Latest / Automotive State of The Union / California’s CARS Act, Chargers Fail 30% of the Time, Nvidia and xAI Make a Deal?
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Monday, October 13th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Kyle Mounts here. Got my co-host, Steve Greenfield.
- 0:09Today, we're talking about the California CARS Act, chargers failing, and chips in AI. Here I go. The people really wanna know who I is and who I be. Not AI eating chips.
- 0:20[laughs] Unless you, you know, AI's never gonna eat chips. But it does kind of eat chips. Well, well, at least a, at least a year away. Yeah. At least a year.
- 0:26[laughs] Or at least if the Optimus robot gets a mouth at some point. Just gets a mouth on them. Other than Kung, Kung Fu- Kung Fu... the next thing, it's gonna start eating chips maybe. Yeah. [laughs] Kung Fu and chips.
- 0:35That's great. [laughs] That's great. Uh, Steve, it's so good to have you here today. Uh, I'm excited to jam with you.
- 0:40I wanna talk about, just real quick, we've got an ASOTU Edge webinar, uh, that we, that we have coming up. You're gonna wanna check it out.
- 0:47You can go to asotu.com, A-S-O-T-U.com, scroll down just a bit, and check out Rules of the Road: Why, When, and How to Move Vehicles Between Stores.
- 0:56As consolidation happens, it's w- uh, a growing infrastructure change to have a used car director moving car, uh, cars around.
- 1:03Uh, and Paul Galias of Modern Auto Group is gonna share with us exactly how, why, and when they do it. You're not gonna wanna miss it.
- 1:11Uh, but let's get into the show today, 'cause we've, we've got some heavy topics coming around the bend.
- 1:16Governor Gavin Newsom has signed the California Combating Auto Retail Scams Act, a landmark law that establishes new consumer protection standards and stricter sales transparency across the state beginning in October of 2026.
- 1:30The, uh, California CARS Act closely mirrors about 70% of the vacated CARS rule, uh, that the FTC had brought out, and prohibits dealers from mis- misrepresenting key facts about vehicle sales, leases, or finances, uh, or financing.
- 1:46The CARS Act bans valueless add-ons, such as unnecessary service contracts or redundant, redundant protection products.
- 1:53Buyers of used vehicles under $50,000 now have a required three-day right to cancel with mileage and condition limits.
- 2:00Senator Ben Allen stated, "Some of the behavior and standard business practice in the car sales world I found very despi- dispiriting and distasteful. I wanted to make the car buying experience for regular folks better."
- 2:13A big move by California, Steve. Yeah. I mean, obviously dealers in, in California will be impacted by this immediately. I think just the rest of the country needs to keep a close eye.
- 2:24Um, California is always indicated as being way too left-leaning and embracing these sort of, quote-unquote, "radical" ideas early. But, um, you know, typically what we see is there's a trickle-down effect.
- 2:36California is the first adopter of many of these kinds of consumer protection policies, and then eventually the rest of the country adopts.
- 2:43So this may not be the case, you know, while, while Trump's in the White House, but I think, uh, you know, dealers around the country should at least be paying attention to this and seeing what the implications are for them eventually in their local markets.
- 2:54Yeah.
- 2:54I think similar to some of the EV changes that they had brought about, uh, this kind of opens the door for something that looked like it was gonna be a national campaign with the FTC leading it, to other states, probably those 11 and 12 that followed with EV mandates similar to California, to kind of open up the door to, "Hey, do we wanna implement something like this at a local level?"
- 3:14Uh, so I think that especially those states that maybe saw, uh, you know, the, their, their political regime follow California from an EV mandate state should be looking out to say, "Okay, this might be something that over the next five to six months we might see similar things coming into play," uh, or at least being voted on, uh, at the state level.
- 3:33Yep. Great point. Absolutely. Uh, I've got no segue for this one other than, uh, other than this was in Steve's email, so Steve gets to talk about it.
- 3:41But a new EV charging reliability report from ChargeHelp reveals a critical gap between charger availability and usability, showing that nearly one in three charging attempts fails despite reported uptime near 99%.
- 3:55The study analyzed 100,000 sessions ac- across 2,400 chargers, finding only a 71% first-time charge success rate. ChargeHelp CEO, Kamale Terry, argued, uh, "FTCSR is the true measure of reliability, not uptime."
- 4:12Uh, FTCSR standing for First-Time Charge Success Rate. They've got, uh, acronyms too. Uh, she's, they state, "It captures the real driver experim- experience.
- 4:23The biggest culprit is software fragmentation with EVs, chargers, and payment systems often failing to communicate properly." That's APIs, folks. Uh, Terry remains hopeful it's a solvable problem.
- 4:34Even gas cars had their growing pains before becoming mainstream. Yeah.
- 4:39I mean, l- look, I mean, my, my point of view on this is at some point there will be a tipping point where the average consumer says, "Hey, EVs are better than gas cars."
