Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Smiling Lieutenant (1931)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:16at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. That confused me. That sounded
- 0:23wrong, but that was right. Well, I shared with
- 0:25you off pod that I'm very, like, my sinuses are
- 0:28killing me today. So I was wondering when you
- 0:31said, like, I think you got that wrong. I was
- 0:32like, did I? It was absolutely right. Okay. It
- 0:35was like my brain was catching up. Mine too.
- 0:38Hey, what do you think of the new theme song?
- 0:40Let's talk about this. We're like four or five
- 0:42episodes into the new theme song, but this is
- 0:44the first time you and me are talking about it.
- 0:46So this is the first time that we're talking
- 0:48about it or recording once that theme is available.
- 0:51Right. So you're right. I really like it. I think
- 0:54it's like a nice, I really like the idea of having
- 0:56a different intro than an outro. So, and you
- 0:59have like, it's the same song, but it's different
- 1:00sections of it. Right. So, and I guess that was
- 1:02technically the case with the last one too. But
- 1:04no, I'm really liking this one so far. Look at
- 1:06all the applause. We're getting, look at everyone's
- 1:09reception to it. Everyone loves it. Hopefully.
- 1:11Guys, at home, if you do have feelings on it,
- 1:14like, just let us know what you think, if you
- 1:16enjoy it, if you don't. Probably won't change
- 1:17it if you don't like it, but I'd still like to
- 1:19hear. Your thoughts matter. Yeah. Not enough
- 1:22for us to change it, but they matter. Exactly.
- 1:25Besides that, we are back today talking about
- 1:28the fifth Academy year. I'm super excited for
- 1:31this year because this is the first time since
- 1:33we started the show, my cadence is weird, that
- 1:36we're talking about movies that I haven't seen
- 1:37yet. Not technically true. I know we've got like
- 1:40the new, the modern, yeah. But that's a little
- 1:43different. For sure. This is the first time we're
- 1:45going back and experiencing. What is happening,
- 1:48dude? My chair just like. Is it creaking nonstop?
- 1:51Oh my God. That just like spun. The arms on my
- 1:54chair? Okay. Clearly we're possessed. Studio's
- 1:57possessed right now. Let me square up to the
- 1:59mic and stuff. Guys, you excited for the fifth
- 2:03Academy year? It's chaos. Your chair is. But
- 2:05I think it's cool that we come back to the fifth
- 2:08Academy year and... We start off with a director
- 2:10that we're very familiar with, and I think we
- 2:13both enjoy quite a bit. Yeah, definitely. I mean,
- 2:16you know, we've talked about Ernst Lubitsch previously
- 2:18with The Love Parade, and we talked off -pod
- 2:22and also on -pod back for the Love Parade episode
- 2:24how there is a Criterion collection of Ernst
- 2:27Lubitsch musicals that have four movies in them,
- 2:30three of them being The Love Parade, One Hour
- 2:33With You, which we'll talk about later this season,
- 2:35and the movie we're talking about today, The
- 2:37Smiling Lieutenant. Yes. There is a fourth movie
- 2:39that we think might be called Cavalcade. We're
- 2:41not 100 % sure. Pretty sure that's what it's
- 2:43called. It's not Charade. Should I look it up?
- 2:45Sure. Let's look it up. Monte Carlo. Monte Carlo.
- 2:49Sure. Okay. I don't know where we got Cavalcade
- 2:51from. That is nominated, but I don't think that's
- 2:53a Lewish movie. There you go. So it has Cavalcade.
- 2:57Oh my God, I did it again. It has Monte Carlo,
- 3:01One Hour With You. which we'll talk about later
- 3:03this season, the love parade that we've talked
- 3:06about previously, and then our movie for today,
- 3:08which is The Smiling Lieutenant. Absolutely.
- 3:10And you do own this Criterion Collection, correct?
- 3:14I do, but I own the DVD. The DVD of this came
- 3:17out before the Blu -ray. Oh, okay. The Blu -ray
- 3:19just came out like a month or two ago. So it
- 3:22is available, and I would like to update that
- 3:23at some point. But this was the first of those
- 3:26movies I ended up watching on disc, because Love
- 3:29Parade I caught on YouTube before I was able
- 3:32to pick up this on DVD. So very excited to talk
- 3:36about the quality of that, how it looks on DVD,
- 3:39and I'm very excited to hear how you felt about
- 3:40watching the Blu -ray. I actually don't know
- 3:42if I watched the Blu -ray. No, I must have, because
- 3:44the PS5 won't play a DVD. I don't think. It will.
- 3:46Will it? Yeah. I have no idea what I watch then.
- 3:48It will, as far back as DVDs, it will play up.
- 3:52But you can't put like an 8 -track or VHS in
- 3:55there. Fair play. I don't know if you've tried
- 3:57that. I did watch part of the collection as well,
- 3:59the Criterion. I actually rented it from the
- 4:02Atlanta video store, Videodrome. Big fan. Which
- 4:06I love Videodrome. I love just going in there
- 4:09sometimes and walking around. And they probably
- 4:10hate that. But I just walk in and they're like,
- 4:13can I help you find anything? And I said, no.
- 4:16I found my home. Thank you. Do you ever feel
- 4:18like, and that's a very sweet thing to feel,
- 4:20but do you also feel like part of you is ever
- 4:21Ron Swanson from Parks and Recreation? No. Where
- 4:25someone's like, hey, can I help you? And you're
- 4:26like, I know more than you. Never. Not once.
- 4:30Actually, when I was grabbing this movie, the
- 4:32guy came over and he was like, can I help you
- 4:34find anything? I'm looking for the Lubitsch collection.
- 4:36And like, he immediately went to the shelf, pulled
- 4:39it off, handed me, this was probably coincidence,
- 4:42but handed me the right. disc from the collection
- 4:44that had both the movies from this year and i
- 4:46was just like you're a god how did you know he's
- 4:49like i listen he was incredible he knows that
- 4:51we're talking about smiling lieutenant so he
- 4:52just pulled that for you yeah i did mention the
- 4:54podcast i mean he's talking about the fifth academy
- 4:55awards right now how did you know but yeah let's
- 4:59let's get into it i'm excited so the smiling
- 5:01lieutenant came out in 1931 to add to the confusion
- 5:05of the early academy years this was directed
- 5:07by ernst lubitsch starring marie chevalier Claudette
- 5:11Colbert, Miriam Hopkins, and Charles Ruggles.
- 5:14I also have George Barbier as King Adolf XV.
- 5:18Very nice. You know, just to go one out from
- 5:20you. I think there's one more person in the movie
- 5:23that gets credited, but I don't remember who
- 5:25it is. So we're both wrong. We'll take that.
- 5:26So this had one nomination and this was specifically
- 5:28Outstanding Production on behalf of Paramount
- 5:30Publix. So it's not the last time that we'll
- 5:33talk about a movie here that was nominated for
- 5:35one thing and it being Best Picture. But how
- 5:38did you feel watching this and knowing that the
- 5:41only nomination that we saw was Outstanding Production?
- 5:44I think it's something to think about when the
- 5:47first movie we cover, for this year is one of
- 5:50those because I'm like okay well what what was
- 5:52nominated for cinematography or writing like
- 5:54where are those nominations gonna go especially
- 5:57because spoiler alert I enjoyed this movie so
- 6:00it's kind of like well there are things better
- 6:03than this I'm excited this this is good uh foreboding
- 6:07I guess but I really enjoyed it I mean we we
- 6:10can talk about the comparisons to Love Parade
- 6:12and Smiling Lieutenant when we get to it but
- 6:14the uh general plot of The Smiling Lieutenant
- 6:17is Nikki, who is a Marie Chevalier. He is a lieutenant
- 6:22in the army, and not a surprise, picking right
- 6:24back up from Love Parade, a bit of a player.
- 6:26Yeah. Just gets around, and he ends up going
- 6:30to an all -women orchestra with his friend to
- 6:33see someone that his friend is interested in,
- 6:35and that rat, Scallion, is interested in that
- 6:38woman instead. And that ends up being Francie?
- 6:41Francie. Francie. So that's Claudette Colbert.
- 6:45And they end up striking up a romance and it
- 6:48is kind of forbidden. It is kind of how it feels
- 6:51like the lieutenant isn't supposed to have that
- 6:53kind of relationship. But then specifically while
- 6:56attending a parade. for a love parade, if you
- 6:59will, for the king and princess of Flossentherm.
- 7:04He ends up winking and smiling and laughing at
- 7:07Franzi, but the princess, Princess Anna, actually
- 7:11is driving by in a chariot while this happens
- 7:14and mistakes this advance towards her, which
- 7:18of course is a legal offense and something that
- 7:21he ends up having to answer to the king and the
- 7:23princess themselves. And in order to get out
- 7:26of this, he kind of charms his way. into their
- 7:28life and ends up being more involved in Princess
- 7:31Anna's life than he originally intended. And
- 7:33that is The Smiling Lieutenant. So what did you
- 7:35think about The Smiling Lieutenant overall? It's
- 7:37so much fun. It is a lot of fun. I think that's
- 7:41just what you have to look forward to, at least
- 7:44in all of these Lubitsch musicals. Like, I can't
- 7:47wait for one hour with you. I've heard it's not...
