00the,
- 13:01the Bible is,
- 13:01is quite skeptical of cities.
- 13:04Um,
- 13:04there are good things that come from cities,
- 13:05but there are a lot of bad things that come from cities.
- 13:08And I think one of them is,
- 13:10is this sensation that you can sort of divorce yourself from the rest of the world,
- 13:14the real people
- 13:15in sort of,
- 13:16you know,
- 13:16flyover country.
- 13:17I always hate that term,
- 13:18but,
- 13:19um,
- 13:19living here on the coast in San Diego,
- 13:21we,
- 13:22we have,
- 13:22uh,
- 13:22you know,
- 13:22sort of inflated ego about our importance.
- 13:25And I think that's sort of what's happening.
- 13:27We see that with the creation of artificial intelligence.
- 13:30Which is both as also as the Bible says,
- 13:34is a double-edged sword.
- 13:35So I,
- 13:36I often joke,
- 13:37you know,
- 13:37where are the single-edged swords that only do good,
- 13:39but
- 13:40In this case,
- 13:40it's a double-edged sword.
- 13:42It can do good,
- 13:43it can do wonderful things,
- 13:44it can discover drugs,
- 13:45it can
- 13:46help your kids with their homework,
- 13:48uh,
- 13:48but it can do awful things too.
- 13:49It can create super viruses,
- 13:51it can create,
- 13:52you know,
- 13:53incredible weapons and technology that could be used for destruction,
- 13:56and it could
- 13:57teach your kids to fall in love with an AI avatar that doesn't exist and in some cases,
- 14:02allegedly be contributing to their propensity for suicide.
- 14:06So how do we monitor this as parents,
- 14:07as,
- 14:08as,
- 14:08you know,
- 14:08members of cities,
- 14:09of society in America,
- 14:12when we can't divorce ourselves from
- 14:15the other countries that are also striving to create this technology?
- 14:19And what I see now is a,
- 14:20is a very terrifying
- 14:22juxtaposition
- 14:23of,
- 14:24of these two forces,
- 14:25the two sides of the sword,
- 14:26the two edges.
- 14:27In in that you have the creators,
- 14:29the progenitors,
- 14:30the,
- 14:31the ones that are responsible for that.
- 14:32And by the way,
- 14:33they have these interesting names like Sam
- 14:35Altman,
- 14:36like an alternative man,
- 14:38and then Dario,
- 14:40Dario Amode,
- 14:41which means lover of God or love of God,
- 14:43right?
- 14:43Amo like amateur day means God.
- 14:46In Latin,
- 14:47and then Elon Musk,
- 14:48I don't know,
- 14:48maybe he's got a nice smell or something like that.
- 14:50But
- 14:51there,
- 14:51there are these names that are associated,
- 14:53and they've become like gods to us,
- 14:55right?
- 14:56They can do superhuman things.
- 14:57It used to be,
- 14:57if you had a question,
- 14:58who do you go to?
- 14:59You go to your
- 15:00priest,
- 15:00you go to your rabbi,
- 15:01you go to your minister,
- 15:02you go to your preacher.
- 15:03Now you tell things that you would never tell to them,
- 15:06to the AIs to get answers,
- 15:08to get the hive mind,
- 15:10the,
- 15:10the brain,
- 15:11the global brain
- 15:12working,
- 15:12coordinating with the sum total of human knowledge,
- 15:15which is both beautiful and it's terrifying.
- 15:17And
- 15:18these models have gotten incredibly powerful,
- 15:21and there's no slowing them down.
- 15:22And the leaders,
- 15:23the Anodays,
- 15:24the Altmans,
- 15:25they're now saying that we need to slow down our own technology
- 15:29because it's so dangerous,
- 15:30and you need to regulate us.
- 15:31And by the way,
- 15:32you may need to take us over,
- 15:34and I think that is the ultimate goal.
- 15:36They want the government to subsidize them.
- 15:38They want the government to be responsible,
- 15:40to shepherd them
- 15:42as they play God
- 15:43themselves.
- 15:44And I think that's quite dangerous,
- 15:46unprecedented,
- 15:47and I'm quite excited,
- 15:49but I'm also worried.
