Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 264. Show Your Receipts: Communicating in a Post-Truth World
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: The best way to connect and truly communicate
- 0:06is to be curious and respectful.
- 0:09My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:13Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:15Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:19Today I'm really excited to speak with Fareed Zakaria.
- 0:21Fareed is the host of CNN's flagship International Affairs
- 0:25Program, Fareed Zakaria GPS.
- 0:28And he's a weekly columnist for The Washington Post.
- 0:31He specializes in translating complex geopolitical trends for a broad audience.
- 0:36His insightful book, Age of Revolutions, is out now in paperback.
- 0:41Welcome, Fareed.
- 0:42I have benefited so much from what you do on television and in your writing.
- 0:46Thanks so much for being here.
- 0:48Fareed Zakaria: It's a pleasure to do this.
- 0:49Matt Abrahams: Shall we get started?
- 0:50Fareed Zakaria: Absolutely.
- 0:51Matt Abrahams: You argue we're living in one of the most revolutionary
- 0:54periods in all of history.
- 0:56What specific forces are leading you to make this claim?
- 1:00Fareed Zakaria: So if you look at the base of change, particularly along
- 1:05the kind of key drivers that have tended to produce this kind of sense
- 1:09of society being upended, they tend to be technology in the first instance.
- 1:13Almost always, you know, in my book the Age of Revolutions, I talk about how
- 1:17starting with the Dutch and the invention of the kind of technology that allowed
- 1:22the Netherlands to become rich, you know, this was water management, then financial
- 1:27management, they created the first joint stock companies, the first stock exchange.
- 1:30Then transportation equipment, they invent tour ships that can go around the world.
- 1:36It produces a huge set of revolutions.
- 1:38If you think about the information revolution, this really is the mother
- 1:42of all revolutions at some level because you are almost replacing,
- 1:47or at least replacing in central importance, the material economy and
- 1:51supplanting it with a digital economy.
- 1:54And now with AI, that becomes even more true.
- 1:56The second is globalization, which is, we have seen an explosion of globalization
- 2:02on a scale, in the last 30 or 40 years, on a scale like nothing we've seen before.
- 2:07To put it in simple context, globalization, you know, the rest of
- 2:10the world joining in the kind of western open market system, 1950s and 60's, you
- 2:15had Japan joining, 80 million people.
- 2:17South Korea, 40 million people, Malaysia, maybe Singapore, Hong Kong, 5, 10 million.
- 2:23Between 1985 and 1995, roughly, China, India, most of Latin America,
- 2:29Indonesia, you talk about 3 and a half, 4 billion people joining
- 2:33the open world trading system.
- 2:35So that shock, but then the other one, which people don't think about
- 2:39enough is we have gone through enormous cultural change in the last 40 years.
- 2:44Think about the role of immigrants in society, in western societies.
- 2:48And another point I'm trying to make is that this is all
- 2:50happening at the same time.
- 2:51So when you put that all together, this does feel like
- 2:55the mother of all revolutions.
- 2:57Matt Abrahams: It's amazing how much has happened, and how much has happened
- 3:00in a relatively short amount of time.
- 3:02In an age where we're in the midst of this information revolution, and
- 3:07information is infinite, and algorithms influence who sees and hears our
- 3:11messages, I'm curious to get your opinion.
- 3:13Do facts still matter or has communication just become purely
- 3:17about identity and emotion?
- 3:19Fareed Zakaria: It's become much more about identity and emotion because
- 3:23of the disaggregation of channels.
- 3:26I think the fundamental technological shift here, which is driving all
- 3:30this, is that there used to be centralized modes of communication.
- 3:34You know, think about radio's a one to many broadcast system.
- 3:37That's why in the old days when they'd have a coup, you would try to take over
- 3:41the presidential palace and you tried to take over the radio station, 'cause
- 3:45you wanted the source of political power and the source of information power.
- 3:48Then you went to the TV station and the presidential palace.
- 3:52Today in a networked many to many broadcast system, there
- 3:56is no node to take over.
- 3:58There's no hierarchy of information, and in that situation, you are
- 4:01going to see a much greater degree of contested facts, contested
- 4:05narratives, and things like that.
- 4:06It's very disconcerting because it does mean, as you're suggesting, a kind of
- 4:11post-fact or post-truth environment.
