Latest / The Vegan Report / How 5 Arab Nations View Industrial Animal Agriculture | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hi everyone, this is Suedda and Gülbeke from
- 0:03Animatrix and we would like to start by saying
- 0:06that it's such a great pleasure to be here again.
- 0:10For those of you who may be new to our work,
- 0:12Animatrix is a research and capacity building
- 0:14organization. With Animatrix we are primarily
- 0:17focusing on supporting animal advocates in the
- 0:20majority world, or often referred to as the Global
- 0:24South. And our goal is to generate reliable and
- 0:27context -specific data. But not only that, we
- 0:30also want to help translate the evidence into
- 0:33practical strategies that advocacy organizations
- 0:37can use for impact. And today we'll be briefly
- 0:42reintroducing our work and then we will dive
- 0:45into the insights from our brand new study which
- 0:48is focusing on five countries in the Gulf and
- 0:52Southeast Asia, namely United Arab Emirates,
- 0:56Kuwait, Lebanon, Qatar and Saudi Arabia. So in
- 0:59this project we explored how people in each country
- 1:03relate to industrial animal agriculture and what
- 1:06this means for animal welfare and food system
- 1:10change and the respective opportunities in each
- 1:16country. Please connect with us. Our email and
- 1:19social links are in the episode notes. And you
- 1:22can also find new episodes every Wednesday on
- 1:25this podcast. And please don't forget to share
- 1:27this episode with your community. All right.
- 1:31Before we jump into talking about our organization
- 1:34and study, let's quickly share a bit about who
- 1:36we are. So I'm Gidbike, co -founder of Animetrix,
- 1:40along with Sveta. My background is in economics.
- 1:44So basically, I completed my PhD researching
- 1:47how behaviors spread between people, like in
- 1:50other words, how social influence works, as well
- 1:54as the economics of crime. So alongside that,
- 1:58I work part -time as software project assessor,
- 2:03and I also teach and speak about animal rights,
- 2:06animal welfare, and environmental issues. Much
- 2:09of that has been in collaboration with Middle
- 2:11East Vegan Society. So with them I have delivered
- 2:15more than 25 talks and workshops across countries
- 2:18like Egypt, Turkey, Rwanda, Uganda, Mozambique,
- 2:23Sri Lanka, Philippines and El Salvador. And I'm
- 2:28Sueda, the other co -founder of Animatrix. I'm
- 2:31a behavioral and experimental economist. And
- 2:34I'm also currently a post -doctoral researcher
- 2:36at Berlin Social Science Center. So my academic
- 2:40work is focusing on discrimination and bias.
- 2:45And I'm also looking at ways to encourage pro
- 2:48-social behavior across the society, like charitable
- 2:52giving or making more sustainable choices. And
- 2:56for this work, I've been gaining quite a lot
- 2:58of experience designing and running large scale
- 3:01surveys across different countries. And with
- 3:04Animatrix, I'm trying to bring these perspectives
- 3:06and this expertise into animal advocacy. Yeah,
- 3:11so now let's talk about what we actually do in
- 3:14Animatrix and why we think this work is needed
- 3:17in the movement. So basically, our work is about
- 3:21making animal advocacy more evidence -based.
- 3:24with research that is rooted in specific social,
- 3:28cultural and economic contexts where we want
- 3:31to create a change. We generate that evidence
- 3:35locally and then translate it into practical
- 3:39strategies that organizations can actually use.
