Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Meet Family Law Commissioners and Learn About the Selection Process with Judge Kaufman and Judge Weiner
Transcript
- 0:05All right, everybody. Well, welcome to meet the
- 0:10family law commissioners. I am Ryan Wetteking,
- 0:14co -chair of the HBA's family law section. I
- 0:17am delighted to introduce our speakers today,
- 0:21just as Shelley Kaufman and Timothy Weiner. Judge,
- 0:26Shelley Kaufman really needs no introduction,
- 0:30but... I will do a brief intro anyway. Judge
- 0:34Kaufman was appointed to the LA Superior Court
- 0:37by California Governor Jerry Brown in December
- 0:402013. She has been assigned to Family Law Department
- 0:4560 at Stanley Mosque since she was sworn in on
- 0:49January 17, 2014. Managing a busy calendar is
- 0:54nothing unusual to Judge Kaufman as she managed
- 0:56a demanding and complex civil caseload before
- 0:59joining the bench. Judge Kaufman was a partner
- 1:02at the renowned firm Garagos & Garagos, with
- 1:05its main office in Los Angeles representing a
- 1:07diverse group of civil litigants and criminal
- 1:10defendants. Next, the Honorable Timothy Weiner
- 1:15is a Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge
- 1:18presiding over Department L, Family Law Home
- 1:20Court at the Torrance Courthouse, and Judge Weiner
- 1:24serves as supervising judge of the Southwest
- 1:27District. appointed to the bench by Governor
- 1:30Edmund G. Brown Jr. in 2018. He previously served
- 1:36as a court commissioner and spent 15 years as
- 1:39a deputy attorney general with the California
- 1:41Department of Justice, prosecuting misdemeanor
- 1:44and felony cases before courts, including the
- 1:46California Supreme Court and the Ninth Circuit
- 1:48Court of Appeals. He also serves as a lieutenant
- 1:52colonel in the California State Guard's JAG court.
- 1:58With that, Judge Kaufman, Judge Weiner, I will
- 2:02hand it over to you. Did Tigran Palyan want to
- 2:07say hi? Oh, sure. Thank you. Good afternoon,
- 2:09everyone. I'm Tigran Palyan, this year's chair
- 2:12of LA County Bar's Family Law Section. Together
- 2:15with our friends at the Beverly Hills Bar, we
- 2:18thank you for being here. To our commissioners,
- 2:21thank you for making yourself available this
- 2:23way. And thanks to Judge Kaufman and Judge Weiner.
- 2:26Weiner for your continued partnership with the
- 2:28bar. Without further ado now, Judge Cobb, I'll
- 2:32have it off to you. Thank you. Thank you. Many
- 2:35of you know that a judge is either elected by
- 2:38the general public when there is an open seat
- 2:41at a certain point in an election cycle, or maybe
- 2:46more readily you know that a judge is appointed
- 2:48by the governor's office and then the seat flows
- 2:52into an election cycle. But in talking to some
- 2:56of you, I became aware that many attorneys, rightfully
- 2:59so, because I know I didn't know this either,
- 3:02did not know how a commissioner is selected.
- 3:06The purpose of this session is to explain the
- 3:09process, which you will then realize is a highly
- 3:12competitive process among experienced qualified
- 3:16attorneys who are fully vetted through our county.
- 3:21And the other purpose of this session is to introduce
- 3:25you to four new family law commissioners who
- 3:29we are so happy to welcome to the Family Law
- 3:33Division, and I think you should be too. First,
- 3:38let me introduce you to each of the commissioners.
- 3:41They'll identify their name and their location
- 3:45where they are presiding right now. Go ahead,
- 3:48Commissioner Berta. And when they took their
- 3:51oath of office. Oh, good morning, everyone. So
- 3:55I sit in Stanley mosque and Department 519 in
- 3:59the family lot home court. And I took my oath
- 4:01of office on, I think, February 2nd of this year.
- 4:05OK, Commissioner Shapiro. I'm sitting in a restraining
- 4:09order court in Van Nuys. And I took my oath of
- 4:13office the end of March, March 29th, 2025. Commissioner
- 4:19Schultz. Hello, I sit in Department Y in a family
- 4:24law home court in Van Nuys and I took my oath
- 4:28of office on April 9th. And Commissioner Blossom.
- 4:32Hello everybody, I sit in a restraining order
- 4:35court in Inglewood currently, although on September
- 4:3716th I'm moving over to mosque also to do restraining
- 4:41orders and I took my oath on May 15th of this
- 4:44year. Thank you so much. Judge Weiner. First
- 4:50of all, well, I'll start out with, when you joined
- 4:53the court, you were joined as a commissioner,
- 4:55is that correct? Yes, in March 2016, I became
- 4:58a commissioner. And tell me, and then when did
- 5:01you become a judge? October 2018. Tell me a little
- 5:08bit about your process in becoming a commissioner.
- 5:11Sure. So, first of all, thank you to our partners
- 5:14at the bar. It's a pleasure to be here and talk
- 5:17a little bit about this process. So, yeah, I
- 5:20was at the attorney general's office and I learned
- 5:23about the opportunity to become a commissioner
- 5:27and applied for, like I said, in 2016, went through
- 5:32the process there. I think we're going to get
- 5:34into a little bit more detail. in that in just
- 5:37a minute. I became a commissioner. I was assigned
- 5:40to the criminal division, where I stayed until
- 5:43about 2019 when I moved over. I volunteered to
- 5:47come over to the family law division. When you
- 5:50became a judge, did your duties change in terms
- 5:55of your work? Not in the slightest. So as a commissioner,
- 5:59I was at the time of my appointment. I was sitting
- 6:02in department 48 in the now the false criminal
- 6:05justice center or as I would call it ccb because
- 6:09i've been around for a little bit. And my judicial
- 6:12assistant actually printed out the word judge
- 6:15and taped it over the word commissioner but i
- 6:17remained in that assignment. For many months
- 6:21my level of responsibility really didn't change
- 6:24at all my work certainly didn't change my assignment
- 6:27didn't change i was just a. Judicial officer
- 6:31with a different title, but my, you know, my
- 6:34duties were identical really. Did you eventually
- 6:39get the tape judge? They eventually it's the
- 6:42county, so they ordered it, but it's coming in
- 6:44on Tuesday. Now I also believe that you were,
- 6:51not I believe, I know that you were part of the
- 6:53commissioner hiring process, not this last go
- 6:56round for these commissioners, but the one right
- 6:59before. Was that in 2024? Correct. So I wasn't
- 7:03the most recent commissioner selection committee,
- 7:05but the immediately prior committee. I served
- 7:08on that committee. So I have like a really sort
- 7:12of. You know, a pretty detailed knowledge of
- 7:15the process, both from an applicant's point of
- 7:17view and also from a committee member's point
- 7:19of view. What is a commissioner select? What
- 7:23is the commissioner selection committee? So the
- 7:25commissioner selection committee is a committee
- 7:27of judges appointed by the presiding judge. And
- 7:32I knew it was a lot of work before I did it because
- 7:35I had talked to people, but I really had no idea
- 7:37how much work it was. It is the group of judges.