- 7:49Thanks, buddy. I've heard it's not the strongest
- 7:53of the musicals, but just... Knowing what you
- 7:55get from Lubitsch and how how much comedy is
- 7:59involved and not just in like the dialogue, but
- 8:02also in the deliverance of like Maurice Chevalier's
- 8:06singing. It's so unique. It's not like really
- 8:10great, beautiful, melodic singing. It's played
- 8:13for laughs. It's it's kind of Muppety at times.
- 8:16And I'm all for that. I also like the opening
- 8:20of this movie. Did you enjoy? Like the physical,
- 8:23not even physical comedy, almost like the editing
- 8:26comedy. Yes. Isn't it cool? I very much enjoy
- 8:29that. I think what you're referring to is the
- 8:30opening of the movie is a tailor ends up walking
- 8:33up to Nikki's house and knocking to try and get
- 8:36his attention to pay his bill that he hasn't
- 8:39paid. charges upon charges of gray army pants
- 8:43or jacket and he hasn't paid it and he knocks
- 8:45multiple times rings the doorbell which by the
- 8:47way we got to talk about that doorbell i think
- 8:49that was of the time in the 1930s but still i
- 8:51want to talk about it but then ends up leaving
- 8:53and as he's leaving going down the stairs a woman
- 8:55walks past him and she has a specific knock on
- 8:58the door yeah when she makes that knock then
- 9:00the door opens all of a sudden because he Nikki's
- 9:03aware of who's at the other side of that door.
- 9:05And I really liked the editing of this. That
- 9:07then cuts to another bit of the editing that
- 9:09you talked about, the light being off and then
- 9:12turning on and then turning off again to kind
- 9:14of show the passing of time after this has happened.
- 9:16I really liked the comedic side of the editing
- 9:19here. So I agree with you. You know, it is a
- 9:21musical, but the music itself is a lot more vaudevillian.
- 9:27than it is like, you know, what we've come to
- 9:29expect from like an Andrew Lloyd Webber type
- 9:30situation. Sure. Those tend to push the narrative
- 9:33along in a very catchy, rhythmic way. And this
- 9:37is almost like a little, almost like nursery
- 9:39rhyme. Like they're almost like little nursery
- 9:41rhymes. The one that he keeps coming back to,
- 9:43Nikki, is the ra -ta -ta -ta -ta -ta -ta -ta,
- 9:46like this, that over and over, and that pattern.
- 9:48And you're right. He doesn't have a great voice
- 9:50or anything. But one thing I want to talk to
- 9:51you about, and this is kind of right off the
- 9:53bat, after he has that scene with the woman who
- 9:55comes to visit him, he then has a song that he
- 9:57sings, but he's actually singing it directly
- 9:59into the camera. Right, yeah. This is not something
- 10:01I remember happening in Love Parade. No, I don't
- 10:03think that does happen. But I think that's kind
- 10:06of the thing. He's presenting to you who he is
- 10:11and what he's looking for and kind of breaking
- 10:13the fourth wall there. I think that song is a
- 10:15lot of fun. And again, His style of singing,
- 10:18I don't even know if I would say he's a bad singer
- 10:20because he might be great, but I think his characters,
- 10:22he specifically does this very playful, I don't
- 10:26know, it's like he's winking at the camera with
- 10:28his voice in a way. Yes, that's a good way to
- 10:31put it. Like he's aware of his talent. Yeah.
- 10:34Quote unquote, like either lack of or amount
- 10:37of talent that he has. That's clear in the way
- 10:39that he's singing here. And it is interesting
- 10:41because obviously this leads the way for what
- 10:43musicals become, but it's very a different look
- 10:46of what musicals are. There are maybe, I think,
- 10:48five songs that I counted that happened throughout
- 10:50the movie. And then, of course, we see musicals
- 10:53like Les Mis, where the movie itself, well, I
- 10:56mean, the stage play as well, but the entirety
- 10:59of the movie is done in sing -song form. So we've
- 11:02seen the evolution of what these become. And
- 11:04this was kind of an interesting, you know, step
- 11:06from Love Parade in the sense that it felt like
- 11:08it was more they use the songs comedically than
- 11:11they did in Love Parade. Love Parade was a little
- 11:12bit more narrative focused. This was a little
- 11:14bit more intentions. Yes. And you can see it
- 11:18even when there's not like singing, just when
- 11:20the music is playing. For example, the girl that
- 11:23runs up the stairs after the tailor leaves. The
- 11:25string instruments kind of have that like...
- 11:27Yes. As she's going up the stairs. Yeah, it's
- 11:30very like a Mickey Mouse cartoon kind of thing.
- 11:33So... Specifically, this was Conrad Salinger.
- 11:35That was the composer behind the score here.
- 11:37And this inspired the MGM musicals of like the
- 11:4040s and the 50s. So the decade and two decades
- 11:43to come after that. And it's exactly what you're
- 11:45talking about, where the music kind of matches
- 11:47the characters. And you'll see this, you know,
- 11:49there's a scene I'm jumping ahead here where
- 11:51Francie and... princess anna are walking out
- 11:54of a room from him just having like a song together
- 11:56and when francie walks out the theme is very
- 11:59like subdued and kind of solemn but then princess
- 12:02anna walks out kind of hurriedly and the score
- 12:04picks up just a little bit of pace to match this
- 12:07and i really like this this was something we
- 12:09didn't see in love parade so i love how they're
- 12:11kind of i mean i say they salinger and lubitsch
- 12:14together are evolving the musical just from like
- 12:17two, three years from what we've seen. So the
- 12:20whole reason that I really enjoy doing this pod,
- 12:22well, with you, that's one. But the other thing
- 12:25I really like doing about this pod is the history
- 12:27of it. And we see the evolution of things. Yes.
- 12:29And it's really cool that we're already seeing
- 12:31the evolution of musicals from what Lubitsch
- 12:33did previously with Love Parade to this. Yeah.
- 12:36Speaking of musicals, one thing that I find interesting,
- 12:40I've talked about like when I'm on set, so many
- 12:43people are like... yeah, I don't really watch
- 12:44movies. I'm like, what? I don't understand that.
- 12:47But when you do find somebody that's into movies,
- 12:50even unprovoked, it comes up very often that,
- 12:53yeah, I don't like musicals. I can't get into
- 12:55them. And that's always been so bizarre to me
- 12:58because people love music and people love movies.
- 13:02What don't you like about combining them? You
- 13:04know, it's funny. We had just been talking about
- 13:07world building and movies like John Wick or the
- 13:09Ready or Not franchise where it's the establishing
- 13:12of rules. So you know what this world lives in.
- 13:15And musicals can be such a wide ranging of variety
- 13:19of what kind of musicals there are. I mentioned
- 13:21Les Mis, sing -songy throughout all three hours
- 13:24of that. Some even longer with the show. Mamma
- 13:27Mia, more of a jukebox musical. Then you have
- 13:29something like Love Parade where it is narratively
- 13:32focused. but it doesn't really communicate like
- 13:34the characters. That's the song, not the score.
- 13:37But then you have movies like The Smiling Lieutenant,
- 13:39where yes, people are singing songs, but the
- 13:42score really is its own kind of musical piece
- 13:45here, right? Like it's telling a different version
- 13:47of that story. So I think the reason for that
- 13:49is that it's kind of like saying, I don't like
- 13:51horror movies. You do. You just, you prefer like
- 13:54Monster Squad versus like... Right. Like you're,
- 13:58you're more horror, like, like Gremlins is like
- 14:00perfect, like little, like children's horror.
- 14:02Yeah. You have to find your sub genre in the
- 14:04genre. Cause I mean, you know, I can't remember
- 14:07the last time I said that I hated, like I didn't
- 14:09enjoy one genre and there's one, not one movie
- 14:12that I enjoyed from that genre. I don't love
- 14:14anime historically, but there's anime that I've
- 14:17seen that I've really enjoyed. It's just not
- 14:19indicative of the rest of the anime that I've
- 14:20seen. So I think it's, people have tried the
- 14:23wrong version of it. Now I say that. And I don't
- 14:26want to perpetuate the idea of what's been perpetuated
- 14:31to me with anime, where I'm like, yeah, I've
- 14:32watched like five different series, like 10 seasons,
- 14:35and I'm just not into it. Someone's like, no,
- 14:36you just haven't watched my favorite one yet.
- 14:38I'm like, oh, man. Yeah. Come on. But with musicals
- 14:40especially, there's so many different versions
- 14:42that you can get into that I agree with you.
