Latest / FWDstart / Mark Kahn (Omnivore) on GCC Food Security, India’s Venture Depth & Agritech Investing
Transcript
- FWDstart PODCAST - EPISODE 1 Guest: Mark Khan, Co-founder & Managing Partner, Omnivore --- [INTRO] MARK KHAN: Almost no country in the GCC can be truly food sovereign. Vertical agriculture is an idea that came about over the last 15 years that has, for the most part, been a fucking disaster. Hey, little old India—only one sixth of humanity—would be an equally great investment opportunity if you are building an agritech company. You have to understand what you're going to be when you grow up. It's really funny now, 21 years later, to be like, yeah, I thought American politics was really toxic. And it's like, this weird kid from Texas is like, "Hey, I'm gonna do agribusiness." And everyone's like, "What the hell?" Life and material sciences might be a little under the radar right now, but there is a lot that is coming. Let it cook, as Gen Z would say. Any person really thinking about food security in the GCC needs to think in a framework that I believe has three parts. --- JAMIE: Hello. My guest today is Mark Khan. Mark is the co-founder and managing partner of Omnivore, India's leading agritech and climate tech venture capital firm with more than $300 million under management and over 45 startups backed. When I first conceived this podcast, Mark is someone I immediately wanted on—one, Mark was never shy of an opinion or hot take, and two, he's also just a fountain of knowledge when it comes to all things agriculture and climate related, as well as India's broader venture ecosystem to boot. We cover a ton of ground. We get into why he's not trading India's deep venture ecosystem for newer regional opportunities, how to build bridges between India and the GCC, whether the region can ever be truly food secure, and how on earth a Harvard Business School grad from Texas can end up investing in something like a tractor marketplace in India. I am super grateful to Mark for being the first guest on the podcast. I learned a ton from this conversation, so I hope that you find it just as valuable as I did. [AD BREAK - SARWA] But before getting into the episode—Warren Buffett once said the stock market is designed to transfer money from the active to the patient, and Lebanese-American mathematician Nassim Nicholas Taleb reminded us that you cannot predict, you can only get ready. Those two insights define today's investing environment. You don't win by guessing the next move. You win by preparing, cutting through the noise, and letting discipline compound over time. That's exactly what Sarwa delivers. Sarwa's modern platform is grounded in simplicity and lets you trade stocks, ETFs, crypto options, and higher savings all in one app. They keep your fees low so more of your money goes to work, with minimums as low as $500. Sarwa is loved by experts, not just beginners. Whether you're a first timer, an active investor, or a day trader, you'll join hundreds of thousands of users who choose to grow their wealth. As a FWDstart listener, you get $200 when you open a new account with code FORWARDSTAR. All the details are in the description, and if you're chatting to the team, please do tell them that Jamie sent you. So what are you waiting for? Get started in minutes and take control of your money your way. Sarwa is regulated by the ADGM Financial Services Regulatory Authority. The information shared in this segment is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investing involves risk, and past performance is not indicative of future results. [AD BREAK - HUBPAY] If you've ever tried opening a business account in the UAE, you know the drill. Endless paperwork, minimum balance requirements, and traditional providers that move at the speed of bureaucracy, shall we say. Hubpay, however, was built to change that. It's a fully digital, ADGM-regulated fintech platform that gives UAE businesses instant access to multi-currency accounts with named IBAN in 30+ currencies, payment links, payroll, and much, much more. There's no hidden fees, no minimum balance. And if you're like me and you're in a hurry—there's no waiting. It's amazing. So whether you're a startup paying contractors in Asia, a scale-up managing suppliers in Europe, or an enterprise running treasury across multiple geographies, with Hubpay you can open a business account and become financially operational within a week. Can you imagine? A week. No paperwork, no branch visits, no barriers. It's trusted by 1,000+ UAE SMEs from tech startups all the way up to mid-market enterprises. So what are you waiting for? Open your Hubpay business account today and get a 30-day free trial at hubpay.com. Scale your UAE business with confidence. --- [INTERVIEW BEGINS] JAMIE: Mark, very welcome to the FWDstart podcast. Thank you so much for joining me today. MARK: It's really nice to be here. JAMIE: If we can start with actually just getting straight into it—maybe we'll get some of the backstory later on. We did have a conversation a couple of weeks back, which I found very interesting, and I'd like to maybe kick off with something that you mentioned then: that you're spending more time in the Gulf of late, and that you're frequently encountering a particular question. And your refrain is, "Well, no, no, not really. That is not the case." Can you expand on why that is? MARK: We are an Indian fund. Omnivore is an Indian fund. We are the largest, oldest, and most active venture capital firm in India focused on agritech and climate. I like to say that we're a climate VC with roots in agriculture. There's a lot of interesting things that can be done between India and the GCC. And for that reason, and for some others, I've been spending more time in Dubai and in the GCC more generally. But it's an interesting point that whenever you're here, people sort of immediately assume you're going to drop whatever you're doing to pursue the incredible domestic opportunity. And while I acknowledge that there is one—and I see that there's a very strong opportunity to do venture in the GCC, in MENA more generally, and that even within the scope of what we do, which is to say agrifood and climate investing, there are incredible opportunities—I'm not going to trade India for MENA. India is an absolutely fantastic venture ecosystem that is incredibly deep. It offers quite a bit of liquidity, offers markets at scale. What we are instead trying to do is find ways to build bridges between India and the GCC, between India and MENA, and create synergies that are mutually beneficial for Indian startups that are interested in bringing either technology outside or agribusiness—essentially agritech companies that are nascent