- 7:40that is responsible for just start to finish,
- 7:46collecting all the applications, vetting the
- 7:49commissioners, which is just an incredible amount
- 7:52of work, interviewing the applicants. Ultimately
- 7:57ranking the applicants and we can talk a little
- 7:59bit about that in a minute about, you know, we
- 8:02actually produce a ranked list of applicants
- 8:06that is given to the presiding judge to be approved.
- 8:10And then it's also given to the judges of the
- 8:13court to be voted on throughout the year. How
- 8:17many members are part of that committee, at least
- 8:19from your, from when you - So it's dynamic. When
- 8:22I was on the committee, I believe there were
- 8:2412 people, but it's usually somewhere between
- 8:2710 and 12, which allows there to be between five
- 8:30and six teams of two judges. The work is divvied
- 8:34up amongst little subcommittees and usually there
- 8:37are two judges per subcommittee. So how - How
- 8:43is the advertisement? I mean, how does somebody
- 8:45know about being a commissioner? You can use
- 8:46your experience or when you were on the committee.
- 8:48Sure. So yeah, no, great question. So it's on
- 8:51the court's website. So if you go to the careers
- 8:53page on the court's website, I think they still
- 8:57use jobs .gov, if I'm not mistaken. But the court
- 9:00has a button on the website that says careers.
- 9:04But the court is also very proactive in advertising.
- 9:08When they're going to be, there's going to be
- 9:11a new commissioner selection process. So the
- 9:13court will put it out. On social media that will
- 9:16usually send out an NTA notice to attorneys.
- 9:19I know that in years past, the court has hosted
- 9:23at least 2 meetings where. The PJ and members
- 9:28of the committee will try to answer general questions
- 9:32about the hiring process and those typically
- 9:35take place and the. at Stanley Mosk in the presiding
- 9:39judge's courtroom. So the court really does push
- 9:42that information out through all of the channels
- 9:44that it has control over. And I mean, just in
- 9:50general, is this like hiring for a job with the
- 9:53firm or a government entity? I mean, compare
- 9:56it to you applying for attorney general or commissioner
- 10:01and what you know. I mean, So the process I'm
- 10:05going to describe the process is incredibly rigorous
- 10:08these first of all you have to fill out the application
- 10:11The application is very similar to the judicial
- 10:16application that the governor's office pushes
- 10:18out And they ask for a lot of information Including
- 10:23contact information for people you've worked
- 10:25with throughout your career That information
- 10:29is then I think I'm trying to remember. I think
- 10:31my commissioner application was probably 40 pages
- 10:34long by the time I was done with it. I mean,
- 10:35it was really detailed. Those applications are
- 10:41screened initially to make sure that the applicant
- 10:45meets the minimum qualifications. So to be a
- 10:49commissioner, you have to be an attorney of at
- 10:51least 10 years experience in good standing and
- 10:55a resident of California. So they screen them
- 10:59to make sure you meet the minimum qualifications.
- 11:01That's the same qualifications as a judge as
- 11:05well. Correct. Correct. And then the applications,
- 11:09however many there are, they are divided amongst
- 11:13the judges on the commissioner selection committee.
- 11:15They're just equally divided and that's where
- 11:17the vetting starts. And I will tell you, I mean,
- 11:23my partner and I on the committee, we called
- 11:25every reference for every applicant we had and
- 11:29we spoke or emailed with every single person.
- 11:32It's just a tremendous amount of vetting that
- 11:35goes on for commissioners, which is why we have
- 11:39such fantastic commissioners on the court. I
- 11:41mean, the process is just very rigorous. When
- 11:46you were on the selection committee, about how
- 11:47many applicants were there? So I know in my class,
- 11:51when I was an applicant, there were 427 people
- 11:54who applied. I just happen to remember that number.
- 11:57When I was on the commissioner selection committee
- 12:00for my year, I think there were about 325 to
- 12:03350 people who applied. Typically what happens
- 12:06is that number is then whittled down to a hundred
- 12:10applicants who are given the first interview.
- 12:14So, and then of those hundred people who get
- 12:18interviewed, For the first round about this number
- 12:22is also dynamic but about twenty five to forty
- 12:26would go on to the final interview so the first
- 12:29round interview is just with the subcommittee
- 12:31of two judges. And of those people in your group
- 12:34that you interview with your partner a number
- 12:37of them then go on to the final interview which
- 12:40is with the entire. Commissioner selection committee
- 12:44the number of people interviewed at the final
- 12:46stage is really. It really depends on how many
- 12:50commissioners the PJ has asked a list of. So
- 12:54in other words, we'll get direction from the
- 12:56presiding judge of, hey, I'm looking for a list
- 12:58of, I'm going to make a number up now, 30 people
- 13:02to put on the commissioner selection, the commissioner's
- 13:05list. I think in the last round, the PJ asked
- 13:08for 38 because there were eight openings and
- 13:11then he wanted a list of 30. But that number
- 13:13is just dynamic. It's surely PJ driven. Does
- 13:17it have to be 38? Or do you have to find somebody
- 13:20if you don't think there are 38 applicants? Absolutely
- 13:24not. Absolutely not. So hypothetically, if the
- 13:26PJ had asked for 38 names and the committee had
- 13:29said we can only pass along 30, that's what we
- 13:33would have done. We're not going to fill the
- 13:36list with people. At least on my committee, and
- 13:39I'm sure all committees, there's no way that
- 13:42we would. put somebody on the commissioner list
- 13:45if the committee did not believe that person
- 13:47could serve as a commissioner. And ultimately,
- 13:52so once you have this list, you keep referring
- 13:55to a list. Can you explain what that means? Sure.
- 13:58And I know this is sort of a work in progress,
- 14:01but I'll explain. When I was on the selection
- 14:04committee, we had a group of 30 people on the
- 14:08list. And it's actually ranked. one through 30.