- 4:48Uh, we're, we're y- years away from it, and a lot of it's gonna come down to battery chemistry, right?
- 4:52So you need to have a lot of range in the vehicle, you need to be able to charge that vehicle very quickly, but, but then the last thing is there needs to be charger availability.
- 5:01And wh- when you can't have the luxury of charging at home- Mm-hmm... then you're charging out in the w- in the wild, right? I- in, in the public space.
- 5:08And when a third of the time that you try to charge your car it doesn't work, forget charger availability. We could have a lot of chargers- Right...
- 5:13but it's, y- you know, playing Russian roulette and one out of three times your car isn't going to work with the charger that you pull up to, we, we need to do better.
- 5:22And, you know, Te- Tesla, the compatibility thing is a good observation. T- Tesla works because Teslas go to Tesla superchargers. Yep. And they almost always work.
- 5:31I, I think that the, the, the non-work, uh, percentage is, like, 4% or something- Wow... um, that get, that get kicked out compared to, like, you know, 30%. But, uh, yeah, it, it's tough.
- 5:41Um, it is going to be a software handoff thing, and, uh, we're, we're gonna continue to have challenges.
- 5:46But hopefully over time we can, we can get past this, because without consumers having confidence that when they pull up to a charger that shows available on their app and they can actually get charged from it, then we're gonna have a continued, uh, challenge to, to sell consumersDefinitely full battery electric vehicles, but, but even hybrids.
- 6:04Well, yeah, and I, I, you know, you look at this, it's like if I pull up to an Exxon or a BP, I can, I can fill up my gas tank, and I know that it's gonna work no matter what car I'm, uh, no matter what car I'm in.
- 6:14I kind of relate this to, like, the early days of, of cell phones, where you'd have USB-A or, uh, you know, uh, the, the, the Apple charging standards, and kind of everyone's moving to a USB-C standard, so it's kind of universal, uh, the way it goes.
- 6:29Even cars, uh, now are only coming with USB-C, uh, inputs. Um, so that's kind of, like, a trend in, in a similar direction.
- 6:37You study China a lot, and obviously there's a lot more, um, universalism when it comes to the charging port, but also the battery swapping.
- 6:46And, and that's how you drive adoption, is this kind of, like, universal framework in which things get adopted. We go back to, like, the way that Bluetooth was a universal framework for sending connection over airwaves.
- 6:59Um, and this is where all the manufacturers of every charger, of every car are going to have to agree on some sort of standard software hand up so- some sort of API standard in order to c- to increase the reliability and access to where you can literally roll up on any of these places and, and be able to charge.
- 7:20Yeah, there's been a movement towards the Tesla standard- Right... the NACS, North American Charging Standard. Uh, but that doesn't mean the software's gonna work, right?
- 7:26So you can have a charging standard where you can plug it into the hole, but it still doesn't mean that- Yes...
- 7:31you know, the s- the software's gonna communicate with one another to make sure that it'll- it'll draw current through that connection.
- 7:37So it's, it's actually a little bit harder even than just getting all phones on the same standard. You have to have the same standard, and then have the software handshake work. The backup. Yep. Mm-hmm.
- 7:47Speaking of a handshake. Stop. Segway. Time.
- 7:50[upbeat music] Since August, we've been talking about Elon Musk wanting to raise around $20 billion, uh, at a $200 billion valuation, and it looks like that now may include NVIDIA, both as chip supplier and key investor, an arrangement highlighting the increasingly intertwined nature of the AI hardware race.
- 8:13The proposed structure reportedly combines equity and debt within a special purpose vehicle that would buy NVIDIA chips and lease them back to xAI.
- 8:21NVIDIA could contribute up to $2 billion in equity while also profiting from the chip sales. Analysts note that the circular nature of these AI financing deals where investors also serve as vendors.
- 8:33NVIDIA has made similar moves recently, including a $100 billion commitment to OpenAI and a $5 billion stake in Intel, interestingly enough, another chip supplier.
- 8:44Uh, critics are seeing signs of tech market froth, but NVIDIA's def- uh, defenders argue the company is simply investing to strengthen its ecosystem.
- 8:53And Steve, you brought up, uh, a, a most recent graphic that I think Bloomberg put together. Let's pull that up, and talk us through, like, the way this ecosystem is kind of playing out and how it relates to auto.
- 9:04Yeah, this is from a f- the la- over the last few days it's got a lot of press, especially on Twitter or X. Um, you can see here ba- basically the, the size of the circles represents the market cap of these companies.
- 9:15NVIDIA being the juggernaut in the middle with, like, a $4.5 trillion market cap or whatever. But the arrows represent the cross-investments into different companies.
- 9:23And the speculation right now is that, you know, we are in a, in a bit of a, a bubble, right? Whether it's a healthy bubble and warranted or not.
