Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Emergency Podcast: NCUA Conserves and Removes the Board of Aldersgate Federal Credit Union - Why its a Bold Move
Transcript
- 0:03Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with an emergency episode with flying colors.
- 0:07It's an emergency because NCA conserved a credit union today,
- 0:11and they just announced it.
- 0:13I got an email, let's see, when did my email come in?
- 0:16I got an email.
- 0:18I.
- 0:18Nsu a express at 1203.
- 0:20I'm recording this one hour and 15 minutes later.
- 0:23One 18 on Wednesday and they conserved a credit union by the name of it's
- 0:29in the Western re region, alders Gate Charter number 1 5 0 6 8 2.
- 0:34Assets listed of $10,577,000.
- 0:39811 members.
- 0:42And the CEO's name is Marilyn Sullens, and the credit union was conserved and
- 0:50which used to only happen on Fridays because it was easy to close the books.
- 0:55This might be a church credit union potentially and maybe they weren't
- 0:59open, so it made it easier to do it in the middle of the day on Wednesday.
- 1:04Or at the close of business on Wednesday, which may have been noon or the morning.
- 1:08In any event the press release, June 18th, the NCA today placed Alders
- 1:12Gate Federal Credit Union in Marion, Illinois into conservatorship Member
- 1:17Services will continue while the NCA works to resolve issues affecting
- 1:22the credit union's operations member deposits at Alter Gate Federal Credit
- 1:26Union remain protected by the NCUA.
- 1:28Share Insurance Fund the National Credit Union Share Insurance
- 1:31Fund administered by the NCUA.
- 1:34The Share Insurance Fund protects individual accounts at federally
- 1:37insured credit unions up to $250,000.
- 1:41Member's interest in all joint accounts combined is also insured up to $250,000.
- 1:47The Share Insurance Fund separately protects IRA and Keo
- 1:51retirement accounts up to $250,000.
- 1:55The Share insurance Fund has the backing of the full faith and credit
- 1:58of the United States, although that's actually implied if you go back to the
- 2:01NGN days, but that's another story.
- 2:03They do have the full credit, but it's a nuanced interpretation of the
- 2:07full credit, not as clean as the FDA's full faith and credit, but I digress.
- 2:12It talks about how the members make.
- 2:13Conduct financial transactions via phone.
- 2:16By calling the NCA Assistant Management Center Monday through
- 2:19Thursday, those calls will be routed to the appropriate specialist.
- 2:23Members can continue to conduct financial transactions such as depositing funds,
- 2:27making loan payments, and requesting share withdrawals during the conservatorship.
- 2:31Members, members with questions about the conservatorship may review The
- 2:34Elder Gates, federal Credit Union's frequently asked questions posted on
- 2:37the NCA website members with questions about their share insurance can.
- 2:42Find more information at the share insurance coverage section of the NCA
- 2:45website, and then it goes on to say, aldersgate Federal Credit Union is a
- 2:50federally insured credit union with 811 members and reports assets of 10.6
- 2:54million.
- 2:55According to the credit union's most recent call report, aldersgate Federal
- 3:00Credit Union serves the ministerial and probationary members, full-time employees,
- 3:03local pastors, clergy persons, and.
- 3:07DD Diacon Diaconal.
- 3:08How my diocese Dia.
- 3:11So it's diocese, I don't know the word Diaconal.
- 3:13Ministers under appointment of the Bishop of the Illinois Great Rivers
- 3:17Conference of the United Methodist Church.
- 3:20So they took it over.
- 3:23And looking at the financial statement, let's see, I pulled
- 3:27down the FPR as of March.
- 3:30They had.
- 3:3410.3
- 3:35million in loans, 260,000 in total cash.
- 3:41They.
- 3:43Key ratios, net worth ratio, 10.9%
- 3:47compared to the pier of about 15.
- 3:49So then the 27th percentile.
- 3:51There is one stat that does speak volumes.
- 3:54Their income 1.27%,
- 3:57127 basis points.
- 3:58And as of March, December was 55 basis points.
- 4:02The previous December 65, previous December 58, previous
- 4:06December 46, so it's making money.
- 4:09High loan to asset ratio March.
- 4:11It was 97%, 98, 97, 93 85.
- 4:16Going back to the end of years in 2021.
- 4:21And let's see if this number stands out to you.
- 4:23Listeners and Watchers Delinquent Loans.
- 4:28The one, the first percentile.
- 4:30Nobody's better.
- 4:32At the end of March, they had zero delinquencies.
- 4:35The end of December 20, 24, 0 delinquencies.
- 4:40End of December, 2020.
- 4:42Three, zero delinquencies.
