Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / 2024 Music Industry Legal Update
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to this audio edition of Beverly Hills Bar Association's 2024 Music Industry
- 0:11Legal Update.
- 0:12This presentation was recorded on August 23, 2024, during the first annual Entertainment
- 0:17Law Summit.
- 0:18In just a moment, you'll hear William Hochberg, Peter Anderson, Rami Yanni, and Jeff Biederman
- 0:23discuss cutting-edge issues in the music industry, from the impact of AI on copyright
- 0:28law to the complexities of live event ticketing and catalog sales.
- 0:31The Music Industry Legal Update, put together by Bill Hochberg, bill specializes in music
- 0:37and media law representing top artists, estates, and companies.
- 0:42As a thought leader, bill writes on music business and law topics in leading publications,
- 0:47including The Atlantic, Wired, and regularly in Forbes.
- 0:52Hedy speaks on industry-changing issues at South by Southwest and other key forums,
- 0:57including right here at the BHBA.
- 1:00Bill is a lifelong musician and he's a board member of the New England Conservatory and
- 1:04New Music USA, helping create opportunities for great musicians.
- 1:09Bill, take it away.
- 1:11Thanks so much, Jeff.
- 1:13So, I want to introduce our panel here.
- 1:17We have Peter Anderson, one of the foremost copyright litigators anywhere.
- 1:23Peter's trial victory in the stairway to heaven case where he represented Led Zepp's
- 1:28plant and page with one-hand-wonder chapel music really closed the floodgates that were
- 1:34opened by the blurred lines case a few years earlier, which encouraged really a river of
- 1:41sketchy demand letters and infringement lawsuits that many of you may have received if you're
- 1:46an entertainment.
- 1:47Our music attorney from someone saying, hey, that's on on the top 10.
- 1:52That's my song and then you listen to the two and it's, you know, hey, they both have
- 1:55a high hat and they both have crowd sounds.
- 1:58That's a ripoff and a lot of those kinds of things were encouraged after the blurred lines
- 2:02case.
- 2:03Well, Peter kind of closed that, okay, not completely, but quite, quite effectively with
- 2:09his huge went in stairway to heaven lawsuit and he represents many of the top recording
- 2:15artists and songwriters of all time and also major music publishers and labels.
- 2:21In fact, he represents so many top artists and labels that he's not going to be able
- 2:26to speak today actually.
- 2:28He will just be out here as high candy, but you'll actively, you can judge by his facial
- 2:35expressions what his views are on this definition.
- 2:38But joking aside, Peter will give us some great takeaways for all of you, whether you're
- 2:43transactional or litigators, great takeaways today from his insights about what's going
- 2:48on today and what's going on tomorrow, what likely will happen tomorrow in the copyright
- 2:52litigation world.
- 2:55Then we have Rami Yani, who's my partner at Reins Feldman-Litrow, is a terrific intellectual
- 3:01property and entertainment attorney, also teaches at the USC Gould School of Law.
- 3:10And he also happens to be a badass bass player who's played at Madison Square Garden, I
- 3:14mean, serious bass player.
- 3:17Me and I play in a group together.
- 3:19We do 60s and 70s TV themes and we play at events like the San Fernando Valley Bar Association's
- 3:26Judges Gala, a really wild and crazy event.
- 3:32And for $100 we'll play.
- 3:36For $200 we won't play.
- 3:39That's an old Groucho Marx line, but it's great to have him on here.
- 3:44And thank you.
- 3:46And he'll be also talking among the things that we're going to talk about.
- 3:50There's so many things to talk about.
- 3:51We could talk about each one of them for at least an hour, but we're going to try to really
- 3:55hit on the core essential thing so you have a takeaway on that.
- 3:58One of the things Rami will be talking about, which he has experienced with, is walk on
- 4:02music and political campaigns.
- 4:06And he represents a PRO, which he also can't name, but he will talk about the trends and
- 4:14what's going on.
- 4:15There's a lot going on, isn't there, with walk on music and campaigns.
- 4:19So that's one of our issues.
- 4:21And then we have Jeff Biedermann, who's a terrific transactional attorney at Greenberg
- 4:25Trier with lots of experience.
- 4:27And oh, I mentioned Peter is at Davis Wright-Tremaine.
- 4:31Jeff at Greenberg Trier, tons of experience with music catalog acquisitions.
- 4:37And that certainly is a super important thing to talk about.
- 4:40Are they going, is it a bubble that's going to burst?
- 4:42Is it going to keep on growing?
- 4:44What's been going on in that area?
- 4:48And also we'll talk about how these copyright issues that we're talking about may affect,
- 4:53do definitely affect valuations, things like termination.
- 4:56Notice is that kind of thing.
- 5:00And with Jeff Biedermann, some of you might remember Don Biedermann, his father.
- 5:05Don was a well-loved luminary in the music world.
- 5:10He was general counsel for Warner Chappell for many years and was a professor at most
- 5:16every great law school in the LA Basin.
- 5:20We hope one of Jeff's kids will carry on the family tradition and become a great music
- 5:24attorney like dad and granddad.
- 5:26Roll me to a issue I'm paying.
- 5:27I'm praying for that too.
- 5:30That would be a blessing.
- 5:31So we're going to talk about music AI.
- 5:33We're going to talk about some key music copyright cases, developments, very recent.
- 5:39We're going to talk about a catalog marketplace.
- 5:44We have time and we're going to try to talk about the rap lyrics, which has been a big
- 5:47issue, rap lyrics and criminal and civil cases and election campaign walk on music.
- 5:55So getting started with the AI, I'd like to talk about the Suno and Udio cases, which
- 6:01are in the news right now.
- 6:03Those companies are being sued by the RIAA trade organization for the major labels as
- 6:10well as the major labels themselves regarding their use of, in their large learning models,
- 6:20just about everything, all the music.
- 6:23Their defense, which just came out very recently, is that they liken their machines to a human
- 6:28musician who had played earlier songs to learn the building blocks of music and then use
- 6:34what they had learned to create entirely new works in existing styles.
- 6:38So the question is, that I'll pose to you, Peter, to start it.
- 6:44Is it different for an AI computer to listen to music than for a musician?
- 6:51Obviously, you're not going to sue a musician for listening to music and then using that
- 6:56to come up with something as long as the output is not substantially similar.
- 7:00What do you think, Peter?
- 7:01Well, it's a long-standing rule of copyright that, and it goes back, I think to the video
- 7:07games, to the initial video games, that once you absorb something into a computer, the
- 7:14computer makes a copy, which is an unauthorized, either a licensed copy or an unauthorized
- 7:19copy.
- 7:20So what these companies tend to do is they're using copyrighted works to train their models
- 7:26and some of them, like Suno, are very upfront about it.
- 7:28They say that we make copies of these sound recordings specifically to make music.
- 7:34So they take someone else's sound recordings of music and they make a copy internally to
- 7:41the model and train the model to create competing music.
- 7:46So as a first step, you've got that initial infringement.
- 7:50There's also the question of whether the output is infringing and most of these companies
- 7:54are taking, and there's like 15, 20 cases pending across the US.
- 7:58There was one that was actually supposed to start today in Delaware.
- 8:01It wasn't a music case though, that the judge said he wanted to revisit the cross motions
- 8:07for summary judgments, so he stopped the trial.
- 8:09But what generally these people are saying, these companies are saying, is that the output
- 8:16isn't the same.
- 8:17The output isn't substantially similar, which may or may not be the case.
- 8:21As I understand it, I think UMG recordings came up with some examples where the output
- 8:25was actually infringing, at least in their view.
- 8:29But the general argument is that the output isn't infringing and the mere fact that we
- 8:34make a copy internally to train our models is a fair use.
- 8:39And that gets back to the fair use.
- 8:41Sorry, let me get in on that.
- 8:43Isn't it a fair use?
