Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Parenting Plan Coordinators: Managing High-Conflict Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to parenting plan coordinators
- 0:07managing high flick conflict cases. My name is
- 0:11Jack McMorrow and we are excited to bring you
- 0:14this MCLE today. The family law section is sponsored
- 0:18by White, Zuckerman, Worowski, Lund, Hunt and
- 0:23LLP and Soberlink. White, Zuckerman, Worowski,
- 0:28Lund and Hunt provides a wide variety of resources
- 0:31to plead almost any project, large or small.
- 0:36They also provide traditional accounting and
- 0:38tax practice services. We invite you to contact
- 0:41them to discuss your specific accounting needs
- 0:43and learn how they can be of service to you.
- 0:45Learn more at WZWLH .com. SoberLink provides
- 0:51objective real -time data that can be used to
- 0:54reduce... disputes over alcohol consumption,
- 0:57leading to less conflict in custody cases. To
- 1:00help ensure smoother negotiations for a more
- 1:03efficient legal process, consider using SoberLink's
- 1:07trusted alcohol monitoring system to eliminate
- 1:10hearsay and protect your client's best interests.
- 1:14With an unprecedented combination of features,
- 1:17including advanced reporting, facial recognition,
- 1:20tamper -resistant, real -time results, and customized
- 1:24testing. The discrete system has been the leader
- 1:27in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. Learn
- 1:31more at soberlink .com. Just before we get started,
- 1:36I want to thank you all for attending today,
- 1:38and I want to invite you to come back for more
- 1:41CLEs later this month. We have a few coming up
- 1:44that are on international family law issues,
- 1:46and there's also a really great one being put
- 1:49on on Friday, January 23 at 1230. It's Retirement
- 1:54Division Red Flags and Foundational Quadro Basics
- 1:57Issues brought to you by the BHBA. Before we
- 2:02get started, I now have the pleasure of giving
- 2:04you an introduction to your wonderful speakers
- 2:06today, and I thank them all for presenting to
- 2:09you. Here we have, for presenters today, Honorable
- 2:15Margo Hoy, Mary Lund, and Robin Sachs. Judge
- 2:20Margo Hoy brings more than three decades of family
- 2:24law experience to her work. As a mediator at
- 2:28Signature Resolution, following 11 years on the
- 2:32San Diego Superior Court, and 18 years of private
- 2:36practice. As the court's former supervising family
- 2:40law judge, she oversaw 26 departments and pioneered
- 2:45the use of child custody parenting plans. Judge
- 2:48Hoy is widely respected for her approachable
- 2:51style, leadership in family law innovation, and
- 2:54numerous recognitions, including multiple Judicial
- 2:58Officer of the Year awards. Dr. Mary Lund is
- 3:01a Los Angeles -based clinical psychologist with
- 3:04over 25 years of experience mediating family
- 3:08disputes and conducting more than 600 custody
- 3:11evaluations. A UCLA PhD and a former postdoctoral
- 3:16researcher at the University of Cambridge, she
- 3:19is recognized as one of the region's foremost
- 3:22experts on divorce, child adjustment, and family
- 3:26dynamics. Dr. Lund has has published widely,
- 3:34trained judicial officers, and served in leadership
- 3:37roles with the Association of Family and Conciliation
- 3:40Courts and other professional organizations.
- 3:42And finally, we have Robin Sachs. Robin Sachs
- 3:46is a criminal attorney and victim advocate with
- 3:49over 25 years of experience as a prosecutor and
- 3:53criminal defense attorney. Known by her clients
- 3:56as The Fixer, She is recognized for her strategic
- 4:00problem solving, investigative acumen, and holistic
- 4:04advocacy. In addition to her legal practice,
- 4:08Robin serves as a consultant, expert witness,
- 4:11interventionalist, and family coach. Trained
- 4:15as both an attorney and a clinical therapist,
- 4:17she brings a therapeutically informed approach
- 4:20to her work, offering clients a unique, compassionate,
- 4:24and effective legal experience. Thank you all
- 4:27for coming. Thank you all for presenting. You
- 4:30are in for a treat. This is a wonderful panel.
- 4:33Take it away. Thank you so much, Jack. It's kind
- 4:37of an old bio that you guys read of me, but that's
- 4:40all good. My focus of my main work, and I want
- 4:42to say this because really this is all about
- 4:44family law here today, and I don't want to create
- 4:46any confusion that this is about criminal law
- 4:48or something else different than that. Today
- 4:51we are coming to you to model the Village approach,
- 4:55and I am going to start our PowerPoint here in
- 4:58just a minute, but also feel free to put any
- 5:01questions into the chat throughout. We're happy
- 5:04we'll be able to field them. We don't get to
- 5:05see all of you folks out there in terms of bodies
- 5:09on a screen, but feel free to ask us questions,
- 5:13and we will field those as we go. So. Just starting
- 5:22here from the beginning is, as I said, we are
- 5:26modeling the team approach. Here you have a panel
- 5:28with a retired judge, a lawyer therapist, and
- 5:31a therapist therapist, psychologist, who is here.
- 5:36We're coming here to not only talk to you about
- 5:39how to work together, but we actually really
- 5:41do work together. So in order to get a sense
- 5:43of who's in the room and to... Talk about the
- 5:47topic of parenting parent plan coordination and
- 5:50hopefully sell you on the idea of why parenting
- 5:53plan coordinators could be a very good intervention
- 5:55for your cases Want to get a sense of who's actually
- 5:59ever used a PPC so we're gonna launch a poll
- 6:04here and Hopefully get kind of some feedback
- 6:07just to get a sense of whether or not you've
- 6:08ever used a PPC in any of your cases and and
- 6:14the goal here is today is to help demystify the
- 6:19PPC process. One of the big things that we have
- 6:22found is there's a lot of confusion about PPCs
- 6:26out there in terms of the client world, and there
- 6:28is frankly also a lot of confusion among lawyers
- 6:32about what PPCs do and don't do. And so what
- 6:35we want to do is help be able to talk to you
- 6:39guys about it so that you guys can then share
- 6:41this with your clients. So we have 42 % saying
- 6:47yes, 52 % said no, and 6 % said they've tried
- 6:54and it's never come to pass. So that is kind
- 6:56of very illustrative of what we actually have
- 6:59experienced, is that a lot of people have not
- 7:02used a PPC in their case, and therefore, just
- 7:05like anything else, if you haven't used something,
- 7:07you don't know how it exactly works, and a lot
- 7:10of people take the approach of if it ain't broke,
- 7:12don't fix it. But if you have used a PPC, And
- 7:16we're going to load up our next question. We
- 7:19are going to ask, who was it? Did you use a retired
- 7:22judge, a lawyer, or mental health professional?