- 14:11And there is a reason for that. So on the court,
- 14:15we have 450 or 480 judges. And there are 10 on
- 14:20the commissioner selection committee who are
- 14:22just intimately involved in the details of this
- 14:26hiring process. But the rest of our colleagues
- 14:29really don't know a lot. And so the people who
- 14:33make it to the final list, the commissioner selection
- 14:36committee ranks them. in the committee's order
- 14:39of preference, one through 30, let's say. That
- 14:43does not bind any particular judge from voting
- 14:49however he or she pleases. Just because someone
- 14:52is number one on the list doesn't mean that they're
- 14:55going automatically to be elected, although I
- 14:57will observe we've never deviated from that.
- 15:00The custom on the court is pretty much to vote
- 15:05in the order the commissioner selection committee
- 15:07recommends, but it's certainly not a requirement.
- 15:10And I'm sure there have been, you know, odd,
- 15:13odd variations in it. But that's the purpose
- 15:15for ranking commissioners on the list is because
- 15:19it's an indication to those judges who didn't
- 15:22serve on the committee what the commissioner
- 15:24selection committee's preference is. And what
- 15:28information do the judges get before voting besides
- 15:30just their name? So a summary. Is is is produced
- 15:36by the commissioner selection committee and it's
- 15:39admin staff and that summary is pushed out to
- 15:42all the judges with, you know, it's it's pretty
- 15:44brief. It's the commissioner's name. There's
- 15:47a photograph. There is a brief bio of what the
- 15:51commissioner had done in their career and then
- 15:55the rank on the list. And ultimately, if. Whoever
- 16:00is selected such as our commissioners here. Is
- 16:03it the is that the end that it however the vote
- 16:06is or is there really a final step? So the so
- 16:09the the the vote goes out to the judges But ultimately
- 16:13it's the presiding judge who makes the decision
- 16:15and I said it's a work in progress because I
- 16:18know other counties do it differently So I know
- 16:20some counties the PJ just selects from the list
- 16:23So it's it's really I think depending on who
- 16:27the PJ is that that rule could change but by
- 16:30tradition, or at least by custom in our court,
- 16:33the judges have voted on some number of commissioners
- 16:37at a time. It could be one, two, five commissioners.
- 16:40It really depends on how many openings there
- 16:42are. And then once they're approved by the judges,
- 16:45the PJ can appoint them. But at the end of the
- 16:48day, it's the PJ's decision. I should know the
- 16:51answer to this, but I'm not sure that I do, but
- 16:53maybe you do. How many commissioner slots do
- 16:55we have for the court? There's a finite amount,
- 16:59isn't there? I want to say it's in the 80s. OK.
- 17:02That's my recollection, Judge Kaufman, but I
- 17:05don't know off the top of my head the exact number.
- 17:07It's somewhere between 75 and 80. But just for
- 17:11information, there's a finite amount of commissioners
- 17:15per Rules of court or rules of judicial administration
- 17:20I should say of how many commissioners the court
- 17:23can have and that's guided through the Judicial
- 17:25Council Let me ask you Commissioner Schultz And
- 17:29I might be going a little Around here. How would
- 17:33you describe your experience in applying to be
- 17:37a commissioner? The experience was very interesting,
- 17:44enlightening, and it was robust. I will tell
- 17:47you that it took a long time to do the application
- 17:50and the vetting process as described. I had a
- 17:56lot of people call me and tell me that they were
- 17:59contacted. During the interview process, I can
- 18:02tell you they asked me questions about my cert
- 18:05petition that I submitted as a writing sample.
- 18:08And they asked me about some of the cases that
- 18:11I had handled because they obviously did research
- 18:14about the cases that I handled as an appellate
- 18:18practitioner. So the experience was eye -opening
- 18:24because I didn't realize, frankly, how robust
- 18:28the selection process was and how intensive it
- 18:32was. And so I feel lucky to have been selected,
- 18:35frankly. The application, is that right? It's
- 18:38about 40 pages. Yeah, it took me quite a bit
- 18:43of time to fill out. And there were everything
- 18:47that you could imagine being asked about your
- 18:50career, including published appellate decisions,
- 18:53the most significant cases you handled. You had
- 18:57to list the attorneys that you practiced with
- 19:00and against. And so that was the vetting process.
- 19:05That's why so many people contacted me and said,
- 19:08so I heard you're gonna be trying to become a
- 19:11commissioner. Well, who were the, not who were
- 19:15the references, but what kind of people, lawyers
- 19:17you worked with? All the lawyers that I worked
- 19:20with. And then, of course, I had to list, I think
- 19:22it was four judges. And so I believe the committee,
- 19:29when they were interviewing me and I was in the
- 19:32room of 25 judges who were asking me questions
- 19:36in a roundtable, it was obvious that they got
- 19:39information from every source possible, both
- 19:43people I work with, my ex -colleagues, and even
- 19:49some people from my law school where I teach.
- 19:51So they contacted everybody and they read a lot
- 19:56of the opinions from the cases in which I handled.
- 20:01Thank you. Commissioner Berte, how can you describe
- 20:06your experience in going through the commission
- 20:09selection process? What I'm going to ask you
- 20:12a bunch of leading questions here. Was it daunting,
- 20:16time consuming, a breeze? Actually, it's not
- 20:18leading because I'm giving you options. How would
- 20:21you describe it? It was not a breeze. It was
- 20:25time consuming. I wouldn't say it was daunting.
- 20:28I think that like anything in life, if you really
- 20:32want it, you have to go for it. So I was I really
- 20:38wanted this job. I pushed really hard. I pushed
- 20:41myself really hard to do the best job I could.
- 20:45And I second what Commissioner Schultz was saying,
- 20:48that the process is pretty vigorous. You do have
- 20:52to list all your opposing counsel. And I got
- 20:58a call from one of them sort of seconding what
- 21:01Commissioner Schultz was saying. And they were
- 21:02like, oh, I didn't know that you were doing this.
