Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When AI Met Legal: What Claude's New Legal Plugin Means for Your Practice
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Mark Hoag, the chair of the Beverly Hills
- 0:06Bar Association's AI in the Law section, along
- 0:09with my co -chair Amanda Harris. And I'm the
- 0:12founder of hoaglaw .ai, where I serve as fractional
- 0:14GC to mostly AI first SaaS companies and tech
- 0:19startups. And today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:21our speaker, once again, Stephen Smith. Stephen's
- 0:24the CEO of Intelligence by Intents, where he
- 0:27provides AI strategy advisory and training to
- 0:30law firms and to professional services organizations.
- 0:34He's delivered AI training and strategic guidance
- 0:36to over 1 ,000 organizations with a focus on
- 0:40practical adoption, governance, and measurable
- 0:43ROI rather than just theoretical overviews. Stephen
- 0:47brings over 25 years of executive leadership
- 0:49experience, including CFO and SVP rev ops roles
- 0:54at multiple organizations. and strategy partner
- 0:57roles at IBM Global Services and TCG Advisors,
- 1:01developing growth strategies for Fortune 100
- 1:04technology companies. Stephen holds an MBA from
- 1:07the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania
- 1:10and writes the Intelligence by Intent newsletter
- 1:13at smithsteven .com. And that's Stephen with
- 1:17an E -H. So thanks everyone for being here today.
- 1:21And Stephen, please take it away. Awesome. Thanks,
- 1:25Mark. Look, I'm glad to be back here again. There
- 1:27have been a lot of announcements just in the
- 1:29last couple of weeks since I last presented to
- 1:30this group. So let me jump in because we were
- 1:33on a pretty short timeline today and there's
- 1:36a lot of really interesting things to cover.
- 1:38So I'm not going to go into presentation mode
- 1:40because I'm going to bounce around between PowerPoint
- 1:42and Claude, which is the focus of the conversation
- 1:45today. Um, and also Excel because I want to show
- 1:48you a couple of things that are in there as well.
- 1:50But look, the last 25 days have been pretty disruptive
- 1:53from an AI perspective, right? And I'm going
- 1:55to really focus only on Claude right now, which
- 1:58is where the focus of the conversation is today.
- 2:00There also been big announcements we're expecting,
- 2:01you know, today or tomorrow from Chachi BT and
- 2:04from Google's Gemini that will also, you know,
- 2:06add way, a bunch more of additional capabilities.
- 2:09But look back in January 12th, um, anthropic
- 2:12launched something called cowork, which is agentic
- 2:14AI for knowledge workers. I'm going to talk about
- 2:16that today because it's related to what they
- 2:18announced on January 30th. But the big thing
- 2:20about what cowork does is it allows you to actually
- 2:25use the power of Claude on the files on your
- 2:28computer and spin up agents and have it do activities
- 2:30autonomously for you. So you can actually give
- 2:32it an activity. It can work on one or multiple
- 2:34files. It will go off and do what you've asked
- 2:36it to do. And then on January 30th, Anthropic
- 2:40with Claude launched 11 open source plugins.
- 2:43with one specifically focused on legal, right?
- 2:46And that caused a lot of impact in the markets,
- 2:48right? In fact, a couple of days later as people
- 2:50really started to understand what these plugins
- 2:53could do and how simple and powerful they were,
- 2:55right? It wiped off almost $300 billion of market
- 2:58cap from, you know, from legal tech stocks in
- 3:00a single session. And we'll talk about that as
- 3:02well. And then to cap this on February 5th, they
- 3:05launched Opus 4 .6, which is their smartest model.
- 3:07And with that, they updated these plugins for
- 3:10Excel and for PowerPoint, which lets you take
- 3:13the power of Claude in those models directly.
- 3:16And again, I'll show you, which really makes
- 3:17working in these tools far easier for a lot of
- 3:20people than it ever was before. And so just quickly,
- 3:23look, as I said, there was a big market meltdown,
- 3:25right? Thompson Reuters was down 16%. It was
- 3:27the biggest single day drop on record, right?
- 3:30Rolex was down, LegalZoom was down. You can see
- 3:32what happened here. And it's not that it was
- 3:34impacting these stocks so much specifically,
- 3:37you know, from what Anthropic did, it's that
- 3:39the market's starting to realize that these tools
- 3:41are going to fundamentally change the business
- 3:43models that these companies operate on. So, and
- 3:45it's far broader. You can see, you know, you
- 3:47know, Goldman Sachs software basket went down.
- 3:49The NASDAQ was down. The S &P 500 was down. So
- 3:51a lot of things happened there. And so. What
- 3:54was different about this set of announcements?
- 3:56Because these companies make announcements all
- 3:58the time, right? There's new models. Like I said,
- 4:00we're supposed to get chat GPT 5 .3 soon. Google
- 4:04actually launched Gemini 3 Deep Think today,
- 4:06which had a massive increase in capabilities.
- 4:09But there was something that was different about
- 4:11these announcements, right? So this was the very
- 4:13first time that a foundation model company, and
- 4:16when we refer to foundation model companies,
- 4:18we talk about Anthropic, which has Claude, OpenAI,
- 4:20which has ChatGPT, or Google which has Gemini,
- 4:23right? It's the first time one of those companies
- 4:25packaged legal workflows directly into its platform.
- 4:28Right. And that started disrupting the disruptors.