- 8:44Is it any different than a musician?
- 8:47And in your reign, somewhere in your neurons and synapses, you have like a memory of a
- 8:53song.
- 8:54Is that copying?
- 8:55Why not sue everyone who remembers a song and starts whistling?
- 8:59Well, I think first of all, there's a license.
- 9:02There's a license.
- 9:03If the person who's listening to the song on the radio, for example, there's a performance
- 9:06rights, there's like a license.
- 9:09With the idea, either expressly or implicitly, that someone's going to hear it in their head.
- 9:15And maybe they remember it.
- 9:16Maybe they can discern certain chord progressions or something that they like.
- 9:24But when you've got a computer, it's making an exact copy internally.
- 9:29And traditionally, as I said, and you mentioned this before, well, how's it different from
- 9:34what the human mind does?
- 9:36Maybe a chord buys that argument.
- 9:38But as of right now, when you do this, you're making a copy internally to the computer and
- 9:45that is an unauthorized use.
- 9:48I mean, with a human listening to a song and then somewhere it's in their gray matter physically,
- 9:54it's being stored in a fixed medium, that might somehow be an infringement.
- 9:58But what are the damages?
- 9:59It might be brain damage if it's a bad song.
- 10:02A bad song going around in your head could cause brain damage.
- 10:05What are you guys, I mentioned one other thing there's other theories to it.
- 10:08Just to round it out, some of these cases argue that the terms of use have been violated.
- 10:14Where the content is posted by the copyright order, that the terms of use are violated.
- 10:20Other, there's a few cases that raise that it's a use of the play.
- 10:26It's not even a copyright claim.
- 10:27It's a voice in the claim.
- 10:30So you can have a state law claim.
- 10:31But I just wanted to make a...
- 10:32Yeah.
- 10:33Rami, what do you think?
- 10:34So I think, and I agree with Peter's analysis, but I think using the brain example versus
- 10:41what's copied onto a computer.
- 10:43I think the distinction here is fixation.
- 10:46And when a piece of music or anything is copied onto your brain, it's not...
- 10:53It doesn't fall within the definition of fixation as we understand it under the Copyright Act.
- 10:58And that's what distinguishes these AI models.
- 11:02They're actually making copies of whatever the content may be.
- 11:05And there's already some jurisprudence around text material.
- 11:10There's the Anderson versus stability AI case, which recently had a ruling from Judge Orrick
- 11:16and the Northern District.
- 11:18And they're distinguishing...
- 11:21I'm distinguishing fixation, which is recognized under the Copyright Act versus what you're
- 11:28saying Bill, which is a very valid question.
- 11:30Well, if you record or remember a song in your mind and then use it to create new music,
- 11:36how is that distinguishable?
- 11:37And I think it doesn't fall within the fixation, which... and Peter, you can recite the Act
- 11:42much better than I can, but it has to be fixed in a way that it can be perceived by others.
- 11:47I would even go back to the Constitution because the right... the ability for Congress to issue
- 11:54copyright laws is limited to writings.
- 11:57And your brain isn't a writing.
- 11:59Technically, from an electronic standpoint, the internal memory of a computer is a writing.
- 12:05So, maybe there's even a constitutional problem with that argument.
- 12:09Could be.
- 12:10Yeah.
- 12:11And you had talked about the Orrick case, which involves... that's a comedy case, right?
- 12:14Sarah Silverman...
- 12:15No, the Orrick case was Anderson, Sarah Anderson versus stability AI.
- 12:21It was an actual based on graphic images.
- 12:24Oh, okay.
- 12:25Yeah.
- 12:26But there is another case by Sarah Silverman also against Chad GBT that's pending along
- 12:32with a few other...
- 12:34He was also talking about something interesting about getting images, and this gets more into
- 12:39transactional issues.
- 12:41Yeah.
- 12:42Sorry about that.
- 12:43Yeah.
- 12:44Yeah.
- 12:45So, the AI quandary dilemma that we're all facing right now, the courts are just starting
- 12:54to chip away at it.
- 12:56And as often as the case with new legal challenges, the market finds a solution.
- 13:03And we're already seeing some market solutions.
- 13:06I have not seen these whether we're replicated in the music industry yet, but in the graphic
- 13:11image industry, Getty Images has now created its own AI engine called AI by Getty Images.
- 13:20Pretty awful branding.
- 13:22And in this, you can use Getty Images universe of images that Getty owns the copyright to.
- 13:30And I think it's something like 700 million images.
- 13:34And use that, use their AI tool, AI generator to generate images put in your prompt like
- 13:40you would with any other AI.
- 13:42And anything that comes out of that is protected because it's based on learning of...
- 13:48All of the learning is based on a controlled universe.
- 13:51It's a universe of copyrighted work all owned by Getty.
- 13:54And Getty has gone the extra step of saying that if you are sued for infringement based
- 13:59on the output of our Getty AI program, we will indemnify you from infringement.
- 14:07I have not seen this with music AI.
- 14:09And I was looking this up yesterday.
- 14:11I haven't found any...
- 14:13I think the analog here in music would be production music libraries where you've got
- 14:21a universe of production music that's owned both the compositions and the masters are
- 14:26owned by the music library and then that can be used and can be licensed.
- 14:31I haven't seen any libraries that are actually created an AI model that allows you to actually
- 14:36create music based on the music that exists in their lives.
- 14:40I don't think that any of the music publishers or labels are going to be too eager to offer
- 14:45up their libraries or something like that or among other things because the artist wouldn't
- 14:50be absolutely thrilled with that idea.
- 14:52And with photographers, it would seem like the same thing if you had a prompt that said
- 14:57I wanted to be in the style of a famous photographer, that's a problem, isn't it?
- 15:04Well, I mean, what you put into the AI prompt might generate something that looks like a
- 15:09particular photographer, but if all of the learning, all of the data that went into the
- 15:14learning of this AI algorithm is data owned by the, in this case, the copyright owner,
- 15:21the data images, there really is not a basis for infringement.
- 15:25I think, yeah.
- 15:26So Jeff, it's, one thing we know too about this is that you can't copyright AI music,
- 15:34that was a guidance from the copyright office which then turned images into creative.
- 15:39Yeah.
- 15:40I mean, it can't be, there was one case cited by the copyright office about a case, Urantia
- 15:47Foundation which involved, you know, that one involved a guy who wrote a book but he
- 15:52said he didn't write it, he was channeling a divine alien.
- 15:56Okay.
- 15:57And he writes this book, somebody steals the book or somebody takes the book and publishes
- 16:01it without authorization, he sues for copyright infringement and the court is like, wait a
- 16:06minute, you said you didn't write it.
- 16:08You said it, bring the alien in here to who has standing to sue.
- 16:14You've gotten a lot of the Ninth Circuit, it actually has that case that says that there's
- 16:20no, that a divine person can't be an author under the copyright act and there's another
- 16:24Ninth Circuit case that says that baboons cannot be, because of that selfie by the baboon.
- 16:30Oh right.
- 16:31Yeah, only the Ninth Circuit.
- 16:32Yeah.
- 16:33So it's hard to monitor that.
- 16:34Years ago, I represented the Miles Davis estate for about 20 years and I get a call
- 16:40that someone has built a Miles Cafe in the Times Square area of New York.
- 16:45So I run the owner down and I said, hey, you know, you can't have a Miles Cafe with a
- 16:50Trump, right?
- 16:51He says to me, Miles spoke to me in my dreams.
- 16:54Sit.
- 16:55And I chased my name to Miles Kobayashi and I opened this thing.
- 16:59I said, well tragically, Miles didn't explain to you the trademark.
- 17:02You can't sue your mother if you don't stop.
- 17:05The night, the dream turns into nightmare.
- 17:07That's like, yeah, that's amazing.
- 17:10In terms of, since you can't monetize copyrights, is there a way to make money?
