Latest / Sobering Stories / Why Aaron Kosminski Is NOT Jack The Ripper
Transcript
- 0:00Subsouvers pick up some merch. Have you ever heard of
- 0:11confirmation bias? The idea that seek and ye shall
- 0:15find. Well, in 2014 they did ADNA test
- 0:20and they successfully identified the identity of Jack the Ripper,
- 0:25allegedly. It's an age-old mystery that has
- 0:27gripped the world for more than a century.
- 0:30Jack the Ripper, the mysterious serial killer whose identity has
- 0:33long remained a mystery. That is.
- 0:36Until now. Yeah, DNA from a shawl recovered
- 0:39at the scene of one of his crimes has incredibly found a
- 0:42100% match. Well, for more, we are joined by
- 0:45the historian who made the bombshell discovery, Russell
- 0:48Edwards in London. Russell, good evening to you.
- 0:51Tell us about the match. Who is this person behind the
- 0:53infamous name? Good evening.
- 0:57Thank you for having me. So the name of the murderer,
- 1:01this has always been known, is the name is Aaron Kosminsky.
- 1:05An author named Russell Edwards was looking to write a book, and
- 1:09this book is called Naming Jack the Ripper, and he had already
- 1:13gone into this thinking that a man named Aaron Kosminsky was
- 1:17the prime suspect. Now, in 2007, this random shawl
- 1:22that was allegedly scooped up from one of the police officers
- 1:26from the Catherine Dow's crime scene.
- 1:29This shawl sat dormant for 120 years before descendants of this
- 1:34police officer brought this shawl to an auction.
- 1:37They were auctioning this shawl as an official.
- 1:40They were auctioning this shawl as an official piece of evidence
- 1:43from the Jack the Ripper case. Nobody really believed that this
- 1:47shawl actually, but nobody believed that this shawl
- 1:50actually had anything to do with the case.
- 1:52It's not mentioned in any evidence.
- 1:54It's not mentioned in any reports.
- 1:56It's not talked about ever. There's really no proof at all
- 2:00that this shawl had anything to do with any of these murders.
- 2:04Now the story goes that PC Amos Simpson, one of the police
- 2:08officers at the time, confiscated this shawl and
- 2:12brought it home as a gift for his wife.
- 2:16The fuck? Obviously this shawl is very
- 2:18old. It's sat dormant within this
- 2:20family, getting passed down from generation to generation, maybe
- 2:24one more generation. A ton of time between the Jack
- 2:27the Ripper murder and when this is being tested in 2007.
- 2:32So the only DNA that really exists on this shawl is
- 2:36obviously Amos Simpson's descendants DNA.
- 2:39But there's mitochondrial DNA that is still leftover on this
- 2:44shawl from 1888. So the theory is that if they
- 2:49test this mitochondrial DNA, if they track down one of Aaron
- 2:53Kosminsky's sister's direct descendants, because
- 2:57mitochondrial DNA only passes through the female side of the
- 3:02family lineage, then they might be able to link this shawl to
- 3:07Jack the Ripper. The only problem is he's going
- 3:10into this completely biased. He assumes Aaron Kosminsky is in
- 3:15fact Jack the Ripper. So we're not naming Jack the
- 3:18Ripper necessarily. We're just figuring out if Aaron
- 3:22Kosminsky or any of his possible female family descendants had
- 3:27anything to do with this shawl. In modern criminal cases, the
- 3:31DNA testing that's used is called nuclear DNA testing.
- 3:35I'm sorry, nuclear, nuclear, nuclear nuclear test.
- 3:41And this involves testing both the male and female parental DNA
- 3:47so it can actually track your lineage of both sides of your
- 3:50family. And this is how you get 99.99%
- 3:54accurate results. The only people sharing this
- 3:57same little snippet of DNA code would be a twin, but outside of
- 4:02that, it's completely unique to you.