- 4:30So people are looking at Harvey and Legora and
- 4:33others that build on top of these models. And
- 4:35suddenly there is a new competitor there. Right.
- 4:38And it opens up new ways for you as an end practitioner
- 4:41to use these tools. There's some vertical integration
- 4:44going on, right? They're, you know, they're bundling,
- 4:46you know, it's its own model and it's wrapper
- 4:47and workflows again, and coming right to you.
- 4:50And it's now making them makers and builders,
- 4:52right? So they're actually expanding their playbook
- 4:54and it becomes a broader end to end solution
- 4:57compared to what they had before. And again,
- 4:59what it really does for you, especially if you're
- 5:01reasonably technically savvy, it opens up a lot
- 5:04of things that you just couldn't do before from
- 5:06a capability standpoint. I want to talk about
- 5:10this for one second. Because I've talked a lot
- 5:12about Claude in the past. In fact, if you watched
- 5:14last session, I did a lot of demos in Claude.
- 5:17They have really done a lot from a reasoning
- 5:20and a logic and a performance perspective. And
- 5:22we were running 4 .5 a couple of weeks ago. So
- 5:25on February 5th, they launched Opus 4 .6. And
- 5:28there was a couple of things that are really
- 5:29important. Not only was it A much, much smarter
- 5:32and better model in every way. There were two
- 5:35things here that were really, really important
- 5:37that I want to highlight. The first thing is
- 5:39the normal Claude model has a context window
- 5:41of about 200 ,000 tokens, right? So call it 150
- 5:44,000 words, give or take. They beta released
- 5:47in this version and I can't get to it. You can't
- 5:49get to it. They only did a subset release to
- 5:52some large enterprise customers, but it's going
- 5:54to have a million token context window, right?
- 5:56So that's 750 ,000 words. You know, it's five
- 5:59X the size of the last one. And why that's so
- 6:02important because look Gemini has a 1 million
- 6:05token context window today, right? Um, but there's
- 6:07something called long content retrieval. So when
- 6:10you load these models up with tons of information,
- 6:12tons of attachments, tons of chats, you're having
- 6:14back and forth, right? Ideally you want them
- 6:17to have perfect recall. Well, they don't, um,
- 6:20prior to this, the best, uh, anthropic model
- 6:23had about 18 and a half percent recall. So, you
- 6:25know, it would, you know, miss some of the things,
- 6:27right? This new Opus 4 .6 model has 76 % recall,
- 6:32which leads all the benchmarks, which means that,
- 6:33you know, it will be able to perfectly remember
- 6:3576 % of the stuff without missing anything, right?
- 6:38Which is honestly, it's a giant leap forward.
- 6:41The last time I looked, I believe Gemini 3's
- 6:43model was at like 26%. So again, we'll see what
- 6:46they come out with today. But again, this was
- 6:47a very large leap forward. But from a writing
- 6:50perspective, a reasoning perspective, Everything
- 6:52about Opus 4 .6 was a huge leap from 4 .5 and
- 6:56it really is leading across the benchmarks today.
- 7:00And so what Anthropic has focused on is Claude
- 7:04is trying to be where you work, right? Whether
- 7:06you're working on a Mac, whether you're working
- 7:08on a PC, they are trying to make all these tools
- 7:11accessible to you because they're really looking
- 7:13at your end to end workflow. And you'll see two
- 7:16things in here. So you'll see in here on this
- 7:18image, right? That there's a new ad in here for
- 7:20PowerPoint. So if you're using PowerPoint to
- 7:23create presentations and obviously look, I created
- 7:24a presentation here, right? There is now a open
- 7:27Claude appear, this little button. There's a
- 7:29workflow in here. I'm going to tell it to allow
- 7:31and continue. And it can now actually operate
- 7:34on the slides in my presentation. And I'll give
- 7:37you a simple example here since I happen to be
- 7:38here. I'm going to make something really simple.
- 7:40I'm going to just say change this slide so the
- 7:43background is white and the text is white and
- 7:48the text is black. This is the simplest example
- 7:54that I could probably do on here just on this
- 7:56particular one But I will tell you I can actually
- 7:58take any of these other slides and you can change
- 8:00formats You can drop in a presentation outline.
- 8:02You can say create slides for me You can really
- 8:04do whatever you want to do so you can see here
- 8:06It's literally real time from just using simple
- 8:09English language changing the slide, right? I
- 8:11could have it, you know Resize slides and do
- 8:14things. I didn't want to have it do much more
- 8:16than that for this But I actually when I was
- 8:18building this presentation, I was actually having
- 8:20Claude Work with me and edit some of the slides
- 8:23when you see sides that look like this and like
- 8:26this Originally they look very very different
- 8:28and I actually had them create it in this common
- 8:30format so I could have a common look in theme
- 8:32Throughout the presentation, but let me stop
- 8:35sharing this the more interesting one Honestly
- 8:37is Excel and so if I go share Excel for a second
- 8:41so I think you know almost every attorney I have
- 8:44ever worked with works in Excel and I have spent
- 8:47years and years in Excel. In fact, I've been
- 8:49using Excel since it came out, I think in 1999
- 8:51and I've used every version of it. And so I'm
- 8:54really familiar with all these things, but I
- 8:56know a lot of people aren't as fluent as, you
- 8:58know, how do I create charts? How do I sort tables?
- 9:00Can I create a pivot table? Things like that.