- 14:44It's kind of strange when someone says they're
- 14:45not a fan of them generally. I think I turn to
- 14:48like Disney movies, especially like growing up,
- 14:51being a 90s baby or whatever. Right. And I think
- 14:55that's what attracts me so much to these early
- 14:58musicals is, again, the music kind of being used
- 15:02to choreograph characters in a way that's not
- 15:05dance. It's just their actions is very reminiscent
- 15:07of Disney cartoons or Looney Tunes cartoons and
- 15:11the music. There's a beat of music when a character
- 15:14trips and bumps their head kind of thing. And
- 15:16it's played for laughs. It's played for emotion.
- 15:19It's played for all of these things that helps
- 15:21paint your characters without having them ever
- 15:24speak a word. I love that type of musical. And
- 15:27that's what this early style is. Right, because
- 15:30you don't want him to come out and say things
- 15:32like... I sleep around. I enjoy the company of
- 15:35a woman. The song kind of does that, especially
- 15:37when, I mean, that opening song is, I love it
- 15:40when she rat -ta -ta -ta -ta -ta -ta. Like, all
- 15:43right, man, you're just going to, honestly, a
- 15:45bar. Because how that's not a rap song from the
- 15:482000s. It's coming. It's coming. But one thing
- 15:51that is kind of communicated by other people
- 15:53about Nicki is this term that keeps repeating.
- 15:56Throughout the movie. Do you know what I'm talking
- 15:57about? Not the rat -a -ta -ta -ta -ta -ta? Not
- 15:59a theme like music, but more a title that they
- 16:03give him. Son of a Gun. Oh, yes. Is something
- 16:05that they refer to a lot with Nicky. And it's
- 16:08interesting because I really like the satire
- 16:10of this movie. We see, I'm jumping back a little
- 16:13bit here, we're introduced to the king and princess
- 16:15of Flossentherm on the boat or the train on the
- 16:19way to Vienna where this is set. Interesting
- 16:22thing. I mean, Vienna, obviously a very real
- 16:24place. Flossentherm. It's not. And I guess the
- 16:26reason why is they make a mockery of the king
- 16:29and princess at time to time from this, and they
- 16:30don't want that to be a geopolitical issue. Right.
- 16:33So they created Flossentherm. There's a whole
- 16:35bit in there about how the emperor of Vienna
- 16:38writes to the king and has misspelled Flossentherm.
- 16:42And while he's offended by this, his daughter,
- 16:45the princess, very much kind of goads him on
- 16:48where she's like, well, that's because they don't
- 16:49think we're worthy of the letters. Like she perpetuates
- 16:52the idea of they're not responsible. When in
- 16:55reality, it's just an honest mistake. And in
- 16:58the letter itself, he does address it with age.
- 17:00This even comes back to when they're interrogating,
- 17:03or rather the king is interrogating Nikki for
- 17:05what he has done to Princess Anna. And he asks
- 17:09him how he spells Flossentherm. So the satire
- 17:12of these royals and the way that they have like
- 17:15way too... Big of a head for themselves. Right.
- 17:19Really enjoyed that aspect. And that's where
- 17:21we see the son of a gun come in. We see a lot
- 17:24of Nikki specifically kind of working the room,
- 17:27right? Whether it be with other women or his
- 17:29friends and kind of cheating his friend a little
- 17:31bit when he first meets Francie. We see the term
- 17:33son of a gun come around. And the satire is there
- 17:36too because they kind of linger on son of a just
- 17:38a little long. Right. So you're kind of wondering
- 17:40what this could be. Like, are they trying to
- 17:42say it but not say it? And this comes after we
- 17:44talked about front page. Yes. Not too long ago
- 17:47with that final scene of throwing your fist down
- 17:50to kind of cover up a curse. Right. And I really,
- 17:53really liked that aspect of this too. Yeah. And
- 17:55I think that's one of many, many elements in
- 17:58this movie specifically where you can see a lot
- 18:01of this pre -code taking effect. I mean, this
- 18:04is another one of those like sex comedies. Yes.
- 18:07That has zero sex, but like 10 ,000 % implied.
- 18:13Sexual undertones. 100%. And we see that in this
- 18:16year as well with the Academy Awards. We'll talk
- 18:18about that here on the next episode. But with
- 18:21this one specifically, I thought the way they
- 18:23tackled it was probably the most racy. Because
- 18:27they didn't show anything specifically, but there's
- 18:28a musical number between Francie and Princess
- 18:30Anna that kind of shows the most like you should
- 18:33be putting in effort for your husband to be interested
- 18:36in you kind of thing. And they show like lingerie
- 18:39and the idea of like these robes and trading
- 18:42out your slippers for heels. Yes. And that's
- 18:44where we start seeing a little bit more of like
- 18:46the alluding to what it takes to like make men
- 18:49interested. Yeah. Interesting that they kind
- 18:52of do this instead of, you know, show them go
- 18:54into a room and slam the door. There's more.
- 18:56hints to it than just that yeah and like there's
- 18:59the early part where nikki has francie over and
- 19:03he asks if she'll stay for breakfast and she
- 19:06declines and there's kind of a sweet little moment
- 19:09there and then they share a kiss in the hallway
- 19:11as she's leaving and the next scene you see are
- 19:14just eggs cooking in a pan yes and you're like
- 19:16got it that's all i needed to know Thank you.
- 19:20Well, because they talk about what breakfast
- 19:22kind of means, where maybe we can get lunch,
- 19:24and then maybe that leads to dinner, and then
- 19:25perhaps we get breakfast. And that then kind
- 19:28of alludes to them spending the night together.
- 19:31So something that we'll talk about as time goes
- 19:33on here, because there is very much this idea
- 19:37in the 30s where it's not proper to be having
- 19:40these kind of relations outside of wedlock. Not
- 19:42as much of a concern in this movie as it is in
- 19:45something like Batgirl that we'll talk about
- 19:47in the next episode. But I thought that was interesting
- 19:49where they were still obviously adhering to the
- 19:51Hays Code with this. But it was a little more
- 19:54fast and loose than Bad Girl was. Bad Girl, we'll
- 19:58talk about it as we get there. But Smiling Lieutenant
- 20:00is definitely playing it for laughs. Whereas
- 20:02I think they take it a little more seriously
- 20:04in other movies. Yeah. And again, we'll talk
- 20:08about it with Bad Girl. But I think that when
- 20:10there is a source material that is so heavy in
- 20:15a lot of taboo subjects. Code office comes in
- 20:19with more strict enforcements, whereas this is
- 20:22kind of just, you know, we wrote this to be playful
- 20:25and funny so we can kind of get away with more
- 20:27because you don't have a preconceived idea of
- 20:30what this is about. Not to say this wasn't adapted.
- 20:33I touch on that real quick. This is super confusing.
- 20:36This is based on the 1907 operetta by Leopold
- 20:40Jacobson and Felix Dorman, which was based on
- 20:43the 1905 novel by Hans Mueller. And that was
- 20:48called Nook Stay Puss Gamal. Yeah. Yeah, nailed
- 20:52it. That's what I have too. Perfect. Awesome.
- 20:55So, yeah, I don't know. Just all of the innuendos
- 20:59and things were so funny to me. There's even
- 21:01the whole musical number, Breakfast Time, This
- 21:04Must Be Love, where it's just breakfast foods
- 21:08with... sexual implications. And it's so good.
- 21:12They're really going for it with Smiling Lieutenant.
- 21:14I want to talk a little bit about the overarching
- 21:16plot of this movie. It becomes a little bit more,
- 21:20and I'd like your opinion on this. It kind of
- 21:22becomes, I guess, spoilers for anyone who hasn't
- 21:24seen the Smiling Lieutenant. We see the complication
- 21:27of Nikki being pretty much married to, married
- 21:30off to Princess Anna in order for this not to,
- 21:33or his action to affect his life or have him
- 21:37killed or banished from the army. So instead
- 21:39of seeing a plot where he is able to get out
- 21:43of this relationship with Princess Anna and be
- 21:44with the woman he loves, Francie, we actually
- 21:46see this flip where he and Francie come to terms
- 21:49with like he cannot be with her because he has
- 21:51to be in this relationship for the things that
- 21:53he's done. So we see Francie actually like helping
- 21:56Princess Anna make him happier. Which I thought
- 21:59was kind of like, I thought that was interesting.
- 22:01I'm not sure how I felt about it because it felt
- 22:03like such a swerve of what you would have expected.
- 22:05The happy ending here would have been Princess
- 22:07Anna's like, you know, I've realized that you're
- 22:09in my ways and we shouldn't judge you like that.
- 22:11Like, clearly you're in love and I don't want
- 22:12to get between that. But instead it was like,
- 22:14well, you can learn to love me. Yeah. And there's
- 22:17a lot of like sexual repression in Princess Anna.
- 22:20And obviously that's the opposite of what we
- 22:22see in Nikki. So even the way that they try to
- 22:24talk to each other is very like, she'll try to
- 22:27hint at things and he's not picking it up or
- 22:29he doesn't want to pick it up. Right. So he tries
- 22:31to be respectful to his relationship with Francie.
