Latest / Kentucky Tonight / SNAP and Other Government Food Assistance Programs
Transcript
- 0:12Good evening. Welcome to
- 0:14Kentucky. Tonight, I'm Renee
- 0:16Shaw, and we thank you so much
- 0:17for joining us. Our topic
- 0:19tonight, the status of SNAP and
- 0:21other government food
- 0:22assistance programs. Nearly
- 0:24600,000 Kentuckians rely on the
- 0:26Supplemental Nutrition
- 0:27Assistance Program. Snap, often
- 0:29called food stamps, to buy
- 0:31groceries. Those benefits are
- 0:32jeopardized by the federal
- 0:34government shutdown. The Trump
- 0:36administration said earlier
- 0:37today that it would partially
- 0:39fund Snap for November, after
- 0:40two judges issued rulings
- 0:42requiring the government to
- 0:44keep the nation's largest food
- 0:45aid program running. Tonight,
- 0:47we have several perspectives on
- 0:49this issue of Snap and other
- 0:51federal food assistance
- 0:52programs, and how Kentuckians
- 0:54are affected by these recent
- 0:55developments. We have four
- 0:57guests in our Lexington studio
- 0:58this evening and Tyler Morgan,
- 1:00a Lexington health care and
- 1:02regulatory attorney and member
- 1:04of McBrayer PLLC state
- 1:06Representative Adam Moore, a
- 1:07Lexington Democrat and member
- 1:09of the Kentucky General
- 1:10Assembly's Make America Healthy
- 1:12Again Kentucky Task Force.
- 1:14Heather LeMire, state director
- 1:16of Americans for prosperity,
- 1:18Kentucky and Dustin Pugel
- 1:20policy director for the
- 1:22Kentucky Center for Economic
- 1:24Policy. And we're joined in our
- 1:26Louisville studio by state
- 1:28Rachel Roarx, a Louisville
- 1:29Democrat and member of the
- 1:30House Families and Children
- 1:31Committee in the Kentucky
- 1:32General Assembly and Doctor
- 1:34Eric Schansberg professor of
- 1:35economics at Indiana University
- 1:37Southeast in New Albany, and
- 1:39author of Poor Policy How
- 1:41Government Harms the Poor. We
- 1:43certainly want to hear from you
- 1:44tonight, and you can send your
- 1:46questions and comments by X,
- 1:48formerly Twitter at Pub Affairs
- 1:49KET. Send an email to KY
- 1:52Tonight at ket.org ket.org or
- 1:54use the web form at ket.org
- 1:58tonight. Or you can simply give
- 2:00us a call at one 800 494 70 605.
- 2:05Before we hear from our panel,
- 2:07this explainer on the Snap
- 2:08program and the Kentuckians who
- 2:09benefit from KET June Leffler.
- 2:12>> First imagined under
- 2:14Franklin D Roosevelt's New Deal
- 2:16and later made into law by
- 2:18Congress and Lyndon B Johnson
- 2:20in 1964. The entitlement
- 2:23program, known as food stamps,
- 2:25has been around for decades.
- 2:27The program is meant to help
- 2:29farmers, grocery stores, and,
- 2:30of course, Americans facing
- 2:32hunger. Today's Snap recipients
- 2:36make up nearly 13% of
- 2:37Kentuckians, more than a third
- 2:39of whom are children. The
- 2:41average household received $344
- 2:45in Snap last month. Last year,
- 2:48Kentuckians received on average,
- 2:51$6.20 per day in Snap benefits,
- 2:54totaling more than $1 billion
- 2:57in 2024. While these recipients
- 2:59live everywhere. Many are
- 3:01concentrated in eastern
- 3:02Kentucky. According to a march
- 3:05analysis, McCreary County had
- 3:06the highest rate of Snap
- 3:09participation, while Oldham
- 3:10County had the lowest rate.
- 3:12These recipients use EBT cards,
- 3:15which the state loads money on
- 3:17to once a month. These cards
- 3:19can be used at participating
- 3:21retailers like grocery stores
- 3:23and even some corner stores,
- 3:25online shops and farmers
- 3:27markets. So who qualifies for
- 3:29snap? A single person making
- 3:32$20,000 a year likely qualifies.
- 3:35So would a couple with two kids
- 3:37making just above $41,000 a
- 3:40year. Snap also looks at a
- 3:43household's net income. That's
- 3:44the money left after paying
- 3:46essential bills like rent,
- 3:49utilities and child care costs.
- 3:51Households must meet both gross
- 3:53and net income limits, not just
- 3:55one or the other. There are
- 3:58other stipulations for Snap
- 4:00recipients. They must be
- 4:01citizens or certain legal
- 4:03permanent residents. Able
- 4:04bodied adults without
- 4:06dependents must work 20 hours a
- 4:08week for long term benefits,
- 4:10though those without work can
- 4:12still receive temporary
- 4:15assistance. Recipients can only
- 4:16have so much money in cash and
- 4:18savings. Very low income
- 4:21Kentuckians can be fast tracked
- 4:22for benefits if they make less
- 4:24than $150 a month, if their
- 4:27income does not cover their
- 4:29monthly bills, or if they are,
- 4:32quote, destitute migrants or
- 4:33seasonal farm workers. Though
- 4:35Snap is a federal program, it
- 4:37is administered by the state.
- 4:39You can apply online or at one
- 4:42of the State Department for
- 4:43Community Based Services
- 4:45offices, like this one in
- 4:47Louisville. All successful
- 4:49applicants will eventually wind
- 4:50up at one of these offices for
- 4:53a required in-person interview
- 4:56for Kentucky tonight. I'm June
- 4:57Leffler.
- 4:59>> Well, we certainly thank
- 5:00June Leffler for that awesome
- 5:02explanatory piece to help us
- 5:03all understand what we're
- 5:04talking about tonight. And so I
- 5:06do want to just get a lay of
- 5:08the land where we are now. And
- 5:10what was not mentioned is that
- 5:12on Friday, Governor Beshear
- 5:13signed an executive order
- 5:14declaring a state of emergency,
- 5:15and Tyler saying a loss of SNAP
- 5:17is a threat to public health
- 5:19and safety. And he ordered $5
- 5:21million from the state's budget
- 5:22Reserve Trust fund, or rainy
- 5:23day fund, as it sometimes
- 5:25called, to go to Kentucky food
- 5:27banks. Now, he even cites in
- 5:29the order 30 nine. A 100
- 5:32permits the governor to declare
- 5:33the state of emergency when it
- 5:35exists in the occurrence of a
- 5:37threatened or impending
- 5:38occurrence of public and safety.
- 5:41So many would say this is
- 5:43unprecedented. To use an
- 5:44executive order in this way.
- 5:45How do you see it? And is the
- 5:47need there for this to actually
- 5:49satisfy that? Well.
- 5:50>> That's right, Renee. You
- 5:51know, programs like Snap are
- 5:53programs that a lot of us take
- 5:54for granted. As has been
- 5:56explained, these are programs
- 5:57that have been around quite a
- 5:58long time and support so many
- 6:00Kentuckians that we tend to
- 6:01think they'll always be there.
- 6:03And so it is somewhat
- 6:05unprecedented that the federal
- 6:06government is at such a
- 6:08stalemate that these programs
- 6:09are really at risk. And it's
- 6:10the first time that an
- 6:13administration has taken the
- 6:14position that these programs
- 6:16must be discontinued during
- 6:17this type of government
- 6:18shutdown. So we really are in a
- 6:21state of emergency, as the
- 6:22governor has explained, for the
- 6:24sake of Kentuckians health. And
- 6:26I believe that he did the right
- 6:27thing by making sure that there
- 6:29were funds there to at least
- 6:30continue those funds during
- 6:32this critical time.
- 6:33>> So I want to go to
- 6:35Representative Rachel Roarx in
- 6:36Louisville and ask you the same.
- 6:38Do you believe this was the
- 6:39right move at the right time?
- 6:41And because I think from what I
- 6:43understand from the cabinet's
- 6:44website and looking at the
- 6:45numbers of households in
- 6:46Louisville, there are like
- 6:4848,000 households that rely on
- 6:50Snap or food stamps there in
- 6:52Jefferson County where you are.
- 6:54How important is it that the
- 6:55governor made this action at
- 6:56this time?
- 6:58>> Well, I'll just first of all,
- 6:59say that it was absolutely
- 7:01crucial that he do so right now
- 7:02with the legislature not in
- 7:04session, we have to have
- 7:06governor, Governor Beshear
- 7:07acting to fill these gaps with
- 7:09these programs. Again, this is
- 7:11unprecedented. It's historic in
- 7:12the worst way possible. And
- 7:14when we have folks that are at
- 7:16risk of going hungry in our
- 7:18community, we as government
- 7:19officials have to step up and
- 7:21fill the role to make sure that
- 7:23no family, no child, no senior,
- 7:25no farmer is going without food
- 7:26access. And so honestly, with
- 7:29the $5 million going to feeding
- 7:31Kentucky, feeding Kentucky is
- 7:33such a trusted organization.