- 9:03So I did a couple of simple prebuilt examples
- 9:05to show you this, but let's say you had a bunch
- 9:07of transactions here, right? Say credit card
- 9:09transactions. I've got credit card dates. I've
- 9:11got categories. I've got business names. I've
- 9:13got amounts. I've got the months of when they
- 9:15are. And I want to do some analysis or some insight,
- 9:18right? I can literally tell it something as simple
- 9:21as, hey, make a pivot table by month, by spend,
- 9:24by category. And you can see here, it goes through,
- 9:26it reads the document, it does the stuff. Again,
- 9:28I'm not going to build it live because I want
- 9:29to spend time in coworking on the examples. But
- 9:32what it created for me then was a pivot table.
- 9:34And this is an actual live pivot table in Excel.
- 9:39So it actually went through and it did what I
- 9:40said. It built it by the spend categories. So
- 9:43here were the categories. And here were the months
- 9:45of the spend. So for a lot of people that aren't
- 9:48familiar with pivot tables, they'd have to look
- 9:49up how to do it and things like that. Now, when
- 9:52you use Cloud in Excel or Cloud in PowerPoint,
- 9:54again, you can just speak in plain language and
- 9:56it will do what you want to do. Similarly, I
- 9:59said, hey, I want you to go take that pivot table
- 10:01now and make some charts. And I literally said,
- 10:03you know, create a chart of the new tab based
- 10:05on the pivot table and it went through and it
- 10:07created a data set. And this was actually the
- 10:10first chart it created over here. I'll sort of
- 10:12zoom in. Um, so you can see this, right? It was
- 10:15given. I said, give me the two highest categories
- 10:16of spend. And it gave me food and hotels because
- 10:19it was excluding jewelry because jewelry is such
- 10:22a, you know, it's such off the axis. But I said,
- 10:24Hey, give me one that also has jewelry in there.
- 10:26So I can sort of see how much bigger jewelry
- 10:28spend was compared to, you know, food and housing
- 10:31or other things. So. My intent isn't to train
- 10:33you on these things, but just to show you that
- 10:35these capabilities are in there. They're really
- 10:37part of the new end to end solution that they
- 10:40are working on. And it's honestly, it's really
- 10:42fantastic. So the thing I want to talk about
- 10:46today and the thing that made the announcement
- 10:47so interesting is this thing called cowork. And
- 10:50so I think last time I presented, we talked about
- 10:52something called Claude code, which gives you
- 10:53the power of the Claude models in a terminal
- 10:57interface, right? And most people don't want
- 10:59to work in a terminal interface. So Claude built
- 11:01as part of their quad tools. a great interface
- 11:04that again lets you work on things on your computer,
- 11:06right? So you give it access to folders in your
- 11:09computer. It can read, it can edit, it can create
- 11:12files, it can combine files. It will plan and
- 11:15do multiple steps. You can give it a whole series
- 11:17of tasks, right? And it runs on an isolated virtual
- 11:20machine on your machine. So it's not going to
- 11:22step out and do other destructive things in areas
- 11:24that you don't tell it to do. It is incredibly
- 11:26powerful. I will show it to you in a minute.
- 11:29It is, it really unlocks the power of these models
- 11:31to do really, really interesting use cases and
- 11:34do really interesting things. So what anthropic
- 11:38announced a couple of days ago, um, back on January
- 11:4130th was these things called plugins, right?
- 11:43And a plugin is a skill. You can give a series
- 11:46of directions to a, you know, to anthropic to,
- 11:50to Claude, and it will go follow those things,
- 11:52right? What made them so unique is they, they
- 11:54launched 11 plugin categories. They launched
- 11:56legal, finance, sales, marketing, et cetera.
- 11:59But skills are just a set of English language
- 12:01directions. It's much like you would give a set
- 12:03of directions to an associate. You would say,
- 12:05do this, do this, do this, do this. And they
- 12:07can be very complex skills, right? And the other
- 12:10thing that's unique about them is they built
- 12:12in these things called connectors. So they actually
- 12:14give you an ability to connect to other services
- 12:16on your computer. So if there are third party
- 12:18services, third party vendor tools, third party
- 12:21databases, if you use... box or Dropbox or Asana
- 12:25or other things. You can actually connect these
- 12:27skills to that. So it actually becomes this really
- 12:29amazing, powerful workforce for you. They allowed
- 12:32you to build these slash commands, which I'll
- 12:34show you. So you can actually sort of have a
- 12:35preview of the command. So if there's a command
- 12:37you use frequently, you can go slash and it will
- 12:39go do something for you. And they just added
- 12:42this thing called subagents. So when they first
- 12:45launched Claude Cowork and Claude Code, like
- 12:47they did that, you know, you would tell it to
- 12:49do something. It was sort of one agent. It would
- 12:51go off and it would do everything in sequence.