- 17:15I mean, you know, Suno and Udio and other companies obviously think there's some kind
- 17:19of market for music that cannot be copyrighted.
- 17:24Is there one do you think?
- 17:27Well I guess the analogy would be when recordings have fallen into the PD, again a good Miles
- 17:33example, some Miles' greatest works were done in the 50s, right?
- 17:37They were starting to fall into the PD in Europe, which is jazz is much more popular
- 17:40there than here.
- 17:41And what Sony has done is repackage the original recordings which are no longer predictable
- 17:46with interviews and clips and unreleased materials.
- 17:49So it's kind of window dressing, but the core, I don't think so.
- 17:52It was interesting.
- 17:53We didn't talk about this on our phone call, but I've been doing a lot of karaoke licensed
- 17:56and weirdly lately and I'm singing and yes, they fit.
- 18:00Well, you can play bass for me.
- 18:03In real time, I'm on the third draft of a license with Sony Music and they sing, this
- 18:07is our new AI paragraph where you have to put in protections so that their data will
- 18:13not be scrubbed from your karaoke service to facilitate machine learning.
- 18:18So it's real time changing.
- 18:20On the monetizing point, you're thinking of resales, but there's apps have value.
- 18:26I mean, if the person just is able to say, you know, they pay FB and they're able to
- 18:30say, tonight I'd like to listen to something like Beyonce and it just starts generating
- 18:35Beyonce songs.
- 18:37So there's value there, even if you can't, you know, then resell it or anyone could copy
- 18:42it because there's no protection.
- 18:44In other words, a tool for musicians.
- 18:46It could be a tool like a, for mastering or orchestration, things that some orchestrators
- 18:52might not love that.
- 18:54You know, it's an art form too.
- 18:55So mastering engineers might think that can't be done, but it is being done.
- 18:59And so it's AI is being used also for content ID to find infringements and things like that.
- 19:06So yeah, you've always had it as a thread to musicians and it really goes back in history.
- 19:10I wrote an article in the Atlantic about 10 years ago about one robots write songs and
- 19:16it's, briefly, it's, you know, you used to have bands that were playing in lobbies of
- 19:24hotels and like Santa Monica and stuff.
- 19:26And then, you know, many years later, the synthesizer came along and all the horn players lost their
- 19:30gig and it was a synthesizer player, right?
- 19:33And then the bass player and then, yeah, and the bass players lost their gig, the synth
- 19:37player and maybe a singer.
- 19:39And then along came the DJs.
- 19:41And so the synth player lost their gig and we're screaming bloody murder because now
- 19:45they don't need that.
- 19:47And now the DJ is losing the gig because it's AI and they're screaming bloody murder and
- 19:52they're saying, wait a minute, you know, like the DJ who sits behind the console and hits
- 19:57the play button is, no, there's much more to it.
- 20:00You've got to read the room and how can a robot read a room?
- 20:03No, there's no way that, you know, that that can happen.
- 20:05If you ever, if anybody remembers that Saturday night live sketch with Andy Sandberg of Lonely
- 20:11Island called When the Bass Drops where you have a DJ who's sort of like a beachy and
- 20:17a big packed club and he's sitting there behind, he's like doing fist pumps and he's moving
- 20:21his head around.
- 20:22And then the camera goes back and you see what he's doing behind there.
- 20:25He's got like a model train set.
- 20:28He's got like, he's a frying an egg.
- 20:30He's playing solitaire.
- 20:33So you know, musicians are going to have been progressively getting it bad.
- 20:38But thankfully, I would think that this trend is back toward live music.
- 20:43Wouldn't you say that?
- 20:44So AI will never create great music.
- 20:46And one reason is because it can't cry.
- 20:48AI doesn't cry.
- 20:49John Lennon lost his mother tragically just about a few years before the Beatles started
- 20:54in a freak car accident.
- 20:58You know, you have Leonard Cohen, you know, banging his head against the floor in a Chelsea
- 21:03hotel.
- 21:04Computers don't do that.
- 21:05So I don't think they come up with great music.
- 21:08What do you think?
- 21:09Some writers are using it for writer's block.
- 21:10I was looking for that really.
- 21:11Well, I thought, yeah, it was really, if I can dig it out, I'll see if I can find it.
- 21:15But yeah, it's interesting.
- 21:17So you know, it's interesting because AI has been used as a tool in many industries, including
- 21:22the legal industry.
- 21:23But what some music libraries are doing now is they're using AI as a search tool.
- 21:30So you can use common language prompts to simply describe, this is particularly for
- 21:36production, music, film, television, video games.
- 21:40You can just put in a basic sentence, English sentence describing the scene, you know, dark
- 21:47work, rainy, alley, etc.
- 21:51And they will deliver music that's suitable to that particular scene just as described.
- 21:59That's something that music libraries are benefiting from with AI, which is different from using
- 22:05AI to actually generate the music.
- 22:07It's what I'd call an advanced search tool.
- 22:11Great.
- 22:12So when we're talking about music copyright, we're usually talking either about infringement
- 22:16termination rights, that kind of thing.
- 22:22And there's a recent case that the Supreme Court came out with, Warner Chapel v. Neely.
- 22:30And Peter, maybe you could talk a bit about that case and what the takeaway is for people
- 22:35here.
- 22:37That's a case where if I can set the table on that, it's a guy who was in prison in Florida
- 22:44found out that Flo Rida, the rapper, had used his song in an interpolation, used his song.
- 22:52But he didn't find out about it in the prison because they didn't have the greatest internet
- 22:55in the prison.
- 22:56In fact, they had no internet in the prison.
- 23:00But he finds out about it later.
- 23:02He sues Warner Chapel and others and they have a good statute of limitations and they,
- 23:11I guess, still latches and less latches is completely out of it, but maybe you could
- 23:15give us your hot take on that.
- 23:18It sort of fall out and it doesn't answer the questions really, but it sort of fall out
- 23:22from Petrella, which in the Supreme Court in 2014 said that latches didn't apply to
- 23:27copyright infringement claims.
- 23:29But in the Ginsburg's opinion, she also had references to that it's a three-year statute.
- 23:35After that, there's no liability.
- 23:38And there's a footnote that referred to the fact that some circuits apply a delayed discovery
- 23:43rule to copyright infringement cases.
- 23:46And so the fallout from that initially was, okay, does that mean delayed discovery no
- 23:51longer applies?
- 23:52We've got clear language in the body of the opinion that says it's three years and you're
- 23:56out.
- 23:57And then we've got this reference and the court didn't say anything like, we're not going
- 24:02to decide that issue.
- 24:03So what happened in the second circuit was they came up with this rule that, look, three
- 24:09years and you're out.
- 24:10That's what the Supreme Court said.
- 24:12But we still have delayed discovery.
- 24:15So you can sue for an infringement that you just learned about that happened 10 years
- 24:18earlier, but you can't get any damages for it, which doesn't make a whole lot of sense
- 24:22because why would you sue over something 10 years ago if you can't get any relief?
- 24:27The ninth circuit said, basically, it doesn't make any sense.
- 24:31And in Starr's entertainment said, no, the Pachelre decision has nothing to do with delayed
- 24:36discovery.
- 24:37So at that point, what you have is some circuits don't allow delayed discovery.
- 24:42The second circuit says it's a partial bar.
- 24:46If you have delayed discovery, you can sue for liability, but you can't get damages.
- 24:49And the ninth circuit said nothing's changed.
- 24:52And so Warner Chapel versus Neely, Warner really wanted the court to roll or whether or not
- 25:00you could have the delayed discovery roll.
- 25:02But in the lower court, they were in a circuit that allowed the delayed discovery rule and
- 25:07no one challenged it.
- 25:08So when it got to the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, six of the justices said, we're just
- 25:14going to assume delayed discovery applies.