- 3:45Yeah, there are actually a few observations that
- 3:48really guided us when we were structuring our
- 3:50work at Animatrix. One was that we saw that like
- 3:56the research in farming animal advocacy majority
- 3:59of it is coming from the global north and majority
- 4:02of it is actually focusing on strategies in the
- 4:04global north even though the majority of farmed
- 4:06animals live in the global south. So this disconnect
- 4:10felt really significant to us especially when
- 4:13we consider the scale because billions of animals
- 4:16are living in these regions. And we also know
- 4:20that strategies don't automatically travel very
- 4:22well. So what works in one country can be ineffective
- 4:25or even create a backlash in another one. So
- 4:29understanding local social norms, cultural context
- 4:32and economic realities really matters. And a
- 4:36key part of this for us is also engaging with
- 4:39Muslim communities. So we know that Muslims represent
- 4:42nearly a quarter of the world's population and
- 4:45their dietary choices particularly around halal
- 4:48conception, is really shaping global food systems
- 4:52at a massive scale. And religious values are
- 4:55known to influence perceptions of animal welfare
- 4:58and food ethics. However, in the global animal
- 5:01advocacy conversation, Muslim communities are
- 5:04often very, very underrepresented. And on top
- 5:08of that, another thing that we've noticed is
- 5:10that economics or field of study and also behavioral
- 5:13science, it wasn't really deeply integrated into
- 5:16the movement. And it's quite important because
- 5:19advocacy is at its core about behavior change,
- 5:23which actually requires an understanding of how
- 5:26people make their decisions, how industries react
- 5:29to different incentives, how systems shift and
- 5:32so on. And as a field, economics really helps
- 5:36us think clearly about these dynamics and really
- 5:39understand them. And one final observation that
- 5:43we had was that even though, you know, there's
- 5:45a lot of very strong research and evidence exists
- 5:50out there, it doesn't often make it into practice
- 5:54because all these research articles and papers
- 5:57are not super accessible to someone without a
- 6:01research background and so on. So sometimes this
- 6:05research is not really reaching the advocates
- 6:08or maybe the research is great and it's reaching
- 6:12the advocates but it's not necessarily answering
- 6:14their most urgent questions. So as Animatrix
- 6:19we wanted to respond to all these challenges
- 6:22in a practical and in a hands -on way. So now
- 6:26give it to Gubike who will explain how we actually
- 6:29do this. Yeah, thanks for that. So what does
- 6:33that look like in practice? So we focus on three
- 6:37main areas. First one is research. We design
- 6:41and conduct original studies using economics
- 6:43and behavioral science to answer practical, moment
- 6:47relevant questions. These are like how to shift
- 6:50food choices, how to design more effective campaigns,
- 6:53or how people think about animal welfare in different
- 6:57contexts. So second, is implementation support.
- 7:02So we don't just publish reports and move on.
- 7:05We translate findings into usable formats like
- 7:09toolkits, short briefs, visuals, and we work
- 7:13directly with advocates to help apply those insights
- 7:17and practice. One thing that makes us different
- 7:20is that we co -design projects with organizations.
- 7:24So the research starts from their needs, not
- 7:27just from academic curiosity. And lastly and
- 7:31thirdly is capacity building that we do. So basically
- 7:35it looks like we train advocates in research
- 7:38design, survey methods and impact evaluations
- 7:42so that they can generate and use evidence themselves.
- 7:46Since we started, we have supported more than
- 7:49dozens of organizations from Uganda to Philippines
- 7:53to Kenya and we delivered hundreds of hours of
- 7:57trainings. Across all of this, we focus especially
- 8:01on regions and communities that are critical
- 8:03for animals, but still very, very under -presented
- 8:07in research. Like Sveta said, these are particularly
- 8:11parts of the majority world and Muslim communities.
- 8:17So yeah, that's about it about Anometrics. Now
- 8:20let's get to our new project. So the starting
- 8:24point for this project was that It is common
- 8:28knowledge that industrial animal agriculture
- 8:31has super serious consequences for animals, obviously,
- 8:35but also for the environment, for the public
- 8:37health, and also for the workers involved in
- 8:40these production systems. And if one wants to
- 8:44create meaningful change, the first requirement
- 8:48is to understand how people actually relate to
- 8:50these issues. You know, questions like what shapes
- 8:53their food choices? Is it about cost? Is it about
- 8:56tradition? Is it about religion? Is it about
- 8:58societal norms? Whether or not people see animal
- 9:02welfare important in the first place. Or would
- 9:05they actually support policy changes? Or are
- 9:08they open to trying alternative food products
- 9:11through animal -based foods? So in this project,
- 9:15we wanted to answer these questions focusing
- 9:18on five countries in the Gulf and West Asia.
- 9:22So United Arab Emirates, Kuwait, Lebanon, Qatar,
- 9:25and Saudi Arabia. where comparable and context
- 9:30-specific data on public attitudes around these
- 9:33issues has largely been missing. So what we did
- 9:37was that we collaborated with the Great Middle
- 9:41East Vegan Society and also Susan Ekinje, who
- 9:43was a fantastic researcher, and we designed and
- 9:47conducted a large -scale survey across these
- 9:50five countries. The survey was actually inspired
- 9:53by a previous international research on public
- 9:58attitudes conducted by Mercy for Animals. We
- 10:02basically took the survey and also adopted it
- 10:05to reflect the social and religious context in
- 10:09the regions and countries that we're working
- 10:11in. We basically looked at three main areas.