- 12:53They've now created this ability to spawn off
- 12:55sub -agents. So let's say you were trying to
- 12:57analyze, you had an entire directory of credit
- 13:00card statements and tax statements and bank statements
- 13:02and things like that. Instead of going through
- 13:04them one at a time, you could actually tell Claude,
- 13:06hey, I want you to go analyze these things, pull
- 13:09this data out. And I want you to actually go
- 13:11now and actually spin up a subagent for every
- 13:13one of these things to run these things in parallel
- 13:15and run them faster. So this is the last page
- 13:19before I kind of jump over back and forth between
- 13:21the PowerPoint and Claude Cowork. So what specifically
- 13:25did they launch for legal, right? So they launched
- 13:27these legal plugins. They launched a contract
- 13:29review. They launched an NDA triage, right? They
- 13:33launched compliance workflows, legal briefings,
- 13:36and then templated responses, and they built
- 13:37these slash commands to make it really easy to
- 13:40do. As I said, the thing that I want to highlight
- 13:42here is the way that they built these is you
- 13:45can actually customize these now. to your environment,
- 13:49to your business. So if you have a set of rules
- 13:50around NDAs or contract review, or if you've
- 13:54got a pre -done set of guidelines, it can build
- 13:57on all those. So they've given you the framework
- 13:58and the template to truly customize it to your
- 14:01business. And they made it really, really easy
- 14:02to do so. So there are a couple of questions
- 14:05in the Q &A. Let me just look at these really
- 14:07quick. And I'll answer a couple of these and
- 14:11I'll come to some of these at the end. How is
- 14:13Cowork Skills better than a robust cloud project
- 14:15already set up in custom instructions? Oh, the
- 14:19simplest answer, the simplest difference is it
- 14:22can operate directly on multiple files on your
- 14:24computer. You don't have to preload them up and
- 14:26it can actually operate on hundreds of different
- 14:28files and it can actually, as I said, spawn up
- 14:31sub -agents to do lots and lots of things in
- 14:32parallel. So it's a very different use case for
- 14:35that one. So I took care of that one. Will it
- 14:39redline NDAs in Word? The answer is yes, it can
- 14:42absolutely do that. This is a great capability
- 14:44in here. So let me keep going. I'll come back
- 14:46to some more of these later, but I love seeing
- 14:48the questions. So the first one that they launched
- 14:50is called review contract, right? So you can
- 14:54actually have it go review a contract clause
- 14:55by clause, right? And they built in sort of this
- 14:57traffic light, this green, yellow, red, right?
- 15:00So based on the clauses they built in, it will
- 15:03read the contract and say, okay, the green ones
- 15:04are perfectly acceptable. yellow ones need attention
- 15:07and red ones are, you know, a high risk deviation
- 15:10from what our norms are, right? So it will then
- 15:12output back to you in a word document, right?
- 15:15Specific red line suggestions, risk explanations,
- 15:17track changes. And again, you can go customize
- 15:20these things, right? So the scenario they talked
- 15:22about is, Hey, you got a 47 page vendor agreement.
- 15:24You know, the business team wants to sign by
- 15:26Friday. Claude based on your rules can instantly
- 15:29flag the most important things that you have
- 15:31to work with and give you some suggested responses.
- 15:33Again, it's not trying to replace you. It's trying
- 15:36to, you know, short circuit some of the things
- 15:38you can do. So I'm going to pop over to Claude
- 15:40for a second. I've pre done these because I want
- 15:43to show you what these things can do and just
- 15:46quickly. I'm so if you're in the clot app and
- 15:49I'm really happy to say now that they just launched
- 15:51the windows version of co -work. I think two
- 15:53days ago. So originally they only launched this
- 15:55in the mac. Um, but now this is also a windows
- 15:57thing as well. Um, you know, normally you have
- 16:00chats over here. You can go have all of your
- 16:02chats and you have projects and all the things
- 16:03that you do. Uh, you have co -work here and by
- 16:06the way, Cowork only runs in the specific clot
- 16:09app. It doesn't run in the web browser, right?
- 16:12But it basically says hey I want to go work in
- 16:13a folder here and you can pick a folder to go
- 16:15work on I'm gonna work on let's say the downloads
- 16:17folder and then I've got these different legal
- 16:20commands here. Well, let me go back here Um,
- 16:23I'm going to work in legal and I've got, you
- 16:25know, brief vendor check, I've got respond and
- 16:27to start one, I can just literally say, Hey,
- 16:29vendor check, right? I can start typing it out
- 16:32and then I can upload a file or I can say refer
- 16:34to these files in the directory, do whatever
- 16:36I want to do. Um, and go, you know, go do this
- 16:39work for me. So the first one I had to, and I
- 16:41prebuilt these cause I want you to see the output.
- 16:42Cause these take, you know, five, 10 minutes
- 16:44to run, you know, they're not short. So the first
- 16:47one I did was a legal triage one where I said,
- 16:51Hey, there's an NDA in the folder. Go analyze
- 16:53it, right? So it said it found several NDAs.
- 16:56Let me go grab the most recent one. And so I've
- 16:58got it. I'm going to go do the rules. And what
- 17:00it creates for you here is I'm going to make
- 17:03this a little bit wider so you can see it. is
- 17:05it went through, and I know I'm going a little
- 17:07bit out of order with the slides on the presentation,
- 17:10but it went through here and created this NDA
- 17:12triage report, right? So it says, hey, classification
- 17:14red, there are significant issues. We need to
- 17:16do a full legal review on this document. So it
- 17:19created a summary here. I didn't happen to have
- 17:22any parties in this example one. But the things
- 17:24that I told it to look for things like mutual
- 17:26obligations, right? It failed. This was not a
- 17:28unilateral NDA, right? There are some issues
- 17:30in the definition scope. It's over broad, right?
- 17:32There was no the term of five years was too long.