- 22:34And we see that evolve over time, especially
- 22:36towards the end. But how did that, how did you
- 22:39feel about that as like, that's where the musical
- 22:41kind of went to? I honestly was kind of sad by
- 22:44the end of this movie. I agree. I felt so bad
- 22:47for Franzi. Ultimately, Nikki does stay with
- 22:50Princess Anna. Yes. And she has like a complete
- 22:52change of personality and character. So the idea
- 22:55is supposed to be, wow, Nikki lucked out. He
- 22:57was with this like lack of knowledge, young girl
- 23:02that he didn't really vibe with. And now she's
- 23:04kind of grown up into this similar to Franzi
- 23:08kind of racy girl. But you feel bad for Franzi
- 23:13when she leaves. I did read something that Billy
- 23:16Wilder wrote about Ernst Lubitsch in general,
- 23:18and specifically The Smiling Lieutenant, how
- 23:21the Lubitsch touch is kind of stacked jokes.
- 23:25So the whole movie is played for laughs and you
- 23:28get your jokes from the situation itself, but
- 23:33the ultimate big joke is you don't get what you
- 23:36expect. The final cherry on top joke moment is
- 23:40he ends up with the wrong girl. Yes, but... The
- 23:44tough thing for me, and I get the joke on that,
- 23:46the tough thing is that the entire movie, we
- 23:49fall in love with Francie as well. Sure. Right?
- 23:51I mean, so let's take a beat here. Claudette
- 23:53Colbert, what's going on? She's great. She is
- 23:56great in this movie. She's beautiful. Yes. I
- 23:58love the scenes where she's playing violin or
- 24:01viola? Violin. Yeah. Okay. She's playing for
- 24:04the orchestra. She's leading the all -women's
- 24:05orchestra. She's so good. in performing whether
- 24:09she's really playing or not but also in singing
- 24:11and in the romance scenes between her and nikki
- 24:15she's also keeping up with nikki um intelligence
- 24:18like the conversation they have they're very
- 24:20witty to each other oh yeah so i really enjoy
- 24:22her overall in this movie which makes that end
- 24:24portion where essentially she's like okay well
- 24:26i'm gonna lose uh nikki and he's gonna have to
- 24:29be in this relationship so what's the best thing
- 24:31i can do i know why don't i teach his wife how
- 24:35to be sexy So he'll want to be in this relationship.
- 24:39And it's a good musical number. I actually like
- 24:42this musical between her and Princess Anna. Yes.
- 24:45Because I think that's that Lubitsch touch of,
- 24:47well, let me tell you the glory of trading out
- 24:49a robe for a lingerie and like the glory of this
- 24:52and why you'd want to wear a heel. And I like
- 24:54that you kind of see Princess Anna picking this
- 24:56up in real time. She's not like immediately,
- 24:58cool, I know what I'm doing now. So you're trying
- 25:00to practice it while Nikki is like coming down
- 25:02and seeing her change. That sequence is really
- 25:05great where he comes down and sees her playing,
- 25:07smoking a cigarette. He runs upstairs to check
- 25:09the bottle he's been drinking to see if he poisoned
- 25:11himself. And then he runs back down and she's
- 25:13in a completely different attire and she's in
- 25:15the mirror. And I was like, this is great because
- 25:17you can tell that she's like running to try and
- 25:19get like different things on. Yeah. So again,
- 25:21it's showing that not everything is perfect and
- 25:24they are trying in this. And I guess ultimately
- 25:26it is a happy -esque ending, but not for Francie.
- 25:29No, not for Francie at all. And I think that
- 25:32cherry on top joke that Billy Wilder was referencing
- 25:36is kind of... Stuck in that bubble of 1931 or
- 25:411950 from when Billy Wilder was writing about
- 25:44it. And it works on a very like male forward
- 25:49audience. Yes. From the time. Whereas to us now
- 25:53in 2026, looking back at it, we're like, but
- 25:56what about Francie? Yeah. And it's one of those
- 26:00things where I would love to get like a woman's
- 26:02opinion on it. Are they happy that Francie like
- 26:06stepped up? for the man she loves and gave him
- 26:10the life that she feels he deserves because he
- 26:13has no other choice? Or do women watch this and
- 26:16they're like, yeah, Nikki sucks. Yeah, I don't
- 26:19know if you know this. I guess I'll just go ahead
- 26:21and state this for the pod. I'm not an ambassador
- 26:22of women. I don't intend to speak on their behalf.
- 26:25But what I will say is I thought about Taylor's
- 26:28thought, my wife. I thought about what she would
- 26:31feel at the ending on this. And I'm pretty confident
- 26:33to say that she would say that's busted. Yeah.
- 26:35It is absolutely busted to do this. But it's
- 26:38because you're exactly right. Like in the 30s,
- 26:40this was more like, what a dame that she would
- 26:42do this for her husband. It's like, yeah, you
- 26:45shouldn't. Like, I understand that it benefits
- 26:47Nikki, but that doesn't mean she should do it
- 26:49and have to deal with all that. But with all
- 26:51that said, I like the letter that she leaves
- 26:53him of like, hey, I visited. P .S. I visited
- 26:55your wife and she's not half as bad. Like she's
- 26:58not just a blonde. Oh. Yeah, that's that's the
- 27:01joke there, too. And it's actually very sweet
- 27:03because when he first has an evening with Anna,
- 27:06Princess Anna, excuse me, don't want to, you
- 27:09know, put some respect on. How do you spell Flossentherm?
- 27:12They're Nikki and Franzi are flirting and flirting
- 27:16and flirting. I'm Sebastian from The Little Mermaid
- 27:19all of a sudden. She asks, what color is her
- 27:24hair? Is she a blonde or brunette? And he goes,
- 27:25I don't know. showing that he doesn't care. It
- 27:28doesn't matter. He's in love with Francie. So
- 27:30then at the end here in that letter, she specifically
- 27:32says, it may interest you to know that she is
- 27:34blonde and very charming. Yeah, that's right.
- 27:37And it's such a sweet, a bittersweet note, rather.
- 27:40I love Francie. I feel so bad for her. I do too.
- 27:43And I think the three leads here are very good
- 27:45in Maurice, Claudette, and Miriam. Miriam is
- 27:48Princess Anna. What I do want to talk about is
- 27:51something that I read here where while they were
- 27:52filming this, they actually made a French version.
- 27:55of The Smiling Lieutenant at the same time. So
- 27:57while they were filming The Smiling Lieutenant,
- 27:59they were also filming the French version of
- 28:00The Smiling Lieutenant with Maurice, Claudette,
- 28:02and Miriam as the three leads. Okay, gotcha.
- 28:05So obviously the other characters, King Adolph,
- 28:09Max, that they were not reprising their roles
- 28:12because I assume they didn't speak French. But
- 28:15Maurice, Claudette, and Miriam did, so they were
- 28:18able to... do this at the same time. And I thought
- 28:21this was interesting because we've heard of remakes.
- 28:23We've heard of like, you know, well, this is
- 28:24the Spanish version of this. I've heard of remakes.
- 28:26Have you? But this one is the first time that
- 28:28I've seen kind of both filmed side by side. So
- 28:31I thought that was really interesting. And the
- 28:33reason for that is in 1931 to 1933, at that time,
- 28:38subtypes or dubs weren't a thing. So in order
- 28:41to make the French version, you had to make a
- 28:43French version of it. Yeah. So I thought that
- 28:45was really interesting. It's not something I'd
- 28:47seen before. And it kind of speaks to the power
- 28:50of those three leads, how good they are, but
- 28:52also that they really are the face in America
- 28:55or in France of The Smiling Lieutenant. So I
- 28:59really liked that. But this is also, along with
- 29:01being available internationally as well in France,
- 29:04this was Paramount's biggest hit of 1931. Yes.
- 29:07Not terribly surprising, giving Love Parade and
- 29:10everyone's interest in musicals. Yeah, no. Lubitsch,
- 29:14I think, solidified himself in the musical scene
- 29:18with the Love Parade two years prior to this.
- 29:20And I would imagine that it was something audiences
- 29:23were wanting. They were like, man, we love Maurice.
- 29:26Let me get some more of that. And Lubitsch stepped
- 29:30up, came out with this. And it's it really is
- 29:33a ton of fun. And I think it does capture that
- 29:36that very similar vibe to the love parade. Makes
- 29:38sense. It being in the Criterion collection.
- 29:41They all do have the same similar vibes. It does.
- 29:44The other side of this, along with Maurice, is
- 29:47with Miriam and Claudette. They were specifically
- 29:49like they when they're being filmed, they had
- 29:51the request of their angles being exactly the
- 29:53same, which for most of the movie. Well, like
- 29:56the angles. Oh, I thought you said ankles. I
- 29:59was like, what does that mean? When you get my
- 30:01ankles on shot, it has to be this specific angle.
- 30:04Ankle angle. There's a t -shirt idea for us.