- 7:26And I guess we only give you a single choice
- 7:28here. So if you've had more than one PPC with
- 7:31different type of people, I think just... do
- 7:35the one that pops in your head as your connotation
- 7:38of who a PPC is and who the person is. Because
- 7:42one of the things we're going to highlight is
- 7:44that there are different people that can act
- 7:47as a PPC and different strengths that different
- 7:50disciplines bring to the process, even though
- 7:52this is potentially a team process and how the
- 7:55PPC process actually works. So hopefully we can
- 7:58get our results here. So interesting, 61 % were
- 8:07mental health providers. And that's a surprise,
- 8:10I think, to us because in our conversation that
- 8:13we had in our preparation for this, we were going
- 8:15to try to talk and make a plug as to why more
- 8:18mental health professionals maybe should be PPC.
- 8:21So maybe for those of you who are using PPCs,
- 8:23you guys are ahead of the curve and can help
- 8:25demonstrate that point because there are definitely
- 8:28cases where a mental health professional can
- 8:30be a very valuable PPC. brings different skills.
- 8:35And then our last question just to see kind of
- 8:38where you are in the mood on what you think about
- 8:42PPCs. Were they helpful? Yes? No? And this is
- 8:46for everybody. They could be, but I'm skeptical.
- 8:49or there could be and I'm optimistic. Just want
- 8:52to get a sense of, I mean, there are a lot of
- 8:54different views out there and I think this may
- 8:56be evolving. So just want to get a sense of who
- 8:59and where your mindset is as you come into this
- 9:01conversation. So if we can get the results of
- 9:03this, we will be ready to jump into learning.
- 9:07Good, so we have 54 % saying that they were helpful.
- 9:123 % saying not helpful, and 17 % of they could
- 9:17be, but I'm skeptical, so we'll kind of put those
- 9:19in the, so we have 20 % that are no and I'm skeptical,
- 9:23and 26 % being optimistic. So hopefully, with
- 9:27this training today, people will feel more optimistic,
- 9:30but in addition, feel like they have a better
- 9:33sense of how to use PPCs and what PPCs are. One
- 9:37thing that I, I tell people all the time, and
- 9:40we'll jump into more of the details here in a
- 9:42minute, is a lot of people say, especially clients,
- 9:46one of the things that we hear are, I don't want
- 9:49a PPC because I don't want someone to have to,
- 9:52I don't want to give up my parental authority.
- 9:54I don't want to have to have someone make decisions
- 9:56for me. If there is a case that is in litigation
- 10:00in any form or was in litigation in any form
- 10:02or could be in litigation in any form, you have
- 10:05a PPC. That PPC is called the judge. So I try
- 10:10to explain to people that this doesn't usurp
- 10:11parental authority, but allows for potentially
- 10:15decisions to be made earlier, quicker, more expeditiously
- 10:20on particularly things that may be time sensitive
- 10:23and not worthy of filing an RFO or going to court
- 10:27for. But we'll get into all of these details
- 10:29as we go on. And I am going to move us along
- 10:35to the next slide if I can. There we go. So that
- 10:40I'm Mary Lund and I'm going to talk about. That
- 10:44system so we're gonna start out with this cartoon
- 10:48about the elephant the blind men touching the
- 10:52elephant it's an old parable. And you see that
- 10:55the guy who's touching the side is saying it's
- 10:58a wall the guy in back says it's a rope the ones
- 11:02look touching the tusks as it's a spear none
- 11:07of these are right. but each one of them, it
- 11:12has their point of view about it and they believe
- 11:15that they're right and are talking to each other
- 11:19so they cannot get the whole. You need all of
- 11:23these things to make the elephant work. And unfortunately,
- 11:27a lot of us in any family law case, we're only
- 11:31touching one part of the elephant. And we don't
- 11:35get information that helps us understand the
- 11:38whole elephant. So then we go on to family systems
- 11:42theory, which may help us. So that's the next
- 11:45slide. So complexities, I think that what we're
- 11:55looking for is the family system about definition,
- 11:58conflict, and separation. Robin? OK, hold on.
- 12:06Then we have. That was just the wrong slide.
- 12:10I think we just have the wrong slide. So why
- 12:11don't we just talk through it? I'll just talk
- 12:13about it. So let me try to help you understand.
- 12:18what we mean by the family system. So a family,
- 12:21the idea of a family system is that it's a group
- 12:26of interdependent individuals who are all acting.
- 12:33It and reacting to each other at the same time
- 12:37and people can end up with sort of individual
- 12:40roles like you know we've got the achievement
- 12:43oriented child and we've got the child who's
- 12:46always getting into problems and people get get
- 12:50labeled in a family and stuck so. The important
- 12:55thing is to remember that you can't understand
- 12:58any one person without understanding their role
- 13:02in the family and how they're reacting to each
- 13:04other. And it's very important in these cases
- 13:09to have information about the whole system or
- 13:14as much information as you can have. PCC, by
- 13:18the way, is in a very unique position to gather
- 13:22all that information because, per the stipulation,
- 13:26they should be able to say, I want to talk to
- 13:30this person and get that information, whereas
- 13:33the judge, by the way, cannot always do that.
- 13:36The judge is constrained and has information
- 13:39filtered through evidence, et cetera, et cetera.
- 13:43So let me just talk about the basic unit in a
- 13:47system is going to be a triangle, not a couple.
- 13:50It's got to be a triangle. And so an easy example
- 13:54and a frequent example in our cases would be
- 13:59the clinging emotionally dominant mother and
- 14:03the passive but angry father, not that involved,
- 14:08and a child who's anxious and clinging to the
- 14:11mom. So if you just see the anxious child, you
- 14:14might say, well, the only problem in this family
- 14:16is that we have an anxious child. But really,
- 14:19you have to understand that the child may be
- 14:22anxious because they're not just reacting to
- 14:25dad, the angry dad, but the child's anxiety may
- 14:29be made worse because the mom's anxious and clinging
- 14:32to the child. The child is reacting to each parent,
- 14:36but they're also interacting to the parents,
- 14:39interacting, they're also anxious because they're
- 14:43looking at the parents interacting with each
- 14:45other. A child can be made anxious by observing
- 14:48conflict between the parents. And then there
- 14:51are many other people and many other triangles
- 14:54going on in this system. We're dealing in our
- 14:58work with people in conflict and who are breaking
- 15:01up. And there are some unique things that we
- 15:05need to understand about conflict and how it
- 15:09affects children. One thing that happens in separation
- 15:15is that people's perceptions of each other become
- 15:20exaggerated, and usually they tend, at least
- 15:23in the beginning and sometimes forever, holding
- 15:27onto a very negative perception of who they are
- 15:31in conflict with. And they find people and information
- 15:36to... increase or help solidify that attitude.
- 15:41So they're going to get a whole bunch of cheerleaders.
- 15:45They're going to get their mothers and their
- 15:48therapists and often their attorneys who are
- 15:52going to be their echo chamber. And that happens
- 15:54on each side. So it keeps reinforcing the conflict.
- 16:00You also need to understand that although people
- 16:02say they want to separate and they really can't
- 16:05stand the other person, they also have an underlying
- 16:08drive to keep this going. You can call it negative
- 16:13attachment or something, but these people who
- 16:16keep fighting and fighting and fighting, they're
- 16:18still fixated on each other. And our job often
- 16:22is to create boundaries. But so that they can't
- 16:26keep doing that, acting out the negative part
- 16:29of it. The problem is when you have a child,
- 16:34you can't just completely cut each other off.