- 17:35So you can see here. It took a document that
- 17:38I uploaded and basically went through and created
- 17:40this entire thing. And then it goes through and
- 17:42it identifies all the issues here, gives me the
- 17:45risks, give you suggested fixes. So it's a much
- 17:48faster version. And then I can actually open
- 17:51up this document in Microsoft Word with all these
- 17:54suggested changes and red lines and things like
- 17:56that. So again, it makes it a lot easier to go
- 17:59through. And do what you're talking about. I
- 18:02think this was actually yeah, this was the second
- 18:04one that I did This was the NDA one. So again,
- 18:06you can pre -screen for volume You can have a
- 18:08screen a whole bunch of NDAs at one time and
- 18:10do the analysis for you So, you know again the
- 18:13example is you get 30 NDAs in a week, you know
- 18:15Most are standard Claude categorizes each one.
- 18:17It flags with specific things. Let me go back
- 18:20to Reviewing contract for a second. Let me go
- 18:24back and find my zoom link here. I seem to have
- 18:26lost the the zoom window. Hold on here Let me
- 18:31go back to the PowerPoint for one sec. What I
- 18:35was saying is, I was looking at the NDA one here,
- 18:37right? Your team gets 30 NDAs per week. This
- 18:39is what we just looked at. I'm gonna go back
- 18:41and show you the actual example of the review
- 18:43contract, because that's another really good
- 18:45example. But again, it looks clause by clause
- 18:47against your configuration. Again, it will give
- 18:49me sort of green, yellow, red. So let me go back
- 18:51there. And this is always the challenge of bouncing
- 18:54around in these tools, is let me go back and
- 18:57find now, here we go, review contract. And again,
- 19:00that's why I did these. So I literally just said,
- 19:02hey, do legal review on contract. You know, I
- 19:04was in cowork and I just typed legal review.
- 19:07I said, you know, it asked me some questions.
- 19:08What do I want to go look at? I answered the
- 19:11questions. But again, it found, hey, four things
- 19:14that are in red, you know, limitations, liability,
- 19:16indemnification, IP ownership, scope change.
- 19:18And again, I'm going to show you the output of
- 19:20this. So it did a consulting proposal that was
- 19:23redlined. So someone asked earlier in the questions
- 19:26about redlining. So I'll pull this up. And while
- 19:30that's pulling up, let me just look at the other
- 19:32questions here. So you can see here, by the way,
- 19:36that it actually went through and redlined. And
- 19:38it's really good at doing this, especially if
- 19:40you work in Word docs, at doing this automatically,
- 19:43right? So it actually redlined this, it made
- 19:45the suggestion changes and all the things that
- 19:47it thinks should happen again based on my firm's
- 19:50guidelines. And the other doc that's in here.
- 19:53is the contract review at the actual summary
- 19:55itself would actually goes and identifies the
- 19:57different clauses and things like that that shows,
- 19:59hey, here's where the issues are. So we'll let
- 20:01that go ahead and load. You can see here overall
- 20:03risk. Don't sign this document as written. So
- 20:06again, It's not meant to replace your judgment,
- 20:09but it's meant to really shorten the time to
- 20:11help you and be a really powerful assistant as
- 20:14you work on these documents, as you do all these
- 20:16different things, right? So here's all the findings,
- 20:18here's all the flags. And again, if you're dealing
- 20:21with very, very large contracts, and I do this
- 20:23all the time, right? This makes it really, really
- 20:25easy to go through, take a look at these things
- 20:28and figure it out. So let me pop back to the
- 20:30PowerPoint for one second here. I'm not going
- 20:33to do all these because there's a lot in here
- 20:34and I do want to get to Q &A. There is a vendor
- 20:38check one. I won't do this one because this one
- 20:41really is powerful. If you actually have a vendor
- 20:45system connected into your infrastructure or
- 20:47your client does, right? So if you're a large
- 20:48organization, you know, or you're in corporate
- 20:51and you've got, you know, a vendor tool, you
- 20:53can actually have it check, you know, the current
- 20:55status of your agreement with all the vendor
- 20:57deliverables and where they are and things like
- 20:58that. It'll also look for things like renewals,
- 21:01auto -renew triggers. It'll flag any gaps you
- 21:03have in coverage, right? Maybe you don't have
- 21:04a DPA with that vendor. So again, it's a really,
- 21:07really powerful tool. And it makes it very easy
- 21:10to go through and do this stuff. Another one
- 21:14they added was called Brief. And it allows you
- 21:17to generate contextual briefings in three modes.
- 21:19So I do want to talk about these. And I did one
- 21:21of these as a really good example. So maybe you
- 21:24want to set up a daily morning brief on any overnight
- 21:26contract requests, compliance questions. So you
- 21:28could actually point it at either email coming
- 21:31in or a shared directory that you have or some
- 21:34other mechanism maybe a slack where these things
- 21:36come in and you can say hey go do a morning brief
- 21:39for me every single morning and identify you
- 21:42know what came in what things I have to focus
- 21:43on and break it down for me right or you can
- 21:46create a briefing on a topic right in essence
- 21:47it's sort of a deep research kind of category
- 21:49I want to go focus on a particular legal question
- 21:52and that's actually the example that I did that
- 21:53I'll pull up really quickly Or you can perhaps
- 21:56do a brief on an incident. You had a data breach.
- 21:59People are working on it. What are you doing?
- 22:01And let's go make this thing happen. So I'll
- 22:03show you the briefing on the topic, because that's
- 22:06actually a really interesting way to use this
- 22:08here. Go back into Claude. Go back up here to
- 22:11the projects. And I'll do the brief on AI disclosure.