- 4:04Now, in terms of mitochondrial DNA testing, you only have half
- 4:08of the puzzle. So it's only identifying whether
- 4:11or not this person or whoever you're testing for shares the
- 4:16same mother or grandmother or female down the line, but it
- 4:21doesn't necessarily prove that it's 1 Pacific person in a small
- 4:26area like Whitechapel. There's potentially thousands of
- 4:30people that could share the same mitochondrial DNA.
- 4:34So it's not necessarily the most accurate or reliable testing,
- 4:38especially for this situation. Plus, nobody even believed that
- 4:42this thing actually belonged to Jack the Ripper or had anything
- 4:45to do with this case because there was no proof.
- 4:48It was never logged as evidence. It was never mentioned at all in
- 4:51any of the reports. So people doubted whether this
- 4:55was legit or not. And of course nobody bid on it
- 4:58for that reason. But Russell Edwards, this
- 5:00author, ends up calling up the auction house and purchases and
- 5:05purchases it, and he purchases this thing, purchases, and he
- 5:08purchases it privately. Getting a direct match on this
- 5:12shawl with Aaron Kosminski would really only imply that he
- 5:17handled the shawl. And since we can't place this
- 5:20shawl within any of the murderers within any of the
- 5:23story of Jack the Ripper, what does that even really mean?
- 5:26It just means that this guy touched this random shawl that
- 5:29just happens to turn up 120 years later with no explanation.
- 5:33Even if this DNA comes back and says that Aaron Kosminsky does
- 5:37match with this profile, whoop Dee Doo.
- 5:40What does it all mean, Basil? But as it would turn out, Aaron
- 5:44Kosminsky would be a match for this DNA off of this shawl.
- 5:48So that would mean that one of his female descendants,
- 5:53grandmother or great grandmother, passed this DNA
- 5:56down to the person that touched this shawl.
- 6:00It's not saying that he pacifically was identified, it's
- 6:03just saying somebody within his female family lineage touched
- 6:06this shawl. So did Russell Edwards
- 6:09successfully name Jack the Ripper?
- 6:12I think not. Let's go.
- 6:31All right, welcome back to Sobering Stories with me, DJ
- 6:34Petrovsky. Welcome to the mini dive series.
- 6:37Trying to get more videos up for you guys during the week.
- 6:40So we do a mini dive every Tuesday.
- 6:42We do a deep dive every Friday. Please like this video, push it
- 6:46out to more people. Subscribe to the channel If you
- 6:48don't, I think you'll like what we got going on here, but I'm
- 6:51biased. Got tons of videos for you to
- 6:53check out. I'll leave a playlist at the
- 6:55end. You can start cruising through.
- 6:57Otherwise, follow me on my other social medias and let's go.
- 7:01This is going to be Part 2 of this series.
- 7:04Part 1 was actually posted a couple weeks ago.
- 7:07I'll link it in the description and I'll put a card.
- 7:09At the end of this video. We talk more about the victims
- 7:12and a general overview of the Jack the Ripper case.
- 7:16But this week I wanted to focus in on the widely recognized and
- 7:21accepted Jack the Ripper killer, Aaron Kosminsky.
- 7:24Aaron Kosminsky is one of those names that continuously pops up
- 7:28in the Jack the Ripper saga because, well, the dude was a
- 7:32little bit crazy. But he was a 23 year old Polish
- 7:35Jewish hairdresser and he lived right in the heart of
- 7:38Whitechapel. He was a part of this wave of
- 7:41Jewish immigrants that moved out of Russia from all this
- 7:44persecution and landed in Whitechapel, probably because it
- 7:49was cheap. In the last 139 years, there's
- 7:52been well over 100 different possible suspects who could have
- 7:56been Jack the Ripper, and with this case being so old, it's
- 8:01certainly difficult to even find new evidence to look at.
- 8:05All we really have to go off of is the police reports, this
- 8:09shawl, apparently old stories, possibly any new evidence that
- 8:13comes from information being passed down through the
- 8:17generations, but there's really nothing new.