- 7:34They have the relationships
- 7:35with our food banks. But let me
- 7:37be clear that while it's going
- 7:38to go to food banks, which
- 7:41we're seeing historic instances
- 7:42where our food banks have empty
- 7:44shelves, SNAP is such an
- 7:47efficient program where we
- 7:48don't have to have this crisis
- 7:50moment. And so it's so vital
- 7:52that we bring snap back that we
- 7:54get it back to where our
- 7:56families have access to that
- 7:57program, because at the end of
- 7:59the day, our food banks are
- 8:01there for that emergency moment
- 8:02where you're not going to be
- 8:04able to make ends meet with
- 8:05your family and they fill the
- 8:07gaps. But it is so crucial that
- 8:09our community is stepping up
- 8:10that the governor has stepped
- 8:12up to declare the state of
- 8:13emergency and provide these
- 8:14funds.
- 8:14>> We know that before the
- 8:16governor made this action,
- 8:17there were some who were
- 8:18calling on the governor to call
- 8:20a special session to deal with
- 8:21this matter. And this gentleman
- 8:22from Radcliff, Kentucky, Pete
- 8:24Countryman, says, quote, with a
- 8:26state surplus of over $1
- 8:27billion in the rainy day fund,
- 8:29can't the governor call a
- 8:30special session of the
- 8:31legislature to fund $104
- 8:33million to fund Snap statewide
- 8:35for November? Is that something
- 8:37the governor should consider
- 8:38doing? Representative Adam
- 8:39Moore.
- 8:39>> I do think that the governor
- 8:41needed to take bold action,
- 8:42Renee, and he's done that by
- 8:44joining on to a lawsuit from
- 8:45Democratic governors and
- 8:46attorneys general from, I think,
- 8:4825 other states. And we saw
- 8:49that that resulted in two
- 8:51different judges striking down
- 8:52what has happened and saying,
- 8:53no, the federal government,
- 8:55USDA, you do have to provide
- 8:56these funds. It is obligated
- 8:57and it is there in a
- 8:59contingency fund. I believe
- 9:00there's $5 billion in that
- 9:01contingency fund to go towards
- 9:03SNAP as far as needing to call
- 9:05the legislature into session
- 9:06for that. Again, I think the
- 9:07first thing was getting that
- 9:08official court order done. He's
- 9:10made that $5 million available
- 9:11to our food banks. But now we
- 9:13have to see what the
- 9:15administration in Washington,
- 9:15D.C. is going to do and make
- 9:17sure we're not playing politics
- 9:18with people's tables. You know,
- 9:20Thanksgiving is coming up
- 9:21around the corner. We ought to
- 9:23be thankful for having plenty.
- 9:24And right now we're looking
- 9:25kind of down the barrel of
- 9:27potentially a lot of people
- 9:28going hungry than they need to
- 9:29be going right now due to this
- 9:31fight.
- 9:31>> And we do know that the
- 9:34General Assembly did put caps
- 9:35on how much the governor can
- 9:36expend during a declared
- 9:37emergency. So he started at 5
- 9:39million. He can go up to what,
- 9:4050 or 100 million Dustin Pugel.
- 9:42>> I'm not sure what the cap is,
- 9:44but, you know, I think it's
- 9:46important to point out that we
- 9:47spend about $100 million a
- 9:49month on SNAP here in Kentucky.
- 9:51$5 million is important. I
- 9:53think the courts requiring the
- 9:55Trump administration to pay
- 9:57partial benefits is really
- 9:58important. But in our budget
- 10:00reserve trust fund, we have
- 10:01essentially 37 months worth of
- 10:03Snap benefits. You know, it's
- 10:06possible that with some help to
- 10:08food banks and these partial
- 10:09benefits, we may be able to get
- 10:11through November without too
- 10:12much disruption in everyday
- 10:13people's lives. But if we go
- 10:15much past that, I think there's
- 10:17a strong case to be made that
- 10:19we should use some of those
- 10:20rainy day funds for this very
- 10:22rainy day we're facing right
- 10:24now, at least to get us into
- 10:26when the General Assembly comes
- 10:27in for a regular session, when
- 10:29they can take whatever action
- 10:30they need to at that point.
- 10:32>> And we do know that it is a
- 10:34budget making session, and that
- 10:35usually comes later in the 60
- 10:37day session, not at the
- 10:38beginning. So that would be a
- 10:40very interesting to see how
- 10:41they handle that. I want to go
- 10:43to Doctor Schansberg, who is
- 10:44joining us in the Louisville
- 10:45studio, to get your perspective
- 10:46on this. Do you think the
- 10:48governor made the right move at
- 10:49the right time? And what is
- 10:51your perspective about the
- 10:52federal government shutdown and
- 10:53how Snap beneficiaries are kind
- 10:54of caught in the crossfire?
- 10:56>> I'm not sure about state
- 10:57policy so much in this issue.
- 10:59It's probably quite reasonable.
- 11:00We're really talking bigger
- 11:01picture about the role of
- 11:02government. And if the
- 11:03government is going to be
- 11:04involved in these kind of
- 11:06things, why is it the federal
- 11:07government? That's really a
- 11:08bigger question. Why is this
- 11:09not something that state and
- 11:11local governments handle along
- 11:12with nonprofits? Federal
- 11:14government has got its own
- 11:15problems and it's already
- 11:16sending the money here. Why
- 11:17don't we divorce the federal
- 11:18government from that and let
- 11:20state and locals handle that?
- 11:21And we don't have these
- 11:22problems going forward.
- 11:24>> So that's very interesting
- 11:25perspective. You say the state
- 11:27should just handle this money
- 11:28altogether, get the federal
- 11:29government out of it entirely.
- 11:31>> Yeah. What's the
- 11:33philosophical, ethical,
- 11:34practical reason of the federal
- 11:35government providing it? I mean,
- 11:37it's an artifact of what we did
- 11:3960 years ago and the origins of
- 11:41the federal efforts here are to
- 11:42keep USDA bureaucrats with jobs.
- 11:45That was the main reason we did
- 11:47this federal back in the day.
- 11:48But what's the reason today to
- 11:50have it a federal program?
- 11:52Maybe you do block grants and
- 11:53send us the money and let us
- 11:55run it. But we I think the
- 11:57ideal thing would be for each
- 11:58state to run 50 different
- 12:00Democratic experiments, to see
- 12:01how best to handle poverty, and
- 12:03having the federal government
- 12:04just sending money to states
- 12:06risks the sort of problems
- 12:08we're seeing today.
- 12:10>> Interesting idea. How do you
- 12:11feel about it, Miss Lohmeyer?
- 12:13>> I mean, I think the bottom
- 12:15line here is this is a disaster
- 12:18that is created by Congress.
- 12:20And really what needs to happen
- 12:23is this clean CR needs to be
- 12:25voted on in the Senate, and we
- 12:27need to reopen the government.
- 12:29We can we can have all of the
- 12:31more difficult discussions on
- 12:33budget reconciliation and all
- 12:34of those things once the
- 12:36government reopens. But I mean,
- 12:38the bottom line, and we're
- 12:39hearing this from Kentuckians
- 12:41all across the state, is
- 12:43they're tired of this political
- 12:44game of Republicans versus
- 12:46Democrats. And and, you know,
- 12:49any legislator using this as
- 12:51leverage. So they're ready for
- 12:54the government to be reopened.
- 12:56And for, you know, politicians
- 12:58to stop playing with people's
- 13:00lives in this way.
- 13:01>> Who are they blaming? Are
- 13:02they blaming a particular party?
- 13:04>> I really think with the
- 13:05latest polling, we're seeing
- 13:07almost equal blame across
- 13:08Republicans and Democrats. I
- 13:10mean, obviously right now
- 13:11Democrats are really the key
- 13:13voters on this CR. We need the
- 13:16Democrats to vote yes on a
- 13:17clean CR in the Senate. And 12
- 13:20times they voted no. And, you
- 13:23know, are saying that this is
- 13:25leverage for them. And so
- 13:26that's super disappointing to
- 13:28hear. And while people are
- 13:29suffering.
- 13:30>> And of course, we know that
- 13:31those health care subsidies,
- 13:32what Democrats are saying that
- 13:34they're holding out for,
- 13:35expected to really increase in
- 13:36premiums to a significant
- 13:37amount. Representative Adam
- 13:39Moore that's why they're
- 13:40holding out. They say.
- 13:41>> You're right and this and
- 13:42you cannot divorce one issue
- 13:43from the other, because if
- 13:45people do not have enough money
- 13:47to afford groceries, they're
- 13:48not going to have enough money
- 13:49to afford health care,
- 13:50especially when these premiums
- 13:51that we're seeing are exploding
- 13:522 or 3 times what a family may
- 13:54already be paying. And these
- 13:56are not rich families. We're
- 13:57seeing this impact. Middle
- 13:58class Kentuckians, working
- 13:59class Kentuckians. And so we
- 14:01can't just say, all right, well,
- 14:03we can deal with this and then
- 14:05we'll deal with that. This is a
- 14:07cost of living crisis that
- 14:08we're into, and we've got to
- 14:09have to be able to address
- 14:11these both head on.
- 14:12>> Yeah. I do want to come back
- 14:14to you. You're not trying to
- 14:15discredit the foundations of
- 14:16Snap or Supplemental Nutrition
- 14:17Assistance Program. You believe
- 14:18that that program has a place.
- 14:20Do you agree with Eric
- 14:21Schansberg that perhaps it
- 14:22should be just all in the
- 14:24state's control and not, and
- 14:25get the federal bureaucrats out
- 14:27of it? Do you agree with that
- 14:28perspective?