- 22:15And this is actually something we were talking
- 22:16about before the call. I was talking with Mark.
- 22:19around AI disclosures and requirements for attorneys
- 22:21and things like that. So as of when I ran this
- 22:24a couple of days ago, there's no single statewide
- 22:26rule mandating attorney AI disclosure and filings.
- 22:29But I wanted to know, hey, what are some best
- 22:31practices? What are some things I should look
- 22:32at? The question is. Do I have to disclose that
- 22:34I'm using AI, you know, with my clients? And
- 22:37so I asked it just to go research that really
- 22:39simple question and it came back with, you know,
- 22:42when it looked at, you know, the California,
- 22:44you know, the rule, you know, 10 .4 30, the state
- 22:46bar ethics, you know, Morgan Lewis, California
- 22:48court appeals rules, things like that. And it
- 22:51came back and prepared for me a very nicely formatted
- 22:54document that I can go through and read and analyze.
- 22:56So again, is your preparing things as you're
- 22:58thinking about things, or if you want to explain
- 23:00things to clients. This is a powerful use case
- 23:03for using these tools. And again, you can see
- 23:07it actually creates it basically in a Word document
- 23:09format. You can see up here, I can open it up
- 23:11in Word. It will do that. So one of the great
- 23:13things about using Cloud this way is it actually
- 23:15really is generating Excel spreadsheets or PowerPoints
- 23:20or Word documents for you. Again, that's all
- 23:23part of these new updates. So we go back to the
- 23:25presentation for a second. I'm only going to
- 23:27bounce back, I think, maybe one or two more times.
- 23:31Respond. If you've got typical autoresponse for
- 23:33certain kinds of legal inquiries, you can actually
- 23:35have it do different kinds of responses for you.
- 23:38So you can generate template responses for the
- 23:41common things you get. Maybe you get data subject
- 23:43access requests or litigation discovery holds,
- 23:46vendor questions. So again, if you've got pre
- 23:49-created stuff, and again, this one's probably
- 23:51more at you know, attorneys in corporations,
- 23:54you can actually have it really pre -draft things
- 23:56for you to make your life, you know, a lot easier.
- 24:00So I know we have five minutes left. I want to
- 24:02get to some questions and I've got just a few
- 24:04more slides here. One of the things I want to
- 24:06mention to you and I mentioned this earlier is
- 24:08every one of these skills is completely customizable,
- 24:11right? So the screenshots here, you'll see it
- 24:15in the presentation that you can download after
- 24:17this. But all of these rules, all these skills,
- 24:21they're just simple English language, right?
- 24:23So it describes a workflow. It describes the
- 24:25steps that you want it to do. Um, it describes,
- 24:27you know, if there's no NDA playbook to go do
- 24:28this. So every one of these things is literally
- 24:32a very, very simple, you know, set of, you know,
- 24:35set of descriptive texts that you can go do and
- 24:37you can change and tailor to your business. So
- 24:39when they're in Claude. when you're working in
- 24:42Claude, you can actually click on the plugins
- 24:44menu, you can click on the commands, what I did
- 24:45here, and you can see like say triage, and you
- 24:47can literally go edit these skills, right, directly
- 24:50in there. So as you get comfortable with, hey,
- 24:52I didn't like that step, I want this step, you
- 24:54know, please go do this, it's actually quite
- 24:56easy to do as part of that process. So just a
- 25:01couple of other things really quickly before
- 25:03I wrap this up. Actually, let me go back into
- 25:05Claude, I'll show you one more thing, because
- 25:07I shall show you that. And then I'll show you
- 25:09another use case that you can use these for.
- 25:11Cause again, it's really quite simple. So if
- 25:13I go down the bottom left here, I can say plugins
- 25:16and I've got these legal plugins and I can go
- 25:18look at these skills here, right? So if I go
- 25:20look at the NDA tree hours skill, these are the
- 25:23instructions, right? You're an NDA screening
- 25:25assistant for an in -house legal team, right?
- 25:27You rapidly evaluate incoming NDAs against standard
- 25:29criteria. classify them by risk level and provide
- 25:32routing recommendations, right? So these are
- 25:35these tools, right? This is what it came with
- 25:38as the starting plugin point, right? Look for
- 25:40definitions of confidential information, look
- 25:42for obligations of receiving party, standard
- 25:44carve -outs, all these things. If I wanna change
- 25:46this, it's as simple as literally going up here
- 25:49and clicking edit. and then going through, and
- 25:51if I change the text in here, it will then change
- 25:54this skill that every time you use it will actually
- 25:56now have my updated skill. So again, they made
- 25:59this super powerful. And again, I think that's
- 26:01one of the reasons that a lot of those, the stocks
- 26:03in those companies dropped initially, is they're
- 26:05really putting the power of using these tools,
- 26:07you know, call it to the people in a very, very
- 26:09easy way. So I did one really simple example,
- 26:13just to show you. uh, the difference between
- 26:16using this and using, um, say a project or using,
- 26:19you know, chat should be degenerate or claw generally.
- 26:22So I pointed at a directory and I said, Hey,
- 26:25I have a tax return in here, right? It's a corporate
- 26:27tax return. Go extract out the financials against
- 26:29trucking and income statement, right? Very simple
- 26:31prompt, but you can see here, it shows you its
- 26:34progress. It's going to list out step by step.