- 15:50As somebody who uses it every day for his teaching,
- 15:52for his,
- 15:53his own kids,
- 15:54um,
- 15:55I use it,
- 15:55I thrive on it,
- 15:56but you have to be very careful with it.
- 15:58It's a very powerful
- 15:59technology.
- 16:01I agree with everything you said.
- 16:02Now we go back to Tower Bible.
- 16:03The point we made earlier was that
- 16:05they made bricks.
- 16:06So this is a technological advancement like,
- 16:08wow,
- 16:08we're now able to make these bricks and this
- 16:10bitumen and,
- 16:11and stuff.
- 16:11We're able to build taller
- 16:13than ever before.
- 16:14I love your city point as well.
- 16:16Um,
- 16:16but it's like anything with these double-edged swords,
- 16:18right?
- 16:19Uh,
- 16:19who was it who said that fire can be a,
- 16:21uh,
- 16:22a good master but a terrible slave or however it goes,
- 16:25right?
- 16:25And,
- 16:25uh,
- 16:26you can use a knife to cut your food and you can use a knife to murder someone.
- 16:30So as a scientist,
- 16:32how do you think
- 16:34about technological progress?
- 16:35How do you think about a scientific advancement
- 16:38and weigh the good and the bad
- 16:40from a scientific mind?
- 16:41How do you do that?
- 16:42Yeah,
- 16:43purely scientifically,
- 16:45I'm an accelerationist.
- 16:46I would love to see nothing more than
- 16:48The solutions to age-old problems that I've wondered about
- 16:51simply because it would allow me to do something that's uniquely human,
- 16:54which is to
- 16:55have my curiosity stoked to investigate the questions
- 16:59that then I prompt the artificial intelligence with.
- 17:02I think that's the healthiest,
- 17:03the safest way to use it.
- 17:05Use it as a curiosity amplifier.
- 17:07You know,
- 17:07I have graduate students,
- 17:08they're made of flesh and bone.
- 17:10They're the smartest people,
- 17:11you know,
- 17:11I'll ever know,
- 17:13and I'm,
- 17:13I'm entrusted with them by their parents,
- 17:15uh,
- 17:15by the university,
- 17:16etc.
- 17:17and we have deep relationships.
- 17:19Uh,
- 17:19we,
- 17:19I go to their weddings,
- 17:20I,
- 17:20you know,
- 17:21counsel them,
- 17:21and they,
- 17:22they're wonderful.
- 17:22They're almost like children,
- 17:23but,
- 17:24you know,
- 17:24of course it's,
- 17:24it's separate from my actual children,
- 17:26uh,
- 17:27but I feel responsible for them.
- 17:28I get to interact with them and stimulate their
- 17:31young minds to become the future leaders of science.
- 17:34I worry about them in the age of AI.
- 17:36But currently I'm trying to make them AI native.
- 17:39Right now there's a battle in the university.
- 17:41We start teaching today.
- 17:43Classes open at UC San Diego,
- 17:45and
- 17:46there's a war between the,
- 17:47the people that the professors that know how to use AI that wanna use AI
- 17:51and the students who wanna use it,
- 17:53who are,
- 17:53uh,
- 17:54use it for good.
- 17:55And then there's also the double-edged sword again,
- 17:57you cannot escape this analogy.
- 17:59The double-edged sword is that they use it to do their homework to.
- 18:02Solve their problems,
- 18:02to bypass the thought process themselves.
- 18:06You know,
- 18:06when I was a kid in the 90s in,
- 18:07in,
- 18:08in college,
- 18:09we,
- 18:09we had this cartoon in our student newspaper and it was
- 18:11first day of class,
- 18:12professor standing up on stage,
- 18:14a room full of students staring up at the professor in wide-eyed amazement.
- 18:18And then the next day,
- 18:19the students get replaced by,
- 18:20by tape recorders.
- 18:21Remember those?
- 18:22I don't know,
- 18:22you might be young,
- 18:23you might not remember tape recorders,
- 18:25tape recorders recording
- 18:26the professors speaking,
- 18:28and then the last scene is a,
- 18:29is now,
- 18:30uh,
- 18:30uh,
- 18:31the professors replaced by a tape recorder
- 18:33playing that lecture to the students who are listening on their tape recorder.
- 18:36It's crazy.
- 18:37Now we have exactly that.
- 18:39You know,
- 18:39my students don't use Instagram in class anymore.