- 25:16We're not going to rule on whether it applies.
- 25:18We're just going to assume because everyone assumes in the lower courts it applied.
- 25:23But this idea that it cuts off remedies makes no sense.
- 25:27So it rejected the second circuit opinion.
- 25:30The dissent said basically three justices said, we should decide whether or not the
- 25:35delayed discovery is even available because it certainly seems like it isn't.
- 25:40So you've got at least three judges who don't like the delayed discovery rule.
- 25:43And it's anyone's guess whether there's two more of the remaining six that would do it.
- 25:49But they've basically punted it down the road.
- 25:52So at this point, we know that the second circuit attempt at trying to reconcile Petrella
- 25:59just didn't work.
- 26:00We're back to delayed discovery and those circuits were allowed to late discovery and
- 26:04everyone's waiting for another case to go up to the Supreme Court to see whether or not
- 26:08that applies.
- 26:09So speaking of delayed discovery in the Earth's stairway to heaven case, that's like 40 years
- 26:15ago, right?
- 26:16That this guy, this band Spirit was opening for Led Zeppelin and they had a song that
- 26:21they had an A minor with a descending bass line and no stairway to heaven has the same
- 26:26thing and so does music by Boff, by the way.
- 26:29So it's like we're all standing on the shoulders of giants that was originally ascribed to Isaac
- 26:33Newton and then someone said, no, he stole that from French cleric 500 years earlier.
- 26:40But 40 years ago, and so because we have this rolling this idea of a currently in practice
- 26:46of rolling statute of limitations as to copy, it's a three-year statute, but it rolls.
- 26:52So like if you have a new box set in the case of the Led Zeppelin case, was that a new box
- 26:56set?
- 26:57Can we ask a little bit about how you can go back 40 years?
- 27:00Well, I mean, first of all, stairway to heaven wasn't a delayed discovery case because no
- 27:05one could dispute that they're not about to say, right, Alan?
- 27:09Well, if it was in Florida, but no.
- 27:11What they did was they sued for the for alleged profits within three years preceding the date
- 27:16they filed, which included the release of remastered copy, remastered recordings.
- 27:21But what that case did point up was the problem of getting rid of latches because we were
- 27:27trying to be dealing with the access issue and Ginsburg and Petrilla said, look, copyrights
- 27:33or cases are simple.
- 27:35Are they substantially similar?
- 27:36What she left out was you have to prove copying.
- 27:39And so you're faced with what was the access facts in 1969, 1970.
- 27:49Witnesses have died, set lists have disappeared.
- 27:53People are saying, well, Robert Klant was at a bar that had a spirit plane in the background,
- 28:00but we don't know a spirit plane bat song.
- 28:02And so all those issues would normally have raised a latches defense and for good reason.
- 28:08It's a plaintiff, actually the original songwriter, but then the trustee knew about stairway to
- 28:14heaven for 40 years did nothing about it and witnesses pass documents for lost memories
- 28:19faded and but we couldn't raise latches.
- 28:23So anybody else on that before we go to the vet or the resnick case?
- 28:28It is really wild.
- 28:30Okay.
- 28:31So that wreck, there's another very recent case, but it's not the US Supreme Court.
- 28:37It's the district court of middle district of Louisiana and Baton Rouge where you have
- 28:43Judge Shelley Dick ruling that the plaint denying a motion to dismiss.
- 28:51Well, what happened there is you have somebody contending that this song, not that well known
- 28:59a song, it's been covered by some people, but that the termination right, nobody disputes
- 29:04that there is a termination right, but that it only that we all know who anyone who knows
- 29:11it about and works with termination rights knows that what is written in stone is that
- 29:15it only applies within the borders of the United States.
- 29:19And in the rest of the world, everything remains.
- 29:21Well this judge said, why is that?
- 29:24The judge said it's plausible.
- 29:26She didn't rule on it because she just said it's plausible and denied the motion to dismiss
- 29:31and we'll see how that plays out.
- 29:33But the judge had an argument, it was quite a lengthy opinion.
- 29:36I thought it was well written, but you'd probably disagree with a lot of it.
- 29:40But why is it that it shouldn't?
- 29:42And she distinguished or she said the plaint have distinguished credibly that there's two
- 29:47things that you look at, ownership and conduct.
- 29:50And she said the owner, the conduct, yeah, you would go to the country where the conduct
- 29:55is happening and apply the law there, but the ownership issue, you would only use a
- 30:00US law.
- 30:01And that would be a nightmare for all the content companies if people could terminate
- 30:09the copyright world.
- 30:10Why?
- 30:11What happens now is that you threaten to terminate, the kind of playbook plays that you threaten
- 30:15to terminate, US writes on say a major publishing deal or something.
- 30:20And then they go, well, they politely remind you that well, it's only for the US, we've
- 30:24got the rest of the world.
- 30:26And they do see dough and do a little dance and then it's like let's work out a better
- 30:29deal.
- 30:30And that's the playbook play.
- 30:31But if that case down in Badden Rouge became the law, it would be like, I want my copyright
- 30:37back.
- 30:38Thank you very much.
- 30:40And what do you think?
- 30:42Is there any possibility that that case could be the law of the land?
- 30:48And that certainly would, Jeff, that would affect your catalog sales quite a bit.
- 30:53Sure.
- 30:54Yeah.
- 30:55Well, there's actually another issue.
- 30:56There are two things that were undisputed.
- 30:58They had an Oben situation.
- 31:00The author had granted rights in the renewal term, didn't survive to renew.
- 31:04And so it was undisputed that the successor, the statutory successor, got that renewal
- 31:10copyright pre and clear prior grants.
- 31:13And the court determined it was plausible that that recovered renewal copyright extended
- 31:19overseas, which is an issue that has been out there for years.
- 31:24There's good arguments.
- 31:26I think good arguments that that's correct.
- 31:28But the really challenging part of the opinion is what Bill described, where the court went
- 31:34on to say that the statutory termination, which, whether you're talking about 203 or
- 31:40304C specifically says that termination does not terminate any rights under foreign law
- 31:47and only terminates rights under the Title 17.
- 31:52And what the court did in Louisiana was it said, well, the rights, but actually, let
- 31:59me step back, rights in foreign territories are governed by the Byrne Convention.
- 32:03The Byrne Convention, each nation says, will give you our copyright protection that you
- 32:08would get if you were a citizen, if you remember.
- 32:11What the court did was it looked at it differently and it said, no, there's only one copyright,
- 32:15a U.S. copyright that is enforced outside the U.S.
- 32:19And since there's only one copyright, it's the U.S. copyright, it arises under the U.S.
- 32:24Copyright Act, so it's not a copyright that arises under foreign law, which, first of
- 32:31all, if you do that, then the whole exception rights under foreign law are defected, has
- 32:38no meaning because termination by definition only applies to grants of copyrights.
- 32:44And if all copyrights of U.S. works are just U.S. copyrights and don't arise under foreign
- 32:51law, then there's no reason to go on and say, and it doesn't affect rights under foreign
- 32:56law.
- 32:57So it makes no sense.
- 32:58The statute, I think, is absolutely clear.
- 33:00I have never heard anyone make that argument before.
- 33:05And it's definitely not the accepted interpretation of it and the language seems clear.
- 33:09No, and so, Jeff, I mean, even without that, which would just be a huge quantum leap from
- 33:17what we have today, what we have today is still a problem.
- 33:20Like, you have the James Brown catalog, sells to primary wave, and then you have termination
- 33:25notices coming up from the airs and different sets of airs making different competing.
- 33:32But what a mess.
- 33:34So how do these termination rights come into your life as you do a lot of catalog work?
- 33:43Do you in the analysis and what's your thoughts on that?
- 33:47Well, we talked about them once ourselves.
- 33:49I don't know anybody who buys a dacha, who buys the lottery tick, like maybe they can
- 33:53sue somebody.