- 26:36all the activities it's going to go do. And then
- 26:38it calls on these other skills. It says, Hey,
- 26:40I need to understand how to process a PDF because
- 26:42this was a PDF tax return. Um, I need to understand
- 26:45how to call Excel. And these are things that
- 26:47are built into Claude now. So I went through,
- 26:49it processed the document, you know, it said,
- 26:51all right, net revenue, gross profit, total other
- 26:53income. And then because I said, create an income
- 26:55statement, it actually created an Excel spreadsheet
- 26:58for me that it, I can pop up actually, you know,
- 27:00here in Claude, um, I can then open it up in
- 27:03Excel. But again, you know, from a time saving
- 27:06perspective, you know, like think how long it
- 27:08would take an analyst or a paralegal to go through
- 27:10a tax return, you know, create a statement, do
- 27:12it. You could actually have it operate again
- 27:14on multiple files in a directory, things like
- 27:17that. So again, really, really powerful use cases
- 27:19that, that, um, Anthropic just unlocked. So last
- 27:23couple of sides really quickly. They're trying
- 27:26to build the full stack. Everything works together,
- 27:27right? They launched Opus 4 .6, they launched
- 27:30Cowork. They build this legal plugin. By the
- 27:32way, they built in sales ones and finance ones
- 27:34and others, but they're now seamlessly integrating
- 27:36this into Excel and PowerPoint and Word, right?
- 27:38So they're making this really, really simple.
- 27:41They did put out a couple of caveats. Look, this
- 27:43is a research preview, right? It can make mistakes.
- 27:45And as I said in the last meeting, right? All
- 27:49our outputs have to be reviewed by licensed attorneys,
- 27:51right? You're the one that has the bar association
- 27:53number. You're the one that has to stand in front
- 27:54of a judge if there was a mistake. So at the
- 27:56end of the day, these tools are absolutely amazing
- 27:59and getting better every day at creating this
- 28:00kind of content for you. But please, please,
- 28:02please make sure you go through and look at all
- 28:05the stuff that's out there. And I will say bigger
- 28:07picture, this stuff is moving so fast from when
- 28:09we last met in January, right? Big changes in
- 28:13the models, a lot of, you know, a lot of new
- 28:15capabilities, right? And the question, what isn't
- 28:17whether AI is going to change legal work, right?
- 28:20It's whether you'll be ready when it does, because
- 28:21it's already doing it. And again, just last bit
- 28:24about me, right? How do I help organizations
- 28:26besides doing these CLEs? You know, I do executive
- 28:29workshops. I go in depth. I provide training.
- 28:31We go into the tools. If people want firm wide
- 28:33training or, you know, if they need litigation
- 28:35support, because a lot of the advanced use cases
- 28:37are more difficult than people can do. So with
- 28:40that. I know I've got 10 .29 on my clock. I'm
- 28:43going to look at a couple more of the questions
- 28:45here and just see what else is in here. How does
- 28:51the new Clawed legal plugin compare to OpenCase
- 28:54in terms of accuracy on citations? I don't know
- 28:57how to answer that. I'm not familiar with OpenCase,
- 28:59so I don't know if Mark or someone else can come
- 29:01back to that one later because I'm just not as
- 29:03familiar with it. Does it work with Excel power
- 29:06query? What about access? No, right now it works
- 29:08with native Excel. It won't work with power query.
- 29:11Although if you were really experimental and
- 29:13you wanted to use Claude code, I'm pretty sure
- 29:16Claude code could do that. It doesn't currently
- 29:19connect to access as far as I know. How did you
- 29:22get the open Claude option at top of your documents?
- 29:27It's on, so it's in, you have to have the...
- 29:30The Claude downloaded app, right? So I have a
- 29:32Mac. This is the downloaded version. And you
- 29:34have to have a pro or a Mac subscription or an
- 29:37enterprise subscription to get it. If you're
- 29:38on the free one, they have not ruled it out to
- 29:41the free ones yet, but they have now ruled out
- 29:43cowork to the pro users as well. What prompts
- 29:47do I have to use to Claude to help me with the
- 29:49mail merge? Let me take that one offline. I'm
- 29:52happy to answer that one. So if someone could
- 29:54just flag that, that I can come back to that
- 29:56one, cause that's a little bit of a longer answer
- 29:58on this one. I'll hit a couple more. Are there
- 30:01any options to keep the information provided
- 30:03to the agent confidential such that legal use
- 30:05cases would comply with the new rules of California
- 30:07considering for sharing client information with
- 30:09AI? So the answer is yes, yes, and yes. So this
- 30:13is a great conversation. It's very timely. There
- 30:16was a ruling actually two days ago in New York
- 30:18around these tools. So the ruling, at least in
- 30:21New York was basically that if you're using the
- 30:23consumer grade versions of these tools, this
- 30:25information is not privileged. You have to be
- 30:27using the enterprise, enterprise grade versions
- 30:30of these tools, either the teams or the business
- 30:32or the enterprise ones, or accessing these tools
- 30:35over the API. So it's not enough just to turn
- 30:37off training data, which by the way, you should
- 30:39absolutely do, because I know a lot of people
- 30:41will still use consumer ones. But if you need
- 30:43the confidentiality, you need to be using the
- 30:45enterprise tools. And that's where the current
- 30:48rulings that I'm seeing are heading if you want
- 30:49that level of protection. What is a pivot table
- 30:52and what are they used for? That's a great question.