- 8:19For that reason, people are endlessly fascinated by this
- 8:22case. But what makes the case against
- 8:24Aaron Kosminsky more convincing than any of these other 100 plus
- 8:29suspects? Well, for starters, Aaron lived
- 8:33less than one mile from all five of the suspected Jack the Ripper
- 8:37slayings. So that put him right in the
- 8:39heart of it, about 10 to 15 minute walk away from any one of
- 8:44them. The next reason is that the
- 8:45assistant police commissioner at the time, Robert Anderson, he
- 8:49very much suspected a Polish Jew, unnamed at the time as
- 8:53being the main suspect. In fact, he even goes as far as
- 8:56to say that he's confirmed that this is definitely Jack the
- 9:00Ripper, but he doesn't feel like it would be, I don't know, worth
- 9:04his time or it wouldn't benefit the public in any way to
- 9:07disclose this information. Robert Anderson actually wrote a
- 9:10book because he was like one of the lead investigators on this
- 9:13Ripper case. And in his book, he names this
- 9:16Polish Jew as the most likely suspect.
- 9:19This book, however, didn't come out until 1910, a good what, 20
- 9:23plus years after the murders happened.
- 9:26The police commissioner at the time he happened to read this
- 9:29book, and he wrote in the margins of this book of his copy
- 9:32that this Polish Jew was Aaron Kosminsky.
- 9:36Now, this book would lay dormant until 1981, when his grandson
- 9:41would actually find it, see that this dude was named in there and
- 9:45he would bring this information forward.
- 9:47So we didn't get the name Aaron Kosminsky until like the 80's,
- 9:52the 1980s. The other reason that this
- 9:54Polish Jew was listed as a suspect was because there was
- 9:58eyewitnesses that actually saw who they believe was Jack the
- 10:02Ripper actually speaking with Catherine Adow's just minutes
- 10:07before she was found murdered in Mitre Square.
- 10:09All of the descriptions of this alleged viewing, sighting of
- 10:13Jack the Ripper talk about a very big, burly individual
- 10:18wearing a big kind of coat and hat.
- 10:21The typical Jack the Ripper, you know, description.
- 10:24Aaron Kosminsky was a 23 year old, very small, very just, just
- 10:29a small dude. He did not match that
- 10:31description at all. Very frail, very thin.
- 10:34So this isn't sounding like the same person, but because he was
- 10:38named as a possible suspect at the time, well, they had to look
- 10:42into it because he was a hairdresser, a Barber, He would
- 10:46probably be skilled with a blade because barbers, you know, cut
- 10:50hair. And barbers back in the day, you
- 10:52know, maybe 100 years prior would actually do this thing
- 10:55called bloodletting. I think I talked about this in
- 10:57part one. I'm not sure, but they would
- 10:59basically just drain you of some of your blood if you were
- 11:02feeling sick 'cause they thought that the sickness was in the
- 11:04blood and you would go to a Barber shop to actually do the
- 11:07bloodletting thing, which I think is how George Washington
- 11:10died. Anyways, useless fact, but they
- 11:12had a feeling that since he had skills with a blade, that could
- 11:15line up with this whole mutilation Jack the Ripper
- 11:18thing. Now, police looked into it, but
- 11:20they weren't really sure exactly who this guy was.
- 11:24It wasn't until two years later in 1890, when police would
- 11:28actually bring in this eyewitness that happened to see,
- 11:31you know, Jack the Ripper, and he identified Aaron Kosminsky
- 11:35out of a lineup 2 years later. How reliable is that?
- 11:39But then when this witness was asked to testify against him,
- 11:42the witness identified as being of Jewish descent and he didn't
- 11:46want to be the reason that a fellow Jewish descendant ended
- 11:50up in the gallows, so he refused to testify.
- 11:53The last couple reasons why they suspect Aaron Kosminsky is
- 11:56because in 1891 he was institutionalized into an asylum
- 12:00and then he was transferred to Leavesden Asylum in 1894 and
- 12:05notes on his asylum records, they are pretty interesting.