- 16:37That's a way of resolving conflict. One way of
- 16:41resolving conflict. And by the way, in Japan,
- 16:44they don't. expect divorced parents to have contact
- 16:48with each other and kids will lose one parent.
- 16:51That's not the way we do it in California or
- 16:54the US. We value the kids having ongoing attachments
- 16:58with both parents. So we have this tension. Because
- 17:03one way that, or you know, what comes to mind
- 17:07is that if you don't have to see this person
- 17:10you're in conflict with, then immediately you
- 17:13feel some relief. But in the long run, that's
- 17:15not good for kids because they're going to, first
- 17:19of all, learn that the only way you resolve conflict
- 17:22is to cut off the other person. But secondly,
- 17:27they're going to carry the boogeyman around inside
- 17:30them. for the rest of their lives. It's going
- 17:35to lead to unresolved psychological problems,
- 17:38and they'll act it out in their relationships.
- 17:41So it's important over time to resolve the conflict
- 17:46as much as possible and create some structures
- 17:49that allow this kid to go on having two parents.
- 17:54OK. So I'm going to go into, and I'm going to
- 17:57resume this. Share here and talking and I'm going
- 18:01to address the question that came in the chat
- 18:03about the resources, but before I do that I want
- 18:06to kind of explain that the collaborative approach
- 18:08that we're suggesting whoops we'll get there
- 18:11in a second in the. in the team approach is to
- 18:14really try to help coordination, which then leads
- 18:17to answering the question about how you can sell
- 18:21and deal with PPC in cases where there may be
- 18:23limited resources or after people have spent
- 18:26a great deal of resources just to get to the
- 18:28PPC process. And part of what I have seen and
- 18:33what I think helps kind of sell this process
- 18:36is that And what I hear from clients who have
- 18:39a PPC that like having a PPC is that sometimes
- 18:43any answer at least is an answer. What happens
- 18:46with a lot of folks who are in dealing with co
- 18:49-parenting or going to a co -parenting specialist
- 18:52just from a therapeutic point of view is they
- 18:55can sit here and go week after week after week.
- 18:58and there's no carrot, there's a carrot, but
- 19:01there's no stick to be an accountability. And
- 19:04one of the biggest complaints that I hear from
- 19:06people is that there is no accountability or
- 19:08oversight. So if we are trying to actually get
- 19:12to resolution, a PPC does have the ability to
- 19:16make expeditious decisions. So what we're looking
- 19:20at is how we can help through a collaborative
- 19:24process by working with these different peoples
- 19:27folks with different expertise to get to the
- 19:30bottom of questions. It can take, for example,
- 19:32you can have a five minute call with the dentist
- 19:36to find out if they use the gas or not for a
- 19:41cavity. that's going to take five minutes versus
- 19:44having hours and hours of writing an RFO about
- 19:47whether or not someone should have medical legal
- 19:49decision making just because someone wants gas
- 19:51or not. So the idea is that, and to really look
- 19:56at whether or not you're using the level one,
- 19:58two, or three levels of authority. Level one
- 20:01authority on the stipulation really allows for
- 20:05quick decisions on regular everyday things that
- 20:08should not be resource intensive, but you're
- 20:11going to have court dates or 10 court dates to
- 20:14decide whether an exchange should be changed
- 20:17when you can do that by a PPC. So part of what
- 20:21we're looking at in the PPC process is a lot
- 20:25of us mental health folks try to take an assessment
- 20:30and make an assessment of kind of what the levels
- 20:33of conflict with what the cases are. And this
- 20:36will tell you kind of also this lens can be used
- 20:39to You can equate this to resist refuse cases.
- 20:43You can look at it in terms of conflict. You
- 20:45can also look at it in terms of what the likelihood
- 20:48of, or what the expenses may actually be in terms
- 20:55of a case. So looking, borrowing from the theory
- 21:00of. a cancer lens, meaning when someone is facing
- 21:03cancer treatment and has been diagnosed with
- 21:05cancer, they often get staged with what type
- 21:08of cancer they have. So it's stage one, two,
- 21:12three, or four. And that usually, with that diagnosis,
- 21:15then you can create a treatment plan. So think
- 21:18about stage one type of cancer is a small tumor.
- 21:22It's like skin cancer, zip, zip, zip, pop it
- 21:25off, oversight. They're probably going to be.
- 21:27Everybody's going to be fine. It's not in the
- 21:29bloodstream, and it's easily manageable. You
- 21:33go all the way just on the complete other side
- 21:36of the spectrum to stage four. That's kind of
- 21:38where you're dealing with the tumor that's been
- 21:41in the bloodstream, in the lymphatic stream.
- 21:44You have tried various areas of intervention.
- 21:47This is usually a situation where you're dealing
- 21:51with a terminal situation. You're managing symptoms.
- 21:54You're not necessarily working to cure the disease
- 21:57and then two and three are those levels in between.
- 22:01There are cases and I think a lot of folks give
- 22:05cases to PPCs when it's a When you're at a four,
- 22:10the idea of actually being able to help repair
- 22:14and diagnose and cure becomes a lot less. But
- 22:18if you have a PPC who can make decisions when
- 22:22you're dealing with conflict that's in the two,
- 22:24three stage, you... start to be able to train
- 22:28the parties, hopefully, to be able to resolve
- 22:31their own conflict and go, okay, I know what
- 22:33the PPC is gonna say, so I might as well just
- 22:35do it. And that's when you start saving the money.
- 22:39And I see that with a lot of my clients, oh,
- 22:41I know what you're gonna say, Robin, so I'm just
- 22:43gonna agree to it now. That makes things a little
- 22:46bit easier. So that is, if you can conceptualize
- 22:50your cases as what type of people we're doing,
- 22:53you can help manage the expectations and the
- 22:56efficacy of how the PPC process is gonna be.
- 22:59Now, I think that one thing in terms of my sales
- 23:01pitch that I'll get back to is that I think a
- 23:04lot of people assume that it has to be a high
- 23:06conflict or resist refuse case for there to be
- 23:08a PPC. There are many cases that are simply single
- 23:12issue PPC type cases. We get along okay, 90 %
- 23:16of the time, but we can't decide where we wanna
- 23:17send our kid to school. We get along 90 % of
- 23:21the time, but every now and again, there's a
- 23:25history of parental alcohol abuse or mental health
- 23:28issues. So we want eyeballs that in case that
- 23:30person falls off the... the wagon and something
- 23:35happens, and we just want you to be involved
- 23:37in that scenario. So there are a lot of situations
- 23:40that can be very case specific and single issue
- 23:44that are not necessarily high conflict folks
- 23:46at all, but allow for intervention when one of
- 23:49these kind of vulnerable areas come up. So this
- 23:57kind of leads us into who acts as the PPC, kind
- 24:02of the players. in this role. as a PPC. First
- 24:05of all, I don't think it's been mentioned, but
- 24:07you probably already know this, but there's no
- 24:09statutory authority for a PPC. This has to come
- 24:12by agreement of the parties. There's excellent
- 24:13stipulations and orders out there that Robin
- 24:16touched on, having level one, two, and three
- 24:18authority, but this has to come by agreement.