agribusiness companies that are simply exporting fruits, vegetables, spices, food ingredients, what have you. And so that's the reason I've been spending quite a bit of time here. I do see interesting things to invest in locally, but—and maybe that will happen in the future—we're not doing that quite yet. JAMIE: Do you think there's a misunderstanding about India's venture depth versus the GCC? MARK: Oh, 100%. It's a little bit funny. I think it is a function of history and immigration. I think the fact that this region is so close to India and has so many Indians here—especially in the UAE—because of that, there's two ways that could go. One is all of those people here are super active about investing back home. But the other way that in fact plays out is that there is such a strong focus in the GCC whenever they think about abroad. Abroad is the US. Abroad is Europe. If you think about the large asset managers here, they're all fighting to get into these deals in the US and to a lesser extent in Europe. And the notion that, hey, little old India—only one sixth of humanity, the source of a huge amount of labour, both blue and white collar—would be an equally great investment opportunity... It's not that there's no investing. Certainly there have been significant investments from some of the largest financial institutions in the UAE in the Indian startup ecosystem, in growth rounds and the like, but there's sort of a de-prioritisation of almost every overseas market in the GCC in favour of the United States. JAMIE: Is that structural? Is there a degree of hubris? MARK: I mean, look, I think there has always been strong linkage between the UAE, between the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and the United States. And I think the bleeding edge of AI, some of the largest startup outcomes in the world are in the US. Like, there is no question of that. But I think India sort of gets a bit ignored, possibly because of its proximity, possibly because it's sort of seen in a past tense—as a provider of very good chartered accountants and financial and IT personnel. But all of that is more about India's past than the kinds of incredible things that are happening in India's present. And so I'm hoping that changes. It's not that there is no investment, but certainly when I tell people here, "No, no, no, I'm very happy focusing on India," they're like, "Wait. But have you seen the local market?" And I'm like, yeah, I have. It's good. It's way smaller. India's $15 billion a year of venture capital investment. We have multiple decacorns that have gone public. We have possibly the most liquid public markets in the world. JAMIE: This is what I wanted to ask as well, from an exit perspective. MARK: It's better in every way. I mean, I would argue—it's funny, I was at a conference in Europe last week, and I was having a variant of this discussion with a group of European climate VCs. And I explained to them that in India, you can take a company public if the valuation is, I'd say, $400-500 million, and they're like, "We don't even know what an IPO is, dude. We don't know what that is. That doesn't exist here." India, in many ways, because of the long-only domestic investment combined with significant foreign international investment, has resulted in a savings and investment culture that reminds me a lot of the US in the 90s. And the exchanges in India remind me of the NASDAQ in the 90s. To be clear, when I was in high school—not like I have a super intimate knowledge of this—but basically the United States, through regulation, made going public insanely, insanely difficult in two waves, like the first being 2002-2003 and then again after the financial crisis. Which is why you need things like SPACs in order to go public in America. India never did that. It's always had an exchange that was open to medium-sized companies that wanted to go public. And so startups are a huge beneficiary of that. All of which is to say, yeah, it's a great VC ecosystem. That doesn't take away from how good or interesting MENA is. But it is a much bigger opportunity. And I would argue a much deeper set of kinds of businesses that are being built. I think MENA is very strong in fintech. I think MENA is quite strong in the e-commerce consumer opportunity. And then when it comes to things like deep tech or life sciences or material sciences or robotics, there's very little. It's still early days. And I think that will change, and I hope that we can be part of that change. But the interesting thing is the Indian startup ecosystem, which earlier really was like B2B SaaS and the consumer opportunity, has radically deepened in the last few years and has become quite interesting in terms of hardware investments, some nascent stuff in AI, fintech being incredible, the B2B opportunity being incredible. And it will continue to be our focus even as we try to bring Indian startups into MENA and selectively look at opportunities here. JAMIE: That makes sense. Do you think there's lessons that can be learned from that exit environment in an Indian context? I mean, there's an obsession regionally with the idea of the unicorn and the valuation has to exceed $1 billion. And obviously venture returns necessitate that on occasion. But do you think it's unrealistic? MARK: I don't think it's unrealistic because I do think you need large outcomes. There's always this thing about venture math, where your typical VC fund, if they did it right, owns 10% at exit—oftentimes much less. And when you think about your typical VC fund size and the fact that these unicorns are providing one-times the fund hopefully when they go public... I think you do need these outsized exits. And I think small exits really don't help much for a venture capital model. And I don't think the Indian public markets are very easy to replicate. They really are the function of a fast-growing country that has an insane savings culture. And so I don't think it's like a copy-paste. But I do think there has been a real effort to get companies to re-domicile back to India, like the champions that have been built. There was a time where some of the most successful Indian startups were really domiciled in Delaware or Singapore—a good example is Flipkart. And these companies are all flipping back to India, recognising that it's a better public market environment for them. And so I think that should definitely be a priority for the region as they build their public markets—getting, making sure that their greatest champions are domestically domiciled. JAMIE: The next thing I want to talk about is a word that has perhaps popped up the most in my writing over the course of the past year, which is sovereignty. If I have to write the word