Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow with Force: Chapter 1 - Why Force Works (Until It Doesn’t)
Transcript
- Catalyst FWF Chapter 1: Think about something you're good at. naturally gifted at it, just good at it because you've done it hundreds, maybe thousands of times. A skill you have, a profession a hobby, a relationship. Now think about how you got good at it. Most likely the answer is some combination of effort, ⁓ repetition, discipline, attention. You practiced, you adjusted, you improved. ⁓ The relationship pretty clear. What you put in affected what came out. That's one of the reasons force becomes so convincing. It works. Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm doctor G, an executive coach, trained ethnographer, and nonfiction nerd. I read widely, annotate obsessively, and spend a great deal of time thinking about how ideas shape the way we live, lead, and notice the world around us. In this episode, I explore why force earns our trust so early, why competence often reinforces that trust, and why some of the most successful people struggle when they encounter environments where effort and outcome no longer have a straightforward relationship. Before we can understand where force stops working, we need to understand why it works so well in the first place. The reason force becomes our default. It works. Not in every situation, in enough of them, early enough in our lives that it earns our trust. You study harder, your grades improve. You train more, you perform better. You focus, prepare, push, you reach goals. That relationship feels pretty clear. More effort, more control, better results. It's a powerful equation and it's reinforced everywhere in school, in sport, the workplace. You've been part of systems that are structured, predictable, and responsive. Linear. If you do this, you get that. When that pattern holds, you don't just learn what to do. You learn how the world works. Or at least how you think it works. When I was 11 years old, a younger neighborhood kid was being shoved around by someone bigger than him. The other boy wasn't bigger than me, but he was a heck of a lot stronger. But I stepped in. What followed was exactly what you'd expect from a couple of fifth grade boys, you know, trying to settle something on a hot summer day in 1980. It wasn't graceful, it wasn't noble, it it was just a whole lot of clumsy aggression, right? I remember something else. Force worked. The bullying stopped. When you experience something like that early enough, not only your brain, but your nervous system remembers it. Not intellectually, physically. You learn that force can do good. Force properly applied can protect, stabilize. Correct. This series is not an argument against force. After listening to this, I hope you remember that force has its place. Know that place. That's really the deeper consideration under all of this. Many of us learned force not through philosophy, but through reinforcement. My father witnessed my anti-bullying campaign that day. He praised me for it. Still does. You work hard, someone praises you. You stay disciplined, doors open. You stay composed under pressure. People begin relying on you. The pattern repeats. Repeated patterns become beliefs. Then identities. I can trace some of my identity back to yellow legal paths. Every summer morning growing up, my mom would head off to work after leaving me a list of chores. Normal stuff, you mow the lawn clean this, move that. I learned quickly that if I handled the responsibilities ⁓ the rest of the day opened ⁓ Adventures, friends, bikes, woods, frogs, toads, ugly street hockey, whatever the summer day you wanted to become. A habit was born and then raised to an adult. Do the work, stay reliable, then go play. Simply enough, over time, trying to be reliable stopped being a behavior and started becoming my identity. I became dependable, the one who handled things, the one who got it done. There's something important that happens when people begin experiencing you that way. They stop merely appreciating your reliability and start organizing around it. Quietly, incrementally, they trust you with more, depend on you more, expect more. And none of this is bad. Not at all. In fact, these type of traits build meaningful lives. There's a subtle shift that can happen if we're not paying attention, however. The strategy that once served us begins expanding beyond the environments where it was originally effective. That's where things get interesting. In linear systems, force works remarkably well. See bully, stop bully, be praised. In contexts such as these, the number of variables is pretty limited. The feedback is relatively immediate, right? Force-induced competence is one reason highly competent people may struggle when they encounter complexity. Competence creates confidence in the strategy, not just the skill, the strategy, the way of looking at a problem. If something isn't working, do more. Do it better. Refine it. Optimize it. Tighten the process. To be fair, this mindset can create incredible results in the right environment. Not all environments are linear, some are complex. Complexity changes the relationship between effort and outcome. Human relationships are complex. Teams are complex. Leading is complex. Parenting is complex. Teaching is complex. Healing is complex. The human body is complex. In these systems, variables interact with each other constantly. Timing matters. Emotions matter. Attention matters. Interdependence matters. Context matters. Time and place, right? Uncertainty rules in these environments. In complex environments, force may not always produce clarity. Sometimes it produces resistance. Sometimes it produces rigidity. Sometimes it produces chaos. I learned this. In nineteen ninety two, my first year as a teacher. Imagine 27 six-year-olds trying to line up to leave a classroom. ⁓ boy, here's where the herding of cats begins. Catching fleas with a fishnet, they say. These classroom train wrecks happen four or five times a day. Transitions become ecosystems in elementary classrooms, ⁓ social systems full of high emotion, rapid shifts in attention, distinct personalities, and tiny shoes untying themselves at exactly the wrong moments. Early on I approached these transitions the way many adults approach