- 33:54No, my label clients would love that.
- 33:58You know, it doesn't make any sense to me either.
- 34:00We've all built our valuation models and our practices on the accepted rule that it only
- 34:07stayed at the oceans.
- 34:09That makes no sense to me at all.
- 34:11Yeah, it's crazy.
- 34:14But that and also the AI stuff we were talking about before, all of that factors into the
- 34:19transactional world when you're doing a deal, right?
- 34:23But you know, we were talking about this yesterday.
- 34:26We were on it, it wasn't one of these crazy huge deals, but it was a substantial catalog
- 34:30sale.
- 34:31And the evaluator, a pretty experienced evaluator hadn't taken termination rights into effect
- 34:38in their evaluation of the price of the catalog, which seemed, again, as a practitioner, nuts.
- 34:45How do you evaluate what the price of something, if you're not factoring in that you need to
- 34:49come stream may end in three or four years?
- 34:51Yeah.
- 34:52The age of the catalog is critical.
- 34:54Yeah, let me also ask the audience, how many of you are litigators who litigate in the
- 35:01music world to some extent?
- 35:03I know you are, Neville, that's pretty good.
- 35:06And what about transactional attorneys that work in music?
- 35:09A few.
- 35:10But there are a lot of you that we really don't want to lose track here of what we want you
- 35:15to understand, what we're talking about generally.
- 35:18So this termination right under the US Copyright Act really is an odd beast, but it's just
- 35:26so great for heirs, say, old copyrights, and the authors themselves, where they just get
- 35:34regardless, notwithstanding agreements to the contrary, which means no matter what the
- 35:41idea behind it is that the authors typically sign really crappy deals when they're young
- 35:47and they sign something off.
- 35:48And then later on, they may have a catalog that's really worth a lot, but they sold it.
- 35:55And the idea is to give their heirs a second bite at the apple, 56 years or 75 years under
- 36:03first stuff that was published before 78, and it's 35 years for agreements that were entered
- 36:10into after 78.
- 36:11But anyway, it's a second bite at the apple.
- 36:13It's a generous congressional gift to the authors and their heirs.
- 36:21And it's not only to be a gift, it's the basic premise behind it is to espouse more creativity
- 36:28for society.
- 36:29So it's supposed to help society by making it easier to be a creative, give you an incentive
- 36:34to create music or whatever other works you do.
- 36:38So but you have a situation like Jeff is talking about where you're selling a catalog that
- 36:42really has become very valuable.
- 36:47But then you have the possibility that there's going to be something coming out of the woodwork
- 36:51in the form of a termination notice.
- 36:53Yeah, Resnick will not help the value of catalogs, in that sense.
- 36:57Yeah.
- 36:58And while you're talking about music catalogs, just to be clear, this applies across the
- 37:02board.
- 37:03So if you've got someone, a client who did a book or you represent the movie studio,
- 37:07and the movie studio does a movie version of the book, a notice of termination comes
- 37:12across usually what happens, at least what I've heard, is that the studio says your
- 37:18rights are limited to the US, our rights are foreign, you can't get anyone to fund a new
- 37:23movie based on your book if the rights are limited to the US.
- 37:26So let's work together and that usually happens.
- 37:29Under this case in Louisiana, basically, the studio would lose rights around the world.
- 37:35It's just crazy.
- 37:37Yeah.
- 37:38And yet catalog sales are booming still.
- 37:40I mean, that's a question for you.
- 37:42Are they really booming?
- 37:43We have seen that streaming may have some argue that it may have reached a peak, others say,
- 37:49no, it's got a long ways to go.
- 37:51It's like a 6% growth, 6%, 7% growth rate, where people were expecting the last report
- 37:57to be about 10% or 12%.
- 38:00It's still, and people's not as high.
- 38:01And Universal's stock one day in July dropped quarterly earnings by like 24%.
- 38:08Now it's come back quite a bit.
- 38:10I think largely because of that disappointment over streaming.
- 38:16So notwithstanding all that, we have these eye popping deals that just keep getting bigger
- 38:22and bigger.
- 38:23Dillon, 500 million, Springsteen, 500 million.
- 38:28And then you're like, well, okay, we're not going to see that again.
- 38:30And then Queen, 1 billion pounds.
- 38:34So it's like 1.2 million dollars.
- 38:37What's next?
- 38:38Is this going to continue?
- 38:39Or have we kind of reached a top there?
- 38:43Well, we were talking about this a little bit amongst the four of us.
- 38:47I haven't seen the prices dramatically drop.
- 38:49I would say it's plateaued a little bit.
- 38:52But the strong catalog still good good prices.
- 38:54The analogy would be if you are trying to sell your home in a softening real estate market,
- 38:58if you price it, well, I say it this way, in a hot real estate market, if you price your
- 39:03house correctly, you can get two or three full price offers that first day or the first
- 39:07couple of days, right?
- 39:09In the softening market, you may still get the price that you want, but it's going to
- 39:12be a three, four, five, six week nail biter trying to get to where you want to be.
- 39:16That's what I'm seeing.
- 39:17So I'm not seeing a dramatic drop in prices for sure.
- 39:22And I should say I said on both sides of this, so half of me smiling, half of me crying.
- 39:27But it's just taking a lot longer to find a home.
- 39:30The price of money is higher.
- 39:32I think what's happening, this is really more Imperial Rami's what happened with Merck.
- 39:36He was the market maker for a very long time.
- 39:38So I hope we'll touch on that too.
- 39:40But there's a bunch of things that are kind of cooling people's jets a little bit.
- 39:43So the market is still, people are paying top dollar.
- 39:46But I would say when I'm on the sell side, I do a little more homework.
- 39:49It takes me a little bit longer to find a catalog at home.
- 39:52So he's talking about Merck Curiatis who founded a company called Hypnosis, which was really
- 39:59the pioneering company in these eye-popping acquisitions.
- 40:03And he got the name Hypnosis from another company started by a graphic artist named
- 40:09Storm Thurman, third descent or something, Storm something, who actually created the
- 40:16logo for Led Zeppelin among many other things.
- 40:20So presumably he has a license to use the name Hypnosis.
- 40:24But he's been, the company was wildly successful.
- 40:27And then it turned out that there were a lot of other companies that jumped in there and
- 40:30you have Apollo with Harborview.
- 40:33I mean, you've got primary wave.
- 40:34Apollo with Casa?
- 40:35Only is buying up a lot of stuff.
- 40:37What?
- 40:38Concord.
- 40:39The Concord deal with Apollo was massive.
- 40:40We do a lot of ABS, you know, asset-backed securities that to tear earlier question.
- 40:46I think part of what's keeping the prices elevated is that non-music money is chasing
- 40:50music assets.
- 40:51It's something that folks on Wall Street really get because the copyright is essentially
- 40:54an annuity.
- 40:55So you got, you know, Concord and the Spanx.
- 40:58I should mention that we work with that are now investing in copyrights, mostly music.
- 41:03And also some video when it's possible.
- 41:05But then you have copyrights that have a, they're not an annuity forever.
- 41:08It's not like you buy real estate and you can own it forever.
- 41:10I mean, it's got a life term, right?
- 41:1295 years.
- 41:13Yeah.
- 41:14And to the veterans.
- 41:15You know, unless it's a, so even under any circumstances.
- 41:18So if Dylan is selling his catalog of hits in the mid 1960s by the early 1960s, it's in
- 41:26the public domain.
- 41:27So he's got maybe 30 years and he sells it for maybe what's, I don't know, close to
- 41:3230% multiple or something like that.
- 41:36But sometimes the catalogs feel also include name, image and like us rights.
- 41:39You know, which if you protect those can have a much longer lifespan.
- 41:43Name and likeness trade rights essentially, right?
- 41:46Rami don't even have a statute.