sovereignty again... I do an assessment at the end of every year of the frequency with which I use particular words. And I'm sure sovereignty is going to be right up at the top—whether it's AI, space, defence, food. It's nearly become fetishised to a certain extent, I would argue—this idea of sovereignty and self-sufficiency, especially in a Gulf context. But when you look specifically at food, the distinction can get slightly blurred. I'd love to get your take on this idea of food security versus food sovereignty and maybe how we're conflating those terms in a regional context. MARK: So I think the terms are often conflated, often abused. Food sovereignty and food security are not the same thing. Food security is how you make sure that your country is able to feed itself while doing everything you can to reduce potential disruptions, potential risks, climate effects, what have you. Food sovereignty—and I define this sort of in economic terms, which I think is a little bit different from how it is sometimes defined—is something like the ability to say we grow everything we need inside our borders, and so we need nothing from abroad. And that is virtually impossible for many countries, including the GCC. There are a lot of things that you simply cannot grow in the GCC at scale. And that's not a failure of the country, that's not a failure of policy—that's simply the case. Almost no country in the GCC can be truly food sovereign. Water is scarce. Arable land is scarce. And the GCC is not alone, right? There are rich countries with similar issues. Singapore. Japan has issues. Korea has issues. Right? And so the point is when you are in that situation, what you need to do is understand that food sovereignty may simply be out of reach, and the aspiration should really be food security. So any person really thinking about food security in the GCC needs to think in a framework that I believe has three parts. The first is local capacity—what can we grow here, whether that's in the open field, in controlled environment agriculture, using aquaculture, aquaponics, what have you. You want to maximise domestic production. The second is diversified imports. You want to make sure that your imports are coming from multiple locations—that you're not subject to one route, one country, one conflict—and that you've built real redundancy into that system. And the third is foreign direct investment in agriculture abroad. And this is something that the GCC has been doing for many years. The idea that you have large government-controlled or sovereign wealth fund-controlled entities that are farming overseas—not just buying commodities from overseas, but that actually control land and actually control production overseas. And that becomes yet another buffer if things get dicey. And those three things together, I think, are what real food security in the GCC looks like. Not this sort of impossible dream of growing everything yourself. JAMIE: I suppose if you zoom out, the track record is maybe mixed. You could say, at least in public perception, we've seen a lot of high-profile failures that have done a lot to tarnish the image of it. Plenty in the US context—obviously, with Plenty going bankrupt early this year having raised $1 billion from SoftBank, Walmart, Jeff Bezos, etc. In Europe, we've had a couple as well—AppHarvest I think shut down in 2023, Eve Jones Food in the UK collapsed earlier this summer, Infarm in Germany relatively recently as well, which looked super promising. Against that backdrop, what's your take on where we're at with controlled environment agriculture today? What parts of it are still fundamentally viable and what's still hype? MARK: We need to be very careful when we talk about the bust in vertical agriculture and conflate that with controlled environment agriculture. These are not the same thing. Vertical agriculture is an idea that came about over the last, I don't know, 15 years. And the idea was that you could, using artificial lighting, grow plants—primarily horticultural crops, fruits and vegetables—in places that it would not otherwise be possible to do so. In particular, there was a time where this was called urban farming. The vision was, for example, AeroFarms had vertical farms in Newark, and the notion was you have people in cities and using vertical farms you can grow food—specifically greens or tomatoes or strawberries—near the areas of consumption. That has, for the most part, been a fucking disaster. That has not really worked. And that is where all of these high-profile bankruptcies—whether it is Plenty or AeroFarms—that has been that idea. The unit economics of that idea has, for the most part, not worked. Controlled environment agriculture is way, way older than that. Controlled environment agriculture are the greenhouses, the glasshouses in the Netherlands. They are the polyhouses in Morocco. This is not nearly as high-tech. Most controlled environment agriculture—you have some pretty barebones versions which is just putting up shade nets, or just putting up polyhouses. Most of them have some amount of drip irrigation. Some of them, then you start adding cooling systems and the like. Those are very, very old and ubiquitous, and some of the largest horticultural companies in the world use those systems. And those companies are doing hundreds of millions of dollars of revenue. So I'd be very careful when we conflate vertical ag with this other stuff. And I think it's important to understand that if you look at something like Pure Harvest, Pure Harvest was always CEA but it was never vertical ag. You know why? Because we don't need that in the desert. We don't lack light. There's plenty. There is a lot. And so we never really had vertical ag in India either, because we don't lack land, we don't lack heat, we don't lack light. On the other hand, the polyhouse sector—India doesn't really do glasshouses, it's too much CapEx—but the polyhouse sector in India is booming. It has been for a long time. And so I think you will see more and more controlled environment agriculture across the GCC, across the world, especially as climate change accelerates. But I think the unit economics of LED-centric vertical agriculture is quite dead right now. It's pretty hard. And it's also especially hard when what you're ultimately growing with all this technology is greens or a strawberry. JAMIE: How did we get swept up in it then? MARK: Yeah. Zero interest rates made lots of things make sense for a while. I also think there's the whole hype cycle—there was a hype cycle in alternative protein, there was a hype cycle in vertical ag. Many, many funds backed lots of both. We did neither, thank God. But I think there was this real bullishness about