- 4:45End of December, 2022, zero delinquencies.
- 4:49End of December 20, 21.
- 4:52Zero delinquencies.
- 4:54What are the odds of that?
- 4:55What are the odds of flipping a coin?
- 4:5715 times in a row and it always coming up heads.
- 4:59What are the odds of having a family of 13 and they're all girls or they're all boys.
- 5:04What are the odds that there's zero delinquency at this credit union
- 5:07and it was conserved on a Wednesday.
- 5:09And it's a church credit union.
- 5:12I think there's a little bit more delinquency than zero.
- 5:15And that is a.
- 5:18Something that nsu a watches they watch.
- 5:20If somebody reports zero delinquency or they used to and it would seem
- 5:25to be a red flag that would've caused potentially a deeper dive.
- 5:30Or I could be wrong.
- 5:30The credit union could have been abandoned.
- 5:32Maybe the field membership decided they didn't want the want, the credit union.
- 5:36But my gut is telling me the numbers are not what they seem, my gut is telling me.
- 5:41The worst case scenario in some of these instances is there's two
- 5:44case of two sets of records, and the credit union isn't 10 million.
- 5:47It's much bigger, and there's a second set where the manager was
- 5:51stealing money or someone at the credit union was stealing money.
- 5:55I don't wanna indicate anybody in particular here, but those
- 5:59are the typical scenarios.
- 6:00Now, another big takeaway for me.
- 6:03Is that this is the first live action where we've seen Chairman Holtman
- 6:09take an action as the full board.
- 6:12This a conservatorship action has to be signed off on the board.
- 6:15They're saying, they've said publicly, he has the full authority.
- 6:19Now, not that this credit union will, but a credit union could sue.
- 6:26They can't use the funds of the credit union 'cause they're
- 6:28no longer the credit union.
- 6:30But you can contest, I think it's a 10 day window.
- 6:32You have to file a con contestant in court.
- 6:36You could argue that Huffman doesn't have the authority because he's not a quorum.
- 6:40Meanwhile, they could liquidate the credit union and have nothing left.
- 6:44But the reality is this is really in my mind, the first public position
- 6:49where Huffman is saying, yep.
- 6:50I've been saying I've got these authorities, and I just took
- 6:53an action of the full board.
- 6:55I guess it's a good test case 'cause it's small.
- 6:57I would still argue that there's a pretty compelling argument.
- 7:00One argued by Halman, excuse me, by Harper and Otsuka, that
- 7:05a quorum is more than one.
- 7:07And NCA had previously, if you listened to some of my past podcasts, I talked
- 7:11about how when Dennis Dollar was there and I was there as the deputy executive
- 7:14director, they started doing briefings.
- 7:17That's where the insurance.
- 7:18Fund briefing was born but they advised dollar not to take any actions on
- 7:22regulations because they didn't believe he had the authority to do that.
- 7:25Now, legal opinions changed.
- 7:27The act hasn't changed substantively, but I.
- 7:29When you have a board member who wants to get to one position, sometimes
- 7:32they stretch their interpretations.
- 7:34And I'm not saying that's what's happened here.
- 7:36Maybe general counsel is saying, Hey, we've taken another fresh look at it.
- 7:39And you do have these authorities.
- 7:41In any event, conservatorship action takes a vote of the
- 7:44board which is very interesting.
- 7:46So it's gonna be interesting to watch.
- 7:48They don't say a lot publicly about these.
- 7:50There might be a PO post-mortem that gets, that gets released if
- 7:54there's a certain dollar across cost.
- 7:56The the Inspector General of NCUA will have to do a postmortem if the cost,
- 8:04I believe theirs is over 10 million NCOs division of insurance does it.
- 8:08I think if it's over two or 4 million.
- 8:11In any event, it's gonna be a long time before we see any details here.
- 8:14Hopefully it's not something that costs the insurance fund
- 8:17too much, but my guess is.
- 8:19It's very possible, probable, likely, potentially, that there could be
- 8:23fraud here that led to this 'cause zero delinquency in five years.
- 8:27I'm not gonna buy that.
- 8:28That just doesn't make sense.
- 8:30Let's see.
- 8:30And charge offs.
- 8:32Charge offs?
- 8:32No.
- 8:33No charge offs either.
- 8:34I.
- 8:34Amazing.
- 8:35Quite amazing.
- 8:36All right in that regard I saw another thing.
- 8:38I went over to LinkedIn while I was looking at that, and the FDIC
- 8:43announced that they are having a full board meeting on June 26th at 10:00
- 8:47AM and they published their agenda.
- 8:50I went to the link of the agenda and something caught
- 8:53my eye as it relates to NCA.