- 18:41They're using AI.
- 18:43Uh,
- 18:43it could be great,
- 18:44it could enhance their understanding.
- 18:45I'm not the best educator.
- 18:47I often wanna take classes with Albert Einstein.
- 18:49I'm too young.
- 18:50I can't do that unfortunately,
- 18:51but I have all of his collected works.
- 18:53I can create an AIAE,
- 18:55an artificial Einstein.
- 18:57That's the good news.
- 18:58The bad news is that it can completely shortcut the
- 19:01process that not only are these kids dedicating 4 hard years of their lives to,
- 19:05but they're also their parents can be spending at a at a private school,
- 19:08and I teach at a public university.
- 19:10But a private schools,
- 19:11$250,000
- 19:12500,000 dollars.
- 19:13Uh,
- 19:13that to me is insane and it's not what this technology is best used for.
- 19:17So
- 19:18I caution people to,
- 19:19to use it as a thinking partner,
- 19:22as a sounding board.
- 19:23It's a wonderful editor,
- 19:24but it cannot be used for primary creation.
- 19:27And recently I had an article that I wrote in my newsletter,
- 19:30my website Brian Keating.com.
- 19:32And it has to do with
- 19:33the double-edged
- 19:34feature of
- 19:35nuclear power.
- 19:37Nuclear,
- 19:37as you said,
- 19:38fire was a powerful weapon.
- 19:39It could be used,
- 19:40it could be harmful,
- 19:41it could be helpful.
- 19:41Nuclear
- 19:42technology is an even better analogy.
- 19:44Nuclear
- 19:44technology is used to end World War II,
- 19:46but now it's threatening America
- 19:48as well.
- 19:51I worry about this cognitive offloading if we do that for a generation or so.
- 19:55Will we even know what to think or how to think or or can we
- 19:59onload that cognitive thinking process again or
- 20:02have we just totally uploaded it to the cloud and now it's gone forever?
- 20:06I worry about that.
- 20:07How many phone numbers do you remember I guess my last question.
- 20:09Yeah,
- 20:10please go ahead.
- 20:11No,
- 20:11I was gonna say as an illustration of the danger that you just mentioned,
- 20:14how many phone numbers do you remember?
- 20:16I mean,
- 20:16I,
- 20:16I know my,
- 20:17my mother-in-law,
- 20:18my mother,
- 20:19my wife,
- 20:19uh,
- 20:19in case they're listening,
- 20:21uh,
- 20:21but,
- 20:22but besides that,
- 20:23I don't,
- 20:24I don't even know some of my kids' phone numbers and I can't remember them.
- 20:26And that's what we've done.
- 20:27We cognitively offloaded,
- 20:29offshored,
- 20:30just like we're doing with jobs with,
- 20:32with our manufacturing.
- 20:33That has nothing but,
- 20:35you know,
- 20:36at least caution signs that should be flashing in your mind.
- 20:39Mm,
- 20:40I,
- 20:40uh,
- 20:40I can remember my high school friends' phone numbers.
- 20:42How about that?
- 20:43I can remember phone numbers from when
- 20:44I was 13
- 20:46and I wanted to go to Ben's house,
- 20:47but I don't remember,
- 20:48I don't know anyone else's cell phone now.
- 20:50I love that analogy.
- 20:51Um,
- 20:52what do you say about the people who are running this?
- 20:54I mean,
- 20:54you mentioned their names and that's,
- 20:56that's very interesting.
- 20:57What is their worldview
- 20:59that maybe we should be concerned about as the
- 21:01people who are gonna be controlling this technology?
- 21:03I'm very,
- 21:04uh,
- 21:04dismayed by them,
- 21:05to be honest with you.
- 21:06Uh,
- 21:07some of them are,
- 21:07you know,
- 21:08one degree separation,
- 21:09friends of mine,
- 21:10friends of friends of mine.
- 21:12Um,
- 21:12very scary.
- 21:13When you hear things like,
- 21:14uh,
- 21:14Sam Altman when asked in,
- 21:16in,
- 21:16in front of Congress about these
- 21:18effects and,
- 21:19and then considering in the comparison that he made.
- 21:22Uh,
- 21:23was,
- 21:23was to,
- 21:24well,
- 21:24don't look at how much energy and data center usage
- 21:27my models used to train to do these,
- 21:29these queries and responses.