revolutionising food systems that basically failed to take into account price, willingness to pay, and actual consumer desire. And so I think we're all digging out from that still, and I think for funds that doubled and tripled down on them—some of those funds are zombies now. JAMIE: In terms of you mentioning that you avoided buying into this particular hype yourselves—were you presented with ample opportunity? MARK: We were. I mean, to be clear, it was never in India the same way. It was never like there were 100 alternative protein companies and 100 vertical ag companies. That was not the case. There were a couple of each. And we didn't spend as much time on vertical ag, but we definitely looked at the alternative protein sector. In fact, we had a fantastic little summit in February of 2020—what a time. We invited Bruce Friedrich from the Good Food Institute, who was one of the leading thinkers of the alternative protein movement. It was a joint event between the GFI, Xcellerator—the US VC that's very active in India—and Omnivore. We had about 20 or 30 entrepreneurs there and really dug into the opportunity. And I think ultimately, on the other side of that with COVID, people got really bullish. And I think our perspective was always rooted in a couple of ideas that we had about what works in India and what doesn't. One is a real aversion to copy-paste models from the West. There's a tendency in India sometimes to look at what happened in the US and say, "Okay, it's coming here, and therefore we should invest in it." There were a bunch of cold-pressed juice companies that people backed in 2015, being like, "This is really popular. Surely it makes sense in a country that's very price-sensitive, where there's an informal economy of juice vendors on every street." And thankfully we dodged some of those bullets. So I think we've always recognised that copy-paste models don't work. There was a further recognition, and I was on a bunch of podcasts where I was kind of the villain—I played the role of the contrarian villain in 2020 and 2021 and even 2022—basically saying, "India doesn't need alternative protein." And people were like, "No, no, no, no, no. This is so important." And it's like, not here. Let's start with the basics. Number one: roughly 40% of India is vegetarian. They don't want those products. And people are like, "No, no, no, but they could eat them." And it's like, yes, but alternative protein products are for the most part mock meat. And none of those people have a taste for meat, so they wouldn't want a meat analogue. They will actually find it disgusting. A massive change in consumption patterns. A massive change of taste. If you're a vegetarian and you don't really know what that umami taste is like—many, many Indian vegetarians won't eat mushrooms because they think they're too meaty in taste. So one, you have this vegetarian population. In India, we use this one wonderful term, "non-veg," to describe eating meat—because actually the default setting of the society is set to vegetarian, even though 60% of the society eats meat. But you have to ask for it, or it's on a separate table, or it's never what you are automatically served. And so the other reality about the 60% of the population that is non-vegetarian in India is they don't eat a lot of meat. Many of them eat meat once or twice a week. Or the role of meat in the diet is very supplementary—you're served multiple dishes and one of those dishes happens to have meat in it. The notion that we have in the West of "I'm sitting down to my steak and potatoes and the centre of the plate is a giant piece of steak"—that is, for the most part, not the diet in South Asia, in India. And so first of all you've got this huge vegetarian population. Second, the non-vegetarians don't eat much meat. And finally—and this was always one of my objections to the alternative protein movement—it was so devoid of understanding about economic power and economic concentration. This idea that we should replace farmers with factories owned by multinationals was something that I just didn't like. And I remember having an argument with a leading thinker in this space. I was like, "Listen, I eat quite a bit of mutton." Mutton in an Indian context is goat—can also mean sheep, but for the most part in India it refers to goats. "The mutton I eat is raised by literal shepherds, like biblical-style shepherds, in Rajasthan. That mutton is fed crop residues right after fields are harvested—so it's like the ultimate circular economy. There is no feeding of commercial feed or very little. There's almost no usage of antibiotics or any medicines. These goats are fattened and then brought into cities and then slaughtered. And the entire thing is an informal economy that employs tens, if not hundreds of thousands of people and provides livelihoods to them." "And you're telling me that I should replace that by a vat owned by a multinational corporation?" And it was funny, the guy was like, "Well, I really only care about animal welfare." And I'm like, "I get that—when you admit that, it all makes sense. But if you care about, I don't know, people. If you care about farmers or rural communities or landless shepherds that have been doing this since time immemorial—maybe that's not where we want to head." And so yeah, I mean, this is an old argument, but I was bashing people on the head about this five years ago and everyone thought we were idiots. And thankfully we didn't take those bets. JAMIE: Sweet, sweet vindication in the end. MARK: For now. Let's see. That's true. JAMIE: We were chatting briefly about Pure Harvest, and I think you mentioned that in practice, their success stems from the fact that they've adopted from inception a sort of agribusiness-first mindset—as opposed to a tech startup outlook and then sort of trying to retrofit thereafter. Can you expand on what it means to take an agribusiness-first approach in this space? MARK: So I'm a very big believer that one of the failures in agritech globally is a lack of understanding about end states. If you are building an agritech company, you have to understand what you're going to be when you grow up. Let me make a distinction here. I'm referring mostly to tech-enabled companies that are engaged in agricultural value chains. I'm not as much referring to deep tech companies that are producing a better robot—though it applies to that to some extent as well. If you're building a tech-enabled agritech and you're working in, let's say, seafood or horticulture or grain or cotton or what have you—you should have a good sense of what mature, scaled-up businesses look like in your sector. And if you're not building towards something like that, you should ask yourself