- 24:20And this is where really good lawyers do some
- 24:24real effective work with their clients comes
- 24:25into play. As a judge, there's not a lot of things
- 24:28a judge can do from the bench to get a PPC on
- 24:31a case. We can certainly encourage people. throw
- 24:33it out there as an idea, but you can't order
- 24:35it. So from a judge's perspective, I find this
- 24:39to be so valuable when the attorneys can get
- 24:42to this conclusion on their own and get buy -in.
- 24:45So I guess here's part of the sales pitch. Don't
- 24:47wait for the case to get to a number four where
- 24:49it's metastasized because sometimes those cases
- 24:52are, as you know, so far gone. The reason you
- 24:54want to PPC is because you've thrown your arms
- 24:56up in the air and you just don't want to talk
- 24:58to your client anymore. That really does happen.
- 25:01I was a family law attorney at one time and I
- 25:03think I experienced maybe a client or two that
- 25:06I finally just felt like I can't help anymore.
- 25:08But you do need the agreement. The people that
- 25:11work in these roles, as you know, are minors
- 25:13counsel. They're trained, but minors counsel
- 25:15may be the person that leads to the need for
- 25:18a PPC. They have a role. Their role is to represent
- 25:21advocate for a child or children and they're
- 25:24not to be there to advocate for a parent or gather
- 25:28information for a parent or investigate for a
- 25:30parent, they're there to advocate for a child.
- 25:32So they may be the person who is inviting the
- 25:35PPC into the process. Mediators, when you're
- 25:37mediating a case and you know everything else
- 25:40is resolved but these custody issues seem like
- 25:42they're going to go on forever. might be a two
- 25:44or three conflict case in the scale of the cancer
- 25:48line. And that might be an mediator saying, hey,
- 25:50this is a great idea. You guys can end up in
- 25:52court for the next 10 years, or you can get a
- 25:55PPC on to teach the parties how to communicate.
- 25:59A lot of this is a lack of communication or inability
- 26:01to communicate, which is very new in the process,
- 26:04in the divorce process. The property issues are
- 26:07over, but the kids aren't going away. There's
- 26:09always going to be the custody issues. So the
- 26:11PPC mediates a lot of times. In my mediation
- 26:14work, I say, hey, let's stay out of court. How
- 26:16about this PPC as the guidance for the next couple
- 26:19of years? Private judges, like I said, private
- 26:23judges can't order the PPC, but private judges
- 26:25myself, I act as a PPC. I've been on all sides
- 26:29of this. I've been a family law attorney. I've
- 26:31sat in the shoes of an attorney. I've represented
- 26:33the client. I've been a judge who wishes half
- 26:36the time I had PPCs in some of these high -conflict
- 26:39cases. And then, of course, I've acted as a PPC
- 26:41in the capacity. It is the ability of a private
- 26:45judge, and that's where it comes in handy in
- 26:47the sense of who you pick as your PPC, whether
- 26:50it is a mental health professional versus a lawyer
- 26:53versus a judge. Know what you need. Some cases
- 26:56don't need the kind of person that you might
- 27:02think, oh, we want this person. For instance,
- 27:04if this case has a lot of mental health issues,
- 27:06you might not want Judge Hoyt to be your PPC.
- 27:09You want Dr. Lund or Robin Sacks to be your PPC
- 27:11because they have the extensive mental health
- 27:14knowledge. Now, you may say, I need Judge Hoyt
- 27:16because I need somebody who's really good at
- 27:18just making quick decisions and not afraid to
- 27:20make a decision. That is something I can do.
- 27:23But then I may say, I need somebody who's working
- 27:25from the mental health side. So there is sometimes
- 27:28a PPC will come on, and their requirement is,
- 27:31I'm going to do your case, but I need the assistance
- 27:33of a mental health professional because there
- 27:35are those issues. So there's many times in my
- 27:37PPC stipulations I will say, is there a therapist
- 27:41involved? Because I need that for still working
- 27:43on this case. But you kind of have to know what
- 27:46you need. Well, sometimes like Robin mentions,
- 27:51the needs are different. If you've got a couple
- 27:53that just needs the quick decisions, they get
- 27:56along fairly well, but every month or so comes
- 27:59some silly decision of what's the exchange date
- 28:01and time over the Christmas winter break. I just
- 28:03had that. Is it, you know, technically it was
- 28:07midnight. One parent thought, what time should
- 28:09I go get the kid? Midnight? I had to. chime in
- 28:12and say, no, that would be inappropriate to pick
- 28:14up children at midnight. Let's make it 8 a .m.
- 28:16and next year, you can get those valuable sleeping
- 28:18hours from midnight to 8 a .m. Those are quick
- 28:21decisions that PPCs can make. And you don't have
- 28:25ex -parties. They avoid a lot of the court process.
- 28:28Obviously, other people work as PPCs. I'll turn
- 28:31that over to Rob. To Judge Hoy's point, I will
- 28:35tell you, I have seen many cases where a judge
- 28:38will say, I can't order a PPC, but I really think
- 28:42you should have a PPC. And I would really like
- 28:45for you to have a PPC. And especially, you guys
- 28:49have all heard the term, the frequent fliers,
- 28:51right? Those people that come back and forth
- 28:53and back and forth into court. Those cases drive
- 28:56judges crazy. And I think the... statistics say
- 29:00that you know 20 percent of the cases take up
- 29:0390 percent of the oxygen in the in the courthouse
- 29:05in the time. And so we're doing a service to
- 29:09the other litigants who so badly need the judicial
- 29:11time to focus on things that really need to be
- 29:14done. So um and and also to Judge Hoey's point
- 29:18I too have made the on certain types of cases,
- 29:21like if I have a case where I'm a PPC and I know
- 29:24that there's a strong mental health issue, if
- 29:26I need a specialist involved, that is something
- 29:28that you can actually put into your PPC stipulation.
- 29:31I think it's really important, the question came
- 29:33into the chat, if you have a date certain a PPC
- 29:36will last until, is there a way to switch a mental
- 29:38health PPC during that time? The issue with the
- 29:41PPC stipulation is that whatever you sign is
- 29:44your stipulation, and then everything else has
- 29:46to be subject to a new stipulation. So if you're
- 29:49switching, PPCs, you need a new stipulation.
- 29:52If you are having a requirement that something
- 29:56needs to be part of the stipulation, meaning
- 29:58that there's a requirement about a mental health
- 30:01being provider, all of that should be considered,
- 30:05contemplated, and agreed to in advance. always
- 30:11be cognizant of the fact that why are we switching
- 30:13PPCs in the middle of the process? Now, your
- 30:16PPC should be like, for instance, if I'm the
- 30:19PPC and I realize this is a mental health heavy
- 30:22case and I'm just not equipped to do it, I should
- 30:25be the one that's saying to the parties and to
- 30:27council, you know what, I think you need Dr.