- 41:48Well, there would be a statute of limitations, I guess, or latches.
- 41:53Name can go on in perpetuity, but in terms of the publicity rights, there's a limit to
- 42:00postmortem right depending on state.
- 42:03Some states don't even have a postmortem right of publicity, but many states, I think
- 42:08California's postmortem right of publicity is 50 years.
- 42:10I'm not mistaken.
- 42:12I could be off 10 or 20 years on that.
- 42:15But yeah, so that is, that does have a limit.
- 42:18But I'm curious in this question for Jeff, these staggering numbers, these 500 million
- 42:25or billion dollar acquisitions, what do you think these investors are looking at?
- 42:30In terms of a timeline for return on investment?
- 42:35That's a very good question.
- 42:38On that side, the evaluators, whether it's FTI or I guess virtue is now the group of
- 42:42black, it seems to, well, to your termination, right?
- 42:46How do you, Kelkin and ROI, you don't know how long the stream's coming in?
- 42:50And obviously if the territories disappear, that will not help sales at all.
- 42:56But to your name, image and likeness issue, this seems like that's going like crazy, right?
- 43:01We're talking about a federal, I think Tennessee within the last three weeks to have the Elvis
- 43:06Act predict name, image, likeness from AI.
- 43:10So we'll see how that, I don't think, I guess there's probably not a case on that yet, but
- 43:14we'll see.
- 43:15So are there any other recent developments in that area regarding like legislation around
- 43:22like the Elvis Act?
- 43:23No, we were talking about that the other day.
- 43:27Oops, go away.
- 43:28Oh, Siri has an answer.
- 43:30Okay, that didn't ask Siri.
- 43:33Hey, I can finish it.
- 43:35Siri always has terrible answers, but okay, we'll just let you finish this one.
- 43:45I'll turn that off.
- 43:47But yeah, just here.
- 43:49Oh, I swear you can make this stuff up.
- 43:53The next panel you should have Siri stop.
- 43:57Siri.
- 43:58Just stop here.
- 44:00Okay.
- 44:01All right.
- 44:04Create a song in the create me Siri, create me a life changing song.
- 44:10Nothing.
- 44:11Okay.
- 44:12Siri turned off.
- 44:13Okay.
- 44:14Yeah.
- 44:15So AI and copyright, are they a downer for the market value of some of these catalogs
- 44:26or are they actually something that could be helpful?
- 44:28Like you can, it's a double-edged sword, right?
- 44:30If you buy a catalog, on the one hand, you don't want to get sued for it.
- 44:35On the other hand, you might want to sue other people for infringing stuff that's in
- 44:38there.
- 44:39So it's sort of like you're playing at both ways.
- 44:42What do you think?
- 44:44I think that's absolutely right.
- 44:45I mean, if you're a record company or a music publisher, that is their works are being infringed.
- 44:52You'd like to go back to the beginning of time.
- 44:56But if you're the same company's being sued, you'd like any liability to be cut off after
- 45:02three years or to be able to do these lashes.
- 45:05So it's a double-edged sword.
- 45:06It depends on which hat you're wearing or you have to play for the defendant.
- 45:11So do you think, is your forecast, Jeff, that the values are going to continue?
- 45:17And do the interest rates also factor into the value or how so?
- 45:22The cost of money.
- 45:23Well, the deals, the prices they're laying out, because a lot of it's with borrowed cash.
- 45:29Certainly you thought you would think.
- 45:30But I remember having lunch with a publisher company president.
- 45:34Got to be nigh on a decade ago now.
- 45:36Two companies were chasing a catalog of ours and you made a pitch.
- 45:44I listened respectfully and I said, well, we're probably going to go with company B.
- 45:49And huffly-huffly he says, well, go ahead.
- 45:51He said, you'll be begging me for deals.
- 45:53This is all going to die in 18 months.
- 45:55Well, it's been tight still.
- 45:57But mathematically right, it's a zero sum game.
- 46:00Somebody's paying more for you to get more.
- 46:02I don't know when it's going to end.
- 46:04I mean, thank God, because back to my intro, I have a lot of tuition coming down the pipe.
- 46:08So that's beautiful.
- 46:10But it can't last forever.
- 46:12Right?
- 46:13Okay.
- 46:14Let's pivot a little bit, but stay on this, but to wrap and hip hop.
- 46:18And are you seeing the sales of those catalogs being the same?
- 46:23Does that hold up the same way as, say, legacy classic rock catalogs and things like that?
- 46:30I don't think anything does as well.
- 46:33Motown is the gold standard, right?
- 46:35Because everyone loves it.
- 46:36And then it's used in every movie, every film, every advertisement.
- 46:39Down to, I sold a Christian music catalog a few years ago, and it was like a 2.8 multiple.
- 46:44And the client took it because you can't sell paper towels in front of Jesus.
- 46:48Right?
- 46:49Yeah, it really depends on the spectrum.
- 46:52But hip hop is still the most popular kind of music.
- 46:55Just a question outside of the subscriber play, where else can you monetize it?
- 47:01And to me, again, Motown or the Beach Boys or the Beatles, right?
- 47:06Those are the things that's evergreen.
- 47:08Okay.
- 47:09And then there's one other issue, which is the rap lyrics.
- 47:12And this has been a big issue within the last year about rap lyrics being used in trials.
- 47:19So we had like two trials, one that's still going on.
- 47:23In fact, it's quite a long RICO trial in Georgia for Young Thug.
- 47:28Took a year to pick a jury.
- 47:30And it's Fonny Willis is the prosecutor there.
- 47:33And it's a case where they're claiming that Young Thug is the leader of a gang that's
- 47:40connected with the Bloods.
- 47:42And that he is using his raps or actually like recruitment methods that some of the things
- 47:48in there say like, you know, I'm a general in this rap army, you know, things like that.
- 47:52Turns out the judge, Ural Granville is in the Army Reserve.
- 47:57He is a general.
- 47:58And he read the lyrics to the jury during the jury and panelment.
- 48:05And it's one of the lyrics that he read to the jury is, fuck the judge, which was interesting.
- 48:11But in any event, we have Rearister, Bill Bridgebuilder.
- 48:17But the person is running against Fonny Willis, District Attorney, is a Republican who vows
- 48:23to have that case to submit, have that case thrown out.
- 48:26And it's going on, but it's a case about should rap lyrics be used as evidence in any circumstance.
- 48:35And Judge Ural Granville allowed it to be used conditionally, but with restrictions.
- 48:42I mean, it can't be the only evidence.
- 48:43It has to be specific as to some particular crime with some evidence like that.
- 48:49Meanwhile, so he's allowing it in.
- 48:51And actually, he's no longer in the case.
- 48:53They found a reason to remove him from the case.
- 48:57Very tricky case down there.
- 48:59It's a RICO case in Georgia.
- 49:00Then you go up to Brooklyn and you had the run DMC, a Grandmaster, Jammaster J trial.
- 49:09He was actually in his recording studio.
- 49:13Guy came in and shot him in the head.
- 49:15And it turned out the guy was his godson.
- 49:18But anyway, he was a bad actor.
- 49:20And he actually did a rap saying, we shoot called a headshot or something like that.
- 49:27It's like we shoot him in the head and then we wait and watch him drop.
- 49:30And that's exactly what witnesses said he did.
- 49:32And the judge, it was in District Court in Brooklyn, the Eastern District of New York,
- 49:37wouldn't allow that in or another video of him dancing in front of a mural of Jammaster
- 49:42J bragging about things he did, wouldn't allow it in.
- 49:46And one of the things that the judge, Lachan Darcy Hall said was he may have about the
- 49:54shot in the head.
- 49:55He shot a lot of people in the head, but we don't have any evidence that it was this
- 50:01guy that he shot in the head, wouldn't allow it in.