- 10:15First, we wanted to understand the potential
- 10:17pathways to change and how each country is standing
- 10:20there. the dietary shift, the existing dietary
- 10:24patterns, the support for animal protection organizations,
- 10:29openness to alternatives such as cultivated meat,
- 10:31and also support for stronger animal welfare
- 10:36laws. And second, we wanted to understand the
- 10:40barriers that are standing in front of these
- 10:45potential changes, right? So these barriers included
- 10:49the attachment to meat, the religious and cultural
- 10:53justifications for consuming animal -based products,
- 10:56and also social norms that might make changes
- 11:00towards better life for animals more difficult.
- 11:05And third, we wanted to look into potential facilitators
- 11:08for change. So these include factors that could
- 11:12make change more likely, such as individuals'
- 11:15recognition of animal sentience, or their understanding
- 11:19of the links between animal agriculture and broader
- 11:22harms of the industrial animal agriculture such
- 11:27as climate change, public health or worker exploitation
- 11:31or difficult conditions for the workers. So what
- 11:36we did was we wanted to understand the relationships
- 11:40between these potential pathways to change the
- 11:43barriers, the facilitators. We wanted to understand
- 11:45which ones are the most prominent ones. And we
- 11:49also explored how these views differ across different
- 11:52demographic groups. And finally, we want to understand
- 11:58who people believe should be responsible for
- 12:02the education of the public on animal welfare
- 12:05and the need for legal protections for them.
- 12:09And with this study, we believe that we are addressing
- 12:12an important gap because while research on public
- 12:16attitudes towards animal agriculture is growing
- 12:19globally, We still know very, very little about
- 12:22how people in South -West Asia, or as we know
- 12:26as the Middle East, think about these issues.
- 12:30Like, what resonates with them, where there might
- 12:33be openness to change, as Fedar said, and where
- 12:37might create resistance, what might create resistance.
- 12:41And that really matters because we are talking
- 12:44about a region experiencing a rapid population
- 12:47growth. and a very high demand for and rising
- 12:50demand for animal -based products. And at the
- 12:54same time, both are deeply connected to culture,
- 12:57religion, hospitality and identity. So, strategies
- 13:01developed in other parts of the world can't simply
- 13:04be copied and pasted here. They need to be thoughtfully
- 13:08adapted. And without locally grounded data, advocates
- 13:12and policymakers are also working with limited
- 13:15guidance. What this study offers is a clear picture,
- 13:19like an evidence -based, rooted in this specific
- 13:22context, that can help shape more thoughtful,
- 13:26culturally grounded, and finally more effective.
- 13:32All right, so the more interesting part, the
- 13:35key findings. What did we find? So, first of
- 13:38all, across the five countries, we observed some
- 13:43clear and similar patterns. So first of all,
- 13:48we found that plant -based eating is actually
- 13:52viewed quite positively. So even though most
- 13:54respondents currently eat mostly animal -based
- 13:57diets, around two thirds actually hold positive
- 14:00views towards plant -based eating. And many are
- 14:03also interested in learning more about substituting
- 14:08plant -based protein with animal -based protein.
- 14:10So this is actually quite encouraging. So this
- 14:15actually means that openness is there, but behavior
- 14:18hasn't really fully shifted. And second, we found
- 14:22that there is a very strong support for legal
- 14:27protections for farmed animals. So depending
- 14:30on the country, around eight to nine in 10 respondents...
- 14:34stated that they support stronger and better
- 14:37legal protections for farmed land animals. And
- 14:41this is quite striking and suggests that policy
- 14:44-focused efforts in these countries may actually
- 14:47have a very strong public backing. And another
- 14:51thing we found was that there is a broad support
- 14:55for animal protection organizations as well.