- 30:30Lund or I think you need somebody else on this
- 30:32case. I'm not the right person for the job. keep
- 30:36in mind we all know this when we go to court
- 30:38the judge doesn't like me let's try to get a
- 30:40new judge oh ppc doesn't like me let's try to
- 30:43get a new ppc so watch out for shopping so to
- 30:46speak yes yeah that's and that's an and that's
- 30:48an excellent point i and one of the points that
- 30:50i just want to make is that ppc stipulation one
- 30:52of the benefits we have double benefit, is that
- 30:56the County of Los Angeles has a pre -made PPC
- 31:00suggested stipulation form that Dr. Lund has
- 31:02was hugely a part of creating. And it has in
- 31:06there that not every jurisdiction has certain
- 31:09kind of levels of authority for each type of
- 31:13decision. What people often get confused on that
- 31:17stipulation form is that people think, oh, if
- 31:19it's a level three, that means you can't talk
- 31:22about it. The different levels. does not mean
- 31:26that you can't weigh in on an issue. The levels
- 31:29tell you what the PPC needs to do in order to
- 31:33make a recommendation or not. Who needs to be
- 31:38heard, how quick it needs to be done, the notice
- 31:40time, etc. It's a great form. It is in our materials
- 31:44that we've provided today, the stipulation form,
- 31:48but your form can be modified and changed for
- 31:52what your needs are. And we should do another
- 31:56completely nuts and bolts training on how attorneys
- 32:01understand and can use that PPC step. For example,
- 32:06people think that those levels of authority have
- 32:09to be all in there. They don't. They can be a
- 32:13level one or a level two. You can change which
- 32:15level of authority. In any level in any one point
- 32:21anyone issue so yeah we should do that we should
- 32:24do that and until we do i'm a resource i'm an
- 32:27offer doctor london's a resource that if you
- 32:29have questions about your stipulations feel free
- 32:32to reach out to us or contact materials there
- 32:34because. really understanding what the stipulation
- 32:37is is really important. This is different than
- 32:40co -parenting. It is not co -parenting. You're
- 32:42using a mental health provider. It is a decision.
- 32:45It is a quasi -judicial process that has authority.
- 32:50So just going through the rest of our chart here
- 32:52so that we don't derail too much, there are many
- 32:54other people that are involved in, as we've talked
- 32:58about, some of the legal people. But in addition
- 33:00to the kind of family law people, sometimes in
- 33:04these types of cases we may find that there's
- 33:06criminal and DVRO or restraining order counsel.
- 33:09There may be consulting lawyers behind the scenes.
- 33:12There may be jurisdictional issues where you
- 33:14have a New York lawyer, a California lawyer,
- 33:17a Texas lawyer that you may be having a deal
- 33:19with things that have multi -state issues, even
- 33:22though the jurisdiction has been given here.
- 33:24There's also DCFS lawyers. So we're big fans
- 33:28of collaborating here. Lawyers, often more siloed
- 33:33mental health providers. We really consult with
- 33:35each other, talk to each other, and we view the
- 33:38lawyers as a valuable member of the team to helping
- 33:41a family to a resolution. Other roles will be
- 33:45explained by Mary. Okay, so let me just, I'm
- 33:49gonna start with a mental health professional
- 33:52being a PPC and say that one of the weaknesses
- 33:56of mental health professionals who've done this
- 33:59work that I have known, who I have known, is
- 34:03they don't make enough decisions. So if part
- 34:06of your dissatisfaction with the PPC process
- 34:09has been that mental health professionals don't
- 34:12make decisions, That I have to own. And by the
- 34:17way, I made decisions. My husband, Angus Strong,
- 34:20who helped do the PPC stipulation, he was on
- 34:24that committee that developed it. He makes decisions,
- 34:28but if you get a mental health professional,
- 34:32make them use the authority that they have and
- 34:37make it clear that they are not to keep trying
- 34:40to mediate past a certain point. to make a decision.
- 34:47I'm going to use my example of the kid who is
- 34:52clinging to his mother and the angry -ish father
- 34:58and the kind of emotionally clinging mother to
- 35:01talk about these different roles. Divorce case
- 35:10will say oh the kid needs therapy. Well, you
- 35:14know, that's not gonna help I mean the kid may
- 35:17be anxious and the kid may need therapy But that's
- 35:20not gonna help little Johnny start spending time
- 35:23in dad's house You know because there are all
- 35:26kinds of things about the way that this dynamic
- 35:29goes on but We want to protect little Johnny's
- 35:33therapy if he needs it. Johnny may have had separation
- 35:36problems from both parents when going to preschool.
- 35:39They may have been in family therapy prior to
- 35:43the divorce with a family therapist who's working
- 35:46with both mom and dad to help little Johnny adjust
- 35:50to preschool. And maybe little Johnny has developmental
- 35:53issues. You know, little and these parents have
- 35:57been struggling with how to take care of this.
- 35:59kid who is anxious for reasons that are temperamental,
- 36:05not necessarily caused by the divorce itself.
- 36:09So let's talk about who's likely to get involved
- 36:14when mom and dad divorce here. Well, quite often
- 36:17they are going to go to individual therapists
- 36:20or now increasingly divorce coaches. Drives me
- 36:23crazy. when they're going to divorce coaches
- 36:26by the way you know influencer divorce coaches
- 36:29but individual qualified psychotherapist who
- 36:34have ethics still make the mistake of over identifying
- 36:38with their clients and they can make problems
- 36:42worse by telling people to keep fighting or protect
- 36:46themselves or you're right and she's wrong and
- 36:49so And it increases the cutoff between the parents.
- 36:54I think one of the most valuable roles, and this
- 36:57is why I'm still doing this in my semi -retirement,
- 37:02is to get a co -parenting therapist. Oh. Sorry.