- 8:55Anyway, they're going to talk about minutes of a previous board meeting
- 8:58and some customer identification program rule exemption order.
- 9:03Their third item is a summary report, status report, and report of
- 9:06actions taken pursuant to authority delegated by the board of directors.
- 9:10So they're going to talk about actions that the office took, talk about
- 9:15actions that the general counsel took, talk about actions at the regens.
- 9:19Took, I've talked about here publicly there's, it's essentially the Bible
- 9:23of what the NCA board is delegated.
- 9:25They say the regional directors have the authority to write letters
- 9:29to credit unions and supervise the credit unions to do the exams.
- 9:32They say the general counsel has the authority to do X, y, and z.
- 9:36The e and i director can do this.
- 9:38The office of the executive director and the executive director can do this,
- 9:42and they talk about, by the way, how all these delegations throw flow through the.
- 9:46Chain of command, which is a way to put political pressure on the individual
- 9:50areas of operations if they don't believe they're following the delegations
- 9:54or doing what needs to be done.
- 9:55But what.
- 9:56This also triggered me to think about was actions taken by the
- 10:00NCA Board by notation vote.
- 10:02Those things are not public.
- 10:04And I, some of those things they say they have to be done in a closed session.
- 10:08There's so many things since Harper came in.
- 10:10Todd Harper, previous board chair, previous board member, still suing to
- 10:14get back on the board where they started basically not having closed session
- 10:18board meetings where you could see they were taking a personnel action, or you
- 10:20could see they were doing an appeal.
- 10:23They've done all those behind the scenes and there should be some method
- 10:27of getting that information reported.
- 10:29I don't know, I'm gonna watch this FDIC board meeting or the follow
- 10:33up on it to see if that's something where they report something there.
- 10:36Maybe I'll make a request to NCUA saying, Hey, what's going on with
- 10:39all your notation votes lately?
- 10:41All right, so what else?
- 10:43There was one other thing that popped up here.
- 10:45I talked about the conservatorship I talked about.
- 10:50The FDIC and their agenda NCUA is not having a board meeting in June
- 10:58because they I've talked about this in a previous board meeting.
- 11:01They are going to have one in July where they'll probably talk about
- 11:04the budget and such, potentially maybe do a cybersecurity briefing.
- 11:08If it were me, I would have at least one briefing each board meeting to
- 11:11show that we're relevant, however.
- 11:14Conserving to Credit Union definitely shows the relevance of the board.
- 11:17And I'm a bit surprised that they decided to do that.
- 11:20There must have been something so compelling that they felt they needed to.
- 11:23It wasn't tie goes to the runner type conservatorship.
- 11:26It must have been something that really needed to happen and they decided,
- 11:29okay, this is the one we're gonna test.
- 11:31That Houtman really, truly does have the ability to vote for a full board.
- 11:34And I guess one out of one is a quorum, right?
- 11:36That's their argument.
- 11:38We'll see if that gets addressed in the lawsuits.
- 11:40By Harper and Ska.
- 11:42I'm not really gonna go into the lawsuits on Harper.
- 11:44And Osky did some research on it.
- 11:45But again, they went to court.
- 11:47They made their positions.
- 11:48The administration made their positions.
- 11:50They didn't say when they'd make a decision.
- 11:53The administration did argue, I guess that even I.
- 11:57If they were wrong to fire him, that they shouldn't put Harper and ska back so they
- 12:02could win by default, if that's where the, what the judge decides makes sense.
- 12:06And I'm hearing some rumblings about who the next board members could
- 12:08be and I'll just leave it at that.
- 12:10But I think if what I heard on the grapevine is true,
- 12:14I think it could be cool.
- 12:16Alright I have a couple other announcements I'm
- 12:19going to make on a podcast.
- 12:21Tuesday on some changes.
- 12:23Some.
- 12:23I like to reinvent what the podcast does every year to keep it fresh fresh
- 12:28for me and hopefully fresh for you.
- 12:30Which part of the thing is we're doing more of these YouTube
- 12:33videos linked to the podcast.
- 12:35I'm gonna be doing a little bit more of that and I'll have it podcast
- 12:39on Tuesday, which we'll announce another couple nuances to the
- 12:42podcast that I think you will enjoy.
- 12:44Enjoy.
- 12:45I know I'm going to enjoy doing them and stay tuned for that.
- 12:48All right.
- 12:49I'm gonna get back to work here, but I wanted to get this podcast out.
- 12:52As always, I appreciate you listening.
- 12:55I hope you'll listen again soon or watch.
- 12:58And this is Mark Rele signing off with flying colors.
- 13:02I.