- 9:30But, you know, so- something like 54% of all VC money right now is going into AI related companies. Wow.
- 9:36Um, you know, you look at these big, big checks being, being, um, being cut between NVIDIA and a bunch of the companies that rely on them for chips.
- 9:44You know, leaseback agreements around chips and, and buyback agreements, et cetera. So I think g- good for NVIDIA. NVIDIA's got this huge market cap, and it should try to keep the AI ecosystem very healthy- Right...
- 9:56and prop up their customers.
- 9:58But at some point you gotta kind of scratch your head that, you know, it's just a circular sort of, like, the, the market caps are feeding off of one another, sometimes from public companies into private companies or vice versa.
- 10:08And, um, you do kind of wonder, you know, if, if the, if the money going back and forth to continue to inflate these valuations is just a circular path.
- 10:16At what point does, you know, the music stop, um, to use the analogy with musical chairs, and someone's left standing. So- Yeah...
- 10:23I, I think that the, hopefully it's not the average retail consumer, but there, there's growing concern here that, you know, if this is just self-referencing, you know, i- is, is this healthy overall?
- 10:32So I think that, you know, Wall Street will be keeping a watchful eye on all of this.
- 10:36You know, I'd love to hear your take because obviously with your dealer investment fund, um, and, and some of the ways that you think about dealers investing in the tech partners, that they're also then turning around and, and more globally, right, maybe not directly, uh, but, but leveraging for, you know, their actual business, and how that there is some validity to this cross-referenced investment cycle that allows both to kind of grow together.
- 11:04Can you talk to how that kind of, like, plays out in auto and, and where we've seen the benefits of that?Yeah. We, we've seen a growing appetite of dealers, uh, investing directly within technology companies.
- 11:14I think deal- dealers, you know, have had a few years where they've had excess cash flow. Um, so they had the luxury of looking around and saying, "You know, where might I deploy that?"
- 11:23Coupled with the fact that now a lot of these early stage companies are very open to taking money directly from dealers. And it, it is, it is synergistic, right?
- 11:31So dealers can then not only adopt it, uh, within their stores, but also go to their 20 groups and really spread, spread the word to a lot of their net- their network to drive adoption for these, these companies.
- 11:42So I think, I think we're gonna continue to see that. You know, we, we've now raised three funds. More than half of our L- LPs or our investors are car dealer principals. Wow. And it's been, it's been great.
- 11:52Quite often that they, they want to invest in funds like ours because we see so many deals per month. We're seeing over 300 deals a month now, and they want the optionality to invest directly.
- 12:01To your point, it would be interesting if we saw more technology companies invest in dealerships.
- 12:06Um, the o- the only one that I know of was, you know, Tekion invested in some stores early on as a testing ground locally to their headquarters. They have since divested those.
- 12:15But we, we do hear many times dealers investing in startups, and I think we're starting to see more of a trend that you've documented, Kyle, you know, with, with dealers now, you know, kind of vibe coding their own solutions.
- 12:26Yeah.
- 12:26And I think we're gonna continue to see dealers that are a little more tech, tech savvy and may skew a little younger, may be open-minded to say, "Look, instead of me waiting for one of my vendors to build a feature, let me have a go at it and see if I can cobble together, you know, a, a pretty good solution as a stopgap that we can be using at our store."
- 12:44Well, especially locally and, and to provide a proof of concept.
- 12:47And what if then you were able to enable a, a, a strong entrepreneur that was able to take a prototype or a localized concept and bring it to market, right?
- 12:56And, and incentivize that person to bring it to market so that... Because you, you, you watch so many...
- 13:02You know, I think about Orion Moorman, and he, he, uh, he and I have talked about, "Why do you share all of these things that you're doing in your store?" And he's like, "No, you don't understand.
- 13:10If I share this and just a few dealers pick it up, the whole entire ecosystem thrives way more."
- 13:17And so I think more dealers are also thinking in that direction, which is, "If I can find a solution that works for me, and it probably works for others, then the whole thing rises."
- 13:27Uh, and, and so I, I love the, the cross-pollination of that.
- 13:31The kind of like a, you know, rising tide lifts all ships, uh, mentality between industry partners and dealers that we've seen over the last four to six years.
- 13:39Uh, I think it's providing actually some of the most entrepreneurial, uh, minds and highest, you know, cycle of innovation that we've ever seen within our industry.
- 13:49And, and kudos to people like you that are enabling that, uh, to happen, so. Well, thanks. No, I appreciate it. I, I couldn't have said it better myself. Hey, I'll take it.
- 13:58When Steve Greenfield says he couldn't say it better than, than him- than himself, let's go. Hey, you got some people to care for.
- 14:05Uh, whether t- tech or chips or AI or anything like that, there's people on the ground that need your, your service today. [upbeat music]