- 30:07Ankle angles. I like it. So, no. When they were
- 30:09on camera, they preferred the same angle from
- 30:12that. Which isn't a big deal, because for the
- 30:14majority of this movie, I would say maybe the
- 30:16first 80 -85 % of this movie, they really don't
- 30:19share screen time. The only time they really
- 30:21do is whenever the incident happens and the lieutenant
- 30:24is indeed smiling at Francie and Princess Anna
- 30:27happens to drive by that exact moment. That's
- 30:30really the only time that they're ever truly
- 30:31on screen together until the last 15 minutes
- 30:34of this movie. So I read this and I was like,
- 30:36oh, it's really interesting. I wonder why that's
- 30:37important. The reason that's important. is that
- 30:40musical number between Francie and Princess Anna,
- 30:42where even though they have the same angles,
- 30:45you'll see them kind of switching spots. So they're
- 30:47not in that different angle. This didn't result
- 30:49in like a feud or anything. It's not like they're
- 30:51like battling on set, but they did have a request
- 30:53to have those same angles. And this was something
- 30:56that Ernst actually thought Lubitsch were cool
- 30:59like that. That he thought kind of helped the
- 31:01rivalry of Princess Anna and Francie. So he kind
- 31:04of kept that idea in there of... both accommodating
- 31:09both of their requests to make them feel a little
- 31:11more at odds with each other. Yeah. And I thought
- 31:13that was a nice touch, too. Yeah, that's pretty
- 31:15common. I feel like we've talked about that in
- 31:18the past before. Maybe not. Maybe I'm thinking
- 31:20of... I'm sure we'll continue to. Yeah, like,
- 31:22it'll definitely show up. Right. These two hated
- 31:24each other on set. Blah, blah, blah. Can you
- 31:26imagine when we get to, like, what happened to
- 31:28Baby Jane? Is that a thing? I think so. Oh, is
- 31:31it? I may have made it up. We'll see. I guess
- 31:33we'll have to wait for the 60s, 70s to get there.
- 31:35Let me ask you... We'll figure it out. Let me
- 31:37ask you this. Did you miss the dancing from the
- 31:41love parade in this? Because there's no dancing
- 31:44in this movie. It's not that kind of musical.
- 31:46There's not. And I think that that kind of lends
- 31:48itself to that opening sequence of Nicky looking
- 31:51into the camera. Like he's sitting on his bed,
- 31:53like just singing this song. Not really moving.
- 31:56He's very animated in the way that he'll move
- 31:58his shoulders and his arms when he's doing it.
- 32:01Especially that. And he'll be standing. There's
- 32:04a couple moments where he'll stand. And especially
- 32:06in the end, he does a reprise of that song with
- 32:09Princess Anna in the background. And he's also
- 32:10kind of doing the hands and the gestures. But
- 32:13he's not dancing. I don't know if I'd say I miss
- 32:16it because there's never a moment where it feels
- 32:18like they should be dancing right now. Sure.
- 32:19It's a little more subdued than that. And I appreciate
- 32:22that because not every musical has to be, well,
- 32:24this is a big musical number, baby. Sure. Yeah.
- 32:27Yeah. It can be in that world specifically. And
- 32:30I think if it was dancing, it would feel kind
- 32:32of out of place in this movie specifically. Yeah.
- 32:34I can, I can totally get behind that. I do think
- 32:37it. I picked up on it because I thought so much
- 32:40about Lulu and the, I forget the guy's name,
- 32:45but they have that whole dance number where he's
- 32:47like falling on his head and break dancing in
- 32:51a way. Yes. It's so insane. And the love parade
- 32:53is what I'm referring to. But it got me thinking
- 32:56about one of the biggest complaints I think from
- 32:58this era of movies, early sound films, is they're
- 33:03very stilted. There's not a whole lot of like
- 33:05moving around on the screen. Most people are,
- 33:08they plant their feet and they deliver their
- 33:10lines. They move, plant their feet, deliver their
- 33:13lines, that kind of thing. And that's kind of
- 33:15due to the restrictions of sound at the time.
- 33:17And I thought that was interesting and probably
- 33:19a big reason why there aren't dance numbers in
- 33:22this. I'll be curious to see what the other Lubitsch
- 33:25musicals look like that we cover. But when you
- 33:27look back at the Love Parade, you can see that
- 33:29they hadn't really figured that out. And they
- 33:32were throwing in these dance numbers. It really
- 33:34is. I appreciate this because I think we've seen
- 33:37movies like Cimarron and previously in Old Arizona
- 33:41where we've seen them try to do some things that
- 33:44they weren't able to do yet. And while I appreciate
- 33:46that, that affects the quality of the movie that
- 33:49you're like, yeah, that's cool that you did that.
- 33:50But the audio is terrible. Right. Because you're
- 33:52running around the microphone at all times. So
- 33:55I almost appreciate. Ernst Lubitsch making this
- 33:58musical to now say, okay, well, dancing around,
- 34:00we weren't able to get everything on microphone.
- 34:02So what if we limit how much people are moving
- 34:05around in a musical setting? Because I mean,
- 34:07people are still walking around and everything
- 34:09in this, but when they're singing, we see that
- 34:11more contained. And I really appreciate that
- 34:14because it felt like it was in that world. Again,
- 34:17the world building of it. Yeah. So I appreciate
- 34:19that. I did too. I think it is one of the things
- 34:22too that contributed to the music itself kind
- 34:25of I'll say the cliche, being a character in
- 34:28the movie, because you didn't have the dance
- 34:31numbers and things. So at a point, you have the
- 34:34music kind of playing over just their normal
- 34:37actions. The girl running up the stairs. There's
- 34:39a moment at the end where Princess Anna keeps
- 34:41trying to woo Nikki with the chessboard. Yes.
- 34:45And he throws it on the ground at one point,
- 34:47and it doesn't make an audible sound, but the
- 34:50music kind of plays that blink. As it happens.
- 34:54I did notice that because there's other moments
- 34:55where like a door will close and you won't hear
- 34:57that close. But then in that same scene, when
- 35:00he walks into the bedroom and closes the door,
- 35:02you hear that close. So there's some inconsistency
- 35:05to it. But I think that consistency that you're
- 35:06talking about is that if they ever don't show
- 35:09or play the sound for that action, there's music
- 35:12to accompany it. Right. And that's that level
- 35:15of intention. Yeah, it feels all very intentional
- 35:17and purposeful. For sure. I do want to talk about
- 35:20Charles Ruggins. Ruggles? Sorry, Ruggles, not
- 35:24Ruggins. I heard this name and I was kind of
- 35:26like, oh yeah, we've seen him before. I've heard
- 35:28this name. Yeah. And I looked into it and we
- 35:30haven't in any of the movies that we've talked
- 35:32about. But maybe this is what I was thinking
- 35:34about. This is not the last time we'll be talking
- 35:36about Charles Ruggles this year. He appears in
- 35:39the other Ernst Lubitsch picture, which is One
- 35:41Hour With You. Oh, does he? He does. Okay, nice.
- 35:44He does. I made sure I wrote that down. He is,
- 35:49I don't know if he's the lead, but he does appear
- 35:51in One Hour With You. Not an incredibly present
- 35:54character in this. I believe he is the friend
- 35:57in the beginning who is interested in Franzi.
- 35:59Gotcha. That Nikki just straight up steals from
- 36:02him. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Just straight up like,
- 36:03oh, this guy's bothering me during your song,
- 36:05isn't he? Isn't he a snake? You should hang out
- 36:07with me. But he does show up, and I thought that
- 36:09was interesting that, I mean, A, that Ernst Lubitsch
- 36:12has two movies coming out in the same year. Yeah.
- 36:14But then to have the cast kind of repeat themselves.
- 36:16Maurice obviously showing up from Love Parade
- 36:18to Smiling Lieutenant, and then Charles Ruggles
- 36:20showing up from Smiling Lieutenant to One Hour
- 36:22With You. Well, Maurice Chevrolet is also the
- 36:25lead in One Hour With You. Oh, well, there you
- 36:26go. Perfect. And you know who else returns? Is
- 36:29it Claudette? Jeanette McDonald from The Love
- 36:31Parade. Oh, wonderful. So I'm looking forward
- 36:34to seeing those two together again. Mostly because
- 36:37I want to see if I prefer the chemistry of Maurice
- 36:41Chevrolet and Jeanette McDonald or Maurice Chevrolet
- 36:44and Claudette Colbert. Because I really like
- 36:46them together. I was going to say, I think I'm
- 36:48team Smiling Lieutenant on that. I did like Smiling
- 36:51Lieutenant a bit more than I liked Love Parade.
- 36:54Because Love Parade, again, you can kind of feel
- 36:55them trying to do things that it didn't feel
- 36:57like that didn't land as well. The technology
- 36:59didn't catch up. Exactly, in terms of technology.
- 37:01This one, it felt like, top to bottom, there
- 37:04weren't any issues that I had with the quality.