- 14:29>> I honestly don't know if
- 14:30that's the right solution or
- 14:32not, but I mean, I just I
- 14:33strongly believe that the
- 14:34government just needs to reopen
- 14:36so that we can stop the bleed
- 14:38that's happening right now. I
- 14:40mean, it's affecting people in
- 14:41the military. It's affecting
- 14:43federal government workers,
- 14:44it's affecting the airline
- 14:46industry. This is a very costly
- 14:49shutdown to lots of families.
- 14:51And people are suffering,
- 14:53especially right before the
- 14:54holidays.
- 14:55>> Yeah. Mr. Pugel.
- 14:57>> Yeah, I mean, I think it's
- 14:59important to remember that
- 15:00we've known that the expiration
- 15:01of these health care subsidies
- 15:03has been coming for three years
- 15:04now, four years now. And so
- 15:06it's really important to
- 15:08recognize what that means in
- 15:09everyday people's lives. I mean,
- 15:11I think the the tragedy of SNAP
- 15:13is, is really important. And I
- 15:15think it highlights the very
- 15:16important role that government
- 15:18plays. But, you know, a month
- 15:20ago, the state sent out 75,000
- 15:22letters to people who get their
- 15:23coverage on connect. And out of
- 15:25those, about 60% of notices saw
- 15:28increases of $100 or more. Most
- 15:30of those folks saw their their
- 15:33rates doubling 10,000. Of those
- 15:37saw rate increases of 500 or
- 15:39more per month, and hundreds
- 15:40saw increases of of $1,000 or
- 15:43more, you know, like
- 15:46Representative Moore said, you
- 15:47know, these folks are largely
- 15:50people who are owning their own
- 15:52business. They're farmers.
- 15:54They're folks who work in low
- 15:56wage jobs. In fact, the church
- 15:57administrator at my church gets
- 15:59her coverage on Kinect. I wish
- 16:01we could provide her with
- 16:02health insurance. But, you know,
- 16:03our church just isn't big
- 16:05enough to do that. And so she
- 16:07receives subsidies there. And I
- 16:08was talking to her today, and
- 16:10they're going to have to pay
- 16:11$100 more per month for a worse
- 16:13plan where their deductible is
- 16:15going to go up $3,000, they're
- 16:17out of pocket. Max is going to
- 16:18go up $4,000. So, you know, I
- 16:20think Congress knew that the
- 16:222017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
- 16:24expiration was coming for some
- 16:26time, and they made that a
- 16:28priority. I don't see why they
- 16:31can't make these tax credits a
- 16:32priority now. And that's really
- 16:33what they are. They're advanced
- 16:35premium tax credits designed to
- 16:36help people afford their health
- 16:37insurance.
- 16:39>> You were going to say
- 16:40anything there, Representative
- 16:41Moore?
- 16:41>> No. I agree a lot with what
- 16:43Dustin has to say, and I'm glad
- 16:45he's bringing a lot of
- 16:47information to this debate.
- 16:47>> Yeah. So this comment from
- 16:49Jefferson County, at what point
- 16:50is this spending enough 41
- 16:52million Americans on Snap? At
- 16:53some point, we have to stop
- 16:55with continuing resolutions and
- 16:56cut spending. How can we do
- 16:58that when people kick and
- 16:59scream because their handouts
- 17:00are being taken away? You want
- 17:02to respond to that on Tyler?
- 17:03>> Sure. Happy to. Renee, I
- 17:05would disagree that most
- 17:06Americans feel that way. We
- 17:08have a 2025 poll from April
- 17:11that shows that about 64% of
- 17:13Americans are in favor of Snap
- 17:15benefits, and that's fairly
- 17:17consistent among all polling.
- 17:18This has been a hugely popular
- 17:20program, so I certainly
- 17:22understand that many people
- 17:23want to argue with various
- 17:25levels of spending in the
- 17:26federal government, and there
- 17:27are spending cuts that probably
- 17:29need to be made in the federal
- 17:30government. I don't think that
- 17:32most people believe that that
- 17:33should come from people's
- 17:34eligibility for Snap benefits.
- 17:36This is really food for
- 17:38families who are making very
- 17:40little per month. If you look
- 17:42at the eligibility for Snap
- 17:45benefits, we're looking at
- 17:47folks who have no more than
- 17:49$2,750 a month in cash or
- 17:52assets. If you look at your own
- 17:54bank accounts, I would beg you
- 17:56to think from from your heart
- 17:58about whether folks should get
- 18:00a little extra food assistance
- 18:01if they have that on hand. And
- 18:05so most Americans support Snap.
- 18:07It's a bipartisan effort these
- 18:10days, and I think most
- 18:12Americans would want this to be
- 18:14something that stays intact.
- 18:16>> I do want to come to you
- 18:18because you kind of wrote the
- 18:20book about poor policy and how
- 18:21government can make people poor,
- 18:23and I want to give you a chance
- 18:25to kind of answer this, this
- 18:27viewer who wonders when is
- 18:29enough, enough and that
- 18:31handouts should be taken away.
- 18:32Do you agree with that?
- 18:34>> Well, let me back up a half
- 18:36a step. So to be clear, the
- 18:38title of the book is about how
- 18:39interest groups often use
- 18:40government to help themselves
- 18:41at the expense of the poor.
- 18:43Tonight we're talking about a
- 18:44far more complicated issue,
- 18:45which is where government is
- 18:46trying to help the poor. And
- 18:48that's a that's a very
- 18:49difficult thing to do.
- 18:50Economists call it the welfare
- 18:51dilemma. When we help, we also
- 18:53harm because we're subsidizing
- 18:54the very state we don't want
- 18:55them to be in. And so it's
- 18:57always complicated to to and
- 18:58maybe we'll talk more about
- 19:00that later. But to the
- 19:01listener's question, I think
- 19:02it's worth noting that food
- 19:04stamps is really a fairly small
- 19:05program. And so yes, I am
- 19:07worried about the debt and
- 19:09spending and all that as well.
- 19:10We're not on a trajectory that
- 19:12works in terms of the debt, but
- 19:14it's a small piece of the
- 19:15puzzle, very small piece of the
- 19:17puzzle. It's the bigger, you
- 19:18know, things like Medicare,
- 19:19Social Security, interest on
- 19:21the debt. Those are the things
- 19:23that are the real markers in
- 19:24that debate, not food stamps.
- 19:26>> Well, we do know that on Fox
- 19:28News Friday, the U.S.
- 19:29Agriculture Secretary, Brooke
- 19:31Collins, called SNAP, quote, a
- 19:33broken and corrupt program,
- 19:35saying that they found 5000
- 19:37dead people still getting
- 19:38benefits. And she said, quote,
- 19:40it's time to drastically reform
- 19:41this program to make sure those
- 19:43who are truly needy, truly
- 19:44vulnerable are getting what
- 19:45they need. Do you agree with
- 19:47that, Miss Lohmeyer?
- 19:49>> I mean, of course there's
- 19:50always going to be abuse and,
- 19:52you know, any, any sort of
- 19:54system assistance program. But
- 19:56I believe that this program
- 19:59helps the most vulnerable
- 20:00people in our society. And I
- 20:02think that clearly, right now,
- 20:05Americans are struggling.
- 20:07Housing is more expensive,
- 20:09groceries are more expensive.
- 20:11What we were able to make it on
- 20:13maybe several years ago, people
- 20:15are struggling to make it on
- 20:17that same salary today. So I
- 20:20think this is something that is
- 20:22much needed for the most
- 20:23vulnerable of our of our state.
- 20:25>> What are some of the popular
- 20:28misconceptions, Dustin, that
- 20:29that you think people have
- 20:30about SNAP? I mean, one of the
- 20:32things that June Leffler
- 20:33pointed out in that explanatory
- 20:35piece is about that
- 20:35undocumented are not receiving
- 20:37benefits, but yet we often hear
- 20:39that illegal aliens, the term
- 20:40that's often used, they do
- 20:42receive benefits. That's true
- 20:43or false.
- 20:45>> Definitely false. So
- 20:46undocumented immigrants don't
- 20:48receive Snap benefits. They
- 20:49don't receive Medicaid. In fact,
- 20:51there's almost no public
- 20:53assistance program that an
- 20:54undocumented immigrant can
- 20:56qualify for. As a matter of
- 20:58fact, there are very few
- 20:59programs and even fewer now
- 21:00that many legally residing
- 21:03immigrants can qualify for. You
- 21:05know, the other, I think common
- 21:07misconception is that adults
- 21:09who participate in the Snap
- 21:11program are not working. You
- 21:13know, you hear this a lot when
- 21:15there's debate around, you know,
- 21:17who should a work reporting
- 21:18requirement applied to, you
- 21:20know, who is using these
- 21:22programs? The fact of the
- 21:23matter is, you know, there are
- 21:25about 190,000 workers in Snap
- 21:27participating households.
- 21:28There's a 1 in 4 chance that
- 21:30the cashier who is helping you
- 21:32purchase your groceries, or the
- 21:33cook who is making your food at
- 21:35a restaurant, is using snap to
- 21:38feed their own families while
- 21:39they're helping feed yours. So,
- 21:42you know, I think it's really
- 21:43important to recognize the role
- 21:45that snap plays among working
- 21:47Kentuckians. The remainder are
- 21:48are folks who are disabled.
- 21:50They're seniors who need help
- 21:51with their groceries or their
- 21:53children in those households.