- 4:14But it is where we are, and that means that you try hard to make
- 4:19your case as forcefully as you can.
- 4:20You can't rely on authority anymore to say, trust me, this is what happened.
- 4:26You are gonna have to show the receipts.
- 4:28Matt Abrahams: You know, if you were to give people advice on how to talk
- 4:31smart in an environment where all the incentives are to speak loudly,
- 4:37what would you tell people to do?
- 4:38Fareed Zakaria: The first thing you try to do if you're trying to genuinely
- 4:41persuade people, as opposed to preach to the converted, which is what I would
- 4:45argue, 90% of what passes for political discourse on television and even beyond
- 4:50television, social media for sure.
- 4:53The first thing you've gotta do is you've gotta try and make the case
- 4:56as plainly, and I don't wanna say unemotionally, but in a way that
- 5:01does not rely on demonizing somebody.
- 5:05You are trying to present the facts and you're trying to say, this
- 5:08is what the landscape looks like.
- 5:10Now, here's why I think what I do.
- 5:13So you're not doing, you're not, there's not a lot of ad hominem.
- 5:16There's not a lot of name calling.
- 5:18There's not a lot of screaming, because otherwise you're turning
- 5:21off a whole bunch of people.
- 5:23The second thing I think you have to do is you have to marshal the facts.
- 5:27When I say the receipts, you have to have real evidence, real data,
- 5:31so that people can see that you are coming to your conclusions from an
- 5:36honest place of analysis, rather than a preconceived place of this is my
- 5:41team and I'm rooting for my team.
- 5:43And the third, and this may sound like it's contradictory to the second, you
- 5:47have to be able to establish a connection, almost an emotional connection, with
- 5:52the person reading you, viewing you.
- 5:55And what I mean by that is you have to establish trust and you
- 5:58can do it in different ways.
- 6:00One way is to not demean the other side.
- 6:03Do it in a way that says, look, I'm trying to be as honest
- 6:06and honorable as I can here.
- 6:07This is the situation as I see it, it seems to me we're going
- 6:11down a bad path and here's why.
- 6:13So if you do those three things, you are likely to help, the way I think about it
- 6:18is lead somebody down a series of steps.
- 6:21Now, they may not get to the place you want them to get to, but at least they've
- 6:25gone down those steps and they've seen that you're trying to go down those
- 6:28steps honorably and reasonably and fairly, and then they may back away.
- 6:32Matt Abrahams: What I heard you say is that it starts with respect.
- 6:35You don't start with challenging and vitriol.
- 6:39You then provide the facts and then connect in a way that's
- 6:42genuine, authentic, and that's how you can foster understanding,
- 6:46which is different from agreement.
- 6:48I think that gets conflated a lot where we see understanding and
- 6:52agreement being the same thing.
- 6:53As somebody who does both writing and video camera work, many people are finding
- 7:00themselves having to be on air more.
- 7:02I mean, much of our communication now is visual.
- 7:05If you're a leader in an organization, you have to have a camera presence.
- 7:09What have you noticed has helped you be successful in making that
- 7:12transition from writing and speaking in meetings, into being on camera, in
- 7:18a way that we all could benefit from some of the advice that you've learned?
- 7:22Fareed Zakaria: What I am struck by is visual media is actually quite, it's
- 7:27the opposite of what most people think.
- 7:28It selects for a lot of things, but one of them is intelligence.
- 7:33Think about it this way.
- 7:34If you have an article that you're reading in a long magazine, say
- 7:37The Atlantic or The New York Review of Books, or the Harvard Business
- 7:40Review, it's not quite that long.
- 7:42They can often meander.
- 7:44They can often be parenthetical.
- 7:46You can't do that on visual.
- 7:48People will stop, they'll click off, they'll switch the channel.
- 7:51They'll stop watching the YouTube video.
- 7:53You have to stay focused.
- 7:55You have to be linear.
- 7:57There has to be a narrative.
- 7:59You have to be saying something important.
- 8:00You can't be doing a lot of throat clearing.
- 8:03So that I think I'm just, I happen to be good at because that's my
- 8:07way of thinking and talking anyway.
- 8:09And I tend to think that it's also that I am myself.
- 8:13I don't put on airs.
- 8:15I don't try to speak in a very fancy way.