if you really have a clear path to success. The notion that whatever you call yourself—"Oh, we're a platform"—it sounds nice, but ultimately you're going to have to be a participant in a value chain in some sort of end state that probably looks like a digitally native version of what is there right now. And that could be you become a retailer or you become a trader or a processor or a branded food company or what have you. But if you don't know what that looks like, you should study the space you're building in more. And additionally, whatever you are digitally disrupting right now, eventually you're going to have to be a boring agribusiness. And hopefully that digital-first approach allows you to scale much, much faster than some of the legacy companies that maybe are 150 years old. But you're going to eventually compete with those players and you're going to have to play their games. And so knowing what sort of end state you're building towards, I think, is very important. When we look at some of our portfolio companies in India, this notion of agribusiness end states—or agritech to agribusiness convergence—is something that we're always talking with these guys about. If you think about a company like Tractor Junction, which is a little bit under the radar but will announce a big round quite soon—Tractor Junction is one of the largest platforms for rural vehicle sales, tractors and light commercial vehicles. They run the leading online comparison portal for people that are thinking about making these purchases. And India is the largest tractor market in the world and has a huge market in commercial vehicles. They also run dealerships and then they have a financing business. But ultimately when you think about the end state here, the end state is this will be the largest rural used vehicle dealership network in the country. And people know what used car dealerships, used vehicle dealerships—that goes back many, many decades. Many of those companies are publicly listed. They have scaled. People have made great fortunes. But that's the—you can say, "Oh, this is a platform," but really when it goes public, what people are going to fundamentally understand is that this is a dealership network at scale. JAMIE: Can you tell me a little bit about the Omnivore origin story? What was the thesis, how it's evolved, and broadly where you're at with fund three? MARK: Look, I think when we started, I don't want to say it was naive, but it was definitely ahead of its time. I think the vision was—we were sitting there in a large agribusiness company, and startups were coming and asking us for money. And I had seen this a few years before I founded Omnivore—that there was sort of no capital that existed in India for startups that were building in this space, because for the most part the generalist VCs were focused on B2B SaaS or e-commerce. And so we said, "Cool, we're going to be the first, we're going to back this, off to the races." And I think we had a sense that there were opportunities in remote sensing, automation. I think for the most part we were looking at people that were building hardware. And so it's kind of funny because the "deep tech" ecosystem in India has really taken off in recent years, but we were doing hardware deals going back to 2012. Some of the first stuff we backed were hardware deals—people building IoT, people building automatic sprayers and the like. And so I think we backed the best things that came along that fit into this very, very narrow thesis. And for the most part that's how we behaved—2012, we started investing in 2011-12. So 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015. And then when we came back to market and became an independent, completely independent fund—that was when "agritech" in India had started to take off. It had started to take off globally, but in India it had also. Some of the generalist investors started participating, for the most part building platforms and marketplaces. And I always link the history in India to the history of the B2B marketplace phenomenon in India, which really starts in 2016 when e-commerce took a pause. There was a downturn that started in 2015 in Indian e-commerce that wiped out a bunch of startups. It was like a cataclysmic event in what had otherwise been an up-and-to-the-right process for many years. And in the wake of that event, some teams that had been part of some of the most successful e-commerce companies founded the first big B2B platforms—Udaan, for example, being a very notable one, where they came out of Flipkart. And the discovery of agritech came as some of these B2B platforms decided to focus on the agritech opportunity—many of them with absolutely terrible business models. And so when we came back and started investing again in 2018, we backed a mix of the kind of product companies we had backed earlier, plus some platforms and marketplaces—thankfully many of which have done quite well. But we were part of this overall take-off of the agritech sector and certainly the most active investor in it—largely seed stage at that point. And so we had a very large portfolio in that first independent fund—we had 31 companies from an $80 million fund. In retrospect, I wish it had been a smaller portfolio. I think it should have been maybe 20 to 25. That was sort of a learning for us. But that was because we were syndicating, the ecosystem was hot, hot, hot. And thankfully things have still gone very well there, but I wish we had had a slightly more concentrated portfolio with slightly larger ownership in our best companies. And when we came back to market—COVID happened, downturn starts mid-2022, we launched the new fund—we're like, "Oh God, this is going to be tough." And thankfully the earlier portfolio had done quite well, and people came in to back us to the tune of $215 million. And the biggest change that we made was saying, okay, number one, we are probably going to pivot from seed to Series A—largely because Series A pricing in India compressed starting in the second half of 2022 and early 2023, and continues to be much more muted than it was in the stupid days of 2020 and 2021, but also in 2019. People forget that the crazy valuations that we saw during the pandemic really started a little bit earlier. The pandemic slowed things down for a second and then free money meant everything took off. But it was building on a wave that had started earlier. And so we've pivoted to being largely a Series A/pre-Series A investor. We do seed much less frequently now. And some of that is also because there is kind of a glut of seed capital in India. There are so many solo GPs, so many family offices that have entered the seed stage, micro VCs. And you have the