- 21:54So, you know, Snap really is an
- 21:57important program that supports
- 21:58working Kentuckians. And I
- 21:59think the other thing to
- 22:00recognize is that Snap, besides
- 22:02being the most powerful
- 22:03anti-hunger tool we have, it's
- 22:05a pretty powerful economic tool.
- 22:06So we spent about $1.1 billion
- 22:10through of federal dollars in
- 22:12Kentucky at 4700 retailers
- 22:14across the state. That money is
- 22:17generated right in their
- 22:19broader economy. So, you know,
- 22:21grocery store workers and truck
- 22:23drivers and farmers then use
- 22:25those dollars to pay their own
- 22:26bills. And so it really ends up
- 22:28being an important economic
- 22:29engine, particularly during
- 22:31downturns. So I think it's
- 22:33really important to recognize
- 22:34the value that snap plays in
- 22:36our society, not just for the
- 22:39folks who use it, but for all
- 22:40of us who then benefit from
- 22:42that greater economic activity.
- 22:44>> And Tyler Morgan A few years
- 22:45ago, there was a public
- 22:47assistance reform task force
- 22:48and a working group. I believe
- 22:49you were a part of that. And
- 22:51there were lots of discussions
- 22:52about how do you get the able
- 22:54bodied to contribute to society
- 22:55through productive work. And we
- 22:57know that the big beautiful
- 22:58Bill addressed that. And we'll
- 22:59talk a little bit more about
- 23:01that when we when we hear about
- 23:03fraud and abuse. Help us
- 23:04understand who's doing that. Is
- 23:06it the people who are receiving
- 23:07the benefits or who is it?
- 23:09>> Absolutely, Renee. Well, you
- 23:10know, there are obviously a lot
- 23:12of compliance tools in place at
- 23:14every level of the government.
- 23:15So, you know, we've talked a
- 23:17little bit about the federal
- 23:19government's role in
- 23:20administering Snap benefits.
- 23:21And obviously, one of the
- 23:22biggest roles that the federal
- 23:24government plays is oversight
- 23:25of program compliance. And
- 23:26that's played in large part by
- 23:28the USDA and FNS. And, you know,
- 23:31the reason that I bring that up
- 23:33is because there are a lot of
- 23:35studies done by both the
- 23:37agencies involved and by groups
- 23:38that are looking at benefits
- 23:40regularly on both sides of the
- 23:41political aisle. And they would
- 23:43all tell you that Snap is one
- 23:45of the most compliant programs
- 23:48of the welfare programs
- 23:50available under that heading,
- 23:53because of the way that they're
- 23:56built. So the benefits are
- 23:57built to be quite restrictive
- 24:01in how they can be used. It is
- 24:03a food benefit program. They
- 24:04can only be used on certain
- 24:06types of goods. They have to be
- 24:08used at certain retailers who
- 24:10accept an EBT card that is
- 24:11populated exactly for that
- 24:13purpose. And so the program
- 24:15itself, rather than programs
- 24:17that are built a little
- 24:19differently and with fewer
- 24:20restrictions, is really quite a
- 24:23well-structured program. It's
- 24:24why it's been so highly
- 24:26approved of, again, on both
- 24:28sides of the aisle, because it
- 24:30does suffer less fraud and
- 24:33abuse than most programs. Now,
- 24:35again, any program that
- 24:37involves government money
- 24:39probably deserves regular look,
- 24:41but I believe it's getting that
- 24:43from the federal government and
- 24:45the state government
- 24:46involvement.
- 24:46>> The caller Deb, siege and
- 24:49Louisville hope I'm pronouncing
- 24:50your last name correct. Miss
- 24:51Deb wants to know what people
- 24:53can do to help those in need.
- 24:54And we're going to cue a story
- 24:56from KET Laura Rogers, who is
- 24:58in Bowling Green and who's been
- 25:00talking to those who are the
- 25:01helpers. Rotate.
- 25:02>> We give a box of crackers.
- 25:04We give a box of instant
- 25:07oatmeal, different packets.
- 25:08>> Doug Watson volunteers three
- 25:10days a week at the Hillview
- 25:12Heights Church Food Pantry.
- 25:13>> The only risk of running out
- 25:15is if we underestimate how much
- 25:16to order week to week, which we
- 25:18did this week.
- 25:19>> They had to make an
- 25:20emergency run to restock as the
- 25:22church gave out well over 100
- 25:23food boxes the last week of
- 25:25October, close to double an
- 25:27ordinary week.
- 25:27>> It's just like a mad rush to
- 25:29get here and get some food.
- 25:31>> A lot of people calling in
- 25:33with concerns about losing
- 25:34their Snap benefits.
- 25:35>> United Way of Southern
- 25:37Kentucky's 211 connects callers
- 25:38to agencies and resources to
- 25:40help with food, housing, rent
- 25:42and utility bills and numerous
- 25:45other needs and concerns.
- 25:46>> Since the first full week of
- 25:49October, we noticed an uptick
- 25:50in our calls.
- 25:52>> Predominantly about food
- 25:54insecurity.
- 25:54>> One thing with 211 is that
- 25:56we're not even just sharing
- 25:57where to go, but we're already
- 25:59screening them and giving them
- 26:00the list of the ones that
- 26:02specifically can help them.
- 26:04>> For many of those callers,
- 26:05that's House on the Hill.
- 26:07>> We have basically doubled in
- 26:09the last month.
- 26:10>> Executive Director Joel
- 26:11Hawkins says they prepare 350
- 26:13food boxes a month, helping
- 26:15more than 600 families through
- 26:17their food programs, free
- 26:19grocery pickup and delivery.
- 26:21>> We've had a lot of people
- 26:22coming who are out of their
- 26:24food stamps. They know they're
- 26:25not going to be getting, or
- 26:27they believe they're not going
- 26:28to be getting, as we all
- 26:29believe, they're not going to
- 26:31be getting food stamps in the
- 26:32next month.
- 26:33>> Friday morning, there was a
- 26:34virtual meeting among area food
- 26:36pantries and nonprofits, along
- 26:37with family resource and youth
- 26:38services centers in the school
- 26:40systems to discuss challenges
- 26:42and solutions.
- 26:43>> Some of the smaller pantries,
- 26:45feeling like they're not going
- 26:46to be able to sustain the need
- 26:48of the community, you know,
- 26:50they're smaller, they don't
- 26:51have a lot of food anyway.
- 26:53>> We're all working together
- 26:54to try to figure out how do we
- 26:57all maintain one, the clients
- 26:58that were already serving and
- 27:00then the influx that we might
- 27:02see.
- 27:02>> Hawkins says. House on the
- 27:04Hill is preparing for that
- 27:06influx. By purchasing more food.
- 27:07>> We plan ahead. We always
- 27:09have extra food on hand. It's
- 27:11just part of our model.
- 27:12>> Especially as they plan to
- 27:14make 1000 Thanksgiving boxes
- 27:16for area families in need.
- 27:18>> We have ordered stocked a
- 27:20little bit of extra food
- 27:22knowing what was going to
- 27:23happen.
- 27:24>> He says. There are
- 27:25misconceptions about many
- 27:25people who rely on government
- 27:27assistance.
- 27:27>> People that are on Snap
- 27:29benefits are not people who are
- 27:32not working. They're not people
- 27:33who are just sitting around
- 27:35their house waiting for
- 27:36somebody to give them food and
- 27:37do everything for them.
- 27:38>> Hawkins says. Many of those
- 27:40they help are employed, but
- 27:41their wages are low and Snap
- 27:43benefits make up a fifth to a
- 27:45quarter of their household
- 27:46expenses.
- 27:46>> Without those Snap benefits,
- 27:48they're going to have to make
- 27:49up for, you know, between 5 and
- 27:52$600 in their in their monthly
- 27:53budget.
- 27:54>> And that's difficult for
- 27:55those who may live paycheck to
- 27:57paycheck.
- 27:58>> We need the government to
- 27:59open back up. People need their
- 28:00Snap benefits.
- 28:01>> And then a can of soup.
- 28:03>> But there are people
- 28:04stepping up and helping out.
- 28:06Until that happens.
- 28:07>> Our community is really
- 28:08coming together so that people
- 28:10don't go hungry.
- 28:11>> For KET chicken. I'm Laura
- 28:13Rogers.
- 28:14>> Thank you so much, Laura. So
- 28:16that's an example of how you
- 28:17can help. And you can contact
- 28:19your local food pantries to
- 28:20help you see where you can fit
- 28:22in. So if you're just joining
- 28:24us tonight, we are talking
- 28:25about Snap, the Supplemental
- 28:26Nutrition Assistance Program,
- 28:27otherwise known as food stamps.
- 28:29And we do encourage your
- 28:30comments and your feedback
- 28:31tonight. You can call us at one
- 28:34800 494 7605. And somebody
- 28:37standing by to take your call.
- 28:39You can email us at KY Tonight
- 28:41at ket.org. And you can also
- 28:43look us up on X, formerly known
- 28:45as Twitter at Public Affairs
- 28:49KET. Either way, just give us a
- 28:51call and we'll make sure we get
- 28:53your question in tonight. So
- 28:54when you hear about the ways
- 28:55and we've we've been reporting
- 28:57all throughout on Kentucky
- 28:58Edition for the last week or so,
- 28:59each night we've we've
- 29:00highlighted a food pantry
- 29:02program or people who are
- 29:03really trying to help during
- 29:04this time. Perhaps
- 29:05Representative Moore. That's
- 29:07one of the bright, shining,
- 29:08bright silver linings. Is that
- 29:10kind of a Fred Rogers motto is
- 29:12look for the helpers and hear
- 29:13where the helpers come in.
- 29:14>> Right in Kentucky we help
- 29:16one another. We absolutely do.
- 29:17And the food banks themselves
- 29:18are stepping up. People who've
- 29:20never donated to a food bank
- 29:21before are stepping up by doing
- 29:23that. And we're seeing that
- 29:24there was great reporting today
- 29:25in the Herald-Leader that had
- 29:27people across the state at
- 29:28different food banks, like we
- 29:29just saw in that feature,
- 29:30saying that they were seeing
- 29:32people that either they had
- 29:33never seen before or they
- 29:34hadn't seen in years, both who
- 29:36needed food, but also who were
- 29:37coming and giving food. And
- 29:38that just shows the compassion
- 29:40and the love we have here for
- 29:41our fellow Kentuckians.
- 29:42>> Yeah. I want to go back to
- 29:44something the doctor Schansberg
- 29:46proposed a little earlier, and
- 29:46that's about moving this whole
- 29:48program to the States. And,
- 29:49Tyler, you've been around for a
- 29:50long time in state government.
- 29:52Would that work?
- 29:52>> I think it would be
- 29:54overwhelming at first. I can at
- 29:55least promise that. And I'd say
- 29:57there are some state government
- 29:58officials who are sweating
- 29:59right now hearing this
- 30:00suggestion just at the just the
- 30:02mere manpower that's required
- 30:04for this type of program. You
- 30:05know, I mentioned the great
- 30:07oversight function that's
- 30:08currently served by the federal
- 30:10government. And of course,
- 30:12theoretically, you can move
- 30:13anything to the state
- 30:14government, but you have to
- 30:16give it the manpower to
- 30:17actually work. The money is
- 30:18coming from the federal
- 30:19government. There's a lot of
- 30:21manpower coming from the
- 30:22federal government to work a
- 30:23program like SNAP. So I would
- 30:25say it would be an uphill
- 30:27battle, but anything is
- 30:28theoretically possible.
- 30:29>> Doctor Schansberg, I want to
- 30:30give you an opportunity to kind
- 30:32of give a more robust defense
- 30:34of your proposal, sir.
- 30:36>> Okay. I just think helping
- 30:38the poor is so complicated. We
- 30:40want to help, but by by nature,
- 30:42we're subsidizing the very
- 30:43state we don't want people to
- 30:45be in. And so it's just a tough
- 30:47thing to do. And you take this
- 30:49dog's breakfast programs. We
- 30:50have we have housing and
- 30:51Medicaid and food stamps and
- 30:52this, that and the other. And
- 30:54it's being administered by
- 30:55different levels of government.
- 30:56And I think just to bring it
- 30:57under the state would be much
- 30:59more effective. It's so hard to
- 31:01handle this problem anyway, DC
- 31:03Chuck and resources in by
- 31:05itself just makes it more
- 31:06complicated. So I understand
- 31:08the transition would be
- 31:09exciting, but we've done that
- 31:11with Medicaid, we've done that
- 31:12with other programs, and I
- 31:13think it'd be nice to have all
- 31:15of those things controlled by
- 31:16the state so that Kentucky can
- 31:18try things that work for
- 31:19Kentucky, and Wyoming can try
- 31:20what's good for them. Oregon
- 31:21can try what's good for them,
- 31:23what's what's good. Poverty
- 31:24policy in Oregon is not the
- 31:26same as Kentucky. And so why
- 31:27are we doing federal policy for
- 31:29something that really requires
- 31:30a state and local touch to it?
- 31:32>> Representative Roarx, I want
- 31:33to get your view on that. You
- 31:35serve on a committee where that
- 31:37idea might actually be vetted a
- 31:38little bit. What do you think?
- 31:40>> Well, there's so many
- 31:41questions. So I think typically
- 31:43I am always more in favor of
- 31:45local control. I think the
- 31:47people that are representing
- 31:49local government, state
- 31:49government, they are closer to
- 31:50the problems. They understand
- 31:51the needs and the solutions
- 31:53better. And but with a program
- 31:55like SNAP, having a federal
- 31:58oversight, having consistency
- 32:00across states is key, because I
- 32:04think what we've seen over the
- 32:05course of the last few years is
- 32:07SNAP has been politicized. And
- 32:09when SNAP gets politicized, we
- 32:10see more work requirements. We
- 32:12see people getting kicked off
- 32:13SNAP that maybe would benefit
- 32:16from it. And ultimately, again,
- 32:17we've talked about the economic
- 32:19drivers, the health benefits.
- 32:20What we really need to be
- 32:22talking about is the things
- 32:23that Representative Moore's
- 32:24task force are dealing with in
- 32:25terms of Make America Healthy
- 32:26again, we have the food in the
- 32:29United States to feed everyone.
- 32:31What we have is a distribution
- 32:33problem, and making sure that
- 32:35we have the financial solutions,
- 32:38the logistical solutions to get
- 32:40the food where it needs to go
- 32:42in a cost effective way is
- 32:44critical. And I think for
- 32:46myself, I have proposed
- 32:48actually a budget request to
- 32:50allocate more money to feeding
- 32:51Kentucky to allow them to
- 32:54expand farms, to food banks, to
- 32:57make sure that we have healthy
- 32:58local food that includes dairy,
- 33:00meat and eggs, all in the
- 33:04pipelines for our food banks to
- 33:05be able to meet these greater,
- 33:07more expensive needs. But also
- 33:09at the same time, we know that
- 33:11people want to have more
- 33:12healthy options. They just
- 33:13can't always afford them or
- 33:15know where to get them. And so
- 33:16I think creating more pipelines
- 33:18to where we can have greater
- 33:19policy solutions around this
- 33:21subject is key, and we need
- 33:22people to that want to think
- 33:24outside the box. But I do think
- 33:26moving this program away from
- 33:27the federal government would be
- 33:28extremely overwhelming. And I
- 33:29would really fear the
- 33:31inconsistencies across states.
- 33:32So we're already seeing that
- 33:33right now with H.R. one that's
- 33:35going to be taking effect. And
- 33:37then also, I think we've just
- 33:39seen attacks on SNAP at the
- 33:40state level in years prior.
- 33:42>> Yeah. Anne-Tyler Morgan, I
- 33:43want to go to you about that
- 33:45idea. What do you think?
- 33:46>> Well, that's an excellent
- 33:47point. And, you know, I think,
- 33:49Renee, that's a great segue
- 33:50into what the Kentucky
- 33:51Department of Agriculture has
- 33:52also done for this effort. You
- 33:54know, we've talked about the
- 33:55governor making sure that money
- 33:56was allocated to cover benefits
- 33:57to feeding Kentucky food banks.
- 33:59And I know that the Kentucky
- 34:00Department of Agriculture has
- 34:02done something similar,
- 34:03partnering with organizations
- 34:04around Kentucky like the
- 34:06Kentucky Association of Health
- 34:07Plans and others to continue
- 34:09the work that's going to
- 34:11feeding Kentucky food banks.
- 34:12You know, I think as we've
- 34:14talked about, it's really
- 34:17important for agriculture to be
- 34:18such a driver. In the
- 34:19conversation about Kentucky
- 34:20hunger and Kentucky health. And
- 34:22everyone is working together in
- 34:25making sure that Kentuckians
- 34:26are fed in this critical time.
- 34:28>> Yeah. And we know the
- 34:29commissioner has called food is
- 34:31medicine. That's exactly right.
- 34:32And to be well fed is
- 34:33differently than just eating
- 34:34good. I mean, or just eating
- 34:36junk, right. There is a
- 34:37difference. So I'm really
- 34:38curious, Representative Moore,
- 34:39about this Make America Healthy
- 34:40Again Task force, the Kentucky
- 34:41Task Force, and how this fits
- 34:43in with the work that you're
- 34:45currently doing on on that task
- 34:46force.
- 34:46>> I really appreciate
- 34:47Representative Rourke bringing
- 34:48that up. She talked about farm
- 34:50to food banks. We had
- 34:51Commissioner Shell and people
- 34:53from his organization
- 34:53testifying to us, work that's
- 34:55being done right now, a lot of
- 34:57it through the Appalachian part
- 34:58of the state in eastern
- 34:59Kentucky, in which they're
- 35:00bringing these kind of farm
- 35:02programs to the local hospitals.
- 35:03And they're setting up there in
- 35:05the hospital parking lots, and
- 35:06they're getting food boxes for
- 35:07the doctors, the nurses.
- 35:08They're getting food there for
- 35:10the patients and getting food
- 35:11there for those in the
- 35:12community. What we're seeing is
- 35:13that the doctors and nurses are
- 35:15healthier, which means they
- 35:16take care of people better.
- 35:17We're seeing the patients.
- 35:18They're having improved
- 35:19recovery time and not having to
- 35:20get readmitted to the hospital.
- 35:22So there's a great way to use
- 35:23Kentucky, produce Kentucky
- 35:24agriculture to heal and feed
- 35:25Kentuckians.
- 35:26>> Right. And is it enough of
- 35:28it available to do that at
- 35:29scale? Right, of what's needed?
- 35:31That's a big question.
- 35:32>> We have to put some. That's
- 35:33why there's some good things
- 35:35for the government to take role
- 35:36in. How can we help? How can
- 35:38government be a good thing to
- 35:39get more food to more people?
- 35:41>> Right. We heard
- 35:42Representative Roarx, you
- 35:43mentioned Representative Roarx
- 35:44about how sometimes this
- 35:44conversation about SNAP and the
- 35:46people who benefit from it are
- 35:47vilified. Or I want you to tell
- 35:49us more about that, because it
- 35:51seems that everyone who's
- 35:52assembled around this table and
- 35:53the table you are sitting at
- 35:55tonight in Louisville seem to
- 35:56be on some accord that SNAP is
- 35:58a viable program that serves
- 36:00the right people when it's
- 36:02needed. What are you hearing?
- 36:03Contrary to that.
- 36:05>> I think what often
- 36:07perpetuates itself is that the
- 36:08program is abused, that folks
- 36:10use it for luxury items, that
- 36:12they are making poor choices
- 36:14with their spending and a lot
- 36:16of judgment around just
- 36:17basically personal decisions
- 36:20and scrutiny around what food
- 36:22people eat and are choosing to
- 36:23eat when on a government
- 36:25assistance program. And I often
- 36:27say nobody's monitoring my food
- 36:29intake in that same, same
- 36:30manner. And some people would
- 36:32argue that maybe there should
- 36:33be held to a higher standard if
- 36:35they're getting government
- 36:36assistance. But I also think
- 36:37when you are working two jobs
- 36:38just to barely put food on the
- 36:40table and pay your rent, afford
- 36:42to have a family in general,
- 36:44we're seeing a lot more young
- 36:45people and young families
- 36:46wanting to delay having
- 36:48families because of the cost of
- 36:50living increases and grocery
- 36:51bills. And so when we factor
- 36:53all those things in, I think
- 36:54it's really critical that one
- 36:56of the top issues for voters is
- 36:59always health care. And when we
- 37:01talk about food being medicine,
- 37:03these conversations are all
- 37:04intertwined. Because when you
- 37:07need quick meals, where are you
- 37:09going to go? You're going to go
- 37:11to fast food. You're going to
- 37:12go to things that are simple to
- 37:14make. There's a reason why the
- 37:15food banks are asking for pop
- 37:17top canned meals. It's so that
- 37:19children can make a meal. My
- 37:21favorite was always Chef
- 37:23Boyardee. Pop that open. Be
- 37:24able to heat that up real fast
- 37:26for you and your siblings.
- 37:27While your family might be at
- 37:29work while your parents are at
- 37:30work. And I think those are
- 37:32really critical things that
- 37:33people know that there is
- 37:34limited time and resources that
- 37:35go around. And so I think,
- 37:37absolutely, we need to combat
- 37:39issues of misuse, but also make
- 37:43our systems more efficient. But
- 37:44honestly, SNAP is one of the
- 37:46more efficient programs that we
- 37:48have. And my faith teaches me
- 37:49that feeding the hungry is of
- 37:51the utmost importance.
- 37:52>> Miss Heather LeMire, do you
- 37:53have any issue with folks who
- 37:55may spend their government
- 37:57resources on less than healthy
- 37:58options?
- 37:59>> I mean, I don't think that's
- 38:01anything that's for me to judge
- 38:03or say. I think people are
- 38:06probably making the best
- 38:07choices that they can. And I
- 38:10think that a lot of times,
- 38:12unfortunately, healthier
- 38:13options are more expensive. And
- 38:14I think that if we started
- 38:16seeing, you know, local farmers
- 38:18being utilized more with food
- 38:20to schools and different places
- 38:22like that, then people would
- 38:23start learning healthier,
- 38:25healthier options. But it
- 38:27oftentimes is more expensive.
- 38:28And that's extremely
- 38:30unfortunate.
- 38:30>> Yeah. There's a price to
- 38:32health, right? Eric Schansberg,
- 38:33I want to come back to you to
- 38:35to talk more about what you see
- 38:37as possible improvements in the
- 38:38SNAP program. You mentioned
- 38:40about the Federalizing it in
- 38:42some capacity. Where else do
- 38:43you think there could be
- 38:45greater efficiencies to get the
- 38:47food to the people who really
- 38:49need it?
- 38:49>> Well, economists are
- 38:50agnostic on the question of
- 38:52paternalism, right? How much
- 38:53are we going to tell people
- 38:54what they can buy? But one
- 38:56thing is that if government is
- 38:57handing you money, government
- 38:58gets to make the rules. So some
- 39:00in government want to be more
- 39:02restrictive for decent reasons.
- 39:03I mean, that's a decent
- 39:05argument. Others are like, no,
- 39:06let people do what they want.
- 39:07And that's a perpetual argument
- 39:09we hear in public policy. Aside
- 39:10from that, I mean, just to be
- 39:12careful not to connect it with
- 39:14so many other programs where
- 39:16it's just, again, very
- 39:17complicated to do poverty. Well,
- 39:19if it's connected to forming
- 39:21single parent households, you
- 39:22get more money. If you're a
- 39:24single parent household. Again,
- 39:25that's dangerous because now
- 39:26you're paying people to be in a
- 39:28state that we're not really
- 39:29excited about. So just be
- 39:31really careful about how we're
- 39:32giving. How do we help without
- 39:34hurting? It's just a constant
- 39:35problem in this arena.
- 39:37>> Representative Moore.
- 39:38>> Yes, and the Make America
- 39:39Healthy Again task force we've
- 39:41heard people talk about, well,
- 39:42they shouldn't have the super
- 39:43processed foods or high sugar
- 39:45foods or high calorie foods.
- 39:47For those who are receiving
- 39:48these types of funds, I would
- 39:49like to see instead of us
- 39:51taking things away from
- 39:52Kentuckians giving more healthy
- 39:53options. And part of that would
- 39:55be from this kind of
- 39:56agriculture food as medicine
- 39:57program. How do we address
- 39:59things like food deserts, and
- 40:00is there a way that we can
- 40:02allow for our retailers and our
- 40:03grocers to perhaps incentivize
- 40:04choosing healthier options? So
- 40:06we're not taking away that more
- 40:08sugary food, but maybe we can
- 40:09find a way to get healthier
- 40:11foods in front of people and
- 40:12teach people how to cook and
- 40:14use healthier foods through
- 40:15things like UC's Cooperative
- 40:16Extension Service, which does
- 40:18that throughout the state.
- 40:18>> Dustin.
- 40:19>> Well, what's interesting
- 40:20about that is we actually had a
- 40:22whole federally funded program
- 40:23that was designed to help
- 40:25people understand nutrition
- 40:26better, to give them recipes,
- 40:28to give them opportunities.
- 40:29Cooking. It was called Snap
- 40:31Nutrition Education HR one
- 40:33defunded that. So, you know,
- 40:35here in Lexington, there was a
- 40:37location there off Tates Creek
- 40:38that was there for years and
- 40:40years, and it's gone now.
- 40:42>> And this is the big,
- 40:43beautiful Bill.
- 40:44>> This is the one big,
- 40:45beautiful Bill act. That's
- 40:46right. So, you know, we have we
- 40:48had opportunities to be able to
- 40:50do a lot of this. And Congress
- 40:51chose to get rid of those. I
- 40:53think the other thing that's
- 40:54important to point out when we
- 40:56talk about, you know,
- 40:57potentially restricting what
- 40:58types of foods people can buy
- 40:59with their Snap benefits is
- 41:00that USDA has done a lot of
- 41:02studies to look at what people
- 41:04purchase with their Snap
- 41:05benefits, and what they found
- 41:06is that, generally speaking,
- 41:07people on Snap buy the same
- 41:08things you and I do. The top
- 41:11ten types of foods that a snap
- 41:13purchaser purchases, the same
- 41:15as everybody else. And so I
- 41:16think it's important to
- 41:18recognize that, you know, we
- 41:19need to maybe do a lot of work
- 41:21to make our entire food system
- 41:22healthier. But when when it
- 41:25comes to restricting what
- 41:26somebody who just needs help
- 41:28with their grocery bills can
- 41:29purchase, you know, to some
- 41:31degree, those restrictions
- 41:32already exist, right? If you
- 41:33ever go to a grocery store and
- 41:35you see, like the hot plate
- 41:37with the rotisserie chickens,
- 41:38and then you see refrigerated
- 41:39ones right next to it, it's
- 41:40because you're only allowed to
- 41:42purchase cold foods, foods that
- 41:43you can prepare at home with
- 41:44your Snap benefits. So, you
- 41:46know, we've done some of that
- 41:47already. And, you know, I think
- 41:49there's a lot of discussion you
- 41:51can have around how effective
- 41:52that's been. But the bigger
- 41:53issue is our food system as a
- 41:55whole. And I think penalizing
- 41:57Snap beneficiaries just because
- 41:59they need help with their
- 42:00grocery bills isn't the way
- 42:01forward.
- 42:02>> Well, one of the other
- 42:03elements of the big beautiful
- 42:04bill is it's going to require
- 42:06folks who maybe had gotten
- 42:09these benefits to have work
- 42:11requirements attached to them.
- 42:12Right. So now you've got
- 42:14114,000 Kentuckians, I think,
- 42:16is what the Kentucky Center for
- 42:17Economic Policy could be
- 42:19threatened to no longer be able
- 42:20to get Snap because of the one
- 42:22big beautiful bill requirements.
- 42:23Is that the case?
- 42:24>> Yeah, those requirements
- 42:25started Saturday at the same
- 42:27time as when Snap benefits ran
- 42:29out. So there are a lot of
- 42:31folks who are at risk now of
- 42:33losing those benefits. You know,
- 42:35I think it's important to
- 42:36recognize that Snap already
- 42:37incentivizes work without
- 42:39having to report work hours.
- 42:41Benefits are prorated as
- 42:42incomes rise so that you're not
- 42:44creating what's sometimes
- 42:45called a benefits cliff. And so
- 42:48it really tries to encourage
- 42:50folks to to earn more while
- 42:52they're also receiving these
- 42:54benefits to implement
- 42:56additional requirements to
- 42:57report work hours, to report
- 42:59other types of community
- 43:00engagement. It's really
- 43:01difficult the populations that
- 43:03the one big beautiful Bill act
- 43:05applied this to are pretty
- 43:07unique as well. So you know, in
- 43:09one instance, it reduced the
- 43:11age of children in the
- 43:12household that might exempt you
- 43:13from 17 down to 13. In another
- 43:16case, it expanded the age range
- 43:18up to age 64. For folks who
- 43:21would have to adhere to these
- 43:23requirements. And in another,
- 43:24it got rid of the exemptions
- 43:26for folks who are veterans,
- 43:28former foster care youth and
- 43:30people experiencing
- 43:31homelessness. There are 8000
- 43:33cases where there are so-called
- 43:36households that are homeless in
- 43:38Kentucky who are currently
- 43:40using that exemption. How we
- 43:41anticipate that they will be
- 43:43able to meet this requirement,
- 43:45or even get notified
- 43:46effectively that they have to
- 43:48adhere to this requirement, I
- 43:49don't know, and I'm really
- 43:51concerned about what that's
- 43:52going to mean for for them and
- 43:54their ability to to eat at.
- 43:56>> And this is the 80 hour a
- 43:58month work requirement or
- 44:00participation in a certain
- 44:01training program. We know that
- 44:03Kentucky has experimented and
- 44:05discussed this for a long time.
- 44:07What is your take on this Anne
- 44:09Tyler, and what the results you
- 44:11think might be of this
- 44:12particular provision in H.R.
- 44:13one?
- 44:13>> Well, like Dustin said,
- 44:14there was already a work
- 44:16requirement and incentive built
- 44:17into the Snap program. So
- 44:18unlike some other benefits,
- 44:19this is not new. It's just an
- 44:21expansion to other populations.
- 44:22One of the things that comes to
- 44:24mind from a state government
- 44:26perspective is at a time when
- 44:27state government is now already
- 44:29going to have to figure a lot
- 44:30out about what to do with
- 44:32partial funding of Snap
- 44:33benefits as a result of the
- 44:35court orders that we saw late
- 44:37last week, the state is also
- 44:38now going to have to and is
- 44:40already in the process of
- 44:42figuring out how to administer
- 44:44these enhanced work
- 44:45requirements for, as Dustin
- 44:47said, populations like the
- 44:48homeless, you know, when you
- 44:49have reporting requirements of
- 44:51people who have trouble
- 44:52receiving mail and who have
- 44:54trouble reporting to work
- 44:55because of of their current
- 44:58situation, their homelessness,
- 44:59it's a very difficult thing for
- 45:01the state to actually monitor
- 45:03and implement. With some
- 45:05populations, it's somewhat
- 45:07easier. The former foster care
- 45:08youth are already in the state
- 45:10system, although former foster
- 45:11care youth are at a marked
- 45:14disadvantage for being able to
- 45:16be educated on how to report
- 45:20these types of requirements to
- 45:22the state. So I see enhanced
- 45:24state administrative hurdles as
- 45:26a result of this. Now, coupled
- 45:29with the partial funding issue
- 45:31that they're having to deal
- 45:33with. I also think, you know,
- 45:34we've talked a lot about the
- 45:38kind of merits of the Snap
- 45:41system and whether people
- 45:42should spend their Snap
- 45:44benefits in a quote unquote,
- 45:45more healthy way. But I think
- 45:47in that we're losing a lot of
- 45:49what's really happening here.
- 45:51Snap is not being cut right now
- 45:54because of disagreements with
- 45:57the Snap program. Snap is being
- 45:59cut right now because of the
- 46:00dysfunctionality of Congress.
- 46:02And so I want to kind of go
- 46:05back to the real point here is
- 46:07that when talking about whether
- 46:10people should spend their Snap
- 46:11benefits in a more healthy way,
- 46:13I can almost guarantee you and
- 46:15I can't present empirical data,
- 46:16but I can almost guarantee that
- 46:18people will not be eating
- 46:19healthier because they have
- 46:20less money to afford food.
- 46:22>> Absolutely.
- 46:22>> Snap benefit is the only way
- 46:24they could afford healthy food.
- 46:26So taking away that benefit
- 46:27certainly won't make
- 46:28Kentuckians healthier.
- 46:29>> One other thing to to
- 46:31mention too, about these new
- 46:32reporting requirements. So many
- 46:35states have the ability to give
- 46:37people one off exemptions, one
- 46:39off waivers if their life
- 46:41circumstances change and they
- 46:42need an extra month essentially
- 46:44to be able to get employed or
- 46:46what have you. House Bill 7 in
- 46:482022 took that away from the
- 46:50state. So in Kentucky state law,
- 46:52that is no longer an option on
- 46:54the table. So I think as we
- 46:56move into this new chapter of
- 46:58Snap that's required by federal
- 46:59law, you know, if there are any
- 47:01state lawmakers who are
- 47:02interested in fixing that, I
- 47:03think that would be a really
- 47:05worthy next step.
- 47:06>> For Representative Roarx, do
- 47:07you think that there is the
- 47:09political capital and will to
- 47:12embrace that idea that that
- 47:13Dustin brings up?
- 47:15>> I think it could definitely
- 47:16be discussed, and I think this
- 47:18is one of those topics that we
- 47:19are really seeing a lot more
- 47:21unity and dialog on, because
- 47:24poverty affects every single
- 47:26county in Kentucky, and some
- 47:28more than others, especially in
- 47:29certain regions and especially
- 47:30in our mountain region. So when
- 47:32we talk about SNAP and
- 47:34exemptions that used to exist
- 47:35that now work requirements are
- 47:37becoming more present for, we
- 47:40are going to see the unintended
- 47:43consequences down the line. I
- 47:45think when we think about the
- 47:47teenagers that now no longer
- 47:49their household no longer
- 47:50qualifies for Snap, we're going
- 47:52to then see maybe high schools
- 47:54that are would be less eligible
- 47:56for free and reduced lunch,
- 47:58which then affects how people
- 47:59are getting meals in that
- 48:01entire school system. So it is
- 48:03there's a lot of trickle down
- 48:05impacts there that I think when
- 48:08times get tough, we can really
- 48:10come together about what is
- 48:12most important for families in
- 48:13our districts. And I think food
- 48:15access, health care, these are
- 48:17some of the top priorities for
- 48:19every single one of the 100
- 48:21legislators, legislators in the
- 48:22House and the 38 in the Senate.
- 48:25And so what I'm hopeful for is
- 48:27that we are going to continue
- 48:28to have more robust dialog,
- 48:30more coalition building, unlike
- 48:32what we've seen in the past,
- 48:34because when the rubber meets
- 48:35the road, these are things that
- 48:37our constituents call us about,
- 48:39that they are telling us that
- 48:40we need to step up and make
- 48:42make these processes work for
- 48:45them. And I think what is often
- 48:47lost in translation is, you
- 48:49know, federal government will
- 48:51do something. The state will
- 48:52step in and kind of bandaid it.
- 48:54But a lot of times people
- 48:55aren't paying attention to
- 48:56who's doing what. And so I
- 48:58think at the end of the day,
- 49:00you just know that your bills
- 49:01are more expensive and that
- 49:03it's harder to pay your
- 49:04groceries and feed your family.
- 49:05So I think ultimately us as
- 49:07lawmakers and Kentuckians, I
- 49:10think, are more willing to sit
- 49:12down with each other and say,
- 49:13what is that commonality that
- 49:15we share and what are the
- 49:16solutions? And how can we work
- 49:18together in a bipartisan manner
- 49:19to fix these problems?
- 49:20>> I want to widen the aperture
- 49:22just a little bit and ask your
- 49:24seatmate there in Louisville,
- 49:25Professor Eric Schansberg, I
- 49:26mean, from an economic
- 49:27perspective, as an economist,
- 49:29as you are when you think about
- 49:31these programs, we haven't even
- 49:32talked about work for women and
- 49:34infants and children, right. In
- 49:35TANF, if you think about all of
- 49:37these public assistance
- 49:38programs that we make the
- 49:39economic case for, why they are
- 49:41good and perhaps why they are
- 49:43not so good for the overall
- 49:44economy.
- 49:45>> Well, we want to help the
- 49:46poor, but we should not do it,
- 49:48imagining that it's going to
- 49:50contribute to economic
- 49:51development. I mean, take food
- 49:52stamps as an example. When I
- 49:54was researching a bit,
- 49:55preparing for the program, I
- 49:56saw one report that said A
- 49:59dollar of food stamps creates
- 49:59$1.87 of economic activity.