- 21:06And it was... I would just say to everyone be
- 21:09nice to your opposing counsel because you never
- 21:12know when you're going to need them and you know
- 21:14it's family law. I had a very big family law
- 21:18practice. I was a partner at one of the most
- 21:20reputable firms in the city and you get in the
- 21:24trenches with people and so I remember like one
- 21:27of the lawyers who called me I was like oh boy
- 21:30what did they have to say and you know I didn't
- 21:32ask but I found out it was very respectful and
- 21:37very nice. And thankfully, I curated, I hope,
- 21:40a reputation for being smart, hardworking, and
- 21:43bringing a lot of integrity to the practice,
- 21:46which is what I did with the application and
- 21:49hopefully what I'm doing here on the bench. But
- 21:51yeah, it was, I wouldn't say I sailed through
- 21:53it. It was a lot of work on my part to... to
- 21:57put the best foot forward that I wanted to. I
- 22:00really wanted this. So I don't think, I'm just
- 22:01going to say, I don't think anybody sails through
- 22:04that process. I mean, if there's one takeaway
- 22:06that I would love, you know, attorneys who are
- 22:10considering this to know, and you know, the people
- 22:13who are on this on this meeting. Is that the
- 22:17vetting is real. I mean, it is the commissioner
- 22:19selection committee really takes its job extremely
- 22:23seriously. There is a there is a real awareness
- 22:26of sort of the gravity of the task that we have
- 22:29been given by the presiding judge, which is to
- 22:31select judicial officers. And that it's really
- 22:34I think everybody on my committee certainly took
- 22:38it very, very seriously. So Commissioner Bertain,
- 22:42I'm sure it's true with everyone, but you raise
- 22:45a point that's interesting. You can't really
- 22:47do this quietly. So everybody in your universe
- 22:50knew that you were planning to be commissioner
- 22:53because you had to list them, right? Right, right.
- 22:58I had to list partners that I, my law partners
- 23:03and a lot of the retired judges even that I worked
- 23:08with, and mediation, past judges that I appeared
- 23:11in front of, you're right. So you do have to
- 23:15put yourself out there. And, you know, it's important
- 23:18to, you know, your reputation really is everything.
- 23:24And especially in this small -knit family law
- 23:27community, which I was blessed to be a part of.
- 23:30So. So I'm going to move over to Commissioner
- 23:35Blossom for a minute. Tell us a little bit about
- 23:39your background that stands out and maybe stood
- 23:42out, which was part of the reason you were selected
- 23:44to be a commissioner and then assigned to family
- 23:49law. Sure. Well, the bulk of my life's work has
- 23:53been as a public defender. I started with LA
- 23:56County public defender in 2004 and was there
- 23:59for 20. Some no night. Sorry 19 years and So
- 24:06had a lot of contacts for the committee to call
- 24:09lots of judges lots of opposing counsel But I
- 24:13think and then I worked briefly between being
- 24:15a public defender and Joining the bench. I worked
- 24:19in government in the LA County CEO. That's sort
- 24:22of the implementation arm of of the county government
- 24:26when the Board of Supervisors wants a project
- 24:30done. They go to CEO and say, you know, you've
- 24:32got to find the money and you've got to figure
- 24:34out how to do it. And so I was assigned to a
- 24:36couple of projects there related to jail conditions.
- 24:39But I think what probably stood out and what
- 24:42I'm finding pretty relevant in this practice
- 24:45now in the Family Law Division is that for the
- 24:48last couple of years of my career in the public
- 24:50defender's office, I was exclusively working
- 24:53in what's called the ODR program, Office of Diversion
- 24:56and Reentry. It's a very high touch alternative
- 25:00collaborative court for people accused of serious
- 25:05felonies who also have serious mental illness.
- 25:08And if you're accepted into that program and
- 25:11getting someone accepted into that program is
- 25:13a challenge in and of itself, then you can get
- 25:16treatment instead of prison essentially for very
- 25:18serious crimes. But it's not a one off experience.
- 25:21When you're figuring out, and it is collaborative,
- 25:25with the district attorney, with the judge, with
- 25:28the probation department, with the healthcare
- 25:30providers, how to build a plan for somebody who
- 25:33is extraordinarily vulnerable and challenging.
- 25:38You've got to figure out how to build a plan
- 25:40for them that takes into account liberty, safety,
- 25:46due process. and the community. And I find that
- 25:51I think that sort of high, and we stick with
- 25:54those clients for the entire term of their supervision.
- 25:57So they're coming back to court all the time
- 25:59in the same way that family law litigants kind
- 26:01of come back to court. And we're checking in,
- 26:03how is this working? Is the treatment working?
- 26:05What's happening in the family? What are all
- 26:08of the factors that are leading to success or
- 26:11challenges? And I think that experience probably
- 26:14was I don't think at the time of my interview
- 26:17anyone knew for sure where I might be assigned,
- 26:19but I find that that's most relevant to my current
- 26:23assignment in family law is that the experience
- 26:24of working with that population in a much more
- 26:28collaborative setting. That leads me to a question.
- 26:33When you apply, do you apply for a particular
- 26:36division or? put down something to the effect,
- 26:40I wanna do acts, I wanna do family lie, I wanna
- 26:44do misdemeanor trials, I wanna do probate? Yeah,
- 26:48no, not at all. You apply to serve wherever you're
- 26:50needed. And I think that was a good bit of discussion
- 26:54in the interview too, especially for someone
- 26:56like me who was exclusively devoted during my
- 26:59legal career to criminal defense, minus some
- 27:02civil work. So I'm going to go one step further.
- 27:06How did you feel when you were told that your
- 27:08assignment was going to be in family law? I was
- 27:11excited, honestly. Be really careful with this
- 27:13answer. I'm really careful. I was honestly excited.
- 27:19This is such a unique role. And so it's sort
- 27:23of the, to me, the epitome of being a bench officer
- 27:28in many respects. I practice in criminal court
- 27:31where the bench officer is much more of a referee.
- 27:35And the responsibility in a trial for deciding
- 27:40what happened and what it means lies with the
- 27:43jury. And being a family law bench officer, all
- 27:46of that responsibility is with the judge. And
- 27:49it's profound and humbling. and awesome in every
- 27:57possible way. So I think this, when I heard I
- 27:59was doing family law, I was nervous. I've been
- 28:03studying constantly. I was hiding it from the
- 28:05camera. But anyway, I have books here that I'm
- 28:08constantly reading to make sure that I'm on solid
- 28:11ground when I do things. It's a wonderful experience
- 28:17and I love being on the bench here. Thank you.
- 28:21Commissioner Shapiro, I noted that you said you
- 28:25took your oath in 2025. Yes. When in 2025? I
- 28:31guess I'm the elder of the commissioners here.
- 28:36Time for Botox. I'm sorry, your question was
- 28:40when? It was in March, end of March of 2025.