multi-stage funds that have come heavily into seed—some of the largest funds in India—in order to build early pipeline. And I think our conclusion from this was, "Cool, that's great. Let's look at Series A where pricing has become quite reasonable relative to traction and focus there. And if we go earlier, we go earlier. We still do for some entrepreneurs some of the time." I think the other big change is our bullishness about platforms and marketplaces has definitely diminished. There were too many of them funded from 2017 until 2022. And now when we do them, I think—and to be clear, some of those are excellent, like Tractor Junction is great, RuTi is great, it's been a good run—but when we do them now, our real belief is that you have to get the unit economics and the cash conversion cycle right from day one. And there is no point in building lots and lots of GMV that doesn't have those unit economics and cash conversion cycles in it. And I think there were a lot of agritech startups that were built in that time in India and Southeast Asia that were able to show huge scale, but I think in retrospect, not a lot of value creation for anyone. The dangerous and terrifying thing about marketplaces is that you can generate GMV without creating a lot of value. The example I've always used that's become very real to me is: let's imagine you're trying to build a B2B marketplace and you raise a $3 million seed round. You can probably get loans on top of that equity—working capital loans—that will allow you to do a multiple on that equity check. So $3 million of equity could probably do another $6 million of working capital. So you can play with that $9 million. And depending on how many times you can rotate that $9 million, you can have a GMV that very quickly looks like $30, $40, $50 million. And the problem is then people were giving the next round valuation on that GMV without really digging hard enough into where did all of this GMV come from. Because it's also very easy to go to existing market participants and say, "Digitise your trades with me because I get more valuation from it." But all you've done is become a middleman taking out other middlemen. And so I think that was a real problem in the Indian B2B ecosystem that thankfully, as people have gotten a lot more sceptical, has largely washed out. Where people are doing B2B marketplaces today, there is a much clearer source of value for the participants involved. We see this with some of the people that we're backing now, like Simplify or Aggregate, which are really full-stack CDMOs—contract development and manufacturing organisations. They do trade, but the hook for them is the ability to fill the capacities of factories in India with more business. So they create a lot of value for those factory owners, and they create value for their customers with work around formulation, new products, and the like. And so I think we're pretty sceptical now about people that are just effectively using venture capital to build trading businesses. JAMIE: I think we've seen something similar in a MENA context as well. You're starting to see consolidation of the B2B marketplaces. And it doesn't necessarily seem—it seems more enforced from a survival perspective as opposed to consolidating for the sake of a land grab opportunity. Can I ask as well—you mentioned the fundraising process doing that post-2022. Interesting time to be doing that. Obviously you have the track record and the pedigree and a couple of exits under your belt as well. Has the LP base shifted over time? Did the climate framing help, to be blunt? MARK: I think it did. I mean, I think if you think about a 2022-23-24 fundraise, climate was not a dirty word at that point. It has suddenly—people are a lot more... there are connotations now. But I think it's something that is not—I think it's still, it's a little bit funny because coming from India, there's no debate about climate. That's the bizarre thing to me about the US. India is aggressively working on climate. It is at the pointy spear of climate change. Indian agriculture will get badly mauled if efforts at adaptation and resilience aren't successful. And also like mitigation matters. And so—but it's really funny. Climate is not a political issue in India. There's no one in India on the right or the left who's like, "Yeah, it's not getting warmer." There's obviously, India has incredible energy needs, but India is also throwing down solar faster than almost any place in the world. And so it's so funny to me how politicised this issue is, so divisive in the US. And likewise in Europe—the European debate is very different. The European debate is not whether there is climate change. It is a question of what should we do about it and what price should be paid and how much of it is on our small country's historical emissions, or how much should be on our agricultural sector. You wind up with these farmer strikes in the Netherlands. But it's a much more grounded and practical debate. The American debate is bizarre. The American debate is a discussion about like, "Climate is the most important issue in the world" on one side, or "It's not man-made, it does not exist" on the other. And it's kind of hard to grapple with in the US because of this incredible divide. And I think there is sort of a happy medium, which is to say, yes, there is climate change, we need to do something about it fast. And probably some of the things that we need to do—I don't think it's a bad thing that the US is working on, probably the statement of a kid from Houston—I don't think it's a bad thing that we're generally working across the energy stack. What I dislike is where we decide that sources like wind and solar don't matter. And that's insane. Why would we unilaterally disarm and take away some of these tools? And similarly, I think there are essentially own goals on the other side, like Germany shutting down its nuclear plants where France is humming along status quo. I think we need a lot less dogmatism about this and sort of a recognition: we need energy, there are a lot of different ways to do it, we should do the things that make sense, we should stop doing the things that don't make sense, we should clean up every source. But I am a very boring centrist. I'm like the last centrist moderate. JAMIE: There's some of us out there. Few and far between these days, it seems. But respect it nonetheless. I'd love to chat about life sciences as well, because I think that's something that you're more acutely leaning into potentially in this fund—looking at animal health, bioinformatics, precision fermentation, that kind of thing. Why now? What's changed that the timing is right for that sort of investment? MARK: So I think it's a very India-specific point. India has missed a beat on life sciences. If you think about where the US is and where China is—and Europe kind of happily muddling along, it's not a bad thing, it's what we do—India did not put the same emphasis on life sciences. And I like to think of it from a perspective of talent. 