- 37:06Yeah. And it helps, and again, let's talk about
- 37:09this, that I'm watching the DVD. You know, you
- 37:11watch the Blu -ray of this, and I'm interested
- 37:13in how the quality was on that, but I popped
- 37:15in the DVD on my Xbox, and I had a great time.
- 37:17I very much enjoyed my time on this. Imagine
- 37:20my surprise when I put on closed captionings
- 37:22and it's the exact closed captions. Whoa. I know,
- 37:24right? Instead of on YouTube when they're like,
- 37:26it's kind of like what they said. Yeah, maybe
- 37:29they said robot here in this 1931 film. Yeah,
- 37:32I love how they always mention... Do you ever
- 37:36have this happen where you think of a reference
- 37:37and you think of two despicable things and you're
- 37:39like, well, I don't want to say that. Like, why
- 37:41were those the two references that I came with?
- 37:42Yeah. There's always a word that you're like,
- 37:45that wasn't a thing in the 1930s. Right. Yeah.
- 37:48I don't think Grateful Dead was a band in 1930,
- 37:50but sure. Yeah. They did say Grateful Dead. One
- 37:52thing I want to start doing, and we're getting,
- 37:55obviously we're in the fifth Academy Award year,
- 37:57and I want to start talking a bit about the writing
- 38:00of these movies. Sure. In the sense that we've
- 38:03seen really great lines and deliveries in previous
- 38:06movies that we talked about, but this year specifically.
- 38:09I've done the research on Aerosmith, on Bad Girl,
- 38:12on Smiling Lieutenant. And from all three of
- 38:14them, there are lines, and also deliveries of
- 38:17those lines, that I really enjoyed. And it felt
- 38:19like I kind of want to make sure that we're talking
- 38:21about this moving forward, where call this the
- 38:23line corner or the delivery corner. I want to
- 38:26talk about these lines specifically. There's
- 38:28a line that Maurice Chevrolet says, Chevrolet?
- 38:32I have no idea. The problem is I'm trying to
- 38:34say it like you, but I end up saying Chevrolet,
- 38:35which I know isn't right. I thought it was Chevalier.
- 38:37Let's just call him Maurice Chevy. Don't do that.
- 38:40Yeah, there you go. MC. So Maurice specifically
- 38:43has a line where the king is trying to push the
- 38:47relationship between him and Princess Anna. And
- 38:49he walks out of Princess Anna's bedroom when
- 38:51she is like, well, maybe we could, you know.
- 38:54There's like a 30 second scene where she's just
- 38:55like, you know, we can, you know. Raised eyebrows.
- 39:00Essentially saying for like 30 seconds. And I
- 39:04thought it was funny how he kind of like at first
- 39:06was like. What? What are you? I don't know what
- 39:09you're talking about. And it was genuine. And
- 39:11then when he did realize, he's like, oh, no.
- 39:13And I'm out. See ya. Yeah. And he leaves. But
- 39:15when he was leaving the bedroom, he's going up
- 39:17the stairs to his own room. He passes the king
- 39:20and he ends up kissing the king. And he has a
- 39:22line. And I love this line. That's as far as
- 39:25I go. That's my limit. Yeah. And it's not even
- 39:28a great line. It's just the delivery of it specifically
- 39:30is like. this is what I'm going to do. This is
- 39:32how happy I am to be here. Not happy. Right.
- 39:35And I thought that specifically was great because
- 39:38he kind of does like this arms cross or not cross,
- 39:40but like arms out thing of like, that's my limit.
- 39:43Yeah. That's as far as I go. And it's nice because
- 39:46in an otherwise very comedic performance, it
- 39:48felt kind of like his drama coming out. Like
- 39:50you can see like his like training on that. So
- 39:52I really liked that line. We talked about son
- 39:54of a gun, but. I mean, have you found that too?
- 39:57Like as we get more into the writing is more
- 39:59intentional with these, that the lines and deliveries
- 40:01are very notable? Absolutely. I think it first
- 40:05started to show up. Well, I really enjoyed it
- 40:09in The Love Parade, and I think that's a testament
- 40:11to Lubitsch himself. Sure. But I think last year
- 40:14that we covered with Skippy and the Front Page,
- 40:16where it's got very snappy dialogue. Very. And
- 40:19very, like, of the time as well. That was just
- 40:22fun. It's almost, there's a lot of slang in Skippy
- 40:24especially that I really enjoyed. But in this,
- 40:28the jokes are just so witty and quick. And I
- 40:32like how, I don't know, how willing they are
- 40:35to dive into. the modern language yes i don't
- 40:39know maybe i'm i'm still in the in the mindset
- 40:42of everybody's kind of stuffy in the 1930s you
- 40:47know but it's so much more playful than i expect
- 40:50my big worry is that this is a sign of the pre
- 40:53-code era and like we're gonna hit 1934 and everything's
- 40:57just gonna feel like the desert just dried out
- 41:00and this is obviously the something we haven't
- 41:04mentioned yet on this episode the reason that
- 41:05we're talking about these movies in this order
- 41:07is that this is the order of release yeah right
- 41:09so smile lieutenant came out first and then bad
- 41:10girl and i think that's interesting that those
- 41:13two movies came out back to back or like you
- 41:15know smile lieutenant then bad girl because those
- 41:17two movies specifically kind of lead the way
- 41:19for what hayes code was doing The Hays Code specifically,
- 41:22I mean, we'll get it with Bad Girl. There is
- 41:24a lot going on with the production of Bad Girl
- 41:27that was to fit the Hays Code. With Smiling Lieutenant,
- 41:30though, I think you're right. That stuffiness
- 41:32that you're talking about isn't present in Smiling
- 41:34Lieutenant because the tone that they've set
- 41:36overall is much more whimsical than that. Whereas
- 41:38the other movies that we see previously and of
- 41:40this year that do kind of touch on that Hays
- 41:43Code a little bit and push the limit just a bit.
- 41:46adhere to that stuffy tone if that makes sense
- 41:49like i know specifically is a lot more like grounded
- 41:52in like well hey this isn't right right and like
- 41:54we can't do this smiling lieutenant throws that
- 41:57out the window and it's just like i will sleep
- 41:59with whoever i want whenever i want sure and
- 42:02it's fine and isn't that like cool to watch me
- 42:04do that now aren't i such a scamp yeah son of
- 42:06a gun but but still in a way that you know they're
- 42:09not blatantly showing things on screen right
- 42:11they can dance around it yeah and and just to
- 42:14be clear the It is like the Hays office that's
- 42:18regulating all of this, but the Hays Code itself,
- 42:21that code, doesn't come into effect until 34.
- 42:24Oh, interesting. I thought there was something
- 42:26specifically with the—well, we'll talk about
- 42:28it with Batgirl, but Batgirl, I'd read a lot
- 42:30of how the Hays Code was affected by this, and
- 42:32maybe that's more after the fact, but we'll talk
- 42:34about it. Yeah, like, again, it was Hays, the
- 42:38man. that the code is named after, was still
- 42:41there regulating everything. But like that list
- 42:44of 12 commandments or whatever the Hays Code
- 42:47is, is like that was 1934 that came out. Copy,
- 42:51yeah, because he was the president of the MPPDA.
- 42:53Yeah. Yeah. Thanks, man. We'll talk about him.
- 42:56You done messed up my Lubitsch. You done goofed.
- 42:59I do want to talk about one last thing here about
- 43:02Smiling Lieutenant specifically. Did you feel
- 43:05that there were any... I don't want to say similarities,
- 43:07but the same scenes or same settings and locations
- 43:11from Love Parade to Smile Lieutenant. I don't
- 43:14know if I identified them as like the same scenes,
- 43:16but it does feel very reminiscent. kind of a
- 43:20similar setting in general with the royalty and
- 43:22the soldier and all of that. I was thinking specifically
- 43:25of the king and princess of Flossentherm's mansion
- 43:28or castle, that staircase. Yes. I felt like that
- 43:32was like, that's the same staircase from Love
- 43:33Parade. Yeah. And Princess Anna's bedroom to
- 43:35me felt like the bedroom from Love Parade. So
- 43:38there's scenes specifically, and it's not like
- 43:40they reused every set, but it felt like, well,
- 43:43hey, this worked so well the last time that we
- 43:44filmed it, why don't we do this again? I wasn't
- 43:46sure if you caught on that as well. The staircase.
- 43:49Above all else, yes, that did look familiar.
- 43:51I have no idea if it... I didn't find anything
- 43:53on my research of it, but it was something that
- 43:55stood out to me, so I just wanted to check with
- 43:57you. Yeah, because I don't know how long they
- 43:59would be leaving up sets. Like, they definitely
- 44:03did it during that time period, but I don't know.
- 44:06Well, I wondered if it was an actual location.