- 14:59And this support is often in the form of the
- 15:05public agreeing to following or following the
- 15:10organization online or sharing their content
- 15:12online and so on. So this kind of signals a potential
- 15:16base of engagement to build on in these regions
- 15:19for advocacy organizations. And at the same time,
- 15:23remember that we were also trying to understand
- 15:25certain barriers that were standing in front
- 15:27of change. So we found that strong attachment
- 15:32to meet And the belief that eating meat is an
- 15:36individual's right, this entitlement idea, emerged
- 15:41as an important one. So in some contexts, we
- 15:45also found that religious justifications and
- 15:48norms around hospitality, you know, one should
- 15:50be serving meat to be able to be a good host,
- 15:54they also appear to be relevant. And just to
- 15:57clarify here what we mean by a significant barrier,
- 16:01the observation we had was the following. So
- 16:03the respondents who scored high on these barrier
- 16:06factors such as meat attachment and so on, they
- 16:09tended to score lower or one or more of the pathway
- 16:13to change measures such as the dietary shifts,
- 16:16the openness to cultivated meat, support for
- 16:19advocacy groups or stronger legal protections.
- 16:23So let's look at the facilitators also. So pretty
- 16:29consistently we found that recognizing the fact
- 16:32that farmed animals are sentient and understanding
- 16:36the links between industrial animal agriculture
- 16:40and broader harms such as the climate change
- 16:44and public health and so on. These were associated
- 16:49with stronger support across multiple pathways
- 16:54to change. And finally, when we asked the respondents
- 17:00who they see as responsible for educating the
- 17:04public about farm animal welfare, we saw that
- 17:07government institutions and certification bodies
- 17:12were very frequently mentioned. In several countries,
- 17:16however, we also saw that religious institutions
- 17:18were also seen as important actors in this context.
- 17:22So from a comparative perspective, this is actually
- 17:25quite interesting. So the prominence of religious
- 17:27institutions as being responsible actors in animal
- 17:31welfare is not something that comes up very often
- 17:33in Western contexts. So this actually suggests
- 17:36that the institutional landscape and the strategic
- 17:39entry points in these countries may look different
- 17:43than the ones in the global north. And beyond
- 17:48these overall patterns, a few cross country differences
- 17:51were especially interesting for us. For example,
- 17:55cultivated meat. Support is relatively consistent
- 17:59in Qatar, the United Arabian race, Kuwait, and
- 18:03Saudi Arabia. like around 1 in 3 respondents.
- 18:07But Lebanon really stands out with significantly
- 18:10lower support at around 14%. We think this could
- 18:15reflect lower familiarity or greater skepticism
- 18:18towards new food technologies. Or it may also
- 18:23relate to broader national contexts like difference
- 18:25of the public investment, innovation agendas
- 18:29and how prominently food technology features
- 18:32in national development strategies. In some Gulf
- 18:35countries, alternative proteins and food security
- 18:38are already part of public policy conversations
- 18:40which could shape awareness and receptiveness.
- 18:44And another particularly striking pattern that
- 18:47we realize relates to meat attachment and legal
- 18:50protections. In the UAE, Lebanon and Kuwait,
- 18:54respondents who reported a stronger attachment
- 18:57to meat were also more likely to support legal
- 19:00protections for some animals. And this is an
- 19:03important and somewhat counterintuitive finding
- 19:07at first sight because it suggests that attachment
- 19:11to meat does not automatically translate into
- 19:15resistance to welfare reforms. People who hold
- 19:19positive views about meat can still prefer animals
- 19:22to be raised under better conditions, whether
- 19:24for ethical reasons or because it aligns with
- 19:27their ideas of responsible consumption. And finally,
- 19:32religious and cultural factors changed a variety
- 19:35in importance across contexts. In Lebanon and
- 19:38Qatar, religious justifications and hospitality
- 19:41norms appeared more important to our salient
- 19:45at barriers. And in others, they were less central.
- 19:50And that really highlights how much context matters.
- 19:55What may be a key consideration in one country
- 19:58may play a smaller role in another. So approaches
- 20:02need to be more sensitive to those differences.
- 20:07Okay, so we have all these interesting insights
- 20:10and findings. The next question is, what does
- 20:13it all mean for advocacy? So one clear takeaway
- 20:17is that there's actually real openness to plant
- 20:20-based eating, right? Even though the behavior
- 20:22hasn't fully shifted, these attitudes are actually
- 20:26suggesting some room to grow. So we believe that
- 20:29advocacy organizations can actually benefit from
- 20:32building on this existing openness. So they can
- 20:35actually use these consumer insights insights
- 20:37when they are engaging with corporations, institutions,
- 20:42and food service providers, and basically tell
- 20:46them that, hey, the public is actually open to
- 20:48this, so you should maybe provide more plant
- 20:51-based options, improve their quality, and also
- 20:55make them more accessible and easier to choose.
- 20:59And another important implication is about policy.