- 37:06OK. Ah. is to get a co -parenting therapist because
- 37:11it's vitally important to get these people the
- 37:15skills that they need now that they are no longer
- 37:18communicating informally. They need to now do
- 37:24things like make decisions about how little Johnny
- 37:27is going to play soccer and maybe he really needs
- 37:30that. so that he can go on with his life and
- 37:34develop some skills socially, but the parents
- 37:36can't agree on getting him into soccer. So a
- 37:42co -parenting therapist is going to be skilled
- 37:45at trying to get the emotions dealt with and
- 37:49to lower the tone and get them to communicate
- 37:55better, but the co -parenting therapist can't
- 37:57make a decision. They can only try to deal with
- 38:00them voluntarily doing things. And so then maybe
- 38:04what we've got going on here is little Johnny
- 38:07is not going to dad. Maybe dad has remarried
- 38:11or not remarried has said he the marriage broke
- 38:15up because he's got involved with another woman
- 38:17and has decided the other woman is immediately
- 38:20going to live with him and little Johnny is increasingly
- 38:23reluctant. to go over there well a reunification
- 38:28therapist who only works with mom i mean with
- 38:32dad and the kid is not likely to have a lot of
- 38:36success in my opinion you need to get the whole
- 38:40team in there but the reunification therapist
- 38:43is not in a position to make a decision about
- 38:48when little Johnny's going to spend more time
- 38:50with dad. The therapist doing the work can inform
- 38:55the PPC what's going on, but that therapist isn't
- 39:02able, they're going to risk their license if
- 39:04they make a statement about how much time the
- 39:09little Johnny should spend because that is a
- 39:12custody. recommendation and the PPC can do that
- 39:16and usually these are long term cases where they
- 39:19have to get you know desensitized and change
- 39:24in short amounts of time spent with the other
- 39:29parent over time and that is not something that
- 39:32is amenable to court at all you need and that
- 39:36might be a good kind of a case for a mental health
- 39:41professional PPC as are, I think, like baby cases
- 39:48where you have a developing child and you can't
- 39:51really know when the child's ready to spend more
- 39:54time and maybe a mental health professional might
- 39:56be in a good position to be a PPC because it
- 40:01involves developmental issues and often observation
- 40:04of the child with both parents in order to determine
- 40:07that. I think all of you understand what a custody
- 40:11evaluator is, because that is somebody who is
- 40:16a mental health professional who has special
- 40:18training, they're forensically trained, takes
- 40:22years to become one, and lots of effort to remain
- 40:27being an evaluator. But if you were to send little
- 40:32Johnny and family to get an evaluation over the
- 40:36fact that he doesn't want to spend time with
- 40:39dad when he's six years old. Well, he'll be seven
- 40:43years old before the evaluation is done and there's
- 40:47a trial on it. So in the meantime, very often
- 40:52the situation gets worse. And so going to a PPC
- 40:58during this process is going to be a more immediate
- 41:02and effective intervention. And then there are
- 41:07As Robin said, there are many other kinds of
- 41:12mental health services. Children have special
- 41:15needs. They're going to be involved in the regional
- 41:17center. They're going to be behavioral therapists
- 41:20going back and forth to the homes, who might
- 41:23be excellent in terms of their ability to give
- 41:27you information about what goes on in the homes.
- 41:30Teenagers sometimes have to go to inpatient or
- 41:34outpatient. Sometimes parents need to be, maybe
- 41:39dad does really have an anger problem. And maybe
- 41:42the PPC needs to get involved and can't necessarily
- 41:47recommend or order, but can talk to, as Robin
- 41:52said, the family about dad being in therapy.
- 41:56And then the PPC would get information about
- 41:59How's dad doing in therapy? And then there are
- 42:06other things, especially the child abuse cases,
- 42:09and you get the other more complicated steward
- 42:12house involvement and things like that. So that's
- 42:16a brief overview. And often, if you know that
- 42:21there are like 10 therapists involved in a case,
- 42:25that is a very bad sign. One of the benefits
- 42:30to having these therapists is having the voice
- 42:35of different people. There is a big difference
- 42:38between how a parent or party or litigant reports
- 42:41what is occurring versus how the person who is
- 42:45actually experiencing it may report it. It's
- 42:50very valuable when you hear a party say, this
- 42:53is what happened. And then you hear the other
- 42:55party say, no, this is what happened. And then
- 42:57you talk to the therapist and you hear what they
- 42:59say happened. So you start to be able to develop
- 43:02credibility questions or answer credibility questions.
- 43:06And as Judge Coy had brought up, there's the
- 43:08ability in the PPC process to really bring in
- 43:11and get the voice of a lot of people that otherwise
- 43:14may never, who have valuable information, who
- 43:17may never ever make their way. I mean, grandparents
- 43:19can be... great sources of information, nannies,
- 43:23teachers, monitors, consultants, sober coaches,
- 43:28pediatricians, dentists, nutritionists, people
- 43:30who are saying like, a lot of people will say
- 43:32to me, oh, my child's, you know, not overweight.
- 43:35And the other person's, yes, they're overweight.
- 43:37You're feeding them horribly. Well, the nutritionist
- 43:38said this. Well, let me go just in a two second
- 43:41call, I can call the nutritionist and say, what
- 43:43did the nutritionist actually say? And that puts
- 43:46an end to that real quick. in terms of what an
- 43:49issue may be. So the question came up in the
- 43:52chat, I'm trying to try to get the questions
- 43:54out there too, was could a PPC be useful in both
- 43:57co -parenting planning and parental planning?
- 43:59Absolutely. Co -parenting, we've talked a lot
- 44:03about the co -parenting, but particularly a lot
- 44:05of people think that parallel parenting means
- 44:07that you never need to speak to or deal with
- 44:10the other parent. That's just false. There is
- 44:13a... reality that there is going to be certain
- 44:16touch points and certain intersections where
- 44:18decisions need to be made, plans need to be made,
- 44:20and in the parallel parenting model, if you have
- 44:24these cases where you're in constant impasse
- 44:27to having decisions and the kids' lives need
- 44:30to go on, a parenting plan coordinator is excellent.
- 44:34I can't tell you how many people are sitting
- 44:35here on the eve of Thanksgiving having a fight
- 44:39about whether or not the exchange is going to
- 44:41be at Starbucks or Taco Bell. Right? And so the
- 44:44kid doesn't remember what Thanksgiving was about
- 44:46anymore. All they remember was the fight about
- 44:49Taco Bell or Starbucks. And instead you just
- 44:51put an end to that. And that is like a level
- 44:53one decision that is easy and it's not going
- 44:56to take a lot of analysis. So just to answer
- 45:00this last question and then we'll move into the
- 45:02case studies. is what happens if one party does
- 45:05not agree with the PPC decision. The stipulation,
- 45:08and when we do our nuts and bolts, we'll get
- 45:09into this further, the stipulation provides the
- 45:11remedies. You can always go to court. There is
- 45:15nothing about the PPC process that prevents anyone
- 45:17from going to court. There is a period of time
- 45:20that the PPC recommendation becomes an order.
- 45:25And even in that circumstance, even if it becomes
- 45:27an order, there's a way to... dispute that order
- 45:32and go to court. You always have judicial oversight.
- 45:35It does not usurp judicial oversight. So please
- 45:39understand that. Bouncing to you, Judge Hoy.
- 45:44Thank you. Yeah, think about that as, think of
- 45:46it as the Superior Court kind of has appellate
- 45:48rights over the PGC through the lawyers who need
- 45:50it that way. Following up on the co -parenting
- 45:53counselor, some of the cases I do do, I actually,
- 45:59suggest to the parents, why don't you go work
- 46:02with a co -parenting counselor? Because I think
- 46:03that only just will assist in what we're doing
- 46:05in the case. But what I want to do in the case
- 46:08study is tell you or kind of go to what kind
- 46:12of case, why you would want a PPC in a case,
- 46:14why it's so important. Some of the things that
- 46:17I think about when I'm talking to lawyers and
- 46:21litigants in mediation processes. Why would I
- 46:25suggest a PPC for you? Well, number one, I find
- 46:29cost is big. These cases have probably taken
- 46:33a life on their own. Maybe they're after a custody
- 46:37evaluation already. And they have spent so much
- 46:39money, they're exhausted, they have litigation
- 46:42fatigue. And sometimes the cost is much, well,
- 46:46it is much less. It's two people probably sharing
- 46:48the cost of one PPC. The PPC can hopefully narrow
- 46:51down the team to the necessity of the people
- 46:54that we need. We might need a child's therapist,
- 46:57but they can collaboratively look at the entire
- 46:59team and figure out what we really need to gather
- 47:01all the information. The PPC also kind of access
- 47:04the coach of the team, meaning I've got all these
- 47:06players here that are working with this family,
- 47:09and the PPC can gather the information and kind
- 47:11of package it up and put a nice bow on it so
- 47:14that it's relayed to the parties. Another reason
- 47:17why PPCs would be really beneficial in these
- 47:20kinds of cases is access. How many times have
- 47:22your clients, I just want to talk to the judge.