- 12:09They say that he would eat food only out of the gutter.
- 12:12He refused food from other people.
- 12:14He would never eat food that somebody else gave him.
- 12:17He only ate food out of the gutter.
- 12:19He declares that he is guided and his movements altogether
- 12:22controlled by an instinct that informs his mind.
- 12:25He says he knows the movements of all mankind.
- 12:28He refuses food from others because he is told to do so, and
- 12:32he eats out of the gutter for the same reason.
- 12:35He goes about the streets and picks up bits of bread out of
- 12:38the gutter and eats them. He drinks water from the tap and
- 12:42he refuses food at the hands of others.
- 12:46Which they interpreted lined up pretty well with this Jack the
- 12:49Ripper character. And I mentioned this last week,
- 12:51but there was more murders that happened after 1888.
- 12:55It's just that those ones have all been widely debated whether
- 12:58or not they were actually Jack the Ripper or not.
- 13:01So most Ripper historians all agree that 1888 Mary Jane Kelly
- 13:06was the final Jack the Ripper victim, and these other ones
- 13:10were unrelated. But these other murders
- 13:12continued going on until 1891, the same year that Aaron
- 13:16Kosminsky was institutionalized. His time in this asylum is also
- 13:21some of the best evidence against why he would be Jack the
- 13:24Ripper #1 the dude was crazy. It seems implausible that
- 13:29someone with such serious mental illness could have planned and
- 13:33executed 5 murders without being caught, particularly if we
- 13:38propose that the Ripper was an organized killer.
- 13:41So a person who was absolutely insane and out of their minds,
- 13:45I'm not really sure how well they'd be able to carry out
- 13:48these very quick, very elusive and very graphic gruesome
- 13:55murders and have nobody catch him or see him at all.
- 14:00It's also noted that even though he hated women, he was not
- 14:04violent at all. He made one threat against his
- 14:06sister, one time using a knife, but that was pretty much the
- 14:10only violent activity that they could come up with for Aaron
- 14:13Kosminsky. He took up a knife and
- 14:15threatened the life of his sister.
- 14:17He is very dirty and will not be washed.
- 14:20He has not attempted any kind of work for years.
- 14:23So he didn't exhibit violent tendencies.
- 14:25As I mentioned before, people who saw Jack the Ripper, they
- 14:28say that he was over 30 years of age.
- 14:31He was a pretty big, strong character, very, very large
- 14:34size, and he had this big coat on.
- 14:38That's not Aaron Kosminski. He's a 23 year old, very small
- 14:41individual. And by 1888, he was noticeably
- 14:45insane. People commented that he came
- 14:48across as very frail. He was extremely dirty and
- 14:52frankly, kind of gross. He did not match this
- 14:54description at all. Plus, we have to take into
- 14:56consideration the fact that all of these victims were sex
- 15:00workers. And at the time, you'd have to
- 15:03understand who would these sex workers legitimately service
- 15:08because at that time there was extreme unrest and hatred
- 15:11towards the Jewish immigrants. So I highly doubt that sex
- 15:16workers at the time are going to be very quick to service someone
- 15:21of Jewish descent. I also don't feel like anybody
- 15:24who is of Jewish descent would find themselves in the
- 15:27sketchiest area of the sketchiest slum in all of London
- 15:32knowing the danger that comes with that.
- 15:34Plus he was noticeably crazy and filthy and disgusting.
- 15:39Not sure if any sex worker is going to want to service that
- 15:42dude and I doubt he had any money.
- 15:45If Kosminsky's illness was so overt and he looked as though he
- 15:49wouldn't have any money, sex workers would have been
- 15:52reluctant to accompany him to a dark corner, especially after
- 15:56the news of the first murders hit.
