Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Constantly Interrupts
Transcript
- Lucas: We've all had that team member who, in a meeting, cuts people off mid-sentence — maybe it's enthusiasm, maybe it's impatience, but it creates a real friction. Luna: And if you're the manager, it's one of those behaviors you know you should address, but it feels awkward to call out in the moment. Lucas: Exactly. So today I want to talk about how you handle an employee who constantly interrupts. Not the occasional overlap — that's human — but the pattern that makes others feel steamrolled. Luna: What's the first step? Do you pull them aside after a meeting, or is it better to address it in a one-on-one? Lucas: I'd say start with a dedicated one-on-one. Don't try to give this feedback in the hallway or right after a tense meeting. You want a calm, private conversation where you can be specific. Luna: Right. And I think the framing matters a lot. If you say 'you interrupt too much,' they'll get defensive. Lucas: Exactly. Instead, you describe the behavior and its impact. Something like: 'In yesterday's team meeting, when you jumped in while Sarah was presenting her numbers, I noticed she stopped sharing a key insight she had. I think we lost a good idea there.' Luna: That's concrete. It's not about their character — it's about what happened. Lucas: And then you follow up with a question: 'What's your take on that moment?' You want to understand their perspective first. Maybe they were excited. Maybe they thought Sarah was rambling. Maybe they didn't even realize they did it. Luna: And once you understand, then you can agree on a fix. What's a good fix? Lucas: One technique I've seen work well is the 'pause and pass' system. In team meetings, the manager sets a rule: after someone finishes a point, everyone counts to three before responding. Or you physically pass a talking stick — that sounds silly, but it works. Luna: I've heard of that. It gives people a moment to process, and it signals that interrupting isn't the norm. Lucas: Right. And for the specific employee, you can agree on a private signal — maybe a subtle hand gesture or saying their name — to remind them to let others finish. That way you're coaching in real time without embarrassing them. Luna: But what if the employee doesn't see it as a problem? They might say, 'I'm just passionate' or 'I'm trying to move things along.' Lucas: That's common. In that case, you can bring data. There's research from the University of California that shows interruptions in a team meeting can reduce the group's problem-solving effectiveness by nearly 20 percent. So it's not just a politeness issue — it's a productivity issue. Luna: That's a strong argument. And you can also tie it to their own goals. If they want to be seen as a leader, interrupting less actually builds more influence. Lucas: Exactly. Because people who listen well are trusted more. So it's in their self-interest to develop that skill. Luna: What about when the interruptive behavior happens in a meeting with senior leadership? That's higher stakes. Lucas: That's a harder conversation. You might need to say something like: 'I noticed in the Q3 review you cut off the VP of Product when she was explaining the timeline. I want you to be visible, but I also want you to be strategic. Let's talk about when to hold back and when to jump in.' Luna: So you're coaching them on the politics of timing. Lucas: Right. And sometimes you need to model the behavior yourself. If you, as the manager, never interrupt, it sets a standard. People watch what you do more than what you say. Luna: That's a good point. I had a boss once who would literally put her hand on her chin and nod when someone was talking — it showed she was listening, and it made everyone else do the same. Lucas: That's a great example. The physical cue of listening can change the room's energy. Luna: So let's say you've had the conversation, you've agreed on a signal, but a few weeks later, the behavior hasn't changed. What then? Lucas: Then it becomes about consequences — but not punishment. You might say, 'I'm seeing the same pattern. I need you to commit to a specific change. If it continues, I'll have to step in during meetings to redirect the conversation, and that won't feel great for anyone.' Luna: That's firm but fair. And I think at that point, you're also protecting the rest of the team. If one person's interruptions are silencing others, you have to intervene. Lucas: Exactly. Because the cost of not addressing it is that quieter team members disengage. They stop sharing ideas. And that hurts the whole team's performance. Luna: I've seen that happen. One interrupter can shift the culture toward a 'loudest voice wins' dynamic. Lucas: Which is exactly what you don't want. You want the best ideas to surface, not just the most assertive ones. So managing interruptions is really about managing psychological safety. Luna: And if you handle it well, the employee often becomes more self-aware and more effective. So it's a win-win. Lucas: Absolutely. And look, if we've helped you think about a tricky conversation you've been putting off, that's exactly why we do this show. These episodes take time to research and produce, and they stay ad-free thanks to listeners who find them useful and choose to support us. Luna: Yeah, it's really simple — if today helped you, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's all lowercase. Lucas: And honestly, it means we can keep digging into these real-world management challenges without any sponsor pressure. So thank you to anyone who's ever chipped in. Luna: Alright, back to interruptions. One last thing — what about when the interrupter is a high performer? The one who actually delivers? Do you approach it differently? Lucas: That's a great question. And the answer is: you still address it, but you frame it as part of their growth. You can say, 'Your contributions are valuable, but your impact is muted when people feel cut off. If you want to move into a senior role, learning to create space for others is a must.' Luna: So you're connecting the behavior to their ambition, not just to team harmony. Lucas: Exactly. And honestly, that often works better than any other argument. High performers want to advance, and they'll usually adapt if they see the link. Luna: Good. So to recap: address it one-on-one, be specific about the impact, agree on a signal, model the behavior yourself, and if needed, escalate with consequences tied to growth. Lucas: That's a solid framework. And the key is to act early — don't let it become a habit. The longer you wait, the harder it is to change. Luna: Alright, fair point. Next week we'll talk about managing an employee who never speaks up in meetings — the other side of the coin. Lucas: Can't wait. Until then, keep the interruptions to a minimum and the good ideas flowing.