30 years ago, the best and brightest coders left India and moved to California. The best and brightest MBAs left India and moved to New York or London or what have you. At some point, that brain drain—we used to use this term "brain drain" circa 2005, 2010—kind of stopped. I think as the Indian economy really took off in the aughts and then continued in the teens, and as the startup ecosystem took off—so it was no longer just about working at Unilever for 30 years—more and more of the best and brightest in India stayed home. And some of this was also the challenges of immigration, and some of this was kind of a recognition that the upside that America offered or Canada offered wasn't as good as it used to be, relative to a chugging, fast-growing Indian economy where you get to be near your parents and be near your families and be in your community. And so for the most part, I think a lot of financial talent, managerial talent, tech talent started staying back in India. And that has really continued. There is still obviously a lot of emigration, but I don't think it's anywhere near—especially with respect to elite talent—what it used to be. Those aspirations have changed. But life sciences in India continues to haemorrhage talent. There's a bunch of reasons. One is that India does not—while India has insanely great undergraduate education because it is such a nightmare to get through those processes, such an incredible talent selection—the postgraduate education in India isn't quite at the level of the IITs, if you will. And so a lot of people go abroad for their masters and PhDs. The best and brightest in India right now—you have exceptions, the Indian Institute of Science near us in Bangalore is one—but you have a lot of people that head to, whether it's Cambridge, Massachusetts or Cambridge, England. They head abroad for their PhDs and then they stay there, and very few of those people come home. And while India has a very strong pharma ecosystem, actual biotech is still dominated by the players that dominated it 20 or 30 years ago. And there were very few of them. And so you haven't seen this same kind of life sciences take-off that, for example, China built over the last three decades by encouraging its diaspora—the best and brightest of its diaspora—to come home. And so that is something that I think maybe about five years ago, we started saying, "Look, we want to do something about this. And we want to start helping those entrepreneurs that are coming home or that never left—to provide capital to life sciences because it is so critical for India's future, and it's so critical that we build this ecosystem." And that has gone beyond just capital. We've launched a non-profit—"non-profit" sounds funny—an organisation in partnership with Nucleate called BioWave, with a lot of support from IndieBio. Nucleate, for folks that don't know, is an organisation of postgraduate—so graduate school students—who are interested in bioenterprise. It is not an Indian thing; it is like a Harvard and Yale and Stanford and Oxford thing. It is an organisation of these students largely in Europe and North America. India of course has a chapter. And the goal with BioWave is to bring more and more capital to back life science startups in India. So we started by doing deals ourselves, but now we're building this larger organisation to really drive this ecosystem—to encourage entrepreneurs to come home, to support those entrepreneurs that are there, and to make people aware of the leaps and gains that are being made in the Indian life sciences sector, because otherwise it definitely flies under the radar. But by the way, hardware and space tech was totally under the radar five years ago, and now it's not. So our view is that life and material sciences might be a little under the radar right now, but there is a lot that is coming. Give it time. Let it cook, as Gen Z would say. JAMIE: My God. Kill it with fire. That's going to be an introduction that I can guarantee you... Maybe we should talk about Eruvaka as well. It's something—you have the technologies. MARK: Eruvaka. There you go. JAMIE: It's okay. It's a Telugu word describing a weather pattern? MARK: Yeah. I'm not sure an Irish kid needs to be able to pronounce that. JAMIE: Unlikely. MARK: We can go to Andhra Pradesh and ask them if they can properly pronounce the Irish Prime Minister. That's the flip side. JAMIE: There you go. We'll do it. We'll set aside time in 2026. But that was super interesting when I was reading about it. You guys first got involved back in 2013? MARK: Oh yeah. No, it was an early corporate venture investment in a young entrepreneur named Shriram Ravi. Shriram had worked in the semiconductor space and was a brilliant hardware engineer. And at some point he had quit his multinational job and gone back to his small town—a small city in coastal Andhra Pradesh—and had started working in aquaculture. Basically, there's a long story about it that he used to tell about how an uncle of his had lost a bunch of money in fish and shrimp farming. And he had decided to, in a shed, build some IoT tools. He had built a prototype and he had a couple of farmers using it, and we saw it and we thought it was cool. And this was in our days where we were like, "Ah, okay, this is the kind of innovation we want to back." And ultimately, about five years later, Nutreco—which is a Dutch multinational and basically the leading aqua nutrition player in the world—decided to do their first ever venture deal by investing in Eruvaka. And then ultimately acquired it, I guess three or four years later. JAMIE: And you guys—what was your stake? MARK: Oh, we owned like 30%. It was an enormous stake because we had come in when the company barely existed. And so that was an excellent exit, and it became kind of the digital arm of Nutreco. And it had really scaled up. It's interesting—it had scaled up not just in India, but the biggest chunk of the business was in Ecuador. JAMIE: Really? Ecuador is a shrimp powerhouse? MARK: No idea, right? The best shrimp. The best-tasting shrimp—well, I mean, if I say this, there are going to be some Indian shrimp farmers... JAMIE: That's a big claim. If you want to roll back on that one... MARK: It is what people are saying. People are saying that the shrimp grown in Ecuador are the largest, cleanest-tasting aquaculture shrimp. And that's kind of the market reputation. And so