- 50:03But in that case, there were plenty of other, there's a lot of other evidence and they convicted
- 50:08this guy.
- 50:11But they wouldn't allow the rap lyrics in and she wrote a really, really beautiful opinion
- 50:15actually.
- 50:16They've talked about the history of rap actually and how the exaggerations and things are.
- 50:22It's like the public demands it and it's part of that thing.
- 50:26And it's not to be used in less, it's very specific.
- 50:33It's not enough to say.
- 50:35Very recently, Drake released a rap very recently that actually has young thug in it.
- 50:44And it's like, I think it's an old recording.
- 50:47But even in that, Drake has a rap that says something about, I get blood money or something
- 50:57like that and he talks about it.
- 50:59And almost like thumbing his nose at the court, like sort of admitting that he's got, I have
- 51:04the way I read it.
- 51:05Maybe he's got some connection to the bloods.
- 51:08But anyway, that case wouldn't allow the lyrics in or the video hadn't they convicted him.
- 51:18And then down in Georgia, you really don't have much evidence.
- 51:22You have a manager who was shot to death outside in Georgia, outside of a barber shop.
- 51:29There was a drive-by shooting and they traced the car rental to young thug.
- 51:35And there's not a whole lot more than that.
- 51:36They're really leaning on the lyrics and they say that the lyrics are specific enough.
- 51:42What do you guys think?
- 51:43I mean, it's sort of character evidence.
- 51:46Should it be allowed in?
- 51:48Any thoughts on that?
- 51:50But you generally can't use, I don't know what the Georgia rules and evidence are or New
- 51:56York, but as a general proposition and definitely in federal court, there's trick limitations
- 52:01on character evidence.
- 52:02And my understanding in both cases is that it's not being used for character evidence,
- 52:06but it's being used to try and prove an element in the crime.
- 52:10In Brooklyn, I think you identified the distinctions.
- 52:13In Brooklyn, the allegation was that they had shot Maizel and there was nothing in the
- 52:20lyrics that actually supported that.
- 52:23And also, there was this point that, look, if you just look to the lyrics, it's not really
- 52:28positive of anything because it's artistic expression, you make all kinds of exaggerated
- 52:32claims.
- 52:33And then also the suggestion that if you allow this, then there's a racial element that you're
- 52:39basically tainting them with this music.
- 52:43And I mean, no one thinks that Neil Young actually shot his baby down by the river.
- 52:51He said that.
- 52:52So people say things in lyrics and that makes sense.
- 52:55In the Georgia case, it's the Georgia RICO Act, which they have to prove something different.
- 52:59They have to prove that there was this organization and collaborative behavior and the songs the
- 53:05judge found.
- 53:06I think there were 17 different lyrics that supposedly supported the idea that there was
- 53:11some organization to it.
- 53:13And also, by the way, it just, last night, I didn't even realize this.
- 53:17In 2017, there was a case in California that allowed the use of rap lyrics in a criminal
- 53:22case.
- 53:23In fact, California passed the decriminalization of artistic expression or something.
- 53:29They amended the evidence code to place specific limitations on the ability to use rap or any
- 53:36artistic expression that has to do things like identify details that aren't publicly
- 53:41known, details about the crime that aren't publicly known, or it has to really be specific
- 53:49to that kind of back-and-back alleged crime.
- 53:53And there's the ability to show that, no, this is a creative element.
- 53:58There's by statute.
- 53:59You can come in with experts to talk about that.
- 54:00You can talk about and you have to consider the court has to consider any racial prejudice
- 54:05that might result from it.
- 54:06So California acted to actually kind of limit that.
- 54:09So I would think that the only kind of rap lyrics or any lyrics that you could really
- 54:15rely on would have to be basically a confession.
- 54:19The kind of thing that happened in the billionaire who admitted, right, with the sonning the
- 54:25mic, yeah, I killed him.
- 54:27It has to be something like that.
- 54:29Yeah.
- 54:30There's another statute in New York and there's attempts to have a federal statute that
- 54:34haven't passed.
- 54:35But yeah, you have like lots of lyrics.
- 54:39I shot a man in Reno.
- 54:41You got from Johnny Cash.
- 54:43I shot the sheriff, Marley.
- 54:45He's got Mack the Knife.
- 54:48Very violent, super gory, violent stuff.
- 54:51Sinatra.
- 54:52And you have Mick Jagger, Midnight Rambler really.
- 54:56If you look into those lyrics, they're pretty gross.
- 55:00But Mick Jagger was knighted at Buckingham Palace.
- 55:03So he served Mick Jagger and Young Thug is languishing in Fulton County jail.
- 55:10So I'm not saying there's anything to that.
- 55:13Maybe you have, but you have that the public likes violent entertainment and lyrics.
- 55:20I mean, that's just the fact.
- 55:21And that's something that Judge Darcy Hall talks about in her decision.
- 55:29But you know, and then you have that going on.
- 55:32What else is in the news is the beef between Kendrick and Drake.
- 55:38And one question I would put to the panel is, would it be wise for one of them to file
- 55:44a defamation claim against the other one?
- 55:49Any thoughts on that?
- 55:50I mean, look, standard for defamation is so high.
- 55:55The lyrics I saw, two lyrics I saw, there may be others were really sort of just opinion,
- 56:00I think.
- 56:01But it got some press.
- 56:04And I don't know if it's even real, but the idea of actually suing over someone else's
- 56:10lyrics seems a little bit.
- 56:12But also, discovery, whether or not the damage is what?
- 56:14Yeah, well, what discovery looked like getting into people's business, you know.
- 56:19Another reason not to sue in that.
- 56:22But didn't Drake use AI in that beef?
- 56:24I think he did.
- 56:25He did AI, created versions of Snoop Dogg and somebody else.
- 56:28Sort of ironic.
- 56:29Yeah.
- 56:30What's that?
- 56:32They did.
- 56:33Yeah.
- 56:34But is hip hop, do you see a lot of catalog sales that are as big as the other ones yet,
- 56:47or will that happen later, hip hop catalog?
- 56:49I think it'll come later, but you know, it's still the most popular genre of music, I think.
- 56:55Yeah.
- 56:57So I think we're going to talk now about something that everybody is paying attention
- 57:03to, which is the elections.
- 57:05And you have candidates walking out to the podium and they have their walk-on music,
- 57:10like baseball players, and they have walk-off music too.
- 57:15And in the case you have Trump, who I would let, Rami's going to talk about this, I would
- 57:21suspect doesn't have a lot of permission.
- 57:23And then Kamala, who we know that she's getting endorsements and she's palling around with
- 57:30a lot of big musicians and she's playing their music when she comes out.
- 57:34Some people don't want to get political.
- 57:36I mean, there's some artists that don't want to get near that.
- 57:40Like hold on, I'm coming, isn't that Sam and Dave?
- 57:43Yeah.
- 57:44Yeah.
- 57:45Well, that's Isaac Hayes' composition.
- 57:48Yeah, he's Sam and Dave.
- 57:49Yeah, okay.
- 57:50Right.
- 57:51And he says something that even though they supported, they wrote a letter, even if that
- 57:54was back in Obama days, they supported him, but they said, please don't play that when
- 57:59you're going out because I've got a lot of fans that are on the right.
- 58:02I don't want to get political here.
- 58:05But Rami, take it away on what's going on.
- 58:08Yeah, so if you wouldn't mind.
- 58:09I started doing the little research by just simply doing a Google search for musicians
- 58:16who oppose Donald Trump's use of their music.
- 58:19Just for the fun of it.
- 58:20I'm not to be biased towards one side or the other.
- 58:26And I got one, two, three, four, five pages of results.
- 58:36And I did, in fairness, make a similar prompt with respect to Kamala Harris and Biden and
- 58:46did not come up with anything.
- 58:48And that's why maybe Google is biased in its results.