- 28:43Go ahead. My first assignment was traffic court
- 28:47commissioner. in Santa Clarita, and then I pushed
- 28:51them because that wasn't enough work at the time.
- 28:53I pushed them to allow me to be a backup officer
- 28:56for the misdemeanor courts, so I was bouncing
- 28:59between the two courts, which made it a lot of
- 29:02fun for me. And you came over to the Family Law
- 29:04Division. Remind me when that was. I think my
- 29:08first day was in June 8th of this year. So it's
- 29:11just a couple of months that I've been doing
- 29:13restraining orders. And I've learned a lot. And
- 29:17it's a very dynamic court. I know that you asked
- 29:24to come to the family law division. Why? So first
- 29:29of all, I was a traffic court commissioner, which
- 29:31is a wonderful place to start when you get on
- 29:33the bench, because the stakes are relatively
- 29:36low and you're just learning how to get your
- 29:40footing on the bench. So that was good, but after
- 29:42a while it's not that interesting. So this position
- 29:46came open in Van Nuys and it's sort of the perfect
- 29:51fit for me because I have a civil background,
- 29:56I have a criminal background, it kind of blends
- 29:58those two worlds. And the other thing I was trying
- 30:02to think of like, why restraining orders? And
- 30:04it made me think about what I like. When I go
- 30:06out to eat dinner, I don't like the entree. I
- 30:09like to choose off of the appetizer menu. I like
- 30:12the smaller tastes. And restraining order is
- 30:15a lot of different tastes. And I think that that
- 30:17totally fits my personality. What's the civil
- 30:20and criminal background that you blend together?
- 30:25I retired from the city attorney's office after
- 30:2826 years. I spent 16 years as a law and motion
- 30:32attorney doing police litigation, and I practiced
- 30:35in state and federal court. Then I transferred
- 30:38to the civil appellate section where I was an
- 30:40appellate attorney in the state court, Ninth
- 30:41Circuit Court of Appeals. And then at that point,
- 30:45I realized I could write really well, but I didn't
- 30:48know how to ask a question. So I decided to completely
- 30:51upend my career, transfer to our criminal branch.
- 30:55at the later part of my career, which is not
- 30:58easy. I was, I think, 48, and I switched over
- 31:01and had to learn how to do a jury trial and ask
- 31:04questions and lay a foundation and get really
- 31:07familiar and good with the evidence code. But
- 31:10that was really the entree into my interest in
- 31:13becoming a commissioner because I got to spend
- 31:15every day in court and I loved being in court
- 31:17every day. And then you decided to upend your
- 31:21career once again and learn something brand new,
- 31:23family law. You know, it's so funny because to
- 31:26me restraining orders has, I didn't tie it that
- 31:30much to the family law aspect. It felt very much
- 31:33like it had so much criminal element to it because
- 31:37I've prosecuted domestic violence cases and that's
- 31:40a big chunk of restraining orders. So now I've
- 31:44had to learn visitation issues and I'm always
- 31:47calling. Commissioner Berta, who, by the way,
- 31:49is my brother -in -law, and saying, OK, what
- 31:51do I do? I get very afraid of the family law
- 31:55stuff. But he guides me. And he's like, best
- 31:58interest of the child. You'll be fine. Judge
- 32:04Weiner, I'm going to kind of go back to you.
- 32:07And I think you mentioned, we've all mentioned
- 32:10about this application process. uh, for commissioners
- 32:13about being some 40 odd pages and a lot of references
- 32:17and a lot of information. Can you recall the
- 32:21comparison to, uh, the judicial application?
- 32:25Sure. It's, well, it's extraordinarily similar.
- 32:28I mean, uh, to the point where I would, I would
- 32:32suggest that once one has applied for either
- 32:35a judgeship or a commissioner position, there's
- 32:37almost no reason. unless there's a personal reason
- 32:40not to apply for the other, because there's so
- 32:43much crossover. Both involve similar questions
- 32:47about your background, the cases you've worked
- 32:49on, opposing counsel, if you have any publications,
- 32:53if you have published appellate work, a lot of
- 32:57similarities. Maybe the commissioner one might
- 33:00be a little bit more county -centric. um a tiny
- 33:04bit but i mean generally speaking i think that
- 33:07they're very very similar uh and in fact um some
- 33:11of my colleagues on the commissioner selection
- 33:13committee would even ask applicants like have
- 33:16you applied to become a judge and if so why and
- 33:21if not why not because it was just sort of an
- 33:23interesting question to ask because we knew they
- 33:25had done the work um already with that application
- 33:29and it was very easy to sort of transfer an answer
- 33:32from your judicial app to your commissioner app
- 33:35or vice versa. But yeah, a ton of crossover.
- 33:40Commissioner Schultz, let me ask you this kind
- 33:43of two questions in one compound. Why did you
- 33:47want to be a judicial officer? And was there
- 33:50a specific reason why you applied to be a commissioner?
- 33:53OK, thank you. Well, let me start with saying
- 33:57that I had been practicing for 36 years. in civil
- 34:01litigation and spent more than 10 years as a
- 34:05certified appellate specialist. And so I guess
- 34:07the question was, you know, why a judicial officer?
- 34:11And it was very simple for me. It was two words,
- 34:14public service. Throughout my career, I was able
- 34:18to do pro bono, teach law school, do various
- 34:23things in public service. And each time that
- 34:26I did that, I realized, you know, the best place
- 34:29you could perform public services on the bench.
- 34:33And so it is a terrific, I think about every
- 34:38time you appear before a judicial officer, they're
- 34:41really there to help and they're there to help
- 34:43the litigants. And so that was the major reason
- 34:48why a commissioner stems from my first trial
- 34:52in 1991. before Judge Stephen Lacks, who was
- 34:57a family law supervising judge way back when.
- 35:00He's now retired. And I looked him up and I researched
- 35:03his qualifications. And I do that for every judge.
- 35:06When I was a practicing lawyer, I found that
- 35:08he was a commissioner. Emily Elias was a commissioner.
- 35:12All these judges that I really respected started
- 35:17out as commissioners. And it really opened my
- 35:19eyes to the fact that they're is a true meritocracy
- 35:23in the commissioner application process. And
- 35:27it's really the best and the brightest. And I
- 35:29really feel very lucky to be part of this group.
- 35:33I've never met a more diverse, intelligent and
- 35:37hardworking group than the commissioners that
- 35:40are on this panel, my other commissioners that
- 35:42I'm colleagues with. And so I just think it's
- 35:46the greatest job in the world. with the greatest
- 35:49ability to sort of help the public and be forward
- 35:52-facing with the public. So that was my reasons.