- 44:09Oh, that probably not, but maybe? Like the orchestra
- 44:13and everything, for sure. Like there's set pieces
- 44:16there and production designs, or sorry, set designs
- 44:19that are built for it. But I wondered with that
- 44:21staircase and how grand it was, I wasn't sure
- 44:23if like that was an actual location or maybe
- 44:25they just put it, hey, we built this large staircase,
- 44:28put it in the studio lot and we'll just come
- 44:30back to it whenever we need it. Right. And maybe
- 44:32they just use that. But the setting itself just
- 44:34felt very reminiscent of Love Parade. And not
- 44:37in a bad way of like, boo. Yeah, we've been here
- 44:40before. Exactly. seen this yeah it's the same
- 44:43guy too um no i it wasn't anything like that
- 44:46it was just more like i wasn't sure if i was
- 44:48having flashbacks or deja vu but it did feel
- 44:51especially maurice running down kind of jauntily
- 44:53from the stairs that that to me was like well
- 44:55that's love parade yeah well i'll be curious
- 44:57though uh when we watch one hour with you if
- 45:00maybe we'll start to pick up on some of that
- 45:02uh and and not just with one hour with you but
- 45:05but any of these paramount paramount pictures
- 45:08well three times it takes three times to be a
- 45:11trend right yeah so yeah third movie we'll see
- 45:14and you know that's that's a good time to really
- 45:16talk on that in general that's how these films
- 45:18were made you if you were a studio film which
- 45:21most of these movies we'll talk about in the
- 45:24early era are studio films you would build these
- 45:27sets and leave them on the lot and just say okay
- 45:29this is our royal castle set Whoever wants to
- 45:32make a movie about royalty, there you go. You
- 45:34can use it until they tear it down to replace
- 45:36it with something else. Giant paddock for a T
- 45:39-Rex or something. Probably not a Paramount.
- 45:41Is that in one hour with you? I'm not familiar.
- 45:43I think that is for Skippy 2. Ah, Skippy 2. Yeah.
- 45:49I'm trying to think of the tagline for Skippy
- 45:512. This time the dog's back for more. Oh my God.
- 45:54The dog bites back. Twice the bike accidents.
- 45:58This is really your fault for drinking whenever
- 46:00you're trying to tee me up for a tagline. Well,
- 46:02I can't drink when I talk. So I got to drink
- 46:05when you talk. And you throw out a kid hitting
- 46:08the telephone pole with a bike. I thought about
- 46:10this. You know, there's a couple movies that
- 46:12I was having some difficulty finding the ends
- 46:14to. And I was like, well, I wonder if I could
- 46:15just look up what happens in them. And I was
- 46:17like, no, no. Because then that's how I miss
- 46:19out on Skippy. Yes. To where I don't get to see
- 46:21this until on pod. Which don't get me wrong.
- 46:23Incredible moment that we get to have that on
- 46:25pod of me discovering that scene. It's so good.
- 46:29But yeah, we'll get there. What else do you want
- 46:31to talk about with Smiling Lieutenant? I mean,
- 46:33I think that this was one of the easiest we've
- 46:36ever kind of just flowed our enjoyment and the
- 46:40highlights of the movie. It's weird. It's one
- 46:44of those, this was nominated for Best Picture
- 46:46and that's it. So you don't really get the opportunity
- 46:48to say, well, that's why this was nominated for
- 46:51that. It's all enjoyable. It is. And I got to
- 46:55tell you, like this year specifically of what
- 46:57we've watched, I've really enjoyed myself. And
- 47:00that is a nice change of pace because last year
- 47:03we were watching, well, the last month, but our
- 47:06last year that we covered, it felt like whether
- 47:08it was Traderhorn or Cimarron, it felt like,
- 47:11man, this is research. Like you're not enjoying
- 47:14it as much. It really is just the research of
- 47:16it. And at the end of the day, like, you know,
- 47:17the research is a big part of it, but also the
- 47:19enjoyment of like watching these movies is another
- 47:21part. And of the movies I've watched for the
- 47:24fifth Academy Award year, I've really enjoyed
- 47:26myself more than I did with like Trader Horn
- 47:28or Cimarron. I really enjoyed Front Page. You
- 47:31know, I semi enjoyed East Lynn and then I enjoyed
- 47:34Skippy too. Skippy too. It's back. I enjoyed
- 47:38Skippy as well, but. I'm so happy watching Smiling
- 47:42Lieutenant where I'm like, oh, this feels more
- 47:43confident, right? Like obviously from All Quiet
- 47:46on the Western Front to Cimarron from A Best
- 47:48Picture Win, it feels a little bit like, well,
- 47:51hey, we can do these sprawling epics and that's
- 47:53what these movies are now. It's nice to see that
- 47:55we can still like have a joyful tone in things
- 47:58like Aerosmith or in this, The Smiling Lieutenant
- 48:02being a musical. So I'm really enjoying my time
- 48:05so far this year. That's good news. You've actually
- 48:07watched one more movie. So far this year or for
- 48:10this Academy year than I have. Correct. I have
- 48:13not looked up who won anything this year. Oh,
- 48:17well, I know best picture, but that's beyond
- 48:19that. Yeah, nothing. I kind of want to leave
- 48:21it that way. Cool. Because I'm really curious
- 48:23who was nominated for what. Because watching
- 48:26Smiling Lieutenant, they're like, I get nobody
- 48:29getting nominated for this. I probably would
- 48:32have pushed a little bit for Claudette Colbert,
- 48:34but otherwise I agree. Is that because her performance
- 48:37was great or because you're like, like mini smitten?
- 48:40Both can be true. Yes. But I think that of the
- 48:43character work in this movie, she has the most
- 48:45to do. Yeah. And I thought she was breathtaking
- 48:48whenever she was on screen. Whereas Princess
- 48:50Anna was like more comedic and then Maurice a
- 48:53little bit more comedic. The heart of the movie
- 48:55really lies in Francie, Claudette Colbert's character.
- 48:58Sure. So I would have thought she would have
- 49:00gotten nomination for this, but I'm not going
- 49:02to say I'm campaigning on the streets for it.
- 49:04With a cow. Yeah. I am looking forward to seeing
- 49:08who does get nominated. Yeah. But yeah. Overall,
- 49:13what did you give The Smiling Lieutenant? So
- 49:16I gave The Smiling Lieutenant three and a half
- 49:18stars. And spoiler alert, not only did you give
- 49:21The Smiling Lieutenant three and a half stars.
- 49:23I was about to ask if this is a rewatch, but
- 49:25I realize now you said this. Not anymore, baby.
- 49:28But a friend of the pod, Bryce, also gave this
- 49:32three and a half stars. Wow. So look at us. You
- 49:34heard it here first, folks. And I'm intentionally
- 49:36not looking at your score before I put my score.
- 49:39Oh, good. Because I want to be like, you know,
- 49:41genuine to have the conversation of like, well,
- 49:42how did you get that far? Yeah. Why am I so far
- 49:45ahead than you? And I think that's right. I think
- 49:47three and a half is very good. You know, I'm
- 49:49not going to say Smiling Lieutenant is my favorite
- 49:50movie of what we've watched, but I did very much
- 49:53enjoy my time with Smiling Lieutenant. I maybe
- 49:56upon revisiting would give it four stars, but
- 49:59I think that final sequence of Francie just kind
- 50:03of being sad. They're like, ah, happy ending.
- 50:06Right. You're like, not for her. Yeah. Like that
- 50:08to me, I was like, eh, half a star. Right. Yeah.
- 50:10I think that's really what did it. And I, I wonder
- 50:13if rewatching it, knowing the outcome. I'll be
- 50:15more loose with my rating. Right. But well, and
- 50:19it would be one thing if her character is kind
- 50:20of like, you know, well, I don't need any of
- 50:22you. Forget all of you. Actually, I'm going to
- 50:24leave. Where's Max? I want to get out of here.
- 50:25Yeah. And there's like that little jokey element
- 50:27of like, she's mad. So she's going to go storm
- 50:29off. So then you're like, well, she didn't handle
- 50:31that well. So I guess everything's okay. But
- 50:33in the end, she's like, no, I'll fall on my sword.
- 50:35So you can. have a wife who puts out like, just
- 50:38come on, what are we doing? Yeah. So that stopped
- 50:41me from giving like a full four stars. But I
- 50:43mean, I very, I did really enjoy Smile of the
- 50:45Tenant. I had a lot of fun with it. And thankfully
- 50:48we get another Lubitsch musical with Maurice
- 50:50in maybe a couple of weeks. A couple of weeks.
- 50:54Yeah. I would say for certainly a couple of weeks.
- 50:57That's a good point. That's a good point. At
- 50:59least in the next four. Yeah. Accurate. Very
- 51:02nice. I think so. Double feature. I had some
- 51:04fun. with the double features on this year specifically.
- 51:08Mostly because I'm very much trying not to make
- 51:11things complicated for you when you make the
- 51:13letterboxd list. Appreciate that. Of make everything
- 51:15like, this really reminded me of The Brutalist.
- 51:17So that being said, I did choose The Brutalist.