- 47:25Well, you can't do that. And so access. The PPC
- 47:28is accessible to the parties. They can have an
- 47:31open conversation with the PPC, really spell
- 47:34out why they think what they think, and have
- 47:36an open dialogue with the PPC. And you can't
- 47:38have that with the judge who is making a decision
- 47:41in your case. So access is huge. Quick decisions.
- 47:45I think the one I find to be most useful for
- 47:48families. Things that aren't resolved quickly
- 47:51take on a life of their own. I think Dr. Lunn
- 47:54mentioned this. If something really started out
- 47:57small, but it's now been two, three months and
- 48:00everybody's talking about it, boy, it's gotten
- 48:01to be big now. It's a huge problem and facts
- 48:05have probably been exacerbated. My golly, we
- 48:07are now really in a crisis mode. It could have
- 48:10been, the fire could have been put out a long
- 48:12time ago. A lot of you as lawyers understand
- 48:14the ex -party process with the courts, and every
- 48:17judge is different, but I can tell you from the
- 48:19feedback I got in sitting as a judge, Judges
- 48:22don't always have time to put out the day -to
- 48:23-day fires. And so your ex -party many times
- 48:26could be denied because it's not a true emergency.
- 48:30It's not because the judge doesn't want to help
- 48:31every case. They just can't. And so a PPC can
- 48:34help put out some of these fires. So the ability
- 48:37for quick decisions is really important. It's
- 48:40also a venue for parents to complain. They get
- 48:43to come in and they just get to speak their mind.
- 48:45They get an open forum to be able to say whatever
- 48:48they want to say and complain about the other
- 48:50side. And the PPC to some degree will listen,
- 48:53but to some degree I think they're trying to
- 48:55redirect the issue. And hey, let's put that one
- 48:58to rest. It really helps the parents get things
- 49:01off their chest. As a lawyer, many of you have
- 49:03walked out of the courtroom and ... The one thing
- 49:06I've always heard lawyers say is, why couldn't
- 49:08the purchase make a decision? When the judge
- 49:10continues your case on a day when you weren't
- 49:12expecting any continuance, that is the biggest
- 49:15letdown for a party. You want a decision from
- 49:17the court. So the parties want to be heard and
- 49:19they want a decision. They want to move on. And
- 49:22so the PPC will allow people to be heard, have
- 49:26a decision made, and move on to the next thing.
- 49:29The other thing that a PPC has the benefit of
- 49:32doing as far as in the case studies is looking
- 49:35and hearing insight from all professionals. This
- 49:37kind of has been touched on. But the PPC can
- 49:39look at everybody, talk to everybody, get releases
- 49:42from minors council so I can talk to the child's
- 49:44therapist. Keep in mind, though, there is no
- 49:47privilege for the PPC. PPC's file is fair game.
- 49:50PPC can be subject to examination. And so you
- 49:53have to, the PPC, you have to really trust the
- 49:56person that you select as the PPC because these
- 49:58are people that have to maintain a organized
- 50:01file. They have to be able to answer questions
- 50:04with the lawyers. Cause if the case does go to
- 50:06litigation, the PPC is fair game. All the evidence,
- 50:11evidence or objections apply as well. PPCs don't
- 50:14get to get stamped as evidence in and it appears
- 50:16safe evidence in like anyone else. The other
- 50:20thing that the benefit is, I get a lot of PPCs
- 50:23because the lawyers are quite frankly, I think
- 50:24I said this before, a little bit tired and they
- 50:27just don't know what else to do. That's a stage
- 50:30four case, which it's tough to come into one
- 50:33of those and think, and believe me, I don't have
- 50:34the ego to think that a stage four case that
- 50:37maybe Robin's worked on before, Dr. Lund's worked
- 50:40on, I'm going to fix it. I'll try to help, but
- 50:42those cases are sometimes too far gone and it's
- 50:44unfortunate maybe we could have caught them at
- 50:46two and three. People also can be very toxic
- 50:50and split professionals. Okay, the splitting
- 50:52of therapist mom's therapist I've had cases where
- 50:56the two parenting coaches Were friends and then
- 51:01now all of a sudden this case these parents are
- 51:03so toxic They don't speak to each other anymore
- 51:06The PPC can help mend all that keep the information
- 51:09Objective and flowing making sure people aren't
- 51:12splitting people the information that's being
- 51:14shared is is the same We all know the telephone
- 51:17game the story changes as it goes on. The PDC
- 51:21can be a really useful person in making sure
- 51:23that the message is clear and consistent and
- 51:26it's not just what, it's not changing as we hear
- 51:29from different people. So there's a lot of reasons
- 51:31and a lot of strengths and using one in a case,
- 51:36using a PDC in a case that will really help the
- 51:39case move forward and stay out of court. I think
- 51:41most people, I've not met a lot of people who
- 51:43say, gee, I love to go to court. So I think the
- 51:45key for most of these families is to stay out
- 51:47of court and figure out a mechanism to get their
- 51:49family through the day -to -day crises that they
- 51:52seem to create sometimes for themselves, but
- 51:54it really helps the children move on. So going
- 51:59into what our case study Two is really an example,
- 52:04and I think it goes to Judge Hoy's point of everything
- 52:07is fair game from the PPCs. The PPCs that are
- 52:10organized, have good files, and frankly have
- 52:13systems, I think do the best and parties respond
- 52:16to them the best, meaning having an organized
- 52:18way of dealing with things. So for example, in
- 52:20my PPC work, I tell my parties what the process
- 52:24is at the beginning of what they need to do to
- 52:26seek an order and the process that they can expect.
- 52:29First step. I'm going to tell them, I will always
- 52:31try to mediate it first. I'm going to try to
- 52:34mediate it and see if they can get to resolution
- 52:36on their own. Number two, then I give them a
- 52:38period of time of what they can provide, whatever
- 52:40documents or whatever I need to have depending
- 52:42on the level of decision making and what's required
- 52:45by the stipulation. Then level three, I will
- 52:47then tell them after I know. kind of what documents
- 52:50and what needs to be reviewed, what process it's
- 52:52gonna look like so that they know kind of from
- 52:54an expense perspective, a time perspective, what
- 52:57it's gonna take to make a decision. So I'm gonna
- 53:00offer this for you to look at. I'm not gonna
- 53:02go through it right now, but it's an example
- 53:04of a very frequent PPC area that I think comes
- 53:07up a lot is in school recommendations. So for
- 53:10examples, here are some of the factors that I
- 53:15look at in terms of making a school decision.