- 35:56Thank you. Commissioner Brute, from family law
- 36:00practitioner to judicial officer, what has been
- 36:04the most surprising thing to you? And again,
- 36:07this is kind of a compound question and satisfying.
- 36:12So surprising and satisfying or separately or
- 36:16both together. Sure. So I would just say that
- 36:21everyone, every judicial officer that I've come
- 36:25to know here at Mosque and in other courthouses
- 36:29is so incredibly hard working. And you take that
- 36:34as a given. You expect that the judicial officers
- 36:37here would be hard working, but multiply that
- 36:42by 10. They are working a lot harder. than I
- 36:47think we gave them credit for as practitioners.
- 36:52And everyone here is so smart, conscientious,
- 36:55and everyone wants to get to the right result.
- 36:57That's not surprising. That's sort of an expectation.
- 37:00But the level of professionalism, the level of
- 37:09personal attention and care, I would just say,
- 37:11is really that part was surprising. Everyone
- 37:14really wants to get to the right result. And
- 37:18you can expect that, for example, if you were
- 37:22to come into my courtroom, you would get the
- 37:25level of expectation from this bench officer
- 37:28that I would have had from another bench officer.
- 37:32I read everything. And you can expect that not
- 37:36only have I read off 500 pages of the moving
- 37:39paper and 200 of the response, but I've given
- 37:41it a very thoughtful analysis. And I know all
- 37:45the judges here take that level of concern with
- 37:50respect to the cases. We know this is a really
- 37:54demanding job. We know that the families and
- 37:57the decisions that we make are important and
- 38:00will have far reaching consequences. One thing
- 38:04that was surprising to me was just the level
- 38:07of generosity of the other bench officers from
- 38:12our colleagues. Everyone here really wants to
- 38:16be supportive to one another. The bench officers
- 38:19will call me with a family law question. I'll
- 38:21answer it. If I have a question, if there's a
- 38:24contempt issue, I'll call, you know, Judge Powell
- 38:26or whoever. Everyone is available to one another.
- 38:29And that is both wonderful and It really speaks
- 38:34to how serious we take our jobs and how we really
- 38:39want to get to the right result. And so I'm inspired
- 38:43by the level of collegiality from this division.
- 38:47I know that Judge Kaufman has taken big strides
- 38:52to make sure that there's a retention of family
- 38:55law officers. So there's a lot of respect to
- 39:00you, Judge Kaufman. So thanks for that. And I
- 39:02would also just say that what I love about this,
- 39:06I love family law. I love this practice area.
- 39:09I got on the bench. I know that I didn't get
- 39:12to say where I wanted to go, but I let the commissioner
- 39:15selection committee know where I wanted to go.
- 39:19And it's been a dream to get into this chosen
- 39:23field and extend my reach and experience for
- 39:26LA County. because I really wanted to shape,
- 39:29I wanted to lend my experience and shape outcomes
- 39:31for families on a larger scale, not just for
- 39:33my individual clients. And when I spoke with,
- 39:37I randomly ran into Judge Toppy in the hallway
- 39:39the other week, and he said to me, he had a sort
- 39:43of philosophical conversation, and he looked
- 39:45at me and he said, you know, Commissioner Berte,
- 39:47you are exactly where you need to be. And I really
- 39:50felt that to my core. I do believe that. So it's
- 39:55great to be here. Judge before I forget, I want
- 39:59to point out there are some questions that have
- 40:01been asked in the Q and a that I've been answering.
- 40:04So if anyone has any questions that I can answer
- 40:07while while we're speaking, I'm happy to do so.
- 40:11Okay, I didn't quite catch it, but that's great.
- 40:16Commissioner Blossom, I'm asking the same question.
- 40:20What have you found to be the most surprising
- 40:23to you, the most satisfying, maybe even the most
- 40:28challenging, if you want to go those three, incorporate
- 40:33them how you want. I mean, I think the sort of
- 40:38dovetailing with what Commissioner Schultz said,
- 40:39the public service aspect is so incredibly rewarding.
- 40:43especially in restraining orders, where so many
- 40:45people are self -represented, have no other existing
- 40:50case connected to the situation that they've
- 40:53come to us for help with. The litigants are so
- 40:59respectful. I practice in criminal court for
- 41:03a long time where that's a place people are reluctant
- 41:06to come. And people would roll in at 10 a .m.,
- 41:0911 a .m. sometimes, and you'd have to walk back
- 41:11a bench warrant. it's not like that at all in
- 41:14my court in Inglewood. People, if they're coming,
- 41:16people sometimes decide to abandon their prosecution,
- 41:18but if people are coming, they are there and
- 41:20they are prepared and they are, they humble me
- 41:25with their earnestness, which makes sense, right?
- 41:30They need something. And it's such an honor to
- 41:33be able to try and provide what they need in
- 41:37a fair way. So I think that's I didn't expect
- 41:40it to be as rewarding as it is. I love every
- 41:44day. I go home so exhausted because I've spent
- 41:48so much emotional and mental energy paying attention.
- 41:54I ditched my Apple Watch. I'm just on the bench
- 41:59with my yellow pad and my notes, and I'm writing
- 42:02down every detail and thinking about what people
- 42:04are saying. And it's a level of mindful present,
- 42:10presentness, if that's a word, but just being
- 42:12truly in the moment that is so challenging. And
- 42:15I feel grateful to be able to grow in this way
- 42:17that I've never grown before on the bench while
- 42:21serving. Thank you. I'm going to ask you the
- 42:27same question, Judge Shapiro, Commissioner Shapiro.
- 42:31I just appointed you, Commissioner Shapiro. That
- 42:34is one thing I'll have to say is From my perspective,
- 42:39we try really hard to use the word judicial officers.
- 42:42Sometimes we say bench officers. We don't make
- 42:45a distinction in our division. And I don't think
- 42:49the court at all and all the meetings I attend
- 42:51between commissioner and judge, except for certain
- 42:57things in terms of voting and things like that,
- 43:00that really don't affect. you, the public or
- 43:03litigants, but more than internal workings and
- 43:06fundraising and things of that nature. But we
- 43:10endeavor in our court, there is no distinction.