- 8:18I, if you watch my show compared to, let's say you pull up a broadcast from
- 8:23Peter Jennings or Tom Brokaw, old anchors of 20 years ago, they would speak in
- 8:28these perfect clipped sentences with a, usually a low Midwestern baritone.
- 8:34And I don't talk like that.
- 8:35I talk the way I would talk to you normally.
- 8:37I also will have an occasional, um, in there.
- 8:40I think that conveys to the viewer, this is a real human being and you're getting
- 8:45him talking the way he normally talks.
- 8:48I, I tend to think that's an advantage.
- 8:50It's maybe partly I say that because I don't think I could pull off this
- 8:54sustained staying in that anchorman mode, but I do think it's an advantage.
- 9:00Matt Abrahams: So I'm hearing concision and authenticity are really important,
- 9:04and the visual medium is not as forgiving.
- 9:08And these are skills that you can learn and you have to practice,
- 9:10and yet it's becoming more and more relevant and important.
- 9:13I want to tie in some of your work on revolutions to things that
- 9:17we think a lot about, which is entrepreneurship and disruption.
- 9:21Many of the revolutions you described started with radical ideas that
- 9:25eventually became mainstream.
- 9:27Are there lessons we can learn that can help entrepreneurs and activists
- 9:32take their disruptive ideas and make them more generally acceptable?
- 9:36Fareed Zakaria: I think that more than anything else, the ones that seem to
- 9:40succeed have two elements to them.
- 9:43One is luck.
- 9:44I will be totally honest with you, and I think anyone who doesn't
- 9:47admit this is just being silly.
- 9:49You know, you get the right time at the right place.
- 9:52The timing worked.
- 9:53Other factors came together to make something happen.
- 9:57But the second is a certain kind of determination, a certain doggedness.
- 10:03You, you can't get too disheartened when you're trying to do something and you have
- 10:07to be willing to ride the ups and downs.
- 10:10The way I think about it is so many of the people who I've seen who've been
- 10:13successful entrepreneurs, the, the company that worked was their third company.
- 10:17They were determined to find something that works and you adjust and say,
- 10:21okay, the market doesn't want this, or the consumer doesn't want that,
- 10:24but you are going to do something.
- 10:26You're going to make it work in some way or the other.
- 10:29Matt Abrahams: So it's determination and taking advantage of the
- 10:31situation that is around you.
- 10:33Fareed Zakaria: Maybe the thing about luck is to recognize when fortune
- 10:37is favoring you and ride the wave.
- 10:40And that does take skill and that does take, you need to be prepared, you
- 10:43need to work hard, and you need to ride the wave when you see the wave coming.
- 10:47And the other side to it is recognize when you are against the wave.
- 10:50I remember having this fascinating conversation with George Soros once.
- 10:54And he said, you and I do the same thing.
- 10:57We look at the world and try to analyze it.
- 10:59The difference is I put my money where my mouth is and you don't have to.
- 11:02I said, okay, given that, what do you think are the differences
- 11:05in the way we approach it?
- 11:06And he said, I'll tell you I think one of the principle differences.
- 11:10People who are intellectuals get very wedded to their ideas and they're
- 11:14very wedded to their theories and they're slow to notice that the
- 11:17world is disconfirming your idea.
- 11:20He said, if I see that the market is telling me I'm wrong, I will
- 11:24sometimes wait, but it's very expensive to wait and so you really
- 11:29need to take in that feedback that the market is telling you you're wrong.
- 11:33And there are times when I have made a bet and the market is telling me
- 11:36I'm wrong, and I'll bet against myself twice as hard on the opposite side of
- 11:41that bet because I've realized that the market is right and I'm wrong.
- 11:45And intellectuals tend to be way too stubborn in holding onto their theories.
- 11:49And you know this from being at a university, 'cause people in a way
- 11:53get famous for their theory, right?
- 11:56Matt Abrahams: I think that's a really valuable point.
- 11:58In addition to tenacity and recognizing, and being able to observe the patterns
- 12:02to decide what decisions to make, we need to be willing to let go and cut bait.
- 12:07And that's so hard.
- 12:09There's so many things that conspire against that.
- 12:12I'm gonna be very curious to hear your thoughts on this.
- 12:15I and a fellow colleague at the GSB, Rachel Konrad, have become very
- 12:18concerned about how teens communicate and the challenges that they have.
- 12:24I'm sure you've seen the same decline that I have, that critical
- 12:27thinking, interpersonal communication among teens has really taken a hit.
