Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use At-the-Market Offerings
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this quiet, almost stealthy way that public companies raise money that doesn't make headlines like a secondary offering or a convertible bond. It's called an at the market offering, or ATM, and it's become a go-to tool for post ipo companies. Luna: ATM — like the machine? But for stocks? Lucas: Exactly. Except instead of dispensing cash, it lets a company sell shares directly into the market at prevailing prices, over time, through an investment bank acting as a sales agent. No big announcement, no fixed price, no roadshow. Just a steady trickle of new shares hitting the market. Luna: Doesn't that spook investors? If I see my company is constantly issuing shares, I'd think they're desperate for cash. Lucas: That's the critical question. The signaling depends entirely on who's doing it. Take Tesla, trading around $380 today. If Tesla announced an ATM program, the market might shrug — they have plenty of cash, so it's opportunistic. But if Rivian, down near $16, did the same, it could look like a lifeline. Luna: And Rivian has actually used ATMs. I recall they filed a $1.5 billion ATM shelf in 2024. Lucas: Right. And they used it judiciously, through 2025. The beauty of an ATM is control. You decide when to sell, how much, at what price. If the stock pops on good news, you sell a block. If it's tanking, you can pause. No forced dilution at the worst moment. Luna: But the dilution still happens. The shareholder base gets diluted gradually, maybe without even noticing until the quarterly filing. Lucas: That's actually one of the critiques. But for companies that need capital to fund operations or R&D, a slow drip can be less disruptive than a single large secondary that knocks the stock down 10 percent in one day. Luna: So which companies are using ATMs right now? It's not just the cash-burning startups, right? Lucas: Correct. In fact, some of the biggest names in tech have ATM programs on file. Alphabet, Apple, Microsoft — they all have shelf registrations that allow ATM sales. They rarely use them, but the option is there. And in 2025, total ATM issuance in the US topped $35 billion, double what it was in 2023. Luna: Is that partly because of the regulatory environment under the Trump administration? Lucas: That's a good point. The SEC under the current administration has issued guidance that makes ATMs easier to execute, particularly around disclosure requirements. They've streamlined the filing process for shelf offerings, so more companies are putting ATM programs in place just in case. Luna: It feels like a tool that benefits the company more than long-term shareholders. But I guess if you're a shareholder who bought because you believe in the growth story, you might prefer gradual funding over a debt pile. Lucas: Exactly. And ATMs are often used to raise equity without triggering the negative signaling of a traditional follow-on. Some companies even pair them with buyback programs to offset dilution — buy back when the stock is low, issue when it's high. Luna: That's pretty sophisticated treasury management. Lucas: It is. But it's becoming standard practice. And there's a broader trend here: as more companies stay private longer with venture capital, the public markets are seeing younger, less mature companies that need flexible capital-raising tools. ATMs fit that need perfectly. Luna: Quick honest thing — we're able to dive into these niche capital markets topics because of listener support. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many episodes. Lucas: Yeah, we don't run ads, and we like it that way. So if you find these conversations useful for what you're building or running, you know where to find us. Luna: Alright, back to ATMs. One thing I wonder: with the Fed holding rates where they are, does that make ATMs more attractive than debt? Lucas: Absolutely. When borrowing costs are high — and short-term rates are still above 4 percent — equity financing via ATMs can be cheaper on a risk-adjusted basis, especially for companies with volatile cash flows. And because ATMs are done at market prices, there's no interest expense. Luna: But what about the mechanics? How does a company actually execute an ATM? Lucas: It's surprisingly simple. The company files a shelf registration with the SEC, then enters into a distribution agreement with an investment bank — could be Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, a smaller boutique. The bank then sells shares directly into the market on behalf of the company, usually through its trading desk. Luna: So the bank is basically a broker, not an underwriter. Lucas: Exactly. They take a small commission, typically 0.5 to 1.5 percent, while the company retains full control over timing and volume. Some companies even use algorithms to sell automatically when the stock hits certain price targets. Luna: That feels like it could backfire if the algo keeps selling into a downtrend. Lucas: That's why most programs have human oversight. But the flexibility is a double-edged sword. If you're not disciplined, you can end up selling shares at the worst possible time. The best practitioners treat ATMs like a strategic tool, not a crutch. Luna: I want to look at a specific case. Take C3.ai — they used an ATM in 2023 to raise $100 million. How did that play out? Lucas: C3.ai announced the ATM after the stock had fallen from its post ipo highs. They sold shares over several months, raising the full amount by mid-2024. The stock didn't crater, partly because they spread the issuance out. But the dilution was still about 5 percent. Luna: Five percent — that's noticeable but not devastating. And it gave them cash to invest in AI products. Lucas: Right. And that's the trade-off. For young public companies, especially in tech, having quick access to equity capital can be worth the dilution. It's a lot faster than negotiating a debt deal or a private placement. Luna: So what should investors watch for? When a company files a shelf, is that a red flag? Lucas: Not necessarily. Many companies keep shelves active for years without using them. The red flag is when the company starts actually selling shares aggressively, especially if the stock is already under pressure. You can track that through the quarterly filings, which disclose ATM activity. Luna: And the SEC now requires more frequent updates on ATM sales, right? Lucas: Yes. Under the current SEC, companies must report ATM sales within two business days for any transaction over $1 million. That's a big improvement in transparency compared to a few years ago, when investors might not learn about dilution until the next 10-Q. Luna: So ATMs are here to stay. And with more companies going public earlier in their lifecycle, we'll probably see even more of them. Lucas: I think so. And that's actually a healthy development. The public markets should offer tools that fit different stages of a company's growth. ATMs are one more option in the toolkit. Luna: Alright, let's move to a related topic — how companies are using structured equity programs to manage dilution, like capped calls and accelerated share repurchases. Lucas: That's a great next step. But for today, I think the takeaway is: don't panic if you see a shelf filing. Check whether the company is actually using it, and if so, how disciplined they are. That tells you a lot about management's capital allocation philosophy. Luna: And a disciplined ATM program can be a sign of a company that's thinking long-term. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening.