Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / People-Powered Supports: Building Effective Mentoring Systems for All Learners
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:03and today we're speaking to Kate Cochran from the Partnership for Student Success.
- 0:08The Partnership for Student Success is a national coalition of school districts,
- 0:11nonprofits, and higher education institutions focused on expanding evidence-based
- 0:16and people-powered support for K-12 students.
- 0:19Based out of John Hopkins University, Everyone Graduates Center,
- 0:22PSS supports efforts to implement, expand, and improve high-impact tutoring, mentoring,
- 0:28post-secondary transition coaching, student success coaching,
- 0:31and wraparound integrated student support for all students.
- 0:35Joining us today is Kate Cochran, the Partnerships Managing Director.
- 0:40It's so great to have you here today, Kate, and it's great to be reunited and
- 0:44talking about all things student success and mentorship. Great to have you here.
- 0:49It's great to be here. Thank you for inviting me to join you for this conversation.
- 0:54It's been, for those of you who know, Kate and I have worked together at Innovate
- 0:58EDU, and we've definitely had our share of on-the-ground, in-the-field experiences
- 1:03and also behind-the-scenes work as well. So let's kick it off.
- 1:09Tell us a little bit more about PSS and the work that you're doing.
- 1:12Absolutely. So as you already framed, we are a national coalition that brings
- 1:17together leaders and practitioners from nonprofit organizations, schools, districts.
- 1:24And higher education institutions, all with the shared goal of expanding evidence-based
- 1:29and people-powered student supports across the country.
- 1:33Evidence-based and people-powered student supports could mean a lot of different
- 1:36things, but we're particularly interested on five roles that each have a pretty
- 1:41robust evidence base demonstrating their positive impacts on students.
- 1:47So those roles are high-impact tutoring, mentoring, student success coaching,
- 1:52which is kind of a combination of a tutor and a mentor, post-secondary transition
- 1:57coaching and wraparound or integrated student supports.
- 2:00We do this through technical assistance. We convene a bunch of solutions networks
- 2:06and working groups for practitioners who are working to tackle particular barriers or opportunities.
- 2:13And then we also publish a lot of resources that are intended to be practical,
- 2:19to support implementation, and we also conduct research each year.
- 2:24That's what we do. You know, it's.
- 2:28When I was reading the intro, I was really interested about this piece that
- 2:32you're doing around post-secondary transition coaching.
- 2:34We talk at ELO, we talk a lot about this post-secondary cliff for students with disabilities.
- 2:40You know, what happens when you're no longer have the structured support of
- 2:44an IEP or a special education program, a 504 plan.
- 2:50So tell me more about why is mentoring, how could that be a real game-changer
- 2:53for students during that specific time, that specific transition.
- 2:57Definitely. And this is a topic that is super interesting to me,
- 3:01both through my work and personally.
- 3:03My brother has Down syndrome, and growing up side by side with him in the same
- 3:08household, same school, same grade for most of our school experience,
- 3:13and seeing really the stark difference in particular during that post-secondary
- 3:17transition period between my experience and his was a big driver for me to go
- 3:22into the field of education.
- 3:24And I also actually worked for a peer mentoring initiative when I was in high
- 3:28school that was run by a social service nonprofit in the town where I went to school.
- 3:34And I worked to recruit high school students to mentor our peers with disabilities
- 3:38through sort of outdoor activities, recreational activities,
- 3:41which was definitely a formative professional experience for me.
- 3:44So this is something that definitely hits close to home in addition to being
- 3:49something that's important to our work at the Partnership for Student Success.
- 3:53Mentoring is an evidence-based intervention that research demonstrates can have
- 3:59really positive impact on all students, and,
- 4:03in particular, these types of supports can be important for young people with disabilities.
- 4:08So young people with disabilities often face more barriers to post-secondary
- 4:12education and career success than their peers who don't have disabilities.
- 4:17Research indicates that students with disabilities are less likely to graduate
- 4:20from high school, less likely to enroll in college, less likely to graduate
- 4:24from college than their peers who do not have disabilities.
- 4:27And this group is also more likely to be unemployed or underemployed.
- 4:32And for these reasons, quality post-secondary transition supports are really
- 4:38important for people with disabilities in particular, as they are for all students.
- 4:45IDEA mandates that all students with disabilities receive post-secondary transition
- 4:50planning supports, but we know from federal data that not all students are actually
- 4:55getting this support, and it's happening more in some states than others.
- 5:00And we also know that many youth with disabilities are already participating
- 5:05in mentoring programs, which is great, with some research indicating that as
- 5:09many as 10% of youth served by mentoring programs actually have a disability,
- 5:14which is a pretty good rate for something that's typically a sort of a voluntary
- 5:18or opt-in participation program.
- 5:22And just a little bit about mentoring more broadly, this applies to students
- 5:26with disabilities and beyond,
- 5:29can really have positive impacts on academic outcomes, on self-confidence,
- 5:35on career-ready skills, and on also career-ready planning.
- 5:39And then, in particular, research indicates that mentoring can have positive
- 5:44impacts on youth with disabilities, including durable skills,
- 5:48important factors like improving academic performance,
- 5:53development of career development planning skills, job seeking skills and confidence
- 5:58in the job search process, and also transition and life skills,
- 6:03including being able to access available support services.
- 6:08Yeah, the fact that you brought up access and awareness, that's a big kind of
- 6:13gap that I'm seeing and our EALA partners are talking about. And just as you
- 6:17mentioned before, that post-secondary support is part of IDEA.
- 6:21And I think that's kind of a little known fact.
- 6:25You have to be sort of very well-versed in your rights.
- 6:30And how to advocate for yourself. Not everybody has that.
- 6:34Not every student with disabilities or family with student disabilities knows
- 6:37what's out there, which is why the mentoring, the coaching, all that kind of
- 6:42stuff can really sort of help bridge an awareness and an access gap.
- 6:47What does effective mentoring look like for this population?
- 6:50Is it different from traditional mentoring?
- 6:53What are some of the key factors there?
- 6:56Yeah, it's a great question and sort of high level.
- 7:00All mentoring kind of contains the same key elements for quality.
- 7:06But there are definitely places where this type of programming needs to be more
- 7:11enhanced or more intentionally built to support students with disabilities effectively.
- 7:17So more broadly effective mentoring for any student, the purpose of that is
- 7:23to connect a young person to personal growth and development,
- 7:27as well as social and economic opportunity.
- 7:30Mentors might work one-on-one with the student or in group settings.
- 7:33They might be in an after-school program setting, an in-school setting,
- 7:38another community-based setting,
- 7:41and really work to help youth explore and affirm their identities,
- 7:44support navigation of life transitions, whether, you know, we're talking really
- 7:48about the transition from high school into whether it's college or career or,
- 7:54other pathways after high school.
- 7:56But mentors might also support students with the transition from elementary
- 8:00to middle school or other big life transitions.
- 8:04And they also help young people buffer against adversity, which we know people,
- 8:10everybody faces, right?
- 8:12And so all types of mentoring programs can be designed in a way in ways that
- 8:17include and effectively serve students with disabilities. And we know many mentoring
- 8:21programs are designed to serve a broad range of students, including students with disabilities.
- 8:26But we also know that there are effective examples of mentoring programs that
- 8:31are designed specifically to serve students with disabilities or even specifically
- 8:35serve students with specific types of disabilities, which can be really powerful.
- 8:40In particular in this context, because a key part of mentoring is connecting
- 8:45students with peers or with adults who can relate to,
- 8:49their life experiences, help them navigate a range of challenges,
- 8:53or at least identify with a range of challenges that they may be facing.
- 8:57At a high level, effective mentoring generally involves well-trained and supported
- 9:02mentors. They might be paid, they might be volunteer, but they really need to be well-trained.
- 9:07They need to be well supported by experienced staff and supervisors.
- 9:12There needs to be an intentional mentor-mentee matching process to ensure that
- 9:16it's the right fit. Not every mentor is the right fit for every mentee.
- 9:22And then there also needs to be a sustained and supportive relationship over
- 9:25time with proper oversight from that experienced staff.
- 9:30Mentoring relationships don't really work with quality if you don't have that
- 9:34sustained relationship, that trusting relationship over time.
- 9:38And so, in addition to these factors that are really important for any mentoring
- 9:42program, we know that programs that are serving students with disabilities specifically or who are.
- 9:50Supporting a range of students, including students with disabilities, are,
- 9:54can also really improve their programming by, first, intentionally building
- 9:59knowledge and understanding of disability and making an intentional effort to,
- 10:05include people with disabilities in their programming.
- 10:09That includes both people who are receiving mentoring services or students.
- 10:13It also includes mentors. It also includes staff.
- 10:17And making sure that the program is designed in a way that is welcoming to people
- 10:23with disabilities and their parents, their families, their support systems.
- 10:29And as I said before, relatability when it comes to challenges,
- 10:33life transitions, other experience really is at the crux of the mentoring relationship.
- 10:38So this is, I think, particularly important in this role, whereas it might not
- 10:43be as it might be beneficial, but might not be as important for a role like
- 10:47a tutor, which is more about academic supports.
- 10:51And then developing partnerships with local organizations and agencies that
- 10:56support people with disabilities at different stages of their lives can be really
- 11:00important, both with recruitment for a program that may be trying to recruit
- 11:04more students with disabilities into their program,
- 11:06but also ensuring that, as we said before, staff are able to connect students
- 11:12with and their families with their range of resources that are in their communities.
- 11:16That doesn't mean that a mentor has to be the expert on all services available
- 11:22for students with disabilities, but really making sure that a mentoring program,
- 11:28has a good understanding of who the resources are that they can connect families
- 11:32with in the community when they need more support, whether it's.
- 11:36In middle school, whether it's in high school, whether it's during transitional
- 11:40periods or during job search processes or or college or throughout the college experience.
- 11:48And then making sure that young people have decision making power in the activities
- 11:53that they're participating in when it comes to mentoring and also the people who mentor them.
- 11:58We know that in particular, students with disabilities.
- 12:03We often see, I'm sure you've seen this in the work that you've done,
- 12:06that parents may complete surveys for students or parents who are the best advocates
- 12:11for students may voice kind of what the student needs, which is obviously really helpful information.
- 12:17But in a mentor-mentee relationship, it's also really crucial to ensure that
- 12:22the student who's receiving those supports, who's participating in those activities,
- 12:27has a voice in what they're doing to ensure that that relationship piece is important.
- 12:34As quality as possible. Tell us about a success story or a bright spot,
- 12:38something really promising that you've seen in the field.
- 12:41Yeah. So the program that I get most excited about when we think about mentoring
- 12:46for students with disabilities is the Eye to Eye Mentoring Program at the Neurodiversity Alliance.
- 12:51I think they're involved in the EALA Network too, if I'm not mistaken.
- 12:54Yes, they are. Yes. Shout out to the Neurodiversity Alliance. Yes.
- 12:58Absolutely. And so they have a program that is well-studied,
- 13:02that provides school-based mentoring that's really run by and for students with learning differences.
- 13:09And through their program, older students in high school or in college who learn
- 13:15differently lead school-based chapters and then serve as mentors for elementary
- 13:20and middle school students who also learn differently.
- 13:23And they do this through really structured weekly mentoring sessions,
- 13:27again, really focused on that relationship building over time and connection.
- 13:34Through similar lived experiences, which really exciting and promising work.
- 13:37I mean, they've been around for decades, so more than promising,
- 13:41really exciting work. And there are a lot of programs across the country that
- 13:47are focused on mentoring students with disabilities.
- 13:50Many of them are small and even more of a reason to lift up that these programs exist.
- 13:57And we also know that many mentoring programs exist.
- 14:00That are designed to serve a broader range of students are effectively supporting
- 14:05students with disabilities.
- 14:07I know that PSS has been really busy lately. You've got some new training content.
- 14:12So tell us, can you tell us a bit more about the training that you've developed?
- 14:16Absolutely. So we've been fortunate over the last almost year now to have the
- 14:22opportunity to collaborate with experts from nine different organizations focused
- 14:27on different aspects of the post-secondary transition,
- 14:31to help develop three new online training modules.
- 14:34These topics we really aimed at filling gaps that our expert consortium identified
- 14:40as places where there wasn't already free online existing training opportunities,
- 14:48for practitioners.
- 14:49And so the three trainings are what the first one is focused on engaging high
- 14:54school students in peer mentoring roles.
- 14:57So in particular, peer mentoring roles through post-secondary transitions.
- 15:01And so when you first hear that, you may think, how can you possibly mentor
- 15:05somebody through something you have not been through?
- 15:08You're a high school student, you haven't yet been through a post-secondary transition.
- 15:12But it turns out there are actually a number of programs doing this across the
- 15:15country that are well-studied and do this effectively, but obviously require,
- 15:20really robust training, intentional design to do that effectively.
- 15:24So that training really goes deep into how to design a program,
- 15:31how to train students, how to recruit students, and how to measure effectiveness.
- 15:36The second one is on supporting uncertain seniors, which provides a range of.
- 15:42Support options, mindsets, and.
- 15:47Potential post-secondary pathway information meant it's designed for coaches
- 15:53or school counselors who may be supporting students
- 15:56who aren't yet sure about what their path is after high school or not yet sure
- 16:00that they're not yet planning to apply to college or,
- 16:03don't yet have a plan about transitioning into their career of choice.
- 16:09And then the final one is focused on paying for college and particularly the after FAFSA phase.
- 16:15You know, there's a lot of great content out there on how to complete the FAFSA.
- 16:19And then what happens after? What happens after?
- 16:23What do you do when you get your financial aid offer letter?
- 16:27How do you understand the true cost of college with that offer letter,
- 16:30other expenses? So that's what that third training is on.
- 16:34And these complement a broader training library of content that we've developed
- 16:38with partners, including mentor and others for mentors and post-secondary transition
- 16:44coaches in particular or people who lead programs doing that type of work.
- 16:49This is all great. We're almost out of time for today, but we're almost at the
- 16:53end of our time. So before you go, how can folks get involved,
- 16:57stay informed, find out more about the work that you're doing at PSS?
- 17:01Yeah, so practitioners from schools, districts, nonprofits, higher ed institutions,
- 17:07can get involved by joining our coalition or signing up to participate in working
- 17:12groups or learning communities on,
- 17:14topics ranging from engaging college students, high school students,
- 17:18older adults in K-12 student support roles like mentoring, like post-secondary transition coaching.
- 17:25We have groups on tutor apprenticeships, on addressing chronic absence,
- 17:28on other pressing challenges, opportune opportunities in the field right now.
- 17:36We also offer technical assistance through a network of expert partners for
- 17:41any effort to implement, expand, or improve tutoring, mentoring,
- 17:46and similar supports, which can be requested on our website.
- 17:50We host a lot of convenings to in-person summits a year and a lot of meetups
- 17:55at conferences and other places where we know that practitioners gather.
- 17:59And all these supports are available for free for nonprofits and folks from
- 18:03public institutions, so public schools, government agencies, et cetera.
- 18:08That's incredible. It's always I think sometimes when we're in this this world,
- 18:12especially an educator, a parent, a school leader, sometimes you can be listening
- 18:17and wondering, well, what's the price tag?
- 18:19And so the fact that Partnership for Student Success is able to offer,
- 18:23amplify, and kind of, you know, make these resources available for free for,
- 18:29you said, nonprofits and for schools.
- 18:32People who are publicly serving students.
- 18:34Great. That's fantastic. Well, Kate, it's been great talking to you today.
- 18:38Thank you so much for joining us on the EALA podcast.
- 18:42Thank you so much for having me, Aurora. I'm excited to see how it turns out.
- 18:45And I'm honored to have been invited and been able to share a little bit about
- 18:49the work that we're doing.
- 18:51Well, that's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Kate Cochran.
- 18:54And to learn more, check out their website at partnershipstudentsuccess.org.
- 18:59If you enjoyed this episode, don't forget to subscribe on your favorite podcast
- 19:02platform and follow us on social media.
- 19:06I'm Aurora from EALA, and this was a deep dive with the Partnership for Student Success.