- 30:55A pivot table basically lets you summarize analysis
- 30:58in Excel, right? It actually lets you take like
- 31:00a long sets of rows of data and then actually
- 31:03create different types of analysis of different
- 31:04rows and columns and sub -columns of data. It's
- 31:06just a really powerful analytic tool that lets
- 31:09you crunch through a lot of stuff. Are there
- 31:12any concerns about privacy and the sharing of
- 31:15confidential private information when using cowork?
- 31:17Again, It's tied to your subscription. So if
- 31:20you're using an enterprise subscription, you
- 31:23are completely covered. And again, I encourage
- 31:25people to do that or use the Teams one. You can
- 31:28use the consumer grade ones and turn off training.
- 31:30But as a ruling just came out, that information
- 31:33will not be considered privileged. So again,
- 31:35this is evolving. It literally is changing day
- 31:37by day. So always turn off training. And again,
- 31:41I tell everybody, please use the enterprise class
- 31:43tools. Yes, you can limit the files and folders
- 31:46it has access to in your computer. Absolutely,
- 31:48you can restrict it and it will only work on
- 31:50those. It's really powerful and it's really great
- 31:51that way. Can it be used to maintain confidentiality
- 31:55without paying for enterprise? Honestly, the
- 31:59answer, as far as I'm concerned, the answer is
- 32:00no. You can have it not trained in your data,
- 32:04but again, literally based on the ruling I just
- 32:06saw that came out two days ago. And again, that
- 32:07was a New York based ruling, but I suspect California
- 32:09will adopt similar rules. You can't just use
- 32:12consumer grade tools. You need to pay for enterprise
- 32:14ones. And candidly, they're not that much more
- 32:16expensive. You can get ChachiBT enterprise grade
- 32:20ones for 50 bucks a month. You can get Claude
- 32:23ones for $150 a month and you can get Gemini
- 32:26ones for $15 a month. So they're not materially
- 32:28more expensive than using consumer grade ones.
- 32:32You just need to understand how to set them up
- 32:33and turn on the privacy. Can I talk about privilege
- 32:37concerns when using Claude? I think I've covered
- 32:40this. You can, you know, these companies are
- 32:43allowing you to get zero day retention. You got
- 32:45to request them specifically. But given their
- 32:48commercial terms of service, you know, The rulings
- 32:50I'm seeing is that these generally should be
- 32:52covered by privilege. Again, check as they come
- 32:55out, they're changing every day. How do you access
- 32:57co -work? Is there a charge? Yeah, you have to
- 32:59be a subscriber. You have to either be a pro
- 33:01or max or an enterprise subscriber to use it.
- 33:06All right, I'm going to do three more because
- 33:07I know we're running over here. I've used AI
- 33:09for legal research leads, but not yet Claude.
- 33:11How much does it cost? Oh, so like I said. To
- 33:15do sort of the minimum cost for Claude to use
- 33:17an enterprise one is $50 a month. You get to
- 33:21basically commercial grade subscriptions. So
- 33:24I would encourage you to use that. Can you work
- 33:27with briefs? What about legal authority hallucinations?
- 33:30Yeah, you can upload briefs. Look, these things
- 33:32are getting better and better all the time at
- 33:34minimizing hallucinations. But again, and it
- 33:37can check citations. And there are ways to start
- 33:39plugging these tools into third party sources
- 33:41and have it surf the web. That's beyond what
- 33:42we can cover here. But you should still be using
- 33:46Lexis, Nexus, and Caseload and other things to
- 33:48get official legal authority and citations for
- 33:49this stuff. Use this as reasoning and writing
- 33:53tools when you have the research done. What is
- 33:56the jury simulation function? Somebody saw that.
- 34:00I actually have built a set of skills that uses
- 34:03Claude agents and sub -agents to allow you to
- 34:06basically mimic a jury so you can fire up a bunch
- 34:09of agents that actually allow you to say hey
- 34:13these are the jurors here's the descriptions
- 34:14here's their background here's the education
- 34:16here's the everything we presented at trial here's
- 34:20my set of arguments i want you to now use the
- 34:22power of ai and have you know claude simulate
- 34:25you know this number of jurors have them analyze
- 34:28the all the things I've uploaded, all the arguments,
- 34:31and then have them come up with conclusions,
- 34:32have them debate with each other, and then have
- 34:34sort of a jury format and come back with how
- 34:35they think they would rule. So it's a simulation
- 34:37I've built to help firms start to do that. I've
- 34:40done the same thing on the judge's side. So it
- 34:42really is an interesting thing. You could put
- 34:44in a lot of information about judges and have
- 34:45it try again, simulate how it thinks a judge
- 34:48and things will rule. So I'm going to pause there.
- 34:51I know I've been talking really fast. We went
- 34:52five minutes over. There's a couple of other
- 34:53questions. If they can be captured, I will try
- 34:55and get them in an email because there's like
- 34:5718 more. But again, thank you so much for your
- 35:00time. I really appreciate this. I hope you found
- 35:02this valuable. I normally focus on all the tools,
- 35:06not just Claude, but because of the updates and
- 35:08what they launched in the last couple of weeks,
- 35:10it was really worth doing a deep dive. Again,
- 35:13reach out if you have any questions, and thank
- 35:14you so much for your time today. I really appreciate
- 35:16it. Bye bye.