you have farmers there that are quite large, that are willing to invest a lot, and that bought a lot of these systems. And so ultimately Eruvaka was acquired by Nutreco. It was a great exit for us. And it helped sort of validate the thesis that you can build global tech from India. And we see this in a lot of companies that we back now, like Niqo Robotics. Jaisimha is definitely from a less rural background—he went to Carnegie Mellon and he worked at BlackRock for many years in New York. But he moved back to India to kind of bring tech to farms. And it's interesting—he originally worked in drones, but drones were more or less illegal in India until 2021. And so he quickly pivoted to terrestrial robots and has built the lowest-cost robotic platform in the world, and arguably one of the best see-and-spray systems in the world. And he started out commercialising in India. But these days, he's selling like crazy in California. And so this whole thing of "build in India for the world" is quite real. We've been doing it for a long time. And we continue to back founders that are building tech in India for the world. JAMIE: From an exit perspective, what do you expect the more natural outcome is? Is it—I guess Eruvaka was a good example as far as your agribusiness convergence theory, and Nutreco is a natural buyer for a business like that. Do you expect it to come via public markets or is it acquisitions from larger agribusiness? MARK: I think it's all of the above. I think in India there are like three paths to exit. One path is M&A. And I think that's largely going to be for product companies. I don't think a lot of platforms and marketplaces can be acquired—makes sense, right? There are very few people that would want to. You could imagine a large farm retailer being acquired, but I think that's more of a stretch. The second is this whole space of secondaries, which has really, really taken off. There are more and more great players in secondary funds that buy out VC positions, recognising that with the time-limited nature of Indian VC funds—or any VC funds—there's an opportunity to buy those assets and create DPI, create liquidity for those funds. And those funds are willing to sell them, sometimes at a little bit of a discount, making the model of secondary funds very viable. And there's also other forms of secondaries—just bilateral secondaries. Some company is raising a pre-IPO round, it's super hot, they're raising $100 million, there's $200 million of demand. Great—you have a secondary. And then IPOs. The first Indian agritech IPOs will be happening over the next, I think, 24 months. And the nice thing in India is the public markets are very good both for taking things at scale public but also for taking deep tech public. There was a very successful IPO of a drone company—mostly a defence-focused drone company, but a drone company—that was many times oversubscribed. And so I think we see the potential with product companies as well—if they are profitable, to take them public. And so there's a lot—I think that's one of the nice things in the Indian market: it's a huge M&A destination, there's deep secondaries, there's deep public markets. And that creates a lot of liquidity and a lot of opportunity for exits that I think many countries wish they had. JAMIE: One of the last things I want to ask you about is this idea of value-add. And I'm particularly interested in this in an agritech context as well. It's probably one of the most overused phrases, and I think there's debates regionally about—exactly. Everyone keeps playing the same Vinod Khosla clip. MARK: It's just about quotes, right? JAMIE: I've ruined it. I'm sorry. MARK: It's that ubiquitous. I have it right here. I'm going to quote it to you. JAMIE: "Most VCs add zero value. Some add negative value." What does value-add look like for you guys? MARK: I think many sectoral funds add value. And I think it is very different than the value that is added by general funds. JAMIE: I was going to say, naturally. MARK: And my sense of the Khosla quote was that he was really talking about the pure money funds. Maybe he's talking about everyone, but I think if you took a sample of Omnivore portfolio companies and said, "Has there been value-add?" I think the answer is yes. And I think the answer is there has been value-add in terms of actual business. Because we come with a global network in agribusiness. So we've been able to help with strategic partnerships. We've been able to help with literally B2B business overseas. I went to Germany last year to help a portfolio company ink a deal for exports of an innovative biological product. And we've also built Omnivore with people from the sector. One of the things that we always say is you want us on your cap table because the people that are going to be working with you are not generalists. They are people who have been in this industry, that have built in this industry. And we have some very senior people attached to Omnivore. For example, Dr. H.K. Barnala, the former chairman of the National Agriculture Bank in India. We have the former head of Bayer's Seeds business. We have the former head of the second-largest dairy and food processing company in India. And so we have these people as advisers and supporters for portfolio companies. And I think it adds an incredible amount of value and perspective and connections and support. So I think it's somewhat the way that we're built. I also think that we have a culture in Omnivore of rolling up our sleeves—because we started out so small and so early and everything was so goddamn hard that we got very used to the idea that you roll up your sleeves and you dig in. And sometimes we find it very frustrating when we work with generalist VCs that don't do this. They're like, "Yeah, it didn't work out. It's fine." And it's like, "Wait, we haven't done the hard part yet. We're good at this part." And we've been good at actually turning things around. I mean, listen, the story of Eruvaka is: before it was a great exit, it had two weeks of cash in the bank and almost shut down in 2016. And there was that part of just digging in and making this connection to Nutreco and encouraging a pivot from the domestic market to overseas. And yeah, I think Omnivore is good at this. JAMIE: What are you most excited about? MARK: I mean, the thing I'm most excited about sitting in Dubai is trying to build this food bridge and this technology and this agritechnology bridge between India and the GCC. I think that is—if I'm going to be on this podcast—that is what I would say I am most excited about. JAMIE: Brilliant, Mark. Thank you very, very much. Appreciate your time. Great having you here. MARK: Thank you. --- [END OF EPISODE]