- 21:03We saw that there's very strong support for legal
- 21:08protections and advocacy organizations can actually
- 21:12use this insight when engaging with policymakers
- 21:16and regulators and tell them that, you know,
- 21:18this is what the public actually wants and expects.
- 21:22And next to this is that, you know, actually
- 21:28building awareness in the public. about the current
- 21:34shortages or like current bad practices in the
- 21:38industrial animal agriculture can create a bigger
- 21:43support in the public and a bigger demand in
- 21:45the public for change. So this is something that
- 21:48the organizations can also take into account.
- 21:53And finally, since we saw that government bodies
- 21:56and certification institutions are seen as responsible
- 22:00actors and also in some context religious institutions
- 22:03as well, advocacy efforts may be strengthened
- 22:07by communicating these public expectations to
- 22:11the relevant actors and by encouraging a discussion
- 22:14around farm animal protections and where they're
- 22:18actually currently lacking. Yeah, so there are
- 22:23also important insights about how to engage with
- 22:26the public. So basically, many respondents indicated
- 22:30willing to support animal protection organizations,
- 22:34like often starting with low -effort actions
- 22:36like following or sharing content online. This
- 22:40suggests outreach strategies should meet people
- 22:43where they are, like it can be offering accessible
- 22:47entry points. while also creating clear pathways
- 22:51for more involvement over time. At the same time,
- 22:56the findings remind us that barriers like strong
- 22:59meat attachments or religious or like hospitality
- 23:03norms need to be addressed really thoughtfully.
- 23:07That means careful testing, culturally sensitive
- 23:10messaging and avoiding approaches that might
- 23:14unintentionally trigger resistance. And finally,
- 23:19on the messaging side, one of the most consistent
- 23:22facilitators we saw across countries was recognizing
- 23:27animal sentience and understanding the broader
- 23:31impacts of industrial agriculture, like on health,
- 23:34communities, and the environment. So centering
- 23:38communication around those may resonate across
- 23:42different contexts. And what is our next step?
- 23:47So now that the findings are out there, now it's
- 23:51time to implement them. So for this, we are currently
- 23:55working in close collaboration with Middle East
- 23:58Vegan Society, who's very active in the countries
- 24:00that we had mentioned. And we are trying to help
- 24:04them translate these insights into practice.
- 24:06So together, we'll be developing strategies that
- 24:09apply these findings to their public communication,
- 24:12their campaign design. and also their engagement
- 24:15with policymakers. And on top of that, we're
- 24:19also planning broader engagement opportunities
- 24:22where other organizations can also benefit from
- 24:25these insights. So these include webinars and
- 24:29also sharing the findings in more depth and also
- 24:35opening a space for dialogue and questions and
- 24:40so on. Well, yeah, and we really see this as
- 24:45an ongoing conversation because research is only
- 24:48valuable if it's used. And that happens mostly
- 24:52through collaborations. So if you would like
- 24:55to explore the study in more detail, you can
- 24:58find the full country of course, along with the
- 25:01short two -minute feedback survey. And you can
- 25:04find this in the podcast notes and our website
- 25:07at enymetrics .org. If you're interested in applying
- 25:11these findings into your own strategy that can
- 25:14look like campaign design, policy engagement,
- 25:18community outreach or messaging, we are really
- 25:21happy to connect. And we just want to remind
- 25:24you that this invitation goes beyond this study.
- 25:28You can also explore our other research projects
- 25:30online. If you are thinking about implementation,
- 25:34collaboration, or simply like exchanging ideas
- 25:37about evidence -based advocacy or any other questions,
- 25:41please feel free to get in touch with us. And
- 25:44before we wrap up, we would really like to sincerely
- 25:47thank The Vegan Report podcast for inviting us
- 25:51back and giving us this platform to share our
- 25:54work. This is really, really valuable for us
- 25:56and it's a great opportunity to continue this
- 25:59conversation. And we'd also like to thank our
- 26:02funders, Animal Charity Evaluators and Craigslist
- 26:05Charitable Fund. Their support made this project
- 26:08possible in the first place. And finally we would
- 26:12like to thank everybody who is listening. We
- 26:15appreciate your time, your curiosity and also
- 26:18the work that you are doing in whatever format
- 26:21that could look like to build a better future
- 26:24for all non -human animals. Thank you so much
- 26:28for listening and hopefully we will see you again
- 26:31soon with more research and new projects to share.