complexity. More structure, more direction, more control. I tried managing every variable like an air traffic controller or a police officer directing traffic at an intersection. Stand here, move there, no talking, straight line, face forward. Honestly. And this will be no surprise to you, the more I controlled it, the worse it became, like a golf swing, I would learn decades later. I was applying linear logic within a complex human environment. To kids, little kids. A monumental shift happened when I loosened control without removing expectations. The students still had parameters. We still had a purpose. They were allowed a voice in the choice, some ownership. Immediately things flowed better. Not perfectly, just better. They participated in the process instead of merely complying with it. And that distinction matters more than we often realize, especially in leadership and relationships, especially with ourselves. Force often seeks compliance. Flow invites participation. Now, if you're listening carefully, as I know you are, you might notice this creates tension. The modern world rewards force constantly. False urgency, optimization culture, productivity theater, performative professionalism, respond immediately. Fix immediately. Decide immediately. Scale immediately. Answer immediately. We've normalized urgency to the point that many people no longer consider calm attention productive. If something isn't moving quickly, we assume something is wrong. Biologically, psychologically, relationally. That's often untrue. Some things, most things, need latency, time. Learning does, healing does, trust does. Even physical coordination often emerges after periods of awkwardness and discoordination. Cognitively, too. Your brain frequently makes sense of things after you stop consciously forcing it to. There's neuroscience behind this, you know, systems thinking. Honestly, most people already know it intuitively though. Sleep on it? We've been saying that phrase forever. Many of us continue to live as though every moment requires immediate, force filled attention, personally, professionally, emotionally. Notice how in demand your attention is. Notifications, messages, emails, deadlines, updates. Everything arrives in formal attire, dressed up as urgency. Over time, that repeated urgency trains something into us, a default relationship with force, not intentional force, unconscious force. That distinction is critical. Force itself is not the villain here. Misapplied force is force used in the wrong environment, force used reflexively, force used because we don't know what else to do with uncertainty. That's where the trap forms. The trap becomes even harder to recognize when you perceive yourself as competent. When force stops working, your first instinct usually isn't, hmm, this approach may no longer fit the environment. Your instinct is to try harder, refine more, control more precisely, double down. That's what force induced competence does. It trusts its previous evidence until the evidence changes. For me, some of that evidence manifested physically. In 2025, I dealt with a long stretch of GI issues, multiple appointments, multiple professionals, different conversations that all seemed to circle back toward the same question. They'd ask, what's happening in your life right now? Not just physically, emotionally, socially, relationally. At first I treated those questions the same way many force-centric people do, as secondary considerations. But over time, a pattern became difficult to ignore. Much of the stress I was carrying around was self-induced, not intentionally. Induced through a constant internal force, Trying to align everything with my expectations, trying to manage outcomes, trying to keep everyone and everything aligned with a vision that really wasn't necessarily necessary. My body responded accordingly. Looking back now, I acknowledged something I wouldn't have recognized then. My body was not betraying me, it was informing me. That realization changed something, not overnight. This podcast series is not a collection of stories about an overnight transformation. It's about the long-term effects of a recognition, an awareness, a discernment. In learning how to ask, what kind of environment am I actually in right now? And what might it need from me? Different environments require different relationships with effort. Sometimes force is appropriate, necessary even, a child at risk, a boundary crossed, an emergency is unfolding. Force has its place, know that place. Many situations asking for presence, responsiveness, patience, listening, emergence, trust or participation are often met instead with a tightening, more pressure, more urgency, more control. Eventually we begin forcing conversations that need to be listened to, forcing solutions rather than offering considerations, forcing ourselves into identities we may have outgrown. At first the inconsistencies are subtle. Things that should respond to force don't. Effort no longer translates cleanly. Control creates instability instead of calm. At first you explain it away. It's an off day. It's just a missed variant. A chance occurrence. Eventually the pattern becomes harder to ignore. There are situations where force doesn't just stop helping, it starts interfering. Once you recognize that, a different kind of question begins to form. Not how do I do this better? But is this the kind of situation where force will work best? That's the quieter realization I hope lingers with you after this episode, that force has its place. We need to know that place. Force works, that's what makes this conversation difficult. It does protect, it stabilizes, it creates results. Many of the qualities we admire in ourselves and others were built through effort, discipline, reliability, and control. The challenge begins when a successful strategy quietly becomes a default response. When force stops being something we use and starts becoming part of who we are. Because repeated success doesn't just build competence, it builds identity. And sometimes, without realizing it, We begin organizing our lives around a simple question. What needs to be fixed here? That's where we'll begin in the next episode, chapter two, The Fixer Identity. I'm Dr. G. Those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.