- 50:00Well, that's impossible. If I
- 50:02take $1 from Rachel and give it
- 50:04to me, that's not going to
- 50:06magically create an extra $0.87
- 50:07worth of economic activity. So
- 50:09it may be a wonderful thing to
- 50:11do, but we should not imagine
- 50:13that we're going to do it for
- 50:15the sake of economic
- 50:16development. There's good
- 50:16reasons to help the poor,
- 50:18private sector, public sector,
- 50:19whatever that looks like. But
- 50:21let's make sure we're doing it
- 50:22for the right reasons. And
- 50:24again, just be super careful
- 50:25with what the dog's breakfast
- 50:26of programs is doing as we try
- 50:28to help the poor without
- 50:29harming them.
- 50:30>> Yeah, as we kind of come up
- 50:32on the conclusion of tonight
- 50:34with six minutes remaining and
- 50:35we've talked a little bit about
- 50:36the helpers who are doing this
- 50:38work, and I am curious about
- 50:40what kind of what's happening
- 50:41on the federal level that the
- 50:43states are dealing with, how
- 50:44that will affect the tone and
- 50:46tenor of the legislative
- 50:47session that is coming up on us.
- 50:49Fast and furious starts January
- 50:51the 6th, I believe. What are
- 50:53you expecting? Well,
- 50:55Representative.
- 50:55>> Moore, staying on this topic
- 50:57right now, I think we have to
- 50:58ask ourselves, like, what does
- 51:00it mean to be American, to be a
- 51:02first world country, the
- 51:03richest nation in the world? I
- 51:04don't know about the other
- 51:05people sitting here, but we had
- 51:07to memorize the preamble to the
- 51:08Constitution back in, I think,
- 51:10seventh grade civics. But one
- 51:11of them is, is promote the
- 51:12general welfare. And part of
- 51:14that means that we are a rich
- 51:15nation. We're a first world
- 51:17nation. Do we want our own
- 51:18people going hungry? If we can
- 51:20do a little bit more to ease
- 51:21that? And I think that we
- 51:23should keep that in our mind
- 51:24when we go back into session in
- 51:26Frankfort in January.
- 51:27>> Representative Roarx, I'll
- 51:28come to you since you'll be
- 51:30among those going.
- 51:30>> To.
- 51:31>> This is my second, my second
- 51:33budget session. And I think
- 51:34what is always goes unseen is
- 51:35all the work that has gone into
- 51:37building the budget. Even
- 51:38before we get back in to the
- 51:40legislative session, it's going
- 51:41to be 60 days. It's going to be.
- 51:43It'll go by in the blink of an
- 51:45eye. But I do think we are all
- 51:47going into this budget session,
- 51:48you know, with these gaps from
- 51:50the federal government in mind,
- 51:52with the way that revenue is
- 51:54right now, looking at, we've
- 51:57reduced the income tax so much
- 51:59that this is going to be a
- 52:00really tight budget year for
- 52:02Kentuckians. And the question
- 52:04of, are we willing to spend
- 52:06more of our rainy day fund, our
- 52:08budget reserve trust fund to
- 52:09help solve some of these
- 52:10problems that we are seeing
- 52:12because of the loss of federal
- 52:14funding? Kentucky is a receiver
- 52:15state in a lot of ways, and we
- 52:17benefit from federal
- 52:18distribution of funds. And so I
- 52:20think it really is a question
- 52:22around what is the state of
- 52:23Kentucky willing to put money
- 52:25behind and continue to program?
- 52:27And for all those folks out
- 52:28there who are looking for ways
- 52:30to cut red tape, ways for
- 52:32things to be more efficient,
- 52:33this is where the rubber meets
- 52:35the road. This is where we're
- 52:36going to be looking at this
- 52:38budget year, because the
- 52:39budget's going to be tight.
- 52:40>> Miss Lohmeyer, we know that
- 52:42Americans for Prosperity
- 52:43Kentucky always talks about
- 52:44practicing fiscal restraint.
- 52:46Right. And smaller government
- 52:48is where does that those
- 52:50principles fit into this
- 52:51conversation about food
- 52:52assistance from your view?
- 52:54>> Yeah. I'm so glad you asked
- 52:56that. I, I think that more,
- 52:58more Kentuckians are even
- 53:00needing Snap benefits because
- 53:02of different issues like
- 53:04housing expenses. I mean, you
- 53:07know, it's becoming where
- 53:11Americans cannot even dream of
- 53:14having or owning a home. A lot
- 53:16of kids who get out of college,
- 53:18that's something that they
- 53:19don't even see for their future.
- 53:21And that's really, really a
- 53:24shame. And so there that's our
- 53:26main priority going into
- 53:28legislative session this year.
- 53:29We're going to be focused on
- 53:30affordable housing and cutting
- 53:33zoning requirements and
- 53:35permitting issues and all of
- 53:37those different things to
- 53:38really make it easier for
- 53:39Kentuckians to buy a home.
- 53:41>> Well, as a regulatory
- 53:42attorney, Anne-Tyler Morgan, I
- 53:43would think that some of that
- 53:45sounds pretty good to you.
- 53:46Perhaps.
- 53:46>> Certainly. And Renee, I work
- 53:48with a lot of groups that are
- 53:50focused on affordable housing
- 53:51and housing in general. We, you
- 53:52know, have had a shortage, and
- 53:54certainly that's a very
- 53:55important issue. I think child
- 53:56care, obviously, is another
- 53:58focus for making sure that
- 54:00Kentuckians have a certain
- 54:02level of welfare and can afford
- 54:03to work and keep their kids
- 54:05safe while they're doing so.
- 54:07>> Yeah. Dustin, what is what
- 54:09do you hope lawmakers will
- 54:10consider, particularly when it
- 54:11comes to these public
- 54:12assistance programs and how it
- 54:13should respond?
- 54:14>> I mean, I think everything
- 54:15that's been mentioned is
- 54:16important. I also think that
- 54:18the General Assembly, in many
- 54:19ways, may have their work cut
- 54:21out for them. This shutdown is
- 54:22not over yet, and there are a
- 54:24lot of programs that still have
- 54:26a little bit of runway, but
- 54:27we're we're sort of meeting the
- 54:29end of that. SNAP was the first
- 54:30sort of program to to see the
- 54:32expiration of those dollars.
- 54:34But, you know, there are
- 54:35programs like that you
- 54:36mentioned where 107,000
- 54:37Kentuckians receive nutrition
- 54:40assistance, including 38% of
- 54:41infants who are formula
- 54:44dependent and get their formula
- 54:45through Wick. So, you know,
- 54:48that's a program that could run
- 54:49out of money soon.
- 54:50>> What about TANF? Temporary
- 54:51assistance for Needy.
- 54:52>> Families is another one
- 54:53we're seeing.
- 54:54>> And what's the difference
- 54:55between that and Snap.
- 54:56>> Yeah. So so TANF is the
- 54:58federal grant that funds our
- 54:59one and only basic cash
- 55:01assistance program. And it goes
- 55:02to households with children who
- 55:04are around half the poverty
- 55:05line. So very the poorest of
- 55:07the poor kids in Kentucky. And
- 55:08it provides a very meager
- 55:10benefit, even more meager after
- 55:12recent cuts from the state
- 55:13government to to deal with some
- 55:14child welfare shortfalls. We're
- 55:16also seeing the expiration of
- 55:18housing assistance funds
- 55:20through through the end of the
- 55:21year. So there are a lot of
- 55:23ways in which this is
- 55:24potentially going to hurt
- 55:25people, which is to say nothing.
- 55:27Of the 23,000 federal employees,
- 55:29many of whom have gone a month
- 55:30without a paycheck now, that
- 55:32includes air traffic
- 55:33controllers that work in 53
- 55:35general aviation airports in
- 55:36Kentucky. So there are a lot of
- 55:40significant needs. And I hope,
- 55:41if nothing else, the shutdown
- 55:43has really showed us the value
- 55:45and importance that the federal
- 55:46government plays in our state
- 55:47and the many, many ways that it
- 55:49helps our families, our friends
- 55:51and our neighbors, and that
- 55:52when we move forward making
- 55:54decisions at the state and
- 55:55federal level, we'll kind of
- 55:56keep this moment in mind,
- 55:58because these are really
- 55:59critical programs that help a
- 56:00lot of folks.
- 56:01>> Well, thank you all very
- 56:03much for your attention to this
- 56:05and sharing your thoughts with
- 56:06us. And same to you all in
- 56:08Louisville. We thank you for
- 56:09being with us tonight and next
- 56:10Monday night on Kentucky Night.
- 56:12More about food insecurity and
- 56:13the work of agencies to help
- 56:14families in need. Be sure to
- 56:16join us for that next Monday
- 56:17and for Kentucky Edition each
- 56:19weeknight at 630 eastern, 530
- 56:21central, where we inform,
- 56:22connect and inspire. And of
- 56:24course, Bill Bryant and a team
- 56:25of working journalists will be
- 56:26right here on Friday night for
- 56:28comment on Kentucky to wrap up
- 56:29the news of the week. Thanks
- 56:31for watching tonight. I'm Renee
- 56:32Shaw. Take really good care and
- 56:34I'll see you soon. So bad was
- 56:41it.
- 56:42>> Great job.