- 43:15And when we say judges, we mean everybody who
- 43:18is sitting on the bench who are ruling on matters
- 43:22and making decisions. There isn't, in our view,
- 43:26a distinction that somehow, just like Judge Weiner
- 43:30said, that the day he got appointed, he just
- 43:33took a piece of paper, his JA took a piece of
- 43:35paper and wrote judge. Nothing changed in terms
- 43:39of what he was doing. And that's the way we look
- 43:42at it as well. So Commissioner Shapiro, now that
- 43:48you've been on the bench a whole year, but only
- 43:51two months in family, what would you consider
- 43:55to be the most surprising, satisfying, challenging?
- 44:00Let's start with surprising, like you just didn't
- 44:03really think about that's what was going to happen
- 44:05when you became a commissioner. Oh, just as commissioner,
- 44:09I was thinking of an answer that was more specific
- 44:11to restraining order. You can do that. Go to
- 44:13restraining orders. We'll take it. So restraining
- 44:16orders, I didn't know, but they are they can
- 44:19be used by some people to try to short circuit
- 44:24going to other courts and through other processes.
- 44:28So you have to be, so for example, you can have
- 44:32landlords that are using the civil harassment
- 44:35restraining order in order to avoid the unlawful
- 44:37detainer court, which can take a very long time.
- 44:40So you have to be very savvy in making sure that
- 44:44you're not an inadvertent tool to someone coming
- 44:49to court and then knocking out another individual's
- 44:53due process rights. So that happens with the
- 44:57civil harassment. And also you have to be careful
- 45:00with domestic violence because you can lose custody.
- 45:03So it's really important that people meet their
- 45:07burdens of proof. You have to be very careful.
- 45:10So I didn't know that that was part of it. I
- 45:12thought it was just you have your petition, you
- 45:15do it, and that I was naive so there's a level
- 45:18of sophistication to some litigants that I did
- 45:22not anticipate. I'm always amazed with how much
- 45:26the court does with how few resources we have.
- 45:31I think people assume because it's the bench
- 45:34it's really well funded and there's lots of resources
- 45:37and really that's not the case. So the court
- 45:41does a lot with very little and I'm also surprised
- 45:45and just been very so fortunate at the high level
- 45:51of professionalism and quality and knowledge
- 45:54that my judicial assistant and court clerks have
- 45:58brought to me. We are a team. It is not the bench
- 46:04without your team, and your team is what makes
- 46:07a good courtroom. So I really am so grateful
- 46:11for the instruction and the guidance that I get
- 46:15from my judicial assistants every day. They're
- 46:19critical to any success I have, and I'm really
- 46:22grateful for that. Thank you. All right, Commissioner
- 46:28Schulz, I'm going to come back to you. How do
- 46:30you feel your experience as a lawyer benefits
- 46:32you in your present assignment in a home court
- 46:34in Van Nuys? I think it was the number of years,
- 46:41level of sort of civil litigation that I did.
- 46:45And that kind of experience I think I'm bringing
- 46:49to bear every day. in my family law home court.
- 46:53I can't tell you the variety of issues that come
- 46:56before me, both procedurally and substantively.
- 47:00I mean, just like this week, I think I have a
- 47:04contempt trial, a motion to quash, a motion to
- 47:06transfer venue, a discovery motion. And those
- 47:09are things that I handled as a civil litigator
- 47:14for 36 years. I teach civil litigation in law
- 47:18school. And I I think those kinds of experiences
- 47:21have helped me particularly with self -represented
- 47:26litigants where we I think have an obligation
- 47:30to at least explain the process to them and explain
- 47:33why it is we are and of course we owe that to
- 47:36everyone but for them they really don't have
- 47:39a frame of understanding of what's exactly going
- 47:42on and so I do make a point of citing the law
- 47:47cases and describing why it is I'm reaching a
- 47:52result. I mean, just today, this morning, I discussed
- 47:56the fundamental due process requirement of proper
- 48:00service of process of a summons that didn't confer
- 48:03jurisdiction on the court until it was established.
- 48:06And the litigant, the petitioner didn't understand
- 48:09that. And so I think they appreciate it. I also
- 48:15think that I've become a better lawyer in the
- 48:19past five months that I've been on the bench
- 48:22than in the past 36 years, because the requirement
- 48:27of sort of making the legal rulings and factual
- 48:31findings that you need to make, you really now
- 48:34start to understand how a record is preserved
- 48:38and what arguments need to be ruled upon. It
- 48:41really is an incredible job that the judiciary
- 48:44does and I'm learning every day and the beauty
- 48:48of this job is that I am learning every day and
- 48:52everything is Important because in a family law
- 48:56context, it's the most important things in people's
- 49:00lives their children Their family and so I'm
- 49:05humbled by it. I think it's an incredible service
- 49:10that the judiciary does in our division to the
- 49:12public in general. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner
- 49:17Berta, I'm going to ask this question carefully
- 49:21and you're going to answer it carefully. But
- 49:24now that you're sitting as a commissioner with
- 49:27all your family law experience, everybody has
- 49:31a right. They have to stipulate to you, right?
- 49:34That's under the code. It's not that that's right.
- 49:37Everyone has and no one's taking that right away.
- 49:41But when do you feel that somehow because you're
- 49:46a commissioner, you're lacking in ability as
- 49:52a judge to do the job, be prepared, all the things
- 49:55that it takes to make a good ruling. And now.
- 50:00And in fact, I would just say the opposite. I've
- 50:03had 23 plus years in family law at the highest
- 50:07level. I was a partner at a really reputable
- 50:11firm. And I love family law. It's in my blood.
- 50:15I've been doing this for so long. And so when
- 50:19people come to the court, obviously, there's
- 50:22going to be some strategic piece to it at times
- 50:26when someone wants to non -stip the commissioner.
- 50:28It's kind of like a get out of jail free card
- 50:30or you know, if someone doesn't want to share
- 50:34custody or if they want to delay custody or if
- 50:37their lawyer wants to you know, I don't know.
- 50:40Sometimes people will make those types of tactical
- 50:42decisions or if they want to delay support. I
- 50:45think it's short -sighted. I think that you know,
- 50:48you run the risk of not having a judicial officer
- 50:52who knows the nuances of the law and the case
- 50:56and has so much experience in family law. So
- 51:00you may delay the inevitable and it's also sort
- 51:04of you're going to get to another judicial officer
- 51:06who's very smart and savvy. Everyone in the court
- 51:10in this division it's going to probably get to
- 51:15maybe the same result. I don't know everyone's
- 51:17very thoughtful and smart but non -stipping the
- 51:21commissioner to delay something is probably short
- 51:24-sighted. It may be, you know, a quick sort of
- 51:31stop gap in whatever or delay that, you know,
- 51:34in terms of custody or support. And support,
- 51:36you're just gonna get retroactivity anyway. So
- 51:38it's gonna be retroactive to whenever they filed.