- 12:31Do you have thoughts on what parents, teachers, communities can do to
- 12:36help adolescents communicate better?
- 12:39Fareed Zakaria: I do.
- 12:40I hate to be clichéd about this, but I do think that Jonathan Haidt
- 12:43is dead on when he talks about the effects of phones and social media,
- 12:48and it's the combination of the two, I think, and I have personal examples.
- 12:52I've seen this with my kids, and in one case, one of my kids put aside their
- 12:57smartphone for two years, they only had a flip phone and it totally transformed
- 13:02the way in which they had the ability to connect and think and savor life almost.
- 13:09I think that the thing about a smartphone, which is like a supercomputer
- 13:12in your pocket, is it creates a certain kind of learned autism.
- 13:16What I mean by that, say when you and I were younger, we were
- 13:19in a awkward social situation.
- 13:21We're at a cocktail party, school mixer, you have to make your way around, right?
- 13:26Like you have to figure out what to do.
- 13:28You find somebody you can talk to, you look around sheepishly and
- 13:32hope that you catch somebody's eye.
- 13:34You are engaged in social interaction.
- 13:37Today, you know what happens.
- 13:38The minute somebody feels socially awkward, take out their phone.
- 13:42And they're on their phone and they're now looking at Instagram or
- 13:46they're connecting with some friends.
- 13:47But those are people that already know.
- 13:49You're not engaging in the hard work of social interaction, which
- 13:53is with the people you don't know.
- 13:55Breaking the ice, finding a way in.
- 13:58Similarly, if you're listening to a lecture, the minute it gets boring
- 14:01for you, you take out your phone.
- 14:03You're not asking yourself, okay, is there something interesting here?
- 14:06Is there something I can connect with?
- 14:08Is there, no.
- 14:08So that's what I mean by the learned autism, right?
- 14:11Like it, you immediately retreat to yourself.
- 14:13And the supercomputer in your pocket allows you to retreat to
- 14:16yourself so quickly that you lose the muscles of doing those other
- 14:21things that you should be doing.
- 14:22I think that's most of it.
- 14:24I do not believe that kids today are stupid or, they're good, they're
- 14:29hardworking, they have good morals, they have good ethics, but I think
- 14:32we have given them the biggest temptation you could ever imagine.
- 14:37Imagine if you and I were trying to study in the old days, and you were
- 14:42given a machine on which you were told, you can watch every movie that
- 14:46has ever been made, every song that has ever been recorded, you know,
- 14:51here, or you could do your homework.
- 14:53You are giving them an impossible temptation.
- 14:56And so I just think the degree to which you can limit it is the best you can do.
- 15:01Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 15:02I do agree that social media phones absolutely have implications.
- 15:07I do think adults in kids' lives can take action by role modeling, good
- 15:12communication, walking through the decisions that we make as we communicate
- 15:16with others, just so that we can make sure that these skills are, at
- 15:20least, demonstrated and encourage.
- 15:22Fareed Zakaria: Yeah, I would, I'll give you an example.
- 15:24In my family, we always sit down to dinner together.
- 15:26No phones at the table, and we always talk.
- 15:30Now, contrary to what a lot of people think, we don't talk about the world and
- 15:34international affairs and what's going on.
- 15:37We talk about just pretty mundane stuff.
- 15:40I think that's the more important, 'cause I want, I don't want them to have
- 15:43to feel like characters in my movie.
- 15:45It's about what happened in their day and what happened in the
- 15:47dog's life and things like that.
- 15:49And that I think just, it seems very simple, but it does seem to me that
- 15:55it's a fairly good force multiplier.
- 15:57And when I've talked to them, they often point out that when they talk to their
- 16:00friends, it's becoming uncommon for family to just sit together dinner and have
- 16:05that meal together and sit down, talk.
- 16:07No phones.
- 16:08It's usually, let's be honest, it's 30 minutes, but it's
- 16:12a very useful 30 minutes.
- 16:14Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 16:15And I love that you take the time to do that.
- 16:17And I'd love to be a fly on the wall on those conversations because in my mind,
- 16:21I would imagine one thing and you're telling me it's something very different.
- 16:25Before we end, I like to ask three questions of everybody.
- 16:27One I create just for you, and then the other two are
- 16:30similar across all the episodes.