- 51:20Excellent. No, for this one, I tried looking
- 51:22at the, this isn't my pick, but the she's all
- 51:25that of this kind of movie. Of like, we took
- 51:28this down and out princess that no one wanted,
- 51:31boo. And what if we made her into this like starlet?
- 51:34And this relationship between them. And I thought
- 51:36it was kind of a nice touch on like a Shakespearean
- 51:38kind of like, these two don't get along. How
- 51:40are they going to end up together type thing?
- 51:42Yeah. It reminded me a lot of 10 Things I Hate
- 51:44About You. Okay. 1999, directed by Gil Junger.
- 51:47This was, might be younger, I don't know. But
- 51:49this was the Heath Ledger, Julia Stiles movie
- 51:52adaptation of Much Ado About Nothing. I very
- 51:55much enjoy this movie. I love 10 Things I Hate
- 51:58About You. It's funny to say that. And even the
- 52:01sequence in 10 Things I Hate About You with Heath
- 52:04Ledger doing the can't take my eyes off you sequence
- 52:07on the bleachers. I love you, baby. Yeah, that
- 52:09feels a little bit like Smiling Lieutenant as
- 52:12well, especially with that quick jaunt he does
- 52:15of kicking his legs like the WB frog. Yeah. I'm
- 52:18aware that's not what it's from, but that's just
- 52:19immediately what I think of. A lot of that feels
- 52:21like... smiling lieutenant and specifically the
- 52:24connection between how i almost said maurice
- 52:27nicky finds himself in this situation yeah and
- 52:30then the journey of where he ends up i thought
- 52:33that reminded me a lot of 10 things i hate about
- 52:34you too so not one -to -one by any means but
- 52:37a nice double feature of the themes from smiling
- 52:39lieutenant in 10 things yes i like that a lot
- 52:43uh and that is like a very fun movie it's so
- 52:46much fun i have been watching friends a lot lately
- 52:50Ziggy has never seen Friends, so we're going
- 52:52through. She's reliving her 90s days. Oh, that's
- 52:55right. Yeah. Is that why you have the Rachel
- 52:58cut right now? That's exactly why. I'm so glad
- 53:00you noticed. It looks good. Thank you. But in
- 53:03like every episode of not only Friends, but just
- 53:05sitcom television, it is always a setup of this
- 53:09tiny little incident occurs that throws. our
- 53:13characters into chaos for the next 30 minutes.
- 53:16I smiled at a princess and now I'm married to
- 53:18her. Exactly. Yeah. And because of that, I almost
- 53:22went with the Jennifer Lawrence movie, No Hard
- 53:24Feelings. Oh, great call. But that felt like.
- 53:28Too heavy? Well, I mean, sex comedy. No, you
- 53:29know what? I'm going to go with that. Yeah, I
- 53:31mean... I'm absolutely going with that. That
- 53:32makes perfect sense because Lubitsch is very
- 53:34clearly making sex comedies. Yeah. And that is
- 53:37probably the most notable sex comedy of the past
- 53:39couple years. Yeah. You know what? I like it.
- 53:41I was going to go with another Lubitsch movie,
- 53:44but I'm going to save that one for a better scenario.
- 53:47And I wonder if that's nominated at some point.
- 53:49It wasn't. I made sure that it... It wasn't.
- 53:51What's it like to do that research? I just did
- 53:54it. Just now? On the podcast. Okay. Well, vindication.
- 53:58Yeah. But yeah, no hard feelings. Kind of a weird
- 54:02little note of a plot that just throws our characters
- 54:06into chaos. Hey, we really want someone to sleep
- 54:09with our son because we feel bad for him. And
- 54:11they hire Jennifer Lawrence and... There's like
- 54:14a goofy, funny, maybe inappropriate relationship
- 54:16that not everybody agrees with. No hard feelings
- 54:19is such a great. You're crushing these double
- 54:21features. Thanks, man. Appreciate it. 10 Things
- 54:24I Hate About You was fantastic. Thank you. I
- 54:26love it. I appreciate that. You got it. You got
- 54:28it, my dude. But that's it for The Smiling Lieutenant.
- 54:32Like I've said a million times, I'm super excited
- 54:34for the fifth Academy a year because I haven't
- 54:36seen these. And that's super exciting for me.
- 54:39I'm sure it's super exciting for you who also
- 54:40hasn't seen these. It's nice coming. I mean,
- 54:43I know we've already done this with Cimarron
- 54:44and the fourth Academy Award year, but it's nice
- 54:47to hear you say that there's I've seen more of
- 54:50these movies from the 30s than you have. So the
- 54:52first time this will happen. Well, we'll see
- 54:54if it's the last. I'm trying to do my research
- 54:55as much as possible. So you're not like this
- 54:57week we're doing these. I'm like, oh, right.
- 54:59I have to watch it now. I'm trying to get ahead
- 55:01of it. So glad to hear it. I'm also at the movies
- 55:04a lot because there's a lot coming out. We're
- 55:05filming this in March, recording this in March.
- 55:07So we're seeing a lot of, you know, we talked
- 55:10about Sinners last, well, two months ago. No,
- 55:13last month. We did talk about Sinners. Yeah.
- 55:15Anyways, so now we have the movies that are trying
- 55:17to fill that time slot that Sinners was in last
- 55:19year. Right. It's an interesting time. So I'm
- 55:21balancing watching the older movies with still
- 55:23watching newer movies. And all that to say, I'm
- 55:25tired. Yeah. Yeah. I hope that movies don't.
- 55:29feel like a chore anytime soon i'm glad that
- 55:32they don't yet yeah there's a couple that by
- 55:35the time i'm like 90 done with it i'm like okay
- 55:37sure let's get there yeah i'm doing my fingers
- 55:40in a circle like let's pick up the pace but we'll
- 55:43get there you know what one of my favorite things
- 55:44about this academy year is nothing is over two
- 55:48hours long period thrilled not not even just
- 55:51the best picture nominees but i was looking at
- 55:53like what a death race would look like for this
- 55:55year Nothing is over two hours long. I always
- 55:57like, I swear to God, we'll wrap. I always like
- 56:00the idea of looking at trends and reactions from
- 56:03the Academy Awards. And I think last year we
- 56:05saw that Cimarron was kind of a, oh, look what
- 56:08we did with All Quiet on the Western Front. We
- 56:10should do like a big sprawling epic like that
- 56:11too. These movies should be longer. And then
- 56:14this year they're like, let's get back to basics.
- 56:15Yeah, calm down. And I really appreciate the
- 56:17overreaction to correction. Yes, especially when
- 56:22it's... for this and it makes movies shorter
- 56:24not that i'm a proponent uh you know pro short
- 56:28movie right but sometimes it feels good especially
- 56:31if they're not great movies i i will tell you
- 56:33that popping on some of the movies that i have
- 56:35been i see 90 minutes and i'm like let's go yeah
- 56:38let's go it's like a treat well especially with
- 56:40the the subject matter but yeah that's a whole
- 56:42time If you have thoughts about The Smiling Lieutenant
- 56:45or any of the other films we'll be covering for
- 56:48this Academy year, next episode we'll be doing
- 56:50Bad Girl, shoot us an email at outaopodcast at
- 56:54gmail .com. Those email responses get read on
- 56:57our ceremony episodes at the end of every month.
- 57:00I'll just throw out a question, too, if you want
- 57:01to respond to that in this email. How do you
- 57:04feel about musicals? Do you love movies, but
- 57:06you're like, yeah, but I don't vibe with musicals.
- 57:09And if you don't like musicals, tell us the one
- 57:11musical that you were kind of okay with. Yeah.
- 57:13Because I think that's indicative of the kind
- 57:15of musicals you would like. Even if it's like
- 57:16a Disney movie. For sure. Or a musical episode
- 57:19of a TV show that's gone on for like eight seasons.
- 57:22Because it's happened. I mean, Community did
- 57:24it. Will Trent did it. A musical? Yeah. Interesting.
- 57:28Yeah. Didn't, well, I mean, Glee does it every
- 57:31episode. American Horror Story did it. Simpsons
- 57:33did it. They all do it. If you'd like to show
- 57:36your support for the show, check out patreon
- 57:39.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. By doing so,
- 57:42you'll gain access to the community Discord,
- 57:44monthly watch parties, movie reviews where Ryan
- 57:48reviews fun current movies. Oh, I need to do
- 57:51that for Project Hail Mary. Yeah, hit me up with
- 57:53it, man. We'll get it posted if it's not already.
- 57:56And what else do we have on there? Oh, you can
- 57:58vote for what film you think deserves to win
- 58:01Best Picture for each Academy year. That's fun.
- 58:04But yeah, check that out. Again, patreon .com
- 58:06slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. Subscribe, rate,
- 58:10review the show. And yeah, I think that's it.
- 58:13We appreciate you guys listening. Yeah, we do.
- 58:16That's going to do it for this episode. As always,
- 58:18I'm your host, Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 58:21you at the movies.