- 15:58He would have been considered even more of a threat in the
- 16:02view of the general consensus among White Chapel's inhabitants
- 16:06that a Jew was a responsible. Also, if we agree with most
- 16:12Ripper historians, the five actual murders of Jack the
- 16:16Ripper ended in 1888, so that would leave another two years of
- 16:22him just wandering around crazy, not doing anything, until
- 16:25finally getting picked up for being insane and sent to an
- 16:29asylum. And this last piece goes back to
- 16:31the beginning with the mitochondrial DNA, because Aaron
- 16:34Kosminsky had four siblings living in Whitechapel at the
- 16:37time. He had two brothers and two
- 16:40sisters, Isaac Abraham's Wolf Abraham's, Matilda Lobnowski and
- 16:46Betsy Abraham's. Now I'm sure you're wondering
- 16:48why they went by Abraham's. Well they were all Polish Jewish
- 16:52immigrants and living in Whitechapel at the time with
- 16:56crazy anti-Semitism. They decided that they would
- 16:59just change their name so that they would fit in better and it
- 17:02didn't sound so foreign. Which could actually lend to
- 17:06evidence in favor of Aaron being Jack the Ripper because if he
- 17:10wasn't going by Kosminsky and he was going by Abraham's, maybe he
- 17:14fooled the sex workers into thinking that he wasn't Jewish.
- 17:17But still, I would highly doubt that they would service this
- 17:20filthy gutter food eating psychopath.
- 17:24I don't know, but this shows there is not only two sisters
- 17:28living in Whitechapel at that time, but he also has two
- 17:31brothers. So it's very easy for these two
- 17:34sisters to then pass down that DNA to other people who live in
- 17:39that area who very well could have had contact with this
- 17:42shawl. Basically, it could be anybody
- 17:45in Whitechapel. This mitochondrial DNA does
- 17:48nothing for us. And the thing that's shocking to
- 17:51me is that they're making these bold claims that he is Jack the
- 17:56Ripper with this flimsy evidence.
- 17:58So I think it goes without saying that Aaron Kosminsky and
- 18:02these DNA results or not Jack the Ripper, I have a real hard
- 18:06time believing that someone who was so crazy to be
- 18:09institutionalized in 1891 and was so off his rocker that even
- 18:13the staff at the facility were just amazed at how crazy he was
- 18:17eating food out of the gutter. Just completely schizophrenic, I
- 18:22would imagine. So I would have a hard time
- 18:24believing that he could carry out the Jack the Ripper
- 18:27slayings, which required so much precision, timing, elusiveness,
- 18:32and obviously thought because he never got caught.
- 18:35I would imagine that the suspect would have to be someone who's
- 18:39not Jewish, not foreign, not dirty or homeless, someone who's
- 18:44very respectable, Someone who at the time, during all of these
- 18:49Jack the Ripper slayings, which had everybody in Whitechapel on
- 18:52edge, especially sex workers. It had to be somebody that these
- 18:56sex workers felt confident enough to service despite all
- 19:01this stuff going on because I'm sure that they had a very
- 19:05heightened state of awareness and they would be very selective
- 19:08about the person that they would go with for obvious reasons.
- 19:12So this person had to come across as extremely normal,
- 19:15extremely non threatening, and someone who you would definitely
- 19:19not expect to be carrying out these slayings.
- 19:23So who is Jack the Ripper? Who is the suspect if it's not
- 19:27Aaron Kosminsky? Well, let's talk about that in
- 19:30part three. If you guys haven't watched my
- 19:32duvet chase video, I think it is super good and I think I did
- 19:36find something that could possibly connect Diddy and
- 19:39Epstein's networks very interesting.
- 19:43Go check it out. I'll put it at the at the end of
- 19:45this video, but please like this video on the way out.
- 19:48Subscribe if you like what we got going on here, please hit
- 19:51the notification bell so you don't miss when I post, whenever
- 19:54I post. And yeah, I look forward to
- 19:58seeing you guys on Friday for another one.
- 20:02But until then, sleep safe, stay sober, stay awake, stay alive,
- 20:07and don't eat food out of the gutter.
- 20:09What the fuck? Later Sobers.
- 20:12Let's go.