- 16:31Are you up for that?
- 16:32Fareed Zakaria: Sure.
- 16:33Matt Abrahams: You have made your career, or part of your career, by asking
- 16:36tough, insightful questions of people.
- 16:39What makes for a good question and do you have a go-to question
- 16:44that you like to ask people?
- 16:46Fareed Zakaria: No, I think that's a mistake.
- 16:47I think that ,in general, you really should be listening to people and
- 16:51watching them, and that's each person has a different button you want to press.
- 16:55I think the most important thing, and you've said it, it is being genuinely
- 16:59curious and genuinely believing that everybody has a story to tell.
- 17:04Everybody has something to teach you.
- 17:05Everybody has a lesson you can learn, and I really do believe that.
- 17:09And if you have that kind of curiosity, it's fun to ask people questions.
- 17:14If I go to dinner parties and I find that, like, people have just
- 17:17asked me lots of questions, I leave disappointed because I know what I think.
- 17:21I'm only learning when I'm listening, not when I'm talking.
- 17:24Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 17:25One of the mantras we learned from another guest we had on the show was,
- 17:28it's all about being interested and not interested, and when you take
- 17:31that approach, it can be very helpful.
- 17:33I'm curious to know your answer to this.
- 17:35Who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 17:38Fareed Zakaria: Well, there are many, but let me give you one right
- 17:41now just because it's top of mind.
- 17:43I think Mamdani, the new mayor of New York, is remarkable.
- 17:47He may be one of the best communicators I've seen because
- 17:50he's figured out the medium of the moment, you know, these short form
- 17:54videos, they're very expertly done.
- 17:57They're not, this is not amateur.
- 17:59Remember, his mother is one of the great directors of our age,
- 18:02you know, so they're done, right.
- 18:04But then he brings to it a kind of intelligence,
- 18:09imagination, and authenticity.
- 18:12So the imagination is, if, I dunno if you remember, he's
- 18:14advocating for rent freezes, right?
- 18:17So he jumps into the Long Island Sound in February in freezing waters
- 18:24in his entire, in his full suit.
- 18:26And he comes out saying something about how he's freezing and how
- 18:29he wants to freeze the rents.
- 18:30That's the imagination, to get your attention to, he, that
- 18:34is really very compelling.
- 18:35That, that mixture of intelligence, imagination, knowing the
- 18:39medium and being authentic.
- 18:41I should say, I find many of his ideas deeply troubling and I don't agree
- 18:47with the substance of the policies, but I am irresistibly drawn to the
- 18:52power of his communication skills.
- 18:55Matt Abrahams: Isn't it interesting how somebody can appreciate
- 18:58and understand the new way of communicating, new technologies,
- 19:02and still bring that authenticity intelligence to take advantage of it?
- 19:07Thank you for sharing that.
- 19:08Final question for you.
- 19:10What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:15Fareed Zakaria: I would start with authenticity because I think
- 19:18that's where you get the trust.
- 19:19Some say, you know, clarity and, you know, kind of a concision.
- 19:23And then the final one is probably that leap of imagination that
- 19:28allows you to be a little different.
- 19:30That allows you to do something arresting.
- 19:33That gets you into the top tier, I think.
- 19:36Matt Abrahams: So it's about authenticity, clarity and concision,
- 19:41and creativity and imagination.
- 19:43And I think when you combine that recipe together, you get great
- 19:47communication and certainly you are a good example of putting those together.
- 19:53I appreciate all of the ideas and best practices you have shared, and I really
- 19:57appreciate the intelligent conversation that you role model for all of us.
- 20:01Thank you for your time and best of luck on your paperback of Age of Resolutions.
- 20:06Fareed Zakaria: Thank you so much.
- 20:07This was so much fun.
- 20:08I actually learned a lot while doing it.
- 20:12Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:14Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:17To learn more about managing complex issues and communication, please listen
- 20:21in to episode 161 with Jen Psaki.
- 20:24This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 20:30Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 20:32With special thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 20:34Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 20:38Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 20:40Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 20:44And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 20:48learning content, and our newsletter.
- 20:51Please consider joining our Think Fast Talk Smart Learning Community
- 20:54at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 20:57You'll find video lessons, learning quests, decision boards, an AI
- 21:01coach, and book club opportunities.
- 21:04Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast
- 21:09Talk Smart Learning Community.