- 21:31Look at how much it costs to train your child
- 21:33till he's 18.
- 21:35And I thought,
- 21:36you know,
- 21:36a child is a precious gift of God,
- 21:38and,
- 21:38and an AI is a,
- 21:39is a piece of silicon electrified
- 21:42and,
- 21:42you know,
- 21:42processed,
- 21:43you know,
- 21:43in,
- 21:43in data centers around the world using tremendous amounts of resources
- 21:47that we'll never be able to capture back.
- 21:49And so I,
- 21:50I worry about this.
- 21:51I worry what they do with your data.
- 21:52I don't trust it with,
- 21:54with personal stuff.
- 21:55There's ways to anonymize it.
- 21:56I'm gonna be writing about that on my newsletter.
- 21:58How do you do safe searching?
- 22:00How do you do get extract the most out of the technology?
- 22:04But keep your private data,
- 22:05it's the most valuable commodity that you have,
- 22:07because it's the one thing that they cannot do.
- 22:10They have to train on what humans have done,
- 22:12which is,
- 22:13by the way,
- 22:13one of the reasons I'm not as terrified as
- 22:16many of my Doomer friends are,
- 22:18that it's going to create a hyper
- 22:20advanced,
- 22:20you know,
- 22:21species of Terminator 9000s,
- 22:24because it has to train on what humans do.
- 22:26It is not generative ab initio.
- 22:29It cannot start from scratch
- 22:31and come up with the Brandenburg concertos
- 22:33or come up with Shakespeare or,
- 22:35you know,
- 22:35anything,
- 22:35God forbid,
- 22:36anything like the Torah,
- 22:38the Old Testament or the New Testament.
- 22:39It's,
- 22:40it's,
- 22:40it's lame.
- 22:41It's impotent.
- 22:42It needs us.
- 22:43It needs the prophets.
- 22:44It needs the minds.
- 22:45It needs human,
- 22:47uh,
- 22:47human intuition.
- 22:48It can't have that,
- 22:49so it won't be what we're worried about,
- 22:52but it can do a lot of damage in the meantime,
- 22:54and it can do a lot of good.
- 22:55And I,
- 22:56I urge people to,
- 22:57to,
- 22:58you know,
- 22:58pay attention,
- 22:59to learn about this,
- 22:59to play around with it.
- 23:01Don't expose private secrets,
- 23:02your medical stuff,
- 23:03your,
- 23:03your accounting,
- 23:04financial stuff.
- 23:06Make sure you trust what you're doing.
- 23:07There's types of AI called local models,
- 23:09which I write about on my website.
- 23:11How do you run it on your own computer so it never goes to Sam Altman's house
- 23:14and used by that alternative man named Sam.
- 23:20Doctor Brian Keating,
- 23:21experimental cosmologist,
- 23:22UC San Diego.
- 23:23Go watch Into the Impossible
- 23:26with Brian Keating,
- 23:27and then you said the newsletter,
- 23:28Brian Keating.com.
- 23:30Brian,
- 23:30great to talk to you,
- 23:31sir.
- 23:31Thank you.
- 23:32Great.
- 23:33Thank you so much,
- 23:33guys.
- 23:35What a superb answer to the question about the problem with their worldview
- 23:38and what a great that that Altman can't understand the difference between
- 23:42the
- 23:42input
- 23:43costs
- 23:44for an AM model versus into a human child.
- 23:47He sees those as interchangeable
- 23:49things because he denies God and therefore that people are made of the image of God.
- 23:52That's a beautiful example.
- 23:53We're gonna talk to a pastor coming up next to expand on.
- 23:56And
- 23:56something else Doctor Keating talked on is that
- 23:58Brian gave or Austin gave a sermon recently about
- 24:00how these AI leaders
- 24:02indeed do want to come up with a,
- 24:05a new Bible or,
- 24:06or their own
- 24:07Bible because
- 24:08AI knows all the truth.
- 24:10So why don't we let it
- 24:11come up with its own
- 24:12book that we should all follow?
- 24:14Scary stuff.
- 24:15I'll talk with Austin Hamrick next
- 24:16right here on the first TV
- 24:18and Politics by faith.
- 24:19Spread the word.