- 58:52But there is a long list of artists whose music has been used for intro and outro, as
- 58:57they call it, walk off music by the Donald Trump campaign and also by the RNC.
- 59:04That's been the majority of jurisprudence we found, the most recent being the Isaac
- 59:08Hayes estate suing just last Friday, the Trump campaign for use of the song that you
- 59:15just mentioned.
- 59:18Hold on, I'm coming.
- 59:20Isaac Hayes was one of two composers and ended up being the, his estate now is the sole owner
- 59:25of copyright in the composition.
- 59:28And it was being used by the Trump campaign for some period of time.
- 59:33And after ignoring demand letters from the Isaac Hayes estate, they sued for $3 million
- 59:39citing 150 uses.
- 59:42So 150 infringements of that song.
- 59:45Now interestingly, we have the performance rights issue.
- 59:51A lot of campaign events take place at venues that have blanket licenses.
- 59:55So they may be stadiums, arenas, et cetera.
- 59:58They have blanket licenses with the PROs, EMI, ASCAP, GMR.
- 1:00:04And that was the case for Donald Trump.
- 1:00:09In this Isaac Hayes case, Isaac Hayes and the co-composer both were composer side with
- 1:00:16BMI.
- 1:00:17And BMI, unlike other PROs, BMI actually grants blanket licenses to political campaigns.
- 1:00:27I understand that GMR, Global Music Rights, does not grant blanket licenses to political
- 1:00:32campaigns, although they do of course grant blanket licenses to venues like stadiums.
- 1:00:38A lot of these campaign events take place in locations like airplane hangars.
- 1:00:45Airplane hangars do not have blanket licenses for use of music.
- 1:00:50So they will need to get an actual blanket license from the PRO for the particular political
- 1:00:57campaign.
- 1:00:58In the case of BMI, their license includes an exclusionary right.
- 1:01:03It's a right to pull music out of the license if it's objected to by the composer who signed
- 1:01:10with that particular PRO.
- 1:01:13We don't have any evidence of that was the case, whether or not the Isaac Hayes estate
- 1:01:17actually challenged that use of the song in the Trump campaign.
- 1:01:23But they do have the ability to pull that back.
- 1:01:26I understand other PROs like Global Music Rights actually have as a standard rule in
- 1:01:34all of their blanket licenses, not just campaign specific blanket licenses, which as I said,
- 1:01:40GMR does not grant, but blanket licenses to venues like stadiums, arenas, concert halls.
- 1:01:46They have in their blanket licenses the ability to exclude certain songs depending on the
- 1:01:52event.
- 1:01:53I understand as a general rule, they do not allow use of their songs.
- 1:01:58This is again, Global Music Rights.
- 1:02:00They don't allow use of their material for any political events, political campaigns,
- 1:02:06or for tribute bands.
- 1:02:08They do not like tribute bands using their music in concerts.
- 1:02:12So that's just an aside.
- 1:02:14Anyway, I can go on Celine Dion, Beyonce.
- 1:02:19Before you go, I wouldn't hear that, but just to set the table just a bit on that, the blanket
- 1:02:25license is a nice blanket that you can put around yourself.
- 1:02:29It's basically saying that the entire catalog, and there's what is it, a billion songs between
- 1:02:34house cats, all your money, something like that, that you can use these, but you can
- 1:02:38only use the audio and it's only at this venue live, so you cannot record it.
- 1:02:46So if you record it, you need another license called a sync license or a synchronization
- 1:02:52license to synchronize the music with the moving images.
- 1:02:56Now Trump does a tricky thing and others as well, which is that they will go into a venue
- 1:03:03that has the blanket license and they will say, well, we're not recording it, but guess
- 1:03:09what?
- 1:03:10There's billions of people watching it on TV and it's being archived, but we're not doing
- 1:03:14that, it's NBC and CNN and MSNBC and Fox that are doing it.
- 1:03:19So is there any kind of liability there, do you think, anyone about like if you're Trump
- 1:03:27or anyone?
- 1:03:28Elizabeth Warren, I think also got to take down for the back when she was running for
- 1:03:34using music and you're just, you're at a venue, it's got a blanket license for a live event
- 1:03:42only.
- 1:03:43You know, it's not for taping, but yet everybody in the world is watching it, it's being taped
- 1:03:48forever, it's going to be on the internet forever, it's archived and all that, but I
- 1:03:52didn't do it.
- 1:03:53It was the news media that did it.
- 1:03:55Well, many of you three may know the answer, I don't, but if you have a blanket license
- 1:04:00and it's going, you know you're going to record that specific performance to issue a live
- 1:04:07album, do you have to get some special permission or do the blanket license cover that?
- 1:04:12And I think the answer is you need a mechanical life.
- 1:04:18So then why wouldn't that apply if you're not recording it, but you know ABC is.
- 1:04:22And so there might be some, you know, contributory vicarious liability theory that would make
- 1:04:26the politician libel for what ABC or CBS does.
- 1:04:30The other thing I want to mention, just to be clear, you've got four or five pages, each
- 1:04:34one has like eight entries.
- 1:04:36So we're not talking about, you know, planes.
- 1:04:40We're talking about 50 or 45 pages, each page has like 10 different, a lot of music.
- 1:04:46Yeah.
- 1:04:47Yeah.
- 1:04:48It's a whole thing.
- 1:04:49So we sent one of the years of what's two or three campaigns ago because it wasn't a
- 1:04:55one-off, but the candidate was making it his walk-off song.
- 1:05:00So we made a lamb act, you know, goodwill, stealing of goodwill kind of argument because
- 1:05:05it was making it his trademark, you know, little T trademark to walk off to this one
- 1:05:10song my client hated him.
- 1:05:13So that was our argument because it wasn't filmed.
- 1:05:14We didn't have a sync book to get him with, but we said, hey, you're trading on our goodwill.
- 1:05:19Actually, that's an excellent point.
- 1:05:20I was just going to mention that part of the Isaac Hates, I'm using the Isaac Hates estate
- 1:05:25simply because the lawsuit was just filed last Friday.
- 1:05:28There have been other lawsuits, 2020 Neil Young sued the Trump estate for using a rockin
- 1:05:34in the free world.
- 1:05:35There have been others, but in the Isaac Hates lawsuit, they did also include Elanomac false
- 1:05:41endorsement claim claiming that the use of this song, I'm not liking the song named
- 1:05:47the Sam and Dave song.
- 1:05:49Well, hold on.
- 1:05:50Hold on.
- 1:05:51Thank you.
- 1:05:52The use of the song as I think it's an out as the outro is creating an association in
- 1:05:58the minds of consumers that there is some affiliation, sponsorship or endorsement by
- 1:06:03the Isaac Hates estate of the Trump campaign.
- 1:06:05That is part of the claim.
- 1:06:07They also included a state right of publicity claim claiming that they're using by using
- 1:06:12the voice of, sorry, not the voice because he's not singing on it, but by using the compositions
- 1:06:20that are so closely associated with Isaac Hates that they are invoking Isaac Hates likeness
- 1:06:27and they're violating his right of publicity.
- 1:06:29I'm not sure if it's Sam and Dave.
- 1:06:31Maybe somebody can correct me out there, but it was Isaac Hates in the case of that song
- 1:06:36wrote was co-writer with someone else.
- 1:06:39Yeah.
- 1:06:40Yeah.
- 1:06:41Preston, David Preston or something.
- 1:06:42It's like it was.
- 1:06:43And Isaac Hates sold or his estate sold to primary wave that.
- 1:06:48David Porter.
- 1:06:49David Porter.
- 1:06:50Okay.
- 1:06:51Sold the rights to primary wave, but and primary wave didn't for the same reasons that I guess,
- 1:06:56as I mentioned before, it didn't want to get into this because it's a political issue
- 1:07:00and right now we have a 50-50 situation.
- 1:07:05You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:07:08Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.