- 53:17Now there's a lot more factors that I look at,
- 53:21including continuity and stability of the kids,
- 53:24the child's development and learning, special
- 53:26education needs, co -parenting logistics and
- 53:29communication, et cetera. But I tell, those are
- 53:32things that I've done in my assessment, but I
- 53:34can provide information to my... parties about
- 53:38what they can expect that I'm going to look like.
- 53:40And I will tell you, by telling them what the
- 53:42factors are, sometimes they start to come to
- 53:45their own decision. They start realizing, wait,
- 53:48you know what? I know how this is going to come
- 53:50down. And that's, by the way, the best thing
- 53:52in the world. I love getting fired for not being
- 53:55needed, that they've made the decisions on their
- 53:58own, that they're able to make their own decisions.
- 54:00If we can use this as a objective way to make
- 54:03decisions, it helps people. So there are other
- 54:06interventions also that PPCs can do. And there
- 54:11are more interventions that PPCs frankly can
- 54:14do than what judges can do. And while judges
- 54:18have the ability to do creative orders, and I'm
- 54:20seeing more and more creative orders, there are
- 54:23certain things that you can actually make a recommendation
- 54:28as a PPC. So I'm gonna turn those to Judge Hoy.
- 54:32And that's a good point. As a PPC versus when
- 54:35I sat as a judge, there are so many different
- 54:37things I can do. As a judge, trust me, there
- 54:40are many times I've picked up the phone and called
- 54:42some child therapist and go, okay, what is going
- 54:45on here, right? called somebody, but I can't.
- 54:49I'm right. I have to take evidence in. I have
- 54:50to take invisible evidences and make a decision
- 54:52based on that. Margo, can I just add to that?
- 54:56Yeah. A child's therapist will not be able to
- 54:59speak directly to a judge unless both people
- 55:02will sign the consent for them. you know, judges
- 55:06want to hear from, often want to hear from mental
- 55:08health professionals, but they can't do it because
- 55:11they are ethically constrained from doing so,
- 55:15except in extraordinary circumstances. So you
- 55:18can pick up the phone and talk to the therapist,
- 55:21right? And you, and whereas a judge cannot do
- 55:24that. Well, PPC, I think PPC still needs the
- 55:28waiver from the parent or the authority. Yes,
- 55:30but there's so much to give it to you. Right.
- 55:33Well, and frankly, you can then make a recommendation
- 55:36saying, I am recommending that both parents sign
- 55:39the waiver, and then that becomes a recommendation.
- 55:42Correct. Right. So like I said, the PPC has so
- 55:44many more tools than, in my opinion, than I did
- 55:46as a judge. As a judge, we knew that I had the
- 55:49intervention, I could get an evaluation. I think
- 55:51Dr. Lund pointed it out that it starts with Johnny's
- 55:54seven and it ends when Johnny's eight and a half.
- 55:57And boy, what's happened to Johnny in the meantime.
- 55:59So we all know what the problems there are, not
- 56:01saying they're not needed. In some cases, they
- 56:03really are. But you need something along the
- 56:06way, I think, and that's what a PPC could be
- 56:08helpful for. Obviously, Miners Council is there
- 56:11as an advocate for the children and voice for
- 56:12the children and I think that is a useful tool
- 56:15and an intervention. Other experts that we can
- 56:19appoint educational consultants things like that
- 56:22are always helpful in certain issues counseling
- 56:25alcohol and drug treatments sober link one of
- 56:28your sponsors today is something that is It's
- 56:32very useful. The one thing I want to make sure
- 56:35on going through the list of the monitored visitation,
- 56:37we all know that that is, but the PPC and the
- 56:40Special Master are the order. When you are getting
- 56:42a PPC, Do not agree to a PPC in a stipulation
- 56:47order saying, we employ Robin Sachs as our PPC.
- 56:50Thank you very much, and that's the end of it.
- 56:52You have to make an order telling us what Robin
- 56:55Sachs's authority is. If I get appointed as a
- 56:57PPC, and all it says is I'm the PPC, and it doesn't
- 57:01tell me I have any authority to do anything.
- 57:03specific or doesn't tell me what my role is,
- 57:05I actually don't want to do that job. I want
- 57:07the parties and counsel to identify in the order
- 57:11what the PPC's role is and their authority. That's
- 57:16why the LI form that is in your materials I think
- 57:19is so wonderful to give the authority. They still
- 57:21get to pick what they want to give the PPC, what
- 57:24levels of authority for what issues, but I think
- 57:27that is very important. So the order is key.
- 57:30take a lot of time in drafting your order for
- 57:32the PPC because it's going to follow you for
- 57:35a lot of years, because usually these are two
- 57:37-year appointments, three -year appointments,
- 57:39things like that. So make sure you take a lot
- 57:41of time in doing that specialized order of what
- 57:43you want. I know we need to finish, so go ahead.
- 57:45I talked a little bit about that in the next
- 57:47slide. That's okay. And I'm going to just pass
- 57:49through this next slide just talking about that
- 57:52there can be specialized orders. You should also
- 57:54know that the PPC can decline. to act on a request.
- 58:01I've had someone say, Robin, we want you to decide
- 58:03if our kid's going to have surgery. I'm like,
- 58:05yeah, I'm not deciding if your kid's having surgery.
- 58:06That's not happening. That's not something I'm
- 58:08comfortable with. So just because I'm given the
- 58:10authority does not necessarily mean that the
- 58:12PPC will take it. There are other tools that
- 58:15we need to just recognize that get part of the
- 58:17PPC process. We've all been talking about AI,
- 58:20just recognizing that there are other people
- 58:22that are behind the scenes in other tools out
- 58:25there. And we want to just make sure that we're
- 58:27aware of those so that we can be a better PPC.
- 58:33Other things to remember, I turn to Mary. Am
- 58:38I closing it down now? Yeah, you are closing
- 58:40it down. OK, so thank you for coming, by the
- 58:43way. I will say on my behalf. And remember that
- 58:47all of us who work with these very difficult
- 58:51families have to remain open -minded. I know
- 58:56that we get stuck in our roles in the system,
- 59:00in the broad family law system, but look out
- 59:03for, you know, take a, we need to continue self
- 59:07-assessment, look out for our biases, challenge
- 59:11ourselves, be willing to change our minds, remain
- 59:15vigilant in seeking new information, and These
- 59:21are things that the PPCs do, but we also want
- 59:24to try to get the word out that it takes a village
- 59:27to really try to solve these clients' problems.
- 59:31And the attorneys who are going to be setting
- 59:33up these cases, you're part of that village.
- 59:37And it strikes me that maybe we should be talking
- 59:41about being consultants to attorneys to help
- 59:45set up the PPC process. And that's the key. Collaboration
- 59:50is key. We are here to model collaboration and
- 59:53we are here to collaborate with you if you need
- 59:55help. If you have questions about the PPC, feel
- 59:57free to reach out to us. And I thank you too
- 1:00:00on behalf of all of us. Thank you.