- 51:42So I don't really, sometimes I don't... know
- 51:45that the lawyers are really thinking through
- 51:47the strategy. But I get it's a right to non -stiff
- 51:51the commissioner. I would just say, if you're
- 51:53going to do it, think bigger about the big picture
- 51:58of the case. Do you want someone maybe? I don't
- 52:03see a lot of it in my department. But I think
- 52:06people know I have a lot of experience in this
- 52:08area of law. And maybe that's something you want
- 52:11to think about before you try that in 519. So
- 52:15I'm just going to ask Commissioner Schultz, is
- 52:17there anything that you found super surprising
- 52:20about your selection? Anything that when you
- 52:24went through it, you wouldn't have expected that
- 52:25did happen? A couple of things. One is I really
- 52:30was impressed by people bringing up some of my
- 52:35judicial opinions that are published out there
- 52:38where I worked as on the appeal. And it was clear
- 52:41that they had read my um briefing sure and listen
- 52:45as a former appellate guy i feel you i feel you
- 52:48yeah so i mean it was i mean they really i really
- 52:52didn't understand how uh complex and um sort
- 52:57of intensive the the procedure was and so you
- 53:01know that was very surprising to me uh in fact
- 53:05this program is so helpful um because it demystifies
- 53:10the process for everybody, including me, after
- 53:15having gone through it. So I'm learning about
- 53:18the process now, too. All right. And Commissioner
- 53:25Shapiro, same question to you. When you went
- 53:27through your process, did anything jump out at
- 53:29you as surprising or something you weren't prepared
- 53:33for or were surprised to see in that process?
- 53:37When I went into so first of all there's the
- 53:41horseshoe was when you get invited it's terrifying
- 53:43right the horseshoe is really really intimidating
- 53:47although i knew there was going to be a horseshoe
- 53:49so so for those on the call when we're referring
- 53:51to the horseshoe during the final round of interviews
- 53:55all of the all of the judges are sitting at a
- 53:59table shaped like a u around the edge of the
- 54:02table and the commissioner is sort of in the
- 54:04middle at the open end of the u So that was visually
- 54:11very, very intimidating. I knew that that was
- 54:14going to happen. And so the only way I psyched
- 54:19myself up was to remind myself that I had represented
- 54:23the Los Angeles Police Department in front of
- 54:25the Ninth Circuit many times. And if you can
- 54:27survive that, you can do anything. So that was
- 54:32good preparation when you represent a very disliked
- 54:35client. So that was good. But I think during
- 54:39the interview, someone went into character and
- 54:41acted like a very difficult litigant and you
- 54:43had to go and respond to that. That was really
- 54:49surprising, kind of intimidating. But I was grateful
- 54:55because I'd been sitting in misdemeanor courts
- 54:57every day and I got to watch really great bench
- 54:59officers deal with very difficult litigants.
- 55:02So I had a lot of experience and it wasn't overwhelming.
- 55:07So I think I was able to respond. Commissioner
- 55:10Brutea, similar question to somebody who is in
- 55:14the family law. Oh, Judge Kaufman is back. Shelly,
- 55:18I've just been riffing. So I'm going to throw
- 55:20it back to you. No, I appreciate it. I could
- 55:23hear you. I could hear you and. My computer just
- 55:26sort of said, sorry, we have to close your device.
- 55:29It beeped and said that and said goodbye. So
- 55:32I know we don't have much time. So anybody that
- 55:36wants to offer something that hasn't been asked
- 55:39the question, any of our commissioners, I'm going
- 55:42to give you the floor for a minute or less than
- 55:45a minute, because I think we have about three
- 55:47minutes to go. So anybody who wants to add something,
- 55:49go ahead. or if we want to bring back on our
- 55:52chairs of the Bar Association. Yes, Michelle,
- 55:54if we have a couple of minutes to take questions,
- 55:56I've tried to answer all the questions in the
- 55:58Q &A, but if there's any people want to jump
- 56:01on or dump something in the chat. If Tigran or
- 56:06Ryan feel like on behalf of their members, they
- 56:08have something to ask, we can go ahead. Oh, no.
- 56:16All right, then leave it to our commissioners.
- 56:19One last word, if you've got something to add
- 56:21that you didn't get to say. Commissioner Blossom.
- 56:25Yeah, I was going to say one question I thought
- 56:27about it was during the application process,
- 56:29I think it was really a bit of a rewarding two
- 56:33way street. It was extremely intense. It was
- 56:35time consuming, but it was helpful to me as well.
- 56:38I wasn't just giving information to the committee,
- 56:41but I was really looking inward about what my
- 56:43motives were and what my hopes were. and whether
- 56:46I would be an asset to the bench or not. So I
- 56:50think it's a worthy experience. It's like applying
- 56:54to college where you really have to crystallize
- 56:56your thoughts and who you are as a person, especially
- 57:00when it comes to demeanor and ethics and public
- 57:02service and decide what your path should be.
- 57:06So it was rewarding. So for members of the bar
- 57:08who are really interested in what it's like,
- 57:11I was just looking on my other monitor here,
- 57:13the questions are still up. So if you go to governmentjobs
- 57:16.com or just Google Los Angeles County Superior
- 57:20Court Commissioner, in the last round, again,
- 57:23this could change every time, but last time there
- 57:25were 52 questions that they wanted answers to.
- 57:28So I mean, if you write a page per answer, you
- 57:32can see how your application is going to be you
- 57:34know, over 50 pages very easily. But those questions
- 57:37are still online. So if you want to take a look
- 57:40at what last the last round, the questions that
- 57:44were asked of the commissioners who are appearing
- 57:45before you right now had to answer, they're still
- 57:48available online. All right. So we just have
- 57:50one last minute. And I just want to conclude
- 57:53by saying thank you, everyone, for participating.
- 57:55I hope you found this helpful. I mean, besides
- 57:57meeting these wonderful commissioners that have
- 58:00now joined the Family Law Division. I also hope
- 58:03you found it helpful to understand the process.
- 58:06Our commissioners are great and I'm happy to
- 58:09have them and their wonderful judicial officers
- 58:12and colleagues. Thank you very much.